ML20069H533

Forwards Analysis of Wall Liner at Square Penetrations for Crbr Cell Liner Design Verification Program,Per Commitment in DOE

ML20069H533
Person / Time
Site:	Clinch River
Issue date:	04/04/1983
From:	Longenecker J ENERGY, DEPT. OF, CLINCH RIVER BREEDER REACTOR PLANT
To:	Grace J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
HQ:S:83-239, NUDOCS 8304060217
Download: ML20069H533 (13)

Text

_ _ _ _ _ _.

Department of Energy Washington, D.C. 20545 Docket No. 50-537 HQ:S:83:239 AP!

o; 1933 Dr. J. Nelson Grace, Director CRBR Program Office Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555

Dear Dr. Grace:

CELL LINER DESIGN VALIDATION PROGRAM - SQUARE PENETRATION ANALYSIS

Reference:

Letter HQ:S:83:231, J. R. Longenecker to J. N. Grace,

" Cell Liner Design Validation Program," dated March 4, 1983 This letter transmits new information related to the Clinch River Breeder i

Reactor Plant Cell Liner Design Validation Program promised in the reference.

Specifically enclosed is the analysis of the wall liner at square penetrations.

Any questions regarding the information provided or further submittals can be addressed to Mr. P. Washer (FTS 626-6179) or Mr. V. Fayne (FTS 626-6394) of %e Project Office Oak Ridge staft.

1 Sincerely, J n R. Longene r

Acting Director, ffice of Breeder Demonstration Projects Office of Nuclear Energy l

Enclosure l

cc: Service List Standard Distribution l

Licensing Distribution l

b l

l 8304060217 830404 PDR ADOCK 05000537 A~

PDR

ENCL.0SURE ATTACHMENT I (1 sheet of 12)

CELL LINER WALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATIONS Analyses of the wall liner near a square penetration were considered based on the mathematical model of Figure A-1.

The following ANSYS elements were used in the model:

STIF 48 for the plate, STIF 20 and STIF 8 for the studs and STIF 52 for the interface between the plate and the concrete.

The maximum liner temperature is 670 F.

Table A-1 shows the maximum strains and Figure A-2 shows the calculated buckling pattern in terms of the displacement contours.

The maximum equivalent von Mises strains are:

Plate -

.016 (in/in) (Membrane); 0.033 (in/in) (Membrane plus Bending)

.057 (in/in) (Membrane); 0.142 (in/in) (Membrane Stud plus Bending)

The strain allowables in accordance with the liner design criteria are.105 (in/in) for the membrane strain and 0.141 (in/in) for the membrane plus bending strain.

Liner strains are well below the allowables by a factor of 4.3.

i l

Stud strains are at the maximum allowable for combined membrane plus bending, however this is acceptable because the large strains experienced by stud do not adversely influence the liner integrity.

(2 of 12) m 3st 1

/"

ssz w

4 :f AM%

3 3/8" THICK h6d

'4' 4 u-g

/ '"hlf an LINER 7 N

jsf

,,+

,1MyW%

h h.

a m

@ 5 0 AH s fil'

,$j@, b,,,

=(='c"A V%Mpv5V'(%

DgQy$.. ~

l /MYMYM%%'

60" 1

i. 7 3

.c DETAIL T 2

45 32 1

8 5 6

/

PPN)WWMMM'pM

'~

SEE DETAIL "X" h

3 g

2 f

a 2 = 2-

/

jAl w2 W MW N7 NWN"

1. fM' M'#WEXMM A

5,,'N I

l,,,

1" THICK COLLAR e

q:

60" 347 242 525 392 324 652 584 503 496 386 281 579 437 368 663 623 560 552 ELD! INT NUMBERS v

429 317 614 484 410 667 644 600 596 FOR STUDS 476 355 636 533 457 671 657 627 625 FIGURE A-1

'a'ALL LINER AT SOUARE PENETRATION MATEDIATICAL MODEL

(3 of 12)

I N

I T

N

- i

\\ i Ig

\\

-1.

A CONTOUR VALUES y

(INCHES)*

,/

__.. W A..g,3 i ii gj l;

3=-1.6 I

D C+-1.4 g

g f

D=-1.2 g

g g

F

)

1 E*-1 g

l H

T l

p._,g j

K lI

,l C=.6 Ha.4 Hl-i i

4 l

I lg 1

.2 J*e s

y J

K.a

,8 K,'

1 I

I I

i K

i3 l

e

--4b Ml l@,

/,'

I

\\

l l

I

\\

\\

l i

{

i) i l

Negative value indicates displacement away from concrete.

l

\\

FIGURE A-2 WALL LINER AT SQ1%RE PENETRATIONS DISPLACEMENT CONTOURS l

l s1-

--.m4

-m-

- ~ - - -

(4 of 12)

Sheet 1 of 9 TABLE A-1 WALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATION ELEMENT M

M+B u--

122 0.001378 0.001556 LINER 144 0.001063 0.001243 LINER 145 0.000875

.O.001131 LINER 146 0.000935 0.001354 LINER 147 0.000900 0.001394 LINER 148 0.000613 0.001153 LINER 168 0.000939 0.001448 LINER 169 0.000S90 0.001430 LINER 170 0.000964 0.001249 LINER 171 0.000876 0.001237

' LINER 172 0.000726 0.001304 LINER 173 0.000591 0.000979 LINER 174 0.000798 0.001210 LINER 175 0.000601 0.001125 LINER 179 0.000585 0.001034 LINER 180 0.000528 0.001050 LINER 181 0.000625 0.001173 LINER 197 0.001052 0.001640 LINER 198 0.000939 0.001233 LINER 199 0.001033 0.001545 LINER 200 0.000957 0.001420 LINER 201 0.000726 0.002015 LINER 202 0.000597

'D.OO1418 LINER 203 0.000705 0.001417 LINER 204 0.000637 0.001652 LINER 208 0.000523 0.001438 LINER 209 0.000496 0.001194 LINER 210 0.000542 0.001027 LINER 212 0.000491 0.000751 LINER 213 0.000532 0.000739 LINER l

215 0.000538 0.001101 LINER 216 0.000544 0.000904 LINER 218 0.000872 0.001956 LINER 219 0.000681 0.001488 LINER 220 0.000817 0.001539 LINER l

l

.._1_._.-....1_._.....

(5 of 12)

Sheet 2 of 9 TABLE A-1 WALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATION ELEMENT M_

M+B 221 0.000811 0.001644 LINER 222 0.001096 0.001839 LINER 223 0.000899 0.001238 LINER 224 0.000990 0.001277 LINER 225 0.000953 0.001329 LINER 226 0.000703 0.001741 LINER 227 0.000477 0.001175 LINER 228 0.000562 0.001766 LINER 229 0.000746 0.002168 LINER 231 0.000716 0.001438 LINER 232 0.000568 0.001180 LINER 233 0.000699 0.001496 LINER 234 0.000559 0.001333 LINER 238 0.000468 0.001173 LINER 239 0.000490 0.001630 LINER 240 0.000530 0.001522 LINER 242 0.005539 0.011177 STUD-TCP 242 0.001031 0.001760 STUD-BOTTOM 244 0.000443 0.000627 LINER 246 0.000484 0.000731 LINER 247 0.001059 0.004321 LINER 248 0.000907 0.003789 LINER 250 0.000SS5 0.003750 LINER 251 0.000917 0.003817

. LINER 253 0.000887 0.004040 LINER 254 0.000893 0.004156 LINER 256 0.000397

,0.001552 LINER 258 0.000469

.O.001486 LINER 259 0.000535 0.001639 LINER 260 0.000481 0.001582 LINER 261 0.000594 0.001533 LINER 263 0.000566 0.001476 LINER 264 0.000664 0.001438 LINER 265 0.000610 0.001513 LINER 263 0.000454 0.001631 LINER 272 0.000455 0.001997 LINER i

273 0.000465 0.001188 LINER 274 0.000449 0.001147 LINER 276 0.000411 0.000942 LINER 279 0.000371 0.000593 LINER l

1

-. _. -.. - - - - - - _. _ _.... _. _,.. ~. - - _ -.. -. _ - - - - _ - -.

(6 of 12)

Sheet 3 of 9 TABLE A-1 WALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATION ELEMENT

_M.,

M+B 280 0.000418 0.000524 LINER 281 0.001588 0.002615 STUD-TOP 281 0.000743 0.000823 STUD-BOTTOM 284 0.001003 O.004526 LINER 286 0.001243 0.011075 LINER 287 0.002043 O.012220 LINER 288 0.001134 0.004958 LINER 289

' O.OO2611 0.011825 LINER 290 0.002142 0.0108S5 LINER O.001256 0.011090 LINER 292 293 0.001841 0.012126 LINER 295 O.002427 0.011749 LINER 296 0.001947 OcO10815 LINER 293 0.000266 0.000865 LINER i

299 0.000268 0.001015 LINER 300 0.000484 0.0018S6 LINER 302 0.000374

.0.001588 LINER 304 0.000325 O.000957 LINER 305 0.000383 0.001053 LINER 306 0.000352 0.001000 LINER 309 0.000460 0.002299 LINER 312 0.000326 0.000435 LINER 314 0.000343 0.000466 LINER 315 0.001069 0.004583 LINER 316 0.001098 0.004902 LINEA 317 0.000744 0.000824 STUD-TOP 317 0.001494 0.002987 STUD-BOTTOM

' 0.001975 LINER 319 0.000588 320 0.000894 0.002932 LINER 321 0.000640 O.002057 LINER 322 0.000989 0.003080 LINER 324 0.029992 0.109678 STUD-TOP 324 0.016468 0.027740 STUD-BOTTOM 325 0.000742 0.001866 LINER 327 0.002563 O.011751 LINER 329 0.000623 0.001170 LINER 330 0.000734 0.001306 LINER 331 0.000729 0.001675 LINER 332 0.002271 0.010999 LINER l

335 0.000749 0.001724 LINER l

(7 of 12)

Sheet 4 of 9 TABLE A-1 WALL LINER AT SQUARE lENETRATION EdEMENT_

}i M+B 336 0.000644 0.001020 LINER 338 0.000292 0.000702 LINER 339 0.000492 0.002080 LINER 340 0.000446 0.001349 LINER 342 0.000389 0.002091 LINER 345 0.000342 0.000784 LINER 347 0.001803 0.005633 STUD-TOP 347 0.000678 0.001044 STUD-BOTTOM 349 0.001054 0.004222 LINER 351 0.001778 0.011450 LINER 352 0.002123 0.012065 LINER 353 0.000825 0.003375 LINER 355 0.000881 0.001599 STUD-TOP 355 0.004673 0.012504 STUD-BOTTOM 357 0.001263 0.012226 LINER 358 0.001841 0.013E80 LINER 359 0.002972 0.015384 LINER 360 0.002094 0.013623 LINER 363 0.002987 0.015376 LINER 364 0.002204 0.014085 LINER 0.013C97 LINER 366 0.001327 367 0.001981 0.014168 LINER 368 0.019139 0.031586 STUD-TOP 368 0.016679 0.017483 STUD-BOTTOM 370 0.001051 0.012157 LINER 373 0.001250 0.003242 LINER 374 0.002840 0.013454 LINER 0.012775 LINER 375 0.002575 376 0.000612 0.001844 LINER 377 0.001957 0.012837 LINER 380 0.000430 0.001243 LINER 381 0.000453 0.002141 LINER OS2 0.000737 0.003079 LINER 384 0.000418 0.001283 LINER 386 0.001001 0.001281 STUD-TOP 386 0.000599 0.000679 STUD-BOTTOM 393 0.001061 0.003086 LINER 389 0.001666 0.011242 LINER 390 0.002080 0.012113 LINER 392 0.023865 0.100340 STUD-TOP

(8 of 12) l Sheet 5 of 9 1

TABLE A-1 WALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATION ELEMENT M

M+B 392 0.011091 0.022317 STUD-BOTTOM 393 0.000662 0.002555 LINER 395 0.001099 0.012900 LINER 396 0.001707 0.013099 LINER 397 0.001864 0.014229 LINER 398 0.001315 0.013048 LINER 401 0.002047 0.012963 LINER 403 0.002647 0.013485 LINER 404 0.001970 0.012810 LINER 0.002614 0.013482 LINER 405 407 0.001707 0.012399 LINER 408 0.001348 0.012535 LINER 410 0.016994 0.017951 STUD-TOP 410 0.017301 0.019396 STUD-BOTTOM 413 0.002866 0.013424 LINER 414 0.003324 0.017475 LINER 415 0.003629 0.016136 LINER 416 0.002583 0.011016 LINER 417 0.003373 0.016260 LINER 419 0.002447 0.014264 LINER 421 0.000424 0.002140 LINER 423 0.000409 0.001773 LINER 424 0.001731 0.010390 LINER 425 0.001945 0.010811 LINER 428 0.000586 0.001507 LINER 429 0.000596 0.000709 STUD-TOP 429 0.001041 0.002505 STUD-BOTTOM 431 0.000457 "0.001940 LINER i

432 0.002115 0.009320 LINER 434 0.001176 0.001833 LINER 435 0.002925 O.011305 LINER 437 0.013582 0.026018 STUD-TOP 437 0.010483 0.011397 STUD-BOTTOM 440 0.000959 0.001807 LINER 441 0.001008 0.001875 LINER 443 0.001051 0.002744 LINER 444 0.001393 0.002894 LINER 445 0.001589 0.004009 LINER 446 0.001421 0.002991 LINER 447 0.002164 0.004940 LINER

(9 of 12)

Sheet 6 of 9 1

TABLE A-1 l

WALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATION ELDENT M

M+B 448 0.001132 0.002728 LINER 450 0.001499 0.003S6'8 LINER 453 0.000983 0.001584 LINER 454 0.001244' O.002634 LINER 455 O.000975 0.002743 LINER 457 0.016711 0.018425 STUD-TOP 457 0.019748 0.036863 STUD-BOTTOM 459 0.002297 0.005624 LINER 460 0.001194 0.003607 LINER 462 0.001350 0.003027 LINER l

463 0.003632 0.017897 LINER 464 0.003552 0.O20223 LINER 465 O.001752 0.002963 LINER 468 0.001603 0.010215 LINER 470 0.001162 0.003686 LINER 471 0.000861 0.007130 LINER 472 0.001501 C.002224 LINER 474 0.000561 0.012893 LINER 476 0.000495 0.001451 STUD-TOP 476 0.001811 0.013613 STUD-BOTTOM 478 0.004344 0.010005 LINER 479 0.004688 0.020623 LINER 481 0.002263 O.009052 LINER 482 0.006855

.O 024241 LINER 484 0.010811 O.011893 STUD-TOP 484 0.011519 0.014224 STUD-BOTTOM 486 0.002350 0.010589 LINER 487 0.002910 0.011522 LINER 488 0.002040 0.010063 LINER 489 0.002898 0.011474 LINER 491 0.001643 0.011927 LINER l

493 0.001562 0.010771 LINER 494 0.001470 O.011818 LINER 495 O.001434 0.010719 LINER 496 0.032518 0.099277 STUD-TOP 496 0.014239 0.024783 STUD-BOTTOM 498 0.002014 0.012412 LINER l

500 0.002314 0.014069 LINER 501 0.001409 0.011555 LINER 502 0.001643 0.011633 LINER

(10 of 12)

Sheet 7 of 9 TALLE A-1 WALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATION Ef.EMENT M.

M+B l

503 0.030500 0.098500 STUD-TOP 503 0.013134 0.023494 STUD-BOTTOM 506 0.001772 0.009965 LINER 507 0.002533 0.011149 LINER 509 0.002407 0.011841 LINER 511 0.001826 0.011593 LINER 512 0.003091 0.013615 LINER 513 0.003165 0.013733 LINER 514 0.003050 0.003414 LINER 0.002118 0.002972 LINER 516 518 0.004643 0.009143 LINER 519 0.002417 0.011482 LINER 520 0.001868 0.009861 LINER 522 0.002955 0.007773 LINER 525 0.054115 0.132927 STUD-TOP 525 0.043697 0.050398 STUD-BOTTOM 526 0.007124 0.015596 LINER 528 0.007388 0.023391 LINER 529 0.003808 0.008908 LINER 530 0.001748 0.007335 LINER 531 0.007986 0.0245S7 LINER 533 0.010588 0.012635 STUD-TOP 533 0.015338 0.033197 STUD-BOTTOM 535 0.001425 0.002275 LINER 536 0.001416 0.002811 LINER 533 0.001241 0.002483 LINER 539 0.001255 0.002660 LINER 541 0.001215 0.002459 LINER 542 0.001290 0.002600 LINER 544 0.001541 0.002429 LINER 545 0.001537 0.002947 LINER 547 0.001425 0.002290 LINER 548 0.001423 0.002531 LINER 550 0.001137 0.002105 LINER i

551 0.001216 0.002273 LINER 552 0.017716 0.029838 STUD-TOP 552 0.015060 0.015S28 STUD-BOTTOM 554 0.001224 0.002031 LINER l

555 0.001146 0.002091 LINER i

556 0.001162 0.001739 LINER l

l 1

r--

(11 of 12)

Sheet 8 of 9 TABLE A-1 WALL LINER AT SQUARE PESETRATION ELEMENT M

M+B 557 0.000876 0.001724 LINER 560 0.016346 0.028365 STUD-TOP 560 0.013064 0.013322 STUD-BOTTOM 564 0.001055 0.001548 LINER 565 0.002006 0.002943 LINER 566 0.003546 0.004645 LINER 567 0.001862 0.016069 LINER i

568 0.003297 0.012858 LINER 569 0.003251 0.004066 LINER 573 0.005344 0.017701 LINER 574 0.006108 0.010105 LINER 575 O.006074 0.009729 LINER 576 0.007486 0.024407 LINER 578 0.045789 0.053131 STUD-TOP 578 0.044513 0.044550 STUD-BOTTOM 581 0.003136 0.011112 LINER 582 0.006931 0.019352 LINER 533 0.006235 0.011236 LINER 584 0.056494 0.140936 STUD-TOP 584 0.034368 0.045127 STUD-BOTTOM i

536 0.005140 0.012533 LINER 587 0.005925 0.010438 LINER 596 0.015627 0.016782 STUD-TOP I

596 0.015225 0.015964 STUD-BOTTOM 600 0.013713 0.014945 STUD-TOP 600 0.013406 0.014696 STUD-BOTTOM 604 0.006184 0.012161 LINER 605 0.008633

.O.017220 LINER 607 0.005034 0.008763 LINER 603 0.004939 0.007702 LINER 610 0.003012 0.019701 LINER 611 0.000890 0.010942 LINER 614 0.044667 0.044776 STUD-TOP 614 0.044891 0.046SS2 STUD-BOTTOM 615 0.000864 0.015056 LINER 617 0.012289 0.021060 LINER 619 0.012121 0.015269 LINER 620 0.003742 0.005925 LINER j

621 0.010672 0.017217 LINER j

623 0.03860S 0.049994 STUD-TOP l

-....-.......--.n.._....

(12 of 12)

Sheet 9 of 9 TABLE A-1 UALL LINER AT SQUARE PENETRATION ELEMENT M_

M+B 623 0.036893 0.037312 STUD-BOTTOM 625 0.014978 0.015577 STUD-TOP 625 0.016865 0.024445 STUD-BOTTOM 627 0.012944 0.013956

. STUD-TOP STUD-BOTTOM 627 0.015951 0.025738 630 0.007752 0.021766 LINER 631 0.012770 0.026052 LINER 632 0.006380 0.023286 LINER 634 0.001866 0.012759 LINER 636

- O.044528 0.046254 STUD-TOP 636 0.046396 0.068346 STUD-BOTTOM 639 0.005164 0.007102 LINER 64*

0.015557 0.020482 LINER 643 0.014617 0.018A09 LINER 644 0.037260 0.C37914 STUD-TOP 644 0.037111 0.038357 STUD-BOTTOM 646 0.010676 0.021051 LINER 648 0.009782 0.010685 LINER 649 0.013779 0.033311 LINER 650 0.012236 0.027110

, LINER 652 0.041820 0.142196 STUD-TOP 652 0.021258 0.035494 STUD-BOTTOM 654 0.009341 0.027222 LINER 657 0.036875 0.037990 STUD-TOP 657 0.038292 0.052200 STUD-BOTTOM i

659 0.009259 0.017949 LINER 661 0.009185

.0.014457 LINER 663 0.024668 10.040416 STUD-TOP 663 0.021354 0.022147 STUD-BOTTOM 664 0.006343 0.018758 LINER 667 0.022140 0.023556 STUD-TOP 667 0.021220 0.021637 STUD-BOTTOM 671 0.021021 0.021370 STUD-TOP 671 0.023272 0.030175 STUD-BOTTOM Allowable Strains

.105 (in/in) - Membrane

.l!.1 (in/in) - Membrane + Bending l

,.-y---,

.