ML17214A588

Forwards Tables Summarizing Investigation of Technical Evaluation Rept (TER) Proprietary Pages.Table 1 Identifies TER Pages Where Proprietary Protection Required & Table 2 Lists NRC Proprietary Repts Requiring Protection

ML17214A588
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	12/12/1983
From:	Williams J FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:	John Miller Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
L-83-581, NUDOCS 8312190130
Download: ML17214A588 (8)

Text

I j REGULATOR NFORMA'TION DISTRIBUTION " TEM (RIDS)

ACCESSION NBR! 83121-90130 DOC DATE! 83/1'2/12 NOTARIZED! NO DOCKET FACIL:50. 335 St, Lucie Planti Unit

~

AUTHOR'FFILIATION ii Florida Power L Light Cog, 05000335 AUTHeNAME NILLIAMS'iJ<N, Flor ida Power 8 Light Co, "RECIP ~ NAME RECIPIKNT AFFILIATION MILLER,Re Operating Reactors Branch 3 SUBJECT; For wards. tables summarizing investigation of technical evaluation rept (TER) proprietary pages, Table 1 identifies TER pages" where" proprietary protection required lt Table 2 lists NRC proprietary repts requiring protection+

DISTRIBUTION COOK! A048S ~COPIES RECFIVED!LTR "'ENCL, -i'IZEi TITLE: OR/Licensing Submittal! Equipment Qualification'OTES;

'COPIES RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME:

NRA ORB3 'BC- 12.

COPIES L'TTR ENCI.

1 0 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME SELLS "g D'1 ~

LTTR ENCL 1'

INTERNAL! ELD/HDS2'2 1 GC 13 1 IE FIl E 09 1 1 NRR. CALVOpJ 1 1

'5 NRR/DE/EQB 07. 2 2 NRR/DL DIR 14 1 1 AB 06 1 NRR/DS I/AEB 1 1=

REG F ILE . 04 1 RGN2 1 EXTFRNAL! ACRS 8 8 03 1 1 NRC,.PDR 02'. 1 1 05 1 1 NTIS 31 1 TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED: LTTR 25 ENCL 24

"'jf f rTrqf, f

~>l tr

'J, > ". '~II ri>'i>'l't l r W,>t ll>r >>'ww >>,> y X I ~,'rwI .>:  ! rr 4 'olwr"' ~ f'.""w~t ilrr.><; > ~>'"J

$ r j l )~

f "'i l ] rrr. f r<

I ~ Ww,l W r ">>>r > 0 ~r1W; J L

,i >>'i, '

w

~ /',

~ CW 3 *41'" r'"I f ) ~ I I wrtw 'I r>a> t'gf>I f 4 I>y'll 'sl lk,>>

I", Wi. ~

'I 4,>> .q ll I'rrW g ~

ll >'$,3 "pl) r, f'i .) r' r w '>> +IW 0 r) f1 ) f f1 r'-"'WVr>> f W r> i i fl r L pP lr 'Ifr4 'll>> I I w >> r, >>> ~

,gap I>>l f c>> f ')4T ww')>f. ~) @gal> q IjW f r>> '1 'f (zl3) ) I'~Wy ~~' ")."W f ~ '>

'.Wai <ri>>aa e>>ni 4g~V w~ r >>r'$ i,w k '>> ii '>> gr Iwr >~

9L w l'w

+fr~ r0>>ef~~q r. Or~ Irtrr ~~ ~m $ r r,rr w>> y WE! f;w J') 6 3 terqi

)11'-.i!:

tr> >>>

~ -), T i'3 8>~ )l <') r W,r.<.jirr,!i

rkfv,p p; 3 lr J > rr<<y ) q, I ir r tr err i>Of <) l)t'ww '>

~ Iw l 1 N>,l p TW>j'0 I '

1 J:) '-'r I'$i> r !j!Wfg J Jy '"9 ki> t,.l ihd! %;Ij~dliji0 Wl j > y >w'iA: X Wj.,'i)J ',i, fir II'il

(, gr )<j f <r )i:,r H J,-!'> ~rwr","ll sf r L i>>w, II .I AW-'t 90 ) ling

'I'

" A>>W, 7 ~r W

>>>>> P *l, R >)6>illiw>>WI I') P ()

W 1

J$ Ir rW Ir l jt rr,'

I l>>>l II g W

Page Two Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Mr. James R. Miller Additionally, pages marked proprietary in the TER which do not require protection are: I) Item P/I09, pages 5a, 5b, Sc, 5d, 5e, Sf, Si; 2) Item 7/I38, pages 5a, Sb, 5c, Sd, 5e, 5f; and 3) Item 8 I 4I, pages 5a, 5b, 5d.

If additional information is required, please contact us accordingly.

Very truly yours, J. W. Williams, Jr.

Vice President Nuclear Energy Department JWW,Jr./R JS/jk Attachments cc: J. P. O'Reilly, Region II Harold F. Reis, Esquire B3i2190130 B3i212 PDR ADOCK 05000335 PDR

TABLE 1 REPORTS AND ASSOCIATED TER PAGES REQUIRING PROPRIETARY PROTECTION Item No. Re orts and Vendors TER Pa es 29 QR52600 - 515 "Qualification Test Report 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d, for IEEE Class IE Solenoid Valve P/N 5e 52600-515 Valve Type 1" Valcor Engineering 104 DP2224"1-004 "Nuclear Radiation Inves- 5a, 5b, 5c, tigation, Summary Report" Fischer & Porter 5d, 5e, 5g, 5h 2204-51-B-006 "Haximum Credible Accident Test on Electronic Transmitter - Differential Gauge and Absolute Pressures" Fischer 6 Porter WCAP-9157 "Environmental Qualification of Safety Related Class IE Process Instru-mentation" Westinghouse 138 WCAP-7709-L "Electrical Hydrogen Recombiner for Water Reactor Containment - Initial Si, 5j Development Report or AEC/DRL" Westinghouse Including Supplements 1 through 7 170 9298 "LOCA Simulation dated 12-21-72" BIW 5a, 5b 9299 "LOCA Simulation dated 12-21-72" BIW

TABLE 2 ADDITIONAL REPORTS REQUIRING PROPRIETARY PROTECTION Report No. Title Vendor 123-1243 Thermal Cycle Testing of Electric Amphenol Penetration Assembly Components Excerpts from BIW Data Simulation BIW Test No. 73J030 dated 10/29/73 Graph of Thermal Aging of Silicone Rubber (Electrisil 9025 Type Com-pound)

BIW Flame Retardant Crosslinked Polyethylene Insulation Long Term Physical Aging Proper-ties - 40 year life (Appendix D)

Graph of Long Term Aging (Figure IA),

2/C No. 16 and 7/C No. 14 AWG cables Test No. 32-1-73 dated 1/23/73 B915 Bostrad 7E Cables, Flame and BIW Radiation Resistant Cables for Nuclear Power Plants CTP-NO-51171 Qualification Tests of Terminal Amerace (FRC F-C5143 and Fuse Blocks QTR 105 Rev 1 Qualification of EA 180 Series Limit Namco Controls switches for use in nuclear power plants in compliance with IEEE Stan-dards 323-1974, 382-1972, and 344-1975

0 BOX 14000, JUNO BEACH, FL 33408 yA hg d ~>>

%Elf'14'44 IFLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY L-83-58 I December I 2, I 983 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention: Mr. James R. Miller Operating Reactors Branch b3 Division of Licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

Dear Mr. Miller:

Re: ST. LUCIE UNIT I DOCKET NO. 50-335 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT QUALIFICATION TECHNICAL EVALUATIONREPORT PROPRIETARY REVIEW In the TER transmittal letter dated April 2I, l983, the NRC requested that FPL review the pages marked in the TER as proprietary and determine if these pages still required proprietary protection. Because of the large amounts of vendor information submitted to the NRC on equipment qualification, FPL undertook a more extensive investigation to evaluate the extent of proprietary protection needed. This investigation consisted of: I) identifying the reports sent to the NRC for use in the review of equipme'nt qualification, 2) notifying the report vendors of transmittal to the NRC and requesting whether proprietary protection is needed, 3) reviewing the complete TER to determine where information was extracted or copied from a proprietary report, and 4) requesting that the vendors submit affidavits directly to the NRC in accordance with 10 CFR 2.790, to assure adequate protection of their proprietary reports.

The results of this investigation are summarized in the attached tables: Table I "Reports and Associated TER Pages Requiring Proprietary Protection" and Table 2, "Additional Reports Requiring Proprietary Protection." Table I identifies the specific pages in the TER where proprietary protection is required as a result of either copying or extracting information directly from a proprietary report. Also for the given item number, the proprietary references are listed. Upon removal of the pages identified in the table, the TER can be released to the Public Document Room. Table 2 lists the rest of the proprietary reports submitted to the NRC by FPL which still require proprietary protection:

PEOPLE... SERVING PEOPLE