ML20138H854

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Intervenor Exhibit I-CCANP-74,consisting of 810318 Handwritten Notes for Briefing Applicant Re Brown & Root Engineering Design Approach.Concern Over Analytical Inconsistencies Expressed
ML20138H854
Person / Time
Site: South Texas  STP Nuclear Operating Company icon.png
Issue date: 07/12/1985
From:
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
References
OL-I-CCANP-074, OL-I-CCANP-74, NUDOCS 8510290164
Download: ML20138H854 (6)


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:' ' H *~,j'.

               $-Y9[                       99 0 L-                                                                             ,

1 - c e n # 7 1 ,., a (Qff(S Ch:c "h" M M5dil0M Std L4TDRt'. IA) 76-7f PERioO SEEuf REIfodJtt/r 7D hL@#6EDJ StA. wor /L 10 7 6-80 PGiop MEMr IA1Vtt86tE IM TETidi M EEIog.f B+f. WBtt'.14 L4Wdo-g; 15 Moff F.Erfatfryg . G . STitoas, eve 0Euc10F HoS7sts h TTnvoc Tbwha Hl N-P.' p  :.,_ - 15kOED 5603 O TCDs AWE (6/GTWw/ ACEDUATE. JM5160 h/f/W ol

                       @               l5 utohu1 Cco0. SteqFst VETw.5 i SfettFic CRITErlik AttE OFTul koESitMhME oll. NAsvi. (TEMP, 90 ADouev T+It.aM1, eTr.).

VEE.1 'LtTTts siiosuCE OF A. Ives-TJfouerrr our IMits FvE bertaa.

                                                                           ~
                               .      . MuG+ eF PLhut Il SMeD on eas's Joosenv1 (.UMDoCUMEUt@ AT M47).

PUE Tb GoutstvA7eJ44 Al'Mo4ch ACTUAL Vo DGils4DG5t6dp,wuots MAY IhE AMDd4TC,

                                                                  -Atavco                   WWEVEf_l Bil Alucutt ha'itd. -

satte are Attv1w C60stsTuscf la jVs+tEVnos STAmD'CAtTGih. % ^0 0 c.v e idri ra k uu sur iS 60E51andh-blC, hsO MktMtheDo% Coast 3fa)cy o' tief. TIMS,IL UAlLIkSLf,- F0'J.ca-Thitco64 AT ptSCIPLsME INiV/coifd71UNVi%CC1 NOA-Ett)TW,rT.

                                                                ~
                                        ~lQ?l' FAOdf 'ENO DOOJMalff (~Edikky04L., EmitR. AU4Lffgs,cutBS,5/lcias 19cm Af.S .4U$T $l0nd BEIdL fCEyh8&D. (4yGtG tS MGMT yMayIdG ?
              -                          How Coov0 'nbs 66 TbLER.hTED TeR. So 4.cacl tal+<n2.c wh$ i+L+P?

P,+L lyTEllukt. Tilgl6 G.45 To eyeon rt 4 tot 2K. IL AIT Fouc7,aarac.

                                     . C.cuiiOE7MLC EV'DEMcc oF GAcTIC uwlt. SttvAT,od. . EE3%uSG TO 4577mf oCChtssaM&l bo Mo*f ADDILCS HL&P ISSUG, TIMGLtdC$$ h tuL Ik$ LEA.

fu Aro leTEtuM. TilxxtW4 51517M-

     ,        /} g                     E%TREMEc/ ext 0 kTTMDOC oO D6516f MEEIr #itC EEQ'N'7'f " 14 tThedT' Ant /

b ,Vf EWitEUCC OF 0985 MIND Tblay.b luHM . &L+P NEint,4f.PGTIA HRC (UTwf, STr.ou6 TEMD6UE.1 To SH-lfT l2EI/b0S: Sit.11y 840:. Tb HL+f. . GV1060C6 THhi 90cVtat093 hl5EDED to TH6 D5Isa Vk'l BG' hoS011* -- .:

L h ot o F. C o ccetta b d E1L TM U LSSUC. OPGCh7*oaAL Uau s TE31'vG MF
                                        % l . PtatsH sfbT. No caricct.Al taec1Hst REqu?rpott ptpatwx << /LAMM
g cw8 h ES/IEW 0F- Val 0ct. 308MITIMJ (Pt45,CAtcp JoMEDMEI t/EEi 6eoD, Soucriun k vo evipeuCs 1>at B+g. insTeac.tf veuvor. oo 0474 uczven ^#ro SVSMiTTAL Folt.Mk7. LEkOS 7b tlo30sl RE-IdEMITTMI. IJo 6utphocr ca) .

2 WHGE AMAtSi} lt fgEFETdED CC Why1( 7E3TsaM (1 PitEft1ttlfP.

   *O        ..        .
   $3' (UTEgaM Docvuorf REvt00 Csun6Wf3 [?.ASEl-f AUSIEVE tie 1LY GeoD Rk7 tag.

8h )' g<.'f,. 6 PT O ) SU pet.FtL'k L . DGS VE9JIT 12EVIGN CoMM$rf) USUhlLY Ikih06%7Es _ Ksy psi. VcDr. Goa'37ous NoT 8.ewL sonateD4A& Mrua/7.m S,, 7.Vkt.tD , t$ 19Po1 EEMo064tfj (3 ouTM IZrAgoogts), . ., D e Sts a R.EVIE W DoFJ UOT CoM51tivTE De5. VG.If.,5 ST&sd6 B+l lu1EicSt Q' l-Wf,f) . . ..l- IM Pilatetvial latTH FilELIHlaAh{ DkTh f.lbitT 09 Th Tve. LeMuac Tome

  • u
                                                                                                           .            .."       'c
g. ,
    ,, f ., Q                       . , VULTU& No' hWAL1 tis CM'MiOrt. F.lus Dercupace, eos cutbipact,"* *. '

Qffo __

                                     ' pot MucM UViDevCC of ConccM Rat eJnhol, 6fQ. (Auh M<fc HisH epl3-EMc sovrn wouu ruds #M* Wrru CMwo Cuats.'   ._              . - .                           -       -
   +,o 2 .,-     M   -

4_' - " A , - , - - - i 1 i l / l p/ / l ['*','#[,# ' s4

                                                                      /                             .
                                                      /Y                                      s-e s-
                                                                                              ,Oh
                                                              *\

l

 ^

t Y

                                                             .+/',,/

7 . ' p da / 4 Nb - - - - . . - ... - _ .

(oA

   .                                                                                                          y 3-11 11
              &JJET2ht. CMGlvktnaas (cm.mewo)

M+114 KETSi2DLS To 3TCa5 czauf, Sgtm. Sinct Osaf, Hv'+c, b TPssE "PuttAL5" NEED S[EtrM. kTTEVTrad.-(tH66 Elst. Map, , 5ff. Pt2ecrocu:ter 700 t.oo3c, pes.nor Fbucy is roce., cevc g CopitoLS Huca Too F(er:6ts. AuntA Doc 5c? s'ess To se wotr-/cc . tract + em0Ew1 CF Uawtu.ruc,Das 70 USE Entrica Ow1.usT1 'To A55026 coMftsin/cIl of DE5i6d f AW44-TJO j kWDTb DocuuevT 7H674 AA11d NO Re5ucts. STT-PC- ol6 Amth cwir rT (5-14-74) ettvrn. v.e:0, MoS De5 VESIF CYTY.LUf l& ThEiR. {9]s' AcheffG NEVOL VJCV Bf BM.14 TPOtt, LtTG. AAT I(J. Wtel'f ,.

                  "po7 tuvenfeu ter syco424 ?.r.
                                                                       -           ~~-~~~                            -

T~"

                 %U6 VCf.'t (Irf/4LC Af40 DQtCkTED FtbPLC lt'oulevsT2.,                    #
                                                                                                                *ThEt R.,                    .                 -

W tt.D u6 MEU Tm S7 kf (deTit Eff. V Sli todG ff A CoacrR>l.

                 '7V6y IJWQ 7b 6G $4Lt TD Opt 116C T1+t>vG3 Afovet) LJsnt TbThl SoNef f Frtan 8tf_ M647. Mucy cecend TN*7 7W/ Hay 6c vfa.)-
  • h3 StAfC-Govf5 by Sh2 P.Cer,
                                                                                                                                                                    ~~
                                                                                     ~
                                               ~

H-Lt-f MEED 3 Tb 'FoJTEL M ~4-TTITuDE 5F PBesevfiuc "/u

  • 6ffoc.Tuhlric5 "Tb SECURE 6f L .WrLUU60eSS Tb ACHIEV5 EE3UL71, . . . .

Fsuwt.-Oouutruc. nusT 8,E SToFecD; TGm-uett Mus7 cc Pr?Ac1tcso.

  • WEf (265fodSt61V1') Fof f6%fcRMAd(6 6M SfA. (M&llt ML+P =:- - =
                                                                           ~

Ecttt.5 In-Hww cMhsruT1. FRovioc varr.auTy i Mcomonoa Io~t- .. ' - '

                                                                                                                                                   -~~~~.'

BtA ccuttasurious == fcssist'f Eveu r Mici,g.'t'ncas1ivi-i.-' NAEG So?S TH+7 Destbd tc roup sooo. . _. a Ibt9. M'4T. TRcF+JITy TttaA/O ML+f Itiovi 0 57DP Alo*0 . .

                                                                                                                                              ~              '              ~

g 591.TEMI LEVEL funcAfod hut.71-DIKiruh1 Ffrttc) 45htf[. D56 JZouTsu6 ef Docuusurf F~ec. gsv:eV 7b . Do "TI-NJ, . .. ., .',* ';_. _ _ . ; - ND 5'{rJ ElLGlif f(. ET1er_t , Does #or Pilosorr 9tIcyuvr-n-D1Jctfuur toupotlickTaoA). . .. . ... -.y- ..- .

                                             ~         ..          ..   ......~...                                        .. .:..                       .

SoHC VIFficuk 'tQ LockTtML BMX VP turetMarced. II evaporT*

           } .           . ..   .--                     . . . . . . - .           . . . . . . . .          ..           . . .          ..           . ...
           &        WOT YLETIUG ($ 41:tv L'EV %QUtADieVTJ'UUUVf EIMc19 Sy.ft.n*, JIo //triknef.

j Y M48/f Bhl f&oY'r f lhCW pl. deed. - . - . 16Cl7ND hY/td

                                                                               - - -           . - .         .. J elnr E a PucN5
                                                                                                                                                     ~ 
            &       Af o M x1wm $mfia)%zt penWrmt. MPts/ t/ Gift *71

(oA

 /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ~

NTiT12 su19E'u TD RE5faaf 7b G4T710tf It*Ut Hs. GGMfMkm/ Mf. 4W l' 4E0 V Ett0~. > { **0 M I1*7i M $7W 0-+

  • M . .* . . . .. .. . . . .
                                   %                                                                                                           I2*dD                                                                                                   ,

K A TTW. f St ilAld OBI M kO A O I N b d 3 .- MILLM t.dtGt.'9-21-8o OU GfwcupCols1 6A pec n6ntN .61 Ht.+P. .. . Scisu ,1.iut part. umt V-fo -, star

       @               M 27              JALVC % #0L kTsAf WD Sv               nti }bMiro o.nserc GstrP7' 47NGE.17%I RJ U*MtW Q              M-2C                              a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ~~

I EKc5 SElfv tsW1. D fed ft407 90s.TED %NI/8WI Abf'(sOSM5B N-24 M.3a tre enDevcc of 84.crh.M taev en suT't. cwcuwt d'DurfW ~' T' "'~~ : n '~

                                                       .                                                                      ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                      " " -~ ' . ~ ~ '

(p M *Euco A 'GH.c.44 .faeT. Zdeuctsrs 7pf..- Pave? - . T .

                                                                                                                    .                                                      - .                                                                                                           ~       ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ./   .l.

Me4 Sts Tnb *A 9tded j 6I foadwu] av M44 _kM hw~ ,,... . . .. ..... L.. . ; ;,.

                                                                                                                                                                   /

Q st.% ,

                                                                                                                                                                      .          .1_                          -

(p M. -y) No twG%i F4. Cusst istut_ t.sc Seert.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ~~                                     '                    *~

R)

  • M.'efo R.MCT WWOWL hsI4visti RuoA{ sif ef/V w $QnQGD~~ ~ ,
                                       ~osee W NA<4 curoQ t.hs red Bsp sfAL.6 hetuuuvi-/c AMkpupM
                                                                             ~
      @ ' 'p.4                                                                                   .
                                            ~                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ,
- @ 3.~4V ~ Mo Pr.esf'of Wrt# sfn488tTry 6nt. ft# ps//zw a4t#<rmei.- . .

g-Iz. W.Vr Fwoule. int - cuit '*ws- . . 4 ' * ~ '~ f'~ :' ~ ~ * ^~ ~ ~ Q H-Co ~ It ScTTWsf (ful 604.')M41 fnottu{ OsacM4t.ttd .

                                                                                                                                                                               -                         .               y , '.

v . ~ do EMt! ynA. tti PM*n' cskeosiest) ~Tani.'.Poup~'GST.r-c.ase esLA

6 51' .- -

U2 " hEAb6d btE*8 3*/'. IAYI) E I',~1E55 ~CCE 8b"q. 4 . .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .~                           ..
                                   . Min 6%. fooC M6 Swd Mhs-1; 2. tw.wn da ; p. pwuJ 9, An vand * .

1 Q C- -

                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ,. , , T 1 ,. . .

Veg.tica Accet. IsarnitrD #4 f% 41JC / * ,,

      @ c
                                                                                                                                                                                   .-                   --     '~'....~I.,.,.
      @ c.a .
                     - .           . HoltiattM. ' . . iW.r.in m.l RC6. AeAlvo' c m m m ,e.                                           .'-                                           .

J ,., rusa. 4eostuwf foR. Anos covet (structum 'MMts , gg . . . . . ._ _ . . . . .. ..

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        . ...~:.             ..

W 4U. LaMw'6 cMncss1 wchar stut soM to usert. ocz/ oM . . , . . .

      @ C.tf              -

s . _ .. i sth C-lb CAblt TFA1' T$0 11tArotr> v9 bestus 6cfal.r tsurrotaen! .. .... .

                             * * ~ ~                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,.,.-                       ..        . . .

G'c;29 . swckwtc ' A&&r .. .. *v&illhaicdcos Gsi .. .. . *cias M"..setude kmt....._. a . . .. . . v.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ..... ,. . n .;; ;

c.-St no ppatoast et cnitesh ts t.scrar cuunaevg. . ;;. . . . i_---- -_ __ _ _ _ - . _ _ - - - _ _ ' ' ' ' - * ' ' w-. ,m ._ , , _

Q i

            @ C,sf t, LonR! MWp, 5410 F95Ft.1T0 MCCPcul Pt+ni km* n' 'Ja '"* T')(w1E 4'1
           @ C-ys                       vu war saw ish <a es oc.                                                                                                    .                                                                                                      .

f Q g.-{ pu l+eLO PLMG} 00 @tt?& Off(ifM53 fe$. (Q( flYf Ch. [ CMC w C 76kf a1 0 *f ? Is r F ? ec _ .

          @ U-}                          vb us.1 of ucc Signes 10 u csastecM                                                                                                ..

Rid. IA) At Ckts-

          @ M~f                                                                                                                    _

M MSup % dbM40 WITtht, PCT Co@t%ar. . .. .. .. . . . . . . . . . .

          & U~$                                        nsa
                                           .W$ANUVfbN CO< TG#sh WbT* 1)nc. .' . . . , . . . .                                                                                                                         .            . , . . .                              .'..- -..
h. 0 ..
         $ N-l)                            L'D95( CMC fat. E(.5 nsdr lacA..+- I san r.o.d.
                                                                                                                                                               .. sNurbrd. . i . ... . .. . -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           '~
                                            % 4M %ITLtK C4f%u.stf ad &_.M.                                                                                   . . . . _ . .                                                          ._. . .                            . , _ .                                          .

Y. -I_9 . Fio .M." Atw m713 swiS t.c4o roi. M14 N~21 kib DY U M il. ftd h d hsf N p u $ , Us PL4?.h (IfG. Luff Uffp.

        @ k-l                                                                                                                                            .
                                                                                                                         ._...../..                                                                    . . . .

bb d D UI k , ,

                                                                                                                                                                                                            . -                 .. ..                              . . . L -. -
                  .H                        SPlethruG Otc.'s                                                                                    -

Ft.VDhas'sF 994, QGttWC M. ._ D [L'1*) .

         @,        11-2 o                       PGK }EM.0d 719 7-0 7f #3 TNT IMud,                                                                                                                                    ,                .
                                                % Covainet, llesn Sotsti;ltidL cmc by bbf V Md. . .'                                                                                                                 .
        @ RAI                            ,
                                                                     .          . .                                         +                                                                                 ".'=                  .,,                                                          .*            ,
                                                                                                                  , . . , ,                     ,     .:;. , -s.                                  .                       .                                       ,
                                                                             . ..              .......-.....w.;..                                           _                                           ....:... . . . . . . . .                                  -
                                                                                                                                                                               ....                                      .               .         ,                ,.             . 3-                      .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ~

l

                                                                                                    .            .-                ' .....:; . u ..

v

                                                                                                                                                                               . . . . . r~
                                                                    ~

1 4 limi 6VIQg4Kt' c}6 UW Of Off3U715, GTC TO AS$Utf Cauft/161Cf l Grs$st;&GS

          '10'kucf TD Lm nr s!CC ef M1C6 - 3IVtn.Sutts Ltlid habenM' cadet /7o Vet / bit & LMTAM of 41tSt,toS, lietot15Fv17A47, ETC.

Juind4t. Sce a swS /d 26ff*Mf')D NSutREMenTT (or!AG acef

             'ittAfs al potub likout66 M7tsd IMt (ItNwsc .qtzstJ) iAfTil Cov4Ts utit IIEt0S of USl1/ of HJF*2h+ Dad *G PMs TW UMts H9 S/Wf twunhitti- TbtStN6 ftTlauftort t21 BJfla)Mitf Regr NRc 12fD%f.f - 20 W7thrsf IAI Tys]Cas ef-liff Mt2%.                               .

CVGfM46 Il Gd CosimitMit' nptf (tektfMcted ycAtz: Stwt,)- , ucw stuc, wasn<-v we no nwt VMtw1 (L1 */ti CEVfITWf WkLf 14 AfDi4 t/MCC4 Muff IAl Pt/als t!P ax7 kmat (ctseat boe;, p.V )%ceyG) , Dc VEAlf LutS kH4Mt. - 00TMlan/u1M TM6 bV IUTYv7 ND MemD)fCI 0/6f 71fttVtit-G~tfiM DfW/AfD, 1

     .          He .57p inct.tkr%d of warfaert Gws wit., terr 1D ptr4 Autos EMIS cFTW Attird6 % Sittine DG'It<.I1t'4926 SoMl'pitftcAtf jgt t4c4ts5 S4tt4 tityctstwed.                                 -

I(,S* f T 4 C.aucact Tkul 1%. cwn. (2rk'f 7) hSIf Mtft Tu cHtatt 1911 m f, , G;kt I) 15b PSI, GCDI l.S I20 $5l j Reag @ftNm ? EI6i 9[66 es % VO St>tMet) fot IWAT S$7Dl4 Owd fI t$1f (fGATs4I k.9 9 a o m e n " r c m e r n o ta n t o. veer? ~

                                                                                                    ~

SHttNin 15 Mod-544W} i4 Wit $

        ~                                                                                                    s lhG 0f MG 0F NkTL9L4!( Q' lim 17Pf- 2 /MM Twit / /lb;(f n e'Achtwa t g             f a        5 9 9}}