ML20196A875

Order (Corrections to 990513 Prehearing Conference Transcript).* Proposed Corrections to Transcript of Board 990513 Initial Prehearing Conference Submitted by Petitioner & Application.With Certificate of Svc.Served on 990622

ML20196A875
Person / Time
Site:	Harris
Issue date:	06/22/1999
From:	Bollwerk G Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
To:	AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED, CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO., NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC)
References
CON-#299-20554 99-762-02-LA, 99-762-2-LA, LA, NUDOCS 9906230027
Download: ML20196A875 (16)

Text

I?

q UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DOCXETED NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION USHRC ATOMIC SAFETY.AND LICENSING-BOARD g Bdfore Administrative Judges:

OHF '

G. Paul Bollwerk, III, Chairman RL1, Frederick J. Shon ADJUC: ,/gp Dr.. Peter S. Lam In the Matter of Docket No. 50-400-LA CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY ASLBP.No. 99-762-02-LA (Shearon Harris Nuclear June 22, 1999 Power Plant)

SERVEDMW 2 21999 ORDER

.(Corrections to May 13, 1999 Prehearing Conference Transcript)

Upon consideration of the May 27, 1999 proposed corrections to the transcript of the Licensing Board's May 13, 1999' initial prehearing conference submitted by petitioner Board of Commissioners of Orange County, North Carolina, (BCOC), and applicant Carolina Power & Light Co.

(CP&L), it is l

t 9906230027 990622 7 PDR ADOCK 05000400 0 PDR OF

g . .

t.

-2.

ORDERED,'that the transcript of the'May 13, 1999 initiial prehearing conference proceeding is hereby revised in accordance with Attachment 1 to this order.

FOR THE' ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

• O Ns G. Paul Bollwerk, III ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE Rockville, Maryland June 22, 1999 l

l l

l l

l u

.* Copies of this order were sent this date by Internet e-mail transmission to' counsel for (1) applicant CP&L; (2) intervenor BCOC;.and (3) the NRC staff.

)

1 .

VTT t.g i

j

a

'h

.l .

.l l

l 1

ATTACHMENT 1 I

l

+

t i

t i

.d...

c-Corrections to May 13, 1999 Prehearing Conference Transcript Pace /Line Chance / Delete Insert 1/10 District Court Southern Human Services Center 1/11 Orange County 2505 Homestead Road Courtroom 1/12- Chapel Hill Post Office Building 1/13 179 E. Franklin Street .

4/10 129 under " Received" 6/10 My MS. CURRAN: My 7/14 Marion Marian 7/24 for us for letting us 11/24 the~ essential not the essential 12/4 interest, and is interest. This is 12/12 injury injury, 12/21 occur occur --

15/24 lack lacks 16/1-2 for hearing for a hearing 16/4 are county are a county l

l 17/3 beside cited in 17/4 speak and speak, and r 17/16 standing is standing, is 18/2 and but 18/22 consequences In consequences. In 19/8 said in said so in 19/9 cases and cases, and

r- ,

, f.

c Pace /Line Chance / Delete Insert 19/11. boundary. boundary,

~

-19/21-. not -no 20/13 their its 20/14 'in in the in the 21/1' position- petition 22/11 possibility. They possibility. But they 26/7 btus BTUs.

27/15 When you referred We refer 27/16 board Board 27/17 5-2, we 5-2. We 28/3 board Board l

28/21- marshalling marching l 30/7' issues issue l 30/9 it may see, which it may see. This 32/19 be having be better than having 33/7 LOCA could LOCA, could l'

'35/10; btus BTUs 36/15,23;25 37/1-2 DR. THOMPSON: Well if DR. THOMPSON: Well j the -- if the -- the i JUDGE SHON: The Applicant l Applicant

~

-37/11;, .

btu BTU 38/2,6; 39/4'

-39/14

-indicates that'the indicates the 1 l

3 40/4 -how can how long can I

^I L

t Pace /Line Chance / Delete Insert i

41/19' vales valves 41/25- .btus' BTUs 42/5 . btu BTU 48/17,19- -breaks brakes 48/17 L50. seat s- 50 seats, 49/25' We are. We are not 50/4 is are 50/12' demand's demands 51/7 don't doubt 52/4,13,14,17.- Holloway Hollaway

.52/5 and to 52/21' this marked this be marked 53/6 received into bound into the evidence.] record.)

53/7,'17 -Holloway Hollaway 53/8 is has 53/15 problems before problems with before 54/13- about a post-LOCA about post-LOCA

.58/1 Shon Shon's l

-58/15 simply simple t '61/4~ says.did says we did 61/6 ' exchanger,' fouling exchanger fouling i 63/2 Their The 65/1 longer longer, l 65/3 .on' cooling'the on the  ;

E 3

W.;

'I f,}

i

..,5

- Pace /Line ' Chance / Delete. Insert.

65/8- at:-the at. The i

I 66/24 capacity but again- capacity. But again

, 67/3. the' emergency the.other emergency 69/12- there,-and 'there. And 69./13- 7 well, this while this 69/17 'on off

.69/24-25 done in 5~.6 -done at 5.6 69/25- turned 5.6 turned at 5.6 70/2. degrees, and degrees. And

70/25; -HOLLOWAY HOLLAWAY

.71/2,8 71/10- is also valved-out. it is valved-out, And when we and we' l 71/12' manually,theheare '

manually. There are CCW .

41: two CCW i

[ .

-72/6 HOLLOWAY. ,

HOLLAWAY 72/14. purpose the. purpose of the 74/23 -basis basic

75/10: .he the l

.75/20 that'is an think that is an 76/3 simply,-and there is simple, .and there are 76/19- .not no l

76/20 btu.- BTU  !

-77/11 (A) .

l 77/13 attached the attached, the Applicant's response Applicant's c' response,

4 r..

• f,

  . -

e .. ,,-

y, q, e )4'

v: ,

5_

. Paae/Line . Chance / Delete ' Insert

v. ,78/4-- :like this set 'like this is set' 79/,3,25- Holloway' Hollaway

79/13 1 pleasing pleading 80/2;14;? Holloway Hollaway

- 82/25; 83/18 c 83/23 is are 84/16;f85/5 Holloway Hollaway 86/6,'18. HOLLOWAY HOLLAWAY

'86/14 implemented and this~ implemented, and amendment concerns this amendment is'the one that says ~ concerns, is the one that says:

86/15 following factors, fouling factors, two tube

'86/22' with some' changes "with some changes

'in; design assumptions in design assumptions"'

87/3' HOLLOWAY- HOLLAWAY 89/13 fuel racks fuel racks --

91/2. received into bound into the evidence record

' 92/8 burnup in burnup element in j .92/9- surrounding' surrounded l 4 92/13- sites cites 95/17 estate estimate I 197/10,14' Holloway Hollaway l 98/6- may. must 98/13 issue and issue. And i

a >

.: e

.r:

\ z Pace /Line Chance / Delete Insert

'98/14 'think put think we put 99/2 allows'.and allows. And 99/3 some other methodology some methodology 100/3' LTherefore therefore 100/11 these,'as these~ amendments'.

As 100/13 assembly, that could assembly, there could

~ 101/ 3 ,12 ,1'8' HOLLOWAY. HOLLAWAY

-101/31 not staff not a staff

'101/5 .

amendment, it amendment -- it 101/18 said say 103/1- newer' new or 104/12: ,

allow, to- allow. To I 104/14 burn-up. They're burn-up, they're  ;

104/15 advocate we advocate that we 105/16 contention to - if contention too. If l 106/11 .Mr. HOLLAWAY MS. ZOBLER i

106/20 include could 106/22- that's that 107/22 lbe, is-in- be what is in 109/23 -will well,

'109/24 physical. " physical."

110/1'- decision decisions l 110/10' staff staff, 110/15 Applicants' Applicant's a.

n- '

i f,M .

ei'~- ,

p

..s.

~

Pace /Lirig . Chance / Delete- Insert 110/16 .Ihitervenors Intervenor's

-110/22~ '

criteria ~ criterion

.) 7116/12 to them- to put them 116/16 .then maybe then, maybe 116/23. ~t he Staff document they're Staff documents 116/24 . Appeals. an Appeal 116/25. ' controlling-the- controlling, the "The Commission has The Commission has

~

117/3

' stated,-if stated, "if 117/7' , criteria, and that's criteria," and particularly true.in that's particularly true "in

'120/1- for a lay-up for lay-up 1 120/11 implicate implicates 120/12 future future, i

122/1' .

or, the but the

'122/19 giving given I i I 122/20 you're on are gone j l

122/22-23 to do other to do it other 123/22. dry-cast dry cask 125/1'3 yet that ,

l 1127'/12- pipe was._ pipe, was

.128/5' system-is system, is 128/21 Any In 4 1

p

' I 129/2 sum. a time

[

i l

i

Pace /Line Chance / Delete Insert 129/17 received into bound into the evidence.] record.]

129/25 identification.] identification and bound into the record.]

130/1 Pictures Picture's 130/6 with be 130/8 closes closest 130/16 commission commissioned 131/22-23 which operate which will operate 132/9 alternate alternative 132/17 adequacy. adequacy?

133/10 cast cask 133/20 very, difficult very difficult 133/21 do. If go even if 133/23 FASR FSAR 133/23 Why isn't a Why isn't it a 134/7 that the CP&L that CP&L 134/12 rejection. rejected.

134/12 regulations, case regulations and case 134/13 requires require 135/12 Now MR. . O'NEILL: Now 135/20 that that really that it really 135/21 basis in specificity basis and specificity

-136/4 Unit 2, Unit Unit 2 and Unit 136/12, 25 alternate alternative

r e

Pace /Line Chance / Delete Insert 137/12 data existed data report existed 137/23-24; basis in specificity basis and 138/6-7 specificity 138/14 points that points to 139/5' treateed treated 139/10 basis that the basis.in the 139/11 Petitioners at Petitioner that at 139/14 in and 140/10 infrmation information 141/12 is acceptable is not acceptable 142/6 nad and i 142/8 SCR SER 143/11 submit, if the submit, that the 143/19-20 nonetheless Staff nonetheless something the Staff 144/2-3 follow that they would follow that follow that .

144/10 MR. O'NEILL 144/16 componetns components 144/17 requirement requirements 144/18-19 assurance in the assurance and the l

. design basis, or design basis, or

} replace. replaced.

144/23 barrier buried 145/10 altnernate alternative 1 145/11 contentions go contentions, go 146/3 sorry, didn't sorry, I didn't i

l I

r, c.

n t .

, Pace /Line Chance / Delete Insert 148/17- MS. CURRAN:-

i-148/19. ' schedule scheduled 150/3 of material dispute- of a material dispute 150/17 MS. CURRAN:

~

151/13 and leak and a leak 151/20 pool pools.

151/21- filled,- filled --

151/22 -- demineralized -- with demineralized )

152/10 stated that stated, that 156/2 that we'll deal that we that we 156/19- on. or 157/20 Licnesing Licensing L157/9 you that you. But 157/9 >before, which- before us, which 158/5 in VEPCO in the VEPCO

'158/12 the spent fuel the spent ,

modification, spent  !

l 158/14 = Decision decision l 158/14 and it said and it is said 158'/17 objected cn1 objected, on 162/5 Robinson Brunswick Robinson and c . plant Brunswick plants 162/14' is- or

-162/18 of contentions of have contentions 165/14 Harris.- I Harris, I i

I

e o

P Pace / Ling Chance / Delete Insert 165/19 licensed exactly they licensed -- exactly how they 166/19 cast casks 168/21 Nuclear Policy Nuclear Waste Policy 168/23 there's why we're that's why we're here today, is here today, it is I

169/23 it's it's up j 171/9 admit a admission or admit a -- admission contention as of a contention is 171/18 hearing. hearing --

171/19 not, to not. To 171/20 knowledge a knowledge there has never been a 171/22 Beckhoff Judge Bechhoefer ,

172/20 that that advances that it advances 173/6 there's they're 173/7 contention contentions 175/24 Anything my Anything from my l 176/8 would 176/17-18 was recessed, to was adjourned.]

reconvene at 9:30 a.m.,

Friday, May 14, 1999.]

l

o UNITED STATES OF ANERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMISSION In the Matter of CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY Docket No.(s) 50-400-LA (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing ORDER--CORRECT'S TO 5/13/99 TR have bean served upon the following persons by U.S. mail, first class, except as otherwise noted and in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR Sec. 2.712.

Administrative Judge Office of Commission Appellate G. Paul Bo11werk, III, Chairman Adjudication Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Washington, DC 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Frederick J. Shon Peter S. Lam Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Mail Stop - T-3 F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Marian L. Zobler, Esq.

Richard G. Bachmann, Esq. Diane Curran, Esq.

Office of the General Counsel . Harmon, curran, Spielberg Mail Stop 15 BI8 & Eisenberg, L.L.P.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission 1726 M Street, NW, Suite 600 Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20036 William D. Johnson John H. O'Neill, Jr., Esq.

! Vice President and Senior Counsel William R. Ho11away, Esq.

l Carolina Power & Light Company Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge P. O. Box 1551 2300 N Street, NW l

Raleigh, NC 27602 Washington, DC 20037 l

m Docket No.(s)50-400-LA ORDER--CORRECT'S TO 5/13/99 TR Dated at Rockville, Md. this /

22 day of June 1999 7 Dffice of the Secretarf of the Congfssion j

l 4