IR 05000456/1987003

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Safety Insp Rept 50-456/87-03 on 870105-23.No Violations or Deviations Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Action on Previous Insp Findings,Preoperational Test Procedure Verification & Preoperational Test Result Verification
ML20210S653
Person / Time
Site: Braidwood Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 02/06/1987
From: Azab B, Dupont S, Wright G
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
To:
Shared Package
ML20210S617 List:
References
50-456-87-03, 50-456-87-3, NUDOCS 8702170671
Download: ML20210S653 (15)


Text

_ - - -

_ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

_ _ _ _ _. __.

.

.

t

!

L

.

.

U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

REGION III

Report No. 50-456/87003(DRS)

_

Docket No. 50-456 License No. NPF-59 Licensee:

Commonwealth Edison Company Post Office Box 767 Chicago, IL 60690 Facility Name:

Braidwood Station, Units 1 and 2 (

laspection At:

Braidwood Site, Braidwood, Illinois

[

fm pection Conducted:

January 5-23, 1987 S. G.h'<

~ ' ~

^ /6 /if7

[

Insped e s:

DuPont JL Date <

/

-

N [0[

B. Az Date Approved By:

rsht / hief 8[0[f7 Test Programs Section Date-Inspection Summary Inspection on January 5-23, 1987 (Report No.-50-456/87003(DRS))

test procedure verification, previous inspection findings, preoperationalpreoperational test r Areas Inspected:

Action on

.preoperational-rest result evaluation.

Results No violations or deviations were identified.

<

G

.

G

-

.

_. __

_

_

.

G,

',

'

.

~

,

,

~ DETAILS.

1.

Persons-Contacted

  • M. J. Wallace, Project Manager
  • G. Fitzpatrick, Station Manager
  • M.E..Lohmann,ProjectStartupSuperintendent
  • W..E. Hahls, Project Construction Superintendent
  • C. W. Schroeder, Services Superintendent'
  • L. Davis, Assistant Superintendent
  • P. Barnes, Regulatory Assurance Supervisor
  • S. Stapp,, Quality Assurance
  • T. J. Lewis, Startup Staff
  • C. Bedford,in,gulatory' Assurance Re
  • T.- W.-Simpk Regulatory Assurance
  • M. Takaki, Regulatory Assurance

2.

' Action on' Previous Inspection Findings (Closed) Open Item (456/86060-02(DRS)):

The recorded test data for preoperational test VP-ll, " Containment Ventilation," did not include the correction factor for densities to the test values.

During the review for acceptance of the preoperational test data, the Project Engineering Department (PED) accepted the test results based upon their calculations-which included the density' corrections but did not document the-calculations in the PED review letter.

Subsequently, PED provided these calculations for review by the NRC. -The PED calcuir 'ons included a

corrected value based upon the design corrected de.d cies (0.075 lbm/ft )

which is extrapolated to the accident density (0.189'lbm/ft3).

PED also concluded that-the ventilation flow' rates will meet the accident requirements. The inspector reviewed the PED calculations and found them

. acceptable. The inspector also verified that the calculations, including F

the density corrections and their bases were included in the completed i

preoperational test result package. The inspector has no further concerns.

preoperational test C5-10, " Containment Spray,y that the method used b (Closed) Open Item (456/86052-03(DRS)): Verif

!-

to demonstrate that the

,

l containment spray nozzles are not obstructed agrees with Table 14.2-18 of l-the FSAR.

The licensee submitted a revision to Table 14.2-18 to Mr. H. R. Denton, Director, Office of Nuclear Regulatory Regulation (NRR)

E

.

on 0ctober 30, 1986. The inspector reviewed the revision tc the FSAR and found that the test method used by preoperational test CS-10 is in L

agreement with the revision.

NRR has also reviewed-the revision and o

i.

concluded that the next amendment to the FSAR (Amendment 48) will include this revision.

The inspector has no further concerns.

"

-(Closed) Open Item (456/86052-02(DRS)):

Acceptance Criteria 4.2 of

-

l preoperational test AP-16, " Bus Loading and Independency," requires the

bus to be loaded to greater than or equal to 30% of the startup load; however, the recorded test' data appeared not to meet this criteria.

l.

..

.

.

Further reviews of the test data by the licensee revealed that the loading requirement of 30% was based upon a varying power factor and loads. The actual recorded value of 7.5 MW instead of 8.5 MW (expected value) was due to an actual power factor of 1.0.

The prescribed test value of 8.5 MW was based-upon a power factor of 0.9.

The licensee re-evaluated the data and concluded that the prescribed value of 8.5 MW was not correct at a power factor of 1.0 and that 7.5 MW was equal to 30% of the startup load. The inspector reviewed these evaluations and found them to be adequate. No further actions by the licensee is required.

(Closed) Open Item (456/86052-04(DRS)): Verify that the results of preoperational test EF-11 "ECCS Full Flow," derronstrated that the Core Spray Pump "1B" was not degraded due to a different Total Developed Head (TDH) while taking a suction from the Refueling Water Storage Tank (RWST)

instead of the containment sump. The licensee reviewed the test data and the purrp curves provided by PED and detennined that the data did not include compensation for the instrument zero drift discovered during the post-test calibration. The licensee corrected the curves to include the instrument zero drift and concluded that the pump was not degraded. The inspector reviewed the corrected curves and agrees that the pump was not degraded. This item is considered to be closed.

(Closed) Open Item (456/86052-05(DRS)): Licensee to complete actions required by Construction Work Request (CWR) NR-10-09. The CWR was initiated to resolve a preoperational test deficiency (NR-10-175)

where the Upper and Lower Deviation channels could not be tested during preoperational test BWPT-NR-10 " Neutron Monitoring - Excores."

Westinghouse was requested, by the licensee, to provide a guideline for testing the Upper and Lower Deviation channels. The Westinghouse provided guidelines were incorporated in the station procedure BWIP 2505-001, " Calibration of Nuclear Instrumentation System Flux Deviation NSO INY-NR8050" which was perfomed on August 13, 1986. The inspector verified that BWIP 2504-001 met the objectives of section 9.20 of the preoperational test BWPT-NR-10. This item is considered to be closed.

(Closed) Open Item J456/86027-01(DRS)): The licensee should evaluate the measuring and test equipment (M&TE)_ calibration and tracking programs of the Instrument Maintenance and Electrical Maintenance Departraents to resolve differences in the program that could possibly result in the failure to trace an out of calibration instrument to the applicable preoperational test. The inspector discussed with the licensee their l

evaluation and conclusion as follows: The Electrical Maintenance Department tracks N&TE usage and calibration results on an individual bases while the Instrument Maintenance Department issues calibration results for all instrurrents at the same time.

In addition, all instruments used during preoperational testing are listed in the applicable preoperational test procedure. The licensee concluded that the method used by the Electrical Maintenance of providing individual notification of out of calibration M&TE will be used by all station departments. The inspector found this to be acceptable.

. _

- -

,_

-.

.

.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _

.

.

3.

Preoperatic_nal Test Procedures Verification The' inspector reviewed the following preoperational test procedures and verified that they were written, reviewed, and approved by the licensee in accordance with the requirements of Regulatory Guide 1.68 and the licensee's Quality Assurance Manual:

.BWPT-FH-10, Revision 1 " Fuel Handling Tools"'

-

BWPT-FH-11, Retest 65, " Fuel Handling Transfer System" BWPT-GW-10, Revision 1, " Radioactive Gas Waste" BWPT-RC-12, Revision 0, " Reactor Coolant" BWPT-VQ-10, Revision 2, " Containment Purge System" PWPT-DC-50, Revision 1, "125 V DC Distribution"

'No violations or deviations were identified.

4.

Preoperational Test Resu_lts Verification The inspectors reviewed the following preoperational test procedure and verified that the results were reviewed against approved acceptance criteria and an evaluation of the test results had been performed in accordance with Regulatory Guide 1.68 and the licensee's Startup Manual:

BWPT-FH-10, Revision 1, " Fuel Handling Tools" BWPT-FH-11, Retest 65, " Fuel Handling Transfer System" BWPT-GW-10, Revision 1, " Radioactive Gas Waste System" BWPT-IT-10, Revision 0, "RTD Cross Calibration-Safety Related" BWPT-RC-12, Revision 0, " Reactor Coolant System" BWPT-RC-12, Retest 102, " Reactor Coolant Wide Range Pressure Loops and CV Miniflow Valves" BWPT-VQ-10, Revision 2, " Containment Purge"

'BWPT-DC-50, Revision 1, "125 V DC Distribution" BWPT-RY-10, Revision 0, and Retest 79, " Pressurizer" BWPT-VA-11, Revision 2, " Containment Ventilation"-

BWPT-RY-17, Revision 1, " Pressurizer (IHF)"

BWPT-VA-10, Revision 1, and Retests 107 and 131, " Auxiliary Building Ventilation Cubicle Coolers" No violations or deviations were identified.

5.

Preoperational Test Result Evaluation The inspector reviewed the results of the following preoperational tests to verify that all test changes were identified'and approved in accordance with administrative procedures; all test deficiencies were appropriately resolved, reviewed by management and retested as required; test results were evaluated by appropriate engineering personnel and specifically compared with acceptance criteria; data was properly recorded, signed, dated, and documented; test packages were reviewed for adequacy of contents; and test results were approved by appropriate personnel:

BWPT-SI-12, Revision 0, Retest 90, " Safety Injection" BWPT-EF-12, Revision 3 " Engineer Safety Features" BWPT-AF-10, Revision 2. " Auxiliary Feedwater"

l

. -

-

-

-

-

_ _ _ -___ _ __ _ _ _ - - - _ _ _ _ _

J

..

.

+

~

Pertaining to BWPT-AF-10, three retests (R-75; R-105 and R-140) were-not available for review. This is considered to be an Open Item-(456/87003-01(DRS)) until the NRC can review the test results and ascertain that all of the BWPT-AF-10 testing requirements have been met.

6.

Open Item 0)en items are matters which have been discussed with the licensee, w1ich will be reviewed further by the inspector, and which invclves some action on the part of the NRC or licensee or both.

An Open Item disclosed during this inspection is discussed in Paragraph 5.

7.

Exit Interview The inspectors met with licensee re)resentatives (denoted under Paragraph 1) at the conclusion of tie inspection on January 23, 1987.

The inspector summarized the purpose and findings of the inspection.

The licensee acknowledged this information.

The licensee did not identify any documents / processes as proprietary.

._, _- _ - - -_,_

. _ -

.

.

... -.

. - - - -

,

_

NRC FORMh06 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION PRINCIPf.L INSPECTOR @pne gst, kst my mce erg b

'A

'"

INSPECTOR'S REPORT REVIE WER

,

Of fice of inspection and Enforcement Qg g,g IN S, E C T OR S h

a v7 YS

^ 8 EMT W MC M LICENSEE VENDOR DOCKET NO <8 d gits> OR LICENSE y,

NO (BY PRODUCTit13 cgts NO.

SEQ MO.

YR.

ga y

' ac,F 1 y ' - 'N5' a'

o roc o vet v7 o o 1

^

M - MODIFY

-

C D - DELETE

~

D R

RE PL ACE

2

15

8 E.dOD OF INVESYlGA TION > tN5PECTION INSPECTION PERFORME D By ORGANt2ATON CODE OF REGON/HQ CONDUCT-FKOM TO K,7 - REG'ONAL OFFICE STAFF OTHER

.

MO DAY VR MO DAY YR 2 - RESIDENT INSPECTOR

_REGON DIVISON BRANCH

3

/

Oli Olf BI7 olI 2l3 1517 3-"'"'

"*^NC'^"""^'S*^*

25

31

33

35 TYPF OF ACTIVITY CONDUCTED (Check one bos onY REGIONAL ACTON (CWWkmW C2 - S AF ETY 06 - MGMT. Vl97 10 - PLANT SEC.

14 - INQUIRY 1 - NRC FORM 691 03 - INCIDENT 07 - SPECIAL 11 - INVENT.VER, 15 - tNVESTIGATION 2 - REGONAL OFFICE LETTER 04 - ENFORCEMENT 06 - VENDOR 12 - SHIPMENT / EXPORT 06 - MGMT. AUDIT 09 - MAT ACCT.

13 - lMPOR T

37 38 sN5FEC1 SON eNvE5IlGAf SON FINOtNGb TOTAL NUMBER ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE REPORT CONT AIN 2.790 LETTER OR REPORT TRANSMITT AL DATE

"

OF VOLATONS AND HELD INFORMAW A

C D

DEviAYONS NRC FORM 691 REPORT SENT OR REG TO H'1 FOR v.

1 - CLEAR f

LETTER ISSUED ACTON

2 - VIOLATION Af8 C

D A

C D

MO DAY YR.

MO.

DAY YR.

3 - DEVI ATON A

B C

D 4 - VIOLAYlON & DEVIATON QQ l

1 - VES 1 - YES l

l l

l l

l

,

,

,

,

4041

43

49

. $5 MODULE INFORM ATrON MODUt F INFORVAYtGN MODULE REQ FOLLOWUP g[g MODULE REO FOLLOWUP MODULE N !MBER 6NSP 6 g"9 a g"9 l

MODULE NUMBER INSP i

55 5 Eg 5 *2 s8

'

'

r i

s !5 si s i l f@s$s

?@$-a! sis

!ss i s !5 si s

  1. 5 8=

<-

5:

5 g-3-

g-g

>

g-

-

.

=

a a

-

.

.

.

si s s ii si s

i s !5 si s ; 8 e

c E a!a54 r82 ra I

su

?

r a5r r82

I

> 5 E3 c ?

I s5

a I a5

e u E

DlD Obif C-liil Q V 70l3 d d Di ill

[f r d

, liil M 7 p l3,st:4l

^

^

i i

S i i i

I i it t

I i l l 1 1 l

I i l

f f i f f

I l l I l l l

I l Ii,1 liil o

=

e i

, i i

1 t

,,

,

c4M f glo e i li,i Ii,I 4 y p la, ul 4 Y 7pi m,il oloa

,y e

,

^

-

i I i i l

l 1 1 l 1 l I

i i liil li,l

!__a i i i i

c i i i i i

1 I I t t

t t

l t

t t

i i t liiI a o1 4 7p lri wi oil a ipp t

liil #

f '7017 9i !

Goil

^

^

i i i

i liil i i i i i Iiil a

a i i t i i

I i t i

!

1 I t i i f I

l 1 1 1 I I l

l I l

t I l t

f I lOgll D io it i,

7g c hipd

^

l I l l l I

'

l 1 i S

k l

1 i f I I

l 1 l l l

l l

l l l

l l I 1 I

i i i l l

l t

i 1 O CIRCLE SEQUENCE IF l

l

'

g vtOL ATION OR DEVtATION i g l l i [ l [

l l

[ j l l l l [

!l2 3l 4 l5 t l2 3l4 l5

12

15

18

20

26 to

13 t$

18

20

26

-

...

.7.__...

... _ _ _ _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

,

gemC Fonas M A DOcaEt NO (8 detsiOR L:CENTE F.EPOR T MODULE NUMBEa

,

<ym NO. CY PRODUCTH13 0tts)

NO SEO l l l l l l i Mcos3s INSPECT!R'S REPORT

"on T Y # 2 "

,,5),o

^

l suPL.

(Continuation)

e Office of Inspection and Enforcement c

eo-

,

,

,

,

,

,

,c D

2.'

n a

vsoLArnoN oR DEvtAicN sEnter up to 2400 characters W esch stem. H the test enceeds thes number. M wil be necessary so paraphrase LMut hnen fo S0 charactern eech3 9.

2.

4.

s.

.

1.

e

to.

ti.

1

i

15

!

I to 17.

j l

is i.

I

j

23

a n

.

2a

_

so

32

34 n

.

37 h

sa

3,

" ' "***'

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

  • ^

aercar uoouta=uwsea 5,'

oocactuoisa.ionter.nse gocaus No <av prooucims a.a,

,o

,,,

,,,,,,

INSPECTIR'S CEPORT A

vero. s.ve -1.

sne e,o-OR DEvaATow RELATED (Continuation)

a

,l,

,

,

,

,

,c Office of Inspection and Enforcement c

l

-

.o D

r n

-

vetAron on ouvnArnon sEnter up to 2400 cherectors for each trem. H me test onceetts thus number, it wut be necessary 00 paraphrase. UmstItnes to 50 characters each.)

2.

3.

4.

s.

s.

7.

9.

s 10.

11.

.

13 14.

1s.

16.

is 19.

21

23

a 2s

28

ao

22

34 ss

'*

,-

3P h

.

ss

  • *o a e r-s e '

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

.

RE NR y MODME NW8ER

~90RC fores 15 A DOCKET NO (8 dget JOR LCENSE 8J NO (1Y PRODUCTH13 digets)

NO SEO l l l l l

>JE ve"oe^v'mtv ggg-a INSPECT!R'S REPORT na Arm RELATED

(Continuation)

,

3

.

,

.

o ic Office of Inspection and Enforcement

_

e o __-

c

,

2'

25 vCLATCH OR DEvtATCN Enter up m 2400 characters for each item. It the test onceeds this numDer, it e*IIbe necessary to paraphrase. Lomet Nnes to 50 characters each.)

1.

2.

3.

4.

6 7.

S

10.

11.

13.

15

-

17

19.

20.

22

24 M

l l

l

I

30

I

34 l

36

~

f 0'

4WO ely.ggi U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION


...

-

-

- - - -.

wooutt moonwatch

,

woouit ihsoew,aich Og wooutt ato rottowur "',{

esooutt ssuweta nse.

j M

encouts esuwet2 assP.

woovtt at2 Fottowur

!!!!! !E gg I-

!g!!i!!!

I I

I 1i il i

g! il ! ! ! i na il v i lia!I fl;e 1 11 ll ll ! al tia:I ris c r ia e

=

s,

=

.

,

.

.

.

.

.

a r ia 9 d 7P i l 7 sol 3 h d IiiI i i i i i liiI

  • T '/

'

003 e i

f e

1 1 iliil liil

'

-

i i i i i

i,

i,

iliil i i i i i liil

-

c c

i, ii iliil li,1 o

o i i

, i i

,,

,,

. se v nizlvioirl wo lsu ul liiI Iiil

^

a oiel ii

.

,

i i i i i i

iliil ii I

'

-

i i

,,

i

,,

,,

li.I liil c

c i,

i i i

i,

i i i

I,,I 1.

I o

,,

,,

i i i

,,

,

'l 4 sid ?pi l riolsio izi I,iI IiiI

)

l oen

,,

a a

.

. i i

i i i i i

liil i i i i i liil

a i i

. i i

I,il ii I

c c

, i i,

i i,

,,

,

Iiil 1,il o

i i i i i

,,

,,

,

liil iliil lii1 e i i

i i i i i liil

^

-

.

i i

i i i i liil liil

-

-

i i i i i

,,

,,

,

liil liii c

c i i i i i

i i i,

i lg l

NN'tNNYo[vfation g

i g g i

_

g ll l l D

o i

l l il23la l5 to u

is

is is in

21

'l 2e il2 3l 4 ja

- 10 u

is -- is is -

te is ti ti

- 26 MooutiiNFomvatCN woout, sNFompatoN woouts ato pottowur

" ',c wooutt huw.ta nsP.

Og 9 wooutt mEo Fottowup

"(Cf wooutt huweta msP.

e-ry 6g

illa

mE_
:

e-s s,

-

.

_

_

_

ffig!

n:gi

_1

E_

v.

i i.

,. s

e

.

.

.

-

,

.

= g:

a=

.

=

=

= a:

.

-

,o en e =

c

>

_

i:

o

3 -,K s :> :s>=<

st E

E g :

sa s ;

r5st_E sa:

s

>

s

.

t y

ea s e rsar

[8 s

.8:

f 3 u a r s

-

a a

au a a s

.

.

5-m E a u *

E

-

3 u a z s

e 5-m_E o

,

s ll l

g s

g l lg l

g g g g

lg g l

.

g g

g g g g g g g

liil i i.I

-

-

i i i i

.

i i

,,

,

liil i i i i i liil c

c i i i i i

liil i i i i i l. i i l o

o i,

,,

i cliil liil l,il liil

^

^

.

i

.

,

i i i i i i

i i i,

i liil l,il

-

. i

..

i

,,

,,

i liil liil c

c i i i i i

i,

i i i

I,,1 l,,1 o

o

,,

,,

i

.

,,

,,

,

iliiI

~

liil liiI liil

^

^

a i

i i

,,

i e

i i

i i i i i

Iiil i i i i i liil

i i

, i i

Ii,I Iiil c

c i i i,

i i i

,,

,

liil liil o

i i

, i i

,,

, i i

-

i iliil liil liil i i i i i liil

e i i

i i i,

i I,il i,

i,

i liil a

-

, i m

,

liiI

_

i i i i i liil c

c i i

, i i

  • =msT&'ateN I,il

,,

,,

i I,iI o

o

,,

,,

,

ilnl. is'

l 2.,u n is 4.

i...

.o r,

f a.,l2 3l a i s.

4,.

. u

,3 -

is

,..x...

is

,i

,, -

2.

,

-

.c c.

..,... ;,.,.,,, s

-

.._. ',. ~ [

' h..b

.h, *) h. : [

' -('

,

. :.<

__y

___.;;.y '_ ' 3 3,

-

.

..

--

_.

-

'

'

D 051*3 SALP FUNCTIONAL AREA A55E55ENT AND PRELIMINARY INSPECTOR EVALUATION FORN

'

Factitty:

M,beo) d Inspection Report No.: 1C7o03

-

l FUNCTIONAL AREA 5 i / 1 I I II I III I IV V i Dev UnitlRatinel l PLANT DPERATION5 l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l

1 I

I I

I I

I l

l RADIDLOGICAL CONTRDL5 l

l l

l l

l l-l l

l

<

l

1 I

I I

I I

I I

l 01

,l MAINTENANCE l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l Pl l

l l

1 I

I I

I I

I l El

l 5URVEILLANCE l

l l

l l

l l

l-l l

Rl l

l

1 I

I I

l l

l l Al l FIRE PROTECTION l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l Tl l

1 l

l l

l

1

l Il

l EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l 01 l

l I

I I

I I

I I

I I N1 l 5ECURITY l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l 5l l

l l

l I

I I

l i

I l

l l OUTAGES l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l

1 I

I I

I I

I I

l l QUALITY PROGRAMS & ADMIN.

l l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l CONTROLS AFFECTING QUALITY I

I l

l l

l l

l l

l l LICENSING ACTIVITIES l

l l

l l

l l

Rwepsen:%d 2d Ewsulhlt t/ l A ll

l l

l I

I I

I I

I l TRAINING & QUALIFICATION

l p ll E lI l

l l

l l

l l

'

.

l EFFECTIVENESS I

l l

l l

I I

l 50lL5 AND FOUNDATIONS l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l l

!

l l

1 I

I I

I I

I l

Cl

)ll CONTAINMENT, SAFETY-RELATED l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l 01 STRUCTURES & MAJOR STEEL SUPPORT 51

I l

l l

l l

l l

Nl l PIPING SYSTEMS & SUPPORTS l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l 5l l

1 I

I I

I I

I I

l Tl l 5AFETY-RELATED COMPONENTS l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l RI

-

l MECHANICAL I

l l

l l

l l

l l

l Ul l AUXILIARY SYSTEMS l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l Cl l

l

l l

1 I

I I

l Tl l ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT AND CABLES l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l Il I

i i

I I

i I

i i

I l

0l l INSTRUMENTATION l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l Nl l

l

1 I

I I

I I

I l

l CFunctional areas for Construction and Operations CRITERIA FOR DETERMINING CATEGORY RATING 1.

Management Involvement in Assuring Quality.

2.

Approach to Resolution of Technical Issues from a Safety Standpoint.

3.

Responsiveness to NRC Initiatives.

'4.

Enforcement Nistory.

5.

Operational and Construction Events.

6.

Staffing (including management).

RATING KEY: (For Categories 2 - Declining and 3, provide narrative basis for conclusion)

Category 1 Category 2 - Declining Category 2 Category 3 Inspector (s) concerns adequately addressed or

  1. l-l Inspection Evaluation Form being processed.

LeadInspect[or15dd, f/s-d7 lL N/[7

_

section Chief

/(Signatur() (Date)~

(51gnatufe)

(Dat4) /

.--

.. L ---.

anarch 3. less

.-_-

. _

_ _ _ _

_ - - _ - _ - -. -. - - _. _

. - -

.

-

-

.

_

A T'E A C K I N C SYSTEN TYPE RECION

-

-

NEW ENTRY INPUT CODE

-

NDOIFY

PERSON WHO FOLLOWUP AE0'S A

-

STAWS IDENTIFIED ITEM DUE DATE DEVIATIONS D

,,,,,

ITEM NO.

TYPE

.

t 50.55(E)

E DKT YYXXX XX X

, () u u

l o p p

F CODE

_

eg g

,

i

S $

p L_ p 5 7 o_5

eMTYMMDD IAL I

-

-

ORDERS TO LICENSEE K

[

/

l

-

-

LER LICENSE DSG. f LER L

'

g LER LER REPORT LER CONFIRMATORY ACTION LTR. N ll ll l

l OPEN ITEM

,

EVENT DATE REPORT DATE TYPE REVISION I

i!

lI

]

V' i

'^RT 2 P

SIGNIFICANT SAFETY FIND. S

$1 Y ri 7. I' I'

MYYMMDD eIt'8 CIASEQUT UNRESOLVED ITEM U

RESPONSE REPORT NO.

WITNDRAWN W

NDDULE NO.

W E DATE PERSON ASSIGNED VIOLATION - SEV. LEVEL 1. 2 rl l

l l

f* V CU t > M

}

4. 5 P a w

D j g w

gy.g QTTMMDD

'fg y

!'"I I'

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

-

II I I

II I

Ill I

III Ill

-

INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSPECTOR

$3:

&

lilli llIL 11 l

&

,

\\

%

%

i

-

I I

__

INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSFECTOR

,5-gjg

l

IIII lli

%

l

-

-

..

I INTERIM REPORT NO.

IpsygCTOR 5-6/gg d

I Illli

I]

A

%

,_

_

l

<

-

!1*/o

mrocsanJTu aav. 4/85

-

_ _

.

.

..

A TRACKINC SYSTEM TYPE RECION

-

-

I INPUT CODE

)

M00lPY PERSON WO FOLLOWUP AE0's A

~

IDENTIFIED ITEM DUE DATE STA_TUS DEVIATIONS D

ITEM NO.

TYPE

.

'h l o p gsA 50.55(E)

E CODE

{}

_

,.

10 CFR 20 F

3K1 YYXXX XX X

,b 2M

  1. r AnacATION c

g

  • / E 6/ F 6 [02 '7 c_/

'kT Y M M p a IAL, I

-

-

ORDEas 10 LICENSEE K

[

/

-

-

LER LICENSE DSG. #

LER L

g LER LER REPORT LER CONFIENATORY ACTION LTE.

N.

II l

!!

}

OPEN ITEN O

EVENT DATE REPORT DATE TYPE REVISION

$mlYYMMDD

]

]

Vs4 PART 21 P

l l

SIGNIFICANT SAFETY FIND. S

$Y Y a y, L I, b

,N CLOSEOUT UNRESOLVED ITEM U

REPORT NO.

WITNDRAW N

m I2 No.

DU E

PERSON ASSIGNED VIOLATION - SEV. LEVEL 1. 2c I

c rk, el I I

II II L' 4 N

"

c o 1 4. E y,9 3p 7

-

m

.

41Y=ana k

ra Y'"8

! '-

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

.

!! I l l l l l l l

II I

!

I

Ill l l 11111 -

INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSPECTOR I$3 I

r*

I II 11111 11 l

.

w w.

&

i I

-

g l

__

l

-

INTERIN REPORT NO.

INSP3Cr0R i 5-gjg

I 111111111

,

%

I

-

- - -

-.

y INTERIM REPORT NO.

INgygCTOR 04/gg d

111 11111111 O

k

%.

,

,

e

-

\\**/a

M

P

.

.

E I 4.

m o - w a z o.. = =.J i

E

-

i gU

_

r

.e

-

_

I e

e

a N

~

-

c

_-

p

_

a g

~

-

-

-

_

g

{

-

-

_,

_

-

-

-

-

gQ

.

_

_

,

R

-

-

-

_

_

3.

".

-

-

_

I

  • !

R l=g

. _

_.

"'~

-

5

-

-

-

E n

_

g s "$e! s.si.gg m]

-

-

-

-

B

E

~

~

H

-

.

-

me

i

..

.

.

.-J n

,

-

-

_

_

s w

.,

,

. _

,

--

-

_

lII it

-

.

MS

%

-

.

-

-

gg

_

=

a

,--

,

_

__

',

M o

-

Z E g

E

.

e

-,

g

-

-

i.

g u

=

e

-

1 3

'g

,

I.

E

.

_

_

-

ll s

'

=

g

-

l 8.

"

=

g" s g t a,

-

,. y>

-

-

5

-

.

-

u

,

u

.

_

11J G

s n

g

=

-

_

m

-

g

_

-

u

_

_

U

<

_

-

_

-

_-

-

e

O:5

__

_

-

_

"g g __

_

'

-

_

_

_

--

-

--

5

=

e

-

m$w

$2*

'0 o

.

S

-

e g

g4

o

'

e sn =

  • E.a.

_

~

-

c 21.E

-

=

22 A

.

w-a

_-

k l5 H.$ _- "

w

-

-

E A

MQ wp

'8

-

-

-

d=

=g.

a C

xLo g

g,. gg

,,

g

-

i

.

-

_

_

.

j a

g B,5_, n x

-

-

,

-

-

-

i i

m

-

- -

,

>

M N

W

-

w A

=

g e

-

_

ing

-

x 1

.

a

-

-

,. _

,

> 4 1$

-

a

-

m

-

-

a l

5

-

-

m

g

-

N N ss

-

-

E W

_

,

l l I

b a J=

>

w

,

-

b g*A d

$

%

a 2

=_ a e

f f

e r

,

gg*

g 3 f.

W I

A

--.C...<

. _. _ -.,

..

.

_._____

_

lA T'E A C K I N C-SYSTEM TYPE RECION

j

-

-

W ENTRY INPUT CODE

)

MODIFY

PERSON WHO FOLLOWUP AE0'S A

~

IDENTIFIED ITEM DUE DATE STAYS DEVIATIONS D

-

ITEM NO.

TYPE

50.H(E)

E f-l p

CODE M 9 3 r

u CFR 20 DET YYXXX XX X

.g g

i g 8kTYNMDD IAL I

i V C C_/ 5 4 0 V I o 7

~

~

ORDERS TO LICENSEE K

o s-f. / p (, o 5

o t/

-

-

LER LICENSE DSG. 4 LER L

g LER LER REPORT LER CONFIRMATORT ACTION LTR. N l!

!!!

l OPEN ITEM

EVENT DATE REPORT DATE TYPE REVISION

'

'44

RT 21 P

liIIII

]

i]

SIGNIFICANT SAFETY FIND. S

$1 Y a s. E' Ii MY~Y M M D D b

M CIASEOUT UNRESOLVED ITEM U

i

,

REPORT NO.

WITMDRAMM W

1000LE NO.

Du DATE PERSON ASSIGNED VIOLATION - SEV. LEVEL 1. 2 I

II t%

?

4, r v v c o

o s t f l

n e > m r

.

$TTMMDD M66 M

q r / y 7 0 0 3

'"I

-

BRIEF DESCRIPTION lIIIIIII I

III I

I II1111111I1-INTERIM REPORT NO.

I,3,,c, l 9,,

r*

11111 IIII I

,Il

!

u w

w.

.

--

.

INTERIM REMRT NO.

INSFECTOR s.gjg

l ll111111 Il I

!

-

%.

-,

INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSPECTOR U-6/gg d

Illl 11111111 Il N

%

v T

-

-camssmrm-

--

Mo 0/85

A T'R A C K I N C SYSTEM TYPE RECION

-

-

INPUT CODE

,

\\' NODIFY PERSON WHO FOLLOWUP AE0'S A

-

IDENTIFIED ITEM DUE DATE M A_TUS DEVIATIONS

'D

ITEN NO.

TYPE

.

l gd 50.55(E)

E CODE D gn

o c

F

_

DKT YYXXX XX X

,

eg g

'/ s-LI 2r & OAo o

D

'MY T M N D D IAL I

-

-

[

/

ORDERS TO LICENSEE K

-

-

LER LICENSE DSG. #

LER L

, y, l

LER LER REPORT LER CONFIEMATORY ACTION LTR. M

!!

!

!

!

OPEN ITEM

,

l EVENT DATE REPORT DATE TYPE REVISION

,

/glY'Y M M D D

]

'/sq PART 21 P

'

lllll SIGNIFICANT SAFETY FIND. S 7g T T m p, It I, s#4'8 CLOSEOUT UNRESOLVED ITEM U

REPORT NO.

WIm W

1000LE NO.

DATE PERSON ASSIGNED VIOLATION - SEV. LEVEL 1, 2. >

I I

t d6 -l H II

!l (* =vre* > o

=

M 4. 5 l o

j yo s w

$TYMMDD t/teh M

!' * l f

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

-

11 1

III I

I Illi 1111 l l-F/3 INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSPECTOR

.

id I

I I

111I1 11

&

Shc

-

that.

l<

_

'

I l

! -4/g

INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSFECTOR

!

ll II Illi l

-

%

l

-.

04f INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSPECTOR d

Ill Ill IIll Il y

'*/.s

'

!

!; '

-

.j'-0/g

-

ppp;3gggi) gy:

Rev. 4/85

.

.

A TRACKING SYSTEM TYPE RECION

-

-

E M EI INPUT CODE

]

MODIFY

PERSON WHO POLLOWUP AgG 3 A

-

IDENTIFIED ITEM DUE DATE STAYS DEVIATIONS D

g.

TYPE

.

d

$

50.55 W E

f-l l

g F

CODE C

o e

u 3KT YYXXX XX X

sj g

,

9 r 6_/ y 7 po

o _1 -l0 agry3ygD IAL I

-

[

/

l -l ORDERS TO LICENSER K

-

LER LICENSE DSC. #

LER L

y, LER LER REPORT LER CONFIRMATORY ACTION LTR. N I

II

_I OPEN ITEM

EVENT DATE REPORT DATE TYPE REVISION hlY Y M M D D ]

]

'/a4 PART 21 P

lllll SIGNIFICANT SAFETY FIND. S

$ 7Y N h Il-p

' _1.,

-

-

.

b eM CIASEOUT UNRESOLVED ITEM U

I'

REPORT NO.

WIM N

mu MO.

DU DATE PERSON ASSIGNED VIOLATION - SEV. LEVEL 1. 2a d

pl Ill i

4. c w qu o

i 4 m

-

w raann h,

u y

!' * t

-

BRIEF DESCRIPTION e

s t s

IcI7 r

,

e i ols-l Imlal Ial tivlol.1 1 I l -

elv Isiwle TI-4 r

-

< o r

ali r,

r o lyI.1-1,Itisl I+1s.

t c <

s

INTERIM REPORT NO.

INSPECTOR

$3

.

ra y-Ill IlllllL il w

w.

-

l

-

l INTERIM REP 6RT NO.

INSFSCTOR

~

s. gf,,

I 111111

'

_

w.

_

_

t

'-

,

,

INTERIM RAPORT NO.

INSPECTOR 04/cg

lll 111 11ll Il N

%

r

.

l

_

b.-*/a

-

-

-

-.

.

h 0/GL