ML19305E436

LER 80-008/01T-0:on 800417,while Performing Insp Requested by IE Bulletin 79-01B,discovered That Safety Factor Was Less than Acceptable.Caused by Refined Calculation.Unit 3 Isolation Valves Closed.Mods Will Be Made

ML19305E436
Person / Time
Site:	Peach Bottom
Issue date:	05/01/1980
From:	Cooney M PECO ENERGY CO., (FORMERLY PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
Shared Package
ML19305E435	List: ML19305E434 ML19305E436
References
IEB-79-01B, IEB-79-1B, LER-80-008-01T-01, LER-80-8-1T-1, NUDOCS 8005120452
Download: ML19305E436 (1)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:aan .. LIGLbl.iL L LVLW HEPOHI Rep:rt No. 2-

                                                                                                                                                                                        - /dh 12 0 4SA

(,b CON il801 OLOCK. l_ bd ,] (PLNAEE PRINT OR TYPE alt REIUIRED INFORMATIONI [j[...P _[A.jf_ _[r:_l c, l 2 l@l o] ol _lo l oJ_o_j o j o l _ l o l o l@l 4l1l111!1l@! l  !@ 3 9 LICENSEE LODE 14 15 LtCENSE NUMULH 24 h LICENSE TYPE JO b7 L A I b6 oN "T[J _ ss $30[/c!' 00_LL J@io i s I ol -1 oL2 17 LLJGl oEVENI l' 111718101@l0 14 75 i sREPORT 1011 18 lo l@ t;t oncgg y Nyytig n soli in DATE DATE Ito EVENT OEscHir rioN ANo enOGAULE CONSLOUEfJCES h sqT) l Safety factor less than acceptable. As requested in IE Bulletin 79-OlB. l

   -] T ) l                 environmental conditions associated with high energy line breaks were                                                                                                          l
  .T.i] l made indicating that a guillotine failure of HPCI steam supp1v pipinn                                                                                                                            l
  @l                        in outboard isolation valve room would result in pressure peaks that                                                                                                           1      I
  @l                        could affect the integrity of a conc _ rete b_lork wall (safety fnetor of                                                                                                       I

. .> [ i l l approximately 1.4 as reanalyzed.l. The block wall supports conduit I o liq l containing some engineered safeguard cables. I I

,             eg                                                                                                                                                                                          80      l l

SYST E M CAUSE C Af>'.I COMP. VALVE CODE Ct>DE  !.UHCOD E f OMPt)NENT CODE SUSCODE SUBCODE l uijl] I slP JO LBj@ LA_J @ l z l z l z I z I z I z l@ L_zj@ LIJ @ ' il 9 10 11 12 13 18 19 20

                                                                                                  'F(AUfNilAl                                  OCCUH H F NCE        REPof1T                   HEVISiON t t it            EVENT Yt AH                                       RLi*0H T NO.                                     CODE               TYPE                        N O.
                    @lgg,In);                     18 10 I                  l-j                 l 0101 si                       l-l              10111                Ir I          L-J          L o_]

L'#! 'A"n'd O ber 'aV'r'3 $,ons h ^s'd "'d>' b"idu "l'u"4 Sib ub'"Ifnu"n'En l33F_J@[Fj@ 31 l_zj@ t's [zj@ m l 0 l 0 l 0 l OJ l41 Y l@ l42N l@ [A_j@ lz l9 19 19 4;l @ f/ 40 43 44 cAUSE DESCH6 PHON AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS h [[j] l Cause was a refined calculation. Immediate corrective action on I ilq l Unit 3 consisted of throttling steam line isolation valves (7st closedL I

   @][ proving HPCI quick start capability and daily visual inspection of area                                                                                                                                l u [j l for st_egn__ leaks. Further analy_ sis allowed reopening of isolation valves -                                                                                                                      1   I gi,] l modifications will be made to achieve an acceptable safety factor.                                                                                                                                 I a ,                                                                                                                                                                                        so t ti                      . roht it                           O T H E H a. i n i u'.              JIM f I li                                DiSCCVERY DESCRIPTION
   '.ld {Jil@ [0 {,,0 l0 l@]U/3 - 1007. Power j
                                            ,,_ ,                                                                          l D j@l Notification from AE                                                      l o ,S' n n t             "                                                   "         "            "'                                                                ""
               %dnvnv i

int i t.,v.i n < u ni s i u.i b'ilh L2]O LzJ@l t1NA "aMr, Urn or n noir . [

                                                                                                                                          < h') j NA LOCATION OF RELC ASE l
                    't                   10                                                                      44               4',                                                                     80 l't etM un a t i A l't )'.Ul ti '.                               -

NUMill t t B YPf 16( 'Aitti' i tf nN . [jfj l 0l 0 l Ojh,l z lhl NA l

                                                              "                                                                                                                                     so consOnni t irou'dit s                              ,,

t.UMus u onCHil' HON QII)

   ' b.l ( 0,,I O l 0 j@j                                                     NA                                                                                                                              l
                    's                    tI         t/                   ~'

80 t O',*. ul s ple u A up.t.1 I O e Se it i \/ I y /.')' svre i,i t.cnir t ios

      . l ."l I zjb .._. _ _._                                                 NA                     _ _ _

l

                     ..              i.,                                                                                                                                                                  ,,,

4 UH4 n.1 y , NHC t r.J t sN! Y omur onN Q-) J.. c.woI81 Ln NA_. l l l l l l l l l l l l l lh

               "                   '"                                                                                                                                    ce ss                          soE
                                                                                                                                                                                         ~
                                                                                                                         *

• UUUU7 PHONE:

E N AME Of PitLPAHEf t . . o}}