ML17334A494

Rev 1 to Program Plan Rept for Detailed Control Room Design Review for Indiana & Michigan Electric Co,Dc Cook Units 1 & 2 to Nrc.

ML17334A494
Person / Time
Site:	Cook
Issue date:	12/02/1983
From:	AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER SERVICE CORP., CANYON RESEARCH CORP., WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML17320A900	List: ML17320A899 ML17334A494
References
RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-737 PROC-831202, NUDOCS 8401040196
Download: ML17334A494 (202)

Text

PROGRAMPLANREPORTforaDETAILEDCONTROLROOMDESIGNREVIEWforIndianaandMichiganElectricCompanyDonaldC.CookUnits1and2toTheUnitedStatesNuclearRegulatoryCommissionRevision1Oecember2,1983preparedbyAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporationandWestinghouse'lectricCorporationCanyonResearchGroup840i04019h83i229,PDRADQCK050003i5F---'PDR TABLEOFCONTENTSSectionTitle~PaeINTRODUCTIONl-l.General1-2.1-6.1-9.Background1-3.PlantDescription1"4.DefinitionofControlRooms1-5.ControlRoomStatusScopeoftheProgramObjectivesoftheProgramDCRDRProgramActivitiesDefinitionofTerms1-21-21-21"31-31-41-51-7MANAGEMENTANDSTAFFING2-1.Purpose2-2.DCRDRTeamInterfaces2-3.ManagementFunction2-4.ProjectReviewTeam2-5.DesignReviewTeam2-6.AssessmentTeam2-12-12-12-12-22-22-4DOCUMENTATIONANDDOCUMENTCONTROL3-1.Introduction3-2.ReferenceDocumentation3-3.DCRDR-GeneratedDocumentation3-4.DocumentControl3-13-13"13-23-3DESCRIPTIONOFPHASEI,PLANNING4-1.Introduction4-2.DCRDRMilestones4-3.ControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaReport4-14-14-16755B:1/112583 TABLEOFCONTENTS(cont)SectionTitle~paeDESCRIPTIONOFPHASEII,REVIEW5-1.Introduction5-2.ReviewPhaseStaffing5-3.MethodologyforReviewPhaseTasks5-4.Task1--OperatingExperienceReview5-5.Task2-SystemFunctionandTaskAnalysis5-6.Task3-ControlRoomInventory,5-7.Task4--ControlRoomHumanFactorsSurvey5-8.WorkspaceSurvey5-9.AnthropometricSurvey5-10.EmergencyEquipmentSurvey5-11.Heating,Ventilating,andAirConditioningSurvey5-12.IlluminationSurvey5-13.AmbientNoiseSurvey5-14.MaintainabilitySurvey5-15.CommunicationsSurvey5-16.AnnunciatorSystemsReview5-17.ControlsSurvey5-18.DisplaysSurvey5-19.LabelsandLocationAids5-20.ComputerSystemReview5-21.ConventionsSurvey5-22.Task5--VerificationofControlRoomFunction5-23.Task6--ValidationofControlRoomFunctions5-24.ProductsoftheReviewPhase5-15-15-15-25-25-35-35-35-45-45-55-45-55-55-55-55-65-65-65-65-65-75-75-75-76755B:1/112583 TABLEOFCONTENTS(cont)SectionTitle~PaeDESCRIPTIONOFPHASEIII-A,ASSESSMENT6-1.Introduction6-2.Methodology6-16-16-2DESCRIPTIONOFPHASEIII-B,IMPLEMENTATION7-1DESCRIPTIONOFPHASEIV,REPORTING8-1COORDINATIONWITHNUREG0737,SUPPLEMENT1,ACTIVITIES9-110QUALITYASSURANCE10-1SUMMARYAppendixALiSTOFABBREVIATIONSA-1AppendixBRESUMESOFKEYPERSONNELB-lAppendixCANNUNCIATORSURVEYTASKPLANC-16755B:1/112583 LISTOFILLUSTRATIONSFi<iureTitie~PaeRelationshipofNUREG0660TaskActionItems1-2GeneralArrangementDrawingofDonaldC.CookUnits1and2ControlRooms1"3FunctionalLayoutDrawingofDonaldC.CookUnit1ControlRoomPanels1-13FunctionalLayoutDrawingofDonaldC.CookUnit2ControlRoomPanels1-151-5ListofAbbreviationsandFunctionsforControlPanels1-171-6FourMajorPhaseActivitiesfortheDCRORProgram1-192-1OCRDRProgramOrganizationStructure2-52-2DCRDRProgramReviewTeamInterfacesDuringPlanning2-72-3OCRORProgramReviewTeamInterfacesDuringReview2-9OCRORProgramReviewTeamInterfacesDuringAssessment2-112"5OCRDRProgramReviewTeamInterfacesDuringImple-mentation2-132-6DCRDRProgramReviewTeamInterfacesDuringReporting2-154-1PlanningPhaseDevelopmentOutline4-34-2OCRDRProgramScheduleforPhasesIandII4-56755B:1/112583 LISTOFILLUSTRATIONS(cont)~FiureTitle~pae6-1AssessmentMethodologyChart6-36-2HumanEngineeringDiscrepancyEvaluationFlowChart6-56-3HEOCategoryGuidelines6-78"1SampleofProgramSummaryReportFormat(2Sheets)8-39-1ScheduleofPerformance9-36755B:1/112583viii SECTIONIINTRODUCTION1-1.GENERALThisProgramPlanReportdescribestheplantoperformadetailedcontrolroomdesignreview(OCROR)oftheDonaldC.CookUnits1and2nuclearpowergenerationstationsoperatedbytheIndianaandMichiganElectricComoany(IEMECo).ThepurposeoftheDetailedControlRoomDesignReviewProgramistostudyandevaluate,fromahumanengineeringpointofview,thetotalcontrolroomworkspace,environment,instrumentation,controls,andotherequipmentforbothsystemdemandsandoperatorcapabilitiesandtoidentify,assess,andrecommendcontrolroomdesignmodifications/enhancementstocorrectidentifiedinadequaciesintheexistingdesign.TheapproachoftheDCRORProgramwillbetoperformatotalreviewontheUnit1controlroom.ThenareviewoftheUnit2controlroomwillbedonetodeterminethedifferencesbetweenunits.TheUnit2controlroomreviewwillbebasedontheresultsoftheUnit1review,withalldifferencesbeingaddressedseparately.Therefore,thisreviewtechniquewillensurethatallasoecsofheUnits1and2control.oomswillbeevaluatedforhuaanrac:ors.ThisprogramispartofanintegratedplantoaddresstheTMI-relatedactionsreferencedinTMI-2ActionPlan,NUREG-0660.TheplanwillincludeaconsiderationoftherelationshiportheDCRORProgramwithNUREG0737,Supplement1(figure1-1),includingthefollowing:I~Designingcontrolroommodificationswhichcorrecconditionsadversetosafety(reducingsignificantcontributionstorisk)andconsideringtheadditionoftheinstrumentationnecessarytoimplementRegulatoryGuide1.976755B:I/062883

~Verifyingthesafetyparameterdisplaysystem(SPOS),datadisplay,andfunction~Usingselectedplant-specific,symptom-basedemergencyoperatingproceduresforverifyingandvalidatingcontrolroomfunctions~CommunicationinterfacewiththeTechnicalSupportCenter,EmergencyOperationsFacility,andtheOperatingSupportCenterIKMECohascommittedthenecessaryresources,includingYnowleageablemanagementandtechnicalpersonnelfromtheplantstaff,AmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporation(AEPSC).technicalconsultantsfromWestinghouseElectricCorporation,andhumanactorsspecialistsFromCanyonResearchGrouptoeffectheprogramcefinedherein.1-2.BACKGROUNO1-3PlantOes-,i-tonTheIndianaanaMichiganElectricCompanyiscurrentlyooeratingatwo-unitnuclearpowerplantlocatedalongtheeasternshoreofLakeMichiganinLakeTownship,BerrienCounty,Michigan,approximateiy'milessouth-souhwestorBentonHarbor.ThisFaciliyhasbeendesignatedtheDonaldC.CookUr.i:s1and2wnichbegancommercialoperationinAugustof1975andJulyor1979,'esoectively.=achunitcontainssWestinghouse-suppliedfour-loopnuclearsteamsuoplysystem(Unit1-3250M<t,1030KdeNetandUnit2-3411'Kft,1100i&feNet).'oneturbinegeneratorsforUnits1and2wererurnisnedoyGeneral"=;ectricancBrownBoveri,respectively.Thearchitect~'engineerForbothuni:sisAEPSC.1-4.OefinitionofControlRoomsTheOonaldC.CookUnits1and2controlroomsareessentiallyidentical.Thecontrolroomforeachunitisdefined,ForthepurposesoftheOCRDRProgram,6755B:I/0628831-2 asthepanelsandotherequipmentinthemaincontrolboardareaincludingtheSPDSdisplaysandthehotshutdownpanels.Ageneralarrangementdrawingisillustratedinfigure1-2;functionallayoutdrawingsofthecontrolroompanelsareshowninfigures1-3and1-4,andacomprehensivetabulationofthismaterialisshowninfigure1-5.1"5.ControlRoomStatusThemaincontrolboardsareoperationalandcompleteexceptforthoseareasofactivitywhicharenowbeingperformedtoaddresstherequirementssetforthbyNUREG0737,Supplement1.1-6.SCOPEOFTHEPROGRAMTheDetailedControlRoomDesignReviewProgramcoversthehumanengineeringreviewoftheverticaloperationalandassociatedhotshutdownpanelsidentifiedinparagraph1-4,andthecontrolroomworkspaceandenvironment.Theequipmenttobereviewedincludesalldisplays,controls,peripheralconsoles,communicationequipment,ancillarydevices,andothermaincontrolboardcomponentswithwhichthecontrolroomoperatorsinterface.Duringthereviewprocess,thegovernmentregulationsandguidelineslistedbelowandotherrelatedindustrystandardsandguidelineswillbeusedforinformationorbackground:~NUREG0659(staffsupplementto1580)~NUREG0660(actionplanasaresultofTMI-2accident)~NUREG0694(TMI-relatedrequirementfornewoperatinglicensees)~NUREG0696(functionalcriteriaforemergencyresponsefacilities)"~NUREG0700(controlroomhumanengineeringguidelines)~NUREG0737(clarificationofTMIactionplanrequirements)6755B:I/0628831-3

~NUREG0737,SupplementI(requirementsforemergencyresponsecapability)eNUREG0801(draftevaluationcriteriaforcontrolroomdesignreview)~NUREG0814(methodologyforevaluationofemergencyresponsefacilities)~NUREG0835(humanfactorsacceptancecriteriaforSPDS)~NUREG0899(guidelinesforthepreparationofemergencyoperatingprocedures)~RegulatoryGuide1.47(bypassedandinoperablestatusindication)~RegulatoryGuide1.97,Revision2(postaccidentmonitoringinstrumentation)1-7.OBJECTIVESOFTHEPROGRAMTheDetailedControlRoomDesignReviewProgramwillbeconductedtoachievethefollowingobjectives:~Determinewhethertheexistingcontrolroomdesignprovidesthesystemstatusinformation,controlcapabilities,feedback,andanalyticalaidsnecessaryforcontrolroomoperatorstoperformtheirfunctionseffectively~Identifycharacteristicsoftheexistingcontrolroominstrumentation,controls,otherequipment,andphysicalarrangementswhichmaysignificantlyimpair/impedecontrolroomoperatorperformance~Analyzeandevaluatetheproblemswhichcouldoccurduringemergencyconditions,andidentifymeansofcorrectingthosediscrepancieswhichcouldleadtosubstantialoperationalorsafetyconcerns6755B:I/0628831-4

~Verifyandvalidatetheproposedmeansofcorrectiontoprovideaneffectiveplanofactionwhichapplieshumanfactorsprinciplestoimprovethecontrol'oomdesignandenhanceoperatorefficiencyandeffectiveness~IntegratetheOCRDRProgramwithotherareaofhumanfactorsidentifiedintheNRCTaskActionPlan~Provideeffectivecoordinationofcontrolroomenhancementsand/ormodificationswithidentificationsofNUREG0696andRegulatoryGuide1.97considerations,plantoperating/emergencyproceduresdevelopment,andtheimplementationoftrainingasnecessarytoensurethatcontrolroomoperatorscanfunctionadequatelywithanycontrolroomdesignchanges~EnsurethattheresultsofthistotaleffortmeettheintentofNUREG0737,ItemI.D.l,andNUREG0700.Inaddition,performtheOCRORProgramcognizantofthesedocumentsasclarifiedinNUREG0737,Supplement1,Item5.2.a1-8.OCRORPROGRAMACTIVITIESThedesignreviewprocesswilladdressfourmajorphasesofactivity(figure1-6):oPHASEIPLANNiNG(section,4).TheProgramPlanReportfortheD.C.CookUnits1and2DCRORandthepreliminaryControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteria(CRHEC)Reportwillprovidethebasisforthedesignreview.~PHASEII--REVIEW(section.5).DuringtheReview'hase,datawillbecollected,reduced,andanalyzedtoobserveanddocumentwhethertheexistingcontrolroomdesignprovidesoperatorswiththecapabilitiesnecessarytoperformtheirfunctionandtasksundernormaland67558:1/0628831-5 emergencyoperatingconditions.ResultsofPhaseIIactivitywillgeneratetasksummaryreportsandalistingofdeparturesfromtheControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaReport.~PHASEIII-A-ASSESSMENT(section6).Ouringthisphase,anassessmentwillbemadeofthesignificanceandimpactofthedeparturesfromtheCRHECreportsidentifiedinPhaseII.Forthose'departuresassessedassignifi-cant,recommendeddesignchanges/enhancementswillbedeveloped.oPHASEIII-B--IMPLEMENTATION(section7).AftertheassessmenthasIIbeencompletedandallcorrectiveactionsidentified,aschedulewillbedevelopedtoensuretheintegrationoftheproposedcontrolroomchangeswithotherpost-TMIprograms,refuelingoutages,andothercompanymodifications.~PHASEIVREPORTING(section8).AProgramSummaryReportwillbepreparedwhichwilldocumenttheoverallreviewprocess,describeandidentifyallofthehumanengineeringdiscrepancies'andfindings,andsummarizeallOCRORactivities,methodologies,andproposedcontrolroomimprovementsandschedules.EachphasewillbeperformedbyateamofspecialistsfromI&MECo,AEPSC,Westinghouse,andCanyonResearchGroup.Oisciplinesrepresentedontheteamwillincludeinstrumentationandcontrolengineering,nuclearsafetyandli-censing,electricalengineering,humanfactors,plantoperations,qualityassurance,projectengineering,andtrainingtomaximizetheefficiencyoftheeffortandtocompletethetotalreviewidentifiedinthisProgramPlanReport.6755B:I/0628831-6 I"9.DEFINITIONOFTERMSAlistofabbreviationsandacronymsiscontainedinappendixAtothisreport.Also,toalleviateambiguityofterms,thefollowingdefinitionsareprovided:ControlRoomEnhancement.Achangetoapiece'ofequipment,suchasacontrolpanel,whichcanbeperformedwithoutinterferingwiththeoperationofthatequipment.Suchchangesmightincludetheapplicationoflabelsordemarcationlines.ControlRoomModification.Achangetoapieceofequipment,suchasacontrolpanel,whichislikelytointerferewiththeoperationofthatequipmentonwhichthechangeisbeingperformed.Suchchangesincludetheremovalorrelocationofanexistingcontrolpanelcomponentortheadditionofapanelcomponent.EmerencOperatinProcedures.Plantprocedureswhichguide,theoperator(s)duringatransientoremergencycondition.EmerencResponseGuidelines.Symptom-basedguidelinesfromwhichemergencyoperatingproceduresaredeveloped.HumanEnaineerin.Thescienceofoptimizingtheperformanceofhumanbeingsandthedesignofequipmentformoreefficientusebyhumanbeings'umanEnoineerinDiscreanc.Adeparturefromtheestablishedhumanfactorscriteriaforthecontrolroomdesignwhichcouldimpair/impedeoperatorperformance.Photomosaic.Ascaledphotographicreproductionofthemaincontrolroompanels.SafetParameterDislaSstem.Displaysystemwhichprovidescontinuousindicationofplantparameterstoassistcontrolro'ompersonnelinevaluatingthesafetystatusoftheplant.6755B:I/0628831-7 Validation.Theprocessofdeterminingwhetherthephysicaldesignsupportstheproceduresforoperationinanadequatemannertosupporteffectiveintegratedperformanceofthefunctionsofthecontrolroomoperatingcrew.Verification.Theprocessofdeterminingwhetherinstrumentation,controls,andotherequipmentmeetthespecificrequirementsofthetasksperformedbyoperators.6755B:1/062883 PLANT'CIFICEMERGENCYOPERATINGPROCEDURES(EOPs)NUREG0899SYMPTOM-BASEDOPERATINGANDEMERGENCYPROCEDURESNUREG0799NUREG0660I.C.1,I.C.8,&I.C.9CHANGESINREQUIREMENTSFORTRAININGANDSTAFFINGNUREG0660I.A.1&IA.2TMIACTIONPLANNUREG0660NUREG0737DETAILEDCONTROLROOMDESIGNREVIEWPRELIMINARYCONTROLROOMHUMANENGINEERINGCRITERIAREPORTPROGRAMPLANREPORTNUREG0700PRCAPERTURECARDDCRDRPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORT'OST-ACCIDENTMONITORINGINSTRUMENTATIONREG.GUIDE1.97'AlsoAvailable6zApertureCardSAFETYPARAMETERDISPLAYSYSTEMNUBEG0660,III,A.12NUREG0835EMERGENCYRESPONSEFACILITYNUREG0696NUREG0814Figurel-l.RelationshipofNUREG0660TaskActionItems1-9s401040196-o) 0PN UNIT1CONTROLROOMUNIT2CONTROLROOMUNIT2HOTSHUTDOWNAREAUNIT1HOTSHUTDOWNAREAFigure1-2.GeneralArrangementDrawingofDonaldC.CookUnits1and2ControlRooms BARCOTUSGPRZFPRCPCPRHROPERATOR'SCONSOLEPSSOCRTASISSPYPSSCRTBRMSBISICRTCRTCRTCCWESWNESWCOMPUTEROPERATOR'SCONSOLETYPEWRITERSANISIVVSSVEFRMSCABINETFFCMFXAPOMSFlCWFigure1-3.FunctionalLayoutOrawingofOonaldC.CookUnit1ControlRoomPanels6755B:1/0628831-13 PANELFFCMFXAPDMSFIDCABINETCWSVEFVSIVNISSANESWTYPEWRITER+COMPUTEROPERATOR'SCONSOLEESWCCWBISIBISIRMSCRTCRTPSSDCRTBSPYSISCPPSSDCRTAOPERATOR'SCONSOLERHRRCPFPPRZSGDTURCFLXBAFigure1-4.FunctionalLayoutDrawingofDonaldC.CookUnit2ControlRoomPanels67558:1/0628831-15 FLXRCOTUSGFPCPSABAPRZRCPRHRSISSPYCCWESWFluxPanelRodControlPanelOe)taTandUnitPanelSteamGeneratorPanelFeedPumpPanelCondensatePolishingPanelCondensatePanelTurbinePanelStationAuxiliaryPanelGeneratorPanelBoricAcidPanelPressurizerPanelReactorCoolantPumpPanelResidualHeatRemovalPanelSafety'injectionSystemPanelContaiqmentSprayPanelComponentCoolingWaterPanelEssentialServiceWaterPanelNESW-NonessentialServiceWaterPanelIVVSEFSVNISFIRMSFFCMFXAPMSFIDRMSCWIsolationValvesPanelVents.latlonPanelEmergencyFirePanelPlantServicePanelNuclearInstrumentationCabinetsFixedIn-CorePanelRadiationMonitoringSystemPanelFailedFuelCommunicationsPanelMovableIn-coreCabinetAxialPowerDistributionMonitoringSystemCabinetFixedIn-coreCabinetRadiationMonitoringSystemCabinetCirculatingWaterPanelFigureI"5.ListofAbbreviationsandFunctionforControlPanels6755B:I/0628831-17 ugQIz0ZUJa2cgCg5zUgCLCL+CaCaCCCa>OOOOCCCa0Z.CLug00.Coa:20II2ug0CLChz0IOOCC2agag'D22Ezcn00IOOIUOILZ~gI-0UgI2ulcnlu0OQZJugugzE~a~CCnugulooluUlCnDluggIL~~cn0ca220ID0ICn208t'TIILI<Icaa.(-5O)Qm]I>UgIch>)L(Jo+0OoUg0Zca>ZcaOzOzOZILcaOg00caI-Zl-gl-oIOlu0g2oguoZ~X..-~cucnug~IUlu~gcnZZ<)I-I-Oolu0CCZUJCL~ugca~o<ca<zoxwc@InviaUJ20ID0CnID200zoO2gzI20II2I0I0cn<2IL00hl-CLEOCZDC)20IO2E0OOcaIO2zCJ022020CCD2IZIuOIu324gz82g02CCoo0ggOI-iogvzCCgIlgg0IUgluluI~>2cav0UgNOgcn2ca-QWQI5ICCcn20-2IUOIUE~C0CJCaIQZQ0cC4caaug0.0.caQPgOzCaOOZCCCCg'2Oa.UgY)calu0OQ2luOQlZIU0,coQOzl-22Ug~UugILca300caIZCLIL2CaIOOCUCaIVIUQ2+2CLugcaca~a<2~O.ZUJ<OgzaCCUl)CUE~lugaoca00.ZVYcaIXIU0ZcaZQgOcaI00>CCu.CJCaKx<CLUliIca)~COIQ~0~2luz~caa:COOI-zca2+~ZCC00.5caI-UJQlucfO0I->ILa:~CC0zoIuI-0QcgtcocaQ0gI>2cacnIL0UICJUJIgZYVIu00Iu0gaZZILUgO20IIUO0I~ILIUCL02CC22Ul2CCIOQugDozzu.0.I~R0oOu.2CCII-UgOoCLUJ~IUl(yO2ooIL-CacnZCaPuQO-coVzUgILCCN0CU>cnUga2cazX~QCnol<~u00Ugcap<00.ILozcn0CCIZOQZ<u.2IU~IUugIuzozozUgILZQZo8~~Iul~QcaZCn02ozozol=$zcagEa:CCPy400caca0II220UgVQUJIUI<0IP2ECaCaCCCao020ca02a.OKRaIZCClgJOg00.Icag000luO~CQ2caIL2I0D2cnCC0.Co2CCI-zo0.UgQCnZ0I0IUILIUIUIZ:zzQOo~~ugIU1CLIIzIII20I~CzI-o2-luI0.0.FgoOPRCAPERTURECAROI0oIL2DZOQ200a.~,0g~gaableOILApertureCard$-0$-0ncclcoI1-198401040196W~2 04t~(f~U, SECTION2MANAGEMENTANDSTAFFING2-1.PURPOSEThepurposeofthissectionistoidentifytheOCRORProgramteamsandtheirareasofresponsibility.Figure2-1detailstheorganizationalstructureofpersonnelinvolvedintheOCRORProgram.(}ualificationsofkeypersonnelareprovidedinappendixB.AllpersonnelontheDonaldC.CookOCRDRProgramteamswillmeetorexceedthequalificationsprovidedinNUREG0801andrelatedguidance.2-2.DCRDRTEAMINTERFACEToeffectivelyperformtheDCRORProgramandstillbeabletobesuccessfullyaudited,aninterfacebetweenthevariousreviewteamsisrequired.The"OCRDRProgramLeadEngineer"willbetheprimarycontactandliasionforthemanagementorganization,designreview,projectreview,andassessmentteams.Figures2-2through2-6showthesevariousinterfaces.2-3.MANAGEMENTFUNCTIONThemanagementfunctionfortheOCRDRProgramwillbeprovidedunderpreviouslyestablishedAEPSCproceduralrequirementsandresponsibilitiesdefinedinAEPSCGeneralProcedure25,"EngineeringDesignChanges,"andGeneralProcedure32,"PreparationofSubmittalstotheU.S.NuclearRegulatoryCommission."Thefunctionofmanagementisto:~Approvethe'ProgramPlanReport~ReviewandapproverecommendatonsforcontrolroomdesignchangesI6755B:I/0628832-1

~ProvidetheresourcesnecessaryforimplementationoftheDCROR~ApprovetheProgramSummaryReport~ProvidethemechanismforthepreparationandsubmittalofdocumentstotheU.S.NuclearRegulatoryCommission.,2-4.PROJECTREVIEWTEAMTheProjectReviewTeamwillcoordinatetheDCRORProgram.Typicalteamfunctionsareto:~ApproveTaskPlanspriortoperformanceofassociatedReviewTaskA~EnsurethattheDCRDRProgramisperformedinaccordancewiththeAEPSCgualityAssuranceProgram~ProvideoverallsupporttotheDCRORprocess~MonitortheDCRORprogressoEnsurethatthedesignreviewobjectivesandtasks,inrelationtootherNUREG0660efforts,areproperlycoordinated~EstablishandinitiateacontrolroomimprovementprogramKeypersonnelfortheProjectReviewTeamareidentifiedinfigure2-1.2-5.DESIGNREVIEWTEAMTheDesignReviewTeamcomprisesthequalifiedmultidisciplinepersonneltoperformthevariousreviewfunctions.Theareasofexpertiseinclude:~NSSSandbalance-of-plantsystems~Instrumentationandcontrol6755B:1/062883r2-2

~Conrolboarddesign~Humanfactors~Plantoperations(licensedoperators)~Training~Licensing/nuclearsafetyThefunctionoftheDesignReviewTeamistocarryouttheentiredesignreviewprograminaccordancewiththeguidelinesdetailedinthisProgramPlanReport.DesignReviewTeamresponsibilitiesincludethefollowing:~DeveloptheProgramPlanReport~DeveloptheLicenseeEventReportReviewReport~DeveloptheControlRoomInventory~Developforms/checklists~DevelopTaskPlansoDevelopControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaReportoPerformReviewTasks~DevelopTaskSummaryReports~AssistAssessmentTeamastechnicalsupport~,DevelopImplementationPlans~DeveloptheProgramSummaryReport6755B:I/0628832-3 KeypersonnelfortheDesignReviewTeamareidentifiedinfigure2-1.2-6.ASSESSMENTTEAMTheAssessmentTeamwill:~EvaluatethesignificanceoftheobserveddeparturesfromtheCRHECReportidentifiedinthePhaseIIreview~Identifytheapplicabledeparturesashumanengineeringdiscrepancies(HED)~AssignacategoryandprioritytotheHEDsforschedulingofcorrectiveaction~Review/approvecontrolroomrecommendationsforHEDcorrectiveactionpriortooriginationofarequestforchange(AEPSCprocedure25).KeypersonnelfortheAssessmentTeamareidentifiedinfigure2-1.6755B:I/0628832-4 P10J1CZREVIZÃTEAM*DCBDRProgramMninistrator:A.S.Grims*DCRDRProgramLeadEngineer:R.F.Shoemaker*DCRDRProgramPlantCoordinator:T.R.Stephens*DCRDRProgramProjectEngineer:F.VanPelt,Jr.*DCRDRProgramManager(Westinghouse):J.D.Young*~SCHumanFactorsConsultant:Dr.T.SheridanDESIGNREVI1%TEAM*DCRDRProgramAdministrator:A.S.Grieves*DCBDRProgramLeadEngineer/AEPSCI&CEngineer:R.F.Shor*AEPSCNuclearSafety&LicensingEngineer:K.J.Toth*I&MEG3ReactorOperators*DCRDRProgramPlantCoordinator:T.R.Stephens*AEPSCQualityAssuranceEngineer:J.B.Brittan~*DCRDRProgramProjectEngineer:F.VanPelt,Jr.*AEPSCElectricalEngineer:L.P.~co*DCRDRProgramManager(Westinghouse):J.D.Young*DCRDRHumanFactorsConsultant(CanyonResearch):Dr.G.A.Elliff*I&MECO&WestinghouseTrainingPersonnel*WestinghouseTrainingPersonnel:R.J.WartenbergASSESSMENTTEAM*DCRDRProgramAdnunistrator:A.S.Grimes*DCRDRProgramLeadEngineer:R.F.Shor*AEPSCI&CSectionManager:J.C.Jeffrey*AEPSCNuclearSafetyandLicensingSectionManager:J.G.Feinstein*D.C.CookPlantManagemnt:B.A.Svensson*AEPSCHumanFactorsConsultant:Dr.T.Sheridan*I&MECOSeniorReactorOperator(s)*ArPSCManagerofQualityAssurance:R.F.Kroeger*AEPSCElectricalGenerationSectionManager:R.C.CarruthFigure2-1.DCRDRProgramOrganizationStructure6755B:1/0628832-5

DESIGNREVIEWTEAM~PREPAREPROGRAMPLANREPORTPROJECTREVIEWTEAMI~APPROVEPROGRAMPLANREPORTPROGRAMPLANREPORTACCEPTABLESUPERVISORYREVIEW/COMMENTSYESAEPSCGENERALPROCEDURENO.32"PREPARATIONOFSUBMITTALSTONRC"MANAGEMENTORGANIZATION~SUBMITPROGRAMPLANREPORTTONRCPROGRAMPLANREPORTNRC6755B:I/070583Figure2-2.PersonnelInterfaceandInformationFlowDiagramforPhaseI,Planning2-7 DESIGNREVIEWTEAM~DEVELOPTASKPLAN~DEVELOPCONTROLROOMINVENTORY~PERFORMREVIEW~DEVELOPLERREVIEWREPORT~~DEVELOPTASKSUMMARYREPORT~DEVELOPFORMS/CHECKLISTS~DEVELOPCRHECREPORTSUPERVISORYREVIEW/COMMENTPROJECTREVIEWTEAM~REVIEW/APPROVE/COMMENT-TASKSUMMARYREPORT-FORMS/CHECKLISTSNOTASKSUMMARYREPORTACCEPTANCEYESINPUTTOPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTSEEFIGURE2406755B:I/070583eFigure2-3.PersonnelInterfaceandInformationFlowDiagramforPhaseII,Review2-9 ASSESSMENTTEAM~DETERMINESIGNIFICANCEOFHEDS~REVIEW/APPROVECONTROLROOMENHANCEMENTS/RETROFITSDESIGNREVIEWTEAM~ASSISTINHEDEVALUATION~DEVELOPFINALCRHECDOCUMENTSUPERVISORYREVIEW/COMMENTPROJECTREVIEWTEAM~REVIEW/COMMENT/APPROVE-FINALCRHECDOCUMENT-ASSESSMENTREPORTSUPERVISORYREVIEW/COMMENTNOASSESSMENTREPORTACCEPTANCEYESINPUTTOPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTSEEFIGURE2.60Figure2-4.PersonnelInterfaceandInformationFlowDiagramforPhaseIII-A,Assessment6755B:I/0705832-11 SUPERVISORYREVIEW/COMMENTNOCONTROLROOMIMPLEMENTATIONDOCUMENTACCEPTABLEYESASSESSMENTTEAM~DEVELOPCONTROLROOMIMPLEMENTATIONREPORT~DEVELOPIMPLEMENTATIONSCHEDULEDESIGNREVIEWTEAM~ASSISTINDEVELOPMENTOFCONTROLROOMIMPLEMENTATIONREPORT~ASSESSCONTROLROOMIMPROVEMENTSFORDEPARTURESFROMTHECRHECDOCUMENTPROJECTREVIEWTEAM~REVIEW/COMMENTAPPROVECONTROLROOMIMPLEMENTATIONREPORTAEPSCGENERALPROCEDURENO.25"ENGINEERINGDESIGNCHANGE"MANAGEMENTFUNCTION~REVIEW/APPROVECONTROLROOMENHANCEMENTS/MODIFICATIONSSEEFIGURE24CFigure2-5.PersonnelInterfaceandInformationFlowDiagramforPhaseIII-B,Implementation6755B:I/0705832-13 DESIGNREVIEWTEAM~DEVELOPPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTSUPERVISORYREVIEW/COMMENTPROJECTREVIEWTEAM~REVIEW/COMMENT/APPROVEPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTACCEPTABLEYESNOASSESSMENTREPORTSFROMFIGURE24BTASKSUMMARYREPORTSFROMFIGURE2.3APROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTMANAGEMENTFUNCTION~APPROVEPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORT~SUBMITPROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTTONRCCONTROLROOMIMPLEMENTATIONREPORTFROMFIGURE2-5CAEPSCGENERALPROCEDURENO.32"PREPARATIONOFSUBMITTALSTONRC"PROGRAMSUMMARYREPORTNRCFigure2-6.PersonnelInterfaceandInformationFlowDiagramforPhaseIV,Reporting6755B:I/0705832-15 SECTION3DOCUMENTATIONANDDOCUMENTCONTROL3-1.INTRODUCTIONAcompleteandup-to-datelibraryofreferenceinformationisnecessarytomanageandperformthevariousphasesoftheDCRDRProgram.Thislibrarywillprovidesupportduringthedesignreviewaswellasadatabaseforfuturecontrolroommodifications.3"2.REFERENCEDOCUMENTATIONThefollowingdocumentationwillbeusedduringthereviewphase:~.Controlroomdrawings(panellayouts,floorplan,andthelike)~Controlboardequipmentspecifications~Controlpanelphotographs(photomosaic)~Controlroompreliminaryassessments~Descriptionofcodingconventions~OriginalandUpdatedFSARforD.C.CookUnits1and2~Instrumentationandcontroldiagrams~Operatortrainingmaterial~Systemsfunctiontaskanalysis6755B:1/0628833-1

~Listsofacronymsandabbreviations~Pipingandinstrumentationdrawings~Plantcomputersoftwaredescriptionandsampleprintout~Procedures(emergency,normal,andthelike)~Systemdescriptions~RegulatoryguidesandNUREGs(paragraph1-6)~Controlroominventorylist~AEPSCqualityassuranceprocedure~LicenseeeventreportsAnyadditionalreferencematerialidentifiedbythedesignreviewteamduringthereviewphase(PhaseII)willbeobtainedandaddedtothelibrary.BecauseO.C.CookUnits1and2areoperating,accesstothecontrolroomswillbelimited.Therefore,photomosaicswillbeusedtaperformmostofthetasksoutlinedinsection5.3-3.OCROR-GENERATEODOCUMENTATIONThedocumentationgeneratedbythedesignreviewprocesswillbesubjecttothosecontrolsidentifiedinparagraph3-4.ThefollowingdocumentationwillbeproducedbytheOCRORprocess:oProgramPlanReport(thisdocument)~Controlroomoperatingpersonnelsurveys6755B:I/0628833-2

~Controlroominventory~Controlroomhumanfactorsurveys~Taskplans,checklists,datacollectionforms,sketches,photographs,andphotomosaicsusedinthereviewand.assessment/recommendationphases~Controlroomhumanengineeringcriteriareport~Licenseeeventreport(LER)review~ProgramSummaryReport3-4.DOCUMENTCONTROLAcontrolled-accessfilewillbeestablishedforallhardcopyDCRDRProgramoutputdocuments.Inaddition,thesedocumentswillbeenteredintoacomputer-baseddatasystem.AccesstothesefileswillbecontrolledbytheDCRDRprogrammanager.67558:1/0628833-3 P.Ill SECTION4DESCRIPTIONOFPHASEI,PLANNING4-I.INTRODUCTIONTheplanningphaseconsistsofdevelopingawell-definedworkprogramwhichoutlinesspecificrecommendationsforpersonnel,referencematerial,anddocumentationneededtoperformtheDetailedControlRoomDesignReviewProgram(figure4-1).IEMECointendstocommencewiththeDCRDRProgramasdocumentedinthisProgramPlanReportpriortoformalacceptancebytheNRC.AnydeficienciesnotedinthisProgramPlanReportshouldbebroughttotheattentionofaI&MECoinatimelymanner.FinalacceptanceofthisdocumentwillendthePlanningPhase.4-2.DCRDRMILESTONESAscheduleforPhasesIandIIofthisProgramPlanwasdevelopedandisincludedasfigure4-2.AsstatedintheI8MECoresponsetoG.L.82-33(AEP:NRC:0773)onApril15,1983,anintermediatemilestoneresponsewillbesumittedtotheNRCwiththecurrentstatusoftheDCRDRProgramonSeptember1,1984.Atthattime,PhasesIandIIwillbeessentiallycompleted,andanestimateforthePhaseIII-AAssessmentwillbedevelopedshortlythereafter.TheNRCwillbeprovidedwithmoredetailedinformationregardingPhaseIII-AAssessmentschedule(inanotherintermediatemilestoneresponse)whenthisestimatehasbeenmadeandtheevaluationofitiscompleted.4-3.CONTROLROOMHUMANENGINERINGCRITERIAREPORTwAtthebeginningofthereviewphase,apreliminaryControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaReportwillbedeveloped.Thispreliminarycriteriareportwillcontain,asabaseline,detailedTaskPlanswhichwillbeexecutedtocompletespecificPhaseIIReviewTaskswithintheDCRDRProgram.TheTask6755B:I/0628834-1 Planshavebeenproveneffectiveonover20humanfactorscontrolroomreviews.TheTaskPlanswillprovideadetailedaudittrailtothegenericguidelinesprovidedinNUREG0700,yethavebeenrestructuredtofacilitatethedatacollection,documentation,andauditingrequirementsinherentinaNUREG0700orientedDCRDRProgram.BasedonobservationsandassessmentsoftheDCRDRProgram,thegenericguidelinesofNUREG0700foundinthepreliminaryCRHECReportwillberevisedtoreflectplant-specificdesignconventionsandplant-specifichumanfactorscriteria.AsectionofthefinalCRHECReportwillbededicatedtodeparturesfromNUREG0700withtheapplicablejustificationprovidedtherein.ThefinalCRHECReportisintendedtoensurethatanyfuturecontrolboardmodificationsreflectpreviouslyevaluatedhumanfactorspracticesanddonotdetractfromoperabilityofthecontrolboard.6755B:1/0628834-2 REVIEWOVERALLDCRDRPROGRAMOBJECTIVESEVALUATEOBJECTIVES&DESIGNGUIDELINESTOBEUSEDIDENTIFYRESOURCESREQUIREDOUTLINEALLREVIEWTASKSTOBEPERFORMEDASPARTOFTHEDCRDRPROGRAMDEVELOPTHEDCRDRPROGRAMSCHEDULEISSUEPROGRAMPLANREPORT~ASSESSACTIVITIESCOMPLETEDBYAEPSCANDl&MECo~EMERGENCYOPERATINGPROCEDURES,~DESIGNCRITERIAINCLUDINGPLANTSPECIFICITEMS~NUREG066007000801~DEFINEPROGRAMSTHATHAVEANIMPACTONCONTROLROOMDESIGN(NUREG0696,REGULATORYGUIDE1.97)~DEFINERELATIONSHIPWITHOTHEREMERGENCYRESPONSEACTIVITY~PRELIMINARYCRHECREPORT~FINALSAFETYANALYSISREPORT~SYSTEMDESCRIPTIONS~PIPINGANDINSTRUMENTATIONDRAWINGS~FLOORPLANS~PANELLAYOUTS~ABBREVIATIONSANDCODING'SOFTWAREDESCRIPTIONS~PROCEDURES~OPERATORTRAININGANDEXPERIENCE~TASK1-OPERATINGEXPFRIENCEREVIEW~TASK2'-SYSTEMFUNCTIONSREVIEWANDTASKANALYSIS~TASK3-CONTROLROOMINVENTORY~TASK4-CONTROLROOMHUMANFACTORSURVEY~TASK5-VERIFICATIONOFTASKPERFORMANCE~TASK6-VALIDATIONOFCONTROLROOMFUNCTIONS~AEPSCANDl&MECoINPUTSTOSCHEDULE~REVIEWPROCESS~METHODOLOGY~TEAMQUALIFICATIONS~DESIGNGUIDELINES~SCHEDULE~INTERFACEREQUIREMENTSOFPARTICIPANTS~DOCUMENTATIONANDDOCUMENTCONTROLPRC.;APERTURECAROFigure4-1.PlanningPhaseDevelopmentOutlineI4-38401040i96~Q

]~>CQ7 19831984MAYJUNEJULYAUGSEPTOCTNOVDECJANFEBMARAPRMAYJUNEJULYAUGSEPTOCTNOVDECJUNE27PLANNINGPHASEI~PLANNINGPPRToNRCPPRToNRCJAN1PHASEII-REVIEWTASK1LERREVIEWCROPSLERREVIEWSEPT1OCT1NOV1CROPSJAN2CROPSMAY22JUNE1TASK2SFRTATASK3CRITASK4CRHFSTASK5VERIFICATIONTASK6VALIDATIONPHASEIIIDETAILEDESTIMATIONCRISEPT1OCTIMAR22JAN29MAR25iUNITNo.2)OUTAGECRHFSNOTE1JUNE30JULY14AUG15VERIF.SEPT1OCT6OCT20VALID.NOV1NOV22COMPLIESWITHSUPPLEMENT1NUREG0737PARAGRAPH52.A"LICENSEESSHALLSUBMITPROGRAMPLANWITHINTWOMONTHSFROMSTARTOFDCRDR."~AEPSCANDINDIANAANDMICHIGANACTIVITY~~DCRDRREVIEWTEAMACTIVITYNOTE1CRHFSACTIVITIESMAYOCCURINPARALLELWITHCROPS.CRHFSSUMMARYREPORTDUEJUNE30,1984.Figure4-2.DCRDRProgramScheduleforPhasesIandII SECTION5DESCRIPTIONOFPHASEII,REVIEW5-1.INTRODUCTIONDuringtheReviewPhaseoftheD.C.CookDCRDRProgram,datawillbecollectedandhumanfactorsissueswillbereviewed.Thus,theobjectiveoftheReviewPhaseisthecollectionofdataidentifyingattributesoftheD.C.CookUnits1and2controlroomswhichdepartfromcriteriaspecifiedintheD.C.CookControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaReport(paragraph4-3).TheReviewPhasewillgenerate:oTaskSummaryReportsforeachmajorreviewphasetaskspecifyingmethodsusedandfindings~Componentsheetsspecifyingthefindingsofeachtaskrelatedtoeachcomponentinthecontrolroom~Checklistobservationformsdocumentingdeparturesfromthehumanengineeringcriteriaestablishedbeforeandduringthereviewphase5-2.REVIEWPHASESTAFFINGTheReviewPhasewillbeconductedbytheDesignReviewTeam.RepresentativesofI&MECo,AEPSC,Westinghouse,andCanyonResearchGroupwillbeincludedontheteam.Appropriatedisciplinesfromtheseorganizationswillbeincludedoneachtaskteam.DesignReviewTeammembersinclude:~Systemdesignersandanalysts~Humanfactorsconsultants~Controlboarddesigners6755B:1/0628835-1

~Instrumentationandcontrolengineers~Plantoperators~Licensingengineers~Datamanagementtechnicians~Electricalengineers~gualityassuranceengineers5-3.METHODOLOGYFORREVIEWPHASETASKSThemethodologyfortheReviewPhasetaskswillconsistofexecutingTaskPlansandcompletinghumanengineeringsurveysasreflectedintheD.C.CookControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaReport.5-4.Task1--0eratinExerienceReviewTheoperatingexperiencereviewconsistsoftworelatedactivities.ThefirstisareviewofplantperformancerecordsforD.C.CookUnits1and2(andareviewofLERsforothersimilarplants)toidentifyareasinwhichhumanerrorhascausedproblemsinthepastthatmayberelatedtocontrolpaneldesign.ThesecondactivityistheControlRoomOperatingPersonnelSurvey(CROPS).TheDesignReviewTeamwillinterviewarepresentativesampleconsistingofatleast50percentofthelicensedcontrolroomoperatorsatD.C.CookUnits1and2.TheobjectiveoftheCROPSistoidentifyspecificattributesoftheD.C.CookUnits1and2.controlboarddesignwhich,intheoperators'pinions,havecausedorcouldpotentiallycauseoperatorerror.TheCROPSwillbeconductedbyadmini'strationofquestionnairesandbyconductingindividualandgroupinterviews.6755B:1/0628835-2 5-5.Task2-SstemFunctionandTaskAnalsisTheSystemFunctionandTaskAnalysiswillestablishinstrumentationrequirementsandperformancecriteriaforselectnormalandemergencyconditions.Thistaskwillbeperformedbyusingplant-specificproceduresgeneratedfromtheWestinghouseOwners'roupEmergencyResponseGuidelines.Theseplant-specificprocedureswillbesubmittedtotheDesignReviewTeam.ThisdatawillprovideinputtotheDesignReviewTeamfortheverificationandvalidationofcontrolroomfunctions(Tasks5and6).5-6.Task3-ControlRoomInventorThecontrolroominventorywillbedevelopedonacomputerdatabaseandwillincludealldatarequiredbyNUREG0700foreachcomponent.AEPSCwi11developandmaintaintheD.C.CookControlRoomInventorydatabase.FormatsandcompletenessofthedataitemlisthavebeenreviewedbyallreviewteammembersandcommentshavebeenincorporatedtoensurethattheinventorydatabasetosupportrelevantD.C.CookDCRDRProgramtaskscanbeaccepted.5-7'.Task4-ControlRoomHumanFactorsSurveThebulkofthedetaileddataregardingspecificdeparturesfromtheControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaReportwillbegatheredintheControlRoomSurveysTask.TheControlRoomSurveysTaskwillbeconductedbycompleting14humanengineeringsurveysasfollows:~WorkspaceeAnthropometrics~Emergencyequipment~Heating,ventilating,andairconditioning~Illumination6755B:I/0628835-3

~AmbientnoiseoMaintainabi1ity~Communications~Annunciator~Controls~Displays~Labelsandlocationaids~Computersystemreview~ConventionsDetailedTaskPlans,checklists,specialdatacollectionforms,NUREG0700criteriareferencesapplicabletoD.C.Cook,andmethodologydescriptionsforeachsurveywillbeincludedintheCRHECReport.TheAnnunciatorSurveyTaskPlanisincludedinthisProgramPlanReportinappendixCasanexample.5-8.WorksaceSurve--Thissurveyconcentratesonthegenerallayoutandarrangementofcontrolroomequipment.Theworkspacesurveywillalsoaddresstheadequacyofcontrolroomnoninstrumentationitemssuchasdesksandchairs.5-9.AnthroometricSurve--TheanthropometricsurveywillassessanddocumentthevisionandreachenvelopesforallD.C.Cookcontrolroomequipment.ThisdatawillbeevaluatedforgeneralcontrolanddisplaylocationadequacybasedupontheCRHECReportanthropometriccriteriaforthe5thpercentilefemaleand95thpercentilemale.Inaddition,theanthropo-metricdatawillbeusedtosupporttheverificationandvalidationtasks.6755B:I/0628835-4 5-10.EmerencEuimentSurve-Emergencyequipmentwillbeevaluatedforusabilitybythecontrolroomoperators.Includedwillbeanassessmentofemergencyequipmentstoragelocations;operatoraccessability;tactile,visual,andauditoryadequacyofbreathingapparatusandprotectiveclothing;andothercriticalfeaturesofthecontrolroomemergencyequipment.5-11.HeatinVentilatinandAirConditioninSurve""Theailflow,temperatureregulation,andhumiditycontrolwithinthecontrolroomwillbeevaluatedintermsoftheCRHECReport.Theprimaryconcernistoidentifyparameterswhichmaybeoutoftoleranceorunstabletothepointofadv'ersely,affectingtherecommendedcomfortzonesforthecontrolroom.5-12.IlluminationSurve-Ambientilluminationwillbemeasuredusingappropriateinstrumentsforlightinglevelsatvariousworkstationsandcontrolboardareas.Presenceofglare,ifany,oninstrumentationwillbedocumented.Illuminationwillbeevaluatedforcompliancewithrecommendedandrequiredlightlevelsforidentifiedtasks.5-13.AmbientNoiseSurve--Ambientnoisewillbemeasur'edusingappropriatesoundmeasurementequipment.Aprimaryconcernwillbethepeakandaveragedecibel(A)levelsandthepreferredoctavebanddecibellevelsfortheambientnoiseconditions.Thedatawillbereviewedforpotentialsoundproblemswhichmayinterferewithoperatorcommunicationrequirementsorwhichmaymaskauditorysignals.5-14.MaintainabilitSurve--Themaintainabilitysurveywillassesshumanfactorssuitabilityofallequipmentinthecontrolroom.Primaryconcernsarethattheoperatorscanmaintainindicatorlights,determiningifannuncia"torsystembulbsarereplaceable,replenishingexpendablessuchasrecorderpaperandink,anddeterminingthatsparepartsandexpendablesareavailableandaccessable.V5-15.CommunicationsSurve--Thecontrolroomcommunicationsystemswillbereviewedandevaluatedtodetermineiftheyareadequatetosupportemergencyandnormaloperations.Systemssuchasthepagingsystem,intercom6755B:1/0628835-5 system,-telephonesystem,sound-poweredandportableradiocommunicationsequipment,andfree/air,unaidedvoicecommunicationswillbeincludedinthisreview.Auditorysignalswillalsobeevaluatedforapplications,meaning,codingtechniques,signaltransmission/propagation,andsignalcharacteristics.5-16.AnnunciatorSstemsReview--Theannunciatorsystem,asaspecialcaseoflegendlightdisplaysandauditorysignals,willbeevaluatedintermsofitsgeneralhumanengineeringsuitabilityandalsoasacriticalandcentralcontrolroomsystemusedintheidentificationoftransientandemergencyconditions.Datacollectedwillbeanalyzedfordiscrepantcharacteristicswhichmaypotentiallyincreasetheprobabilityofhumanerror.Also,relevantdatawillbeusedtosupporttheverificationandvalidationtasks.engineeringsuitabilitywithoutreferencetospecifictasksupportiveroles.TheprimarycriteriawillbethatcontainedintheCRHECReportbasedonsection6.4ofNUREG0700.fgeneralhumanengineeringsuitabilityindependentlyofthespecifictasksinwhichthedisplaysareused.TheprimarycriteriawillbethatcontainedintheCRHECReportbasedonSection6.5ofNUREG0700.5-19.LabelsandLocationAids-Thecontrolpanelsandinstrumentationwillbesurveyedforgeneralreadabilityandconsistencyofterms,abbrevia-tions,andacronyms.Datafromthistaskandtheconventionssurveywillfurnishthebaselineinformationusedtoestablishastandarddictionaryofterms,abbreviations,andacronymsusedthroughoutthecontrolroom.5-20.ComuterSstemReview--TheP-250processcomputersystemusedinthecontrolroomwillbeassessedforitsfunctionalintegrationintotheoperationalrequirementsofthecontrolroom.Itwillalsobeevaluatedforgeneralhumanfactorssuitabilityandforitssupportiveroleincontrolroomoperation.Thecritiera.fromtheCRHECReport,basedonNUREG0700,Section6.7(processcomputers),formsthebasisforthis=taskplan.6755B:I/0628835-6 5-21.ConventionsSurve-Thepurposeoftheconventionssurveyisthreefold.ThoseconventionsusedatD.C.Cook,whethergeneralstereotypes,industryconventions,orplant-specificconventions,willbeidentified.Second,theidentifiedconventionswillbeevaluatedforgoodhumanfactorscharacteristics,asdefinedinthecriteriafromtheCRHECReportbasedonsection6ofNUREG0700.Finally,anyinconsistenciesintheapplicationsofidentifiedconventionswillbedocumentedandtheirimpactassessed.Datafromthistaskandthelabelingandlocationaidstaskwillbeusedtodevelopranddocumentastandarddictionaryofterms,abbreviations,andacronymsfortheD.C.Cookplants.5-22.Task5-VerificationofControlRoomFunctionAsoneofthetwoterminaltasksinthereviewphase,thepresenceandsuitabilityofcontrolroominstrumentationwillbeverified.Theprimaryconcernwillbedeterminingthatallrequiredinformationandcontrolcapabilitiesareinthecontrolroom.Asacorollary,thepresenceofnonessentialinformationandcontrolinstrumentationwillbeassessedtoensurethatitdoesnotdetractfromadequateoperatorperformance.DatafromtheControlRoomInventoryandthesystemsfunctionandtaskanalysisareextensivelyusedintheseactivities.5-23.Task6--ValidationofControl.RoomFunctionsThroughaprocessofwalkthroughsandtalkthroughsselectedemergencyandnormaloperationswillbevalidatedfortheavailabilityofrequiredskillsandknowledgeofthetrainedoperators.5-24.PRODUCTSOFTHEREVIEWPHASETheprimaryoutputoftheReviewPhaseisasetofchecklistobservation(CLO)forms.EachdeparturefromestablishedhumanfactorscriteriaobservedduringtheReviewPhasewillbedocumented~EachCLOformwillstatetheproblem,affectedcomponents,criteriaviolated,probableerror,andotherrelevantdatarequiredforanalysisoftheproblem.67558:I/0628835-7 TheCLOswi11providetheprimaryinputtotheAssessmentPhase,whereeachwillbecategorizedaccordingtosafetyand/oroperationalimpact.Inaddi-tion,atthecompletionoftheReviewPhase,componentsheetfileswi11becomplete,andTaskSummaryReportsforeachtaskwillhavebeenprepared.6755B:1/0628835-8 SECTION6DESCRIPTIONOFPHASEIII-A,ASSESSMENT6-1.INTRODUCTIONThereviewprocessdescribedinsection5willresultintheidentificationofdeparturesfromhumanengineeringcriteriadefinedintheCRHECReport.Analysisandinterpretationofthesedepartureswillberequiredtoestablishtheirpotentialsafetyimplications.Meansofcorrectingorminimizingtheeffectsofthedepartureswillbeidentifiedanddocumented.Aplanofactionwillbeappliedtoimprovementsaffectingoperatorperformanceunderemergencyandselectednormaloperatingconditions.ThePhaseIIIactivitiesofassessmentandimplementationarecoveredinthissectionandsection7,following.TheAssessmentPhaseoftheDCRDRProgramwi11achievethefollowingobjectives:~Analyzeandevaluatetheobserveddeparturesfromhumanengineeringcriteriaidentifiedduringthereviewphase~Recommendthemeansofcorrectingthosedepartureswhichcouldaffectsafetyorplant/operatorperformance-~Defineaplanofactionwhichappliesthehumanfactorprinciplestoimprovecontrolroomdesignandtoenhanceoperatoreffectivenessandefficiency~Applytheassessmentprocesstootherprojectsrelatedtothecontrolroomwhichareconcernedwith,ormaybeaffectedby,thehumanfactorsreview(RegulatoryGuide1.97,Revision2,safetyparametersdisplaysystem,procedures,training)6755B:I/0628836-1 6-2.METHODOLOGYTheassessmentprocessinvolvesthereviewandevaluationofallCRHECReportdeparturesidentifiedbytheDesignReviewTeamduringPhaseIItodeterminewhichdeparturescanaffecttheoperator'sperformancesuchthatthepotentialforoperatorerorisincreased.Thisprocessalsoinvolvesdeterminingtheextentofcorrectionsandjustifyinganyrecommendationswhichdonotcompletelycorrectthediscrepancies.AlldeparturesfromtheCRHECReportidentifiedduringtheReviewPhasewillbeprocessedaccordingtotheassessmentmethodologypresentedinfigure6-1.ThesedepartureswillbedocumentedonchecklistobservationformsandwillbeprovidedtotheAssessmentTeamforanalysisandassessment.Also,someoftheoperatingpersonnelwillbecanvassedusingthephotomosaictoresolveanyfactorswhichcouldcontributetoperformanceproblems.TheAssessmentTeamwillreviewtheCLOstodeterminetheneedforreassess-mentbytheDesignReviewTeamortheiracceptanceasHEDs.ThedispositionofeachCLOwillbejustifiedand/ordocumentedbytheAssessmentTeam.TheAssessmentTeamwillevaluateandcategorizeeachHEDaccordingtothemetho-dologypresentedinfigure6-2.ThisapproachaccomplishestheassessmentobjectivesofNUREGs0700and0801.AllcategoryI,II,andIIIHEDswillbeanalyzedforcorrectionasperfigure6-3.CategoryIVHEDs,consideredoptionalforcorrection,willbeassessedfortheircumulativeandinteractiveeffectsonallotherHEDs.Thosecate-goryIVHEDsshowntopossesstheaboveeffectswillberecategorizedtotheappropriatecategoryIIlevel.'ITheinitialstepinthisprocessistoidentifythoseHEDswhichcanbecor-rectedbyenhancements,trainingofoperators,and/orproceduralrevisions.TheremainingHEDswillbeanalyzedtoidentifyandprovidedesignimprovementalternatives.Acost/benefitanalysiswillbeperformedtodeterminewhichcorrectionsarethemostfeasibleandacceptablefromahumanengineeringpointofview.Asapartofthereview,IEMECo/AEPSCwillperformacost/benefitassessmentforimplementationoftherecommendations.6755B:1/0628836-2 Thecontrolroomreviewprocesswillbereappliedasappropriatetoensurethefollowing:~ThatthecreationofnewHEDsisidentified~Thatothercorrectionsarenotinvalidated~CompliancewithhumanengineeringguidelinesdevelopedduringPhaseIITheHEDsandfinalrecommendationsforcorrectionprovidedbytheassessmentteamwillbesubmittedtotheProjectReviewTeamforreviewanddisposition.RejectedCLOsand/orrecommendationswillbereturnedtotheAssessmentTeamforadditionalassessment.6755B:I/0628836-3 INTERFACE/REASSESSDESIGNREVIEWTEAM~PERFORMSTHEREVIEW~PREPARESCHECKLISTOBSERVATIONFORMS-LISTOFDEPARTURESFROMPRELIMINARYCONTROLROOMHUMANENGINEERINGCRITERIAREPORTCLOASSESSMENTTEAM~REVIEWCLOS~DETERMINESIGNIFICANCE/IMPACTASHUMANENGINEERINGDISCREPANCIES(HEDS)~INTERFACEWITHDESIGNREVIEWTEAM~CATEGORIZEHEDS(REFERTOFIGURE6-3)~FINALRECOMMENDATIONS~DEVELOPIMPLEMENTATIONSCHEDULEHEDS(W/FINALRECOMMENDATIONS)PROJECTREVIEWTEAMREASSESS/DISAPPROVE~REVIEW/COMMENTHEDSWITHFIMALRECOMMENDATIONS~INTERFACEWITHASSESSMENTTEAM~AEPSCGENERALPROCEDURENO.25"ENGINEERINGDESIGNCHANGES"Figure6-1.AssessmentMethodologyChart6755B:1/0628836-5 DESIGNREVIEWTEAMCHECKLISTOBSERVATIONSFORMS(REASSESSMENT)ASSESSMENTTEAMHUMANENGINEERINGDISCREPANCIESEVALUATEFORSAFETYCONSEQUENCEYESNOYESHIGHPROBABILITYOFOPERATIONALERROR/SIGNIFICANTDEVIATIONASSESSFORSIGNIFICANTOPERATIONALIMPACTSNONOYESCATEGORY2REFERTOFIGURE6-3CATEGORY3REFERTOFIGURE6-3NOSIGNIFICANTCOSTVERSUSOPERATORBENEFITCATEGORY1REFERTOFIGURE6-3IDENTIFYCORRECTIONSANDCOSTSTOFIXYESSELECTRECOMMENDEDBACKFITQQc0oz5PeItASSESSFORNEWDEPARTURESFROMPRELIMINARYCRHECREPORTDOCUMENTANDPREPAREFORIMPLEMENTATIONCATEGORY4DOCUMENTREFERTOFIGURE6-3Figuzq6-2.HumanEngineeringDiscrepancyEvaluationFlowChart 1I4-t'e+P)'.1 REVIEWPROCESSOBSERVATIONSHEDASSESSMENTSASSESSMENTCRITERIACATEGORYIVASSESSMENTFACTORSAFETY(")CONSEQUENCES:DOCUMENTEDERRORSINCREASEDPOTENTIALFORERRORLOWPROBABILITYOFERRORNOTASSOCIATEDWITHPROBABILITYOFERRORIMPLEMENTATION(RATING)EARLIESTOPPORTUNITY(MANDATORY)EARLIESTOPPORTUNITY(HIGHPRIORITY)CONVENIENTOUTAGE(ACCEPTED)MAYORMAYNOTBEREQUIRED(NOTMANDATORY)HEDS(I,II,III)(")EXAMPLE:RESULTSINUNSAFEOPERATION,VIOLATIONOFTECHNICALSPECIFICATIONSCATIVRECOMMENDEDCORRECTIONSNODOCUMENTYESANALYSISFORCORRECTIONFigure6-3.HEDCategoryGuidelines6755B:1/0628836-9

SECTION7OESCRIPTIONOFPHASEIII-B,IMPLEMENTATIONApprovedsolutionsofHEDsbytheProjectReviewTeamwillbescheduledforimplementation.Thecategoryguidelinesestablishedinsection6willbeusedasabasisforthecorrectiveactionschedule.Additionalconsiderationsinthedevelopmentoftheimplementationschedulewillbe:~Safetyconsequencesofoperatorerrorsthatcouldbecausedbythediscrepancy~Integrationwithotherpost-TMIprograms~PlantoperationconstraintsoOperatortraining/retrainingrequirements~OutageschedulesoEquipmentprocurementschedulesThefollowingdesignations,identifedinNUREG0801,willbeadoptedforschedulingpurposes:theNRC.Makechangesatthefirstrefuelingaftersubmittalofthereportorthefirstoutageafterreceiptofequipment(expedited).~Nearterm.CorrectproblemsonascheduleapprovedbytheNRC.Makechangesatthesecondrefuelingoutageaftersubmittalofthereport.~Lontermotional.Correctionsofinsignificantdiscrepanciesmaybeimplementedatanytime.6755B:1/0628837-1

SECTION8.OESCRIPTIONOFPHASEIV,REPORTINGAProgramSummaryReportwillbepreparedinaccordancewithNUREGs0700and0801uponcompletionoftheOCRORProgram.Thisreportwilldocumenttheoverallreviewprocess,describeandidentifyallofthehumanengineeringdiscrepanciesandfindings,andsummarizeallDCRORactivities,methodologies,andproposedcontrolroomimprovements.Thisreportwillalsoprovideanimplementationscheduleforplannedcorrectiveaction.Thescheduleforplannedcorrectiveactionshallbebasedonrealisticandachievabledates.TheuseofintermediatemilestonesinplaceofenddatesmaybeusedifadditionalrelevantinformationisnotavailableatthetimetheProgramSummaryReportis.submittedtotheNRC.Intermediatemilestonedateswillbedeterminedbaseduponthedatebywhichnecessaryadditionalinformationwillbeknown,thuspermittinganinformeddeterminationofenddates.TheProgramSummaryReportwillupdatetheProgramPlanningReport.TheProgramSummaryReportwillbepreparedusingtherecommendedformatshowninfigure8-1.Inadditiontothisfinalreport,supportingdocumentationwillbeavailableforcompletenessintheeventofanNRCaudit.6755B:I/0628838-1 II CONTROLROOMDESIGNREVIEWSUMMARYREPORT1.0METHODOLOGY1.1DetailedControlRoomDesignReviewProgramPlanObjectives1.1.1DetailedControlRoomDesignReviewmethodology1.1.2DetailedControlRoomDesignReviewprogrammanagement1.1.3Proposedscheduleofthefourphasesofactivity(chart)1.1.4IntegrationofotheremergencyresponseactivitiesofNUREG0737,Supplement11.1.5Qualityassuranceprogram1.2ManagementandStaffing1.2.1QualificationofDetailedContxolRoomDesignReviewpersonnel1.2.2OrganizationalstructureofDCRDRReviewTeams1.3DocumentationandDocumentControl.1.4ReviewPhase1.4.11.4.21.4.31.4.41.4.51.4.6OperatingexperiencereviewSystemfunctionsreviewandtaskanalysisControlroominventoryControlroomhumanfactorssurveyVerificationoftaskperformanceValidationofcontrolroomfunctions2.0REVIEWCONCERNS2.1ControlRoomHumanFactorSurveyConcerns2.1.1WorkspaceSurvey2.1.2AnthropometricsSurvey2.1.3EmergencyEquipmentSurvey2.1.4Heating,Ventilation,andAirConditionSurvey2.1.5IlluminationSurvey2.1.6AmbientNoiseSurvey-Figure8-1.SampleofProgramSummaryReportFormat(Sheet1)67558:1/0628838-3

CONTROLROOMDESIGNREVIEWSUMMARYREPORT(cont)2.1.72.1.82.1.92.1.102.1.112.1.12MaintainabilitySurveyCommunicationSurveyAnnunciatorSystemsReviewControlsSurveyDisplaysSurveyLabelsandLocationAids2.1.13ComputerSystemReview2.1.14ConventionsSurvey2.2Panel/WorkStationConcerns2.3SystemConcerns2.4OtherReviewConcerns3.0ASSESSMENTRECOMMENDATIONANDIMPLEMENTATIONPHASE3.1HEDAssessment3.2ProposedImplementation3.3ScheduledImplementation

4.0CONCLUSION

Figure8-1.SampleofProgramSummaryReportFormat(Sheet2)6755B:1/0628838-5 SECTION9COORDINATIONWITHNUREG0737,SUPPLEMENT1,ACTIYITIESTheactivitiestobecoordinatedwiththeDCRDRinaccordancewithNUREG0737,Supplement1,includethefollowingrequirementsforEmergencyResponseCapabilities:SafetyParameterDisplaySystem(SPDS)UpgradeofEmergencyOperatingProdecures(EOPs)ApplicationtoEmergencyResponseFacilities-RegulatoryGuide1.97EmergencyResponseFacilities(ERFs)IEMECowilladdresstheseactivitiesasreferencedinI&MECo'sresponsetoNRCGenericLetter82-33forD.C.CookUnits1and2;letterPAEP-NRC-0773,datedApril15,1983.AscheduleofperformanceandintegrationoftheseotherpostTMIactivitieswiththeDCRDRisshowninFigure9-1.6755B:1/062883 C)(TlER(X7D.C.COOKPLANT-DCRDRCOORDINATIONSCHEDULE1983198'985JFMAMJJASONDJFMAMJJASONDJFMAMJJASONDSPDSHARDWARESOFTWAREINSTALLED$7ATv5AVAILABLERFm'~FORTRAININGOPERATIONALWITHOPERATORTRAININGCOMPLETEDCRDRPPRTONRCINTERMEDIATESTATUSREPORTREVIEWPHASECOMPLETEFINALSUMMARYREPORTTONRCREG.GUIDE1.97EOPEQUIPMENTREPLACEMENTSSPECIFIED,STATUSPFFAk'7INTERMEDIATESTATUSREPORTPRGCEAlRE(jEN.PACk:QQG/hl0pzmvoqncRCrg~wlN8COMPLETEREVIEWREV.2IMPLEMENTEDKEYTARGETCOMMITMENTFigure9-1.ScheduleofPerformance SECTjON10QUALITYASSURANCETheOCRORProgramwillbeperformedinaccordancewithAEPSCQualityAssuranceProgramfortheOonaldC.CookNuclear'lant,specificallyAEPSCGeneralProcedure2.1andotherapplicablegeneralproceduresasreferencedhereinandtheapplicableportionsofWestinghouseWCAP-8370pertainingtodocumentcontrolandauditability.6755B:1/06288310-1 SECTION11SUMMARYThisProgramPlanReportdefinestheoverallprocessbywhichtheO.C.CookUnits1and2DetailedControlRoomDesignReviewProgramwillbeperformed.Itisaneffectiveandthoroughdesignreviewwhichwillensurethattheresultsofthiseffortmeettheintentofallapplicablegovernmentregulationsandguidelines.IndianaandMichiganElectricCompanyhascommittedtheresourcesneededtoperformthedesignreviewasdetailedinthisdocument.Therefore,theacceptabilityoftheDetailedControlRoomDesignReviewProgramwillbebasedontheapproval'fthisProgramPlanReport.TheIndianaandMichiganElectricCompanyCorporationreservestheright,however,tomakechangesandwillnotifytheNRCpriortotheexecutionofanyplanneddepartures.FinalacceptanceofthisdocumentwillendthePlanningPhaseofthisprogram.6755B:1/062883 APPENDIXALISTOFABBREVIATIONSThefollowingabbreviationsapplyonlytothisProgramPlanReportanddonotnecessarilyapplytoeffortsassociatedwithplantstandardabbreviations.A/EAEPSCBOPCLOCRCRICROPSCRTDCRDRDRTEOPEPRIERGFSARHEHEDHFI8(CIKMECoINPOLELERMCBMWeMWtNRCNSSSOSDPCPMPPRArchitect/EngineerAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporationBalanceofPlantChecklistObservation(form)ControlRoomControlRoomInventoryControlRoomOperatingPersonnelSurveyCathodeRayTubeDetailedControlRoomDesignReviewDesignReviewTeamEmergencyOperatingProceduresElectricPowerResearchInstituteEmergencyResponseGuidelinesFinalSafetyAnalysisReportHumanEngineeringHumanEngineeringDiscrepancyHumanFactors-InstrumentationandControlIndianaandMichiganElectricPowerCompany(licensee)InstituteofNuclearPowerOperatorsLeadEngineerLicenseeEventReportMainControlBoardMegawatt(electric)Megawatt(thermal)NuclearRegulatoryCommissionNuclearSteamSupplySystemOperationalSequencesDiagramsPlantCoordinatorProgramManagerPreliminaryPlanningReport6755B:1/062883 PRT-ProjectReviewTeamPSR-ProgramSummaryReportPWR-PressurizedWaterReactorSFTA-SystemsFunctionandTaskAnalysisSPDS-SafetyParameterDisplaySystemTMI-ThreeMileIslandWOG-WestinghouseOwner'sGroupCRHEC-ControlRoomHumanEngineeringCriteriaTP-TaskPlanCRG-CanyonResearchGroupCRHFS-ControlRoomHumanFactorsSurvey6755B:I/062883A-2 APPENDIXBRESUMESOFKEYPERSONNEL6755B:1/112983B-l

RobertF.KroeerManagerofQualityAssuranceTwentythreeyearsexperienceinelectricalengineering,nuclearfuel,andqualityassuranceinvolvingmajorpowergeneratinganddistributionintheU.S.EDUCATION:B.S.ElectricalEngineeringPurdueUniversity-1960AdditionalEducation:-IndianaUniversity-BusinessManagement1960-62-GeneralElectricCo.PowerSystemsEngineeringCourse1967-1968-AEPManagementProgram-UniversityofMichigan-1980EXPERIENCE1978'toPresentAmericanElectricPowerServiceCororation.ManaerofualitAssurance-Responsibilitiesinclude:formulatingandrecommendingpoliciesandpracticeswithrespecttotheQAandQCprogramsforCookPlant;establishingeffectiveQAandQCprogramsfortheCookPlant;insuringeffectiveimplementationoftheestablishedQAandQCprograms;providingguidanceandassistancetoAEPSCandCookPlantmanagementonQAandQCrequirementsandthenimplementation;monitoringofcompliancewithestablishedQAprogramsthroughaudits,surveillanceandreviews;andreportingtoSeniormanagementandQAprogramseffectiveness.Directtheday-to-dayoperationoftheAEPSCQADepartmentincludingrecommendingthehiring,salaryadjustments,promotions,transfers,disciplining,andterminationofpersonnel.ContinueasSecretaryoftheCCB.ElectedamemberoftheAEPSCNuclearSafetyDesignReviewCommittee(OffsitereviewcommitteeforCookPlant).1976to1978StaffEnineer,NuclearEnineerinDivision-Responsibilitiesincludedpaiticipationinnuclearfueldesignreviews,vendorevaluation,andinprocesssurveillanceandauditsofnuclearfuelfabrication.ContinuedasSecretaryoftheCCB.1973to1976StaffEnineer,ProjectManagementDivision-Responsibilitiesincludeddevelopmentoftransmissionanddistributionprojectmanagementsystemsandtechniques,methodsofmanpowerallocations,andmethodsforcostcontrol.WasassignedtheresponsibilityasSecretaryoftheAEPSCChangeControlBoard(CCB)fortheDonaldC.CookNuclearPlant.'Wasassignedtoa2persontaskactiongrouptodevelopcorporateprojectmanagementandcontrolproceduresforananticipated,newhightemperaturegascoolednuclearreactorproject.ReceivedadditionalspecialassignmentsonCookPlantintheareasofcontrolofmodification,andtrackingofcommitments.6755B:1/112983B-3 RobertF.Kroeer(Page2)1971to19731970to1971AdministrativeAssistanttotheAEPSCViceChairman,EnineerinandConstruction-Responsibilitieswerenumerousandwidelydiversifiedinvolvingallfacetsofelectricutilityengineering,design,constructionandoperation.Assignedresponsibilitiesforcoordinationofnumerousspecialprojects,.studiesandproblemsolvingtaskforces.Preparedresponsestooutsidecorrespondenceforalllevelsofseniormanagement.DevelopedandimplementedanAEPSCengineeringmanpowermonitoringprogramstocontinuallymonitorchangesinengineeringmanpowerandtechnicallevelofengineering.SeniorEnineer-ElectricalEnineerinDivisionSecialAssinmenttoNuclearTaskForce-D.C.CookNuclearPlantElectricalEngineeringDivisiongAprocedures,siteelectricalconstructiongAprocedures,electricalequipmentspecifications,originalcorporatewideseismicqualificationspecification,andelectricalequipmentsupplierqualificationprograms.Conductedpreawardauditsofandinprocesssurveillanceonsuppliersofsafetyrelatedelectricalequipment.Conductednumeroussiteauditsofelectricalconstructionactivities.1965to1970Enineervariousrades-ElectricalEnineerinDivision-DistributionSectionNYOffice-PrimaryresponsibilitywasforlongrangeplanningofthedistributionsystemsfortwooftheAEPsystemoperatingcompanies,includingimprovementplans,loadforecasts,systemoptimization,costanalyses,coordinationofplanswithtransmissionplanninggroupsandpresentationofplanstocorporatemanagementforapproval.Otherresponsibilitiesincluded:administration(furtherdevelopmentofandimplementationoftheAEPsystemwidedistributiontransformersloadmonitoryprogram(programtopredictonastatisticalbasisthemonthlyandannualpeakloadsonover400,000distributiontransformers);developmentandimplementationofanAEPsystemsidedistributionsystemtrouble,damageandinterruptionreportingprogramtoprovidestatisticaldataoncircuitandequipment"reliability"forplanningandequipmentevaluationpurposes;participatedinataskforcetodevelopdistributionsystemplanningguidelines;conductednumerousspecialstudiesondistributionsystemequipment,constructionstandardsandplanningcalculationtechniques.67558:1/1129838-4 1963to1965RobertF.Kroeer(Page3)AssociateEnineer-CantonOhioEnineerinOivision-Primaryresponsibiljtieswerebasicallythesameasthoseshownfor1965to1970.Th'ispositionwasestablishedaspartofanefforttodevelopanAEPSCengineeringgroupinCanton,Ohio.Aftertwoyears,thedecisionwasmadetotransferthedistributionplanningfunction,totheAEPSCNewYorkoffice.1960to1963Indiana5MichianElectricComoanAssistantEngineer-SstemEnineerinOffice,OistributionSection-Primaryresponsibilitieswereforshortrangedistributionsystemplanning,developmentofdetailedworkplansforimplementationofdistributionsystemimprovements,andspecialcustomerrelatedstudies.Additionalresponsibilitiesincluded:evaluationofsheetlightequipment,equipmentutilizationstudiesandinstallationstandards;continuousevaluationofdistributionconductorconnectsandassociatedtoolingandhardware.67558:1/1129838-5 RESUME:RobertC.CarruthTITLE:HeadElectricalGenerationSectionAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporationEDUCATION:BachelorofEngineering1965StevensInstituteofTechnologyMasterofEngineering-ElectricPowerSystemsEngineering1967RensselaerPolytechnicInstitutePRESENT:ManagerElectricalGenerationSectionElectricalEngineeringDivisionAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporation1979-1981AssistantManagerofElectricalGenerationSectionElectricalEngineeringDivisionAEPSC:Executeabroadrangeoftechnicalandadministrativeresponsibilitiesinsupervisionof,anorganizationof40engineersandsupportingtechnicalpersonnelinvolvedinallaspectsofPowerPlantElectricalDesignEngineering,includingpowerequipmentspecificationandapplication,auxiliarypowersystemdesign,applicationofprotectiverelayingandprotectiveinterlockingcircuits,designofrelayandsolidstatelogiccontrolsystems,applicationoffaultdiagnosticequipment,performanceofequipmentand,systemfailureanalysisandthemonitoringandupgradingofinstalledandoperatingelectricalequipmentandsystems.Specifictechnicalandadministrativeresponsibilitiesinclude:ConductingJobPerformanceReviews.Administrativeofthetrainingandorientationprogramfornewtechnicalpersonnel.Manpowerplanningandmanpowerallocation.Providingindependenttechnicalreviews.ParticipatinginNuclearStandardsDevelopment.ParticipatinginNuclearSafetyDesignReviewSub-Committeeactivities.ConductingspecialstudiesinNuclearandFossilPlantDesign,constructionandoperationrelatedarea.Researchorconductevaluationofsystemsorequipmentmisoperations,reportableoccurrences,equipmentfailures,etc.ParticipateinNuclearPlantSiteAudits.6755B:1/112983B-7 R.C.CarruthPage2PreviousNuclearExerience1972-1979SeniorEngineer,andProjectElectricalEngineerforD.C.CookNuclearPlant;two1100MWWestinghousePWR's.Responsiblefortechnicalandadministrativesupervisionofanorganizationofsixtotenengineersandengineeringsupportpersonnelinvolvedinconstruction,qualification,licensing,pre-operationaltesting,startupandpostoperationalengineeringanddesignsupport.Specifictechnicalandadministrati'veresponsibilitiesincluded:PerformingorsupervisinghhedetaildesignofClassIEaswellasbalanceofplantelectricalsystems,circuitsandcomponents.PreparationofEquipmentqualificationtestprocedures.Witnessacceptancetesting.Supervisethepreparationofplantsiteauditplans.Writeandsupervisethepreparationandexecutionofpre-operationaltestprocedures.SupervisethedevelopmentandtestingofClassIEcomponents.Provideonsitestartuptechnicalsupportandsupervision.DevelopanEngineeringProceduresManual.Establishproceduresforengineeringqualitycontrol.InstituteanEngineeringequalityAssuranceProgram.AssistintheestablishmentofaCorporateDesignChangeControlProcess.Performworkplanning;schedulingmanpowerandassignments.PersonnelPerformanceReviews.SuperviseandprovidetechnicalliaisontoaconsultantorganizationcontractedtosupplementthepermanentstaffassignedtotheProjectElectricalorganization.6755B:1/112983B-8 R.C.CarruthPage3GeneralIndustrExerience1977-1979SeniorEngineerandSupervisoryEngineerfortheelectricaldesignofRacineHydroelectricProject.Responsibleforconceptualaswellasdetailengineeringoftheelectricalsystems,protectives,plantcontrols,dispatchautomationandsupervisoryanddiagnosticsystemsforremoteunattendedoperationsSpecificareasofactivityincluded:GenerationofElectricalOneLines.Specificationpurchaseandapplicationofmajorelectricalsystemsandhardwareincluding:600Vand6.9kVswitchgear.6.9kVIsolatedandNonSeg.Phasebus.Programmablecontrollersforcontrolanddispatchfunctions.Equipmentstatusandalarmmonitoringsystem.Remotesupervisoryanddataacquisitionsystem.Batterycharger,inverterandUPSsystem.Parametermonitoringanddatamanagementsystem.Designof'lantcontrolsandprotectiveinterlockingcircuitsandlogic.Developmentofdispatchalgorithimsforeconomicdispatchofthefacility.Applicationofgeneratorandauxiliarypowersystemprotectiverelaying.Integrationofplantcontrolsandoperationwithsubtransmissionsystemrelayingandswitchingrequirements.Applicationofstationoscillographandplantsystemsstatusdiagnosticcomputerandannunciatorsystems.Applicationofon-siteemergencydieselgeneration,andthedesignofautomaticloadshedding,restoration,re-transferandtestingcircuitry.6755B:1/112983B-9 R.C.CarruthPage41969-1972EngineerandSponsor(ProjectElectrical)Engineerfor.MitchellPlant-two800MWcoalfiredsuper-criticalunits:Responsibleforelectricalcontrolandprotection,auxiliarypowersystemsprotectiverelaying,relatedoperatortrainingandrelatedstartupandcommissioningsupervision.Specificresponsibilitiesandactivitiesincluded:Designofelectricalcontrolandpowercircuits.Applicationandsettingofprotectiverelays.Applicationofswitchgearandotherswitchingandprotectivedevices.Designofrelayanddigitalsolidstatelogicforplantcoalhandlingautomation.Designofrelaycontrollogicandinterlockingforplantsystems.Preparationofoperatorreferencesystemdescriptionsandoperatinginstructions.Prepareanddeliveroperatortrainingandorientationlecturesonkeyplantsystems.Writetestandcommissioninginstructions.Provideon-sitetechnicalsupporttoconstructionandrelaycheckoutpersonnel.1968-1972EngineerandProjectElectricalEngineerforthedesignandinstallationofa345MVARsynchronouscondenserinstallationaspartofa765kVEHVsystemexpansion.Responsibilitiesincluded:Designofallcontrolsandprotectives.Designofauxiliarypowersystem.Ratingmajorelectricalcomponents.Specificationandpurchaseofcontrolcomponents,switchgear,transferswitches,auxiliarypowerequipment,motorcontrolcenters,transformers.Reviewandapprovalofallvendorsuppliedsystems,includingexcitation,generatorcoolingwatertreatmentanddemineralizersystemequipment,andallstartingsystemequipmentincludinggeneratorstartingandrunningbusswitchingequipment.6755B:1/112983B-10 R.C.CarruthPage51967"1969AssociateEngineer,AssistingProjectElectricalEngineerinvariousaspectsofastripmineexpansionproject,automatedcoalhaulage(railroad),overlandconveyors,coalprocessingstationsandmisc.coalhandlingsystems.67558:1/1129838"11

KARLJ.TOTHEDUCATIONUniversityofSouthernCaliformia,M.A.,SystemManagement,1968UniversityofOmaha,B.S.,MilitaryScience,1962CentralMichiganCollegeofEducation,1950REGISTRATIONProfessionalEngineer,StateofCaliforniaEXPERIENCEAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporation,1983-PresentNUSCorpodation,1980-1983U.S.AirForce,1951-1980MichiganSchoolSystem,1950-1951AMERICANELECTRICPOWERSERVICECORPORATION-AssignedtotheNuclearSafetyandLicensingSectionwithresponsibilityforsafetyimplicationsofallproposedD.C.CookNuclearPlantmodifications.Reviewsallproposedchangesfor10CFR50.59requirementsandD.C.CooklicensingcommitmentstotheNRC.NUS-AsaconsultingengineerwiththeConsequenceAssessmentDepartment,isresponsiblefortheanalysisofprobabilitiesandconsequencesofindustrialandtransportationaccidents.ConductedaircraftimpacthazardanalysisfortheSanOnofre,Skagit/Hanford,andHopeCreeknuclearpowerplantsandwroteSection3.5.1.6ofthepreliminaryandfinalsafetyanalysisreports(PSARandFSAR)fortheHopeCreekplant.Performedanalysisofprobabilitiesforaccidentsinjuries,anddeathsfortheenvironmentalimpactstatementforaway-from-reactorfuelreceivingandstoragestationsatNuclearFuelServices,WestValley,NewYork;GeneralElectric,Morris,Illinois,andAlliedGeneralNuclearServices,Barnwell,SouthCarolina.Conductedriskanalyses,includingpossibleaccidentsscenarios,onmilitarydeploymentanduseofkrypton-85advancedairfieldlightingsystems.PerformedexcavatioonplanningandtimeestimatesfortheGinnaNuclearPowerPlant.ConductedaccidentandriskanalysesofremotelypilotedvehiclesfortheU.S.DepartmentofEnergy.Theseanalysesincludedpossibleaccidentscenarios,failuremodes,andprobabilities.Inaddition,performedfieldsurveys,collecteddata,andmanagedprojectsforbothoffiteandonsitehazardsanalysisforcontrolroomhabitabilityforUnits1and2oftheSurry,Skagit/Hanford,andMidlandNuclearPowerPlants.ThisworkresultedinwritingrevisionstoSection2.2oftheMidlandFSAR,which,includedanextensivestudyandreport,andwritingSectionZ.ZoftheSkagit/HanfordPSARandtheHopeCreekFSAR~ParticipatedintheIDCORAtomicIndustrialForumonNuclearPowerPlantControlRoomOperatorHumanFactorsStudy.6755B:1/112983B-13 KARLJ.TOTHPage2U.S.AIRFORCE-Servedaspilotandinprogressivemanagementpositionsinboththeoperationsandsafetyfunctions.AtterminationofAirForcecareer,wasChiefofSafetyforAirForceSystemsCommand,withresponsibilityforsystemsafety,reliability,maintainability,andoverallproductassuranceforapproximately90percentofthehardwareandsoftwarepurchasedbytheU.S.AirForce.From1974through1977,wasresponsibleforreviewingandapprovingevacuationplansandcontrolcenteroperationsfor20installationsintheeasternUnitedStates.Hashadextensiveexperienceworkingwithanddirectingpostaccidentsradiation-monitoringteams,decontaminationteams,andaccidentinvestigations.AsChiefofSafetyandDisasterControl,from1962to1974,conductedevacuationstudiesatsixnuclearinstallations;oneinJapan,twoinEurope,andthreeintheUnitedStates.Studiesincludedtimeestimates,routes,methods,andproceduresfordispersingpersonnelandcriticaldefenseequipment.Responsibilitiesalsoincludedestablishinganddirectingemergencycontrolcenterproceduresandoperationsateachlocation.InvestigatedacatastrophicbomberaircraftcrashinJapanwhichresultedinmanyunnecessaryciviliancasualties.Theselosseswereattributedtoalackofknowledgebythelocalpopulation.Asaresult,developed,andtranslated,anddistributedemergencyprocedureschecklistsforlocalofficials.Alsowroteanexplanationofthehazardsandrisksandestablishedsimpleprocedurestobefollowedintheeventoffutureaccidents.Theseproceduresweretranslatedandpublishedinlocalpapersandbroadcastperiodicallyonlocalradioandtelevision.ThesechecklistsandnewsmediareleaseswerewellreceivedandsubsequentlytranslatedandsuccessfullyusedatlocationsinEuropeandintheUnitedStates.MEMBERSHIPSAmericanDefensePreparednessAssociationAmericanNuclearSocietyCertifiedHazardControlManagerInternationalSocietyofAirSafetyInvestigatorsNationalAerospaceEducationAssociationNationalSocietyofProfessionalEngineersSystemSafetySociety6755B:1/1129838-14 ARTHURS.GRZMESConsultinMechanicalEnineerThirtyfiveyearsexperienceinmechanicalengineeringactivitiesinvolvingmajorpowergeneratingfacilitiesintheUnitedStatesandZsrael.EDUCATZON:PzofessionaldegreeinMechanicalEngineeringUniversityofCincinnati,1948AdditionalEducation:BusinessAdministration,AdelphiUniversity1955AutomaticControl,UniversityofMichigan1954EXPERZENCE:1978toPresentAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorConsultingMechanicalEngineer-Consultanttomechanicalengineeringandotherdisciplinesinareasofautomaticcontrol,plantoperationandthermalperformance.Performnuclearplantaudits.Consultonresearchprojects.1972-77AssistantDivisionManager-MechanicalEngineeringResponsibleformechanicalengineeringactivitiesinplantmodificationandoperationofanuclearpowerplant.1955-72Manager,ResultsSection-Responsiblefordesignandpurchaseofinstrumentationandcontrolsystems,steamcycleanalysis,andpezformancetestingofpowergeneratingplants.Plantsincludedcoal,oil,nuclearandhydro.1950-551948-49Engineer-Responsiblefordesignandpurchaseofinstrumentationandcontrolsystemsforfossilpowerplants.AalachianPowerCo.,Loan,WestViriniaResultsEngineerresponsibleformaintenanceofinstrumentsandcontrolsandforperformancetestingincoalfiredpowerplant.PROFESSZONALAFFZLZATZON:Fellow,AmericanSocietyofMechanicalEngineersChapter8,PumpHandbook-McGraw-Hill1976OperatingExperienceWithTheCardinalPlantTrainingSimulator-AmericanNuclearSociety1970ServiceExperienceWithAnalogComputersForUtilityPowerPlants-AmericanPowerConf.1962 CMeasurementofDensityandMoistureinaLargeCoalStoragePile-AmericanPowerConf.1961ApplicationofanAutomaticDigitalDataCollectingSystemToThePhiloSupercriticalUnit,AmericanPowerConf.1958ThermalPerformanceOfThePhiloSupercriticalUnit-AmericanSocietyofMechanicalEngineers,1958PATENTS:4,343,682FeedwaterHeatingMeansforNuclearUnitsDuringStart-upandMethodofControllingSame.3,721,898,ApparatusforDetectingLeakageFromorRuptureofPipesandOtherVesselsContainingFluidUnderPressure.3,211,135SteamGeneratorUnitContxolSystem SummaryResumeofTHOMASB.SHERIDANThomasB.SheridanattendedPurdueUniversity(B.S.1951)and,aftertwoyearsinmilitaryservice(AeromedicalLaboratory,WrightPattersonAirForceBase,Ohio)attendedtheUniversityofCalifornia,LosAngeles(M.S.1954)andM.I.T.(Sc.D.1959).Hisdoctoralprogramwasinterdepartmentalbetween'systemsengineeringandpsychology,withoneyearspentincross-registrationatHarvardUniversity.Formostofhiscareer,Or.SheridanhasremainedatM.I.T.,whereuntilrecentlyhewasProfessorofMechanicalEngineeringandisnowProfessorofEngineeringandAppliedPsychology.HeheadstheMan-Machine'SystemsLaboratoryandteachesbothgraduateandundergraduatesubjectsinMan-MachineSystems.HeisaFacultyAssociateoftheM.I.T.Science,TechnologyandSocietyProgram.HehelpeddevelopanewinterdepartmentalgraduatedegreeprograminTechnologyandPolicy,and.hastaughtthecoreseminarsforthatprogram.Hehasalsotaughtcontrol,designandotherengineeringsubjects.HehasservedasvisitingfacultymemberattheUniversityofCalifornia,Berkeley,StanfordUniversity,andtheTechnicalUniversityofDelft,Netherlands.NDr.Sheridan'sresearchhasbeenonmathematicalmodelsofhumanoperatorandsocio"economicsystems,onman-computerinteractioninpilotingaircraftandinsupervisingunderseaandindustrialroboticsystems,andoncomputergraphictechnologyforinformationsearchingandgroupdeicision-making.Heisauthor,withW.R.Ferrell,ofMan-MachineSstems:Information,ControlandDecisionModelsofHumanPerformance,M.I.T.Press,1974,1981(publishedinRussian,1980)andco-editorofa1976PlenumPressbook,M~onitorinBehaviorandSuervisorControl.HeisafellowoftheInstituteofElectricalandElectronicsEngineers,wasformerlyeditoroftheIEEETransactionsonMan-MachineSstems,ispastpresidentofthe'EEESystems,ManandCyberneticsSociety,servedasChairmanoftheIEEECommitteeonTechnologyForecastingandAssessmentandwaschairmanofthe1981IEEEWorkshoponHumanFactorsinNuclearSafety.HeisalsoaFellowoftheHumanFactorsSociety,andin1977receivedthe'irPaulM.FittsAwardforcontributionstoeducation.HeisAssociateEditorofAutomaticaandontheEditorialAdvisoryBoardofComuterAidedDesin.Dr.SheridanhasservedontheAccidentPreventionandInjuryControlStudySectionsoftheNationalInstitutesofHealth,theNASALifeSciencesAdvisoryCommittee,theNSFAutomationResearchCouncil,theNASAStudygrouponRobotics,theU.S.CongressOTATaskForceonAppropriateTechnology,andtheNSFAdvisoryCommitteeonAppliedPhysical,MathematicalandBiologicalFactorsandservedontheNRCAdHocCommitteeonAircrew-VehicleInteractionandtwoadvisorypanelsoftheNRCMarineBoard.Hisindustrialconsultingactivitieshaveincluded:TheGeneralMotorsCorp.(autosafety);GeneralElectricCo.(telemanipulators);C.S.DraperLaboratory6755B:1/112983B-17 ThomasB.SheridanPage2(designofastronautinterfaceforApolloguidancesystem,industrialrobots);Biodynamics,Inc.(biomedicalandhumanfactors);PublicBroadcastService(TVaudiencefeedback);NationalBureauofStandards(industrialrobots);GroupDialogSystems,Inc.(groupmeetinganddecisiontechnology);NorthropAircarft(pilotworkload);BabcockandWilcoxCo.(industrialinstrumenta-tions);Lockheed,GeneralPhysics,AmericanElectricPower,Consumer'sandWebster,theBWROwners'roup,BrookhavenNationalLaboratory,YankeeAtomic,andElectricPowerResearchInstitute.(man-machineaspectsofnuclearplantsafety).67558:1/1129838-18 Manaer,InstrumentationandControlSectionSeventeenyearsexperienceininstrumentation,controlandequipmentprotectionactivitiesinvolvingmajorpowergeneratinganddistributionfacilitiesintheUnitedStates..EDUCATION:B.S.ElectricalEngineering,IllinoisInstituteofTechnology,1966REGISTRATION:EXPERiENCE:1977toPresent1976to1977AdditionalEducation:AEPManagementCourse-UniversityofMichigan,1979ProfessionalEngineer-California(1977)AmericanElectricPowerServiceCororationManager,Instrumentation&ControlSection-Responsibilitiesincludesupervisingthedevelopmentoftheoverallplantcontrolphilosophy.Review,approveandrecommendationsofinstruments,controls&computersuppliedwithallmajormechanicalequipment.Organizethedevelopmentofsoftware,selectionofhardwareforpowerplantprocesscomputers.Supervisethearrangementofcontrolrooms,simulatorsandpanelsincorporatinghumanfactorconsiderations.Assuredocumentationofinstru-mentation,controlandcomputerstrategiesviatheEngineeringControlProcedure(ECP)packages.CarryouttheinterfacebetweenMechanicalandElectricalEngineeringforControlDesignandEngineering.Provideforprofes-sionaldevelopmentandtrainingofSectionpersonnel.Recommendhiring,salaryadjustments,promotion,transfersandreleaseofpersonnel.ProjectworkincludesMontaineerUnit1andRockportUnits1&21300mwfossilfiredpowerplants,CookNuclearPlantUnits1&2upgrades,thePressurizedFluidizedBedCombustionProjectStudies,andanewseriesofFossilFiredPlantstudiesin-plantmonitoringcomputersforStackEnvironmentalData.AssistantSectionHead/Instrumentation&ControlSection-Responsibilitiesincludedsupervision,instrumentandcontrolwork,training,evaluatingpersonnelperformance,reviewandapprovalofpurchaseorders,standardsanddrawings,supervisethearrangementanddesignofcontrolpanels,superviseanddesignofcontrolsystems,coordinatethepreparationofboiler&turbineinterlockdiagramsandanalyzingthepowerplantcycleandtheircontrols.Projectworkincludedaseriesof1300MMFossilFiredPowerPlants,D.C'.CookNuclearPlantUnit1&2andaMechanicalEngineeringDivisionPowerPlantCycleStudy.67558:1/1129838-19 JohnC.JeffreyPage21975to1976Engineer,Instrumentation&ControlSection,N.Y.Office-"Responsibilitiesincludeddesignofcontrolsystems,selectionofinstrumentsandcontroldevices,preparationofspecifications,reviewofconstructiondrawings,inspectionofnewfacilities,preparecalibratedandoperationinstructionsandmakedynamicresponsestudies.ProjectworkincludedtheCookPlantWasteEvaporatorandWasteEvaporatorBottomsSystems,RequestForChangeSheet,LotandUnitP2replacementequipment.1974to19751972to1974Engineer,Instrumentation&ControlSectionatCookPlant-ResponsibilitiesincludedsupervisionoftheNERVEorganizationasoutlinedbelowplusassistingtheCookPlantwithstaffprocedures,audits,testsandtraining.Indiana&MichianElectricComtianSupervisingEngineer,GeneralOffice,StationDepartmentatCookPlant-Responsibilitiesincludedsupervision,engineer,design,construction,maintenanceandoperationofstation&plantfacilities,superviseinstallation&maintenanceandofstationandplantequipment,formulatepoliciesandprocedures,supervisespecialstudiesandreports,assistinplanningandengineeringnewstations,superviserepairingequipmentinconnectionwithfailure.Responsibleforemployment,promotion,transfer,disciplineanddischarge.ProjectsincludedallelectricalcontrolsandD.C.CookNuclearPlant.1971to1972SeniorEngineer,GeneralOffice,StationDepartmentatCookPlant-Responsibilitiesincludedperforminganddirectingothersintesting,adjustingstationandplantequipment,reviewingconstructionprintstoassurethattheyareconsistentwithintendedfunction,inspect&coordinatetheworkofcontractors,makerecommendationstocorrectmalfunctions,planandperformspecialtests,analyzetestresults,prepareestimates,reportsandstudies.ProjectsincludedallelectricalcontrolsatD.C.CookNuclearPlant.1970to1971SeniorEngineer.,GeneralOffice,StationDepartmentatNewYorkOffice-ResponsibilitiesincludedparticipatinginthedesignandengineeringofD.C.CookNuclearPlant.Projectsincludeddieselloadanalysis,safeguardpumpcontrol,essentialservicewater,sewagedisposal,auxiliaryfeedwater,controlair,black"outsequencing,componentcoolingwaterthe345/765stationandthe69/4KVemergencypowerstation.6755B:1/1129838;20 JohnC.JeffreyPage31969to19701969to1969Engineer,GeneralOffice,StationDepartmentatMichiganPowerCompany-ResponsibilitiesincludedMaintenanceandPerformanceTestsofStationandHydroequipmentsuchascircuitbreakers,transformers,relaysandprotectiveequipment.Iwasresponsibleforinspectionofstationconstructionprojectsandcoordinatingcontractor'sworkandtraining.Projectsincludedtwo69KVtransmissionanddistributionstationandConstatineand'MottvilleHydroelectricplants.Engineer,GeneralOffice,StationDepartmentatBigSandyPlant-ResponsibilitiesincludedperformingtestsofPlantEquipmentsuchascircuitbreakers,heaters,transformers,pumps,valves,relays,protectiveequipmentandtraining.Projectsincludecirculatingwater,coolingtowers,trans-formers,pulverizers,generator,unitcircuitbreakersandthe765KVstationequipment.1968to1969Engineer,'GeneralOffice,StationDepartmentatMichiganPowerCompany-Responsibilitiesincludedmaintainingandperformingtestsofstationequipment,suchascircuitbreakers,transformers,relaysandprotectiveequipment.Iwasresponsibleforinspectionofstationconstructionprojectsandcoordinatingcontractorswork,design,economicjustificationofnewstationcontrolandtraining.Projectsincludedinspection,testing,repairandpartialredesignofControlatallMichiganPowerTransmissionStations.Thecontroldesign&economicjustification,testing,calibrationandplacinginserviceofa69/34KVtransmissionstationSchoolCraftSouth.1966to1968Engineer,GeneralOffice,.StationDepartmentatIndianaandMichiganElectricCo.-Responsibilitiesincludedrunningspecialequipmenttest,performingtestingofstationequipmentsuchascircuitbreakers,transformers,relaysandprotectiveequipment,carriercurrentandsupervisorycontrol.Iwasresponsibleforinspectonofstationconstructionprojectsandcoordinatingcontractor'sworkfortrainingandtrainingequipment,forcalibrationandtimingstudies,calibrationrecordsystemandcalibrationaids.Projectsincludedtestingofsolidstaterelays,testingshockpreventativedevices,designandconstructionofatrainingsimulator,developmentofacalibrationrecord,calibrationcharts,stationcalculations,timingcoordinationstudies,installationof345KVcircuitbreakersatTannersCreekPlant.Stationremovalandinstallationof345KVcircuitbreakersatBreekPlantStation.6755B:1/112983B-21

'\/A0 RexfordF.ShoemakerSeniorEnineer,Instrumentation&ControlSectionTwenty-oneyearsexperienceininstrumentation,controlandprotectivesystemsactivitiesinfossilfuelpowergenerationstations.EDUCATION:B.S.MechanicalEngineeringWestVirginiaInstituteofTechnology,1961EXPERIENCE:1972to1983ApalachianPowerComanPlantPerformanceSuperintendent,JohnE.AmosPlant-Responsibilitiesincludedallplantinstrumentation,controlandprotectivesystems,cyclechemistryandcontrol,environmentalcontrolsandthermalperformanceandtesting.Superviseeighty(80)technicalandsupervisorypersonnel.Wrotefirst1300MWIntegratedUnitControlSystemlineupandcalibrationprocedure.Alternateweekendcall-outdutieswithOperationDepartmentSuperintendent,superviseunitstart-upsandoperationsWrotefirst1300MWunitnormalcoldstart-upprocedure.1970to1972PerformanceSupervisingEngineer"Responsibilitiesincludedsupervisingtechniciansandengineersincheck-out,calibrationandstart-upactivitiesofAmosplantinstrumentationandcontrolssystemsontwo800MWandone1300MWcoalfiredsupercriticalpressureunits.1969to1970PerformanceEngineerSenior,ontemporaryassignmenttoAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporation,Instrumentation6ControlSectioninNewYorkCity-ResponsibilitiesincludedhelpingtoassemblecalibrationbooksforAmosUnits1and2.ReviseasrequiredforautomaticcontrolBigSandyUnit2IntegratedUnitControlSystem.Developfirst800MWIntegratedUnitControlSystemcalibrationandlineupdrawings.HelpwithMitchellUnitOneWestinghouse-HaganfactorycheckoutofIntegratedUnitControlSystemCabinets.1968to1969PerformanceEngineer,KanawhaRiverPlant-Responsibilitiesincludedsupervisinginstrumentandcontroltechniciancrew.6755B:1/112983B-23 RexfordF.ShoemakerPage21966to19671961to1966BaileMeterComanSystemsEngineer,Wickliffe,Ohio-Responsibilitiesincludeddes'ign,specify,documentstandardcontrolsystemlogicforcentralstationapplications.Troubleshootlargeelectroniccontrolsystemsonsupercriticalunitsandreviseasnecessarytohelpdevelopcompanystandards.Helpdesign,assemble,check-outandputintoservicefirstclosedloopanalogsimulatorforfactorycheckoutoflargeelec'troniccontrolsystemsforsupercriticalunits.FieldServiceEngineer,Cincinnati,Ohio-Responsibilitiesincludedserviceandmaintainexistingcontrolsystemspluscheckoutandstart-upnewcontrolsystemsrangingfromsmallpneumaticonindustrialdrumboilersandprocessestolargeelectroniconcentralstationunits.6755B:1/1129838"24 FrankS.VanPelt,Jr.ProfessionalEngineer-MichiganSectionManager-ConstructionProjectManagementIIIAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorp.BachelorofScience-MechanicalEngineeringVirginiaPolytechnicInstituteandStateUniversityJune,1982-Present-AmericanElectricPowerServiceCorp.SectionManagerforCookPlantProjectManagementIIIPlanningandSchedulingRFCworkforCookPlant.March,1980-May,1982-AmericanElectricPowerServiceCorpSectionManager-PlanningandScheduling;ProjectControls.CoordinatedCookPlantFSARUpdate;begandevelopmentofdetaillogicnetworksforCoalFiredPowerPlantConstructionprogram.HeadedoneofthreeteamsduringStudyprogramfornewcoalfiredpowerplant.July,1979-'ebruary,1980-AmericanElectricPowerServiceCorp.ProjectControl-Engineer-ConstructionProjects.Beganthedevelopmentofcomputerprogramforschedulingtheengineering,designandconstructionofacoalfiredpowerplant.April,1978-June,1979-AmericanElectricPowerServiceCorp.ProjectManagerassignedtoHeliumBreederAssociates,SanDiego,California.AssistedinthedevelopmentoftheManagementSystemandprogramtobeusedfortheGasCooledFastBreederReactorProgram.May,1977-March,1978-I&MElectricCo.-D.C.CookPlantLeadStart-upEngineerDirectedsixStart-UpEngineersinthecompletionandstart-upofUnit2'ntCookPlant.MaintainedthePreopscheduleandassuredtimelyreleaseofsystemsforPreopTesting..August,1972-April,1977-I&MElectricCo.-D.C.CookPlantStart-UpEngineer/AssistantLeadStart-upEngineerCoordinatedthecompletionandstart-upofassignedsystemsforbothUnit1and2.Preparedsysteminitialoperatingprocedures,flushingproceduresandhydrostatictestprocedures.6755B:1/112983B-25 FrankS.VanPelt,Jr.Page2June,1970-July,1972-CentralOperatingCo.-PhilipSpornPlantPerformanceEngineerPlanned,set-upequipment,tookdata,calculatedandanalyzedtheresultsandmaderecommendationsforequipmentperformanceimprovementsformyassignedunits.67558:1/1129838-26 JamesB.BrittanSeniorEnineer,ualitAssuranceMorethantwentyyearsexperienceinvariousgualityAssuranceandReliabilityactivitiesincludingsevenyearswithnuclearpowergenerationfacilities.EDUCATION:B.S.inMarineEngineering,NYStateMaritime1954GraduateStudiesinNuclearEngineering,UCLAMBA,CWPost,'Div.LIU.EXPERIENCE:1977toAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporationResponsibleforestablishmentandimplementationofcompletesupplierqualificationprogramforallcompaniesfurnishingequipmeatorservicesimportanttonuclearsafetytoAEP(morethanfourhundreddiverseorganizations).Responsibleforauditortrainingandcertificationprogram.Responsibleforplanning,schedulingandimplementationofinternalgualityAssuranceauditprogram.ProjectgArepresentativeonspentfuelrackmodificationandPlantsecuritysystemprojects.1962-1976LundElectronics8Sstem,Inc.gualityAssuranceManager,responsibleforqualityplanning,reliability,qualityplanning,qualityengineerng,qualitycontrolandalltestingassociatedwiththecompany'sdiverselineofelectromechanicalproducts.Directedenvironmentallab,modelshop,electroniclab,andmetrologyfunctions.Managedbudgets,testprogramcontracts,otherplanning8schedulingfunctions.Wroteproposals,testplansandreports.6755B:I/112983B-27 LouisP.DeMarcoEXPERIENCE:6/73-PresentEngineeringAssistantElectricalGenerationSectionElectricalEngineeringDivisionRESPONSIBILITIES:4/79-PresentResponsibleforSystemEngineeringfunctionssuchas:Evaluatingandimplementingallphasesofdesignmodificationsfortwo1100MWnuclearunits,includingRadiationMonitoringSystem,ReactorProtectionSystem,HydrogenMitigationDistributedIgnitionSystem,FireProtectionSystems,variousplantsystemsandtheirsupport.Provideplantstaffwithelectricalengipeeringsupport.InvestigateandprepareresponsesinconnectionwithNuclearRegulatoryCommissioncircularsandbulletins.CoordinatePlant'AnnunciatorResponseProcedureReview.TaskforcememberforOnsiteLowLevelRadiationWasteStorageFacility.3/76-4/79(}ualityControlEngineerresponsibleformanagingandimplementingthequalitycontrolsystemfornuclearplantengineeringdesignmodifications,includingreviewofallelectricalengineeringdes'ignmodificationsfortechnicalandproceduralcompleteness.6/73-3/76TechnicalAssistant,assistingbothfossilandnuclearengineeringstaffby:performingengineeringcalculations,datatabulations,equipmentspecifications,purchaseandexpediting.EDUCATION:PolytechnicInstituteofNewYork110creditscompletedtowardB.S.E.E.StatenIslandCommunityCollegeA.S.S.Degree-1973Electro-MechanicalTechnology6755B:1/1129838-29 ftJ ThaddeusRussellStephensCitizenshiU.S.(Born-Niles,Michigan)PositionTitleSeniorPerformanceEngineerPresentEmloerIndianaandMichiganElectricCo'mpanyDonaldC.CookNuclearPlantEducationNovember1980:AttendedCombustionEngineering'stwo-weekSimulatorTrainingProgramandcompletedthereactorstartupexaminationsatisfactorily.April1980:UniversityofMichigan,AnnArbor,Michigan.Successfullycompletedthetwo-weekReactorOperatorTrainingProgramatFordNuclearReactor/PhoenixMemorialLaboratory.March1978:Asixteen-hourcourseonvibrationanalysisgivenbytheIRDCompany.(June-August1976:AmericanElectricPower'sPerformanceImprovementProgramconsistedof240hoursofbothclassroomlecturesonpowerplantrelatedsubjectsandperformancetestingof1300megawattcoalfiredunitwithrelatedequipmentandcalculationsoftestdata.March1975:Aforty-hourrecorderandcontrolsmaintenancecoursegivenbytheLeeds8NorthrupCompany.1974:Graduated,Tri-StateCollege,Angola,Indiana,BachelorofScienceinMechanicalEngineering.Attendeda40-hourManagementTrainingCoursegivenbytheIndiana4MichiganElectricCompany.6755B:1/112983B-31 T.R.StephensPage2Setember1979toPresent:SeniorPerformanceEngineerassignedtotheOperationsDepartmentattheDonaldC.CookNuclearPlant.DutiesincludethereviewandrevisionoftheOperationsDepartmentProceduresandgeneraltechnicalsupportfortheDepartment.Auust1976toSeptember1979:SeniorPerformanceEngineeratTannersCreek,havingthedutiestosupervisethePerformanceEngineerswhohaveunitresponsibility,toscheduletestworkandassignandmonitorprojectwork.November1974toAuust1976:WorkedasaPerformanceEngineerina1050megawattgeneratingstationwhichhasfourcoal-fi,redunits.ThestationistheTannerysCreekStationownedbytheIndiana5MichiganElectricCompany,asubsidiaryofAmericanElectricPowerCompany.Mydutiesincludedtestingofmajorunitequipment,assortedprojectwork,andthemaintainingoftheunit'scontrolsystems.March1974toNovember1974:WorkedasafirstlinesupervisorofaforgelineandweldinglineinthemanufactureofsinglepieceaxlehousingsintheHousingDivisionofClarkEquipmentCompany.Lefttogetworkmoreinlinewithmyprofessionaltraining.June1968toMarch1974:Co-opstudentwithClarkEquipmentCompanyinBuchanan,Michigan.6755B:1/112983B-32 JOHND.YOUNG-SeniorEngineer,ElectricalPowerSystems/ControlBoardDesign,WestinghouseElectricCorporationEducation:-B.S.inElectricalEngineeringfromTri-StateCollege~EMr.YoungiswithWestinghouseElectricCorporationintheInstrumentationandControlDepartment,ElectricalPowerSystemsandControlBoardDesigngroup.Hisworkexperienceforthepasttenyearshasbeenintheareaofmaincont'rolandpanellayout.design.HeistheleadengineerfortheControlBoardDesigngroup.Mr.Youngwastheresponsibledesignengineerforthecontrolboardsforthefollowingnuclearpowerplants:a)SequoyahUnits1and2b)WattsBarUnits1and2c)KrskoUnit1(Yugoslavia)d)NapotPointUnit1(Philippines)HewasalsotheresponsibleengineerinthedesignofamodularoperationconsolewhichcanintegratetherequirementsofReg.Guide1.97andNUREG0696intoexistingcontrolrooms.Mr.Youngalsohasoverthreeyearsexperiencewiththereactorprotectionandsafeguardssystemspanels.Hewasinstrumentalinthedesignofthesafeguardson-linetestingsysem.Mr.Young'sexperienceinthenuclearindustryspansfourteenandone-halfyearswithWestinghouseintheInstrumentationandControlfield.6755B:1/112983B"33 WAYNER.YOUNG-Engineer,ElectricalPowerSystemsandControlBoardDesignEducation:-A.S.inElectronicsTechnologyfromtheCommunityCollegeofAlleghenyCounty-ContinuingtowardsaB.S.inElectricalEngineeringfromtheUniversityofPittsburghExerience:Mr.YoungiswiththeWestinghouseElectricCorporationintheInstrumentationandControlDepartment,ElectricalPowerSystemsandControlBoardDesignGroup.Hisworkexperiencehasbeenintheareaofmaincontrolboard/panellayoutanddesign.HistotalnuclearexperiencespansnineyearsofservicewithWestinghouseintheinstrumentationandcontrolfield.HeisthecognizantengineerforthehumanengineeringevaluationfortheLouisianaPowerandLightWaterford3nuclearplant,aprogramwhichincludedthefollowing.a)Assessthelayoutandadequacyofthemaincontrolboard(MCB)requiredtosupportoperatingcrewactivitiesthroughtheuseofplant-specificEmergencyOperatingProcedures(EOPs).b)VerifythattheEOPsequenceofstepsandproceduralflowarecompatiblewiththeMCBlayout.c)ConductEOPverificationwalk-throughsintheWaterford3controlroom.d)=ProviderecommendationsforresolutionofHumanEngineeringDiscrepancies(HEDs).e)Assistinthedevelopmentofplantspecific,symptom-based,eventscenariosforuseintheEOPverification.6755B:1/062883B-35 WAYNER.YOUNG(continued)f)Assistinthepreparationoftheeventrecognitionreport,MCRdisplaymaps,taskmaps,andlinkanalysisdocumentation.Mr.Youngisalsoresponsibleforthemaincontrolboardequipmentqualificationprogram.DutiesforequipmentqualifiedtoIEE323"1974and344-1975include:a)Participationinthepreparationofequipmentqualificationreports.b)Generationandmaintenanceofbaselinedesigndocuments.c)Generationandmaintenanceofcomputerizedspecifications.d)Equipmentquotations.e)Equipmentprocurement.f)Maintenanceofqualificationfilsforauditability.Additionally,Mr.YoungisthesystemsengineerfortheNuclearSteamSupplySystem(NSSS)onthefollowingpowerplants:a)ComanchePeakUnits¹1and¹2b)McGuireUnits¹1and¹2c)CatawbaUnits¹1and¹2d)MannshanUnits¹1and¹2e)KoreaUnit¹2f)MillstoneUnit¹2g)VirgilC.Summerh)BeaverValleyUnit¹2Activitiesincludereviewandapprovalofarchitect/engineerdocumentation,designoftheroddropdisconnectswitchbox,equipmentprocurement,schedul-ing,anddocumentationtransmittal.6755B:1/062883~B-36 ROBERTJ.WARTENBERG-InstructionCoordinatorandInstructor,InstrumentationTechnologyTrainingCenter,WestinghouseElectricCorporationEducation:-CommunityCollegeofAlleghenyCountry,12credithoursinEducation-SouthernIllinoisUniversity,69credithoursinEducation-Militaryschools:ElectronicTechnician"A"School,BasicNuclearPowerSchool,andNuclearPowerPrototypeExerience:Mr.Wartenberghasover8yearsofexperienceinthenavalandcommercialnuclearfields,withemphasisonplantoperationsandtraining,andsupervisoryexperienceinallaspectsofcoursepresentation,personneltraining,andprogramadministrationanddevelopment.Mr.Wartenbergassistsinhumanfactorsevaluationsofcontrolroomdesignsandprocedureverifica-tions.InOctoberof1981,hereceivedSeniorReactorOperatorcertification.Asaninstructioncoordinator,heisresponsibleformeetingtheoverallobjectivesofallcustomersimulatorcoursesandthedirectionofinstructionalactivitiesoffifteeninstructors,withparticipationdirectlyinstudentandinstructorevaluationsandaudits.Previousworkexperienceincludesanassignementasaninstructortothereactorcontrolsdivision,andasaqualifiedreactoroperatorandshutdownreactoroperatoronanavalnuclearprototype.Asatrainingengineer,Mr.WartenbergalsoassistedinthestartupoftheSNUPPSIIsimulator.6755B:1/062883B-37 G.ALLENELLIFF,EDUCATION:Ph.D.,M.S.,B.S.,IndustrialEngineering/OperationsResearch,TexasARMUniversity,1973IndustrialEngineering/OperationsResearch,TexasARMUniversity,1971'ndustrialEngineering,TexasARMUniversity,1970AFFILIATIONS:AmericanInstituteofIndustrialEngineers.OperationsResearchSocietyofAmericaAlphaPiMu(IndustrialEngineeringHonorSociety)SigmaXiPROFESSIONALBRIEF:Dr.ElliffisaBranchManagerinEssexCorporation'sAlexandriaoffice.Heiscurrentlyresponsibleformanagement,technicaldirection,andreviewofprojectsfornuclearindustryclientsoftheIndustrialServicesDepartment.Dr.Elliff'sutilityexperienceincludesdirectprojectmanagementresponsibilityforseveralnuclearpowerplantcontrolroomdesignreviews,aswellasmanagementoversightandreviewofrelatedprojectsfornuclearindustryclients.Hehas10yearsconsultingexperiencewiththemilitary(Navy,AirForce,andOfficeoftheSecretaryofDefense);otherfederalagencies(DepartmentofEnergy,DepartmentofTransportation);andprivatesectorclients(utilities,motorcarriers,railroads,militaryhardwarevendors).Hisexperienceincludesappliedhumanfactorsanalysis,maintenancemanagement,logisticsupportanalysis,lifecyclecost/designtocostanalysis,informationsystemvalidation,businessandfinancialmanagement,marketanalysis,transportationoperationsanalysis,mathematicalmodelling,reliability/maintainabilityanalysis,productionengineering,statisticalqualitycontrol,andtrainingcoursedevelopmentandpresentation.PriortojoiningEssexin1981,Dr.ElliffwasassociatedwithEvaluationResearchCorporation;Peat,Marwick,Mitchell,RCo.;LogisticsManagementInstitute;andtheTexasARMUniversitygraduatefaculty.Dr.Elliffalsohasthreeyearsexperienceasafull-timegraduatefacultymemberatTexasARMUniversityteachingindustrialengineeringandoperationsresearchcoursesandsupervisingthesisresearch.EXPERIENCE:CANYONRESEARCHGROUP,aDivisionofEssexCorporation(1981-Present)Manaer0erationsAnalsisBranchIndustrialServices

Deartment-ProvidemanagementandtechnicaldirectionforconductofIndustrialServicesDepartmentoperationsanalysisprojects.Haveprimarytechnicalresponsibilityforalloperationaltaskanalysis,

probabilisticriskassessment,andhumanreliabilityanalysesfortheIndustrialServicesDepartment.Serveasseniortechnicalresourceforapplicationofindustrialengineeringandoperationsresearchtechniquestoclientsituations.Responsiblefortechnicalreviewofclientdeliverables.B-39 G.ALLENELLIFF(continued)Providemanagementreviewofprojectplan,technicalscope,andresourceestimatesforIndustrialServicesDepartmentprojects.Asbranchmanager,supervisehumanfactorsanalystsandlicensedSeniorReactorOperators(SROs).Assignappropriatepersonneltoclientprojects,asneeded.MonitorcostandschedulestatusonallIndustrialServicesDpartmentprojectstoensurecompletionofproductstoclientsatisfaction.Projectmanagerfordetailedcontrolroomdesignreview(DCRDR)forPublicServiceElectricandGasCompany'sHopeCreekGeneratingStation(HCGS).HCGS'isaneartermoperatinglicenseboilingwaterreactor.Thecontrolroomisoneofthemoreadvancednuclearpowerplantcontrolr'oomsintheUnitedStatesandemploysseveralCRTs.AlsoservingasprojectmanagerforDCRDRofDonaldC.CookUnitland2controlrooms.D.C.Cookplantisanoperatingplantwithseveralyearsofoperatingexperience.ManageddetailedhumanfactorscontrolroomdesignreviewforTexasUtilitiesGeneratingCompany'sComanchePeakSteamElectricStation(CPSES)Unitl.Evaluatedcontrolroomforcompliancewithhumanengineeringprinciplesandapplicableregulatoryguidelines.DirectedEssexhumanfactorsanalystsandSROsinassessmentofproposedclientrearrangementofCPSEScontrolboards.Assistedclientindesignandapplicationofmimics,demarcation,andhierarchicallabelingoftheCPSESUnitlcontrolboards.Developedamodelforpredictinghumanreliabilityinnuclearpowerplantcontrolroomoperations.Foraforeignnuclearutility,developedestimatesofexpectedimprovementsinoperatorreliabilityforsuggestedbackfitstoresolvethirty"genericcontrolroomdesignproblems.Providedgeneralmanagementdirectionformajorproceduresdevelopmentandproductionprojectforaneartermoperatinglicense(NTOL)plant.Thefirstphaseoftheprojectinvolvedrewriting/reformattingofallemergency,abnormal,andstandardoperatingprocedures.Asaresultofprojectteamperformance,Essexwasalsoawardedcontractfordevelopmentandproductionofapproximately300nuclearpowerplantsurveillance/testprocedures.Thisphaseinvolvedrewrite/reformat,technicalreview,andeditingofprocedures;technicaldirectionofallprojectstaff;andcoordinationoftheproductionoftheproceduresfrominitialwritingthroughfinalwordprocessing.Essexprojectteamwascomposedof6to8technicalwriters,twoeditors,twonuclearplantoperationsspecialists,and8wordprocessors,plustwoshiftsupervisorsfromclientorganization.EVALUATIONRESEARCHCORPORATIONVienna,Virginia(1979-1981)PrincialEnineerandBranchManaerSstemsEnineerinandAnalsisGrouProvidedtechnicalandengineeringsupporttoNAVSEA,NAVELEX,NAVAIR,andotherFederalgovernmentclients.Thissupportincludedintegratedlogisticssupport(ILS)analyses,systemsanalysis,systemsengineering,costanalysis,andapplicationofopera-tionsresearchtechniquesforshipandsystemacquisitionprogramsandILSfunctionaloffices.B-40 G.ALLENELLIFF(continued)ParticipatedindevelopmentofNAVSEAReliabilityandMaintainabilityTechnicalSeminar.Performedacomparativelifecyclecost(LCC)analysisof3EREDandCHTmarinesanitationsystemsforDD963classships.ResultswereaprimeinputtoNADECbriefing.AsamemberofCAPTORProductionReadinessReview(PRR)Team,assessedthecapabilityofprimecontractorandfirsttiersubcontractortoeffectivelymanagefull-scaleproduction.AsaresultofthePRR,thecontractorswererequiredtomakesubstantiveimprovementstoproductioncontrolprocedurespriortofullproductionrelease.DevelopedmultipleregressionmodeltoprojectNavyship-buildingqualityassurance(QA)manpowerrequirementsbasedonworkloaddescriptorparameters.Developedananalyticapproachandplanfortrade-offandcostimpactanalysisofalternativeaviationintermediatemaintenancesupportstrategiesfortheAviationInter-mediateMaintenanceImprovementProjectOffice.Objectiveofthistaskwasidentifica-tionofthecomplementofintermediate-levelmaintenanceequipment,spareparts,andpersonnelskillsthatwouldmostimprovemissioneffectivenessofthedeckloadofagivenaircraftcarrier.AnalyticapproachintegratedexistingNavydatafilesandmodelstothegreatestextentpractical.ManagedprojecttoassessperformanceandeffectivenessofdefensecontractorinprovidingsupplyanddepotrepairsupportonAN/SLQ-32(V).Evaluatedtimeliness,quality,andcostofdepotrepairandsupplysupportprovidedbycontractor.Integratedandcross-validatedtransactiondatafromnumerouscontractorinternaldatasources,includingADPreports,manuallogbooks,andsourcedocuments.AssessedoperationalavailabilitybasedonanalysisofCASREPTSand0790-2Kformsanddata.DeterminedsystemstockandmaintenancerepairpartsrequirementstosupportAN/SLQ-32(V).AssistedinconductingFY1981provisioningconference.Preparedcontractorderstoimplementresultsofprovisioningconference.Attendedprogramreviewsinsupportofprogramoffice.ProvidedtechnicalreviewofLogisticSupportAnalysis(LSA)ProgramPlanforArmyStand-offTargetAcquisitionSystem(SOTAS)undercontracttoMotorola.SeniorAnalstandPro'ectManaerPlanninandSciencesGrou-ManagedanddirectednumerousprojectsforU.S.DepartmentofEnergyclients.SeniortechnicalanalystforquantitativeanalysistasksforthePlanningandSciencesGroup.DirectedindependentvalidationsofvariousDOEandindustryinformationsystemsandmodels.ManagedaprojecttovalidatetheDOECrudeOilTransferPricingSystem(ERA-51).Projectincludedassessmentofuserrequirements,respondentreportingandmeasurementpractices,andDOEdataprocessingprocedures.Qualitativeandquantitativeanalysesfordataconsistencyandvaliditywereperformed,bothwithinERA-51andbetweenERA-51andrelatedDOEreportingsystems.8-41 G.ALLENELLIFF(continued)Providedtechnicalandmanagementdirectionforquantitativedataanalysesforfourdatasystemsprovidinginformationonmajorindustrialcombustorstosupportenforce-,mentofthePowerPlantandIndustrialFuelUseAct.SystemsanalyzedincludedtheDOEBoilerManufacturer'sReport(ERA-97),DOE1975MajorFuelBurningInstallationCoalConversionReport(FEA-C-602-S-O),DOE1980ManufacturingIndustriesEnergyCon-sumptionStudyandSurveyofLargeCombustors(EIA-063),andEPANationalEmissionsDataSystem(NEDS).Developedscenariosforassessmentofrefineryindustrycapabilitytorespondtovarioussupplyanddemandscenarios.Analysisrequiredfamiliaritywithtworefinerymodels:BonnerandMooreRefineryandPetrochemicalModelingSystem(RPMS)andTurner,Mason,Solomon(TMS)refinerymodel.RPMSandTMSmodelswerelinkedtoaccountforrefineryprocessingcapabilities,transportationnetwork,andpetroleuminventorymanagementconsiderations..Developedproductpricesandcost,quality,andquantitycharacteristicsofcrudeslatesforseveralrefineriesusingDOEdatainquick-reactionsupportfortheOfficeofSpecialCounsel(OSC).DatawasinputtoRPMS,whichwasusedinsupportofOSCauditandcomplianceanalysis.~c"PEAT>MARWICKyMITCHELLRCOWashington,D.C.(1975-1979)jISeniorConsultantandPro'ectManaer-Managedthe'evelopmentandimplementa-tionofalifecyclecostbudgetaryprojectionmodelfortheHARPOONProjectOffice.Determinedanddocumentedlogisticsresourcesforsupportofagivenprocurementschedule;developedandvalidatedpredictivecostestimatingrelationships;identifiedappropriationandbudgetsponsorsforeachenditemandlogisticresourcecategory;anddevelopedtime-phasedfundingrequirementsbyappropriationtosupportaparticularacquisitionscenario.Asamemberofamanagementauditteam,evaluatedtheanalyticcapabilityoftheF-16SystemProjectOfficeorganization.Areasevaluatedincludedlifecyclecost/designtocost(LCC/DTC)estimationandtrackingcapability,configurationmanagement,ILSplanningandcoordination,andassessmentoftheextenttowhichacommondatabaseofcostandperformanceparameterswasmaintainedforuseinperformingthevariousanalytictasks.Definedanddevelopedanintegratedprojecttaskmanagementinformationsystem(MIS)fortheShipboardIntermediateRangeCombatSystemProjectOffice.Surveyedinformationrequirements;conductedaninventoryandasse'ssmentofinformationsources;definedinformationflows;investigatedinformationprocessinganddisplayalternatives;anddevelopedanMIStoprovidekeyprojectpersonnelwithcurrentandprojectedcost/schedulestatus,varianceanalyses,financialflexibilityanalyses,andassessmentoftheprobableimpactofpotentialmanagementdecisions.8-42 G.ALLENELLIFF(continued)Developedandpresentedseminarsforcommercialclientsonlifecyclecost/designtocost,DepartmentofDefense(DOD)acquisitionpolicies,andDODmarketing.Servedascorporaterepresentative'totheWeaponSystemLifeSupport(WSLS)groupunderNSIALogisticsManagementCommittee(LOMAC).ManagedaprojectfortheFederalRailroadAdministrationtoperformsystemsengineeringforintermodalfreightsystems.Identified,described,andanalyzedthefullrangeofimprovedandinnovativecomponents,subsystems,andsystems.Assessedproposedinnovationsandimprovedtechnologiesforpotentialtoimprove"profitabilityandreturnoninvestmentforrail-basedintermodalfreightsystems;PrincipalInvestigatorforaprojecttodevelopanimprovedpassengercarmainte-nanceandutilizationprogramfortheNationalRailroadPassengerCorporation(AMTRAK).SpecificresponsibilitiesincludedassessmentoftheeffectivenessofthecurrentAMTRAKpassengercarmaintenanceprocess,identificationoftrade-offsbetweenpassengercarmaintenanceandpassengercarutilization,anddevelopmentofrecommendationsforimprovingboththequalityofAMTRAKmaintenanceandutilizationofitspassengercarfleet.ManagedastudyfortheFederalRailroadAdministrationtoassessalternativeorganizationalstructuresforyardsandterminalsfortheUnitedStatesrailindustry.Analyzedmanagementcontrolsystems,measuresofeffectiveness,andtheeffectoforganizationalalternativesforyardsandterminalsontheinfrastructureoftherailindustry.Managedprojectsforprivaterailroadsinvolvingmarket,operations,andtrafficanalysis,anddevelopmentofbusinessstrategies.Foramajormotorcarrier,performedananalysisofterminalandline-hauloperationstoimprovecarrierprofitabilityandoperationalefficiency.LOGISTICSMANAGEMENTINSTITUTEWashington,D.C.(1970-1975)SeniorResearchAssociate-ForPMS306,underjointsponsorshipwiththeAssistantSecretaryofDefenseInstallationsandLo'gistics),analyzedandevaluatedtheabilityoftheNavy'sintermediate-levelmaintenanceactivitiestosupportthesurfaceFleetinthemid-1980's.ResponsibilityincludedassessmentoftheadequacyoftheNavy'smainte-nancedatacollectionsystem(MDCS)indocumentingmaintenancedeliveredtotheFleet,trade-offanalysestodeterminethemosteffectiveutilizationofNavyresourcesinsupportingthesurfaceFleet,anddevelopmentofspecificrecommendationsforimprovement.DevelopedamanagementinformationsystemandtheassociateddatabasetoassistplannersintheOfficeoftheAssistantSecretaryofDefense(InstallationsandLogistics)inmakingpolicydecisionsregardingavionicsstandardization.Thesystem.wascapableofproducingannualprojectionsofthedemandforavionicssystemsintermsoffunctionalrequirementand/orassociatedhardwarebyTMSofaircraft,attheequipmentlevel,foraircraftscheduledformajormodificationoracquisitionduringthe1975-1985timeframe.

G.ALLENELLIFF(continued)Thedatabasecouldbereadilyupdatedonanannualbasis,therebyenablingthesystemtocontinueproviding10yearprojections.Developedacostelementstructure(CES)forlifecyclecost(LCC)analysisoftrackedvehiclesasinputtoanLMItaskaddressingthefeasibilityofastandardizedLCCCESforvarioustypesofDODsystems.TEXASARMUNIVERSITYCollegeStation,Texas(1972-'1970)AssistantProfessorofIndustrialEnineerin-Taughtgraduatecoursesandsupervisedthesisresearchinoperationsresearch,productionengineering,manufacturingprocesses,productionmanagement,engineeringcostestimating,productionandinventorycontrol,andqualityassurancetograduatestudentsinreliabilityandmaintainabilityengineeringprogramssponsoredbytheArmyMaterialCommand(nowDARCOM).Dissertationtopicaddressedeconomicdesignofacontinuoussamplingqualityassuranceplan,whichhasresultedinapublicationandpresentations.PUBLICATIONSANDTECHNICALPRESENTATIONS'ranco,3.,Elliff,G.A.,andTulis,E.A.MemorandumReort-DevelomentofProductPricesforRPMSStaticRefinerModel,3une2,1981.PreparedforOfficeofTechnologyandComputerSciences,OfficeofSpecialCounsel,EconomicRegulatoryAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofEnergy.Elliff,G.A.,andFranco,3.AlicabilitofDOEModelsinShort-TermContinenc~plannin,March27,f981.PreparedforOfficeofTechnologyandComputerScience,OfficeofSpecialCounsel,EconomicRegulatoryAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofEnergy.Elliff,G.A.MemorandumReort-AssinrnentofCoststoCrudeOilFeedstocksforEstablishinStaticRefinerBaseCasesMarch19,1981.PreparedforOfficeofTechnologyandComputerScience,OfficeofSpecialCounsel,EconomicRegulatoryAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofEnergy.Elliff,G.A.,andTulis,E.A.MemorandumReort-Analsisofthe"AveraeDa"ConcetforEstablishinCrudeandProductSlatesforSohioBaseCases,February9,1981.PreparedforOfficeofTechnologyandComputerScience,OfficeofSpecialCounsel,EconomicRegulatoryAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofEnergy.Elliff,G.A.,andTulis,E.A.PreliminarAnalsisoftheDOETransferPricinSstem,February1,1981.PreparedfortheOfficeofEnergyInformationValidation,EnergyInformationAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofEnergy.Leilich,R.H.,Elliff,G.A.,etal.SstemsEnineerinforIntermodalFreihtSstems(3volumes).PreparedfortheFederalRailroadAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofTransportation,March1978.B-44 G.ALLENELLIFF(continued)Yager,R.,Elliff,G.A.,andBauer,R.StudtoDeveloanIntercitPassenerCarMaintenanceandUtilizationProram,April1977.PreparedfortheFederalRailroadAdministration,U.S.DOT,andNationalRailroadPassengerCorporation(AMTRAK).Fisher,W.,Elliff,G.A.,andWhite,3.M..DODDemandforSelectedAvionicAssemblies-PhaseI.InterimReportonLMITask75-9,November1975.Shepherd,F.,Elliff,G;A.,andWroblewski,P.SurfaceShiMaintenance,LMIReport70-21,ADA008233,3anuary1975.Elliff,G.A.,andFoster,3.W."ANoteofCalculationoftheAverageFractionInspectedforaContinuousSamplingPlan."International3ournalofProductionResearch,1975.Elliff,G.A.,andFoster,3.W."LeastCostContinuousSamplingPlans."PresentedatORSA/TIMS3ointNationalMeeting,LasVegas,Nevada,November1975.Elliff,G.A.,andFoster,3.W."EconomicDesignofaMultilevelContinuousSamplingPlan."PresentedatAOASymposiumonLogistics,FortLee,Virginia,February1970.Elliff,G.A."AnEconomicBasiswithInspectorAccuracyConsiderationsforDesignofaMulti-levelContinuousSamplingPlan,"unpublisheddoctoraldissertation,TexasARMUniversity,1973.Elliff,G.A."CostOptimizationofaTricklingFiltrationSewageTreatmentFacilityUsingPatternSearchwithSummationofGradients,"unpublishedmasters'hesis,TexasARMUniversity,1971.SECURITYCLEARANCE:SECRET,grantedbyDISCO(1970).B-45 JOHNFFARBRY,JR.EDUCATION:BachelorofArchitecture,WashingtonUniversity,1965.M.A.ExperimentalPsychology,UniversityofMissouri-Columbia,1973Ph.D.ExperimentalPsychology,UniversityofMissouri-Columbia,1978;MajorArea:HumanMemoryandCognitionAFFILIATIONS:AmericanPsychologicalAssociation(Member)Division21:SocietyofEngineeringPsychologistsHumanFactorsSociety(Member)TechnicalInterestGroup:ComputerSystemsPotomacChapteroftheHumanFactorsSociety(Member)PROFESSIONALBRIEF:Dr.Farbry'sactivityinpsychologyhasbeenconcernedwithbasicresearchinhumanperformance,teaching,andtheapplicationofpsychologicalknowledgetocomplexsystemsinindustrialsettings.Hisresearchactivityinvolvestheinvestigationofstresseffectsinteractingwithindividualdifferences.andtheanalysisofhumanmemoryandlearning.Inthefirstarea,stresseffectswereexaminedwithregardtocopingresponsesinaVAhospitalenvironment.Also,theeffectsofstressonproblem-solvingbehaviorwerestudiedinalaboratorysetting.Thesecondareaincludesthestudyofqualitativechangesinmemoryoveranextendedperiodoftimeandtheobservationoferrorbehaviorinrotelearning.Theundergraduatecoursestaughtincludeexperimentalmethod,physiologicalpsychology,introductorypsychologyandthepsychologyoflanguage.DuringhisthreeyearsatEssex,hisworkhasbeenprimarilyconcernedwiththeanalysisandevaluationoftheoperator-machineinterfaceinnuclearpowerplantcontrolrooms.ThisworkhasbeendirectedprimarilytotheevaluationofconventionalPWRandBWRmaincontrolroomsintheU.S.andaBWRradwastecontrolroominJapan.Hehasconducteddesignstudiesofcontrolpanelcomponentarrangementinbothcases.ThetwomostrecentprojectshavefocusedontheevaluationofCRTdisplaysystemsinadvancedcontrolroomsforBWRandPWRfacilitiesinJapan.EXPERIENCE:ESSEXCORPORATION(1980-Present)roomofChubuElectricPowerCompany.Thisworkincludedtheupdatingandreorgani-zationofCRTspecifications;analysisofpopulationstereotypedatafromclientoperationspersonnelandapplicationoftheresultstoCRTevaluation.Conductedreviewoffunctionalallocationbetweencontrolroomoperatorvs.CRT,systemandaninformationavailabilityanalysis.Evaluation,ofCRTdisplaysystemincludingfeaturesofCRTformatorganization,color/symbolschemes,alarmsystem,CRTinformationaccessandlabeling.ResearchScientist.Developedgeneralguidelinesand'criteriatosupportdesignofmaincontrolroominanuclearpowerplant.TheguidelinesweredirectedtotheB-47 3OHNE.FARBRY,3R.(Continued)arrangementandgroupingofcomponentsandcomponentsystemsonthemaincontrolpanel,thedeterminationoftheprofileandfloorplanconfigurationofthecontrolpanelandtheplanningofthecontrolroomfacility.ResearchScientist.Developedpopulationstereotypequestionnaireforcontrolpanelelementswithresultsappliedtostereotypespecificationforanadvancedcontrolroom(ACR)ofapressurized'waterreactorunitforMitsubishiHeavyIndustries.AlsoevaluatedCRTpagesforACRandstudiedoperatormovementamongCRTs.Developedvoice-computercommunicationguidelinestosupportinteractivecomputersystems.Pro'ectEnineer.Evaluationofproposedandexistingcontrolpanelsforradwastecontrolroomofboilingwaterreactorplantfor3apanAtomicPowerCompany.Short-andlong-termrecommendationsweremaderegardingthearrangementofpanelcomponents,proposedcomponenttypesandannunciatorsystem.Therecommendationsincludedadesignproposalforthecomponentarrangementoftworadwastecontrolsubpanels.ResearchAssociate.PerformedhumanfactorsevaluationandadesignstudyformaincontrolpanelarrangementofnewpressurizedwaterreactorpowerplantforCarolinaPowerandLight.Alsoparticipatedinon-siteevaluationofindividualcomponentsandpanelarrangementformaincontrolpanelofexistingboilingwaterreactorplantandpreparedlabelbackfitsupplement.HELLMUTH,OBATA,ANDKASSABAUM,INC.SaintLouis,Missouri(1978-1980)ArchitecturalDraftsman/Research.Commercialstructures:preparationofcon-structiondocuments,statisticalresearchonfirmsdistributionofmanpoweracrossdifferentbuildingtypes.Clientcontact,coordinationwithstructuralandmechanicalengineers,buildingcodeanalysis.CHINNANDASSOCIATESColumbia,Missouri(1977-1978)ArchitecturalDraftsman.Commercialandresidentialstructures.Coordinationwithstructuralandmechanicalengineers,preparationofconstructiondocumentssuchassiteplans,floorplans,elevations,constructiondetailsandperspectives.STEPHENSCOLLEGEColumbia,Missouri(1976-1977)Instructor.DepartmentofPsychology.FullresponsibilityforsixcoursesinBasicPsychologyandcoursesinPsychobiologyandthePsychologyofLanguage.Also,studentadvisingandstaffseminarparticipation.B-48 3OHNE.FARBRY,3R.(Continued)MID-MISSOURIMENTALHEALTHCENTER,Columbia,Missouri(1970-1976)ResearchAssistant-Coordinatedmedical,research,andtechnicalstaffforpsychologicalresearchonstressinhospitalpatientsreceivingadifficultexamination(endoscopy).Alsorecordingofpolygraphdatabeforeandduringexamination,pre-andpost-patientinterviews,datareduction/preliminaryanalysis,libraryresearch,andassis-tancewiththepreparationofavarietyofjournalarticles.CHINN,DARROUGH,ANDCOMPANYColumbia,Missouri(1973-1970)ArchitecturalDraftsman.Commercialandresidentialstructures:preparationofconstructiondocuments,coordinationwithstructuralandmechanicalengineers.UNIVERSITYOFMISSOURIColumbia,Missouri(1973)TeachinAssistant.DepartmentofHomeEconomics.ArchitecturalDesignII:Taughtdesign,process,planning,anddevelopmentofdraftingskills.Delineationcourse:Emphasisoncolormediaappliedtointeriorperspectivedrawing.UNIVERSITYOFMISSOURIColumbia,Missouri(1969-1973)"TeachinAssistant.DepartmentofPsychology.GeneralExperimentalPsychology(LaboratoryInstructor;GeneralPsychology(CourseCoordinator,DiscussionLeader);andResearchMethods,TheSenses,AppliedPsychology(Assistant).UNIVERSITYOFMISSOURIColumbia,Missouri(1969-1971)ResearchAssistant.DepartmentofPsychology.Designofgraphicstimuli(faceassistancewiththewritingofjournalarticles.HELLMUTH,OBATA,ANDKASSABAUM,INC.*(1966-1968)SaintLouis,MissouriArchitecturalDraftsman.Commercialstructures:documents.preparationofconstructionA.L.AYDELOTTANDASSOCIATESMemphis,Tennessee(1965)ArchitecturalDraftsman.Commercialstructures:documents.preparationofconstructionB-49 3OHNE.FARBRY,3R.(Continued)TECHNICALREPORTS:SummarReort:AHumanEnineerinReviewofanAdvancedControlRoomCRTDislaSstemfortheChubuElectricPowerComan.TechnicalReportforChubuElectricPowerCompany,Inc.inNagoya,3apan,inpress.(withD.Eike)HumanEnineerinSecificationsforanAdvancedControlRoomCRTDislaSstemfortheChubuElectricPowerComan.TechnicalReportforChubuElectricPowerCompany,Inc.inNagoya,3apan,inpress.(withR.Kane,S.Fleger,andT.O'Donoghue)AFunctionalAllocationReviewofanAdvancedControlRoomCRTDislaSstemfortheChubuElectricPowerComan.TechnicalReportforChubuElectricPowerCompany,Inc.inNagoya,3apan,inpress,(withT.Harding).AHumanEnineerinEvaluationofanAdvancedControlRoomCRTDislaSstemfortheChubuElectricPowerComan.TechnicalReportforChubuElectricPowerCompany,Inc.inNagoya,3apan,inpress.(withS.Fleger,R.Kane,T.Harding,andD.Pilsitz).ResonseSterotesof3aaneseControlRoom0eratorstoElementsofCRTDisla~Sstems.TechnicalReportforChubuElectricPowerCompany,Inc.inNagoya,3apan,October,1982.AHumanEnineerinEvaluationofCRTFormatsCRTsandKeboardsfortheMitsubishiHeavIndustriesAdvancedControlRoom.TechnicalReportforMitsubisiHeavyIndustries,3apan,3uly1982.withR.Kane,S.Fleger,T.HardingandF.Piccione)ExtracontractualStudieson:StressMethodforDesinCriteriaEvaluationandPCCConfiurationStud.TechnicalReportforMitsubishiHeavyIndustries,3apan,3uly,12.withR.Kane,D.Metcalf,R.Benel,S.Fleger)Resonsestereoesof3aanesenuclearowerlantcontrolroomoerators.StudyforMitsubishiHeavyIndustries,December1981.(withR.KaneandS.Fleger)Sstem-SecificSecificationsBasicConsoleEvaluationandHumanEnineerinLibrarBibliorahforAdvancedControlRoom.TechnicalReportforMitsubishiHeavyIndustries,3apan,3uly1982.withR.Kane,H.Manning,S.Fleger,T.O'Donoghue,N.Tulloh,andL.Grealis)HumanfactorsevaluationreortontheTsuruaNumberOneNewRadwasteControlRoom.Finalreportpreparedforthe3apanAtomicPowerCompany,September1981.(withA.Strong)LabelbackfitsulementBSEP1andBSEP2.PreparedforCarolinaPowerandLight,September1981.B-50 3OHNE.FARBRY,3R.(Continued)HumanfactorsevaluationreortfortheBrunswickUnit1andUnit2ControlRoom.FinalReportprepared!forCarolinaPowerandLight,September1981.(withW.Talley,D.Beith,E.Talley,andT.3ustice)HumanfactorsdesinevaluationreortfortheShearonHarrisUnit1controlroom.FinalreportpreparedforCarolinaPowerandLight,September"'1981.(withW.Talley,3.Haher,T.Amerson,D.Beith,andT.3ustice)3OURNALARTICLES:Control-displayintegrationonlarge,multi-systemcontrolpanels.ProceedinsoftheHumanFactorsSociet25thAnnualMeetin.Rochester,NewYork1981.(withT.HardingandK.MalloryEvaluativepersistence:Saltfromtheevaporativeforgettingprocess.DissertationAbstractsInternational,1979,39(No.8),0068B.Greaterrepetitionoferrorsunderperformancecomparedtoobservationinmultiple-choicehumanlearning.PercetualandMotorSkills,1973,37,909-950.,(withM.H.MarxandD.Witter)Psychologicalpreparationforendoscopy.GastrointestinalEndosco,1977,20,9-13.(withR.H.Shipley,3.H.Butt,andB.Horwitz),Preparationforastressfulmedicalprocedure:Effectofamountofstimuluspreexposureandcopingstyle.3ournalofConsultinandClinicalPsvcholo,1978,06,099-507.(withR.H.Shipley,3.H.Butt,andB.HorwitzLong-termpersistenceofresponse-repetitiontendenciesbasedonperformanceorobser-vation.BulletinofthePschonomicSociet,1978,8,65-67.(withD.W.WitterandM.H.Marx)PRESENTATIONS:Evaluativepersistence:Alongtermmemoryforfirstimpressions.PaperpresentedattheconventionoftheAmericanPsychologicalAssociation,Montreal,September1980.Videotapepreparationforastressfulmedicalprocedure:Effectsofnumberofexposures.PaperpresentedatthemeetingoftheAssociationforAdvancementofBehaviorTherapy,NewYorkCity,December1976.(withR.H.Shipley,3.H.Butt,andB.Horwitz)8-51 ASw.CIn EDUCATIONUniversityofHartford,B.S.,MechanicalEngineering,1965UnionCollege,graduatecourses1966-1969NortheasternUniversity,graduatecourses1969-1970GeneralElectricAdvancedCourseinEngineeringEXPERIENCEAmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporation,1983-PresentNUSCORPORATIONS1978-1983AmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporation,1971-1978StoneaWebsterEngineeringCompany,1969-1971KnollsAtomicPowerLaboratory,1965-1969AmericanElectricPowerServiceCorporation-Manager,NuclearSafetyandLicensing.ManagementanddirectionofsectionpersonnelincarryingoutassignedresponsibilitiesandactivitieswhichincludesmaintenanceofNRCrelateddocumentation,reviewcoordination,andresolutionofallmatterspertainingtonuclearsafetyaffectingAEPSC.Provideknowledge,expertise,andanalyticalcapabilityinnuclearsafetyrelatedmattersnecessarytosupportplantoperationsandlicensingefforts.IalsoserveasSecretary,NSDRC,andasCorporateCognizantEngi'neerforNuclearSafety.NUS-Havebeenresponsibleforavarietyofsafetyanalysisandlicensingactivitiesinsupportofdomesticandforeignutilities.Typicalactivitieshaveincluded:ServiceforeightmonthsasamemberoftheOn-SiteSafetyReviewGroup,SalemGeneratingStationgtechnicalspecificationcoordinatorforalargedomesticutilityyprojectmanagerforNUSsupportactivitiesontheFSARupdateoftheDonaldC.CookNuclearPlantyprojectmanagerfortheBigRockPointPlantSpentFuelrackAdditionConsolidatedEnvironmentalImpactEvaluationandSafetyAnalysisReportsandtechnicaladvisortotheJapaneseSurveyGrouponnewsitingconcepts.UntilOctober1982wasManager,NuclearWasteManagementDepartment.DutiesincludedprojectmanagementandtechnicalcontributiontofulfillNUScontractualresponsibilitiestotheBasaltWasteIsolationProgramandtheOfficeofNuclearWasteIsolation.Varioussafetyandlicensingactivitiesperformedunderthesecontractsincludeddevelopmentoflicensingcoordinationplans,performanceofoperationalandlongtermradiologicalsafetyandriskanalysesfornuclearwasterepositories,developmentofapreliminarysafetyanalysisreportforanuclearwasterepositoryinadomedsaltformation,developmentofguidelinesforaqualityassuranceprogram,andperformanceofcostbenefitanalyses.AlsoservedasamemberofanONWI-sponsoredtaskforceongeotechnicalandanthropomorphicproblemsassociatedwithsitinganuclearwasterepositoryinadomedsaltformation.

JhNES0FEZNSTEIHPAGB2AmericanBlectricpcnrerServiceCorporation-LeadEngineerSafetyAnalysisandsubsequentlyHanager,NuclearSafetyanLicensing.Dutiesincludedsupportoflicensing,design/construction,andoperationoftheDonaldC.CookNucleartthefirstNestinghousePNRwithanicecondensercontainmenttobelicensedforoperation.Princpa1ibilitywastoassurethatallsafetysystemsweredesignedandanalyzedinamanneracceptabletotheUnitedStatesNuclearRegulatoryCommission.Involvedinmanyfirst-of-a-kindanalyses,systemsdesign,andtechnicalspeccaonifitidevelopmentintheareasofheattransfer,fluiddynamics,thermalhydraulicstpostLOCAyghdroengeneration,icesublimation,radiologicaldoseanalyses,etc.Responsiblefortechnicalandadministrativecoordinat'ionofmajorprojectssuchasplantmodificationsrequiredtomeetNRCconcernsonhighenergylinebreaksoutsidecontainment,ECCSsystemsdesign,andenvironmentalqualificationofonsibilitsafetyrelatedequipment.HadleadtechnicalresponsibyforAmericanElectxicPowerformeetingswiththeNRCandforpresentationstotheAdvisoryCommitteeonReactorSafeguards.Nasresponseoxiblfthetechnicalinputandcoordinationofsafetyreviewsofdesignchanges,theFinalSafetyayRtndamendmentsandoralandwrittencorrespondencewiththeNRC.Supervisoryresponsibilityfordevelopmetcommitmentlists,Nestinghouseownersgroupactivities,firettirogramN-lists,technicalspecifications,securityplan,emergencyplan,internalQAprocedur,peslanthealthphysicssupport,nuclearsafetyandlicensingaspectsff1eloadsprobabilisticriskassessmentstudies>etc.WasSecretaryofNuclearSafetyDesignReviewCommittee,memberofEdisonElectricInstitutead-hoccommitteetocommentonNASH-1400'ompanyrepresentativetojointutility-AEC-vendortaskforceonwatexreactorsafetyresearch(latertakenoverbyEPRI),memberofjointTVA-DUKE-AEPicecondensertaskforce,andChairmanofHeliumBreederAssociatesCommitteetoreviewsafetyandlicensingproblemswithgascooledfastreactors.StoneSWebster-Nasresponsiblefordevelopinganalysismethodsforcontainmentdesignandpost-LOCAhydrogengenerationanalysis.ManyassumptionsfromthisworkwerebntlyadaptedbytheNRCintheirpublishedRegulatoryGuide1.7~Alsoperformedprelimyinarevaluationstodeterminewhetherpx'obabilistictechniquescouldbeusedfornuclearpowerplantdesign.KnllAtomicPowerLab-Performedthermalhydraulicanalysisofnuclearreactors,des'nedtestsandexperiments,anddeliveredtraininglecturestoNavalpersonnel.

gAP JAMESGoPEZNSTEZNPAGE3EDUCATIONALHONORSUniversityofHartfordRegent'sAwardforbeingtopstudentinMechanicalEngineering,1964and1965AmericanSocietyofMechanicalEngineersGreaterHartfordChapterAnnualAward1965KappaMu-HonoraryEngineeringFraternityPUBLICATIONS"PostDBAContainmentHydrogenMethodsforCalculatingandControllingHydrogenAccumulation'co-author)gpresentedatANSTopicalMeetingonPowerReactorSystemandComponentstWilliamsburg<Virginia,1970."SurveyMethodsforAssessmentofRadiologicalReleasefromGeologicalRepositories"(leadauthor)gpresentedatANSAnnualMeetingAtlanta,Georgia,June1979.'Procedures,Barriers,StateVariables,andProcessesImportanttoNearFieldAnalysis"-(leadauthor)ypresentedatANSAnnualMeeting,LasVegas,Nevada,June1980."EvaluationofConsequencestoRiskofTimeFanCoolingUnitsareOutofServiceatSalemGeneratingStation,"preparedforPSE&GgNovember1981."EvaluationofAnalyticalProblemsAssociatedwithChangeovertoHotLegRecirculationFollowingaHypotheticalLossofCoolantAccidentatSalemGeneratingStation,"preparedforPSE&G,October1981."EvaluationofSafetyConcernsAssociatedwithLossofCoolantAccidentWithoutAutomaticActuationofContainmentSprays,"preparedforPSE&G,September1981."EvaluationofEffeetofDesignBasisAccidentsonProposedChangestoAuxiliaryFeedwaterSystematSalemNuclearPowerGeneratingStation,"preparedforPSE&G,October1981."EvaluationofHeatBalanceCodeUsedatSalemGeneratingStation,"preparedforPSE&G,December1981."EvaluationofInadvertentHumanIntrusionintoaSaltDomeRepositorybySolutionMining"(co-author)draftreportpreparedforOfficeofNuclearWasteIsolation,September1980~"CriticalityAnalysisforaBrineFilledCavityinaSpentFuelNuclearWasteRepositoryLocatedinaDomedSaltFormation"(co-author),NUS-TM-326,January1980.

JAMESQoFEZNSTEINPAGE4"QuestionnaireforPerformingSafetyEvaluationsforChangestoStructures,Systems,andComponentsattheSalemNuclearPlant,"preparedforPSEaG,July1981.'DonaldC.CookHuclearPlant,UnitHo.1,ResultsoftheDecember1974InitialWeighingProgram'reparedforAmericanElectricPcnrer,March1975"LongTermEvaluationoftheIceCondenserSystem:ResultsoftheJanuary1976andApril1976IceWeighingPrograms"(leadauthor)July1976."LongTermEvaluationoftheIceCondenserSystem!ResultsoftheJanuary1977IceWeighingProgram"(leadauthor),May1977'SurveyofNewTypesofSitingResearchforNuclearPowerPlants"(leadauthor)NUS-4068,April1982."BigRockPointPlant:SpentFuelRackAdditionConsolidatedEnvironmentalImpactEvaluationandSafetyAnalysis,"(co-author),April1982."SuggestedQualityAssuranceRequirementsforaMinedGeologicRepository"(co-author),NUS-TM-338,May1981."SafetyAnalysisReportAnnotatedOutlineforaNuclearWasteRepositoryinaDeepGeologicFormation,"(co-author)NUS-TM-360,April1981."PreliminaryInformationReportforaConceptualReferenceRepositoryinaDeepGeologicalFormation,"(co-author)draftreportpreparedforofficeofNuclearWasteIsolation,January1980."MethodforDevelopingtheQ-listforaGeologicRepository"(co-author),NUS-TM-343,April1981."APreliminaryAssessmentofthePNLStrontiumHeatSourceDevelopmentProgramtoDetermineitsAdequacyforLicensingPurposesinFY1981,"(co-author)draftreportpreparedforBattelleNorthwest,August1979."AnnotatedBibliographyforaCostBenefitStudyofSeveralAspectsofaNuclearWasteRepository"NUS-3528,July1980."CostBenefitStudyofSeveralAspectsofaGeologicNuclearWasteRepository"preparedforBasaltWasteIsolationProgram,NUS-3569,April1980.

JAMESGoFKINSTEINPAGE5"QualityAssuranceClassificationRequirementsforStructures,Systems,Components,andActivitiesRelatedtoaMinedGeologicRepositoryforPermanentDisposal'ofHighLevelNuclearWaste"(co-author)preparedasadraftforOfficeofNuclearWasteIsolation,March1980."ApplicableRequirements,SupportingSequences,andPreliminaryStrategyfortheOfficeofNuclearWasteIsolationLicensingCoordinationPlan(co-author),NUS-3267,October1980.NWTSLicensingPlanforHighLevelWasteRepositoriesinGeologicFormations(co-author),preparedasadraftforOfficeofNuclearWasteIsolation,September1978."DonaldC.CookNuclearPlant,Units1and2,FinalSafetyAnalysisReport-Update"(pro)ectmanagerandleadcontributor),June1982."DonaldC.CookNuclearPlant,Units1and2,FinalSafetyAnalysisReportandAmendments"(co-author).

APPENDIXCANNUNCIATORSURVEYTASKPLAN6755B:1/062883C-1 181TP-3.11May1983D-C.COOKNUCLEARPLANTDCRDRPROGRAMHLMANFACTORSTASKPLANFORTHEANNUNCIATORSYSTEMREVIEWCanyonResearchGroupTheEssexBuilding333NorthFairfaxStreetAlexandria,Virginia22314(7O3)S48-4SOOPREPAREDBY:SignatureDCRDRDesignReviewTeamHumanFactorsConsultantDateAPPROVEDBY:SignatureDCRDRProjectReviewTeamDate)PERFORMEDBY:SignatureDCRDRDesignReviewTeamHumanFactorsConsultantDate)

D.C.COOKNUCLEARPLANTDCRDRPROGRAMANNUNCIATORSYSTEMREVIEWTP-3.11May1983RECORDOFREVISIONSRev.DateDescrition 181ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983TABLEOFCONTENTS1.0OBJECTIVES2.0REVIEWTEAMSELECTIONANDRESPONSIBILITIES3.0'RITERIAPacae4.0PROCEDURES4.1GeneralInstructions4.2DataCollection4.3Analysis5.0EQUIPMENT/FACILITYREQUIREMENTS6.0INPUTSANDDATAFORMS7.0OUTPUTSANDRESULTS8.0FIGURESANDTABLES'"9.0PROCEDUREEXCEPTIONSA.CRITERIAB.DATAFORMSC.CRITERIAMATRIXD.TASKPLANCRITIQUEAPPENDICES 181ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May19831.0OBJECTIVESa.ToassesstowhatdegreetheannunciatorsystemconformstothegenericcriteriainNUREG-0700.b.ToidentifyanddocumentanyfeaturesintheannunciatorsystemdesignthatdonotconformtothecriteriainNUREG-0700.c.Toidentifyanddocumentanyplant-specificdesignconventionsandotherplant-specifichumanfactorscriterianotdefinedinNUREG-0700.2.0REVIEWTEAMSELECTIONANORESPONSIBILITIESa.Ahumanfactorsspecialisttoconductthedatacollectionandanalysisandtopreparethetaskreport.b.Aclientnuclearoperationsspecialisttosupplyplantsystemsinformationconcerningalarmparametersandalarmresponseprocedures.c.AclientplantIhCengineertoassistinidentifyingrelevantplantsystemsinformation.3.0CRITERIAThecriteriaarefromNUREG-0700;paragraphs6.3.1.1;6.3.1.2athroughd(2);6.3.1.3athroughd;6.3.1.4aandb;6.3.1.5athroughb(3);6.3.2.lathroughf;6.3.3.1athroughb(2);6.3.2.2aandb;6.3.3.1athroughc(3);6.3.3.2athroughf(2);6.3.3.3athroughf;6.3.3.4athroughd;6.3.3.5athroughd(6);6.3.4.1athroughd(2);6.3.4.2athroughc;6.3.4.3aandb;6.5.1.6athroughc(2)ande(1)through3(3);and6.6.6.2a,b,andc(seeAppendixA).4.0PROCEDURES4.1GeneralInstructions4.1.1PreparationandConductofProceduresa.Priortoconductofthistask,ensurethatallrequireddataforms,plantdocumentation,engineeringdrawings,equipment,andmaterialsareavailable.Ensurethatpermissionhasbeen'btainedforallrequiredaccesstothecontrolroomorotherplantareas.

181ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983b.Recordallexceptions,deviations,orchanges"totheseproceduresinSection9.0ofthisTaskPlan.Numbereachentrysequentially,startingwith1.Includeanexplanation(technicaljustification)astowhytheexception,deviation,orchangewasmade.4.1.2TaskPlanCritiqueUponcompletionof.thistask,fillouttheTaskPlanCritiquecontained'inAppendixD.Submitthecompletedcritiquetoyou'rsupervisororprojectmanager.4.2DataCollectiona.Dataarecollectedusingvariousmethodsandproceduresconsistihgofmeasurements,observations,interviewsandquestionnaires,anddocumentreviews.,AppendixCillustratesthedistributionofthecriteriaforthevariousmethods.b.MeasurementsandobservationsshouldbemadeforallitemscontainedontheMeasurementsdataformsandObservationschecklistscontainedinAppendixB.c.Theoperatorquestionnaire(AppendixB)shouldbeadministeredtoatleast50,percentofthelicensedreactoroperatorsfortheplant.Administrationmaybeconducted;.singlyorinagroup,butshouldbeproctoredormonitored.d.TheresultsoftheSystemFunctionandTaskAnalysistasksshouldbereviewed-forannunciator-relevantdatainreferenceto6.3.3.1;6.3.1.4a;6.3.3bandd(2);6.3.3s4aandc;6.3.43a;and6.6.6.2a(l),(2),and(3).e.Inadditiontothereviewresultsfromd,above,plantdocumentationshouldbereviewedtoverifytheitemslistedintheDocumentReviewChecklistinAppendixB.Therequiredplantdocumentsinclude:1.AnnunciatorResponseProcedures2.AdministrativeProceduresrelevanttoannunciators.4D~Analslsa.AlldeviationsfromthecriteriashallberecordedonHumanEngineeringDiscrepancy(HED)reports(AppendixB).Recordedinformationshallincludetheinstru-mentorinstrumentsinvolved(e.g.,auditoryalarmhorns,specificlighttiles,etc.),adescriptionoftheproblemincludingthe0700paragraphnumberofthecriteria,andarecommendedsolution.

181ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983'b.Datacollectionmethod(s)shallalsoberecordedontheHEDform(seeAppendixB).Wheredatafromtwoormoresourcesarecontradictory,resolutionoftheconflictthroughdatareviewandclientinterviewshallbemade.c.UsetheanalysisaidsfromAppendixBforalldatareductionandanalysis.Uponcompletionofallanalyses,ensurethatthecriteriainAppendixAareproperlyannotated(asspecifiedintheanalysisaids).d.Submitthecompletedtaskplantoyourimmediatesupervisorforreview.Uponprojectmanagementapproval,initiateTaskReport3.1.5.0EQUIPMENTANDFACILITYREQUIREMENTSa4b.coAccesstothecontrolroom.Soundlevelmeter.Protractorandtapemeasure.d.Flashcomparator.6.0INPUTSANDDATAFORMSa1b.cod.e.AnnunciatorResponseProceduresAnnunciatorAdministrativeProceduresCompletedTaskReportsfor:1.SystemFunctionandTaskAnalysis2.LabelsandLocationAids3.MaintainabilityCriteriaList(AppendixA)ThefollowingfromAppendixB:l.MeasurementsDataForms2.Questionnaire3.ObservationsChecklist4.DocumentationReviewChecklist5.AnalysisAids6.HEDReportFormsf.CriteriaMatrix(AppendixC)g.TaskPlanCritiqueForm(AppendixD) 181ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May19837.0OUTPUTSANDRESULTSa.CompletedHEDsb.CompletedTaskReport.

181ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May19838.0FIGURESANDTABLESNone.

181ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May19839.DPROCEDUREEXCEPTIONSThefollowingexceptions,deviations,andchangesweremadetotheseproceduresduringconductofthetask(includeastatementofjustificationoneachitem):

ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983APPENDIXACRITERIA ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May19836.3.1.1GENERALSYSTEMDESIGNAnnunciatorwarningsystemsaretheprimarycontrolroominterfacetoimmediatelyalerttheoperatortooutof.tolerancechangesinplantcon.dition.Annunciatorwarningsystemsconsistofthreemajorsubsystems:(a)anauditoryalertsubsystem,(b)avisualalarmsubsystem,and(c)anoperatorresponsesubsystem(seeExhibit6,3-1).Together,thesethreesubsystemsshouldbedesignedtoprovideapreferredoperationalsequenceforannunciatorwarningsasindicatedinExhibit6.32.N/AYESCOMMENTS8.3,12ALARMPARAMETERSELECTIONa.b.C.SETPOINTS-Thelimitsorsetpointsforinitiatingtheannunciatorwarningsystemshouldbeestablishedtomeetthefollowinggoals:(1)Alarmsshouldnotoccursofrequentlyastobeconsideredanuisancebytheoperators.(2)However,setpointsshouldbeestablishedtogiveoperatorsadequatetimetore-spondtothewarningconditionbeforeaseriousproblemdevelops.GENERALALARMS(1)Alarmsthatrequirethecontrolroomoperatortodirectanauxiliaryoperatortoagivenplantlocationforspecificinformationshouldbeavoided.(2)Ifgeneralalarmsmustbeused,theyshouldonlybeusedforconditionsthatallowadequatetimeforauxiliaryoperatoractionandsubsequentcontrolroomoperatoraction,MULTICHANNELORSHAREDALARMS(1)Annunciatorswithinputsfrommorethanoneplantparametermtpointshouldbeavoided.Multi.inputalarmsthatsummarizesingle-inputannunciators.elsewhereinthecontrolroomareanexception,(2)Wheremulti-inputannunciatorsmustbeused,analarmprintoutcapabilityshouldbeprovided.Thespecificsofthealarmshouldbeprintedonanalarmtyperwithsufficientspeedandbufferstoragetocaptureallalarmdata.

ANNUNC1ATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nlay19836,3,1.2ALARMPAR'AMETERSELECTION(Cont'd)N/AYESHOCONMENTSc.MULTICHANNELORSHAREDALARMS(Cont'd)(3)Areflashcapabilityshouldbeprovidedtoallowsubsequentalarmstoactivatetheauditoryalertmechanismandreflashthevisualtileeventhoughthefirstalarmmaynothavebeencleared.d.MULTI.UNITALARMS-(1)Alarmsforanysharedplantsystemsshouldbeduplicatedinallcontrolrooms.(2)Whenanitemofsharedequipmentisbeingoperatedfromonecontrolroom,astatusdisplayorsignalshouldbepro.videdinallothercontrolroomswhichcouldpotentiallycontrolthisequipment.6,3.1.3FIRSTOUTANNUNCIATORSa.REACTORSYSTEM(1)Aseparatefirstoutpanelshouldbeprovidedforthereactorsystem.(2)Thefirstoutpanelshouldconsistofseparateannunciatortilesforeachoftheautomaticreactortripfunctions.{3)Intheeventofareactortrip,thetileassociated.withtheeventshouldilluminate,andnoother.b,TURBINE.GENERATORSYSTEM-Aseparatefirstoutpanel,similarinfunctiontothereactorsystempanel,isrecommended.c.POSITION-Firstoutpanelsshouldbelocateddirectlyabovethemaincontrolworkstationforthesystem.d.APPLICATION-Firstoutannunciatorsshouldconformtothegeneralauditory,visual,andoperatorresponseguidelinesofthissection.A-2 ANNUNClATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Hay19836,3.1.4PRIORITIZATION0.LEVELSOFPRIORITY(1)Prioritizationshouldbeaccomplishedusingarelativelysmall(24)numberofprioritylevels.H/AYES'OMMENTS(2)Prioritizationshouldbebasedonacontinuumofimportance,severity,orneedforoperatoractioninoneormoredimensions,e.g.,likelihoodofreactortrip,releaseofradiation.Exhibit6.3-3providesanexampleofprioritizationbasedonthreelevelsofprioritization.b,PRIORITYCODING(1)Somemethodforcodingthevisualsignalsforthevariousprioritylevelsshouldbeemployed.Acceptablemethodsforprioritycodingincludecolor,position,shape,orsymboliccoding.(2)Auditorysignalcodingforprioritylevelisalsoappropriate.SeeGuideline62.2.3forrecommendedcodingtechniques.6.3.1.5CLEAREDALARMSa.AUDITORYSIGNAL-Clearedalarmsshouldhaveadedicated,distinctiveaudiblesignalwhichshouldbeoffinitedurationb.VISUALSIGNAL-Theindividualtileshouldhaveoneofthefollowing:(1)Aspecialflashrate(twiceorone.halfthenormalflashrateispreferred,toallowdiscrimination),or(2)Reducedbrightness,or(3)Aspecialcolor,consistentwiththeoverallcontrolroomcolorcodingscheme,pro-ducedbyadiffeentlycoloredbulbbehindthetile.

ANNUNClATORSYSTEMTP-3.1IMay19836.3.2.1SIGNALDETECTIONN/AYESNOCONTENTSatb,C.INTENSITY-Thesignalshouldbesuchthatoperatorscanreliablydiscernthesignalabovetheambientcontrolroomnoise.Anominalvalueof10dB(A)aboveaverageambientnoiseisgenerallyadequate,CONTROL-Signalintensity,if,adjustable,shouldbecontrolledbyadministrativeprocedure.LIMITS-Thesignalshouldcapturetheoperator'sattentionbutshouldnotcauseirritationorastartledreaction.d.DETECTION-Eachauditorysignalshouldbeadjustedtoresultinapproximatelyequaldetectionlevelsatnormaloperatorworkstationsintheprimaryoperatingarea.e,RESET-Theannunciatorauditoryalertmechanismshouldautomaticallyresetwhenithasbeensilenced.f;.IDENTIFICATION-Theoperatorshouldbeabletoidentifytheworkstationorthesystemwheretheauditoryalertsignaforiginated.Separateauditorysignalsateachworkstationwithintheprimaryoperatingareaarerecommended.6.3.2.2AUDITORYCODINGa.b.LOCALIZATION(1)Auditorycodingtechniquesshouldbeusedwhentheoperatorworkstationassociatedwiththealarmisnotintheprimaryoperatingarea.(2)Codedsignalsfromasingleaudiosourceshoufdnotbeusedtoidentifyindividualworkstationswithintheprimaryoper-atingarea.PRIORITI2ATION-Codingmaybeusedtoindicatealarmpriority.(,".eeGuideline6.3.1.4.)A-4 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay19836.3.3.1VISUALANNUNCIATORPANELSLOCATION-Visualalarmpanelsshouldbelocatedabovetherelatedcontrolsanddisplayswhicharerequiredforcorrectiveordiagnosticactioninresponse'tothealarm.(SeeExhibit6.34.)b.LABELING~(1)Eachpanelshouldbeidentifiedbyalabelabovethepanel.(2)Panelidentificationlabelheightshouldbeconsistentwithasubtendedvisualangleofatfeast15minuteswhenviewedfromacentra(positionwithintheprimaryoperatingarea.YESCOMMENTS6.3.3.2VISUALALARMRECOGANDIDENTa.FLASHING-Thespecifictile(s)onanannun-ciatorpanelshoulduseflashingilluminationtoindicateanafarrpcondition.b.FLASHRATE-Flashratesshouldbefromthreetcfiveflashespersecondwithapproxi-matelyequalonandofftimes.c.FLASHERFAILURE-fncaseofflasherfailureofanalarmedtile,thetilelightshouldilluminateandburnsteadily.d.CONTRASTDETECTABILITY-Thereshouldbehighenoughcontrastbetweenalarmingandsteady.ontiles,andbetweenilluminatedandnon-illuminatedtiles,sothatoperatorsinanormallyilluminatedcontrolroomhavenoproblemdiscriminatingalarming,steadywn,andsteadywffvisualtiles.e."DARK"ANNUNCIATORPANELS-A"dark"annunciatorpanelconceptshouldbeused.Thismeansthatundernormaloperatingconditionsnoannunciatorswouldbeillumi-nated;atlofthevisualtilesoftheannunciatorpanelswouldbe"dark."EXTENDEDDURATIONILLUMINATION-tfanannunciatortilemustbe"ON"foranextendedperiodduringnormaloperations(e.g.,duringequipmentrepairorreplacement),itshouldbe:(1)Distinctivelycodedforpositiverecog-nitionduringthisperiod,and(2)Controlledbyadministrativeprocedures.A-5 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay19838,3b.C.Cl0~e,,3.3ARRANGEMENTOFVISUALALARMTILESMATRIXORGANIZATION-Visualalarmsshouldbeorganizedasamatrixofvisualalarmtileswithineachannunciatorpanel.FUNCTIONALGROUPING-Visualalarmtilesshouldbegroupedbyfunctionorsystemwithineachannunciatorpanel.Forexample,arearadiationalarmsshouldbegroupedononepanel,notspreadthroughoutthecontrolroom.LABELINGOFAXES(1)Theverticalandhorizontalaxesofannunciatorpanelsshouldbelabeledwithalphanumericsforreadycoordinatedesignationofaparticularvisualtile.(2)Coordinatedesignationispreferredontheleftandtopsidesoftheannunciatorpanel.(3)Letterheightforcoordinatedesignationshouldbeconsistentwithasubtendedvisualangleofatleast15minutesasviewedfromacentral,positionwithintheprimaryoperatingarea.,PATTERNRECOGNITION-(1)Thenumberofalarmtilesandthematrixdensityshouldbekeptlow(amaximumof50tilespermatrixismggested).(2)Tileswithinanannunciatorpanelmatrixshouldbegroupedbysubsystem,function,orotherlogicalorganization.OUTNFSERVICEALARMS-Cuesforpromptrecognitionofanoutof.serviceannunciatorshouldbedesignedintothesystem.BLANKTILES-Blankorunusedannunciatortilesshouldnotbeilluminated(exceptduringannunciatortesting).N/AYESNOCOMMENTS8.3.3.4VISUALTILELEGENDS~.UNAMBIGUOUS-Annunciatorvisualtilelegendsshouldbespecificandunambiguous.Wordingshouldbeinconcise,shortmessages.b.SINGULARITY-Alarmswhichrefertheoperatortoanother,moredetailedannunciatorpanellocatedoutsidetheprimaryoperatingareashouldbeminimized.A-6 ANNUNClATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay19836.3,3.4VISUALTILELEGENDS(Cont'd)c.SPECIFICITY-Tilelegendsshouldaddressspecificconditions;forexample,donotuseonealarmforHIGH-LOW,TEMPFRATURE-PRESSURE.d.ABBREVIATIONS-Abbreviationsandacro-nymsshouldbeconsistentwiththoseusedelsewhereinthecontrolroom.N/AYESNOCOMMENTS6.3.3.5VISUALTILEREADABILITYa.DISTANCE-Theoperatorshouldbeabletoreadalltheannunciatortilesfromthepositionattheworkstationwheretheannunciatoracknowledgecontrolislocated.(1)Letterheightshouldsubtendaminimumvisualangleof15minutes,or.004xviewingdistance.Thepreferredvisualangleis20minutes,or.006xviewingdlstanceo(2)Letterheightshouldbeidenticalforalltiles,basedonthemaximumviewingdistance.Separatecalculationsshouldbemadeforstand.upandsitdownworkstations.b.TYPESTYLE-Thesizeandstyleofletteringshouldmeetthefollowing:(1)Typestylesshouldbesimple.(2)Typestylesshouldbeconsistentonallvisualtiles.(3)Onlyupper-casetypeshouldbeusedonvisualtiles,c.LEGENDCONTRAST-Legendsshouldpro-videhighcontrastwiththetilebackground.(1)Legendsshouldbeengraved.(2)Legendsshouldbedarkletteringonalightbackground.d.LETTERDIMENSIONSANDSPACING-(1)Stroke.width.to-cnaracter-heightratioshouldbebetween1:6and1:8.(2)Letterwidth.to-heightratioshouldbebetween1:1and3:5.(3)Numeralwidthto.heightratioshouldbe3:5.A-7 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May19836.3.3.5VISUALTILEREADABILITY(Cont'd)d.LETTERDIMENSIONSANDSPACING-(Cont'd)(4)Minimumspacebetweencharactersshouldbeonestrokewidth.(5)Minimumspacebetweenwordsshouldbethewidthofonecharacter.(6)Minimumspacebetweenlinesshouldbeone-halfthecharacterheight.N/AYESNOCOMMENTS6.3.4a~>>>>b.:;C.d..1CONTROLS(SeeExhibit6.35.)SILENCE(1)Eachsetofoperatorresponsecontrolsshouldincludeasilencecontrol.(2)Itshould'bepossibletosilenceanauditoryalertsignalfromanysetofannunciatorresponsecontrolsintheprimaryoperatingarea.ACKNOWLEDGE(1)Acontrolshouldbeprovidedtoterminatetheflashingofavisualtileandhaveitcontinueatsteadyilluminationuntilthealarmiscleared.(2)Acknowledgementshouldbepossibleonlyattheworkstationwherethealarmoriginated.RESET(1)Ifanautomaticclearedalarmfeatureisnotprovided,acontrolshouldbepro.videdtoresetthesystemafteranalarmhascleared.(2)Theresetcontrolshouldsilenceanyaudiblesignalindicatingclearanceandshouldextinguishtileillumination.(3)Theresetcontrolshouldbeeffectiveonlyattheworkstationfortheannunciatorpanelwherethealarminitiated.TEST(1)Acontroltotesttheauditorysignalandflashingilluminationofalltilesinapanelshouldbeprovided.(2)Periodictestingofannunciatorsshouldberequiredandcontrolledbyadministrativeprocedure.A-8 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983.6.3.4.2CONTROLSETDESIGNa.b.C.6.3.4.3ANNUNCIATORRESPONSEPROCEDURESPOSITIONINGOFREPETITIVEGROUPS-Repetitivegroupsofannunciatorcontrolsshouldhavethesamearrangementandrelativelocationatdifferentworkstations.Thisistofacilitate"blind"reaching.CONTROLCODING-Annunciatorresponsecontrolsshouldbecodedforeasyrecognition,usingtechniquessuchas:(1)Colorcoding;(2)colorshadingthegroupofannunciator'controls;(3)demarcatingthegroupofannunciatorcontrols;or(4)shapecoding,particularlythesilencecontrol.(SeeExhibit6.3.5,Example2.)NONDEFEATABLECONTROLS-Annunci~atorcontroldesignsshouldnotallowtheoperatortodefeatthecontrol.Forexample,somepushbuttonsusedforannunciatorsilencingandacknowledgementcanbehelddownbyinsertingacoinintheringaroundthe-pushbutton.Thisundesirabledesignfeatureshouldbeeliminated.K/AYESKOCOMMENTSa.AVAILABILITY-Annunciatorresponsepro.ceduresshouldbeavailableinthecontrolroom.INDEXING-Annunciatorresponseproceduresshouldbeindexedbypanelidentificationandannunciatortilecoordinates.6.5.1.6COLORCODINGa.b.~REDUNDANCY-Inallapplicationsofcolorcoding,colorshouldprovideredundantinformation.Thatis,thepertinentinformationshouldbeavailablefromsomeothercueinadditiontocolor,NUMBEROFCOLORS(1)Thenumberofcolorsusedforcodingshouldbekepttotheminimumneededforprovidngsufficientinformation.(2)Thenumberofcolorsusedforcodingshouldnotexceed11.A-9 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay19838.5,1.6COLORCODING(Cont'd)c.MEANINGOFCOLORS(I)Themeaningattachedtoaparticularcolorshouldbenarrowlydefined.(2)Red,green,andamber(yellow)shouldbereservedforthefollowinguses:Red:unsafe,danger,immediateoperatoractionrequired,oranindicationthatacriticalparameterisoutoftolerance.Green:safe,nooperatoractionrequired,oranindicationthataparameteriswithintolerance.Amber(yellow):hazard(potentiallyun-safe),caution,attentionrequired,oranindicationthatamarginalvalueorparameterexists.d.CONSISTENCYOFMEANING(1)Themeaningassignedtoparticularcolorsshouldbeconsistentacrossallapplicationswithinthecontrolroom.(2)ThemeaningofaparticularcolorshouldremainthesamewhetherappliedtopanelsurfacesorprojectedinsignallightsoronCR,Ts.N/AYESNOCOMMENTS6.6.6.2DEMARCATIONb.C.USE-Linesofdemarcationcanbeusedto:(1)Enclosefunctionallyrelateddisplays.{2)Enclosefunctionallyrelatedcontrols.(3)Grouprelatedcontrolsanddisplays.CONTRAST-Linesofdemarcationshouldbevisuallydistinctivefromthepanelbackground.PERMANENCE-Linesofdemarcationshouldbepermanentlyattached.

ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983AUDITORYALERTSUBSYSTEMVISUALALARMSUBSYSTEMrOPERATORRESPONSESUBSYSTEM~~;51i--."""1bExhibit6.3l.Annunciatorwarningayatern.,

ANNUNC1ATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983lCdenassesnssceetn~$~A&antAsonsaarcLHHtcNaSsaaededeIyft~~g~~~~4~idscarywealarsosnaceNnonsaooassseerMCSNon(san)VscssdAnssssKsecorTiltAccsrecsonsorest(eysnsddormteesnnsssssnaseweormINUnssnnnlendncensssacc~racenndssraednanccnwcsonSlLSNCS"ControlIleonsnce(AnyMCSLate(seelAyennySsoKSCeeae.nKeenansonAKece"AC@HOWLSOQS"ControlAeowsta(OnlyecIICSLoeecnnNwAsrsssssitsalaseassetIIslaossneceases.(ssstTiklternasncInvnssnatadIss0sedsaescendAernedsacsanolesotnnnecesscessa+sear(llNecssrnadtoNormoIMeanIersonISssn~~~~~e~(JsswssaAsses(drySslnellorClearedANnssp~~~~qVsosdAnnssncsacarTileAetwtw~wSoecselelcerssnedenalvssssnTriacolndscece"OwedANnss"nsssr-CarnndN~(OseyceMCSLacenonNwAnssssncsetorecnn)NoMoleAssceesearVsssMaA4nnTSSlIAtSealsSoearlnAenssKntarCanclnSecLoaetsonlIKlioeMAccessoryANrcsianesendlsleaneeANvsosnTilessnNdendAnsnnsesecoreorm(slLSOSNOQQ~SessosneKActsang+g~oaeeccssrAcean~Aecdsceceassdessn~Exhibit6.3.2.Annunciatorsystempreferredoperationalsequence.A-12 ANNUNCIATORSYSTENTP-3.11Nay1983PIRSTPRIORITYALARMS~Plantshutdownlraectortrip,turbinetrip)~Radiationrelease~Plantconditionswhich,lfnotcorrectedimmediately,willresultinautomaticplantshutdownorradi~tionralaae.orwillrequitemanualplantshutdown.SECONDPRIORITYALARMS~Technical~ificetionviolationswhichifnotcorrectedwillrequireplantShutdown~Plantconditionswhich.Ifnotcorrected,meySaadtoplantshutdownorradiationreleasesTk(ROPRIORITYALARMS~plantconditionsreoresantinaproblemsie9'ystŽdaeredationIwhicheffectplantooarabilitybutwhichshouldnotleadtoplantshutdovm,radiationrelease.orviolationoftechnicalxsecificationsExhibit6.33.ThreelevelannUnciatorprioritizationexample.ecctnas'rsacorrteotaasissVISUALALARMSW<<&<<<<8'sita<<i~isa'aIst~GrwtsaiorsISita<<otHtsai~'st~OINISaOl<<IIRELATEDDISPLAYSgi>liaur~>ac'rtoartsau<<rsRli<<irttoarts~HlElRELATEDCDNTRQLSCIIExhibit6.M.Vistralalarmslocatedabovethcrelatedcontrolsanddisplays.(FromSeminaraetai.,1979).A-13 ANNUNClATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay19B3E'xample1SILENCEACKNOWLEDGEExample2::::::ANNUNCIATORCONTROLS:::::::SILENCE.::.ACKRESETTESTRESETTESTExhibit6.35.Annunciatorresponsecontrols.ColorSerialOr<<eleetrOnnumberGeneralcolornameISCCNBS/rtunsettrenotetronolcolor.centroidnameISCC4<<SSCentroidnumberlaboraviation)Color123456789101112131415'l6171819202122whiteblackyellowpurOleoreneelightblueredbullOrevcreenpurplishpinkblueyellawiehpinkvioletoranceyellowpurplishredare<<nishyellowreddishbrownyellowcreenyellOwithbrOwnreddishor<<nileOliveareen253257822184818011902651392471782620756255974011575126Whiteblackv.Y~.Pv.Ov.l.dv.Rey.YmedGyv.G<<,pPk<<,8<<,yPk<<.Vv.OY<<.oRv.aYa.rBrv.YGdecoyBrv.rOd,OIG2.5PB9.5/0.2NOdr3.3Y8.0/14.35.5P4.3/9,24,1YR5.5/1502.7P87.9I6,05,OR3.9/1544.4Y7.2/3.83.3GY5.4IO13.2G4.9/11.15BRP6.8/9.02.9PB4.1/104S.4R7.0/9.50.2P3.7/10.18.6YR7.3/15.27.3RP4.4/11,49.1Y8.2/12.00,3YR3.1/9.96.4GY6.8/11.2B,BYR3.l/5.094RS.4/14,5B.0GY2.2/3.6Exhibit6.57.Twentytwocolorso(maximumcontrast(tramKelly,1965).A-14 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Hay1983APPENDIXBDATAFORMS ANNUNCIATORSYSTENAPPENDIX8DATAFORMSTP-3.11May1983TABLEOFCONTENTSBl-MEASUREMENT,DATAFORMSBl.lLinearMeasurements81.2SoundMeasurements81.3LightMeasurements82-OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIRE83-OBSERVATIONCHECKLIST84-DOCUMENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLIST85-ANALYSISAIDS85.1LinearMeasurementsAnalysis85.2SoundMeasurementsAnalysis85.3LightMeasurementsAnalysis86-OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIREANALYSIS87-OBSERVATIONCHECKLISTANALYSIS88-DOCUMENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLISTANALYSIS89-SAMPLEHEDREPORTFORM~Pae81.1-181.1-181.2-181.3-182-183-184-185'-185.1-185.2-185.3-186-187-188-189-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXBl.lMEASUREMENTSDATATP-3.11May19831.LINEARMEASUREMENTS(LABELING)1.1AnnunciatorLightBox(ALB)SummaryLabels-6.3.3.1b(2).a.Iftherearenosummarylabels,checkhere:b.Iftherearesummarylabels,measureandrecordinTablel.lbthefollowinginformation:ITEMNO.1)2)3)4)5)6)ITEMDESCRIPTIONCharacterheightCharacterwidthand/ornumeralwidthCharacterstrokewidthCharacterspacingWordspacingLinespacingTABLE1~lbITEMALB-ALB-ALB-ALB-ALB-ALB-ALB-2.3.4.6~1.2TileLabeling-6.3.3.5a(l)anda(2),and6.3.5.5d(1)throughd(6).a,MeasureandrecordinTable1.2athecharacterheight(s)usedinthetiles.Ifmorethanonesizecharacterisused,recordtheheightforalloftherepresentedheights.Alsomeasureandrecordthefarthestleftandfarthestrighttilefromitsassociatedacknowledgestationforeachoftherepresentedcharacterheights(startattheleftmostacknowledgestationandnumberthestationsgoingclockwisearoundtheMCB).

APPENDIXBl.lMEASUREMENTSDATA~I'J~J1Nay19831.2(Cont.)TABLE1.2aSTA1STA2STA3STA4STA5CHARHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTb.Foreachacknowledgestationinthetableabove,measureandrecordinTable1.2btheheightfromthefloorforthefarthestleftandfarthestrighttilefromthissametable.TABLE1.2bTILEHEIGHTFROMFLOORCHARHTSTA1STA2STA3STA4STA5Bl.l-2 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB1.1MEASUREMENTSDATATP-3.11May19B3c.Measureandrecordthefollowingforeachofthedifferentcharacterheightsfroma,above:TABLE1.2cCHAR/NUMHT(ref)WIDTHSTROKEWIDTHCHARSPACINGWORDSPACINGLINESPACING1.3DataReductionandAnalysis.Fordatareductionandanalysis,obtaintheappropriateanalysisaidsfromAppendixB5(ref.B5.1).B1.1-3 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB1.2MEASUREMENTSDATA'P-3.11Hay19832.SOUNDMEASUREMENTS(AUDIBLESIGNALS)2.1AnnunciatorAudibleAlarms-6.3.2.1a.MeasurethesoundlevelindB(A)foreachannunciatoraudiblealarmateachofthefollowingoperatorpositions:TABLE2ALARMLOCATIONMCBSAFETYSYSTEMSPOS1POS2CONTTURBELECRADMONOP'SGENDISTCONSOLEDESK2.3.4,5.2.2DataReductionandAnalysis.Fordatareductionandanalysis,obtaintheappropriateanalysisaidsfromAppendixB5(ref.B5.2).B1~2-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXB1.3MEASUREMENTSDATA3.LIGHTMEASUREMENTS(TILEFLASHCHARACTERISTICS)-6.3.5b(l)and6.3.3.2b3.1UsingtheFlashComparator,measuretheflashrateoftilesinalarmandinclear,Recordtherates.AlarmFlashRate:ClearedFlashRate:3.2UsingtheFlashComparator,measuretheon-offratioforthealarmflashrateandclearedflashrate.On-OffRatio(Alarm):On-OffRatio(Cleared):B3.1-1 ANNONCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Hay1983APPENOIX82OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIREINSTRUCTIONS1.Thefollowingarequestionsconcerningthegenerallayout,functionalorganization,andoperationalconsiderationsinyourcontrolroom.HostofthequestionswillrequireaYESorNOanswer,withsomeadditionalinformation.02.Whenyouhavecommentsorsuggestions,usethespaceprovidedbeloweachquestion.If.youneedadditionalroom,usethebacksofthesheets.3.Ifyoudonotunderstandaquestion,pleaseaskthemonitorforclarification.4.Pleaseanswerallofthequestionsascompletelyaspossible.5.Takeasmuchtimeasyouneedtocompletethequestionnaire.6.Allofyouranswers,andyourbiographicalinformation,willbekeptinthestrictestconfidenceandwillbeusedtoaidinthe'erformanceofthedetailedcontrolroomdesignreview.PLEASEBEGIN82-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Hay1983APPENDIXB2OPERATORINTERYIEW/QUESTIONNAIRE'BIOGRAPHICALDATA:Name:Age:Sex:Height:Weight:CurrentPosition/Title:1.Doyouhaveacurrentreacto~operator'slicense'?YESNO2.Amountoflicensedexperienceatthisplant:3.Totalamountlicensedexperience:4.Relatedexperienceandamount(example:operator-trainee,HodgeNPPUnit1,1yr.):5.'ducation:a.Highestlevelattained:beSpecializedSchoolsorcourses(list):6.Militaryexperience:B2-2 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXB2OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIREl.Doyouhaveafirstoutannunciatorpanelwhereonlythetileassoc-iatedwiththereactortripeventilluminatesandall'subsequentalarmsonthatpanelare"lockedout"?YESNO2.Doyou'knowofanyautomaticreactortripfunctionsthatdonothaveaseparateannunciatortileonthefirstoutpanel(eithermissingorsharedwithotherfunctions)?YESNO3.Aretheannunciatorpanelsinthecontrolroomidentifiedbyalabelaboveeachpanel?YESNO4.Fromyourprimaryoperatingarea,canyoureadallannunciatorpanellabelswithaminimumofeffort?YESNO5.Istheannunciatorsystemprioritycodedbycolor,position,shape,orsymboliccodingofthetiles?YESNO6.Doesyourannunciatorsystemusecolorcoding?YESNO7.Aretheremorethanelevencolorsusedforcodingthepanels?YESNOB2-3 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXB2OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIREB.Isthereastandardmeaningattachedtothecolorsusedforcodingthepanels?YESNO9.Isthecolorredeverusedforaconditionotherthanunsafe,danger,immediateoperatoractionrequired,orasanindicationthatacriticalparameterisoutoftolerance?YESNO10.Isthecolorgreeneverusedforaconditionotherthansafe,nooperatoractionrequired,orasanindicationthataparameteriswithintolerance?YESNO1'l..Isthecoloramber(yellow)everusedforaconditionotherthanhazard(potentiallyunsafe),caution,attentionrequired,orasanindicationthatamarginalvalueorparameterexists?YESNO12.Doyouknowofanyunnecessarycolorcodingontheannunciatorpanels?YESNO13.Doyouknowofanycolorsthatarenotusedconsistentlyacrossallapplicationswithinthecontrolroom,frompanel-to-panelorinsignallightsandonCRTs?YESNOB2-4 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXB2OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIRE14.Areauditorysignalsprioritycodedbypulse,frequencychange(warbling),intensity,ordifferentfrequenciesfordifferentsignals?YESNO15.Ifyouhaveseparatealarmhorns,canyoueasilyidentifytheworkstationorsystemwheretheauditorysignaloriginated?YESNO16.Doyouhavedifferentalarmhornsforworkareasnotatthemaincontrolboard?YESNO17.Iftheauditoryalarmsignalhasonlyonesource,isthesoundcodedtodirectyoutodifferentworkareas?YESNOII18.Doanyofthealarmhornsstartleorirritateyou?YESNO19.Ifyouhavedifferentalarmhorns,doanyofthemsoundtooloudortoosoftincomparisontotheothersatyournormalworkstation?YESNO20.Doyouhaveasilencecontrolwitheachsetofresponsecontrolsinyourprimaryoperatingarea'?YESNOB2-5 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIX82OPERATORINTERVIEM/QUESTIONNAIRE21.Isacontrolprovidedwhichterminatesaflashingvisualtile,butallowsasteadyilluminationuntilthealarm'iscleared'YESNO22.Canyouacknowledgeanalarmfrommorethanoneresponsecontrolarea?YESNO23.Ifclearedalarmsdonotresetautomatically,doyouhaveacontroltoresetthemyou'rself?YESNO24.Doestheresetcontrolsilencetheauditorysignalaswellasextin-guishtheillumination?YESNO25.Doestheresetcontroloperatefrommorethanoneresponsecontrolarea?YESNO26.Canyoudefeatanyoftheannunciatorcontrols,suchaslockingouttheaudiblealarmorlockingdowntheacknowledgecontrol?YESNO27.Canyoutesttheauditoryandflashingilluminationsignalsofalltilsforeachpanel?YESNOB2-6 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXB2OPERATORINTERVIEM/QUESTIONNAIRE28.Isthereanadministrativeprocedurethatcontrolstheperiodictestingofallannunciators?YESNO29.Arealltilesdarkonannunciatorpanelswhennoalarmisindicated?YESNO30.Canyoueasilytellifatileisnormallyonforanextendeddura-tionduringnormaloperatingconditions?YESNO31.Areyouimmediatelyawareifanannunciatortileisoutofservice?YESNO32.Canyouimmediatelydeterminewhentheflasherofanalarmtilefails?YESNO33.Doyouknowofanyalarmsthatoccursofrequentlythatyouconsiderthemanuisance?YESNOB2-7 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983APPENDIX82OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIRE34.Doyouknowofanyalarmsthatdonotgiveyouampletimetorespondtoawarningcondition?YESNO35.Whenrespondingtoanalarmtile,canyoureadilylocatethecontrolsanddisplaysrequiredforcorrectiveordiagnosticaction?YESNO36.Doyouhaveaccesstoannunciatorresponseproceduresinthecontrolroom?YESNO37.Doyouknowofanyalarmswhichrequireyoutoobtainadditionalinfor-mationfromasourceoutsideofthecontrolroomarea?YESNO38.Aretheretoomanyalarmswhichrequireadditionalinformationfrompanelsoutsideyouroperatingarea?YESNO82-8 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983APPENDIXB2OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIRE39.Ifalarmsareusedthatrequireinformationoutsidethecontrolroom,dotheyallowyouampletimetorespond'YESNO40.Arealarmsprovidedforsharedequipmentinallcontrolrooms?YESNO4l.Isthereastatusdisplayorsignalprovidedforsharedequipmentinallcontrolroomswhichindicatesthattheequipmentiscurrentlybeingoperated?YESNO42.DoyouhaveanytileswithdualmessagessuchasHIGH-LOW?YESNO43.Doesthemulti-inputalarmhaveareflashcapabilitythatreflashesthevisualtileafteranauditoryalertevenifthefirstalarmhasnotbeencleared?YESNOB2-9 ANNUNCIATORSYSTENTP-3.11Nay19B3APPENDIXB2OPERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIRE44.Domulti-inputannunciatorsprovideyouwithanalarmprintout?YESNO45.Doesthemulti-inputalarmtyperhavesufficientspeedtoprintthealarmdatafastenoughforyourneeds?YESNO46.Doesthealarmtypereverskiporlooseinformation,orgarble(mixup)theprinting?YESNOB2-10 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXB3OBSERYATIONSCHECKLISTINSTRUCTIONSl.Usingtheattachedchecklist,makeallthenotedobservations.2.RecordallnecessaryinformationinthecommentscolumntojustifyanN/AcheckandtodetailaNOcheck.3.InsurethatallcommentsforNOchecksincludecomponent,instrument,panel,equipment,etc.identificationandlocationinformation.4.InitiateHEDreportsonallNOchecksperthedirectionscontainedinthechecklistanalysisaids.83-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTENAPPENDIXB3OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTTP-3.11May1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS.1.Aseparatefirstoutpanelshouldbeprovidedforthereactorsystem-6.3.1.3a(1).2.Aseparatefirstoutpanelisrecommendedfortheturbine-generatorsystemthatisfunc-tionallysimilartothereactorsystempanel-6.3.1.3b.3.Firstoutpanelsshouldbe,locatedabovetheirmainwork,.stations-6.3.1.3c..,4.Allfirstoutpanelsshouldconformtothegeneralauditoryandvisualitemsintherestofthischecklist-6.3.1.3d.5.Asmallnumber(2-4)oflevelsofprioritycodingareused-6.3.1.4a(l).6.Prioritycodingofcolor,posi-tion,shape,orsymbolisusedfor.visualsignals-6.3.1.4b(1).B3-2 ANNUNCIATORSYSTENAPPENDIXB3OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTTP-3.1"1Nayl983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS7.Auditorysignalprioritycodingmaybeused-6.3.1.4b(2).8.Ifmorethanone,eachaudi-torysignalshouldsoundatapproxi-matelyequalloudnessatnormalwork.tationsintheprimaryopera-tingarea-6.3.2.ld.9.Anauditorysignalshouldcapturetheoperator'sattentionbutshouldnotirritateorcauseastartledreaction-6.3.2.1c.10.Separateauditorysignalsateachworkstationwithinthepri-maryoperatingareaarerecom-mended-6D.2.1f.ll.Theoperatorshouldbeabletoidentifytheworkstationorareawheretheauditoryalertorigi-nated-6.3.2.lf.12.Theauditorysignalshouldautomaticallyresetwhensilenced-6.3.2.le.B3"3 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB3OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTTP-3.11May1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS13.Whenanalarmclears(oriscleared)thereshouldbeadedi-cated,distinctaudiblesignalwithafiniteduration-6.3.1.5a.14.Auditoryalertsignal(s),ifadjustable,shouldbecontrolledbyadministrativeprocedure-6.3.2.1b.15.Thespecifictitle(s)inanALB'shouldvisuallyflashtoindicateanalarmcondition-6.3.3.2a.16.Incaseofflasherfailure,analarmingtileshouldilluminateandburnsteadily-6.3.3.2c.17.Contrastbetweentilesshouldpresentnoproblemdiscriminatingbetweenalarming,steady-on,andsteady-offconditions-63.3.2d.B3-4 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIZB3OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTN/AYESCOMMENTSTP-3.11May198318.Undernormal(nonalarmed)conditionsnoannunciatortilesshouldbeilluminated-6.3.3.2e.19.Ifatilemustbeonforanextendedperiodduringnormaloperationsitshouldbedistinc-tivelycodedforpositiverecog-nitionduringthisperiod(seealso6.3.3.2f(2),item2contheDocumentReview.Checklist)-6.3.3.2f(1).20.Clearedtilesshouldhaveeitheraspecialflashrate,areducedbrightness,oraspecialcolor-6.3.1.5b(l)throughb(3).21.Alltilesassociatedwithagivenacknowledgecontrolshouldbereadablewhenoperatingthatcontrol-6.3.3.5a.22.Characterstyleonalltilesshouldbesimple-63.3.5b(l).23.Characterstyleshouldbeconsistentonalltiles-63.3.5b(2).B3-5 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEM,'PPENDIXB3OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTTP-3.11May1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS24.Characterstyleshouldbeuppercaseonalltiles-6.3.3.5b(3).25.Tilelegendsshouldhavehighcontrastwiththetilebackground-6.3.3.5c.26.Tilelegendsshouldbeengraved-6.3.3.5c(1).27.Tilelegendsshouldbedarkandopaqueonalightandtrans-lucentbackground-6.3.3.5c(2).28.Tilelegendsshouldbespecific,unambiguous,concise,andshort-6.3.3.4a.29.Tilelegendsshouldaddressspecificconditions,HIGHTEMP,orLOWPRESS,notHIGH-LOWTEMP-PRESS-6.33.4c.B3-6 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB3-OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTTP-3.11Nay1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS30.Abbreviationsandacronymsinlegendsshouldbeconsistentwiththoseinotherlabelinginthecon-trolroom-6.3.3.4d.31.TilesshouldbeorganizedasamatrixwithineachALB-6.3.3.3a.32.TheverticalandhorizontalaxesoftheALBsshouldbealpha-numericallylabeledfortiledesig-nationcoordinates-6.3.3.3c(l).33.CoordinatedesignatorsarepreferredattheleftandtopsidesoftheALBs-6.3.3.3c(2).34.Characterheightforthecoordinatelabelsshouldbethesameheightasthoseusedintilelegends-63.3.3c(3).35.ThenumberoftilesinanALBshouldbekeptlow,withamaxi-mumof50tilesperALBsuggested-63.3.3d(1).B3-7 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEM,APPENDIX83.OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTN/AYESNOCOMMENTSTP-3.11May198336.Cuesforpromptrecognitionofanout-of-serviceannunciatorshouldbedesignedintothesystem-6.33.3e.37.Blankorunusedtilesshouldnotbeilluminatedexceptduringannunciatortesting-6.3.3.3f.,38.Demarcationlinesmaybeusedtoenclosefunctionally'elatedtitles-6.6.6.2a(l).,.39.Demarcationlinesmaybeusedtogrouptileswiththeirrelatedcontrolsand/ordisplays-6.6.6.2a(l)througha(3).40.Ifused,demarcationlinesshouldbevisuallydistinctivefromthepanelbackground-6.6.6.2b.41.Ifused,demarcationlinesshouldbepermanentlyattached-6.6.6.2c.83-8 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB3OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTTP-3.11May1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS42.ALBsshouldbelocatedabovethecontrolsanddisplaysrequiredforcorrectiveordiagnosticactionwhentheyalarm-6.3.3.la.43.EachALBshouldbeidentifiedbyalabeldirectlyaboveit-6.3.3.lb(1).44.Eachsetofannunciatorcontrolsshouldincludeasilencecontrol-6.3.4.1a(1).45.Anacknowledgecontrolshouldbeprovidedthatterminatestheflashingandcausesthetiletocontinuouslyilluminateuntilithascleared-6.3.4.lb(1).46.Ifanautomaticclearedalarmfeatureisnotprovided,acontrolshouldbeprovidedtoresetthesystemafteranalarmhascleared-6.3.4.1c(1).B3-9 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB3OBSERVATIONSCHECKLISTTP-3.11May1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS47.Acontroltotesttheauditoryalarmandtheflashingilluminationofalltilesinapanel(i.e.,inoneormoreALBs)shouldbeprovided-6.>.4.1d(1).48.Repetitivegroupsofannun-ciatorcontrolsshouldhavethesamearrangementandrelativelocationatdifferentworkstations-6.3.4.2a.49.Annunciatorcontrolsshouldbe'codeddifferentlythanotherpanelcontrolseitherbycolor,demarca-'tion,orshape-6.3.4.2b(1)throughb(4).50.Shapecodingispreferredforthesilencecontrol-6.3.4.2b(4).51.Annunciatorcontroldesignsshouldnotallowtheoperatortodefeatthecontroloperationsuchasinsertingacoinintoacontrolguardring<<6.3.4.2c.52.Annunciatorresponseproce-duresshouldbeavailableinthecontrolroom-6.3.4.3a.B3-10 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXB4DOCUMENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLISTINSTRUCTIONSCollectthefollowingdocumentsandreviewthemfortheinformationcontainedintheattachedchecklist:l.AdministrativeProceduresconcerningannunciators2.AnnunciatorResponseProcedures3.Resultsfromthefollowingtaskreports:a.ConventionSurveyb.SystemFunctionTaskAnalysis'c.LabelingSurvey4.InsurethatallcommentsforNOchecksincludecomponent,instrument,panel,equipment,etc.identificationandlocationinformation.5.InitiateHEDreportsonallNOchecksperthedirectionscontainedinthechecklistanalysisaids.B4-I ANNUNCIATORSYSTENAPPENDIXB4DOCUMENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLISTN/AYESNOCOMMENTSTP-3.11May1983l.ANNUNCIATORRESPONSEPROCEDURESa.ResponseproceduresshouldbeindexedbypanelI.D.andtilecoordinates-6.>.4.3bb.Thereshouldbenoalarmsthatrequiretheoperatortodirectanauxiliaryoperatoroutsidethecon-trolroomtoobtainmorespecificinformation-6.3.1.2b(1).c.Annunciatorswithinputsfrom~.morethanoneplantparameterset-pointshouldbeavoided(multi-inputalarmsthatsummarize..single-inputalarmselsewhereinthecontrolroomareanexcep-tion)-63.1.2c(l)2.PLANTADMINISTRATIVEPROCEDURESa.Periodictestingofannunci-atorsshouldberequiredandcon-trolledbyadministrativepro-cedures-66.4.ld(2).b.Ifaudiblealarmintensityisoperator-adjustable,itshouldbecontrolledbyadministrativeprocedures-6.3.2.1b.B4-2 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIX84DOCUMENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLISTTP-3.11May1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTSPLANTADMINPROCESS(cont)c.Whenannunciatortilesmustbeonforanextendedperiodduringnormaloperations,itshouldbecontrolledbyadministrativepro-cedures(seealso6.3.3.2f(1),item19ontheObservationsCheck-list)-6.5.3.2f(2).CONVENTIONSTASKREPORTa.Colormeaningsshouldnotbetheonlymeansforidentifying~pertinentinformation,thatis,allcolorcodingusedshouldberedundantinformation-6.5.1.6a.b.Thenumberofcolorsusedforcodingshouldbekepttothemini-mumneededtoprovidesufficientinformationandshouldnotexceed11-6.5.1.6b(1)andb(2).c.Colormeaningsshouldbenarrowlydefined-6.5.1.6c(1).,d.Redshouldmeanunsafe,danger,immediateoperatoractionrequired,oranindicationthatacriticalparameterisoutoftoler-ance-6.5.1.6c(2).Itisimportanttonotethatinonesense,astrictinterpretationof84-3 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB4DOCUMENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLISTTP-3.11May1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTSCONVENTIONSTR(Cont)thisstatementwouldmeanthatastandard,andbroadlyappliedconventioninthenuclearindustrywasincorrect.However,keepinmindthatflowingelectricity(closedbreakers),flowingwaterorsteam(runningpumpsandopen'alves),andanactivereactorcanbeconsideredinherentlylesssafethanashutofforshutdowncondi"ion.e.Greenshouldmeansafe,shutoff,shutdown,nooperatoractionrequired,oranindicationthata'parameteriswithintolerance-6.5.1.6c(2).f.Amberoryellowshouldmeanahazard,potentiallyunsafe,caution,attentionrequired,oranindicationthatamarginalvalueor.parameterexists-6.5.1.6c(2).g.Meaningsassignedtoapartic-ularcolorshouldbeconsistentacrossallcontrolroomappli-cationsregardlessofwhetheritisoriapanelsurface,inindicatorlightsorinCRTs-6.5.1.6d(l)and(2).h.Abbreviationsandacronymsshouldbeconsistentacrosscontrolroomapplications-6.3.>.4d.B4"4 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENOIXB4DOCUHENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLISTTP-3.11Hay1983N/AYESNOCOMMENTS4.SFTATASKREPORTa,Theannunciatorwarningsys-temshouldbedesignedasthepri-maryalertinginterfacewiththeoperatorforout-of-tolerancecon-ditions.Itshouldconsistofthreemajorsubsystems:auditoryalert,visualalarm,andoperatorresponse.Thesethreesubsystemsshouidfunctiontoprovideapre-feredoperationalsequenceforannunciatorwarnings-6.3.1.1.b.Visualalarmtilesshouldbegroupedbyfunction,system,sub-system,orotherlogicalorgani-zationwithinALBs-6.3.3.3bandd',2).c.Prioritizationofannunciatorsshouldbebasedonacontinumofimportance,severity,orneedforoperatoractioninoneormoredimensionssuchas,thelikelihoodofareactortriporthelikelihoodofareleaseofradiation-6.3.1.4a(2).d.Tilelegendsshouldaddressspecificconditionsratherthanarangeofconditionsand/orparam-eters.Asanexample,separatetilesshouldbeusedtoindicatetemperature-low,temperature-high,pressure-low,andpressure-high,ratherthanasingletilewiththelegendHIGH-LOWTEMP-PRESS-6.3.34c.B4-5 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983APPENDIX85.1MEASUREMENTSANALYSIS11.LINEARMEASUREMENTS(LABELING)1.1ALBSummaryLabels-6.3.3.l.b(2)a.'Iftherearenosummarylabels,checkN/Aforcriterion6.3.3.l.b(2)inAppendixA.b.Iftherearesummarylabels,calculatethevisualangelsforeachlabelfortheoperatorpositionslistedinTablel.lbTablel.lbSAFETYSYSTEMSIDENTPOS1POS2MCBREACTURBELECRADMONOP'SCONTGENDISTCONSOLEDESK2,3.5.7.Calculations(useextrasheets,asneeded):B5.1-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIX85.lMEASUREMENTSANALYSISTP-3.11Nay1983c.IfallvisualanglesinTable1.1bare15minutesofarcorgreater,checkYESforcriterion6.3.3.1b(2)inAppendixA.d.IftherearevisualanglesinTablel.lblessthan15minuesofarc,recordonanHEDreportformtheposition(s)andlabel(s)wherethisisso.IncludethecodenumberTP-3.1B5.1.1indatacollectiondescription.Forcriterion6.3.3.1b'(2)inAppendixA,checktheNOcolumnandrecordtheHEDreportnumberandthecodenumber,TP-3.1B5.1.1intheCOMMENTScolumn1.2TileLabels-6.3.3.5a(1)andd(1)throughd(6).a.CalculatethevisualanglesforeachcharacterheightatitsfarthestleftandfarthestrightlocationforeachworkstationinTable1.2a,below.TABLE1.2aALBNO/STA1STA2STA3STA4STA5CHARHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTLEFTRIGHTCalculations(useextrasheets,asrequired):85.1-2 ANNUNCIATORSYSTENAPPENDIXB5.1MEASUREMENTSANALYSISTP-3.11May1983b.IfallvisualanglesinTable1.2aare15minutesofarcorgreater,checkYESforcriterion6.3.3.5a(l)inAppendixA.c.IfanyvisualanglesinTable1.2aarelessthan15minutesofarc,recordonanHEDreportformtheposition(s)andtilelegend(s)wherethisisso.IncludethecodenumberTP-3.1B5,1.2inthedatacollectiondescription.Forcriterion6.3'.5a(1)inAppendixA,checktheNOcolumnandrecordtheHEDreportnumberandthecodenumber,TP-3.1B5.1.2,intheCOMMENTScolumn.d.Comparethecharacterdimensionsandlegendmeasurementsforeachcharacterheightrecordedwithcriteria6.3.3.5d(1)throughd(6).e.Ifallcharacterheightsandlegendsmeetthecriteria,checktheYEScolumnforthesecriteriainAppendixA.f.Ifanycharacterdimensionsorlegendmeasurementsfailtomeetthecriteria,recordonanHEDreportformthetilecoordinates,characterheightimplicated,andadescri'ptionofthefailure.IncludethecodenumberTP-3.1B5.1.2in'thedatacollectiondescription..Forcriteria6.3.3.5d(1)throughd(6)inAppendixA,checktheNOcolumnandrecordtheHEDreportnumberandthecodenumberTP-3.1B5.1~2,intheCOMMENTScolumn.B5.1-3 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB5.2MEASUREMENTSANALYSISTP-3.11May19832.SOUNDMEASUREMENTS(AUDIBLESIGNALS)2.1AnnunciatorAudibleAlarms-6.3.2.la.a.Obtaintheaverage.ambientnoiselevelindb(A)fromtheAmbientNoiseSurveyTaskReport(TR-1.6)and'recordbelow:Averagenoiselevel:db(A)b.Baseduponthebelowadjustmentfactors,reduceeachmeasuredannunciatoralarmlevelandrecordinTable2.1b.ABSOLUTEDIFFERENCEBETWEENMEASUREDLEVEL(Lm)ANDAVERAGENOISELEVELLn5678910ll12131415SUBTRACTTHISAMOUNTFROMMEASUREDLEVEL(Lm)ANDANDRECORDINTABLE2.lb2.21.71.31.0.8.6.4.3.3.2.2.1TABLE2.1bALARMLOCATIONMCBSAFETYSYSTEMSPOS1POS2CONTTURBELECRADMONOP'SGENDISTCONSOLEDESK2.3.4.5.85.2-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB5.2MEASuREMENTANALYSISTP-3.11May1983c.ComparealladjusteddB(A)levelsinTable2.1btotheaveragenoiselevel.d.Ifalladjustedaudiblealarmlevelsareatleast10dB(A)abovetheaveragenoiselevelchecktheYEScolumnforcriterion6.3.2.1ainAppendixADe.Ifanyadjustedalarmlevelsarelessthan10dB(A)abovetheaveragenoiselevel,recordeachoccuranceonanHEDreportform.Include"thecodenumberTP3.lB5.2.1inthedatacollectiondescription.Forcriterion6.3.2.1ainAppendixA,checktheNOcolumnandrecordtheHEDreportnumberandthecodenumber,TP3.1B5.2.1intheCOMMENTScolumn.B5.2-2 AxeuxCIATORSYSTD1APPENDIX85.3MEASUREMENTANALYSISTP-3.11May19833.LIGHTMEASUREMENTS(TILEFLASHCHARACTERISTICS)3.1AlarmedFlashCharacteristics-6.3.3.2b.a.Fromtherecordeddata,determineifthealarmedflashrateisbetween3to5flashespersecondandthattheon-offratioisapproximately1:1.b.Ifbothparametersmeetthecriteria,checktheYEScolumnforcriterion6.3.3.2binAppendixA.c.Ifeitherparameterfailstomeetthecriteria,recordthediscrepancyonanHEDreportform.IncludethecodenumberTP-3.185.3.1inthedatacollectiondescription.Forcriterion6,3.3.2bin'AppendixAchecktheNOcolumnandrecordtheHEDnumberandthecodenumber,TP-3.185.3.1,intheCOMMENTScolumn.3.2ClearedFlashRate-6.3.1.5b(1).a.Fromtherecordeddata,determineiftheclearedflashrateisapproximatelydoubleorQthealarmedflashrate.b.Iftheclearedflashratepassesthecriterion,checktheYEScolumnforcriteria6.3.1.5b(l)inAppendixA.c.Iftheclearedflashratefailstomeetthecriterion,recordthediscrepancyonanHEDreportform.IncludethecodenumberTP-3.185.3.2inthedatacollectiondiscription.Forcriterion6.3.1.5b(1)inAppendixA,checktheNOcolumnandrecordtheHEDnumberandthecodenumber,TP-3.185.3.2,intheCOMMENTScolumn.85.3-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIXB6OPERATORINTERYIEW/QUESTIONNAIREANALYSISTP-3.11Nay1983l.GENERALa.Reviewallquestionnairesforcompletenessofbiographicalinformationandquestionresponses.b.Deleteincompleteandunusablequestionnairesfromthedatabase.Ifrequiredbycontract,re-schedulethesequestion-nairesforcorrection/completeness.c.Whenthedatabaseassemblyiscompleteperformtheanaylsis,below.(2.BIOGRAPHICALDATAa.Assemblebiographicaldataanddeterminerangesanddistribu-tionsforallrelevantdimensions.b.Usingappropriatestatistics,determinethedistribution(oritsapproximation)forthisdata.3.RESPONSEDATAa.Summarizeallresponsesanddeterminepercentfrequencyresponseforeachnegativeanswer.b.Foreachnegativeanswer,initiatePreliminar'yHEDs(PHEDs)fordiscrepancy"review.Recordfrequency'data,responsequestionnumberanddatacollectioncodenumberoneachPHED.Codenumbersaredevelopedasfollows:(SeeList3bforcriteria}Example;TaskPlanNumberAppendixTP-3.1B6.10questionNumberc.SubmitallPHEDstoyourimmediatesupervisor.d.Subsequentverification,validationanddispositionofallPHEDswillbeconductedperTP-10.1(HEDReviewProcedure).B6-1 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIX86'PERATORINTERVIEW/QUESTIONNAIREANALYSISTP-3.11Nay19831,6.3.1.3a(3)2.6.3.1.3a{2)3~6.3.3.1b(1)4,6.3.3.1b(2)5.6.3.1.4b(1)LIST3b20.6.3.4.1a(1)&(2)21.6.3.4.1b(1)22.6.3.4.1b(2)23.6.3.4.1c(l),24.6.3.4.1c(2)40.6.3.1.2d(l)41.6.3.1.2d(2)42.6.3.3.4c43.6.3.1.2c(3)44.6.3.1.2c(2)6.6.5.1.6b(l)7.6.5.1,6b(2)8.6.5,1.6c(l)9~6.5.1.6c(2)10.6.5.1.6G(2)11.6.5.1.6G(2)12.6.5.1.6b(1)13.6.5.1.6d(1)&(2)14.6.3.1.4b(2)&6.3.2.2b15.6.3.2.1f16.6.3.2.2a(1)17.6.3.2.2a(2)18.6.3.*2.lc19.6.3.2.1d25.26.27.28.24.30.31.32.33.34.35.36.37.38.39.6.3.4.1c(3)6.3.4.2c6.3.4.1d(1)6.3.4.ld(2)6.3.3.2e6.3.3.2f6.3.3.3e6.3.3.2c6.3'.2a{1)6.3.1.2a(2)6,3.3.la6.3.4.3a6.3.1.2b(1)6.3.3.4b6.3.1.2b(2)45.6.3.1.2c(2)46.6.3.1.2c(2)86-2 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEM'PPENDIXB7OBSERVATIONCHECKLISTANALYSISTP-3.11May19831.Foreach.checklistitemcheckedNO,initiateanHEDreport.EntertheHEDreportnumberintheCOMMENTScolumnofthechecklistforthatitem.IncludeallnecessaryinformationontheHEDreportconcerningidentificationofthediscrepancyandthecriteria(checklistitem)notmet.2.'nterthefollowingcodenumberinthedatacollectiondescription:TP-3.1B3.nChecklistItemNumber3.FindtheappropriatecriterionorcriteriainAppendixAfromthereferencenumberinthechecklistitem.ChecktheNOcolumnandentertheHEDnumberandthedatacollectioncodenumberintheCOMMENTScolumnforthatcriterionorcriteria.87-1 IdANNUNCIATORSYSTEMAPPENDIX88DOCUMENTATIONREVIEWCHECKLISTANALYSISTP-3.11Nay19831.ForeachchecklistitemcheckedNO,initiateanHEDreport.EntertheHEDreportnumberintheCOMMENTScolumnofthechecklistforthatitem.,IncludeallnecessaryinformationontheHEDreportconcerningidentificationofthediscrepancyandthecriteria.(checklistitem)notmet.2.Enterthefollowingcodenumberinthedatacollectiondescription:TP-3.184.nChecklistItemNumber3.FindtheappropriatecriterionorcriteriainAppendixAfromthereferencenumberinthechecklistitem.ChecktheNOcolumnandentertheHEDnumberandthedatacollectioncodenumberintheCOMMENTScolumnforthatcriterionorcriteria.88-1 APPENDIXB9HUMANENGINEERINGDISCREPANCY(HED)REPORTOR16IHATOR:VALIDATEDSY:PLANT/UN!T~)HEDTITLE:b)ITEHSIHVOLVED:C)PROBLEHDESCRIPTIOH:d)DATACOLLECTIOHDESCRIPTIONCODEHUHBER:e)SPECIFICHUHAkERROR(S):B9-I APPENDIX89HEDREPORT(CONTINUED)TlANT/VNITHEDHO.:f)SUGGESTEDSACKFlT;g)REVlEHAHDDlSPOS1T10H:89-2 0

ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Hay1983APPENDIXCCRITERIAMATRIX ANNONCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.1IMay1983CRITERIA~'ATRIXCriteriaDistributedAcrossDataCollectionMethods.Notes:1.Thefollowingcodesapplytothematrixcolumns:M-Measurement(instrumentsand/ormeasuringdevicesrequired)0-Observations(observationnotestaken)I-Interview/guestionnaire(generallyastructuredinterviewunlessotherwisespecified)0-DocumentReview(documentationreviewtoincludeengineeringdrawings,CMDs,etc.)A-AuditoryCriteriaV-VisualCriteriaC-ControlsCriteria(physicalcharacteristics)P-PhysicalArrangement/LocationCriteriaF-FunctionalCriteria(usuallyrequiressomeoperationaldataforverification)2.Datasourceslistedaresuggested.Alternativesshouldbeusedwhenthoselistedarenotavailableorarenotadequate.

ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Hay1983CRITERIAMATRIXCRITERIANUREG--0700CrithB-'.3.1.16.3.1.2a(1)a(2)b(1)b(2)c(1)c(2)c(3)d(1)d(2)DATACOLLECTIONMETHODSXXXXXXXXXXXSUGGESTEDDATASOURCESSFTARptOpsOpsOps,AnnRespProcsOpsAnnRespProcsOpsOpsOpsOpsREMARKSalsoinTP-9.1(SFTA)6.3.1.3a(1)a(2)a(3)bcd6.3.1.4a(1)a(2)b(1)b(2)6.3.1.5ab(1)b(2)b(3)6.3.2.1a6.3.2.2a(1)a(2)b6.3.3.1ab{1)b(2)c(1)c(2)c(3)PFPFPFPFPFPFPFPFFFPFFFXN/AXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXN/AN/AN/APnlOpsOpsPnlPnlAllPnlPnl,SFTARptPnlPnlPnlPnl.PnlPnlCRCR,AdminProcsCR,OpsCR,OpsCRCR,OpsOpsOpsOpsPnlPnlCRseetextpara.4.2aalsoinTP-9.1(SFTA)inTP-1~8-(Maint)inTP-1.8(Maint)inTP-1.8(Maint)C-2 ANNuNCIATORSYSTENCRITERIAMATRIXTP-3.1IMay19B3CRITERIADATACOLLECTIONNUREG--0700CritMETHODS'UGGESTEDDATASOURCESREMARKS6.3.3.28bcdef(>)f(2)6.3.3.3abc(I)c(2)c(3)d(I)d(2)'fFFFPPFPFPFPPFPPPPPFFFXXXXXXXXXXXXXPnlPnl,Pnl,PnlPnl,Pnl,CompSpecOpsOpsOpsAdminProcsPnlSFTARptPnlPnlPnlPnlSFTARptOpsPnlalsoinTP-9.1{SFTA)alsoinTP-6.1(Labels)alsoinTP-9.1(SFTA)6.3.3.4abcd6.3.3.5a(I)a(2)b(I)b(2)b(3)cc(I)c(2)d{I)d(2)d(3)d(4)d(5)d(6)6.3.4.1a(1)a(2)b(I)b(2)c(I)c(2)c(3)PPFPFPPPFFFFFFXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXPnl,OpsPnl,Pnl,PnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnlPnl,OpsPnl,OpsPnl,OpsOps5FTAOps,SFTARptConvRptOpsOpsOpsalsoinTP-9.1(SFTA)alsoinTP-9.1(SFTA)alsoinTP-8.1(Conv)C-3 ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11May1983CRITERIAMATRIXCRITERIANUREG--0700CritDATACOLLECTIONMETHODSSUGGESTEDDATASOURCESREMARKS6.3.4.1d(1)Fd(2)FXXPnl,OpsXOps,AdminProcs6.3.4.2ab(1)b(2)b(3)b(4)cXXXXXXXPnlPnl,ConvRptPnl,ConvRptPnl,ConvRptPnl,ConvRptPnl,OpsalsoinTP-8.1(Conv)alsoinTP-8.1(Conv)alsoinTP-8.1(Conv)alsoinTP-8.1(Conv)6.3.4.3abXXXCR,Ops,SFTARptXAnnRespProcsalsoinTP-9.1(SFTA)6.5.1.6ab(1)b(2)c(1)c(2)d(1)d(2)XXXXXXXXXXXXXConvRptOps,ConvRptOps,ConvRptOps,ConvRptOps,ConvRptOps,ConvRptOps,ConvRptalsoinTP-8.1alsoinTP-8.1alsoinTP-8.1alsoinTP-8.1alsoinTP-8.1alsoinTP-8.1(Conv)(Conv)(Conv)(Conv)(Conv)(Conv)6.6.6.2aFbVCcPPnl,Ops,SFTARptPnlPnlalsoinTP-9.1(SFTA)alsoinTP-6.1(Labels)alsoinTP-6,1(Labels)

ANNUNCIATORSYSTEMTP-3.11Hay1983~~APPENDIXDTASKPLANCRITIQUE

~\

ANNUNCIATORSYSTENTP-3.11Nay1983APPENDIXDTASKPLANCRITIQUEINSTRUCTIONS1.AttachacopyofSection,4,0.2.Fillintherequiredinformationandanswerallquestions.3.ExplainallNOanswersindetail.4.Whencomplete,turnintoyourimmediatesupervisor.1.NameofRespondent:2.NameofPlant:3.DateofSurvey:4.Wereallofthecriteriacorrectandappropriateforthistask(donotexplaincriteriathatwereN/AbecauseSystem/CRdidnothavethatdesignfeature)?YESNO5.Didthetaskplaninstructionspresenttheeasiestandbestmethodologyforperformingtheassessment?YESNO6.Werethedatacollectionformsadequate?YESNO