ML20138B965

Suppl to Air & Water Pollution Patrol 860224 Response to NRC 860127 Document to EC Bauer Identified as Monthly Notice, Applications & Amends to OLs Involving NSHC ,30 & 860109

ML20138B965
Person / Time
Site:	Limerick
Issue date:	03/19/1986
From:	Romano F AIR AND WATER POLLUTION PATROL
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20138B949	List: ML20138B945 ML20138B965
References
86-522-02-LA, 86-522-2-LA, 86-526-04-LA, 86-526-4-LA, OLA-OLA-2, NUDOCS 8603250237
Download: ML20138B965 (3)

Text

=

7-

L.

? T J g 4 gpg gg' # -

-~

. a.

y g.g y 4 'g

% 'g, n + -

m% %. m.%;.Q, M y.y.,y.ng ' y'JP s - M,4g.:j;.g,M..g& -

g g '-

MgfMqN ym.p.-WMb 3:pn R InnEWATER$M 2hg[M,q,wu&gy, bigg&

M

gusz gg

. :; y h a.

. ;msn p:,

n g;wg y,p -.g. qq@.~, nyM g2 u, ;jpsyjg

w y

q s

4PolldtionfPatrolE@qrh:

"00CKETED6 - f.h <W '"S p.m -

.,,,;--w % p g g;,gpqwpgc;4 y

a Y

L BR D AX'E, BPM NEhc 8

~

U.S.

Nuclear Regualtory Commission i

Washington, D.C.

20555 EOFFICE OF SECRETAR f 4_ m

' 00CMETING & SERVICE s

BEFORE ADMINISTRATIVE' JUDGES:

BRANCH Ivan W.

Smith, Chairman Richard:F. Cole 'i Gustave A.

Linenberger, J r.Hs

-In The Mat'ter Of Docket No N50-352-OLA-1 PHILADELPHI A ELEC'"RIC COMPANY

[ASLBP.Noi.86-522-02-LA]

(Limerick Generating Station (Check valves) iUnit 1)'

Docket"No. 50'-352-OLA-2 4

-i ASLBP No. 86-526-04-LA]

(Contaimnent Isolation)

.~

f

' SUPPLEMENT OF AIRJ&) WATER POLLUTIONIPATROL 1(AWPP).0FJ_

l FEB.' 2 4,.1986 RESP,0NSE TO DOCUMENT [ DATED Ul/27/86) TOO '

3 MR.' J E. C.JBAUER,' PHILADELPHIALELECTRICICOMPANY;.'FROM' THE NRC WHICH RELA'l'ES

• TO LIMERICK (GEt(ERATINGi STATION, -

UNIT 1. THIS DOCUMENT, IDENTIFIED AS5"MONTHL,Y'(NOTICC; i

7

APPLICATIONS AND. AMENDMENTS'.,TO OPERATINGaLICENSESSIN.

t IVOLVING NO SIGNIFICANT.HAZZARD CONSIDERATIONS $ DATED i

3

.,DEC. 26 and.30,*1985-AND JANUARY 95 1986"*bi R

4 s%w

.m.w M, cmh m

% > W W tm.e tW W A m...m M.h ' L }

' Air and Water Pollution Patrol / Romano S(AWkP)' seeks to show I

^

~

that Philadelphia Electric (P.E.)' Company's long[ standing l con-1 tempt for NRC regulations 'and specified:: procedures can 'signifi-

~

cantly increase.the potential for" accident thatyylll endanger me.

my f amily, members of AWPP and the public.

- m;l%

-On the other side,5the'NRC,=via'partialityfto P.E.,'has di-a -

5 i

cy rectly.or indirectly' allowed a. pattern:of,careles'sness'that now'.i; s

f f*~

' AWPP ! contends di'squalifies,. P.E. ?f rom. se'ekin'g exerdptio'nss !frombany/

• inspections what-so-cver; The Associated Press > reports' stated

~

,.the shuttleLdisastier maylhave resultedifrom 80tio,fuspec. waived on; g

a key shuttle"pai-ts...how ' many already'.waivedf fory' Limerick?

b Contempt;bh P.E.1foriNRC regula'tions, iffoc' curring %at any f

1 l

5.

activity,iothergthan0 governmental,' would'be?labeTed.asJfraud.T It'.i lisi this s already--experienc'ed s potentialNof iP.Est'olev5n cfdisify 0 t ' t e

(

v h '4.. %-

wM. W W. c4Ibref,erf,.t. o TIE.4.76-06-0.1+wh,enjin /19 76ypn..,n, a' ystatement's 3 e

.~

a

.i a ty c e rt'a'in. (e l e+v$to #,11g h t,Yva.ations twe nc o the,.r ;6; < W ititcamc,

m v-a w-g & M@: p/ w welders,ithatVaif'icult9 welds c

.. ~, - --

, i f

c t, ort wh,'o esk,i_ppedp,LE19e' ids M. W,6.

dMdon.,ded f as / O.h,if,M,d sd,1_"dE,,M.n elrisyJ,iinifusl '

M,Thos.m E M.. N. R.

c gn q ;e/cn n e cor byea~n.

a sn icns ectionsg P M Ma

'N -

@%;y&&[.3.k%WWM%%MdMGpns

\\

f *;

$;Tj ~

U ;$s%Mf;*A M&de yrfffd

^

gg/Q@[p,f,1 {. -,,, -@

I z@GhhbY$1QfWJM1N,QQW;b, m n.Gp 1,.

G,,o,, :b fddJ

?.'6'M.

AW d S/-

c.,4vr s u y

L h-

..c us n

$Ny a " M D ;'

e j<i0&hhqf n

hf.,, m.&

. k,, m.

e 5

8603250237 860319

' ~ cmM r#mu

.m PDR ADOCK 05000352 g

PDR

. ?

a UR i

. - - - rg:, per y s...

.a,

-,,.. ~,,

7--

?

/.

A

&Gc

.g w' m m:

a

- < wm

,y>v MQt%@Q &+&;_Q&

s-

....c

. i;Nih&

.s:

hO @m &}M W 4 Q Q."&, b M rM&g[OQQSl

^

/;R M @ Ut % @M SW N & d @O [h p %Mf M%.,. dj, j Id E

f W4QpW eV $ ?.C,MGgr4 O

'RQgM-L N"

JM dt m

, ;ieN Mnl& g xW o?..

" '.W: > #M" n.

m - p[.--

.9

+

w-y ;w N'

a f

.M

){}

.[f

• 8

'N 4

y x<

sq c

is

,sSupplement of AWPP of Feb'.*24 gl986; response.icontinued:

f 1..

ei Philadelphia Electric disagreed that ithe welds were.improp--

j er,-but-after a forced re-inspection proved;they were~ improper,

.P.E. agreed t;,q_re-inspect other. welds supposedly inspected 1by e

that' errant i~n s pec to r.

In as much as thisl incident involved safe-ty, I. asked the NRC, during the.past three years, to require P.E.

to prove such welds were reinspected.

Because of conflicting in-

~

formation supplied by P.E. both 40 me and the NRC, in July, I in-fluenced the NRC to require legal affidavits from P.E. represen-

-...tatives, as they repeatedly stated, that all welds were reinspect-

'ed. -

t.

I

,On/ August 10',

1983, John S.

Kemper,-Vice-President forJP;E.'s Limerick reactor admitted that questioned" welds previously stated to be reinspected and found to be nroperly performed, were actu-ally not reinsepcted / (J.

S.

Kenper, Affidavit of~8/10/83)

Report 86-02 now details (again sof tly) Pipe rupture on the ifirst week of Jan., 1986, attesting to danger to the public from

. improperly performed-welding,with release;of radioactive. water lout'sideLthe reactor building hsein 476.017 report).

1 1l

(

. Further as it relates to softness on the'part of the NRC,-

{

?I.E.sreport #76-09-02, described "six; major! areas of defects"_found ;

tonlremoval of concrete forms.

The.reportJdescribes a " honeycombed" l

,. all' with holes as ' deep as five1 feet'into.a six foot wall enclos--

w p

7 orie~ holelbein'g lai gelenoughi toidrive a1Volk's-d p-W ing4therreactoryvessel i

n

~wagen through as stated by one former.empolyce.

Mr..Boyer, Senior Vice Presicent'for the Limerick reactor re-ceived the above report which stated 3600 tons of grout cement was l

j

used; to' patch. defects in that wall. - Regarding the defective con-l

' crete the report further states that1P.'E. personnel (1) did not check'that something was wrong _until,many' loads of concrete were e

placed,. (2) that.when found out did not report.it, properly, (3) y

/ nor make ' required ; follow up proc,edures<. to. insure correction-8 Again AWPP contends that radioactive steam'that condensed and iseeped :through the concrete wall (I'.E. (86-02) was capable of seep-Ting through'because of poor concrete placement.

l

[

,3That was in 1976 the pattern ofscarelessness continues: App-Lm E6 ro'ximately 120 LER's of inexcusable; careless',' contemptious acts, f ; g.n. MMaliphbs.geheigas;whichicouldjcontia' min' ate.

g (like3 missed' inspections, missed fire; watches,3ctc.

One could have g devastatedjPennsylvania.1rA detector was installed,to' detect leth-

!q wD

.x

% [> 9 A W LimeEickereactoricontroli/ room...'thc Nery' heart?and. brain'ofdthe.od.,

'g G 9 @ @ 9 5'n&!o'rfnafetEafCAlnost/oWeSycadaf@cOinst'al'ldtionJit5aslcacci$@

a i

MJib/My - ide t'1%foiil"dithaty%]VMS@%Jh?.:

E the? phos $ ne @asyl'thEtor $ hichi.would souWdlcan % L !

Ww<&.%.m,#G Ni-I w &v r m.s wp >.Q11 m y @s N

h -:'. M W N f,Q M :2&D, W WW %;/ l (

t V

%;%, 4my

, ~, c Y rw; + GO x y n.,: m w N,

r y

/

%y. ~ r.

. uq sF10

. c o.'

• b,*$ ' ;... x wp2 g u-v f a.s yg 3~

n

~<e a

p af:y v g # A,&q@t w,plg...YUy!*.Ws.W @u, v

i

J$C C4%,lj;; JLo3 N.

' 4-i 449 LZ D ul$

G

?

! 's.Q. c':;A]50 h 5&k-Qlh+g,juA

.m p $ W h N:. 9 pO*$ V i :&

g

'Wy,*,

M, hrs, }

"%~

'- i Nca<W

~

bl h &S:..N b

i& Q)C Q Q 1; &}e Q y Y' {n w Q $"%a $1???f *.* K l ~

Q%pj

.Q WM&;Qj. f' MT wem,.f f

k m %, Vi %' N W W g? k

,a~..u, y --

v

{ j, L ' v.

+

p

[~9 j

• y 1

~

w i wf*

i.

9

r m. i-ww'v 7-vFP"T ' W ~7P~'W'D'H

?.&v;,l.,lw.p? wW-Y- $u.cU&?. 0V

.;.. ?^n.$.;Tl wv ng~. s

,a n'

vm

" m.., esq;a:. n,.

e p+c.m: a.,

.it?

Mp @Q,..B+{Supplenient { ofIAWPP"dfj FebM'G"m. :4v. D F ?.. :

8

,:y y

nY'Wek L

%' tM,.s w: ?

24,4::9862r: esp.eonsc 'soittinue'd? ?.'N.?,

~

z

.w r

' fg @f '

M?

g,j m sy

_p-y V

h.

..j.,a g, -,37

- g -

o t

. T p

4 falarm Ohen ph'osgene reach'ed the,Jdanger limit'o'f 3 i%,

S l p$

~

. ion

.5 parts ly left at 50 ppm when installed.(ppm), ~ would not he' ' activated because the l

j

~

s careless- !

Think of it...for almostione5~

j year, if there.s would sound until the gas reacted 50 ppm,;with all controlJroom=had c

j,,

1 operators dead at the controls. ~Such a situation.couldimean a run-m

' ~ ~ ~

~

away meltdown accident. bringing. death and* devastation tolthe State of Pennsylvania.

" Dangerous Properties offIndustrial Materia'ls".,

the chemists Bible, conforms that in a quick build-up "there may be no immedi-ate warning that. dangerous. concentrations.of the gas'are being

' breathed", and that ~ ptiosgene gas' [at} ~ "50. ppm q,',

is rapidly fatal 'a f-

[

ter even short cxposure".

Exemptions and imporper follow up'of this type of situation 1

and its potential for-accidentidemands;there be no exemptions since there y

is alreadyiEco many3 safety' questions, s

as above, to j

.; allow other leeways.

P J

b. h -

.@+ -

The mishap.at. the1Kerr-McGee*Sequo. :..

l f

mv.

a worker and radiatedforhe'r's exciplifies':\\yah plant Kwhich k,illed ; onei i

plants which spawn ~s (tin. l5,,,3 ievableierro' si.,(read Seg'uoyah) -the contemptjlaE r

w m

%,p y

feels Limerick { is !an^%y, identIw,aiting:'to' happen AWPP q

s c

wc y;( j w p f,that,increasedrInadequate evacuation 1 plans beggthatith,ere be noiexemptio.w/> - A

-+

.s n s D..J. b e g ~.

1 care (b'e}t kenP.Th6tldsh[ " ' * ^ ~

g

. Respectfully / qbmitted*.

(

s

., s

', K~'.sMyM,biha n o, c

.M s

DFrank'R.

Chairman b

AIR &' WATER POLLUTION PATROL 2

y.61 Forest' Ave.

4-

. o; _ y ;. Ambler', 'Pa. 19002

{,'

h $.

,h f S.

F 1.

/

I j

6,

- { g- - f 1

t' '

I s

i e

s p{ '.

)

r-

>I g

I a,

L &

a s.

~S t

y

• '*/

y t

t

. c,W.

9;fx:+shW &< f. Q, s g. ('q l ^ ^

j Y

,,l :,.. M.,%

n,

?

o w

j

.O

,.. - (: QN. f; by.

.Y y

, c,

. a.., w at w h,;,!.cdd M M 8)s/3,,M MNM*n$$[ U. 3'"[?

?d ^$,MN h ?' < kd'

+,..

a 1

h &..

A,p m M:

9 m w la @d e s,yW S Y;$

? ? N & g Ml W Nr $ $ g & %.3 e sl @ 4 9 aw

,,.: w L O

WWWOW

&m m

m

h_hW'fYhhk:wuhh hp 3.

. &L,wN i

v-b g,..;

,f t

r-N -

yg a n gymv4 h,.pk.

r eN bbkhhb >

g,mq,h q-

??+ ' ~;m)

1. ,W

t fyC %m!

V ;y.C 6:N,-lt ?W

• f' p/

Q; & 'p! *fr f*,

+/;q. ?%

< s?Q w g. ' a y

^Wb,

- e.

e.

y

. :;,4

. I, t.,

.l

-- _