ML20023D032
| ML20023D032 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | LaSalle, 05000000 |
| Issue date: | 07/26/1982 |
| From: | GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20023A480 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-82-366 PR-820726, NUDOCS 8305190093 | |
| Download: ML20023D032 (2) | |
Text
[. .. . s n. .. >
1.
n.
uuW1
~
F ,,
-S. -
- .Ar Accotmiab.11Mo,rs .m,youject g yt i
h 3stitute for.PA..s$tudies . ..
I!881 Que .% rats N W. -
l W.i hmgt n. Ilii .5 or,n l Tel. 3m C f3a m.e . .
g s '. - .i . ' .y i
- l .- Q ., FOR-1N:32.1tATF. Re:*.*MSEs
.Tilly 26, 1992'.
. g y a,n , g.NE".9 Cn m itrJ:CP AY:
~ -
.3 f oer- evta: 1,t:T!*.y._TO "cirrt.cre ,.
4 3901 gw sgge,e, g, w, 7 .. LA,hitit etAtC/P tt.1.s g r,;Atu: *
?P'"
D. C. f > . 2 f-, ? ,
(202) '23el-9.W2 * ' -
A .' *.* *yan.s..t "g g
- *
,*...M ~db e. Wa shin
-.. y f.;.c ..?.5 s%on, .}3 .-.'
. . .*,N-t i.< ey .g %
Q,,b * . . > - . .
NUbt. EAR M.bt3.AMRT n r--sc WE/FDestn eu se g gggIn gy;c. gor,mseyem. .d.,3. >; 4 a
n ggiuda *~. .o., . . .
'h W,. V sh .
r,e . ; m;,. . d. .ehW,,L r.
- g. . . . . .
% .q
,e:d;
. ' ' ' in as letter del ivered tudny' tn Nuclearit ir ejul.atory - -
Commir.niont(NRC) 'Chal'rE.an; .
..-.s. ..> m as.k. s s ..
.Q - fasnzJn J. Palia Jiao, the r.overnment, Mcuunt.4Llity: v.Project (r;AP) ot }the*Insatitu+.y for . .. . . .n s -
us ^ lulley . studies catter! f or er .Invimtigat:f orr or NPC 3tegion III 's (RIII) .'c.s
- e. ,,.y.,railure:tzied.iorst
. . - . . , . 2 -rn m> 4t y; p- ,', , in qnad f aith to evideer.c or cc1minal This-it ic;iittlu:s
. and a Quality .Assuranee.jQA) . . .. e., . ;
.,** breakdwis. at tho !#alio asuvica r tow.;r st.uiert im Id.Lille, Illinnis. : CAP ch'at9=d Wt '
"4 : .. . . Man the 7:V' totalty Lgrurad; or ressus.Jud suirerficin! ty to (nx trvidence at. thisam...' ..
% , .c e
- *
"Vj- * .R111 M:na nir.trator 'Jirwu r. cpg *1cr was t ect.uctr. ling gmi nsinn for LaSalld' ,
o w nc r ,, ' '
- sat;v,, Lime -
J ,
- :/,hp a
.., - tbaimon.colth k;dimrr en opetate the plant:t cyos@.."tero lower.". * *
.-4 'S
' . .._.. ;. w . e.
CAR I4931' Ilif t1.;t'.3r. Thorrian DeVine chdt*Jt d=-*
~
M[v *
. . /'* [ ra
, {' ...A -.
c
. , , , .4 . . . I.
14mer tMr. A yeat M19 thu NRC 'admi ttef( thsrt al*rjlurt 1'11' inved i, gator.a at]hk #;' h.,
Y. inner 'pla.nr. f ai Letti to swat the minimosiir.tarviards< of apy
- vvusteent 'myncy. 3*
- r. ,,, , . Huw iteglen TTT hair flunkte.f again. Itut this t,isee the: NFC LueArd ,thn nt.hcr e-- -
p* war et the critical voNnt . - j ua.t_ 4t: n 7 1an t- i s cbont ' to open'. . *1 hic canc . .'
- . involvru delli:craec, ret wLettart refiumi . tti Icmic .at the evidsnee whilifthe'.* < '
[',** . j ' .ht:C v4.s suyhi erj the p hr.'. in' e opet.atdei.*. g h.* the puhtic,h S'"'
"in rmar:1cet prer when the 'HFC's.ptiotith-n.puh public safety to the I acP'[elbw[can *'
. , scat, behi::J utility tirwtablem? . . - Q. , ., , ph.,' , ,
a.L .u CMt ,c1ridai ed th.it ItIT T i nvcitica tn c s- haw. ..ibern "sj ttis.9" for P,months r . : ~o.e n
. . . 4aw ', .
rs.{ .neriuus e.videnco of widoscale falsificatiem c f QA,yecnrds at the :ancle cut p4n.y,'a' ,
o
- g, theating.. v. ntit tat.lon and air enndi ' .
tinnt eg. tontiacs.or fur the 1.asalle , Mirf a6*nd and S
- *. , < , g, . . .
,-
- Clinton rewlear rowr r xtatioits. (.5n itiy- 3,19W. whis t leblowet s f roc. r4ck prenened n
')-inda thick r:ru.h or riocUnents tu It1II:officistis..' 'The ducus ents
. . . ,;n . g.y . .
- a providn3 'cvidenc9 A .*.* 1 ' .
- J } Q.. i}** ::L-that rd$uede n;beses.4 -- p/cylW* ' ',* :=' W ::
'i'f.6{'
.. a +3
.t. W W..d;.J Q.'.,.
9 6 *
. ',.;4',g*g.
- f. Klf' -
Cicrical . Fasetes - 1,dd uf reference. tn "AST:t" revision yeat , ,ur, corp 3ritnl ,. , .
J a cJe . o( .starwar.1 desirin.ition,. ...s y*
~. tQ-* ' ,
E~% , .
g.. .
W gM* ' . ~
~
Si.nt.atur e Mi: ninci -. lack of # wr itt est $1wnat.ure ' *,; 7; w M., h? GM fr .
n* t, - - ginnature t rs: r . Type slynature on.k hors.1 written r.ignattaro.or ini tials'"ij ,
.f ,q ,; ares no t niunt.ical,. , ,' ,, ., ,- . - W-2 ... 3.J. fr *
{<
.T.+..., Oa.wn/!i .rch Tout- fu..t".i. - Chemica i anaty .1 e asy.1A.ir mrchanical ' tcst 'daLa MOZ .
- . ;, y .. alunityp ~
raerl/e.r- r> > t E.
p - 6 --Wibedr f .i. .C.ertifi c.9.f ons Certain - yet t. ext.lanat packagr$i. sty. lackL*'2 %g, hm- Pin accordase;e with. As
',./. -A e -. or ' f o r crity .ca.rtaies.t i tensi I'.%' . :.
" la 4f' .W/ ' certtifica tion f or a t I,Yliec.dlors' of de!rt-1fi'c h tl'or b ~ *
- f.
A N.Al'teratien's1 wrs.Ltr S a.hilth e.A M rent"
- i 7# 72. i'~M*% 'f['ty$59?8W1.
-~"* ' ' hedM$tNFN
.$. .Y,.m t :: - st i;kes u - r;w-c. cst 1.it.ct ::
[ s
% . L *,^i *. 5.*nn h*us: n v.. & ~.**~,.
s
. atPI Q f aical < " :to 4 cet'tif @T;;&r., f dit Idn' - *t k 'ce' Q th,..atidENNIT.h-R -i f35 -M. . .. ...
.WL.. *.h%', %c .diet Nmt s i.n.t...13 Q :.'5-...s'.ri y .da.n t i.&i $t y.i. ..r - s i. ,, :1n.M.y si.:wti.su.viongi i a..u.t e ge&,W
.N:.i s.otT.
Q -.:sg Q Q't.yi-y s tie M&yhi7 -
~
' N,. *; te twt to the r epr.it.~i , .. . . cas :.s. . sh.a. ,.5 os '.r . wiijst .,. tehleculM ..; 9~'- .91mc5mC-i*r-w tr.l . RTTT (s ye'a t,4 i. t!st gi.,r.; . .2 . . w:...,..A.'!9stt (Terry) . . .a. .. . . ,,'.9.g.gd.st N
u .,- 3. .. 3.q e.ir
-- dida tatat*M.,.'t;n i .-m ,.. f.,u . .,.. b ,,p.cagy . . . tuy<M [Mtict.t c[ j -
Ar
.a .,,m., ,. -
% ~i*. .;,v.g.qf,.,..* ..to.r.APj i.i.4 C. q'g, h.3,.gy,,Myyf.?;.,. .,,..
u,,. . ;.
L ,,tuok their evaduno ti.e.tInuprcettigert 4 *,p e -- -. M, - - . .
., e . . . .
CAlt f:f r.i .r.n.t Ct8t.it, fil rec tor it
- t t.- *
. ,s r n . .;.o r M e ', "A s .. .. .'.tWs Se g ,crt t.% .
3 4 .
tr'idere sc. v.a.id Lv nn .i IV umgonc,, .it dni.;rd .lo um ft .tra inve:st[q[ tion. ant nnt tartt.il thv e. ,
, . , , . . . . . . .. 4%s s. i y 6 5 m+ ..
l 8305190093 830311 4_. .- . . _ _ .
T Wr S.M.N
. v-1 v. ,w -~.- -- :
J '"
~
m i PRENDER82-366 PDR - - -" ~ ~ ~ ' ' - - ~ ~ " " ^ ^ '
." ="3.'. _ . i.: a3 m. ~>
gp)
- u. a ..
- 6 s
- - * " - * * " *
- e -e. gg g ,
. . . s
<- 2 W.a t is toi l .i t a' . Hegian ill has l a sudy ti[Ted i ts h.,rvl. We pisoded with then esn sucievous occasinrm in i m"- t ig a t e t h.; Zach ev id enc e. . .
They weren't in t et est est . Why .he.u t et we trust them sw ? . Tim whole goint of .iny R11I investigation anw will be to justify HI!!'s failure to ac t wh<.n it shruld have.
CAP also ch.irged that a recently-coms.leter1 RIII probe into alleged concrete voids; hoics core-dritted in tra the reactor pedest.als cheating on thle masonry by diluting n>rtar or even not using mortar for somo,concrcte blocks, .
among other issucs; may have been sorse than no investigation at all. fast f all NRC Executive Director William Dircks 6.trii,tted that prcvious NPC probes relied t.oo much on the utility's paperwork, while fotogol'ng witness interviews and indeperu. lent hardware tests. Dircks pledged ttut the .
s NRCWuld not m.ske the same mistake again, a commitment rcaf firmed by Mr. Iteppler in
- u. ., . , . . , a . .s .. .
June 10 congression~al test.imo,ny. *unfortunately,' the diff erences li. w.otween 'old' and 'new' tr s .
. =* l NRC %:
investigations are cosmetic at best,". observed Devine. "Whenever
. . . . , . . .. there was a conflict Q,.5 - botw'cen eyewitnesses and utility p3perwark, the papemork won.",* r . ,s , ,
.- '
- s t; :. :n . ,
- i.- ~, ,
'y Specifically, CAP charged that RIII-- 1. r . % 3.,.; . .y 7 .
-: ..'
- C. ** failed to take sworn statements f rom witnesses who had not 'aiready '
.0- '.@-eE J ' . provided affidavit s to CAP 3
^
<< 7
- W%, *1 e 7
- z: .
m . . . . .-
- ~.
".+ ** totally ignored issu.es that dealt with the causes of QA deficiencies
. 7.= at !.as.sile, such as retaliation; and manipulation of the QA program ' '
'
- T' through r.Inrt-staf fing, conflicts of interest, 'and advan'co warnings '
+^l . 5 .
e; -* of QA inspections:
i .
, .n . . ;g;y7.c ..yi .;..w.
,.,. r j.. .. . .
7._ ... [ ** redefined the issues it did cover by omi,tting key f acts', making _it '; . ,
e
.(>,,.".
? c
.fLg.".'bj7 ' easter to rejcct the charges M .. M. n . '.K .'.{$ . 3 f..'.e.1. ys ,,**. p.' W v. yui .. %r Q' g M,n ., . L D ,y .., '#** rejected witnesses' allegat'i.oEs, o~ri thE bEi's of su'st4ct"utilit'y J" r- *-
paper airk or " independent." tests in fact contr'o lled by the]utilitys' r[ *
? .. . . . _ . . .. .
.5 . ** manipulated the evidence by failing to include key facts in' the. ., 5
[,.,I, 'r t. -su. . r.cIo r t - such as i t s f in.d ing "t. t.u t. a pp ro'x ima 'tel.y .h_a l f. o. f.. r. e in..fo. r.'ce#.
k W c .
p... Q. N
.t? -f e r ? f s, acr.t lwrs wes o damaged - .lwhile concludi.tyg . . . plant i,s safes andg,e f *
{ >, , j y IP * ?**falled t.: irulependently learn the full extent 'o f probit;ms ' tlu t N '*R .g. , 9
' .u l
14 4'1 -
were cunfirmed,tobeforo pose itadism.isced those e.xam,ples ,~,, 5 as . insufficient- / .g.-
c s .
by tlumcive.s public safety threat. . .
%c ;.~ ' . s. 7
.~ .--.a,.
., -
- QM. f.?j g t:*C-r ? -
f*. , }.( ' . . , lis. Garde concluded-- .
. . . .jv, y .'p,.*....? ..
- p. . A . .
.to.cJ .- u .-. . .. .
y ys* . . - . .., e . ?. :
i
.w .4- It is a disservice rely on the utility's paperwork to reassure '. ** *'
. the public that LaSa11e's safety is, proven. 'As the Zack tecords ,.,
h"e.
indicate, the paperwork cannot tw trusted. We arc not saying' t aSalle i
[ ... 1,s unsafes se arc charging that p.III does not know. 7-The Commissioners (g, I t- ** J r , . - must tat.' decisive action. The ginhlic no longer has valid grounds to . ....-e. k trust tme ronclusions 'about nuclear ' safety.* ' < ' YD *'~ *~* *@ ~ . 'a. ; f ".~.* (
-f'. ~, .n , . ,.9:: .
n.
. :~. .
.7 ;...; .-~..p:. ~ n w. . ? y.1.m. .p:.
> . ::.. .; . .?
f g., . ,.
- - ., ,. ..
- t' .,* v8 g *-- q 'y A g v*;,c,r.,.-'f.n.e,* v;. 'Ae q ;-
- '. * ..,..v. 4
..m. . . u . . . ~ .. . . . .
.. _,a, . w . . . . . . . .. . .
. -- - . + - + .
. .bh 4 ' $. . ' [ , . . . [, . . ' _ .)* . . ' I eQ,, ' 3 '* [ich..k.2 '. 'd ,e[. s *g. Q'y%p .., .... .[- .* ...
-4 7 .
a ..
e %. _ ' . . s,., .s =,a' O.
.. : q :.,. w :,y,%;: y, .
..hs. s
....'u,** a . 6to.. .& t n, =J \ s.% ' . ?;w%ti.
- dg. a.: :.QJyg:v. . g . fa *s.%m , . .'... -
f.
~. . % ~.
- . .- .si,%l, ~
- s. w -. . L. y '. g . s . 6 p+. '.pe2. . p. y :ii' M N:.1 h]s y .p. Q .}.Q.Q.. . g p._7.. g .,. .
- .. p&Yed*: c'**".2. '~.*'~~ *'."*Jfr,.. . .%.i~7 '.W.,:r&,g ,y TrL . - -W. .*n'M7 ':Q.G .'
g Q'.A L g ,*- REPRESEffrATIV1:~. Ol' Tiu'.DIRECT ZI.CK FOtlR WIIJ., DE' FAMTIC *.' . TPATII:
"*'.3 -.AN.D WILI. LIC AVATI.APLI: IVR If3TEINICWS. . . . . .. .q
- TCI.EPHONE LIffES l;667-7904
- W - y.'l O N --
w %K % { , . ? ? V'.:. g-@L.'t-+.@*
W. ~Ea.a.
p4+.-1156.D.,wIj.t
,s( ..4. t. ..,.%..-...~_....t-e ~ ;.. .w . . m x --
s... ..
. . .k. ,.
- n, y ~.:
.M yLie..
. . ,.'%. i %_.tn.,.g:;.. &.G.!e...
a ..:
M.p; ,. 3.cy . . .. ..a ;.g e ,cs.u.,3,% .s .y. ,. _ .-e %
.7 + r*
7,.Ci
.m.....;.'..
~ -. ;'.; a-y =v m . w. N. m .:. .p. e gv... e- W . a.m..g k%,jef m . y. 2.g~1m
,,, , w,%x ... . , .' ,x : ,.yrye.
, y 3 - .. , = q_ c,.
. o.
. . .-. . . . , ..y ... , s., ,,_.y -
~ _ . . .
- b. .. p,
- p ~~r .
'M M:% M p**.dV.m W ~ : W . . -s -
C- w. e* , .twlnyg t%[M% GMn;d ; n h'- M.hg. .n
< w. v. .-~r m .+>: d'. m.g... Cm.L ,e,. ..e . m ..4, . v.w;M. y . ..,o . .
s.
fy
. .' 1: n:
M, s . .
gCp ;'g-yl3'?
M'*2 % &M*'.7 W.
Q ..
f f :,~* -
e *
~
- - Ma.t. .gr-e. t- ; .
9.J . : . r..~.d. v. :r#-: . . M..s***.:.". " .V ,.b r.- r.
~
~ .T .. "q l . , . '. 1- ?,'.? Lv ,
. "7 :. ;..J, . .,. ; '. * . , ,
.".? ..- .m ..%
i , , ,.
. - >: . . . . : g . l.y.m . -;1 .
x-- - .- - - -. ,,- . -.:
. ~ * , ., l.,f.G. $p n7= - - + .-r - ' m .:~ ~' !-
~..? O '- M.
. ' -6 s
.C.?.
=
..a. .*
. .m. . ;i4. 6. s . . . J. ~ . *,** . h. .
--.Ee .- . * . "
.