ML17266A061

Submits Request to Amend App B to License DPR-67.Believes Effluent Limitations & Monitoring Requirements Are in Conflict w/ALAB-515.Requests Deletion of ETS Requirements Re Nonradiological Limitations

ML17266A061
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	04/12/1979
From:	Robert E. Uhrig FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:	Stello V Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
L-79-88, NUDOCS 7904180228
Download: ML17266A061 (10)

Text

529100 33 i ~ ~

aox~gg. vi-,'i. ='<".:c Enclosure

= I.'3RloA PGWER 5 IGrl April 12, 1979 L-79-88 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention: Hr. '/ictor Stello, Director Division of Operati'ng Reactors U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission llashington, D. C, 20555

Dear Mr,

Stello:

Re: St. Lucie Unit No. 1 Docket No. 50-335 Proposed Amendment to Facility 0 eratin License DPR-67 In accordance with 10 CFR 55 50.90 and 50.30, Florida Power & Light Company (FPL) submits herewith three (3) originals and for ty (40) cooies of a re-quest to amend Appendix 8 to Operating License DPR-67 for St. Lucie Unit Ho. l.

The specific modifications are described below. Their basic thrust is to delete Environmental Technical Specification limitations and monitoring requirements which pertain to non-radiological liqui'd effluents and other matters within the jurisdiction of the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) under the Federal 'rlater Pollution Control Act (FMPCA), 33 U.S.C.A. H 1251 et sece.

On March 1, 1976 the Nuclear Regulatory Covmission (NRC) issued Operating License DPR-67 for St. Lucie Unit No. 1. Appendix B to the license, Environ-mental Technical Specifications (ETS), imposes water quality effluent limitations and monitoring requirements. The National Pollutant Discharge E1imination System (NPDES) Permit issued by the EPA For St. Lucie Unit No. 1 on June 14, 1978 (NPDES No. FL0002208) also contains such conditions. In ALAB-515, however, the NRC's Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board held that the NRC may not specify restrictions in excess of those imposed by EPA.

That is, the Commission may not incorporate into licenses water quality requirements above and beyond those specified in the EPA permit allowing the discharge. The existence of Appendix B effluent limitations and monitoring requirements in the St. Lucie Unit No. 1 Operating License is therefore in confli'ct with the intent of FHPCA and in contradiction with the guidance given in ALAB-515.

On the basis of the above, deletion of the following ETS requirements pertain-ing to non-radiological effluent limiting conditions and surveillance is requested.

~Pa e Descriotion Definition 1.6, Total Residual Chlorine 1-2 Definition 1.7, Intake Temperature 1-2 Definition 1.8, Discharge Temperature 1-2 Definition 1.9, Dissolved Oxygen cp< 4 ~ ~ ~ ~

Mr. Victor Stello, Director Division of Operating Reactors U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Page 2 Pa<ac Descri tion 2-1 Section 2.1, Thermal consisting of Section 2.1.1, Maximum Discharge Temperature, and Section 2.1.2, Maximum Condenser Temperature Rise 2-2 Section 2.2, Chemical consisting of Section 2.2.1, Biocides and Section 2.2.2, pH-3-1 Section 3.1, Non-radiological Surveillance, consisting of Section 3.1.A, Abiotic'o adverse effects are anticipated as a result of the requested modification of ETS limitations, and FPL will provide additional information as needed.

Deletion of the Biotic monitoring requirements contained in Section 3.1.B and the Special Surveillance and Special Study Activities contained in Sections 4. 1 and 4.2 is not being requested at this time pending discussion with the EPA regarding inclusion/clarification of these requirements in the NPDES permit.

Expedited consideration of this amendment application is requested for two reasons. First, FPL plans to undertake discussions with EPA in the near future regarding modification of certain effluent limitations and monitoring requirements as they presently exist in the NPDES permit. These discussions will be conducted much more efficiently and productively if the conflict imposed by the current regulatory overlap can be eliminated. Second, FPL is currently in the process of refining the design of the circulating water system for St. Lucie Unit No. 2, now under construction. Engineering decisions and subsequent procurement and construction will depend in significant measure on the outcome of the planned discussions with EPA. For these reasons FPL requests that action on this request be completed as quickly as possible but, in any event, not later than May 15, 1979.

This proposed amendment has been reviewed by both the Company Environmental Review Group and the Company Nuclear Review Board of FPL, and they have deter-mined that the proposed amendment is administrative in nature and will result in no adverse effects to the environment. FPL has determined that this is a Class II amendment in accordance with 10 CFR 170.22 and accordingly encloses a check for one thousand two hundred dollars ($ 1,200.00).

Vice President REU:TCG:cf cc: Mr. James P. O'Reilly, Region II Harold F. Reis, Esquire

D ZF METTCNS 1 I Tne definitions for te=w used in these environmental t chnical specifications are listea belcv.

National P~er ~ cree c Sha~" =~a- any event caus~kg au"ho<"ed Federal of icinls to reauire or request that Florida Paver and Light supply electricig to points dt~~ o-vithout the State ox Florida.

4 Regional ~erzenc Shall mean my o" the following occurrences NtP th State oZ Florida:

(') a catastrophic natu-al disaster x~clud~ag h:."tie~ es, floods and tidal vaves; or (2) other o ergenc es d clared by St"te, co"-~, -micipal, or Federal authorit'es du~"g vhich an unintemjted supply o" electric power is vital to publ'c hea1th and safety.

P.eactor >~errenc Sh~~ mean an unanticipated equipment mat-"unction aecessit*ti" g pr~t r~d9.al action to avoid e dangering the public health or sa"ety, Circulat~"z Mater S st~

C~rised ox. the follmrLug; velocity cap, intake pipe, 'ntake canal, d'scha-ge canal, discharge pipe, "Y" port, discharge and "-:sc~>>aneous chan"cal devices. The recirculation canal is eluded, i= constructed.

m~

Frequency Definitions Daily - Hot less than 360 times per ann~.

Ve~y Hot. less. than 48 t~es per annual' m~terval ~y vary=by 3 days.

Monthly - Not, less than 12 tMes per annum - interva'y vary by 15 days.

Quarterly Nor less than 4 tim s per annum - interva'y vary by 30 days.

Semi-annm1~y - Hot. less than 2 ti-es per annux - interval may vary by 60 days.

Refu ~~"g - at refuelm~g, i"tervals not to exceed 24 months..

To a ';esidusl Qlo 9 e The a=ou"t o"" free and c ~1r.ed avai3.able 1

ante!<e Te-.oarature The te .peratu=e of the cooling --ater as rezsu ed zt the plant in zke stxucturee Discharge Te cerztu=e The te perature of the cooling water as measured rear the te '" s of the discharge canal Dissol; d Ozv~en 0:cygen disso1ved pe>> 1" te in the 'condenser cooling wate , 'znd e~ressed in villi =s.

Lmitinz Condit cns Those- conditions'to.be i-posed..on plant effluents and, operating practices which nay have an adverse ~pact on the env ron+ant.

'Continuous. Pecordin~

Recording of a measured. parameter on a chart by z single pen or a ~ulti-

~

point recoxde- with less. than a one-~inute interva1 bet"e n successive.

printing of the sate par@aeter..

Channel Calibrztion' Channel Calioration shaD> be ..e adjust~ant of the chznne3 o"tpu" such that the it cor esponds with speci pa mater which the charnel ied range znd accuracy to Lao>>w values of nonitors. Tne Channe1 Calioration sha31

'encompass the enti e channel including the sensor and alarm and/or trip functions, znd. shall. include the Channel 7"nctionaL Test.

Channel Functional Test A. Cnannel Functional Test shall be the inject'on of a s"mlated signal into tne channe1 as c1ose to the primary senso>> as practicable to i c~. di g a3.ar znd/or trip functions verify'pe~bility

>isco- nous =elease o gaseous o 1iPu d lu .,t -hich tapes pl i

~

ov = a =inite pe 'od or e, usually hours or days.

of, gaseous or 11cui"" ef f1uent ~hicn is essent' ly unintemoted, for e .tencec p r'ods durin~ normal opo=zt" on of the cility.

A:.endaen t Fo . 29

L"H:TDi'G CO'LDY.TZONS Generz1.

ng wate system shall o op rztec to resi'--- -"- zn i

zl i'pzc Fle ~ b 1 ity of operzt on s p

~ 't. ec) cors ster witn'onsideration of health and sa ety, to ensure th the publ c s ovi ec z denandable "source- of -pcwa= even "ndar u"usuz'perzting ccnditions wh'ch mzy set foz h ='n tnis spec'f'c" 'c, zs provided below in 2.0.2 and 2.0.3.

During z nat'onzl pe-er emergency, a regional: e e gency, 'boreactor e ergerzy>

or zny time when the health or safety af the publ.c .zy erdznge H by th inzb ~ 'ty of Florida. Power zz d Light to supply electr=city rom zny othe- sources ave~ ble to it; the operat. g limits proviced, in this spec~ication. shaD oe inzpp3 'cable. Fo.=ever, d "'irg such e ergencies, tne one at ng lMts shall not: oa exceeded evcap- zs is racassitzted, by the emergency whenever in'.accordznc~ with pzragrzpns 2.0.1 znd 2.0.2 zbove, Florida Power and. Light exceeds the operating l~wi'ts othe <<ise imposed, notification shall be..made; to the Dirac o- of the Region Xi Regional OHic of the Office of

. Inspection. znd. Enforcement, in accordance with 5.6 2.z

/

Ti:"iP4L Maxim'isch e Tempera"ure Obi ective-

.one purpose of this specificztior is to lie t therma~ st=ass to the aquatic .

ecosystem by lacing the temperature rise in tha Atl stic Gcezn,.~ the area of the"subaqueous- discharge dur< g. operation Saacificat"on ~ ~

Tna tharma2'ischargo of St'ucia Unit 2$ o. 1 into t!le Atlantic Ocean shall be; limited to a maximum release temperature oz 11K F'= 44'C znd shall not cause a temperature rise in. excess of 1.5'F or 0.8'C zoove ambient surface temperature. outside a 400 acre zone of mixing during the months oz June through. September, nor a 4'F oz.- 2..2 C r se during the re a" ning months..ln add'tion, the.- surface temperature conditions within the =one of mimrg sha13 not exceed. z rise of 5.5'F'- 3.1'C over ambient temperature nor a max um C temperature of 9.3'F or 34 C as an instantaneous max-'-wI zc any point.

The~w defou~"'ng oz.the intake pipeline is allowed. subject to o" mci~m re ezs~ temperature of 120': or 49'C'nd a. vxi~m su"=~ca temper" cure rise

~

o~ ' .

I

~ l>CCe "he folic'-" ng cc=d'" ons, . h ch mzy be expec"ec to -ause the disc..-="-

te="ez t =e to oe nigher than design, the u:~am d schar".-e temper t re sna '=e 1'-" ted to I'5; or 46 C: 1) Condense" and/or c'"culzting wat r pump m"'ntenzrce; ):hrottl~~g circ ~ating;zter p~s to mini '-e use. oz chio'ne; 3) Fouli" g of circulating wzter s-stem.

Amenc e..t 3o. 29

2-2 TMDoray transients due to accide" t'al loss of ci cuwting .-ater. svstem components wy cause temperature rises in excess of limitations stated above.'aziances cue ta these trans" eats shall oe 1'ted to no ~re t'!an 7 hours per manth.

P continuous tcmperamure measure t system shaU be ~tailed

" in the disc".age canal at appro~tely mid-depth. Temperat s shall be tzansm tted to the control room A. continucus temoeratuze monitor" ~g sta ion loc"ted wi"%in 500 feet from the. pri=azy monitoring device snaU be used as a backup system pz~a~ systole fa<~s. ln this event th"s station shall be checked every if tne S hours until the pray system is restored.

complete deta~~s of. the monitoring prog am.

See Sect'on 3.1.A,S for 2;1.Z '~!~~um Condensez- TemDerature Rise Under no al full power operation, the temperatuze rise- across the condense shal! not exceed 26'P oz 3'C'.'" Under the: following,.conditions, the condenser t pez" tu-e rise shall not exceed. 35'.= Qr 20'C-"zer. g care than"..a:72.-hour period: ..

1) Condenser A/or circulating wate pump mainte~ce; 2) 5 "ottL~ag circulating water pals. to min" ~ "e. use. of Marine; 3):"oulingof cizn '! ating wate system Honitorin Requirements The V across; tlie: condenser shall. be detez~ed onc per hou= while the un"e is in. operation The system's accuracy and precision is as described M, Section 3.1.A p of Append .3 oz. the technical spec'cat ons.

Eases The limitations-. pzovide reasonable: assurance that the overall aquatic ecosystem in. the area of the thez~ plume wilX expe ie .ce an acceptable en'rmental impact.. The placement of the'empe atuze monitoring instment in the discharge canal ~! give the. temperature of the discharge water befom mming. w""x the z'eceiving water.

~0'b 'c='vs.

'ie pu ose Q .

se sDec at:Q s s 1) to m n" " e- ~ pac s'o tile qua a tne " wc~~> 2} to D otec th~ ocal biota ==a= 3e"hal and sublethal ezzects c" exposuz . to chemical discharges due to ope=at-'on oz the plant,

3) to assure tnac continuec multiP ' use of tne z ceiv g wats s by h an pop~ticns is protected, and 4) to control the qualit- of th~ receivi"g r'-enc=ent No. 29

Biocides Soecificztion Total Residual Chlori e snail not excoed 0.1 ng/1 at any t<=e at the terminus of the discharge cana3s (prior to enter~ g the ocean outfa>>). lf th's level is e..ceeded, ad)ust ents to the i")ection system shall be m de to reduce ti:e concentration, and each succ edi"g chlor~tion period snail be

-onitored until the conce tration is with& the spec~=ication. Cnlor""e sha3~ not-be added for ~re than 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> per day.

Honitorina Reaui e ents A, grab sa~le of co""'enser cooli"g water sha'1 be taken weekly in the discharge canal and analyzed for total residu~~ chlorin . The sa~les sizZ~ be taken dur""g the period of cn1oraation. The t~we of oeg'w~

the chlorination and ~men the sample was taken shall be logg d.

"=sees When in5ected, chlori~e is diluted by the cooling water and cons~ed in the process of controlling slMe. To be sure that e ough c'nlo <~e is m~jected to control the sl~ e, the residual chlorine concentrat on will oe approzi-

~tely 1 mg/1 at the condenser outlet.

'7 '7

~ H e eeeoe Sa eel f( cetiaa The pE of the cooling water in the discharge canal sha s not be less than 6.0 nor greater than 9.0 pH units.

Monitorinz Requirement pE shall be measured on a daily basis in the discharge canal, and, it shall be accomplished using eitner a grao sample or recorder.

Bases The pZ limits se" forth vill provide reasonable assuxa ce of an acceptable 2",;=to-.=~ntal ~~act wnen discharg~"g vaters to the At antic Ocean.

2' ."="-S R~

~ 4 ". ~>'QAC='~ V~l LS S e ss o d ~ the -'ts anc conditions =or the contro3~ed release of radioactive mate=-2's in li"uid and gaseous elf 1 ents to the e .irons to ensure that

M"JL?CM~ AL SVRV T~~~C-Hc -Radiclozical Surveillance 3 ~ *eA A<<iOTTC

'7 I ~

~ ~ Q easel Q4

~ oc 42~d s Oh<eat"-.a The purpose or th" s surveillance is to ~incr Tora'esidual QQcr~=a in tha discharge canal to insure that no acv rse ipact on t e anvErcQ Mt is occurring o Soacificaticn otal Residual Chlorine sh~~ ba nonitored ~~ "he discharge c~>>~'n a.~eel'y basis eh~" e a ccnde ser section is be~~ c>>or~ared. Saa Sect" on 2.2.1 for l~~~~g cond'icns.

2anort~mz Require~ant Total Residual Chlor<m concentration shal3. be reported in the Annual Zn& rcn-~tal Mon'oring Report.

3.1.A.Z Eaavv M tais Ob 3 active The purpo e of this study is to nonitc heavy - tz's c=ca t".at"o s tn the intake and discharge coals to datec" any'easurzbla ~ "c=a"sa 'n hea~p metals.

Snecif icaticn Grnh smples s~~ be tu'en on a mntDy oasis at the '"Me and d" scharga canals and analy"ed for Marcu~, A-senic, Chrcniun, Copper, iron, Lazd, HiM, and Zinc.

Rapo<<td~z Raqui<<anent Conc "t=aticns shall be reported ~~ tha A ual E"'~ropital Monitoring

<<i%a v'c <<

3 1~ g,3 na on=pc~a of th's surveillance is tc ncnitcr pP ~ tha receiving waters to "'-=.u=a t<.. t p2 is not be'"g ra" sad or lo-ared are= tna spec~~=iad l~-'ts, in c"ca= to p" vent a acve sa anvirc"=antal ~-pact.

SPECKY SURX~~XLL<iCE AUD SPECLQ'<GDY. ACTIVXT3:ES Entrz" .ment of Aquatic Or~zni ms Oofectiva The purpose of this study is to zssass the e zects on plzv~ton c orgznisns of passage through the plant condensers. Spe'cialists .'- the biologiczl sub-disciplines of zooplankton and ichthyology wi3~ "erfow appropriate portions of this study. Eiguxes obtained for the i=tare and discharge canals will be compaxed to data collected zt z contxol station.

S ec" ficztion Samples shall be collected'rom the intake z d d schzrge canals znd z contxo3.

st t~on zt monthly intervals when the unit is -'n operation to identify the organisms involved, znd to attempt to quantify ho~ many of eacn organism are po'tentially zxfected. Bio~as measurements, umbers of eggs collected, and identification of larvae 'to the level of major taxonomic znd'umoers groups,'f possib3.e shall be. performed. Present "state-of-the-art" infox~-

tion shall be used to attempt to quantify the mortality of the organisms due to entrainment. This'rograx shall determine the seasonal abundance of fish eggs and. larvae R'eoortinz Recuire ants Results of this study sha3'L be s~xi"ed in tne Annua3 Environ ntzl ~ronito 1; Report. Tf; at. the end. of two years, no sigxificznt problem i" evident, an option to fora>>y delete this portion of tna Technica3. Specifications mzy be initiated~

4.Z: H nimum.Effeative Chlori e Usable

~oh ective'he purpose of this study is to determine the mini= - z=ount of chlorine necessary which will zfford zdequzte protection to the condenser

'void ng unnecessary cU.scharge of chlorine to the en..+xonment. while S ecificztion A program shaM be initiated after Unit 1 has,initially reached 75% power level. The initial chlorine injection rate shall be deter~ed. based on pxenperztional.dztz, previous e~e ience, and lzboxzto g chlorine demand tes-s. A"te= reac.." g z pave p3. tea above 75% power, a controlled

~

incre' ntzl reduction of the chloxf"a injection rate shall be inp3.emented.

Conda-..ser foul' hall be monitaxed in coordinztion with chlorine'eduction.

Re o ti z Require ants The esults of th"'s st dy shall be s~ri ed in. the Pxnuzl Znv'xo"-entzl Honitoring Report When the min~ um level of chlorine usage, as deter 'ned by the str dy, has been reached, a p oposal shall be submitted to the <NRC to te~~ nate the s tucy.

Amendment No. 29

,J ~ ~~

~+tI