ML18139B213

Updated LER 80-010/01X-1:on 800131,overstress on 18-inch Line CC-9-121,unit 2 Supply to RHR Exchanger,Found During Pipe Stress Reanalysis on Show Cause Lines.Caused by Supports Installed to Prevent Overstress During DBE

ML18139B213
Person / Time
Site:	Surry
Issue date:	03/27/1981
From:	Joshua Wilson VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.)
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML18139B212	List: ML18139B211 ML18139B213 ML18139B214 ML18139B215 ML18139B216
References
LER-80-010-01X-01, LER-80-10-1X-1, NUDOCS 8104020621
Download: ML18139B213 (2)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:NAC ~ORM 365 '

• U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION t;~n, . UPDATE REPORT e LICENSEE EVENT REPORT PREVIceREPORT DATE 02-14-80 CONTROL BLOCK: I

                                               !o-1_ . . . _ _ . . _ . . _. . . . . .

l Ii' _..._-:.6 \.!./ (PL.EASE PRiNT OF! TYPE AL.L REOUIREO INFORMATION! [IE] I V l A I S I P I S I 1 IQ)l O I Ol - I 0 l 01 01 01 01 -I Ol O l(Dl 4 11 11 1111101 ' I© 7 S 9 ~ICENSES COOE 14 is LICENSE NUMBER . 2S . 2S LICENSE TYPE JO 57 CAT 58 CON~ 1o i 1 6: ~;~~~~  !!!.J© I o I s l o I o I oI 60 61 OOCKET NUMBER 21 s I o 66 101 o I 1 I 3 69 11 EVENi OAT! I s l o.74I© I7SO 13 REPORT 12 l CA,7JE s f1 80 I© EVENT OESCi:IIPTlON ANO PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES@ l Pipe stress reanalysis on show cause liries outside cont*ainment has **t-eV'ealed an over- [[ID I stress on line 18"-CC-9-121, Unit No~ 2 supply to the "A" Residual Heat Removal .[[E) J Exchanger. This event is reportable in accordance with. the NRC- order lifting susp~ri- []J]J lsion of facility operation dated August 22,1979 and Technical Specification 6.6.2.a.9.J

 ~ ]The health and safety of the public were not affected since the redundant train was

.[]JI] ! operable and isolation capability of the affected line was available. I [ill] 7 8 9 so

                                        *SYSTEM                   CAUSE                   CAUSE                                                           COMP.            VAL.VE r:rril 7         8                         9 cooE 10 CODE 1w IB I@ Ll.J@ L!..J@ , p , r , p 11 SUBCODE 12                1:J COMPONENT CCDE
                                                                                                                              , E,   x, x 18
                                                                                                                                               ,e      SU8COOE 1..~..1 19 SUBCODE w@

20 SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE REPORT REVISION t:::... LERIRO LVENT YE.11,.R v.:.; Re"oRT NUMBER I21 a I o22I I2:J I REPORT NO. lo *1 1 I o26I 24 I27/I CODE I2So I 1 29I TYPE

                                                                                                                                                            .LLJ

JO 1-1

n w __

3' NO. ACTION FUTURE EFF!:CT

• SHUTDOWN ~ ATTACHMENT NPFID-4 PRIME COMP. COMPONENT

               'TAKEN       ACTION              ON PLANT                  METHOO                            HOUR$      ~       SUBMITTED       . FORM tiUB.         SUl"PUER              MANUFACTURER LI@W@ :JSW

J:l ~

W

J6

                                                                                                    !,o lo! *o Io40I 41L.!J@). L!J*

17 42 W@ '-Jz I 2 I 2 I 2 I

                                                                                                                                                                       '3                               47 CAUSE DESCRIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS                                            @              .                       .

[II§] JStress calculations revealed that the installed supports would riot prevent an oyer-o::::o:::J 1stressed condition on the affected line during a Design Basis Earthguake. Modifics1,tjorl o:II] !was initiated in accordance with preliminary design drawings and completed priori~ to [il]J !the final stress calculation.

,{IE]     a   .-.L.....---------~--------------------------~

9 *so FACIL.ITY

                                    ~ POWER
                                                                                        .            '3o'        METHOD OF DISCOVERY DESCRIPTION ~

t,;:;\ tIELLl.J 7 8 STATUS . 9 ACTIVITY 11 10 CONTENT IOIO 12 13

                                                                          . OTHER STATUS \:::;:/

__;.;N~/A;;,;,__ _ _*__.

                                                                                                   /.:'\

44 DISCOVERY W@I'6 Architect 45 Engineer Analysis a....,=~.:..:--:;.;....:;:.:;,:.c.i.;;=--:--:==.~=------8""'-0

                                                                                                                                                       .             .      . .    ~

I: REL.EASED OF RELEASE AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY ~ .. _I.DCA'!ION OF RELEASE ~ _ITJI] UJ@ WI . . N/A I I N/A ., a e 10 11 " ~ 80 PERSONNEL EXPOSURES IC\ NUMBER ~TYPE~ DESCRll'TION ~ [TITI

,         a e jO j OI O11,~Ll.J~l,,_..----.;;;.N:..:/
                                           ,2              13

• A,;,___ _ _~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ so PERSONNEL INJURIES t::':'\

NUMBER OESCRll"TION\!,;., EE] Jo I o I ol@i...*------~N1..:./A;!,..__ _ _ _....;..._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~~ 7 8 9 11 12 80 I.OSS OF OR OAMAGE TO FA(;II.ITY TYPE DESCRIPTION

                                                                 '43'
                                                                 ~

[TJil 7 a

               -~{s)'---*-**--*------~N~/A~----------------------~

SI 10 80 PUBLICITY . ~ NRC USE ONLY ISSUED~ OESCR.IPTION \e!,I "' [fIT] l!Ll~-------------N_/A _____________~ _I I I 1 l I I I I l I I J_! 7 8 9 10 68 69 80 ;; l>Y0N::.....;;(_B0_4..;.)_*_35_7_-_3_l_B4__,_ __ ~

e SURRY POWER STATION, UNIT 1 DOCKET NO: 50-280 REPORT NO: 80-010/0lX-l EVENT DATE: 01-31-80 TITLE OF REPORT: EXCESSIVE STRESS ON PIPE 18"-CC-9-121

1. DESCRIPTION OF EVENT:

During progress of the pipe stress reanalysis effort, it was determined that line 18"-CC-9-121 would have been overstressed (exceeding 50 percent ultimate capacity) in the event of a Design Basis Earthquake. The affected line feeds the Unit No.2 "A" RHR. Heat Exchanger. This event is reportable in accordance:JWith the NRC order lifting suspension of unit operation dated August 22,1979 and Tech. Spec. 6.6.2.a.9.

2. PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES AND STATUS OF REDUNDANT SYSTEMS:

Since the redundant train was operable and isolation capability, for the affected line was available, the health and safety of the public were not affected.

3. CAUSE:

The problem was disclosed when the architect engineer, who is conducting the pipe stress reanalysis required by the NRC Show Cause Order, discovered the overstress condition.

4. IMMEDIATE CORRECTIVE ACTION:

The overstressed condition was relieved by installing a constraint in accordance with preliminary design drawings.

5. SUBSEQUENT CORRECTIVE ACTION:

No subsequent action is required since the overstressed :condition has been rectified.

6. FUTURE CORRECTIVE ACTION:

None required.

7. GENERIC IMPLICATIONS:

The reanalysis has been directed towards all Show Cause Lines. As overstressed conditions arise*, the appropriate corrective actions are implemented.}}