ML17347B588
| ML17347B588 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Saint Lucie, Turkey Point, 05000000 |
| Issue date: | 03/01/1990 |
| From: | Goldberg J FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| GL-90-01, GL-90-1, L-90-83, NUDOCS 9003090155 | |
| Download: ML17347B588 (22) | |
Text
ACCELERATED DISTRIBUTION DEMONSTIRATION SYSH28 t
t REGULATORY INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM (RIDS)
ACCESSION NBR: 9003090155 DOC ~ DATE: 90/03/01 NOTARIZED:
NO FACIL:50-000 Generic Docket 50-250 Turkey Point Plant, Unit 3, Florida Power and Light C 50-251 Turkey Point Plant, Unit 4, Florida Power and Light C 50-335 St. Lucie Plant, Unit 1, Florida Power 6 Light Co.
50-389 St. Lucie Plant, Unit 2, Florida Power 6 Light, Co.
AUTH.NAME AUTHOR AFFILIATION GOLDBERG,J.H.
Florida Power 6 Light Co.
RECIP.NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk)
SUBJECT:
Responds to Generic Ltr 90-01, "Request for Voluntary Participation in NRC Regulatory Impact Survey."
DISTRIBUTION CODE A001D COPIES RECEIVED LTR ENCL SIZE:
TITLE: OR Submittal:
General Distribution NOTES DOCKET 05000000 05000250 05000251 05000335 05000389 R
D A
D RE FILE EXTERNAL: LPDR NSIC 01 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME PD2-2 LA EDISON,G INTERNAL: ACRS NRR/DOEA/OTSB11 NRR/DST/SELB 8D NRR/DST/SRXB 8E COPIES LTTR ENCL 1
1 5
5 6
6 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
0 1
1 2,2 1
1 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME PD2-2 PD NORRIS,J NRR/DET/ECMB 9H NRR/DST 8E2 NRR/DST/SICB 7E NUDOCS-ABSTRACT OGC/HDS2 RES/DSIR/EIB NRC PDR COPIES LTTR ENCL 1
1 5
5 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
0 1
1 1
1 D
D D
NOTE TO ALL"RIDS" RECIPIENTS:
PLEASE HELP. US TO REDUCE W~l CONTACI'HE.DOCUMENT CONTROL DESK, ROOM PI-37 (EXT. 20079) TO ELMINATEYOUR NAMEFROM DISHUBUTION LISIS FOR DOCUMENTS YOU DON'T NEEDl TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED:
LTTR 33 ENCL 31
P.O. Box14000, Juno Beach, FL 33408-0420 L-90-83 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn:
Document Control Desk Washington, D.
C.
20555 MARCH 0 i )99O Gentlemen:
Re:
St. Lucie Units 1 and 2
Turkey Point Units 3 and 4
Docket Nos.
50-335, 50-389, 50-250,
& 50-251 Res onse to Generic Letter 90-01 NRC Generic Letter (GL),90-01, "Request for Voluntary Participation in NRC Regulatory Impact Survey" 'issued on January 18,
- 1990, requested that nuclear utilities, on a voluntary basis, complete the questionnaire enclosed with the generic letter.
The purpose of the questionnaire was to provide the NRC with insight on the time which key power plant managers spend in responding to the various operational inspections and audits.
Florida Power 6 Light Company (FPL) has reviewed the inspection and audit records for our St.
Lucie and Turkey Point Plants and the requested survey results are enclosed.
The information provided by this survey is based on estimates of the time spent by personnel interfacing with the NRC and INPO and is not traceable by documentation to specific numbers.
The primary manpower impact is at the first line supervision/professional level, i.e., the level that responds directly to the inspectors
- before, during, and in response to the inspection.
The impact at this level has been added as item 5.f. on the questionnaire.
Information on the other related inspections and audits is not readily available and is not provided.
V ry truly yours, J.
H. Goldberg Executive Vice President Nuclear Energy JHG/GRM/slh Enclosure cc:
Stewart D. Ebneter, Regional Administrator, USNRC Region II Senior Resident Inspector, USNRC, St. Lucie Plant Senior Resident Inspector, USNRC, Turkey Point Plant 9OOS0SO>m SOOSOS PDR ADOCK 05000250 P
ant.
an FpL Group company
(
t
.Units 1
& 2 Docket Nos.
50-335
& 50-389 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
Other
- resident, Regional, Headquarters inspections audits based on 1988
& 1989 2.
3.
4 ~
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
Average 10 Resident
& 15 Regional Inspections per year Operations/Construction areas covered:
Inspector-days/year (I-D/YR)
Operations 93 I-D/yr Maintenance 67 I-D/YR Security 56 I-D/YR Tech Support/
Eng 135 I-D/YR Chemistry, Health Physics
& Emergency Plan 89 I-D/YR QA
& Management Programs 76 I-D/YR Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long) 5.
Regional Inspections 6 Inspector-Days per Inspection Resident Inspectors 362 Inspector-Days per Year or an Average of 1.5 inspector Years/Year continuous Average 3600 inspector hours/Year Approximate percentage of total time
(
on an annual basis) which the following managers must, spend in direct involvement before, during, and in response to the activity described in Item 4 1.
Note:
Percentages listed below are the percent of the inspector-days that management is involved with the inspection for this type activity.
a ~
Plant Department Heads 60 or 2160 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 64 or 216 man-hours ear c ~
Corporate Department Heads l.
or 36 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 d.
e.
Corporate Vice Presidents 4~
or 144 man-hours ear (number involved) 3 Chief Nuclear Officer 24 or 72 man-hours ear First line Supervision/Professional 400 or 14'00 man-
~
~
Turkey Point Units
& 4 Docket Nos.
50-250
& 50-251 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET 1 ~
Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
Other
- resident, Regional, Headquarters inspections audits based on 1988
& 1989 2 ~
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about.
how often is this activity conducted?
Average 12 Resident,
& 22 Regional inspections per year 3.
4 ~
Operations/Construction areas covered:
Inspector-days/year (I-D/YR)
Operations 127 I-D/YR, Maintenance 131 I-D/YR, Security 125 I-D/YR, Tech Support/Eng 208 I-D/YR, Chemistry, Health Physics
& Emergency Plan 147 I-D/YR, Training 23 I-D/YR, QA
& Management Programs 104 I-D/YR I
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long)
Regional Inspections 7.5 I-D/Inspector Resident Inspectors 711 inspector-days per year or an average of 2.8 Inspector-years per year continuous Average 7000 inspector-hours/year 5.
Approximate percentage of total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before,
- during, and in response to the activity described in Item 5 1.
Note:
Percentages listed below are the percent of the inspector-days that management is involved with the inspection for this type activity.
a 0 Plant department Heads 384 or 2660 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 h
b.
Plant Manager 4
or 280 man-hours ear c ~
d.
Corporate Department Heads 44 or 280 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 Corporate Vice Presidents 3% or 210 man-hours ear (number involved) 3 e.
Chief Nuclear Officer 3% or 210 man-hours ear First line Supervision/Professional 400'r 28 000 man-
"'""!x"
~
~
St. Lucie Units 1
2 Docket Nos.
50-335
& 50-389 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET 1.
Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
NRC Team Inspections based on 1988
& 1989 2.
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
Average 4.5 inspections per year 3.
Operations/Construction areas covered:
Inspection areas:
- SALP,
& Maintenance 4.
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long)
Average 5 inspectors per team Average of 50 inspector-days per inspection Average of 1800 inspector-hours/year 5.
Appro'ximate percentage of total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before, during, and in response to the activity described in Item g 1.
Note:
Percentages listed below are the percent of the inspector-days that management is involved with the inspection for this type activity.
a ~
Plant Department Heads 45 or 810 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 74 or 126 man-hours ear c ~
d.
(number Corporate Department Heads 8
or 144 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 Corporate Vice Presidents 44 or 72 man-hours ear involved) 3 e.
Chief Nuclear Officer 3~ or 54 man-hours ear First line Supervision/Professional 400~ or 7200 man-
~ Turkey Point Units
& 4 Docket Nos.
50-250
& 50-251 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit, or evaluation:
NRC Team Inspections based on 1988
& 1989 2 ~
3.
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
Average 8 inspections per year Operations/Construction areas covered:
Inspection areas:
Fire Protection, Management
- SALP,
& Maintenance 4 ~
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long) 5.
Average 6 inspectors per team Average of 42 inspector-days per inspection Average of 2700 inspector-hours/year Approximate percentage of total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before, during, and in response to the activity described in Item 4 l.
F Note:
Percentages listed below are the percent of the inspector-days that management is involved with the inspection for this type activity.
a ~
Plant department Heads 674 or 1800 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 11> or 312 man-hours ear c ~
Corporate Department Heads 224 or 594 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 d.
Corporate Vice Presidents 34 or 135 man-hours ear (number involved) 2 e.
Chief Nuclear Officer 4> or 108 man-hours ear First line supervision/Professional 400 or 10 800 man-
0
~ St. Lucie Units 1
2 Turkey Point Units 3
& 4 Docket Nos.
50-250, 50-251, 50-335
& 50-389 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
INPO Corporate Evaluation 2.
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
3 ~
4 ~
Average of 1 per 12-18 months Operations/Construction areas covered:
Maintenance
& Outage Management, Material
& Outside
- Services, Technical Services, Design Engineering, Document Control, Human Resources, Independent Monitoring
& Assessment Groups, Industrial Safety, Training
& Qualification, Radiological Protection, Chemistry,
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long) 10 evaluators per evaluation 50 evaluator-days per evaluation 400 evaluator-hours per evaluation 5.
Approximate percentage of total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before, during, and in response to the activity described in Item 4 1.
a ~
Plant Department Heads 12~ or 48 man-hours ear (number involved) 20 b.
Plant Manager 4
or 14 man-hours ear c ~
Corporate Department Heads 35~ or 140 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 d.
e.
Corporate Vice Presidents 18 or 72 man-hours ear (number involved) 3 Chief Nuclear Officer 16% or 64 man-hours ear (includes CEO
& President)
First line supervision/Professional 750 man-hours ear
4 6
e
't
~ St. Lucie Units 1
2 Docket No.s 50-335
& 50-389 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
INPO St. Lucie Plant Evaluation 2.
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
3 ~
Average of 1 per 15-18 months Operations/Construction areas covered:
Operations, Maintenance, Technical Support, Training and Qualification, Radiological Protection, Chemistry, Operating Experience
- Review, Emergency Preparedness, Outage Management.
4
~
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long) 20 evaluators per stet 180 evaluator-days per stet 1440 evaluator-hours per yr 5.
Approximate percentage of total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before, during, and in response to the activity described in Item Nl.
a ~
Plant Department Heads 52% or 746 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 5% or 80 man-hours ear c ~
d.
Corporate Department Heads 34 or 40 man-hours (number involved) 15 Corporate Vice Presidents 2> or 30 man-hours (number involved) 3 ear ear e.
Chief Nuclear Officer 2 or 30 man-hours ear (includes CEO and President)
Management
& Supervision 110% or 1600 man-hours ear
/
+t1
~
~
~ Turkey Points Unit
& 4 Docket Nos.
50-250
& 50-251 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
INPO Turkey Point Plant Evaluations 2 ~
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
a.
INPO plant evaluations every 12 months b.
Annual simulator evaluation 3 ~
Operations/Construction areas covered:
Operations, Maintenance, Technical Support, Training and Qualification, Radiological Protection, Chemistry, Operating Experience
- Review, Emergency Preparedness, Outage Management.
4 ~
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long):
a.
20 people, approximately 2 weeks, approximately 1720 evaluator-hours/yr 5.
b.
3 people, approximately 1 week, approximately 215 evaluator-days/yr Approximate percentage of the total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before, during and in response to the activity described in Item g1:
a ~
Plant Department Heads 19> or 320 man-hours ear (number involved) 4 b.
Plant Manager 12% or 208 man-hours ear (number involved) 1 c ~
d.
Corporate Dept.
Heads 35 or 600 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 Corporate Vice Presidents 54 or 90 man-hours ear (number involved) 3 e.
Chief Nuclear Officer 5~ or 80 man-hours ear Management
& Supervision 1704 or 2960 man-hours ear (number involved) 38
It 4
4
- St. Lucie Units 1 2
Docket Nos.
50-335
& 50-389 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:'RC Required QA Audits 2 ~
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
3 ~
Approximately 35 per year Operations/Construction areas covered:
Not required 4,
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long)
Approximately 2 auditors/audit Approximately 30 auditor days/audit Approximately 1050 auditor days/year Approximately 8400 auditor hours/year 5.
Approximate percentage of total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before,
- during, and in response to the activity described in Item gl.
Note:
Percentages listed below are the percent of the auditor-days that management is involved with the audit for this type activity.
a 0 Plant Department Heads 34 or 280 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 24 or 140 man-hours ear c ~
d.
Corporate Department Heads 14 or 84 man-hours (number involved) 15 Corporate Vice Presidents 2~ or 140 man-hours (number involved) 3 ear ear e.
Chief Nuclear Officer
<1 or 70 man-hours ear First Line Supervision/Professional 50< or 4200 man-
Il J
'6
~
. Turkey Points Unit
& 4 Docket Nos.
50-250
& 50-251 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET 1 ~
Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
2 ~
3 ~
NRC Required QA Audits Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
Approximately 59 per year Operations/Construction areas covered:
Not required 4 ~
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long):
Approximately 3.1 auditors/audit Approximately 41 auditor-days/audit Approximately 2400 auditor-days/year Approximately 19,200 auditor-hours/year 5.
Approximate percentage of the total time (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before, during and in response to the activity described in Item g1:
Note:
Percentages listed below are the percent of the auditor-days that management is involved with the audit for this type activity.
a ~
Plant Department Heads 104 or 1920 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 1~ or 190 man-hours ear c ~
Corporate Dept.
Heads 5> or 960 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 d.
Corporate Vice Presidents
<14 or 118 man-hours ear (number involved) 3 e.
Chief Nuclear Officer <1 or 118 man-hours ear First Line Supervision/Professional 50% or 9600 man-
4
~
~ ~
~
. St. Lucie Units 1
2 Docket Nos.
50-335
& 50-389 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
Self Assessments 2 ~
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
Approximately 21 per year Continuous Performance Monitoring 3.
Operations/Construction areas covered:
Plant Operations, Maintenance, Training, Health
- Physics, Chemistry Engineering, Technical Support,
- IMA, etc.
4 ~
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long)
Independent Management Appraisal 2,000 man-hours Approximately 2 auditors/assessment Approximately 30 man-days/assessment Approximately 650 man-days/year Approximately 5200 man-hours/year Total 27,200 man-hours/year 5.
Approximate manhours (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before,
- during, and in response to the activity described in Item 41 ~
a ~
Plant Department Heads 7504 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 668 man-hours ear c ~
Corporate Department Heads 7 668 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 d.
Corporate Vice Presidents 1 584 man-hours ear (number involved) 3 e.
Chief Nuclear Officer 242 man-hours ear First Line Supervision/Professional 27 000 man-10
0
" Turkey Points Unit
& 4 Docket Nos.
50-250
& 50-251 Generic Letter 90-01 NRC REGULATORY IMPACT SURVEY UESTIONNAIRE SHEET Type of inspection, audit or evaluation:
Self Assessments 2.
Based on actual experience over the past several years, about how often is this activity conducted?
Approximately 45 per year Continuous Performance Monitoring 3.
Operations/Construction areas covered:
Plant Operations, Maintenance, Chemistry, Health
- Physics, Technical Support, Training, Engineering, etc.
Independent Management Appraisal, Performance Monitoring 4
~
Extent of the activity (how many people, for how long):
Independent Management Appraisal 20,000 man-hours/year Approximately 3.1 auditors/assessment Approximately 41.25 man-days/assessment Approximately 1900 man-days/year Approximately 15,200 man-hours/year Total 55,200 man-hours/year 5.
Approximate manhours (on an annual basis) which the following managers must spend in direct involvement before, during and in response to the activity described in Item 41:
a 0 Plant Department Heads 8 080 man-hours ear (number involved) 14 b.
Plant Manager 860 man-hours ear C ~
d.
e.
Corporate Dept.
Heads 7 860 man-hours ear (number involved) 15 Corporate Vice Presidents 1 680 man-hours ear (number involved) 3 Chief Nuclear Officer 400 man-hours ear First Line Supervision/Professional 57 600 man-11
O.
Ae
~
J
~
E