ML20129A509
| ML20129A509 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Catawba  |
| Issue date: | 12/14/1983 |
| From: | Bentley R DUKE POWER CO. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20127B003 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-84-722 NUDOCS 8507270237 | |
| Download: ML20129A509 (73) | |
Text
y 7.
< PLACE:a 1 . _ /A ,/ f(
DATE/ TIME: /la / </ _ /9 fl!' $
i I,'[j./,,[ <w b, <f , do hereby T.ake the follos.ing voluntary statement to 1 ,2 #/ / je who has identified himself to me as an Investigator with the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission. I do hereby make this voluntary statement without any threats having been made against me or any promises extended to me.
Txn ri,i,~ $ / G m x sierneh i, h bw $nssu <s ,c / $8$,f',
~
A4,L, A L / m e f rr. 7L<La n c , ,- c ! , 4 s ,,, ~ i , , f x r :6 .,- - "7) d- . -/// 7 -c- .-b'~/A -16 s- .
, , , &4 /4 .n. _, / r i<& /<in 7 L M~ f nnj'h Ll'A &LL A_'s AL 1 &-// SV w/,ta., ~<< c-C, <~,Jn, /o,,, A~,tf f AfoC '
'W n ~,, n' Mr/ d6o ~ < .eu n e n , c ,,/ 72(fds /- s.,,.%
(Ofs,w u- ///N //st'//r iM:m</r1, . As,4rs x ,dreacri w ? 7'f( W T/u<r d' bw dde O '/. sn lurin5C .f57'7%., J./A/~ siols c,4
'lir, n ,. - h ; 7 % % c -12% a,n 'n z'n s~/Af /,, -H 4,"//'
dr~,, s A, 4<,J</N L.s <,// J-M +o <isu a., /<,-.,o./a' -fr 8 5 &:A, L' s..! chre-,iL .T rof A Si.wn~ 3 r, <en//7., v'4'-
B o/r 6, ,,,, s A" -/r 14,,,'% ,/- L ' 1 4 2 % ,, A ~ / h ~ x/
- L., a in 'A///Ks v4A e . -A'~/ , . 3Ail + v /; u // 4 s c ,~, -
610 /M <4 s,lf4 ,Jf -//R." 2!-ZjL -t"<A' a n, ossL Rea ><<& sJr< z&,-/h//< AL, M'5% Zn%.~<<:
$b '7%,.. /' ,,.m n / . .-/ w ,-, -ta </d,,~<!,l-Mc ~ , A a</
eeu a , ,L Dn/,,, X/6~~ s a , . ~a~v's r' rs& L L ,,,.s
~ j, -4 n ., . :, u , 2 , L er i, 4 ~ > -EA ~ n ., , AM cw,n,,in /L~ A /J~ a r </ us W <4 L //N 4//A7%i twc
/~T s-r r K ~ ,.4 ~ J L o., L - -. I A -k,r-4 ,, , ,,..-, A J u en-,> km, ,- u d <, <4 . J' fo~ s-d
<<4, m /L-,. / ~ .,., A d d.a,n .? A < r s- ~ a-
- 9) <'i-x A / <_L 4r <r # su,,..;/-4,n In~ lc ~Wo c..e & ci_cn.o ., v< /na.,
w -fL $^M/. i.oc4,"i~7'~ wiwr / lvr/<et 4,r rn ,~0 & Aol Arc 'r n,i;' wror & L 4AL-a'1 as 2 ,, L i d lif7%&m?@WTLu .-,~-L,c 'sAA~ n 6 <-~/2 '
-ft'C "a,nJ, /X no4/x1, fccAn ad'A,rAn
,,~s rt A. ,# /,L /~ cn,-L r sloJ d< s<<~,, a, 2 - oc , b e r / L 6 c ,, ~ 5 ,c ,, x m s s L A % / 's c h 71 L
% A~-Av'O#'nA,v% LA Jor m,h,: _ "n,',,
~ -
i _a.n w
'a m r : . a,u. ,. . .
I a ><dr Y s'n,due n e,/, - n m' e>W ce /k // . a <. / l <r t
l d)t' tbA ,1 i,/n,7' de'$ // Ofswow<;//r r!rs-lW c9vt',/<Yr W t:/, 61 W i()c'soes,e $ k s t,A1 i
( ssa / A s, ANesesv Yf 1 r d M A 7C r 2 f 1 W r/< N / ,, 0 4 /} A.,,4 s#W AJ Jn d' rih
///b,we tbvi x>Y d'uo-,,stl,/ k s? d,Er -15 m A k r [ b u,
^ '
//s i /n a be r $id/M b lZ % / u s f/ f se a teer,o,W XeWW w us43 L,1/r~. ,/ -/t Lc, M~ ,s &,, ,, J ,6.,x 'r J /r is,e ,,i,,b 7 's-Lu'L ',c/,).4 u,u, d,,,f4 x' ds&. 7L ',,,,,,
r!r s n.r</ 3 i, ., Wlres Aon b er( W k rff 5 !vrer $ 0 />v< %, ,b /977 onen ad,Tr,i,,5/s n // se -d u,,E. 'rsid'ro,,,/r # /c A,,'
trev //bn Y to W Y/ bueW/m a ers u T Wsl/'/d W N b}r/n-hewvrs b r 4004 2/ l b /,!/h< fe N / /Aa, </ 6 / AiLCD/n Tbe,- s re, be$//r~Y $h tier ,Y s' to//-/b/ T/s,//n'e,$/.
-~ s y - /
/
/
~ /
m'h V
,v
/
/
/
/
/ p,7 d__ handwri tten/typetP I have read the foregoing statement consisting of pages. I have made and initialed any necessary corrections and have signed my name in ink in the margin of each page. I swear that the foregoing statement is true and correct. Signed on /p- /d-g'5 at 9 '4B //77 .
SIGNATURE:
/
R f re me this /// ' day of [7 '
[' '
Subscribe 1983 at rf [dand ,
INVESTIGATOR: [/,,, ef fj/ .
. /
WITNESS:
NAME/ TITLE
' f A l
C e
'0FFICIAL USE ONLY ,
MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE TYPE ACTION PARTIC3 PANT 3 FILL MO.
( ) RECORO OP CONVEAfJm0N
( ) east. mayltw/ STAT 1ps OATE
( ) OTMER Tsue CONPIDENTIAUTY ltE0utSTED YE5 30 0 Suasaper i
1 a .
l l
l
_ PAGE OF PCEPAREW SY OATE ACTION REQUIRED RtylEWED BY DATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY- -
00 NOT DISCLOSE h -7 ) YFD
I
'0FFICIAL USE ONLY _
MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE TYM ACTION MAftc3 Pants Pld No.
( ) secono or conversattom part
( ) cAag naview/ starug,
( ) erwen Tiest connoar:Aurr acous Tro vas no suam m e l
l
. not or PRsPARED SY CAfg ACTION REoulRfD REVIEWED SV DATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY' 07 NOT DISCLOSE Z 0 /- /0
'0FFICIAL USE ONLY ,
MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE.
TYPE ACTION PenTIC4 PANTS Fi d 4
( ) secono Or convensAT10m
( ) cass navatw/ svaru 8*TE
( ) ernan Tinst col 6M006TIAUTY MQUESTED TES NO SuameARY O
e 4*
G
. sNp l
. PAGE OF PREPARED AT OATE ACTION REQUIRED l
REyltwtD av OATE
{
OFFICIAL USE ONLY' DC' NOT DISCLOSE 3 of /0
f
'0FFICIAL USE. ONLY ,
l MEMORANDUM TO CASE. FILE FILE 800.
TYPE AETION PARTICIPAasT3
( ) RECORO OF C00fvtsSAT10W DATE
( ) east.REyltw/ status .
TitW.
COsePIDENTIAUTY MEOuESTER TER 11 0 i,
SusmARY E
e O
e
. PAGE OP' PREPARED BY ggyg ACTION REOUlltED ftEVIEWED BY DATE 0FFICfAL USE ONLY - 00- NOT DISCLOSE y of A>
- . 0
' FFICIAL USE ONLY -
l MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE
""' mon ,,,,,,,,,7, F)LL 090.
( ) escono or cowvensaTien
( ) saas. asynsw / staru l
' )
( ) erwan DE CONMoENTIAUTy Ngggggygg g gg
]
suessaarr
- i l
e l
- met or PREPaAfD sy DATE ACT1'[N REQUIRED i
i l
REYlEWED BY DATE j OFFICIAL USE ONLY- DO NOT DISCLDSE 6 a[ /0
\ -
"0FFICIAL USE ONLY .,
MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE TYM ACTICII PARTIC3 PANTS Fid n
( ) MCORD 07 CONVERSATION
( ) Case. mEy:Ew / Statue. .
Oart
( ) gTwER T1Ist COIIMDENTIALITY NEOUESTED TES IIO SUIsaneerf
~
l 1
. PAGE OF PREPAAE0 SY ggyg ACTION REQUIRED l
REVIEWED BY DATE l OFFICIAL USE ONLY' - 00 NOT DISCLOSE [e ( /0 g
'0FFICIAL USE ONLY
~ i 1
MEMORANDUM TO CASE. FILE TYPE ACTION PARTICIPANTS FILE N0.
( ) RECORO OF CONVERSAT10N
( ) Cast mEviEw/ statue, eaTE
( ) STMER
- Tiene col 8Pl0ENTIAUTT fttetE87ED VEB IIO SutIIIANY l
l l
l P
. Paar Or PREPARED ST DATE ARTION 2E0018180 Ii l
i l
l REVIEWED SY '
DATE.
QFFICIAL USE ONLY' - Do Mor Disetaar h r /n 'l
1
'0FFICIAL USE ONLY .
MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE TYPE ACTION pamflCIPANTs Pl d *
( ) #ECORD OF CONvtMATION
- TE
( ) cAss. naviEw / statua ~
( ) einen rime connosnriAurr secutaran var no summaRr
. FASE OF PREPARED SY DATE ACTION REQUIRED REVIEWED BY DATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY' 00 NOT DISCLOSE 8 of /0
"0FFICIAL USE ONLY _
MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE TTPE ACTloN PamTIC3 PANTS NE "
( ) ucono or comytasarion 8""
( ) casa. naview / status. .
( ) ernen '
commosar Aurr mousstra vus no suannant l
l
- enen or P CPARED SY DATE ACT1oM REoulRED atystw(D BY DATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY 00 NOT DISCLOSE 7 t[ /0
s l
~
0FFICIAL USE ONLY ,
MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE TvM ACTION PARTICIPANTg F6LE fec.
( ) NECORO OF COIfvgNSATION d
( ) Cass. naview/ stating _
04r
( ) etuta Tiene C04eRDEltTIALITY REQUESTED TES NO t
6 l
l I
e 9
e l
l PAGE OF PREPARED ST ggyg ACTl0N RKOUIRED
- CVIEWED ST DATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY' 00~ NOT DISCLOSE /0 0/ /0
OFFICIAL USE OriLY MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE FsLE Mo. !
TYM CCT40N PARTICIPANTS
( ) mEconD or convEasafson #^TE
( ) cast REvatu / s7ATes
[
II 97MER Time 4
COMPIDENTIALITY #EcutsTED TES No suuraaf I
I I
E i
i
.i i
PAGE OF DATE PIEPa:ED BY l
ACT8:3 REculRED n il l
l DATE C.EvigCED SY OFFICIAL USE ONLY DO NOT DISCLOSE k') I gp3f
r
.e e
- 7tlE E %:. E E. 7 (c u c: Cu YHa r T 14 /5
/)5 Fr]/Z A.s NCT BEoW& S u f ft /2TED IN i
. . 1MPt & NiMTt d6i YH&.' q A f/ED Gi?/)h is f/f8 M CT -rN87 A WTi r1E.S R&S c Lu TrodS A W1 Gt! Nil?A l- GRBy ARGns HA/t B Ffr/ WAT&l2Eh De Wal IN ORMtL fcR. CRAFT To fifer Scar 3ktid(rg DE Ah l>WE.S . A LCT o F TH&S E D C C nSt 0NS HME- BEBA/ Sp AcTLf Offe s tTE of ffocEbo G Bi pitREPIE di'S , yE T~ fil E l'R08 LENS B& SNG S2rv6 ffT u P wet?E To 2le /Gi ed R E3, BeausE Af ThtlS PC I NT~ (U tf L tTf D ibN'T fift T*E/2 DNL t{ ])2 pb Lin/th $.
ScmE E f n e:fL& S 6 f THthSE PRO BLE/HS 4
'EYl5'T C^f TH E Ep rt RE F W s y'5 tem /N T//E P UKitt A R (( S ut t.h t W6, && THE Na ns bfiz CNE StDE.
A Nu m SE/? DF fit &SE weab5 Hal) Tc BE
~ RE- tivs fEc TE Z) BECrty.SE o f" A A/ NCT CCNcfRdid6; W y'tE wtW4) f0R r.S . Lif UMTtL. fd/S TIML WE (q.c,
///$/%CTCAS IN THr.s ARGA} 2 Dth WOT //pdf Agf A'ASCtC. f)CCblitt A SSu R /NC,, 7"gftf THE Vf 5t3jdf, (ECCGD t.'l2 E S A Wh Gt.1 t ZE Lt us S C f T/?& F V D.S 'S V ; f. d C F LLC Lv Eh ,
CN ONi fnfTtC ULA f2 %lEL3 AE fslil THE RISMf:TC H W P S > d . C d fEGsittu.5 (CCA5f WS
\ wi."Et?i THE ~TCidf Mr.spu?f/fr:iWT WAS NC T /^I t ,
ACCCRlfidCE k'ITH THE f. tu!} S.
- file k' iller 2 5 R Ft TTEt23 Vit u Lh hl:2g WtTH TflE Plcbdm ildTic if ht 1-fML REQttCGhisT3 CF TME FWhS.
Sur oN THis DCASsicd, BEC AuSE THE WEthdS t CRAFY wgs issufb /F SHUT 30 NN 7"O .b0 Tdt S
~
AtO THEt{ WEREn'T GotWf Tb & MEETTHE PRb~
Lidi.) WE- W&RL nt--.D TH A T A tS AUSNNEdr
_ . ' .i
a A
'. 11 tc r. 'g*- C.' C ( r: tv . L r.i .r ' t 3 I:. t t < fl ~~ .
- f. r.'y'C TJ E k,'h' WS Th t) T ~7't'E A LIG N/Gr 7^ C 5 THG. fooN7" /.S E S *.>E tvd A L. 'TC A1A(<tN & A (a A ll T f LA/*t b a, ?
{}LSO Car ALL D F TH ESG- tr/Eil Rist'llitis
) ON THIS F kl 6 fSTEin M~ ) '{ hAfTErtrJAl-
' I C5.6ANLiMES S) /2E QuiIMn4E473 WE AG WritL Eb WITit /3bl f- 9B. TH(S B Litdh2/2. /MAhE tr A t.PioST /n'PtssiBLE. 7~O M A (< E T H & S E 0F0 N/2S
- SEC AUSB. 77tE. SYST*Ett STil L- CcNYt9 t WG .
PRE \ft=Wn=.h A Co mPz&rE. pa/2(,E WRTE& (WHIC H ON THis S.L Sy'5TffM RLSD T'HE d2tWhird,
?> tiST + T12AS H WAS S TI LL PRESENT.
/N EFFEC'r WHed ufE. CHECKEh 7T1ESE
( AE.fA IA FC (2- W5Lb/NC1 A LL k'E- Vd512E lctN/df)
FCR. WA S 70 6EE- lF THEf HR.D (7I?? udh R N:tE
/t) 7/!E. LlWE To WE L1 - U f.
w/E. ARL Na VEce. Suppc12rsD /M tuk 3G/LE{ ACU7~f ME t/VSPEL,77c WS . WHEN WE M6k'E Mis #KE.s Wa ARE ReAhn-f BLAMb RW.D CDt2/2ECT&b. y&T~ Wl/Et/ PRCCF2ur2Es Mh SPEC.S. h/2G tilCLA7'Eb 77/E /?ulES A 12E B?^7~ TD MSTut.
J pd /f A%
4
] i a
b b I E
tn
'.i
\
>,Ato m
- sm.) ---~
- ~ ,
{
f ;. Nm ( } *. rni_ D2
=
.% Go* +.- u. v..
1
,' ' \!b b fM E W Sl W k X.4 C L. d N. W h {
I Da v./S t.,i n.o
$b g , S'77, deco gg ,,%,,fgL y[
S"biac'
{. i . .l.:
g Ch hi qsXue-z se) . s4 l Sheen No. si . i.
tc> w& w AA. wyp,pJ
' ~
4 k AA .
Nil.-2121.5 Alinim nii 'Ihittnen of Atalcri.ds,
~
f a) Sidt tr terredertmre.
on Viale maletial shull hc ordered not thinner than the design thickness. Vewels ,l l i
[
i l In,ade of plate furnished with an undertolerance of. .
, l *l l '
- l**'
not more than the smaller value of 1101 in. or 6 per. NE.2124 Material Size Ranges and Tolerances l ceni of the ordered thicknew may be used at the full ~
des,ign pressure for the tiiicknew ordered. If the (a) Material outside the limits of size or thickness i specificatmn to which the plate n ordered allows i given in any specification in Section II may beaned if
. a greater undertolerance. the ordered thickness of the material is in compliance with tlifoth@lTe.
ments of th'c;;spel:ificati6 Carid*,0 Ilic material shall be sulhc,ently greater than the de.. gg, %- [zeglimitation ,; is i
g;,, g 3 ; !
sign thickness so that the thicknew of the material furmshed is not more than the smaller of 0 01 m. . whicEhemical.E5M5r' Mechanicalaijqdrties or 6 percent under the tiesign thicknew. ' WWaf are%*sMrgfeilint~p' material o'ut's'ide$thegp Q'ihafe !' beh' g
. Ih ) l', osse . Iladertaleranc.cp.1I, pipc gir '..t n ;,4 ordcted ,by;,it@ominalga Fthicknew;-the Rhe . 7, .G* ,;pasttsoxhn[5in'e$ni.~
manu. .
erATrs"heare~st specified range' facturing undertoleranchi6n . wall,thigkpty.jhallihe
- g.g.5ggggg '
takeli.;*;ntol,acenu.ntQIijc n}yxt hcavict 'coimnercial
( (b) Plate material shall be ordered not thinner than wall thickness may.then.,be,i:sedg,.l,14 pian.ufacty! E '
g, unde _ rtolcranejs are given in the several
, e piggarn!
' the design thickness.\ Vessels. except for piping.'made O"bc of plate furnished with an undertolerance of not more spec o jt nyhey,
- penM,,kiteghc}gy),,murig,hhik
- liedh!q..tahlgin 1_tktct , .
than the lesser hp.value of 0.01 in. (0.25 mm) or 6% of i
'the ordered thickness may be used at the full design !
min e d,iti.sh all . b@ ct,coligtl;)pj a,rt!1trQolmKs 61Ticie n ti
{ topressure which thefor platetheisthickness ordered allows ordered. a greater If the to .provid(hipe nW1Yiks%lfi$hMrh7[V'thgnilif6citYid'gWnid&td1cPa7&
Il$cilft'h' l , undertolerance, the ordered thickness of the material
- , , i 4.shall be sufficiently greater than the design thickness
. so that the thickness of the material furnished is not ~
NI?2124 Nier Itauges . more than the lesser of 0.01 in. (0.25 rnm) or 6%
under the design thickness. ! ',
. . Materials outside the limitt Ef.)dEc.- [r. thickness)
Icl If ipe P or tube as ordered by its nominal wall
- ddf7(Nf'ihIs(TKle h .
h_
k*r g,
" Win"nqh
- d. M t 4, .E AwM MM.I ~'."~ ow
- thickEs,qht trilh'ufa*cniring@dde'r16tershePon* wall j
' b thicYrisP$ska'if@ta'TeEinfoia~cTiu$tITIIi!TIn MI.h.{J1T."SMEbd=$MlE@. ftilM%A.J$*.J4!!c '""N.M"/V 'i
!?[turin~g'.iiS36. to!HfAcesia're given in' t!Ie s'everal pipe
.hngip3Agineti.%S.phsgction.;,In those spect,- p. e
- ficatJanuJnahickshendoalgompmitmngand/or 1 I). g,6-tg. .e g
w
, g I
- On,MPe.nd;k.g g n$cchanihl: prnpertievare4ndicated-tiev'aiy 'with~ size y ps,njym,wahqhj$nen s .u
_. or.sthick'n' c Arany rharirtat ont<ide"the specification etermmed,gtpaHMngrease6 4:n amount
+ range shall le required to conform to the composi. . sufficient to provide for the manufacturing undertoler- i 4; g g.g .
g g; y tion and mechamcal properties shown for the nearest-
. . , , r;-
specified.Tange.**" . . . . -
l l . .
- \llit.Tua 00' ids-sdiccl.0 ' !' i -
s s'2 wk Ce l l 37G I.I- acw aw =
q..
' D a . n. s .. . . ..
] U""
\
1
- Sul,ju. *
%)j I-gi* ll s.
Sheu t:. . '
_ .___ j.
i.
NE 2500 EXAhllNATION AND itEl' AIR NE 2500 MNIERIALS REPAIRS 1 01 PHE.S.NUHE IlhTAINING 8
4 hlATElllAL NI:.25 t fi Gl NI.it AI, HI QUlHl:Ml:N'IS g NE 2510 PRESSURE RETAINING .
Defects in material may be repaired provided ap- 5 MATERIAL l
prmal of the impccior ii first obtained for the method ami exicni of repairs (sec.NI! 4f>21.1). De- Pressure retaining material shall be examined and rep 4: red in accordance with the material specification fcctive material that cannot be satisfactordy repaiicd and as otherwise required by this Subarticle.
shall be_ relected.
NE.254tl 11 l % - WO N.RWI EI'Allt' Ol' I)l:l'l:CIS IN Z'. k'.
Y ,
2530 EXAMINATION AND REPAIR OF l'OllGINGS
- l'I. ATE NI:.254H 1:limination of !)cletts -
~
i NE 2531 Itequired Einmination (o) Surface impetitctions such m chip marks. -
- Plates shall be examined in accordance with the hiemishes or other irrecularnies shall be remmed h3 requirements of the material specification.
grinding or machining and the surface caposed shall .l
, he bicm!cd smoothly into the adjacent area where 4l e
suflicient wall thicknew permits tion areas m compli. J! NE 2537 Time of Exuminatiun h-g once with she requirements of N!!-4223.OMewcasD f1 Acceptance examinations shall be performed at the V f b) Thinning to remove defects beyond those per- p
' l time of manufacture as required in (a), (b), and (c) mitted in NE-4223 may be repaired by wchling, only i i below.
! alter approval by the impccior. ,.
i
- g. ; (u1 Examinations required by the
- material speci.
NE 2549 Hepair h3 Wc hling yl fication shall be performed at the time of manu-facture as specified in the material specification.
. .i 7: ; , (b/ Radiographic examinanon of repair w elds, l
, / '
when required. may be performed prior to any
,) '
rcquired pustwcld heat treatment.
j ; I ! r*
I (c/ Magnetic particle or hquid penetrant examina-
, lion of repair welJ> shall be performed afier any
./,
' required postweld heat treatment, except for P No.1 I
i material which may be exammed before or after any l
e / 'i required postweld heat treatment.
l l /f
- t
- ~
l 8
/.
/,
[3 .
I t DNE 2538 Elimination of Surface Defects ,
i ; (a) Unacceptable surface defects may be removed i by grinding or machining provided the requirements
, of (1) and (2) below are met:
,: , (/) the reniaining thiskness of the section is not i '
j , ,
reduced below the minimum required by the design;
- l , . (2) the depre>> ion, after defect chmination, is blended uniforinly mio the sortuumiing susfacc p :,s !
(b/ Whtn the chnunatiun of the d46 reduces the Vf,s g AN 90vEo6tM gh thicknc>> of the scetion belaw the mimmum required by NE 3000. the material shall be repaired in accor-i
/g u to WE2535 d.meeonhNit.25g 1 3
6....... _
g Dev./St..t o... fl iii i iii. I .'.. -
g 9 : < 1). it Sbset No. ... .. .:. ..
- .. I . .! 13, 11. . i . . .
I
~$ -
- l*;I l
! l 8
, i I
i
- I.
i e !
.I * : .
l l l ! l ( :,
- I . .. .
... .W ' '
NE-4k30 J.REPA1R'OF MATERIAL *' * * '3 f.q;WB1!,'l
. N I'...l l 3 tl ' I l.thilNA III)N AND lil'.I' A llt ()F I t Ill l I.C I S NE-4131 Elimination and Repair of Defects ' Ws1 i L
, NI'..,4131 Iluin Goscaning t.limination and i .
.. ; } 9; Matenal on. .ginally accepted on deh.very in which HiPair defects exceeding the limits of NE 2500 are known or , i ,,
Defecn in materiah wliich were accepted on de. discovered during th'c process of fabrication or instal .;f.j).;. ,
1.ition is unacceptable. The material rnay be used ,. * ' 'j
} livery or which are diwmcred during the process
' of f abrication or imtallation may be climinated or provided the condition is corrected in accordance with repaired by welding, provided the defects are re- f77 the requirements of NE 2500 for the applicable ' .e'N i i moved. repaired and esamined in accordance with Ilic resguisements of Nii-2511(i for the apphcable inod-f product form. except: (1) the limitation on the depth 'I.
of the weld repair does not apply; ancf(2) the' time of .
uct form, cacept that the limitation on the depth of caamin.stion of the weld repairs to weld edge prepara-
, tions shat!bein accordance with NE.5130. ,
repair does not apply.
' ; i i i ;
i h .k i i ! . . I l<
i !
!i -
i ij ,
i .
i :
n- ! .
. . , i .
l i -
1 i
gig,1 l i t .
i .
,# hbG!
i i l 'I l ;
i i ! i I. . i i t
l l ; '
' I
' t
- i j i
) I 'i
. !!9 i !
4 i
i 1
i -:
4 e
l1 l
l l
l l l.
t I
i '
l g
i l .
I. *
.i
. I I i .. l
,j r '
l ' I
! I I .
l
$ g i j I l .
l r g i^
I i
i l
' 6 I ,' * .
l, 1
l-
.i I
- e.
y i
i l . i i
- [
i
' I I i l Y ,
[>
C .
- I .
' ; 'l O 1 { , ;
] .
. 9 i -
I
' l .
l I !
l . . b
+ i l j l ; i ; i
\ ; ; ; .1 5 '
l i .
8
. F w . ,' ,
y .
3 I '" " '
De v./ h t .. . 1 Sulagui .
D .} $ Y
. . . t u.! ti ,
I ,
l' -
l.a 59 g.
- 8 -
q ; l 1 ! '
i l j !
l e -
-i i l y '
i.
l .
i
.i l.i . I I .' _iL' l
NE-4220 FORMING TOI.ERANCES I NE.4220 FultMING 101.EllANCES d 1
- ' ~~
- y NE 4221 Tolerance for Yessel Shclis, g422I
]
f N E. Tolerance for Ve selShcIls y , , ,
N E.42 21.1 Maximum Dillerence in Cross Sec: NE 4221.1 Maximum Difference in Cross.
linnal Diameters. ., D ameters. *
' ' ' ' '[
[ 3 3 I
NE.4221.2 Maximum Desistion from True *t he.
nrotical l'orm 'j,$ ! NE-4221.2 Maximum Deviation From True Theo- l
- retical Form for External Pressure. - i i
{
NE 4221.3 Desintions from Tolerances. 'l) e -
' 'I _
l ,
g ,
NE 4221.3 Deviations From To!crances.1 l
i ,
.' 9. i ,
NI: 4221.4 Tolcrance Desiations inr vomi Parts ,
NE 4221.4 Tolcrance Deviations for Vessel Parts p Fabricatol from Pipe. .\ -
Fabricated From Pipe. ,
l . g. : 't ! -
. I<
4 NE 4222 Tolerances for Formed Vessel IIcads The tolerance for formed vessel heads shall be as .
fj \ '
NE 4221.5 I.oenlized Thin Areas.. Localized thin f !
l Dic35 are Permitted if the adjacent areas surrounding j set forth in the following subparagraphs. y each has suflicient thickness to provide the necessary ;l V lI, reinforcement according to the rules for reinforcement g NE.4222.1 Desiation for Specified Shape. : in NE-3330.
I (a) 't he inner surface of a head shall not deviate } kD
. t from the specified shape by more than 185 percent of g, .
i the inside diameter n! the head skirt. Such deviations i t i shall not be abrupt changes, shall be outside ' E-4222of the
. Tolerances f.) for Formed Vessel licads a deugn shape and shall be measured perpendicular to the specified shape. ., j The tolerance for formed vessel heads shall be as set ;
(h) 'Ihe stirts of heads shall he sulliciently truc
'l l foah in the following subparagraphs.
3 g
to rimmt ui that the dillesence between the masimum 5 and minimum diameters shall not exceed I percent }
of the nominal diameter (see Fig. NE-4221.1 1).
D.':En ucters. 4222.1 The skirtMaximum or cylindrical end Difference of a formed gin Cro
) $, heu shall be circular to the extent that the difference NE 4222.21olerance on Forged I! cads. Forged t ; in in Aes between the maximum and minimum diame. I, i
heads shall be as true as is practicable to make $ i ters i ces not exceed the lesser of(D + 50)/200 or (D i them to the shape shown on the design drawings. ( + l.1 e'100, where D is the nominalinside diameter in
._ Any deviations therefrom shall merge smoothly into q inches and shall match the cylindrical edge of the l the general shape of the head and shall not evide - adjoirng part within the alignment tolerance specified a decrease of strength for the sections as requi in NEed '232.j ,
by the formulas for design. NE C 22.2 Deviation From Specified Shape NE 4223 f.ocalized Thin Arcas S qo g -
l Localiicd thin arcas are permitted if the adjacent g ,
f
..y arcas surroumhng each has uithcient; thickness to, p '
4 ,
( provide the necessary reinforcement according to the ; ';' g l
cs for reinforce,mer;in NE-3330. t', O i l .
_ I _ _ _ _ .
I l
>6 April 23,1982 Memo To File Re:
Catawba Nuclear. Station, Units 1 & 2 Steel Containment Vessel Dome Pitting,' Unit 2 .
NCI 9092 '
File No: CN-ll44.13 v ~-
On April 23, 1982, I received a call frodi Mr. Jim West, Quality Assurance Manager at Newport News Industrial Corporation. NNI's technical staff has reviewed photographs of the surface conditions observed on the dome -plate, and Mr. West wanted to advise us of what.they believe is the source of these conditions.
L Mr. Jerry Cobb, a metallurgist for NNI stated that they have experienced similar
! - surface conditions as a result of exposure of plate to the environment. Near Ii the Chesapeake Bay, where the atmosphere is considerably more brackish than .
! this area, up to 25 mils of corrosion pitting can be experienced in one year. i l These conditions are aggravated by standing water on the plate. Localized effects are generated by dirt spots on the surface allowing the formation of oxygen pockets which accelerate the effect. NNI does not believe that this would be caused by inclusions, since these would be more elongated and indicative of rolling directions. .
Mill scale would probably not be the source of t'hese problems, but the presence of l scale could accelerate fomation of localized oxygen pockets. In sumary, NNI l does not believe the conditions existed when the plate left NNI, since an inspector i would have to be totally negligent to miss the conditions.
Mr. Cobb stated that if the plate were sandblasted to white metal prior to coating, the condition would be stable.
Dv.c.
Jo M. McConaghy, Dq i n Engineer I Civil / Environmental Di i ion
~ JMM/ks t xc: I. W. Pearce D. E. DeMart l c
~
.c ME'MORANDUM DATE
~N flLC
,o l
l ADDRESS l FROM SUBJECT K#8##!d'b ~bb iOiZ i
OMAO47
. . . . 1 . . . . . . .
w aA4
.. & .._)_. ..& _
. j m......d..- h. a L
_.4 _ . . _ .. _ __
..y _ ... __ .- _ _ ..
.xsnaa..py _uA.yp
\ .. .._ yy Jnut, + m pi'a,.x _y
,L_W 9m.M _..k
+ .
twp u~tm-s n._._
, . N & . @ y. Q sA M J ~;f L . q A nm, n .apa. - - . . . _
.....% p % i y .i .. J V ,_. _
A-. - - . . . . . . . . . . . . - -
h%Q p& - g a & u . y- 4 a.m n Qu b
. m mur,wu pn W ff .w m A. q uav A..k+ } f M y s f w p % . 4 y g +y._
~a ~ Ap smaj L g scv. P p g.p a - Q w a
~
f . . .. JLJ A
{
L __wbsME ..wa Q ap .
f o .
l i
C.LUsev : /'d RJufM !
4-29-gZ
-si ttto - 12 2 r.: r :te. Pr. .-
Arc i o recent1 discovered NRC docunentr, shoving Duke Porer Ccmpany quality assurance employee complaints of harassment.
nrders to felsify records and a " Duke whitewash", Palmetto Alliance and Carolina Cnvironmental Study Group have gais.ed
, ,- the assistance of the Government Accountability Project in their challenge to the Catauba Nuclear Station operating license.
. GAP is s Washington, D. C. baued organization which monitors government and 2ndustry practice througn the use of whistle .
olowers - vork crs who expose fraud, vaste and improper practices.
CAP has'helpeo expose widespread quality control problems at
. the Zimme; nuclear plant in Ohio, where the NRC has nalted
- anstruction. M :: . Billie Garde. CAP staff investigator, will be present at the April 21 press conference. CAP agreed to assist in investigation and monir.cring of the QA-QC programs at Catsuba based on evicence of serious, systematic and videspread problems at the plant.and indications that NRC cfforts in correcting the problem have been ineffective.
In the .NRC licensing case, ... based on information proviceo by two former Cctawba workers -
including a Q/C inspector -
Palmetto Alliance charged that company pressure on i.;spectera
'o approve faulty workmanship and subvert the N3c required 0/3 pregram preduced systematic deficie,caes in plant I construction...
R t a k n a t i u g r.p x a p a r u t t a x x x I Curing prenearing preparation, Palmetto Alliance fcund 0/A-Q/C arublems had caused Duke Power Company to conduct its cun investigatic.: from December, 1901 to ria r c h , 1982.
hecently released documents show that Q/C inspectors hed
- omplained as early ao February 1, 1962, to the NRC that Duke Power Company o n.s i d attempt to "whitevash" investigation that the QC personnel hac been " harassed on the job" Enc that they had been " told to falsify lecords".
gg i. Wn d 4., v. A . ,
2-77
- c. L /. X w : y .~ ~.
d ,', e-ar-
. . 3 ' n, . . . <e -- i ; ~~~~
Dbd.
9, my enamind 'emal t=9sm dl Q =t'E" 'E5-.:s17<<' ,'
I manar4W=tum>J*2apad d se ao uma passud W
5 8 j 21 y
gL JJ=
p' >h-d ~
.- peu w 2avi r
au em *>ecam4ow Pcv norte n,a 4emo 2 cut q ruoip asa as aa,.curawoi reqqmd M, m zuvid Justm momtz so w g g2a. g restemd noomorum on, timb m ,a peu opsmaisAs roopw amm( )2
~J -
f j; aimie.dau onn a av aa pouc; ~*"*" " "" " "
g2 ?!? 23 9TE , *****"d N ,
Q -1 3 '
j'
- D A " #' M 83* N .*'***" ~ '""'"" **.'" W H
2 : :wu [-
.. layj f f.3gi :41*j M*u. gem penof seg'soet ' 'wahnal g
jj mu > I y r2t.{ as - - [ 44 AJarapai pesop 42gveh .30 asummset 44 mmW q ..s. -- .l og 'Ame==o y sJemoiq . opsRa funb Jefem Art aan sagt -siTM.
par li=nummar .--..,.m.-.p-syg. pg sogez. .
h ,h ld]dE"f,. ..
la c 18812W 9 J- , tem.3 1*h mmo, e rea at .pepacovs.a
- e. - 2. -, .
pcv soopv 5
[ .ya .
1j 1, j
" ' " "#* Ie mm ==we =nmamm os.
4884 fGhl 4o Jj.
11a. 1 m .
" ".i-, -
- ,m '% ,7y, ,, ,ry,:
-u
%"#.!. T, 3 ,".',.= w.-=a>e s- ; .
. = ~ .... n , ---
ao
'y.(";((fi)1,g
!dj/hdgi ! I SP30331Ilueld 380Iany ur 3 ' azng asnaay ol dnoa9 NM Si g "j i b'i$'gne .( -
~
% m VM '110.0380 kj.n.,qp;pjf c . s..
- m. M:.4 g_asurma
. .dO3'80.03H"'
- L;s-Q ha..
~ ~
riidtjlltij!!
=*
9d '80 0380 815flif ceg H0:.MWOV 01 LSSV W 't
- g g p =1.i. l '.
- e w j 9 ' -.'1011SNMV .
l!0 1 5 R 0V AIM 30 IVES3r / .-
. 4..h e.e 4 i
- j'liU#p,!,!I 2 ga g
1
.' kY
?$
N
.k
~
$Yiebtlib{ l- $ $f x fy ; 4 Pn a E. ' j n wao ? Q;s d p o c i m# fi!*.!J e d,1
<g ..i i
fdit]p . o a a
** " b e h !;1ta t
,r 2 n se p :- -<-h>
- r. ,
e ! INDEX OF DOCUMENTS CATAWBA NUCLEAR POWER PLANT CASE NO. 2-83-039 I. Main Case File A. Inside Front Cover
- 1. Region II, NRC letter dated October 21, 1983 requesting OI:RII investigative assistance regarding Catawba Nuclear Power Plant - 1 page
- 2. Completed Allegation Data Form, NRC Form 307 - 1 page
- 3. NRC Investigation Status Record, NRC Form 306 for Case No. 2-83-039 - 2 pages
- 4. Region II, NRC letter dated November 1, 1983 requesting 01:RII investigative assistance regarding Catawba Nuclear Power Plant - 1 page
- 5. Event Chronology Sheet for 2-83-039 (partially completed - one entry) - 1 page B. Front Facing Divider
- 1. Region II, NRC letter dated October 31, 1983 providing additional information of interview conducted on 10/25/83 - 2 pages
- 2. Original draft Results of Interview provided by Region II undated - 10 pages
- 3. Corrected draf t Results of Interview provided by Region II undated - 11 pages
- 4. Signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated January 19, 1984 - 2 pages C. Facing Back Divider
- 1. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated November 29, 1983 - 5 pages
- 2. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated November 30, 1983 - 6 pages
- 3. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated December 7, 1983 - 5 pages
- 4. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated December 7, 1983 - 5 pages
/N 3 sr-t D. 7 } m
r 2
- 5. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated December 8, 1983 - 4 pages
- 6. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated December 13, 1983 - 5 pages
- 7. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated December 14, 1983 - 4 pages
- 8. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated December 14, 1983 - 2 pages
- 9. Draft copy of Results of Interview with information source dated December 15, 1983 - 7 pages
- 10. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated January 4, 1984 - 4 pages
- 11. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated January 5, 1984 - 7 pages
- 12. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated January 18, 1984 - 5 pages
- 13. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated January 19, 1984 - 5 pages
- 14. Draft Results of Interview with information source dated January 19, 1984 - 7 pages
- 15. Copy of sworn statement written for interviewee, undated and unsigned - 4 pages
- 16. Copy of signed sworn statement provided by interviewee dated January 26, 1984 - 4 pages D. Inside Back Cover Interview Notes in Draft or Rough Form
- 1. Rough interview notes of an information source dated November 28 and 29, 1983 - 5 pages
- 2. Rough interview notes of an information source dated November 30, 1983 - 6 pages ]
l
- 3. Rough interview notes of an information source dated i 4 December 1, 1983 - 6 pages 1
- 4. Rough f,nterview notes of an information source dated .
December 6, 1983 - 6 pages I l
- 5. Rough interview notes of an information source dated December 7, 1983 - 4 pages
__ . 20[b
- f. 3
- 6. Rough interview notes of an information source dated December 9, 1983 - 6 pages
- 7. Rough interview notes of an information source dated 1 December 14, 1983 - 4 pages
- 8. Rough interview notes of an information source dated ,
December 14, 1983 - 3 pages )
- 9. Rough interview notes of an information source dated !
December 15, 1983 - 8 pages
- 10. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 3, 1984 - 4 pages
- 11. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 4, 1984 - 8 pages
- 12. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 17, 1984 - 4 pages
- 13. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 18, 1984 - 6 pages
- 14. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 19, 1984 - 8 pages
- 15. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 24, 1984 - 6 pages
- 16. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 25, 1984 - 5 pages
- 17. Rough interview notes of an information source dated January 26, 1984 - 7 pages E. Auxiliary Folder #1
- 1. Memorandum from R.C.' DeYoung to B. Hayes dated December 19, 1983 (1 page) with GAP letter to R.C. DeYoung dated December 2, 1983 (4 pages) with affidavits attached from three information sources (12 pages, 16 pages and 46 pages, respectively).
- 2. Memorandum from J. Lieberman to B. Hayes and G. H. Messenger dated January 13, 1984 (1 page) with letter to R. C. DeYoung from W. H. Owen, dated January 5, 1984 (2 pages) with attached DPC to GAP undated (53 pages).
80{ $
s seRC F08 tea 30s U.S. CUCLE AR CE GULt. TORY C088Mi3tDN INVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD MTRUCT @ S Thes torm is to tie completed whenewe sarmfont activity has occurred relatiw to e case or et leert ene, 2 days if no change hos occurred during the 30 dey eeporting pereM. Ind cate "No Owner 6n the status t>4od. Keep the oree nel with the esse fde eM send one copy to Headowerters. Oft.ce cf Innstiget ons. CASE 8 sus 8et R CAftGOnv Of FsCE O OPERAfsssG atacTom 8 8'sDiveDuaL Lectnesta 2-8,3-038' y .vtNDom "x .'"THtm O AmC=tD io Suo'c' Possible Violation of Board Order; Lack of QA/QC E. L. Williamson Independence & Harassment / Intimidation of QC Inspectors STATUS (Specify dete. edprovide a knef dancripton) 10/31/83: General information was provided by an alleger regarding possible violation ! of a Board Order, Lack of QA/QC Independence and harassment / intimidation of i OC welding inspectors at the Duke Power Company's Catawba Nuclear Power Field work will commence with interviews of some inspectors. This i Plant. investigation is initiated by 01:HQ. EDC 01/15/84. 4 11/7783: Field work in progress.
- 12/05/83 No Change 01/03/84 No Change 2/6/84 No Change.
3/3/84 No Ch'ange i 4/2/84 No Change l 4/28/84 Field work complete. Draft report in write-up. i I 6/2/84 Final repor.t in HQs for review. 6/29/84 No Change 7/28/84 Final report issued. Case closed __ _ t L. R b u .
e y _: . m .2 m R tre ro,ru m ALLEGATION DATA FORM u s nucle AR REGUL ATORY COMMISSION NE Instruct ons on revsrse sede RECEIVING OFFICE Docket Number (if applicable)
- 1. Facility (ies) Involved: (Namel att enore than 3. or it /*,.~, c, , ! . - /) ;- o q > L. ? l f
generic, write GENERIC) i
- 2. Functional Areals) Involved:
ICheck oppropriate bontest i operations onsite health and safety construction offsite health and safety safeguards emergency preparedness other tspecifyl i 3.
Description:
l< ls l'>l 5 lr ld 7 I r/lcl l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l (Limit to 100 characters) l l l l l gl l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIl l l l l l l 1l l l l l l l l l l l l l IIIIIIIIIIIIIII
- 4. Source of Allegation:
(Check appropriate box) Contractor employee security guard _ licensee employee news media _ NRC employee _ private citizen organization aspecifyl othe r (specify1 SMM MM DD YY
- 5. Date Allegation Received:
I O 9 J ?3 -
- 6. Name of Individual trirst two initi.is and last name) ' I- '
^T l l
Receiving Allegation: , I
- 7. Office: g g ACTION OFFICE
- 8. Action Office
Contact:
trirst two initi is and inst namel
- 9. FTS Telephone Number: ,,
- 10. Status:
Icheck one) - Open, if fo!!owup actions are pending or in progress Closed, if followup actions are completed MM DD YY
- 11. Date Closed:
1
- 12. Remarks: l l l l l l l l l l l l j l l l l l j l l l l l l l (Limet to 50 characters)
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII l Office Year Number hel . l
- 13. Allegation Number: ,
WC I
- 1 anc as vs. mucuan nievumv ca .
~ "
INVESTIGATEN STATUS RECORD WnUCTMWW: Then toren le to to someested wherever saysifiseret estivery has escurred reistle to e one er et toast every 2 ders. If no changs has esosted dwg sie 2 doy reportets perted. heissee No Change"in We statue 64eek. Keep the origined wNh the sans flee end send one empy to Headguerters Offles of incessepasons. CASE sevesSER CATEGOsty Of f 6CE O OPERAfissG REACTOR e .eseOsve0 VAL LtCtesett E "* "'"*""''"" "" * * " 2-83-038 v vtNDom x .0THER
^='s=< o To **c' Possible Violation of Board Order; Lack of CA/QC E. L. Williamson Independence & Harassment / Intimidation of QC Inspectors STATUS (Specoty date, omtprovide a brief duecepten) 10/31/83: General information was provided by an alleger regarding possible violation of a Board Order, Lack of QA/QC Independence and harassment / intimidation of QC welding inspectors at the Duke Power Company's Catawba Nuclear Power Plant. Field work will commence with interviews of some inspectors. This investigation is initiated by 01:HQ. EDC 01/15/84.
11/7/83: Field work in progress. 12/05/83 No Change 01/03/84 No Change 2/6/84 No Change 3/3/84 No Change 4/2/84 No Change 4/28/84 Field work complete. Draft report in write-up. 6/2/84 Final repor.t in HQs for review. D o. P A. i m e
IsetC F0elu 35 UA. IeUCLE A't CEQULATC4Y ComeWCong INVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD
- wTauevioses; m swin m to m. unes.=d + e.fii.ni .a.,*iv h. ms mm,= => e == ., e m.m rv m d.y. if R sh.nes h= amd anine e.
E day ressortsne potsod, kulicots *Teo Chenge** 6n the natus bied. Kamp the eripnel w*th the emme fine aral send one copy to Headquarters. Off ce of amemptions Cast NuesseR CAftcoRv 0F FsCE O 0PERATING RE ACTOR I
- WBOlVlOVAL LDCt8delt 2-83-038 V .vtNDOR N .OTHER
^='oa* o 'o "'c' Possible Violation of Board Order; Lack of QA/QC E. L. Williamson Independence & Harassment / Intimidation of QC Inspector!
STATUS (Specify dyre, aruf pmyd a ersef sherremn/ 10/31/83: General infonnation was provided by an alleger regarding possible violation of a Board Order, Lack of QA/QC Independence and harassment / intimidation of QC welding inspectors at the Duke Power Company's Catawba Nuclear Power Plant. Field work will comence with interviews of some inspectors. This investigation is initiated by 01:HQ. EDC 01/15/84. 11/7/83: Field work in progress. 12/05/83 No Change 01/03/84 No Change 2/6/84 No Change 3/3/84 No Change 4/2/84 No Change 4/28/84; Field work complete. Draft report in write-up. O
1 U.S CUCLE A3 ClGULATO?.Y Cow &5iO4 CRC FOR3 M6 ~ ~ INVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD , MTRUCTIONS. This toem n to lie completed w*wnever sgnifant oct.wity has owed reist ve to e case or et seest eve v 30 d.ys if no chev has occurred during the
- d. .nd.c.ie ~uo o.e.e w = um m.e. i,. o,+ne. .. % ..e u. .nd .e,.s one oop, so we.ooo.ne .
m d., ,em.n. ,e. Ott.co of Invest.priens i. I>
'i cAtscony os e sCt CAstseuweta 0 OP(RATING RE ACTOR s .eseDiviDuaL Lecteestt E "* -
. .. vtaiat w ust 01 Atlanta Field Office 2-83-038 v .vi.oon . .or in s
^$5'cano vo 5unic' Possible Violation of Board Order; Lack of QA/QC E. L. Williamson Independence & Harassment / Intimidation of QC Inspectors STATUS ispecify derr. aw1prende e bnet dancevren) 10/31/83: General information was provided by an alleger regarding possible violation of a Board Order, Lack of QA/QC Independence and harassment / intimidation of
- OC welding inspectors at the Duke Power Company's Catawba Nuclear Power Plant. Field work will commence with interviews of some inspectors. This investigation is initiated by 01:HQ. EDC 01/15/84.
11/7/83: Field work in progress. 12/05/83 No Change 01/03/84 No Change 2/6/84 No Change l Sci?
U $ Nuci.t A3 CE Cut ATOAV c0&v Esich C C DORw 306
- INVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD
..r,.ewi omn.o .eiet.. to . uw o, ei i..n e* , so e.v. is no en.ar nei o=n.o oe.as the susTrucTeous Th.. so - so in compineo **a n... . h.
.tw in, a w v.i .ne uno on. copy io u..oas.ner .
30 a., ..pon.a. ..ao. u.c.i, No c>.,, .a n. c.i . i,io$ x in, o....n. on.c, of sa.c.pi.on. CattGoa, Opp CL C' St Nup.t h 0 . Ort AAf e4G RE AC10m 8 . shDiviDuat tectN5tt u .uaita.Atsi,vit 01 Atlanta Field Office 2-83-039 @ c *&^NOCTs'" _ a .OYMER v .vthDOa amcat o io 5**c' Alleged Cheating of QC Welding Inspectors E. L. L'illiamson Duke Power Company, Catawba Nuclear Plant ST ATUs Coere4 d.re. sad provede a brief derreteel 10/28/83: Regional Administrator requested an investigation into allegations that an entire class of welding QC inspectors were provided copies and answers to examinations in 1977. EDC 03/15/84. 02/03/84: Interviews are being conducted in conjunction with Case No. 2-83-038. 2/6/84 No Change
'lof4
1 RRC f 0mW Soli U.5 kJCLE AR CIGULATORY COM*Ai&5:0h BNVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD
*eSTIUCTIONS: This form is to tre completed whenever s.gnif-cont activity has occurred reistiw to e come or et least every 30 days if no chener hei occurred dweing the . 30 doy reporting pereod, indemte **No Chengr~ an the status block. Keep the oregene! wrth the case file end send one copy to Headovarters, t Office of lawstigations.
CISt NueseER CATEGony OFFsCE O . OPERATING RE ACTOR e . pMDiviDUAL LICEN$tt E c gg,Tcyg.*,a . . =*Temiatwun 01 Atlanta Field Office 2-83-038 - V VINDOR x .OTHER assichia to Su*>5c' Possible Violation of Board Order; Lack of QA/QC E. l.. Williamson Independence & Harassment / Intimidation of QC Inspectors STATUS (Soecify dere, andprovide e brief desception) 10/31/83: General information was provided by an alleger regarding possible violation of a Board Order, lack of QA/QC Independence and harassment / intimidation of QC welding inspectors at the Duke Power Company's Catawba Nuclear Power Plant. Field work will commence with interviews of some inspectors. This investigation is initiated by 01:HQ. EDC 01/15/84. 11/7/83: Field work in progress. 12/05/83 No Change
)
01/03/84 No Change l 1 g . g ed set.j
l
. l e h RC F D" M 306 U.S. NUCLE AR EEGULATOAY COMv11$10h.
INVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD , 1 INSTRUCTIONS This form es to be comparted whenever segmf cent GC1,vely has occurred relative to a case or et least every 30 days if no change has occurred dweens the 30 d., ,eport no per.od. .ad.c tr No Ch.n, en in, si.i . nioci x.e, the or,,,n.i ..ih the c..e f.ie nd .end one copy to weedaos,te,.. , Off.ce of Invest.getion, i l Cistenvue:R C AT E Go*
- O H ect o .o,...ri o e.cro. . . .~oiviount tica sie 2-83-038 11 * ' EMEUcTo='" -
" "^a'5"ut' 01 Atlanta Field Office l V .V NDon x .OTHER
^"' ' ***c' E. L. Williamson Possible Violation of Board Order; Lack of 0A/QC >
Independence & Harassment / Intimidation of QC Inspector! 4 STATUS I5peedy dete, andprovide a bnet enacretion) 10/31/83: General information was provided by an alleger regarding possible violation of a Board Order, Lack of QA/QC Independence and harassment / intimidation of QC welding inspectors at the Duke Power Company's Catawba Nuclear Power Plant. Field work will commence with interviews of some inspectors. This investigatior, is initiated by OI:HQ., EDC01/15/84 l i b Wh
= OFFICIAL USE ONLY CASE CHRONOLOGY
'nLE nuuaca ca7E oPENEo CPENED SY !
~
7- P 3-0 W DATE ACTiv lTY
'/- fo--V4 '2~C : 0*7!<? */b 8rt.c t 4~ % ~ 9d 1C: kt dir 1 mw ~,k Doo 1-to-24 M 75 AM /A a,,n.>u , 441 a + b rs ..__.
W-H-84 1C .* M/4 omrou -4 (pig N, - /L W nr&: /ft/Ao$ coa,./Joxro, [Hs, /)fc dm4', Agsgfdz._dalWem- - - 5/5 #8W b?7Z' ' /MS ANth . Vs.nre $*ts /d///su r ._ V2 3-h t/ iAre : ~7ssue saA y
'sf AA6w;i /DNA>~ esee,sief. >
/ =
. r W' W50 )J}/f
- I
'Tb /// Art hen . /
M /// an es,. ___ ~
*/- 9 S -t'l .
-1 o '
UJ N < wie %. CA a ,L
%-p s-M Tc. '. C. A n n % C A3 ello s w e ,
<+. 3 w - 8 s1 f.//n '. Yttusu.h s eJ % h tY__
Q*7->4 TL : dvill omsd~ h Mkss c' Abrizit. . _ _ _ S J.4 H lln '. Up r e lo k c_ ,
/
_...___ .. __ __ _ O_ S
, m.
__ __ee .. ...
. . - .. m e e ena w Mum em. -
-m - m
- ie- - eem . e .. . eeem.m-
.N6 h me.m a e-mm , emie heg amese amy 6 e4e- umph. . . eempw-gom-w . w ewee-- .---eee s--w--en eeMh e4mm =ww e e- gus ee ee mm- 6 *6m * * -P . ++ * *+ 8'le O
- M N = dumb mm we weim.use a me,..en.as>% e..wew em 6 , m eme - ee -e w -w-M.- - e qu'a
"*h*'
=m. ._.
*e=-4W.em 6hu=> -g m ,- -w mes.ms ee ,e
- h66+*--N66 ,ase4 -
N.m==e.*he a>ew- M& B =-M . + e - N .ea a e,_e eaw- g g e e
-e.__ e_ . . _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ ._. . ..
l l f3 AC73VITY CCOES L/M s LETTER CR WENQ TC e TELEPHONE CALL INSP s 64SPECTION
,,. . . 1,No .N . . - E.1,.. re N .EP . o.c.. ... E. D !
OFFICIAL USE ONLY 00 NOT DISCLOSE /#1 Y - 1pc 3 ,
;~
OFFICIAL USE ONLY CASE CHRONOLOGY FILE Ngas3ER DATE OPENED OPENED SY 9 - 9 %-03g A c- a s - Er s Gotzs c. DATE ACTivlTY I- Ha-n sa_c : (A). Ih s.,s o'~. / Uue
- i 1 W . -tt - Vo ,t 3 e % C-,%c',noief-
i
! - 1 3 - l 'l l'C . We //a a m w~. to Os't) __.
I- V " JV Tc' LJlts'. 's > s s .) 'to L fu~slu D- t Tc ' ' R.6,,adt -fm w in. L e s _ ._ _
.2-t-84 'rc : N //iarn.L +, Vos s< , L L Lu /na,, L ajo,u ca.,hd wit \(c.4b
.2- s- a y n/wo: /%w Orc 4 Nco B -
- a f,,4ok a J- f4 Tc- Lo, t 1.Lu 4, / li..-l EA,4 J- s - as rc- PAM EAm-els b w . t l .' *,) ~
Q h 'l twt O'. Qht in w s'c u f k u ra dt R Ilo w _ O - b"- N *
.. m *TA MA//, .ua.ru (JJa$ c, fAly CW%
c? . 9-Y'l KrC . (1/> lit w o u , C.h4 C ./ y ThclO W . O - N* Y'$ Of70 ' W sfl'*3?rs1/*=*. Yct$$( _ ktfstrftl SA) __
,) 4 - b 'l 7~ f '. Yo se 5 < [+ Nt'ni _ [ g 2 f!rI),e
.o - Isr-s 't mn- c.x, ,,,sia - Juo .. ..
*L - ih5Y $11 tb : W/ll* Ysi" 4- Ni4 _ _ _ . , .. .. . . . .
y . 2J -N thTG ', W.//oN>f".44,46< '
$//.o C#<<N.*' -t _._
j * [t - W /*f?Cr*. Wr/$ Yrpr).* so Y 045 & $/W O/? Aft _ d. _. .. 2 '3 2 - L .sto '. Mfli$ nub ~* , 6 u< t "Tm fyty; der _..s. . . . A '*S ~ h W- NId' ' WJl11strJ.*** N A f.l * . Al - . './ CeN . _ . . . . _ . _ 3 .1s -R Tc wi%,~ # 6%, wet % + 4Ww. _ b ?.k. .$. N TD
- LA)LL$L M 14g..& $lC,-. Y $
L' 2-'
- tL ._ .M vu - LA.%lh A1o , .U !.*u < Co.s-~ tt~
ki t ~ b H N% L Mfle 2 QJe v--, UJ.dL4.- . b irsj # h ' M .- ... .- --
- g~e3k'd 7 - 6*'i( _c._ L__.lu. Utami_/-
.* .Ge# -I(u n 4 '.5j. -_
S& G - . ..hoc ((q - N'46.n' or C * $4!*/frlkerttu ~ 't w RosJ .e W.W. h.', ha0 $ N}?1 - 3 ~l* 4'l D.L VGA 5 c.,, Mtihrn w s .- '9- euej. .. h_' N " *$..*...
. 0U G.. b- Al$[f .. . . .
4- 3-m w rc _. w a e. ,,ea ., u;Pa re . ..{deu . - . . I f ." ~ D. b T.G .' .. . .' h. ' W 8 8 =#,_ O fifA
- b dM -
us-w mu- u> . H , s , . . s A ,+ 4 toss ACTIVITY :CCES L/M e .ETTER CR wtMO TC e TELEPHONE CALL INSP s INSPECTION WTO e wgTING .NV s .NVESTIG ATIJ N REP s AEPORT il$ut3 CFFICIAL USE CNLY 00 NOT DISCLOSE pg
0FFICIAL USE ONLY CASE CHRONOLOGY FILE Nuns 3ER DATE OPENED OPENED 3Y D if 3 - O W Len%; .ak (> L A ._2 OATE ACTIVITY
//-2 2-93 Tc ~ Willo,$,o C, -h Alleya _
l 1 - 2 3 -L1 "rc ? (AI.II. m s,> -h Liacles r r h . w ir3 (h n iE . G *Ladt +o ld I(iaMea e _. ._ i) .2 2 - 23 JNrs. : ks/Arr,. sos Vare A/49 e c k / / 7 /J' e) O !r A9 d-I/-29-93 47&5 h//A gm e.u bb.a. e //A. e-c N/ /__?_op - /2tb W ~l-i
.))-d 9 -fs'h 'TC
- 144/b.amees.* % A//*'9o'se J 2 2ne kl.o Il- ._
i 1 Y3 Mvro . wi \\ ia ,so-t J o ,, a A ti, e.e tf 2. dA/ro//' i tL f 3 N r e. '. M tt,2 i s. Dr fr 3 4, n a t, es es _2, d e d'A*//~ t t- i - 1A, w. - W .th m e V tie,,rc Atte)< < u% C-8<TL ~ WI%3 hars
- LO . t t aw. E t>e u 4 t e g s .c d 4 h i t 93 m .r . - tv . i t . -o , a vyo a n,s ,t a3 64 a
la-1-u ew r o - tu . \ t . a .'s , de ,rr, 4 iig , e d5 Sos r>2P ---
#1-V-S5 u r c. - w , t 1 2m r, -
Lk, .2 3 < Afi,o 4 ss 'i O '5 k - t 'l - t' - 9 & W T- e. L W ll, g t, - O o ,ts e_ 64 1f y .s. e4 8___ _ % gye-83 ')-fr 3 MT c, : us tI, L ,os , (je, y, i+ (, u es 6 L r.4. _ . __
/
l a - l'5 -9.} mre i A), t h , msg __d_c,1W *1.te,je/r__st6. 1 .dv. <t <2 ._
- i .2 - i 9e O N ', L W oN,VJillb me t# -I2-U _T_C_ 14ll //s N.c , :s 4. A I is.,rft ,e 17 ___ LK k.s_ _ _ _
t e "' 3 -f} 'l' C . '. D JsI/v ~ .ssy_ _ h as _I_ I .o p << cl ,V_ __ _ fos 4
- t-
_ L 1 . W P,5 rc. A O <$e[b u) < ? /, a_,,3 qa ._ __ tu q _ _ _ .____
.J.L -/ W PZ6L_-.W/II'm v ", h!ath<-
, A /I'Y' *749 Cbd%, W3 . _ .
. t 2. -tJ'-tr3 m re __lut//<.En, ~ ,, y'sters s+yse M 2 f~05 A '- t
.D*h%-EA .T 6
- WiU9m ,ok . - _"t e . . .T*' to f.'?"N
- 10 1% w
_l} .16 O
~T C_ .._ __ _v)_. _ t \. , o wn p ., h $,yk ep.r *
- sw.a. ys _ t_t _ _ . . h' L., . . . . . .
I S- M IktL w,thnch_tioax__sA__k_, beak <g te to .L4 w .s J .W. _ LQ bO'6 .tAf_1.1 (< % ,, . M oA,s c. .f. _ J~ t.bq_ .
.L f -E M hrr-G ' M .1ti.+mso.v-..UOArt r 1+ awl . Et b1.__ . .
r
! ' V "% L M 'I'_'l h [tuew t._ h t- 6tilu_) , b cde- b Md _. . . . . . . .
I - IJ -#" TC ' __ _ (Al t h M 8
- i % k.h3s ._ _
i ?_S tc.s ... .k.4Lham5.a A C K. e daeJ _ __ __ .... _ ACTivlTY CODES L/M a .ETTER *R
, WCMO TC TELEPHONE CALL INSP 14 S P EC TIO N v70 e wtETING INv s iN v t371G ATIJ N REP a AEPORT IS$ut0 0FFICIAL USE ONLY 00 NOT DISCLOSE ,
OFFICIAL USE ONLY CASE CHRONOLOGY PeLE muasSER QATE OPENED OPENED SY Q - f 3 - d is \C'M-G UOM OAfg ACTiv1TY 10-2t-93 tc. . w.w i cs ( Vo m - (le.E b , _. to -3s-t3 -t- c. '. w ti. w a tWW. La-St- h "Tr_ - r p (ti ro > d, N d a.rv6- _ _.__.. to - Al- Ec3 Yt. - tAMit we ae AA) & le -3 s - FA w &A + LAJdIt w sda _ ._ ._ t t 1 - kJ 't- e , W d\Mw %n Cs t a i a. __ i , , - r3 Tc - c, w % wa w;, . It. 1 - kJ TT ' L unIle w e a '% .Sweln< ar n I- 1 -V1 rt - Weth amron h L4lAru/ r1-t-l T'C : & wwalla Mn h (D //t 2 ced @was 5' v) 11-1-E'3 Tc ' LJ ii1. b ..s +-o 14mstd tj - Q - F 5 Tc' n/ . f 1, >$ r o 'r s G m2O _ _ . _ _ _ _ h 't - r3 Sc , vJ.a, _ w pn h-M> -T c ', a) t L .2 -oo ~ to _reng/(__.. _ . _
\\-3'D Thtb1 W\Ubdod foacAt. Suadidtt MSLO .
j 4- .. l l- M -10 1% TG ', LL),If.*msLu . (orQ.Lucfmn____.Sybl .sf. t .. _ . _ . .
!i' 4 -83 MT G_*, W l. w g_v,__6 m ih2.4,
/& y J , /*< 4 - o, tud
//- F-&3_ t e. ' W . i t . . ,,, co
- J J ,,,Els,4 _. . ..
II W TLv &saAs , ll-V-23 Tc: u % kmso._E w) 1o Aca for hua [d?? LuEsdsr v Dh.IK-21 Tc' W!EL&niod,.l/0*1c, Ma c/m a. - tI- f 5_%3 Tc. ' lA.h R.q m.oa _b _ 1 3 @ k._ _ .. _ . . . . _ . _ o s rct3_ T.? - u)A t a nv s 4. . _.h. _.fo . .E-o s s .__ . . _ . _ tu._tr<*) T t- 1 la b W o m 3e a _ ** A LA .g c. _ . . _ __ . _ _... .. . . _ u -sto 1.c ',_._MJ.&, 6 vs -b 0$MJ-t . . . _ . _
.it-t u > _T.t. - .t^h.ha m u a_a _lsm _R.o 5.5 -_
y -IG-U TC ' 6., _l/Mtpo U_ +v do tyc . . . . . . . _ . Il..~1.k43 T_C. ~ ___ L/o <t 3 c ~% __'Fs_4bA . ... . ..._ . ._.. II' I t'43 T 4.'_ f.l,off D W. TO .Uo re fe. _ .-_- _
//~u2 43 G_:._.?bdr*k!N ._b WdbamsN . . _ - - . . . . . _
ACTfvlTY CODES L/M e 6ETTER OR WEMO TC s TELEPHONE CALL INSP s IMSPECTION WTO e wETING 6NV a 4 NV E$TIG ATIJ N REP s REPORT i$$ut0 CFFICIAL USE CNLY DO NOT DISCLOSE
. _ _ S@L4.
.J . ,
e , S
, fy - ;
- m. u !
.j i m W . m y' .
3 , dl am av
?s l a& L w& ms aceawh 5 !i,re n tin 51 S J - b n Odiie h
~
/ lAh Wa .kca<m <r LA .
/htuhtIc h qi n d n y d tw CO W uj W ucd,
.a Ov.uh3 JLtetut1,u eil (wd pu
() i' d [w .ldx.dt litj .un d ! L, c m, 4 n e w cm s an3s. i
, , .bdb L I ['i'-+ ON ,' Ob'
) ,
,(U S k ,
Q\ \ , a ( D.*' I'1 M t's, u(( Y h' d d\Ml\d I,7,Q bbD
. s t , (, M O NA S ,
\ *
,h(4
\, .
( 9h'w'1C,% W . d @7Y-D 1,\ C~LduJ ,Q & /~601'm1 R-M
) A -
' Q ' GkWc'gA\ C1'@\ e,M.O's ),L' R t sl M (C s C [, O MI'LACX li 'h C-ss ~
- s. }. k .
\
l'(d_A.d ,0'i.co s d,. w n[a u 5,
' g tedt d L cm[v ,c.,d I G ,.
cT
-ut cuc L1 pew;cf'h.
huwdu SG1 ac 4 Hk cu$ cu lC( ,Q .t t [' 2..L E O .g, 'p0M .jp4#so ,,ctr48W fi l' ' / 2 Cttb).Q c.Q,rfi .Ah YW ' ]} /ee l.ha lo l mytlgm J an .naGL.li pam abbcla .M-P.n' ul .M 3 , x.z,m.- _ . ~ . . . . - _ _ _ . - -
3 , i
, i
, i gip c u m e y t d ;v. , a p e 5 ,;, y , e ,n' :.i 7 ': hw9 tin 2ducek cn a cbt/<OncY Ccd.itclui
. j) w u t u A aug %ds<y a ' uwuc + v
-)4Maubg u chu 7 .%y % cv W * & G'/ g ut 0ah h,, m$ i d ,
A Ya clad hd dsl 1 14 cm 1 9 m4 afu a cwa 17 i; ! p d L , o v ai d d a s i L (~ z b Oc k exa epQaha d)
=' '
- m9 osu&
. 7 Lpaynpw.- /m, A,at ; ) ! adyn a nAQ up& sawn l
Ia W uh.dx.4 ao
\ f c, m n % p z w : p q a d o 4 db u d i dua %d, bd a Al2w dcd /
cjx f 4 A u amo d rb,3 l .. ,
, h G: rn:9 m:Llucr ci:.c!p.,7]sI c>'
24 m. j.Cl.ebwcb
;. 'nsc/jla u :-4 0 iJ%c./ fin.-Cuttgu 3 q + L e ,n -
!CDT 1la$/ Y.~
.nm CD 4 pw f. w /w,cdm,
\ f
'. ! mw A ndtd wu J
'hy A.L ' .n n aut bxad)>M e{g..L 5 ,cudd k duply appm% g, 6 bes : 1 9 Pd,.If 1 =.7 [gg gg m.: ::. g ~ - y 3 gggggg
p ra-b 93-d 48/
,a d Sn1orv
' bx/A-9 ,y
.sk vr re(rz,,f ' , rrxM: 'rr m( z qnw p- u I % g ~m f- 77 r nk y.w e
,gy' > ; .k1 j '? ? ' ' ? y r ;;- Q ,' ^(')
rwre g, - n,y nmp p;y~ y2y2^/ mnvr^' t _p2r+, -c nl- g
, .,ypg?p f p 7 j 2 ?y h * ,c 7 c;7 T^q /
l 7Lg _)7ij
, ^
,Q720'T/' 'iW7 ^f* ,(
^
T)- i ~~P'f jnr 97=uu?Y .+o& vw pyy gy n? '??' eer wpp
, p e n a r c r]_,
^
by ,/= y Tp/h'2rC)7' b';?'2 Tvff
?)?2wm.'27'
~'
C
>,d gwp- ed of Q(Mm-,pw.,fy>'N n:r niml2d
' - \.
)'h! f f f') ^ ]O9 T(9}
27.+p ypvyp l ne:r -vapmp4r . r,w ; byyb ('enf;f~m%gp %j '>^!'ar2p ! pw ye>r rvE yy mty n g y n w n !) v o u k ;
'2' W ,W If 'WY:
39 nyvn~wz) f" Cw, Y '
p -.- - - - e 0 e h I i L /b' W ' l.<Y
! kod 2s sak. Ae hw.
pw s% Auk JW _po I df/ tan. jupdn Aioumdl f i i I
..fl.4V.viL- ' fT,(
I e e f w $ t i i e i
! I 1
s 4 s 1 e e"*' u EwaJ
h;f 9 CW 302 U.S huCLE tA CE GULATO2T Cowv'S1:04 CC INVESTIGATION STATUS RECORD e%5T RUCTIONS This bem se to to coensweted whenew sefant sci. tv has occuaso reistem to e csee or et neer. every 30 days H no eneage hos oceed durin6 the 30 de, reporting pee.od end.cate **Peo Chengr~ sa the aetwo tHoch Keep the o'epne; with the case file and send one copy to Meadoweriers. Offect of Investruons CAftGoa, Oe f ect Cist Nuutta 0 OPERATING RE ACTOm a skDiviDUAL LeCEN5f t 01 Atlanta Field Office 2-83-039 @ *'Es.'#CCWo'" v vtNOOm
= . .Af ta Ato.utt x OTuta An'chio To 5"' Alleged Cheating of QC Welding Inspectors E. L. Williamson Duke Power Company, Catawba Nuclear Plant ST ATUS isoeofy date, er'd omradr e knet deerretsont 10/28/83: Regional Administrator requested an investigation into allegations that an entire class of welding QC inspectors were provided copies and answers ,
to examinations in 1977. EDC 03/15/84. l 02/03/84: Interviews are being conducted in conjunction with Case No. 2-83-038. 2/6/84 No Change 3/3/84 No Change 4/2/84 No Change 4/28/84 field work complete. Draft report in write-up. 6/2/84 Draft report in write-up. 1
OFFICIAL USE CNLY MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE CONTINUGION SHEET TE II;FORI"_A110I. COi:TAII;iD EEIN WAS FE0VIDEL AS FEE FOIA S46 48 m I I j rior no. oart time pact or l OFFICIAL USE ONLY DO NOT DISCLOSE p. h 7
._.,,._.7,,.,..
- i b E .4 fia -
l
. . . \
' Company No 1
SS NO Name
*1 .
1 Last. .', first Middle - p 3 c.
..e
.n.a
.,v z . ... . .
...Ddte of. Employmend" J' ' N . '
. Date of Birth -
.-g - . " '- ..
.,v Y.' .:: .; . . .y..u,. . - ,
.y,
~.ch;gege .. ' >:. !,3's ?u'.y*, .,. .,... : > ,
\n,9 7,y , nat, .
- .
- y ;,~
t ..t
.. 4 ' .. . . ,:a
, ;. . .._ . . -. :. g. r.,; -e
.c ..e.
i ,. .- . ' t
. . :., . . . : - . m. .: C .'" ' . . '
? >+
.n. .
' . m e.s , Na m. . + : ~: ,.:. . :. u . s 7. w .. ~ .c?
- 1 . - - . .
.... . . . . . . , . .c .
s .
-} ,E ,-[. .). ":'.:..." .1. ' ' ' ls L; O .
k'islf.,',: . .
,'f,r.*...M,?..:':.?u:$}..:'a."Rv.,f'.k:%.)!@.Tl.."*. !s'k.? fcf6;h.. .,'I h!.'.,
..r.. ... s .
i <:.;;; *. .
;. -. . .c,o. ~
i r. , w.
, ' ,. ., j . + . .:: r- . .vf.r,:.
n<.t.a.%..e . :::e . S A1. A:.RY .,,:. 3"~. ., . ..'.s. g 3 . a : , . ..: -.. ,
. . . - t. ...% r
. : , .m
. cr.n. . . . .
c.1 . .::.. ;.
. - . . .e
... .f , .-
., '.a v.
, ' ' .,.::. . .. ,. v .. ;s? . ..6 .8
.g. .
- x. :7. w. 4.g' '.
^
;' * . .Amt o ..
* .r , . .. . .
- ..~.. .....
~ Dite ' Increase
.." Salary i
. {. .ocition. .
, . Basis 1 '
- ' - 4: n' .
.E.W!,
~ (,. , . :. . .'. : .. ' .. ;
\.i". ,'. .n..- . 1 . ..;.'.%.,.:. yl.f.N.M.
. , -c .. .. . ,- . . e. ,.. i t, . a , . ,.,,~.;.:,._,- .. w. .
.a
.. .r.- . . . .
... .. e, v.... .;
.,~,.,....,.,;..,. ,s..
- ,. ...~.~:... 3 .
-ny ...,.,s.-
., n, : .y: s.
~. ..- .. .
_, s. , , ;;,;;. l..
~
,u
.a . , .;:.i.y.,'y ; .
- "J.
, ; : ..:.,n. .,,.t
..,...s.. 3 ,,
. .v,. ..f .
. . . . . ,. y, .
. . .. , ... . ..r,
- ...r.~.. .'.,-
... f.;:4", :l" .: *. m...; ,,:. a. .1.'.*; .. .,7.; .; . .. f.;.,
...{
. '. ! ': .. W..v,, :s.2 1,:
..n t. A..:l'..!Q, . : . . ., , .. >.... .. . . ., ; ,
..+ .. . a., ;,. t;; .$..aw:,....n. s... -: . .,.. . . . .
.<.....,,.s,.
.,: x .. n. .
9.... h.n. a ., . v,q . ,..:m. . . ,e.
. u, wy
.n .m,. .
.w .
;ifO
',.; :' :. i..:.g, 9Q9; .) =Wy.- y .": . : 2 >.
.. ...a...., a...~.,.,..~.... :,. - - .w . ..
..n w ,.
.s, ..., +. . .
..a,......... .c. ...
, n
. . , p . ... . , .. g g .;
;. : ...u... ..:
go, . s..;sm., n: s s '.,'n. v. ; m.n
.?.; .
.n,*q.. ,.m%,. .* '&q .: - w;:;,;g0. ..
"r:y ,, y ...:.
- s . . . .~ .
. ( ,c s'
a
.. .....y, .
,, , . . : . ., . n . . .
s.. .f $
.. ', .3
.r s .
, ,., . L. .. . ,
. . . . I. . .
. :,. .,..n.
. f . . . . ..i, ,
. * . s' : . .,... :,' >
,'Y:g,,,,*.y.4*',y',
M:, ,, , , 4 . ;- - 1.'.'.',,.*.3. . .;; ' a,9. AY.
. ) '.
,' . . . :. y M. *.- ' 's . . .
' I .*r>,.' .. .. - , . , . .. .
. .t !. . - ';- ..h : . : ~l.1 . lC,.)*. ..A . .. ; = - '
,.p..3.- ..~.
; a. . j s.: ,. : e' --
. v
. . . \
=.
~
O
~
6% l . .. . , .
;~ _
1-I
A -
~-
~
4
* * , l
. ;; o ~q )
N yl . * * ' ~ f* t
, p 'z ,e '* , * * ,*
g, s's . _o , /, f , c.s 2 u . . . 310 Je s :.'Cr
/ /
T* t : :./ :::>. A ):7 s g):c.,
!l'( / h.d /7 ?/ / $ '. $
$/ffS a* u.o:e j<w p.w ors. 4. hw o.; 6e
,l:42 ,sD *}'2297:' }2fc AJIli"If 6At^. fig'eb . 7.< utt u '
& %=t G?n:o /D <upcLOJav Diu%79.u.a zic .
U
$nga.-t /G'i's . ].xD C1'y'?2tO.t*d it L~ .Zr.,r'2 (00 )
a x,cco m .aa<u . b w ~ d..zi y u x .. s-u l
/7.'oC 42&g .7D A< f/ CM A ,Cd.d.'t6LL- h t guou;,ccinoAt4,Cl.t... 7.vi J aza ti. y l ,tn a'o & z .i n u :o a. soy .my a ,p:wx l tz.c Wi r.- t%w - t;as .
V a x <~. k ~d.6 a e.- ec.:, maw, aw
-lh'sA.) 2. :::tDxL- AJCLL. b$4 $ . cin.u-, ja;.A' h g ...
@ # $4 1
} ns. C c,J L : r a p / a t :A7 6 62. f tA ~', .j i's t2 ,4:
. :i u b & . su .tr x<.sw.li piu:A .N 2:l re.Ay '
f
\
&<o 2gw.) eumpz wt Azt , zu u. au
. 77'u 's22.r;g , /7;J/_1. " < ,$D ,E/ Q fE> s .b f .4ot .t:C?xeJ
($5/7 E !}
- 8/,WA .l'.*Y,C . Lift % ',b / . f.4.lL-)
g2s i.n :<4cw czz xn/:J. ss.n des b41/ anu
; w ( [fa 1! ,'.),%'-.k'. -!N*[4r.& .
LiCl ' $tI- C't' 3'h^ bC/hw s v 9 JJ ... f X 2i>g;
!l /0$ W ~k )- l .' !* [/d !, w 0 g .n '.$.' ,_.
/ U $ / 7~.% 3{ '
2 s*. $ / , s /' Y~l v c&* A' + - /
,$l,? /J. L/4 , ,/4d M.M' .b.* ** .$ */ ).J . . . b 'l.L x 2.=. . J c'.c/L'<<.- x./t,.G /,ar ga af/:
SA W$o*' ' $b^ A /7:<'d M. (fll/$ l'>**b 0 0.'b JU' D o t/r: c e n ;'c t. A u x A u u .2/ < s y cp % C
<%e x .e Jxp u s 2ia. .w.nu; y C/10/ Z ./J!l WG 4:= d2- S/',.LZL l' ACIl"<- ,
Ay
, i I )~ M I ur. -
A,-
,, .i. . . . .- . . . . .. . .... ./. . . .-
~
( ; .k,
*::.= - ? .. . . c a . />'I .. :.~. i.. & :.= .-).. m- ,
6.'::ng , .-: j >y .Zto J.e 7:.< /* . .= ,6 .*t.'A ?^ ' A i
.U;i ,onct. . . . tuo A e s,e c<'t..'1 2Ai-;O ' w ^ I l
.sr M .rj u /ca.:.t. . .
i
&E h t's ht/f ?* J $- a A hk. h, h(OA'AU
~4 tuso a'ang /. meg,, & . . . s e is 4tz;'.ctd' w
.f)?tg 5 jsu cz't>>y .st: y & ... J. gi.a' .fdu i 4 w teazi <?7:u .t4 20 irr9 g 4 , & /7atss )
(Laa L . csp. ,mtZ g'o7)u /.r72e., .ts.,cj. :or/7MSgrJ4-L '
.e.).o .wJ.- p, .&<.ezad .Ade zM .hycz. ec . . . 1Je)
.me :xe< 6- zushum , >'. v/n'JD
. . .\
$O <l *)* 05 *** h .a O '$.- $U
@pz?dsmx n=r.1 f:td /as .srx,ck. a.o, .zJL-
/* .Z. ~
f : f :' 6 97~.c . . .
.l.C ivi n;,cla a ,; a+=' .a ct /. 062CM/J w , b. s sJul/Am ... )w u f=? w.z 124 r al v
[c2///A ,,dm ,,,f. . gyg,"j g( ,Z/,'jo /_ED . p r <
\ ,@ N hvf.-< ^
so*=A- .ds.1/.f2<. , W.Lif. g/W- 4.. LC / '
.:. . i
\ &*7MA % </C.4'O , ,a;;;VIG f / l,YCf-j /214~ Y/tifu n sC s CAlclat. / <d fr:.t<< th& p.26ttL-Q s h n v ~ .sc.s & A 4.s sa3 s<.wwm ,ce d ,, C h d <7 5 / t2$'?(I':}'s.f-.f,<,44 A / .A* ' '
6<.J@ds.) 222 of pacy ppu.
.sime c.c ys.n, ew1wr~ umo
!Alb, --
' t ?YC'L' /5' li^ h 7.5.bo$tT*3 4':%lal4v' o- Ar & nrxb- eu.s'tI Au is ./tJd.m
./ D<, ./.:c;,s ' n <'.2s <7:A' 1
& s'u.l ,477.M'"1. ZC /Z?d. J2 . la.!* l
J .ca:4 .4<u gu!x' Athq ) M9 ' p/ v-d
'A76 ,
, l
. I s.
/
.=. '
',;'c1 Lc'. l. :. 7
, ' ' l-
.... .'-.' .t { .-
. &'4 4f,SaWel5A'C ha'a f,c'Af 8 /bh. A! Oi &f<., u*l c7
' c/- W +.42/siusa!a/,/f;Ns- fo#k6,/h2?du
' ~
. <~s 2:</ s,y u&64 (ssx Asn AG
- 64/.j/ef>.A A.~c, ,)944axddik .< k ;Fea.A/,a.
ss. .aa,4W# /i M'd> Ay au.sha fa e-t n
. & de7 CLA A (l. -
ff
#&<d L. A su ,arfdsa94 a svA.eds 'A e l % ssVM - As AsoAxpsox<de w A, dA'/Ada A d4 Ai/
Wiaeseasty/-/2-sa mAisxMia fn 64ddtgja)
~
;d A
h0 ? A Nf ^ A
,6uh s;pouaa A cM 7 69 d,s.cauddue d tme n xxinep'suAGaspaG swA, cs< 90s&,yk,iW'edx/gwyaGdapw
, mad ,
csced I sredath. are fack.,4~ar~eds1 - 9 A02 # , C /d /2/2 20 d/U ?S,02
$ b l l< A C
.drdsw so/aan A pa'&,Aa6. ,
k ul g b
. . . . .e. . : e
. c:.;.;. ;.: :.. .:
. . aa.& <dclerh ., .# em.::/A d4dw
' ~
.M.;....
4 sv.<s.et.fsLeAd .
.sidy(c./ msw/A ad,e-:k/ e a<A/ada'
-a esv/dtu aWxamtl'A,44.!dtwJaac x /ueraadL' MSS J/C /
,-e $$ Sf,/2&
3/SS kW AbdeWsAshlI4 ii w n & A a'/ q wud< enha d o. ll! .,4ussa'sasu awMh' r/m,Adb sea'
;( At <<a e62atw& sh n . dy .sA a p
? hW65# fW
~
l ' Axzh>xiea ,dx A A aad ? hf AA 8WAN/ /d/-YG d<- gy.m/?b-add ,ess&L ,7- 3 /- [ c - /2 5' I ?
,f/lJa i fMtdl dr7A/dlW14Cf -l' AffdrM.)b~ - t A6
\ sx.e aa%w.rso 44,//sdbr~ .! j 1 WA,M 76ut'sda s.Aadabr /w ehz l 0"$ 0 Nbf ? A S l/)[ $!/ hhY $ t
.l .h & ,y'g4cck/f,,rs/.ddf sa Ade/;c54$i
/A Ai - e--w~ . x .
9 e . *
- O
.c-I - / .e . . .. . C .-
. u A :',; : - ~-
~a *
.. ..~
- l. . . 3. . . s;;~,}-
f'*f
.R.[$4 ,--d{
p"A ,.
- _ f'}8dd4 et se,mtAjiddadD A t . .
Wooadey <Ax'2 y2bs l.. & sp
~
b . ei
. ll)
[ l l f/f f 0
' l.
ei. S 48A. S 9 e
.9 .
L
2
) i l .
- f. 4" s ,
y's s. a's ~ ! . .- s s ,, - t '. . . .* . is.
;* *'.j s.' t. %- r~ d *. '.* W- ' ES- / .v.'.$" d s' - O * Y 0
fu ,sr w 4 t +1/$ .x w ?C C .I N /.*t fll tb'd
,! & . f g sf /dx ,ee.-MJ d << ./ax f<y.<y
.asex .ty p aw,x .t-y ,4s .s~J~
h,.g 4% ac.a ud.Zs a sy .sAa. x eZJ fu. <<.L<.hru .<JA d& Aw -.i .zasy l ydd
.dy ./a~ud A e ea el 4 . s/t/n f- . K
<4. xstay A m% .2d h esesy.e l
.xymp> A a:&& 4d ,a, wad.eA su-pa.wat ena ep/ ./g ,wai.a. . .
ana p a s o,.xA .:a. s ut m<ue:p .eL
't.!d LE y /.~,atf% ) .<.J.vdA && x L<24 X CI5 Au my .y-!- a,aa k x >4 ,WS.Jj.x< c<da.J g 4.4 .<x.:Ls& ,M -q w.pur~<.:, /d:n Jan duLax ,! r ,.u w y b h ;h .,u g <. o .
m at L w % ,xe .4 4 csv s;..y z,n & 44 sla /6.<.pum. .J1 .a w .de 44 %
.k,& es. cu/1 gau,- ~ dud .y .M. ,-c e.-J k /k ;lfd M .-l b d a ,,c.a-/t~ , ~f
-s.<,cau : ~ .4tx ms .4 deAz 4 e<Lt~
$J l'+) /c ~ ~.A / & ,,s a / L
' a<,. A a-d d W mm. M& wx + & :.JA A( An&E6 sten Cel~ . 4:14w ,a. .Mw ML .t--L - .u<c~ a '.:u cJ~< .-Ged
.<.t- .<w'.4A '
~~ A&- Q,< +$.7,c.c&.ud .:/
da- s 4 s a w sa ,1. , s & , u u
' a<ul 1s /
) &&-z~ .-,.;xd .
~~ -
S j i , , ._
4 Y' .'
- '. . . . . . .~ ; ..
..< . t. ,.,..a. .~ .i . - % ,
,: Al .< . 'su. . A . . .,, < f k 4 .:.m..i ~ of . ., . . . .
o se s u .n* nea--w .: d.i /< uu. w eda /d 1.j sl .Lx l 4 Uilt y ./q&J. .:' /<. sJaw
. .<Ji a. ~ l .a ye- o M Q wg a'</<eb. d /<J s'
./ J 2 / b .< J.< a . C4c/d ss<<- 20 Co .4 4 .a.4 ~
Cu/8 l<p.r~ k. ) .d<d A &.~s8d. .Ay xpa - S , s.).t. .k.,n~ fi.Sy /<< ==ud 4 s b~ .d<-
. .a'd ej/.
y?C 4 I c ' yw& <> .eu. .h M 6. .<J N l .<. s1./Edd ( $ <* 0 /;{ . /.u..a A<E. /,$<x.x Of . // Adec Sk.:ak vf Act a & h /4 4 , . h d e t.- AL .a7+I .A .ddM.7 ( O O Asas - ,y 7 r. .r*. a .J-dml .<<.r J.c&.u ad ts.yd/1<l n / . -rs . .4 l'ai 6 ,,c a L L. s /l :s da. acus, st L f / w r.s I
'? .<J.w -A Cs ,4LL .A< u < <f s.4. s.r e< s< .J.sr .
q' .) La . y . M & q eL2. y s<. m .<r: , d a .~- ; A. <.a d 4 wp44 .d u. szaw / s v. w CM 2-y my A y~ <**<
- A C/ Led b t<L Q d4 dxw Jid h~ c.<.-pf<4d & c:da<<.,A c . 6<<y rn d wwl 4 d4 el , A& twd 4wf .~< c f44 A't. .<s a~.A /~ .-A su-% J sJn
.<d 24 .J l.4$ k .y'.$a y 0r ;9~
s (*.,.*d . % .b < DC d * .<~i.<1 l' . lad s. Ma g .<Q
, b CA el .<JR dkl ad sgn Ale m ./r/ *:4' . ,
e?L sk js<-c r.u:. L'.<. c-,,at. w .<.6 .<Je<d
.<u'w C.*r-p /< 4 1 N - l .< J. w od , f!L 4
4 .$ .$' Z , A6. funi 1 ~de 2 w.u. sd M. d 4. I f4 . 2 4 <& >st w:u. cQ m A \\ A pn - a w as i , ~+
$ h . .c.l 284. ss sY A A M dk*
m ) , ll _
i e.'* s e? / r 's ; .<f < ,a .zy 4' ,, ea . . ./. . p > . . .~k. l
.2d was ,24/A,, G k. .'? I . / S A $ J.y"U.Y f,lf.
./-t <uf 24 . A A st/J 4~ tj ,' s.s.z..,un w
/414 sdf 4 .cus .uA<<-
.<JJa._ sJ.</AQ a~
/4 m/r5 .<J.<u. sej-ul syd. 4 .24d r--
A4y sJ.<sL /e. /,J/f w/nlSy #~- a d-s.J . .54. s.al <J.al A- .<J<M'y &
./.<p.2~ .<a'n l o~. J.4. sJM AGl d><<. "<'
un,cAfx . 24 .<,04<.rL< s~ sc!= d'ar Ja J J l dad o r g < u s ie /nsu& M .2 <J.w
.f w <.pcl A ,<4. aw aZS q' .s< sr.,::<<-wwJ
.<Jw pa .:~ A' iC s% y as;~ y .M.
'd eg . Mal .<J w s2 e. v ta1 . ./ J 4 Q . .t.-~. ~ ~r--
EQ J pu w bat! .uy::Ls.~ A s:A~ -l , l-- 4 aCl A pd uy 4,c~d / i
.f .,a- < - ~ . ;L 2:4 4 +,yl dw G~ A-f wg ./v, sc.:< .r ,. - .~ 4 l-~ s.4 c./d t.y
.1 s-? w ci&te. e,.,O.xw e~Au. s vd <<.
;l d -
'jaL4 y Z.uak. r~. /4 64 J~ /&st
.-ut .~;ns.,& ad u a.tg 4 s p . a , p d ~ g
<<< p<dda 4 se Ak QA' fpLt 6A UA.dQ . /~ <a.%.- .a u. c.- W sJ =4u
.<<> .1 <ex y y - s.) a. Ud .
n -
/. % '
. -s'y .]-y n J ./
^
p.. O Np A+& hA t 1 I l 1 l s j F n ; ;. J
e 9
#' $ O U L* ~ 'N ^ C ,OACdCrd ' ,
j h i_.a g A T d oe t mfce_4 i t u { A lo.o i%gx , A c1% c4deWL : O Lau Aus . T te. mwx. i edeen b 's .s l Mot c_.l o o -A k e. & e4ce F we.c.V Dd- ! M lugu$<_e-O % 4 kE f 2ccess h et.t f b it$ov. p,.a tlc ms a A h_..a 'Is" e e tLe y .st-
@lcecbu.ee L.-Soo , ftte acjaph 5 o2. spec 1P-IdD $dade s j -l-LLf) (LLL ~~5uLUM L,0
/>" ou e Ac k 6ies oc d/e g e ,',a t
[lu:.u.Se rasc crem p_,.u+ m a . .u i f %ca c et im L , AL Eql.~t c la c.cs e e , e w) ,t
%.7%
u padicJoe i~e.ien+ m a ca-DE D CCLs-s $1/iX0a. 8 4 ,l A.i c, J i n , E L.~ lwo.s qaesJhaco ps 40 HE impockers oF 44is Alow 0 car-ccm<~$14 6 % .Lt~45 Qw in.auden -lo Dsejaco +.Ls lQ-1A lad l M&ou2i QL dD+ ,'-v Uw Ed 1 uE
~
QL1tui L lcm +Le c rd a.s lempm 6 _ +Le pens.n,lwaacu
#e paoA ,
ms M 4 Le e yom /y i linvolocs ew+icz gewp ' bF Lispc_ Ace _s. G kc4- we e
&ain1
;Lua a u tu cm i
s p s t r. m 7 e A19 RdCYEWNEDi -
4 1 I i fCf m a.ructo e A,ewd-'. O llof k Affc-El s l Lake 4 +kk 6 s o\ a.k' e ~ occu.en afcra .D lb me , ,u u .. & c s h o i A ." cs i iwE iacuc3 c_rf_Ar-4 40 c let,u.
-+Lr p
m det A g(totess .spcen:,a dw
' sera ie i& L_^ 6 c~LL c_oby 6eea 05bdcoP yoe" Do uE sl- L co E O c c72_ 4 kF.
'h t u_ a d-( b het d.c+ & kpfc,'.,7%ua_e. g lTEL-+
Cb *G IN & S lNwepy ip lc alc . j O_ ALL , Sis.\ en -4o no +LE 4 A. ++ QE fD6%ieL a
, !Ecs+ ' o th C _c L 4 .
g . iBu_* i Bec.cm es. G w_ y De me.J4 (Joe l Du_ Ir. aDE no 25wfpsd , & qt clwd na $
!I rwa. Mess
- u. d. 'm
'l e n-l I
i i e
~
f) { & k *~4 % . .LY N' T AA -%- l _gl) J st1 LinNA Cn e u h """ ' e w~ 9 ) toe #s I. t ' i
.L
^
} . ., {
. cy
,/ - J An coa c ern ed psont suppo F -+h e q. c . 4'epp rimeu f An s nf Cn /pula Aluc lek Sk/an.
}l0 a c om e Q. A. depne ks ar & does s o f recog n, re ic h n + @ pr oceolu <es say pao.,d-AIC2 s . %-lSnys Unf A' C T s w 'll As s~r;+/e n ,+Ae~ r~f w;t L recelu e. ss er,'plivu Jee i f u n t e d. ~3~ f ao f u n l . d' it w.tL s e.
}{c p+ O *J $;Ler I ? Sh ey won Y L e Y 4 5 we,4e cer+n;a A C't. s o ~rvset,,les o P q. d.
pr ocedu re s ,ulh a w : L. l $NDW w b e$2' ik l 5 0 Alid or su o+ . T A nv e. A n cl pro h tem g efl; q ^l CZ s s?9 a c ql 1 y yp e e m w n -m o ~ /- hernasc'/Aey 5p y i f i s- a s-f sprab L em. Atr f ec A v.'c s L. o npp o s +- 3 ro y sSoutd de / e, in , w e w h e fAa - Eht a p i a s t, x o r ov a + . q C N e ps i /.'c u /p
\ cmc e.a r' < w Aea Z ~nscattc.d Ao e is f* ' A- Al 3 1 v.sast ;~ yec+ron o ~ in . s c e a s ~ e n-,
v s /-o e & U *A n- f is s s s p fe Ly r e taf e d . 7~A e w e /o/ u., s s-0 5'. o n4 ')~h er c w it s a a Yrneend;li'ly * ~ lA e s lec L , 7 w a s -fo t'd Jy wqe msk ~ o -t- t o NCE i4 hec n n. se c r n F4 sAid if uns 'f h e l c orre c 4 moderi s L - TA s ** .s i A doie c $ vre M ohs oP Q . A . p r o ce ol u r e s . T ndso w a u l o' L Ne i 4-o K'anw wh y 54 5 o sse- s ' 'In n lo o u r us e h A u e 4 e A nve- w pf a es s
-lo 3 e+ .s o in e + 4 . .a g p ro s eef
.. I
.f !
-f o upper na as ~g emed oc e e n sh u c 4 a c e., de-S /> o u / o/* N o Y dnu e loAnoe w;4~ess w -h o y e.4- .
so ru el h a y p r oved . 5 f +Ae domppay does a cl-haoe a ay for/4 ier wad we s ny , +^ e y s ho uld y e.d ei d afaLL o f g .S . L'u'A y doe.5- oue > Fo re a, n o naa seseca no -oa + cit u s -+ o up o a c or Sn .* a Its sp e cdr o n . "I'^ e a a 4i9 A fee we e /{ L A-/ c r c oin e A,9c./d' ppd 5 sq y .s L Ac k' s P.s o y .s- 7ou nce f. a d ~g -t o na c4 w,oug. o.~'e weeg fe we,4e De +Aey -f e & L u. s 4-In s o a cend-s la 1 + e ,, , s e d + A es e eseeA' l A} e r. -f e / L u s -/ e s lop w r t'll og @ - / n 's-becpase ;-fis loo /c'sa 3 A4 d o a co a .rle a c'lso a .
-/ A e 5e.
.}-f % . peop de preavo+ g oiu g +ogo by S.A. p r o c edu,e3 .-fA e y s4 e gL d g c.,L ,;g ,_p fsep, T -f h , a It' 4he m a n s ,J g e m o u f j a Q A . depp,-lin ed de&L
,4.
<s a ff e c-/ e d 77 g < e e + "b y c o a s / r ~ c 4i o u deps ,4 Feceu s e if c o ~ v fr a e froov ^ns a de a d /, n e 1 es s oin e +h i a g +Ac y w: Li y e -+ 14 o ~ L *, s e s ,i e w ay o, }he ofAer h +A /a N -fA e Gl A deparire.e/--
has & A s of o ud L oor b ec a u s e_ -fd e yp e., l m a a n g o n a u-t- ia Q. A . wo w i+ te+ -t^ e ;- sp ec-l ors-do -lac ic Oob c : a ^ +- 7^ c y s e + as ao J u s-+ ah a4 4A ey waaf u s +odo. 7^ ey s Ay o u r 1' '
) ob ;S n o t &S i m c e, r +pa f i +0 day a s if w as l yesie,dny. Ye + # we g e.+ 'm o , e p, e c e du r e s pa4 os as o v ery dm . We h as a a l o f mo re C on + ,, c lio%
[ 84 proc e du r e s +odoy I A s ,,. x Ard ny ese as o.
- ,a
. ,/ u .-
. ~.
._ N
~ - /
) /^ 2e / EAcJ- c_.
/5
& N s 'C M 7 -
o . / kJ, M.: ~ n ,.-
'o r ;
> V V' b r ~ "m' 0A /< c. ) . Dr ii ' C .a . V~ b .)( i ;? <_
/: V"/: /ui 2 D e t'.),
v
\J U
*,,f t'/~
- /' / 3 <'],
s' !.
- '. ' ] .
.*'.) ~
' /- 5, - - *-
e x. .; : . ,. , 1 5~.- E.b lJ 5' r: ' ) -' .,J < a~ 'T . -- p ,- , r i <.
,v._ :: : .. .*
rJ C oa. . c. sl./cI'.3 (;- o i ^T'/- e :' /i / C I '~ y c 7' Q .s ; .:f- / : i. M Codceet5 / i .m r- c. : /C o /J c .%'/r'
'To 9 0 e- ..>
. 3 .t. #c:d/o7 T ese en ~T 5 ft cc_e-;T ~i c _ .s u_;/e's. c D N( g.,
*J kh,
. /' M i -= .** e p_ w~s rc % - e ;- tv- v . ,3 g p.t 3 ii , c. -
\
m .- % d-N f . m l -- , -
/,,.) h \
. ' ~
3 tes *w ' ( C. < C e1,s b rd 3 0 /d { r S. ' O' . % ng L . l'i . 6 J
.s / -
C.'. < C / 5 , *, b (y ( )-( [iCfd -SO ld C' R .- C. f- Q 'T' W % ( , B . '/ I- f_ V #_t3 C C ! Q, NN O c. C 'e c #- 7 e c -4 h,p.t3 IA 'i 9 e /A Q ._ ( __
%e
- w q s .
' ' f- } f
C. L .
% C t .-~ f t '\ bkq E ~% [',' A ":: /N .If) <
# 1 #
*i
, . ' - - ;/' - e' '
Y Afl l C L/C &f b / /T !C $. lb hY Q? , r' h r ? 't~.% , f
,D C / D \
-ON *w ( .^
s [~ C C
- C 1 .
f"" C 'O b .' b $ (* 4='-
\ _
== % y i\ N ' \ D [* b f
- f e# ".
s ,
-' b .b *E f(O " ) w (.,. S %= O ."" k % ,
(b l 's._, - kC- ~./ % % s-
&,sw-aaja m n/y - .o ~
~
j g
/ ~~ ' .JE q#b Z ./ CyY $6 f.' -s' &. '
4ufdp, .6 Ay~ .ad cauct.ds w' Fapare m 0.& 9 4 6xt~ M aJ16At
& p U' ./ .ea% twe air
'RaauutAum.fLLa,oda A rr i
~I exawb.oA.iratarw;Add '
JAe.ydass ..- dl
.zYZ
?d d f' g'u2& w2%. '
pura&x', doaux/spo ta Q h o 7x.o' z e e / sp sFamorau. zat : i
-upyau/A&s.
,0 3$ ster.<%.th fww,AftMr-wAerae ~
N* -ef dxc,sAs/dm.u,AJ_, t aa 4 .Mi 1s a a r. ] fa c'a w l fdus d;aato mow / e 'eastanofue Jancily da r.d /dl~s iAunt nA .s*J~aikawner .d4 en,t aed /n .* Se!-lace
.6 A Aadi Anu 6xpagr , .
\
8 X ).. \ G e 7t e :r a. ls s-f ,s $ f/yer maxafencxr ages rdseem. fa ajad edAr., insplechts ws4 sur .sfgh/yuajkJisas, Wu'. 8]c}l.5 ad Mrs.jec7 D?t. he ShdemeXf ?M4S ba Gu//;s b a is thJ /he;Aw of my k#a i.usjndrs, a$cA pesex/ hispechts are wer-7ad:b/ . and /hdpyk s# /he .sArd could be LaJ '
;4 4 our jod.s.
3 .
.Tx a. meeba wi%4 4.1 . , sa l- 7-n , 4 e g ais.sinded u, N J-uil.[p, A s,d u,, frust Ain,76)I a,s ys .
_. a..p p=.vv4n
,uy+~.. .
.- ~- -
u v a n //i 7tfb xof jusfily or corted /ccision.s he or M dc /bu} arc ip coAc,etcc u.i%i r'Ac Sh frece/ ares or feh9n drawitj .reguire mexds' . QC xe/Any bs deen ins /rucle/ Jy .l.a.D.v
~ lare .&lr3, o
,/ 110Ad~
concer>c /o Ne7 chredions den..(Z/ has been yGen. en. a Q xddf I l Qc Naf navy q-/4 ress/dbxs do .nd' od/re.ss /he i .by&h/prol/ent.
.s or ress/ve Jhe prodlem aAh 6e inlexf p?our QAprof70711.
4 . 1. D. *' C. L 8 Ja ae s/a/ed BJJ irp.,/ of dW, rJNou Ijibs h mari dechions as/{* /jenrerb'/nce 74 gAw,yA Me = de p c. &s u b in accor S. decisionshen mNaac ;<c versal d&ec/ans ney 4 prou/aas.xd a/a>ays acc wad /> y/cr/s de re.spx.sMYy Mem.
- n.,A :
L2.D. nc//Acc/ Mc Sc sc//h)ino inspcdsrs, a/ sac 7nisc. .skelwe
}ixe, /Aa/ Hey were orer-imod ere Adk because an/ Q4 pesce sey w/ans. Z/ywere ac we/A /heeA.Le'craffk A &case h
.cLu// 4: acceph/. BQ whn He sucA as, ucid rep:nmeds, Hey 7ttc cme asJ 9
&x/ Acrepanele and wed . sizes .s4ANj i leng/h fo skor/ (
exAr (awry., L'7)p L.E/). s')Sie/ -k pJace ne fa responsis;/,Q <>pon Ne inc)nders andissue T rio/a/irxs % -Nexc. 4 . 7Ered's 7>w/c la we/dky inspdas, by cra/f - whl/e prArmi-nj Neir arsipel clalies luwe ruf been proper /g, hax/k/ Jy aype noaynted h pickef /Jeir peyk La lahre. jscihnh . /clia kren Ay our aper-
- ~
?
.s .~v .v .
u ,_
.o pr msnoyn<ed je/ S of worb ,,oosa A,Ae/,eacou, ny&/ Neir appe maso .
weld %y ipspecb,s A 7 xdiens Neir.run in/e ,; . .r
\.suppch 6i'cee air He cra#skan a//ihde auf /,o, ems /rocficx i /rexce w
,our upper nianagemex}.
es:
~
o dder, Kwa</ ked, /1,cJened /o pesh we OMa.
\
(sea ()/ fold aJkr refecliaj A s ue//is axor/sace
\ pnprocedere us,/Ad4)hes cocounbrsais wi/hocc.urte safered M
era /kmea Ld/t & sHaJbx.areisaaprfpn of' ag/ecshna/ wxet. a/so rcmixdc/ me BJ cra// Aos cae k 4,4 ou
- oestsions, complainix ahd we. Z Aaec Aus/
$ '. \aws /A rienc/g a// of craNf)comploix/.s abm/ pn hem b aA'ere desi/y 4
\.shm from me hanxy Ne A,w yrax, ud /deg come h 1.2..D ip bye-
/L Je wi// have we le mur /kri/ia my jib.
a) CroN foremos, M2e /3razeH, caeseJ nc So, 6en;,3 as ASME li/-u,p dain ip acc.ordoace wy/; (M prxedures M-4 / J/4(f"'EL&. Tiu xcurrence was reparkd fu J.D., bd 7.o 1%&kaQalle achox asar kha by 4:n-to f cyaesa.\ ka:n. -Ab ve j,3 % as 4ke. lact
&3 ke. k e., ke w.u.te see h a NA I unu.W '
I be temoved Stom 4ke. Au.4 bk. . [' .i
.Zn laNiedin9 f-/As we/d;m inspedsrs lave lea
- /irech/, A/ Ney nus/ a,/4a c. A. 8. h teeks 4-as prior /v sekurinj a seria/ xxmser Sor Nex -
.. , f y -:9 1 U W Y w :1ww -
X}
. ~.. .:
1 cko sd frd b\5 direcNow b ix. o.cc. orb 0cc. . toIW. he. 'vntewY oE QR procedWe-Q-12 h.2., re.o. Sp. 5-5, T < o c.e Au c, Q-\ regu'wes &cd o.n.q .ms ,iw&4ek b irreeve o. sesed. sambe.r, a3N 3 k % sw% w.gh. voided.
. ,1. R. B . c J. c .R,6. Loe. wA ke.w bbaisg -Wes.c QA l j
' ' brequhem.-ds, Sor c.94er reoitussg o. Q-4 , o.es %g do l wd kd ik sbd koe. kee isYded , neg 8.istad We_ ,
' 3& r14
) g- m. wha ' o_ se.ek\ saber. Q- t , h S) reu 8 .
1 w.p.4 imass,s n kw iwracht as- h ,u i ' direchkns b era /f p:riod f~ aver, Me &x;%s ik/ ke. ( ben f isex h esaff, are -xd Bise direcks /WwuM h is ad estrec);
'y omWN as ixspdor b pcce,of scueN4 /k Ads %cBoxs &f hxpine le.raf/qc comunaaNous,
{- Jucrease ,oraducGify, ana sues ZLEc Rwer rouxMss Mousads of dd/ars each doy adga-s auxenkedse
.7xognizeJ. Id Ares a c c a G , - / i s s p :- A c 4J you.
Le xcu> b bc as/c h do Mis a.ud .r Ae/ Nd are a Jea peopk is aper-maaymer./ who recoprhe. Hris, JJ aser f w/ wex/ k gire. be inspchts recopJHon.
.decause M e h is p c h t 61 ecomplubed .seddixy yd /s, l u e c , ,,, ,,
-,e un a, ,, a
.cred,Y f,or,. , as ac,
\
codiwuc. ho k p(ar_ed oO [ddl4*owa.k res:powsibi\ifies _) %_ wcAdig us.eechts ,_smca. a_s zo t- as . - -[. l . l So b , L . A n s, , 6 3 %uy h N% o r. C L ies $ 4 4 5 k we km uwdde b @9 e. psM hecks 3
'+
& v Air decisio,ts Rd were mde- ouMde. h 44
- i. pro v a p de b es ad Nx Ar accis;oss A+ sw i
- s. 9mppsti 6 Rpw ect&M iwspeckers.
a un. w u. n. vgww - g r . k\so, L td& ku asteA e[b p asid< w3 spec:he, d;s.tepcg issues b eip Re3 de. 3
\ dea ,aga
- b sWt ecue.
i-s s2. e se #
,e 9
a
=G e
e hem 6 d
~5, .-?#
w O
_. 1 ;.._ y_ 'p
- ,'fy-- v
, _.l
_ 7:_' d'
.5 y ec.ik i c s !
.}
.I6 -. w, ma :
b eg be hk or<. re_iu.ttecrk\g signwg h Q-M 3 3 l j sgesicS 4\d usg'I.a.ton.s owr.-iwsyt.tMag 4% c
~J. N % toe.1&s bg c.varls A\d c.o .\d. u 5x
%d be seew uAW. We. ese abe., i
\ "j, toev e. , i9 h c9'tse vt i ios'tcpUElco.wY- (C. d ~ h
'us1W cr e - L.sc%eetwedh .
T:e m. - Q-l A S.;stci.rde d tonbu4. a. se.,4a.l. wa.m.ber . N Q-LR u>a.s presmkee 4. L.V.D. kor Miieu) add. f processi9g, tcoo\0ly.g toelSig solS. pd a.cd koreip 3 cakm'twa.-43 io % toele yu. ad h dsutd cq>pavaece r ok N tock K . Q- ik WCt.5 %d Sty'tediz.ed .Dr prve.c55ed. J. L. L. b .'s u y\c. w a % w w a.s b d ooig a. parHcA peu.
- >cQ is rep ved c.e& sioce. a. QtJl. pe6d-inn. he.s ben. wcqu.irce , he is u pow no.
14e m. -Ells 14 L.R.D. u;oulcl u>t ace.pt sci covcer n:tw$ A uc \id:% acc0 c.6.urg e4 e pacJ. pebdios g we3dy sgyn.W1 (< w N*d ,alAA.I wa.s a A b show % ;e % e AW .s C. A L.t, n.m D, .4.2.s' AA- %,s i.co.s wk aw o.cce.pbbk p sgmbi be u.se . Ahv. b bs3 agerocach
.- k m. x % iss e Le reu3 rote. A Q-IA aod 6.a wo -b sip - H .
e o
ny y s oc % p.-. e;_f c' elpeci//cs : S&PL - Q-/A /,*scarded .phbdhn of A'-5lCh3 f $/ strsb f 4.1. b. was apionade)wM. a Q-a, encemixy
/ a. Ax+/ v4aa/ m misc dec/Z n<ade whca
- Mc akeid was nd Wcd;Aed:n aaor/nce ,
uwi u-r/cns. Leo ku,a% m exaJ
~~
t
.O' hs/rach} me sv} staNwy ,od Me fraua4W/y ~,\ *i o x. N e m a lcri d a d Nis h xze . .
A Q-in ux.s iW&a,4 Sr arc. shw eresed om b be kh leN- b3 ee. h6ccivs.~L Q-IA receb. y shha k sq ke_ ac .s+rtes ;a oo.r wwAde e we.l1 areas. ooJA kuc h be remvel, A Aus m sult presee m & (.,d- hkc, Cv;ot. cu pes sd Jc' 34% - No vadects s6id,s kh 055 Crw. u)Clh5 (W d ll .25"f.26 y f 4u vaak sheils asu we m<c MJ m L T4.- 4 ct As. , bJr Mr wwts ur.re wd og h Werkk. q fy_bc c_ Q- M usa.s i.6 htej , c_0_6 u3c.s emdach6 0, uN L a cabhJ QA b.L sqpet owd as o. resu.R it as desdel 44 Se cNt bw ,wu e cat sw h h u3etaers'chec6ls Som N pEsc co-drA e kac 4L, wdan s%c.i(. % wt, La. I-L) , 31m bh58 yes%4 resobb cLA&ge wekk ud u
-+ 14.c1. es, o3Abw b. 4.
[ ecb s4eWis. L. Q-IR addressed ocQ % edS ciAc.bs , LJ wt % . p s h ex & wede/s C' sGL .
w' ';^ m- V H
- 4.l y .. , ..1
=qo
=-
hs - stz , su.9 4 su.6 uv. ,4 ;w u c tlH L.it.B., N % p u e .) crdt o.d er s W 9 quesmuJbab*t,0monga.mealybsim 3 3
')' hspech, b3 emd-iw %d W swdl cleedts
. d s% bppee a.mq L. e es of R. Wfi-pss iwsigw.;3 cme; m,e %d1 shl/
\aSer.s u3er e.
~
kaoe caLej 4Le cr#: Ao grN1 O. ycossue o_cwe. w'iduc but b u>i4h. Lo lemhle h>n;6; '
' Gem sch 92 9/
e. 0 gfk, Jtc.nt<t/ wra a>iAAada w. b<en indhko@ h Ach,c MJ Desip& l D'3 y> areas s>0 Ne rion- coxArsi;xy aid /s are ru/ Q 7taclev saA/j-re4hol, ahu af /da be o/
,Me ./ez, Mey aa.
Yin.- Que.r//o?xd/< %CZ~re.sc/dbr:. - ?fGE9295 J/-Ma x0/ 7xard/ 7b iskak ox seesxpa lx f-9B a7:/ fle. f-M AsJ -xs AI aprdure.y/>f neso/uhbr:. Ar rd c6,/y sAu.' iw'er./o/ @ pryw. Z/ex- Q-/A kca<4/wik no se<:J# -yueAoxJa heck
? & A/a
.remsud areaaseMerl skncus' p)ed af vicwJ
\
D.' 7%' we//ct.s skneid are rui' ~/J+<y on /ene,s. - ca L s.me d si us. 9w .1Vem- XcZ'/998 yuedo7 table .msoldiox.
,) /4 ey rusf 4gr0 accephJ/c as it (p/ g.w)
D .
? l
mwp. cw vu ns.yv. j . & q ,u;u : i Sbm' h*r/hx of XCZ reso/wNox.- 1(CZs /4 S W a' J N N-%& 'dehf
. . p irsed ja #< L,!'!?.sAde-c, a.4cre Ji/4/
,* bVVs// /C / i DA) $ .s lbINeEe.s'iZe4)Ybeffe?L
~ ~
Al-UJ . 7 [ ,e ks cm seurd 7x-es issuoJ siace / Air .resotJisn. MJ des xo/ kn de. p s4:e shurt . he .erm,r4 is/ s /#Kis-2/
.Z/~m -nccu,acy i0 f/4 resolad'ird s4/eMen/r '
'f 7tcf /4ar3 wa.s uv%k Ar -- emsis de.
700/ p.ss as/hi /diy }ase x4//k , css /aGa e40cJ #em s/9Wyuges. pg :s a 4 .sNeucg/ I. .2I4x u e. ,/rs n M i d r u c h x s (ysinn)
)y$V nyu,*,csa. 340 "A//e/ a.+ Me enA i / Ane.
D f heaces,, hawcer de 6foi;d e.sa4 z ,,, ,na j/< g ,,,g, 9 a,dioxlsspixt), de Ayre / s;,eg g/ ceg cfire.cfe/nc h sip Mest-of // dey, awe e,lcd, Ihn- cpe>/9mh4 7xtreso/uksx-AG is Miwd 6n icfaced WI /6lbM p%)e s Wow wL ud/ is aca,cAu 9 . \q ne gyizy an/t dis s as is . Jhn- Q-tA di: scar &J (g-ui)
-M-UA, Ar aMs arca , rig nrGu) re.ywh/ a. -
b./ J li'ml gEaa/ $c Aux 0 dd D' 6 a/y lo.ra.A//e/ weld,//de ollai:e//da,h value cin%
/7/ eru
- C,X& d:rcarbol7xy Q-// anddrede/me h '
~ a//sw we/Eng kc4 h c.orncf Mic Asc/eiarm,
}. j
a.d f- ' t!.A 0W~Ik9" w ' G' sq: Neni- c7&fer/i07ta}k 7ttZ.resolalio7t- ( 14G //,534, s~gd- N aje/#ny oi> hash /c o/ 9 9\ od-psr, whi/c de dsigr. c6wi-ng require) vetoig l ;
/px /k roof-ouh
~
Zem-I pcsfisxa/>k vio/a% ,/ g4 -c.A.a WJdx3 acrost /Anjer of beamt has been prei//nO ; by }M/dinf hA..suppef a. sir.9 te C/221aG - [ 9.. ? ly. -c a- tqiS tI rev. s - pH- ivos1 sa=Non 14. .
/?nrt - quoficnbk &cisioxr
- h wel/ KA&7-//(gf), QC kun/ ffJMc 90 N/
;I hs d 34 specs. 07 it'. 448. J.> de/ h p ~
-xde or. ble 7n.its .aad /s acce,o/ if. (H-a?)
D*
$<m.- v.iar ixus:p/de 0.a4x An/MwJf ls ad/ /-37(x 'd, '-n 9, ni % CR/3 i/sfruelef -inc N ecc40/ fle weld,xt 4/M .
Z'eni- Wcld 4/.5-2(Mir) wes dax/ h k a;ef/c}ddum AN'/}C X A
,"'s apa// rd a//sw a q-in /s be indiakf,U d/~/ &
cra// welof one hp file ,orewan wej/r. s-ir- ri D
. .17c7rt- Ap)ok at rod o/ Au//-cupbxg accephd &per di recfue Prm Cb1, beause oh no pia'dhe.t is ne G4 &crJger..) 7 'o-r/
q, . 9 g zr-ea,,ig gca . han.s.,ni,x
- areceire ushnJ, Intel stag tw us./ c.ucroxJ&c, 9 y asd an sh/A'et exsishcl m.,d4 4' "lvdispdior ic/d ne h y a h2 ad urHe N-+
~
wol eraJ/ biris.< n s t-f r/
;JVf M [ 7 Ud dpg.k.i : }
D<- l Q- /# reso/dkn Gz,zis) sL&J HJ /wd.s ws is accepkb/e adwe procetr cn//o' < e7u;r<J 9 1.b -,0dsun 44e used /n /4 usf 7-t?-1/
* ~
.Z/ enc:ftMa,.237 reso/uhbn a//ows d<Ach infaba 43 h he accepkA/e, because s/27 0' y f?4 procedure 470 cr/% tie. .
X/rnr : %nspd 6'xx s /r.un iks/Je a- e/ow 6 pye /ss) D ^A N 3 ?' ~3) " " '!NN by 3' A"Y' ' # "I "f Z/m : Q-le 1.1,m s44) aJ a>ct/ixy sah,A aape,y <ame.
- 9 ,s% h accep 6Ak .
Cr2 AA st '/ s-1. pam sys; )
\
//fI Wd IN1N2.-M Cc r-pr' (0Q S /- 0% NC too(- side A c k h c.pprn . - 7 ' k & cp ed oi-p ; pe. . I k.B bd M 1 ca.dd nw.k e_ c< naiqD g&D h. 4binspechw dme 6 accecy;6Hi , c.. R.. A . i n s b 4 4 nu Lo s.i p - 004 44 ed ) .
.%
- Q-/A 15,028 4/ by CAR a.ido said Itc ha) w prob /em u'ill Mc >sd posj, where I, ku, k
D .\*( JL, W a'ek c/cd 4p -'wg .e/ces.c s /vx/, o o/ a A<v/- Yy$ 3 d veld pic/'ik . 14x: Au QA pricex spect. kee been suised /= .1M a' / cJbaxed mdrei / may be octad ai
;~ s/,in/c a so< 0/axy /Latess. I Ael' /k/
, /his erited hs been maA a/MsJ LJa
~
A{e e7xpbye5 in/tre.sN 17i ?r&/. Accaux Oa.:fer'<f et
) Me wa.kr is n/cr A;oh u .- c. i. u -.." pescuee
,,,, A J-/asxd Me use/4, j
%.> "tc & ca A g e -
, l' - 1
_ /w
.* s y-
. v I'-
J~m5 :i I
, j f OY & N O
- b/
/b// cen beam. einba/4A p $
- O 9
e e 9 9 (. ,i 6 e emuum d'.'. s 9
.: . l
> cuk cf bt%*<-,[ g ~ ~z E A. h,c J pa .ar- .x in ja ew !
gla Q c52 wic Q oa.o . A~t&A ok !
,o m qp & c~ c0 A Dia'. J' M OM L Edd m JkDL f maA & .27% A + m M gw
& b afoao
% (~ w& &..xcm A.
ca 6 9 .s. fLc-cyo V ~ g sA l g.2 % ,a~2 r h zGy A d- pag , fp rx .4&e La pq na~'A.Lg J y' , . 4 2 2 . & g & .,cf . A A E n.c.x. 2C f *r . e' Afr ! Y .x DA Ep'a A . sum -e m .% (& wa-
~
O l-a -e po 7ter. r A . p p2try.f~L.-G.M. M cah D/-49 ,Jc4*A & JAd ' 7- M 7e - q~ . m. m c Q 42M
.-i'Xe. gx .% c.cz e.'t ZC. Q & xe- A
- 26. g LC cfOa& X 7t.c. x, w. me QQ aJcy o4 m 0~2 g%. A we 42.2 X pr e -r2 y n g2 au c x J , 6 x m -n.c.r.
Q<Rx J.&, a b g ]e i-a. z4 R c.r. o~ A~is ., x N M mcy A r m - ~ L b d >ic S pG L od L. 1 5- l d cqw 4 A .2 A a. M 'd ' y c& f) h or @ k, zh && au -me a. L . J & dag , d mch A . s~2 x NN* A41 '# ks; gg5- ' f f
..' .c (ch' s oar zfcs y s~ w- at r.
0-ne q EA (4 was ca g2rwf A~1rl y iMAo oM-w .A 4 M gc-p. J m .xt2 p.A L,: _
}* .40 .62- ~~ im A '~ .x s z&. J abo
% k n cg . 4 .fi m9s- 4 R ( *z; E J A .S x t w h a- p p , J a.ol A zc. cl e
.g4 X cx-c e .. a. - &c. &
Q. J G'f%e.AL q w& .An<. c5 . zC~ a .J+a. J y 8~L wA n n. c.7 99, J os D ny gx .x w .r ~~u-lg 0 48~Q Wni-- ,n n. J La. K2 A.1 an .<d.t .c (aa ~ J M Lc u.e. w~ n2 x M - a,o n..e .r. .'s at- cu k. a wif el a- m &a w Q <Lyuu -ar eam n vit 4 -z @ .nz y zt. L . Js Lo 2~ \
&fM -n g
- ino,~ f _, A .R p &~ eky
& ,& J vrq . A c+ -
b, c~$ . vale J u 4,y rQ A q Jgu s .pJ <.>.:x 6
,J p .Ah J M , -n n as % _
25 & n "2 t-l - E ge~m ., ., .24z- d R w.
.x a- g p a z:'e , - A -
c a.<A g % gn X on M-M (W TON 27t p.2% k -~ a zt. cG
- 7 - o, e.zb%.
I' , l 9.e. .Aw<. 4% gm .AO ( & nial O~. ,I A -< ys'dD af e O L M A , f g cm. A pA , A4 mf Jeff -t O a'l~4 .2br .Ae w % X 1;~c4 a._ ,
- - - - - n - .
g
;* u-
.f n .4 4 4 Ao .)aa M wwa2 A*~.ALsDJ k An 1. c z. J . J g ~ J >.e 4 L e, n a k2~ g Us<. m& L 24. #/ so b c/m an. dg<A dryuk , 247 c/ /Jr ALL.2% $
cha. st J2 .A%< sc.~ -n.c..r.e.Q.
. 3 4 , & w M ou 5<~ 0 m 25 & A. , w.in a. St-8,wJh
-) rw n.c.z. M . cJa..J a ] ~ l z + s e .x n . L c.a a L n e if , w 'z w - a e r r -
a- w44 01& Q an QL c- y
.ZAX A< % .Ld) & a J & w - L.6-, M vn a - c 6 ~ d . A c. necAo .W , & AA A '
gw L aAn .2L. O m Ar i & R OJA nuxA.exDf.x n n p s .xx w w h n s A M 6<. n ., c. E. d a l w . Oga CaX~ es oas H. k
i f ! 1,c_. _ 1.
.4
. i
-W I
h/PL- f'Ah* fl Yk 8 kW2 cary Aw xuvro r -; c/ n W./~~ Wls -Sc .e.cira4 p:.~dk s J oc'od R m D & w p l Q<A mr.ro e - /. J4 - r 1 a/~x & ~ f & P W A g <hf d I'& - cA Mpm M r
.*~A % MMerep s ~ s ' o , a e J d s r n 9 , &,A d<
e d.a ct v>.&~a n W m .
$4 e-4 A dy A w & , J ,. /
d'ym&m Mr A R h .s.a H/ M w = f24-a~/ m. Dks n
$p&%~ w n ~ :Ls n
>7- VY MAsmy '
dw2.4r~ S 4. {pnad eg'Z4 &gg u wa pn w am.
%p dm &ZA &
A M k M e2F' c '# / f~ ~
. syn - my & ~ 1 L
i # 4 ../d d l i s A61
. 2-% P}}