ML19273D125

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Forwards Licensee Accident Analysis Re Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment.Requests Safety Evaluation.Licensee Plans to Submit Auxiliary Feedwater Sys auto-initiation Sys Which Delays Auxiliary Feedwater Flow for Three Minutes
ML19273D125
Person / Time
Site: Millstone, Calvert Cliffs, 05000000
Issue date: 02/14/1980
From: Benaroya V
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Novak T
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML093450149 List: ... further results
References
FOIA-80-515, FOIA-80-555, RTR-NUREG-0578, RTR-NUREG-578 TAC-42410, NUDOCS 8003120963
Download: ML19273D125 (2)


Text

. ~.<w. u.w agg,y g m y, 7-gg.g,.4pgy g

y.

.o

,s os..

._ m

. o ;h 9;;.;y' 4;c i.+

a

  • e

.%. c: 7 y y..,

v :

"5 s

2 V [. Y N,.

(mW(;g i~

WB: 11.4 1980

' D(STRIBUTLON

-650 TRAL FLhE

' %, ~f ' "

4'

+

' T ;6 4,

KRR R.EADING' is o

c ACB-READING

' " '2 4

v.

>4 m

s +

a

.71; *m

  • 2' let0PAMCN E. ors: '.Tia No. v. aE. hief
  • m, ek..,

. 3:s c/-

Reaetor Sey. stems} BWandN 033i t4 :m'5 1

,e.

4, " ~, %

^

3, 7'm'

- 3 w N.

>f

l

<m y -

k m g f u yfsr,c g gs g Q 7 3 :y, ~33f-3 g. } ' :' g ;~ $@y b'

a J

g<.~

r;tGeaWinnerrt:9Fsitsumet 89anchi D5Si mN n

. ',, j ? @in..t

.y g 4;.,. g; g,j / p $.

y.

,u -. m.. m. m.,

s.

,;jiy

. :(

4 * ',,,

.1 f

a-

. ';,, jf L

, 3C ' Atrenar9ya?,1 Chi:s:f? ', c.1.

FR'ONL m

af.T"UAusifbitart g dQ $.Qw M, '

%.h e.w;,f(ys%masrIFranchd DSSE vv c~

n.Q WQ w:y$ $ i

potenti'al f rtatups tot reeeurppewer' fEl)1ow$nt. a< mint ritaamp os '

l matin feetl!ine&ambtrrstde eocainment:.. Itiersfork. G55 ti naquested2to

i -7m c

awa:1*uata-the. f6'rmare consavacanE. RSE is: requestadMo, avatlutte.,th..es la.t. t.ar.i - N 3;.'. m x. m& :, D 'y%,QQ.';W[o:.-.

, ~. b v. v l

2*..

. p ' n ? ', w'.:<

~

+

4 f

x;. ' -

. concern.

, s v

Os 0,;.~ w 9 r j%'ln ' m" ~

y ;r c

"A fj; ~ ?

yfe

_ _.',. '%. ;f j ^

  • a g ~; V, l f*

z, y

.Besat on the;onerosed anaTyansVtheGieanseest pilam to. s@sttf an: AEW aute:-

.O

,fn.1tiationLsyites whi'ch,deTay[AFE fl#wt for 3 miputas; asftar the, piptabis h

'ASB cahy a'ce.apN this: faa;tugtf4b8B' one veriif@ taag titsi time: dil'an wliljli f..fl' f stillgcaru;11tfin _sWrietant;weh Teve>llini tha: intacti staar generaitor tF V F

(metntain pr'iinary!sys;taaW6puineh15 a;fter* tb tLibeirdown> cf the) arffiscted ~ l

/

t

-' D'

0"* 9D a'

a_

  • ou J.g1 ) J m;

s( J i-s a

3 1

O F FIO

.8.003 120' g sun ~~

CATO t.

__.__.._L__._.-.r-.%u--~---a-~-- -----------V----------

NRC FORM 318 (9 76) NRCM OP40 D U.Se GM r.nNMENT PRINTING OF rtC E : 1979-289 369

'y;wo mm wa s gy v,m

~r,

. m y~-

n?-

+

s ww

-,y ' ' < n:a.,.

. c y

m;

, y._

.4 5; q.

..m 4~; y y~

+

q;

.* x s

e

'4 y,g '. !

'4 w

,,,e-x.

m,

2,- --
  • 'e % =

'T. Novak and k IrutTer -

+

M. w.M "FEB> L41980, z,

. w 3.,

< x, 1;

c; Y

. ~,

.for CE plants' by; BAO) TE and (2j that' no operator action is required-in.

T;*

Tess, thno -l'0 minutes to blite the affseted SG. and' reU&gn AFW-valves: to b 'M

%gQ direct AfV flom onty' toi the intact S'S,. including. the avatlabtitty of:

suff1ctants i,nstrumentatiipo-toydiagnosas thec situation and; take: co.rrectt m-c. a.

actfanr.

~

ge 5 9. f.7;. 'y/.

r$p yp.Py'

,ny.~

~

A~-

M. Idtbess concMeannoth,re&q 3 3 ;f tie necessarry tha L

m y :n,. nq v3 ;:

>~

livadiffts sa syrtes:automatictibitiatron, stystems contarnt Tosi#eLto automatically tsolategJ, "the affected SG' andt dtne'ett1AN f0'owi'on.12 to.the intact SG.

Thi.s courd; dQ Whatves aima{ortimpast;on.k thoiAPW au,to41:hiitfa'tions s.yst.em dosign.,

, _ ~J. g, j,,.w k gi

/

u... s.y s #. h 1,

,J, N.. -"

w.

4 m.m.

,o

/. e...e I(t< fs h.otad> that(W, ;. ljfeenstear di[d; not, ena'l.yzaJthe e cas e of mais' fesd' liilne' h Mh tseah insitdW contatement armentionedbin' ths' NRC' l:etter of T242S7R.. 'Thisd;1.K'J'/*

-- -:+

.,+

e 2

^

a G'

e f Mt I say noicks%di!fifcanttni't$ onEy: ai3iafnute, delay ik fnitiating AEW fil'aws,i%w.-

a h-M'

.n._ y-

- a s

- q :,. %.4,.., s gpc.

c

~

A.

e

_.s_

N ' Ti'censees das.1rei @

4 q

" 10$8s wiil!1r svailha;ts t!ieiATSauth s,tEnte system. des:tgn..

go

. Mp@.$

. tm res51tveshis fssualWafore mShi'ng;at deefs<ioni on';the modif1satfons:..Y/ou~

h

. ars> requattedt tbt sonfrata' your:$evtewt bE343118_li.( ! '

j.,,3 Z, Tou ave _rer#esta'ditm evadua,tatthat at'tached. analyses'and su

. ;- :eim Q N j.W _,

^

.m:,

y e + y yh eti 1, W c

4e L: L. Genner.LCEPM' fon40thipfants.. Please.aandicopias o.f any: questionst %AQ and(yosr15ERL to; AS3 and. I:0EL.m

., ; i- -

t N

. Mist 1lstens 2 9 asia 3s % f 3 p ? ' '

,,? N,7,

  • - @dj(

- t'- 3; E orfndicatedt ahi'ncrease< radt'o; logical, doesesin' tAav e. venti l%~

oOat stsamt genanstor.tubet pupiurast.ines; t6e turbine. exhausts: dirac.tryEtos a 41'M '

. tee afactphere!.QIift R5blin,s :a.ny;1co:nearns regard;ing the dose' inerense ther.Mf '

r shenT@ coondinatde wGth MA;be e "-

.JW W:

,'s x

,+.

y.-

y
~ x g;

-. q7 x - -

u.

s,

. If you have, addttfonaill techn,tcalFquestions., contact -P. Matthews. k27c760!. Y^","nW

-r

.a

~

+

A $.,iV :ly(u e

, %. ?.mc L I L ',::[ l8-15?..:'.. '*:aNVnal.51Bned\\bY' i.

?

I u.s

+

aw-p' -

2.pp

.~wy,

, w;,w: e y a -

y

< %, g;,,g; /.%. * < n ' Mp.; c,, mm awarma

.,4 Q,,neRJ f

~-

ye

-~,.7 r ;*

M@ ton' Beye, Gntef;

,JM,W:

y m1 f

?Auxtl.tary Systemssetanch-M %.n J A..,.,3$r.l SM.l dT 4tvis ion. o:f~ Sys hams /Safatp'

?,,.R % &,'

.~

E m

q, 9 :. QQR T j g g. $ y,. j J

  • ' ccey/o. attachment'si ' g,7 gg;,4a g,<.

1.

_ ' %.m i

i N M P N #j M"

. !MW, E Rbidk S. $NM ' i gc< ' 'Ci

@[ - [N 'f [ j

.WM

4. Maittson.
YE Mooyu

I.$. jane: 7 %-7 @;zf 7 7 j 1

^.4!

R. Deefso; Rs - Tadea'co.

le - A 7 2 x '.

~

'i

,[1 ^'%.

^

~%LakavaI J.dchwencen Q'Fh,

~.

  • N' i

E'.. E. Gonnor D/..Efemann

~ c,,P, '

cc: w/ attachments

~, '

,m

,, a II. Sattarfield

@ ', opl{g *T O

N If P'. Matthews

.I G. '. Lai nas D. Thatsher J

.c J. Joyce t

DS' ARR D"

SB l DSS:A ornce>.

A g

.4;vaena..n.

sunn4Me). w e a ve.:mc:

.M ttness roya om). 28/ 80 2//f~/80 2/[#/ 80 y

m._

b _ _ _,,._

....m NRC FO AM 318 (4 76)-N RCM 0240

'1$r.us. NMV ER NMENT PRINTING OF FW E. 19 79 289.J69

HANDLED ON JAft 261930 ImtrnIIUurr trrII.rrIES

~ -~s lMJ4"co~t t.wm mm

._;.:., m- =c-l

...;,7,.

7,.,..-. -,

-,, ~sencuro.oi t

eta

z. ' ::::

January 25, 1980 Docket No. 50-336 Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attn:

Mr. R. Reid, Chief Operating Reactors Branch #4 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.

20555

References:

(1)

D. G. Eisenhut letter to All Operating Nuclear Power Plants dated September 13, 1979.

(2)

H. R. Denton letter to All Operating Nuclear Power Plants dated October 30, 1979.

(3)

W. G. Counsil letter to J. Hendrie dated November 30, 1979.

(4)

R. Reid letter to W. G. Counsil dated December 21, 1979.

(5)

H. R. Denton letter to W. G. Counsil dated December 27, 1979.

(6)

W. G. Counsil letter to R. Reid dated February 12, 1979.

(7)

R. Reid letter to W. G. Counsil dated May 12, 1979.

Gentlemen:

Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Unit No. 2 Automatic Initiation of Auxiliary Feedwater In Ref erences (1) and (2), Northeast Nuclear Energy Company (NNECO) was informed of the original Staff requirements regarding the issue of automatic initiatica of auxiliary feedwater. NNECO's ongoing evaluations of this requirement were thoroughly articulated in Ref erence (3), which also forwarded NNECO's determination pursuant to the requirements of 10CFR50.59.

Subsequently, via Reference (4), NNECO was advised of a revision to the Staff directive of References (1) and (2), in that implementation of automatically initiated auxiliary feedwater is prohibited until the NRC completes its review and issues an approval.

In accordance with the Reference (4) request, it is noted that NNECO has continued with the procurement of equipment and proceeded with the installation to the extent possible without activating the automatic-start system or adversely aff ect;ing the manual-start system.

In Reference (5), the Staff accepte and reiterated the need for an anal, NNECO was verbally advised that the Reference (5) results in no additi DUPLICATE DOCUMENT specified in Reference (4).

Theref respond to Reference (4) format. I Entire document previously entered into system under:

ANO No. of pages:

DOCKET NO. 50-336 ATTACHMENT 3 MILLSTONE NUCLEAR POWER STATION, UNIT No

.2 AUIDMATIC INITIATION OF AUXILIARY FEEDWATER 1

- PROPOSED REVISIONS TO TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS i:

DUPLICATE DOCUMENT Entire document previously entered into system under:

^"O No. of pages:

JANUARY, 1980

i BALTIMORE GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY P. O. BOX 1475 BAl TI M O R E. M A RYLA N D 21203 January 25, 1980 ARTwun E. LUNOVALL.JP.

vecc Passios=v s*%,

Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Ccmission Washington, D. C.

20555 Attu:

Mr. Robert W. Reid, Chief Ocerating Reactors Branch A Division of Operating Peactors Sub. ject : Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Rover Plant Units Nos.1 & 2, Dockets Nos. 50-317 5 50-318 Automatic Initiation of Auxiliary Feedvater System

References:

(a) NRC letter dated 12/21/79 from R. W. Reid to A. E. Lundvall, Jr., same sub. ject.

(b) BC&E letter dated 1/22/80 from A. I. Lundvall, Jr.,

to H. R. Denten, Request for Amendment to Opersting Licenses.

Gentlemen:

Reference (a) requested that we provide certain infoz-.stien concernine the effect of our proposed automatic suxilisrr feedvster initiation design on containment pressure and likelihood of a return to ecver following a main steam line bresk. Submitted herein is the infor-estion concerning the main stess line break transient requested in the enciesure of reference (s). We shall not i=nlenent our proposed design for the sutematic initiation of suxilia:f feedvater flev until your approvsl is received.

Technical Specifiestions regsrding the automatie initiation of sux111ary feedvater flev vere sub itted in reference (b).

Very truly yours,

/'

f

.l-m-

cc:

J. A. 31ddison, Esquire G. F. "'rovbridge, Esquire Messrs. Z. L. Conner, Jr.

DUPLICATE DOCUMENT

?. W. Kr'ne - C2 J. W. 3rothers -

Entire document previously entered into s stem under:

ANO No. of pages:

..