ML20115A844
Text
.
........--.......;,,,.,,,_7,..
=
/** %',g
, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION UNITED STATES I '-I.((~;f -
f WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 April 17,1979 Note to:
Dom Vassallo Jerry Wilson Tony Abell Sybil Kari LBill Lovelace l
Jim Coughlin will be in on May 3 at 9:30 A.M.
(my office) to reclama the results of our Marble Hill CFP visit and conclusions. He also wants to discuss his proposed tendering of the FSAR in May.
I would appreciate your joining me in the meeting.
4 Roger S. Boyd t
I E2 L M 81 UdV 6M!
. J N C?,:W 8504160198 840606 PDR FOIA KILLEFEB4-367 PDR
APR 2 31979 MEETING NOTICE DISTRIBUTION Docket File J. Knight NRC PDR S. Hanauer Local PDR R. Tedesco TIC S. Pawlicki Branch LWR #4 File F. Schauer NRR Reading K. Kniel H. Denton T. Novak E. Case Z. Rosztoczy i
D. Crutchfield R. Bosnak D. Bunch-R. Satterfield R. Boyd W. Butler R. Mattson F. Rosa R. DeYoung V. Moore D. Muller M. Ernst D. Ross R. Denise D. Vassallo R. Ballard D. Skovholt B. Youngblood W. Gammill W. Regan F. Williams G. Chipman J. Stolz R. Houston R. Baer J. Collins
- 0. Parr W. Kreger S. Varga G. Lear P. Collins M. Spangler T. Speis V. Benaroya W. Haass L. Hulman C. Heltemes H. Ornstein ACRS (16)
J. LeDoux. IE L. Crocker Principal Staff
Participants:
H. Berkow A.
11 Project Manager, J. Wilson
. Lovelace Attorney, ELD IE(3)
SD (7)
Licensing Assistant, M. Service i
Receptionist L. Rubenstein L. Soffer h,5 0 R
9 1 \\M 0;f,1 C P 0 ~O 1.
r-MEETING NOTICE J. Knight Docket File S. Hanauer NRC PDR R. Tedesco Local PDR S. Pawlicki TIC F. Schauer LWR #4 File K. Kniel NRR Reading T. Novak H. Denton Z. Rosztoczy E. Case R. Bosnak D. Crutchfield R. Satterfield D. Bunch W. Butler R. Boyd F. Rosa R. Mattson V. Moore R. DeYoung M. Ernst D. Muller R. Denise D. Ross R. Ballard D. Vassallo B. Youngblood D. Skovholt W. Regan W. Gammill G. Chipman F. Williams R. Houston J. Stolz J. Collins R. Baer W. Kreger
'O.
Parr G. Lear S. Varga M. Spangler 4
P. Collins V. Benaroya T. Speis L. Hulman W. Haass H. Ornstein C. Heltemes J. Ledoux, IE ACRS (16)
Participants:
S. rnri
+
L. Crocker
/ s. Lovel h H. Berkow
- d. Schweibinz Project Manager: J. Wilson Attorney, ELD IE (3)
SD (7)
M. Service Receptionist L. Rubenstein L. Soffer 8 6 gj g; gy, ( g L';I :v.:.7.
.a MARBLE HILL PROPOSED AGENDA FOR CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL. MEETING February 27-28, 1979 February 27th 9:30 a.m.-3:30 p.m.
1.
Overview of construction management organization and activities.
2.
Overview of project construction schedule including major milestones and schedule for licensing.
3.
Procurrement management and current status of major components including hangers, snubbers, pipe whips, valves, piping and etc.
l 4.
Construction status and problems including bulk quantities (Total estimate cuantity and quantity status of HVAC work.
%L installed to date ), M l( & _
O
,,...J.) w L
A.
Concrete B.
Structrual Steel C.
Large Bore Pipe - 2h" i D.
Small Bore Pipe - 2" 4
E.
Hangers, Snubbers etc.
F.
Cable' Tray 3 G.
Conduit i
H.
Cable l
I.
Terminations i
~~'
p 5.
Engineering organization and current status of design /
engineering activities.
6.
Actual and proposed craft work force, craft availability, productivity, potential labor negatiations and problems.
7.
Current status of pre-op test procedure writing and integration of pre-op testing with construction schedule.
Pre-op test schedule and number of engineers writing procedures and performing pre-op test.
8 Construction scheduling staff:
A.
Method of calculation of percent complete.
B.
Method of monitoring rate of completion, identifying critical path items and implementation of corrective actions.
C.
Critical path activities, logic network and computer printout of critical and/or near critical items, i
- ~m
- e-**
% e... w. h. m w.*. %
,. %.4 1
e 2-t February 28th 9:30 a.m.-2:00 p.m.
Tour Marble Hill site to observe construction activities
- and present-NRC staff conclusions.
k k
4 l
- f n
i 9
L S.
.?
t-ROUTWIG AND TRANSMITTAL SLP 1Ek emne syneed, mens amater, temete Date Agoney/ Post) l w__
- s. Y l
[ Mt.lACG l'"IW v
\\
.m, 5
state and Itetum Aetion Fee-noseeves per closeense per convwesuen 3
AsItseuested For caemellen Ptepose Reply j
Dieselste For Your Infennation SeeRio
.. _)E-
^
Investigste Signature i
T t 2^
Justur
+
l W W W W. w. 1/ek I
LwA m
tw~g' e
y
-o.-
.+. ~,..,
m
.A m; a *0 es5.
4p :,; f._,,
r
- p, u ce.w:..,
(h DO 900T use thie tenn~as a 11E00010 of eenounenese, espenale, steenness, and settene fee.
f yOftes 41 (Itev. 7-76) essa-see
" #8
~8 "
f
- s.o.ese en
-eas/ esse
l L.* *,p gly
>, 9 s y.
,? d
.. 'a c 4
0
' * ~ ' -
ff [M-
~
- e. w. w
..: ~.
n
.g w e*,
... g m r
s 4
l. 0-
- ' *' Le V * ?mb;, "
- p,
r -
s
- f's J*
-'.f.i.~.
44
.j - k ' h.
$'+
)
g'
- f" M
N 4F f-
'O Th.
4 e
g g' hy
Q G-k a
~
_hfsf 91 F kt&
18_[ ~
{&7
- A
3 0
80Q 4-..
g+ ' - T. M* / - f ' '
g.,
- r
.3,
/ #f ;?.. ', ~,. / w a f,4 i,. + ' '
~,.
(
f n @, *,;f } }g'ggg.f. ly[.at., - GQ::R:~p ;
6 l g.. y n_ >1:..
_
- M m.
%)
b_y 0 a i
3 a,.,,,
e.,...,
),,.,,
/
(*
[
/
y#-
W*h'p g
r.
l%
5 4)$ k ^ 3,h. $'5 & %.W & ~
ey$ s, ) 3*
' ~,
y, a
./
-.,h'.(,X-4,'
$25..w%p W p9..,.. 7g. s ~ -...,k.g.g...,,.a mg. 3 '4 y
p% w i
qi-g yT g h.,.,,..,% g,,
m.
.4,.,,
3C 2,
< e 9-2
- .. ~ - w,. y~. % _wejr
,4. g s,,b.,
- f,-
J*.
g*f,i.,. a
.,.%f4 Q +.- -.-
f ih A$
- Alupts,.,s 03 u.
~
w y -
- b.
g 4
a.,.,
b,_&.
h f)]lj f?
9,),;&
. M %^ 3.n.s a w,
- ;d p;w e m m. a
)
f s., ppm W-a
. s
'%('
^. q_
5.
~
,y
/J Ar
/o/d.qA
',- 'o
+
[
J
. <f B&'
Y' s
,y'.
.f b b.
A/.,[l,) k h " '
., f
i-
+
b-me r
s.
f.e Lui n -1 la/77
- m, 9
~4l'/h?
-f S..*
C.P.
~
- c. '....
3,
.L
' '; [
s
/
s h Q,.,2',[.h,/ 5
--[f'(' 5 4
- 5 U
., =
v
- ..., < y v., m.. c - -
p f
.p -
j Q N Q C w Q 'j.' g M % F c
~
' ~
8, 4
' 1 p. $) d'. Y k.
,,., NU[, * '~
r d?
?"
,e W
[.
{
d1 y
"y gM h
kw_u -
~
i, l
a 4
e
-,. 4: 9
- g.,
. w.,uw
- ?
-g u., r.,- xt O
-f k~
- -A a.
agybgg,-b g.
l
, n... n n,.. n., m.s v
...+.w'
~
. r
, c,..,sg4.
4g...
fytypy,4 e.
2
- ')('
8 g4 4"_'
f' v'"
'[
g' h.
- 'h ' l 8'-
3
+
=.[
a
]
e.
-#6e l
t
',ij Vj,}h*
_ r_
..;~%,
. ;j~
y Jas,
4 *,'
- t
,y o
~
L Nrw u.a.wp.
~
4 l
l C
1
{
a h
h L
fMW
/-
5
'p tt!
4" k.
"W.
8 #
- s
a t
a4 g
~ s.l
{f&* n'-l
? f.l y {
, A').h? );-
t s
9.
.~
+
n.
.-.-<.y w..l-z; i.Q
\\
}
i e
Y
- w.. * =
p
- , % s.'
r i -
~
?. 3 l 4." N " Q t).,j %
% '3 ~
~
W ',
e J*
+
'e e
p
[
Y
+
.%,,. J,,
/h k
M.
2 7
r. - *,,
y
~ rl
!) Ly&
'f*$
f.
' '4*'
' ' b
"Y
^ * * ' ' "
~ fn3 f 2
~
.S
. w-.r,y #w g g h.~m.W, Wc,9-
,,.7 s v.
,,, ;. :, w q v-
, a'+~
,n r..- c..,.e
~
'4 p
rC
... +...
L ;Qe.;i;[>.b d), /.- I
"),,,,
g' e-A
^.,..
.. $N~
4
.g
.....9
-'*"E:
- #M )
I'~h h '
~
1 *
-f. '.
h &y :;--f. Q, ' %
}<-
f f g Q,q.[:;';.Q y g>
gyq;^lQf $47,fG-Qu k
s
'ff y. ; $ 4 Q %, < q) gw::;f,,Q.
$ & g 57) h - y_am' i -
.y-i~
e m~.
.n s up c.-' 4 -
- ; ;) - ' " -
p x ;.c ww,:/
- m e.
e
~. ~
- w <
. w v N.%.w..D, ri Add,...-[
- 1. Q "'f6 M hO:"&.'i'*P'b,,b.? W[fD,~# N...*M,c*\\.'Q /#N'5 N.*(^ fY.k N.
Y.
n M J'j.' O 1, J 'd 3,N[p
_ Mg * *
^ -- -, p h.,. ' ^- [ ' "
........I 9
' d5 e.-
g*'
f 9p Y
8%,.s-A.
A, # M [
p M
k
'Oy y-
_gg j
- f. Q y,
'}
' '* ~ " P t ?, W.' <
- A W '* I f
.}_ ~ p,f,
( l* * ] g g
ay
+
s s
j g
b
]
(8 L
j L h,-
d $0D 4
/
-t-
_. 3
..w.g s,; e u g %.. w p-4 &, 1
, 9 _
x:
r,. Qcqv. 3 z, S e d ><GD L. 3 %
^
ps
'~
somn ~,
I - N
-c Ar, ? U,f,.oeo nid pc Xp-= ' t 14.*..
'. f;
...p-r
-,'r,
.. J-- ;/
s t
y 7 j. b~
\\
/; k ro. m d _ M ah h
- a A k
L m _ T 1r " '2/w M5 /j E.12 2
~
o n.
c.
- - - c
' ' ? & %,,{' ff tL*}
'ka'
- {, % f -
s qw
_.=e.
*W
~
p e hi. g 4 p
d l,'
_l
?,
y r_..,J e k.
~
^_
/.
.Ih s={
h s l'-
'.s E
A s#
".m m W y.;
L-v y
P,[ a.? h.f47 dib.-%o L L..smlm*.ypw3 y,'
ah Q :-5. a
[dne, g,
(,(>
I E --
m;,w -a.x::,9
.,p i m
,3, :-v-vs,
)
(_
c+
y. ;;h i $l h &,
Q [(.h j
}^
V.
.w e -
u.
f ? ?,-
('fl&
,, '/>
l+
,Y**'-
_, ne I,.
l/
Mh'~
s' 4,.Wy g-)* (,.o60
~
m =, - >_Af.,,.
.;,, a s wm
- c, o g ;.-
(,
g-
+
v
(
...r>
,,!, e.
'l l.
- a. A vbl&..o n t.x. 4 ( ' ' *L L'.4 ; 4 S,pje V ~ - - -
J
. e.,
M.,JV2
- l. '
,1I,
-.,j,
.s j
s tz a e ' - - n*P; l v e t.
~
z r
+
4"_
. No'D I
ds:b wgS -
h.
w "N Y}E '
'tyujj fl_u.
j f.
~
, 4 y.o
~. :;g
.q q
+
s.
(
H $55' a., d S_y...
a
/ M> ',Z dw
=
J-
. _, - w
,o h
f
-- am emp..p w.
.m.m.go-=
.m e g
,-k 6
4 w
k
..,.gw
-d y
.g
. e ca.
-s
,m v
e'-
d e
.e to
- N.
a'8'*
]gg., -
g hg hg'
') N k T
4 e
g (. ;b*
>k [*
74. *
[+
f i h k 7, __...
[f 9
. M. * ?,
,.g -
r e.w-
.i
..< ;,. v (.W G ^
s;,-
,,r, s
y
- I' #I <
3 *. *. ' ' '
.M, r
l '.T'
~
e
- e'p3 r.. -.'
-rs-j
.'~ $ '. {
r A48V.*
s i
y t
i ~
0Ah.
, s y,, p:.,*.p g
'. Q ',.m'y %. 's~ L Y L.,? Q uw>.., &~.
- r. v,.
>m
- i s
_c
,m..
~.=
~-
}
n-s, n
A.
A
&a c
mnanmaa.
m [.
(,_,.m b
- C 1
}
1 $
Ma S
E 1.+M p:+w'-1a.e I a, F~.e.s =.-d N h w *m.sps.
.Wf -
[
.d
.. 1 i s:, i.
- x.w..
n.
}fe- -.
w~c x,, 9 -
<; 3 F'+; W~t :^
s g'...
c.,
%.
- r :
g
[fg' gg t,,p
. ~
wu.w:, :. ~..,v.,. mv.
.,. ~
s..
c
.c.
s' g'
Y#
Q h
- e 1.'
.h. f 'N* ;
.5 h (b-Qa Y, g';. V
- f** ?
0';
' ftf ' k 3ml-
- N'f Ytf L
//d M' f'
,p-
[,
,4-1#
,h '%#f $
=+E nim. r f
O=
2 eu q74 ~ (~ w)k'**'r=' 8m 47g
._,r
.q.#.
p
.c-
- [t t d Q y.* 4,. #.
84
, g' g "
t J
i g.s 4
3 Qs a
~.
... v
(
v s.
u
., -., - s,m s
-,ya r
s s
. - +
)g 4
m
[
6 gt a
g
'd
,.l..-
p
. 4' -
t 6
< * *,r tg y m'., ~ s u :; -j g g ;_
f.
,c
.,,,.e-
,rn>
eme.m-.-
)
1
- I. - [
,*I
( ;4 e
~
J e'b...; f '. r.g '- '.1, p 4 J,-
7 1
[
6
+
' -...,.,-.Q
.,LCf% Q*~j;Q'g,,Q Q f.,
t W.
1
,.M b-f b
. h.
h
+-
f, T -
a
- Q' y*.? j_f*; &, y 'f, s, w Q.,,.
'. _Z %, *.-
~
9 4
.e
.h ap.s,I' g,,.
g g
e l.$
,__,, " #:e- ;
d ?&w.. +
- a *
4.,
,y e'n 35 l
- A *g a'h. ph,Q c,'.1 av
- m. f. Y. ', x-p..', w 3 *, gs,5 g p a v;.
'A o.
- g 9 q.y e. s g
? ?.Q. %.%, u,w M Q. n% <- ??.. f.n = > h w:. )^ k.,
- p% ;< s5 4.e.v, 6
4
. ~
e.e
.e
- rm w n
s Y 'Oh:4*'N'$i
% s.;
=
'. *> I ;: f i > N '
l $ ' i Y % W- ?.Y Na y $ h;I
~ h s#
(
b
- 4, 'W,, 9, e +p.?.. qg$.-Q.. p,7,1; f. g, m@c.M~ N_ M_;W i.g.;;,i4,*a $
[
6,,ag,
?
- s. i Q.
- A.; w
,., a e..
c
.. s.-
-.s-p 3 '.s, f, r,, h :.n,r e f, ~., Lf.- : + f.'Q ' ' vAkJ}
.'s,
- -. ~w y p :
i r;.
y s.
y.
yu a
,, e
- * - s
}.
,5 9
[
g*
e 3
d' 0
.f I'
s 5
,g
- 4
'-e%i hg p A5i S i' 7 w,4 8[p '
){
- r F
r 3
3
,,.1.
t
'"Q ( & ; - ['*
K jf
'***9
%f%.
- 9' ;,, '. * *f'
- Q e
[N $ 9f36
" - # f.
4 4 ( ', \\
- [<.
w I'
.a ' % '
- . T. ++
F.'
. g' f
4,
- 2
~
I
- 3-(# $
f
.d*
>p 4
j
~
t
,I, j
s s
l
.3-s d
~
).
..g y 4[
e 8
w e.
p
,1P'-
% d
- M l,
e=
t
- e
.N g
- 4 s
.y
- 7,,..._. s
_._._y_
7.* W }x?,-.fi p~.ci-Q.GO,1.', f-V.r?.r P..: b~d '4 t
T
}
_ a,*4
- ~,
L n
f 4
'.~
v
- (;s. g;g g,
)
-c
- ^.
'.4j p. *, j
.g.,. j y
s.
J. : -
MG.
. 4!,
..- 4..
A e
.s
. p.s.,,....-
.t
,.-m a-p,; y 4.w. +, -..
~us s
.,.n.,-
,v.p.,
.. x;.
.p. -
3; *py_ gp f [g.
n c
5.<. N.,, v.t.: e o, m-. m f e
+
t
.x, Y 7.&w '
e f:
()fgp gj 3
e.
3 i
v
.N.
jf-e r
<.s... ~
gf
..g.
47 ;_gg.
- y. # %. _ n e.-
.,s J' we 4. < sv.>
M w
t
,u f
li.'k.Y 5* %
~
hOYe OOO D. ' &, 'f
~5:Q. %d,Q&&
Qlr.
yj;;.y gj,,
f sa.
~~
(v
~ d'.V
[f '
lf-
.. ~. 3 q~[,9 9pg 3.q.g.
z.
q,.,...,,,
L n = +L,, M&.8% & k.:sA..l (q;.Asw
' ?l2$/. J.;/
%,p.,g. g.gg g
p I
- 9m aQLy,,
'a g Qlg'QQp: ygn. ;.r.
f -
j k;" ;:f % g 6 y-
" * ~ " *
- w ~m " '
.Q9 7//
n ca p..,
~'
~ X u 1 i
/M3
/1A 2.- '49 4:> - -
J.'
~*- -
h l
':.yl.
." > i :. A.
- %.Q.-q[;y3. 3,~9)5 c;ppy e[.;e -
4 y
.A
...-r. _,,
. ~~:.-
i
+
=
a.
... - W. u -n."..gs",'
,.m l
/n9 /4 m
thhs
.LS%
7"
~~
-:+.
~l' l
y-b l. M'3 O (l
l
. l'
- ~
~
- ^*
I s
w-,>p ; y e, i,.
i.
q
..s - 2.
n y ' :.
..s a, e.
g t 3. d-L,xs.
,?
~,
J2 sa
/
+
-[
.4.
.e...%
1 e-r, t
.<.s.:
b
)$.
3p n
y_
.y
.-w,,.;-.
)
1 y V1 ', '
\\
6 t
Y
~
>~4
..1...,.g
' a.
s.r.
,e,x
.p.
.g
_ n_m_ _n.__
n_
n.-
.t.nn
- --=.
.s
-t i
y cu.
~
^ '
r_I e
M I8--u s
s
.' ' '.,_ ;.,, oo. v;ge.w d;gg,W.g gi.;#4f.pu s.y y.
g 3.a ; ~'
~.
,4 hy;; ai Q W:pp higQpph ae..y a
- .y.,., Lfg ; QQl$yf A, } %.dfy.pi.O (..
l.
'. < m, w.
m
,.3..
, p;,, -A
..., y e. g' w.C.., J;p g vgg Wg,, ggstygg.w;,p g.. A,.. g.,.g e ;,,,.,
,w
._,.z....
c.
_i N^'
h
"/IAA igisk L m0I.i Y IlifUS
. C/ :., ; x. n m. ' !*v +.
r -.
3..
grq c r
~
- ..a a f a
~
r % r,
.+ y. i, y,
m.&t, sk' g y
7'14.y -
'ti' d
t F v h-
,J a c c-t 4 9. < ? >. ps f.a..
7 4 g e'.',, e
)
s i
(
,. +
.s
)
-, ~. c -. n8
- f :.,
.. u s-t e
- y 1
1 s
9.i
- t; -
1, s
o..
g t '.;;,4
, - y i ; 3 'i. A,y,
~.\\,;. ; + 2 y+ c g g g G.ff.,.; l 's ;
3 y.
3 _,, * :Q; *
)
.< s
w-
)
1 9M-Q/pi
'e
'.,T yd S 44.,p I.p
-- O h,,'
[
- M3-f
',Npdf11Nf*J,M l r-s,,
- _... ;. :. n... t p
i n.
s o
+
-,m
.e %
i vi f g,
,J t
.-l ry->
Y
)..
b g w a. rn... e r
a e
'I*
- [
~
' M f__
M m_
T-r
[&
- } QQ f.
a r
l
'a
- n V.
- 12. v L $ j.)f. --
-v...d +f'jl3
/, b b, *
- F'15 l A.
$ f.; & kf;f
. r :']. )<o
..+ h l\\lf ' ' '.
- $ f
?
A-f w
,'ae V
g,
4'
%b p./
'T.
g 1 a Q
(
'4 b
s'g.,,
m
,s. qw
..s
% g, a
.apy
/
9 3
~.
,. 9..,- w -.2._.s E
a
'+
[ ' '
['
/
f 9, &,i, xyy'Mof;,,nf;%t; ? ~.,,ff,1 g. t.
~
1.' % f R~ y.d.T, ~tjk:
G \\
- ~* 3
- s
~hv
" n; s
y s. _ u.
I
- f
[
di-i'g. p d,,
88 p
g p/,. nky. -
- q w 4 % g;p;:g y ; Q 4 y s M W c m.n m V.
t o
(" I,', ' ' j g P
k *
- 4 m
1
[
e A p
}gf phQ
,V,' b. 2 m
- ;i t
a u.
j
~
- J.h.gh _
\\},}
['
w + *
',e s.
O h-
- A A
lA t.s
/
r a
~
~ '
t f nm P
N w
-)
} *)t -
a
._yv: v.,. w.
.c urv-
}
.. w p o y It w w V i M. N : ? ' L' M.
~
t.
Y
)
op em o;G%o110.t wn+
5,=>E,b A~
k k.D u
- ~,
?
'y 4
3
,; a#,...
s b
h N 4
'N-ww.
,=J g **,
.5 P&g'l
~
8 t
d --
4 9
~., ' -,
- i.., w
, a
.W-a.w g r. h s n.. w m m...,ys, %, W ; M /3.Q. y1i; WM.pt.; LV.
+,.:. ~;. >,,. -
d S,
'9 p'J '$ ' T ;e f
E gf
,4,,e fE * ) '"" 4' 4
A
[%
l,.. :w : c
'4
..f
,b
-?:...,.$it y, 94 9%9%v; %.; ;&u:W
+; n. -x y -
h_ t_ m > J.. :._- 1
'E lW~
'** ; ~ ' '
^ * '
}A
&,*eN*
- 9'.t,-.
S
- RN,W p >,tk sh
~
soi g
w
% g, w.
Mr 4
'[ " *i
'I j
c; c
[ ?f w
/ ;h i "*v s
- % g ;
e N.,
.f._
g t'
7 3
u m,.
~
a M
F I
4 7_5 t he d
,y-
[
,,a \\..
i D[
r I
{
s P [v.
m i
~ -
g
'e
+
5 F
m y.. A e r: s yyedw m<
l-WO W.w s u j':,,._
v
,p-.,-
0 ' q. ; f4i I
.e.,,
s g..
p.;, g.-
g e
b' b
1 g
- 4. j*w.-
p
- ,4*7 1
~...,,
(
' #5 5%_S.6 1 w_c I40-79 i
4,o y, g g a d l e E s.. u
% W f.
<. m m. m s-w w e.. w
,g pMs'
[,
['
g
'y
(
N
\\
.. ts s
s a
/1.
'-g A,
a "k
L.h j
g ",
r.g
{
ht%7 t
.. ' ',,, er f-%gy *
- 89 As' 9*
'f i,g 3m --
1.'
+
4 k 3I
'4*
%ap
'e f
/
v' 6
g n.
SL _ e t.
m - m
.. % g.e -
I-4!*
~ ' ? f _f : E h -
'h
}j.
{
._-a
=j _
y k _',
,4 p
i i
+
Y '
h4,O TM g.
a, m-e q'"
),;
y+.,---
-L.,
m e g
-e..
,I 5
e.,
r
- 4, 4-.
r
(
-f s
k
.*JP f
'.'p
,{ +.'f, (i i M' a
' I. E, t
F '-*
s E
,r.
,. s...,.
6
. y,,
.; 9 - i
[,
4 g
y
/
4
(
a
_}
. 1_
- h
-l
- f
_. Y L ).
3-r w
w w_
L_
/ W
'.2 m-_i M, M [:. n..,.~2' $ *[ &.
h e.
w k-1 y
F t
j=ze> -_J)A.,Z W
- cir,W..c
/
- , w#, sagd"% n ?
- sf g ss
- w
',e t s, J;.<%p
^
e__
/ 2.,
s
- Rt-
-A--
- g. a n.
y.,
y, 7.;
vd;-6 3
- 9. i g,., ]
9-:
9 m
,. ;.. - -..,, ;;. ' ::ei.,8,v,Q..vir%4 m.sy+-.
n r,
v r
-,. m u m s.=
up
% 6,
- ~ % ' _., :%: 2 _OjY k.? G # % ;4 % "*.9?C 2 :.t k o % Z? T %
m O-
/:
n, w', Q X; ?f ;
s n:5 + a v-m Y
a m.
..r w..
4, ' 'b
_es "y
y,
- ^ Y W'k l
f-55 y4 w
p 4
9
,b-sew
' k. gb, % Y '
.i
=%
N'--
Y
~
L
+%.
-s a
I
{
s
-s
\\
~
s du I
~
t w
....w 4
j
S
} 5.i k.
1 f
J t
....._.....p f ~ ;fll ; 5f'$'hl l.cf e
[
- ' /p
_$ "?$ t
-~>
- a g
i'
' - ('
~ '-
'f,Q c
w.
gg
.; Q.,*
,i~ /
.d 9
t~...v
- 7*% 3 ;L.I' '. L
- f. :
.} r.
e
.,[*-
\\
- 1. ',o' c Y,.f
-$'S
' *', j 4
>z
, ~
s
- m s, ::,
., ; i. l q ~xf,: i[,.:.
c:
~
~
9
/ *.r
,' pum.,
%i#
- P r
yy
%m.+.ud -.f::
r
~
e
.. +
+. - -
w.u.=
u,
.m e: H Y.
t
- 0
. t1 n -
a813s_ci-: w
/24,,.Gbp Q,)
piew
- n. ? ? - W L& #: y -r Q,?,h'lm....S h6
__h_ $O'-
.~
} Il e S &
- u.,:m, w'*4$ 7 Y n, n. ; n.m... '
- +C f =
2
- -n
-,_. % >. D f :-
. ~
g }, E, f >1!_1
- %O n L L.
.g w a.,
u w ey g
.c
_ y-f- ) Q Q /u y
n 1 -
t.
.a
'[ h
[pg / /-'J M,c N Uah> /4
. il fb O g : 4 /*
O e d 1, ? h e
a u
I ks. ' g
. :. 4
,,v c w rys.p
..7,.y; g g y. c a. u s w ye g
._ s (L / 3,;l.cu
'O*
QL
.t v
y e,g eb m.~. ~ n,, n m
~.. v.c,s g.,
d.<>.
... a w en.,
^ - i-a g i
see t
y-r-m.,
^ '
$"+
f
})m - - --
4 m
~
w c
eIEmuRD i
f , ~'
,.y -
u p ;.ry.
f -.
s'o. on o O
o.C__
,k -
g g.
., v) f
- h
,,"y*
..s...
wm -
y e,f A
1 f
m.i.
M g
, g
~
e we p
e
.~..
~,
f
~
r
.,-,m.+
q.
4 m, -
,,s
..,.~
+.
- - ~
~
- s.
- 7. p,. m
+-
f 6f+mRw? ' ' g.- - -
^-=
- y z; :. p g, y, Q i g g g} C,,7 y,; ;,. A ay/fr *g p%,{ 41.4 A m j1 yL,
- r >.*,
s F
-.Ag.e qf-8 k
f r
k p %
.a%; c. g ;
, p gg : ~,9,, +,,;;,..y.
y.v.
d 5.,
4g.
es;
,". ye t.
E... (,..,
s
. - 4 e
'M s
,, rr
+,, -
y k
{.
.q, ud g
g g g
% g "d
.m p.
.~
s t
f as w
t i
I n,.
f
'+. ;. *
[
~+ '
4-9^
}
p
- sv v s,
s c
p
j h)ith71 meef aiki standaEds ^
--~
~
NRC admits. wrongs in M'arble Hill tests
~
svaa stava more '
Tom Dettdo, a lawyer with Save The ' 'Aptd and again in July to review its uruchon to begin pgam.
Madison. Ini - The Nucicar fleg. Valley, own testing standards after the llowever, if a defect was found, E"'"E' *"E***
E*
ulatary Comnussion has admdted it yglE NHC edatJeshed testing stan-ing M m4 meet statistacd entena. M beWMM W We did ad meet its own standards an tests dards and insaged those standards be uh w kconste kgan. W W used to permit condruction of flee used in determamng af the. plant should "The (NRC) staff was wrong and "Almost all the tirae all the enn-MartJd 1I:11 nuclear power plant here.
reopen, Detdo ad didn't meet its own crdena* Dattdo crete is good." Ikshop said referring to
.in a letter to Save The Valley. an Cendruction of the facihty was said.
the tests anta nuclear power group, and Putdec halted in 1979 when an investigation BRAD BIsilOP, nuclear division ' In the letter, the NRC requested all Service Indiana, said Wednesday the! parties involved in the case to media services supervisor for Pubhc Service indana, owner of the pla:st. revealed concrete work was faulty.
their opinions by Wednesday on what the NitC said methods used by its Construchon at the facihty. began agency in testmg concrete at Martde agam in March.
PSI. found no faults in samples of the NRC should do about its testmg listi were - stat Macally incorrect. said Save The Valley asked the NRC in concrete,it tested before allowmg con, problem.
ilOWEVER. DATTit.O said he
- -~
wasn't sure what else his group could
.. J..Q..,,.jf.,vuce, s(),4c.
adJ to what it has already submitted.
l'1
", cn::scre..
g n,o c. ooos As far as we're concerned, the WPPSS COnce,5 r-o6-nest move beiongs to the NitC siall.-
.E*.
- F*S*
.P*0*
he said.
{
" " ' ^ ' ' ' ' " ' ' ' ' ' ' " '
'"I'"'I*""^**"'*""E Dattdo said his group does not e
- annUO, m0eha9 IsII stall.
is that the commission meets its own Standards."
Althmengh thg Wanhtsigten IIewever. meine louching ggrlilIIM 317,(319 "Smce it hasn't snet its own stan-Pist,hc Power Eupply Syn, esp, to aceded en the agree.
$'/
- 7 0 s, dards, why 66 et necendsy to bleak to
,.tMl!MY tens has canceted a meettng snenta le maahball auhc
, anythmg else? We wdl not acceld ten nest week. It has scheduled projects Nom. 4 and 3 aml
. than that."
two this weck, a WPl%S that udt be dune at a spe-Construction delays have increased
{} *f O g
'the cost of the plant from orgmal cial board sneeling in spukensnaa satJ today.
it. V. Nummkowakt said ' Seattle Thursday.
eshmates m 1976 of $14 ladhon to 813 the annual anceting met Ier The newly le ed esecu-ladhon. The delays have set openmg of.
Nov. 4 was casaccled be-E8V* b**rd, whkh 1.as taken the gdant 144ck four years to 1966.
cause we have tseen in a
- *f ""*I *I th* P**f* *I.
Putdec Service Imliana plans to set
~. *JJ jlaglyasica, Jsac.
II"8 8'kl tsuard ad directors.
the dome on the first contamn*cnt series e.f meetings for the is te niect Vrtday in w^soouciore, oc zo '
building ak the f actidy Saturday.
pa6t two mecks and that's S**III'-
I'ent EA:
0 hes eneaugh."
The organimataan of the race raoe roo.
lie said the annual snect.
Ing la sinestly to teilew new lamard, whk-h uma en-panded te il mendan with - 1,ASCO. EASIIINGTON progrens and everything has tacca reviewed enuugh fouC Imn outskie WPI'SS.
TH1-CITY !!ERALI) in the assaratiana of succt-88 ** "*e agenda. Rules for gj 'f g g saga hcid in Seattle the the new lanard atae unit tad gygggg,
adopted, i.e said.
pad two weeks.
,SUleDAY -- 38,432 9
1
%en ]ntJhynce, 9nc.
wasumSTON. O C. soCCS Front edit Cther Page Page Page ft:33 $ntsNgence,.0nc.
LOU 1SViLLE, n.
W ASHINGTON. O.C. 20C03 ggg3 OCT 2 g 5
,,s.,
m c..,
,9 EVENING - 163,100 PHILADELPHIA, PA.
$larble Hill decision EVENING - 462.137 won't necessarily.
-"*d"'
be recon'sidered E8
'a
...t.
House votes.
,, me co.--on to revie. Se
.w...
Although federal officials have But an engineer hired by Save m fQ Qf pfQQ achaowledged that an insufficient Valley said at least 700 tests needed
=.s tamber of concrete tests were to be performed to ensure the 95 naq.
w enhg e.
VB3
.T T Q LUI made beforehand. they won't neces-percent accuracy rate required by sanly formally reconsider their de-the commission. The commissloc re-canoa to tuow the resumption of jected the argument and ordered Bulletrn Wastungton Bureau construction at the Marble Elll nu-concrete work resumed la the safe-csear power plant.
ty.related areas.
'The House Public Service Indiana received But to a memorandum to the voted yesterda'y to ban the dumpmg me go.shead March 27 to resume commiezion, a staff member said
'of any radioactive water from the coscrete work la safety related mat as many as 40 to 80 more tests damaged Three MHe 'sland @the ID areas at'the plant, about 31 miles up s4ould have been doce. The tests for nuclear power plant into he Ohio River from Louisville.
Sargent & Landy would assure a 90 Susquehanna River.
The five. member federal Nucigar percent chance of accuracy he said.
-Regulatory ("-*= ion wants its But he said that a different method By a voice vote. the proposal was prepare recomtnendations of testing would have provided the tacked onto the appropnations bill en me issue for a meeting Nov.13. staustical assurance the commission for the Nuclear Reguta:ory Commis.
-w The matter centers on the num-required.
ston, which is overseems the cleanup ber of concrete tests done in 1979 in Thomas DattHo. the attorney for of TMt.
the safety.related areas - the two Save the Valley, contends that the The commission has not approved reactor. containment bundings and commAssion is admitting it has not any plan for re'noval of the estimat.
n me a y buuding.
ed J00.000 gallons of contaminated I
spok id tse ut!!!!y water at the plant. Ircated on an is.
la August of that year the com* company has met the commission's,
land m the *,usquehanna 10 miles maston had ordered concrete work s'equire.ments, halted la the safety.related areas downstream from Harrisburg. Offi-because of questions of whether the cials of General Public Utilities concrete was sound and questions of.
owner and operator of the facility' wh er PSI had enough staff at the have said they believe there would be no danger m allowmg the water to Save me Valley, an environmental
$!owly tnckle into the nyer.
group that has led the opposition to The city of Lancaster, wh2ch l
the construction of the plant, re.
(
quested that the commisaton hire draws its drinkmg water from the j
tadependent engmeets to review the nyer after it passes TMI. has ob -
l 60 ultrasound tests. The tests were tained a court order also tantung the done for Sargent & Lundy. the gen-dumpmg of any water mto the oral contractor, and the fLrm that Susquehanna.
did them coactuded that the ap-Rep. Robert S. Wa:ker (R.Pa),
Prnatmately 90.000 cubic yards of sponsor of the anti <1umpmg amend.
coecre'.e already poured in the safe-ment, said he hopes the Senate will ty-related areas was sound..
also listen "to the.wtsbes of the peo.
That was the same conclusion
_ftached by the two,eogineers hired ple of the area and approve the House-adepted tan.
l l
$8'
=-- -Safety coq, need debated - -
w &m agwp%%engn 6&
AsMsEA 2e %D!
tle of morble Hilli 1*' N,4 --
-g e
- CJJ
- F8&p WARMtNWTO9t. D.C 2000T I
ri e ese os.c k
L 1,
INDIANAPOLIS, IND.
d STAR MAY 3 M.
j MORNING - 217,619
. SUNDAT -7,704 ^5** ~, l ) 1.5;3i e n.n
- m7 um er i --
_ m _. __ . af .._... nesimEENBE=_~_- 3 u,ik'ngEiUtYh0 - - nw n - - = r-NNW LN 'h-amraensassaccand3EMB3?EUI ._2 ...........___.__.__o,- 5,.f
- s m ua Am 4 3 2 1 m mt,= # M 5
.\\ m, N_ [g % NUN 1 1( NQg - S *Q i 1 g 'a. ./ .= ~P DL f'.7-7h.,h,.7
- l
,N t h. = g I, brker-ud<l ninforring nul to nmtaininent buil< ling tw fore rea.irn te i-Imun il C. o NT ,----,_--------,-,.r-, .-w--- i -ev-vy---=-
- w - -
3Cowf - W y M., A ku. n!q 3- /? VI By JEFFREY W. PETERS gaiety figures m two of tre mes: I. Star Staff Reporter ()PP'enente continue pesisterst quas - whetNr ceficiencies have lowered the plant,s ' Madison. Ind. - ! Ass than 10 in pore' (f uc3h.on> lin*5 ability tn contain dangerous rad:a-years ago. Viola Baker could 3as retnain annanswerrel tion and whether the NRC has been walk across the silent. wooded bluff tough enough in its insoegtsons tc on h'er way to fish ' e.ent Ma-ele Hill from becomm; pr Scarred only by a marble quarry state and federal regulatory agen-tte scene of the nauon's first nuclea-abandoned more than a, century be-cies. The battle eventually may catastrophe. fore, the area was rich in both move into the courtroom. Economics rears its head as well.- mmal Ilfe and history - arrow
- Eight years after plans for the as debate ine* eases over Indiana's heads were common and toortsts nuclear generating stauon were an-need for the power generated by the traveled many miles in hopes of nounced. the issues are old and well-twin nuclear reactors schedu'ed for discovenng, one cf the Indian hatch-known. But the controversy and the site. Opponents claim that its ets buried hundredarof years earlier. emotion they generate is as hot and electricity may neser be neejed.
. To Robert Gray. Save The Valley fresh as the fires in one of the nat would stick Indiana resicents chairman, and cther environmental-utility s coal-burnmg plants. with paying for a monstrous waste ists. the isolated bluff with a majest-For a laymar., the arguments elephant which has alreacy more ic view of the Ohio River symbolized often appear dt!fi.: ult. if not impossF than doubled m cost and remams at a face of the river valley which was bie. to enderstar:i All too often the least five } ears from complettor fast disappearmg. Already the giant debate is ennducted m the language smokestacks of electne power plants of nuclear pnysicssu or stock market From a distance, tre c:13 9: ".a d-nad begun to litter the horizon. analysts. The translation to Englisn ison appears to be flanked cs two Standing 250 feet above the s a challenge both PSI and the pairs of power plant smo.;e stacks snoreline. the emironmentalists saw plant's opponents have yet to rneet-In reality. all four are part of tne a *emnant of the past t' hey thought ne conditional and tentative na Cifty Creen compier perenec pr i trould be saved for the futun. ture of eacn side's claims furcer nver dans just below tne rictu - To engineers and planners from e ouds the issue. Not even the escue and histone Scutt.er-Ins-Public Service Indiana. however, the s.aunenest opponents seem wi!!ing to 'ana river town. The view :s a v:vic 'uture revolved around a state with say conclusively that the facility is rem:nder. however, tnat Mac:wn as msatiable thirst for electne pow-safe or unsafe: will or won't con-and power plants hardly are stran-er. In that future, the bluff had an tinue to escalate in cost. is or is not gers. important role to play. needed to satisfy Indiana's need for In fact. it was Cifty Cre' k kne e The stable bedrock, plentiful wa-power in the next decade.
- the growing proliferation of similar
- er supplies and relatively isolated Instead. Gray. Fred Hauck. for coal-fired power plants m tne Ohio location lit up the eyes of those men mer Save ne Valley chairman. and River Valley which spawned Sase seeking a sustable location for the others conunue to pose a series of ne Valley in 1970. To area enciron-firm's first nuclear power plant troubling questions - questions they mentahsts. the Marbie Hill nuetear Today. conditions on the 2.000 contend that the NRe ind PSI have facilay is but the latest and rnost acree 15 miles south of Madison bear yet to answer.
outrageous attempt t5 forever alter much greater resemblance to the d the faoric of life along the nyer. future envisioned by PSI than to Gnys dnams. W hv n have kit as oniv a remnant.' Gray says sadly. And even that will soon disappear espite construction deficien-cies stead;!v escalating costs. IndeX To ir the,,spoiten are allowed m ca-federally ordered de!ays and ongoing tmue. p.,,,,y qh,j protests. trucks and trams rumble ,f,= Q 3 in contrast. PSI and otner eier-across the former w,lderness which tric utilities contend that a steadily i is now the home of a mmi-city. Each increasing demand for all sorts of day brings the Marble Hill Nuclear L*.S.Stissile Plan.. Page 2 ocuer necess; tater plants like Mar-Power Plant closer to reality. Bill stauldin Profile. Page 3 ble Hill and the coal-burning Gibson Although the. Nuclear Regulatory Puzzles. Hobbies. . Page 4 5 plant near Pnneeton. Severai Commission recently resemded a Wrtd of Books. ... Page s times in the last few years psi s stop-mork order for areas of the Editorials'. Columns. Pages 5.7 rhairman has warned Hoosiers stant whreh will contain radioactive 81aser} In Urica.. Page 8 . The economie vtabihty of Ind:ana materiais. M1 and opponents of the piant cente 6: tc. epar Defore various See MjRBLE HILLPs ee-' e. - -
- ~
g. ). (' r& &ywp-O %) M o Mi, & ymY - 7e, 3 h M.., .E. J '"WbWe5'at;t$F. Marble Hill plantf y'.. . U#".4
- th Ure~iiextf6uYtirtix months the..' performed that. inspection. but. ac '
,f."' Oedmeed FromPage L. ? number of workers Will-increase ' cording to' train.- many-'were more. !.', slowly and ' steadily eventually.ris j crete construction rather tha ~ used.to working-on conventional coo. : rin the 1960i depends on Ma$r WF - ing te almost 3.506. ~ edacid','*. Much of the work now unthr.weY[ clear facility. "On a dam or' ordi- >$and the power to be b -. T'i Vt 493&*. on t!)e reactorcontainment and con ' nary building a finisher finding:. %ere?' blemishes.like we ud would proba. cJ '% #pR trol buildings involves repairing aMi > T ike Crsy.'MadisgoldscePSE shoddy or suspect. concrete patching.. bly justegrab a secop of patchings. materiaPand.troweinit in, so that's; 2dThomas DeGDo consa responsible for the: August 1979 ' tait - whatthey did here." he explaineC s iler. For tnore.thaar ' ees%dowm..One,. ness concrete pour has' I Unfortunately for PSL NRC regud y has. m.. : d 'taketer plaiterg andr'othecarw !%nesbgetensa@s 3.,geesidwfos<.the.gn. inkoccurugths. ao-of flawe& concrete are considerably; tat;stoft ' lations one the inspection ande repair- 'issd! tmnremmmatatfaseoemkfeasissues,,_.,s,ordingtidetro. w. ,. /.-l ...Het-say the csuM*nbre stringent..Because hollow; 'bes served as+econset,torth* problems! 'spauiin the three. foot thick contairM County Planning.QwnmisQ._ ated numerous.so4 left mang-.wockers. confused mentwalls can lower their ability to. hefping to develoVmaster plan!. about what. wor.k is permitsed-even ' prevent radiation leakage, the agen- > w % br*the area. ..dF W^.* wafterdhe March 2TNRC ruling that errequires that any surfaceblemish' ]. "0bviouslys,we.hevefW',rdn that3 several weeks. the most. eommorr a e all construction eould' resume. "For' be' tested to.see if it represents a l moir serious problem. 'the test re-suits'and method of repair must alsar,; for a.nucleacreacto PSI blew'that plan apart" be-wesponse to an order was:.iCan wea A. disarmingly f6tksy. mar;who-. ' 'tessyds that?"' Peti 6recelfst.'Z be feigorded for future review. 1 g.,, y-p.,. w w. P$linformation offh er Slanley J: es to describe himself'a,"Just *-trwit> aise remembers-ttie long, Men PST officials agree those O steps were not taken at Mar-recuntry lawyer." Daniloand ' months of irractivityv Walking, ble liill Several former constructen Oelg.eNents trave' napfertheless ;othrough a reactor building filled with workers have charged they were ged ts tie up construction ort s.1 the. noise and dust of workers repair. actually ordered to fill cracks before ti-biBion dollar pr,oject.by taking.$ng one of Indiana's' biggest corpo ' ay.-blemishes _iri,the' walli; Irwins i they could be inspected, but a feder. 'rsu;ons and the federal. bureaucracy. s. "It'sr strange tot see'1H this al grand Jury found there had been" } Evert he seems a bit' awed b activity irr an area whicfr waylike.. PST says the mistakes.w no criminal neg!!gence at the site / tomtr for so lonf 't W'i d ~ .- - - M d fr h .whar. they have accomplisheda D hose biernisbes shich turned,* matter of inexperienced personneh
- ewe'v'e set that plant back foug o-] Marble. Wnto,a-tornb andi Mars." he says. " bus,.1 can't sayA working under new ands. unfamiliar,
~' O. hat wilt finally happen.", 'h % fm occupy / tha. attendons d@ regulations.eterxretafinishers w Whether.mrclea6 fissionit / faker. pin at Marbie Hill'aill des.Seeeptiny innocuous Most are. ttiNRC found them serious enough. that workers will spend the next four k* ' ir large measure on-Williara(4 bis orr. the. face of the wall.. Tsmallimperfections,scarcelynotice amuclear veteran witir eight and more than 26 years op tsained. inspectors = Wwrc ther\\ and around the plant's concrete. 'ence te his creditJie ass ade.c!ues - symptoms. of>petentisk walls with chisels and air hammers. ' trol, of,'thes Marbl4HR sitei .They will tear out patches in more-bes 190gi 7.5 - 7 M. y W en the te fh than 4.000' surface blemishes, chip _ Petro is an athletle,, budding.waE lr piourd.16.' -around manywoi than to makeesure. g masrH~ Y,",,3p there are no more defects hid!ng. wilh dark hair and stead H* behind the surface and re-fill the- ,3.l holes with concrete. 'ewdes aLquiet confide. br the nnetearindustry as a wholt.and-14y** i 'the between his ability to'congte the probi is scar ly larger' 'Meanwhile: about 30 percent # which havy plagued-Marble Hill. f.' ghe rocks 5 the concrete..Some. the nuclear s -a,luE' t'ock wM IWge be-plumbing work remains on hold Ithough'. activity never coup t - unablerto proceed until the repasrs y ceased during the NR J,weert two -of the bars, preventing he mortar from surrounding the gg g,, 't shutdowrr of work orpoten-Despite.the problems of. the past.. llally rhdioactive areas of thi plant.Ahprs The result.is a void, or hon g. yetire reniains confident of the fu i 7 tyromb effect..whielt cari be-as ture I iiy city awaking from a.sesonsthMarble Hill today resembles a drow e smalf.as.several mehes,of gover$ m mistakes. o&'thee type. which; Misca of several square feef.-
- v...d
' gleep. 'Ita!!ic once again fs insteasF have~ changed MarWe Rilrs planned 1 . Net every ' urfaceAlamishnasan'qt operung from early 1983 s ing alongthe asphalt road flind with advertisements for<sleepng.roomsQ( ' '.s.)ioW" tin,.tlie> W bu ..Wp wilt-not hevf any more shut; "iipartments 'aiid mobile hiomesJetro
- crete finishees go over'every inc!r ofeegulh4 To avgid those costly a says there is a new seme of purpose ; the-poured : concrete'." searching. forg consuming problems; Petro arnong the 2.005 technic 2ans andcoo* f defectsr.and reparing any'dencYi has introduced' many. new proc strucpsm.ktmaQM sde
.,,n.Ai.m.. m. A.s " - m - he n aW -_trupcitus " ' ^ " ' ' " m
. A._', e L J. A L 5-3-U Red ?* Q,r,hk( D~~W5h ' : - N!.$h (~..* ij e,.ggy - -_,. ,.. y.w ~..<. - 3,.n.g.: % - ?. - nj q? 4: yt..
- s. n; y s
.,@a.. eb.. , de 'M.g.. t p.. 4...s .A v ~.. r% 4g ,~$jw . j '* W. f. a. {. f. %,R. &.( $,'.i &v.,.,.N,; '.f.. f L, si; O ~ _ Wy .g. w.,,,. ~- r%. r j.t... s...- 4 - <y Ie'
- f.. ' y
. t. '- ..sdf..". .t...-sme ~ ' k '* d " * * * = h t. 4'*W A" - - - - q".;- -:~ -. % ~~ " a,.___ d 3dC , W-m ' m st.s.t.s.t.,, .s, f pn, I 8 w
- .g._Q.
. i.: n, e wiitt 1 -. ~
- s
--.s v"% ; _ !, w.' t -d a - i _ ~_ $."
- f. j
. _l. ? ^ '~ . 2.-w = c ,c2 ._2 .w%. 9~y *. o..c. ~ fm ".' h '**** Y. ? v r _ _ p ~:.. ~,.. lI ; I k j ~.k, se*.: ' 3- .4 _ '"~.. 4>.,. '..a .T : <:.. - --
- M 3:~
l' +; The cooling towFr far Reactor Ilhoritantal building) itibehind the water iank J 2 till'hafr'emained" sympathetic to'. Ne key changeTrevofWaround[Qetinhattilo-has; asked the full qhe-utility. "It has neve h'a Sa've The planmng'and erpertence.. f,m I"'.y,;;,y;ieview its staffs decision.t indes of promoting atomie power - Irwm reports there now ste rm ' NRC ta ihan 140 full-tiner quality control aHow work at Marble. HIII td, pro. rather than regulatmg Jt. We expect engineers working at MarbleW.'..ceed. IMwants the com:mssioners to little more of them at this point." Before the shAttdown'. he recatisy determine.it.the. staff abused its i We Gray sa)s-the safety issue. there were only.4% dividing these dtscretiom Tbt petition charges that ** won't go away." -he-does expect time between. the construction sitar PSL has not conducted. sufficient. economic constderatgns to begm and the utility's headqm ag tests. tot make sure there are not.. playing a larger role m public de-bate about Marble Hill. Plainfield. undiscovered honeycombs; lurking In that' arena, as well as in issues designers rath extensive nuclear es. under the surface of concrete.wans. j Petro has hired only planners. ort p'~eriMe77echnicians.4veraged two [jp The problems' remain,f Datill6, ~ .isys "I can:t tell thepeople of-this i their " tough analysts and common - t three yearnf. atomic work befored ares 1*m. confident,in the quality,o(j vea'e approach' come sen ling the truth than the projet- -e y.h.,.Y.'W P.N.W.dh t, y? tions of alleged experts. Tetro arrived: the:figurenow isfive% therconwete." y sevengaist. N' X J 'W M "We resent the amateur tag with; o falso. fsars. the, same ' which we've been. labeled. Gray
- i. M ?,T..m. k 4 -Lc.A -lemaryliFrecerinh 4../..
g se riew' techn0cians' spend .W complams. "In reality, many of our nmch of theih tirne in. detailed-Mticrett.pouret att planningstrying tolainticipate and, have no. evidence.N, thne',they estimates,on cost and the need for-g avo d the mascues and'ilip ope whichs
- PSin areespablecL.eertretting the. eEt3?cty h' ave been right on' the i
so-far havedogged'the' project W4 construction. ;No-amounteo& war (s. money,','- ' ~ l ."We've alae doubled: our stM will correct the problems,and we're-c- l lance activstles" Petro points. catmnot aware of asyone connected with. :.1 A lthough PSI offietals put most "And because of their greater ex-Marble HH1who we think can do it.".T' A.of the blame for r: sing costs on The NRC's. assurances of cfoser, t scrutiny also carry little weight with,the 20 month shutdown, they un perience. our inspectors now know; edly have been embarrassed by cost where to look/. .-N Aware: thateths N C:. wilt-be1 plant opponentsr.In fact. Datillo :estirhates which have ballooned watching'6tosely to see, tallcpe-1 clamu;tbe agencyis'themainvillian. Usom an. initial-projection of $1.4-ditaoas of.the;worit.tesurnstion.per t in his. version of the Marble Hill lbWonto today's s3 4 billion figure. nut aresmet Petresays:everyonen., drama. "They;ve merely audited tha '.< As a result, the utility is under Marble Hill realizes %vott mass be work rather than really. supervising !eriormous. pressure to-ratse outside l i top quality.??Wt.can't Heralrskr tkitl'he charget '.J. 4,.: r - Ucspital needed for completion of the have. asyent<ggeneJa been an$ ly;DatiDo demurs when, pressed tok Igenerating station. In the next year spect us.* he says.-addng." alone. PSI head Barker told stock-now' na one could give us half the j explain the:NRCralleged defitien-cresa Grag.however is. sa.cir4 ' holders last month, the firm needs scruttny we're givmg ourselves/.T'; tumspect.. In',.the.past rd.more than $430 mtllion from inves-l .Grap arMFDetale,goweven thferred.to the agimer as the *ever':.Jacs outside,the company. I _ w s s - m u..esa m a. m --w - - --a-P-N-" --y a'.*W'r-ew-w-N-e7N-w-.ww-rs=-u-.- w..-mwwww.--r"mw'rw - - - - = - -
_N o t k d .q,Q) g g".3.gf = 56onde bempter trist wn!T meart ~ ,,-,-w,,,....,. t Madison;3hers=' tree-lined: higher rates for alf PSI cus:omers. Estimates ofeicess ge'nerating'y ]s"treets and beautifully re-capacity once the plant begins Whert. and how much.is.one of the hottest. debates this side of gun con-operating. range from PSTs 25 per, stored homes dating almost to the . cent to Heuck's 50 to 60 percent-town's 18&T beginnmg hide a stag, trol 1-nanting economy and unemployment l 'Vernley R. Rehnstromar. PSI's-senior vice-president for finance.g.Qlthough.opponeena-once had.runnmg m excess oE 14 pecent. opin, charged PSI wouldireap sub ion swings back and forth. A 'Three ' contends the increase will about d 3. t " plicate the 2l1 percect' rate hike thefstaeual prpGts bytselMag the excess,.it.ile Island incident aids the oppo-]. h H k said nents; another round of layoffs utiittyenow Is asking the Indianad electrictytte.ot errarossa aucPublic. Service Commission,ta prove (br 1901. Although psi rates. saysshinet.alher..stines slaa face.a% and.makes the jobs the-plant might t 'cannot include Marble HIS costs un. glutorgenerahng capacitf I off1M?, create seem enticing.4. e.Both. sides. re ~ t Rehnstromm admiteinterim rasei@, 'Rehusarosam.andother-PS .tH the. plant is-finishecbirr-1986. t='contiate teLmaineen t!iat the iPenrisylvania accidents altered theJ 'al to the firmis';.'sthaaWeilmseran:,of)Instns,Hars,-) egostierr forever. -Ns utility would-i foe meruC conweit.to a noclear.faisility.tadayit . creases.are:c "Aaphsity dind64' .shility Esset-wheirthere 1 Rehes;romm says, citing neva regw 41 % M y ;,.7 a v earig an 19..>.. 7 fare escess s@therciaim. Iowllations which.cam .tiom -M.j e Hill' disaster'swaka. 3 /. %. nanctal. reputation currently f a.bargainfor; customers.'.J J.He co~acedes. tha Many of the plant's neighbors
- dmWon,hild" among'many nnanciak, ' Although~ the.issoas of-safety, conf. however, seem more concemed with sinalystsChut is confident If. cat 4and need.all are importartt.both PSI i the construction proleet
. money. The"dtility's construction bily;.realiaestheytart o:Wr. tacticek skiry which will event recoverrand ?sise the necessary j by the mishes'fer tif(.h' ttkfqr public -: g.. Viola Baker and her husba'nd. I l a ' has been swelled not.only,he factr g.;;;;y,; outside the gates of the1 plant s rismg' cost. but byct opuuort..,r - ;,. t r- (.-l., , PSI noar' owns.33 percentof, Marble. ;. Eactr:s;ide is.neue geartag up to. r b l Massive pow.
- Hill. rather than tha 6f=. percent it. wage an aRous wac forthe " hearts '. lant. but just are y er lines which will carr 75&
I and.msods of.SouthernIndiana." in order to p'utittTihaiocialhous z Acegrding to Petry, Madison area' 7j,** 6 ".*CD"*9 began with in 1973. ..W in order. PSL win rely on todiana,eis, resident 0were " starving.for infor-r,.'$ fast-of aDJ. t den.d lilie.an they
- ,.m.m-c.
q reputation.for beingigenerally favor-.tnatico aboutMarlyld.Rilf'iwhen he: tble.to. utilities. and their. requests; larrfved; PST has.a!Iempees to. feed' r traffic. sher. saidiPWe. m Ethat hu'ogei by'mountmgan massivejhere for the peaseandquiet." for higher rates. '.... s PSL also,is' considering sellir pdbfiPrelations?afhpaignr" ~ J...Mrs. Barkerw'm to be un., !some oO ths efectricity thesef'os(tW.. The effort h'as'-inettsted'the' cre. ; worried:st their' p m completed GibsesGlaciUty will prth stiegrof a nuclear.inforraatsort center y oelear plant buLdoes allow tt duce. That. Rehnstromm says,could: itr ar remodeled Madisoir f!!!ing sta. g' glad; ther found the bugs.before started riamings" N. w's e.v ts raise op to-$112 millionDr.figsref. f tion'. ant conduedogiguaded Marble {pJest'.ulk rut. 61' front.tteplant. j t HBlit'oun foreanyonenlaterested. termstnot. insignificant.*W2 From AprW (6 DetoberHhst year,-iDoddy'Biggs.llestauranrwattressg
- head and: environmental' more than-It.000; members of service..Shirity.CistshaD: bas mtzed, feelings.g HauciQfornfep5avei andcivieclubsi aswenasinterested hbout;the plast It has htiped busi-j s
s says his owiiahaljimis of otter nuc . ear planty sugspsts the '2L4eBillion; individuals; filed past giant'reactdred, nesidshawadmits.ibut.new d
- People who!
peiced,hardly;affordu and. half-finished buildiagr.tIhler A;qr j siser has.. ~ ! 'estima'te 3110 is toe lon41sighest s e'an't riffe moret.'thand I'.21Fpersorup toegdere burm einsen.tsS.5,6illioresand.De atfventageof P5fpeperstenese. N'ak3p d}pinliikh(M.AEce h. hen como fspr6asymotel.S s i ,it coul&soortormorothed . 'J Gray;husevettTemhihs'coander 2 4i s rAftileia'tni:reasseheE6=* _ sun't' mutn care: forj ' hikes:sf $lttC00tyesceng'it;-)tr6% that'the mfore'dfefientleertr:'aboutb&Wei als e . economics wili be whatluG5%gm.^, to, stand lett itG%seglesson While r . ~~ r he said: 'Ihey've done'itas.thest.j botts sides claths t!sey.are, winning < J ~~,.1'EI.W +,the bettle, most:.obsetvers estimate 'selves.:'T d, Hauck's predictions ort'hoirwoelp, the public is neasty esenly split overe more.electri.c ponenDidans will{ tfle pthnt;with rslight* tilt tooppos6-o$ T! tree Mife~ need~also- %quir.231 tionrirr_tllep, 5 M9L Mhh d and-egrr .utili have beguons .w e. . e w e.eme
s' [ b b' d k=== g_em cb, tO,2f.I~. ",k;j. 4 ?N pes m g .~r*'- MF ... " riarr worke*rs bring to her bar. 2 ~ -rAbout:. 00ce a. week.;we have to. throw someone out " she reports. Despite Mrs. Cutshairs assess-4 .f" -. d ment'..ll'arold K. Gossman; Madise i 1 i aena Chambler ol' Commerce execue" 2,',Ihe victe president remains leer > of, t5e econonuc' bonama:many mer - eBants,espected, would. accompany. .d, 5.5 fM. Marble" Hilt station's 'co.nstruc 1 i .5 5 -s g.. _ -.. + 'M. dell!T:n..erebeefr ,,p us; he b eth
- n economie 4.k,.h
. : m.co n:. : 'F S ITre~iEIdi@tsnfEh at iniPpEint.**T.fid. continues: "5st at 5 -[;,J.f 'e - .'qtitting tiise65 percent of triose cars * ~ -rs-T. will3 urn and.go the othef.'way,
- -.* 7 ildwarCouis,ville).?.-
,r. ge 3 1
- n !=p }s.'V'i.y..@.**
g p e.s s r - ~ u. 1 j._.,Witli a.,-lIeMt fi' e mor.e. years t v i before the first atoms are scheduled l.tettie. split, along,.the. banks of the,; Ohiagthe'5farble IDl!' battle is far from ovef..'Ibe two sides.will con-t itimie' tot trade evidemet and'accusa. '.ltfons',IraEV6eforethe NRC, rate i .' hike ~ fights'yndnoutt 3ans. %. add ] wulithe'IndianaP.SCand. p~*' , probablyce 4 . fifeE to the: controversy,:. e u.,. : - $1n;g.the,rneantimQhowei,et PSI. k gg,. [qo_one,. continues te Dow..mto the i py in nstructiori)itCand.'the buildings 1 >coittinuee ta-rise over the site en-i vironmentalists hast hoped wo61d re - r miinueplace'jirbere t5s3ecould.show k"*. htAsie childrert-and. grandchildren whatFilrecalonglthehver'used to be ;
- [IlhirQi u.p 1.ic. J.' :.
JF.Desadaitheir;arumes.itysPSEand i !P" Marble; HiWs, de' tractors areinot -without;ycommon grou4 Datillds. j 3 A"' 1 ~ dfDte B cozily in the shadans of.P5Fs: ' tastefoIIy.!andscaped informatiest of-f.l,%,fte dn Madison s;MairStrret.f.surthaveboosted myproper-l {bY3tINO "'N'
- j
,p .i .s - w.marn'. Petro.'ltois)l.exeastive therac 6f the Morbiemi pr.oiecs.,' ..PF5: and: V9tnien b B ',-foe..finanw.1 s.ni .vic pre.idene are'eendime-ths.pkrewilkoww, conut'seshocles,ameFprowfe Wj
- .iew-ene.aotp. met; m--
e e 6 y-r,.e,.e.-r .y -.-w- --g r- ,-------.w-,
Y7 t G }1\\< t l Nh;..wffie dy..s, critics to discuss MarEe Hill ~ By MARY DIETER-could not afford the trip to Chicago in two reports sent to the NRC in cammraamatJean wrrier and wondered what could be gained. September and Marca. Cassaro said MADISON. Ind. - The attorney for "We had no reason to believe at the many more tests were necessary. Save .Save the Valley, a leading opponent of time that anything posicve could come the VaUey President Robert Gray mas the Marble HLII nuclear power plant, of it." he said. said that Cassaro told him that as says he believes the Nuclear Regula. Now that NRC officials have agreed many as 700 tests were needed. tory Ccrnmission may be having sec. to the mecengin Madison.Dartito said. The NRC rejected Cassaro's argu. ond thouga:s about its decisico to allow "I'm not sure this is not a partial re. ments in a letter to him dated Marca all constnction to resume at 13e plant sponse to 13e pet: tion." 20. near Mad: son. Strasma of the NRC said the agency The agency's decisica to allow a!! An NRC spokesman, however, says invited Cassaro to e. sit tBe Chicago of. construccon to resume was based in that's not true. f1ce - and to pay his transportacon part on an oral report from the two Madison atterney Thomas Dat:1:o costs - because "2ere conunues to be California engineers that they ap. said yesterday that he and Dr. Micnael a professional disagreement.. as to proved the tesung. Cassaro.an eng:neer hired by Save the t3e statstcal adequac* of that testing He was unsure of how many NRC of. / Vanev. 3 ave been invited to a tneeOng program." f!ciais would be present. but he said ne.tt Thursday with NRC o!ncials and tl nut the NRCs March 27 order. J.J. Harr: son. res: dent inspector, and two Cai!fetta engineers hired by the Save 13e Valley had recently based its Frank C. Hawkins, a civil ens:neer and regulatory commiss;on. oppostcon to Martle HiU on Cassaro's concrete expert, would prcoacly be ~1t would seem there's a possibility ana]>s:s of the testing to determine there, their accons were premature." Dacilo whether the concrete was sound. Bestdes inspecung the pour. NRC of. said. Sixty ultrasound tests were done en flcials and the Californsa engineers concrete in summer 1979 by a corn. will also inspect vanous places in the But Jan Strasma. an NRC public-af. pany hired by Marble Ell!'s general ertsung concrete tatt need repair, fairs officer, said. "It's a dead issue at contractor. Sargent is Lundy of Chica. Marabito saad. this point.... There s no indication go The NRC has no legal respons:bility there'11 be any caange." Ite tests concluded that the 90.000 to meet with Save the Valley represen. Russ Marabito. another NRC spokes. cubic yards cf concrete in safety.relat. tatives. Marabito said. "It is a good.or.U man, said. ' 'Meetingtmight be a ml> ed areas were scund. The two Ca!1for. ' gesture on the pen of the NRC because ocmer. That they're going to do ts In-nla eng:neers analned the tesung and of the concern Save the Valley has" spect the tconcrete) pour that oc* informed the NRC that they consid. he said. curred last week." ered the tests adequate. Although Cassa.*o's analysis of the The pour was the first in safety.re. But Cassaro inade a siml!ar analysis testeg was rejected. he was invited to lated areas of Marble HiU stcce con-and concluded that not nearly enough the session because he has been "; arty str' action of those areas was stopped in was done to ensure at least a SS per. to all of the informance ttat has been August 13*9 when defects were found cent chance of accuracy, as required gathered ever since the stop work or. In er:stinit concrete. by the NRC. der was in place." Marabito said. An NRC order on Marca 27 allowed all construction to resume. Save the Vaney penticced the NRC /g<cJJ w,tlalligencc, enc. q n g last week to rese:nd tse order because tBe group contends cat the commis. wasmsrc r. o.e. :oces sion aDowed construccon to resume Frer.t Est Cther even though condit:cns the NRC set py, pg, py, had not been met. The group ctarged that NRC im. .,-.r*-..-..:.* * " ' g., properly allowed all construccon to re. sume befcre the two California engl. 000?. E?."-JO*J7 7A L - nee's had submitted a written report-on their analysts of *he concrete tests. ,,b.,....,. '".*d - d. e'U It also con
- ends t3at off!ctals at the NRCs Chicago eff!ce agreed that Cas.
E7?.'OA? - ~344,5 H.. saro would be a' lowed to comment on g ')5 m= 13e report before a dec:szca was made about resuming worit. By failing to meet *.aose condit!cas. Victor Stello, the NRCs director of in. spectica and enforcement." abused his discretica." Dattito said. Dattlo said t at NRC officials have scught a meet:ng vita Save tue Valley since the March 27 order but that tue group resisted tecause its m nbe
wA .n, o s ? _) di New challenge threatensi Marble Hill constr, uctiod [,fgg,g g g, m,
- u..
By MIKE McNAMEE Ior both the ensumers and the utilfUes of' De Star's Beelness Editor Indiana " Barker said. Annual mee. tings of Public Service
- Meanwhile, PSl ls trying to raise rates Indiane "always seem to come at crucial v,
and lower its capital needs with opera-times for the company," as chairman tions on two fronts. It has asked the Statg ~ i Hugh A. Barter put it, and Monday's shareholdermeeting was no esception. blic Service Commissaan for a $120 After 19 months of delay, work st the.
- 23. percent rate increase for its own customers, and soon expects to ask
./ v'tility's Marble Hul nuclear power piang the Feieral Energy Regu'atory Comnus. C can finauy go ahead unimpeded.. I8im for an incmme in whcimale power . De U.s. werar w% c-*- sion, wmen nauso worm a ia Money..dbs %,"'N is.also. talking to othe.' utilities ' " * **" ""'"* *-*" ad-8-) August IM, gave PSI the final " green 6 gnd people " _j* plant te mduce ite capital b
- "' *H"8 d' = d 5 mens Ught" for construction a litde more man i
a week ago. Today, for the first time.. 1 ..1 . ~ _.
- _.
ash Valley Power Association, a griup of since July 1979, fresh concrete.will be 2 aus futre dimmities with putting new 4 rural electric moperatives tREMCs),- poured for the plant's safety related .De soluhon to those probians, Bar,'and Indiana Mumcipal Power generating capacity on line." structures. group of 14 nneci kar said, has-mon in poutics man inD @ % pal'utiHues, am coe..', BUI' BARKER wunal PSI's share- @,s_ mal-Gnd Gib. holders that the utility's troubles aren't our. After struggHng wie proWeen of business.'." Agenda No.1" is contmlung son 5 plant, now under construcuan.SdcE. l quauty, management and' safety in its inflation, which,is' driving up utiHty co*' a sale would transfer much of the cost.br. l nuclear construction program. PShno, struction costs.hiang with wery other,i capital invested in Gibson 5 to those onipe faces another challenge: Raising the-. cost, he said. p. utiMiss and free up funds for PSI to use money.to pay for its construction pro-FOR UTILITIES, the next highest elsewhom.Barkersaid. F priority is " sound,' solid rate regnwn" MANY Olr VIE REMCs and munici - gram. "We have to raise sanething like Ih thatwSt.auow us to pay a better returni pal utilities involgd already are PST. bGilon in external capital between noir on.our_. common equity, Barter saidl customers, and the new generating cae i and 1988" Barker said. "After that,in "% compets gir capital, we have toears pacity at Gibson *was planned to serre ! the next f!w years.we'n need very little Te rater.of' return ~.tp attract investorsJ the power nesda that these companiest. l l capital. But in ther meantbne, we have Regulatorr and' the public have got te have,"'Berker said. ~1nstead of us seik. t quite a job to do." reauseest." C. \\ ing power to Hendricks County REMCs Most of those runds war be sowing,/ For PSI, that menen CWIP "cek which would then seththe power.to cus. south, to the Marble IBil. site ce the structieswartr in pragmas," what Barker { tomers; the REMC would own the capsicig 'I hanks of the Oldo River near Madison. chDed s,"peras.you.go plan for financH. ty and sell the power directly. 7ts two nuclear imits there are espected 'ftig% a U.u,"' Utuities tha? "There's only one difference kie,4 l to cost 33.4 bHllon s up fteen an original ' customers wGl paF ess over the rum REMG would be carrytng the capiraf ' if they are charged'forconstruction m'tsi costs."' That's.important, Barker said,' d estimate of 31.3 biluon -ladore they start producing electricity in 158 and while the work is in progress, rather then because the federti rate setting commin,. i 1987. This year alone, PSI espects to waiting until the plant is in service.te sion "hasn't suowed us a rate of return' l raise Slag minion in cutside money to inchsde its caste is rates. - ~ l > an whoisaale power sales that makes it ; support WB1 mlBion in 151 construction Under CWIP, capital chargea - tile, worthwhGe for us'to seu power.to thiiie costs. etIDeles'. cost'ef money - wenid be paid adser utluties." . ; - 0 ~..., ' PREI)tCIWG, THE udliefs p=mariat, at once, rather than accumulat2O But in the long run Barker sakt, needs is one eing meetag man is tirse$setthesigkto15 years neednito-business deals won't solve utihties' prob. anseer. Barter didWt aihmsnima to gap sbuild A neur. power plant..CWIP weishF Isme. Instand, solutions willdspend-on's two. Many invester6eumed ' meur"asse modest, monier increases ' patdic renusation that "consumesst intste i between te' finding all their traditiceal is # as we go along,meer.aise.ests and investors' interests are utRides.me DamW avpassa clesed to esen,he laid Bleting Nt with. major leeresses ad'at: identical," the diairman said "Elther ' ese thne" when new pients come into sideiang"he served by balancingf#e.,, sharehoWars, "158: interest rates and fant'ng band sentos, Barber as ruedaof ,,,g ' ratings are ' making debt fla***iat USE 0F CWIP would regelte a ' INDIANAPOI,IS
- INO"
~ tbonds) almeet.unreacheMe for many change in Indiana law, and past attempts utilities," Barber said; "Utuity stocks to get the memiure poseed have raised STAR, APR 7 1981 y ~ are selling below their book value, so it's questions about legislative manlets of' I hard to raise money in the stock mar-laterest. As a results this year's scandal
- MORNING - 217,619 conscione General Assamtdy has not been I ket." De limits on espital avaGateHty,the chairman said, near result.in "seri-particularly laterested is.tecklag, the.
SUNDAY - 357,706 w' v.=="*
p Q o j.. C.,,, 4 .-.-L~- %:. J.
- QQ,.
L.a.& ( ( F ad ~ .m 3 . L56 4 sh-X [. -y,,. r - V,r _Slb Bth Street, N.W. g Suite 400%. P e igh p ,J f Washir gton, D.C. 20005 4 02-638-4260
- )
" 7.s cre d Cs~.w! W -. _. m% e %?'**. O.um.xs:sttowxs: ~~ r.<.. 1:k
- Gi.M.,
N'M 4 Tti^esdaKIa'tittaryg7,1984 61Eme. Number 11 -. f.s@,JL~%.ttere t - h ya ,p, cg5g ~ = w S - .w U 6 f d W NTIi W $ a ls 1e m d. c;&lli.M e .Ba uet Aft 5a seNof lin'gt! aYd N d N s N NItIEi.ii N a$t ' afe r ruh 5 mil 5 " meetings late last ' week 'and,'earlfhing'fhNen16Ts;'anYEliori 66that. of that) PSPs'abil tylt'6' provide. .3 this,a bloodied Public Senice ofIn front, PSI said, would have to'com an'heceptable lev'el'of service to its t . diana has decided to withdraw; fromQfrom Wabash Valley Power Associ$e 7 liistomerg;i'ill.be'impiiisd unless : w the h1arble Hill nuclear project,' a]% Publi[.3ervice 'of ' Indiana ' jp in6re cashA',the!a , fation. Mud gw:.q the"c'oinpan'y.*5s i struction and expected to cost ath been'. cutting ' costs two-unit station now under7 con-ntilit/taid.' t i foi a least 57 billion?'Esen with thc'most" ~ somd, time, tryin~g t'oleep^'ths com? - stock ~."Over thi last ? i. ' stringent internal cost controlsNe*'p'any,? ' mployment Toutsid'e7itsfholders of Public S and'htarble Hill'alloatTICo~m i pS have not been able to generate a suf 7 7pany ' i e nuclear. division has been cut by $39 * ~ ' to operate our' system,' much less to',' people since June 1982, a' drop of 771." stock and secu ficient amount of cash to continue 7 e' than $1 billion due to the drop in' operations a;nd maintenance.liudget'.,l man Hugh Barker., PS hiarble.. chairman ;;., percent.s r - '.,. finance construction at Hill,',' said company Hugh Barker. So sorry is the com.. to the 19821evel. And in October,it fluctuated between a 52-week high ' ,) [ pany's financial condition that the 1 reduced employment at hfarble Hill {of 27-3/8 and a low (at c!csing on( from 1,200 to 150 people. Even bail' hionday) of 10.'On hiondav, the ' -
- f pany's! dividend lon its commonboard also voted to slash the com *ing"out of h1arble Hill no(will notTitoc restore' thef company'.s ' health,' gor ovei'one million shares.
Y stock by 65 percent, cutting it from' o Reducing its dividend by 65 peicent m E Thejroject's troubles date ba _ 72 cents per share to. 25 cents.4 ~ ~ . The company also announced on. will cut $100 million from 1984 cashN!f4? D 4 C(Continued on rape 4) 5-I i1on i ge rate re ief J. .. a 14 percent'.senis.;mcrease,*ssionN cog / r andTha Wyfje ** gajv g%q-g>atchdog'Dropw$g Lea.gm 7 W S from its public commi L"fyears._PublicSer%cM'P amesJYattxC.onyJjnJJ t egy,W r- - pe*. .tt, rate. n'inidbleTa c o vice of Indiana and fLmogejs a e, ongf sioEil,p~an xamTning C has about $2.5 billion ~i'nvested"at. nterio@r s a g ~ f aslisTed%r.an mvestiga)T 'e' alLeaYing hfarble Hill.Jt' owns 83.peicent70 f ' the project,~ with the b'alance h~ eld b 76g~6cf. fornier ', Unit 1 of the 'pla'nt'is 59'pscentgavid'R(,ussell fo!.fitEi8t{oTficia 4 ? e ram R Wabash Valley PoweFAssociati6n ion 1 .' M r.po's'sible ciimina 7.:;,'2 , coal, lea ~se[ sale [ p. complete ' Unit 22.is rcen nduct'in'the Powder Rivei Basin :- - controversial,id April,1982,and,af 1( ' 8 [,, @cpf-finished.d; '.1j.d, _ land exchange., an s ~ Public Serv ce ofIndiana's act, ion "was' not ' entirely' unexpected.2ThFDe ' b 1981. Lino'wes'confirrn'edV I E.,,'% '? " ' on the project 'several~ Weeks;w,orkh'o.g.cem er r ' utility actually suspended all The' Energy 1 Daily 'ori Monday 4 - ago,gthat'hehad ask'ed Interior's'16Ispec -/. '~ " by Republican Governor Robert Orr$or general to.look into Russell'swo % k ';. W-' Y after a task force appointe'dlastyear~ t ' C6 V Ipublic details,at'the 'c6mmission'sk b ... ','] recommended ' cancelling'. ths3roDmeeting today (TiTesday)RiyN f M I. ^ ^ - L.4 .4 [Q ~. ect. The' utilit'y' was" careful.t.o say .on hionday' that.it1" continues toF"id ab'out irregularitissirfthiiP6wderObelieve that th I'inowes said he became.ccmcernf,,$. + 9-T 9M ~ ^ O Dusk" t-- ~ will be'needed to meet future'powerfg River' sale'and the;t'e' stim $~$i[d requirements, but given the realities, j exchIngefduririg,~' mis'sioni as 8 g
- N F )., %..
on er6re 'o 9 of today's politicalenvironment and th e'"leasTng* com E financial markets, Public Service of., September. A'. trip Jo'_the.Tdivder.g k. "" ~,p~ Indiana clearly cannot continue to River Basin, where he saw the loca- ' -k.; be a part of the project." The utilityi..ig%gjQ.pj, /Coslinded$fpagM3gggDar/d Ru ~ 4, w ;, g g ag p. g m, s- - p 7 q.:., - n 'l- + ~'. g, n p q n a y v,
- LpiS,
,,r w, n... a.w
-d 4
- w. - j i<
i v .c g .c, ;,, y g 7,ig g y,g g y m s 4 ru- -9 A A S12-BILLION-A-YEAR'INDbSTRY IRS A roves [ W TI.c industrial power s3 stems market will grow at an annuat riite of 3.6 percent oser the ness four pears,and, hit 512 billion (in constant,J982,djllap) b 1988,Jrost & Utility-aPapenis 3 e gg Sullnen, the.NenJ ork, market researchftrm, predicts'lagnewjeport. ",' Steam and f.,p g"w 9.ihi, gas turbines willincrease,their share,of the markef Gi6wlis afa'iisserage,4 2Fe'rknt s' To Three Mile, .a
- -- ~
~' ,' % *Jear) as more efficient gystems are offerHI and forme a articu ~ tilities. Is}3Hd (lCHHU [U T W Q & dhaN6 % p ^ seplaceJheir me' idin'dT ^ 59 y 7 *y D . gElectne atllities that cor. tribute to ' d Ng ~ (f fff 1)k[ M N [
- 7 und foIcleaninDip Unit 2 at the T1 j
T Z Mile Island nuclear plant can treat th, g,E (COIden 'dff0mpjge on 'IftDNI_' ( jiording',to;s'rufing from the inte - R ontributio'ns'as business espenses, 1 4 p ' ate's m ue s_ q.- g wog,, [ Yl0* August,19,7pg en , uc. were servi
- RevenueSersice latelast 3 car. In h to Regulatory Commission opp,ed'a 4W +
ho l'w6 Etilities that had requested a r = - sa fely.'relat'ed7dlisfrEietio^nXw'chn d iana eM A j1ng on thelssie, the chief of IRS' C owing'to probIdms%ithiiuality E Occ,essK,ei'~ previous 16'ha7e"its'expe'i'difiir porationJax Branch f,ound that the t h[ our avi ou t [ dol, piping','ednc5t'eTork~ arid'deficiencieslin,thc7 utility's pro}ecf - Marble Hill'frea'te d Y5"pP ri aHoming a deducti 7 I* "5 me, 'A l
- y[" '
r Mndersecgon 162(a) of the Code. lTi a DninagementJhat'sh'utdown lasted [Y work'in'"~ eis,)Orr' ' "'n5M "["" U 7eratin 9#ficM. Il8.m06tiguntil March 1.981fa'nd uppdirigng as'kg6[ t g ,i ge a: nd. y (" the delay sent 'the project ' cost soar . Marble Hil, ici con ji'a g distributinji electric power. Bawd wL 1 g 5 ang upward. S,ince then, with quahty y _the. project :wasprobably.not worth - %n the'information submitted, it i3 ce I ).'N contro]Eanf' project *paiiagementjf,thet $7 ' billion jt *ivould'illiciad? *cluded'thni'Ithe] proposed pa3 ments 5 r., thoroughly' revamped,:.the project. build i e antility stic'ks its last 7 '*ould 'be dedsetible as a businew < ~ saydaj.Mlillion Efisiat'e)(th 're~cbmWd f Pense."j,%Ngip% .+ Z Etililf's' Y,f8?? ' " hat turned ~ around,i' spokesman for NRC's Re[giori111in. board %n'c'lided'that l The IRS, ruling, removes a maj si V. A N , Q..' ' ~ Chi ca g o..? ' Th ey ~h ave", been '$nelf incindailo~ds'.df' thy 1asMidM3pd 4,obstack,to utilit3_ contributions Io E ~ ~ $ ndH8 n elean-up fund conomed I k'g '. ' * . the better' lonstruction sites'intheN1h'e90verii6'r@cndoriement,of' "} region =T*' " M WN V thcrii,ih.a. d.. u _iin.ated -the panies hase. delayed rn sking cor J Governor-Robert. Orrg pany,s+liccess o capital marke. com. tr p ts for mitments to lhe fund until thc3 were ct d - -~ r Indiana i entered the fray last year lwhen the ; purpose,syIoT completin ", Marble tain Iho e pa3 ments would be to J Ti b utility asked its regulators forf rate. - Hill._" ~' p. Mgy edered legitimate business expense E .,h The (El fund contains two pari J M*"'W $&%ba L % ,fy IGmeS Watt Cro,ny,j:fA n' Hot.Wateri : " ta %
- 1a*s u "a% " " n',;"
= N %N idontmuediomNe#'EefM" dhi M d 7 nuclear-generated electricit3 output. Ti ~ o 2*I'". *""Id '""' I'"" "'I " ' i'I'i' JY Tion of varYo'ultractsNghtene R 11 o .re u a
- T ; J "' concern 'he said. Based"oii'.,that, foii?I6f'
- d* "" assessment on the number i i
men i M"p'[, ",s"sh,'hure"d i F for ~him," withouti,to some.mattersDyJames Watt.pygth , l.inowes said, he asked th('commis'-a ceeded ni uch a p ':- ;h.. sion staff to look in ,camelo' interior,with "that about 92 percent of Ihe $150-millie f i pecifymg,why.Wthe fund would come from utilities wi: E W.-s*k. " That material."hejsaid41ed,him'11 '#'M YD inhtark7Hatfield'I nuclear plants'says an eel spokesmas ing 1 S '8konclude that Russell may'have been {R-O '.[ai'deTdthPSenate Erie'rgY -so rar;partl3 because of the uncertaini '2over how the IRS would tre r* ,7.. n 'i nvolved 7n,~1r'regula rities~.*'AlsdVt oriimitteiE%McMayE"' rnin'e'ralsd j;
- ontributions..EEI only 'has con g
b ecbnomist[with'in'leriorJrom -197 c %j$ ' d issue,'according 'to other sources ~~ to 1977.* Aft'es'ths Re'a,,gan'electi6'n*3 r v "h "'"'S I t sona %5 iniuion. M lea Russell's sworn tstimo'(to n ussellT6/k'edjn~jt d6 ip" % eni,Hm.n gin pidggwouy i g 5 hre gress and to the lii10wes cor3misD,minisdalhYn'j*transiho%*neQ'atl $*"pd [ [' p 5 nteEm sion,' which,lalsolmiy ' turn"buQ t n R und h . T:{ ! 'have been at odds,with:thefactstg ferior'*fand',%alsop afthored %, ef Three $ file Island Unit 2 cleari 9 o E H bas
- Industr3'-wide # repercussions an
?44@.Wi s#sultant'? at jnterio'r]afterhaiing ; tefior which~rRussell, 3$ds currently a
- con g eritage
'f O Edommended r' nan ~ U ?thes" satisfied 'one of the criteria f< 5 Tauoming',the' !cduction: "the bandin 3 j h 'k 'been fired by new interior Secretary the7swTepiHg~ pol. han' -* - ; aogether pf, members of an industry ca N 4' # William Clark. ~ Watt taler's,,,mplemen W'gd early this yeafJ,in~ a house-cleaning acce led defense against m corr iniiwes%inm1AtlMonday4p'dii[Qa i,.besp,,,PI" RusseII was acting ~~ eesng M,' $II General u I n c.,hCdirect'or ',oG1hE Qhc hiiricral n .- somew'hatgironger,551,,Ianguage ondoj ,g, ,p-lanagement Service.at the ilme EM5Creekjex ti"fcEommtiiiBafi[n)itboutileasing h cha. 3'thI3 hic.ngegwhiytt1, wpald,abl rp 11 1 3 ould ... As. evelM%[41ennder[ths comD urginglof.commisfu ' result of the s'ecident, the cost of capits y racts inl6^the nanhf;Amax,,ccoal 3; Cdal ioner,,yDald to an electric companies has increased E g Ab' 7t$ior,d[and the Powder-Rivegr[eb,' ' ', abo" featured alack *oT e.co hoL1d"' gEcic6g,tha@Ts'e the pricecastnh,]evels "The differencEbetween the 3 eld et uir m,,, e thoT~Nmpejit (ding s&in a i k 'ra 2 'Jutilities'J Iong. term debt and.20-3ca C ,3, ti j*adet ". U.S. ' Triasury""dsuis~'has ; increasei substantially';1a,mddit,1,on[public con 1 [i ~ for ~trahts;Adsel T$s ding ~ 4Ws g[li.- =* assistant ' secttaryA 'Q'djm caYthgh fidence inyhe; nucleer_ power,1ndustr> ^ . h',O. d a
- has dignighed significantly since the ac s'rident
- occurred GPII]%houk
@t~ 4 'saret. He. sosiinal serye m = , assistant, sectetary .Garr at g,wn "becesise?bankiup . "possible tha j p a c'hers, althoug e arge,,- es in there would be a f riher inercase in th r?ctated in3Tendent_ ofisuperv1h, tac'k the Pow'dSp,n_ng@fd982,,Jacted - gnancing.costsMo,;the.,catire, electric j sca f @j s>on, accordir4 to Interior Depart. River atuit dust C-- 3 ' % - - -.sg<sg,l t ~- . v2,
- +
1 u-- ,-w :r,%w lx l [- .M$ .j g Q n,,,_ y,
^ - 4 1 l l l l I l I h-, '., T .'4 5 ** ..-- v .A g ,. w ; ,4,! - ~ - - ., g.,,ew g ~.'trr' 7 ..mm.. %, m f,hV.- "es*4pme***W M W :.- 4. gwa== ~ d* - - *>=W1-- ,'f' l h' s .w..,s. S $ d -.L- - ~ 'f 4 ^ M" OY, l$ W g i sm y s.e g t c--
- ~.
I ys~ e-( A-- h. g 6 ~ i e<.- -d ~ w .Y ,y3g 4.Ny W y9%se - Vt' ' ' _1l i 7 yl f* ' ^ ' ' '+ 2re* h &,"_.,... '.y & w. -s. .f; i f
- y s
-'i.;, M;ff' >A 7 _yw.. w.,,.. - s.. ~ = -. -- ^ g.'. ' 'J' ' ' ~ ' ~r .p* 4,y_,. .o -e e p -
- s Mwk U w.... s.
$e lv...? +1h.4dk 4.- ~ m. ,.e.- , y ~,, e
- x, f f. -&s. y# d ".*g.
. h h :' " AAW2..
- av w_
- A -
. sm s a-* +, n b 'Wy whiubMaiG1M@MMaM,' % ~' M .. ~ \\ _ _ _ _ _ _ -. _ _ - - ~ _. - _ - _
- e r SHIELDS SAYS THAT A NETBER OF OPTIONS ARE BEING CONSIDERED FOR THE MARBLE HILL PROJECT Options under, review by PSI for Marble Hill range fron cancellatier of the project to completing it as soon as possible, according to S.W. Shields, senior vice president, Nuclear Division, during a briefing held for PSI managers en Nov. 4.
"While cancellation has to be considered one of the options. I am personally optimistic about continuing," he said. Members of Gov. Rcbert D. Orr's PSI task force,.which is also considering alternatives for the project, are scheduled to visit the site on Nov.14. Their recommendations are expected before the end of the year. ,1 . 2;, y-m "Although recommendations by the task force are not binding, they will probably be considered seriously by the Governor, the legis-lature and the Fuolic Service Connission," Shields pointed out.. " ~ ' Lee Dozier, the on-site representative of Wabash Valley Power Association which owns 17 percent of the Marble Hill project, also addressed the meeting and emphasized that his company is working very closely with PSI on a solution. Also referenced during the meeting was PSI's decision to reduce construction activities in order to conserve funds while alter-natives are reviewed. This action has resulted in an extension of the construction schedule by two yers. Commercial operation for Unit I is now scheduled for late 1963 and for Unit II by aid ~ 1990. Cost is now estimated at $7 billion. As a result of these decisions, contractors began laying off manual and non-manual employees last week. As of yesterday, re-ductions total about 2,600 personnel. PSI estimates that employment at Marble Hill will drop to 4,000 by early 1984 from a late October high of about 8,000. Significant layoffs of PSI personnel are not expected to take place until afte" the first of the year. In the meantime, nojor concrete placement should be completed on ~ the Unit I Containment dome this week. Exterior concrete work j j on the Ultimate Heat Sink is scheduled t'o be completed by the end of the year but is proceeding ahead of schedule, according to Civil / Contract. T Newberg's structural steel program resumed yesterday in the Unit I Containment and the Auxiliary Building. Other con-tractors will be moved out of Unit I Containment for the struct-ural steel modifications. l l l
..I ' marble hill newsletter from Public Service Indiana for Marble Hill employees y.9 ghg_.f~ - ' .,. v.. n, Number 33
- hJ.g.,Nov er 8, 1983,
g.g,. ,g.4, 7 g, ' 47'y m..,. a....PUBLIC HEARINGS ON MARBLE HILL SCHEDULED FOR'. LAFAYETTE ON.NdV.10, NEUALBANY ON NOV.17 uv9 ,..d. m t_;___.___.______r____;.___.______________. [ [?[ M M(jk % d.N*fhh-/.; - j.$! ',7 " ', Public'mietings invitiing commehts 'on! Marble Hill'are scheduled for the' Jefferson High School cafeteria in'LafsyEttion Nov.10
- 5f".g'm'?qggy '- '
. and at the Prosser Vocational Center's meeting hall in New Al-
- gg.g
..J M bany on Nov. 17. 17..' .?OL ,.s .,....m.... '1 m.A .'S['j., ~. Arranged by the Consumer Advisory Council,' the meetings will be-gin at 7 p.m. at both locations. Those wishing to address members 5 of the council may register to do so at the meetings. Comments
- e. % ::.....-
~- r, y- <.. are limited to five minutes, excluding time for questions by the pp council. . ' - L._,;.g. - y; Since speakers will.be selected in order of their registration, - h*, '1':, T it has been suggested that those1 wishing to speak arrive at the meeting by 6 p.m. to regis,ter.' "C".1:2CQ 4 - ~ a - ^ - -
==ms
Based on information rece1ved during the meetings, the Consumer 4' A. Advisory Council will prepare a report for Gov. Robert D. Orr and the five-member " blue ribbon" panel of business and industrial fi ? s.:.., 7 leaders which the Governor formed. ~ The meetings are open to all residents of PSI's service territory. In announcing them, Gov. Orr noted that consumer concerns are important to resolving the Marble Hill issue and that everyone's help is needed. Other public meetings were held at Terre Haute Nov. 2.and ~'" --r at Noblesville Nov. 3.y g, .g.- .,...gy, OVER 7,300 VISITORS TOUR MARBLE HILL DURING OCTOBER OPEN HOUSES,hGULAR TOUR P A record shattering 7,300 visitors toured the Marble Hill con-struction site during the two open houses held in October as well as the site's regular tour program for individuals and l groups. Capping off the month were 3,400 visitors on Oct. 29 during the first open house ever held exclusively for craf t/ contractor per-sonnel. Earlier in October, about 3,200 visitors participated in an open house held for the public, PSI employees and members of their families. l Last year's open house for all Marble Hill employees, their f an-ilies and the public drew about 3,500 visitors. l
. - mr. -~~ ...., wa - 1, 4 w' .W td.-
- N
~ , rt ?;; 4. '1' ' ~ ,.;;p, + 3, 4 s y f , s. 1 9 ass ~ * .? I m
- g. ;..g : ~;.tv
> v ;..,- y,, y'c,q... ..l<,
- d..
- 3. f.Q... -
- );f 9; t; (4'-i ' ' ' h & & WV;[uq
- b?}
sy Yv ' ' k;a./gf4 - *"[. s,
- 4 2,
t i ? + r',.' 14 * ' g.".. - ' 5f %% 44M g p . * /*, ewe *.y .4 e. d 4- . f
- h 8,
4 t
- 4; kk
? ,n - z. 1 l
marb e h5 news etter fnam Public Service Indiana for Marble Hill employees Number 31 ' October 10, 1983 PUBLIC SERVICE INDIANA ANNOUNCES REVISION IN ESTIMATES FOR MARBLE HILL START-L7 PERIOD ~ Public Service Indiana announced today that it had changed its . estimate of the duration of the start-up period needed to bring the Marble Hill project's first unit into com:nercial operation. ~ Recent detailed analysis indicates that 24 months may be necessary to fully complete Unit 1 start-up, rather than the 18 months previously projected. In the nuclear power industry, " start-up" refers to the period between the dates major systems are essentially completed and the date the fuel is loaded. During the start-up phase, more than 400 plant systems are sequentially tested to assure their safety and readiness for operation. The company also announced that it was considering options available'to finish construction more rapidly, within the stringent safety and quality constraints established for the project. The company's Senior Vice President, Nuclear Division, S.W. Shieldsj described the practical effect of the change in start-up period as a reduction in the time available.for construction. He stated that "the main obstacle to meeting our December 1986 commercial operation date for Unit 1 is the remaining electrical work-especially installing large amounts of cable necessary to operate the plant." He said, "We are confident that we can meet the target date in all other areas. We're now analyzing the a electrical area to determine if we can achieve our goals there." Shields also noted that a second contractor began to do electrical work on the site in June. UNITED WAY CONTRIB IONS CONTINUE WITH DONATIONS TOTALING OVER $64,000 TO DATE ~ _________v-_____-.-_--____________ lost, lonely child wanders the treets and finds a temporary h e; a senior citizen shares h es, dreams and memories wit a new-found friend; a si child receives desperately neede surgery at no cost - he situations are virtually endless. one of J e United Way agencies serving the But chance are Kentuckiana es is he,1fing with these and other similarli depressing situ ionsT l l Problemslikethe'sehnaffectanyone--theemployedaswell l as the unemploy'ed. Harble Hill employees heeded the call for help and responded with the most generous level of contributions Although donations a're still arriving, the grand total, ever. \\ s ^I..
_._._ _ - -. - - - - _ n t .2 i l 1 [s m %talbg. ua, J a.. WASHINGTON. D.C. ecces i prent set other ' Pope Page page i fiJ' YO"lK, II,Y. mu SER 14 283 i E0it:i":!G - 041,090 i SUNDAY -1.403.077 4 i i EraMarEndatMarbleHill I i s i l h h N Rising Cost Estimates 6.w.d g,gijg p$g%,y{gg%@P q f, j On Marble Hill Reactor M+, W. Q. A s a. .~m.. c y Putsc Service beene's revloed Q.hQ.ya hMpH k%x -+iM @% E:1Y# e; Q' W Q p M' y + W. p _f.p esameses,in hm6cne of domare, for total 8 (g,W 'p.}f l oenstruccon cost of Martes He reactor. j 4-p. qi y % g { g, p}1-4
- g-hy
,P ;g y O L.ast her shows cunent essmate made bybweenaPuenc 8entoe w v, ,h g g.gsg,,g 1 g u n,. T.. : l N
- k. 4 s k 'h,,.
[. [p / ;/-- - .. a y n, { g TGN.#IQIg.rk gQ,' pg W,,, 6 i 9,T 4,g a, ? D k, "W'M 4 g 4' ~ + - :, 'u w, v 2 { we s i 4e e { n w% g3 : i_ 2 m j ky 7 @g/q,., n,.m ,y i A yn w b, &e w o .c. 7 c 1 Mac esal8* eenenmon seernew
- pj{
g. , a ;,N ' sensw e tteN = vertrume N 16 Af INDIANAPOLIS, Sept.13 - On a bluff overlooldag the Ohio River near .1, c! the ennall farming tw=n= unity of Natilson in southern ladiana, the t Marble Hill melaar power project is less than half tw=nplanad and all but overw nes=ad by costs and e uncertainty over to n. manos Inneanyways,therefore,ltis tike a i mesnber of other nuclear power prefects around the country; roost Power y IAng Island Casapany. In one
- however, is alfferent:
3,,,,,,,,,,, S-D* The Marble 3511 ausleer power project under esmetreados b W Ied. renewofits Stace it wee ordered. in 1974, all of the 31 other reactors ordered in that tion'in late lege, four years beidnd efladiana, the state's larseet utilit year have been maatad along with schedule, and Unit 3 le to go en line has called a "namel espergency.'y,' all of the 18 reeceore ordered in subse-quant years, because of rising cord two y later. Estlanates of the "Ourproblems is one of cash plant s oest have risen froan a 1M3 flow," said Hugi A. , chair. struction costs, higt laternet rates orojection of $1.4 billion to rnare than 'andslack dennand forelectricity. klbullontoday. snan. "It's critical to the point where And Martde Hill's flaam-nal viabu. It requires additional revenues. I ity is no longer clear and there is no The cuenbination of ccst increases. don't think we're talking about de-and delays, including one of 18 fault. What we are talking about is the i genrantee thet it will eurvive sither. inanths for related pieblems, ability to proceed from: here to fl. Unit'l of the 3,200 snegawatt nu.. has created t Martde Bill's clear +1 ant is planned to begin opera. owner, the Pubtle Service Connpany g Page g )
- cnt, I
Y"-
3. 4 s md w w a g u w e cawam*s C.e -, _, ore.. -. % MarNe Hill Atam Plant Ei.o,aam*.my* ( unit from W . ochedule MayMark an Ers 's Ends.k':e,e,s ih e .e T i the sayhg that delays would
- r' anna-ad Fne First Belmees Page,
N 1 ' Ins, lor.or.i ce Servi -a.d.gte-i ed a.a to u ite e.o. With SLS sunkla the c'e0 temere for the $130.7 mamma cost en peelset, Public Servloe's levestment j ' the plant over 15 years, but ed not i i e searly equal to the vales af allite ausw the utiuty any rate of return eral other electree stuity plaats. Revenue i DIANA (, tse investment. la the H years $500 fees rate payere has est kept pace wie the deseands of east. ' es pmpct was plassed, cost nee 1 i hom8187adlues anS.8
- p his Eul, PuMis un-i i
eMe to teses lhet mort. . d( Whus Public ase.' l hende. Its.least supeestv' say they win not need $s electricierr b ISB0's,y bladio 3481 tatu tha, l ef . As a result, i j.. compand wieb the leer l Servlee said,the osm* f e, as earner peeested, critissu i peely's credit statum has deserterated centend that the plant is set aseded ar-i andit aset asw horrow a por*, I ., =,,,, =, =,,, nJ.n. a 's' ' .te.ww.towe.,ama, ',1,_M., wmte.ie,1, ant," said is.
- 'EE"a na es hope of esefia==cani an t., men a.d -
ne =1,= I customere frnm the of huge { rate imenesse when the plant
- neue Cousino, saamative erector c(
now vannaan. theCittaen ActionCoalition,anladia,, l t to plan" the . ouldincreaseelectrkityratesIper., ',, Service - l w eastforeachof thenestsiayears. .:'sJ has a reserve snargin of ting-er tyof N percent. g 1he plan, wWeh would===* tally Caldwell,a analyst withDuffh* countered est the reserve pay construction costs before th~ePhelpe Inc. of . 1 heir esp closer to 40 percent and that i plant le comp % seet with vocifer* struction may have been a little overJ Itu will be needed in theless run. sus ceanummer esa legleistive oppost* ambitious for the Tto.They W As it , aces of the alters., entalmesan. certainly not close uitor tives now Pubhc Service and, l Gov. Robert D.Orrjeunped into the tidng hka that. I tMnk they're its ladiana rate payere are attractive. l camiroversy la lese August. act the best situnuca." plant. But
- If the company e plan to phase ces:,
capable of Malaklag the that "pubiu ammad= man in "Y stauction costo lato rates le danaad, i - ^" was at stehe, he asked b_tasassia Putile Servies Connade FarFrom Uelque W the utility says it wul need an smarr ..y 9,,,y,g, g,,,,,,, og gg,g,,,,,m, seen, winch tegelates utility rates, to Of course, Public Service's it and wiu have to seek higher. cost i delay action sa Public Servloe's rete lame are far froen unique.
- , methods of the plant. If he eestrue plan untu a panel of five hust. troubled concern le the le canceled,
, Public i l asasleadoreseuldstudytheleeue. , Lighting ran9aav, wWeh le and lamana consumere wul "If the ammmpany le la a completely for big rate lacreaser to help paf a seul have a 8L0 tiluon bevestment to l tenueus flammenal ettuation, ces that the Shoreham suclear plant in B gathenwlth. herdess es insolveney, them it would haven,L.I. Apanel by i est he unreasemeMe per the comunit. ernor Cuomo a a=n mang the n seetorecommendapiesbywtdcenthe quences of scrapplag the SIA d I Luhters as moretroubledlethe W y Orr. ton Public Power Supply u Even thoudt Pelec Seevice in. wtuch delmalted in July on .35 g'3 eressed seseh evidende by 18 comtein lion in boede used to namara two Is toS.73 a share,its tremides have, clear power plante that wt!! sensedconcern sanoeg analyste. never heihmished. "I woukt describeit as a good coen. Public' Service, which le pany havtag protneme," said t.lada the roost esponsive and caly power plant la laetan,said that tryingtoevert a sinuarca One other reactor was anos na drawing beards in lamana: la ! 3 Northern lamana Puhuc Servicii I t - - - - ~ ~_,-
/ UNITED STATES 4 [ NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS810N 5 VWASHINGTON, D. C. 20006
- g.....
APR 0 61983 + Docket Nos.: STN 50-546 i and STN 50-547 APPLICANT: Public Service Company of Indiana a FACILITY: Marble Hill Nuclear Generating Station
SUBJECT:
SupptARY 0F CASEL0AD FORECAST PANEL MEETING AND FACILITY TOUR t AT MARBLE HILL, UNITS 1 AND 2 i SupetARY On December 1, 2 and 3,1982 the NRC Caseload Forecast Panel (CFP) met with Public Service of Indiana (PSI) and toured the Marble Hill Nuclear Generating Station, Units 1 and 2. The purpose of the meeting and tour was to review construction progress and collect data for assessing the projected fuel load date for Unit 1. The visit was organized into two parts: 4 1. On December 1 a meeting was held with the applicant to review design and engineering, procurment and construction progress on Marble Hill, Units 1 and 2. l 2. On December 2 and 3 a tour of the Marble Hill, Units 1 and 2 site was held to observe the status of construction. In summary, the applicants expected dates for fuel load are June 1986 for Unit 1 i and December 1987 for Unit 2. Due to abilities to modify construction schedules, a six month differential within a three year projection of construction comple-tion is sufficiently accurate to accept the applicant's fuel load date and sche-duel the staff's review. Data from this CFP visit will be compared to information gathered on subsequent visits to Marble Hill during construction. Should the CFP determine that Marble Hill Unit I will not be ready for fuel load within six months of the applicant's schedule, measures will be taken to resolve the discrep-ancy and adjust the licensing schedule if necessary. t i I l t
MEETING AND FACILITY TOUR DETAILS Wednesday, December 1.1982 at Marble Hill Nuclear Generatino Station. New Washinoton. Indiana The CFP met with PSI at the visitors center on the Marble Hill site in New Washington, Indiana. The meeting was open to public observers as stated in the meeting notice issued on November 16, 1982. A list of attendees is included as. The applicants presentation to the staff was divided in eleven parts correspond-ing to'the eleven areas of information requested by the staff in the meeting agenda attached to the meeting notice. Beginning with a project overview PSI presented a list of major accomplishments in 1982. By November 15, 1982 the NSSS vessels were in place and loop piping had been started in the Unit 1 containment. The Unit 2 containment hip and dome had been set by October 23, 1982. A list of Major Accomplishments,1982 is included as Enclosure 2. The applicant reviewed the status of design and engineering efforts for struc-tural, mechanical and electrical disciplines. On October 31, 1982 structural engineering was shown to be 89% complete for Unit 1. Mechanical engineering was 54% complete, and electrical engir.eering was 48% complete. The overall engineer-ing effort was shown to be 64% complete for Unit 1. Similarly the overall engineering effort for Unit 2 was shown to be 38% c'osplete. Structural engineer-was 87% complete, mechanical engineering was 27% complete and electrical engineer-ing was 31% complete. The applicant reviewed the status of design drawings. By October 31, 1982 99% of both structural and architectural drawings were released. 05% of all mechanical design drawings were released. More than 90% of most mechanical drawings were released, however, only 42% of hanger drawings were released. 54% of all elec-trical design drawings for Unit 1 and common facilities were released and 14% of electrical drawings for Unit 2 were released. PSI reminded the CFP that because Marble Hill is a replicate of Byron the project establishes design criteria, prepares calculations and issues design information only for those features which are unique to Marble Hill. The applicant presented the status of procurement of valves, pipe, cable, cable trays, major mechanical equipment and major electrical equipment. Shipment of valves, cable and cable tray is scheduled to be completed in 1983. Shipment of other materials will be completed in 1985. e e
- PSI reviewed the Marble Hill craft work force. Annual manpower averages for all crafts were shown for the period from 1982 through 1988. The largest average work force of 2200 was shown for 1983. 2282 craft people were reported to be at Marble Hill on October 31, 1982. The applicant showed total manpower information for electricians, pipefitters and sheetmetal workers. Major craft manpower peaks for Unit 1 will be in 1984 and peaks for Unit 2 will be in 1986. The applicant indicated that there may be a shortage of electricians in mid 1984. Labor agree-ment expiry dates were shown with eleven of eighteen contracts scheduled to expire in 1983. The current status of large and small bore pipe hangers, restraints and i snubbers was reviewed. PSI noted that the formal pipe hanger analysis for Unit I will be complete by about March 1983. The analysis is resulting in a i deletion of approximately 10% of the pipe hangers included in the previous preliminary analysis. 270 pipe whip restraints have been procured although l 2" and 4" diameter restraints have not yet been designed. The applicant esti-mates that approximately 35 of these restraints will be required for each unit based on the Byron design. 4 Pemanent snubbers will not be installed until late in the construction program. The applicant employs a surrogate snubber program so that temporary snubbers are placed to occupy space during construction that pemanent snubbers will occupy. ^ PSI reviewed the project schedule. Construction of Unit 1 was shown to be 43.8% complete while construction of Unit 2 was 25.7% complete. Overall construction for both units is 37.8% complete. Project percent complete is shown in Enclosure 3. PSI reviewed project critical path items, identifying one critical path item and five potential critical path items. The auxiliary building, Area 5. Elevation 364' is -1/2 month critical path. The auxiliary building, Elevation 383', Area 2 is potential critical path. The containment large bore pipe, quadrant 3 is potential critical path. [ Containment conduit design is potential critical path. l Loop piping is potential critical path. Main control board delivery is potential critical path. PSI presented the requested information concerning bulk ouantities for Units 1 and 2 and combined. This information is included in Enclosures 4, 5 and 6. The status of the Marble Hill preoperational test program was reviewed. 189 pre-operational tests have been identified for Unit 1 fuel load. 108 are non-safety j related 80P, and 81 are safety related. The first preoperational test was sche- . duled to start on December 1,1982. Sixty-nine subsystems were released to construction test and 36 subsystems were turned over to the station. i l ~ ~ -, ,-~.nn--,---e--nn,,n-.e.wnn,,,n_,
- m., e Q _
n,-,n-.,~,,,.__...~__,..._--,,
Thursday and Friday, Decenber 2 and 3,1982 at Marble Hill Nuclear Generating Station, New Washington, Indiana The CFP toured the Marble Hill site on Thursday and Friday to observe the status of construction. Among the areas observed were the turbine building, the auxiliary building, Unit 1 containment building, the pipe fab shop and equipment laydown areas. The CFP's observations of construction activities were consistent with the infor-mation presented in Wednesday's meeting. E. L. Doolittle, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing
Enclosures:
As Stated e
APR 0 61983 MEETING SUWARY 7 Docu:nent Control (50-423) -NRC PDR L PDR PRC System 'NSIC i.LBf1 Rdg. M. Rushbrook . Project Manager E. Doolittle . Attorney, OELD 'J. Love 1 ace
- OPA*
NRC PARTICIPANTS E. Doolittle W. Lovelace J. Harrison P.'Pelke
- CASELOAD FORECAST. PANEL VISITS e
g . M W e a 0 e a . h 's m; e e e g e e g g
Ma. S. W. Shields Santor Vice President - Nuclear Division Public Service Company of Indiana P. O. Box 190 New Washington, Indiana 47162 cc: Jon D. Noland, Esq. Mr. E. P. Martin Senior Vice President and General Counsel General Manager Public Service of Indiana Wabash Valley Power Association, 1000 E. Main Street Inc. Plainfield, Indiana 46168 ' P. 0.^8cx 24700 l 722 North High School Road Mr. William Kortier Indianapolis, Indiana 46224 Water Reactor Division Westinghouse Electric Corporation Mr. James G. Keppler P. O. Box 355 U. S. NRC, Region III Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Mr. P. L. Wattelet < Sa.rgent & Lun,dy Engineers Don F. Martin, Esq. ' 55 East Monroe Street General Counsel Chicago, Illinois 60603 Wabash Valley Power Association. Inc.. Harry H. Voight, Esq. P. O. Box 24700 LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae 722 North High School Road 1333 New Hampshire Avenue, N. W. Indianapolis, Indiana 46224 Washington, D. C. 20036 Thomas M. Dattilo Esq. 311 East Main Street Madison, Indiana 47250 Louisville Water Company ATTN: Mr. Stephen A. Hubbs Environmental Engineer 435 South Third Street Louisville, Kentucky 40202 Mrs. David G. Frey t Sassafras Audubon Society 2625 S. Smith Road l. Bloomington, Indiana 47401 hr. J. J. Harrison, Jr. U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm. i Resident Inspectors Office 3738 Marble Hill Road l Nabb, Indiana 47174 i l a e
e, ENCLOSURE 1 -NRC CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL MEETING DECEMBER 1.1982 LIST OF ATTENDEES NRC Participants E. Doolittle W. Lovelace J. Harrison P. Pelke PSI Participants J. Pope L. Kruse D. Jo111ffs J. Thomas G. Warner J. Layden G. Sinders S. Brewer W. Wogsland G. Allan T. Burns S. Quinn H. Hodge J. Brewer R. Porter B. Spence S. Shields J. Bott W. Petro Other Participants L. Frey H. Cassidy P. Dillinger 6
Crvio u" A - MAJOR ACC(PFLISifHTS 1982 UNir 1 TURBINE /6ENERATOR-READY FOR OIL FLUSH 06-01-8,2 ~ 08-19-82 CIv L/ STRUCTURAL COMPLETE RIVER PUMPHOUSE ~ 5 - ROUsH SET REACTOR VESSEL 08-28-82 765 KV SWITCHYARD COMPLETE 09-15-82 CIRCULATING WATER P. UMP HOUSE STRUCTURALLY COttPLETE 10-15-82 START LOOP PIPING - NSSS VESSELS IN PLACE 11-15-82 tr-UNIT 2 COMPLETE' CONTAINMENT SPRAY PIPING IN DOME 09-01-82 POLAR CRANE SET 09-25-82 - HIP AND DOME SET 10-23-82 ) OTHER FSAR & ER SUBMITTED 11~-26-82 4 CLFP 12/1/82 G g e S k e e
trc'=>. : D I.C PROJECT PERCENT COMPLETE 1. ENGINEERING A. UNIT 1 64% 1. STRUCTURAL 89% 2. ELECTRICAL 48% t 3. MECHANICAL '54% B. UNIT 2 38% 1. strut:TuRAL 87% 2. ELECTRICAL 31% 3. MECHANICAL 27% 2. CONSTRUCT!0N A. PROJECT 37.'8% B. UNIT 1 43.8% 1. Crvtt 82.5% 2. ELECTRICAL 22.3% 3. PIPING 27.8% 4. MECHANICAL 32.0% C. UNIT 2 25.7% 1. Civil 63.1% 2. ELECTRICAL 11.9% 3. P!P!NG 14.2% 4. MECHANICAL 22.0% CLFP 12/1/82 i t [ w +
Ecous x d msa.i.-riix IMITI IDHILY MlH.Y AGIN. EST. FERENT lt6TAl SETAlp EST. ACHN. (DRETE MTE M1E ~ 31 CGERETE (CD 228,912 399,755 5 3,2D 3,055 PirE - LB (Secou0 32,073 5,07/ 42 '256 227 ~ SB QF) 215,732 20,0F 30 L500 4,220 l ~ lhM0ERS IB 38,33) 4,180 23 202 420 SB . 20,571 2,GB 30 350 422 DELE IMY 74,E 24,W8 33 2,W 2,M Camir G000 .667,316 267,486 40 10,900 WA T 412,225 7LE80 37 6,800 10A50 Dets 5,015,358 335,165 3 0' 190,000 ~ TEMEMUG8S 195,1fA 5,GB 3 0 7,000 BAS OfP 12/01/82 l 1
1 frr m 2, -l omane nessumu., ~ WET II 1950 1901U ~ ACRK EST. PBEBII IIEUL. SEUUIED EST. ACRK G M EIE IIRE IIUE GROSE @ B3 78,395 m L32D LW5 i Pwe ~ 5,127 L2PI 25 20 86 LB~ GroOLS) 3 GF) 1LGB 4,lD2 4 - 200 2,557 -l Itsuuns 4,551 L452 32 6 ,/0 ' LBs n,m est 4 20 2ss DeLETARY 31,55 14, lie W 22 ~ 7W Gneuer 0000 216,565 .19,595 9 LED 'll/A N,513 B,555 7 L750 9,ED ~ OeLE SlE,Gi6 3,410 0 L700 175,GB Temusmous H.M 0 0 0 5,ED ~ B4S e e
Enttive. L. ' DEElDB PIESBilATI(N's (UBIED PER&NT EST. ERN. UN'LEIE G m E E (CY) ~322,17/ 2 78, 1118 86 PIPE - LB (Spoots) 17,200 6,351 37 SB Of) 336,751 2fi,909 7 ~ Ym (Greie amove) HueGERS LB 22,800 5,612 25 2,190 7 1 SB 3t1,000 OWLETRAY ,36,E 39,E 37 QueuiT 001AO 885,908 287,(F9 32 NT 61L738 85,2fl3 Ill OWLE 8,1%72fl .138,573 2 TE MIM U W S 3281,290 5,000 2 BAS QFP 12/01/82
r-mo 3 m-mm._ s 1 y 1 .._s 1
- ?4Sbk_4h 1$ 4 / 4 n b A Y 5.N9NCK-JonL Abf N' kwL br lEb.LY 3
tow 7b.I $ O _b E3,boSLN !ot,_ s us L 1 !/wi a n e L L u g a {eba I l O_.af 6 a_$_-. fmuA o 11 I I T i LlrJA _Jl I I I !I .:!oj Xy I L ',J ' i j i j i i i urr: ..t t re. G a-La% lol,yoLLF GACoo
- en k1 d_N 7
4 d Mo b u S_ d. f-NLIL = p_b L__ e,A =W4 r Y AI/2GL./bpsdha.sJ fe~n e-4.sA ~Ogoc I _.J_h3_k EM1b at WLEO- _) h L l'a tps. ,r 1__. /.EJa p #i Nai al *J Jg 9 Jp o d-e 4,y 9 pg + 9 m g, g, m c : .c n I .s. .l 1 MN4L b/fB YeLgL_.fn_-JO_5,_ffS .N.O/o.k Za.nr p 30 0Q I rd / kr,Uh b, th l I
- _1_
j .i TalaAoL---)45,ANS. GL.t.oo LVrws]l 4' l l l l l Unt n.-[0-Yo Od"_fb Me_f? OM% q- &srm]u.o_.b.M'."
- i. 343*4
!'kh- +1,,h ,i e i 4% E7F !l !!h! I l IId.d R N.P4 [_ i L.d_L1 1 17<<ec i '_t i __ O, y h e 1 oa M)m l \\ ras.Jat I i i l-L 7- % DA. t;Al FL ~~32 Ma l % mr Aww : ruyne wm,..us r3, 3 l n n .. + g3 re-4a Jea,,13S .pt - t . vcJ .ts r m s a s. I 4 /. >Jo_fokf_LLXe AL =-_Er .m 7 q r ?//did }e* _ R>.7nLCEP' :f.b]fp.ESd O 4CUAtEY f l J%__ rema.__ ass 4L._&_.._b_L. [ l ._j_1__ 7c_si*- ---h5##4'f l i t o... _. _ t toA[ _ o rr.2,cin_p_ + pa_; j ._g i 1 i.. d_;._ _ a - dp1_7pSPAA/4.T.oo.o EdnA_uli I. j L _L___ L s s h oa!Aeoirc i isL 1 1 ! L I i i i ii; i i I 7. 7. 7-3-- T^~ ~M'~~~~ r 1 i . _. t __4_ i_4 f l } } [ ..__L 4 _4 } 1 o 1 1 1 1 m i 1 1 1 i ,,1 i i
_-w- - - - - -- y y i I I i I I l I l 7 Sm_!,( MnL4Scr / f3,. / 4 Y l l l l '\\ i i i i i m A! !I i #4 mew I I t rJ eo e i i 4 I I I g I l !I /I'y I JI/ff/dg'd dioo d M !! 1&_I I pa_IAA!! [ffL . l i .fg T 3 Olf 6 I I I l l l (' l . ' *:u-sGS
- 9
-t;
- Q
. i: l l f: ~) \\ . ___h' - y. -9 4,*: 28 hy EJ d h i .. 'l 3 '.i l '6 3,, i r 61 l 6 g 1 g kr., ?- * -4. +- ~~ l c, 5 i ~l +- j l
- / 'ff g5t 7 A4 e4 M
/ .g 4 --4 j l l 2 . _. } l l I t i j l l i l l .4 l [ t i I I I I l \\ t --+.---4 l l I 4 l
- -d i
i i ~ i i l i 1 i i i ~ l k i i 1 i l f I I i -~ l l l e . -. + I I i l i 1 i i I l I i t I I j I I I f.g3 ..? %iI s.;:- t y!g ; }, ,g .N I ~ ~ 6 f l h ff a l
- i t Dg,
{3 3 .K, <h,[' 7%' .-f y .p 4 ' ( '- 1 1 .Lo k l .s ? _j r1 i ' *j _ ki 4, p i. l r r 's 9
- y:-
t l y. ,1 51 ff "- Wl s'. A./ .. u - p 1 7 4 i l i - i -7 J i i i i { L t_t p-j l I i I l I i _,i p ;t m i i I [ l I i r_ + _.r w_ j . - - _7 . d____ _ _ _ _L_ L____d_[._d_l_d l t I i i I i l I i I i T Y ~f i i Fi l l i l i j i i + ..- -.i .4 a , _ t _i_._, - t,_ __ t t .i___ t _,___ a 1 c ;-
_ E _L_ _ L_._L J _..... _ P7P~7 1___ i__ L__ L__ L L__ -_ _i_ L _i -1__-_.__i__ ___L.i ' b [ F RI I i I l s/rs [ l I j i l } i + i i t l l l l i ^ -t _!_rEnAr!vid j j l - * ~ ~ ,_,-t BAdo2s d! I,na $_NL(rom <,_kur) 4. k51.1Mfi$$ll& GNosrs 3.3 L. A 4 8,i, v L N. .J,._.k,, W /iysuJd,ahAJul
- Ilob, 3
r ,7 ..-.nNAAl M2 !$f .$ Of 'k I e a ^^ g 5 _bL ..is sL7f._W
- ,}ps
/42,_an sc4tr.nor Q En %nLF ^ kJ.n2L& Jrks dah r L,.Q.f_i .-;Goan,a i W Jchaa A rs s,sw e ur.3sa in
- 54) j'p_A rg-r i ws 2 _ono
.A L, d.aica e
- Mw.
L. s y i .e.- .,_-_z_ & 27 ]&>K n' ~ ,l ... ~. l. f m I I l __a 4 2_. f 1 l . ' _ _l l l I 7 .I r.ee.s= I g ,,m w_ ! t_Lia_iii,!;I LLl i. i ii: i i iI t I l l l 1 i i i 3 l l l P i l l _ _4 l l l 4 i !l l l l l l l h I -_4 i i l d l i i ^ j j e m + 9.g .a s- ~., u- ~. =. \\ n +
- 1. 2 4
k. j .t i i I ) e en~ -, I i - - - h ---+ 9 -} 4~ _( ._t i i I L_u u_1 i 1 I 4 [7!_7; !i I i i I I l__L_p__i_._1_d___! i i l i i I i i i I i t 0 + I I I l l-1 1 1 l l L_i i 1 I O i i i i I i wwww i 1 1 i i i i i i i i ^ i
j ,i 0 l l l l [l l l l l l l f j
- 2'+~
z! % ~ s _.._1 /_l/_-l I t l I I I 6 1 l o.n _.l _ _. _ i 1 ( -..i i s -r l i i i i t i i. L. r l A l l l l I im l M i i i I l l i j j t j j j j .sm s 1. l _ i_ _.1 1 +a S. i dAl @ 9 7pc. / Q/ . _ 2N, T a W fJ. .f. p..kk,4s 6 -I ., _.a, _b i...__b.- s._ s e r, i
- -- r-i
- _ _72l 1_. t ,l i 1 i i I I I I l l i t _ _ n__. ._t___ c_ t_u l i I i 4 Ii i 4 i l 1 -- +-- [ j j - ) i j i .. 1 _ _ i j l j .i i I l u_ I a i l 4 ~ i 4 i l n i T i i I l i i 1 4
- Q 3h
= ^ y '[j = ,9 ., y ' "'1 g --- l l (.. n_1 l I .g. O '} l l a - a x y r C 1 i j j y 3 i - +- .L ._h .l i i I i ~ ~~ i 1 i l i i i i i 1 I i 7 j i i i i j i f i i l l I i I I i 1-t l 7 t }.I i l I I I I t rT ! i i j j ! ~l n !i t l l i i i i
- l l
i 1 q_ i
T ~ I Y Y li _ 'l l j{ I ii! l I. i l 1 l l t i I l iI I I l' R, _I __ I i j l i i i l I s .t i j ~ 'k f ' ]fp j l 1 i 3 p N, i i y T-l e r 'd l 4 g g m n T M s t 9 j j c e 4 c:., vl^ r ,ip s N _A l 1 o. i 1 \\ l l N i i r-T I k l l l l l i ~ j ( ll l l l i l s i, l1, \\ N _4. I l i i s \\* 4 l j s '~ q{ \\, l l j \\%\\ _ M x 3(3 2B r 2_t s \\ah le i l 1 s 4 tv x, g, c 2 m w -s s. - mww\\ m. m i yy-k_. w y t s s s "q s' ) g Y Q .% Q & [ ~ g t m pq v c gg c u T N NY A% Q- ( [; i i ~ h l \\ i . a L M x x _ x. 4 i i g 2 N s . _ _y [ t l l l i i u _t s l i i i i pt g L. l l
- _1 I.
N i l i i r i k A i i i j
e w-e, tow =yy .,7 m 6, ( '\\ .. \\,s Fi -. = N ~ t a.- s. nm, f. cm,r n -? n. .<4 w ._I, '"'r ~.v.e. Y gA, e 'J F
- n F *Te i sia,*;psWW.2piggyf7Q Q' fl.y
.*: y. n
- e r*
- ; y" 4
CASElD0 F0ECAST P#EL ~ '.e,. q %.e <.y w 4 - a p s... . s,,' 3.,. .s 4+ 'F MMBLE HILL ECifAR GEERATIE STATION w n.+. a - I. PUBLIC SERVIE IEIANA i - 44 ec-w, ^ g IECENER 1-3,1982 ~ ~ J. ' ^ 4^- '} '.'g*- y i .-m e.. _.. q,, l ?? , '.l,\\.- t'. k* *r t ' y y ' + kA 3 -@ x;.s.:,_. _ =+ - % ,.jy p. s e f*- 4 1 A., ; v -- + %-
- N _4
..L -- ,s 4'<.t,,' ~ : *
- e. ;
e ' %.f s f-3..,og _u r g o 'A s C.. ". ' F.. af c vt d '[ h % I % k '4 [w ak -.4x4' }'. ',? > '.M... ; flu,.,Fs.*/ 'i g]h, G,.r,^. %.,>..p..n- _r ,... s, ,L .-a ..,. v ;r - ,+,5 T-. .f~,, Y ~, e' ) 6 Y 6 q (
- 0. $
u... .m, ...,y , p >.. w ~ n. s . w.e l y., ,'s i j' n> 3, b ~ 4
- ?
9* 9 4 a b ~ 2 .{ k 1-- m f' .t y ~3 .- n ~. __,....~,,,,,,.,_..._~._.~e~_.n--------.... - -.,,...
CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL MEETING AGENDA DECEMBER 1,1982 TIME TOPIC SPEAKER 9:00 - 9:05 Opening Remarks W. Petro 9:05 - 9:25 overview of project construction including W. Petro progress and major milestones completed, current problems and any anticipated problem e areas that may impact the current projected fuel load date. 9:25 - 9:55 Detailed review and current status of design T. Burns and engineering effcrt (by major discipline) including any potential problems that may arise from necessary rework. 9:55 - 10:15-Detailed review of current status of procure-H. Hodge ment activities including valves, pipe, instru-ments, cable, major components, etc. 10:15 - 10:35 Actual and proposed craft work force (by major D. Layden craft), craft availability, productivity, potential labor negotiations and problems. 10:35 - 10:50 Break 10:50 - 11:20 Detailed review and current status of all S. Quinn i large and small bore pipe hangers, restraints, anubbers, etc., including design, re' work, procurement, fabrication, delivery and installation. 11:20 - 11:50 Detailed review of project schedule identify-C. Allan ing critical path items, near critical items, l amount of float for various activities, the i current critical path to fuel loading, methods of implementation of corrective action for any l activities with negative float, and provisions l for contingencies. The estimated project ( (;i percent complete as of October 31, 1982. 11:50 - 12:30 Lunch 1: / 4 I
CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL MEETING AGENDA y DECEMBER 1,1982 (Continued) j TIME TOPIC SPEAKER 12:30 - 1:30 Detailed review and current status of bulk B. Spence quantities including current estimated quantities, quantities installed to date, quantities scheduled to date, current complete for each, actual versus forecast installation rates, in cubic yards /mo., linear feet /mo., or basis for figures. (a) Concrete (CY) (b) Process Pipe (LF). I l - Large Bore Pipe (2 1/2" and larger) - Small Bore Pipe (2" and smaller) (c) Yard Pipe (LF) (d) Large Bore Pipe Hangers, Restraints, Snubbers (es) (e) Small Bore Pipe Hangers, Restraints (ea) l: (f) Cable Tray (LF) ( (g) Total Conduit (LF) l l (h) Total Exposed Metal Conduit (LF) l (i) Cable (LF) l l - Power - Control - Security l - Instrumentation - Plant Lighting (j) Terminations (ea) - Power - Control - Security - Instrumentation - Plant Lighting IW
~ CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL MEETING AGENDA DECEMBER 1,1982 (Continued) i TIME TOPIC SPEAKER 12:30 - 1:30 (k) Electrical Circuits (ea) (Cont.) 4 - Power - Control - Security (1) Instrumentation (ea) 4 I -1:30 - 1:55 Overview of current construction and startup J. Brewer management organization showing interfaces between the two. i. 1:55 - 2:35 Detailed review and current status of prepara-J. Brewer tion of preop and acceptance test procedures, integration of preop and acceptance test activ-ities with construction schedule, system turnover schedule, preop and acceptance tests schedule, current and proposed preop and accept-ance tests program manpower. (a) Total number of procedures required for fuel load. (b) Number of draft procedures not started. (c) Number of draft procedures being written. (d) Number of procedures approved. (e) Number of procedures in review. (f) Total number of preop and acceptance tests required for fuel load. (g) Number of preop and acceptance tests l l completed. (h) Number of preop and acceptance tests currently in progress. (i) Number of systems turned over to -start-up. 2:35 - 2:50 Break 2:50 - 3:10 Detailed discussion of potential scheduler S. Brewer influence due to changes attributed to NUREG-0737 and other recent licensing L 3 requirements. L'[ 3:10 - '3:30 Discussion of schedular impact, if any, S. Brewer lI regarding potential deficiencies reported in accordance with 10 CFR 50.55(e). 1 3 ~
CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL MEETING AGENDA TIME TOPIC SPEAKER . DECEMBER 2, 1982 9:00 - ? Site tour and observation of construction G. Sinders activities. G. Warner DECEMBER 3, 1982 9:00 - ? Exit Meeting I l 1 l. J.. i L t' l l l i f l. i
e t. I' f t W. M. ETR0 VIE PRESIENT-IU1 EAR SERVI &S 1 l. b I t t [ t-t- -
l MAJOR ACCOMPLISHMENTS 1982 UNIT 1 1 TURBINE / GENERATOR READY FOR OIL FLUSH 06-01-82 CIVIL / STRUCTURAL COMPLETE RIVER PUMPHOUSE 08-19-82 I ROUGH SET REACTOR VESSEL 08-28-82 765 KV SWITCHYARD COMPLETE .09-15-82 i CIRCULATING WATER PUMP HOUSE STRUCTURALLY COMPLETE 10-15-82 START LOOP PIPING - NSSS VESSELS IN PLACE 11-15-82 i i e UNIT 2 COMPLETE CONTAINMENT SPRAY PIPING IN DOME 09-01-82 POLAR CRANE SET 09-25-82 HIP AND DOME SET 10-23-82 j OTHER FSAR & ER SUBMITTED 11-26-82 4 I 4 l CLFP 12/1/82 i
't I I)ESIGN AND ENGIEERING ERW I I 4 f T. R. BURNS PRUECT ENGIEERING MNGER i l-I. t i I t. I l t I l l 7
~~ i
- 15
""~~~~~~~ 4 ENGINEERING STATUS INDEX (ESI) j ' / ** " y i UNIT 1 8 i l -h h / he i l E' 100- / / ) ---~y --~_._ b J COW OSITE ,, e " / l mB STRUCTURAL s#< l ~ i i 5 ' s/'s / eg p/ g j s g / / l\\ l / l / ,l R / I l W2. / l I 2 NEOiANICAL CURREKrSTATUS d l g ELECTRICAL 5 ESi 89 (+2) l g ESi 5fl(+2) n g 3, ESI (+1) E ESi 6fl(+2) l i g, l I um SauxuD g ACTUAL 0_ t i N6 19'87 pggt LOAD 10/31/82 CLFP J2/J/82
i ENGIEERING STATUS It0EX (ESI) p UNIT 2 ,/' d s' } .h I ~ 100 - COMPOSITE ..,.., w3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ gl s"# -l l f / l p . 50 e g STRUCTLRAL / / l 75 - / / l / / l i \\ / / CLRRENT STATUS S I 'o i i l l,' / / ESl 87(+2) l 3 l W 50. / 27 (+1) f ESIM i / f d / ESI 31(0) / ./ E l 4 / ESI 38(+1) 8 ,e COMP. l 1
- s l
l W ' ~ ~ - LEGEND MEOiANICAL I 25 _ Samum ELECTRICAL I AcTtal g i I 0 l 1982 1983 198t1 1985 1986 1987 FUEL 10SV& W MVE
REPLICATION DESIGN CRITERIA REPLICATION CONTROL CRITERIA: 1)C-RN-01-MH, REV. 7 ESTABLISHES: PLANT DESIGN PHILOSOPHY, BASE PLANT BEING REPLICATED, APPROACH TO LICENSING, ENGINEER-ING DESIGN PROCEDURE, CONTROL OF CHANGES FROM REPLICATION. APPLIES TO: ALL DESIGN ACTIVITIES UP THROUGH 0.L.; PROCUREMENT ACTIVITIESJ SAFETY AND NON-SAFETY RELATED ASPECTS OF PLANT DESIGN WITH CERTAIN AUTHORIZED EXCEPTIONS. I i BASIC REPLICATION DESIGN APPROACH: MARBLE HILL PROJECT REPRODUCES THE FINAL (DESIGN-IMPLEMENTING) DESIGN DOCUMENTS FROM BYRON, I.E., MARBLE HILL PROJECT DOES NOT ESTABLISH DESIGN CRITERIA NOR PERFORM DESIGN CALCULATIONS FOR REPLICATE FEATURES OF THE PLANT. FOR I UNIQUE FEATURES, THE MARBLE HILL PROJECT ESTABLISHES DESIGN CRITERIA, PREPARES CALCULATIONS AND ISSUES UNIQUE DESIGN INFORMATION. l 1 ClFP.12/ W l' i ~. Lo
M IGN CRITERIA STATUS ALL DESIGN GITERIA HAVE BEEN ADPR0/ED AND ISSUED, 1 0.ASSIFICATION GITERIA 3 STRUCTURALIESIGN CRITERIA r i 37 PEOMNICAL DESIGN GITERIA t i l 17 ELECTRICALIESIGN CRITERIA t. 58 TOTAL DESIGi CRITERIA O 9 i i l' l- -//-
SPECIFICATIm STATIE SPECIFICATIONS SPECIFICATIG6 AWARnFD LNAWARnFD ggL STRICTURAL 25 1 26 ECHANICAL 152 15 357 EECTRICAL _3Z _1 _E TOTAL 214 17 231 l. CLFP WIM -l? - s. L
l [NAWARnFil SPECIFICATI@S SPEC to. (DISCIPLIND Y-2817C (PD FIE FicitLi10N Y-2828B&C @ TIEMAL INSLLATION I~ .Y-2829 @ INSTRPENT CALIBRATIm FACIL. Y-2842 @ COUNTIE ROM INSTIUENTATIm Y-2898 CD IUDIE FULTIPLEXIE SYSTEM Y-2910 (PD TORNAD0/IS0lATIm IWPERS Y-2911 (FD C0f0ENSATE QERP SYSTEM Y-2916 @ STATIM AllXILIARf DIESEL GEN. Y-2926 (M) - MISC.' CMTROL SY5BS Y-2929 @ STARTUP FEEDWATER PLPP Y-2954 @ STRUCTURAL IfffEGRITY & ifAK RATE TESTIE Y-2984 @ HIGH RADIATION S#FLE SYSTEM Y-2985 (PD ASPE FASTEERS ' Y-2986 (M) VIBRATION P0NITORIE SYSTEM Y-2987 @ MISC, PIPIE SLFPORT f%TERIAL ll Y-2988 @ RADWASTE #f0NIA REPDVAL SYSTEM -/. p I CLFP12/1/82 F 1 - jg -
@h&9 6@s G' s e w E E ) e e = e a a ls*H L a e e s ie g m a a b E U b b $n E=2 a a a k2 l = 5 1: - I sf -. ~
~ 'AIJXILIARY~ BUILDING ELEVATION AREA SCHEDULED P.ELEASE l ACTUAL RELE/.SI EL. 364'- 0" 07 82 07 - O l-62 ~ EL. 42d-O" AREA 1 07-!5-62 07-15-82 EL. 43 9'-C' AREA I EL 451'-C' ARIA I EL 426'-O" AREA 2 EL. 354'- 6" 08-02-02 08- 02-02 EL. 355'-4" EL. 355'- 2" EL 374'- 6" EL. 375'- 6" EL. 376'-0" EL 38 -O' d EL 330'-O" 08 82 08-16-82 EL 346'- 0" EL. 439'- 0" AREA 2 ~~ EL. 409'- G" AREA 6 EL. 4 51'- 0" AREA 2 EL. 426'- O' AREA 3 EL. 391 '-6" EL 392'-6" ~ EL 414'-O' AREA 5 09 8 2-09-15-82 EL. 425-O" AREA 5 EL 435'-0" AREA 3 EL 426'-O" AREA 4 ~ EL. 426'-O" AREA 6 EL. 439'-O" AREA 6 EL 451'- 0" AREA 3 EL. 439'-O" AREA 4 I O 82 09-27-82 EL. 414'- 0" AREA 7 EL 4 26'-0" AREA 7 ~ EL 451'-O" AREA 4 l j EL 451',-O" AREA 6 I I 82 I i 82 EL.4G7-0" AREA 7 EL. 463'- 0" AREA 3 EL. 4 G7'- O' AREA 6 ALL REMA!NING WALLS ABOVE EL. 401'- 0" I 2 82 l EL. 4Ol' - O' 02-03-83 I~ 1. TOTAL NUMDER OF WALLS = 721 CLFP M NUMSER OF WALLS P.Ef.;A!NING TO EE ISSUED = 221 9 l 4 .-l 5 ~,
- ~ - m M8M PIPE SUPPORT PRODUCTION u n,r *l $ dr~ ~A L 4 Ar,E th A. E._ 17 I I I I I I I l l l l l lr 1 16 / / / 15 / / 14 / j / / 13 I / _m / O 12 [ g / 11 f I / 10 l = f / = 5 / / / _/ ee AD / / ,s/ / = 8 / O / / / j 5 7 E2 / / FORMAL ANALYSIS 7 / S 6 / TOTAL @/ f / 5 / i / / 4 / l L. / / l l' 3 / l / ---* SCHEDULED 2 ACTUAL 1 I I I I I I 1 1 1 I I I i 1 t J F M A M J J A S O N D J F-M A M e !l 1982 1983 MONTH t - CLFP32/1/82 t I -IL.-
WESTINGHOUSE LARGE BORE SlPPORT DRAWIf6 RFI FASE CONTAllfBir li1IT 1 1500 1@ 1300 m 1100 1000 900 / /< <= o / o 300 2m / ~ / i 0 l-
- ALXi, SB7T.
- OCT, W.
EC. i ClFP.12/1/82 s -/7-
U WCHANICAL INSTRLENT LKATION DRAWIfE RFIFASE STATUS LIIIT 1 300 ~- 8 l, l d .p / / / ./ i l / _,. / / 100 /
- / -
, M 37 32 ,m 84 88 ctnunw l* fcnat I l 0 JASOND JFMAM'JJASOND JFMAMJJASOND 1982 1983 1984 t Cf.FP.12/1/82 ? y e og - /f- ,,4
e 4 e ae mea .**a e t. r-E i 8 t WOMNICAL' INSTRENT LOCATIM DRAWifE RFIFASE STATUS LNIT2 p y)n g N / / / 60 _ / .,l I / l-SCH mis A ArTI W A 7 0 m E 20 _ /. CLM.A ATIVE ./ smens a n. j-0 / ' JASOND JFMAMJJASOND JFMAMJJASOND N N N p. I Cl.FP'N 1 - /f-
EOMNICAL INSTRPENT LOCATION DRAWIMi PFI FASE STATUS . LNITS.1 AND 2 ~ i i r g L yn_ / p .ns*'* / / f' l </* . */
- /
./ g / .p. j j / p. ./ / ~ i..' / y_ / scHstuaim ACR&L PO(TN M 12 / CLMA.ATIVE E 3 t. SCEDLLED f ACRRL I I 1 0 N 12/3/82 J A S O 14 D J F hi A 11 J J A S O.1; D J F ;i A 21 J J A S o :: D 1982 1983 1984 e ~OC~
i STARE T ELECTRICALIMMES Unit #1 & Common Unit #2 [ J t Frojected Scheduled Actual % of Projected Scheduled Actual % of i Initial Initial Ir.itial Total Initial Initial Initial Total I Italeases Releases Releases Released Releases Releases Releases Released + To Date To Date To Date To Date To Date To Date i I Embedded Work 48 48 48 100 31 31 31 100
- l t
j! l Lighting & Communication 147 147
- 147 100 105 105 105 100
?! I li j Cable Trays & Supports
- 499 499 499 100 349 349 349
,100 7 1 Individual Cable Tray Support ?' gg Drawings 4,000 3,427 3.427 86 ' 1,500 252 252 l Electrical Installation ( W *' 1,220 344 327 27 561 ~ S 83 15 Wiring Diagrams 4,600 1,600 1,623 35 2,669 126 5 .i Schematic Diagrame 3,147 1,387 44 1,902 84 4 ]; 2 togic Diagrame 70 54 Instrument Loop schematice 377 200 53 335 2 6 TOTAI.S 14,108 1,037 14 ll 7,658 54 7,506 1 ) Through October 31, 1982 i l 1 N l2/N 1 i 4 I i ~
w ELECTRICAL INSTALEATION DRAWINGS - UNIT 1 i CUMULATIVE l 1300 y,,,g Espected p 1220 1200 p / / j 1100 NUMBER OF / f DRAWINGS / t I / /p# 1000 i / / 900 / / / i / \\ M /p/ i / / j 700 / d / / I Y / Legend ) 800 / /
scheduled
/ l / Actual j 500 / F j / a / Total Total p# Scheduled Released I g
- p#
344 327 I l 300 = gm ge,,,g j Release Release 1 40 17 m j j I 100 t 0.FP.1.2/.1/& j JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC e 1982
- l:
1983 i
p p q AUXILIARY BUILDING - UNIT 1 AND COMMON ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION DRAWINGS - CUMULATIVE 800 Total NUMBER OF e / 750 DRAWINGS f 700 / / / / / / 600 / / / / / / 500 / / / / \\ / u 400 / Legend I / /
Scheduled
/ / Actual / Total Total /p Scheduled Released /j/ 136 127 p' 200 / I l / Schedule Actual Release Release j i 'j/ 30 12 im
- ~
/ w wun j JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP-OCT NOV DEC 1983 1982
- lc a
h
i l CONTAINMENT - UNIT 1 - ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION DRAWINGS - CUMULATIVE 250 Total Expected f 222 1 200 , NUMBER OF g,,,go,1 I DRAWINGS 42sI ______J t l i i I i l Elev.tlon! 412I 150 J I~ 1 l Legend 1 6 lT l
Sch.dui.e Actual
) g i govedon ! j 100 soo I l ' ~ " " ~ ~ Total Total .I Scheduled neles ed 5 5 I Hovation g 37I l l 50 Scheduled Actup! j r- - - - - - - - neie... neie... l l 8 l 1 set.non I 401 l ClFP12/.1/82 JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN-FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC 1 e 1982 l 1983 i l
~ n f m. ~ ~ ALL OTHER AREAS - UNIT 1 AND COMMON 4 j ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION DRAWINGS - CUMULATIVE I Total Legend Expected l 180 l
Scheduled l
Actual i l
- .sp #
i 1M i t. n* \\ f y 1 l r i 100 ) 6 4 } Tolet Tolet Scheduled Released 135 132 l l Schedule Actual Release Release it 10 5 CLFPJ2/.1/82 l JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR
- l:
1983 c 1982 1
O' O G l WIRING DIAGRAMS - UNIT 1 CUMULATIVE i 5000 o Total ,. U ec W P e l NUMBER OF DRAWINGS / / / ,/ l 4000 / ,/ / / l / l 3000 / / ) / ~ M / / Legend l 3 /
Scheduled
? /j Actual 2000 f" / Total Total . #p# Scheduled Released i j, 1600 1623 Schedule Actual { 1000 Release Release 65 42 CLFP.12/.1/82 j I JUL SEP OCT JAN MAR MAY JUL SEP NOV JAN MAR MAY JUL SEP NOV 1982 1983
- l:
1984
- I j
i i i
.w i AUXILIARY BUILDING - UNIT 1 AND COMMON Toisi i WIRING DIAGRAMS - CUMULATIVE , Expected / 2600 2500 j i / / / i NUMBER OF / DRAWINGS / / / 20m / / l \\ ,/ b / / I / / I 1500 / / 1: l I / 9 / 1 4 / 8 l / Legend l i / /
scheduled f
Actual ,ono / / ^ / / 1 / Total Total l ,/ Scheduled Released a r I --________a 550 550 g I Scheduled Actual Release Release j 0 o i N DN MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG l 1984 IE
4 i i CONTAINMENT - UNIT 1 7,,,, WIRING DIAGRAMS - CUMULATIVE Expected 210 l / ] 200 f i / / /p# NUMBER OF I DRAWINGS / / / 4 / / 150 / / / l. / I / 1 u / l * / i l 3 / / i / Legend j f j 100 f
Scheduled I
/ Actuel / / i / Total Total f / Scheduled neleased / / 25 25 \\ / l 50 / '/ Scheduled Actual neiease neiease 0 0 l ClFP32/J/82 JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL 1983 1984
m 9 TURBINE BUILDING - UNIT 1 WIRING DIAGRAMS - CUMULATIVE 800 NUMBER OF Total DRAWINGS
- j#
Expected 590 500 =
- ,s#
- ,/
,#,/ 400
- s#
s# ,,,,,,.,****#p b 4 i 1 Legend
Scheduled Actual 200 e
Total Total Scheduled Released 355 424 100 Schedule Actual Release Release 25 35 OfP 12/.1/82 = JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR e 1982 r!c 1983
i I ALL OTHER AREAS - UNIT 1 AND COMMON WIRING DIAGRAMS - CUMULATIVE Total Expected 1200 I / 1200 / / / l /p# l 1000
- s#
NUMBER OF i j DRAWINGS
- ,/j
/ i R)0 / = /
- ,/,
1 / 2 l /p i 1 N 800 I l Legend f Actual = = =- Scheduled 4 1 ,i Total Total I 4 i Scheduled Released l 870 824 { 1 k Schedule Actual 2m I 40 7 i OfP.12/.1/& j JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC rl: 1983 f e 1982 l l
) t l CABLES RELEASED FOR INSTALLATION - UNIT 1 kb~"** NUMBER OF CUMULATIVE CABLES ,#= 20,000 / Espected p#j 21000 / ,/
- ,/
j 15.000 / / k / ~ / I s'p/ I W /,/- l l 10,000 j /p/ Lanend
- ,/
Scheduled 1
/ Actual / i ,/ Total Total Scheduled Released 6050 6046 5,000 Schedule Actual Release Release j 700 420 i . CLFP,32n/.82 i JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB lAAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB
- lr
- l1984 1983 1982 i
l l l
EPUIPMENT QUALIFICATION 1 CENERIC PACKAGE TO NRC BY W COMPLETE -g y333 ~ GENERIC PACKAGES ) + CENERI CKAGES EQ PACKAGES QA RECORDS PLANT SPECIFIC 77 Packages (Generic) g 39 Complete .W 16 In Progress EQ S199fARY TO P 17 Not Scheduled QA RECORDS 3 (mostly instru-mentation) PREPARE EQ SIRMARY REPORT EQ SIRMARY TO NRC BOP EQ DATA EQ PACKAGE EQ PACKAGE QA RECORDS 1 ) i l 78 Packages 27 Complete l 13 Almost Complete 25 In Progress 13 No Schedule ClFP.12n/82 l
I 30 RA 8 0 M 'E 5 5 EF NS 3 OR B 3 E I E T G F 9 E N LA 1 P H M N lI OF / CO D O. N D A E N / J LU /_ D L N E A f H T i C O 's ST CE / D / EL e U f V. D O N E 7, H C N A ~ / S O N E A I o S T l r A t T A 0 C T N E u / I o O S L t ,D E uc G L R s N E I j I T G A F N N P R I I / W E E2A S N L A E&P R GI D A RSN = / N A ~p ATI EG ./ EID G LNN m N U CUI A A U ~ N E H C I L V YA 4 L R I R H E S T E IU J L C E. B L I l R B 9 A U A M P / C N U J / YA ~ M 'j R .M S P 4 e A M ~ 9 2 R. 8 9 L A 1 2 a M u t 5 30 e c 2 1 a D 6 4 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 3 1 0 0 0 0 c 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 L q F A 6 5 4 3 t 1 O U T S C ,5 I g ga* ASA _..l i l. ,k. t ) l;i;
~. / HVAC HANGER DRAWING RELEASE SCHEDULE 3000- ' l g sc w outro s
- y w
g-s
0
,a# = b a:g 1000 s S / ey AUG. SEP. OCT. NOV. DEC. JAN. F E8'. MAR. APR. MAY. JUN. JUL. AUG.. 1983' . l 1982-1 s' SCHEDULED COMPLETION APRIL' 83 AS OF m-27-1982 TOTAL M. & HANGERS 2?50 SCHEDULED 751 HANGERS MAR 8LE HILL NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION ACTUAL 771 UNITS I S 2 PUBLIC SERVICE INDIANA PLAINFIELD, INDIANA N NN t 8 l l l 1 l l l
b r CONSTRLTION SUPPORT - STRONG FIELD EEIEERIl0 STAFFS u. -PSI - SARGENT & LINh' - WESTIIGHOUSE - RAPID RESP 0 TEE TO FIELD PRGLEMS - USE (F PGELS IN COEESTED AREAS - R0 LITE SMALL BORE PIPE AND LNIQUE CONDUITINFIELD L - ENGIEERIE IfWOLVEPENT WITH ONRACTORS IN PRE-WNSTRUCTIGi WUDMG i 1. -3r-
i. i ^ l POSSIBLE EWDRK C#L IS TO MINIMIZE POTENTIAL FOR EWORK -REPLICATION - FDAML PIPING ANALYSIS PRIOR TO CWSTRUCTIm - USE OF MEELS IN CmGESTED AREAS - EARLY DETECTION AIO PRTFT RESOLUTION OF CmSTRUCTION PRmLEE
1 I ^ s i e =<ge kk5k5$k8kER v E B _d RRRM E S R k R E is s j2,l5R se is sgW E I aE# RRRRRBERRRERS g as sg E E j@ij Wg R R R R R S S R R m m RE i l dd s b a g E i 8 s 0 s s E 2 -E E-E 2-E ^a j-EE s = j $ 3 'ae H :g ~" 5 5 5 W; s ea853$3allgjn Bs i u i: u W ll I e PROCURDENT ACTIVITIES H.B. HEE PURCHASING MWGER b + b 6 e ame
't PROJECT PURCHASE ORDER
SUMMARY
Unit 1 (and common) Unit 2 Safety Related 584 268 Purchase Orders Non-Safety 1694 230* Related Purchase Orders Totals 2278 498 s PROJECT SPECIFICATION STATUS Specifications Specifications Awarded Unawarded Total 'f i Structural 25 1 26 Mechanical 152 15 167 Electrical 37 1 38 Total 214 17 231 h cLFP 12/1/82 -y-
F - e _ Cm S I SPEC. NO. (DISCIPLINE) DESCRIPTION SIAIUS Y-2817C (M) FIRE PRC7TECTICN CQHENT SPE. 70 PSI 10-21-82 Y-2828B&C (M) 7EERRL INSUIATICE "B" IKTPORATING PSI CCNMENIS; "C" CCM. SPEC. TO PSI 9-15-82 Y-2829 (M) INSTRINENT CALIBRATION FACIL. PSI 70 M ARD Y-2842 (M) COUNTING ROCM INSTRLNENIATION PSI HCED (MARD SCHEDULED JULY 1984) Y-2898 (E) REM 7IE MJLTIPLEKING SYSTEM PSI HXD Y-2910 (M) 'IORNADO/ISOIATICN DAMPERS PURCHASE CRDERS ISSUED 11-24-82 Y-2911 (M) CONDENSATE CIIANUP SYSTD1 BIDS DUE l-27-83 l Y-2916 (M) STATION AUX. DT M L GEN. DUE 6-1-83 i Y-2926 (M) MISC. CCNIROL SYSTEMS BIDS IUE 12-1-82 Y-2929 (M) STAIUUP FEEDATER PUMP INCORPORATING PSI'S COME2TTS Y-2954 (S) STRUCT. Dnunurf & LEAK SPEC. DUE 2-7-85; SCHEDULED RATE TESTDG AVARD 7-1-85 Y-2984 (M) HI I RADIATICN SAMPLE SYSTH4 BIDS DUE 12-17-82 Y-2985 (M) ASME FASTENERS SCHEIKTLED AWARD 12-1-82 Y-2986 (M) VIBRATICN MONITORDG SYSTDi IN PREPARATICH l Y-2987 (M) MISC. PIPDG SUPPORT MAT'L BID LVAIDATION Y-2988 (M) RADWASTE NMJNIA REMWAL SYS. BID SPEC. BEING REVID4ED BY PSI DGINEERING, O.E., & PURCHASDG k CLFP 12/1/82 _ yo - l
c PROCUREMENT STATUS EOUIP/ MAT'L
- NUMBER PERCENT OF CATEGORIES UNIT OF SPECS MAT'L REC'D VALVES (NSSS Valves 1
31 90% Shipment to be complete by 12/31/83. included in m Major Mech. 2 29 87% Equip) PIPE (Fabricated 1 1 99% Shipment scheduled to be completed Large Bore in 1985. 2 1 99% only) CABLE Power 1 6 88% Shipment scheduled for late 1983. l CCntrol Instrument 2 6 89% CABLE TRAY 1 1 86% Shipment to be complete by June 1983. 2 1 55% i l' MAJOR MECH. l EQUIP i l (Incl. NSSS) 1 80 88% Shipment to be complete Mid 1985 for Unit 1 and Late 1985 for Unit 2. 2 63 69% ICatruments 1 24 27% 2' 13 42% l [ MAJOR ELEC. EQUIP 1 34 $,34% Shipment to be complete in 1985. ~ 2 32 48% ~ Instruments 1 9 44% 2 8 46%
- Unit 1 includes common equip / mat'1.
- PSI procured permanent plant material only.
CLFP 12/1/82 ' V/
- l I
l t
SPARE PARTS PROGRAM NETWORK 1982 1983 1984 1985 s t_ t t i I t t e a e I a e' s e i e iI
- Evaluated and ordered in accordance with I.evel II
\\Stai i PREPARE PROGRAM PROCEDURES PHASE I { I (PROGRAM DEVELOP PROGRAM SCHEDULE I ORGANIZATION) / \\ i { \\ \\ / A EVALUATE SPARE PART REQUIREMENTS i PHASE E " ac '"d " c"" * '"* """ '" '" " ~ g s PAR PR LOAD DATA INTO SPAWIS PROGRAM U O s ( ) i / I i ( l i. i \\- I DETERMINE PROCUREMENT METHOD 1l i PHASE III ( ) I GENERATE PURCHASE ORDERS (PROCUREMENT ) ( 1 3 'b ""'" "" "^ '"" "" y /=/ 9
ACimL #0 PROPOSED CMFT WORK R)RCE, i CMFT AVAILABILITY, PRWUCTIVHY, P0ERIAL LABOR EGOTATIONS AND PRTLEMS
- a. D. um
[ CONSTRUCTION LABOR ADVISOR r i i l' 4 F 43-I A 9 >4m-- -e-p. y ,-m w o-m ,m_---4 -,.w,uw p-v- ,,qy-w,my m n- --,-r g-- -,w, -w-ms-- - -w'w-"'E'ww" w-me--w=- ' * =~~~* w"
LI: Iz 'L'A'B'O R t 1. 1%70R CRAFI MANPOWER I 2. QUFr AVAHABILITY 3. PRODUCTIVnY 4. IABOR NEDDTIATIONS D GIP 12-1-82.
CONSntDCTION CRAFIS MANPOER AfNUAL AVERAGES 1982 - 1988 4 M N 1982 1850 1983 1984 1900 1985 1400-1986 1000 1987 350 1988 200 PRESENT 'IUIAL 2282. CLFP 12-1-82 l -YS - l.
r I MAJOR CRAFIS 1%NPOWER I EIEcrRICIANS 'IUTAL - LNITS 1 & 2 325 PRESENT PEAK (1-85) 680 INIT No. 1 300 PRESENT PEAK (1-84) 51_0 INIT No. 2 25 PRESENT l' PEAK (1-86) 300 1 PIPEETTIERS I TUIAL - INITS l' & 2 500 l PRESENT l PEAK (4-85) - 1460 INIT No.1 PRESENT 410 PEAK (4-83 to 9-84) - 1000 LNIT No. 2 90 PRESENT PEAK (4-85 to 4-86) 600 SHEE'r ETAL WEKERS T3rAL - INrI5 l'& 2 77 PRESENT PEAK (1-84 to 12-84) 125 INIT No.1 77 PRESENT l PEAK (1-84 to 12-84) 125 i INIT No. 2 0 PRESENT 50 PEAK (1-86 to 12-86) CLFP 12-1-82 f 1 COMMONWEALTH-LOliD JV i i MARBLE HILL MANPOWER REQUIREMENTS .f I 750 i i 025 1 i l 500-1 1 l .c J 4 315-i i i. r / 250-t l 125- ~<.*. i l j w. s s. O 1982 1983 1984 1985 1988 1987 1988 I, LEGEND: - TOTAL Y-2790 UNIT +2 Y-2790 UNIT + 1 TEMPORARY. SU8CONTR ACTOR WORK i
i L i CHERNE 4 I MARBLE HILL UNITS 1-2 & COMMON COMBINED j 1500= l ] 1400= J i is..= is..= .a g 1100=
== , teen-1 O soo-5 z u. O .O 700-E a j o.J soo-q = 2 5 0-g 4.e- ...= I soo= l s.e= q l l t e l i.n i.u su4 wu i.u i.n i.a I i
_.. =. I CHERNE MARBLE HILL UNIT *1 (ONLY) e 1000 8 1 l 9 900 i e aW e ~ R 100-i ) -o . e c o_ i l i O j Z t 4 % s ea. i 9 O e 1 .D e l .J 400. e 4 m \\ n i 3 s on_ [ j e n j E i l l soo- \\ too_ ~ l l t o i 1982 l 1983 l 1984 1985 1988 1987 l 1988 ~ j I i,
I 4 4 I .s } az i o ~ ce i Wp i Z- = z og D = IM a QJ I -z uJ d m oc X e. o ce..
==, ~ (usw ;o oN) 20981 lenuww i h* i w 77--m--*wm-r w-s m y.nyg * . ww w ww w-
I i I PULLMAN SHEET METAL MARBLE HILL MANPOWER REQUIREMENTS 150 l 140. i l ) 130. l' j 120_ ] i I l 110_ 4 4 100_ 1 i 30_ I. l 80. I. i i. l 60-s t l 50_ 1 i 40_ g 30_ 20_ l } /
- .,e.*
j 10 _ O l MbJ FM kM3)k Sb h bJ h h kM h 3 k Sb h bJ h Mk h)) kb b h b J h h kh J J k bb N b J Fh kh J J l 1982 1983 1984 1985 1988 1987 LEGEND: Torat I i UNIT + 1 UNIT +2 l l l
\\; MMOR CRAFI'AVAIIABILITY
- 1. 'PIPDTITERS No Difficulties Anticipated I
2. ELECIRICIANS Possible Shortage Mid 1984 Early Warning Systen Increased Training Welders Apprentices 3. SHEET METAL M No Difficulties Anticipated )
- e 4
12-1-82 b)'
i l IABOR PRODILu vn1 I. ESTDWIES BASED ON INDUSlM AVERAGES PIAN TO }EET AfD IMPROVE CN DOUSIRY AVERAGES l nootx:rivm DFROVDOTT PROGRAMS l 1 ' F ONSIRUCTION MANAGENENT - CONIRACIOR LIAISCE CDtETIEE: i e QUALTIY CIRC ES [ FWENAN DEIAY REPDFCES 0=SrRucr1m IHoaSIn CoSr DTECTIVdESS SIUDIES - IMPUMNIATICE + i t 4 12-1-82 i 1: m--
4 Aa 1w ae -4 e f O t EXPIRY DATES { 1 SUCCESSES M S YEAR g. .i e IS + 12-1-82 E'/ - . J-I.
IABOR AGREEMENIS'rEXPIRY DATES '1982 R00FERS Decenber 31, 1982 1983 CARPENIERS & MIID1RIGHIS April 30, 1983 BRICKIAYERS April 30, 1983 PIPEFITIERS April 30, 1983 - QUAIZIY CONIROL (GERNE) April 30, 1983 EI.ECTRICIANS (Inside) May 31, 1983 IRONWORKERS May 31, 1983 TEAMSIERS May 31, 1983 PAINIERS July 22, 1983 ELECTRICIANS (Outside) Septenber 4,1983 ASBESIOS WORKERS Septecber 30, 1983 BOIIERMAKERS Septernber 30, 1983 i 1984 IABORERS March 31, 1984 CEtENT MASONS April 30, 1984 INSPECIORS (U.S. TESTING) April 30, 1984 SHEET METAL WORKERS August 19, 1984 j .'l 1985 OPERATING INGINEERS March 31, 1985 1 1987 ELEVATOR July 8, 1987 l p CtrP 12-1-82 I t. t l 1 -Sf-I i
b I. IETAll.ED EVIEW AND STATUS T ALL I 1ARGE AND SM.L BOE IWlGERS, ESTRAINTS, SMBERS S. E. ElIRN GIEF EOMNICAL ENGIEER l' f - $(c - l
a MARBE HILL PIE SlPPORT PROGRAM I. ESIGN [. II. PROCUREENT III. FABRICATIm IV. EEIPT INSPECTION V. STORAGE VI. EVIEW FOR INSTAUATION VII. INSTABATION VIII. INSTAUATIm VERIFICATIm XI. ESIGN EPORT XII. PIE M11P RESTRAINTS I-CLFP-12-01-82
li l I I. ESIGN A. ESIGN SUBCamW, TOR SCEDULEil%itS[($f"
- 8. ESim wrem camu mc ms l
i ? t h h 1 e 'l CLFP-12-01-82 -Se - l
.e. Units 1 & 2 (S dh Aux. Bldg. 1000 Supports /mo. 24 Subsystems /mo. (S&L) ' Cont. Unit l' Unit 2 Bldg. 125 Subsystems (pt) 125 Subsystems (W) 300 Supports /mo. 300 Supports /mo. I E E E I Turbine'l Turbine 2 700 Supports Remaining 700 Supports Remaining Float dates for manpower levelina to meet system turnover dates E E i ( lARGE BOE PIR IMNGER ESIGN SOEULE i t 25,000 Large Bore i i l CifP-12-01-82 I N N O x s s I N Y N Y N n n n n n n n A
S 44 Unit 1 & 2 4"-2 " Cat. II & 2" and under Cat. II Aux. 500 Supports /mo. Bld Sl Units 1 & 2 2" & under Cat. I plus Cat. II Hot 800 Supports /mo. t i Unit 1'kl 2" & under Cont. 130 Supports /mo. l Bld @g. 1 Unit 2 2" & under 130 Supports /mo. I I i n e O l 9RL BOE Pl HANIR ESIGN SCEME i i i Turbine Unit 2 - Hot Bldg. 2" and under (S&L) 130 Supports /mo. 24,000 S, mall Bore & 4" - 2 " 4 2 g E g Q 8 i 4 n n n n n
i ESIGN DRAWINGS STATUS LARGE BORE I CATI PROJECTED ISSLED C0tEAltfB E BUILDING LNIT1 1120 883 i UNIT 2 1120 0 OUTSIE C0tEAlttelT BUILDING w 8600 6366 CAT II PROJECTED ISSUED CONTAltf Di BUILDING T UNIT 1 300 236 LNIT 2 300 0 \\,300 7,100 OUTSIE CONTAlttBE BUILDING 8 s 'O o 3 oO CLFP-12-01-82 f l -GI-m
PIPING AND 1%NGER IESIGN IWOR% tim INTERFACE S&L ANALYSIS R ANALYSIS L \\\\ l PAC M t PSI IBEL II i SCEDULE PLRCHASING a sN CONSlRdION 19NER g COORDINATOR g E o e PIPING INSTAUATION DI CONTRACTOR MMGEPBIT h CLFP-12-01-82 {. w,- -w +w w- --w- ---,w v-wwe-w--w-e-w-+w--+ rare,-,---w-sw-rMwrD 'w' rT'V"' -M* -wrerF"'-"'"*"~-*N'T'" --"M*""**7*"t9 W -*'4"-#
- "N* * * ' ' - ^ '
I ' II. PROCIFEENT A. LAKE B0E STATLS B. SMALL B0E STATLS C. C0tETRUlm HANER COORDINATOR D. BULK HANER Pf0 GRAM TO A9E SECTIm III., SLESECTIm IG-3800 E i r CLFP-12-01-82 -
I LI m u u. I LARGE B0E HANGER DELIERY STATUS SLFPORTS SNJBBERS TOTAL lNIT 1 89 0 626 i LNIT2 m W4 l 15,963 LO70 17,033 F i ~ t* l I CLFP-12-01-82 - (A - i-
I l-I III. 'FABRICATIm A. W CTPENTS BY SUPPLIER TO LCD B. AISC CDP 0ENTS SITE CONTRACTOR j C. W CTPENTS BY SITE CMTRACTOR -IESIGN BY A/E D. SOURE StBElllANE I U CLFP-12-01-82 ! n
I. IV. EEIFT INSECTION A. QUALITY ASSURANI EEIPT INSECTIQ4 B. C0tERCIAL EEIPT INSECTION r ,d.8 l s i T ClFP-12-01-82 '
k V. STORAE A. STORAE AND MINIDMI PROGRAM - (SMI Y-277L 2886) B. MNER EFURBISFPENT i I = ClFP-E-01-82 '
I 1. I j VI. EVIEW FOR It6TAllATION A. CCC CG6TRUCTIBILITY PROEDUE AND DEKLIST 4 y i e e e I CLFP-12-01-82 r I
VII. INSTAU.ATION A. CLHeff INSTAllATICN STATLE B. SCEDULED INSTAU.ATION RATES C. INSTAL 1ATION SUINEIUAE i D. SURROGATE SNUBEER PROGRAM i 1 1. i l l i Cl.FP-12-01-82 l '
~. m l C0ft10DITY t! Nit 2 - LARCE BORE MANCERS 4 W &,uc m CtlMULATIVE j SCALE 1 PRO.IECTED TOTAL 5,000 - AVERACE SUSTA1HED 4.500 RATE 70 PER HONill
- p umami
- p#
4,000 - - l p# l 1 3,000 - - 4 O
- g I
2,000 - ACTUAL TOTAL
- p#
1504 1,000 - - i i i 1 11 111111111 I l l 11111111 11111111111 11111111111 1111111tll l l 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 .l PROJECTED e me um aus e ACTUAL aummusumums i STATUS THRU NOVEMBER 20, 1982 l 1 i CLFP-12-01-82 i
I e 0 C0tWODITY f UNIT 1 - 1ARCE BORE MANCERS f#^D8N n u,ux,. A _: CUNULATIVE SCA1.E l I' ~ ~ AVERACE SUSTAINED
- p#
RATE 420 PER MONTH p 0 TOTAL. 16.000 - p d 14.000 - -. /j 12.000 - - 10,000 - - a l 8,000 - j
- p#
i i M i I 6,000 - p#p l { ACTUAL TOTAt, 1 4519 4,000 - j# l l 2,000 - IfI I aaeaea eI aaeieaeai e i a a n_ gj,JLt t I eeaaaie: I e 1982 1983 1984 1985 l i i PROJECTED desus aussus a ACTUAL M STATUS THRU NOVEMBER 20, 1982 l I CLFP-12-01-82
ra1 VIII. INSTALLATION W RIFICATION A. PHYSICAL ERIFICATIm PROEDUE l' B. ERIFICATION CEO(LIST l CLFP-12-01-82 -,2-
I IX. ESIM EPORT II' A. ECGCILLIATIm T If6TAUATIm WRIFICATIM ETA B. ESIGN EPORT PEPARATIM C. MSIGN EPORT EVIEW D. N5 MTA EPORT EVIEW F p i e CLFP-12-01-F2
I l [ l PIE WIP ESTRAltRS l ESIGN #0 PROCUREEtE CTPIITE 103 IfilT 1 CONTAlffENT [03 UNIT 2CONTAINE?E ~ w TOTAL UNIT 1 & 2 OlHSIE CONTAlttBITS 270 ESTRAltRS TCITAL 2" DIAETER,11" DIAETER ESTRAlfES NOT DESIGED SINCE SMUER BORE PIR ESIGN NOT COPPLETED. EXPECT MXIttN OF APPRDXIPRTELY 35 RESTRAINTS ER UNIT DEP90ENT UPON STESS VAllES RESULTING FRCN #MLYSIS, ESIGN #0 It5TAllATION WILL SUPPORT PESENT SCEDulf l t i CLFP-12-01-82 - 7Y -
[ StM% TION EATLES IN HATER PROGPN1 WHICH EMBLE SCEDULE TO E ET:
- 1. FLEXIBILITY OF TWO ESIGN C0ti[PACTORS, BOTH CAPABLE OF PERFORMING PIPING #0 HATER ANALYSIS #0 DESl&l.
- 2. EPLICATION, BYRON DRAWitES ARE BASICALLY AS-BUILT, USED AS IBFUT EDUCES INiterJtrE AND REWORK POTENTIAL.
- 3. FIELD ESIGN CAPABILITY EDUCES 1 URN AROUND TIE OF FIELD PROBLEM ESOUITION.
- 4. FIELD DESIGN OF SSLL BORE PIPING EDUCES COMNICATION DIFFICULTIES BEINEEN FDE #D FIELD OFFICES.
- 5., USE OF fGEL TO ESOLVE INIERFERENCES #0 AS IRT RR SmLL BORE ROUTItE EDUCES PROBABILITIES OF lhlt&tJtNCES N0 ASSOCIATED EWORK.
- 6. FORmL ANALYSIS AT THIS TIE IS ESULTING IN A DELETION OF APPR0XImTELY 10% OF TE 1%NGERS INCLUDED IN PREVIOUS PRELIMINARY #iALYSIS. EDUCES INITIAL CONSTRUCTION EQUIEPENT AND REDUCES REWORK. FORmL AmLYSIS j
CTPLETION FOR IfilT 1 BY AB0lff mRCH 1983 WILL PRWIE INSTAL 1ATION 00NTPACTOR LARGE HANGER BACKLDG WHICH E CAN WORK AS SCEDULE DICTATES. l
- 7. FLEXIBILilY IPNEEtTT IN BULK HANGER PROGRAM AIDS IN EDUCING E0JIPENT l
LEAD TIES FOR ALL BUT PDST COPPLICATED OF SLPPORTS. l [.
- 8. PAC-mN,' INTERFACES LEVEL 11 SCEDULE WITH ESIGN CONTRACTOR CAPABILITIES TO PROVIE BPHASIS WHICH BEURES SCHEDULES ARE ET, CLFP-12-01-82 l
-9T-
W-I L
- 9. CONSTRUCTION HANGER COORDINATOR - AIDS IN MlERIAL EXPEDITING AND
[ ESOLIITION OF FIELD PROBLEMS TO ENSURE SCEDULE IS ET.
- 10. AS-BUILT VERIFICATION PROGRAM KL&PLISHED AS SUBSYSTEMS AE COPPLETED WILL REDUCE PR2 ABILITY OF PROBLEMS EGARDING PHYSICAL INSTAL 1ATION BEING IDENTIFIED LATE.
L . ;. ~ f l I CLFP-12-01-82 . - -. _ _. ~, .___..,.a 1 1. 1. ~ I. narcr somu 6 G. G. AllAN PUMING #0 SOEULING MNGER I I t a I l' l~ l l f CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL PLANNING AND SCHEDULING PRESENTATION l i 1, PROJECT SCHFDULE REVIEW A. PLANNING AND SCHEDULING SYSTEM B. MARBLE HILL ADVANTAGES C. PROJECT PERCENT COMPLETE D. MILESTONE /IARGETACC6MPLISHMENTSFOR1982 E. PROJECT CRITICAL PATH F. SCHEDULE R'EVIEW G. CONTINGENCY PROVISIONS CLFP 12/1/82 - es -
. ;, i. i f d -, ~. I: 1 I.A PLANNING AND SCHEDULING SYSTEM' ~ 1. SCHEDULE HIERARCHY 2. ORGANIZATION t I E a 'W J CLFP 12/1/82
7-- i. i a i 1 SCHEDULE HIERARCHY LEVEL 0 PROJECT MILESTONE SCHEDULE LEVEL 1 LEVEL I TARGET SCHEDULE i i B LEVEL 11 LEVEL 11 CPM SCHEDULE i LEVEL Ill SIX MONTH LOOK AHEAD l LEVEL IV FIVE WEEK WORK PLAN j I T CLFP 12/1/82 ) i
PLANNING & SCHEDULING MANAGER C. G. ALLAN CONTRACT [ MANAGERS CLERICAL / \\ / s i I l CONST. PLANNING ENGINEERING PLANNING ENGINEERING PLANNINC PROJECT PLANNING l & SCHEDULING & SCHEDULING & SCHEDULING. & SC11EDULING I SUPERVISOR SUPERVISOR S&L SUPERVISOR I A. SUCHKO (ACTING) R. D. BOWERS J. H)RTUNSKI N. M. WilITMAN i i l i 1 1 1 I I t I l SENIOR PLANNING 'N SENIOR PLANNING PLANNING & C. JONES & SCIIEDULING SCHEDULING S&L & SCIIEDULING ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS CLFP 12/1/82
r l l.B MARBLE HILL ADVANTAGES 1. IOTALLY INTEGRATED SCHEDULING SYSTEM A. ENGINEERING B. PROCUREMENT 1. LEVEL ll 2. PERCS (PROCUREMENT, EXPEDITING, RECEIPT, COST, STATUS) C. COST / SCHEDULE INTEGRATION 2. REPLICATE PLANT A. ENGINEERING DRAWINGS AVAILABLE i EARLIER B. REDUCES CHANGES C. EARLIER N0'TIFICATION OF CHANGES D. MINIMIZE REWORK _ [ 3. 90% OF MAJOR EQUIPMENT ON SITE 4. HEAD START IURBINE BUILDING IEST PROGRAM 5. MODELING OF CONGESTED AREAS 6. FORMAL HANGER ANALYSIS PRIOR TO INSTALLATION CLFP 12/1/82 - F 2. -- v. ,_y.. r
b I.C PROJECTPERCENTCOMPCETE . f 1. ENGINEERING A. UNIT 1 64% + 1. STRUCTURAL 89% [ 2. ELECTRICAL 48% 3. MECHANICAL 54% B. UNIT 2 38% j-1. STRUCTURAL 87% 2. ELECTRICAL 31% 3. MECHANICAL 27% 2. CONSTRUCTION A. PROJECT 37.8% B. UNIT 1 43.8% 1. CIVIL 82.5% 2. ELECTRICAL 22.3% 3. PIPING 27.8% 4. MECHANICAL 32.0% C. UNIT 2 25.7% [ 1. CIv!L 63.1% 2. ELECTRICAL 11.9% t [; 3. PIPING 14.2% 4. MECHANICAL 22.0% CLFP 12/1/82 9 -F3-4
I: 1.D MILESTONE / TARGET ACCOMPLISHMENTS 1. UNIT 1 2. UNIT 2 i t 1- .i CLFP 12/1/82 , gy,
k b ~ 2 E 8 C / N 1 E A / E E E E I 1 2 l iT T T T T R + 1 A E E E E A T L L L L V P S P P P P F M M M M L O O O O C C C C C E E T T A R. D f 2 2 2 2 p O 8 8 8 8 M T 4 n 6 8 1 6 a O E 2 2 0 2 T E T 8 8 0 1 A L 0 0 1 1 l P fT M C O A C YE f0 E E s.5 T T 1 R. A E t D L p u O l n 2 2 2 2 T i r
- (
8 8 8 8 t D 3 l n 1 1 1 1 E U R. 0 0 0 3 L D r U i u 9 0 1 2 D n D 0 1 1 1 E u R H S H C C S I, S tt J C O NT R &IA' P R 3 O STS6 I 1 BOB 4 ~ R ANA E T L(L T I S S' N X N Q 1 L I E. U R-5 A O E OLC4 T J N T T FT P OE V. A ,I I ME M I L R TP P. T, '9 B D E)3 U C FM ~ S IO R .LL4 S E LC PL R D T GMA HE E DOW E TT S LC 67 9E B E27 R H SN44 2C G .LI R N U XLL .D A BO O UA LN S CC R AWQEA F 3 1 6 3 1 2 o%1 l o ,!i ll
~~ Li_Ti_L 1 u82 USEO (6i I DESCRIPTION ScHRDtif.Rn enMPLETE ACTRIAL rnMPLR9R RTATIIS 4 f.INER PAINTED START 03-17-82 03-17-82 COMPLETE STRUCTURAL STEEL 88 TURBINE / GENERATOR READY FOR 06-01-82 06-01-82 COMPLETE OIL FLUSH - TB-1 5 ANNULUS STR. STL. ERECTED 09-01-82 08-23-82 -COMPLETE UNIT 1 CONTAINMENT BUILDING 36 . SPENT FUEL POOL & CASK AREA 10-15-82 10-12-82 COMPLETE WALLS COMPLETE - FHB '190 CIVIL / STRUCTURAL COMPLETE 09-01-82 08-19-82 COMPLETE RIVER PUMPHOUSE 192 CIVIL / STRUCTURAL COMPLETE 09-01-82 06-14-82 COMPLETE GUARDHOUSE 1 104 CWPH fl STRUCTURALLY COMPLETE 10-15-82 10-15-82 COMPLETE g 8 6 CB-1 STRUCTURALLY COMPLETE 09-15-82 08-27-82 COMPLETE SUFFICIENT TO BEGIN NSSS SET SA STRUCTURAL STEEL PLUMBED, 11-15-82 08-27-82 COMPLETE BOLTED AND WELDED OUT, INC. AUX. STL. AND RCFC STEEL e CLFP 12/1/82 l
1 2 8 E / C 1 N / H A 2 1 I 1 T E E E E E E R t A T T T T T T A P T E E E E E E V F E L L L L L L L P P P P P P M M M M M M C O O O O O O C C C C C C E T E A T 2 E 2 8 D L 2 2 2 2 8 P 8 8 8 8 5 O 4 1 1 T tn 8 1 1 5 0 e 2 0 0 1 9 E 5 1 0 T 1 L 8 1 0 1 1 E A 0 1 1 1 L P 1 1T M P O A C E E T T i E A L D i P I 4 2 2 2 2 2 2 O s N n 8 8 8 8 8 8 T d e 1 1 1 1 1 0 D 5 0 0 0 0 0 3 E 1 n 2 L R O L 8 0 1 1 1 1 2 U O 1 1 1 1 1 1 D 1 M tn E E H C t I ic S l S t R T v C ESO o TEN L T NT H &IA' AD E 3 WUSE T L N STS6 S LED E E O BOB 4) S ECOI L S DI ANA 6 S CNDS P S ET L( L ,9 N II N M E SA S S' V( - I O N V OT Q 1E R C O LS R-5N EEGG I R C OLC4O G STNN D T O NR J ,N T NE EII R P T EOS A I ,S IC LLPP A E PA APII Y I C) .FT ME R A1 I T. '9 L IL IMPP H C E9, GYN E)3I PP TO C NCDL) T S R DLU .LL4M ~ PN E RL I E E LT PL ( OI SEAAS. W D TN BNH GMA SPY S EO ET DOW O ST EIO LC 67 LS EI E H. V S NCB B E27 L PDD HE II SN44 TE EUI K I GL BF- .LI RS DIL UI RF XLL .D AS SRRCE 5 OM UUl UA LN TE HAUNH 6 R( TSI AWQEA SV UYBIT 7 A B 3 9 2 3 8 6 2 7 5 2 1 0 2 1 1@ $I I
2 E 8 C / N 1 R A / l I 2 iT E E E E E E E R 1 A T T T T T T T A T E E E E E E E V P S L L L L L L L F P P P P P P P L m M M M M M M M C O O O O O C O C C C C C C C E E T T A R. D 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 I P 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 O O 4 T Bn 1 6 1 1 3 5 3 7 e 0 2 0 0 1 2 2 E 7 8 9 0 8 9 0 T E TA 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 L I P tT M c O A C ~ E E T T A D t I P N M 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 O U n 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 T e 7 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 D n i 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 E E R. L 9 9 9 0 0 0 1 U t a. i 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 D t a. n E R H l C ic S 1 S . L E 2 N E N O 2 L T O B I O RT C T B H OS C G C IE E U N E E RL M R I G T C EI O T L D E A TM D S O I S N L X( N O R O P E N O C B E I E I C M T FT E E O P OE G 2 T ND D I R L N E AE R E TP I T L RT D C S FM P I P CC N S N IO I N M E A E E LC P U O RR D D C AE P 7 N HE S E 2 L I O TT C T E9 OY H ~ C 9E E N PE ~ ~ R L YR L T 2L 2C) P PP DE 2L R L N3 M MM OW O A BE BO1 O OA CO BR T TW CC0 C CR ET CT S 7 3 - 6 1 3 2 7 7 4 3 1 1 2 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1$ 4 4 I.I r
S-I. E-PROJECT CRITICAL PATH 1. CRITICAL PATH 2. POTENTIAL CRITICAL PATH I' 3. METHODS OF CORRECTIVE ACTION l-3 i l CLFP 12/1/82 -en-
i 1.E.1 CRITICAL-PATH AUXILIARY BUILDING - AREA 5, ELEVATION 364' - % MONTH CRITI' CAL PATH PATH GOES THROUGH BULK LARGE BORE PIPE HANGER AND PIPE INSTALLATION, SMALL BORE PIPE INSTALLATION, CLOSING OF CONSTRUCTION OPENINGS, UP THROUGH THE BUILDING, SETTING OF THE UNIT 1 DIESEL GENERATORS. i
- p COMPLETE LARGE BORE PIPE AT ELEVATION 401'.
i COMPLETE ALL LARGE BORE PIPE AT ELEVATION 401' AND ABOVE (IA TARG. 057). j RELEASE BORON REGENERATION SYSTEM TO CONSTRUCTION TEST. l FLUSH BORON REGENERATION SYSTEM AND ON THROUGH HOT FUNCTIONAL l IESTING TO FUEL LOAD. i i CLFP 12/1/82
7-E.1 AREA _5 i INSTALLATIONS IN (AREA 5) EL. 364' INCLUDE THE FOLLONING QUANTITIES OF MAJOR COMMODITY TYPES. LARGE BORE PIPE - 695 SPOOLS I LARGE BORE HANGERS - 1,185 SMALL BORE PIPE - APPROXIMATELY 8,000 LF AND ASSOCIATED HANGERS 1 l CONDUIT - APPROXIMATELY 4,000 LF l ALL BULK INSTALLATIONS TO BE DONE FROM JAN. 1982 THROUGH JUNE 1984 FOR A PERIOD OF 30 MONTHS. f' INSTALLATIONS DURING THIS TIME FOR MAJOR COPMODITIES TYPICALLY REQUIRE l AVERAGE INSTALLATION RATES OF 48 L.B. PIPE HANGERS AND 32 L.B. SPOOLS l PER MONTH FOR THE NEXT 18 MONTHS. i MAJOR SYSTEMS BEING INSTALLED IN THE AREA INCLUDE (SI) SAFETY INJECTION, l I (CC) COMPONENT COOLING, (CV) CHEMICAL AND VOLUME CONTROL, (SX) ESSENTI AL SERVICE WATER. 1 i CLFP 12/1/82 l I i
Gn = eaU i l e - i~s s'p= s a .I su a. s 8-26
- :asna a
i: ne g [E- = i i s lllg!* .s i i II 3 . l. ! 'd5 I. ! si i $~ i i
===g! a =la a gil i se og 'I[I .a s ] E .3 ~ f."es E ~ E5 I "I 3 l887 l.- l a ,s = g,- z. 2 = lln gI n!. 4 != -a i x I IF
== r i Y! ~! l l - (/ 2. -
1.E.2. POTENTIAL CRITICAL PATHS A. AUXILIARY BUILDING EL. 383', AREA 2 (-l DAY) t B. CONTAINMENT LARGE BORE PIPE QUADRANT 3 (+6 DAYS) l C. CONDUIT DESIGN CONTAINMENT (+5 DAYS) D. LOOP PIPING (+25 DAYS) E. MAIN CONTROL BOARD DELIVERY (+30 DAYS) t l CLFP 12/1/82 .l 1: I 1.E.3. METHOD OF CORRECTIVE ACTION A. IDENTIFICATION l. IDENTIFY PATH 2. REVIEW LOGIC PATH WITH RESPONSIBLE PARTIES-3. EXPEDITE 14. DEVELOP WORK AROUNDS (RECOVERY PLAN) ~ 5. MONITOR PROGRESS ON WEEKLY BASIS' 6. REVIEW. MONTHLY IRENDS OF MAJOR COMMODITY INSTALLATIONS 7. PROVIDE CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT WITH ALTERNATE CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCES B. VISIBILITY l 1. IDENTIFIED TO PROJECT ON MONTHLY BASIS VIA PROJECT REVIEW MEETING, CPM REPORTS, MONTHLY PROJECT REPORT. 'i 2. IDENTIFIED TO CONTRACTOR VIA PROJECT REVIEW MEETING, CPM REPORTS, CONTRACT MANAGEMENT.IEAM. i' 3. DETAILED SUBNET DEVELOPED AS REQUIRED TO ADD VISIBILITY. CLFP 12/1/82 h-
4 -A.,e s._.I a 3 -~A A a 4 _.a_ -.e.- ..J 4_..w_ J _r.L...L.c h I 1: g. 1.F SCHEDULE REVIEW L 1. ENGINEERING t 2. CONSTRUCTION 2 s l I CLFP 12/1/82 15._ www~~w-w ~-~vw-,.ww mwww--,.----- w .ww
1.F.1 ENGINFERING A. POTENTIAL CRITICAL ITEMS 1. CONDUIT DESIGN IN SUPPORT OF INSTALLATION FIELD WALKDOWN 80% REPLICATE DESIGN
- i' 2.
SMALL BORE PIPING DESIGN OF SUPPORT OF INSTALLATION ON SITE DESIGN IEAM FOR SMALL BORE JANUARY 1983 3. DESIGN AND PROCUREMENT OF INSTRUMENTATION B. DESIGN COMPLETION 1. AUXILIARY EUILDING A. ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION DWGS. 4/12/85 L B. WIRING DIAGRAMS UNIT 1/ COMMON 5/1/84 [ 'L C. WIRING DIAGRAMS UNIT 2 3/15/85 l D. MECHANICAL INSTRUMENTATION 8/17/84 LOCATION DRAWINGS 2. CONTAINMENT UNIT #1 A. ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION DwGS. 3/15/84 B. WIRING DIAGRAMS 6/15/84 C. MECHANICAL INSTRUMENTATION 8/17/84 LOCATION DRAWINGS i 3. CONTAINMENT UNIT #2 A. ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION DWGS. 10/15/84 B. WIRING DIAGRAMS 6/14/85 I-C. MECHANICAL INSTRUMENTATION 5/14/85 LOCATION DRAWINGS CLFP 12/1/82 -%~
1.F.1 ENGINFFRING (CONT'D) 4, Tunnius #1 A. WIRING DIAGRAM COMPLETE 4/12/83 5. Tunnius #2 A. WIRING DIAGRAMS 12/31/84 B. MECHANICAL INSTRUMENTATION 2/25/83 LOCATION DRAWINGS 6. CONTAINMENT LARGE BORE PIPING 12/31/82 FORMAL ANALYSIS COMPLETE 7. AUXILIARY BUILDING, FUEL HAND-3/15/83 LING BUILDING, MAIN STEAM IUN-NEL LARGE BORE PIPING FORMAL ANALYSIS COMPLETE \\. I I I CLFP 12/1/82 { --.
g -i I _.;~' ! A. 2 i s i, k $ ~ l Iig I i = y = i,. 4 lL - y ~ .o + 4 ! L ]f S g r__ 4 U LL u._f '- .O.. I_N. j ~ i$ t! E !-) 4 1,: f.]_ m 1 J pg p $ AN N! d '! rm o ato a ei W iT 1 7 lIn N m i. .lil. !. %e !n~ U.i ] 1 i. i i EBC4 ) ^ i s n#. - in i Il i tb a s gt gn.... '9..;N.. p.i! r,, 1. _e j= x--- - a z =y m ._2 t! b,
- t S II a
W ii" $ 1 '. w W 10 a "U Rn f 8 I I LH----1: AI IF e K itgi I ..!~ ' I .1_J d ..I ! t w oto; enx t u a. l t 14 11 I .i 10 5 % s !.1 ' If I i L ! LI II I 1-H-fM i if k' l i, r E l 6 5 i I I Ji 7
- pf " i.4 h!i 5.L.3 if ! l 3'n si I
li' 3l l != l n h"PHH-1J 'i I ETF id, t Ji / Rii t t e J,P it 'lir 52,,i ' ilf F ! Q-ii P I li r ~ t1 e i L r.d l j ) l I I "l t it i i l [ f 8{ i g I I l'lI i l[j!!ll g IIl I I = 8 j, !I g II e l l{: I I I.1 I l i rill il !.! lii l l i Il. !r fi J l I E 1 il !!i 2 i i o - ge -
- g ipl in%
a n o, i 1i, w a ~m g
- liilt. 8 i r i:
C - s, m i ,c LL YL w eg e 9 Wijij 0 ej scih Va ' L_L
- n ad m,
........py -- g...,
- g.._. _..
- i 4
g N ./ F A ,,lA llilf 9 j 2' W e g d J .i 9. 11. RI g J. ii c - ib 'ir"r a.k I.,. i!f mibi'F l1__ 1,,: de. 1;i s s t,1 II, tU IT!b 01 $1 lb Y! I I. C
- ._..m.k.
a., M4 'il i,.... i, iir. t i i l' ~TFi i i f h! h ,1 m 3 i i I !i !If id l i M' i di 8 ; i. i e i p i iv i e ge .x q I i ? i. ,tf! n nio 4,. ir g.' i is i r g i li : t e e fi. r c... - kr. i. e nV. :....im.._. :... 4 l i a .e J J, i i N. ............s. ,l. a-i ii g, i g p. .e - - g 3...:... a i y. 1 i., i s:t;.3. io t .a l' j<.....ll : _ a= f t? G ::: s
- I'! l h..I "~fij j
gj G i i, - I'. ,,I il e ~ f !1l i I 'l N I ' !I I i l1 .l g r 8 !r i c = l I lr l ln rl l 1 1 i 7 i e ii I ~ ~ I. I. ~ 2 3 / 1 / 2 8 1 8 9 P 1 PL C 7 8 9 1 E N i R E V G 8 a J 8 H L 9 C C eb .N N 1 N W I E O L D E L R E B E G Y e e L 8 A A I 8 9 U 1 A S B E ~ G N l e l I jA E R E E A E E e W M Y L 4 E WL S E 8 E U R A A 9 N P 1 E A A D E i E U I E A S A R L ] B L T 3 E I 8 L A A S A X 9 P h b Ik A S 1 O S U [ S C A S h% 2 A A 0 0 8 9 0 9 8 1 [d 1 1 2 S 2 R - S S S E Y S
- R T
S R 4 T T G M8 E E L S E N N N N I
- G E E A A 0
D T S O D G D N MM H P T O E R O L N
- I A
1 2 U U E U D M R E P E A SH - - R R L D N 1 L S WH S P. P. T T T B N E M C G T A *2 Qb E O N E N C C O T A U B. E. B L B. B. S S A A O E (_ G / N H C C C C S H D L L LC1 S S I l L @i I'
2 8 / 1 / 8 2 8 1 9 1 P FLC 7 8 9 1 E T N R V 8 E N J 8 H L 9 C C E 1 e .e W N O M E L E E L E E R E N G Y 8 I 8 9 s A A 1 o E e T E E A G N E R N \\!.l A b E M B 4 L O WL 8 E G E U i e 9 N P E A 1 C A A E L L D E E U J J R L A A B 1 3 8 A 9 s 1 s qu e T ei \\ I E S a N b b b d d d U ns 2 o n 8 S o 9 i 1 01-S S ~ R R Y E S S E ~ T G S R T G N L E S N N N ss I D E A O G D E A A ne O TE H O N L E M H P T is M R L P A E P U E U D l I M C E T S'H WP R 1 L D N OA T T B N E O N E C C O T U B B B B. S A A O G C S D LLLS N C C C E I L gx$ 1 ll jlli!ll t
l l 2 8 / 1 / 2 1 8 8 P 9 F 1 LC e a 7 E 8 9 E 1 a e A T nn v. E ea N A uo 8 8 9 c c e i' E S w E 1 i i' n M o E e t A E E E nt A ne N E av 8 A E I 8 S A A A 9 1 T A a n s G A E n N a e e u E m s S S S wt O t 4 8 eu 9 S nr C 1 s a os r su no a s 2 3 8 T 9 a 1 I NU ss 2 e n 8 s o s 9 1 D1 8 SR S S E Y S R T G T L E S N N N ss I ET S O G D E A A ee D O E R O) N L E M H P T s s I P U E U D & E P E A )E E )E M R L I H W P R L D N 1 M C E TG S M M M T T B N E OA O N E CN .O B. ' O .O B. S A A O G C O T UA B B C S DH L (D L (D L (D S C C C E N I L i3Y1 !l1 f: )lilI ii l ) j! l: !l!
l 1 l CEBLE 1 l i COMMODITY 1982 1983 1984 1985 1see 1987 toes i t UNIT 1 S 'A E i i UNIT 2 A A e i I i I l i s d i tn l \\ i i i 1 l I 1 LEGEND: O - ses 0-ses nEn-nEwsEne eREEN-CHERNE 0 - 585 -I - 1eos BLUE-PULLMAN YELLOW-CLJV l l l CLFP 12/1/32 i l l t
i s TERMS i l conneoo Tv seen sees tes4 ines tese tear tese l I uni a A m i UNIT G A E i a i N i O i 4 l \\ l 1 i l i LEGEND: l O - ses 0 - ses neo-newmane ennen-cumnue i A - ses sees stus-Pittman , vettow-ctav i CLFP 12/1/82
+a -m-- ,----_m. a - a-u_ -a-.4 -a a__-- 4 A..- ,-#-.A2 G. CONTINGENCY PROVISIONS o 1. PREMIUM TIME 2. ADDITIONAL SHIFT IIME i I i CLFP 12/1/82 /c7 - L
e I BULK MTITIES B.A. SPENCE PRaECT CMOLS PW9GER (ETING) t I lob-
CASELDAD PESENTATI(M cli*' LMITI 3 d# /v UfilLY f EllM. EST. PEKENT
- INSTAL, SUSTAIED EST.
EllR. UNLETE MTE MTE CONCRETE (CY) 228,9tI2
- h,755 86 3,890 3,055 Pipe vos,n) #
y,sn ,,,z g LB (Spoots) 32,073 d 5,077 21 2 256 + SB(iF) 205,732 20,097 10 1,500 4,220 - I i y ABOVE1 HANGERS lB 18,300 11,180 23 202 IE0 - i SB 20,571 ' '2,009 10 150 id2 h' /.w,, w yCABLETRAY, 7't,363 24,878 33 2,400 2,500 Corouir 0 0iM.) 667,345 267,l186 11 0 10,900 N/A 1 N '02,225 ^ 7L690 17 ' 6,800 10,Il50 CABLE 5,015,358 135,163 3 0 190,000 TE MINATIONs - 193,1fA 5,000 3 0 7,000 enam .v;o e o BAS sc. c, : e. :,,.yo, e ~, (gyp 3,,93,g, a
CASELOAD PESENTATim lNITII ENRY ENRY ERIAL EST. FEKENT INSIM., SUSTAIED EST. EIUAL C& RETE MTE MTE CONCREm (CY) 93,235 78,393 8f1 L320 LO75 PIPE i LB (SPOOLS) 5,127 L274 25 20 86 i SB GF) 13LO59 4,812 4 200 2,557 so l 7 YARD (CareltED ABOVEJ HMGERS 1 l LB 4,500 L432 32 6 70 SB 13,103 481 4 20 256 CRETRAY 3L538 14,6t16 46 290 740 C e utT (10TAL) 216,565 19,593 9 L800 N/A N 199,513 13,553 7 L750 9,800 CRE 5,185,066 3A10 0 L700 175,000 TERMINATIONS 13L126 0 0 0 5,900 BAS ClFP 12/01/82
CASELOW PRESENTATION C&BIED PER&NT EST. EllW_ CORETE 4 i CMCRETE (CY) 322,177 278,1118 86 I PIPE LB (Spoots) 37,200 6,351 37 SB(LF) 336,751 211,909 7 1 YARD (COPSI is ABWE + i lhNGERS LB 22,800 5,612 25 SB 3ft,000 2,l19 0 7 CABLETRAY 105,T1 39,52ft 37 Corou1T (TOTAD 883,908 287,079 32 NYT 611,738 85,2f13 Ili W 8,195,72tl 138,573 2 ~ CABLE Pm i TERMINATims 32ft,290 5,000 2 BAS CtFP 17101/82 l 1 b
6 l I. C(NSTRUION #0 STAR 1DP MWGUENT OGNI7ATION J. H. BIBER TEST DIECTOR m 6 t -Ho-
O R . s. e. j 3#3
- i!
.=
== d
==_ o ggg.E e 3" i 33h s . g ;.. g=fi i -= t.cs
- ==
- 38.
88 6 O#h3 l 408 B Ss.g 8 Os,g i Coo 8 i E<* ~ e x p#3 E! sg. I 4 E l f l.
- w e
. a e S.e a O 5,8 8 e 9 3 m *E e g 8 i e e 3 a,8 s a i
- ar o.5-
=. o* $E3 3 s ag sE a O 38 a >S 8 se i e,a 6.= I l EE ~~ "E e E t 3 gEI. a -l ff .!j l ~ O 2:=52 o; = ', ; a i l i z m 8 Ia i l l go.e
===.
I I i i l we
- a g
i 3; 5 .f..
== l 3, 8 a =
== OE 8 I I .!s's igi >= 3e. 3:: i g g - I.: = q > I s. l o C .o.s l 9 33; I Eli ~g 8 .gs esg
- *# e O".g Eq No a E
4 3 - //t - m- - m
m-Ge me ee d y a _-3 .o .8 >W E OPI 4 es us 3 m e &E 3W l >G l E. 4E >4 83 .A 4 g => E.g 4mg IP g I W 3 6 1 0 l' I- ..E -e ge 4 J S-g W t 4 Ee-E e = 3 se 4 = egg 9 E Eum E W 4E6 5 d 8 J O.3 3 a = g E
- 45 _L
- l..
E..: D
- g,
& ed g E _a sg s E o*
- ~'
OZ = 3=" E2 = a we g-E me g4 eo 2
== Em 3 m.o E= E >x 2 =t = e = w< MW O* E = i g a E m m= e_ ad MS E E a N 9 9 4 4 l, t l .C e.d g E o" a 4 E w l o>$ ,l
- E=3 no.
3 so 3 e EW. W45= E 3 >>q edg>G g W E e I 9 3 E W W e o a I e l o e d E 4 E a .2.- g S p W =E 9 ed y P S 3 I E W W e g E = i 1 -/t? -
itEutHATIONAL TEST PROGRAM J.H. BREWER TEST DIECTOR I t u ( l - // $ ~ --s
e 8Y87EM' COMPLETION AND TE8T LOGIO CONSTRUCTION AC TY l '. TES.T NETWORK A A s s, s CONSTRUOTION HOT EL20TaloAL 7 .gggy 4 TURNOVER PRt0P ,PUNOTIONAL~ 4 ^*'""'" l .....T.... . U.. T.T.E,,
- e..,,1 T..
Ant AttYSTE= e aveT== . 11 7. 71.. ig;v;t,,, ayg= - T.r BONSTRUOTIOR 0050YSTEM #9 SUBOYBtew at 7897 *e ' TESTING I m AREAftYSTRW I d b I i i 00Nef AUSTIO. " = E C H A N10 AL" C
- 7887,
.==.D ' TURNOVER ACTIVITIE6 GUG9YSTEN.es SUSOYSTEK 49 AntAfeYtTsu .l e OLFP 13 1-S E'. 1 i e
SUBSYSTEM SCOPING G SCOPING $ BREAKDOWN LARGE PLANT SYSTEMS INTO UNIQUELY IDENTIFIED SUBSYSTEMS 9 184 IDENTIFIED PLANT SYSTEMS $ 103 UNIT 1 E COMMON 9 81 UNIT 2 G 671 SCOPED SUBSYSTEMS G426 UNIT 1 & COMMON 8245 UNIT 2 l CLFP l 12-1-82 1 - H.
SUBSYSTEV. RELEASES . AND TURNOVER STATUS L KEY DEFINITIONS PHASE I (RELEASED TO CONSTRUCTION TEST). CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES COMPLETE SUBSYSTEM UNDER CONSTRUCTION TEST ~ CONTROL l CONSTRUCTOR NOT RELEASED PHASE II (TURNOVER:AND PREOP TEST) CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES COMPLETE CONSTRUCTION TESTING CDMPLETE 7 I STATION STAFF ACCEPTED SUBSYSTEM UNDER STATION CONTROL CONSTRUCTOR RELEASED CLPF 12-1-82 4 e "Y e* -r t-m--
- -w-e
,---,.w.,e.*rrw~weegr + we v=*-t--9-w--w-=ew--w-- - + - -~ ww---w ' - - - -ww w w a-== ---ee-----ene-=--we===-'w--wiwe'e-==------v w-e-wwi-w em----eet,e--
i ~. l TEST SCHEDULING G TEST SCHEDULE IS MILESTONE ORIENTED 9 STARTED WITH MAJOR MILESTONES AND TIE,D SUBSYSTEMS TO EACH 9 TEST SCHEDULE IS INTEGRAL WITH THE CONSTRUCTION' LEVEL II LOGIC 9 THE IEST LOGIC IS A SEPARATE SUBNETWORK BUT INTERLACED AND TIME ANALYZED TOGETHER WITH THE LEVEL II LOGIC I i 9 CHANGES IN EITHER SUBNETWORK AFFECT THE OTHER O e i I e CLFP 12-1-82 I - Il9 -
STARRP l%NNING e PRESENT - STARTlP MWER 1
- SCEDUl.ED
- 1983 8 ~ -1984 31 j -TOTALSTARTLP 20 SLFPORT MMING 8 STATION PR0UCTION ENGIEERS -PRESENT 16 (INCL 10 LNG SUPERINTENDEND -1983 4 -1984 5 -TDTAL 25 (INCLIEES 4 SEA'S - 2 YR. DEGRED
- EACTOR ENGIEERING l
- 1983 1 -1984 3 L. -1985 ISFERINIEEENT L L -1DTAL 5 L i l i - 120 -
1. STATIE
- TEST PROGRAM AMINISTRATIVE PRDIDURES - 00PPETE AND IN USE e PRE-0P TEST - ETIODS AND OBJECTIVES - 95% COPPETE e 189 PRE-0P TEST PROEDURES - UNIT I AND C0Pfi)N
-308NON-SAFETYRELATEDB0P f. - 81 SAFETY RELATED -5 NON SAFETY RELATED WRITTEN AND APPROVED - 2 f0N-SAFETY RELATED DRAFTS IN EVIEW .1 SAFETY RELATED - RCS IWDR0 - Jsr DRAFT WRITTEN 0 IsT PRE-0P SCEDULED TO START DEEMBER L 1982 e PRE-OP TEST PROEDlRE TRACKING INDEX 00PPl#ERIZED s e FOT RfCT10NAL FRAGET 00PPETE WITH DESCRIPTION OF EACH STEP O W 32-1-82 -/2./ -
MM
- M
- =,....e
- g.e.
.++..e
- ..==~e*w******=
e m-. ^ 8 man... SCHEDULED PREOP TESTS PER MONTH NOTE: 18,T DRAFT - NOT RESOURCE LOADED 25 25 23 e LEGEND ~ l9 2. l 20 gjj,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, o O g ::::r: n, is e e \\ l5 14 s S yv 4 n+ ), ( 10 lg j, 10 F4 I I 'I 8 3 3 7 [ s 7 555 ) i 5'j ( 1 j
- j 0
i s ls{ Il e n 5 j 5 2 2 .o 2 2 4 a 4 9 3 ) I v p g w._ _Eh. - _ "" g' f -hh l l l, l _;!.;I I e2 es 84 L m,.... p . a.,s,/ o o >_. xxeausua Ml;y f wk
SLWARY - 2E PRE-0P TESTS EQUIED FOR REL LMD - 20 DRAFT PROEURES NOT STARTED 2 DRAFT PROEUES BElfra WRITTEN 5 PE-OP TEST PRDEUES APPROE 2 DRAFT PROEURES IN EVIEW 0 PRE-OP TEST COPPETED i i' 1 PE-0P TEST IN PROGRESS O 36 SUBSYSTDE TURED CNER TO. STATION ) e a 4 E-1-82 -/73 -
a4 4 m _+m__ e 4a ) d lWEr0737 ItexTs S. J. BREER MA SAFETY AND UCENSIE PWNER f I -l i a 124 -
MMOR NUEG-0737 AEAS i PROEDUES & GUIDELIES I STUDIES & ANALYSES i L' E0JIPPENT E2JIEENTS I i I f e r ~
+ r ~ OPEN f0REEM)737 ITEMS / ITEMNO. SUBICT SCEDULE Igg ( I.D.1 Hlf%N FACTORS REVIEW 0F CONTROL ROOM 12/83 R I.D.2 SAETY PAR #EIER DISPLAY SYSTEM 9/85 U II.B.2 RADIATION & SHIELDING REVIEW FOR J2/83 R POST-ACCIDENT CONDITIONS /, l II.B.3 POST-ACCIDEhT S&PLING SYSTEM 5/85 R i e l II.D.1 TEST PROGRAM FOR RCS RELIEF, SAETY 11/83 R & BLOCK VALVES l L l II.E.1.2 AUTO % TIC INITIATION & FL N Il01, CATION6/83 R FOR AUXILIARY FEEDWATER SYSTEM l II.F.1 CMIROL ROM INDICATION FOR C0tKAIN-10/85 R ENT 10NITORS l CLFP - / 2.G - 32/1/82 . - ~
OPEN RJEG-07371196 CMTIMED ITEMNO. SUBJECT SCHEDUE UgN II.F.2 INADEQJATE CWE 10/85 R i COOLING INSTINENTATIm II.K.2.13 THER%L ECHANICAL EPORT 1/83 R II.K.3.30 SBLOCA ETH@S ER10 CFR 50 11/82 R APP. K II.K.3.31 SBLOCA CALIULATIGE PER 11/82 R 10 CFR 50.46 III.A.2 EERGENCY ESPONSE FACILITIES 6/85 U i. III.D.2.4 TF-SITE DOSE 7/85 U l
i .I 10 CFR 50.55(E) ITACIS S. J. BRBER MX1 EAR SAFETY AND LI&NSING MNGER Z P l r k i 1 i I i p t i - 12 6 -
MfEER (F [ PORTABLE 1196 AT MMBLE HILL . = 10 PLM AVERAGE + = PSI IRTA g g i ~v Y E + + (EXPECTED PSI + VENDOR) 10 'l + (MttitlJ PSD 5 I + s a i I 8 5 1980 1981 1982 E2
i OPEN SAFETY EVIEW COMTTEE ITEMS u i ITEM NO. STATUS l. S80-13 POTENTIAL PRTLEM OF CENTRIFUGAL MEINGEVAUUAKDFORBASEPLANT. CHARGING PtW S DURING SECONDARY NAITING FE DYR CORRECTIW LINE BREAK. ACTION. -INAL DUE.12-9-82. S81-18 ABSENCEOFPROCEDURESTOINCLUDE % ISSUED, SPECIFICATION /DESIGNCHANGESIN FINALMEPORTDUE8-1-8 PROCUREMENT DOCUMENTS. S82-12 ING W THOUT PROCEDURES GAEVALUATINGDEFICIENCIES ON. I SWITCHGEAR. ?EPORTDUE1-12-83 j I S82-13 THERPOSTATIC VALVE PROBLEM WHICH INEERING,1NygSHGATING. MAY CAUSE OVERC00 LING IN DIESEL DUE.14.U-52. GENERATORS. i S 8 2 -114 INCORRECTLYFABRICATED NEWBERG EXAMINING PREVIOUSLY U=uUeLEM,"- S" l = =- l 882-15 STRUCTURALSTEELERECTEDAND ENGINEERING DETERMINING E I INSPECTED WITHOUT USE OF OF PROBLEM. DUE - 4. CORRECT DESIGN DRAWINGS. l l / 30 "
I t .j - OPEN SAEW REVIEW ClMITTEE ITUS CMTINUED ITEM NO. STATUS ~ 882-18 % t 7ABLE FAILURES IN SOLID '%STINGHOUSF, TING PROBLEM bTATE CTION SYSTEM. M DUE l-S82-19 [*lEAREDPINIONKEYSIN E.STINGHOUSEPURSUINGWITH LIMITORQUE VALVE OPERATORS IMITORQUE. M DUE l 8. S82-20 INCORRECTLYDISPOSITIONEDNCR M TO REV1JE NCR ON POLAR CRANE. M DUE.z- $@-21 MISSINGANDDAMAGEDWIRE INEERING I IGATING. ANCHORS ON EPBEDDED PLATES. DUEL-S82-23 WEl.D CRACKS ON UNIT 2 POLAR ENGINEERINGDETERMINING 1 S@-25 DAMAGED WIRE ANCHORS ON EPEEDDED QINJERINGINVE]TIGATING. PLATES INSTALLED AFTER RESLPPTION EdjKIH.E3-11-e. OF SAFETY RELATED WORK. i I ' j L _ ni -
,e MEETIfiG fiOTICE NOV 161982 Document Control STri 50-546 and STf4 50-547 NRC PDR L PDR PRC System NSIC LBil Rdg. M. Rushbrook Project Manager E. L. Doolittle H. Denton/E. Case D.. Eisenhut/R. Purple A. Schwencer G. Knighton E. Adensam G. Lainas F. Miraglia F. Schroeder M.-Ernst. J. Knight W. Johnston D. Muller T. Speis L. Rubenstein W.-Houston ~ E. Jordan, DEQA:IE a ^ J. daylor, DRP:IE-Attorney, OELD ACRS(16) ~cc: Service List flRC PARTICIPANTS: ti'.Si.ovelace J. Ha rri son ~- *" ~~ ~. E. Doolittle J. Konklin o O.8 m e
- -memum.
6 9 SD
e ~- 7, 83 MARBLE HI LL PROPOSED AGENDA FOR CASELOAD FORECAST PANFL MEETING February 27-28, 1979 February 27th 9:30 a.m.-3:30 p.m. 1. Overview of construction management organization and activities. 2. Overview of project construction schedule including major milestones and schedule for licensing. 3. Procurrement management and current status of major components including hangers, snubbers, pipe whips, valves, piping and etc. 4. Construction status and problems including bulk quantities (Total estimate cuantity and quantity installed to date.), status of HVAC work. A. Concrete B. Structrual Steel C. Large Bore Pipe - 2h" i D. Small Bore Pipe - 2" 4 E. Hangers, Snubbers etc. F. Cable Tray G. Conduit 11. Cable I. Terminations 5. Engineering organization and current status of design / engineering activities, i 6. Actual _and proposed craft work force, craft availability, productivity, potential labor negatiations~and problems. 7. Current status of pre-op test procedure writing and integration of pre-op testing with construction schedule. Pre-op test schedule and number of engineers writ ing procedures and performing pre-op test. 8. Construction scheduling staff: A. Method of calculation of percent complete. B. Method of monitoring rate of completion, identifying critical path items and implementation of corrective actions. C. Critical path activities logic network and 4 ~ computer printout of critical and/or near critical items. l m
MARBLE HILL UNITS 1 & 2 CONSTRUCTION MILESTONES ( Unit 1 Unit 2 1
- 1. Service Building Occupancy 10- 1-79 NA
- 2. Water Treatment & Demineralizer Plant in Service 11-1-79 NA 3.
Firing of Auxiliary Boiler 11-15-79 Est.10-1-80 4. Buildings Closed and Heated (except Unit 2 Containment) 12-1-79 12-1-79 5. Begin Construction Testing of Circulating Water l System 8-1-80
- Later
- 6. Energize 345 KV Switchyard 10- 1-80 NA 7.
Begin Construction Testing of Instrument Air System 12-15-80 Later
- 8. Begin Construction Testing of Component Cooling System 1-1-81 Later 9.
Begin Construction Testing of CVCS 1-1-81 Later
- 10. Begin Construction Testing of Safety injection System 1-1-81 Later
- 11. Nonessential Service Water System Operational (partial) 4-1-81 6-1-82
- 12. Begin Construction Testing of Containment Spray System 10- 9-79 Later
- 13. Main Condenser Hydrostatic Test 6-1-81 9-1-82
- 14. Condensate System Operational 7-1-81 10-1-82
- 15. Main Turbine Oil Flush (start) 8-1-81 11-1-82 l
l
- 16. Begin Construction Testing of Radwaste System 8-2-81 Later
- 17. Reactor Coolant System Cold Hydro 10- 1-81 1-1-83
- 18. Begin Construction Testing of Essential Service Later Water System 11-1-81
- 19. Turbine Generator on Turning Gear 12-1-81 3-1-83 1-1-82 4-1-83
- 20. Hot Functional Testing
- 21. Fuel Load 4-1-82 7-1-83
- 22. Commercial Operation 10- 1-82 1-2-84
- Hydrostatic testing of these systems is underway for embedded portions.
NRC CASELOAD FORECAST PANEL MEETING February 27, 1979 INTRODUCTION L. A. CREWS CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT ORGANIZATION L. A. CREWS OVERVIEW OF PROJECT SCHEDULE L. A. CREWS LICENSING SCHEDULE T. R. BURNS ENGINEERING ORGANIZATION AND DESIGN STATUS M. L. MORRIS PROCUREMENT MANAGEMENT AND STATUS OF MAJOR COMPONENTS M. L. MORRIS CONSTRUCTION STATUS M MNK CRAFT LABOR J. S. DENNEHY TEST PROGRAM R. S. PETERSON J. U. BOTT CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULING Percent Complete Calculation L. A. CREWS Monitoring Progress E. J. EVERSON CRITICAL PATH ACTIVITIES E. J. EVERSON i-
ctnstructi:n plins Firm construction plans unit is slated for service in late During the year,5137 million already in place will assure 1982 or early 1983 followed by was spent on the Marble Hill Company customers that their the second unit in 1984. The units and $87 million was electric energy needs will be Company will own 83% of spent on the Gibson Station, met well into the 1980s. these units; Wabash Valley including initial expenditures Economic expansion and Power Association, Inc. will of $24 million on the fif th unit. population growth are own the remaining 17%. Substation additions totaled expected to increase the Expenditures for nuclear fuel $17 million, transmission lines demand for electricity by for this station will total $234 517 million, distribution nearly 20% between million in the 1979-1982 facilities 530 million and now and 1982. period, including 520 general property $10 million. million in 1979. Construction of new facilities Ground will be broken at mid-to keep pace with these energy While construction year 1979 for a planned needs calls for estimated expenditures were estimated at expansion to the Company's expenditures of 51.9 billion for 5371 million for 1978 in last general headquarters in the 1979-1982 period, including year's Annual Report, actual Plainfield. The 59 million estimated 1979 expenditures of construction expenditures for addition, to be completed in $421 million. Major additions the year were 5298 million. 1981, is needed to relieve under this program include the The major reasons for this present facilities and to completion of a fourth 650,000 decrease included the delay in provide for planned expansion kilowatt coal-fired unit at the receiving the full construction into the 1990s. Gibson Station early in 1979 as permits for Marble Hill, well as a fif th unit of similar extremely cold weather in the size to be in service early part of the year which in late 1982. hampered preliminary construction work and some Construction on two nuclear delays due to units at Marble Hill represents lack of manpower. over half of the 1979-1982 construction program. The first 1.13 million kilowatt nuclear i construction cost per kilowatt (5) r 0 150 300 450 600 750 900 6 wabash river #6 1968 cayuga #1, #2 1970-72 gibson #1, #2 1975-76 gibson #3, #4 1978 79 gibson #5 1982 marble hill #1, #2 1982-84 l
- Nuclear construction costs per kilowatt are somewhat higher than for comparable coal.
fired units. Fuel economies over the life of the nuclear facility more than ofIset the dif-ference in conaruction costs and result in lower cost energy. 10}}