ML18139B387: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
| issue date = 06/05/1981
| issue date = 06/05/1981
| title = LER 81-031/03L-0:on 810508,amp Reading for Heat Tracing Panel 11,circuit 1B,found Below Acceptance Criteria.Caused by Mechanical Damage to Tape.Heat Tracing Replaced & Tested. Design Change Initiated
| title = LER 81-031/03L-0:on 810508,amp Reading for Heat Tracing Panel 11,circuit 1B,found Below Acceptance Criteria.Caused by Mechanical Damage to Tape.Heat Tracing Replaced & Tested. Design Change Initiated
| author name = WILSON J L
| author name = Wilson J
| author affiliation = VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.)
| author affiliation = VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.)
| addressee name =  
| addressee name =  
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:* NRC FORM 31;;6 -ICENSEE.
{{#Wiki_filter:*
EVENT REPORT U.S. NUCL.EAR REGUL.ATORV COMMISSION r,. 7i'll .*
NRC FORM 31;;6                                                                                                                                                                             U.S. NUCL.EAR REGUL.ATORV COMMISSION r,. 7i'll
* CONTROL. BL.OCK: I I f'i\ (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIREC INFORMATION)
            .*                                                                                                         -ICENSEE. EVENT REPORT I
~....__ .............
CONTROL. BL.OCK: ~....__.............____...---.!s "-!.I                                                 If'i\                (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIREC INFORMATION)
___ _...---.!s  
    ~                    I V I A I s I p I s I 2 101 0 I O I -10101010101-10101@1411111111101                                                                                                                                                         l I©
"-!.I I V I A I s I p I s I 2 101 0 I O I S 9 L.ICSNSEE CODE 14 ~S -10101010101-10101@1411111111101 l I© LICENSE NUMBER 25 . 26 LICENSE 'iYPE JO 57 CAT SS CON'i [ITIJ ; 6 LI© I o J s l o l o I o I 21 s 1 1 101 o I s I o I s l s I 1 I© Io ! 6 I o I s I s 11 I© 60 61 COCKE'T NUMBER 6S 69 EVENT DATE 74 75 REPORT OAi'c BO EVENT DESCRIPTION AND PROSABL.E CONSEQUENCES@
    ~              S      9          L.ICSNSEE CODE                              14              ~S                                    LICENSE NUMBER                              25 . 26         LICENSE 'iYPE             JO         57     CAT         SS CON'i
l With Unit No. 2 at 100% power, PT-27C revealed that amp reading for heat tracing . Panel 11, circuit lB was below the acceptance criteria stipulated in the PT. IIm This everit is contrary to T. S. 3 ,3 .A. 4 and is reportable per-T, S. 6. 6. 2. b (2). 'T'he _l]J]J [§]]:] __ [ill] redundant.heat tracing circuit was operable, therefore, the health and safety of the L-...;;P.;;u;,;;;b.;;l;,;;;i:.;;c;....;.w;.;;e;,:r;.;;e;_;,n:.:o;.;;t:.....:a:.:f;.;f;.;e::.:c;;.;t;;.;e::.:d::..:...*  
[ITIJ
-------------------------------'!  
    ;               6
[ID] 7. B 9 lTIIl 7 S (.":;\ LER/RO LVENT YE~.R \:.:,/ REPORT L.? I 11 . . NUMBER 21 ::z:z CAUSE CAUSE COMP. COOE SUBCODE COMPONENT COtlE SUBCODE ~@ ~@ 1 H' El A' T'E ,R ,e LEJ 11 12 t3 ,s 19 SEQUENTIAL.
                                  ~~~~~~        LI©                     I61 o s l COCKE'T J                  o l o I o I 21 s 11 101 o I s I o I s l s I 1 I© Io ! 6 Io I s I s 11 I© 60                                                                             NUMBER             6S     69           EVENT DATE               74       75           REPORT OAi'c                           BO EVENT DESCRIPTION AND PROSABL.E CONSEQUENCES@
OCCURRENCE
l     With Unit No. 2 at 100% power, PT-27C revealed that amp reading for heat tracing
*REPOF!T REPORT NO. CODE TYPE I I I o 'I 3 I 1 l I .,....., I o I 3 I 1.1..J 23 24 26 27 28 29 . lCI VALVE SUBCOOE ~@ 20 REVISION NO. l:=l kLJ 31 J: ACTION FUTURE EFFEC"l' SHUTDOWN t.:::\ Aii'ACHMENT
                              . Panel 11, circuit lB was below the acceptance criteria stipulated in the PT.
* NPRD-4 PRIME C:.OMP. COMPONENT SUPPLIER MANUFACTURER BO ,:':,' ** . TAKEN AC"l'ION ON,_PLANT METHOD HOURS @ SUBMITTED FORM :.UB. .. -:, * *_ Lf..l@)Ll.l@}.-_
IIm                         This everit is contrary to T. S. 3 ,3 .A. 4 and is reportable per-T, S. 6. 6. 2. b (2).                                                                                                                                             'T'he
L.Ll@ Li.J I* o! oi ol -ol l!J@). Ll!J .. lJ
_l]J]J                         redundant.heat tracing circuit was operable, therefore, the health and safety of the
* JS . .-; 36 37 40 41
[§)):] L-...;;P.;;u;,;;;b.;;l;,;;;i:.;;c;....;.w;.;;e;,:r;.;;e;_;,n:.:o;.;;t:.....:a:.:f;.;f;.;e::.:c;;.;t;;.;e::.:d::..:...*-------------------------------'!
* 42 lLJ@ *-IT 11**1s Is*!@) -*-CAUSE DESCRIPTION ANO CORRECTIVE ACTIONS @) DJ:[] l The loss of heat tracing was due _to mechanical damage to the-**tape, -, 4J
__[ill]
* 44 * '. ' 47 Personnel had been working in the near b'y area, !he defective heat tracing was replaced and test-[I]]] .ed. A design change has been initiated to change the manner by which these borated liries are heat traced. o:m 7 8 9 FACILITY /jo'I STATUS % "0WER . OTHER STATUS '.;::;:; iI1TI .LI@ __ I 1 l O I O l .... I _!_i/_A~---
[ID]
8 9 10 12 t'l ACTIVITY CONTENT I.::\ RELEASED OF RELEASE AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY Em 1_~@) W(§)I . N/A 7 a s
: 7.             B 9                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               BO CAUSE                          CAUSE                                                            COMP.                 VALVE COOE                        SUBCODE                  COMPONENT COtlE                        SUBCODE                  SUBCOOE lTIIl 7              S
* 10 11 80 7 METHODOF r.;:;,.. DISCOVERY DISCOVERY DESCRIPTION L!J@I Routine Test. -45 . 46 N/A .~OCATION OF RELEASE @ '--~-----80 80 .
                                                                                                      ~@ 12~@
* PERSOIIINEL EXPOSURl:S Q NUMBER r:;:;,. TYPE~ DESCRIPTION I2:E] .r 01 0 I O ,~~~1...-----~N/;..;.A;;...._
11 1
___________________
t3 H' El A' T'E ,R ,s,e LEJ ~@                  19                      20 SEQUENTIAL.                               OCCURRENCE            *REPOF!T                                    REVISION
__. 7_ .:a 9 *-.* i1 12 13 BO _ .*. y,,,*,,_ PERSONNEL.
(.":;\ LER/RO LVENT YE~.R                                                                                 REPORT NO.                                    CODE                TYPE                                            NO.
INJURIES C\ -*. * .. . *. ---NUMBER . *.', DESC1'11l'TION6 Cl:li:J j 01 01 01@1...-*
                            \:.:,/ REPORT
______ rr.;../A __________________ 7 S 9 11 1:i! BO *---' * * *
                                . NUMBER L.? I 11            ::z:z                      I23 I                         I o 'I 3 I 126l          I27.,.....,         I28o I 329I .        1.1..J                   l:=l                  kLJ 21                                                                          24                                                                 lCI                     31                    J:
* LOSSOF*OR*DAMAClE TO FAl:;ILITY 12, * . 'TVPE * . DESCRIPTIOI\I
ACTION FUTURE                                 EFFEC"l'                           SHUTDOWN                                         t.:::\     Aii'ACHMENT
\:;I IITIJ-~@)..___._.
* NPRD-4           PRIME C:.OMP.                         COMPONENT
________ N;.../A___;*---------------------------
    ,:':,'       ** . TAKEN           AC"l'ION                     ON,_PLANT                                 METHOD                             HOURS   @           SUBMITTED         FORM :.UB.           SUPPLIER                        MANUFACTURER
7 a
.. -:, * *_.. Lf..l@)Ll.l@}.-_
* s *
lJ              ~
* 10 *
* L.Ll@
* so * * :-. PUBLICITY C\ . * * .:-:-1ssuEC~
JS . .-;
DES_CRIPTION rm:i we., ....... ___ -__ . _____ .....;;.;.N,_/
Li.J I* o! oi ol -ol 36                    37                      40 l!J@).
A~-------------'
41
__ , , 1 ., , , , , NFIC USE ONLV "' I I I LL 7 B 9 10 68 H BO ;; : ~1 ~6 ~:~sE o, **Ee.RE~.
* Ll!J lLJ@ *-IT 11**1s Is*!@)
J. Lo llil~n' '*, -, * ',: 0: 1'._ * ..;{;...8
42                    -, 4J
__ 0 __ 4.;..)_,3_:
* 44 *                        '. '      47
__ 7-.--~-,-1-.*_8
          -*-              CAUSE DESCRIPTION ANO CORRECTIVE ACTIONS                                                                         @)
___ :-..... -.:::~~-,,""',.-_,.~,--~----~~-
DJ:[] l                   The loss of heat tracing was due _to mechanical damage to the-**tape,                                                                                                                           Personnel had been working in the near b'y area,                                                                               !he defective heat tracing was replaced and test-
.-**-;:->>.:,-:-, ---*-*-''=-------**----------------*-*---------
[I))]                   .ed.         A design change has been initiated to change the manner by which these borated liries are heat traced.
*-----* __ . __ . ---*. ---. -. . ' ' -*.
o:m 7               8     9                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         80 FACILITY                                                                                                             /jo'I     METHODOF                                                                                r.;:;,..
ATTACHMENT SURRY POWER DOCKET NO: REPORT NO: EVENT DATE:
STATUS                  % "0WER .                                                      OTHER STATUS '.;::;:;               DISCOVERY                                    DISCOVERY DESCRIPTION ~
* STATION, UNIT NO. 2 50-281 8l-031/03L-O 05-08-81 TITLE OF EVENT: HEAT TRACING FAILURE 1. DESCRIPTION OF EVENT:
iI1TI .LI@__ I 1 l O I O lI...._!_i/_A~--- L!J@I 7              8     9                   10                         12                 t'l Routine Test.                                          -
* With Unit No. 2 at 100% power, PT-27C revealed that the amp reading for heat tracing Panel 11, circuit 18 (BIT Outlet Valve, MOV-2867D), was below the acceptance criteria stipulated in the PT. This event is contrary to Technical Specification 3.3.A.4, and is reportable per Technical Specification 6.6.2.b(2).  
80 '--~-----
45          . 46 ACTIVITY             CONTENT                                                                                       I.::\
RELEASED OF RELEASE                                                     AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY                         ~                                                      .~OCATION OF RELEASE                  @
Ema 1_~@)
7                    s
* W(§)I 10                  11
                                                                                                              .N/A                                                         N/A 80
            .*                   PERSOIIINEL EXPOSURl:S                                                                    Q r:;:;,. TYPE~ DESCRIPTION I2:E]                .r    01 NUMBER 0      I O ,~~~1...-----~N/;..;.A;;...._                                                                    _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___.
7_       .:a
        .*. y,,,*,,_
9        *-.*       i1 PERSONNEL. INJURIES 12                        13 C\
BO Cl:li:J j 01 01 01@1...-*_ _ _ _ _ _rr.;../A_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
  -*. *       ..    . *. ---NUMBER . *.',                    DESC1'11l'TION6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ~
7              S 9                        11            1:i!                                                                                                                                                                                                                    BO
  *---' * *      *
* LOSSOF*OR*DAMAClE TO FAl:;ILITY                                            12,
      *                 . 'TVPE * . DESCRIPTIOI\I                                                \:;I IITIJ-a
* s~@)..___._.
7                          *
* 10
* ________N;.../A___;*---------------------------
* so
          *          * :-.     PUBLICITY                          C\                                                                                                                                                                NFIC USE ONLV
                                                                      ~
rm:i we.,. . . .___-__._____.....;;.;.N,_/A ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - '
            . * * .:-:-1ssuEC~ DES_CRIPTION
__ , ,     1 .,     , , ,          ,          I    I IBOLL
                              ~:~sE*-''=-------**----------------*-*--------- *-----* _ ._ .---*.
7              B      9              10                                                                                                                                                                      68      H                                                              ;;
0 1
: ~1 ~6                                              o, **Ee.RE~.                                        J. Lo llil~n'                              '*, -,              *              ',:    : '._  * ..;{;...8__
0__4.;..)_,3_:__7-.--~-,-1-.*_8___:-.....-.:::~~-,,""',.-_,.~,--~----~~-. -
 
ATTACHMENT
* SURRY POWER STATION, UNIT NO. 2 DOCKET NO:      50-281 REPORT NO:      8l-031/03L-O EVENT DATE:    05-08-81 TITLE OF EVENT:    HEAT TRACING FAILURE
: 1. DESCRIPTION OF EVENT:
With Unit No. 2 at 100% power, PT-27C revealed that the amp reading for heat tracing Panel 11, circuit 18 (BIT Outlet Valve, MOV-2867D), was below the acceptance criteria stipulated in the PT. This event is contrary to Technical Specification 3.3.A.4, and is reportable per Technical Specification 6.6.2.b(2).
: 2. PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES and STATUS of REDUNDANT EQUIPMENT:
: 2. PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES and STATUS of REDUNDANT EQUIPMENT:
The heat tracing circuits are intended to maintain a fluid temperature above that needed for flow. The redundant heat tracing circuit was operable, fore, the health and safety of the public were not affected.  
The heat tracing circuits are intended to maintain a fluid temperature above that needed for flow. The redundant heat tracing circuit was operable, there-fore, the health and safety of the public were not affected.
: 3. CAUSE: The loss of heat tracing was du~to mechanical  
: 3. CAUSE:
~amage to the tape. Personnel from various crafts had been working .in the nearby area. 4. IMMEDIATE CORRECT I VE ACT I ON: The immediate corrective action was to verify that the redundant circuit was opera9le.  
The loss of heat tracing was du~to mechanical ~amage to the tape. Personnel from various crafts had been working .in the nearby area.
: 5. SUBSEQUEST CORRECTIVE ACTION: The defective heat tracing tape was replaced and tested within the time span specified by Technical Specifications.  
: 4. IMMEDIATE CORRECT I VE ACT ION:
The immediate corrective action was to verify that the redundant circuit was opera9le.
: 5. SUBSEQUEST CORRECTIVE ACTION:
The defective heat tracing tape was replaced and tested within the time span specified by Technical Specifications.
: 6. ACTION TAKEN to PREVENT RECURRENCE:
: 6. ACTION TAKEN to PREVENT RECURRENCE:
No additional actions:were deemed necessary.  
No additional actions:were deemed necessary.
: 7. GENERIC IMPLICATIONS:
: 7. GENERIC IMPLICATIONS:
A task force has reviewed the total spectrum of the Heat Tracing *system and a Design Change is being prepared as a result of the Task Force's study. Long lead ttems are being procured.}}
A task force has reviewed the total spectrum of the Heat Tracing *system and a Design Change is being prepared as a result of the Task Force's study. Long lead ttems are being procured.}}

Latest revision as of 12:33, 17 March 2020

LER 81-031/03L-0:on 810508,amp Reading for Heat Tracing Panel 11,circuit 1B,found Below Acceptance Criteria.Caused by Mechanical Damage to Tape.Heat Tracing Replaced & Tested. Design Change Initiated
ML18139B387
Person / Time
Site: Surry  Dominion icon.png
Issue date: 06/05/1981
From: Joshua Wilson
VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.)
To:
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML18139B384 List:
References
LER-81-031-03L-02, LER-81-31-3L-2, NUDOCS 8106090548
Download: ML18139B387 (2)


Text

NRC FORM 31;;6 U.S. NUCL.EAR REGUL.ATORV COMMISSION r,. 7i'll

.* -ICENSEE. EVENT REPORT I

CONTROL. BL.OCK: ~....__.............____...---.!s "-!.I If'i\ (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIREC INFORMATION)

~ I V I A I s I p I s I 2 101 0 I O I -10101010101-10101@1411111111101 l I©

~ S 9 L.ICSNSEE CODE 14 ~S LICENSE NUMBER 25 . 26 LICENSE 'iYPE JO 57 CAT SS CON'i

[ITIJ

6

~~~~~~ LI© I61 o s l COCKE'T J o l o I o I 21 s 11 101 o I s I o I s l s I 1 I© Io ! 6 Io I s I s 11 I© 60 NUMBER 6S 69 EVENT DATE 74 75 REPORT OAi'c BO EVENT DESCRIPTION AND PROSABL.E CONSEQUENCES@

l With Unit No. 2 at 100% power, PT-27C revealed that amp reading for heat tracing

. Panel 11, circuit lB was below the acceptance criteria stipulated in the PT.

IIm This everit is contrary to T. S. 3 ,3 .A. 4 and is reportable per-T, S. 6. 6. 2. b (2). 'T'he

_l]J]J redundant.heat tracing circuit was operable, therefore, the health and safety of the

[§)):] L-...;;P.;;u;,;;;b.;;l;,;;;i:.;;c;....;.w;.;;e;,:r;.;;e;_;,n:.:o;.;;t:.....:a:.:f;.;f;.;e::.:c;;.;t;;.;e::.:d::..:...*-------------------------------'!

__[ill]

[ID]

7. B 9 BO CAUSE CAUSE COMP. VALVE COOE SUBCODE COMPONENT COtlE SUBCODE SUBCOOE lTIIl 7 S

~@ 12~@

11 1

t3 H' El A' T'E ,R ,s,e LEJ ~@ 19 20 SEQUENTIAL. OCCURRENCE *REPOF!T REVISION

(.":;\ LER/RO LVENT YE~.R REPORT NO. CODE TYPE NO.

\:.:,/ REPORT

. NUMBER L.? I 11  ::z:z I23 I I o 'I 3 I 126l I27.,....., I28o I 329I . 1.1..J l:=l kLJ 21 24 lCI 31 J:

ACTION FUTURE EFFEC"l' SHUTDOWN t.:::\ Aii'ACHMENT

  • NPRD-4 PRIME C:.OMP. COMPONENT

,:':,' ** . TAKEN AC"l'ION ON,_PLANT METHOD HOURS @ SUBMITTED FORM :.UB. SUPPLIER MANUFACTURER

.. -:, * *_.. Lf..l@)Ll.l@}.-_

lJ ~

  • L.Ll@

JS . .-;

Li.J I* o! oi ol -ol 36 37 40 l!J@).

41

  • Ll!J lLJ@ *-IT 11**1s Is*!@)

42 -, 4J

  • 44 * '. ' 47

-*- CAUSE DESCRIPTION ANO CORRECTIVE ACTIONS @)

DJ:[] l The loss of heat tracing was due _to mechanical damage to the-**tape, Personnel had been working in the near b'y area, !he defective heat tracing was replaced and test-

[I))] .ed. A design change has been initiated to change the manner by which these borated liries are heat traced.

o:m 7 8 9 80 FACILITY /jo'I METHODOF r.;:;,..

STATUS  % "0WER . OTHER STATUS '.;::;:; DISCOVERY DISCOVERY DESCRIPTION ~

iI1TI .LI@__ I 1 l O I O lI...._!_i/_A~--- L!J@I 7 8 9 10 12 t'l Routine Test. -

80 '--~-----

45 . 46 ACTIVITY CONTENT I.::\

RELEASED OF RELEASE AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY ~ .~OCATION OF RELEASE @

Ema 1_~@)

7 s

  • W(§)I 10 11

.N/A N/A 80

.* PERSOIIINEL EXPOSURl:S Q r:;:;,. TYPE~ DESCRIPTION I2:E] .r 01 NUMBER 0 I O ,~~~1...-----~N/;..;.A;;...._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___.

7_ .:a

.*. y,,,*,,_

9 *-.* i1 PERSONNEL. INJURIES 12 13 C\

BO Cl:li:J j 01 01 01@1...-*_ _ _ _ _ _rr.;../A_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

-*. * .. . *. ---NUMBER . *.', DESC1'11l'TION6

~

7 S 9 11 1:i! BO

  • ---' * * *
  • LOSSOF*OR*DAMAClE TO FAl:;ILITY 12,
  • . 'TVPE * . DESCRIPTIOI\I \:;I IITIJ-a
  • s~@)..___._.

7 *

  • 10
  • ________N;.../A___;*---------------------------
  • so
  • * :-. PUBLICITY C\ NFIC USE ONLV

~

rm:i we.,. . . .___-__._____.....;;.;.N,_/A ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - '

. * * .:-:-1ssuEC~ DES_CRIPTION

__ , , 1 ., , , , , I I IBOLL

~:~sE*-=-------**----------------*-*--------- *-----* _ ._ .---*.

7 B 9 10 68 H  ;;

0 1

~1 ~6 o, **Ee.RE~. J. Lo llil~n' '*, -, * ',:  : '._ * ..;{;...8__

0__4.;..)_,3_:__7-.--~-,-1-.*_8___:-.....-.:::~~-,,""',.-_,.~,--~----~~-. -

ATTACHMENT

  • SURRY POWER STATION, UNIT NO. 2 DOCKET NO: 50-281 REPORT NO: 8l-031/03L-O EVENT DATE: 05-08-81 TITLE OF EVENT: HEAT TRACING FAILURE
1. DESCRIPTION OF EVENT:

With Unit No. 2 at 100% power, PT-27C revealed that the amp reading for heat tracing Panel 11, circuit 18 (BIT Outlet Valve, MOV-2867D), was below the acceptance criteria stipulated in the PT. This event is contrary to Technical Specification 3.3.A.4, and is reportable per Technical Specification 6.6.2.b(2).

2. PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES and STATUS of REDUNDANT EQUIPMENT:

The heat tracing circuits are intended to maintain a fluid temperature above that needed for flow. The redundant heat tracing circuit was operable, there-fore, the health and safety of the public were not affected.

3. CAUSE:

The loss of heat tracing was du~to mechanical ~amage to the tape. Personnel from various crafts had been working .in the nearby area.

4. IMMEDIATE CORRECT I VE ACT ION:

The immediate corrective action was to verify that the redundant circuit was opera9le.

5. SUBSEQUEST CORRECTIVE ACTION:

The defective heat tracing tape was replaced and tested within the time span specified by Technical Specifications.

6. ACTION TAKEN to PREVENT RECURRENCE:

No additional actions:were deemed necessary.

7. GENERIC IMPLICATIONS:

A task force has reviewed the total spectrum of the Heat Tracing *system and a Design Change is being prepared as a result of the Task Force's study. Long lead ttems are being procured.