ML19254D927

LER 79-087/01T-1:on 791015,during Verification of Computer Analysis of Seismic Restraints,Svc Water Reservoir 151 Found Inadequately Designed.Svc Water Reservoir Redesigned & Replaced

ML19254D927
Person / Time
Site:	Crystal River
Issue date:	10/22/1979
From:	Cooper J FLORIDA POWER CORP.
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML19254D908	List: ML19254D907 ML19254D927
References
LER-79-087-01T, LER-79-87-1T, NUDOCS 7910300322
Download: ML19254D927 (2)

Text

NaC PQaM fM U= 3= NUCI IAA RECULAICRT COMM8DCN

.. a.n' EXHIBlT A

' LICCNSEE EVENT REFCRT

,

couract succc l

,

I  !  ! I l lg

.

tri.tAsa natur ca rvet ALL accusato isecauAncs:

l osi 171 iLICauQn 31  ?! 3 Gl u010-t- 1 01u..u O! J l Oi o i ;0 i 0a gl 4 i Cawa 1Llri i gl a

_.,-ai _ i g

, . , Ceca i. - . o  :. r...

l

a

'fegILgl0150t-i0i2;01

, ,

.a .. CoC.or %i,, visa 2 g; u 1l0 u

g 1 ;5; 7;9 g l1; Og 212 avs~rsars 7. >> aa Car :*ri 1 7 l 9 ;g n

avtur cascaiaricN Ano eacsAata constcuv4 css @ ,,

o62 I At 1220 in Mode 1. it was dis _ overed that on 13 October 1979. I

., g , during the verificat'oniof couputer analysis of seismic restraints, that Sb'R 515

, , , ,was inadequately designed. This :reated an event reportable under Technical  !

Specification 6.9.1.8.1. N, effect upon the plant or general public. This l

,

, , , ,is the third occurrence of this tepe reported. Reference LER 79-061/01T-0, t

,,, ,79-087/0lT-0  ;

3 to.4 ST S,14 CAust C&438 =

AOV. v.Ly t COCE C008 SW8C008 COV8C94,,C00E SW3 COOK $65COct

,

oi, a

i 3

!

Zi @ O@ I A l@ l SIU i P l O f RI Tl@ l X l@M J @

to as 92 12 t. i, CC;ggsq%Cg agpcar etw Icas

,

sv ta,7 vtAn SICt t 'o f,,46 a t*Ca f 0. COOE **t NQ g

@ ,,(yy. at gso_,l,7 i9 al l- ]

u

[ 0 l 8 I 7l 1  ;.

. l /l 2,

l n l,

., .,

I lT l u.

b

Wu 3 **Cy e s sygw #Cm A 3. . g v.% a age f's C f V8

.

irt@ W @ W@ Iu vi@ l ni oln i n I

,,

l .y_l@ Inl@ U., @  != 1 311 I T.,f(

n ,. ,, .,

causa etSCalPTICN AND ceaaccnvE AcrtcNs h

, o (The cause of this event is attribiited en fa,aam.,*a an .- % cuo cic ..-, ,_ f

, designed and repaired through modification 79-6-86H. Rework of Sb? U 5 v' I completed on l'.> October 1979, i I

42 I

'

... i

, . , -

wr , .. .-.. n., @ nas  :.:,...=uc...C,@

,. _ (Ej@ l1iGiOl@l

,,,

NA l lnl@lNotificationfromA/F

- - -

I

o. ,

.,;,,,,,, g,,, .. ,, -

. <.C . sos C. ..u.o @

. . . , . . . .. . .u o,

.,ms ..na. m.- @ i i u i

i. ,

. zi

u. u@i ., ..

,

, . . ,,

. . ...

,s s u ,.,, .u u . .,,

i ,i, 10i0: 0 Gi z,i@i u

"

i

!

' ' ' ...,. ,J.',.us'in

l ,i, 1071I'f 0 I@f"*'"~ ' i; na 0000 a

NOlDIM4l g,y gy 3 h yg ggggg ggj( 3; 1

,

, 8 8 1i

• . 013 C. C. 3E50av.a 33 ",3 84Clu f*

8.'tC f**f l i i ,o Iz @l v

, . . ..

w

!

.

!

.,y sr.iC'a ggf"'* g 33 7910300 g y , rii sacusacut, ii ie: ir

, . , is u o n

..

u.,.

• g, , g,2, g, _

l' C. coper, Jr.

. , (904) 795 6486

~

---

.,__ (Sc A17'

_

] SU2?tMCARI EECIL CICN SM)

, . ,

.

. -

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION Report No.: 50-302/79-087/0lT-1 .

Facility: Crystal River Unit #3 Report Date: 22 October 1979 Occurrence Date: 15 October 1979 Identification of Occurrence:

Inadequate design of SW system restraint SWR 515, reportable under Technical Specification 6.9.1.8.1.

Conditions Prior to Occurrence:

Mode 1 power operation (100%)

Description of Occurrence:

a At 1220 it was reported that on 13 October 1979, seismic re-straint SWR 515 was found to be inadequately designed. Original computer analysis conducted by Gilbert Associates indicated a need for a horizontal restraint. During verification of com-puter analysis, it was discovered that a vert 4 cal restraint was improperly designed and installed. A modification was initiated to correct this deficiency and provide an adequate design for SWR 515.

Designation of Apparent Cause:

The cause of this event is attributed to inadequate design.

Analysis of Occurrence:

No effect upon the plant or general public.

Corrective Action:

SWR 515 was redesigned and repaired through modification 79-6-86H.

.. Repairs to SWR 515 were completed on 13 October 1979.

Failure Data:

This is the third occurrence of this type reported. Reference LER 79-061/0lT-0, 79-087/OlT-0.

/rc ,, 7 .,