IR 05000400/2008301: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Adams
{{Adams
| number = ML082200269
| number = ML082200101
| issue date = 08/07/2008
| issue date = 08/07/2008
| title = March 05000400-08-301 Exam Administrative Documents
| title = March 05000400-08-301 Exam Draft In-Plant Job Performance Measures
| author name =  
| author name =  
| author affiliation = - No Known Affiliation
| author affiliation = NRC/RGN-II
| addressee name =  
| addressee name =  
| addressee affiliation = NRC/RGN-II
| addressee affiliation =  
| docket = 05000400
| docket = 05000400
| license number =  
| license number =  
Line 12: Line 12:
| case reference number = 50-400/08-301
| case reference number = 50-400/08-301
| document type = License-Operator, Part 55 Examination Related Material
| document type = License-Operator, Part 55 Examination Related Material
| page count = 76
| page count = 116
}}
}}


Line 18: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:,.., fI1GE: rs 2WBJ-30 t}11l-l!L:_1f-c2 trO 8 ADMINISTRATIVE DOCUMENTS(YellowPaper)ExamPreparationChecklist ES-201-1ExamOutlineQualityChecklist ES-201-2/ Security Agreement(s)
{{#Wiki_filter:Final Submittal (Blue Paper)
ES-201-3/TopicsOutline(Final)
DRAFT IN-PLANT JPMS
ES-301-11 A:OperatingTestQualityCheckSheetScenarioQualityCheckSheet ES-301-4/TransientandEventChecklist ES-301-o/CompetenciesChecklist ES-301-a/ExamQualityCheckSheet ES-401-6/XWrittenExam Review Worksheet ES-401-9ExamGradingQualityChecklist ES-403-1/'CheckSheet ES-501-1 XFacilitySubmittal Letters/-i-dl t')-t9 8 11-c9 CJ-cQ L7Z>.rr ES-201,Rev.9E Examination Preparation ChecklistFormES-201-1Facility:Harris2008-301ExaminationPreparedBy:DatesofExamination:
/::1/9 fi? 12/.s, oL t>lJ 8 - 3LJ I
Facility3/10-14andXX/2008 NRC Written I Operating TestWritten/OperatingTest Target Chief Date*TaskDescription (Reference)
;tJ. A- LC-t( c:2 CTO 8
Examiner's Initials-1801.Examination administration date confirmed(C.1.a;C.2.aandb)
8/2007-1202.NRC examinersandfacility contact assigned(C.1.d;C.2.e)
10/XXl2008-1203.Facility contactbriefedonsecurityandother requirements (C.2.c)10/XXl2008-120 4.Corporate notificationlettersent(C.2.d)
10/XXl2008
[-90][5.Referencematerialdue(C.1.e;C.3.c; Attachment 2)]01/07/2008{-75}6.Integratedexaminationoutline(s)due,includingFormsES-201-2,ES-201-3, 12/17/2007ES-301-1,ES-301-2,ES-301-5,ES-D-1 Is,ES-401-1/2,ES-401-3,andES-401-4,as applicable(C.1.eandf;C.3.d)
{-70}{7.Examination outline(s)reviewedbyNRCand feedbackprovidedtofacility 01/09/2008 licensee(C.2.h;C.3.e)}{-45}8.Proposed examinations (including written, walk-throughJPMs,and scenarios, as applicable), supporting documentation (including Forms 01/07/2008ES-301-3,ES-301-4,ES-301-5,ES-301-6,andES-401-6),andreference materialsdue(C.1.e,f,gandh:C.3.d)
-30 9.Preliminary license applications(NRCForm398 1s)due (C.1.1;C.2.g;02/08/2008 ES-202)-1410.Finallicense applicationsdueandFormES-201-4prepared (C.1.1;C.2.i;02/25/2008 ES-202)-14 11.Examination approvedbyNRC supervisorforfacilitylicenseereview(C.2.h;C.3.f)
-14 12.Examinationsreviewedwithfacility licensee(C.1.j;C.2.fandh:C.3.g)-713.Written examinations and operating tests approvedbyNRC supervisor(C.2.i;C.3.h)
-7 14.Final applicationsreviewed;1or2 (if>10)applicationsauditedtoconfirm qualifications
/eligibility; and examinationapprovalandwaiverletterssent (C.2.i;Attachment4;ES-202,C.2.e;ES-204)-715.Proctoring/written exam administration guidelines reviewedwithfacility licensee (C.3.k)-716.Approved scenarios, job performance measures, and questions distributedtoNRC examiners (C.3.i)*Targetdatesare generallybasedon facility-prepared examinationsandarekeyedtothe examination date identifiedinthe corporate notificationletter.Theyareforplanning purposesandmaybeadjustedonacasebasisin coordinationwiththefacilitylicensee.[Appliesonly]{Doesnotapply}to examinations preparedbytheNRC.


ES-201 Examination Outline Quality Checklist Form ES-201-2 FacHit: HarrisDateofExamination:
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.: 001010H404 Task Title: Perform the local actions for a JPM No.: 2008 NRC i dropped rod recovery (AOP-001)
3/10/2008 Author Facility Reviewer ("')NRC Chief Examiner (#)NRC Supervisorc.Assesswhetherthe outlineover..emphasizesany systems,evolutions,orgeneric topics.Date Z/ZkJ/O'?Initials Task DescriptionPrinte.d I
KIA Reference: APE003 AA1.02 (3.6/3.4)
To},,, b?t e;....
Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
..Checkforduplicationand overlapamongexamsections.
Facility Evaluator:  Date:
Method of testing:
Simulated Performance: x  Actual Performance:
Classroom  Simulator Plant X READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.


Determine ifthereareenoughdifferentoutlinestotestthe projectednumberandmixof applicants and ensurethatnoitems are duplicatedonsubsequentdays.
Initial Conditions: * The unit was at 50% power when Control Bank "0" control rod H2 droppe * The crew is performing AOP-001, MALFUNCTION OF ROD CONTROL AND INDICATION SYSTEM, and is preparing to retrieve the control rod.


Check the entire examforbalanceofcoverage.EnsurethatKIA importanceratings(except for plant-specific priorities)
Task Standard: Field actions correctly support rod retrieval and restore system to normal operation.
are atleast2.5.Assesswhethertheexamfitstheappropriatejoblevel(ROorSRO).


Assesswhetherthe 10CFR 55.41/43and55.45 sampling is appropriate.
Required Materials: Keys for any locked cabinet(s).


Assess whetherplant..specificpriorities(includingPRAandIPEinsights)
General References: AOP-001, MALFUNCTION OF ROD CONTROL AND INDICATION SYSTEM, Revision 29 Handout:  AOP-001, Section 3.1 Initiating Cue: The USCO has assigned you to perform the local actions associated with the retrieval of the dropped rod. Perform AOP-001 - Steps 3.1.13, 3.1.14, 3.1.15, and 3.17. The control room will perform Step 3.1.16 (logging Step Counter readings) while you are performing the designated steps. Report completion of the steps to the control room and then standby for further direction.
are covered intheappropriateexamsection.


C.Tothe extent possible Iassesswhethertheoutline(s)conform(s)withthe qualitative andquantitativecriteriaspecified onFormES..301-4anddescribed inAppendixD.a.Verifythatsystemswalk-throuqh outlinemeetsthecriteriaspecifiedonFormES
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0    NUREG 1021, Revision 9
..301..2:(1)theouUine(s)contain(s)therequirednumberofcontrolroom and in-plant tasks, distributedamongthesafetyfunctionsasspecifiedonthe form (2)taskrepetitionfromthelasttwoNRCexaminationsis within the Hmits specified ontheform,(3)*notasksare dupHcatedfromthe applicants)audittest(s}
(4)the number of alternate path, low-power, emergencyandRCAtasksmeetthecriteriaontheform.


b.Assesswhetherthere are enoughscenariosets (and spares)totesttheprojected numberandmixof applicants in accordance with the expected crew composition and rotation schedule withoutcompromisingexam integrity; andensurethateachapplicantcanbetestedusingat leastonenewor significantlymodifiedscenario,thatnoscenariosare duplicatedfromtheapplicants'audittest(s),andscenarios wiB not berepeatedonsubsequentdays.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Time Critical Task: No Validation Time: 22 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


b.Verifythattheadministrative outlinemeetsthe criteria specified on FormES-301-1:(1)thetasksare distributed among the topics asspecifiedon the form(2)at leastonetask isnewor significantly modified (3)nomorethanonetaskisrepeatedfromthelasttwoNRClicensingexaminationsa.UsingFormES..verifythattheproposed scenariosetscover therequirednumber ofnormalevolutions,instrument andcomponentfailures
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
, technicalspecifications,and major transients.


b.Assess whether the outline was systematically and randomly prepared in accordance with SectionD.1ofES..401andwhetherall KiA categories are appropriately sampled.d.Assesswhetherthe justifications for deselectedorrejectedKiAstatementsare appropriate.a.Verifythatthe outline(s)
Appendix C  Page 4 of 12  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
fit(s)the appropriate model per ES-401.c.4.a.G b.E N c.E d, R A e.L f.S I M U L A T o R 2.3.1.W I T W R I T T E N ltem b.c.d.a.NOTE:#Independent NRC reviewer initial items in Column He", chief examiner concurrence required.NUREG-1021,Revision9 ES-201ExaminationOutlineQuality ChecklistFormES-201-2Facilit: HarrisDateof Examination:
START TIME:
3/10/2008 Initials Printdme I Signature Task Description Determine if there are enough different outlines to test the projected number and mix of applicants and ensure that no items are duplicated on subsequent days.Check the entire exam for balance of coverage.Ensure that KIA importance ratings (except for plant-specific priorities)areat least 2.5.Check for duplication and overlap among exam sections.Assess whether the 10CFR 55.41/43 and 55.45 sampling is appropriate.
AOP-001, 3.13 Performance Step: 1 Reviews procedur Standard:  * Reviews applicable steps and obtains or discusses obtaining key(s) for Control Rod Disconnect Switch Bo * Proceeds to Control Rod Disconnect Switch Bo Evaluator Cue: Provide key. Ensure applicant informs control room if any alarmed cabinet will be opene Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Assess whether plant-specific priorities (including PRAandIPE insights)are covered in the appropriate exam section.Assess whether the examfitsthe appropriatejoblevel (RO or SRO).c.Assess whether the outline over-emphasizes any systems, evolutions, or generic topics.a.Using Form ES-301-5, verify that the proposed scenario sets cover the required number of normal evolutions, instrument and component failures, technical specifications, and major transients.
Appendix C  Page 5 of 12  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.14 Performance Step: 2 POSITION lift coil disconnect switches for rods IN THE AFFECTED BANK as follows:
  * Dropped rod - ROD CONNECTED (down)
  * All other rods - ROD DISCONNECTED (up)
.y Standard: Locates rod disconnect cabinet and unlocks cabine Points out and simulates placing the disconnect switches in the UP position for CBD Group 1 and Group 2 rods:
  * B8
  * H14
  * P8
  * F6
  * F10
  * K10
  * K6 and leaves H2 in the DOWN positio Evaluator Cue: Provide switch position feedback as each operation is simulate Comment: Critical to move only the desired ro AOP-001, 3.1.15 Performance Step: 3 RECORD the Pulse-To-Analog (PIA) converter reading for the affected bank:
  * Bank - - -
  * PIA Reading _
Standard: * Locates the PIA converter and opens the cabinet
  * Points out position for Control Bank D and logs 165 steps Evaluator Cue: Control Bank "0" is reading 165 step Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


a.Verify that the outline(s)fit(s)the appropriate model per ES-401.b.Assess whether the outline was systematically and randomly prepared in accordance with SectionD.1ofES-401and whetherallKIA categories are appropriately sampled.d.Assess whether the justifications for deselected or rejected KIA statements are appropriate.c.Tothe extent possible, assess whether the outline(s)
Appendix C  Page 6 of 12  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.17 Performance Step: 4 RECORD the Master Cycler light status (LIT/NOT LIT) on Card A105:
conform(s)withthe qualitative and quantitative criteria specified on Form ES-301-4 and described in Appendix D.b.Assess whetherthere are enough scenario sets (and spares)to test the projected number and mix of applicants in accordancewiththe expected crew composition and rotation schedule without compromising exam integrity; and ensure that each applicantcanbe testedusingatleastonenewor significantly modified scenario, that no scenarios are duplicatedfromthe applicants'
  * Top light
audit test(s), and scenarioswillnotbe repeated on subsequent days.a.Verify that systems walk-through outline meets the criteria specifiedonForm ES-301-2:(1)the outline(s)
  * Middle light
contain(s)
  * Bottom light Standard: * Locates Card A 105 in Logic Cabine * Logs
the required number of control room and in-plant tasks, distributed among the safety functions as specifiedontheform (2)task repetitionfromthelasttwoNRC examinations is withinthelimits specified ontheform,(3)*no tasks are duplicatedfromthe applicants'
  * TOP: NOT LIT
audit test(s)(4)the number of alternate path, low-power, emergencyandRCA tasks meet the criteriaontheform.
  * MIDDLE: LIT
  * BOTTOM: NOT LIT Evaluator Cue: A105 lights "As Found":
  * TOP: NOT LIT
  * MIDDLE: LIT
  * BOTTOM: NOT LIT Comment:
Performance Step: 5 Report completion of steps to Control Roo Standard: Reports Steps 3.13, 3.14, 3.15 and 3.17 completed to Control Roo Evaluator Cue: * Acknowledge repor * After the report is made: Time compression is being used to report recovery of the dropped rod. The control room has informed you that the dropped rod is recovered and has directed you to perform Steps 3.1.25 and 3.1.2 Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


b.Verify that the administrative outline meets the criteria specifiedonForm ES-301-1:(1)the tasks are distributed among the topics as specifiedontheform(2)at least one taskisnewor significantly modified(3)no morethanone task is repeatedfromthelasttwoNRC licensing examinations 2.1.S I M U L A T o R 3.c.4.a.G b.E N c.E d.R A e.L f.W R I T T E N W/T Item a.Author b.Facility Reviewer (*)c.NRC Chief Examiner (#)d.NRC Supervisor b*II-------t-----------------------------------+---+--
Appendix C  Page 7 of 12  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001,3.1.25-Y Performance Step: 6 Repeatedly PRESS the "Master Cycler +1" button as needed to produce the following light status on Card A 105:
NOTE:#Independent NRC reviewer initial items in Column"c", chief examiner concurrence required.NUREG-1021, Revision 9 DR From: To: Date: Subject:MarkBatesGerardLaska 12/11/20072:42:30PMRe:HarrisOutline commentsPerourdiscussiononthephone,youmaysignformepertelecon.Ihavereadyourcommentsandagreethattheyare satisfactoryforsendingtothelicensee.MarkA.BatesSeniorOperationsEngineerUSNRC-RegionIIOperationsBranch 404-562-4612
  * Top light - LIT
>>>GerardLaska 12/11/20072:32PM>>>Mark/Malcolm,attachedaremy commentsontheoutlinesthatHarrissubmitted.Overalltheyappeartobeacceptable.IhaveseveralquestionsthatIamgoingtoaskregardingmethodof developmentoftheoriginaloutline,andselectionof replacementK/As.Iwillcall J.Daltonthisafternoonwiththisinformation.Thanks,Gerry.GerryLaskaSeniorOperations Examiner 404-562-4626 lis 2002NRC 1.Pre-Examination-z; P CANT ATJ'AC:HMENT
  * Middle light - NOT LIT
  * Bottom light - LIT Standard: * Locates Card A 105 and Master Cycler +1 Pushbutton in the Logic Cabine * Presses +1 Pushbutton 3 times to achieve desired light pattern. (-Y)
Evaluator Cue: A105 lights "As Found":
  * TOP: NOT LIT
  * MIDDLE: LIT
  * BOTTOM: NOT LIT A105 lights "After 1st Push":
  * TOP: NOT LIT
  * MIDDLE: LIT
  * BOTTOM: LIT A105 lights "After 2nd Push":
  * TOP: LIT
  * MIDDLE: NOT LIT
  * BOTTOM: NOT LIT A105 lights "After 3rd Push":
  * TOP: LIT
  * MIDDLE: NOT LIT
  * BOTTOM: LIT Comment: Critical to set the circuit for the desired operation.


I L c.F)(A-{Y)EXAMINATION SECURITY AGREEMENT Sac.U(L,T'/
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
AdR E..E(Y)E.rJl'" I acknowledgethatIhave acquired specialized knowledgeabouttheNRClicensing examinations scheduledforthe period indicatedbelowas ofthedate ofmysignature.IagreethatIwillnot knowinglydivulgeany informationaboutthese examinationstoany personswhohavenotbeen authorizedbytheNRC chiefexaminer.I understandthatIamnottoinstruct,evaluate,or provide performancefeedbacktothose applicants scheduledtobe administeredtheselicensing examinationsfromthisdateuntil completion of examination administration,exceptas specifically noted below and authorizedbytheNRC.Furthermore,Iamaware of the physicalsecuritymeasuresand requirements and understand that violation of the conditions of this agreement may result in cancellation of the examinationsand/oran enforcementactionagainstmeorthefacilitylicensee.Iwill immediately reporttofacility managementortheNRC chief examiner any indications or suggestions that examinationsecuritymayhavebeen compromised.


2.Post-Examination NOTE DATE
Appendix C  Page 8 of 12  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.26-v Performance Step: 7 CLOSE ALL lift coil disconnect switches opened in Step 1 Standard: Points out and simulates placing the disconnect switches in the DOWN position for CBD Group 1 and Group 2 rods:
__4:fIC../01-.
  * B8
__5-2.
  * H14
  * P8
  * F6
  * F10
  * K10
  * K6 Evaluator Cue: Provide switch position feedback as each operation is simulate Comment: Critical to restore CBO to all rods operatin Performance Step: 8 Report completion of steps to Control Roo Standard: Reports Steps 3.25 and 3.26 completed to Control Roo Evaluator Cue: * Acknowledge repor * The control room crew has completed Step 3.27. You have been directed to perform Step 3.28, RN Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


_
Appendix C  Page 9 of 12  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.28 RNO-v Performance Step: 9 PERFORM the following at the Pulse-To-Analog (PIA) Converter:
__I.{-f-0t?4'3-ae__POST-EXAMINATION
a. POSITION the Bank Display Selector Switch to the bank recorded in Step 1 b. POSITION AND HOLD the Auto-Manual switch in MANUA c. Repeatedly PRESS EITHER the UP pushbutton OR the DOWN pushbutton as needed to make the display match the PIA reading recorded in Step 1 d. RELEASE the Auto-Manual switc e. POSITION the Bank Display Selector Switch to DISPLAY OF Standard: Locates the PIA Converter, opens the cabinet and selects Control Bank D. (-V)
.IGNAlNRE (2)htfb 6 I'3 k'-/fog
Evaluator Cue: When Bank Display Selector Switch is selected to Control Bank "0": The display is reading 33 Points out and simulates placing Auto-Manual switch to MANUAL and holds. (-V)
__uo-.:-.""""'....''#A wr
Evaluator Cue: After the AUTO-MANUAL switch and MANUAL position are located: You are holding the AUTO-MANUAL switch in MANUA Depresses the DOWN (-) pushbutton until counter indicates 165 steps. (-V)
)
Evaluator Cue: As the DOWN Pushbutton is pushed. The indicator is lowering one step at a time. Assume that it has reached 165 step Releases the Auto-Manual switch Evaluator Cue: The AUTO-MANUAL Switch is release Places the Bank Display Selector switch to DISPLAY OFF Evaluator Cue: The Bank Display Selector Switch is in DISPLAY OF Comment: Critical to restore circuit to pre-retrieval condition.
3 rj,i;'P--
DATE v A l\c...\\).5:+S}(O (\0-SilO S-r.{'tiT£\(Lb PRINTED NAME 1.-2.&...-}Tothebest ofmyknowledge,Ididnotdivulgetoany unauthorized persons any information concerningtheNRClicensing examinations administeredduringthe period indicatedbelow.FromthedatethatI enteredintothissecurity agreementuntilthe completion of examination administration,Ididnotinstruct,evaluate,or provide performancefeedbacktothoseapplicantswhowere administeredtheselicensing examinations, except as specifically noted below and authorizedbytheNRC.Examination Periodj/1::>I 07 g?>/dL/d8 , 3k')08 JOB TITLE/RESPONSIBILITY PRE-EXAMINATION SIGNATURE (1)NOTES: I TAP-410 IRev.9 IPage15 of 20 I


;dIs EXf\l\tIINArrION f\GREElVIENrr1.Pre-ExanlinationIacknowledgethat1haveacquiredspecializedknowledge about the NRC licensing examinations scheduledforthe period indicated bel 0 v." asofthedate of Illy signature.Iagree that 1willnot knowingly divulge anyinformation about these examinations to any persons who have not beenauthorizedbythe N'RCchiefexaminer.1understand thatIam not to instruct,evaluate,or provide performance feedback to those applicantsscheduled to be administered theselicensingexaminations from this date until completion of examination administration, except as specifically noted belowand authorized by the NRC.funhermoreI Jain aware of the physlcalsecudty measures and requirements and understand thatviolationoftheconditionsofthisagreementmayresult in cancellationoftheexaminationsand/or anenforcementaction against meorthe facility licensee.I\-vi II immediately report to lilcility management or the NRC chief examiner any indications orsuggestions that examination security may have.been compromised" 2" Post-ExaminationTothebest-of illyknowledge,1 didnotdivulge toany unauthorized persons any information concerning the NRC licensing examinations administered during the period indicated below.Fromthedate that I entered into this security agreement until the completion of examination administration, I did not instruct;evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicantswhowere administered theselicensingexaminations, except as specificallynotedbelow and authorized bytheNRC.Examination Period 3/'2-1'SLUe,v-MS KO ,1lb\..-.l)
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0   NUREG 1021, Revision 9
12.0 JOB TITLE I RESPONSIBILITY PRINTED NAME NOTBS:sr}
Or;.F\/\f>'
I TAP41Q IRev.10 I Page15of 20 I
<, l\-..i\.C t i-'I 3/5 EX/\IVII.NArriON 1.Pre...Exatninatiol1 I acknowledgethatIhave acquiredspecializedknowledge about the NR(;licensing examinations scheduled for the period indicated below as of the date of my signature.


I agree that I will not knowingly divulge anyinformationabout these examinations to any persons who have not been authorizedbythechief examiner.I understand that I am not to instruct, evaluate, Of provide performance feedback to those applicants scheduled to be administered these licensing examinations from this date until completion of examination administration
Appendix C  Page 10 of 12  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Performance Step: 10 Report completion of steps to Control Roo Standard: Reports Step 3.28 completed to Control Roo Evaluator Cue: Acknowledge repor Comment:
..except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC.Punhermore,1am awareofthe physical security measures and requirements and understand that violation of the conditionsofthisagreement may result in cancellation of the examinations and/or an enforcement action against me or the facility licensee.I wi U immediately report to t:1.cility management 01'the NRC chief examiner any indications or suggestions that examination security may have been compromised.
Terminating Cue: After Step 3.1.28 completion is reported: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.


2.Post-Exarnination To the best of Illy knowledge, I did not divulgetoany unauthorized persons any information concerning the NRC licensing examinations administered during the period indicated below.From the date thatIentered intothissecurity agreement until the completion of examination administration, Ididnot instruct,evaluate,orprovide performance feedback to those, applicants who were administered these licensing examinations, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC.Examination Period to 312.\l 0'8----------
STOP TIME:
't;,{)y illior NOTE DATE DATE....
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0   NUREG 1021, Revision 9
SIGNATURE (1)S'L-l:):t115't JOB TITLE I RESPONSIBILITY PRINTED NAME*I.


3.SQ.)rr 4.(OiV1__
Appendix C  Page 11 of 12 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM i Examinee's Name:
__6.__.7,;_9.10.___12._
Date Performed:
14.._N()TES: I IRev.10 I Page 150f201 I.i;. l!:Xj\IVlJ..Nt,\'[I()NSI&#xa3;.*C tJIl I/\.(;
Facility Evaluator:
I.Pre-ExanUIl3!l.&#xa3;Hl1acknowledge that.I have acquired specializedknowledgeabout HGcnsing examinations scheduledforthe period indicated below as of the;dale of IllY 5ignature.
Number of Attempts:
Time to Complete:
Question Documentation:
Question:
Response:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature:  Date:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


I thatI will not knowingly divulge any information about theseexaminationstoany persons who have not beenauthorizedby the chief examiner.1 understand tharl am not to instruct, evaluate, Of provide performance feedback to those applicants scheduled to be administered these.licensing examinations from this date until.cornpletion of examination violation of the conditions of this agreement may result in cancellation of the examiaations and/or anenforcement action againstmeor the facility licensee.I\viH immediarely report it)fftcIHtji management or the NRC: chief examineranyindications ersaggestions that examinstion security may have.been compromised.
Appendix C  Page 12 of 12  Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * The unit was at 50&deg;J'c> power when Control Bank "0" control rod H2 droppe * The crew is performing AOP-001, MALFUNCTION OF ROD CONTROL AND INDICATION SYSTEM, and is preparing to retrieve the control rod.


2.POSl.-EXHTnina.ti9i.J1 To the.best of n1Yknowledge,I did not divulg.e to any unauthorized persons any information concerning theNlcClicensing examinations administeredduring the period indicated those applicants who'w'ere administered these licensing examinations, except as specifically noted below and authorized by-the NRC.ExulllinMf()f\PeriQt:!
INITIATING CUE: The USCG has assigned you to perform the local actions associated with the retrieval of the dropped rod. Perform AOP-001 - Steps 3.1.13, 3.1.14, 3.1.15, and 3.17. The control room will perform Step 3.1.16 (logging Step Counter readings) while you are performing the designated steps. Report completion of the steps to the control room and then standby for further direction.
to.\"L\\ifY
._.


_.-4.5.PRINTEI).N.AJ\ilE J()B 1'rrLE I RESPONSIBILITY N
HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
(1) IF::'" ( Dl\]]2;POST-.EX.AlvfIN.AJ]()N 1)ATI3 N(lT:E*
****mmm 6..7.8.-------=--=----=""""""-=='='
9.


-10.J.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.:
Task Title: Isolate the ECCS Accumulators JPM No.: 2008 NRC j after a control room evacuation (AOP-004, Step 38)
KIA Reference: APE068 G2.1.30 (3.9/3.4)
Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:  Date:
Method of testing:
Simulated Performance: x  Actual Performance:
Classroom  Simulator Plant X READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.


__...............
Initial Conditions: * The control room has been evacuated due to a fir * A cooldown is in progress in accordance with AOP-004, REMOTE SHUTDOW * RCS Pressure is 975 PSIG by PI-402.2.
12,
...............
__
___........
__N I TAP41Q*.*Rev,10: Page 15 pf?QI ,#


eKAM..5/5 EXAIVIINA"fION*
Task Standard: All accumulators isolated and MOV's de-energized.
SEC'U*Ilrr\;f 1.Pre...E>uuninatlol1 2.Post-*Ex aminatiQ 11 were administered these speciflcaUynoted below and authorized by the*NRC.Ex;amina!ionPefiod DATE-..-,:::::::.s?
(\rtf'.,Ml-..-r===r)"''''.'""''.
JOB TITLE lRESPONSIBILITY PRINl'ED NAME rosTlEXAMINATION DAtE NOTE SIGNATURE (2)64?5tfi:l Z>f n ,lEah..
::::J<)!t
--
5.. ON ON NOTES: CD C:J(1 eJ
_ye-a-'T<2.\<.o.N\*t TAP410!101 Page 1 qof 20 I ES-301 Facility: HARRIS Administrative Topics OutlineDateof Examination:FormES-301-1March,2008 ExaminationLevel(circleone):
IRol/SRO OperatingTestNumber:
NRC Administrative Topic(seeNote)Conduct of Operations Conduct of Operations Equipment ControlRadiationControl Emergency Plan Type Code*M M M MDescribeactivitytobe performed Determinethecold,xenonfreeboron concentration requirementpriorto commencinganaturalcirculation cooldown.(EPP-005/0ST-1036)G2.1.25(2.8/3.1)-Abilitytoobtainand interpretstationreference materialssuchasgraphs,monographs,andtableswhichcontain performance data.EstimatePrimaryto SecondaryLeakRate.(AOP-016,CurveBook)2.1.25(2.8)-Abilitytoobtainandinterpretstationreference materialssuchasgraphs,monographs,andtableswhichcontain performance data.Performa QuadrantPowerTiltRatio(QPTR)
calculationwithacontrolrod misaligned.(OST-1039)2.2.12(3.0)-Knowledgeof surveillance procedures.Givenan emergency situation, determine the applicabledoselimitandthe numberofpeoplethatwillberequiredtoperformthetask,withnoone exceedingthelimit.2.3.4(2.5/3.1)-Knowledgeofradiation exposurelimitsand contaminationcontrol,including permissiblelimitsinexcessofthoseauthorized.


NOT SELECTEDFORRO NOTE:Allitems(5totalarerequiredforSROs.RO applicantsrequireonly4itemsunlesstheyareretakingonlythe administrativetopics,when5arerequired.*TypeCodes
Required Materials: * Standard PPE
&Criteria:(C)ontrolroom (D)irectfrombankforROs;forSROs&ROretakes)(N)ew or (M)odifiedfrombank(>1)(P)revious2exams (s 1;randomly selected)(S)imulator NUREG-1021,Revision9HARRIS2008NRCRO301-1,Rev2 ES-301 Facility: HARRIS Administrative Topics OutlineDateof Examination:FormES-301-1March,2008 Examination Level (circleone):RO/ISROI Operating Test Number: NRC Administrative Topic(seeNote)Conduct of Operations Conduct of Operations Equipment Control Radiation Control Emergency Plan Type Code*M P,M N M M Describe activitytobe performed Determinethecold,xenonfreeRCSboron concentration requirement prior to commencing a natural circulation cooldown.(EPP-005/0ST-1036)G2.1.25 (2.8/3.1)-Abilitytoobtainandinterpretstationreference materialssuchasgraphs, monographs,andtableswhichcontain performance data.Perform a Control Room Supervisor reviewofthe control board readingslog.(OST-1021, Attachment 4)G2.1.18(3.0)-Abilitytomakeaccurate,clearandconciselogs,records,statusboards,andreports.
  * Unlock or ensure A TP Cabinet unlocked or provide the evaluator with a key.


Review the completed surveillance for Motor Driven AFWPump"A".(OST-1211)2.2.12(3.4)-
General References: AOP-004, REMOTE SHUTDOWN Handout:  AOP-004, Step 38 (Pgs. 46/47)
Knowledge of surveillance procedures.'Givenan emergency situation, determine the applicabledoselimitandthe numberofpeoplethatwillbe requiredtoperformthetask,withnoone exceedingthelimit.2.3.4 (2.5/3.1)-Knowledgeofradiationexposurelimitsand contaminationcontrol,including permissiblelimitsinexcessofthoseauthorized.
Initiating Cue: You have been assigned to perform AOP-004, Step 38 - Isolate SI Accumulators.


Evaluate a change in conditionswithanEALineffectandtakethe required actions.2.2.41(4.1)-
Time Critical Task: NO HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0    NUREG 1021, Revision 9
Knowledgeofthe emergencyactionlevelthresholds and classifications.NOTE:All items (5 total)are requiredforSROs.RO applicants requireonly4itemsunless they are retakingonlythe administrativetopics,when5arerequired.


*Type Codes&Criteria: (C)ontrol room (D)irectfrombank (=::;3forROs;=::;for SROs&RO retakes)(N)ew or (M)odified from bank (>1)(P)revious 2 exams (=::;1;randomly selected)(S)imulator NUREG-1021, Revision 9 HARRIS2008NRCSRO301-1,Revision2 ES-301 Facility: HARRIS Control Room/ln-Plant Systems OutlineDateofExamination:
Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 18 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
Form ES-301-2 3/2008ExamLevel(circleone):
RO I SRO(I)ISRQ(U)OperatingTestNo.:
NRCControlRoom Systems@(8forRO;7forSRO-I;2or3forSRO-U,including1ESF)
System IJPMTitlea.Initiate EmergencyBorationfollowingareactortrip(AOP-002)System:004/BankJPMCR-037 b.Align ECCS for long-term recirculation (EPP-010)System: EPE011/BankJPMCR-031c.InitiateRCSFeedandBleed(FRP-H.1)
System: E05/2007NRCExamJPMdd.RespondtoalossofNormalServiceWater(AOP-022)System:076e.Placethe ContainmentHydrogenPurgeSysteminoperation 125)RO OnlySystem:028/BankJPMCR-021TypeCode*M,A,S M,A,S P,D,A,S N,A,S D,C Safety Function 3 4P 4S 5 f.Transfer an Emergency Bus toanEDG duetoa degraded grid N,A,S 6 condition (AOP-028, Attachment 2)System: 062g.RespondtoaFuelHandlingBuildingRMSalarm(AOP-005,OP-170)N, L,S 7System:072 h.Align CCW to support RHR Initiation (OP-145)D,L,S 8 System: 008/BankJPMCR-085 In-Plant Systems@(3forRO;3forSRO-I;3or2forSRO-U)
i.Perform the local actions for a dropped rod recovery (AOP-001)System: 001/BankJPMIP-153 D,E 1NUREG-1021,Revision9 HARRIS2008NRC301-2,Revision2 ES-301 Control Room/In-Plant Systems Outline Form ES-301-2j.IsolatetheECCS Accumulatorsafteracontrolroom evacuation N,E 8 (AOP-004,Step38)System: APE068 k.Terminate a Waste Gas Release (OP-120.07)
P,D,R 9 System: 071/2007NRCJPMk@AllROandSRO-Icontrolroom(andin-plant)
systemsmustbe differentandserve different safety functions;all5SRO-U systemsmustserve different safety functions; in-plant systems and functions may overlapthosetestedinthecontrolroom.


*TypeCodes (A)lternate path(C)ontrolroom (D)irectfrombank (E)mergency or abnormal in-plant (L)ow-Power
Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
/Shutdown (N)ew or (M)odifiedfrombankincluding1(A)(P)revious 2 exams (R)CA (S)imulatorCriteriaforRO/SRO-I/SRO-U4-6/4-6/2-3 9/8/41/;;,:.:.1/
11/1/1>:2/3/3/2 (randomly selected);'::::.1/1/:2:.1 HARRIS2008NRC 301*2 JPM SUMMARY STATEMENTSa.Initiate EmergencyBorationin accordance with AOP-002, EMERGENCY BORA TION, following a reactortrip.The alternatepathistotake correctiveactionfortwoormore stuckrodsas determined in EPP-004, REACTORTRIP.ModifiedfromBankJPM037byfailingfirst borationpathdriving candidatetouse secondary means.b.TransfertoColdLeg Recirculation in accordance with EPP-010, TRANSFERTOCOLD LEG RECIRCULATION, followingaLBLOCA.The alternatepathsare corrective actions for alignment failuresintwo different flowpaths.


ModifyBankJPMCR-031bychanging the misalignedvalveinoneRNOstepandtherunningpump combination.c.InitiateRCSFeedandBleedlAWFRP-H.1, RESPONSETOLOSSOF SECONDARY HEATSINK.The alternatepathisto establish an adequateventpathusingRVHead Vents followingfailureofone PORVtoopen.Randomly selectedrepeatfrom2007NRCExam(JPMd)notinthe facility bank.d.Respondtoalossoftheonly available Normal Service WaterPumpin accordance with AOP-022,LOSSOF SERVICE WATER.The'alternatepathistostartoneEssential Service WaterPumpandtotriptheMain Turbine with powerlessthanP-10.NewJPM.e.Placethe Containment HydrogenPurgeSystemin operation in accordancewith 125, POST ACCIDENT HYDROGEN SYSTEM.BankJPMCR-021.ThisJPMwillbe simulatedintheMain ControlRoom(usingcues)
Appendix C  Page 4 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
because some equipment important tothetaskisnot simulated.NUREG-1021,Revision9 HARRIS2008NRC301-2,Revision2 ES-301 Control Room/In-Plant Systems OutlineFormES-301-2f.Witha degradedgridcondition, transfer an emergencybustoanEDGin accordance with AOP-028, GRID INSTABILITY-Attachment 2, ENERGIZING EMERGENCYBUSESFROMEDGS,by purposely de-energizingabus.The alternatepathisstartinganEDG following evaluation of Voltage/Frequencyonan emergencybusand manuallyresettingtheLoad Sequencerafterthecycleis complete.NewJPM.g.RespondtoaFuelHandlingBuildingRMSalarmin accordance with AOP-005, RADIATION MONITORINGSYSTEM,andOP-170,FUEL HANDLING BUILDINGHVAC.AFHB monitoralarmsandFHBHVAC componentsfailtoalignproperly.New JPM.h.AlignCCWto supportRHRInitiationin accordancewithOP-145, COMPONENT COOLING WATER.BankJPMCR-085.i.Performthelocal actionsfora dropped rod recovery in accordance with AOP-001, MALFUNCTIONOFROD CONTROL AND INDICATION SYSTEM.Bank JPM-IP-153.j.IsolatetheECCS Accumulatorsafteracontrolroom evacuation in accordance with AOP-004, REMOTE SHUTDOWN,Step38.NewJPM.
START TIME:
AOP-004 Performance Step: 1 Obtain locked valve and ATP Cabinet key Standard:  Discusses how to obtain keys (ACP Room Key Locker).


k.Terminate a WasteGasReleasein accordance with OP-120.07, WASTE GAS PROCESSING.
Evaluator Note: The Evaluator can elect to have the applicant locate the ACP Room Key Locker or to discuss the key acquisition. The key to the ACP Key Locker is in a "break glass" cas Evaluator Cue: * Provide Handout for NRC JPM * Acknowledge discussion and tell applicant to assume that they have the required key Comment:
AOP-004, Step 38.a-v Performance Step: 2 WHEN RCS pressure is 900 to 1000 psig, as indicated on PI-402.2, THEN ISOLATE SI accumulators:
286' RAB / RO with locked valve key a. UNLOCK AND TURN ON accumulator discharge valve breakers:
  * Accumulator A: 1A21-SA-5C (both breakers)
  * Accumulator .C: 1A21-SA-3D (both breakers)
Standard:  * Locates 1A21-SA-5C, identifies UNLOCK then ON position for both breakers for Accumulator * Locates 1A21-SA-3D, identifies UNLOCK then ON position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Comment:  Assumes the locked valve key has been located. Critical to provide power to MOV for operation.


Randomlyselectedrepeatfrom2007NRCExam(JPMk).NUREG-1021,Revision9 HARRIS2008NRC301-2,Revision2 ES*301 Operating Test Quality Checklist Form ES*301*32.Walk-Throu h Criteria 3.Simulator Criteriab*c#InitialsDateofExamination:1.General Criterialicateitemsfromthealicants'audittest s.seeSectionD.1.a.
HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Theo a.d.NRC Supervisorc.NRCChiefExaminer(#)b.FacilityReviewer(*)d.Overlapwiththewrittenexaminationandbetweendifferentpartsoftheoperatingtestiswithinaccetablelimits.e.Itappearsthattheoperatingtestwill differentiatebetweencompetentand less-than-competentalicantsatthedesinatedlicenselevel.a.EachJPMincludesthefollowing,asapplicable:initialconditionsinitiatingcuesreferencesandtools,includingassociatedproceduresreasonableandvalidatedtimelimits(averagetimeallowedforcompletion)andspecificdesignationifdeemedtobe time-criticalbythefacilitylicensee operationallyimportantspecific performancecriteriathatinclude:detailedexpectedactionswithexactcriteriaandnomenclaturesystemresponseandother examiner cuesstatementsdescribingimportant observationstobemadebytheapplicantcriteriaforsuccessfulcompletionofthetaskidentificationofcriticalstepsandtheirassociatedperformancestandardsrestrictionsontheseuenceofstes,ifaIicablea.AuthorTheassociated simulatoroperatingtests(scenariosets)havebeenreviewedinaccordancewithFormES-301-4andacoisattached.Facilit:b.Ensurethatanychangesfromthepreviouslyapprovedsystemsandadministrativewalk-throughoutlines(FormsES-301-1and2)havenotcausedthetesttodeviatefromanyoftheacceptancecriteria(e.g.,itemdistribution,bankuse,repetitionfromthelast2NRC examinations)
Appendix C  Page 5 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-004, 38.a
specifiedonthoseformsandFormES-201-2.
~ Performance Step: 3 WHEN RCS pressure is 900 to 1000 psig, as indicated on PI-402.2, THEN ISOLATE SI accumulators:
286' RAB / RO with locked valve key a. UNLOCK AND TURN ON accumulator discharge valve breakers:
  * Accumulator B: 1B21-SB-5C (both breakers)
Standard: Locates 1B21-SB-5C, identifies UNLOCK then ON position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Evaluator Note: Opening the ATP door actuates an alarm in the control roo Comment: Assumes the locked valve key has been located. Critical to provide power to MOV for operatio AOP-004, Step 38.b
~ Performance Step: 4 SHUT SI accumulator discharge valves at the Auxiliary Transfer Panels listed:
Cable Vault A / RO with A TP cabinet key
  * 1SI-246, Accumulator A Discharge (at ATP A)
Cable Vault A / RO with A TP cabinet key
  * 1SI-248, Accumulator C Discharge (at ATP A)
Standard: * Locates and opens ATP "A" and identifies SHUT position for 1SI-246
  * Locates and opens ATP "A" and identifies SHUT position for 1SI-248 Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on switch positio Comment: Critical to close discharge valves to prevent inadvertent discharge during cooldown.


c.b.Thereisnoday-to-dayrepetitionbetweenthisandotheroperatingteststobe administereddurinthisexamination.NOTE:ThefacilitysignatureisnotapplicableforNRC-developedtests.
HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


#IndeendentNRCreviewerinitialitemsinColumn"c";chiefexaminer concurrencereuired.ES-301,Page24of27 ES-301 Simulator Scenario Quality Checklist Form ES-301-4 Facility: HARRISDateofExam:
Appendix C  Page 6 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-004, Step 38.b-v Performance Step: 5 SHUT SI accumulator discharge valves at the Auxiliary Transfer Panels listed:
03/2008ScenarioNumbers:
Cable Vault B / RO with A TP cabinet key
1/2/3OperatingTestNo.:
  * 1SI-247, Accumulator B Discharge (at ATP B)
QUALITATIVE ATIRIBUTES Initials ab*c#1.Theinitialconditionsare realistic,inthatsomeequipmentand/orinstrumentation maybeoutof P k'1Jiservice.but it doesnotcuetheoperatorsintoexpectedevents.
Standard: * Locates and opens ATP "B" and identifies SHUT position for 1SI-247 Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on switch positio Comment:  Critical to close discharge valves to prevent inadvertent discharge during cooldown.


2.Thescenariosconsistmostlyofrelatedevents.
Evaluator Note: The Evaluator can elect to have the applicant discuss the remaining steps since it involves returning to equipment already located and re-opening the breaker AOP-004, Step 3 Performance Step: 6 286' RAB / RO with locked valve key TURN OFF AND LOCK accumulator discharge valve breakers:
  * Accumulator A: 1A21-SA-5C (both breakers)
  * Accumulator C: 1A21-SA-3D (both breakers)
Standard:  * Returns to 1A21-SA-5C, identifies OFF then LOCK position for both breakers for Accumulator * Returns to 1A21-SA-3D, identifies OFF then LOCK position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


iPf\.../..V , 3.Ea.cheventdescriptionconsistsof
Appendix C  Page 7 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-004, Step 3 Performance Step: 7 286' RAB / RO with locked valve key TURN OFF AND LOCK accumulator discharge valve breakers:
*thepointinthescenariowhen itistobeinitiated
  * Accumulator B: 1B21-SB-5C (both breakers)
*themalfunction(s)thatareenteredtoinitiatetheevent 10..J*thesymptoms/cuesthat wHlbevisibletothecrew
Standard: Returns to 1B21-SB-5C, identifies OFF then LOCK position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Comment:
";:!*theexpectedoperatoractions (byshiftposition)
Terminating Cue: When all SI Accumulator Discharge Valves are de-energized:
*theeventterminationpoint (if applicable)
Evaluation on this JPM is complete.
4.Nomorethanonenon-mechanisticfailure(e.g
.*pipebreak)isincorporatedintothescenariowithout to 1])-acredibleprecedingincidentsuchasaseismicevent.


5.Theeventsarevalid withregardto physicsandthermodynamics.
STOP TIME:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


rr{:)"..*....6.Sequencingandtimingofeventsis reasonable,andallowstheexaminationteamtoobtaincomplete/If'Ievaluationresultscommensuratewiththescenarioobjectives.
Appendix C  Page 8 of 9  Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM j Examinee's Name:
Date Performed:
Facility Evaluator:
Number of Attempts:
Time to Complete:
Question Documentation:
Question:
Response:
Result:  SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature:  Date:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


;to i----7.Iftimecompressiontechniquesareused,thescenariosummaryclearlysoindicates.
Appendix C  Page 9 of 9  Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * The control room has been evacuated due to a fir * A cooldown is in progress in accordance with AOP-004, REMOTE SHUTDOW * RCS Pressure is 975 PSIG by PI-402.2.


Operators!\havesufficienttimetocarryoutexpectedactivitieswithoutunduetimeconstraints.
INITIATING CUE: You have been assigned to perform AOP-004, Step 38 - Isolate SI Accumulators.


(10 l\1[)i:?**8.Thesimulatormodelingisnotaltered.t1 v yo 9.Thescenarioshavebeenvalidated.Pursuantto10CFR55.46(d),anyopensimulatorperformance Jodeficienciesordeviationsfromthereferencedplanthavebeenevaluatedtoensurethatfunctional
HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
/!...fidelity ismaintainedwhilerunningtheplannedscenarios.


<"v'10.Everyoperator winbeevaluated using at feastoneneworsignificantlymodifiedscenario.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.: 071104H112 Task Title: Respond to High Rad Alarm During JPM No.: 2008 NRC JPM k a Waste Gas Decay Tank Release KIA Reference: 071 G2.1.30 3.9 Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:  Date:
Method of testing:
Simulated Performance: X  Actual Performance:
Classroom  Simulator Plant X READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.


AU other?fly.-scenarioshavebeenaltered inaccordancewith Section 0.5ofES-301.l'""Y: r--11.AUindividualoperatorcompetenciescanbeevaluated,asverifiedusingForm ES-301-6(submitthe If)1f;)_.formalong withthesimulatorscenarios).
Initial Conditions: * "A" Waste Gas Decay Tank is being release * Monitors REM-3546 and RM-3546-1 are OPERABLE.


0'"12.Eachapplicant wiltbesignificantlyinvolvedintheminimumnumberoftransientsandevents-tbspecifiedonFormES
Task Standard: Waste Gas Decay Tank release is terminated per OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Section 8.37.
..301-5(submittheformwiththesimulatorscenarios).


'.,J 13.Thelevelofdifficulty isappropriatetosupportlicensingdecisionsforeachcrewposition.
Required Materials: On the day of the IP JPM performance, notify the RadWaste Operator that applicants will be entering the area and may be accessing the reading for REM-3546 on the RM-11 Panel.


\rlf) ,., Target Quantitative Attributes (Per Scenario;See Section D.5.d)Actual Attributes
General References: OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Rev. 46 Handouts: * A copy of OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Attachment 3 completed through Item 2 * A copy of OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Section 8.37.
.-..1.Totalmalfunctions(5
...8)9 IV..r*\J 2.Malfunctions afterEOPentry(1
..2)2/2/2 it;:*3.Abnormalevents(2-4)
4/5/4 v1?.-11..4.Majortransients(1-2)
2/2/1....5.EOPsentered/requiringsubstantiveactions(1
..2)2/2/3.:It, ,1 ,.'" 6.EOPcontingenciesrequiringsubstantiveactions(0
..2)1/1 I 0iJ/57.Criticaltasks(2-3)
2/3 I i/ov-NUREG..1021 1 Revision 9HARRIS2008NRC 301-4,Revision2 ES-301 TransientandEventChecklistFormES-301-5 Facility: HARRISDateofExam:
03/2008 Operating Test No.: SROU/IAE Scenarios P VPE 1 2 3 4 T MLN 0 I I T CREW CREW CREW CREW T N C POSITION POSITION POSITION POSITION A I A T L M N Y UTP M(*)E S ABSABSAB S A BRI URT 0RT 0RT 0 R T 0 0CP 0 C P 0CP 0 C P RX11 0 NOR 1 1 1/211 1 I/C 3,4, 2,3, 4/644 2 5,6 4,5, 6 SRO-U MAJ 7,9 7,9 2/4 2 2 1 TS 2,3 3,5, 2/2 0 2 2 6 RX 1 111 0 NOR 1 111 1 SRO-I I/C 3,4, 2,4, 744 2 5,6 6 MAJ 7,9 7,9 4 2 2 1 TS 2,3 3 0 2 2 RX11 0 NOR11 1 I/C44 2 MAJ22 1 TS 0 2 2 Instructions:
1.Circle the applicantleveland enter the operating test numberandFormES-D-1 event numbersforeacheventtype;TSare not-applicableforRO applicants.ROsmust serviceinboththe"at-the-controls(ATC)"and"balance-of-plant (BOP)" positions; Instant SROsmustdoone scenario, includingatleasttwo instrument or component (I/C)malfunctionsandone major transient,intheATC position.2.Reactivity manipulations may be conducted undernormalor controlled abnormal conditions (refertoSection D.5.d)but must be significant per SectionC.2.aof AppendixD.(*)Reactivityandnormal evolutionsmaybe replaced with additional instrument or component malfunctionsona1-for-1basis.


3.Whenever practical, both instrument and component malfunctions should be included;only thosethatrequire verifiable actions that provide insighttothe applicant's competence count toward the minimum requirements specifiedforthe applicant's licenselevelinthe right-hand columns.NUREG1021Revision9HARRIS2008NRCSRO301-5,Revision2 ES-301TransientandEvent ChecklistFormES-301-5 Facility: HARRISDateofExam:
Initiating Cue: You relieved the operator who commenced the release. The control room has just directed you to implement OP-120.07, Section 8.37, Actions for a REM Monitor Alarm During a Waste Gas Decay Tank Release, because an ALERT alarm has been received on REM-3546.
03/2008 Operating Test No.: RO A E Scenarios P V P E 1 2 3 4 T M L N 0 I I T CREW CREW CREW CREW T N C POSITION POSITION POSITION POSITION A I A T L M N Y U T P M(*)ESABSA BSAB S A B R I U R T 0RT 0RT 0 R T 0 0CP 0 C P 0CP 0 C P R01 RX 1111 0 NOR 1111 1 I/C 3,5 3,5444 2 MAJ 7-9 7-9 422 1 TS0022 R02 RX 1111 0 NOR 1 1 111 I/C 3,5 3,5 444 2 MAJ 7-9 7-9 422 1 TS0022 RX NOR I/C MAJ TS Instructions:
1.Circle the applicantleveland enter the operating test numberandFormES-D-1 event numbersforeach eventtype;TSarenot applicableforRO applicants.


ROs must serviceinboththe"at-the-controls (ATC)" and"balance-of-plant(BOP)" positions; Instant SROs mustdoone scenario, includingatleasttwo instrument or component (I/C)malfunctionsandone major transient,intheATC position.2.Reactivity manipulations may be conducted under normal or controlled abnormal conditions (refer to Section D.5.d)but must be significant per Section C.2.a of AppendixD.(*)Reactivity and normal evolutionsmaybe replaced with additional instrument or component malfunctionsona1-for-1basis.
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


3.Whenever practical, both instrument and component malfunctions should be included;only thosethatrequire verifiable actions that provide insighttothe applicant's competence count toward the minimum requirements specifiedforthe applicant's licenselevelinthe right-hand columns.NUREG1021Revision9HARRIS2008NRCRO301-5,Revision2 ES..301 Competencies Checklist Form ES-301-6 Facility: HARRIS Date of Examination:
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Time Critical Task: N/A Validation Time: 20 minutes HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
03/2008 Operating Test No.: SRO APPLICANTS SRO-U SRO-I Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 123 412 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 Interpret/Diagnose 3,5 2,3 , 2 ,3 Events and Conditions 5,7 7,8 5,7, 6,7 9 9.9 8,9 10 Comply With and Use An 1,3 1,3 1 AU Procedures (1)5 5 Operate Control NA 1,3 1.3, NA Boards (2)5,8 5,7, 9 , 9 10 Communicate and All 1.3 1.2 1 All Interact 5.7 3 15, 8.9 7,9 10 Demonstrate AU NA NA All Supervisory Ability (3)Comply With and Use 2,3 NA NA 3,5 Tech.Specs.(3)6 Notes: (1)(2)(3)Includes Technical Specification compliance foranRO.Optional for an SRO-U.Only applicable to SROs.Instructions:Circlethe applicants'
license type and enter one or more event numbersthatwill allow the examiners toeveiuete every applicable competency for every applicant.


Author: NRC Reviewer: NUREG-1 021, Revision 9 HARRIS 2008 NRC SRO 301-6, Revision 2 ES-301 Competencies ChecklistFormES-301
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
..6 Facility: HARRISDateof Examination:
03/2008 Operating Test No.: RO APPLICANTS R01 R02 R03 Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 Interpret/Diagnose 4,6 2,4 2,3, 3,5, 4,6 2,4 Events and Conditions
.8,9 6 t9 5,7, 7,8, 8,9 6,9 10 9 9.10 10 Comply WithandUse 1,4 2.4 1,3, 1,3, 1,4 2,4 Procedures (1)6 6 5, 5 6 6 Operate Control 1,4 2,4 1,3, 1,3, 1A 2.4 Boards (2)6,8 6,7 5}, 5,8, 6,8 6.7 9, 9 9 9.10 9, 9 10 10 Communicate and 1.4 1,2 1,2, 1,3, 1.4 1,2 Interact 6,8 4,6 3,5, 5,7, 6,8 4,6 9, 7,9 7,9 8,9.9, 7.9 10 10 10 Demonstrate NA NA NA NA NA NA Supervisory Ability (3)Comply WithandUse NA NA NA NA NA NA Tech.Specs.(3)Notes:(1)Includes Technical Specification complianceforanRO, (2)Optional for an SRO-U.(3)Only applicabletoSROs.Instructions:
Circle the applicants'
license type and enter one or more event numbersthatwill allow the examiners to evaluate every applicable competency for every applicant.


Author: NRC Reviewer: NUREG...1 021, Revision 9 HARRIS 2008NRCRO 301-6, Revision 2 ES-401 Written Examination Quality Checklist Form ES-401-6 Facility:DateofExam:
Appendix C  Page 4 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
Exam Level: ROSRO QSJ Initial Item Description a b*c.#1.Questionsandanswersaretechnicallyaccurateandapplicabletothefacility.
START TIME:
Performance Step: 1 Obtain Procedure Standard:  Reviews OP-120.07, Section 8.3 Examiners Cue: Provide the handout (OP-120.07, Attachment 3 signed off through Item 23 and OP-120.07, Section 8.37).


\6)lit!I2.8.NRC K1Asarereferenced fOTallquestions.Del;-XI'/\b.Facility learning objectivesarereferencedasavailable.
Comment:
Step 8.3 Performance Step: 2 Verifies the Initial Conditions:
1. A Waste Gas Decay Tank is being release . Monitors REM-3546 or RM-3546-1 are OPERABL . A REM Monitor Alert or High Alarm has been receive Standard:  Confirms the initial conditions appl Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


3.SROQuestionsareappropriate in accordance withSectionD.2.dof ES-401 o elL1r 4.Thesamplingprocesswasrandomandsystematic(Ifmorethan4ROor2SROquestions
Appendix C  Page 5 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37. Procedure Note: * If an Alert alarm is received, the WGDT release may continue provided the reading does not approach the High Alarm setpoin * This section contains steps which require independent verificatio Performance Step: 3 If the Monitor goes into an Alert Alarm, observe the reading to see if it continues to increase. Record the reading in the Radwaste Control Room AO log Standard: Accesses the REM-3546 monitor reading on the RM-11 Pane Examiners Cue: REM-3546 is rising and approaching the HIGH alarm setpoin Comment:
*W**
Step 8.37. Performance Step: 4 If the Monitor reading continues to approach or goes into a High Alarm condition, the Waste Gas Decay Tank release must be secured. Continue to next step to secure the Gas Decay Tank Releas Standard: Determines the release must be secured and continues to the next ste Comment:
...wererepeatedfrom thelast2NRC Iicenstngexams,consulttheNRROLprogramoffice).
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


y 5.Questionduplicationfromthelicensescreening/auditexamwascontrolledasindicatedbelow(checktheitemthatapplies)andappearsappropriate:_theauditexamwassystematicallyandrandomlydeveloped;or Jr_theauditexamwascompletedbeforethelicenseexamwasstarted:or
Appendix C  Page 6 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37.2.3
\()OtL_theexaminationsweredevelopedindependently;or 0helicenseecertifiesthatthereisno duplication; or_other(explain)
~ Performance Step: 5 Adjust HK-7392, PLANT VENT Controller until indicator reads 0 and record the Actual Stop Date/Time (Log Item 24).
6.Bankusemeets limits(nomorethan75percent Bank Modified New tfromthebank,atleas110percentnew,andtherestnewormodified);entertheactualRO ISRO..only (1 1 q I3<,,(IOt Lquestiondistributionts)atright.


7.Between50and60percentofthequestionsontheROMemory CIA Iexamarewrittenatthecomprehensionlanalysislevel;
Standard: * Adjusts HK-7392 until indicator reads * Records the actual Stop Date/Time on Attachment Examiners Cue: Controller HK-7392 reads Examiner Note: If the applicant incorrectly performs this step then correct performance of either Performance Step 6 or Performance Step 12 becomes critica Comment:
\0theSROexammayexceed60percentjftherandomly60%68fl OtjlL selected KJAssupportthehighercognitivelevels;enter
Step 8.37. Performance Step: 6 Using key, place the WG DECAY TANKS E & F TO PLANT VENT VALVE switch 3WG-229 to KEYLOCKED SHUT and log on Attachment 3. (Log Item 25)
'3I iftheactualRO ISROquestiondistribution(s)atright.
Standard: * Selects WG DECAY TANKS E & F TO PLANT VENT VALVE 3WG-229 switch to KEYLOCKED SHU * Records log entry on Attachment Examiners Cue: 3WG-229 is in the KEYLOCKED SHUT positio Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


c-::>it 8.References/handoutsprovideddonotgiveawayanswers
Appendix C  Page 7 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37. Procedure Note: Independent verification of 3WG-229 position in the next step can be performed out of sequenc Performance Step: 7 Perform independent verification that 3WG-229 is locked shut and log on Attachment 3. (Log item 26)
\0 U:&#xa3;J!or aidintheeliminationofdistractors.
Standard: Logs independent verification entry on Attachment 3 or delays action based on the Procedure Not Examiners Cue: Independent verification will be performed out of sequence in accordance with the procedure not Comment:
Step 8.37. Performance Step: 8 Notify the Superintendent - Shift Operations that Monitor REM-3546 has alarmed and the release has been stoppe Standard: Notifies the Superintendent Shift Operations that monitor REM-3546 alarmed and the release has been stoppe Examiners Cue: Superintendent Shift Operations acknowledges the repor Comment:
Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 9 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:
  * Record the Vent Stack 5 Flow Rate (Log Item 27).


9.Questioncontentconforms withspecificKIAstatementsinthepreviouslyapproved DC)(L.,examinationoutlineandisappropriateforthetiertowhichtheyareassigned;deviationsarejustified.
Standard: * Reads and records Vent Stack 5 Process Flow Rate on Attachment Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


i, jI 10.QuestionpsychometricqualityandformatmeettheguidelinesinESAppendixB.
Appendix C  Page 8 of 11  Form ES-C-1
  . PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 10 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:
  * Record the Final Gas Decay Tank Pressure (Log Item 28).


}'\11.Theexamcontainstherequirednumberof one-pointmultiplechoiceitems;
Standard: * Locates "A" Gas Decay Tank pressure indication and records on Attachment Examiners Cue: Final Gas Decay Tank pressure is 23 psi Comment:
\0 Ott1."iL.thetotal iscorrectandagreeswiththevalueonthecoversheet.
Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 11 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:
  * Calculate the Actual Gas Decay Tank liP and record. (Log Item 29).


Printed Name I Date If 3a.Author ,j D\--\N)If)l:1'("'(,.j
Standard: * Actual Gas Decay Tank ~P calculated and recorded on Attachment Comment:
."""'-::=')b.F acmty Reviewer{*}
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
if.\1,/(./'-\v:..t'/\7J_.


c.NRC Chief Examiner (#)
Appendix C  Page 9 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 12 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:
i:..t'LASk:A{.2 LP.AdZ#It.-Jd.NRCRegionalSupervisor
  * Shut 3WG-230, Gas Decay Tanks to Plant Vent Manual Isolation Valve and log on Attachment 3. (Log Item 30)
/"'A.!pn.u-C\11\0"...
Standard: * Locates 3WG-230 and shuts valve by rotating the handwheel in the clockwise directio * Records 3WG-230 position on Attachment Examiners Cue: 3WG-230 is shu Comment:
f,A..fir'(
Step 8.37.2. Procedure Note: Independent verification of 3WG-230 position in the next step can be performed out of sequenc Performance Step: 13 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:
Note: "It The facilityreviewer'sinitials/signaturearenotapplicablefor
  * Perform independent verification that 3WG-230 is shut and log on Attachment 3. (Log Item 31)
#IndependentNRCreviewerinitial itemsinColumn I4 C ll;chiefexaminerconcurrencerequired.
Standard: Logs independent verification entry on Attachment 3 or delays action based on the Procedure Not Evaluator Cue: Independent verification will be performed out of sequence in accordance with the procedure not Comment:
Terminating Cue: After the independent verification of 3WG-230 step has been read: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.


ES-401,Page29of33 ES-401,Rev.9Harris2008-301SRO Written Examination Review Worksheet Form ES-401-9 Stem IcuesIT/FI J?b-IMinutiaI#(I Back-IQ=I SRO IFocusDlst.Link Units ward KIA On!y 7.Explanation 6.5.Other 4.JobContentFlaws 3.Psychometric Flaws 2.LOD Iiiiiiiii I i I (1-5)1.LOK (F/H)Q#Instructions[RefertoSection 0ofES-401andAppendixBforadditionalinformationregardingeachofthefollowingconcepts.]1.Enterthelevelofknowledge(LOK)ofeachquestionaseither(F)undamentalor(H)ighercognitivelevel.2.Enterthelevelofdifficulty(LOO)ofeachquestionusinga1-5(easy-difficult)ratingscale(questionsinthe2-4rangeareacceptable).3.Checktheappropriateboxifapsychometricflawisidentified:*Thestemlackssufficientfocustoelicitthecorrectanswer(e.g.,unclearintent,moreinformationisneeded,ortoomuchneedlessinformation).*Thestemordistractorscontaincues(Le.,clues,specificdeterminers,phrasing,length,etc).*Theanswerchoicesareacollectionofunrelatedtrue/falsestatements.*Thedistractorsarenotcredible;singleimplausibledistractorsshouldberepaired,morethanoneisunacceptable.*Oneormoredistractorsis(are)partiallycorrect(e.g.,iftheapplicantcanmakeunstatedassumptionsthatarenotcontradictedbystem).4.Checktheappropriateboxifajobcontenterrorisidentified:*Thequestionisnotlinkedtothejobrequirements(Le.,thequestionhasavalidKIAbut,aswritten,isnotoperationalincontent).*Thequestionrequirestherecallofknowledgethatistoospecificfortheclosedreferencetestmode(Le.,itisnotrequiredtobeknownfrommemory).*Thequestioncontainsdatawithanunrealisticlevelofaccuracyorinconsistentunits(e.g.,panelmeterinpercentwithquestioningallons).*Thequestionrequiresreverselogicorapplicationcomparedtothejobrequirements.5.CheckquestionsthataresampledforconformancewiththeapprovedKIAandthosethatare designated SRO-only(KIAandlicenselevel mismatches are unacceptable).6.Basedonthereviewer'sjudgment,isthequestionaswritten(U)nsatisfactory(requiringrepairorreplacement),inneedof(E)ditorialenhancement,or(S)atisfactory?7.Ataminimum,explainany"U"ratings(e.g.,howtheAppendixBpsychometricattributesarenotbeingmet).
STOP TIME:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/FCredoPartial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 76 H 2 X X U 002G2.2.22 AppearstomatchKIA.Some Backwardslogicusedinstemand distractors.
Appendix C  Page 10 of 11 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM k Examinee's Name:
Date Performed:
Facility Evaluator:
Number of Attempts:
Time to Complete:
Question Documentation:
Question:
Response:
Result:  SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature:  Date:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Basis documentstatesthatthe assumptionisthatthePORVorsteamdumpvalvesfailtowork,weshouldworkthisintothe distractors, steam dumpsandPORVsfailto operateetc.Wecan discuss this.Doesnot appear that distractorsAandBarenotplausibleaswritten.
Appendix C    Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * "A" Waste Gas Decay Tank is being release * Monitors REM-3546 and RM-3546-1 are OPERABLE.


MOD ModifiedfromHarris 2007 Both independent examinersagreethat question is unsat.Changed all distractors and portionsofthestem Question appearstobe SAT 1/23/2008 77 H 2 X X U 005G2.4.50Doesnot appeartomatchtheKIA,unlesstheseactionsarelistedintheARP.As written, distractorscanddarenotcredible,iftherodwillnotmove,howcantherodberealigned.
INITIATING CUE: You relieved the operator who commenced the release. The control room has just directed you to implement OP-120. 07, Section 8.37, Actions for a REM Monitor Alarm During a Waste Gas Decay Tank Release, because an ALERT alarm has been received on REM-3546.


The distractorsshouldreadalignthe other grouprodsto198,or
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
=or-12steps.NEW*
Both independent examinersagree.Timesarenotincludedin distractors BandDforwhen accidentanalysisneedstobe complete.TABLED QUESTIONTOBE WORKEDONLATER QuestionreplacedSAT 3/18/208 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOKLOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 78H1 X U 006G2.1.33 AppearstomeetKIA.This question appearedonseveralexams.


Distractors Band Ddonot appeartobe plausible.(Maintain linear heatinthecoreatorabove limits?).(Listedas modified)BANK Last Harris Audit and Summer 2007 and 2006 retake...Not modified Summer 2006hadsame parameter.
Appendix C    Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: . HARRIS    Task No.': 301009H401 Task Title:  Initiate Emergency Boration  JPM No.: 2008 NRC a following a .reactor trip, (AOP-002)
  ". . . .
    .  .
: KIA. Reference: . 'APE024 AA*t ..,17 (3'.9/3':.9) ALTERNATE PATH Examinee:    N*RC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:    Date':
M*etho.d:of testing::.
Simulated Performance: :...... ---..:-:--
Actual Performance: . .x Classroom  X Plant'
. '.  .
*R*EAD TO'THE' EXAMIN..EE twill explalntheinitialconditions, which steps to simulate or.discuss.rand provide initiating .
cues..* When you complete*the**task,suc,cessfuJly.,*.the'*objective forthis Job-Performance Measure willbe satisfied. . '    .
"  '
    .  . . .  .
lnltlal Conditions: -.  * ..The plant was, .'at. tOO%,,;power,whe'n: an .autornatic reactor trip' . '
occurred due toaninadvertent mainturbinetrip
    . . " " (. ' . . : ' .' . ' ,
e, .' The. Grewhasperformed PATH~1"i.mmediateactions  and: have tra'nsitioned'*to'I;,P,P~004,",R,EA'C,TOR ':TR'rP *"RE.S,PO*N*SE .
Task'*Stan:dafd:. Emergency Borationflow ~30 GPMwith Charging flow ~30. GPM
. ", . .
. ' . ' .
.. ', :.'
. '. .
'. Required Materials; General References: .  * EPP*.O:04*, REACTOR* TRIP RESPO,NS*E
    * ,AO*P'-D02,.EMER,*GE'N'CY. BORATIO*N
" . Handout:  'None - usesimulator.references
    .  .
I:nitlating.* Cue:  * . You are the control board-operator,
    * 'Perform EPP~004
    , .
    * *Anotheroperat'orh'asbeen*assigned to perform Step' '3,:Check '
RCSTempsrature
,Time"Critical'Ta'sk:'  No H.ARRIS*08 'NRC JPM:"aRevis:ion O'    NUREG,*1*O'2'1,Revisio AppendixC  Job Performance Measure . Form ES-C-1
  . Worksheet .
. Validation Time: 5 minutes
.HARRIS08 NRC**J.PM. a RevislonO  NUREG *1021 .Revision 9


Both independent examiners agrees not modified Changedtolevel (insteadofboronor pressure)2 distractors changed.REFERTO BOSS LAST HARRIS AND SUMMER 2007/2006.
AppendixC    . Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-.1*
Worksheet
    .SIMULATOR*SETUP
* Any tOO% .power '1 .
~ M'ALF to.: prevent two control rods.from lnsertinqenthe tri * CR*F**16a* 220.,0 4 .
*
  . .... .
CRF16b': 220 ..0. '27'
  . .'.  .
* ~hsure_. step countersarecorrect
.... lnltiate a'**.Mf(N UA~* M'aJn.Turbine trip .
  . ~  '. .. . ' "
".' '. -, ".' ',', '. . .' .
'.....*... Verify*Hnt1l.e:d1at*s.*actioh .,' conditiorisare met .
* .StabilizeRCStetllper:atlJrewifhin the required range for EPP,,004,Step 3
*. ". R.U*N **'CAE*P 1NRC'. JP'M.a
.'*:HARRI--SOS*N.RC .JPM.a: Revision 0    NUREG102t, Revision' 9


1/23/2008reviewedand determinedtobeSAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 79 H 2 XXU 012A2.04Kindof MatchesKIA.Not SRO only DistractorsAandBarenot plausible (theyarethe same).TheKIA asksforthe impactontheRPS,andthe distractors stateRXtripornot tripped.Whilethisisan indirect resultofthelossof power the effectonRPSis nothing.This is really a question of whatisthe impactonalossofadcbus.
Appendix C      Page 4 of9  Form ES-C-1
      'PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Den.ote Critical Steps with. a check mark)
. ; '  . . .
START *-,TI*ME.:.
EP'P-004, Step.. **1
      .  .
    . . ,-  .
. .P erformance StE!P:*~.1   Implement Function Restoration Procedures As Require * Reviews Critical SafetyFunctions on plant computer screen.*
      * May inform U~CO~h.at none appl . . " .  . "':  .  .
. **Evalu.ator**:Cu:e*::  Acknowledge, asnecessar .'. ' . . . ' . .
.. .' . . . '.' . .
Evaluator.. Noter. .'  .The applicantmay .jle.ri"odica*lIy review Critlca! 'S"afety
    '. .' Functionsand ,FOLDOUT criteria, None" applies' 'in this JP* . . . ' .
.  .
- .Comrnent: .
    .. Ep:P~.004,. *Step*2 Performance Step: 2 . .. EvaluateEAL Network Usinq.EritryPolnt ',', ' ... " .... , . . . . . "
Standa~d:  .
    . *lnform.sUSC.O/SS.*O*.*
    .  .
Evaluator Cue:  .Acknowledge, as US*CO . ,or.S:SO*.
. .  . . '  ~
HARRISOS' NRC J*P*M  a RevisionO    NUREG 1021, Revisions


Try writing the questionwithoutthetripornotrip.
Appendix 'C    Page**5*of9  Form ES-C-1
    . .
  *PE*R.FORMAN:CE**I NF*ORMATION
  ~PP-004'" Step 3'
Performance . Step: 3 : Ch~ck.*.RCS* Temperature:
Standard;  *Ack~*lowle.dge.that,perlnltial Condltlons, another operator is'
  .performinqthis task, Comment:*
  . EPP-004~* Step4
'.. Performance-Step: 4-* Oheck RCp* Status:
  ...**. Checl<RCP's- atleastonerUnning* .
.*Standatd.:.  . veriftes*allfhreeRCP'srunning; .
.  . :**.EPP.~O(J4*.~*:*$te.p '5.'. .'
Performance step: 5. ... . Ch~ckFeed:s~st~m Status:.  ..
  .* . .RCStemperature-J.ess than 564 *F
  ..*. Verifyfeed "reg' *valve.s*.-*.SHUT .
    . .. .. " , .
Ii . Oheckfeedflow toSrs's ..... greater than210 KPH
  : . . .. . . . '  . .
. Standard;  ., * *. Verifies RCStemperature indication lessthan564 * F .
    *{YE:~).**  -, .
  * *.Verifieseach Feed Req.Valve indicating SHUT
  * Verifie*s:.:total'A*FW*,flow gre:aterthan *2*10***KPH**
. Comment:
HARRIS08 :NRC JPM.a. Revision '0    NUREG 1021, Revision 9


BANK WCNOC 2007 NRC Both independent examiners agree.That question is unsat for reasons given.Discussed using different componentsintheRPS systemi.e.UVcoilor other component.
Appendix ***Page*6.of*9  Form ES-C-1 PERF.ORMANCE*INFORMATIO.N*
EPP-004,$tep .1 Performance step: 6.' Check control rod status:
    *. Check *DRPI -. available
    * Verify al! .control rod.s*~ fully inserted'
, *Stand*atd::  - DeterminesDfiPlavailable by indicating lights on AEP';1
    * Determines two rodsstuckfullyout
    * Takes RN*O:p.ath:tb AOP~D,02* .
  . ' .' . '
Evaluator-Note;  .: pplic.'ant' mayqo ,to, AEp:~t to' determine which rods are A
  , stuc .i*'  ' . '  '
    . . . ."
    , .
  . . AOP-002, Step 1 . . ..  .* . . ..... ..
  . V'~~IF'Y aBoric Acid {BA)',Pump*RUNNI*N .. Comment: .
  . '
  .AOP-OO?; '$tep*2**.a
.  , . .  . . . ,  .
. ,JPerformanceStep:8  '. E*S.TABLISH*':,boratiqn flowpa*th"*usih'g.' tCS~278 .asfollows:
  - .*-. OPEN1CS';278, Emerge~cyBoricAcid Addition. .
. . .' . . . . ..
  .    ,
Sta*'n*dard::'  .Opens'tC,S-278, Ernerqency: Boric Acid .Additio ,Oomment: .'
    .' "'\
HARRI S08 *NRC* JPM.'a RevisionO    NUR'EG 1'021, Revision 9


LOOK AT AGAIN LATER.1/23/2008 Changed distractorsCandD addedUVcoils SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 80 H 2 X X U015A2.02AppearstomatchKIA.
AppendixC    Page7of9  .Form.ES-C-1
      . .
    *PERFORMAN.C.E*IN*F*oR*MAT.ION A:OP-002,2*.b PerformanceStep: .. ESTABLISH* boration flowpathusing 1CS~278
    . . . .
as follows:
        .
    *e VE*R1FYat.teast 3*0**gpm*boric acid flow. to C*SI.P suction 6n**FI*~.1l0.*
e* GO. TO*Step . Stan*dard:
.. .... .. ... ..... ... AOP-002,Step4  . ... .. . . . . . .. ..
.. .. . Performance Step:  to VERIFYandM'AINrAINatleas130gpm charging f1pwtoRCS
    ..:.. (FF-J ~2J?~:.t.)"lJntii requiredboration is complete ' . . : ".:. '. " . .
: : *Stcindard.:  .Verifies .~*3:C)'*GPM.flow*in.dicated *onFi.-*12.2A~*1-~ .
. :* . Commentr
.  . . .
. ' .. ' .
    ' . -: . ' . '. "...
... T~rrriinatingCue: . Aftel:Charging floWi~ verified: Evaluation on this JPM is
    . complete.. ' .  ..'  .
  . . ' ..
-. . . . ' . .
.S*TO*P* TlivI:E: ..
. HAR*RIS08**N*RC JPM aRevision * NUREG 1-02.1., .Revision 9


What proceduredirectsthe operatortomaintainpowerasis.TheARPincludeddirectsthe operatortomaintainpowerlessthanP-10.NotsureitisSROonly.ThiswasanROquestiononthe Summerexam,anditisslightlymodified, (overcompensated versus undercompensated)butthereisnothingtomakeitSROonly(thereisanoteonyoursheettomaybeaddaTSbasis.
Appendi Paqe 8: of 9 . Form ES-C-1 VERIFI.CATIO.N* OF* COMPLETION Job PerformanceMeasure No.: .2El08 N:RC* J:P*M a Examinee's Name:
Facility Evaluator;
.. NumberofAttempts:
..  .
QUeSfiOn[)OCUmentafion:* .
. .
.**Q*ue*sfipn.:..:..
Response:'
.Result:** .  **SAT*
Examtner'sSiqnature:    Date:".
  ~-----,;.-~--~------.,............---,--~-----.....,.:.-: ------,.----,.--
  . .
H.ARR1S08NRC*:.JPM* a RevislonO . NUREG *1021 ,Revision 9


MOD Modified from Summer 2007 Both independent examinernoticedthat answer isopposite,butactionisthesame.Both independentexaminersagreethatquestionisUnsat,anditisaBankQuestion.
Appendix C*  Page 90f9  Form ES-C-1 JPM CU*E SHE*ET
*INITI*A.L.C.ON*DI*TIONS: *.. The plant was at 100% power when an automaticreactor
  . tripoccurreddue to an 'inadvertent main turbine trip
  . . .
  *. T~~ crew has .perfbrmed*PA-rH-1 immediate.actions .and havetransitioned toEt>*P-0*04,REA.C.TOR*TRI P RESPONSE*.  .
"... ' .
    . .
..1NITIA~TJNG* CU.E:* ., .* You are.. the:. control board . o perator .
  :. *petform:*:E*P*P*-OO:4:
    .. ' ' . ' . .
  .- Anotheroperatorhasbeenassignedlo perform Step 3,
  . :*C*heck*RCS::*Te,mper.ature  . .
, .  . .
. -
H.ARRIS*O*8.N*RC J.PM -a RevisionO  NUREG 1021 , Revision-a


Changed Stem and Distractors, look at again later to determine if question still has discriminatory value.1/23/2008ChangedasrequestedSAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 81 H 2 X U 016A2.03KindofmeetstheKIA.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.: 301149H601 Task Title: Align ECCS for long-term JPM No.: 2008 NRC JPM b recirculation (EPP-010)
KIA Reference: 006 A4.05 3.9/ ALTERNATE PATH Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:  Date:
Method of testing:
Simulated Performance:  Actual Performance: X Classroom ---
Simulator X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.


WhatistheimpactofthechannelfailingHigh,andwhat proceduresareusedtocontrolormitigatethefailure?Iknowthatthiswasusedonthevogtleexamin2005,andIreally don'tagreewiththe statementsthatweremadeastowhyismeetstheKIA.Butwillallow.ThisquestioncanbeansweredusingonlyTSentry conditionsandapplicability.
Initial Conditions: * A large break LOCA caused a reactor trip and safety injection
  * SI has been reset and CCW has been aligned to the RHR HXs
  * CSIP "A" and CSIP "C" (as "8") are running
  * EPP-010, Transfer to Cold Leg Recirculation, was just entered Task Standard: Recirculation flow established on both trains.


ThereforeitisnotSROOnly.Itappearsthatthe question assumesthatyouareinmodeonetobeginwith,butthisisnotstated.
Required Materials: None General References: EOP-EPP-010, Transfer to Cold Leg Recirculation, Revision 17 Handout:  Use Simulator copy of EPP-010 and ensure it is cleaned after each use or provide a paper copy.


MOD ModifiedfromVogtle 2005BothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.
Initiating Cue: Perform EPP-010. In accordance with the Step 1 CAUTION, the steps should be performed without delay. However, this is NOT a time-critical JPM because the procedure would normally be read to you.


Licensee made several changes to question appearstobeSAT.Willhave another Examinerreviewtoverify.
Time Critical Task: NO HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


1/23/2008SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.PsychometricFlaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 82 X X U 025AA2.02AppearstomatchKIA.NotSROonly,thisisjustentry conditions for procedures.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 12 minutes HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


DistractorsAandBarenotcredible.Tryusing variations from distractorsCandDalongwithactionsthatwould mitigatetheevent.NEW Both examinersagreethat questionisUsat.Forreasonsgiven.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP
* THE FOLLOWING STEPS DESCRIBE THE STEPS NEEDED TO ESTABLISH CONDITIONS:
* IC-19
* Substitute CSIP "C" for "B"
* CVC045, 046, 049, 050 removes CSIP "B" and installs CSIP "C"
* Insert malfunctions:
* SIS029 ENGAGED (Fails 1SI-340)
* OPEN 1CS-746 then CVC085 ENGAGED (fails 1CS-746 OPEN)
* Initiate a large break LOCA RCS01A
* Perform PATH-1 to transition to EPP-010.


Did not cometoa resolution to this question Large discussiononSRO (selection of procedures10CFR55.43(b)(5).
* Ensure SI RESET and align CCW to the RHR heat exchangers.


Plausibility of distractors still in question.1/23/2008ManuallyalignSIflowthroughBITSAT 3/18/2008 83H2 E 026AG2.1.27 Question appearstomatchKIA.Needtochangethe distractorsthatstate:Mode1 operations may continueifRCPcoolingis maintained.
* FREEZE the simulator and SNAP to NRC JPM b.


WhatcoolsRCPsatHarris?
* When Applicant is ready, place simulator in RUN.
Question does appeartobemodified.


BANK Sequyoah 2007 Made some changes to stem during meeting.Look at again after SRO portion changes are complete.1/23/2008 ModifiedReplacedwith 057AG.2.1.7 SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 84 H 2 X X U026G2.4.31QuestionappearstomatchKIA.AppearstobeSROonly.
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9


DistractorBisnotcredible,whywouldanyoneremaininEOP-10andperformactionsfrom anotherEOP?The applicantisinformedinthestemthatthe swapovertocoldlegrecirciscomplete,sowhywouldanyoneselectloss of emergencycoolantrecirc?Thismakes distractorsCandDnotplausible.
Appendix C  Page 4 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
START TIME:
Performance Step: 1 Obtain copy of EOP-EPP-01 Standard:  Enters EPP-01 Evaluator's Cue: Provide handout if necessar Comment:
Performance Step: 2 Read CAUTION statements before Step * Do Steps 1 through 8 without delay. Do NOT implement Function Restoration Procedures prior to completion of these step * SI recirculation flow to RCS must be maintained at all time * Switchover to recirculation may cause high radiation levels in the reactor auxiliary building. Radiation levels must be assessed prior to performance of local actions in the affected are Standard:  Reviews CAUTION' Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


WhywouldthrottlingSIflowincreaseCtmtSpraysuctionand dischargepressure,dotheytakeasuctiononthesamesump points?NEWBothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Page 5 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Performance Step: 3 Read Notes before Step 1
  * Foldout applie * CNMT wide range sump level of greater than 142 INCHES should ensure a long term recirculation suction sourc * The following sequence of steps to transfer to cold leg recirculation assumes operability of at least one train of safeguards equipmen Standard: Reviews NOTE's and may review to FOLDOUT item Comment:
Step Performance Step: 4 Verify both RHR pumps - Runnin Standard: Verifies both RHR pumps running by observing RED light ON, flow and/or current indicate Comment:
Step Performance Step: 5 Establish RHR Pump Recirculation Alignment:
Verify CNMT sump to RHR pump suction valves OPEN:
  * Train A RHR pump: 1SI-300 AND 1SI-31 0
  * Train B RHR pump: 1SI-301 AND 1SI-311 Standard: * Verifies Train A sump valves open by observing RED lights ON, green lights OFF on 1SI-300 and 1SI-31 * Verifies Train B sump valves open by observing RED lights ON, green lights OFF on 1SI-301 and 1SI-31 Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


80th examinersagreethat questionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.AddedsomeRHR parameters inthestemtomake distractorsmoreplausible.RemovedEPP-12 referencesin8andD distractorswilllookatagainafterSROportionofexamis complete.1/23/2008ChangesmadetoquestionasrequestedSAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.PsychometricFlaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 85 X U038G2.1.14DoesnotmeetKIA.ThisquestionisonS/GTubeleakage,notarupture.TheKIAaskforatuberupture.Youroriginalstatesthatitistied to 037G2.1.12.
Appendix C  Page 6 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 1.c
-'./ Performance Step: 6 Shut RWST to RHR pump suction valves:
  * 1SI-322 (Train A)
  * 1SI-323 (Train B)
Standard: * Places 1SI-322 and 1SI-323 handswitches to CLOSE
  * Vertty valves closed by observing RED lights ON, green lights OFF on 1SI-322 and 1SI-323 Comment: Critical to isolate RHR pumps from RWST as suction sourc Step Performance Step: 7 Shut low head SI Train A to cold leg valve: 1SI-340 Standard: * Places 1SI-340 Control Power O * Verifies ORANGE Control Power Light O * Places 1SI-340 handswitch to CLOS * Determines that 1SI-340 does NOT close by observing RED light ON, GREEN light OF * Goes to Step 1.c RN Comment:
Step 1.d RNO
-'./ Performance Step: 8 Shut low head SI Train B to cold leg valve: 1SI-341 Standard: * Places 1SI-341 Control Power O * Verifies ORANGE Control Power Light O * Places 1SI-341 handswitch to CLOS * Verifies that 1SI-341 closes by observing RED light OFF, GREEN light O Comment: Critical to isolate one train to comply with EOP BKG assumptions.


MOD Modified from another NRC test question that was not listed.Replaced question with one that matches KIA.AppearstobeSAT.1/23/2008ReviewedagainSAT 3/18/2008 86 H 2 X U 040AA2.05appearstomatchKIA.
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9


DistractorDisnotplausible.WhywouldanyonegotoSI terminationifthecriteriawereNOTmet?SI terminationcriteriaisROknowledge,and foldoutpagedirectionisROknowledge.ThisisnotSRO only MOD Modified from Harris 2007BothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Page 7 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 9 Check RHR Pump recirculation alignment - at least one train establishe Standard: Verifies both trains aligne Comment:
Performance Step: 10 Establish CSIP Recirculation Alignment: Shut CSIP alternate miniflow isolation valves:
  * 1CS-746 (Train A CSIP)
  * 1CS-752 (Train B CSIP)
Standard:  * Places 1CS-746 handswitch in CLOS * Determines 1CS-746 did NOT close by observing RED light ON, GREEN light OF * Goes to Step 2.a RN * Verifies 1CS-752 closed by observing RED light OFF, GREEN light O Comment:
Step 2.a.RNO
~ Performance Step: 11 Shut the associated block valve: 1CS-745 (Train B CSIP).


Another Large Discussion about SRO only.Will Discuss with Malcolm.1/23/2008MadechangeswithXferformEpp-14SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 87 F 2 X X U 068AA2.10AppearstomatchKIA.Thewholetopofthequestioniswindowdressing.WhichONEofthefollowingdescribeshowreactorpowerwillbemonitoredattheremoteshutdownpanelafterthecontrolroomisevacuated,andwhatisthe minimum emergency....Doestheplanthave intermediatemonitorsinthecontrolroom?Ifnot distractorsAandBarenotcredible.Iftheydoand the intermediate detectors are off-scalelowwhenthesourcerangefluxmonitorsbegintoindicatethenAwouldalsobecorrect.
Standard:  * Places 1CS-745 handswitch in CLOS * Verifies 1CS-745 closed by observing RED light OFF, GREEN light O Comment: Critical to CLOSE 1CS-745 to isolate miniflow to RWS Evaluator Note: Applicant may also CLOSE 1CS-753 as part of RNO although this is NOT required.


Distractors Band Carenotplausible.EvacuatethecontrolroomanditsonlyaNOUE?
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
NEWBothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.Removedwindowdressing.


Changed other portions of the question.Added siteareaand alert in distractors.
Appendix C  Page 8 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 12 Verify normal miniflow isolation valves - SHUT
  * 1CS-182
  * 1CS-196
  * 1CS-210
  * 1CS-214 Standard: Verifies at least one valve closed in each line (RED lights OFF, GREEN lights ON.)


Stillneedto determine if thisisa direct look up.With the reference for question 99.1/23/2008SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.PsychometricFlaws4.Job ContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOKLOD(F/H)(1-5)StemCuesT/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia
Comment:
#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation FocusDist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 88 H 1 XXX U 073G2.1.32Isthisaprocessradiationmonitor?IfnotthisdoesnotmatchtheKIA.
Step 2.c
~ Performance Step: 13 Open RHR discharge to CSIP suction valves:
  * 1RH-25
  * 1RH-63 Standard:  * Places handswitches for both 1RH-25 and 1RH-63 in OPE * Verifies 1RH-25 and 1RH-63 open by observing RED lights ON, GREEN lights OF Comment: Critical to supply suction flowpath from sump to CSI Step Performance Step: 14 Reset S Standard: SI RESET in Initial Conditions but may reset agai Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Distractors BandDarenotplausible.Whenwouldanyoneenter3.03foroneofanythingbeinginoperable.These appeartobejusttechnical specification entry requirementswhichisalsoROknowledge requirements.Notsurethishasany discriminatory value.The distractors with 3.3.3.1 entries are subsets, if you were in 3.30 for this reason you would alsobein3.3.3.1 MOD Modified from Harris 2007BothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Page 9 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 15 Manually realign safeguards equipment following a loss of offsite powe Standard: Reads continuous action and determines off-site power availabl Comment:
Step 2.f
~ Performance Step: 16 Shut RWST to CSIP suction valves AND place in pull-to-Iock position:
  * LCV-115B
  * LCV-115D Standard:  * Places LCV-115B and LCV-115D in CLOSE and then in PULL-TO-LOCK
  * Verifies LCV-115B and LCV-115D closed by observing RED lights OFF, GREEN lights O Comment: Critical to isolate RWST suction while aligned for recir Step Performance Step: 17 Check Charging System Status:
  * Check charging line - isolate Standard:  * Checks Charging Line Isolation Valves 1CS-235 and 1CS-238 CLOSED by observing RED lights OFF, GREEN lights O * May also check FCV-122.1 CLOSED by observing flow indication at ZER Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Table and Replace.1/23/2008ReplacedquestionandaddedreasonsforSROonlySAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo PartialJob-Minutia
Appendix C  Page 10 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 18 Verify Both Charging Pumps - RUNNIN Standard: Verifies CSIPs 1A-SA and 1C-SB both running by observing RED lights ON, GREEN lights OF Comment:
#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 89 H 2 XXX U078A2.01MaynotreallymeettheKIAaswritten.NotSROonly knowledge.
Step 4.a
"" Performance Step: 19 Establish Recirculation Injection Flowpath:
  * Open alternate high head SI to cold leg valve: 1SI-52 Standard:  * Places 1SI-52 Control Power O * Verifies ORANGE Control Power Light O * Places 1SI-52 handswitch to OPE * Verifies 1SI-52 open by observing RED light ON, green light OF Comment: Critical to establish injection flowpat Step Performance Step: 20 Check any BIT outlet valve - open
  * 1SI-3
  * 1SI-4 Standard: Verifies both 1SI-3 and 1SI-4 open by observing RED lights ON, GREEN lights OF Comment:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


The applicantdoesnotneedtoknowthe impacts becausealloftheactions are different.
Appendix C  Page 11 of 13  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 4.c-V Performance Step: 21 Shut CSIP discharge cross connect valves based on Table:
CSIP "A" and CSIP "C" running:
  * 1CS-217and 1CS-219 Standard:  * Places handswitches to CLOSE position for valves 1CS-217 and 1CS-219 (-V)
  * Verifies respective valves re-position by observing RED lights OFF, GREEN lights ON Comment: Critical to separate SI Trains during recirculation phas Step 5 Performance Step: 22 Verify High Head SI Flow:
  * Alternate header flow (Train A): FI-940
  * Normal header flow (Train B): FI-943 Standard:  * Verifies Train A flow indication on FI-94 * Verifies Train B flow indication on FI-94 Comment:
Terminating Cue: When the candidate moves to Step 6, Verify CCW Alignment
  - - - : Evaluation on this JPM is complete.


Distractor Cisnotcredible.
STOP TIME:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Whywouldanyoneisolatetheair dryer first beforebypassingorplacingtheotherinservicefirstthiswouldcausealossofIA.This questioncanbe answeredusingRO knowledge.
Appendix C  Page 12 of 13 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM b Examinee's Name:
Date Performed:
Facility Evaluator:
Number of Attempts:
Time to Complete:
Question Documentation:
Question:
Response:
Result:  SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature:  Date:
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Bank Harris 2005 NRC Both examinersagreethat questionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Page 13 of 13  Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * A large break LOCA caused a reactor trip and safety injection
  * SI has been reset and CCW has been aligned to the RHR HXs
  * CSIP "A" and CSIP "C" (as "8") are running
  * EPP-010, Transfer to Cold Leg Recirculation, was just entered INITIATING CUE: Perform EPP-010. In accordance with the Step 1 CAUTION, the steps should be performed in an expeditious manner. However, this is NOT a time-critical JPM because the procedure would normally be read to you.


Tabled (Not SRO knowledge).
HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Wrote new question SAT 3/18/2008 90 H 2 X X E WE04/G2.1.33 AppearstomatchKIA.Lookingat the proceduresomeoneisgoingtoaskdidwestopRHRA,andclose1SI322priortoleavingEPP-013?This questionneedssome major enhancements.Butcanbe salvaged.NEW All examinersagreeE.Discussed Changing KIA.Operations did not believe the 3.0.3 statements should be tested while In the ERGs.1/23/2008.
Appendix C    Job Performance Measure    Form ES-C-.1
      'Worksheet Facility: .  *HARRIS . Task NO.:301170H601 Task Title:  "Initiate ReS Feedand Bleed (FRP-  JPM. No.:' 20.:0'8. NRC JPM c H~"1)    .
  .\"
KIA Reference: E*O.S EA1.1 (4.1)    AL:TERNATE. PATH Examinee:      .N*RCExaminer:
. . . .
Facility Evaluator:    : Date:
.'Method"*of testing ~.
. . '. .    .  : ..
x
        ,'
Simulated Performance: '. --.-,..:. ,. ---,...;.;-_ . . ActualPerformance:
  .Classrco Simulator Plant
  . ',,:' '. .
*REAO* 'TO :THE* EXAIVUNEE" .'
./ will explainthe inltialconditions, whi~h steps.to simulate or:discuss, and provide initiating
..'cues ..':" Wh~n *yo.u**.complete-the task' successfully, the objective for.thls Job Performanc MeasurewiH be satisfie ". '..' . '> . . '. . . * ...* .*.. ,' ' ", . . * . . ...*...... .'
. Initial Conditions:  -ThereactortrippedJrom fOO%powerdue to a loss ofoff-site
    . *power~..   .  .
  . '-' .ASBLbCA occurred following' the* reactor tri e' '.. Adversecontainmentvalues 'are in -. effect. .
  -Sus 1A-SAis'locked  out*on*anelectricalf~ul j- . Motor Driven AFW  PumpB" is partially disassembled for
    '. maintenanc .
      .  . ' .
  ..* The Tl.irbine,;,DrivenAFWPump failed while 'startin .* .The .crew is performinq *FRP._:H.:1*,.RE.S.:P.ONS'"E TO**LO$.SOF
    :*SECONDAR.Y HEAT*sfNK.. . .    .". .
  - TheFoldoutcriteda forinitiationof RCSFeed and Bleed' have
    .just been. me .  . '
    . .... .. .  .  .
Task .Standard:  .RCS~'feed' establishedwith maximum.availablebleed pat Required.Materials: Attach'PAT'H-1 .(3*UI:DE Attachment 1'.: tq*this.JPMfor'-use by the evaluator...
GeneralReferences:  FR*P-H.1*,RESPONSE* TO*.LOSS*OF SECONDARY HEAT SIN.K, Revision 21 ..
*HAR.RIS 2008* NRC'JPM C Revision O'      *NUREG 1'021*, Revislons


ChangedKAto WE04EA1.3new question SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOKLOD(F/H)(1-5)
.Appendix C'  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 .
Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation FocusDist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 91 H 1 X X X U WE06/G2.1.2AppearstomatchKIA.NotreallySROonlyknowledge
Work*sheet Handout: . Use Simulator ccipy*ofFRP-H.1.andensure*it is cleaned after each use
..Withcoreexit thermocoupleslessthan730 degreesF,noentryisevermadeintoC.1.
  .orprovide a paper cop . .
Observe.the 'procedure CAUTION prior to FRP-H.1 ,.Step 1'2,. then initiate RC.*S.*feed and blee .
Time *C*dtical.* Task:*
.Validation Time: 8 minute " "-
. HARRI.S2*OO.8.*:NR*C: JP.M* cRevision 0 . NUREG'1 021*,. Revision 9


Therefore distractorsAandCarenotplausible,andwithC.1andC.2theonlychoicesmostoftheconditionsinthestemarewindowdressing.
Appendix C'  JobPerformanceMeasure
    'Worksheet
  .'.. SU't1U.LAT,OR SET.U.P*
* -Atpower Ie*
  ' . .
* Tag *M.DAFWPumpuB" .
.e ':MALF 'for art electricalfault to.lock out.Bus 1A-SA'
e MALF to trip .T*DAFW Pump durlng.AUTO*.start
  . . .
e Overrides to' blo'ck'MA'"NUAL **QP*EN.orf P.CV-44SA.an*d.:PCV-444*S*
. .. . Loss ofOff-site power
.  .
    . . .
*e -:'Peiiorm **PAT.H-*1- .  . ~ .' .
e*' . Perform EPP~4" .
.... .:SBL()CAaJter e*ntedngH~P-H;1 to get toadyetsecontajnrnenfv~lues;
'HARRIS200a'NRC JPMc.Revision '0


Whatmakesthe distractors thatisolatethePORVsplausible?TherearenoindicationsofthePORVslifting,sowhywouldanyoneisolatethem?RO'sneedtoknowCSFentryconditions,andwithno indicationsofPORVproblemsother distractorsarenotcredible.
Appendix C'    P*ag.e 4 of 10 . Form ES-C-1
  .PERF()RMANCE' INFORMATION (Denote Critic at Steps'.with a. 'check .,nark): .
START TIME:
FRP*:H;1,Step12*  . .
. Procedure CAUTION: Perform Steps *1.-2. throuqhZ! .C1uickl*y to 'establish **RCS heat removalby :RC*S**:*bl*eed* 'and fee Verify *AII Reps'...*STOP*PED .
All RCP;s stopped  on LOOP.****
Co*mrrl'ent:..
  . '.' . .'.'.:'.' -. :: ... :..
.. ' . . ." .*ERP~H.t Step 13 . '
" ' . . .
.Performance.Step; 2* '-:' Actuate .SL**
  . .,' .",  : .. ' .
VerifiesSI'actualed...' .....
'. .
'. Comment: .
FRP,-H.'1,Step1'4 .
  ~~:rF~~6~~6:~~kFOLLOWING:    . .'
  * '.* \lERIFYpSIPS"AT LEASTONERUNNING; .
  .* VE.RIFY:*SI,**VAL.VE*S*~*.*PROPERLY*.AL.IG*N:ED  .. (REFE .' TO-. PATH*-*1*,(3UID:E., ATTACHME*NT 1) .'
  .* Verifie~**:C&sect;J.P.:uB~':: runnlnq. (R.~:p**tig*hts}  .
  '. .Verifies valvealigrllTlent using Guide 1,Attachment1, and/or verifles flow indicationon the Sl.Flow meter .
  . .' .  :., . : . ' .
Guide 1,Attachmenf1 has been performed. Alignment is
  *co.rrecffortlle current.powersltuatlo .
    .    .  .
    :.'  . . ..... .
  .    . .
    . ~  ..
Evaluator Note: . Only Train**"B'f*is*.operable~ no.' power to Train "A".


BANK BVPS 2007 NRCBothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.ModifiedQuestionappearstobeSAT.
HARRIS* 2008 NRC' JP*M* c Revision 0      N.UREG 1021-., Revision 9


1/23/2008SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 92 H 2 X X X UWE10/EA2.1AppearstomatchKIA.
Appendix C*    Page 5 of 10 . Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INF:ORMATI.ON Comment:
  *FRP-H~:1-*,* Step:*1*S
:*v . Performance-Step: 4  ResetS .' .". ..". "." "... ",
    * " 0 '  *
    .  .  .
. ." . " .  . . " .  . '. . ' . .
**Sta*.nda*rd:*. . . Places both Sl Train RESET:Switche*s.*in RE*SET and
  ... releases. <">-  . .
    ..  .
  * .Verifies RES.ETan* Bypass Permissive Panel
      ".  . .
    . . . . .
.**:.C*om'ment: ... . . Criticalto allow operator *co~trol* of equipment/slqnal .. .. . :... . :..
  .. FR*P*-H.. 1..~*.*Step~:1.6.**..  . ...
,perf~rmarice'St~p:5 "MANUALLY~EAUGNSAFE-GUAROSEQUIPMENT
  .. *P*O.LLOW*IN:<3* A LO*SS***O*F:.Of.=*.F:'*S**ITE.** POWER*..
  (REFERTOPAtH~tGUIDE,  ATTl\eHMENT 2.)


Distractor 8 isnotplausible,thereareno indicationsofafaultedsteamgenerator.Twoofthechoicesstartwithtransitions.TheothertowshouldstartwithremaininEPP-05andrepressurizethe ReStominimizevoidgrowth,etc.Itis difficult to determineifthequestionis attemptingtoshowthatavoidispresent.With pressurizerleveltrendingupslowly an operatorcouldbelievethatchargingflowwas adequatetomake pressurizerlevelrise.(Ididnotthinkthattherewasavoid,butsomeonecouldlook at pressurizerlevelandthecooldownandclaimthatAwasacorrectchoice,IftheentryintoEPP-06usbasedonthecooldownratethenthisisROknowledge(entry conditions for procedure)unlessitisonlystatedinthebodyoftheEPP-05.
Sta.n.da.r.ct : .
  .  .
',' , , ' " " 'FRP:'H:f;Step17 ' '
':v "Perform~u16eSfep:6" " ,Reset. Phase AAND PhaseB'lsolation Signal ,.. ,Standard:' .' PlacesTrainA" andTrairrBtPhase "A'iRESET Switches ih'RESET'al1d releases, N) , ",
  ..*.. ****Places.*Tra*in "A'" andTrain "B" Phase "-B"-RE*SET S*witches
    . :in**RESE*T*:ai1d*:rele:as8s*.* .
  . FR:P~H~*1.~Stept8
*1***. PerformanceSteprr  Ene:tgize**AC**Suses* tA1A*N*O:*1* *Stanliard*:*  *.. . Enerqizes Bus 1*B:t:by. closinqthecross-tie from thevital
    **bus.*    .
  . . .
*HA*RR'IS.*.2008 *NR.C:J*P.M c RevisionO .


BANK Harris 2005 NRCBothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Page 6 of 10  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION
  * No power available to 1A Comment:
FRP-H.1, Step 19
~Performance Step: 8 Establish Instrument Air AND Nitrogen To CNMT:
a. Open the following valves:
  * 11A~819
  * 181-287 b.Place air compressor tAand 1 B:i~ the local control mod (Refer to PATH-.1GUIDE, Attachment 5.)


Reworked DistractorsandStemappearstobeSAT.Willhave another examiner review.1/23/2008 SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOKLOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia
Standard: * O*pens*1IA-819(~)
#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation FocusDist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 93H2 X U WE11/EA2.2 AppearstomatchKIA.Doesnot appeartobeSROonly.
  * ()pens1SJ-287 (-V)
  * "Dispatches an AO to place .1A and .1 BAir*Compressors in'
the LOCAL Control Mod Booth .Operator Cue: Acknowl~dge'assignmentthenactuatethe ET to place 1A andt B *Ah"* compressors in the LOCAL Mode and, report bac Comment: Critical to supply air toPRZR PORV's.


Questioncanbe aswered using systems knowledgeandGSF entry conditions.
HARRIS 2008 NRCJPM c Revision 0  NUREG'1021,Revision 9


Distractors BandDwouldmemore plausibleifwasstatedtoreduceEGGSflowtothe values required in attachment1of EPP-012.Suggest putting the procedurefirstandthe actions second,ie,remainin EPP-012andstopall pumps taking a suction fromtheRWST.Remainin EPP-012andreduceEGGSflowtothevaluelistedin attachment 1.BANK WCNDC 2007 NRC Both examinersagreethat questionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
AppendixC,    Page 7 of to  Form ES-C-1
    ,PERFORMANCE,INFORMATION FRP-H.1, Step20 .  .
-v , PerformanceStep: 9  'ESTAB.LrSH**RCS BLEED.PATH*:  ' .
  . ESTABLIS:H lWO ReS: BLEED 'PATHS LISTED. IN*. TABLE 2 BY PE*RFO'RMING,*!.HEFOLLOWI:NG FOR EAC'HBLE'ED PATH:
    . . '  .
    * VE:RIF)~\P.RZ.*PQRV* BLO.CK VALVE - OPEN'..
    '.O*PE:N 'PRZ PORV~
    *. .Eval*.u*ate.EA*L. network usinq entry, point .. .  .
.Standard: :  *... \/erifiesHC':'115 andRC.:.117 indicate OPEN (RED light)
  *. ', ,*No:*,iti*dicalio*n:for**R.C--1*1:3
  .*... *Op*ens .*PCV-44~*~* (1)"
  .', :,*In-forms,.*ShiftS:up.erintendent:to evaluateEat.network using
    ..'entry"poi'h.t.:U*** -.
    . '. " ", ..
    . . .  .
  " ' .
    ~  . ' . , . . '
.EvaluatorOue:
. " .... - ...
  . ....: Fhe tastknownposltlon for *RC-113* was .OPEN*~..
  * . As Shift 5 uperi ntendent, acknowledqe direction to .
    .evaluate fhe,EAL.*.n*etWo'.rk. ustnq entry.pointU: ,
. . .' . ' ,
  . .  . .  .
. . '. .  . .  .
'. Evaluator Note:' ' ,O*n.l.y *P*GV-44513~*.Will**o.pe.n .. Th*e.. applicantshoul..d attemptto o,p*~n.*a*lf~PRZ:,*p6R"' .,' .
  . C"itjcaltoe~tablish the available PORV bleed pat .FRP~H.t,Step 2La(ALTERNATEPATH.begins)* .
"Performance St,ep*:*.*:1 O* VerifyAdequate RtrS *~leed**Path:.  . .' .
  'Chetk.:.PRZ* P()RVs*AND* .associatedblockvalves .. *lWO* BLEED:'.
  .;P*ATHS. *OPE*N*.
RNO a. GO TO Step 21 Sla'lidard:  ...*. "..Determinesonlyone PRZ PORV'is OPE..N~
  .' . . Proceeds to' *RN*().*
*C.omment:
NUREG 1,02'1', Revisions


Examiner does not believe that thisisSRO only knowledge.
Appendix : Page Bot- to,..  *Form ES-C-1 PERFORMAN'CE IN:FORMATION
  *FRP-H.l,.$tep. 2.1.c .
" .Performance-Step:
. . . 11 Open *a*It*Res vent valves to commence ventinq: .
  '*. *.1RC~900
  ., l' RC:"901
  * **tR*C-902
  *. *1-R*C:-903
  .*. :lRC-S04 e.' :JR*C-90.S*
Standard:' Opens: .'
  '.. 1.R*C~9 ..
    . .
  *. ..-.t:RC*~903*:* .
    .~:.. ~. ': : ..
  . * '. '1 RC~905>:'
  .. . . .. . . . ': . ". . ': . ., :., '.0:" .
JiOp()Wer~vailabl(ft01RC~9bol'1RC-902,.1,RC~90 .  .
* ,EvaluafotNote: , Thereis criticalto~stablisl1thelnCl){I~umavailablebleed' pat . .'
. Cornment:
T~rmin~tingCue: , '
l*
. . .
HARR.lS2008NRC*:-J*P*M: C'*Revision O*    N.UR*E.G** *1'021-, Revision 9


Will have Malcolm look at question and decide fate.1/23/2008 Left questionasisSAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychom etric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 94 H 2 X X U G2.1.20 AppearstomeetKIA.NotSROonly.
AppendixC  *P.age*g of.10  Form ES~C-1
    . ' ."
VERIFICATIO'N "OF COMp*LETrON* .
    . .
JobPerformance Measure No.: . :2*0.08:NR*CJPM c
.Date-Performed:
Facility Evaluator:
Number :.of Attempts:
.  .
  .. .
Time to.';Complete;
  . .'
  . . ' .....
'. **Qu*estion** Documentatiorr; .
.  . . .
Q uestion: .
. ' ..... -.
Response: . .
Result: . SA*T
  ' . ~
.' . . .:".'
. .
Examiner's Signature':    Date:
HARRIS 2008 'NRC' JPM' c Revision 0"  NUREG*1 02'1,. Revision 9


Answered from foldoutpage.ThisisRO knowledge.WithRCPsrunningcouldyoureachthe conditionslistedin current plant conditions?
Page*1O' of to  Form ES-C':'1 JPM CUE SHEET
ARCS temperatureat520andthe otherloopsat550?Thisdoesnotseem plausibletome.(With pumpsrunningthiswouldallbemixed).
  * The reactortripped.. from :-1'00'% .power -. due:to.aloss of off-
  . .sitepower. .  ' . ., . .
  * A, S'BLOCA 'occurred followinq the reactor trip...
  .* Adverse containment
    .  .
values are in*effe:c .'. Bus lA-SA. 'is 'locked'
    .
out on ari..electrical faul ' .  .
  *. Motor Driven 'AFW Pump "8'.' Ispartially disassembled for maintenanc . .
  '. The Turbihe-DrivenAFWPumpfailedwhile starting. .
  * ThecrewisperforrninqFfcp-l-l.f; RE*SPO.NS.*E.TO* LOSS
  .~
O*F.SECONDARY:HEAT.SINK*..
    ..' . ".' ' . . . . " .' . .' . '. . .. .
  .* . .The Foldout'criteria for initiationof RGS .Feed and Bleed
    .*h*ave.j~Js.f*been***met~**
      .  "
    .  .
  .. ' . . .: ' . .  . . . . '. . . .
FRP~tt1, Step 12, then
. . .
."'INITIArl Nf3****CUE*:* Observe the procedureGAUTIONpriorto
  *initiat.8.***RC*S*Ofe*ed*a*ndble*e.d*.  .  '.
1 ..
HAR*R.fS 2.0:08N.RC JPM*c Revision O    *NU*Rr=G 102'1., Revisions


BANK (WBN)byFJE Both examiners agree that questionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.:
Task Title: Respond to a loss of Normal JPM No.: 2008 NRC d Service Water (AOP-022)
KIA Reference: 076 A2.01 (3.5/3.7) ALTERNATE PATH Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:  Date:
Method of testing:
Simulated Performance:  Actual Performance: X Classroom  Simulator X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.


Tabled Question 1/23/2008 added actionstakenSAT 3/18/2008 95 H 2 X X U G2.1.34Kindof matchesKIA.Itwouldhavebeen betterforthe questiontestwhatwas exceeded andhowtogetitbackwithinlimits.Aswritten DistractorBisno longer plausible.IfRCS activitywentdown and secondarywentup,howcouldthe problem behighRCS activity?Withthe parameterslistedinthe stem distractorsAandCarenot plausible, becausenoneofthe secondary parametersarelisted.This questioncanbe salvagedwithsomework.
Initial Conditions: * Reactor power is 9%
  * The Main Turbine is rolling at 1800 RPM in preparation for synchronizing in accordance with GP-005, POWER OPERATION
  * NSW Pump "A" is under clearance to investigate excessive shaft vibration
  * CCW Pump "A" is under clearance while electricians investigate a breaker alignment problem.


NEW Both examiners agree that questionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Task Standard: Emergency Service Water isolated from NSW and Main Turbine tripped Required Materials: None General References: AOP-022, LOSS OF SERVICE WATER GP-005, POWER OPERATION Initiating Cue: You are the board operator. Standby to raise reactor power greater than P-10 in accordance with GP-005, Step 97, when the USCO gives the order.


Made changes to stem and distractors will look at final version when completed.
Time Critical Task: NO HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1    NUREG 1021, Revision 9


1/23/2008SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 96 F X X UG2.2.22AppearstomatchKIA.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 5 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Teachinginstem(applicableinmodes1and2).
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP
* IC-38 (Power <P-10, Main Turbine at 1800 RPM)
* Go to RUN on Simulator
* Start "8" NSW Pump
* Secure and tag "A" NSW Pump
* Start "8" CCW
* Secure and tag "A" CCW
* MALF to prevent ESW Pump AUTO start (PT:9101A 200.0)
HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


DistractorsCand 0arenotplausible.Filmboiling?Couldwecomeupwithsomethingdifferent.
Appendix C  Page 4 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
START TIME:
Performance Step: 1 Responds to alarms/indicatio Standard:  * Determines NSW Pump "8" has tripped and "A" is unavailable
  * Enters AOP-022 Comment:
AOP-022, Step 1 (Immediate Action)
Performance Step: 2 CHECK ESW flow lost to ANY RUNNING CSIP - MORE THAN 1-minute:
Standard:  Answers NO Evaluator Note: * Applicant may go back and perform Step 1 RNO Path actions (trip the running CSIP and isolate Letdown) if ESW flow is lost for more than one minut * Applicant may start "A" ESW Pump at any time after recognizing auto start failure (> 20 sees, no SW flow) in accordance with management expectations for operator action on failure Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


BANKBothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Page 5 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-022, Step 2 (Immediate Action)
Performance Step: 3 CHECK ESW flow lost to ANY RUNNING EDG - MORE THAN 1-minute:
Standard: Answers NO - no EDG operating Comment:
AOP-022, Step 3 Performance Step: 4 GO TO the appropriate step as indicated by the parameter LOST:'
Standard: Proceeds to Step 6 for NSW Pump lost/loss of flo Comment:
AOP-022, Step 6 Performance Step: 5 * CHECK loss of NSW Header due to NSW Pump FAILED or LOSS OF FLO * START standby NSW Pump as follows:
  * CHECK ANY NSW Pump - RUNNIN Standard: * Determines loss of NSW header due to loss of only available pump
  * Determines no NSW Pump running and proceeds toRNO Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Licensee to rewrite question.1/23/2008RewrotequestionSAT 3/18/2008 97 F 2 X X UG2.2.7AppearstomatchKIA.Withthewaythequestioniswritten,whywouldanyonechooseanyanswerbesides 0, especiallywiththewordsifrequiredasafetyevaluationhasbeenapproved?Distractorsa,b,andcnotplausibleaswritten.
Appendix C  Page 6 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-022, Step 6.b RNO
~ Performance Step: 6 VERIFY BOTH ESW Pumps - RUNNIN Standard: * Determines "B" ESW Pump running and initiates a MANUAL start on "A" ESW Pump (~)
  * GO TO Section 3.2 (page 30)
Comment: Critical to provide adequate flow to the ESW header AOP-022, Step 3. Performance Step: 7 CHECK Turbine trip required by ANY of the following conditions -
EXIST:
  * No NSW Pump can be operated Standard: Answers YES Comment:
AOP-022, Step 3. Performance Step: 8 CHECK Reactor power greater than P-10 (10%).
Standard: * Verifies reactor power < P-10 and answers NO
  * Proceeds to RNO column Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


BANK BVPS 2007 NRCBothexaminersagreethatquestionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
Appendix C  Page 7 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-022, Step 3.2.2 RNO Performance Step: 9 IF Turbine is operating, THEN TRIP Turbine AND GO TO Step Standard: * Initiates a MANUAL Turbine Trip
  * Verifies Turbine Stop Valves closed Comment:
Terminating Cue: When the turbine trip is verified: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.


Examiner to supplynewKIA.1/23/2008G2.2.2Questionreplaced,SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOKLOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia
STOP TIME:
#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 98 F 2 X U G2.3.6 Question appearstomatchKIA.The modifiedportionofthe questionisthetypeofreleasethatisallowedfromatank.AnNLOknowsthata continuousreleaseisnotallowedfromaWMT.The previous questionalsoaskedfromwhichtanka continuousreleasecouldbe conducted, and the WMTtankwaslistedasthetankthatthereleasewasnotallowedfrom.Notsurethisisreallymodified.MaynotbeSROonly knowledge,ifROandNLO conductreleases.Willhave another Examiner review.MOD Harris 2007 Two independent examiners stated question wasnotmodified, information was just rearranged.Licenseestill believesthatthismeetsthedefinitionofModified.Will consider changing.Tabled.1/23/2008Replacedwithnew question SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo PartialJob-Minutia
HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9
#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 99 H 1 X E G2.4.41 Question appearstomatchKIA.Givingthe applicant the referencelistedmayhelp answer question#87.Theonly differenceisthatinthefirst questiontheRxtrip breakers were openedfromtheMCBandinthe modified version the reactor was trippedlocally.Sowhywould anyone pick distractorsAandB?Willhave another examinerreviewto determineifitistruly modified.DistractorsAandBwillnot discriminate.


MOD Harris 2007 Appearstobe modified.If referencedoesnot answer any other questionsmaybeallowed.
Appendix C  Page 8 of 9  Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM d Examinee's Name:
Date Performed:
Facility Evaluator:
Number of Attempts:
Time to Complete:
Question Documentation:
Question:
Response:
Result:  SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature:  Date:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Tabled 1/23/2008Replacedwithnew question SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.JobContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOKLOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/
Appendix C  Page 9 of 9  Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * Reactor power is 9%
Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 100H2XX U G2.4.49 QuestiondoesnotmatchKIA.No immediate operationofplant systems, components or controls is indicated.NotSROonlythiscanbe answeredusing<1hour technical specification knowledge,withisRO knowledge.Willalossofoff-siteresultinalossofDC?Needtomakesurethebasis statements of distractorsAandBwillhappen.
  * The Main Turbine is rolling at 1800 RPM in preparation for synchronizing in accordance with GP-005, POWER OPERATION
  * NSW Pump "A" is under clearance to investigate excessive shaft vibration
  * CSIP Pump "A" is under clearance while electricians investigate a breaker alignment problem.


BANK Both examinersagreethat questionisUsat.Forreasonsstated.
INITIATING CUE: You are the board operator. Standby to raise reactor power greater than P-10 in accordance with GP-005, Step 97, when the USCO gives the order.


Added actions appearstobeSRO knowledge with basis statements and actions.Discussed with operations rep the plausibility of performing core alterations with a vital battery out of service.Licensee to check and will adjust question accordingly.
HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


1/23/2008 SAT 3/19/2008 I I ES-401,Rev.9Harris2008-301RO Written Examination Review Worksheet Form ES-401-9 Stem Icuesl T/F I cred'lPartialI JOb-I Minutia I#/I Back-I Q=I SRO I U/E/Focus Dist.Linkunitsward KIAOnlyS 7.Explanation 6.5.Other 4.Job Content Flaws 3.Psychometric Flaws 2.LODI,,,,I,,,I (1-5)1.LOK (F/H)Q#Instructions[RefertoSection 0ofES-401andAppendixBforadditionalinformationregardingeachofthefollowingconcepts.]1.Enterthelevelofknowledge(LOK)ofeachquestionaseither (F)undamentalor(H)igher cognitive level.2.Enterthelevelofdifficulty (LaD)ofeachquestionusinga1-5(easy-difficult)ratingscale(questionsinthe2-4rangeareacceptabIe).3.Checktheappropriateboxifa psychometricflawisidentified:*Thestemlackssufficientfocustoelicitthecorrectanswer(e.g.,unclearintent,more informationisneeded,ortoomuchneedlessinformation).*Thestemordistractorscontaincues(i.e.,clues,specificdeterminers,phrasing,length,etc).*Theanswerchoicesarea collectionofunrelatedtrue/falsestatements.*Thedistractorsarenotcredible;singleimplausibledistractorsshouldberepaired,morethanoneisunacceptable.*Oneormoredistractorsis(are)partiallycorrect(e.g.,iftheapplicantcanmakeunstated assumptionsthatarenot contradictedbystem).4.Checktheappropriateboxifajobcontenterrorisidentified:*Thequestionisnotlinkedtothejobrequirements(i.e.,thequestionhasavalid KIAbut,aswritten,isnot operationalincontent).*Thequestionrequirestherecallofknowledgethatistoospecificfortheclosedreferencetestmode(i.e.,itisnot requiredtobeknownfrommemory).*Thequestioncontainsdatawithanunrealisticlevelofaccuracyor inconsistentunits(e.g.,panelmeterinpercentwithquestioningallons).*Thequestionrequiresreverselogicor applicationcomparedtothejobrequirements.5.Checkquestionsthataresampledfor conformancewiththeapproved KIAandthosethatare designated SRO-only (KIAandlicenselevelmismatchesareunacceptable).6.Basedonthereviewer's judgment,isthequestionaswritten(U)nsatisfactory(requiringrepairorreplacement),inneedof(E)ditorialenhancement,or(S)atisfactory?7."Ataminimum,explainany"U"ratings(e.g.,howtheAppendixBpsychometricattributesarenotbeingmet).
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.:
Task Title: Place the Containment Hydrogen JPM No.: 2008 NRC JPM e Purge System in operation (OP-125)
KIA Reference: 028 A4.01 (4.0/4.0)
Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:  Date:
Method of testing:
Simulated Performance: X  Actual Performance:
Classroom  Simulator Plant X This JPM will be simulated in the Control Room.


I 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (FfH)(1-5)Stem Cues TfF Credo Partial Job-Minutia#f Back-Q=SAO UfEf Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 1 H 2 X E 001A3.04AppearstomatchKIA.Thestemstatesthedemandforrodmotion,andthecolumnintheanswersjuststatesRODMOTION,The demand willbeintheoutwarddirection,butwithrodsat216stepsandinautomatic,norodmotionwilloccur.Mayneedtoclearthisup.
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.


Otherwise SAT BANK WCNDC 2007 Enhanced SAT 3/13/2008 2 H 2 X U002A2.02QuestiondoesnotmatchKIA.Thisquestionasksreallywhat happensonalossof pressurizer level.NEW Developed new question SAT 3/13/2008 3 H 2 S003AK1.11Question appearstomatchKIA.
Initial Conditions: * A large break LOCA has occurre * Hydrogen Recombiner problems have resulted in a Containment Hydrogen concentration> 4&deg;A>.
  * The USCG has directed that the Hydrogen Purge System be placed in operation in accordance with OP-125, POST ACCIDENT HYDROGEN SYSTE * The Hydrogen Purge System is aligned in accordance with OP-125, Attachments 4 and * A release permit has been approve * The Containment is at atmospheric pressure
  * An AO is standing by to operate local valves Task Standard: System aligned with release in progress.


BANK McGuire 2005 SAT 3/13/2008 4 H 2 X E 003K5.03Questionkindof matchesKIA.Thereasonsfor distractorsAandCarenotasindepthasthosefortheother distractors.
Required Materials: Key for 1CM-2 General References: OP-125, POST ACCIDENT HYDROGEN SYSTEM.


WhyistheaffectedloopTave unreliable?
Handout:  OP-125 with 5.3.1.1 and 5.3.1.2 initialed.
BANK modified distractors band d.SAT 3/13/2008 5 H 2 X E 004K5.19 Question appearstomatchtheKIA.Alloftheresponseshavea numberinthemexceptforthe 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/FCredoPartial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S correct answer.Needto have a numberinitlike changingthepot settingfromone number to another.(That would increase boron concentration.


NEW Changed number of turns and distractor d.SAT 3/13/2008 6 F 2 X E 005K1.11 Question appears to matchtheKIA.DistractorsAandDdonot appeartobe plausible.
HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0    NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Whatisthe significanceofthe temperatureof345 OF?Whatisthe temperaturelistedintheP
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Initiating Cue: Simulate placing the Hydrogen Purge System in operation in accordance with OP-125. DO NOT OPERATE ANY EQUIPMEN Discuss indications that you would expect to see as a result of the simulated operations. Time compression will be used to report field operations and/or indications.
&Lfor placingRHRin serviceinthecool down mode?BANK Changed all distractors, and added temp and pressuretoall.SAT 3/13/20087H 2 S 005K6.03 Question appears to matchKIA.Needto make sure thatwith1-RH20fully closedand1RH30at 70%open flowwouldbe greater than 3750.Otherwise SAT MOD Wolf Creek 2007 SAT 3/13/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 8 H 2 X U 006K1.08 Question appearstomatchKIA.


With charging in automatic (normal operation)
Time Critical Task: NO Validation Time: 8 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9
chargingflowwillnotbeoffscalehigh.(Mostarelimitedto about150gpmat NOP/NOT.I understandthatanSIhas occurred,andRCS pressure is reduced,butI don't thinkFI-122-1willbeoff scalehighat anytime in automatic.


This makes distractorsCandDnot plausible.
Appendix C  Job Periormance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Enlighten me.NEW Changed distractorAto600gpm SAT 3/13/2008 9F2XU 006K4.05 Question does not meetKIA.This question essentiallyaskswhat 81 parameter isreachedandits coincidencetheKIAasksfor knowledgeofECCS design featuresandor interlocks which provideforthe following Auto start of HPI/LPI/SIPs.
Appendix C  Page 4 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
START TIME:
OP-125 Performance Step: 1 Obtain/review procedure Standard:  * Reviews Precaution and Limitations and Initial Conditions for the tas * Proceeds to Section Evaluator Cue: Provide handout for NRC JPM Comment:
OP-125, 5.3. Performance Step: 2 OBTAIN the key for 1CM-2, Hydrogen Purge Isolation Valv Standard:  * Discusses location and process for obtaining the key(s)
  * Proceeds to ARP-4 Evaluator Cue: After the applicant discusses the process for obtaining the key: Assume that you have the key for 1CM- Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM eRevision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


There is nothinginthis question that address this.BANK (Harris)Changed all distractorsandstem SAT 3/13/200810H 2 E 007AG2.1.23, I believethisKIArelatestoRx TripI stabilization-Recovery.Ifit doesthenthis meets theKIA.NotSurethat distractorCis plausible.Itwouldalsohelptohavethe procedure direction.
Appendix C  Page 5 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-125, 5.3.2.2
~ Performance Step: 3 At ARP-4A SA TURN the key switch for Hydrogen Purge Isolation (CS-3074.1 SA) to O Standard: Points out ON position for 1CM-2 (labeled Control Power Key Switch 1CM-2 H2 Purge Exh Valve) and simulates turning the ke Evaluator Note: Turning the switch to ON energizes control power for 1CM- Evaluator Cue: When the applicant goes to the MCB to operate 1CM-2, he/she may verify the control power light on. If so: The CONTROL POWER ON light is illuminated for 1CM- Verification of the light is not a critical tas Comment:
OP-125, 5.3. Procedure Note: If in MODES 1, 2, 3, or 4, opening 1CM-2 will result in entering an LCO for Tech Spec 3.6.3.


For example:A.The reactor is tripped, performanormal boration as directed by EPP-004 using normal operating procedure XXX.B.The reactor is tripped, perform an emergency 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCuesT/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q==SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S boration asdirectedbyEPP-04using AOP-002C.Thereactorisnottripped, manuallyinsertcontrolrodsin accordancewithFRPS.1untilallrodsareonbottomandreactorislocallytripped.D.Thereactorisnottripped,initiatean emergencyborationofRCSin accordancewithFRPS.1until adequateSDMisverified.
~ Performance Step: 4 OPEN HYDROGEN PURGE ISOLATION 1CM-2 S Standard: * Applicant should inform the USCO of TS requiremen * Points out OPEN position and simulates opening 1CM- Evaluator Cue: * Acknowledge report of TS requiremen * 1CM-2'indicating lights has gone from GREEN to RE Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


')BANK Sequoyah 2007 Added procedure direction SAT 3/13/2008 11 H 2 X X E007K4.01Question appearstomatchtheKIA.
Appendix C  Page 6 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-125, 5.3. Performance Step: 5 Locally, UNLOCK and OPEN the following:
a. 1CM-4 H2 Purge Exhaust CIV (Outside Containment).


DistractorAisnotplausible.If pressurewashighwhywouldyoupurgeit(itshouldbeventedasstatedintheAPP)
b. 1CM-5 H2 Purge Makeup CIV (Outside Containment).
Proceduresshouldbelistedwithallchoices,i.e.,ventlAWOP-100ordrainlAWOP-100andgivethe correctsectionnumber.Thiswillmakethe distractorsmoreplausible.Inthestemchangesecondbulletto:A pressurizer PORVappearstohavesomeleakage,andthethirdbullettoThe associatedPORVisolationvalvefailedtoclosedwhenattempted.


BANKchangedpurgetovent,andadded procedure reference.
Standard: Directs AO to unlock and open 1CM-4 and 1CM- Evaluator Cue: The AO reports: 1CM-4 and 1CM-5 are unlocked and ope Comment:
OP-125, 5.3. Procedure Note: IF the "Containment H2 Purge Filter/System High liP" (ALB-028-7-2) alarm is received, THEN it should be investigated and appropriate action taken.


SAT 3/13/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 12 H X E 008A2.08 Question appears to matchKIA.Ifthe actionsarein accordancewitha procedure,thenthe procedure shouldbelistedinthestem.In accordancewithAPP...
-'./ Performance Step: 6 START HYDROGEN PURGE EXHAUST FAN E- Standard: Points out the START position and simulates placing the E-4 Switch to STAR Evaluator Cue: * E-4 indicating lights have gone from GREEN to RE * ALB-028-7-2 is clear Comment:
NEW Added APP SAT 3/13/2008 13 H 2 X X U 008AK2.03Doesnot appear to meettheKIA.Thereisno controller or positioner mentionedinthe question.I understand that the indicationforthe PORVisinthe correct distractorbutthe question really does not address howitgot there and how itrelatestothe accident.(Althoughitisthe cause).DistractorBisnot credible, nothinginthestemrelatestoa SGTR.NEW Changedstemandall distractors SAT 3/13/2008 14 H 2 S 009EK2.03 Appears to match KIA.SAT MOD Changes made to question still SAT 3/13/2008 15 H 2 S 010k2.01 Appears to match KIA.SAT MOD No changes madefrominitial submittal SAT 3/13/200816F 2 E011EA1.15 Appears to matchKIA.Needtoadd design basis large break LOCA.There are some defined large break LOCAs where RCS pressure 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S doeshangup about 400-500 poundsandRCS pressurewillbe abovetheRHR shutoff head.(10,000 gpm).NEW No changes madefrominitial submittal Added design basistostem SAT 3/13/2008 17 F 2 X U011K2.01 Appears to matchKIA.AandBdonot appeartobe plausible.
HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Please explain what makes them plausible,orfind other suitable plausible distractors.
Appendix C  Page 7 of 9  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-125, 5.3. Performance Step: 7 VERIFY the following dampers indicate open on SLB-7:
a. Window 1-1, H2 Purge CM-B1 b. Window 2-1, Fan E4 CM-B2 c. Window 3-1, H2 Purge CM-B3 Standard: At SLB-7, verifies each of the following are RED:
  * Window 1-1, H2 Purge CM-B 1
  * Window 2-1, Fan E4 CM-B2
  * Window 3-1, H2 Purge CM-B3 Evaluator Cue: As each is checked:
  * Window 1-1, H2 Purge CM-B1, is RED
  * Window 2-1, Fan E4 CM-B2, is RED
  * Window 3-1, H2 Purge CM-B3, is RED Comment:
Terminating Cue: After the damper positions are verified: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.


MOD No changes madefrominitial submittal Used NSW pumps SAT 3/13/2008 18 X E 012A3.02 Appears to match KIA.Some teaching in stem"causing a reactor trip".There is more that youcandowiththis question.Rx tripped/bistables illuminated,Rxnot tripped/bistables illuminated.
STOP TIME:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


BANK Changed B distractorandratetrips.
Appendix C  Page 8 of 9  Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM e Examinee's Name:
Date Performed:
Facility Evaluator:
Number of Attempts:
Time to Complete:
Question Documentation:
Question:
Response:
Result:  SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature:  Date:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


SAT 3/13/200819H 2 S 012K6.03 Appears to match KIA.SAT Changed from original submitted question.Listedasbank, however with changesitisnow: Modified.2006VCS CHANGED Question SAT 3/13/200820H 2 E 013K3.03 Appears to match KIA.Changed from original submitted question.Will both 1-CB2and6beingopen cause a release?IfsothencouldBbe correct?Listedasbank, however with changesitis 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S now: Modified.2007 VCS CHANGED Question SAT 3/13/2008 21 H 2 X U 015AK1.05 Appears to match KIA.WhichloopisRCP1Cin?I assumedloop3.WhywouldDeltaTremainthe same be plausiblewiththelossofan RCP?BANK No changes madefrominitial submittal Changed questionloop1and3, correct values added.ChangedtoRCS flows.SAT 3/13/200822H 2 E 016K3.03 Appears to matchKIA.Add steam dumps will receive an arming signalto"A" distractor for symmetry.Questionwillthenbe SAT NEW No changes madefrominitial submittal made changes as requested SAT 3/13/2008 23H2 S 017K6.01 Appears to matchKIA.Made changes to original submitted question.SAT BANK CHANGED SAT 3/13/2008 24 H 2 E 022AA1.01 Appears to matchKIA.Made changes to original submitted question.Please explain.differencebetween AH-3 and AH-4;How many fansetc.This question is worded much differentthanthe original submittial.
Appendix C  Page 9 of 9  Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * A large break LOCA has occurre * Hydrogen Recombiner problems have resulted in a Containment Hydrogen concentration> 4%.
  * The USCO has directed that the Hydrogen Purge System be placed in operation in accordance with OP-125, POST ACCIDENT HYDROGEN SYSTE * The Hydrogen Purge System is aligned in accordance with OP-125, Attachments 4 and * A release permit has been approve * The Containment is at atmospheric pressure
  * An AO is standing by to operate local valves INITIATING CUE: Simulate placing the Hydrogen Purge System in operation in accordance with OP-125. DO NOT OPERATE ANY EQUIPMENT. Discuss indications that you would expect to see as a result of the simulated operations. Time compression will be used to report field operations and/or indications.


1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (FfH)(1-5)Stem Cues TfF Credo Partial Job-Minutia#f Back-Q=SRO UfEf Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S NEW CHANGEDExplained,andmodifiedstem.
HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


SAT 3/13/2008 25 F 2 E 022AG2.1.28 AppearstomatchKIA..Ifthe controllerfordiverttoRHTistakentomanualwouldthisbe consideredafunctionlost?Maybeweshouldsaywithoutany operator actions?NEW No changesmadefrominitialsubmittalModifiedstem SAT 3/13/2008 26 F 2 E022K1.01Question appearstomatchKIA.Someof the componentsofthis questionarethesameasthosein#24.TrainVRS coolerunit.Canwe change somethingtomakeitmore different.
AppendixC  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet
. Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.:
Task Title:*  Transfer an Emergency Bus to an  JPM. No.: 2008 NRC f EDG due to a .deqraded grid
  *condition (AOP-028, Attachment 2)
KIA* Reference: 062 A4.01 (3.3/3.1)  AL TE-RNATE PATH Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:    .Date.:
Method of testing:*
*Simulated Performance:    Actual Performance: X Classroom -"-------
Sirrurlator--.". '.... X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I wi I.!. explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating
.cues. When youcomplete the task successfully; the objective for this Job Performance .
Measure will be.: satisfied,    .
..
Initial Conditions: " * The unit is at 100%. power
  * The failure of a major line.resulted in the cascading trip of several units on the grid. "
  * Grid frequency is below normal. and the crewhas entered AOP-028.,
GRID INSTABILITY, and has completed Step 9 ~*Check for-
  " indications ofa load rejection. - _..- .
Task Standard:  EDG "8'" supplying. 1B-S8 Bus" and the Load Sequencerreset Required Materials: None General References: AOP-028, GRID INSTABIL~ty
" Handout:  Use Simulator copy. of AOP-028 and' ensure it is cleaned after each use
  .orprovide Q paper cop .. .
Initiating Cue:  Observe the CAUTIO.N prior to AOP-0*28, Step 1O,and then perform the proceduresteps, Tin,-e Critical. Task: NO HARRIS08 NRC JPM fRevision 0    .NUR*EG 1021, Revision 9


LikeSWflowsetc.
AppendixC  Job Performa.nce Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 9 minutes .
*HARRIS08 NRC JPM f Revision 0  NUREG 10'21, Revision 9


NEWFormatchangedonlymade.Modifiedstem SAT 3/13/2008 27 F 2 E 024AK2.03 Question appearstomatchKIA.
Appendix C  Job PerfotmanceMeasure  Form ES.;.C-1 Workshe:et SIMULATOR SETUP
,lC'-19 Bring,up'ERFIS DisplaYofAOP~028',.Attach.ment 1 parameters MALFUNCTIONS:
* PPI08 (59.2 'HZ)
,  '
* 'ZDSQ?2ATB ~ ,FAIL_ASIS (LoadBlock g'tv1anual Loading Permissive fatlure)
HARRlsoa' N'RC JPM fRevision 0,  NUREG 1021, 'Revision 9


WhatcontrolsborationflowthroughFI-110canthisbeadjusted?DoesFI-110scaleindicate90gpm?
Appendi Paqe 4 of 10  ; Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INF'ORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
NEW No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal.
START TIME:
AOP-028, Step 10 Performance Step: l ' CAUTION*
  * W'ith off-site voltaqe .or system frequency unstable, EDGs must *NOT.be paralleled 'w-ith off site power since severe .
load swinqs may occur and overload the' EDGs*.
  * . -,Loss **of .Service Water flow to an EDG requires the
  .affe.ctedEDG be .stopped:
Standard:  Reads/acknowleoqes Comment;'
  *.A*OP~028,_Step 10
-,P erformance Step; 2 '. C'HEC'K ANY EDG operatingparalleled to the Grid. .
Standard:  * Verifies" no 't=DG running 'and answers-No .
  * 'GO' TO'Step 1."2 Comment:
HARRI'S08 NRC JPM f Revision 0-  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


explained SAT 3/13/200828H 2 E 025AA1.20AppearstomatchKIA.Flowratesdonotreallymeananythinginthis questionbothBITflowsare500gpmandbothNormalcharginglinesare150gpm.Wecanleavetheflowsifitdoesnot help 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S answeranyother questions,butitisnotrequiredthewaythisquestioniswritten.(For instancewith2CSIPsrunningwiththeBITvalvesopenwouldnotflowbe greaterthan500?NEW No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal.
Appendix C    Pa'ge 5 of 1*0  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORfylATI.ON AOP-028, Step 12 Performance *~tep: 3 CHECK ALL of the' following parameters WIT*HINthe limits of the indicated ranqe:
6.9 kV Emerqency Buses - 6'550': to '7250* volts:
    * 'EI-6956A1 SA, EMER BUS* .A VOLTS'
    * *EI-69.56*B1 SB,..EMERBU:S
    . .
B VOLTS*
    * Frequency -.59.5 to*50..S Hz Standard':  DeterminesFrequency outsideof ranqe and proceedsto RN Comment:
  . , ' . .
  *AO*P*-028~* Step 12 ~N i '. * *
.Performance Ste:p: 4'" '. E*NE:R*GIZE theErnerqency Buseswiththe associatedEfxs per Attachment . . Standard:  ProceedstoAttachment . .
*Col11*ri1*ent:*
    .  .
    . .  . .
. ' ..... ' . ' .'. .:"
  .. AOP~028. Attachrnentz>- Step 1 .. . . ...
. Performance-Step: ~ ... D:ETE*RM.I N"E which Emerqency 'Bus is' supplyinq .power to.. the operatinq ..C:SI Verifies csu- "A" running -*Su.s .1A~SA.*
HARRISO*8.NRC JPM*f RevisionO . NU'REG 1021, Revision 9


completely changed question.SAT 3/13/2008 29 H 2 E026A3.01Question appearstomatchKIA.WithaLOCAinprogressandRCSat1600psighasenoughsteamenteredthe containmenttocausepressureto10.5psig?
.Appendix C  Page 6. of to  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATI.ON AOP-028,Atta.chment2 - Step 2'
MOD No changesmadefrominitialsubmittalmodifiedinitialconditionto600psig.
Performance* Step: 6 N.OTE
  * MDAFW FCVs will get an auto open signal (unless an AFW isolation signal is .present)*when eitherbreaker 1*05 or 1*25 open * Ona loss of power toanemerqency bus the associated
  .steam supply valve totheTurblneDrivenAftwPurnp wiU open'..
  *. This step' will cause CVIS isolation and render' both Containment Vacuum. Reliefs' inoperable (Tech-Spec 3.0~3).  .
Standard:  * Reads/acknowledqes
  .* Maytnformthe U*SCO
  .Acknowledge .any repor . : . . ". ".'
. .
. Comment; AO.P-028, Attachrnentz>- Step 2 . r
*vPerformanceStep: 7 .. . OPENthesupplybreakerto the ErnerqencyBus NOT supplying power totheoperating CSIP; . * .  . .
  * '. Emerqency :BuS .A~SA**to Aux..:B.LiS* D Tie Breaker t05
    .    .
  * EmerqencyBus B-S:B.~to Aux BusE Tie Breaker 12!? SB
  . "  ' .  ." . .
Standatd: ..O pens Emergency Bus B~S.B to AuxBus E Tie Breaker .125 S . . Comment:  Critical to start.EDG.*without IO'sing chatging**.
HARRfS.OS:* NRC JPM fRevision. 0    NUREG 1021, Revision 9


SAT 3/13/2008 30 H 2 S 026G2.2.22 Question appearstomatchKIA.SAT MOD No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal r-SAT 3/13/2008 31 H 2 E 027AA1.03 Question appearstomatchKIA.
Appendix C    .Page 7" of1 0  Form"ES~C-t PERFORMANCE INFORMATION
  *AOP*-028, Attachment" 2* ~*.StE3.p~*3*
VERI.FY the associated EDG" STARTS AND ENERGIZE'S the' .
assoclated Emergency Bu Standar * Verifie*s*.EDG*"B" start (Speed,Vo'ltage;Frequency)
    * VerifiesBreaker 126 closed C*omin:ent:* .
      ' . ~
.' .: ..... .: .' AOP~028, Attachment  ?'- Step* 4'"  .
Performance Step: 9 .' .VERIFY proper load sequenclnqfortheEmerqency.Bus being
  . .ENERGIZE;Dper 'O:MM~bo4~ Post-Trip/Safequards Review, Attachmentt . '.'  .
  , ' . .  . . .
    .  .
  . . .. . ' . . .
Locates..OM:*M~OQ4.:,Attach*ment -1.2 .... '
  . .": '. . ".  . .  . . .
'. Evaluator Cue . . AfterOIVlIVIL004;Attachment12 is located: Another operator
  ,will" perform.. OM*M~004, Attachment 1: .
Comment: .
    . .  . " . : .
      .  .
AOP':028, Attachment 2- Step 5 .  .
.*P**etform*ance**Slep.:'10* : CH E.CK the 'following'for the Emergency .Bus bein ENERGIZED.:
    .  ' . ' .
  .:.* B..Se.qu:en:cer Load Blocks *AlJTO ACT COMP~.ETE MAN'
LOAD. *P*E.RM ITTE.DJ~9*ht is*.~I: * .Observes the Load Sequencer. progress ontheElxs
    .. pane .
    . : '.  .
    .  .
  . *. Determines "B" Sequencer:Load Block 9 'AUT'O ACT
    :"C()MPLE'TE" MAN* LO*AD*P*ERMITTEDlighf is NO.*T *LI* .Comment:
HARRIS08NRC JP*M*f RevisionO .     NUREG1021, Revision 9


DistractoranalysisforBisincorrect.The setpoint adjustment,isthisa potentiometer?Ifitisweshould use lower/raise the pressure setpoint potentiometer.
AppendixC      Page 8 of 10 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP~02.8,. Attachment 2 ~ Step 5.*RNO
  . .  .
Performance St~p: 11  P*LACE. the applicable Emer Load Sequencer Manual Loading'
    . switches to PERM AND. CHE*CKthe followinq:
    * Load **S.*equencer -.8*'MAN' PERM 'Iight is LIT
.  .
-. Standard:    *. P.LACES,*.the u'S"":Emer'L'o'ad Sequencer Manual Loadinq switch
    . . ....
to *PERM~**
      . .. . .
        .
    * .. Verifies B MAN PERM Hghtis li "'. . . . . . ' .    .' . . .
., ': -'. .' .' . .' ~  .  .' .
'.. Evaluator Note: .'  **"fhereiSa1S()seCOnds time delay (from inltiatlonjbefore ..
    :MAN*UAL: Reset. lspermlttedby.theclrcult..* I.'f-th.e applicant
    .... attemptsa RE$E'T'''befbre that times out then' *:the*y.**sho*uld: . .
    :alI6w***.:s*ori1e:~addltiona.t-time 'and re-attempt.. If theycannot
    .accomplish .reset.wlthouta prorrrptor cuethenthat .
    . .constltutesfalture ofthls critical-ste ....
C~mri1ent:
    .  ' , .: ": . . . . ..' . .
    : ', '. ..... . . : .'. '., ." '. . ' . ' '..:: ' . '
.  .
    .  . .  " .
. .TermlnatlnqOue: .  ". Afterthe B::r\;II*AN:*.PE*RM light is "litt Evaluation on.thls JPM is .
    . ..complete. .  ....  . ' ..  .
,....  .: .:.
**:ST**Ofi:T~IM*E*:.".
HARRrS08'':NR'C J.PM f RevisionO      NU'REG 102,1', Revision 9


MOD No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal SAT 3/13/2008 32 H 2 E 029A4.04AppearstomatchKIA.Secondparto'f lquestionasksfortheactionrequired,butthesecond 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#1 Back-Q=SRO U/EI Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only Spartofthe answersarenotwrittenlikean action from the procedure, the distractors should state something like Immediately evacuate containment, or Immediately dispatch radiation protection personnel to determineif....MOD No changesmadefrominitial submittal modified distractors SAT 3/13/2008 33 F 2 X U 029EA2.05 Question appearstomatchKIA.Thewaythe questioniswrittenthe applicantneedonly knowthereasonfor opening the PORVs in 8.1.If the question was changedsothatthe applicant had to determine what condition the plantwasinandwhatwasrequiredbasedon those conditions thismaybe acceptable.Orwecoulduse variations ofopen1 PORVorBoth PORVsanduse someofthe reasons stated.BANK No changesmadefrominitial submittal.
'Appendix 'C'    Page 90f10  Form ES-C'-1 VERIFICATIONOF,COM,PLETION
. . ". .  . ' .
, Job, Performance Measure No.:  2,008 NRC JPM f Exarninee's Name:
Date Performed; FacilltyEvaluator:
'Number of Attempts:
Timeto :,Co'rn'pl~te:,
  .. ' . .
,
. . ' .".
. ' ". '0" ".".
'Qu:es:fion Docume,ntation:' '
Qu~stion:'
,Respon:se::,' "
    , , '\ " ' .
\,
I, Result; '    SAT UN$AT Examiner's :Sign~turE3: '  Date:
  -;;.:.....,.--------~--------
'HARRI,S:08' N'RC"JPrvlf Revlsion 0    NUREG, '102'1 .Revision 9


made changes SAT 3/14/2008 34 H 2 X U 033AK3.02Doesnot meetKIA.TheKIAasksfora knowledgeofthe REASONSforthe following responsesasthey applyto...The actions are acceptable,butthe question must cover reasons.NEW modified distractorsCandD SAT 3/14/2008 NEW No changes madefrominitial submittal 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 35 F 2 X E 034G2.1.14 AppearstomatchKIA..
    '. Page 10 of 10"  Form ES-C~1 JPM CU"E: *SHEET
DistractorDis not plausible.(Work would never get done).Needto develop another distractor to improve plausiblity.
*INITIAL*CO*N*DITIO*NS:* . * Theunitisat r.oo*%*power
    . .
  * . Thefailure of.a major line resulted in the cascadinq trip of several" unitsonthe grid
  *.. Gridfrequency-isbelow normal.and the crew has entered
  . AOP~028,:.~RID I~STABILIT.Y, and has completed Step 9 -
Check.for indications o.f:a.-Ioad*rejection*",- ~ .
  . -
  ' . "., .
    . . .
. IN*ITJATINGCU*E>.. . Observe the CAUTION prior to AOP~028,. Step .10, and then
  . .perform th*e**pto~ed*uresteps.~* ..
*HARRIS08* NRC.JPM f Revision 0  'NUREG'1021, Revision 9


NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal changed distractor D.SAT 3/14/2008 36 F 2 E 036AA2.01 Question appearstomatchKIA.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS  Task No.:
Task Title: Respond to a Fuel Handling  JPM No.: 2008 NRC 9 Building RMS alarm (AOP-005, OP-170)
KIA Reference: APE061 AA4.01 (3.6/3.6)  ALTERNATE PATH Examinee:    NRC Examiner:
Facility Evaluator:  Date:
Method of testing:
Simulated Performance:  Actual Performance: x Classroom  Simulator X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.


Whichtrain.Dotheynothave separate nomenclature?
Initial Conditions: * 100% power
AtrainFHBwillstart,AandBtrainFHB ventilation willstartetc.Thisisvery general.NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal Modified as requested SAT 3/14/2008 37 H 2 X U 038EK1.03 Question appearstomatchKIA.Notsurethatthereisa correct answer.The WOG does discuss the problemswithanRCS depressurization withoutRCPs,but addresses only operating onePORV,notPORVs.
  * All major controllers are in AUTO and no equipment is misaligned Task Standard: FHB Evacuated and FHBV properly aligned.


BandCcouldalsobe consideredsortof correct,asyou depressurize and loose subcooling,thereisalimitasto howfaryou can depressurize.
Required Materials: None General References: AOP-005, RADIATION MONITORING SYSTEM OP-170, FUEL HANDLING BUILDING HVAC Handout:  Use Simulator copy of AOP-005/0P-170 and ensure each is cleaned after each use or provide paper copies.


Typicallythestep states to depressurizeuntillevelisXX, Pressureisequaltoorlessthan ruptured S/G pressure, or subcooling is either10or20 degrees.Sothisisa concern.This question need some major revision.BANK No changesmadefrominitial submittal Modified Band C SAT 3/14/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 38 F 2 S039A4.01Question appearstomatchKIA.Notvery discriminating.
Initiating Cue: Maintain current conditions.


SAT NEW No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal SAT 3/14/2008 39 F 2 X X X U 040AK1.07QuestionAppearstomatchKIA..
Time Critical Task: NO Validation Time: 14 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1    NUREG 1021, Revision 9
Distractors CandDarenotplausible.NotsurethatBisatotally correct answer.While this statementmaybetrue,itisnotthestatedreasonintheWOGRev2reasonfornotfeedingthefaultedgenerator.Ifflowwasneededforcooldownflowcouldbeinitiated using guidanceforfeedingahotdrygenerator.Someofthe informationinthestemisnotrequiredto answerthequestionandmaybe teaching.Thisquestionneedssomework.


NEW No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal Made changes after discussion.
Appendix C  Job Performance Measure  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP
* IC-19
* MALF to prevent start of Train "A" FHBV Exhaust Fan E-12 start
* 5 seconds after the applicant assumes the watch, MALF to actuate Train "A" FHB Area Monitor alarm HARRIS08 NRC JPM 9 Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


SAT 3/14/2008 40 H 2 X U041K1.05Question appearstomatchKIA.
Appendix C  Page 3 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)
START TIME:
Performance Step: 1 Responds to alar Standard:  Enters AOP-00 Comment:
AOP-005, Step 1 Performance Step: 2 CHECK radiation levels NOT in HIGH ALARM:
  * Area Radiation Monitors Standard:  Checks RM-11 Panel and/or indication, answers NO and proceeds to RNO colum Evaluator Note: The applicant may start FHB HVAC Exhaust Fan E-12 at any time after the alarm is confirmed in accordance with management expectations for operator action on interlock failure Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


DistractorsAandDnotcredible.Mayneedtoshortentotwoitemsin distractorsvice3.Will discuss.MODIFIED No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 41 F 1 X U 045K5.23 Question appearstomatchKIA.DistractorsA,B,andCarenotplausible.
Appendix C  Page 4 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Step 1 RNO-v Performance Step: 3 If Radiation Monitors are in HIGH ALARM then:
  * Sound the local evacuation alarm and evacuate the area
  * Repeat the announcement Standard:  * Sounds local evacuation alarm, announces HIGH Radiation alarm in FHB, and for all personnel to evacuate the FH * Repeats the announcemen Comment: Critical to announce evacuate the specified area because the control room does not know if personnel are in the FH AOP-005, Step 1 RNO Performance Step: 4 NOTE: High area radiation levels may require initiation of the Emergency Pla * REFER TO PEP-11 0, Emergency Classification and Protective Action Recommendations, and entry point X for EAL networ Standard: Notifies USCO/SSO Evaluator Cue: Acknowledge any repor Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Why would anyone manually withdrawcontrolrodsabovethe 100%limit,orsetboron concentrationatthe1 00%limitpriortoaloadincrease?
Appendix C  Page 5 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Step 2 Performance Step: 5 NOTIFY Health Physics to perform the following:
Distractorsneedtobefixedoranewquestion developed.
  * EVALUATE ANY alarm received using HPP-780, Radiation Monitoring Systems Operator's Manua * IF necessary, THEN SURVEY the affected are Standard: Contacts Health Physic Booth Operator Cue: Acknowledge report and directio Comment:
AOP-005, Step 3 Performance Step: 6 CHECK ALL Stack Monitor radiation levels NOT in ALAR Standard: Checks RM-11 Panel and answers YE Comment:
AOP-005, Step 4 Performance Step: 7 CHECK ALL Process Monitors NOT in ALAR Standard: Checks RM-11 Panel and answers YE Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


BANK No changesmadefrominitialsubmittalQuestionrewritten SAT 3/14/2008 42F2 X U 054AA2.04 Question appearstomatchKIA.
Appendix C  Page 6 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Step 5 Performance Step: 8 REFER TO the following:
  * Tech Spec Section 3.3. * Tech Spec Section 3.3. Standard: Informs USC Evaluator Cue: Acknowledge repor Comment:
AOP-005, Step 6 Performance Step: 9 REFER TO the applicable attachment based on the affected area or system monitors:
Standard: Proceeds to Attachment 2 - FHB Monitor Comment:
AOP-005, Attachment 2, Step 1 Performance Step: 10 IF fuel handling is in progress, THEN GO TO the following, as necessary:
  * AOP-013, Fuel Handling Accident
  * AOP-031, Loss of Refueling Cavity Integrity Standard: N/A - no reports of Fuel Handling in Initial Condition Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Distractors BandDarenotplausible.Thesevalvesarerequiredbytechnical specificationstobeopeninmode1.Doesanythinghavetoberesettoregaincontrolofthevalves?Ifsoyoucoulddosomeiterationsoffofthisto determinetheabilityofthe operators to determineiftheyhave proper operationoftheafwpumpsandregulatingvalves.C distractoranalysisisnottotallycorrect,the MDAFW pumpsstartedonalossofthelastrunningMFWpump.
Appendix C  Page 7 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Attachment 2, Step 2 Performance Step: 11 IF Any FHB Spent Fuel Pool Area monitor is in HIGH ALARM, THEN VERIFY proper FHB Emergency Exhaust alignment using OP-170, Fuel Handling Building HVAC (Section 8.1, Auto Start of Emergency Exhaust System).


NEW No changesmadefrominitialsubmittalQuestionrewritten SAT 3/14/200843H 2 X X X U 056A2.12Questionkindof matchestheKIA.Didnotreallyaddressthe procedureactions.Stem(secondbullet)states:AnExtremeHI-HI....ThelessonmaterialcallsthisanExtraHI-HIlevel.Whichisit?Itappearsthatthe answerisonlypartiallycorrect.IfIreadthematerial correctlyalsothe1 Band 2Bheaterswillalsobebypassedandpowershouldbereducedto70%.
Standard: Proceeds to OP-170, Section Comment:
Distractorsshouldbe1Aand2A 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (FfH)(1-5)Stem Cues TfF Credo Partial Job-Minutia#f Back-Q=SRO UfE/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S heaters are bypassed reduce turbineloadto 900/0.1 A,2Aand1 8,28 heaters are bypassed reduce Turbineloadto70%.Andyoucoulddoan iterationoffof ReactorPower.The procedure reference shouldalsobeused.
  -OP-170, 8. Performance Step: 12 Initial Condition:
  * High radiation signal (100 mr/hr) received from the SFP Area Rad. Monitors (1 out of 12 coincidence on either train).


lAWOP-...orAR.
Standard: Indicates Initial Condition is me Comment:
OP-170, 8. Performance Step: 13 * NOTE: High radiation levels on Rad Monitor Train A (B) will automatically start EMERGENCY EXHAUST FAN E-12 1-4X-SA (EMERGENCY EXHAUST FAN E-13 1-4X-SB).


NEW No changes madefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 44 H 2 X U 056AG2.1.2 Appears to matchKIA..Cand Dare both correct answers.If natural circulation does notexist,(andfromthe indicationsgivenandthe procedurestepit appears thatitisnot)thenthe correct actionisto increase dumping steamfromthe intactS/Gsandinthiscaseit wouldbeviatheSG PORVs.Youcanalsotellfromthestem that heat is being removed, and nothing would be wrong with verifying that natural circulation existsinD.Thiscouldalsobe considered correct.Needto make one completely wrong,butstill maintain plausibility.
* NOTE: High radiation levels on Rad Monitor Train A or B in the FHB will secure and isolate normal ventilatio Standard: Reads/acknowledge Evaluator Note: The applicant may start E-12 at this tim Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9


BANK No changes madefrominitial submittal Reworded all distractors.
Appendix C  Page 8 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-170, 8.1. Performance Step: 14 * NOTE: E-84 may require securing from the MCC breaker if high radiation levels exist at its' control switch. (E-84 STATUS CAN BE CHECKED AT AEP-2 SLB-1 WINDOW 9-4)
  * CAUTION: E-84 needs to be secured upon receiving a FHB Ventilation Isolation Signal to prevent the potential spread of contamination through the Fuel Handling Buildin Verify E-84 is secured upon receipt of high radiation signal (1-4B1021-5B).


Question rewritten SAT 3/14/2008 45 F 2 S 058AK3.02 Question appears to match KIA.SAT NEW No changes madefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 46 F 2 S 059A3.02 Question appearstomatchKIA.SAT NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 47 H 2 X X U 059AG2.4.50 QuestiondoesnotmatchKIA.
Standard: Contacts AO to verify E-84 statu Booth Operator Cue: Acknowledge direction. Wait one minute and report E-84 is secure Comment:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM 9 Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9


There is no verification otsystemalarm setpoints.
Appendix C  Page 9 of 11  Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-170, 8.1.2.2-V Performance Step: 15 * NOTE: If the FHB Radiation Monitor spikes << 2 mi duration), dampers may not actuate due to the short duration of the high radiation signal. If this occurs, the fan should not be considered inoperabl Verify the following dampers and fans have properly realigned as follows: If a Train A high radiation signal was received, at AEP-1:
  * EMERGENCY EXHAUST FAN E-12 1-4X-SA ON
  * EMER EXH FAN E-12 INLET 1FV-2 SA OPEN
  * LOADING AREA ISOL DAMPERS FL-D35SAlD37SA SHUT Standard: Starts E-12 (-V) and verifies dampers re-positio Comment: Critical to align fan to radiation alarm interlock positio D Terminating Cue: After E-12 is started and@tmper position is verified:
Evaluation on this JPM is complete.


DistractorsA,B,andCnot plausible.Ifthereleasewillbe automatically isolated,whywouldyou secure ESW?InB,ifthereleasewas terminated, the radwaste operator would verify isolation.
STOP TIME:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


DistractorC,iftheESWsystemdoesnot connecttothe WPB whywouldanyone select this?BANK No changesmadefrominitial submittal Replaced question SAT 3/14/2008 48 F 2 X E 059K3.03 Question appearstomatchKIA.Needtoaddactual feedwaterflowtothestem.
Appendix C  Page 10 of 11 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM 9 Examinee's Name:
Date Performed:
Facility Evaluator:
Number of Attempts:
Time to Complete:
Question Documentation:
Question:
Response:
Result:  SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature:  Date:
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1  NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Someone could selectandarguethatBisalsocorrect.
Appendix C  Page 11 of 11  Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * 100&deg;A> power
  * All major controllers are in AUTO and no equipment is misaligned INITIATING CUE: Maintain current conditions.


Otherwise SAT.BANK No changesmadefrominitial submittal Made changes as requested SAT 3/14/2008 49 F 2 S 060AG2.1.32 Question appearstomatchKIA.SAT NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 50 F 2 X E 061G2.2.22 Question appearstomatchKIA.
HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1   NUREG 1021, Revision 9


Change DistractorDtoread immediately enter TS 3.0.3 andbeinhot....
Appendix C      Job Performance' Measure  .Form' ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility:  HARRIS
Otherwise SAT.No changesmadefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 51 H 2 X X U061K5.01 Question appearstomatchKIA.
        . .
    .Alig*n:,:CCW, tosupport.Rl-R lnrtlatlon JPM.*:N*o*.:    .2008:' NR*C .*h '
    . (OP*-*1.45....'  ,
.. KIA Reference:. 008 A4.0t(3~3/3.1') .....
        . ' . .
Examinee:*' ,      '. NRC* Examine . . Fa.cllit.y* Evaluator:      "Date:
  ' .  .
Method:-' ofte*sting:
Simulated Performance: . _'---.'~    . '. .... AcfuaIPerfQrmance:** x
  **:,d:la*ssrclo"': ,  .Simulator X.: ,.: . .Plant '
". ' .. .: '. ,.' , .' . ' ... ,.. ". : ....., . ','
.' .READ TO THE EXAMINEE ..
." willexpll.:linthEriniti~lconditibnsiWhichsteps*to-simulateorqiscuss,andprovideinitiating
*cue,s~.* :Wh.e.n you.. cornplete.the task.: successfullythe obJe*ctiv~.:.for:thi.sJob Performance Measure.. willbesatisfied. .    . . . ".  .'  .
    . . ."...  . "
, lriitlal Cortditions:  * .' Theunitisln Mdde4,goin&#xa3;ltoMode 5 .....'.    .... . .
    : .:~i:~;~~r:i~sUa:~j~;~fc:laceboth;trainsOfRHR -in service .
    .* ...' ,::CCW:.P,ump.,"A'; *is*.::ru'nnihg
  . ' .
    "..'.    .< .. .'. ......>  . ..
. TaskStandard:  .Two cew PlImpsrunnil1gandthe required.CGW flow rate> established thrqugh.bothRHR,HeatExchClngers .      .
Required..Materials: '.' Non .  . ' .  ' . . .
GeneralReferences;  OP';145,COM~ON~NTGOOUNGv\fA"rE ". '" . ' .
      . ' .
    . .  .
. -. Handout:  '..*. ' *OP.;.1*'4:5,. Sections 't-..O- .'. '. * .: OP:';145. S~ction~&WithlnitiaIConditions signed off
    *. ., *O.P~14.5:; . Section*:* ". .  .  . : . .
    ". .  '.  .  ' . . ' .
..Inltlatinq .Cue:  .Al,ign*.:C.CW* to. supportRl-R operation.in accordance.with Q*P-145,
    **COM*PO*.NENT COOLIN'G .WAT~R ... AU' Sectiorf*3.~.O.,.prere'quisite$ .are met.


With an increase in AFW flow howcanyoubesureifthe heat transferratewillnot increase?Youare changing 2 variables and anyone of these parameters could changed enoughinone directionmorethanthe otherandresultinan increase the heat transfer rate.Theyallcouldbe argued as correct or incorrect dependingonthe values used.I.E.averylarge AFW flow increasealongwithasmallRCS temperature decreasemaystillresultin an increased heat transfer rate.BANK No changesmadefrominitial submittal Changed format and reducedtoone variable.SAT 3/14/2008 52 F 2 062A1.03 Question appearstomatchKIA.
, '. HAR.R1SO,8*NRC jpM,.h*RevIsio*n 0'.       NURE:G**t021.,Revision 9


Distractor S C shouldstate...whenthe instrumentbusandPIC!!]Lenergized.
AppendixC JobPerformanceMeasure Form ES-C-1
  .Worksheet
  .. N.UREG 102"1", Revisions


Otherwise SAT.BANK2005 NRC-HARRIS No changesmadefrominitial submittal Made changes as requested SAT 3/14/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/FCredoPartial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 53 H 2 X U 063AK3.02 Question does not matchtheKIA.Whatarethe reasonsforthe actions.Whyisthe DIG disabledoranyofthe other items listed that were disabled.NEW No changes madefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 54 F 2 S 063K3.02 Question appears to match KIA.SAT BANK No changes madefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 55 F 2 S 064K4.04 Question appears to match KIA.SAT NEW No changes madefrominitial submittal SAT 3/14/2008 56 F 2 X U 069AK2.03 Question does not matchKIA.The relation between containment integrityandthe doorsisnotbeing tested.Questionisnot modified.Nothing pertinentinthestemwas changed.Removeifanyfromthestem,noneofthe distractorslistNo action is required.Recommend:
Appendix 'C  Job Performance Measure,  Form ES-C-1 Worksheet
WhichONEofthe following correctly describes the status of containment integrity and states the TIS action required?A.Containment Integrity IS met;immediately verify the outer door is closed.B.Containment Integrity is NOT met;immediately 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only Sverifytheouterdoorisclosed.
    'SIMlJ.LATOR S'ETU,P,
  .,' rC:* ... , ,
  .' ',Place LTOPS., in NORMAL arrdestablish feed with -AFW to prevent distracting alarms
  * Start both ESW, Pumps "
  . . -.' .
  , '.', "'lR"F' 'C:CW,073 5
  . ., ' .
  *." ,.-tR't=: CCW080:'O'
  ' . .. . .
, ,'.'
, ,',.", ,"checkFH352.tb~t'vVe,el1?850to8500GPrvt(pppro B~OO'GPMwith1GC~508'5%
OP',I;N},
. ~ *. '.' . .
..*.
,'HARRIS08"NRC 'JPM'h"';R'evision',Q'  NURE~G '1'021, Revision '9


C.Containment Integrity ISmet;verifytheouterdoorisclosedwithin1hour.
Appendix C     Pag~ 4 of. 12  Form ES-C~1 PERF,ORMANCE IN:FORMATION (Denote CtiticelSteps with<< check' mark)
    .Op:~*l45*
  .  .
. Performance :'Slep: 1> .  ':Obta'inproce~ure: .
    * . RevlewsSections.t.O'throuqh 4.0*.
    . *. ProoeedstoSection .* . *In.i~iafs*lnitiaIGondition. for .~.9(RHRSystem operation
..
.
'
.
.' .....". .
    - . .destred). . .  ':. ' ..
'. ' '. . .*.... ..' .....*
. ' .
  . . .
.EvaluatorCue: ., '.
.  . ' . .
.HARR1S.b8*. NRC.JP.M . hRevision 0.'    NUREG: 1021 ,Revision 9


D.ContainmentIntegrityis NOTmet;verifytheouterdoorisclosedwithin1hour.
Page'S of FormES~C-1
      .P*ERFORMANC.E* INFO*RMATION
          . .
    . *. .The purpose ofthissection is to ensureCCW pump runout
      .doesnot .occur.: Maximum flow through . one CCWpump is
      .... 1-:*2.,650: gpm~This .sectlonwllt ensure-that one CCW pump 'is
      .. notsupplyinq both.:essential.. coolinqloops andthe .non-
      .essentlalloop simultaneously,
    .* "Nbrrrl-ally it *i:s:*desira;ble to placeboth -, RH.R** cboli'ng trains in
      . operation.. *in :*Mode**4.ThiswHI*req.uire*.both;C.CW.pumps to
    . .*.be**iri* operation and one.trainof non-essential supply an ..
    . ".
      "return'''valves
      .. "
to be. shut ..
        .
        '  .
To~re\fentptJrl1PTUnolltwherj
  ' .  .
  . .
  . ProcedureCautlon:  . aligning* CCWflow totheRHR Hx,
    ...' v~rl.fY* flow :rate. to. theNon-essentialheader withonepum .: ,*run*Oi*n*g.*.is:*.:Je*s*s:than. 850Q**:9Pni, as' lndicate',d .on***Fi~652.1- (FI:-:
65~J }pridfto ope~ing 1CO.:147 (1CC-167).    . .
    . ~p.ER:F.C>Rrvt.:,the .*fblloWI*ng. to-verify total' COW flowrateis between,
    ..'. 7'850 ~lP:rrl:ari*d.*8::5.0.0*:*g.p.m:.**..  .' ,
      *. ' .J,F"*S-F:,P:*.2&3A:js.:in**servic*e~ THEN TH ROlTLE SHUT ..,
1**C:C;.S.0.8*,..*.SFP.:HX. 2&3A:**C*CW::Outlet. lsolation Valv .... <.IFSFP';&3BlsinserviC~iTHENTHROTTLE  SHUT *.
      ... *~1**CC~.5,2J*~:::S:F:P'HX~::2&*3B*::CCW:.O*utleflsolati'o*n.*Valve~
      :.... .,: ;.... '. . '.' .' " .
            ."
  . ' . .
Standard: .  .-. Det~rmib~sJIOw  at approximately 8200 GpM.....
' .  . - .," '...  .
......*.......... Performance Step:*  3:~ ~P~~~5ir1;~~26~RHRCOdlingare
    .*    lobe placed in service, START .
    :: the.::.$ep(~n*dO.CW*pump:*per .::SE?cti.6n.***5>2.*  . .
      . :,: ' , ' . :  . '. . .... .
proceed~ to S6c:tion 5.2 to start CCW, PumpB".


Modified 2007 NRC-HARRIS No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal Changed question SAT 3/14/2008 57 F 2 X U 073A4.02 Question appearstomatchKIA.Thelessonmaterialsuppliedwiththis questiondoesnotmentionanythingaboutRM-11 interfacingatallwith RM-23.Howeverallthree incorrect distractors haveRM-23listedinthem.(RM-80islisted)Ifthereisnot any interface/interactionthenhowcantheybeplausible?Pleaseexplain.
.' .-. . :
. .*S*tand~.a*rd,:*        .
... Comment: .
  .  ..
  . . .
. .HARRIS*O.a NRC*.JPM.::*h RevisionO'


BANK No changesmadefrominitialsubmittalModifiedbankquestion SAT 3/14/2008 074EK1.06NotsurethismeetstheKIA.Needmore 58H2 X U information.
Appendix.C .        Paqe 60f 12 .      Form ES'-C-1 PER'FORMANCE *'1 NFORMATION**
      .  * ** J
  . .  .
Performance..Step: .4  . Verifies' Initial Conditions
  . . ' .
. Standard; . ..'    Notes alltnitia! Conditions aresiqned...
OP-145~ *.5~*2~;2.1: .... " . . . . . . ". ....'  .
Procedu re*:N.o:tes:'"  .** . Startin~lthes.econdpumpco[jldcau~eAP fluctuations
      *.acr6s:s*::*.Rl:M~O:1 GG-3:*5:0"1:ASj\ (B*$,*B)*.~hich*:rr~*ay 'shut
      .sclenoid valve.s**1-CC~2*3.* and fCC:-4*b*~.      .' .
      . Ii* .*. *Startingth~s~~6hdpl1mpmaY9flUSe'ftOwoScillations which ProcedureOautlon: . .*.-:
    .  . . . *w~.~.:*,~.et.%.hjo;.;nl.h.e :~c~c;.:w*.1.:.*;p~. u:m*.~pe.: ~.R C~ru:n;.ond.; P.rnePg~.~a*.n :.~d;.ts*.fh'.~e .C cs:.* &#xa3;tU;a.en~d5*b:'..S*,. m~~pnclbe
      *.  .*    . .* .  *. ...


No changesmadefrominitialsubmittal Made changestomeetKIA SAT 3/14/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job ContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)StemCuesT/FCredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 59 H 2 U 076A2.01 Question appears to match the KIA.DistractorsBandDdonotappeartobe plausible.
Ph.uO
                .* .*:..
      .' capableof an .automatlcstart, ensure-a jnln'imurn flowrateof
      ******7SSQgpmexistsas indicated on FI;'652:1(FH553..1)*.lfboth
      . c&#xa2;W****p*u*m-,p*s:.*~*re.:rurtnlng,.O;Rthe.:.cb\f\l*tr~lins*ate.separated, .
      .. ::~          ~~er
.. *4 **Performanc&#xa2;St~p:5.. ... Althe MCB;'sTART CCW'P[jmp TrainB"S~(A:.sA)....
    . - . .... ..  . ...... ::. '. : .... : ' . '  : .. .' ...... .: :" .
  . . .
Sel~ctsCCVVPump:uB'L to start andreleases
".
  .' * t ,"
  . . ,~  . ",
. *S*ta*rid:ar,d:.* .:  . .* . .
'. .' " ' . '. '.:" .
. ' .. ". .  ", " .
E"allJatorNdte: ...
      "  * : * '. * **** *  * * * ~ * ;  * I *
    . Critical.bec3use twoCCWpumps~rerequiredto support two:RI:i:R.:T:r~*.i*ris. **a"'l:dottJ*erload~.*,*      ..
            'NURE'G *1021,.Revision*g*


Nothinginthe stem relatestoESW.Arethese systems normally cross-connect?
AppendixC'      Paqe 7. of-.t2  Forril.ES-C-1*
Wouldtheleak affect ESW in any way?BANKHARRIS2005 No changes made from initial submittal Rewrote distractors and explained.
        .' .
      . .PE~FORMANCE.I.NFORMATION OP-145, 5.2*.. 2.~
Performance Step: 6*    \/E:RIF'Y:' flow: is g*reatertha..n orequal to 38S0gpm' onFI~653*.1 and::*FI.~**652~~ .
Stan'd~ard::    '., . Vetlfies***~-*385.0*got)rn:*o*n.*Fr~65**3:~.1'an*d:*Fl-652:*1 ..(Actu*al-is.*5.000 on
      "A~'* arld**4000.:o*n* "B~')"  . . ,
*.Comme*nt:: .
    "  . " .
OP~145,,5.2. '. '. .
.' Performance.Step: PERFoRM0l'1e*qftheJoUQwiog:.. .  .
      ". :f~'~~~C;;:::~o~~.:~::~i~:gU:i~:i::~;:~8;9 ..
. '" .' .
      :.~ ' . : . : .. .: . .',", '. -. .'
.' '. 'St~lrld:ard::    * Returns'toSectlon R9, .
.  .
  ..  .
.. " ".......  ','
. *.Comrnent:
.  '. '"  .
.' .  ' .
  . ' .
  .: .. '. . .' ....
'. Procedure Note:
. . . .. ~...:...., ' ..
    .' .
    . . ' .'.  . ':'.' : ' .. .
Standard:*    .'. ... . Pla&#xa2;es1CC'-14'linOPEN(REDlndlcatiQn). *
        ," .  . '
:COI11 nie n Critical to alignflowthtoqgt1R~R "'X:"A"....
. .  .... , : '  " . .,' .
HARR*.ISOS*NRC* J'PM h ..Revision :'0        NU.REG*t021, Revlslons


SAT 3/14/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem CuesT/FCredo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 60 F 1 X U 078G2.1.28 Question appearstomatchKIA..(Functionof1 SA-506), but does not describe the purpose.The lesson material statesthat1 SA-506 isolatesat90psig decreasingintheIA header, Twoofthe distractorsstatethatthe isolation will occur at90psig,andbothof these distractors are incorrect.Thismaybeinan efforttomakethem appear more plausible.
      . Page. 8.of 12* . Form ES-C-1
    "Pt=RFORM'ANGE IN:FORMATION
.".  ' . ' ..' .~.... .
OP~*145,~*:8:~9.*.2..4**
Procedure Caution;  . *\lVitt.{:one>G.CW.PUtlJp:.runnin.Q.*.and the 'standby pumpcapable of
    .anauiomaticstart.ensure.. aminimurnflowrateofvasu g'pm
    .exists .;as* indicatedon FI.:~652.:*1 ::<F*I~653~*.1). If-path CCW*.*pw*m.ps
    .arenmninq.. *Q*R the:.CC*WJra*ins .are .separated,..a minimum of 385Q.:gp~*:per.:plJmp*is:requfred. This lower flowrateshould.. only beallowedforshortdurations'to .accompllsh pump swappinq or
.
  ... " ....
  .
  ",. '",
    *s.~~tem*.:*~e*a.Hg:nm:etlt. *(R*e.fer~rlCEr2*.6.~.6)*
Performance-Step: 9'  '. VERIFYHHR'HXA(B)butflowis5600 to8t50 gpmon FI~
    ...' .68a.A:t* {Fr~6'89A*t) :'.'  .
.  .
. *.Sian d.a-rd*:~**  Verities  RHRHX<A QufflowJs5600td 8150gpm on FI-'688A .,:: *(A~t'uar.i.s: 7:80"GJ G*PJ\l1y-:*.***  .
'. ".'  .
. '. :**Cohi*me*rit:* ..' . . :- .
  -, .'~' .. '.
    ....,: ...
    . " ..... ". . ' , .
    *:.*Q~~t4*5*~:*:8:.9j.2:~*:5~*.
If a leak occurs, . and surqe tank level is 'less than 40% (below the
. .'    . ; .: :
. . :' .~:ta.n*d~rd . ::
    :"., . '.' .. :.: '.:.: '. . '. : : ".:.... .' " . .' , ". .
.C:o.mment:** : .  :Criticalto:. IsolateTrain "A~'~ .from .Non-Essential Heade ..  .
.  .
*HARR.lS08 NRC JPM***h Revisiori . NUR*EG*.t021, Revision 9


Recommend the following:
Appendix C:      Paqesof 12  Form. *ES-C~1
WhichONEofthe following describes the operation of Service Air Header Isolationvalve,1 SA-506?A.Closes automaticallywhenIA header pressure reaches90psig decreasing; Automatically openswhenIA header pressure rises above90psig.B.Closes automaticallywhenIA header pressure reaches75psig decreasing; Automatically openswhenIA header pressure rises above75psig.C.Closes automaticallywhenIA header pressure reaches90psig decreasing;Mustbe manually openedwhenIA header pressure rises above 90 psig.D.Closes automaticallywhenIA header pressure reaches75psig decreasing;Mustbe manually openedwhenIA header pressure rises above 75 psig.NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal No changesmadefrominitial submittal BANK Made changes as requested SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws 5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-.Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 61 H 2 X U103A1.01QuestiondoesnotreallymatchKIA.Wearenottesting exceedingthedesignlimit.Recommendthefollowing:Sameinitial conditionsandstem;A.ContainmentVacuumReliefsystemwill operate to restore containmentpressureto-1.5inchesH 2O.Containment purge operationisthenrequiredtorestoreto-1.0H 2O.B.ContainmentVacuumReliefsystemwilloperateto restore containmentpressureto-1.5inchesH 20.Nootheractionsarerequired C: ContainmentVacuumReliefsystemwill operatetorestore containment pressureto-1.0inchesH 2O.Containment purge operationisthenrequiredtorestoreto-0.5H 2O.D.ContainmentVacuumReliefsystemwill operatetorestore containment pressureto-1.0inchesH 2O.Nootheractionsarerequired.WithAbeingthe correctanswer.Or somethingsimilar.(Thisisa1hourtechspec thereforeitisRO Knowledge).
    .*PERFO.RMANC*E. I*NFORMATIO *O*P~1.45, *8:.9.2..6**
      .    .
  . . .  .  .
Procedure Cautlon;  Shuttin*g*both.. 1:CC-*12'8. and*tCC-127* will result-in the loss of the Nonessential Header. .    . .
    . .' .
.:.. -v...Perfo..r mance :Step: *1*1  .I F .both (~*CW:.pum*ps.:are* in:.service, .CLO.S.E* 1CC-*128 (1: C*C~*127),
    .. C*CW:*NON*ESSENTIA*L<RET.IjRN TO . H.EAD*ER.. A(B};..
    . CI()ses1CC~ 128 (GREEN indication}
        .  .
      .  .
. . ..  .  ' .    .
. . ....Corn.me*nt:*  .Crltlcaf tolsolate :Tra.in*'~A" frornNon-Essentlal Header, OP~1A5;j3.'9,2~.7. .   '; .
.'...* Perforlllahc,~Step:12 '.' *VERIFYthefdllbwing:.**
    , a:.~~ll~~rh~CV\fPurnpsarein* service, THEN PERFORM the .
    . ' "~:::    ~  ~~..
      :'t6.6},:.'*R*Ij*R *Jfx .A** (8).*Outlet. Throttle Valye:,**to:*o btain
      . desired-flow, :  . .
    '\I~rifil?sfld\1tlat1:lpprOximateJy8000GPM~* .'
" '.
  .....
  :.....
  . .'.".
    .',
  ..... .
    *OP~t45,. . a.~9:~**2~8.*
-, *...Procedu ~eCaLJtion:  [JonotsuPPlyCCWioboth RHR Heat Exchangers
  '. . .
    .slmultaneously withonly one . :C*CW*:pum*potu rinln .~. 'Perfo~l1lance Step: 1 *.* *IF.botntrainsofHHR'cooling are .tobeplaced-lnservice, OPEN*
    . .fC:C~~. t67::.(1*CC~**147.), .CCW*.*FR.Oryl .RH.R:.:HEAT EX*C.HAN:G:E:RB~
    <**S*S.::{A-SA)i:  . ..... .
    .. . .. .. .:. : :. ~. : ... .. . .. .... .....
Op~nstCC~:167(REDindicatidn):.
    , .  . '.  ' .  .
*Co*mment:  .Critlcaltoaliqn flow* throuq h**RH R*.HX:*'*~Bn .
  ". ' . " . .
HAR:RI*S{)8::NRCJPM* h.-*Revision**O:*        NUREG1*021,*Revision*g


NEW No changesmadefrominitialsubmittalModifiedasrequestedabove.
Page. 1-*0.oft2*  Form ES-C-1 P'ERFORMA:NC~ *INFQR.MATION**
    .  .
O.P~f45; 8'*.9.2.9:
      . '.  .
. . .  . . . . '. .. . . ' . . ..
Performance' Step': 1"4  vE*R.rFY**CCW* Pump 8.;.$8 {A~SA)-*flo.w. rateinthe required
    . :r~'nge, as-follows; .. , ..'  .:
      . . .... . . .
    * -. CHECk*ccwPurnp B';813 (A-SA) flo~ rate is between
    . 1*O*:~.OQO and t2*~:5.00:*.*.gfi*m.,on:***MCB Jndicator F:I-65*3~*1 .(FI-*
    '.652.'*1 )., ..IF flow.rate is.riotbetween 1O.~:O*OO**and '1""2,-500 -,
g'Prn, *TH*E*N* A*D*J.U$T* the. applicable valve:
  . .
      . .
*Stari'd.ard.*:  . . Verifi~~flowatat>prOXirn<;lteIY11.9bOGPM.*****
. .Stari.:d:ard;  $ff:!pisN/Aatthistime.*.....
' . " : . . ' 0 ** * . '
.* . Corrimel1t:<
'. '. '. . .':" '... . .
..Terminanng* Cue:
: .sro:p**:Ti:ME:**'
Ow' *  ..' *
HARRI.S08*:NRC*JPM.*h**Revision* **NUREG 1021, Revision 9


SAT 3/18/2008 62 F 2 X U WE04EK2.2 Question appearstomatchKIA.DistractorsCandDare secondary monitor pointsthismakethemless desirableasplausibledistractors.(SIflowisbasedonRCSpressure,andradbuildingradiationlevelsloweringisbasedon 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S decay of activity)sowhywould anyone pick these?Tryusing some initial conditionswithaloca outside of containment in progressandthen workoffof which component would be isolatedfirst,and what parameterwouldbeusedto determineifthe leak is isolated.PZRlevelorRCS pressure rising.A.Correct ComponentandPZRLevel rising.B.Wrong ComponentandRCS pressure rising.C.Correct ComponentandPZRLevelrising.
AppendixC      .Paqe
        .
tt of r ,  .
Form ES-C-1
      *VERIFICATION. O,F: 'COM"PL,ETION .
  . . '
. Examinee'sName;
:Fac.ility Evaluator: .
.'. Number-of Attempts:
. ' . ... . . . . , '. ."... '. . .' ';' . .'
  . ,  .
  . . . .- . :.'
... ..*.Time to9ornpl\9te:.. *..
':' .: , .' . :..' " >'. .' ..-'..:. : . .
..Que~tion** Documentation:
..Q.u.estloil:..*. *: .,'
  . ~ .. .
. '. Response;
        -: : "
Result;        *.LJN:SAT: ....
  . . ,  .  .
Exam.iner',s:S*.ig.nature*:        .Date: .
    --'---'-----:--'-~~...,.-;:.-...---:....-..;...~---,-.,.,.--:--~-.::...:....--,..-,~- ~-....:.-.....:---..:.-_-------
NU:REG1021.,.. Revision 9


D.Correct ComponentandRCS pressure rising.WereDwouldbethe correct answer.BANK (This particularKIAhasbeenon several ofthelast exams.No changes madefrominitial submittal Modified asrequestedabove.
Appendix C  Page 12,of 1-2,'
 
J'PM', CUE .S*HEEl
SAT 3/18/2008 63H2 X E WE/05EA2.2 Question appears to match KIA.DistractorsCandDarenot plausible.
, .
 
INitiAL' COND.lTION:S:. ,e The unit-is in ~ Mode :4~; going to Mode 5"
Feeding allS/Gsis okaybutit seems that the stopping point iswhenallS/Gsare greater than (value).These distractors shouldstateuntiloneS/Gis greater than the appropriate value.(15%WRor25%NR).BANK No changes madefrominitial submittal Modified as requested above.SAT 3/18/2008 64F2 X U WE/10EA1.3 Question appears to matchtheKIA.This questionislistedas NEW,butwasonthe McGuire 2007exam.Thewaythe question is asking two thingsthelevelandthereason, Withallthe 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F CredoPartialJob-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S levels being different an applicant need only know the correct level and would nothaveto know the reason.Ifthe applicant knew the reason, he could eliminate twoofthe distractors (and their levels).The question shouldbesetup using two levels and two reasons for example;A.25%to ensure minimum inventory for pressure control.B.650/0 to ensure minimum inventory for pressure control.C.250/0 to ensure adequate volume for collapsing the void.D.65%to ensure adequate volume for collapsing the void.BANK No changes made from initial submittal Modified as requested above SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/FCredoPartialJob-Minutia
  ,e ' Preparationsareunderwayto place, both trains ',ofRHRin
#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S 65 F 2 X X U E11/EK3.3 Question appears to match KIA.The question asksforthe reason and requirements for depressurizingtheRCS.Iamnotsureofthe these requirements.
  .service e,' , Both ,E*SW"Tra*ins are inservice
 
  .   ,
In distractor A (whichisthe correct answer)youstateto reduce CSIP flow, however reducing RCS pressure will increase CSIPflow,itwill allow later for CSIP flowtobe reduced.Question and distractorsarevery wordy and confusing.Notsure that as written thereisa correct answer.Distractor CandDarenot plausible.Ifyou maximize RCS subcooling howcanyou minimize RCS pressure.BANK No changes madefrominitial submittal Modified as requested above SAT 3/18/2008 66 F 2 X X U G2.1.3 Question appears to match KIA.Agree that question is modified.Distractor C does not appear to be plausible.
e,' ' : ':C:CW' P,ump,,"A"i's'*runriln,g', ,
 
  , , ,
Whywouldyou perform a turnover using attachment5and attachment14,this doesn't make sense.In appeal space distractor D could be arqued as correctifthe S-SO desires.Needtofix distractors.
Align QCVYfQsupportRHRopE)rafioninaccordancewith OP-t45,
 
  '*C'O~'PONt=~NT CO*OLIN,G,:VVATER:. "AU"S'ectibh*.3~:O Prerequisites'
MODIFIED No changes madefrominitial submittal ChangedCandD distractors.
  .arernet.. " '  '". ' ,
 
N,U,R~G:102,1", Revisions
SAT 3/18/2008 67 H 2 E G2.1.32 Question appears to matchKIA.Canyou actuallygetto these conditions.
 
During a startup turbine power usually lags behindNIandDeltaT powerduetothe secondary plant being inefficient.
 
Change the powers around so thattheylook more 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)StemCuesT/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only Slikewhat normally happensintheplant,haveDeltaTbethe higher indicationandplaceitin distractor Dinsteadof turbine power.NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal.
 
Changed as requested.
 
SAT 3/18/2008 68 F 2 S G2.1.12 Question appearstomatchKIASAT.
 
No changesmadefrominitial submittal.
 
SAT 3/18/2008\69 F 2 X E G2.2.26 Question appearstomatchKIA.Ifthe boron concentrationwas9ppm greaterthanthe amountrequiredintheCOLRthenCcouldbearguedascorrect.Needtoaddboronleveltothestemandhaveitbe greaterthanthe COLRsothatiftheboron concentrationwaslowered10ppmitwouldstillbeabovethe minimum amountlistedintheCOLR.BANK No changesmadefrominitial submittal.
 
Changedasrequested.
 
SAT 3/18/2008 70 H 2 S G2.3.2 Question appearstomatchKIA.SAT.
 
MODIFIED No changesmadefrominitial submittal SAT 3/18/2008 71 F 2 X U G2.3.4 Question appearstomatchKIA.
 
Similar to AdministrativeJPMA-3butis somewhat different.
 
DistractorsAandCarenotcredible.Replacethe individual's progress energy supervisor with 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job Content Flaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LOD (F/H)(1-5)Stem Cues T/F Credo Partial Job-Minutia#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation Focus Dist.Link units ward KIA Only S Superintendent-Radiation Protection.
 
NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal Changed as requested.
 
SAT 3/18/2008 72 H 2 X U G2.4.10 Question appearstomatchKIA.OistractorsCand0arenotcredible.
 
Another questionontheexam(#60)givessomeIA header pressure actionsandthese occurat90psig,sowhywould someone chooseCorO?NEW No changesmadefrominitial submittal Modified questiontoremove question 60 concerns Changed as requested.
 
SAT 3/18/2008 73 H 3 S G2.4.29 Question appearstomatchKIA,Isthis somethingyourequireRO'stoknow?
SAT MODIFIED No changesmadefrominitial submittal SAT 3/18/2008 74 H 2 S G2.4.48 Question appearstomatchKIA..SAT BANK No changesmadefrominitial submittal SAT 3/18/2008 1.2.3.Psychometric Flaws4.Job ContentFlaws5.Other 6.7.Q#LOK LaD (F/H)(1-5)Stem CuesT/FCredoPartialJob-Minutia
#/Back-Q=SRO U/E/Explanation FocusDist.Linkunitsward KIA Only S 75F2 X E G2.4.6 Question appears to match KIA.Stem should state: Whichoneofthe following describes the Rep configuration and its basis in accordance with EPP-009.BANK No changes made from initial submittal Changed as requested.
 
SAT 3/18/2008 I I ES-403,Rev.9 Written Examination Grading Quality ChecklistFormES-403-1Facility:Harris2008-301DateofExam:
03/21/2008ExamLevel:
RO/SRO Initials 2.Answer key changes and question deletions justified and documented 3.Applicants'
scores checked for addition errors reviewers spot check>250/0 of examinations5.All other failing examinations checked to ensure that grades are justified c b a Item Description Clean answer sheetscopiedbefore grading 4.Gradingforall borderline cases(80+/-2%overalland70or80, as applicable,+/-4%onthe SRO-only)reviewedindetail 1.6.Performanceonmissed questionscheckedfor training deficiencies and wording problems;evaluate validity of questions missed by halformoreofthe applicants Printed Name/Si nature Date a.Grader L{/ls-)l>p b.Facility Reviewer(*)
pA-.1/15//)/
.c.NRC Chief Examiner (*)QlM1l>OAllf,!62:>
d.NRC Supervisor (*)(*)Thefacilityreviewer's signatureisnotapplicablefor examinationsgradedbytheNRC; two independent NRC reviewsarerequired.
 
ES-501,Rev.9Post-ExaminationCheckSheet Form ES-501-1Harris2008InitialLicenseExamination05000400/2008/301Post-ExaminationCheckSheetTaskDescriptionDateComplete 1.2.3.4.Facilitywrittenexam commentsorgradedexamsreceivedandverifiedcompleteFacilitywrittenexam commentsreviewedand incorporated andNRCgradingcompleted,if necessaryOperatingtestsgradedbyNRC examinersNRCchief examinerreviewofoperatingtestandwrittenexamgradingcompleted 03/26/2008 N/A 4/15/2008 4/15/20085.Responsible supervisorreviewcompleted 6.Management(licensingofficial)review completed7.Licenseanddeniallettersmailed8.Facilitynotifiedofresults9.Examinationreportissued(refertoNRCMC0612)10.Referencematerialreturnedafterfinalresolutionofanyappeals SERIAL: HNP-07-175 January4,2008 Mr.Malcolm T.Widmann, Region II United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Sam Nunn Atlanta Federal Center61ForsythSt.,SW,Suite23T85Atlanta,GA 30303-8931 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT DOCKET NO.50-400/LICENSENO.NPF-63 REACTOR AND SENIOR REACTOR OPERATOR INITIAL EXAMINATIONS 05000400/2008301
 
==DearMr.Widmann:==
Enclosedarethe proposed written examinations, operatingtests,and supporting reference materialsforthe ReactorandSenior Reactor Operator Initial Examinationstobegivenatthe Harris Nuclear Plant the week of March 10,2008.This submittal complies the requirement identifiedinyour letter dated October 19,2007, to provide these materialsbyJanuary7,2008.
 
The enclosed materialsshallbe withheld from public disclosureuntilafterthe examinations are complete.Ifyouhaveany questions regarding these materials, please contact Mr.John Dalton at(919)362-3500.
 
Greg Kilpatrick Superintendent-Operations Training Harris Nuclear Plant DGKlmgw Enclosuresc:Mr.P.B.O'Bryan(NRCSenior ResidentInspector,HNP)
wlo EnclosuresMr.V.M.McCree (NRC Acting Regional Administrator, Region II)wlo EnclosuresMs.M.G.Vaaler (NRR Project Manager, HNP)wlo Enclosures Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc.Harris Nuclear Plant P.O.Box 165 New Hill, NC 27562 Mr.RobertC.Haag SERIAL: HNP-07-175 be: (w/o Enclosures)
Mr.J.R.DaltonMr.J.W.GurganiousMr.K.HendersonMs.T.M.Midgette'Mr.T.T.TolerMr.M.G.WallaceMr.J.C.Warner Nuclear Records Licensing File 55 ergy November30,2007SERIAL:HNP-07-161 Mr.Malcolm Widmann, Region II United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Sam Nunn Atlanta Federal Center 61 ForsythSt.,SW,Suite23T85Atlanta,GA 30303-8931 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT DOCKET NO.50-400/LICENSENO.NPF-63 REACTOR AND SENIOR REACTOR OPERATOR INITIAL EXAMINATIONS 05000400/2008301 OUTLINES
 
==DearMr.Widmann:==
Enclosedarethe proposed examination outlinesforthe ReactorandSenior Reactor Operator Initial ExaminationstobegivenattheHarris Nuclear Plant the week of March 10,2008.This submittal complies with the requirement identifiedinyourletterdatedOctober19,2007,tofurnish the outlines by December17,2007.The enclosed materialsshallbe withheld from public disclosureuntilafterthe examinationsarecomplete.
 
Ifyouhaveany questions regarding these materials, please contactMr.John Dalton at(919)362-3500.
 
W.Greg Kilpatrick Superintendent-Operations Training Harris Nuclear Plant DGKJmgw Enclosuresc:Mr.P.B.O'Bryan (NRC Senior ResidentInspector,HNP)
wlo EnclosuresMr.V.M.McCree (NRC Acting Regional Administrator, Region II)wlo EnclosuresMs.M.G.Vaaler (NRR Project Manager, HNP)wlo Enclosures Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc.Harris Nuclear Plant P.O.Box 165NewHill, NC 27562 o 4 Mr.Malcolm Widmann SERIAL: HNP-07-161 be: (w/o Enclosures)Mr.J.R.DaltonMr.J.W.GurganiousMr.K.HendersonMs.T.M.MidgetteMr.T.T.TolerMr.M.G.WallaceMr.J.C.Warner Nuclear Records Licensing File
}}
}}

Latest revision as of 14:16, 14 November 2019

March 05000400-08-301 Exam Draft In-Plant Job Performance Measures
ML082200101
Person / Time
Site: Harris Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 08/07/2008
From:
NRC/RGN-II
To:
References
50-400/08-301
Download: ML082200101 (116)


Text

Final Submittal (Blue Paper)

DRAFT IN-PLANT JPMS

/::1/9 fi? 12/.s, oL t>lJ 8 - 3LJ I

tJ. A- LC-t( c
2 CTO 8

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS Task No.: 001010H404 Task Title: Perform the local actions for a JPM No.: 2008 NRC i dropped rod recovery (AOP-001)

KIA Reference: APE003 AA1.02 (3.6/3.4)

Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date:

Method of testing:

Simulated Performance: x Actual Performance:

Classroom Simulator Plant X READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

Initial Conditions: * The unit was at 50% power when Control Bank "0" control rod H2 droppe * The crew is performing AOP-001, MALFUNCTION OF ROD CONTROL AND INDICATION SYSTEM, and is preparing to retrieve the control rod.

Task Standard: Field actions correctly support rod retrieval and restore system to normal operation.

Required Materials: Keys for any locked cabinet(s).

General References: AOP-001, MALFUNCTION OF ROD CONTROL AND INDICATION SYSTEM, Revision 29 Handout: AOP-001, Section 3.1 Initiating Cue: The USCO has assigned you to perform the local actions associated with the retrieval of the dropped rod. Perform AOP-001 - Steps 3.1.13, 3.1.14, 3.1.15, and 3.17. The control room will perform Step 3.1.16 (logging Step Counter readings) while you are performing the designated steps. Report completion of the steps to the control room and then standby for further direction.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Time Critical Task: No Validation Time: 22 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 4 of 12 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

AOP-001, 3.13 Performance Step: 1 Reviews procedur Standard: * Reviews applicable steps and obtains or discusses obtaining key(s) for Control Rod Disconnect Switch Bo * Proceeds to Control Rod Disconnect Switch Bo Evaluator Cue: Provide key. Ensure applicant informs control room if any alarmed cabinet will be opene Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 5 of 12 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.14 Performance Step: 2 POSITION lift coil disconnect switches for rods IN THE AFFECTED BANK as follows:

  • Dropped rod - ROD CONNECTED (down)
  • All other rods - ROD DISCONNECTED (up)

.y Standard: Locates rod disconnect cabinet and unlocks cabine Points out and simulates placing the disconnect switches in the UP position for CBD Group 1 and Group 2 rods:

  • B8
  • H14
  • P8
  • F6
  • F10
  • K10
  • K6 and leaves H2 in the DOWN positio Evaluator Cue: Provide switch position feedback as each operation is simulate Comment: Critical to move only the desired ro AOP-001, 3.1.15 Performance Step: 3 RECORD the Pulse-To-Analog (PIA) converter reading for the affected bank:
  • Bank - - -
  • PIA Reading _

Standard: * Locates the PIA converter and opens the cabinet

  • Points out position for Control Bank D and logs 165 steps Evaluator Cue: Control Bank "0" is reading 165 step Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 6 of 12 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.17 Performance Step: 4 RECORD the Master Cycler light status (LIT/NOT LIT) on Card A105:

  • Top light
  • Middle light
  • Bottom light Standard: * Locates Card A 105 in Logic Cabine * Logs
  • TOP: NOT LIT
  • MIDDLE: LIT
  • BOTTOM: NOT LIT Evaluator Cue: A105 lights "As Found":
  • TOP: NOT LIT
  • MIDDLE: LIT
  • BOTTOM: NOT LIT Comment:

Performance Step: 5 Report completion of steps to Control Roo Standard: Reports Steps 3.13, 3.14, 3.15 and 3.17 completed to Control Roo Evaluator Cue: * Acknowledge repor * After the report is made: Time compression is being used to report recovery of the dropped rod. The control room has informed you that the dropped rod is recovered and has directed you to perform Steps 3.1.25 and 3.1.2 Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 7 of 12 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001,3.1.25-Y Performance Step: 6 Repeatedly PRESS the "Master Cycler +1" button as needed to produce the following light status on Card A 105:

  • Top light - LIT
  • Middle light - NOT LIT
  • Bottom light - LIT Standard: * Locates Card A 105 and Master Cycler +1 Pushbutton in the Logic Cabine * Presses +1 Pushbutton 3 times to achieve desired light pattern. (-Y)

Evaluator Cue: A105 lights "As Found":

  • TOP: NOT LIT
  • MIDDLE: LIT
  • BOTTOM: NOT LIT A105 lights "After 1st Push":
  • TOP: NOT LIT
  • MIDDLE: LIT
  • BOTTOM: LIT A105 lights "After 2nd Push":
  • TOP: LIT
  • MIDDLE: NOT LIT
  • BOTTOM: NOT LIT A105 lights "After 3rd Push":
  • TOP: LIT
  • MIDDLE: NOT LIT
  • BOTTOM: LIT Comment: Critical to set the circuit for the desired operation.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 8 of 12 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.26-v Performance Step: 7 CLOSE ALL lift coil disconnect switches opened in Step 1 Standard: Points out and simulates placing the disconnect switches in the DOWN position for CBD Group 1 and Group 2 rods:

  • B8
  • H14
  • P8
  • F6
  • F10
  • K10
  • K6 Evaluator Cue: Provide switch position feedback as each operation is simulate Comment: Critical to restore CBO to all rods operatin Performance Step: 8 Report completion of steps to Control Roo Standard: Reports Steps 3.25 and 3.26 completed to Control Roo Evaluator Cue: * Acknowledge repor * The control room crew has completed Step 3.27. You have been directed to perform Step 3.28, RN Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 9 of 12 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-001, 3.1.28 RNO-v Performance Step: 9 PERFORM the following at the Pulse-To-Analog (PIA) Converter:

a. POSITION the Bank Display Selector Switch to the bank recorded in Step 1 b. POSITION AND HOLD the Auto-Manual switch in MANUA c. Repeatedly PRESS EITHER the UP pushbutton OR the DOWN pushbutton as needed to make the display match the PIA reading recorded in Step 1 d. RELEASE the Auto-Manual switc e. POSITION the Bank Display Selector Switch to DISPLAY OF Standard: Locates the PIA Converter, opens the cabinet and selects Control Bank D. (-V)

Evaluator Cue: When Bank Display Selector Switch is selected to Control Bank "0": The display is reading 33 Points out and simulates placing Auto-Manual switch to MANUAL and holds. (-V)

Evaluator Cue: After the AUTO-MANUAL switch and MANUAL position are located: You are holding the AUTO-MANUAL switch in MANUA Depresses the DOWN (-) pushbutton until counter indicates 165 steps. (-V)

Evaluator Cue: As the DOWN Pushbutton is pushed. The indicator is lowering one step at a time. Assume that it has reached 165 step Releases the Auto-Manual switch Evaluator Cue: The AUTO-MANUAL Switch is release Places the Bank Display Selector switch to DISPLAY OFF Evaluator Cue: The Bank Display Selector Switch is in DISPLAY OF Comment: Critical to restore circuit to pre-retrieval condition.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 10 of 12 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Performance Step: 10 Report completion of steps to Control Roo Standard: Reports Step 3.28 completed to Control Roo Evaluator Cue: Acknowledge repor Comment:

Terminating Cue: After Step 3.1.28 completion is reported: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.

STOP TIME:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 11 of 12 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM i Examinee's Name:

Date Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of Attempts:

Time to Complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response:

Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature: Date:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 12 of 12 Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * The unit was at 50°J'c> power when Control Bank "0" control rod H2 droppe * The crew is performing AOP-001, MALFUNCTION OF ROD CONTROL AND INDICATION SYSTEM, and is preparing to retrieve the control rod.

INITIATING CUE: The USCG has assigned you to perform the local actions associated with the retrieval of the dropped rod. Perform AOP-001 - Steps 3.1.13, 3.1.14, 3.1.15, and 3.17. The control room will perform Step 3.1.16 (logging Step Counter readings) while you are performing the designated steps. Report completion of the steps to the control room and then standby for further direction.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM i Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS Task No.:

Task Title: Isolate the ECCS Accumulators JPM No.: 2008 NRC j after a control room evacuation (AOP-004, Step 38)

KIA Reference: APE068 G2.1.30 (3.9/3.4)

Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date:

Method of testing:

Simulated Performance: x Actual Performance:

Classroom Simulator Plant X READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

Initial Conditions: * The control room has been evacuated due to a fir * A cooldown is in progress in accordance with AOP-004, REMOTE SHUTDOW * RCS Pressure is 975 PSIG by PI-402.2.

Task Standard: All accumulators isolated and MOV's de-energized.

Required Materials: * Standard PPE

  • Unlock or ensure A TP Cabinet unlocked or provide the evaluator with a key.

General References: AOP-004, REMOTE SHUTDOWN Handout: AOP-004, Step 38 (Pgs. 46/47)

Initiating Cue: You have been assigned to perform AOP-004, Step 38 - Isolate SI Accumulators.

Time Critical Task: NO HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 18 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 4 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

AOP-004 Performance Step: 1 Obtain locked valve and ATP Cabinet key Standard: Discusses how to obtain keys (ACP Room Key Locker).

Evaluator Note: The Evaluator can elect to have the applicant locate the ACP Room Key Locker or to discuss the key acquisition. The key to the ACP Key Locker is in a "break glass" cas Evaluator Cue: * Provide Handout for NRC JPM * Acknowledge discussion and tell applicant to assume that they have the required key Comment:

AOP-004, Step 38.a-v Performance Step: 2 WHEN RCS pressure is 900 to 1000 psig, as indicated on PI-402.2, THEN ISOLATE SI accumulators:

286' RAB / RO with locked valve key a. UNLOCK AND TURN ON accumulator discharge valve breakers:

Standard: * Locates 1A21-SA-5C, identifies UNLOCK then ON position for both breakers for Accumulator * Locates 1A21-SA-3D, identifies UNLOCK then ON position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Comment: Assumes the locked valve key has been located. Critical to provide power to MOV for operation.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 5 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-004, 38.a

~ Performance Step: 3 WHEN RCS pressure is 900 to 1000 psig, as indicated on PI-402.2, THEN ISOLATE SI accumulators:

286' RAB / RO with locked valve key a. UNLOCK AND TURN ON accumulator discharge valve breakers:

Standard: Locates 1B21-SB-5C, identifies UNLOCK then ON position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Evaluator Note: Opening the ATP door actuates an alarm in the control roo Comment: Assumes the locked valve key has been located. Critical to provide power to MOV for operatio AOP-004, Step 38.b

~ Performance Step: 4 SHUT SI accumulator discharge valves at the Auxiliary Transfer Panels listed:

Cable Vault A / RO with A TP cabinet key

Cable Vault A / RO with A TP cabinet key

Standard: * Locates and opens ATP "A" and identifies SHUT position for 1SI-246

  • Locates and opens ATP "A" and identifies SHUT position for 1SI-248 Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on switch positio Comment: Critical to close discharge valves to prevent inadvertent discharge during cooldown.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 6 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-004, Step 38.b-v Performance Step: 5 SHUT SI accumulator discharge valves at the Auxiliary Transfer Panels listed:

Cable Vault B / RO with A TP cabinet key

Standard: * Locates and opens ATP "B" and identifies SHUT position for 1SI-247 Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on switch positio Comment: Critical to close discharge valves to prevent inadvertent discharge during cooldown.

Evaluator Note: The Evaluator can elect to have the applicant discuss the remaining steps since it involves returning to equipment already located and re-opening the breaker AOP-004, Step 3 Performance Step: 6 286' RAB / RO with locked valve key TURN OFF AND LOCK accumulator discharge valve breakers:

Standard: * Returns to 1A21-SA-5C, identifies OFF then LOCK position for both breakers for Accumulator * Returns to 1A21-SA-3D, identifies OFF then LOCK position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 7 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-004, Step 3 Performance Step: 7 286' RAB / RO with locked valve key TURN OFF AND LOCK accumulator discharge valve breakers:

Standard: Returns to 1B21-SB-5C, identifies OFF then LOCK position for both breakers for Accumulator Evaluator Cue: Provide feedback on breaker positio Comment:

Terminating Cue: When all SI Accumulator Discharge Valves are de-energized:

Evaluation on this JPM is complete.

STOP TIME:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 8 of 9 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM j Examinee's Name:

Date Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of Attempts:

Time to Complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response:

Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature: Date:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 9 of 9 Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * The control room has been evacuated due to a fir * A cooldown is in progress in accordance with AOP-004, REMOTE SHUTDOW * RCS Pressure is 975 PSIG by PI-402.2.

INITIATING CUE: You have been assigned to perform AOP-004, Step 38 - Isolate SI Accumulators.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM j Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS Task No.: 071104H112 Task Title: Respond to High Rad Alarm During JPM No.: 2008 NRC JPM k a Waste Gas Decay Tank Release KIA Reference: 071 G2.1.30 3.9 Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date:

Method of testing:

Simulated Performance: X Actual Performance:

Classroom Simulator Plant X READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

Initial Conditions: * "A" Waste Gas Decay Tank is being release * Monitors REM-3546 and RM-3546-1 are OPERABLE.

Task Standard: Waste Gas Decay Tank release is terminated per OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Section 8.37.

Required Materials: On the day of the IP JPM performance, notify the RadWaste Operator that applicants will be entering the area and may be accessing the reading for REM-3546 on the RM-11 Panel.

General References: OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Rev. 46 Handouts: * A copy of OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Attachment 3 completed through Item 2 * A copy of OP-120.07, Waste Gas Processing, Section 8.37.

Initiating Cue: You relieved the operator who commenced the release. The control room has just directed you to implement OP-120.07, Section 8.37, Actions for a REM Monitor Alarm During a Waste Gas Decay Tank Release, because an ALERT alarm has been received on REM-3546.

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Time Critical Task: N/A Validation Time: 20 minutes HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 4 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

Performance Step: 1 Obtain Procedure Standard: Reviews OP-120.07, Section 8.3 Examiners Cue: Provide the handout (OP-120.07, Attachment 3 signed off through Item 23 and OP-120.07, Section 8.37).

Comment:

Step 8.3 Performance Step: 2 Verifies the Initial Conditions:

1. A Waste Gas Decay Tank is being release . Monitors REM-3546 or RM-3546-1 are OPERABL . A REM Monitor Alert or High Alarm has been receive Standard: Confirms the initial conditions appl Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 5 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37. Procedure Note: * If an Alert alarm is received, the WGDT release may continue provided the reading does not approach the High Alarm setpoin * This section contains steps which require independent verificatio Performance Step: 3 If the Monitor goes into an Alert Alarm, observe the reading to see if it continues to increase. Record the reading in the Radwaste Control Room AO log Standard: Accesses the REM-3546 monitor reading on the RM-11 Pane Examiners Cue: REM-3546 is rising and approaching the HIGH alarm setpoin Comment:

Step 8.37. Performance Step: 4 If the Monitor reading continues to approach or goes into a High Alarm condition, the Waste Gas Decay Tank release must be secured. Continue to next step to secure the Gas Decay Tank Releas Standard: Determines the release must be secured and continues to the next ste Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 6 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37.2.3

~ Performance Step: 5 Adjust HK-7392, PLANT VENT Controller until indicator reads 0 and record the Actual Stop Date/Time (Log Item 24).

Standard: * Adjusts HK-7392 until indicator reads * Records the actual Stop Date/Time on Attachment Examiners Cue: Controller HK-7392 reads Examiner Note: If the applicant incorrectly performs this step then correct performance of either Performance Step 6 or Performance Step 12 becomes critica Comment:

Step 8.37. Performance Step: 6 Using key, place the WG DECAY TANKS E & F TO PLANT VENT VALVE switch 3WG-229 to KEYLOCKED SHUT and log on Attachment 3. (Log Item 25)

Standard: * Selects WG DECAY TANKS E & F TO PLANT VENT VALVE 3WG-229 switch to KEYLOCKED SHU * Records log entry on Attachment Examiners Cue: 3WG-229 is in the KEYLOCKED SHUT positio Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 7 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37. Procedure Note: Independent verification of 3WG-229 position in the next step can be performed out of sequenc Performance Step: 7 Perform independent verification that 3WG-229 is locked shut and log on Attachment 3. (Log item 26)

Standard: Logs independent verification entry on Attachment 3 or delays action based on the Procedure Not Examiners Cue: Independent verification will be performed out of sequence in accordance with the procedure not Comment:

Step 8.37. Performance Step: 8 Notify the Superintendent - Shift Operations that Monitor REM-3546 has alarmed and the release has been stoppe Standard: Notifies the Superintendent Shift Operations that monitor REM-3546 alarmed and the release has been stoppe Examiners Cue: Superintendent Shift Operations acknowledges the repor Comment:

Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 9 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:

  • Record the Vent Stack 5 Flow Rate (Log Item 27).

Standard: * Reads and records Vent Stack 5 Process Flow Rate on Attachment Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 8 of 11 Form ES-C-1

. PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 10 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:

  • Record the Final Gas Decay Tank Pressure (Log Item 28).

Standard: * Locates "A" Gas Decay Tank pressure indication and records on Attachment Examiners Cue: Final Gas Decay Tank pressure is 23 psi Comment:

Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 11 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:

  • Calculate the Actual Gas Decay Tank liP and record. (Log Item 29).

Standard: * Actual Gas Decay Tank ~P calculated and recorded on Attachment Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 9 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 8.37.2. Performance Step: 12 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:

  • Shut 3WG-230, Gas Decay Tanks to Plant Vent Manual Isolation Valve and log on Attachment 3. (Log Item 30)

Standard: * Locates 3WG-230 and shuts valve by rotating the handwheel in the clockwise directio * Records 3WG-230 position on Attachment Examiners Cue: 3WG-230 is shu Comment:

Step 8.37.2. Procedure Note: Independent verification of 3WG-230 position in the next step can be performed out of sequenc Performance Step: 13 The release package must be closed out by performing the following steps:

  • Perform independent verification that 3WG-230 is shut and log on Attachment 3. (Log Item 31)

Standard: Logs independent verification entry on Attachment 3 or delays action based on the Procedure Not Evaluator Cue: Independent verification will be performed out of sequence in accordance with the procedure not Comment:

Terminating Cue: After the independent verification of 3WG-230 step has been read: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.

STOP TIME:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 10 of 11 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM k Examinee's Name:

Date Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of Attempts:

Time to Complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response:

Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature: Date:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * "A" Waste Gas Decay Tank is being release * Monitors REM-3546 and RM-3546-1 are OPERABLE.

INITIATING CUE: You relieved the operator who commenced the release. The control room has just directed you to implement OP-120. 07, Section 8.37, Actions for a REM Monitor Alarm During a Waste Gas Decay Tank Release, because an ALERT alarm has been received on REM-3546.

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM k Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: . HARRIS Task No.': 301009H401 Task Title: Initiate Emergency Boration JPM No.: 2008 NRC a following a .reactor trip, (AOP-002)

". . . .

. .

KIA. Reference: . 'APE024 AA*t ..,17 (3'.9/3':.9) ALTERNATE PATH Examinee: N*RC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date':

M*etho.d:of testing::.

Simulated Performance: :...... ---..:-:--

Actual Performance: . .x Classroom X Plant'

. '. .

  • R*EAD TO'THE' EXAMIN..EE twill explalntheinitialconditions, which steps to simulate or.discuss.rand provide initiating .

cues..* When you complete*the**task,suc,cessfuJly.,*.the'*objective forthis Job-Performance Measure willbe satisfied. . ' .

" '

. . . . .

lnltlal Conditions: -. * ..The plant was, .'at. tOO%,,;power,whe'n: an .autornatic reactor trip' . '

occurred due toaninadvertent mainturbinetrip

. . " " (. ' . . : ' .' . ' ,

e, .' The. Grewhasperformed PATH~1"i.mmediateactions and: have tra'nsitioned'*to'I;,P,P~004,",R,EA'C,TOR ':TR'rP *"RE.S,PO*N*SE .

Task'*Stan:dafd:. Emergency Borationflow ~30 GPMwith Charging flow ~30. GPM

. ", . .

. ' . ' .

.. ', :.'

. '. .

'. Required Materials; General References: . * EPP*.O:04*, REACTOR* TRIP RESPO,NS*E

  • ,AO*P'-D02,.EMER,*GE'N'CY. BORATIO*N

" . Handout: 'None - usesimulator.references

. .

I:nitlating.* Cue: * . You are the control board-operator,

  • 'Perform EPP~004

, .

  • *Anotheroperat'orh'asbeen*assigned to perform Step' '3,:Check '

RCSTempsrature

,Time"Critical'Ta'sk:' No H.ARRIS*08 'NRC JPM:"aRevis:ion O' NUREG,*1*O'2'1,Revisio AppendixC Job Performance Measure . Form ES-C-1

. Worksheet .

. Validation Time: 5 minutes

.HARRIS08 NRC**J.PM. a RevislonO NUREG *1021 .Revision 9

AppendixC . Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-.1*

Worksheet

.SIMULATOR*SETUP

  • Any tOO% .power '1 .

~ M'ALF to.: prevent two control rods.from lnsertinqenthe tri * CR*F**16a* 220.,0 4 .

. .... .

CRF16b': 220 ..0. '27'

. .'. .

  • ~hsure_. step countersarecorrect

.... lnltiate a'**.Mf(N UA~* M'aJn.Turbine trip .

. ~ '. .. . ' "

".' '. -, ".' ',', '. . .' .

'.....*... Verify*Hnt1l.e:d1at*s.*actioh .,' conditiorisare met .

  • .StabilizeRCStetllper:atlJrewifhin the required range for EPP,,004,Step 3
  • . ". R.U*N **'CAE*P 1NRC'. JP'M.a

.'*:HARRI--SOS*N.RC .JPM.a: Revision 0 NUREG102t, Revision' 9

Appendix C Page 4 of9 Form ES-C-1

'PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Den.ote Critical Steps with. a check mark)

. ; ' . . .

START *-,TI*ME.:.

EP'P-004, Step.. **1

. .

. . ,- .

. .P erformance StE!P:*~.1 Implement Function Restoration Procedures As Require * Reviews Critical SafetyFunctions on plant computer screen.*

  • May inform U~CO~h.at none appl . . " . . "': . .

. **Evalu.ator**:Cu:e*:: Acknowledge, asnecessar .'. ' . . . ' . .

.. .' . . . '.' . .

Evaluator.. Noter. .' .The applicantmay .jle.ri"odica*lIy review Critlca! 'S"afety

'. .' Functionsand ,FOLDOUT criteria, None" applies' 'in this JP* . . . ' .

. .

- .Comrnent: .

.. Ep:P~.004,. *Step*2 Performance Step: 2 . .. EvaluateEAL Network Usinq.EritryPolnt ',', ' ... " .... , . . . . . "

Standa~d: .

. *lnform.sUSC.O/SS.*O*.*

. .

Evaluator Cue: .Acknowledge, as US*CO . ,or.S:SO*.

. . . . ' ~

HARRISOS' NRC J*P*M a RevisionO NUREG 1021, Revisions

Appendix 'C Page**5*of9 Form ES-C-1

. .

  • PE*R.FORMAN:CE**I NF*ORMATION

~PP-004'" Step 3'

Performance . Step: 3 : Ch~ck.*.RCS* Temperature:

Standard; *Ack~*lowle.dge.that,perlnltial Condltlons, another operator is'

.performinqthis task, Comment:*

. EPP-004~* Step4

'.. Performance-Step: 4-* Oheck RCp* Status:

...**. Checl<RCP's- atleastonerUnning* .

.*Standatd.:. . veriftes*allfhreeRCP'srunning; .

. . :**.EPP.~O(J4*.~*:*$te.p '5.'. .'

Performance step: 5. ... . Ch~ckFeed:s~st~m Status:. ..

.* . .RCStemperature-J.ess than 564 *F

..*. Verifyfeed "reg' *valve.s*.-*.SHUT .

. .. .. " , .

Ii . Oheckfeedflow toSrs's ..... greater than210 KPH

. . .. . . . ' . .

. Standard; ., * *. Verifies RCStemperature indication lessthan564 * F .

  • {YE:~).** -, .
  • *.Verifieseach Feed Req.Valve indicating SHUT
  • Verifie*s:.:total'A*FW*,flow gre:aterthan *2*10***KPH**

. Comment:

HARRIS08 :NRC JPM.a. Revision '0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix ***Page*6.of*9 Form ES-C-1 PERF.ORMANCE*INFORMATIO.N*

EPP-004,$tep .1 Performance step: 6.' Check control rod status:

  • . Check *DRPI -. available

, *Stand*atd:: - DeterminesDfiPlavailable by indicating lights on AEP';1

  • Determines two rodsstuckfullyout
  • Takes RN*O:p.ath:tb AOP~D,02* .

. ' .' . '

Evaluator-Note; .: pplic.'ant' mayqo ,to, AEp:~t to' determine which rods are A

, stuc .i*' ' . ' '

. . . ."

, .

. . AOP-002, Step 1 . . .. .* . . ..... ..

. V'~~IF'Y aBoric Acid {BA)',Pump*RUNNI*N .. Comment: .

. '

.AOP-OO?; '$tep*2**.a

. , . . . . . , .

. ,JPerformanceStep:8 '. E*S.TABLISH*':,boratiqn flowpa*th"*usih'g.' tCS~278 .asfollows:

- .*-. OPEN1CS';278, Emerge~cyBoricAcid Addition. .

. . .' . . . . ..

. ,

Sta*'n*dard::' .Opens'tC,S-278, Ernerqency: Boric Acid .Additio ,Oomment: .'

.' "'\

HARRI S08 *NRC* JPM.'a RevisionO NUR'EG 1'021, Revision 9

AppendixC Page7of9 .Form.ES-C-1

. .

  • PERFORMAN.C.E*IN*F*oR*MAT.ION A:OP-002,2*.b PerformanceStep: .. ESTABLISH* boration flowpathusing 1CS~278

. . . .

as follows:

.

  • e VE*R1FYat.teast 3*0**gpm*boric acid flow. to C*SI.P suction 6n**FI*~.1l0.*

e* GO. TO*Step . Stan*dard:

.. .... .. ... ..... ... AOP-002,Step4 . ... .. . . . . . .. ..

.. .. . Performance Step: to VERIFYandM'AINrAINatleas130gpm charging f1pwtoRCS

..:.. (FF-J ~2J?~:.t.)"lJntii requiredboration is complete ' . . : ".:. '. " . .

: *Stcindard.: .Verifies .~*3:C)'*GPM.flow*in.dicated *onFi.-*12.2A~*1-~ .

. :* . Commentr

. . . .

. ' .. ' .

' . -: . ' . '. "...

... T~rrriinatingCue: . Aftel:Charging floWi~ verified: Evaluation on this JPM is

. complete.. ' . ..' .

. . ' ..

-. . . . ' . .

.S*TO*P* TlivI:E: ..

. HAR*RIS08**N*RC JPM aRevision * NUREG 1-02.1., .Revision 9

Appendi Paqe 8: of 9 . Form ES-C-1 VERIFI.CATIO.N* OF* COMPLETION Job PerformanceMeasure No.: .2El08 N:RC* J:P*M a Examinee's Name:

Facility Evaluator;

.. NumberofAttempts:

.. .

QUeSfiOn[)OCUmentafion:* .

. .

.**Q*ue*sfipn.:..:..

Response:'

.Result:** . **SAT*

Examtner'sSiqnature: Date:".

~-----,;.-~--~------.,............---,--~-----.....,.:.-: ------,.----,.--

. .

H.ARR1S08NRC*:.JPM* a RevislonO . NUREG *1021 ,Revision 9

Appendix C* Page 90f9 Form ES-C-1 JPM CU*E SHE*ET

  • INITI*A.L.C.ON*DI*TIONS: *.. The plant was at 100% power when an automaticreactor

. tripoccurreddue to an 'inadvertent main turbine trip

. . .

  • . T~~ crew has .perfbrmed*PA-rH-1 immediate.actions .and havetransitioned toEt>*P-0*04,REA.C.TOR*TRI P RESPONSE*. .

"... ' .

. .

..1NITIA~TJNG* CU.E:* ., .* You are.. the:. control board . o perator .

. *petform:*:E*P*P*-OO:4:

.. ' ' . ' . .

.- Anotheroperatorhasbeenassignedlo perform Step 3,

. :*C*heck*RCS::*Te,mper.ature . .

, . . .

. -

H.ARRIS*O*8.N*RC J.PM -a RevisionO NUREG 1021 , Revision-a

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS Task No.: 301149H601 Task Title: Align ECCS for long-term JPM No.: 2008 NRC JPM b recirculation (EPP-010)

KIA Reference: 006 A4.05 3.9/ ALTERNATE PATH Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date:

Method of testing:

Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Classroom ---

Simulator X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

Initial Conditions: * A large break LOCA caused a reactor trip and safety injection

  • SI has been reset and CCW has been aligned to the RHR HXs
  • CSIP "A" and CSIP "C" (as "8") are running
  • EPP-010, Transfer to Cold Leg Recirculation, was just entered Task Standard: Recirculation flow established on both trains.

Required Materials: None General References: EOP-EPP-010, Transfer to Cold Leg Recirculation, Revision 17 Handout: Use Simulator copy of EPP-010 and ensure it is cleaned after each use or provide a paper copy.

Initiating Cue: Perform EPP-010. In accordance with the Step 1 CAUTION, the steps should be performed without delay. However, this is NOT a time-critical JPM because the procedure would normally be read to you.

Time Critical Task: NO HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 12 minutes HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP

  • THE FOLLOWING STEPS DESCRIBE THE STEPS NEEDED TO ESTABLISH CONDITIONS:
  • IC-19
  • Substitute CSIP "C" for "B"
  • CVC045, 046, 049, 050 removes CSIP "B" and installs CSIP "C"
  • Insert malfunctions:
  • Initiate a large break LOCA RCS01A
  • Perform PATH-1 to transition to EPP-010.
  • Ensure SI RESET and align CCW to the RHR heat exchangers.
  • FREEZE the simulator and SNAP to NRC JPM b.
  • When Applicant is ready, place simulator in RUN.

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 4 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

Performance Step: 1 Obtain copy of EOP-EPP-01 Standard: Enters EPP-01 Evaluator's Cue: Provide handout if necessar Comment:

Performance Step: 2 Read CAUTION statements before Step * Do Steps 1 through 8 without delay. Do NOT implement Function Restoration Procedures prior to completion of these step * SI recirculation flow to RCS must be maintained at all time * Switchover to recirculation may cause high radiation levels in the reactor auxiliary building. Radiation levels must be assessed prior to performance of local actions in the affected are Standard: Reviews CAUTION' Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 5 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Performance Step: 3 Read Notes before Step 1

  • Foldout applie * CNMT wide range sump level of greater than 142 INCHES should ensure a long term recirculation suction sourc * The following sequence of steps to transfer to cold leg recirculation assumes operability of at least one train of safeguards equipmen Standard: Reviews NOTE's and may review to FOLDOUT item Comment:

Step Performance Step: 4 Verify both RHR pumps - Runnin Standard: Verifies both RHR pumps running by observing RED light ON, flow and/or current indicate Comment:

Step Performance Step: 5 Establish RHR Pump Recirculation Alignment:

Verify CNMT sump to RHR pump suction valves OPEN:

  • Train B RHR pump: 1SI-301 AND 1SI-311 Standard: * Verifies Train A sump valves open by observing RED lights ON, green lights OFF on 1SI-300 and 1SI-31 * Verifies Train B sump valves open by observing RED lights ON, green lights OFF on 1SI-301 and 1SI-31 Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 6 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 1.c

-'./ Performance Step: 6 Shut RWST to RHR pump suction valves:

Standard: * Places 1SI-322 and 1SI-323 handswitches to CLOSE

  • Vertty valves closed by observing RED lights ON, green lights OFF on 1SI-322 and 1SI-323 Comment: Critical to isolate RHR pumps from RWST as suction sourc Step Performance Step: 7 Shut low head SI Train A to cold leg valve: 1SI-340 Standard: * Places 1SI-340 Control Power O * Verifies ORANGE Control Power Light O * Places 1SI-340 handswitch to CLOS * Determines that 1SI-340 does NOT close by observing RED light ON, GREEN light OF * Goes to Step 1.c RN Comment:

Step 1.d RNO

-'./ Performance Step: 8 Shut low head SI Train B to cold leg valve: 1SI-341 Standard: * Places 1SI-341 Control Power O * Verifies ORANGE Control Power Light O * Places 1SI-341 handswitch to CLOS * Verifies that 1SI-341 closes by observing RED light OFF, GREEN light O Comment: Critical to isolate one train to comply with EOP BKG assumptions.

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 7 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 9 Check RHR Pump recirculation alignment - at least one train establishe Standard: Verifies both trains aligne Comment:

Performance Step: 10 Establish CSIP Recirculation Alignment: Shut CSIP alternate miniflow isolation valves:

Standard: * Places 1CS-746 handswitch in CLOS * Determines 1CS-746 did NOT close by observing RED light ON, GREEN light OF * Goes to Step 2.a RN * Verifies 1CS-752 closed by observing RED light OFF, GREEN light O Comment:

Step 2.a.RNO

~ Performance Step: 11 Shut the associated block valve: 1CS-745 (Train B CSIP).

Standard: * Places 1CS-745 handswitch in CLOS * Verifies 1CS-745 closed by observing RED light OFF, GREEN light O Comment: Critical to CLOSE 1CS-745 to isolate miniflow to RWS Evaluator Note: Applicant may also CLOSE 1CS-753 as part of RNO although this is NOT required.

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 8 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 12 Verify normal miniflow isolation valves - SHUT

  • 1CS-214 Standard: Verifies at least one valve closed in each line (RED lights OFF, GREEN lights ON.)

Comment:

Step 2.c

~ Performance Step: 13 Open RHR discharge to CSIP suction valves:

  • 1RH-63 Standard: * Places handswitches for both 1RH-25 and 1RH-63 in OPE * Verifies 1RH-25 and 1RH-63 open by observing RED lights ON, GREEN lights OF Comment: Critical to supply suction flowpath from sump to CSI Step Performance Step: 14 Reset S Standard: SI RESET in Initial Conditions but may reset agai Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 9 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 15 Manually realign safeguards equipment following a loss of offsite powe Standard: Reads continuous action and determines off-site power availabl Comment:

Step 2.f

~ Performance Step: 16 Shut RWST to CSIP suction valves AND place in pull-to-Iock position:

  • LCV-115B
  • LCV-115D Standard: * Places LCV-115B and LCV-115D in CLOSE and then in PULL-TO-LOCK
  • Verifies LCV-115B and LCV-115D closed by observing RED lights OFF, GREEN lights O Comment: Critical to isolate RWST suction while aligned for recir Step Performance Step: 17 Check Charging System Status:
  • Check charging line - isolate Standard: * Checks Charging Line Isolation Valves 1CS-235 and 1CS-238 CLOSED by observing RED lights OFF, GREEN lights O * May also check FCV-122.1 CLOSED by observing flow indication at ZER Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 10 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step Performance Step: 18 Verify Both Charging Pumps - RUNNIN Standard: Verifies CSIPs 1A-SA and 1C-SB both running by observing RED lights ON, GREEN lights OF Comment:

Step 4.a

"" Performance Step: 19 Establish Recirculation Injection Flowpath:

  • Open alternate high head SI to cold leg valve: 1SI-52 Standard: * Places 1SI-52 Control Power O * Verifies ORANGE Control Power Light O * Places 1SI-52 handswitch to OPE * Verifies 1SI-52 open by observing RED light ON, green light OF Comment: Critical to establish injection flowpat Step Performance Step: 20 Check any BIT outlet valve - open
  • 1SI-4 Standard: Verifies both 1SI-3 and 1SI-4 open by observing RED lights ON, GREEN lights OF Comment:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 11 of 13 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Step 4.c-V Performance Step: 21 Shut CSIP discharge cross connect valves based on Table:

CSIP "A" and CSIP "C" running:

  • Verifies respective valves re-position by observing RED lights OFF, GREEN lights ON Comment: Critical to separate SI Trains during recirculation phas Step 5 Performance Step: 22 Verify High Head SI Flow:
  • Alternate header flow (Train A): FI-940
  • Normal header flow (Train B): FI-943 Standard: * Verifies Train A flow indication on FI-94 * Verifies Train B flow indication on FI-94 Comment:

Terminating Cue: When the candidate moves to Step 6, Verify CCW Alignment

- - - : Evaluation on this JPM is complete.

STOP TIME:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 12 of 13 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM b Examinee's Name:

Date Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of Attempts:

Time to Complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response:

Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature: Date:

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 13 of 13 Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * A large break LOCA caused a reactor trip and safety injection

  • SI has been reset and CCW has been aligned to the RHR HXs
  • CSIP "A" and CSIP "C" (as "8") are running
  • EPP-010, Transfer to Cold Leg Recirculation, was just entered INITIATING CUE: Perform EPP-010. In accordance with the Step 1 CAUTION, the steps should be performed in an expeditious manner. However, this is NOT a time-critical JPM because the procedure would normally be read to you.

HARRIS 2008 NRC JPM b Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-.1

'Worksheet Facility: . *HARRIS . Task NO.:301170H601 Task Title: "Initiate ReS Feedand Bleed (FRP- JPM. No.:' 20.:0'8. NRC JPM c H~"1) .

.\"

KIA Reference: E*O.S EA1.1 (4.1) AL:TERNATE. PATH Examinee: .N*RCExaminer:

. . . .

Facility Evaluator:  : Date:

.'Method"*of testing ~.

. . '. . .  : ..

x

,'

Simulated Performance: '. --.-,..:. ,. ---,...;.;-_ . . ActualPerformance:

.Classrco Simulator Plant

. ',,:' '. .

  • REAO* 'TO :THE* EXAIVUNEE" .'

./ will explainthe inltialconditions, whi~h steps.to simulate or:discuss, and provide initiating

..'cues ..':" Wh~n *yo.u**.complete-the task' successfully, the objective for.thls Job Performanc MeasurewiH be satisfie ". '..' . '> . . '. . . * ...* .*.. ,' ' ", . . * . . ...*...... .'

. Initial Conditions: -ThereactortrippedJrom fOO%powerdue to a loss ofoff-site

. *power~.. . .

. '-' .ASBLbCA occurred following' the* reactor tri e' '.. Adversecontainmentvalues 'are in -. effect. .

-Sus 1A-SAis'locked out*on*anelectricalf~ul j- . Motor Driven AFW PumpB" is partially disassembled for

'. maintenanc .

. . ' .

..* The Tl.irbine,;,DrivenAFWPump failed while 'startin .* .The .crew is performinq *FRP._:H.:1*,.RE.S.:P.ONS'"E TO**LO$.SOF

  • SECONDAR.Y HEAT*sfNK.. . . .". .

- TheFoldoutcriteda forinitiationof RCSFeed and Bleed' have

.just been. me . . '

. .... .. . . .

Task .Standard: .RCS~'feed' establishedwith maximum.availablebleed pat Required.Materials: Attach'PAT'H-1 .(3*UI:DE Attachment 1'.: tq*this.JPMfor'-use by the evaluator...

GeneralReferences: FR*P-H.1*,RESPONSE* TO*.LOSS*OF SECONDARY HEAT SIN.K, Revision 21 ..

  • HAR.RIS 2008* NRC'JPM C Revision O' *NUREG 1'021*, Revislons

.Appendix C' Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 .

Work*sheet Handout: . Use Simulator ccipy*ofFRP-H.1.andensure*it is cleaned after each use

.orprovide a paper cop . .

Observe.the 'procedure CAUTION prior to FRP-H.1 ,.Step 1'2,. then initiate RC.*S.*feed and blee .

Time *C*dtical.* Task:*

.Validation Time: 8 minute " "-

. HARRI.S2*OO.8.*:NR*C: JP.M* cRevision 0 . NUREG'1 021*,. Revision 9

Appendix C' JobPerformanceMeasure

'Worksheet

.'.. SU't1U.LAT,OR SET.U.P*

  • -Atpower Ie*

' . .

  • Tag *M.DAFWPumpuB" .

.e ':MALF 'for art electricalfault to.lock out.Bus 1A-SA'

e MALF to trip .T*DAFW Pump durlng.AUTO*.start

. . .

e Overrides to' blo'ck'MA'"NUAL **QP*EN.orf P.CV-44SA.an*d.:PCV-444*S*

. .. . Loss ofOff-site power

. .

. . .

  • e -:'Peiiorm **PAT.H-*1- . . ~ .' .

e*' . Perform EPP~4" .

.... .:SBL()CAaJter e*ntedngH~P-H;1 to get toadyetsecontajnrnenfv~lues;

'HARRIS200a'NRC JPMc.Revision '0

Appendix C' P*ag.e 4 of 10 . Form ES-C-1

.PERF()RMANCE' INFORMATION (Denote Critic at Steps'.with a. 'check .,nark): .

START TIME:

FRP*:H;1,Step12* . .

. Procedure CAUTION: Perform Steps *1.-2. throuqhZ! .C1uickl*y to 'establish **RCS heat removalby :RC*S**:*bl*eed* 'and fee Verify *AII Reps'...*STOP*PED .

All RCP;s stopped on LOOP.****

Co*mrrl'ent:..

. '.' . .'.'.:'.' -. :: ... :..

.. ' . . ." .*ERP~H.t Step 13 . '

" ' . . .

.Performance.Step; 2* '-:' Actuate .SL**

. .,' .",  : .. ' .

VerifiesSI'actualed...' .....

'. .

'. Comment: .

FRP,-H.'1,Step1'4 .

~~:rF~~6~~6:~~kFOLLOWING: . .'

  • '.* \lERIFYpSIPS"AT LEASTONERUNNING; .

.* VE.RIFY:*SI,**VAL.VE*S*~*.*PROPERLY*.AL.IG*N:ED .. (REFE .' TO-. PATH*-*1*,(3UID:E., ATTACHME*NT 1) .'

.* Verifie~**:C§J.P.:uB~':: runnlnq. (R.~:p**tig*hts} .

'. .Verifies valvealigrllTlent using Guide 1,Attachment1, and/or verifles flow indicationon the Sl.Flow meter .

. .' .  :., . : . ' .

Guide 1,Attachmenf1 has been performed. Alignment is

  • co.rrecffortlle current.powersltuatlo .

. . .

.' . . ..... .

. . .

. ~ ..

Evaluator Note: . Only Train**"B'f*is*.operable~ no.' power to Train "A".

HARRIS* 2008 NRC' JP*M* c Revision 0 N.UREG 1021-., Revision 9

Appendix C* Page 5 of 10 . Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INF:ORMATI.ON Comment:

  • FRP-H~:1-*,* Step:*1*S
  • v . Performance-Step: 4 ResetS .' .". ..". "." "... ",
  • " 0 ' *

. . .

. ." . " . . . " . . '. . ' . .

    • Sta*.nda*rd:*. . . Places both Sl Train RESET:Switche*s.*in RE*SET and

... releases. <">- . .

.. .

  • .Verifies RES.ETan* Bypass Permissive Panel

". . .

. . . . .

.**:.C*om'ment: ... . . Criticalto allow operator *co~trol* of equipment/slqnal .. .. . :... . :..

.. FR*P*-H.. 1..~*.*Step~:1.6.**.. . ...

,perf~rmarice'St~p:5 "MANUALLY~EAUGNSAFE-GUAROSEQUIPMENT

.. *P*O.LLOW*IN:<3* A LO*SS***O*F:.Of.=*.F:'*S**ITE.** POWER*..

(REFERTOPAtH~tGUIDE, ATTl\eHMENT 2.)

Sta.n.da.r.ct : .

. .

',' , , ' " " 'FRP:'H:f;Step17 ' '

':v "Perform~u16eSfep:6" " ,Reset. Phase AAND PhaseB'lsolation Signal ,.. ,Standard:' .' PlacesTrainA" andTrairrBtPhase "A'iRESET Switches ih'RESET'al1d releases, N) , ",

..*.. ****Places.*Tra*in "A'" andTrain "B" Phase "-B"-RE*SET S*witches

. :in**RESE*T*:ai1d*:rele:as8s*.* .

. FR:P~H~*1.~Stept8

  • 1***. PerformanceSteprr Ene:tgize**AC**Suses* tA1A*N*O:*1* *Stanliard*:* *.. . Enerqizes Bus 1*B:t:by. closinqthecross-tie from thevital
    • bus.* .

. . .

  • HA*RR'IS.*.2008 *NR.C:J*P.M c RevisionO .

Appendix C Page 6 of 10 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION

  • No power available to 1A Comment:

FRP-H.1, Step 19

~Performance Step: 8 Establish Instrument Air AND Nitrogen To CNMT:

a. Open the following valves:

  • 11A~819
  • 181-287 b.Place air compressor tAand 1 B:i~ the local control mod (Refer to PATH-.1GUIDE, Attachment 5.)

Standard: * O*pens*1IA-819(~)

  • ()pens1SJ-287 (-V)
  • "Dispatches an AO to place .1A and .1 BAir*Compressors in'

the LOCAL Control Mod Booth .Operator Cue: Acknowl~dge'assignmentthenactuatethe ET to place 1A andt B *Ah"* compressors in the LOCAL Mode and, report bac Comment: Critical to supply air toPRZR PORV's.

HARRIS 2008 NRCJPM c Revision 0 NUREG'1021,Revision 9

AppendixC, Page 7 of to Form ES-C-1

,PERFORMANCE,INFORMATION FRP-H.1, Step20 . .

-v , PerformanceStep: 9 'ESTAB.LrSH**RCS BLEED.PATH*: ' .

. ESTABLIS:H lWO ReS: BLEED 'PATHS LISTED. IN*. TABLE 2 BY PE*RFO'RMING,*!.HEFOLLOWI:NG FOR EAC'HBLE'ED PATH:

. . ' .

  • VE:RIF)~\P.RZ.*PQRV* BLO.CK VALVE - OPEN'..

'.O*PE:N 'PRZ PORV~

  • . .Eval*.u*ate.EA*L. network usinq entry, point .. . .

.Standard: : *... \/erifiesHC':'115 andRC.:.117 indicate OPEN (RED light)

  • . ', ,*No:*,iti*dicalio*n:for**R.C--1*1:3

.*... *Op*ens .*PCV-44~*~* (1)"

.', :,*In-forms,.*ShiftS:up.erintendent:to evaluateEat.network using

..'entry"poi'h.t.:U*** -.

. '. " ", ..

. . . .

" ' .

~ . ' . , . . '

.EvaluatorOue:

. " .... - ...

. ....: Fhe tastknownposltlon for *RC-113* was .OPEN*~..

  • . As Shift 5 uperi ntendent, acknowledqe direction to .

.evaluate fhe,EAL.*.n*etWo'.rk. ustnq entry.pointU: ,

. . .' . ' ,

. . . . .

. . '. . . . .

'. Evaluator Note:' ' ,O*n.l.y *P*GV-44513~*.Will**o.pe.n .. Th*e.. applicantshoul..d attemptto o,p*~n.*a*lf~PRZ:,*p6R"' .,' .

. C"itjcaltoe~tablish the available PORV bleed pat .FRP~H.t,Step 2La(ALTERNATEPATH.begins)* .

"Performance St,ep*:*.*:1 O* VerifyAdequate RtrS *~leed**Path:. . .' .

'Chetk.:.PRZ* P()RVs*AND* .associatedblockvalves .. *lWO* BLEED:'.

.;P*ATHS. *OPE*N*.

RNO a. GO TO Step 21 Sla'lidard: ...*. "..Determinesonlyone PRZ PORV'is OPE..N~

.' . . Proceeds to' *RN*().*

  • C.omment:

NUREG 1,02'1', Revisions

Appendix : Page Bot- to,.. *Form ES-C-1 PERFORMAN'CE IN:FORMATION

  • FRP-H.l,.$tep. 2.1.c .

" .Performance-Step:

. . . 11 Open *a*It*Res vent valves to commence ventinq: .

'*. *.1RC~900

., l' RC:"901

  • **tR*C-902
  • . *1-R*C:-903

.*. :lRC-S04 e.' :JR*C-90.S*

Standard:' Opens: .'

'.. 1.R*C~9 ..

. .

  • . ..-.t:RC*~903*:* .

.~:.. ~. ': : ..

. * '. '1 RC~905>:'

.. . . .. . . . ': . ". . ': . ., :., '.0:" .

JiOp()Wer~vailabl(ft01RC~9bol'1RC-902,.1,RC~90 . .

  • ,EvaluafotNote: , Thereis criticalto~stablisl1thelnCl){I~umavailablebleed' pat . .'

. Cornment:

T~rmin~tingCue: , '

l*

. . .

HARR.lS2008NRC*:-J*P*M: C'*Revision O* N.UR*E.G** *1'021-, Revision 9

AppendixC *P.age*g of.10 Form ES~C-1

. ' ."

VERIFICATIO'N "OF COMp*LETrON* .

. .

JobPerformance Measure No.: . :2*0.08:NR*CJPM c

.Date-Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number :.of Attempts:

. .

.. .

Time to.';Complete;

. .'

. . ' .....

'. **Qu*estion** Documentatiorr; .

. . . .

Q uestion: .

. ' ..... -.

Response: . .

Result: . SA*T

' . ~

.' . . .:".'

. .

Examiner's Signature': Date:

HARRIS 2008 'NRC' JPM' c Revision 0" NUREG*1 02'1,. Revision 9

Page*1O' of to Form ES-C':'1 JPM CUE SHEET

  • The reactortripped.. from :-1'00'% .power -. due:to.aloss of off-

. .sitepower. . ' . ., . .

.* Adverse containment

. .

values are in*effe:c .'. Bus lA-SA. 'is 'locked'

.

out on ari..electrical faul ' . .

  • . Motor Driven 'AFW Pump "8'.' Ispartially disassembled for maintenanc . .

'. The Turbihe-DrivenAFWPumpfailedwhile starting. .

  • ThecrewisperforrninqFfcp-l-l.f; RE*SPO.NS.*E.TO* LOSS

.~

O*F.SECONDARY:HEAT.SINK*..

..' . ".' ' . . . . " .' . .' . '. . .. .

.* . .The Foldout'criteria for initiationof RGS .Feed and Bleed

.*h*ave.j~Js.f*been***met~**

. "

. .

.. ' . . .: ' . . . . . . '. . . .

FRP~tt1, Step 12, then

. . .

."'INITIArl Nf3****CUE*:* Observe the procedureGAUTIONpriorto

  • initiat.8.***RC*S*Ofe*ed*a*ndble*e.d*. . '.

1 ..

HAR*R.fS 2.0:08N.RC JPM*c Revision O *NU*Rr=G 102'1., Revisions

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS Task No.:

Task Title: Respond to a loss of Normal JPM No.: 2008 NRC d Service Water (AOP-022)

KIA Reference: 076 A2.01 (3.5/3.7) ALTERNATE PATH Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date:

Method of testing:

Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Classroom Simulator X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

Initial Conditions: * Reactor power is 9%

  • The Main Turbine is rolling at 1800 RPM in preparation for synchronizing in accordance with GP-005, POWER OPERATION
  • NSW Pump "A" is under clearance to investigate excessive shaft vibration
  • CCW Pump "A" is under clearance while electricians investigate a breaker alignment problem.

Task Standard: Emergency Service Water isolated from NSW and Main Turbine tripped Required Materials: None General References: AOP-022, LOSS OF SERVICE WATER GP-005, POWER OPERATION Initiating Cue: You are the board operator. Standby to raise reactor power greater than P-10 in accordance with GP-005, Step 97, when the USCO gives the order.

Time Critical Task: NO HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 5 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP

  • Go to RUN on Simulator
  • Start "8" NSW Pump
  • Secure and tag "A" NSW Pump
  • Secure and tag "A" CCW
  • MALF to prevent ESW Pump AUTO start (PT:9101A 200.0)

HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 4 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

Performance Step: 1 Responds to alarms/indicatio Standard: * Determines NSW Pump "8" has tripped and "A" is unavailable

AOP-022, Step 1 (Immediate Action)

Performance Step: 2 CHECK ESW flow lost to ANY RUNNING CSIP - MORE THAN 1-minute:

Standard: Answers NO Evaluator Note: * Applicant may go back and perform Step 1 RNO Path actions (trip the running CSIP and isolate Letdown) if ESW flow is lost for more than one minut * Applicant may start "A" ESW Pump at any time after recognizing auto start failure (> 20 sees, no SW flow) in accordance with management expectations for operator action on failure Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 5 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-022, Step 2 (Immediate Action)

Performance Step: 3 CHECK ESW flow lost to ANY RUNNING EDG - MORE THAN 1-minute:

Standard: Answers NO - no EDG operating Comment:

AOP-022, Step 3 Performance Step: 4 GO TO the appropriate step as indicated by the parameter LOST:'

Standard: Proceeds to Step 6 for NSW Pump lost/loss of flo Comment:

AOP-022, Step 6 Performance Step: 5 * CHECK loss of NSW Header due to NSW Pump FAILED or LOSS OF FLO * START standby NSW Pump as follows:

  • CHECK ANY NSW Pump - RUNNIN Standard: * Determines loss of NSW header due to loss of only available pump
  • Determines no NSW Pump running and proceeds toRNO Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 6 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-022, Step 6.b RNO

~ Performance Step: 6 VERIFY BOTH ESW Pumps - RUNNIN Standard: * Determines "B" ESW Pump running and initiates a MANUAL start on "A" ESW Pump (~)

  • GO TO Section 3.2 (page 30)

Comment: Critical to provide adequate flow to the ESW header AOP-022, Step 3. Performance Step: 7 CHECK Turbine trip required by ANY of the following conditions -

EXIST:

  • No NSW Pump can be operated Standard: Answers YES Comment:

AOP-022, Step 3. Performance Step: 8 CHECK Reactor power greater than P-10 (10%).

Standard: * Verifies reactor power < P-10 and answers NO

  • Proceeds to RNO column Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 7 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-022, Step 3.2.2 RNO Performance Step: 9 IF Turbine is operating, THEN TRIP Turbine AND GO TO Step Standard: * Initiates a MANUAL Turbine Trip

  • Verifies Turbine Stop Valves closed Comment:

Terminating Cue: When the turbine trip is verified: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.

STOP TIME:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 8 of 9 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM d Examinee's Name:

Date Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of Attempts:

Time to Complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response:

Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature: Date:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 9 of 9 Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * Reactor power is 9%

  • The Main Turbine is rolling at 1800 RPM in preparation for synchronizing in accordance with GP-005, POWER OPERATION
  • NSW Pump "A" is under clearance to investigate excessive shaft vibration
  • CSIP Pump "A" is under clearance while electricians investigate a breaker alignment problem.

INITIATING CUE: You are the board operator. Standby to raise reactor power greater than P-10 in accordance with GP-005, Step 97, when the USCO gives the order.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM d Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS Task No.:

Task Title: Place the Containment Hydrogen JPM No.: 2008 NRC JPM e Purge System in operation (OP-125)

KIA Reference: 028 A4.01 (4.0/4.0)

Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date:

Method of testing:

Simulated Performance: X Actual Performance:

Classroom Simulator Plant X This JPM will be simulated in the Control Room.

READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

Initial Conditions: * A large break LOCA has occurre * Hydrogen Recombiner problems have resulted in a Containment Hydrogen concentration> 4°A>.

  • The USCG has directed that the Hydrogen Purge System be placed in operation in accordance with OP-125, POST ACCIDENT HYDROGEN SYSTE * The Hydrogen Purge System is aligned in accordance with OP-125, Attachments 4 and * A release permit has been approve * The Containment is at atmospheric pressure
  • An AO is standing by to operate local valves Task Standard: System aligned with release in progress.

Required Materials: Key for 1CM-2 General References: OP-125, POST ACCIDENT HYDROGEN SYSTEM.

Handout: OP-125 with 5.3.1.1 and 5.3.1.2 initialed.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Initiating Cue: Simulate placing the Hydrogen Purge System in operation in accordance with OP-125. DO NOT OPERATE ANY EQUIPMEN Discuss indications that you would expect to see as a result of the simulated operations. Time compression will be used to report field operations and/or indications.

Time Critical Task: NO Validation Time: 8 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Periormance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP N/A HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 4 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

OP-125 Performance Step: 1 Obtain/review procedure Standard: * Reviews Precaution and Limitations and Initial Conditions for the tas * Proceeds to Section Evaluator Cue: Provide handout for NRC JPM Comment:

OP-125, 5.3. Performance Step: 2 OBTAIN the key for 1CM-2, Hydrogen Purge Isolation Valv Standard: * Discusses location and process for obtaining the key(s)

  • Proceeds to ARP-4 Evaluator Cue: After the applicant discusses the process for obtaining the key: Assume that you have the key for 1CM- Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM eRevision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 5 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-125, 5.3.2.2

~ Performance Step: 3 At ARP-4A SA TURN the key switch for Hydrogen Purge Isolation (CS-3074.1 SA) to O Standard: Points out ON position for 1CM-2 (labeled Control Power Key Switch 1CM-2 H2 Purge Exh Valve) and simulates turning the ke Evaluator Note: Turning the switch to ON energizes control power for 1CM- Evaluator Cue: When the applicant goes to the MCB to operate 1CM-2, he/she may verify the control power light on. If so: The CONTROL POWER ON light is illuminated for 1CM- Verification of the light is not a critical tas Comment:

OP-125, 5.3. Procedure Note: If in MODES 1, 2, 3, or 4, opening 1CM-2 will result in entering an LCO for Tech Spec 3.6.3.

~ Performance Step: 4 OPEN HYDROGEN PURGE ISOLATION 1CM-2 S Standard: * Applicant should inform the USCO of TS requiremen * Points out OPEN position and simulates opening 1CM- Evaluator Cue: * Acknowledge report of TS requiremen * 1CM-2'indicating lights has gone from GREEN to RE Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 6 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-125, 5.3. Performance Step: 5 Locally, UNLOCK and OPEN the following:

a. 1CM-4 H2 Purge Exhaust CIV (Outside Containment).

b. 1CM-5 H2 Purge Makeup CIV (Outside Containment).

Standard: Directs AO to unlock and open 1CM-4 and 1CM- Evaluator Cue: The AO reports: 1CM-4 and 1CM-5 are unlocked and ope Comment:

OP-125, 5.3. Procedure Note: IF the "Containment H2 Purge Filter/System High liP" (ALB-028-7-2) alarm is received, THEN it should be investigated and appropriate action taken.

-'./ Performance Step: 6 START HYDROGEN PURGE EXHAUST FAN E- Standard: Points out the START position and simulates placing the E-4 Switch to STAR Evaluator Cue: * E-4 indicating lights have gone from GREEN to RE * ALB-028-7-2 is clear Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 7 of 9 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-125, 5.3. Performance Step: 7 VERIFY the following dampers indicate open on SLB-7:

a. Window 1-1, H2 Purge CM-B1 b. Window 2-1, Fan E4 CM-B2 c. Window 3-1, H2 Purge CM-B3 Standard: At SLB-7, verifies each of the following are RED:

  • Window 1-1, H2 Purge CM-B 1
  • Window 2-1, Fan E4 CM-B2
  • Window 3-1, H2 Purge CM-B3 Evaluator Cue: As each is checked:
  • Window 1-1, H2 Purge CM-B1, is RED
  • Window 2-1, Fan E4 CM-B2, is RED
  • Window 3-1, H2 Purge CM-B3, is RED Comment:

Terminating Cue: After the damper positions are verified: Evaluation on this JPM is complete.

STOP TIME:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 8 of 9 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM e Examinee's Name:

Date Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of Attempts:

Time to Complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response:

Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature: Date:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 9 of 9 Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * A large break LOCA has occurre * Hydrogen Recombiner problems have resulted in a Containment Hydrogen concentration> 4%.

  • The USCO has directed that the Hydrogen Purge System be placed in operation in accordance with OP-125, POST ACCIDENT HYDROGEN SYSTE * The Hydrogen Purge System is aligned in accordance with OP-125, Attachments 4 and * A release permit has been approve * The Containment is at atmospheric pressure
  • An AO is standing by to operate local valves INITIATING CUE: Simulate placing the Hydrogen Purge System in operation in accordance with OP-125. DO NOT OPERATE ANY EQUIPMENT. Discuss indications that you would expect to see as a result of the simulated operations. Time compression will be used to report field operations and/or indications.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM e Revision 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

AppendixC Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet

. Facility: HARRIS Task No.:

Task Title:* Transfer an Emergency Bus to an JPM. No.: 2008 NRC f EDG due to a .deqraded grid

KIA* Reference: 062 A4.01 (3.3/3.1) AL TE-RNATE PATH Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: .Date.:

Method of testing:*

  • Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: X Classroom -"-------

Sirrurlator--.". '.... X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I wi I.!. explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating

.cues. When youcomplete the task successfully; the objective for this Job Performance .

Measure will be.: satisfied, .

..

Initial Conditions: " * The unit is at 100%. power

  • The failure of a major line.resulted in the cascading trip of several units on the grid. "
  • Grid frequency is below normal. and the crewhas entered AOP-028.,

GRID INSTABILITY, and has completed Step 9 ~*Check for-

" indications ofa load rejection. - _..- .

Task Standard: EDG "8'" supplying. 1B-S8 Bus" and the Load Sequencerreset Required Materials: None General References: AOP-028, GRID INSTABIL~ty

" Handout: Use Simulator copy. of AOP-028 and' ensure it is cleaned after each use

.orprovide Q paper cop .. .

Initiating Cue: Observe the CAUTIO.N prior to AOP-0*28, Step 1O,and then perform the proceduresteps, Tin,-e Critical. Task: NO HARRIS08 NRC JPM fRevision 0 .NUR*EG 1021, Revision 9

AppendixC Job Performa.nce Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Validation Time: 9 minutes .

Appendix C Job PerfotmanceMeasure Form ES.;.C-1 Workshe:et SIMULATOR SETUP

,lC'-19 Bring,up'ERFIS DisplaYofAOP~028',.Attach.ment 1 parameters MALFUNCTIONS:

  • PPI08 (59.2 'HZ)

, '

  • 'ZDSQ?2ATB ~ ,FAIL_ASIS (LoadBlock g'tv1anual Loading Permissive fatlure)

HARRlsoa' N'RC JPM fRevision 0, NUREG 1021, 'Revision 9

Appendi Paqe 4 of 10  ; Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INF'ORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

AOP-028, Step 10 Performance Step: l ' CAUTION*

  • W'ith off-site voltaqe .or system frequency unstable, EDGs must *NOT.be paralleled 'w-ith off site power since severe .

load swinqs may occur and overload the' EDGs*.

.affe.ctedEDG be .stopped:

Standard: Reads/acknowleoqes Comment;'

  • .A*OP~028,_Step 10

-,P erformance Step; 2 '. C'HEC'K ANY EDG operatingparalleled to the Grid. .

Standard: * Verifies" no 't=DG running 'and answers-No .

  • 'GO' TO'Step 1."2 Comment:

HARRI'S08 NRC JPM f Revision 0- NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Pa'ge 5 of 1*0 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORfylATI.ON AOP-028, Step 12 Performance *~tep: 3 CHECK ALL of the' following parameters WIT*HINthe limits of the indicated ranqe:

6.9 kV Emerqency Buses - 6'550': to '7250* volts:

  • 'EI-6956A1 SA, EMER BUS* .A VOLTS'
  • *EI-69.56*B1 SB,..EMERBU:S

. .

B VOLTS*

  • Frequency -.59.5 to*50..S Hz Standard': DeterminesFrequency outsideof ranqe and proceedsto RN Comment:

. , ' . .

  • AO*P*-028~* Step 12 ~N i '. * *

.Performance Ste:p: 4'" '. E*NE:R*GIZE theErnerqency Buseswiththe associatedEfxs per Attachment . . Standard: ProceedstoAttachment . .

  • Col11*ri1*ent:*

. .

. . . .

. ' ..... ' . ' .'. .:"

.. AOP~028. Attachrnentz>- Step 1 .. . . ...

. Performance-Step: ~ ... D:ETE*RM.I N"E which Emerqency 'Bus is' supplyinq .power to.. the operatinq ..C:SI Verifies csu- "A" running -*Su.s .1A~SA.*

HARRISO*8.NRC JPM*f RevisionO . NU'REG 1021, Revision 9

.Appendix C Page 6. of to Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATI.ON AOP-028,Atta.chment2 - Step 2'

Performance* Step: 6 N.OTE

  • MDAFW FCVs will get an auto open signal (unless an AFW isolation signal is .present)*when eitherbreaker 1*05 or 1*25 open * Ona loss of power toanemerqency bus the associated

.steam supply valve totheTurblneDrivenAftwPurnp wiU open'..

  • . This step' will cause CVIS isolation and render' both Containment Vacuum. Reliefs' inoperable (Tech-Spec 3.0~3). .

Standard: * Reads/acknowledqes

.* Maytnformthe U*SCO

.Acknowledge .any repor . : . . ". ".'

. .

. Comment; AO.P-028, Attachrnentz>- Step 2 . r

  • vPerformanceStep: 7 .. . OPENthesupplybreakerto the ErnerqencyBus NOT supplying power totheoperating CSIP; . * . . .
  • '. Emerqency :BuS .A~SA**to Aux..:B.LiS* D Tie Breaker t05

. .

  • EmerqencyBus B-S:B.~to Aux BusE Tie Breaker 12!? SB

. " ' . ." . .

Standatd: ..O pens Emergency Bus B~S.B to AuxBus E Tie Breaker .125 S . . Comment: Critical to start.EDG.*without IO'sing chatging**.

HARRfS.OS:* NRC JPM fRevision. 0 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C .Page 7" of1 0 Form"ES~C-t PERFORMANCE INFORMATION

  • AOP*-028, Attachment" 2* ~*.StE3.p~*3*

VERI.FY the associated EDG" STARTS AND ENERGIZE'S the' .

assoclated Emergency Bu Standar * Verifie*s*.EDG*"B" start (Speed,Vo'ltage;Frequency)

  • VerifiesBreaker 126 closed C*omin:ent:* .

' . ~

.' .: ..... .: .' AOP~028, Attachment  ?'- Step* 4'" .

Performance Step: 9 .' .VERIFY proper load sequenclnqfortheEmerqency.Bus being

. .ENERGIZE;Dper 'O:MM~bo4~ Post-Trip/Safequards Review, Attachmentt . '.' .

, ' . . . . .

. .

. . .. . ' . . .

Locates..OM:*M~OQ4.:,Attach*ment -1.2 .... '

. .": '. . ". . . . . .

'. Evaluator Cue . . AfterOIVlIVIL004;Attachment12 is located: Another operator

,will" perform.. OM*M~004, Attachment 1: .

Comment: .

. . . " . : .

. .

AOP':028, Attachment 2- Step 5 . .

.*P**etform*ance**Slep.:'10* : CH E.CK the 'following'for the Emergency .Bus bein ENERGIZED.:

. ' . ' .

.:.* B..Se.qu:en:cer Load Blocks *AlJTO ACT COMP~.ETE MAN'

LOAD. *P*E.RM ITTE.DJ~9*ht is*.~I: * .Observes the Load Sequencer. progress ontheElxs

.. pane .

. : '. .

. .

. *. Determines "B" Sequencer:Load Block 9 'AUT'O ACT

"C()MPLE'TE" MAN* LO*AD*P*ERMITTEDlighf is NO.*T *LI* .Comment:

HARRIS08NRC JP*M*f RevisionO . NUREG1021, Revision 9

AppendixC Page 8 of 10 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP~02.8,. Attachment 2 ~ Step 5.*RNO

. . .

Performance St~p: 11 P*LACE. the applicable Emer Load Sequencer Manual Loading'

. switches to PERM AND. CHE*CKthe followinq:

  • Load **S.*equencer -.8*'MAN' PERM 'Iight is LIT

. .

-. Standard: *. P.LACES,*.the u'S"":Emer'L'o'ad Sequencer Manual Loadinq switch

. . ....

to *PERM~**

. .. . .

.

  • .. Verifies B MAN PERM Hghtis li "'. . . . . . ' . .' . . .

., ': -'. .' .' . .' ~ . .' .

'.. Evaluator Note: .' **"fhereiSa1S()seCOnds time delay (from inltiatlonjbefore ..

MAN*UAL: Reset. lspermlttedby.theclrcult..* I.'f-th.e applicant

.... attemptsa RE$E'Tbefbre that times out then' *:the*y.**sho*uld: . .

alI6w***.:s*ori1e:~addltiona.t-time 'and re-attempt.. If theycannot

.accomplish .reset.wlthouta prorrrptor cuethenthat .

. .constltutesfalture ofthls critical-ste ....

C~mri1ent:

. ' , .: ": . . . . ..' . .

', '. ..... . . : .'. '., ." '. . ' . ' '..:: ' . '

. .

. . . " .

. .TermlnatlnqOue: . ". Afterthe B::r\;II*AN:*.PE*RM light is "litt Evaluation on.thls JPM is .

. ..complete. . .... . ' .. .

,.... .: .:.

    • ST**Ofi:T~IM*E*:.".

HARRrS08:NR'C J.PM f RevisionO NU'REG 102,1', Revision 9

'Appendix 'C' Page 90f10 Form ES-C'-1 VERIFICATIONOF,COM,PLETION

. . ". . . ' .

, Job, Performance Measure No.: 2,008 NRC JPM f Exarninee's Name:

Date Performed; FacilltyEvaluator:

'Number of Attempts:

Timeto :,Co'rn'pl~te:,

.. ' . .

, ,

. . ' .".

. ' ". '0" ".".

'Qu:es:fion Docume,ntation:' '

Qu~stion:'

,Respon:se::,' "

, , '\ " ' .

\,

I, Result; ' SAT UN$AT Examiner's :Sign~turE3: ' Date:

-;;.:.....,.--------~--------

'HARRI,S:08' N'RC"JPrvlf Revlsion 0 NUREG, '102'1 .Revision 9

'. Page 10 of 10" Form ES-C~1 JPM CU"E: *SHEET

  • INITIAL*CO*N*DITIO*NS:* . * Theunitisat r.oo*%*power

. .

  • . Thefailure of.a major line resulted in the cascadinq trip of several" unitsonthe grid
  • .. Gridfrequency-isbelow normal.and the crew has entered

. AOP~028,:.~RID I~STABILIT.Y, and has completed Step 9 -

Check.for indications o.f:a.-Ioad*rejection*",- ~ .

. -

' . "., .

. . .

. IN*ITJATINGCU*E>.. . Observe the CAUTION prior to AOP~028,. Step .10, and then

. .perform th*e**pto~ed*uresteps.~* ..

  • HARRIS08* NRC.JPM f Revision 0 'NUREG'1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS Task No.:

Task Title: Respond to a Fuel Handling JPM No.: 2008 NRC 9 Building RMS alarm (AOP-005, OP-170)

KIA Reference: APE061 AA4.01 (3.6/3.6) ALTERNATE PATH Examinee: NRC Examiner:

Facility Evaluator: Date:

Method of testing:

Simulated Performance: Actual Performance: x Classroom Simulator X Plant READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the initial conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide initiating cues. When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

Initial Conditions: * 100% power

  • All major controllers are in AUTO and no equipment is misaligned Task Standard: FHB Evacuated and FHBV properly aligned.

Required Materials: None General References: AOP-005, RADIATION MONITORING SYSTEM OP-170, FUEL HANDLING BUILDING HVAC Handout: Use Simulator copy of AOP-005/0P-170 and ensure each is cleaned after each use or provide paper copies.

Initiating Cue: Maintain current conditions.

Time Critical Task: NO Validation Time: 14 minutes HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance Measure Form ES-C-1 Worksheet SIMULATOR SETUP

  • IC-19
  • MALF to prevent start of Train "A" FHBV Exhaust Fan E-12 start
  • 5 seconds after the applicant assumes the watch, MALF to actuate Train "A" FHB Area Monitor alarm HARRIS08 NRC JPM 9 Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 3 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION (Denote Critical Steps with a check mark)

START TIME:

Performance Step: 1 Responds to alar Standard: Enters AOP-00 Comment:

AOP-005, Step 1 Performance Step: 2 CHECK radiation levels NOT in HIGH ALARM:

  • Area Radiation Monitors Standard: Checks RM-11 Panel and/or indication, answers NO and proceeds to RNO colum Evaluator Note: The applicant may start FHB HVAC Exhaust Fan E-12 at any time after the alarm is confirmed in accordance with management expectations for operator action on interlock failure Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 4 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Step 1 RNO-v Performance Step: 3 If Radiation Monitors are in HIGH ALARM then:

  • Sound the local evacuation alarm and evacuate the area
  • Repeat the announcement Standard: * Sounds local evacuation alarm, announces HIGH Radiation alarm in FHB, and for all personnel to evacuate the FH * Repeats the announcemen Comment: Critical to announce evacuate the specified area because the control room does not know if personnel are in the FH AOP-005, Step 1 RNO Performance Step: 4 NOTE: High area radiation levels may require initiation of the Emergency Pla * REFER TO PEP-11 0, Emergency Classification and Protective Action Recommendations, and entry point X for EAL networ Standard: Notifies USCO/SSO Evaluator Cue: Acknowledge any repor Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 5 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Step 2 Performance Step: 5 NOTIFY Health Physics to perform the following:

  • EVALUATE ANY alarm received using HPP-780, Radiation Monitoring Systems Operator's Manua * IF necessary, THEN SURVEY the affected are Standard: Contacts Health Physic Booth Operator Cue: Acknowledge report and directio Comment:

AOP-005, Step 3 Performance Step: 6 CHECK ALL Stack Monitor radiation levels NOT in ALAR Standard: Checks RM-11 Panel and answers YE Comment:

AOP-005, Step 4 Performance Step: 7 CHECK ALL Process Monitors NOT in ALAR Standard: Checks RM-11 Panel and answers YE Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 6 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Step 5 Performance Step: 8 REFER TO the following:

AOP-005, Step 6 Performance Step: 9 REFER TO the applicable attachment based on the affected area or system monitors:

Standard: Proceeds to Attachment 2 - FHB Monitor Comment:

AOP-005, Attachment 2, Step 1 Performance Step: 10 IF fuel handling is in progress, THEN GO TO the following, as necessary:

  • AOP-031, Loss of Refueling Cavity Integrity Standard: N/A - no reports of Fuel Handling in Initial Condition Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 7 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION AOP-005, Attachment 2, Step 2 Performance Step: 11 IF Any FHB Spent Fuel Pool Area monitor is in HIGH ALARM, THEN VERIFY proper FHB Emergency Exhaust alignment using OP-170, Fuel Handling Building HVAC (Section 8.1, Auto Start of Emergency Exhaust System).

Standard: Proceeds to OP-170, Section Comment:

-OP-170, 8. Performance Step: 12 Initial Condition:

  • High radiation signal (100 mr/hr) received from the SFP Area Rad. Monitors (1 out of 12 coincidence on either train).

Standard: Indicates Initial Condition is me Comment:

OP-170, 8. Performance Step: 13 * NOTE: High radiation levels on Rad Monitor Train A (B) will automatically start EMERGENCY EXHAUST FAN E-12 1-4X-SA (EMERGENCY EXHAUST FAN E-13 1-4X-SB).

  • NOTE: High radiation levels on Rad Monitor Train A or B in the FHB will secure and isolate normal ventilatio Standard: Reads/acknowledge Evaluator Note: The applicant may start E-12 at this tim Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 8 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-170, 8.1. Performance Step: 14 * NOTE: E-84 may require securing from the MCC breaker if high radiation levels exist at its' control switch. (E-84 STATUS CAN BE CHECKED AT AEP-2 SLB-1 WINDOW 9-4)

  • CAUTION: E-84 needs to be secured upon receiving a FHB Ventilation Isolation Signal to prevent the potential spread of contamination through the Fuel Handling Buildin Verify E-84 is secured upon receipt of high radiation signal (1-4B1021-5B).

Standard: Contacts AO to verify E-84 statu Booth Operator Cue: Acknowledge direction. Wait one minute and report E-84 is secure Comment:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM 9 Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 9 of 11 Form ES-C-1 PERFORMANCE INFORMATION OP-170, 8.1.2.2-V Performance Step: 15 * NOTE: If the FHB Radiation Monitor spikes << 2 mi duration), dampers may not actuate due to the short duration of the high radiation signal. If this occurs, the fan should not be considered inoperabl Verify the following dampers and fans have properly realigned as follows: If a Train A high radiation signal was received, at AEP-1:

  • EMERGENCY EXHAUST FAN E-12 1-4X-SA ON
  • LOADING AREA ISOL DAMPERS FL-D35SAlD37SA SHUT Standard: Starts E-12 (-V) and verifies dampers re-positio Comment: Critical to align fan to radiation alarm interlock positio D Terminating Cue: After E-12 is started and@tmper position is verified:

Evaluation on this JPM is complete.

STOP TIME:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 10 of 11 Form ES-C-1 VERIFICATION OF COMPLETION Job Performance Measure No.: 2008 NRC JPM 9 Examinee's Name:

Date Performed:

Facility Evaluator:

Number of Attempts:

Time to Complete:

Question Documentation:

Question:

Response:

Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner's Signature: Date:

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Page 11 of 11 Form ES-C-1 JPM CUE SHEET INITIAL CONDITIONS: * 100°A> power

  • All major controllers are in AUTO and no equipment is misaligned INITIATING CUE: Maintain current conditions.

HARRIS08 NRC JPM g Revision 1 NUREG 1021, Revision 9

Appendix C Job Performance' Measure .Form' ES-C-1 Worksheet Facility: HARRIS

. .

.Alig*n:,:CCW, tosupport.Rl-R lnrtlatlon JPM.*:N*o*.: .2008:' NR*C .*h '

. (OP*-*1.45.) .' ..' ,

.. KIA Reference:. 008 A4.0t(3~3/3.1') .....

. ' . .

Examinee:*' , '. NRC* Examine . . Fa.cllit.y* Evaluator: "Date:

' . .

Method:-' ofte*sting:

Simulated Performance: . _'---.'~ . '. .... AcfuaIPerfQrmance:** x

    • ,d:la*ssrclo"': , .Simulator X.: ,.: . .Plant '

". ' .. .: '. ,.' , .' . ' ... ,.. ". : ....., . ','

.' .READ TO THE EXAMINEE ..

." willexpll.:linthEriniti~lconditibnsiWhichsteps*to-simulateorqiscuss,andprovideinitiating

  • cue,s~.* :Wh.e.n you.. cornplete.the task.: successfullythe obJe*ctiv~.:.for:thi.sJob Performance Measure.. willbesatisfied. . . . . ". .' .

. . ."... . "

, lriitlal Cortditions: * .' Theunitisln Mdde4,goin£ltoMode 5 .....'. .... . .

.:~i:~;~~r:i~sUa:~j~;~fc:laceboth;trainsOfRHR -in service .

.* ...' ,::CCW:.P,ump.,"A'; *is*.::ru'nnihg

. ' .

"..'. .< .. .'. ......> . ..

. TaskStandard: .Two cew PlImpsrunnil1gandthe required.CGW flow rate> established thrqugh.bothRHR,HeatExchClngers . .

Required..Materials: '.' Non . . ' . ' . . .

GeneralReferences; OP';145,COM~ON~NTGOOUNGv\fA"rE ". '" . ' .

. ' .

. . .

. -. Handout: '..*. ' *OP.;.1*'4:5,. Sections 't-..O- .'. '. * .: OP:';145. S~ction~&WithlnitiaIConditions signed off

  • . ., *O.P~14.5:; . Section*:* ". . . . : . .

". . '. . ' . . ' .

..Inltlatinq .Cue: .Al,ign*.:C.CW* to. supportRl-R operation.in accordance.with Q*P-145,

    • COM*PO*.NENT COOLIN'G .WAT~R ... AU' Sectiorf*3.~.O.,.prere'quisite$ .are met.

, '. HAR.R1SO,8*NRC jpM,.h*RevIsio*n 0'. NURE:G**t021.,Revision 9

AppendixC JobPerformanceMeasure Form ES-C-1

.Worksheet

.. N.UREG 102"1", Revisions

Appendix 'C Job Performance Measure, Form ES-C-1 Worksheet

'SIMlJ.LATOR S'ETU,P,

.,' rC:* ... , ,

.' ',Place LTOPS., in NORMAL arrdestablish feed with -AFW to prevent distracting alarms

  • Start both ESW, Pumps "

. . -.' .

, '.', "'lR"F' 'C:CW,073 5

. ., ' .

  • ." ,.-tR't=: CCW080:'O'

' . .. . .

, ,'.'

, ,',.", ,"checkFH352.tb~t'vVe,el1?850to8500GPrvt(pppro B~OO'GPMwith1GC~508'5%

OP',I;N},

. ~ *. '.' . .

..*.

,'HARRIS08"NRC 'JPM'h"';R'evision',Q' NURE~G '1'021, Revision '9

Appendix C Pag~ 4 of. 12 Form ES-C~1 PERF,ORMANCE IN:FORMATION (Denote CtiticelSteps with<< check' mark)

.Op:~*l45*

. .

. Performance :'Slep: 1> . ':Obta'inproce~ure: .

  • . RevlewsSections.t.O'throuqh 4.0*.

. *. ProoeedstoSection .* . *In.i~iafs*lnitiaIGondition. for .~.9(RHRSystem operation

..

.

'

.

.' .....". .

- . .destred). . . ':. ' ..

'. ' '. . .*.... ..' .....*

. ' .

. . .

.EvaluatorCue: ., '.

. . ' . .

.HARR1S.b8*. NRC.JP.M . hRevision 0.' NUREG: 1021 ,Revision 9

Page'S of FormES~C-1

.P*ERFORMANC.E* INFO*RMATION

. .

. *. .The purpose ofthissection is to ensureCCW pump runout

.doesnot .occur.: Maximum flow through . one CCWpump is

.... 1-:*2.,650: gpm~This .sectlonwllt ensure-that one CCW pump 'is

.. notsupplyinq both.:essential.. coolinqloops andthe .non-

.essentlalloop simultaneously,

.* "Nbrrrl-ally it *i:s:*desira;ble to placeboth -, RH.R** cboli'ng trains in

. operation.. *in :*Mode**4.ThiswHI*req.uire*.both;C.CW.pumps to

. .*.be**iri* operation and one.trainof non-essential supply an ..

. ".

"returnvalves

.. "

to be. shut ..

.

' .

To~re\fentptJrl1PTUnolltwherj

' . .

. .

. ProcedureCautlon: . aligning* CCWflow totheRHR Hx,

...' v~rl.fY* flow :rate. to. theNon-essentialheader withonepum .: ,*run*Oi*n*g.*.is:*.:Je*s*s:than. 850Q**:9Pni, as' lndicate',d .on***Fi~652.1- (FI:-:

65~J }pridfto ope~ing 1CO.:147 (1CC-167). . .

. ~p.ER:F.C>Rrvt.:,the .*fblloWI*ng. to-verify total' COW flowrateis between,

..'. 7'850 ~lP:rrl:ari*d.*8::5.0.0*:*g.p.m:.**.. .' ,

  • . ' .J,F"*S-F:,P:*.2&3A:js.:in**servic*e~ THEN TH ROlTLE SHUT ..,

1**C:C;.S.0.8*,..*.SFP.:HX. 2&3A:**C*CW::Outlet. lsolation Valv .... <.IFSFP';&3BlsinserviC~iTHENTHROTTLE SHUT *.

... *~1**CC~.5,2J*~:::S:F:P'HX~::2&*3B*::CCW:.O*utleflsolati'o*n.*Valve~

.... .,: ;.... '. . '.' .' " .

."

. ' . .

Standard: . .-. Det~rmib~sJIOw at approximately 8200 GpM.....

' . . - .," '... .

......*.......... Performance Step:* 3:~ ~P~~~5ir1;~~26~RHRCOdlingare

.* lobe placed in service, START .

the.::.$ep(~n*dO.CW*pump:*per .::SE?cti.6n.***5>2.* . .

. :,: ' , ' . : . '. . .... .

proceed~ to S6c:tion 5.2 to start CCW, PumpB".

.' .-. . :

. .*S*tand~.a*rd,:* .

... Comment: .

. ..

. . .

. .HARRIS*O.a NRC*.JPM.::*h RevisionO'

Appendix.C . Paqe 60f 12 . Form ES'-C-1 PER'FORMANCE *'1 NFORMATION**

. * ** J

. . .

Performance..Step: .4 . Verifies' Initial Conditions

. . ' .

. Standard; . ..' Notes alltnitia! Conditions aresiqned...

OP-145~ *.5~*2~;2.1: .... " . . . . . . ". ....' .

Procedu re*:N.o:tes:'" .** . Startin~lthes.econdpumpco[jldcau~eAP fluctuations

  • .acr6s:s*::*.Rl:M~O:1 GG-3:*5:0"1:ASj\ (B*$,*B)*.~hich*:rr~*ay 'shut

.sclenoid valve.s**1-CC~2*3.* and fCC:-4*b*~. .' .

. Ii* .*. *Startingth~s~~6hdpl1mpmaY9flUSe'ftOwoScillations which ProcedureOautlon: . .*.-:

. . . . *w~.~.:*,~.et.%.hjo;.;nl.h.e :~c~c;.:w*.1.:.*;p~. u:m*.~pe.: ~.R C~ru:n;.ond.; P.rnePg~.~a*.n :.~d;.ts*.fh'.~e .C cs:.* £tU;a.en~d5*b:'..S*,. m~~pnclbe

  • . .* . .* . *. ...

Ph.uO

.* .*:..

.' capableof an .automatlcstart, ensure-a jnln'imurn flowrateof

            • 7SSQgpmexistsas indicated on FI;'652:1(FH553..1)*.lfboth

. c¢W****p*u*m-,p*s:.*~*re.:rurtnlng,.O;Rthe.:.cb\f\l*tr~lins*ate.separated, .

.. ::~ ~~er

.. *4 **Performanc¢St~p:5.. ... Althe MCB;'sTART CCW'P[jmp TrainB"S~(A:.sA)....

. - . .... .. . ...... ::. '. : .... : ' . '  : .. .' ...... .: :" .

. . .

Sel~ctsCCVVPump:uB'L to start andreleases

".

.' * t ,"

. . ,~ . ",

. *S*ta*rid:ar,d:.* .: . .* . .

'. .' " ' . '. '.:" .

. ' .. ". . ", " .

E"allJatorNdte: ...

" * : * '. * **** * * * * ~ * ; * I *

. Critical.bec3use twoCCWpumps~rerequiredto support two:RI:i:R.:T:r~*.i*ris. **a"'l:dottJ*erload~.*,* ..

'NURE'G *1021,.Revision*g*

AppendixC' Paqe 7. of-.t2 Forril.ES-C-1*

.' .

. .PE~FORMANCE.I.NFORMATION OP-145, 5.2*.. 2.~

Performance Step: 6* \/E:RIF'Y:' flow: is g*reatertha..n orequal to 38S0gpm' onFI~653*.1 and::*FI.~**652~~ .

Stan'd~ard:: '., . Vetlfies***~-*385.0*got)rn:*o*n.*Fr~65**3:~.1'an*d:*Fl-652:*1 ..(Actu*al-is.*5.000 on

"A~'* arld**4000.:o*n* "B~')" . . ,

  • .Comme*nt:: .

" . " .

OP~145,,5.2. '. '. .

.' Performance.Step: PERFoRM0l'1e*qftheJoUQwiog:.. . .

". :f~'~~~C;;:::~o~~.:~::~i~:gU:i~:i::~;:~8;9 ..

. '" .' .

.~ ' . : . : .. .: . .',", '. -. .'

.' '. 'St~lrld:ard:: * Returns'toSectlon R9, .

. .

.. .

.. " "....... ','

. *.Comrnent:

. '. '" .

.' . ' .

. ' .

.: .. '. . .' ....

'. Procedure Note:

. . . .. ~...:...., ' ..

.' .

. . ' .'. . ':'.' : ' .. .

Standard:* .'. ... . Pla¢es1CC'-14'linOPEN(REDlndlcatiQn). *

," . . '

COI11 nie n Critical to alignflowthtoqgt1R~R "'X:"A"....

. . .... , : ' " . .,' .

HARR*.ISOS*NRC* J'PM h ..Revision :'0 NU.REG*t021, Revlslons

. Page. 8.of 12* . Form ES-C-1

"Pt=RFORM'ANGE IN:FORMATION

.". ' . ' ..' .~.... .

OP~*145,~*:8:~9.*.2..4**

Procedure Caution; . *\lVitt.{:one>G.CW.PUtlJp:.runnin.Q.*.and the 'standby pumpcapable of

.anauiomaticstart.ensure.. aminimurnflowrateofvasu g'pm

.exists .;as* indicatedon FI.:~652.:*1 ::<F*I~653~*.1). If-path CCW*.*pw*m.ps

.arenmninq.. *Q*R the:.CC*WJra*ins .are .separated,..a minimum of 385Q.:gp~*:per.:plJmp*is:requfred. This lower flowrateshould.. only beallowedforshortdurations'to .accompllsh pump swappinq or

.

... " ....

.

",. '",

  • s.~~tem*.:*~e*a.Hg:nm:etlt. *(R*e.fer~rlCEr2*.6.~.6)*

Performance-Step: 9' '. VERIFYHHR'HXA(B)butflowis5600 to8t50 gpmon FI~

...' .68a.A:t* {Fr~6'89A*t) :'.' .

. .

. *.Sian d.a-rd*:~** Verities RHRHX<A QufflowJs5600td 8150gpm on FI-'688A .,:: *(A~t'uar.i.s: 7:80"GJ G*PJ\l1y-:*.*** .

'. ".' .

. '. :**Cohi*me*rit:* ..' . . :- .

-, .'~' .. '.

....,: ...

. " ..... ". . ' , .

  • .*Q~~t4*5*~:*:8:.9j.2:~*:5~*.

If a leak occurs, . and surqe tank level is 'less than 40% (below the

. .' . ; .: :

. . :' .~:ta.n*d~rd . ::

"., . '.' .. :.: '.:.: '. . '. : : ".:.... .' " . .' , ". .

.C:o.mment:** : . :Criticalto:. IsolateTrain "A~'~ .from .Non-Essential Heade .. .

. .

  • HARR.lS08 NRC JPM***h Revisiori . NUR*EG*.t021, Revision 9

Appendix C: Paqesof 12 Form. *ES-C~1

.*PERFO.RMANC*E. I*NFORMATIO *O*P~1.45, *8:.9.2..6**

. .

. . . . .

Procedure Cautlon; Shuttin*g*both.. 1:CC-*12'8. and*tCC-127* will result-in the loss of the Nonessential Header. . . .

. .' .

.:.. -v...Perfo..r mance :Step: *1*1 .I F .both (~*CW:.pum*ps.:are* in:.service, .CLO.S.E* 1CC-*128 (1: C*C~*127),

.. C*CW:*NON*ESSENTIA*L<RET.IjRN TO . H.EAD*ER.. A(B};..

. CI()ses1CC~ 128 (GREEN indication}

. .

. .

. . .. . ' . .

. . ....Corn.me*nt:* .Crltlcaf tolsolate :Tra.in*'~A" frornNon-Essentlal Header, OP~1A5;j3.'9,2~.7. . '; .

.'...* Perforlllahc,~Step:12 '.' *VERIFYthefdllbwing:.**

, a:.~~ll~~rh~CV\fPurnpsarein* service, THEN PERFORM the .

. ' "~::: ~ ~~..

't6.6},:.'*R*Ij*R *Jfx .A** (8).*Outlet. Throttle Valye:,**to:*o btain

. desired-flow, : . .

'\I~rifil?sfld\1tlat1:lpprOximateJy8000GPM~* .'

" '.

.....

.....

. .'.".

.',

..... .

  • OP~t45,. . a.~9:~**2~8.*

-, *...Procedu ~eCaLJtion: [JonotsuPPlyCCWioboth RHR Heat Exchangers

'. . .

.slmultaneously withonly one . :C*CW*:pum*potu rinln .~. 'Perfo~l1lance Step: 1 *.* *IF.botntrainsofHHR'cooling are .tobeplaced-lnservice, OPEN*

. .fC:C~~. t67::.(1*CC~**147.), .CCW*.*FR.Oryl .RH.R:.:HEAT EX*C.HAN:G:E:RB~

<**S*S.::{A-SA)i: . ..... .

.. . .. .. .:. : :. ~. : ... .. . .. .... .....

Op~nstCC~:167(REDindicatidn):.

, . . '. ' . .

  • Co*mment: .Critlcaltoaliqn flow* throuq h**RH R*.HX:*'*~Bn .

". ' . " . .

HAR:RI*S{)8::NRCJPM* h.-*Revision**O:* NUREG1*021,*Revision*g

Page. 1-*0.oft2* Form ES-C-1 P'ERFORMA:NC~ *INFQR.MATION**

. .

O.P~f45; 8'*.9.2.9:

. '. .

. . . . . . . '. .. . . ' . . ..

Performance' Step': 1"4 vE*R.rFY**CCW* Pump 8.;.$8 {A~SA)-*flo.w. rateinthe required

. :r~'nge, as-follows; .. , ..' .:

. . .... . . .

  • -. CHECk*ccwPurnp B';813 (A-SA) flo~ rate is between

. 1*O*:~.OQO and t2*~:5.00:*.*.gfi*m.,on:***MCB Jndicator F:I-65*3~*1 .(FI-*

'.652.'*1 )., ..IF flow.rate is.riotbetween 1O.~:O*OO**and '1""2,-500 -,

g'Prn, *TH*E*N* A*D*J.U$T* the. applicable valve:

. .

. .

  • Stari'd.ard.*: . . Verifi~~flowatat>prOXirn<;lteIY11.9bOGPM.*****

. .Stari.:d:ard; $ff:!pisN/Aatthistime.*.....

' . " : . . ' 0 ** * . '

.* . Corrimel1t:<

'. '. '. . .':" '... . .

..Terminanng* Cue:

.sro:p**:Ti:ME:**'

Ow' * ..' *

HARRI.S08*:NRC*JPM.*h**Revision* **NUREG 1021, Revision 9

AppendixC .Paqe

.

tt of r , .

Form ES-C-1

  • VERIFICATION. O,F: 'COM"PL,ETION .

. . '

. Examinee'sName;

Fac.ility Evaluator: .

.'. Number-of Attempts:

. ' . ... . . . . , '. ."... '. . .' ';' . .'

. , .

. . . .- . :.'

... ..*.Time to9ornpl\9te:.. *..

':' .: , .' . :..' " >'. .' ..-'..:. : . .

..Que~tion** Documentation:

..Q.u.estloil:..*. *: .,'

. ~ .. .

. '. Response;

-: : "

Result; *.LJN:SAT: ....

. . , . .

Exam.iner',s:S*.ig.nature*: .Date: .

--'---'-----:--'-~~...,.-;:.-...---:....-..;...~---,-.,.,.--:--~-.::...:....--,..-,~- ~-....:.-.....:---..:.-_-------

NU:REG1021.,.. Revision 9

Appendix C Page 12,of 1-2,'

J'PM', CUE .S*HEEl

, .

INitiAL' COND.lTION:S:. ,e The unit-is in ~ Mode :4~; going to Mode 5"

,e ' Preparationsareunderwayto place, both trains ',ofRHRin

.service e,' , Both ,E*SW"Tra*ins are inservice

. ,

e,' ' : ':C:CW' P,ump,,"A"i's'*runriln,g', ,

, , ,

Align QCVYfQsupportRHRopE)rafioninaccordancewith OP-t45,

'*C'O~'PONt=~NT CO*OLIN,G,:VVATER:. "AU"S'ectibh*.3~:O Prerequisites'

.arernet.. " ' '". ' ,

N,U,R~G:102,1", Revisions