ML20237D038
Text
& Eu.dLl u a,h:.aw.SU$ 2 % ba %Ont..Oh2h EhkAadli:LL.ldL.G4Tu D%a a A, bx..m...~...L.i j
NOV 2S 1"5 q
.}
'(
Mr. Larry W. Duchek
-{
Commonwealth Edison Company Mazon EOF j Q]
960 North Route 4T 5 p a., u
.~
Morris, Illinois 60450 i
j;
_j ii 4
)
Dear Larry:
1
.l I want to thank you for agreeing to meet with myself and our contractor to
.{
.i discuss the technical aspects of setting up an Emergency Response Data System j
.i (ERDS) with your facilities.
As I explained in our conversation, the intent of I
]
this effort overall is to provide us with a detailed understanding of the
)
q availability of the data we desire, the potential for transmitting the data to us, and the hardware and software necessary for use to handle the data.
For-d your information, I have enclosed three documents which describe:
the person-A nel and reference material we need access to; a sample of our questions on the parameters; and our computer and telecommunications information needs.
I m
.j We are attempting to make this data collection effort complete anough so that
- j no subsequent trips to any site will be necessary and that we obtain sufficient 3
information to implement the system should we do so.
Therefore, as discussed, f
- i we will plan on arriving at your downtown corporate offices at 9
- 00 a.m. on December 2,1985 to obtain as much information as possible at that location.
A 3
determination will be made while we are there as to whether or not travel to
'j the sites is necessary.
l
)
{
Should you have any concerns or question please call me at (301)492-4155.
Sincerely, i
i John B. Hickman Incident Response Branch Division of Emergency Preparedness 1
and Engineering Response 1
Office of Inspection and Enforcement 1
j
Enclosure:
As stated J,
2
{
Distribution:
1 IRB R/F e
j T. McKenna K. Perkins a
1 i
- See previous concurrence d
]
IR8:DEPER:IE IRB:DEPER:IE IRB:DEPER:IE
- J8Hickman: ams
- TMcKenna
- KEPerkins j
4
.i 11/26/85 11/26/85 11/26/85
'i (
i fj O 8712220326 871210 I
PDR FDIA
.d SHOLLY87-737 PDR-d
~
.-._-_--_--a
M.w.:c h w b. A i a d.'.U M m m s i.h d G.S.Eti ke:dUjdJgai i.6.
I'
. h.,d,, a_ f. sd5 ]
!l L
!j
.i Ej
}
ATTACHMENT 1
't
'.f
'L ~
PERSONNEL AND REFERENCE MATERIAL O
'.)
v lb fi iilij It is recognized that the key disciplines necessary to support El the ERDS survey will represent different departments and i)i organizational relationships unique to each utility surveyed l
(e. g., Corporate vs. Plant Site Engineering staff).
It is j
- 3 believed that most of the appropriate personnel will be the j
?.j l
i same as those on the project teams for SPDS and Emergency 1
Response Facility Data Acquisition System development.
1 l
!l The appropriate utility manager to coordinate the ERDS site
.l survey is likely to be the same individual who is responsible l j.
for SPDS, RG1.97 or ERF upgrade programs.
The approximate lj man-hours for each site survey are based on a 2 to 2b day Lj survey for a single unit site or a 2 unit site where both units are identical and a common Data Acquisition System has
))
been installed at a common TSC or EOF.
Personnel 1
Approximate
'e Person or Discipline Man-Hours Required V
~
D ERDS Survey Coordinator 8 - 12 NSSS System Expert 4-6 i
Plant I&C Expert 2-4 Computer Hardware Expert (for ERDS signal source (s))
4-6 1
]
Computer Applications Expert 4-6
~i Emergency Planning Coordinator 1/2 - 1 Telecommunications Expert 2-4 Meteorologist or Environmental Engineer 1/2 - 1 u
Radiological Monitoring System Expert 1
RG1.97, RVLIS, SMM Instrument Expert 1
J e
n.>
~.
e 9
a r-
$$58%ba:A n % d 5 b L $ $hh!b 6 S.:a b b h d n.A i O Z 5 5 $ $ldhiuis $ $ 3 k i $ $ E k h..Ja & 2 1 l,EN ]l W {I]
,4-]
j1 ib a
It is understood that many of the areas of expertise listed above may be represented by a single individual. (e.g., One I&C engineer may be able to address instrument characteristics
}h i
and display conventions for RVLIS, SMM, Radiological, and Meteorological 1 instruments).
3 lj Reference Material II FSAR o
Any locally generated Plant Data Book (Compilation of I
N.
System Design Data)
]
1
[
Systems Training Manuals i
!j Tables or graphs for engineering unit conversion (e.g.,
4 feet to gallons for_ containment sumps)
Data System Design documents and block diagrams a
Hardcopy printouts of Data Acquisition System displays 4
i l1 Ikn li lh.:
g j
J.'
s a
1
',i l!
a, -
1, i
b t.)
l Y;
i:4 Ywi sM f
l3:;
i
>A a
1, h
l 2
'ill
.i l
[ "i'j.'
L l'
.i L___
r_us__u _2 4_
nu--
u-
_,_s
,e, e.
.4 r
.mm
..1_.,..
..-..,u,3.o.,-..
s.e
.,e__
m
_m m
yj.0Ei,25Y$UEb:E A. d G d $ $$$ % $ G 5 6$ $ $ 5;"If?.E i & b l n d $ $h ; Li g a L & Q."
-L L,sg l a ; M f1 }
g 1
a e
te l
]
ATTACHMENT 2
(%.:;J x.
,,la1 H]
This attachment consists of three samples from the parameter-1 specific section of the ERDS survey instrument.
The three i1 samples are as follows:
a Pi 14 Generic Checklist:
This four page checklist is repeated
.for each of the 29 PWR parameters and 25 BWR parameters.
d Some questions in the checklist do not apply to every-
'l parameter (e.g., questions on engineering unit conversion d
factors would not be applicable to parameters such as Hot (j
Leg Temperature which is always expressed in' degrees i
Farenheit).
]
Parameter-Specific Checklist for Atmospheric. Stability-
~
p (applicable to both PWRs and BWRs).
R
!l Parameter-Specific Checklist for BWR Low' Pressure Coolant i
Injection Flow I'
ii y $.')
m 3
lN
- )
..J
- 1l!
l.. I 1
\\li k
M A
18 I
a L7 L.;
i.j i
i a
s t
,")
to e---
.zWs.kSS:l%LA2i:u.hOL$a :x$li:c,idsbl Oktl$2ENi$4&l,iAGs k hmsN:.=u.i2.wlsi:2.i:m$
e
.i GENERIC CHECKLIST:
q l
1.
Is this parameter available as a digital signal at the
.3,.J preferred host location, the pickoff point determined in Appendix 1, Section 2?
ij i
e m
A.
If not, what is best alternative host location?
a, I.
it i.3 2.
At the host location, is this" parameter available as a b
processed signal (i.e. validated, averaged, range checked, etc.) or only as one or more unprocessed discrete signals?
P
- ]
3.
Describe the following attributes of the instruments supplying i
either the discrete data points or the inputs to the processed variable:
A.
Sensor type?
3 4
=
B.
Instrument failure mode for:
1.
Loss of power (offsite & onsite AC, but static inverter battery systems survive); does the control room
.i instrument display survive?):
1 2.
Instrument in test?
1
,1 1
l i
3.
If instrument is placed in test, does the preferred ll host location recognize instrument in test?
)
J
't I
i i
' 'l
.)
?}
2 4
d')
j L
s ___ _ - - = -
f.1$'SO.5 N buA S E A D O 5b,d k&a:.k ut1j$U.,ii;ysk&h h b$g;w s s % L6_ h.:.x;lllz a m s s
.(
- I C.
Numbar of coparato locations conitored (i.o. Icop 1, loop j
2, loop 3, etc)?
,1
- j
? '%
', ! b>
~4 l'
D.
How many ranges of instrumentation are provided for each l) location monitored?
1 J
4
- d 1
)
l
- A E.
For each of these ranges, describe instrument range:
- 1 1
i!
1
.,A
'lfl
..j 1
l}
'.;e
- j F.
Reference point of each instrument range (e.g. BWR level; 1
ref.
to bottom head or feedwater sparger or steam separator shroud; PWR RVLIS; etc.)?
J.m l
'i,)
.1 1
G.
Number of instruments within each range for each location fj monitored (e.g. PWR loop 2; Th; 2 NR & 1 WR etc.)?
-i
.l.
,u
-j H.
For those cases where data does not read out at the host W
location in final required units, what is the engineering conversion factor for each range (i.e. tank' level measured J
l in feet, factor to convert to gallons)?
'l 4
1
,q l
, 'l L9 p.
3
..e j
i j
t.!
J p.
i l
lb
'Y 1>
l h
3 1
1.
.k
,1
\\ '.
g
+ ___" - ? :.
~
ir.: _-
__----w'__
i-
__,,e,..
- NOM lIO:iddhlush$%iba11h!$GU$1\\1SubE$ndithilki$i$$ uh2C2L:sx:usS:c=.el;. wwa q
NOTE:
If convorcion fcctor 10 not c oinplo cenotant, ycu c y rGquire a copy of the curve. (For example, in the case of an irregularly shaped RWST tank where level data is
{
provided in feet, you must obtain a copy of the tank j
capacity curve to allow the ERDS system to convert levels
~
- }
to gallons).
]
Not applicable.
..l j
Conversion is a constant, value is:
lj Conversion is not a constant, curve attached.
Conversion is not a constant, curve not required or not obtained.
H 1
H 1
iil 1.
Engineering units for each range?
r );l 4.
If parameter is a processed value, describe the following
- I attributes of how the above instrument inputs are processed to
-}
arrive at a single value:
i 1
b A.
Does the processed variable take inputs from more than one
.; j_~,
instrument range?
K: 1 t
l.
If yes, then describe method used to switch between ranges.
- t,
.j
- t
)
d i
54 B.
Q For each range of the parameter available, identify the instruments whose signals are combined to provide the
' j processed parameter?
t4
,J
- l
!)
6 l
?j i
y 3
p 4
5 i?
l't
.)
C m,=-
m:
~..
r n_ u:,c;;&: 5.w.w;,2agg.g,;g.,gg;gg....g,3g,y,. _,
,,,~ ;
I '.,
r... 6
. i.e n<,
.+
r g,g
..-.....,_..a_
61
,,-.r 9.~.u"o.w-w,,. >,.,. 1
-..~
l :
l,
lj C.
Dacerib2 tho validction ochsca used for renga chseking" error checking and averaging the input parameters?
P;, )
l j.
w 1
J 1
- 1
.a i
6 i*)
, e
.'s1 4
4
,.i
- s
'.)
- 4 e
t I'.
e 4
e f
'i,
'(l' s
i-t
,i h
?
L1
, 4 0) i l
m
)
Ia i
.6
- 4 1
- 6
.l
'^
i
- 1 a
i 1
- ?* s s
'j i
i 5
1 4
w e
e.....__
..i..
(aa 55 2 ll$ 5 52.:.isu eID:2hLnSR hGah:;d:.AAl. ssY$$6:naibUhMinda $:$ai.
zuasi.x.: ]
(.)
.1 1
PARAMETER: ATMOSPHERIC STABILITY
.~s SPECIFIC CHECKLIST:
li (O l}
U 1.
IF THE SITE EMPLOYS MORE THAN ONE METEOROLOGICAL TOWER FOR l]
REASONS OF TERRAIN (AS OPPOSED TO REDUNDANCY), THEN COLLECT THE lj t
DATA BELOW FOR BOTH TOWERS.
j l
i U'l ii i4 1
ij
!j!
- 2. WHAT IS THE LOCATION OF EACH OF THE TOWERS WITH RESPECT TO THE j
PLANT POWER BLOCK?
It i
i d'
i i l l
lj
- 3. WHAT IS THE HEIGHT OF THE LOWER TEMPERATURE DETECTOR?
j
\\a 1
- 4. WHAT IS THE HEIGHT OF THE UPPER TEMPERATURE DETECTOR?
l+
1 i
1
.l
(%,d ll
- 5. WHAT IS THE DISTANCE IN METERS BETWEEN THE LOWER AND UPPER TEMPERATURE DETECTORS?
- .3 T
l
'l
- 6. DOES THE HOST COMPUTER CONVERT THE DELTA T INTO A DEGREES 5!
CENTIGRADE PER 100 METERS VALUE?
1
- 1 P
l i
a 4
.i
..j
- 4
- i g
i i
';I
-i
] hIj
- i 6
l
,1
.i b,
m..--m name-m
_.-am.
m m.=.a
-am.u..
me.
a ar A%.a.
=
A.
Am.
e m.ia ma m.s aes Aem.m i..t
_s ma
_ma s 1.m_
miaAmu_.h2.M'4.A_m4
_m
.A
,di15L.bSO lb ' U$bithh J.uh5$10hbbduhlY$aAE$$$$i5th$i$b$54. Sad &.J.:5A-.Q. :.:
NJ&a 1 fi PARAMETER: BWR - LPCI FLOW
- (
SPECIFIC CHECKLIST:
lij i
l
- 1. HOW MANY TRAINS OF RHR ARE AVAILABLE?
l
.m g%
r
.e :)
-. v j
- 2. HOW MANY RHR PUMPS PER TRAIN?
i
- i s
s
']
- 3. WHAT IS THE DESIGN CAPACITY OF EACH RHR PUMP 7 f
- 4. WHAT IS THE SHUTOFF HEAD OF THE RHR PUMPS?-
1
]
.?
4
..q 1
1
- 6. IS THE RER SYSTEM SHARED WITH ANOTHER UNIT?
t?
(
A.
. c.
IF So, DESCRIBE LINEUP?
t
. i i.
II:t
- }
- .]
y
!.b
< 6 hb
_4
'I
't 4
Q
.i e
'1.;
'f
':t d
LJ as A
b
- 1. 6g i
h d
'I 7
I
. )t '
i b
A z
't'
' ' " - * ^ - ^ - - ^ - ^ - ^ - ~ ' ^ ~ ^ ^ '
- _=_
_ _ = _ > _ _
- .,_-~
~-
= - - - - -... -, -
,f, O ' O S
$ 5 a d 5 N & g z Q j f % b w g; Q Q LLy g i g ; Q g ); & d Z i 3 ;; j Q c. 3 3,
h
)
g*
2 J
ATTACHMENT 3 i
OVERVIEW OF COMPUTER AND i
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM INFORMATION NEEDS d
l1 l1 13 op iJ it j
Computer Systems Related The computer systems related portions of the survey instrument focus on the following general areas of investigation:
1 Characterization of each utility computer system that is p,
a potential data feeder to ERDS:
its hardware and system sof tware environment its data communication technical details 14 1
Characterization of the potential siting locations for j
tlRC-provided hardware.
A Characterization of the documentation available that l'
ll describes the plant-specific details of the engineering II evolution of a parameter value (as it travels from a
] (s'j sensor through analog and digital logic and computer b
systems to a reactor operator's eyes).
J Telephony Related i
i The telephony-related portions of the survey instrument focus H
on the following general areas of investigation:
1 j
Characterization of potential site-related engineering ri dif ficulties associated with the utility providing a l.j dial-up phone line accessible to, and suitably configured
'./,
for, the NRC provided ERDS computer hardware.
y 9
Characterization of potential operating procedures for d
utility personnel creating and maintaining the dial-up j
phone connection between the site and NRC headquarters.
a 54 UIu
- 1
]
i
- )
.1 Iil C\\
Ji
\\,p i;
s I
E 7
O._.--=-_.,,-,--,
- r-au
,mm
. :m =u=w r.==_~
=w 2
muMuLGL: hia6s': LAY:.445.:0 5 L aki$1;.1 lNb k t M Y$ $. a t :.u e : $ a A A 0:-. mL.
u.
.a.<-u..
- A.a:EJ f/t17.S
- t. e. S e, // e JR/ g e
i 1
1 I
/*s e m e v e J e e-A **3 #s e%
,13/
$ 4e +
1 s.o / Me 4 e e / e/ e o. /
i w :-a. sp..s. - sp a. : r :.
,* a n.+
~ y v.. + ~.
<r.
s, e. : < :.
s
- r. -c.
3 y..-:.
wi- + o; -.,si. -. c a. :.
<s.
er i:, s
+ e r
}.;
Us u m tly
+Ae sam e e,s se s
Oem61-e ur }
w= 1 &,.sf9*A.
\\
u n..
a f.;
lll A ll p er a m e + * *s gne e asn e n e e e#
16' 3SA
~
288 is f* e r. -
ss:
- -.+
fac
~~
1]
~03 g 3 #/
c. w e n e st-
&y,f 3 X gi; e 1 aJ e sy e e i !! e.
i e A
I
! ))
I b
J e
4 t,) n e M /e s d e le C m e. 4 s et fee Cm Km w my I
cr o y
/* +es+
Csse)
Cye-pyva 4
q' N
[
4 e.S f
4 mm_______.____..__-._
~
ay
.., g,
.. c.,.h.diEEldt b'.,dds'Ish.a er n Jib,s..U ;,* Avir. A3.
.dal s a2.;
' e Sasc,
' idSVihk idsdi..'.did. Mi.k' rl.14 O.,Ari.&h.
.G
,./.a
'N l
c.
s.E
/ch
/. s S m // e f a e. e e ** s e=
.2*s ave
,s e c +.a e e m.v s o'I e 6 I e C e ~~ A*at so ?
e M e ~')* *'
Syno.
.R****
'j q
s i a.. e.a.
, $nd, 3.reses:~,
ca y
- e. o r Oe-ne++
f m = #f e~ ey s*/s - ~ i ~ y
(, e 3.R-e J e k e, r ep.,. ey, Pl eum. : y,
ssejm e.
fo,
}-
gga Oel A w ++ e e ri oM p.ry e
.nJuo/*e.e 3 e - w e' e w y ggy Ameep CveAe+
=
.}
ggg As*= y 7"h e n.) s * -
Co
,e.*
- e. -
4*+. #v*
=
~"
.J e e J s s Jr le
~U}
- j. g, s o./t e M e a = d o' e o.
Ye**y
- B /a. e 4== * *.
~
C e e 4 e e !! e. s 4g I *t /s o.
I.
=
W^eA a
, e$.,, J -.e - e = *.a.
e
)
, + /:.. :.?! e,.
e =.
r*.
N we
+.
r.u
<=
, r - e.s - + < : v e.
e..o a m-3
' *89 3
.a i
4
(.: :..
Po, eige 5 c e - p a +e
[ _s2
,rr.. y e x *)
y/
- r.. /.
s do.r
.a n.4.
v.u.e.4:.
- ypg,
)
.i freseef. Cenfasee
( /* i o,. e )
e.e
.e / 6 a o.4 o se
'A e.eA s : * *'.
oP2 4 e e, We
- se -4 N e e.E C e e fo e - m #
- j Enns 7 e e,a
,,,,,, e. 4,,e 9
g ;,,,,
'.j j
-)
f
,. e n :
+,
+ - e
.e v.
,P :.- e e..
lj i,j ey
/,.,+
..i e e a.
.a a
de e e s.:
an. 4 / c em n
,1
'1
[-i
{
- i i
,g i
3 I
l4 g
k.
l i1 IJ t'
i 4
4
~
/\\
1 V
i j
l t
i
(?
4 m m.?
_n_
-m.-
...-.-,a,
MS$4dbE' lli.id.iilLii$3c.aja.6fhN $unb.AiEbInbh)idL$hw2Jis.dkl.a.
a
.s q
3
'li 1
i f et i s o -
Asoio en :,
I b
72 W
Adses il a
j g *
P'/ o e See C / s- +
3+.
ee+*s= a w-t sj
- ]
oe. a
+.
Lasa s e e re -
s - ; a es
'(
- j III
.n..-
9.-
~
f_il.
a 1
EE
?
!!i M;
-n.,.a.-
- c.,.a -- c..,.
Q
.*/
c.of
- o*
of A **
- f ** */* /**
/
es.
?
t
.i.
.B i
.i
( 8 / ~V )
v s e - r n P
-c.,
i 8
1 re e i,
1 i
j C YA
+w
-4..y l
'l i
)
Adsms oe Desehenne Me eaI+
1 i
.a
$$ Y
.1, 9
I
}
/ *4 / I y
o4 ** 0 k m 6 **
h ff$3y$$7CC
=
Y l~
j d
is/I -r
- = ' ' " -
- c c d~c v t ***8Y 1
.a f
Il l
l?
$ 5 ** *'e $ m o 9 *=w
$ f/ C f f O SO M O j
A
-T.' y 4
+e 3
/~fs-Ar G..a ao-se et
.c'e.-
su l,
I
'i i
Y
{$ $@
s
-i l
3
?
.i
- )
v.
u.c. ~.. n -
..c
.,, s.
. d221W2;*N.: w:, ~.i. lin.%'25' %,ih' i'a LOsaOM.!.BYamasi.sk.de.&i!$5%Oh.akestML h'ses ek 'as.h Was se.%..nes.*.
. % e X 1 s:\\ 5.se. son-bs'.4 e'--.ab O Zu kllU o
l i
f/9 0 5 os/saf80*
t a
t
.}
]
J-=#ey Duc ose A:
Com B ap-(8ts)typ.gssp
'j gJ
')
A //
ae-pa+e#p e e k k vas+ 7 e.s e, ?en p,
i l}
- fffee, sty 1.,
,1 2"
w i It' se&
$y,,+;,,,
n
- s E.EE Ce-.
y ca..
c o, p., y
'j ggg i
/h z...,
5e/'
..t ng YOY OV$@
YY NN
)1
/~re.- - ' s &
3 /t.
g c +*.S~ O 1
dl a
,o..o-e
. e...e-.
~
I
+ o a.+.,
O-s, y) ye e--
com e
+e e.r c s' e e,
.y si+e p e ep te e
n e,
.-s t y p -o
.e :, f e e
S o-ss Sp e e o ~.' s e NGL 9
e.ar e w e l e n=
a
.s + o. # e
- a.., &.
/J s'9 C i
- i j.]
4 1
J C 0.os
~Z" ye+
C emy w+e-C e *e + m e. ~9=
0 Y*
f * / /*
f*e
?
f * *"
My C e **1/O * * *
- f 0* *' G o "
.a=
n ii$
i.l
- j u
-6 i
'i
~
k,, h'_ *;
,i 4
~
- - l
]
a 1.L d199'81 a
_AE2.
- _m._
J._h.J.'.'e.eg_j;__
_Jg._________3.__,
pp,,
_g m hyr g
.,myJ1 J.a
'F.
- b [dkb.h.S$1dNidabSh.;;d$25b !ibd!'d$dLD});dd:M[.dYalIlksau$ladEa.".ics.. r.n, _Am'J4Sbi i jg,//y 3
j 1
l 1
J 4
eed
/3 ) a e Ac h v en e
.r O A! S 4,,
1 1
]
A,g wee
.,s. 3, a. +-
5MO$
s-! s so ~ e 3
& e. 4 m.
cm s 3 /I,
/U 04.
.a't3
,l k
El A g r e e m * * *'
"'/Jepp / * ~
,*),,,s.
M a.
M.23R; e.s e
- y *.e YeaA rep bb e m e n y ~e a y Cen+9.
???
}o
.3 1.
E'm e rf e ~ a >#
Lu 282..
3 s:l'.2. *.
Q
/ /e e, s e eo-a;ete-ee~o^l~f
- m-s 0
- z- //.
d*-,
e 7
ce
- e-
)
g g e - e e.,
(l afvvi~y e >. e e c
- 3
- e o,
5 de J e 5 m t/ e ex ese Ee e m.
L" h e is y
- I ~,f
]
J d 'o l a
' I
[.
S ts8
[e g
@M
't i
's i
4 1
4 0
i QS,f
$e e he M Q 99 f f0 C I'
Am mgA O /W /'t i =4' fee
/E"/T C 3
,/1 s.o i t h J.m. Se: tr e-5 e.P," s.o e -*
- ,g-q 4 o' fi s s* A n' l a L/ e
'i
'q Com Ed -
ls 6/903 as-e oa wf e om-s 4
5 ff
}Ll O /a
.. n 3
1 4
5
'I g
h QA
.:)
l1 h-
'I 98 A
. _. _. - _ -. _.. - -