ML20138G631

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Final Rept of Investigation on Counterfeit safety- Related Pipe Hanger.Portion of Pipe Hanger Fabricated from Scrap Matl After Original Bottom Piece Removed Due to Improper Welding.Related Info Encl
ML20138G631
Person / Time
Site: Wolf Creek Wolf Creek Nuclear Operating Corporation icon.png
Issue date: 05/23/1983
From: Hayes B
NRC OFFICE OF INVESTIGATIONS (OI)
To: Jay Collins
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
Shared Package
ML20138G131 List:
References
FOIA-84-291 NUDOCS 8512160364
Download: ML20138G631 (42)


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:v g %v

   .#          N                            Uh!!1 E D ST AT E S lg,f(,                         NUCLE AR REGUL ATORY COMMISSION W ASHP4GVOr., O C. 200i'
 ; ,, (g.f , j c, y.24f c
   %, ' - *' j                                 May 23, 1933                                          .

PEMORANDUM FOR: John T. Collins, Regional Administrator Region IV FROM: Ben B. Hayes, Director ffice of Investigations

SUBJECT:

WOLF CREEK NGS - COUNTERFEIT SAFETY-RELATED PIPE HANGER Enclosed is the Office of Investigations' final report of investigation on this subject. Our investigation substantiated an alleger's assertions that*a portion of a safety-related pipe hanger was fabricated from scrap material after the original bottom piece had been removed after having been found to have been improperly welded. The investigation further established that heat and hanger numbers were added to the nonquality piece in order to correspond with appropriate quality assurance documentation. The latter had the effect of deceiving the licensees' QC inspectors who relied on these numbers as well as the apparent quality of the welds in signing off on the counterfeit pipe hanger. Although the identity of the persons creating the counterfeit were easily ascertained (the alleger being one of them), we were not able to corroborate the alleger's claims that he was directed to counterfeit the hanger by his foreman. The investigation did not uncover knowledge of the oogus hanger by any licensee managers or supervisors. Essentially, the allegations of supervisory involvement is a stalemate, with the alleger's accusation balanced by the foreman's denial. 01 notes that the foreman had both the opportunity and motive (productivity being one neasure of his job performance) whereas a craft worker would not normally be concerned with productivity, per se. Further, the circumstances described by the alleger lend credibility to his story, and, on balance, the investigators v.ere unconvinced by the foreman's denials. Nonetheless, 01 dets not feel that the foregoing is sufficient to establish by preper.dcrar,ce of cvidence - supervisory involvement in this matter. It is also our view that additional investigative effort is not warranted given the fact that this appears t'o be an isolated incident. The nature of the case does not justify the use of a polygraph, and edciticntl interviews are unlikely to provide substantive information. Thus, cbsent cny new - information being brought to our attention, we consider this ir,estigation. closed. This report and transmittal memorandum may not be disseninated c.utside the NRC wit 1out the permission of the Director. 01. Internal disswination and access should be on a "nced and right to know" basis, cc: W. J. Dircks E00 R. K. Herr, 01:RIV 0512160364 051107 PDH FOIA DHOGIUf304-7/1 PDH r

                                                                                              ~

() , i o

                    ..a              . ,           . . - -           .        _ . - .                      ._    ..          ..-         . ._ . -                     .                          -.     .

FA' I *e 49 7. US % CLLAr , L C t.*L A T ? ; ~ , INVESTICATIO.*J ST ATUS RECORD l - INT.T Mt-( * .." ! . I t N *- i to t o reme'ett a ** > . .e

  • a , f .ar t 3; .
  • v F's mue-j re'.t he ? : :ese cr at '*.st s.- 2 caos if a c*ra y Pas cus" . +
                          *s' f a , 's.e*t 9 3 J e'>od        r
  • a te ' *. ' C* rp a tea ste: .s Veca *.s e; t*4 o' s
  • e e t** t*e u *
  • e 4 J .cid cae cony to *%e. 4.Nes CMC 1 Of SPte51941065

! h. *el

  • CA?(GCav C# #i:t '

0 C*taat,%G mgACfon '

  • 1%3sv>0uat Lict%st t
          '-82-31E                                 x       c ggagg&ia                          _

o 4.ven, Aa rm CIF0 RIV , v . va%:'ca m .of-en j i m.cs a ro w . DUPLICATION 0F SAFETY-RELATED HANGER BY t GRIFFIN DAIEL INTEPNATTTML PERSO'1NEL / '10LF . CREEK , i $T4iUS.ae..'s *are 4*dare..o*eeretcerreroa- j l On No, ember 1, 1982,0lF0, :IIV, c;en this investigation based cc a contact with a witr.es j during investigation 4-32-003, on October 27, 1982 that resulted in his providing an allegation that he was ordered to duplicate a portion of a safety-related pipe hanger in

March 1981. The alleger stated his foreman instructed him to cut a piece of scrap metal and put ID and heat numbers on it in order that it could be welded into a hanger.

Statement obtained from alleger 10-29-82. DATE: November 30, 1982 - Investigation in progress . 1 J i

)

i 1 OATE: December 31, 1982 - Investigation 90'; complete. l 1 DATE: January 31,190 'll investigative work completed. Report is .. i presently being itten. J DATE: February 28,1: . - his investigation is being typed in it's final drs' .' Field office rc.fi should be completed in l' arch 1983 and fomarded to O!:U~l q for final revie... 1

)

1 j CATE: March 31,19F 't investigation miled to O!:0F0 for final review in the j 1st week of A,e 1 ' i . . . . . . . I J !: April 29, 1: .

investigation in 0:::F0 for review, - .. . ,

1 WI: Pay 31, 190 - inves t 4 <'i t Mn i'i ^ * :DF0 for review. f/ e

__ , .. _ -. - _ . - - - . _ - _ _ _ - _ .. - _ = - _ - . - .

   ; % Fcph 205                                                                                                                                  t' s *. C L i e s h i             647 0 % CL INVESTIG ATION STATUS RECORD U K JeilC'.5 T' s be- t 'o t s ec*r Wd a * * ** 5
  • aat a . tv Ns occu~n2 e et .e to a cve or et least eve v 3C cess
  • ao t s r s* ect ."ec ds e s -

l JJ av, r e s.m ; gee af ' :! w -Da. .* tre n at s P cc. **6 c ; av

  • tm t'e ca e toe a-d se-e :-= *:r . r.. s C" ce et e est.pt o s .

l e e waatt e CATE C4v CF 8'CE I, O . cag p 4 ?.*.3 set ActQe 4 - 8%D'b'CJ AL L'Cl %5t t

             , , ,                    T        c a e:= .pns ce'sst
<a ...,t...<,eut 0I FIELD 0:F1CE i s-32-01e- -

o, i n,,

                                                                                                                                           *U

A* j w . S t % :.s a .0!=td ' 'l i Ass.mo to se u ct DUPLICATI0tt 0F SAFETY-RELATED HANGER BY

,           GRIFFIfi                                                                               n a n i. n
                                                                                                   - - -         t. eT e rv ar t n_ e. n'- ornem *'n-- / t w r. r.p r e v
                                                                     $1 ATUS *$.ech care, ona pro.*?e a Dr.e* cescrocrent 1

OATE: June 30,1983 - This investigation was closed on May 23 I?52, hec.iever,

                                                                                                                                                                                                         ~

closing dccuments were not received by 01F0:RIV until June 1,1983, i i l i l i i l 1 I l 4 4 t I 6 i e l 1 l 1 a == = 1

            /

i l i l I

.                                                                                                                                                                                                                         t

OFFICIAL USE ONLY

                                          . 4ASE CHRONOLOGY FILE muassim                                  DATE OPshC3                                              CPEN . SY 9*-92~0/$                                 AL't' W 2-                                           _ E4 A-01TE                                                       ACTtvlTY A,w/14n/,s,iv&/s,s.aen                                                              de&,.
                                                                                                                                                        ~ ~

4., s y . e

                                                                                                               ~.             ._.=

c aC fivit t CC0ts L/u e Lt??ta on utWO tt e ?titP cat CALL eks* e insett?iCN MTG e esE flNG spy e skytst:taten st P a stPost sgsuCD 00 NOT DitCLOSE VFFICIAL USE ONLY -- roen a:: tie n.  !

jb ,., ., j, . , .~ I.

                       , ced 3'l      G.CCh~I(A Pkd h)cUQ Ccd.1960 %

i 92 5 2-

                       *l5Al E=G-56 f%I.

VAd4 v6s w/o eM' T &

                     & -u d . .< m u r <uys . GL d               ,ra- / 4 f 24     -        W,jswhf                w      sk 5 d
                                                   'P S'208. w y/-7.f.Y
                     $n,$             L     e%(WL~Ad$md csAd,             <w At 74&A-10% 'ench m                              vach
                   . c~p     .. lvfu~, .D A ') ;&% 4 4          e --p d       I l.vc/        ~                                           .
                   % ga                   & Nc6 . %. g =
                  ! lS N 2'to S P k)           -

ude/e cl' we.ld documf v s ., e!okeut sfed

                                                          /

n 4 n . W .s, m .,_p.>. 4:. M - - . t

                                                                          ~
   *
  • e
                                          /
                                          /MAro                   g ._.dr,            ?.2     -
                                     '.{)a~ul' /%d ?9,/hC?

(%L gy 2. . , q'n,. , {w p?,L% g% _ '__ ) . .

                                           %                    L a ~x &                                 : / z e d .. a

( 9 fcm.L & . p.c)t) - - h 'i tr #p*

                                                    &.                        lb~             .?c'                    Lg                                            20.
                                        .lAM .zcy,                                                ya              m a~%i
                                          ,de. p p
                                 .                                                  w.e-                            .

N~ r & .a yf,. a. m s:?a,f[a' c

                                                                                           .          .{.s
                                                                                                                                                                             .Ti a.

dhhlf7c$ ^ Wf#*

c. .

9' *. a9* 6 g g t- .= 1m A ~ . i __ ~

                                                                                                     '?

9 g e e o P W

                         ,?   's u- h    "
                                                       'W M v; t%

D+.d*b l bn% .40pu'p' ceca  %)weA

            -             2
                          .o g.
v < u- qc J, Si udb y l

ip ' n %ij~4 ~ fi Rc G b

                         'M J                        4
                                                                         ~

g,

                           . c% 4A                 a dMa p + r -.. A
                                                                                                           , r n tM
                  ~

l #s , a-c/ . 7= . - I d 10 M. . l 8weqe J e p-;2Co .

                                                                                 #           g O

O I

                                                                                                               ..-)   -     .
                                       -,,uo                                       4                    -2 w     - -                        g        w       .s-ma we    .m,.,_. , 4     --
                  &         a    .6
    ,e                        e*
  .                                                                                                                                                                                           i i

M$

                           ;lct,s            a. = =        is u Mh xocc - .-                                                                                                                                 -
                     .      20 4 FC Us
                &&d(Ai
                              '               uJt                                  J/um
                                                -wdf n          i da I

f e i e

                                                                                                                                                                *w I

e l c t i i i ) a f

pf? n . .? . w .s:- &A' c .2 cs c .> l#& 4 y;&  ?.**= n.r i C2a 9 -S-3/ 4A /2 f # - J,J4.c d:. :.! Mi d, 2 < . nw _ r gAo> fc Alo 3 r; c i 7 . s /b d m l Alc R____.I SN '+? 72 PW

                                                                                                           ~M fv J
                                 ... d M m A(i d~G
                                                                                                                                                                    ~
                . . .          -     .s tor A & 4 red.cX                                           u Im - w.
        .               .                  .J- 1# p# S3'1 C /"Pv'.                                  .
                                                                                                         +
       ..             . . _ -          A .                                                                                                                 _
                                                                        ,Ab n                               aadsj.

J QA

                                     ' b0.%                          ..WN-. .p'%s .Kr &-                                                                                    ..

ia% yw. . A'c R ~ meL

                                                                                   - m +           ! ,4;           ymn~  .

pc R a

                                                                                                                                       -fL={ .

bFw h i ~ c

                                                                                                                                        ~
                                              $   r.       E v' , r ' .,
  • q e' d' s f
                                                                                        ~                                                                                  .

a.~. j., . , ,21.

                                             -f
                                                             ..                 r.

t

  • b
              . .. l L

4 :'c2. Ae,+ g,Q n

                            ..           !         c           e-                                                                              jv 1

I .

5 9 4 l i S e 9

                       - 1. s N            't Atu[
                          -    ', = '( $'u       bi e %
                                                     ')

L v. sd ' S &'s.s ta % .i cT eua - e C l-Q e'ft fc, o pd.xu[ s cuff _L M bx[ l5 ( ,,/

  • O [ W'44.(

{ Ch esg m.s[ ed3 c( p. c(0 NC Cutd wk l cei[ i u.v d \.uq d OCG h V Cf34' "k

              ~ ?> Y' \c                    u<ls d             . 14        Chc      %p                  dT         % e           wlc(

bc scuf -L ec. b 5 -. Tc we tegy3 as m r4 Lc Lid 1 t ww 4 9~d  % ewk we ,,, sJe9 -type My

                          >        waILy                   uo.d    tc ck c u [         f t 6 u u cc.s,
                          >        T         ~~xa              e , cdL9       gwe c, a n                  se    e   gasta .d     .y I

M $di 4 f1V.w.cc_s ek$ko' Cf artve ed dec. T 'd- we, #

  )

l i j (d $PET 1 c,k i L6 L< s ([, 4 f , /_ . . , !c h'w E VJ S " 5+cu4n S t , s. .h @

                           ~

1 h h E

                                                                                      *4          4                      3 4

p urs a. , c. E'ca-. a > '.- ei t0 g cE [*< af -ti . v.s l'(<cal.rs$

                >      dcu' 6       4.d  .           v ed             ,.c -

i i wdCt; d ck'd .I c 6.e ( 7 .

                 >   n e-     mci .uf           dr.v d .

f

                                                     -e W                                               19?&.r4                                  ~~
                                                                                                                ~
                        >   'W             w                                      nstocd G 4 i d40+ % k.if o                                                                                                  _
                  "N5dk>      v. k3 ce d uc.t i.                  4,. %

scya% ; s%. b - M k d:d u1.>

                        >     I          d             b4_ clu e et               hu                cusd     cuss  c. a u g. a) f u#

ef M q%s A.udu.'9

                                                                                              ,wf            L. l9                H dse        diu<p3                                                                                      ,
                                                                                                    .S.

I f, bkd

                       >          f kt4               Suf .              Im N)N l-                          ki ku.2
                                                                                                     -/

0

       ,/ s n                 '-        d ud i u,th cc(%                                               *
                                        ),ca.sch                          W Urs     LjD pqu u.h s' ua LU,y bJs                         vit     -
                                                                                                         ~

(' t V * *. si.d det. 5 c. s 5

                        >      ,e            s.. . ; <       '>- uaun cL samq ce.v's vs       sf.        c'              %        "" heck                       gcetC87           ccush         <su lc,
                       ,                      -       m             -.1         c.x          -           s.       s, s e.c
                               ,,   uTi d                    ~

i c: t .. .. - s cc3 -R d ,.;_c1..%

                                                                                               ..                  'u t.(f.     .

f e

                                                 -~r     ,                                 ,,            .~-                 e--   <~     w-   ,     e
                                                                           '. 5
                      ~Tt.s < ' -
h. %2 . c '

C.'

                                                                                               ~

s \t i1. l 4 b N.Cck g L s -., *)..' C h 3g W. p Cri W '- e e u . , < ..,

                                       . % cc.

Q.. >. . . s (, w .<. m G p ._ p: 6 i e g..

                                                                                                                             .o    4      .m.      ;
                               >            w_    - , y>       'I       Cs.D*               e -< M ,                       dtd a.'4
                                             %s            Q s(M %
                               >                                     w lb                                                                ]J{

QC 69 h Sc tk pe c .

a. Wok poct Oth TwM bus a[ Wd
  • s 9 '- Yo ad o ue. -
         .                                                         W                                  moed up -
                                         >     cmW , p uk kr d -d :. %                                            wm S. pipe dc.                       d.y c m. u. _ -                                                                                                                                           7 zw..               .
w. sed %% ucctbd' a k a &. i y. -l c.)
                                                  +- s    t.x tr                   e c . ,. < c '. t                                   .

LC. -tc ,,u b sysk.t O( [.t J. s/ y e f, i ze.+

a. sYU .I,.,.
  • 0 (, .

lacdv _ , m t im. ate uu r u ,

                                   .T. . Q<g x s.. ~                         r.i- 4.b <~' \ QC &                                                       (
                                   ' p , <.k nc.<lm .                            L >w                   t=ta.cl.d2j                   'tfYcdk.*Q
                                        .kt w%
                         >     m , e c < <.                    i .(. .. c . . .- m e, eeq w .%                                                  t<f.

cts. sitw ksT. '.

                             >               c     YC       w'd '            <<          . h.,t,{ gg .

l t t i d

                     -.M   -
                                    --m   1
                                                                                     --             ,          e, m-    y .
                       ..,(

e

                      . ; ,e c.
                 . -, . , c'        -

c ,< )

                   .s . , f
               .kc.tk lNIG ., s..mlN..                                        p      /0<.G g5: 1h 1 ...                       ; . . . ..    .,m      ,
                                                           ,                     o                     .-
                  , , :.K - f,,
                                               ,.c o . <.

dem  ?, w ,. . .,..

              * & , M A - / l .- b $ a                                 -   y&f     a       ^ ~~-di ,                 i ' - G l .-~ .
i J., i' : . e , > , .:: d ..- A ~,.  % c . .;.... L .

i: _; ,; p'e c..: c-.< - ,j .;

                   - ; 2 y , u . , n n ..        .

4 ' i e $t .<dl-1d - O(Oa,lr wilN UN & J ~~ ' . l $A)m ($m .,fnnN # W. - .

                +'Vu/d4 /                                  J                 u,.=ddd.         b Atle
                      ,Ad                                   A dc             44                        yo o n,/~ .                    )%              J      W    ct.t-~1h J,            p <A4 4 l'

i n b N0 Nb

1. ,w ,,lc . L- .,.,- .. .- : 1
                                                                                                                   ~
                                                                                                                       -   .. ,n&

0n (Q (_

                                  ?     Sia r:   .
                                                         .                                  c Ae . . . . ~ --i-N* 5                                                     *
                                                                                        }-                                         . . . .         .

nAlLn

                         .G9     a:f w        4-.0          . p   p&.              . a. /s' . -
                                                                                       "Je(       _ .:...       .-

m 4*t;,. . 1 O% /~. p.~-6 . cry $: S.t & i % ejs.NI c'! c... .

                                                                                                                         - MJ J L              ;&a            >.a~ p . L! 4.                           .-                     .mu L                    Ld d fu 4 S;.                                                .
                                                                                                                         ..ed
                                        , 6L de>re & ws:: .. > m
                           %rka               i4..- m.

1 2 $ r3 ...- ~ ..;e.a.. .

  • 2LLG .
                              /

C. . . . a *

              . fLL.nl (@sth .- cqc 9 5as2 d A ce
                / f r2                    -
                                               +

k-% a A 1 A < s4 am,A ~wa 4 / w h > - Y p. g

          .h
             , p.                    %wb h
                                                                             - p."_

f-  % f-wm o m 4--

                &          Cec cw]& mb %s                                           '
   ,                                  a                        ~
                ++4I.CTMg                        & JA Q >A .A~"A'>             p x-
           !~

L K . .M~6 -

          ;CM'#l A                  J         cJd2 4L-6                          Ak ln J                         L      m-dgd.$qLit.       .

lQ . A A n s X4 / ,, o4f lv A-g d iM A & i e [ p &*- < v . A n ?'

                                                                           . Tt2e                     .
                                              & - f ;                          y=%.        _.

wa.m - a K. s

                                                                                                  .4e   e nd              J              ;t s    f                         D~                           - '

f% nx~,=, &py-,t A . c:  ;

                       ~         cce ~                         ,W&

J / & -d J J2 ~m(- 4 w ~4 - M 4 L <#c/c .

                                   .-a~n s ce c . :.:.;. ,r   Jt    p<                                         i
                -Jsf               :i(      wa                        s n'    &

el. . b~

        "'            wh n                 .~        La M2 dJ du ,. 4 .. d              J $Sk u. ~d-W i

GCf% M 7f r

                           @.         r'  :  . 2m vRoV                 -                          -
Q l d~d M:q A_~ _
                                                                        .w.

i I

     .     .            i.

G off f 4n 4 n. Arc a. e h%d . pS gfLAtt AwA ,?a Aab . m A - A

                       !A-                         A                               ~

N

                   ~
       .1                           -

q4 f ~ n~&- b a4 f % R j W

                                                                                        ~
                          -               cy,' a n s           d t-x ,a         .
                 .   .i     -                 .

A _ i )lh ' iA

                                             -/d .                                                            .

w ,9 &yo ,x

                      .           /-                    -

w xx w ae w."-s % a.- P h

e E . e 6

                                         \
                     , . . . ,      a            e
                                                          .., .cp' e.:               <nc-a          cn.y s.s ,_ c ,
             ;nb                                               -
                                                                    .odc M                                    pdo         rh
             ,4                       [@ M
                                      ,%            ( ] Qns) ,s.W 5ch T ' .- J                                                                          -

4- A , C - w Jr . m q SKZ M fLh' G?c a J

         -g ba d                                        ,
                                                                                   &,dit42Jf
                                                                                      ~ y                                    M 1e,-   &     , ..n e-Gn ' D.oe. . 't , / 9Q , 4 f.. . . . 9 CT'nC ,                               .        .
                                                                         * ,, . . , ,, y .< ,.r ~ , ~ ,. . d
                                         &'                      , J.              .                 IY,r&pm-
            %.f'$f                                                 A
                                                                                      ')

M H

           .L' A W ..    ,

A

                                                                             -(,
                                                                                               % ; U J,.sL...             '
                                                                                                                            -u ,... , ~.       ...

s i 8D . b #!,

              ~

l n b m%,M - d a l,,Y

  • sN f 5 A-s 4 q & L A ,*' W, .xtd c D:' N:'T/

4 ~M ~ e 9 9 9 n. m. r,

                                           ,'m
                                                                 ..... , /m.

uk b,, , pdf=% WnN . k. & l rY sy w d '

                                                               .. j'! .~               %s
                                                                                                                              &k
           ,. h s p ..:., a x . p z.- f J J '_
                 .                                                                                                          m;%
                .yp.] a J..:...J J g w h -                       .. .                                                    m-               e
              ,                        c-cc 4-It- 1ry *-

g 'ic, < k, c/ - pac <c i. Aw O.<. 6

              .               3- o      79                 l a ,. ,< - c A                      e                       yjw k AI.L?[
                                                            . W.< h.

3- lG %*2/ 3 fw .2%h liq' wj: c tor 2 .!g -ks 7; % .x n,c & Ju- t n+fax,4.mb d //g. owF o w F-3- / 7- A F/ Q q 3-1c i N 3 - /c - E t /Q- - e o wir

                                                        / d + yw "

j l . (d& A cL & p/)? -. I 3 .S -l 7 -F l ( . 2.cuGd aY yo & Ow" ' cc 6 3-/f-p/ gDM/ QM_ . l l 1

                                                ;                                                                                          ~
                                                     . ..s.-LJ
                                                     ~                       c,
                                                                                   . '. :-: .      -        ![ /A ,
                        \
                      . s = . -. = ' ~1                            -_. . . .                                                                           . ..

0 $ ! n a b .a . / ~ C'd //.1(

                                                                                                              /A

_y i (W & ' '). ' . l hllhl7 i

                                   <p.v % /ab                         d cL~,o             .4          c x d AI d.

O t g y b

Epew ch

              > - l6 - ? I       juc Ida' .y      xdtH d isn.cd ea W d si+Iw l35 IS~ct                        /s tu" f
               &               Fra n            gam     'b ~/G -11 7'o            Gm              3 -fF- PI.

( FieId ret ts:Y w re o coo. __ 3 Bl l^It [d in { ofe o 2 g ~ p et M .g s) Sfoud>

            'S-lT-2?/                                 wt (d/sp m ad ers'a.I h s u c c/ . ea         requ.'siNow (3 3 C 7W
                 &            -/-o w               Fr w        Gem , 3 -/&-2I yLocs 51.o- 31. C F?e(d b ay , % ra.u a8 3 !s - b-1       Co ,plefia .F                     vi,us/ 9e
                            // 5 p s fi.s (c. i      Ee!- S4e v/is .

J'! L lfsuc lt r } f et ;i' i

                                             .                            /

T .'-]l lAle(cl.r 54 & rewerf+J ly ' w e (c(e r T b?f9 ( $9&rb (ju, m..

w

                                                                                          ,s
                .            7,                                                                                                               .                        ,

W -*7' & 5 4 } la 2 6 h c /t.. d:En WM -*-7 M'n*M W'2. - b& w A~ : , ps& f 3-thxg.,8~ J n n s-'g- . . , , . , .

                     ,,l >f.*nd:. . 4, AG -zln.., f.. C.R,'f,1]."}.l                                               .
                                                                                                                                                                       ,',l                  __
                     .sf           ,f% G                   ., ' ' .          i.

c ,, . 44 <. - *. ,- . D S .& Au ,. M- g.y -oo y.

                    -ff(.J. 4',s .,.. ..,. Y.< ~ p 6.y' . .i g'                         -
                                                                                           .. ~. .. .
                                                     ? / , . / -;.,
                  . ear             -
                                                                                   . ... .                ..          ,,. ; Q s '                            ,
                                                                                                                                                                        , .a y            ,

Ayo Y D w 4 ,. ,_,y _,r """--'c '"

                                                                                                                                                                                '*M'" r=+
                         .cm           -e-   --+             -w                 ..- - -                      _ , . ,
 .        .                   g c. ..4w .. ,,,,5sE)
            , ; r cf li
                .         I 2- a                             /f3 '

v 3l,

                  .. :.%       icA l'c-ldL i,)..c Ld- : .
                                                                                        , M 5 . .).w   ' :
                                                                                                           .     /      -          . ,(~
                             .. ~...na r e. /; 1. .;. ;>.

i

                                                                       .. .~ ,       <.
                          ' q.?r*v              g ... .), h         Yu'                   &- / / ..h)
                                                                       .~

j .

                              .....,.,.j,........~.,.e<,_,

i .*. , 5kk , l .5* 2.0 (/ !$IN / hs p. . .. . . bu,JN. M r f. w d6_.

     %D,'lLJ~nxw& A ?@

LIf" _ dmi

                                                                                                                          .m, ~ Mci             -
                            # acd .c                                   ". .l. .. . [                          %b
4. .. ' n ..Aed.-.L@A %.'-

c . d?-A M L ~. <~ytL y- Qwe A

                                                  '                              ~        ~
                                                     . K                    ..       .

i M~d /dle g_WA.Ic;2 -

                                                                                                  <.o~ .4 M     #

as_ L y "ce

                        +A~

V

                                                    ~. m a J                              yw%a.2 o y a                         ~              &                   zoo. A n .sd4/~.
                            /A M                                       !  _. lay &&W MLK                                   , M b e M_.
                    .)es..

u.; c~Alg ~ Aw m ,A M & e0 &

                                                                                                    .-ul l.~                  /

2As w & .

                                                                                            /A 6
                                                                                                             .k        -  .6WW       -
       .               ;         &d                        d              Ad &m                      ivc 4,..k'.-6/ y d
                       !'         &                         M                          A l X L.                                     Je
                                                                                                                ' . .. ..fc. /m.

h.y~.,-( 2% ] ,/ a gbre. Zwu-1

                                                                                                                          -..- /. c -- - f (, m-M
                      .         ,(p 4Q                         '       '
                                                                                                          ~E.'                    wy
                      .             M                4<                               y                    c~ . .          , $             ,4,. c y

5 t S 9 9

                                                                                           .            /n m d'Y j'm                              (=fu prm = $%=h-
                                  &n, ~ . , ,  <-     .               0, /)t go7.
                                                                               ,..  ~. .j         o.    .  . . .

y .M' fC .- J ,,,, , wa y a us a

                             ;sA A dy               rn                                     &J D is, w sf% ..                                                    scx &
                                                                                    ~
a. . ".2 2 s9 AhlN * .

e .J=a/ J 'sW A .

                                                                                                                     ~
 .-. . .             . ..       ecK                       .- .. . _ _                                     ..&
                             .)       k E p - A --                                 2             - p y

n- p y-f.A a p n Jf . .

    .            . . .                       _~                                                              .          ..             . _ _ .

b @ M . _.

                                                      . .Are-;L :-                    ~          &.kKjf a &o z 1                                -        J n                 n .& &                                ~
                                &~                                       j'               &       AJJ 4-
                    -        . .Ma+%'u- u-- A y & X.. J 4 ._ _.._ .              _

m& ea~% w_- d'~ . i& A .w m J ~ v A y xe

                                                                                           &~
                                                                                             <>A'.p'%u=( 4 k~Q.                M.
                                             ; k .6 L v I4
                                /w gL . & is/M-g                                       M
                                                                              #c,ml.z.

M n $w .A ,

                                              & y.                #      .

1 cJ .. -- E E

                                                                           $.4 c!Li dP%

cdlul A x vJ l1 4t - 4 . 6:- 4y .:1 y.

                                                                                =e
         ,                                                           4'.<

t 644 M op -/ A rr /aa x, s n. /m~ p  % - < 13 m L^ 4 4 ;.c- JD A,AcR'd a a. v A4 A%L . a.:sf ~ 7 a

                                                                               /

A w

                                            "f0' J n t2/ G
                                                         .,&     M& SW  c~1..bh       -
                                                                           . Say 1 ~                              ~ M.             D 7

A~ Ed 4LJe4J

                                     "                  & ;ds
                                                               ~M(

yM GP'

                  ;(4 U S % 'A'-f h AAj 49 % 'A                                   wM        4
                    &                                   b &        , n ,$s             .
           *        *     = = = - - - . .       . . . .

i e

                                                                               ------s       -      ,          _ _ _       ,

a 4

                 .                  e 4

1 5 9 y .~,Q k i l'f ?. hQ n.. .. D pad A., cAN ' % W t.d n .

                                                          ,                                      ,-      .. t     .
                       <                         0     %.     ]'                       W   (          A<a
                                      %.;Tcl a

ne - Q:.& ~ ~A&(w 9Mn

    .                                        o 4

we/ q & wd .-d G a M m.

 ..                                      .Bh          R C A = f p > Va w n
                                               ~
                             %          ~        ac%                        &L.                         M -w! .

p H <act 4 <t h 4- Bo Q e-ydLi a ~fh ., - ~ ~ a 1ga4 s ~. 1 A ,:- -.4 . . 'syb' w., A. x,av ~. ews :_ < .

                                                                                          -(a n m-JL '             ^/ TD                  t' s 3 L 67
                     ~
                                          &tht
                                                                                                                             ~

l hY .

                                                                                                                               ~
                             /h                  h[nh                                          -
                             $O                       -a'A                    m3                             -

m -2A: .. 4i- M m 4 c . . f .? k

                                                                            /f w~d e -
                           .~

AA S Qu s 4.:yj~.b.-nv

                                                                  ~       . a ;;-; .4 . G n
             ~

lA  : .  : > *' ~ 4 (M l

          /                        .
                           ,:         A(3 .)&& ,,nc                     ,i*
                                                                                .         40 - 2<>c mj ,n . 6 .< - t . . .. . - 9.o , .g ex
                                                                /

u- ..

                                                                                             '                   J.
                                     .a      . . ..: t      ...  ..         ..                   . .                     ..

Mio af /dca 'A'C@ c-Ged ~7".9' e_.r - 9  ; t en.-

                                                                                                                . .u.. . , . ..y .;
x. br M a c c.s e Ss.. . -.'-

M 4 , A xte n . ~ w& A k AJ a

                           .AL.d
                               /J z< - & ) ant #_~:/ y c -p(.-ac t / %
                                                     ~

e

                                                                      / /rs.
                        !D6 .As M
  .           .         I. A O s>c & .A s .. M,c
                                         -                                                           edq-1.4 - d .
                      .        2 4 n.~ J .A                                                                                               _
          .             3                                                                                                                   ..

N# ~

                                                          ;n~ "fX 3 p,na nMk
                    ~

6 c lNCk' & . ..L5N y. cts.o_f*W A c,6?. n t

                                      >-            & A.M3.s w ej                                                                                      ~
               . ~                      ~
                                           &"m                          J 4Q HO                                                         .

y

                        ;   M23rJ                               . :. a # -                                     !4 WA Of- 811s!*s.                                      ccma Ggg,L;y \'
                        .lR5 I           . C.3 \                        .. .;' M
                                                                                                          . ,- c !.Mc r30 p d/ m .J4                           .
                                                                                               , q,:a.u :.f.

t l

e.

                                                          *I' .

w ,,. r. . c-wnls$ M**,

                                             .     ..)\.
            -                      fuL.
                                                                         < w..                    K w dy                       . & f 4 j ,..

I

                                      ,Ja. . n wto.fe2.;fe.
e. .
                                                                                                        .oaao dW.

A%KeA)ch LN

                                                                                                  % L'bC/fo
                                                                                             ~
                                         )              <4                                                                                                                '

M y -.

              .         . .. /

ad n -

                                                                                                  /'

f Y

                                                                                                                                                'y an
                                                                                                              %d.

1

                             . <$5                                             7 &9 f                  A                                   .
                                'c~                       .P                                   -

id2 8s 1 0D64.Mc nh- cd , Tc : ..... x . Adao&~ A ..p _sa. W? Tv./420. _. . t.6 y P2J m .cJf 3 i ,, , .

                                       '                                 /                ( n' _        ,     A                         cr . . y          ..' g
                                                                                                                              $;2;"$.f.
 ~
                                     'h.rmar-!.C'l                                      ')

n...j ,~a en u &a.oA(I .' .,n'.ux

                                                                   /
                                                                                                                                                ...Wun 4
                                         /                                                                       r
                                     ..          .r-
                                                       . . ,yw. o <cp(g           m       ca M        ,

mw>r. -

                                                                                                          ~
                                                                        -/
                                         ,,.:              .         'LgLL            * - -i      nw m. Q                     ,%         J~            .

W + n  ? .~.r.pt0n/* /$in. ..

                                                                                                                                                           .,l. Yg a&

c.t X - 3.~ y6

                                     ,..             .       Id J                    =!

e a Oa e-l ,(t s /l~.: . ,/tc. b W w I , h-e~ G :.< . e - l- u ) .sa Sc ! ,<, kJ, (<*

                                           * &%                        *,*...?.,
                                                                          ,,                                (* . . s       ,es,? "                     . * * > C c * ' s.. . '.
                                                                                 .hv. (,        %                               M         b_ -                    b AE pfd, J c~d&-                                                                                                                                                        _

m L-[en ded

                                 !                                                    1                                                                                        .

F 9 - Q - r 2- 6.gi

n. ..
                                                                                                                                ' i'O% . A                     ,
                                                                                                                                                                                   ~-y. .-.                           - ..
-                    .     ..        feJ?o                      .       .               &..
                                                                                                                              .        Acre J                                                       .           .             .

sq w . 4 ..,.... .

                                                                                                                                                                   .     .
  • 8.*

G , e.g

                                                                                                                                                                        .s               .                                .
                                                                                                                       -- a                 . , . . .                                    - ..                - .

4... . . . ... . . . 9 9 T s m 0 l l 8

                    ,' ;, .- Cs!!

Ahn.a., f;luW M, MFC S.GW en pd. , ce CPC .

                    ,t % . 4- / k i                    tv.d// ' ;&f "h,  ,'y i l ^                                        ...
                    & QA hi.zw-c% cec             L'..   . c:.cjse(/~,m               -
                                                                                  /   '
                                                                                       . e:j i4
c. <
                                                                                                                         ~-

a..@ J a hy r-ys

                                                                                                                  ~

h , w c- ~ '4 4 , ,k c.e, . u

                     /do
              \                                                                                                                            .

4 . . .

                                                                .e   . . .

if pune/ e4 cm

                                                    % w, c
                                                                               =

A /t w. '. . O- y a

                                    .W h.

um .-(h-. = ' . &# -64(

          ~

3Ah ' 6;4. E,1S ~c ' / ?.P2 d) d !"#$$ $?l. e n .N G cc.-c4~w>

                ?A'-D oI-A ./.' / .m                                                1. 9. A   .                                        -

d ,,tL /: w p .e j' .. .J.n- /% e / w a

                                                                                     '     .3 M                                          _
1. d . ,.

4 %Se A W ., . u % .

            . ya .                                                                        .:                  lN
                                                & 2 .N i5m#w%
/ MJJ .
  • AL.A. '%. M/f i ra A k. d&d~.& ', o A 32 ,AG m fd n ; '.c.. AcLLV cd 3::Q~1odi o

or i lG't.

c. . sw-s 0 *;, ,< w ~g,..
                                                 'cdn
                                                                        ~..                .. &c 'a.y                  .

('t._ , . - , t. < <- ~ : . . yn,y;/ ,

            . 5 .wh
                                     * *: K     .fau $ t.
                                          . /.- ' r., ,. i., J .

Sa... .% j Nr-t._____________

v

                                                    .      .__j                                    -
                      ,f_'s   /y        Agha /W. KA44 -                           .

1..%f  % s i,':C~cus ps%

                           ~'
                                                                     + L?

7,; . , , ,, es, s --

                                                                                      ' *NQ)    c.r .W~ %. .r%eb
                                                                                                         '/
                                ~
                                      'k/             %            *                                       -

AM*4 C+. m x & t, ,.s.. & %L t. h " l *=~sJ; hCW v

                                                                                      . ~~ l
                      /]1;           p.-src
                    . ~7      M h ~.( '

26

                                                                           %p w                               .   .     . . . . _ _ . .

b ' s .. . . . . _ .. . .. hN . .. . . . . . . . . . . - J d . m w 4i

                                                                                                                                                                   ~ ~
                      % e                          M .d ~
 .. .           .   ; <4 . ' k- Q+. .wh =x.                                                                                                                             ....
vW ~ & ~ 4 A .... M m . - _.- . ._ .

hY 'f YW . % .. .

                              .              .                        .'                             7'AJ  .
                                                                                                                        ~            * ^ *                               *
u. m wY cdm . ,~w. v: < .

W 47 '

                                                                                                       . W .._                                  __
                                                            $                           A                       4s Qg  /       v H~Y J

o 6 G%~f: . .

                      ~ to n                       w.                         .

_. 4 , c .. . . A L 4,4 . M J c~ - . 4. ',

                         .c & d                                  M11 test.:.n.
                                                   .(J

(

                                                                                                                                           .w

g h t g g pm. ] v., 4 9. . Y). ' [J .al~L lLN ,*cqLa /r? /%.Ln toea n W . NQ " s.. JA%LL 94,u' b diQ f 6 yo- ' ncv $LJ g nv~A' e-% .a A_ n,Zsa e~d '-

                                                                        .ta       hj.c   ~            ,s$

lMqb ,/qs a aa 6

                                                                                                                            ~

J a

                         . w gr g:ih     geg 4                 .<r .b                                                   4
                         ;M                  W                                                                    .A~r
                                                                                                  ..n J%L. &

lmAr i

                                       +SA"M.4                                                     .h w
                                                                                                                  .sf w       OK*t 6                 .
                                                                                                          ;    MW cluqe de                                    ..% n ;t . ,._.
  • I :H(. AIc & t y'iAd ASi.e &

m O/< Az m-rw .-e. - .A.

                           .y. 4 &                         ,

4 r- u-c/ v l i && ' jka &d L i.. a + %& _ g ., .. u /s@  % M '. i A w A ~. . .

                           ./-/LL/p! A p
                                                                 ~ . @ .444'/ d4
                                                                               +
                                        , Q .
                           -R. 4                             As                               -

J Ad m gj, 4 c~ Q< ' 4.% - : -

J L ':( n .
                                                                                            . m.s.4
                             .~. &             .x     .b n'        '
                                                                                        . .)m/A[/eM07h w p)yn,d.th
                                                      ~~

N. t . .W e %1'% &*. . s v2 / o ./ / .- f .J J.) l' l'

e e. a

 '.    ,i                                                                                                                  ..                     .
u. y .
                                                                                                    '~ ,

ANT e b

                       ,3         %v *[               ,' / ,4W 0
                                                                                     ,, i' , h( , 'i c
                        .A/p'<..L       .'                  ,a4. d4.. -                  ;Q>u5" QC f
                           ,p.o .

Q. :. . x. . . . .? <;'N .

                                                                                                                ..s.m           .m b agd %>... P.'"%%.
                       . , . _~ ~.e pxbyy.<a.....pp..;_M                     _ . _ . . .. f
  • 1.. ..

b 'v &(

                                                                                                                                     ~r.e+.swA
                                                    &        h, V           k                           'b,&

zM/ < -i-. & '

                                                                                                                       ~
                      . tL,.i               A                  T C P .- A .c n ; y f e-.                        A .f~<                             b.                     V                    .

s44e ,- a s % ,J a -.~D M.u% .

                                                                  -        +N m,6        --
                                                                                                             ~

f -% c/ n ML q a . i

                          &n                               4 n        ,,; M ~f y A-c cs--.:-       , ox       ==-

aoo.

     .                  , 6L
                                                      .2.0 + . A                         e                        .                   .

CM M J , S< d.we -

cm4 ae
                                                              <            uCf                   . .X#k 1     ~
                   'nsf6p                                    .m %                                                   - sy : ..

yPw .70 .20 9_ #4g) s /!.41&, a. W w% si - 0 , AL&a a

                                 . M                                                        ~ nd                                                      ,
                                                    &w                                               AaLL Mi!M - ~_.L/ w.%.                                                       '/26.de m

M ~ .u..eA MLh-&M

                       -%%h.s. .R) .R . . .AJ.j n,.q&&
                     / e x d d ,. , . : .. . .k m . i v a < /                                     15.*!.;

s- ce M - s 1

                         , IaL LLM                       n.'.

1 - c: M W. K:.t

                                                                                         .2 AG  --~%       > . rA, A
                                                                                                                  .        "     w

___- ______- _______ - m ._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _

            '.:                                      . c..( ')?:36a .. - %y.i.-I.V-      :b (                                                 Ai.
                                       .-/

i

                                                                                                             . . c u. -.
                                                                                                               '            ;I     +4/          day.:-,.                  ,

3.'.T. .i .s ' . T d .', .::' - . a ;.--~.~a-

                                                                                                                                                ~., . c,' y ..t~ . .
                                          . . . . ..,c d: 6. .Y ' , .-r o A..4 l.d            .

(*, - .+ :

              \                    (W 'i/ 0 bi                           /2~v>sr.<         5/,,.,O Y M ~
                 )                 & s'a / 4Gk                                           uld - . Me.-
                                   ;$G' ,. n.e /$.b "g -in-+c                                                                e          D
  • i'j' fS c y _ -@-(

z.v/ 4 %. .

                                   , e,- -             -
                                                                 >rn,                                        m      . d     c        dy     ~.

t.a

                                    %' J' 4 s % ' Ml <.nyx,                                            m                           -

4d Ao wt J Y ~ / '

                                                                                                                  ^
               ,                                                                  AA'%                                                                       4
               \               .
m. a . .o f : .as.M .

i ~ ~

       .              s      .                  .G' .                   .M                                                                  . .          . . . .    ..              .-

k%  % . /(se . . .

                                    . M .;;/                                         Ay                      J                       Ar                   ..
                                    .,dL                       A1..du                                      4.aML--
                               , W A                                              u J

A ,- .

c. 4 % 9 ... .-:
                                                                                                                          ,- v
                                                                               -s ~ -:-(
                          /.L       f'MM M J..4AC             c: L,,

b A.y +

                                                                                                             ,,,.,,.               L
                <.               . .a 'l . A6a                          / .        ..a . Hu- c ~/

MNhd m .-Ww a LJ?..A64 d._ . <~ n

                                   ~                                     ....::.         u Aftk % .,<                          p' Mr r

J'(y s n A, , .: . 7C 4m f' ML pu,.

                                                                                                                                                                       .e a

WW w om,. v-z Q4H M .yAi.c44 n L v

                                                             =
                                                                   -6 N7o..164)cqn.
                                                                        .-d. ne n L J s.

p b  %

                                                                                        ~Mhdi
                   ' "f v fl& yWMI?u                           c^
        .: n..~a8_;aa :                                                                 r                    -
   .         .   . m                           -&A                              -

A i._A&. A ..n A

                  .& A d a . A.h M ~%
s. k- mi A SJ -

5 lMm 6)<

                             -    A      i    k M. . #;fJP&.C &            W4-d U OZ                   K'
                                                                                                   .4e           _

e r 6 - f M c / %6 Mu.We. 1 M R L 7':3s Ad L t.m n.cd p4e.;<+.- scie: .. c a

                ,n t
                                           ,6       L. . & cil J L q(    hre is.so      w(      C gwup- .

o trcedarm r y n!.'y -ll4is e, y # fle J owA. cfe s F 7%e le s d) LA.

                                                     ,   4         .-     arL! .

n sett ce j;. 4a 4

                     ?'d( 7gM . y w:r.                        i     .
                                                                 .      A      .. w, 'd         et dum a p n.s .. .. A                                              -,3    A
            .l"M &i:*/lL :{&LW~h-, .                                               ..

w c  ;-%9 3 : 3. ' - . ,A - _

                                   . . _y , 60hh.                                     ,

l} ,oin>} , 17

                                , O'>"               "
                                                                                                                                    ,[

s 4 A c, - 1

                 ?

i O ' M As n I -

   .. .          ..                                 A..                                  -. &                                 ...                .
                                                                 ~ - -
                         .                    m.

e . . t .. Rk ~p 1 4x' . JO- . MlAd&k < <

                                                                                                                     &                         nu~Q g .-                            .
                    .irf.R.-.ahd.r.
                                                                                                                                    . t. . A A                   .        .

jdd>--- d . c Q , n LAr .

                                   @A                                           w) ~(                         M.                                                   ..
                         .. d ..

A ug  % m.h>&& h Jyp.-da e - Ar 9.d oce w<bk ,'

                                                                                                                                        *-e.

a e e. i - - . . . .. I I ci

r . -  ; w U,

                                    , . ..         ,     -7cu. o y q
                           &J                             3$h .l'-$ .n-U                                                                   <-             73 .

n,n m.s#MA wi. :

                                                                                                                              . &LO+d s                                                                                            ..                                           <
                                           /          -

R/ ,p/%

                                              /a.-> 6 JL. 4 !<my jfi                                                                                            .
                                                                                                                                                        '.d'2'                                                         -
                             .La Y npay. v0 n, .nWhW'
                       . .UC& M                                       y m-W.h i
                                                                      ],0
                                                                                                                                       & a                                           &A t'~o
                                                                                                      ^%Wydg' % [j f
                                                                                                                                          <mf.

A$c.. .f'Ofo.. O.. a.oc- - 5 fd  %- /#.

                                                                                                                              .,                               . i               ,
f. 0. Y . .. . . . s . #. N V .

M c-I 2 .a0' D e cm M

                         & _.s=L :.J :.d,1 4 ~
                                                                                                      %d~ &mk .

fh9msn - .m - wk

                           ,a .s, . . . ' ,-                                                                                                         .
                 ,.s                     i 1                    F-                                                        .                                                     .

hkj . 9,4 ~.,/ <a mL( ..

                    .Q: m                   .

6 mk. . - ..

                                                                         ~

g.

                                                                      /'fw.}YA 4;- -ex- .                                                                                                         .
                         ,              x..                      .<..            c-                             .
                                     . 4-a ~/c u,% j.- M.A                                .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ~

4#/ c &

                                                                                              .g                 4. s J. _ ~
                   .       4.                             J,                                                               MJA a.u .

ms

                                                          ~ ~- ;                                               g ..Ak.

9 , [ f ,,k . # * . f) QL..d .

                                                                                                       . mA, (R-                                                               '

a... . .r er t 9

                                                           -.                         -,                           , , + ~       , . . .                   ,.,,,-..._.--.n.,               .,+...,c,..n,         ,             ,-- , , -,

ril.I e -

       . q ' l .g
         - .n
                         +
           ,                                           y      .<..

i Y N M ---*

                                            ' g A *-                                          J $ A s-<' b                                                                 .-

l  % oGwp cum' & 2"- - j m - n .

m. . .
                                                                                                                                  = =^4             . . . _             . . . - . . . _               . . . _ . . .                           . .
                                                                    . C4Bh JJ. c~r ....
                                                                                                                        , %, 4 _.._
                                   ; @p s 49' .

t . . . . _ . .. _ ._.. - _ . . _ . . __ C__ . . . .. .. .

                                            ~

1 - J & . A. ' . - i

 !                                                                    e%                        e                                      4~

h a a m. - ( .- _ - hM M

1 '
                                                                                                                       -e r-
                                 .n                                                                                                                         . As                                                       _

y ..

                                                                                                                           ..       .._._1._.                                 . . .                                                 .
                                                       -                  A                       .

v +

                                                                           -        ~

g

                                                                             /A . &#L.i                                                                4A
                                                                             ~ca cys                                                                                                                                                                                                      1 We
                                                                                         +e.-                   y-re                 y   --<--.rw                    w          -ee.-    w      v*---         +-     --3mw;-               y-

(6.S.

        ^        '                                  -
                                                                                                 ,e
  • l l

(A (, ' ' P

                                                    }[)~cci                       Q                                                     'I
  • s
                               .fudq                                                     s                             H A . -, b, a                                                                                   i a ~ q fM MS-Am u.ah1ad?%A                                                                                                     A i

i i 9 l

    . . . . . . . _           J A . ~ % _ 6 - y ..d & -6y p-

_i

                                  ~ + = ~ . R = i .. A
                                  /aL- J                                      s~dy                                   a -
f. .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   .i i

f

                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ;l
                            ;Lny %,bap, W
                                                                .d          _ . _ .                                                                                               -

l. G_ MhAv ' A -c M

                                   .2                                                                                                (pwes( M ac's            Lr p ,<. q                                                                                                                                                   i(

fM  % - c- a l p.facs.mM- M L, p

e ea t

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 \
       ,      te .

WW - 4-=- A - Mx 4 . '1 [ 5 a,4 , .

                                                )0u C                                   I cJk D 4 -                                                                                                         o                                           -
                                                 -da
                                                                                        & D W                                                                                                                                 - xs--

M

                                         .         s~lf                                                                                                '
                                                                                                                                                                                                      ~ --

e.. d '. M - 4 . '_ M _.. M M 8 ~ " ~~ m

                                                                                          . . m 124. . . .. .
                                                                                                                                                 .                   94
      -.                                              .        .~. . - . - .                       . - . . . -                      . =                             .. .                 . . . . <                a . .-,             .,. _.-. -
                                                   .         ...              .. .        ...-i.-.E.......,.                                                                               4. -- . . . ... .-.                             --..-                                -
                                                                                                                    - - . . p,                                                                                                                     .. ..

e sgp. .

                                                                                                               , s            .l.         ., J *,                                         e S                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   *. g O

h es e W

                                                           .nm                   -=

m ano e :__ m . en . e. e m - e e

                                                                                          .                m.,        .m6.             & 6 . e e4                pg       e 4         g   6-,
  • t 4

s,.._ m. m.m. ee am +am e - rwoen=~~*. ' ~~ * *

  • m --m- -g-- -y.-. -9w--y- ry y-yw- ., w yo----- e-rw-y----y
                                                                          ---                 -          e4-                                               4   r                                    .
                                                                                                  .-.~.

p s, , I' LACE : ~?~. w. c ( s _ n m. c 9t .w l '

                                                                                          , ' . u .v        ( .~

DATE: it! h ? n e-I, u mtu T f r , res. , , hereby make the following volkntary statement to Mr. D. 4). Driskill, who has identified himself to me as an Investigator with the II. S. Nuclear Regulatory Co::rission. I make this  ; statement freely with no threats or promises of reward having been made to me. i t

                    'T     .ceu ca-( lt:gO                     GS           e--    C ('     L,.*d       3us M e,                        ~
           ~2   N N
  • s.b t.

s ,

                                                                                                                                't J 1   h     r. e t -

U ,9 J T-. d (*,, KV. be % k g c i i; (< t -4 q

           -L- e % s- Cc4c6 RS7.? I ums       er4%c d k g                     33          i m.t sw.

9 d4  % 'hw J = '

                                                                                                            $m            h kwWd   t a.i       u w ' (__, c c. L t u Spt. n , n g I c .dcdh                                                              d W .c-V ,'akd 3's . p w% ' Tea uvoiu                                                                                                           -
                                                                                                   &          d ssu.au)                       L LW cuouf c4 uy ccuccm s
                                                                                                  . ma ,dl.g                   i=m4 d, ei       dic        'DI          CC h-d,                                                            '

s ..< m . ~ e iC. [ g g e t%( g E- ( 'C. E' .W14< ONs

                                                                                     ~
     -        % u,,  pu c m . [ (sc..!c, acck~~cd-tocd"<<0 4 b**ier
                              ,    ,        .M. 1 tc teced '. .

p C .. q Tnld u. s m .a.y syJ. m-.

                                                               %d'                i f t o e_        rye.cicf
                %i            va;.         Le.u \

ct eg ,,

                                                       .T. . .-: w c% ca ic d a a k, usura twd                       i..c. . e ci
                                                                                                                            %t
                -wd y n                                                      u.s i accet b wcci, tie. EYal n L .,.A
              ~
                                                                        % acc ak %                         ~&l~hx                             l ci 4 6         app. ew            i:

A ces'isi %d ushuf 4 a cc=J . W -

                  &               %f d % . - A u d 1 A u -c,c c. e m             ~sE                                                                                      swv4 %'e s                        '

edC.L cm.cd k racted ad

                                                                                                                                                                  \

W s h4 A  %.J,. e . p.ep , ly.c c. g-g it d I 4b- c. '. t-F ps d .e ..; e u N. 2.cd

                                                                                                                                                                  )

C L C- M c $ \' \- ~ *

                                                                          \s %          My
t.  ;

s v, z y hc \ e-wi v. ., Ud' . ,' 1 QQ{ \ 1 (4,,g g. g -

                          -_-_A_-----
e. s h

bA \ W *.s (Lit C *1 $  %

                                                                                %\(         C.c%_L (              bd        (        wl reycds er kis .aad u ,,...r d 6 h J,, & d                                                                                    .

r ,qu pd vy ead d.w eg u wi(t atu; c-( _ mq st quA.cu t

                                                   , ,7d , 3 s            ...        g.   . I           n. _              d q            o M\                t.      ,pi4     C.4 3      (Afkte         C % pC'sts.A d             YiES          MS          Ce p .-dA _ ._ . _

k,,dtu.s tc. ic_c .,a ulE_1 t I r.clu1LJ b n-s) 4 m ., we m c..r 3- pmd m e. s. ,. s -k, - 6a<d CC_. L gica s -k. d.cs.'edtL -7eett Iw sg.ctca.~ ciba_ d'Jtcl  % Oc_ p'<<c2cucs. L w e cr c-T h, e c,. 3 0 4 e, % c. , am-Q s-2 ci.-57 , s 4 m c -< r-t 3.u r. w.m . ,, (~m.s - ,d.,, s .s ,..g .3, . b, ~PI) sC 1. d.Ath.d u.s k ch s vc.c., cud Q cP .911 2bdr c 1w. cbse. c,7c% W A.s ad us -tt, a,g

        -%d a                     '
                                    . . .        ..       u:.e iv.scl A                  re~a an a ,. a Su.L . .

ru 6

          .d w d scA-                                EccaN. c~u.          ~~Ii2      p. cwt               ss   -{b d o u s
         ,      j                 '

r - - tw. v- - c ' t e t. we.Nc u(F cyhC d c. s c;. T.w ~~j

         -\o       wAk               $sQs            CEw.u se<_ c (,                 b5S-          $ sis      aC4( c[ h
          % ea          .

occam.d pi% ,

                                                                             %       +ttds 58aC6cfico cmJ S V5 f.)2.4. E' C i t,         (,         i '. 4 -(. (                    b(P M                      '

A.Q U b N 'a: YoQS.16 gC, .-ttud N dsvedtd U .cc d es e.f .  % . b-wc/.2 3 cbdhcis ed Cec J ou wcr ex_w d vd a.1 t N b.", ud wut Leu tst#fOll. Ch is.is p d a , cd

         'a. .ci.s w w d -I Ltb                               p6 c (S4.4 s t cu cuc} c-R5!c.COC.S Cu" e'k.               et _              w .u o u s-         L utds cutd S o p w i d u , ~tt e I
            -s m 'a                  ~~ ? At.g-(

a c u g9.~:h ( 1c a ( d,,i's 3 _ w c-t. c .

                            /

m . aL. w< dd . 7p e . - ~ > 2 c .I' (

O

,    a.                                                                                  #

s q ... k b

                                                 *s, h          db                                                                                                   l     k p.mdux s.                   ta c_ .
                                                                                                                                                            ~

[,v,ek tex t c.w c us.. I l-G.d t Cets w Q 4%.c cr of _ Q p *

         ^
                                                                  , ;p . 3 9 s 1t           C                    *Cy c 5                                N
  • M W A C. O '.
        ?k.          Ct         s  eQ                  Md              J -bd                   ok ' mr Ld t                                      s de%4                        edO g od& d                                                ter um                    b             dvme c-        Ci           %eesk A u.s k h _ c u i cd Rb% %d                                                                                  .
         &ic 'd . TW                                  sotit. c&-                     uae.w        - (re ,wy
           ,-                                au         'ax k - eLa.d utd ce ~t k a+0< L') k .

ihmb m. L-c4c 43.J5 h L doy A u.  % dc k 1 gw% ow. wA e d d cu z~.'d 9 ektc eul as A a&A .

c. . 2.t. u.i As i :<: Leem, Pdc. l.: kd s-c Oc a s 1 m m .t ,

u-  % qa  % m u ,s aw.m a r . + , ,

                 ._1        s          CId           QWs(4.\        

Q-C- WQ A. I, / k* g 6', s , , , ', _ l

             % i m ,,                  E% MM                                Itvdc, % I                    tlc k cd.(

VAs.g W ".Y '? To 6.uq b  ; MALTCN cH b

                                         .m                                   .                                       4    ,

Qf p s ; ve l, .

                                          %}s c.h      GE.< t. \~            h sed,          ,ML    Y..i        rtqkT               'ig
  • su_b , - . . !

u.q M c R 's . 5d.h Q iwe t, 9.; } i n Ter. A v4-scA. % odco m -b n y a..,. T' wvku s4.J[.yM")' # bl bo.d. = cfAb -5

                                                                                                     -     -/     1         [
                                                                           ~~                                                                   

ho

              -(&,,,q,2. . ..>v.- {nd                 c.w     cu          \. mq c l' . h4p t                        sc& NQ e ,1. L :_ .._         a s           - K e w . u p W Q .c_ & s a %:

s a.-: . 1 md cc~uud it. 3ulrJ.d 'if. u.su1 . h% . . .s b.s w m ca.sc.ma f d.-JT cJ % /2h. 3 te (- 4

    ^

4*.. ...- 7 1 i b b hk\% S $ k. k

                        .:_v u    6%                    red                                       tEsec                       e e u.,      T     tt . c.T.c     4 kt, pickst (JP                   CAL                      CL.                           5 tt.W             bt c.4       ((_p(*       3  (L*ldch 7                          ]

mec.s. c' ei c., c.qu , c- f - c2 N, ih ums d o.s.t.s.Tcs. a', - . I Liredem,i% 'q a p. cleat cua Su.-it bw3 %cc n..,

                                                                                                                                 ?                                ,

_ ce.s m>A ud he eac<_ulocr( pecL[zon sa Rc ccd rec.ra . . T h etal cme audr_ shd > ~ s Adf.cc! ee.,3 , cud. mea.- c_e. m T.ds % h_c_ Tc-sc c; c m c; 4 pcui< l d&y. d . 'T ru % % steIc.tsM fi tq ~M~ _

                         ~4                    te w                                   ucs; J yy N u c e , c ,                                                    3 c- wg ve     (wc(
                                                                                                                           ? wa J <a 2 .2) k n.:.ie
w. u. r m u c = - - a .: , ,. a a W . 6 w u ed ue scw - 4. ,

uct s.t u., d..[ e

u. &. ec
         -                                                                                                                                                          O e

O 4 t 0h - i .

        ..a.,.    -   .

__.__m__.__ ____________.________.______________.____.________.________a- _ _ _ . _ _ _ _

                                                                                                                                                                                                      . ~ . - - - - . - - - - - - -

CroRMiss U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 411 PRmCPAL MSPECTchhame ust. *st. amtmmmate

    'C "
                      ,                                   INSPECTOR'S REPORT                                                                                                M T
  • R ede d 3
                                                                                                                                                                           ,,yy,,,

Office of Inspection and Enforcement ECToRS g3, y,,,, j i rl l Ae $ 9' r in , : < k : I / LICENSIE/ VENDOR TRAN A TcN 00CKET NO 18 eetW OR LICENSg REPCRT NEx T INSPEC. OATE NO.8Sv PRODUCTitt349tm p g SJ 6 vi -INSERT _ O I # o o 4 9 'lt ( . 8 i3 p p a M - MCoiFv _, . D - CELETE C R - REPLAct O MN2P.D% 9%NQe 44hnV*;24'[Et4 *7.%'?' A.4 'NM 14 16 ~- 10 817100 OF INvtSTIGATION/tNSPECTION mSPtCTON PERFORMf D SY ORGANIZATION CODE OF REG 3DN/MO CONOuCT-FROM TO MG ACTMTV ($se sfML' 05J0 ' M 1 OAY i YR. MO. DAY Y R. 1 - REG 80NAL OFFICE STAFF OTHER

                                                                                                                                                                                                      ,w      u,,,gg .. ancomer,Repor,.                       .

2 - PESiOENT WSPECTOR REGION DMS80N 88ANCN

/ 3l0 h 2. dl1 /% 8l3 3 - PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL TEAM M U E E'# D M 6WKQEM[Ch wMhi}Q] Mk%Mdpyyn 'f&,337, b j .<34.yr i,,, . gg t REGCNAL ACTION TYPE OF ACTmTV CONouCTED #Cheet one boa emye 02 - SAFETY 06 - MGMT.VISif 10 - PLANT SEC.

14 - INQulRY t - NRC FORM $$1 03 - aNC0 TNT 07 - SPECAL , 2 - EEGCNAL OFFICE LETTER 04 - ENFORCIMENT 08 - VENDOR t1 - httNT.VER. 12 - SHIPMENT /ERPORT [ 15 - INvtSTIGATION

                                                                ~                                                                 ~                                         ~

05 - MGMT. AUDIT Os - MAT. ACCT. 13.eMPORT

          - WyitW,3nr.'t.Y '% ?*: %
                                                                'CW D*%JSQ?ff MNid*!N W NY$.$ U $ W M 3K3E W ' ~
          .NsetcrioN w.ts r.GATsGN 6NQaNG5 iC** W *
  • YC'ALNUMeER INFORCEMENT CONFERENCE REPORT CONTAm DSO (gTTER OR REPOmf TR ANSMITTAL 0ATI OF VIOLAY10NS AND NELD mFORMATON 1 - CLEAR NRC FORu sst REPORT SENT OR Reil. TO NQ. FOR 2 - VIOLATION LETTERIS 5UED ACTON 3 - OGVtAN A B C 0 A 8 C 0 A B C D MO. DAY YR. 40. DAV VR
                    + - voLAroN a oturoN                        o, f          ,                                      i                       1 - veS
                                                                                               ,             ,                                                                   , - ,,5                  c;g        .2,j        y;3                 ;           ;        ;

WWWW@%7NS @%YMd@ %9!ikHHWFst !M&M9MW "m - ~* *' ,55 Mooutt *FoRvArc4 Mooutt *FoRwareN . Mooute NuMcER wisp cg g MOouLt rec. Followup c"$ Mooutt huMesR iNSP. d5 MoouLt Rect Followup r ERh [gl{5 IS 5 8e > Ew i*e . ha

p 3 ke
             -4 GM5g        *        .
      =

st

             =<

15 e ,g

                         -z 8

s o u 5 L5=sarg o ! < < a gt - 8 g t

                                                                                                                                          =
                                                                                                                                                  =    je5         *
.3 o 3 "E'=i rga m

a :t li 5 grg 8e

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                - s          -

z  : n a r e : z 1 o; e . t i is s -e gar

                                                                                                                                                                                             -a:g             eo2              -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                <    s c =< o                  ..

g=g s

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             =

I I ^ 1 I t t I f f I e g l ll g l g g g g g ll g l t t t t I !t  !

  • e

_ _L. I f f I II t I C

                                                        , ,          , ,                                  ,    lg       ,  l                                                    C
                                                                                                                                                                                               , ,              , ,                               ,      l,,l U

t t t t t lI f l l l t t t II e l 1 1 i # 1 t t t t  ! I I e f f II t l f f I t t l -i e i I t t i t iii! I I e I t I e i I I I t t I e C I t t 1 1 I I I t t t , , I,,I o I t , t e It , I f f I t I e f I t I e i i !I il '

                                                                                                                                                                                ^

t i I I t Iit I i i f i i liil ' i i i i i liil c

                                                       ! t               I                              t     lit I                                                            c t t              t t                               i      I,t I o

I t , I t It t l o t t , i i It  ! I , I i liii

  • i . 1 i i lit i e i i liiI ^

i i i i i Iiil 1 I t , t II i I I t i e i I i(PI CLE StoutNCE 17 c i t t t , liil l,g c

                                                                                                                                                                                             , t               1 i                        Cl iTP LAYiON OR DEVIATION D

0 g , , , i j g l'gt/g l . l

   .-.. ,                 ,               , , - . - -         , - ,          .. - . . ~ - . . - . . .                ,,         , - - , - . . -                                             - --               - - . , , *              - , - - .                         .-}}