ML14307B725
| ML14307B725 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 09/15/2014 |
| From: | NRC/RGN-III |
| To: | Entergy Nuclear Operations |
| Reeser, D. | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML13093A486 | List: |
| References | |
| Download: ML14307B725 (60) | |
Text
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Palisades Scenario No.: ONE Op-Test No.: 1 Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power. P-8B, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump, is out of service.
Turnover: Shift orders are to alternate operating Service Water pumps and then reduce power to approximately 90% at 6% per hour in preparation for maintenance on Heater Drain Pump P-10A.
Event Malf. Event Type* Event No. No. Description 1 N/A BOP (N) Alternate Running Service Water Pumps SRO (R, N) 2 N/A RO (R) Power de-escalation BOP (N)
SRO (C, T) 3 RP11A Power Range Detector NI-5 fails low BOP (C)
RO (C) 4 SI04D T-82D, Safety Injection Tank loss of pressure (leak)
SRO (T) 5 ED36B SRO(C, T) DC Panel ED-21A 300 amp supply fuse failure (AOP-17) 6 MS03B ALL (M) ESDE on B S/G Inside Containment (AOP-2)
ED01 SRO (C) Loss of Offsite Power with failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start, (D/G 1-2 is 7
ED12A BOP (C) inoperable due to loss of ED-21A)
SRO (C) 8 FW17 Loss of Auxiliary Feedwater when P-8A bearing fails (EOP-9.0)
RO (C)
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor (T)ech Spec
Scenario ONE - Simulator Operator Instructions Reset to IC-17 (or similar) 100% power MOL IC.
Place Right Train CRHVAC in service per SOP-24.
Ensure FIC-0210A set for 40-gallon dilution on Panel C-02 AFW Pump P-8B is OOS:
o Use FW16B on PIDFW01 to trip P-8B o Override CV-0522B-G (green light for P-8B) to OFF o Place HS-05422B to CLOSE o Hang Caution Tag on P-8B handswitch o Ensure EOOS indicates P-8B is out of service Ensure SW Pumps P-7A and P-7C inservice INSERT MF ED12A (PIDED08) D/G 1-1 fail to auto start Create Event Trigger 5: Event: Reg Group 1 Rod 21 less than 110 Event # Remote or Instructions Trigger #
1 No actions required.
2 No actions required.
3 REMOTE 1 RP11A (PIDRPNI3) Loss of NI 5 Power Range Detector (fails low) 4 REMOTE 2 SI04D (PIDSI04) T-82D, Safety Injection Tank loss of pressure 5 REMOTE 3 ED36B (PIDED03) ED-21A 300 amp fuse failure MS03B (PIDMS01) A S/G Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment; 6 REMOTE 4 Severity value = 3%, 10 minute ramp 7 TRIGGER 5 ED01 (PIDED13) Loss of Offsite Power FW17 (PIDFW01) Motor Driven P-8A Bearing Failure, 8 TRIGGER 5 Severity = 100%, Ramp = 3 minutes Special instructions:
None.
Page 2 of 21
Scenario ONE - Turnover Information The Plant is at 100% power, MOL. P-8B, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump, is out of service for a bearing inspection (LCO 3.7.5.A.1 - 72 hrs.) It is expected to be 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br /> before bearing inspection is completed.
Shift orders are to alternate operating Service Water pumps (Start P-7B and stop P-7C and place it in STDBY): inform CRS to direct BOP to perform this task. Once this is complete, a power reduction to approximately 90% at 6% per hour is ordered in preparation for maintenance on Heater Drain Pump P-10A.
Page 3 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 1 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
Alternate Running Service Water Pumps Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Directs alternating running Service Water Pumps.
BOP Refers to SOP-15, 7.1.1 and 7.1.2.
Simulator Operator: If called as Chemistry to recalculate mixing basin discharge flow volume, inform CR this is not required if they are alternating SW pumps.
When called as NPO for SW Pp. parameters, report discharge valve open, oil levels normal.
Starts P-7B SW Pump:
Make PA announcement Check discharge valve, oil levels for P-7B (call to NPO)
Remove P-7B from standby (PLACES handswitch to TRIP)
STARTS P-7B BOP Check amps less than 92 amps Check local discharge pressure (call to NPO)
Check packing leakoff not excessive. (call to NPO)
Possible alarm: EK-1138 P-7B basket strainer Hi dp (clears on its own)
Simulator Operator: If asked by NCO, report PI-1322 indicates 72 psig and stable; packing leakoff is NOT excessive.
STOPS P-7C BOP PUSHES STANDBY pushbutton to place P-7C in standby Note: Chemistry recalculation of mixing basin volume is NOT required.
Page 4 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 2 Page 1 of 2 Event
Description:
Lower power to 90%
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Directs lowering power to 90%.
INSERTS Group 4 Control Rods to less than 128 inches:
RO Rod Control Switch MANIPULATED to lower control rods Operates turbine generator on the DEH panel for power de-escalation @ 6%
per hour:
ENTERS setter value BOP SELECTS rate of 6% per hour PUSHES GO pushbutton and observes white light illuminate Informs CRS/RO that turbine is in GO Performs periodic borations and/or control rod manipulations to maintain T AVE within 3°F of T REF For Boration:
RESET PMW and BA Controllers if required SET quantity and batch flow limit on FIC-0201B, BA flow controller SET quantity and batch flow limit on FIC-0210A, PMW flow controller START P-56B (preferred) OR P-56A, Boric Acid Pump OPEN CV-2155, Make Up Stop Valve PUSH start pushbutton on FIC-0210B RO VERIFIES FIC-0210B output signal at zero when boration complete PUSH start pushbutton on FIC-0210A MONITORS reactor power and T AVE VERIFIES FIC-0210A output signal at zero when boration complete CLOSES CV-2155 For Control Rod manipulations:
Operates Rod Control Switch to INSERT Group 4 Regulating Rods in increments specified by CRS MONITORS reactor power and T AVE Page 5 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 2 Page 2 of 2 Event
Description:
Lower power to 90%
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior May divert CVCS letdown to Clean Waste as VCT level rises:
PLACES CV-2056, Letdown to VCT or Radwaste, in the TO CLEAN RO WASTE RCVR TANKS position When desired VCT level is achieved, PLACES CV-2056 to the AUTO or TO VOL CNTRL TANK position (then AUTO)
After power reduction commenced OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, Insert Remote 1.
Page 6 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 3 Page 1 of 2 Event
Description:
Power Range NI-05 Fails Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnose failure of Power Range NI-05:
Indications: NI-05 Lower and Upper power meters read 0%; HI voltage meter reads 0 volts; Rod Drop tell-tale light illuminated Major Alarms:
EK-0948, Dropped Rod; BOP EK-06 Rack C Window 3, Channel Deviation Level 1 5%;
EK-06 Rack C Window 4, Channel Deviation Level 2 10%;
EK-06 Rack C Window 7, Dropped Rod; EK-06 Rack C Window 8, NI Channel Trouble; EK-06 Rack D Window 2, Loss of Load Trip Channel Bypassed, EK-06 Rack D Window 3, Nuclear -T Power Deviation/T-Inlet Off Normal/Calculator Trouble Channel 'A' BOP May DEPRESS HOLD on the turbine Performs Operator Actions of EK-06 Rack C Windows 3,4;and 8 If Reactor Power less than 25%:
CHECK Rod positions normal CHECK detector voltage for NI-05 greater than 650 VDC BOP Follow Up Actions:
REMOVE faulty Power Range Nuclear Instrument from service per SOP-35 NI detector voltage less than 650 VDC, REMOVE from service per SOP-35 SRO May reference or enter AOP-5, Dropped Rod. AOP-5 does not apply Directs ARP actions:
Directs removal of NI-05 from service Declares Channel A Flux-Delta T Comparator and ASI alarm function of TMM A Channel inoperable SRO Directs monitoring and logging the Power Density status of the remaining operable TMMs hourly May call Reactor Engineer to assist in Quadrant Power Tilt and Linear Heat Rate with an NI out of service using Incore Detectors Page 7 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 3 Page 2 of 2 Event
Description:
Power Range NI-05 Fails Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior REMOVES NI-05 from service per SOP-35, Section 7.2.2:
For A Channel RPS, BYPASS the following Trip Units per SOP-36:
Variable High Power Key # 289 High Power Rate Key # 290 TM/LP Key # 297 BOP Loss of Load Key # 298 INSERT bypass key above affected RPS Trip Unit TURN key 90° clockwise VERIFY the yellow light above the bypass keyswitch is ON Repeat for other affected channel(s)
May RESET Rod Drop Telltale and alarm on Panel C-06:
BOP PUSHES Rod Drop Telltale pushbutton for Channel 'A' May check the Power Density status (OK) of the remaining operable TMMs BOP (not in tripped), (Step G)
The following Tech Spec LCOs apply:
(THESE ARE MOST IMPORTANT) 3.3.1, Action: A.1, VHP and TM/LP, 7 days 3.3.1, Action: B.1, High SUR, Prior to entering MODE 2 from MODE 3 3.3.1, Action: C.1, Loss of Load, Prior to increasing power 17% from MODE 3 SRO (THESE ARE OF LESSER IMPORTANCE)
The following ORM, Operating Requirements Manual, items apply:
3.17.6, Item: 12.1, Flux-Delta T Comparator, Prior to next MODE 1 entry from MODE 2 3.17.6, Item: 15, Excore deviation alarm, Once per 12 hours1.388889e-4 days <br />0.00333 hours <br />1.984127e-5 weeks <br />4.566e-6 months <br /> 3.17.6, Item: 16, ASI alarm, Prior to next MODE 4 entry from MODE 5 3.11.2, Excores unable to monitor Linear Heat Rate After BOP bypasses RPS trip units on A Channel RPS OR CRS has briefed loss of NI-05 OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #2.
Page 8 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 4 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
T-82D, Safety Injection Tank loss of pressure Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnose failure of T-82D:
Indications: T-82D nitrogen pressure lowering RO Major alarms:
EK-1334, Safety Inj Tank HI-LO Pressure EK-1336, Safety Inj Tank LO pressure Simulator Operator: When T-82D pressure is less than 200 psig AND the crew is pressurizing T-82D, THEN delete malfunction SI04D.
Operator actions for EK-1134/1136:
CHECK tank level normal CHECK CLOSED CV-3051, T-82D Vent Valve CHECK tank pressure on PPC (EK-1136 only)
RO Adjusts tank pressure per SOP-3, section 7.5.6 to clear alarm (Follow Up Action)
Open CV-1358, Nitrogen to Containment Open CV-3050, T-82D Nitrogen Valve Close CV-3050 when T-82D is at desired pressure Declares Tank inoperable while the pressure switch is actuated The following T.S. LCO applies:
SRO 3.5.1, Action: B.1, enter due to loss of pressure in SIT, 24 hour2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> action statement After CRS has briefed loss of pressure in T-82D OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #3 Page 9 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 5 Page 1 of 2 Event
Description:
Loss of DC Bus ED-21A Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnose loss of DC Bus ED-21A:
Control Power Available lights lost on Panel C-04 for Bus 1D Lights off on Control Panels for Bus 1D 2400V loads (running components will still indicate amps):
P-8C AFW Pump P-52B CCW Pump P-7A and P-7C SW Pumps CREW P-67A LPSI Pump P-66A HPSI Pump P-54A Containment Spray Pump B CRHVAC ventilation valves go to Emergency position V-26B, B CRHVAC Air Filter Fan running Major alarm:
EK-0524, Load Shedding/Safeguards Bus Control CKT Undervoltage EK-0558, D/G 1-2 Start Signal Blocked SRO Enters AOP-17, Loss of 125V DC Panel(s) and directs actions from AOP-17 Operator actions from EK-0524:
CHECK Bus 1D Control Power Available on Panel C-04 BOP May CHECK breakers on ED-21A CLOSED REFER to AOP-17 Simulator Operator: If contacted by Control Room as NPO to verify breakers closed on ED-21A, wait a few minutes, REPORT back: that the breakers are closed.
Page 10 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 5 Page 2 of 2 Event
Description:
Loss of DC Bus ED-21A Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior VERIFIES (from CRS direction) operating:
BOP V-96 B CRHVAC Supply Fan V-26B, Air Filter Unit Fan VERIFIES (from CRS direction) the following:
BOP FIC-1712 local indication, V-26B discharge flow DPIC-1660 local indication greater than 0.18 inches H 2O Simulator Floor Instructor:
REPLACE DPIC-1660 Placard with one showing indication at ~0.22 inches of H2O REPLACE DPIC-1659 Placard with one showing indication at zero Simulator Operator: If contacted by Control Room to check B CRHVAC parameters, REPORT back: FIC-1712 local flow indication reads 3200 CFM SRO May contact Electrical Maintenance to check out DC Bus ED-21A SRO May review equipment lost from ED-21A failure with crew Simulator Operator: If contacted by Control Room as Elect. Maint. To check out, wait a few minutes, REPORT back: blown fuse and the bus will have to be tagged out so that it can be meggered Determines that the following Tech Spec LCO Actions apply:
3.8.9, Action: C.1, DC distribution, 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> 3.8.1, Action: B.1 AND B-2 AND B-3.1 or B-3.2 AND B.4, D/G power (Completes an Off-site source check within one-hour, various): may use SRO LCO 3.0.6 support-supported rule to defer these Actions 3.3.8, Action: A.1, Alternate Shutdown System Functions 30 days: may use LCO 3.0.6 support-supported rule to defer this Action 3.7.5, Action: B.1, less than two AFW Pumps operable, 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> to MODE 3, 30 hours3.472222e-4 days <br />0.00833 hours <br />4.960317e-5 weeks <br />1.1415e-5 months <br /> to MODE 4: can NOT use LCO 3.0.6 since P-8A was initially inoperable After CRS has briefed loss of ED-21A OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #4 Page 11 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
ESDE Inside Containment Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Informs the SRO that indications of excessive load exist:
EK-1148, Fire System Panel C-47, C-47A/B or C-49 Off Normal EK-1343, Containment Air Cooler VHX-1 Dry Pan HI Level EK-1345, Containment Air Cooler VHX-3 Dry Pan HI Level BOP/RO EK-1362, Containment Pressure Off Normal Reactor power rising
'B' S/G Compartment Humidity rising TAVE lowering Enters AOP-2, Excessive Load Determines that unisolable load rise exceeds 1% change in NI or Delta-T SRO Power (may wait for HB Power Steady to also be above 1%)
Directs a reactor trip.
RO TRIPS reactor by depressing reactor trip pushbutton at Panel C-02 SRO/BOP May direct NPO to check for source of steam release.
RO/BOP Perform EOP-1.0 immediate actions Simulator Operator: If contacted by Control Room as NPO to check on steam leak, wait a few minutes and REPLY back: there are no Steam Generator relief valves blowing by or leaking on SIRWT roof area.
Page 12 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 1 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Informs SRO that S/G pressures < 800 psia, CONTINGENCY ACTION:
BOP MSIVs, CV-0510 and CV- 0501, CLOSED by taking one HS to CLOSE and then back to OPEN (may auto close on CHP)
Informs SRO that offsite power has been lost and that D/G 1-1 did not auto start, CONTINGENCY ACTION:
D/G 1-1 started from Panel C-04 handswitch (D/G will start)
(CRITICAL TASK PL-000 056 05 01: The failures considered for this recovery action are failure of breakers 152-105, 152-106, 152-202 or 152-BOP 203 to mechanically open, failure of breakers 152-107 or 152-213 to mechanically close or failures associated with any of the breaker control circuits. The operators must identify the cause of the failure, open or close (as necessary) the failed breaker or electrically disable the permissive logic. Action must be performed prior to starting EOP-1.0 verbal verifications.)
SRO Commences EOP-1.0 verbal verifications Reactivity Control: YES Reactor power lowering RO Negative SUR Maximum of one control rod not inserted Page 13 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 2 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Main Turbine Generator criteria: YES BOP Main Turbine tripped Generator disconnected from grid Feedwater criteria:
PLACES Main FWP Controllers to MANUAL and RAMPS to minimum BOP speed NO - MSIVs closed, Main Feed Pumps tripped PLACES Main FW Controllers to MANUAL, Main FRV and B/Ps CLOSED YES Main Vital Auxiliaries-Electric:
Buses 1C and 1D energized: NO (Bus 1D not energized, D/G 1-1 would not start, Bus 1C being supplied by D/G 1-1)
BOP Bus 1E energized: NO Bus 1A and 1B energized: NO EY-01 energized: YES Six DC Buses energized: NO (ED-21A de-energized) 3 of 4 Preferred AC Buses energized: YES PCS Inventory Control:
PZR level 20% - 85% and trending toward 42% - 57%: YES/NO RO (depends on conditions) Applicable Contingency: Verify max Charging and min Letdown PCS 25°F subcooled: YES (by CETs)
PCS Pressure Control: NO PZR pressure 1650 to 2185 psia and trending toward 2010 to 2100 psia Contingencies:
o Manually operates PZR heaters and spray; heaters will be off due RO to low PZR level, spray valves closed.
o When PCS pressure is < 1605 psia, verify safety injection initiated, EK-1342 in alarm and all available HPSI and LPSI pumps in service and valves open o At 1300 psia, NONE: PCPs already off due to loss of power Page 14 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 3 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Core Heat Removal:
RO At least one PCP operating: NO Verify Loop T less than 10°F: NO Verify PCS at least 25°F subcooled: YES (by CETs)
Informs SRO that P-8A AFW Pump has tripped and cannot be started and BOP that all AFW flow has been lost (if not already reported.)
PCS Heat Removal:
Verify at least one S/G has; level 5% - 70%; Feedwater available: NO (since P-8A is tripped)
Verify both S/Gs intact (no indication of ESDE or SGTR) NO o Contingency: secure FW to B S/G Verify TAVE 525°F - 540°F: YES/NO BOP o Contingency: Ensures Turbine Bypass Valve and Atmospheric Steam Dump Valves are closed Verify BOTH S/G pressures 800 psia - 970 psia: NO o Contingencies: momentarily places either control switch to CLOSE and then back to OPEN) o Ensures Turbine Bypass Valve and Atmospheric Steam Dump Valves are closed Containment Isolation: NO Containment pressure > 0.85 psig Applicable Contingency Actions: When Containment pressure > 4.0 psig perform all of the following per EOP-1.0 immediate actions (attached):
RO o ENSURE EK-1126 (CIS Initiated) OR PUSH High Radiation Pushbuttons on Panel C-13 o ENSURE CLOSED: Both MSIVs (MO-0510 and MO-0501); Main FRVs; Main FRV Bypasses; CCW Isolation Valves o ENSURE EK-1342 (Safety INJ Initiated) OR PUSH left and right Injection Initiate pushbuttons on Panel EC-13 Containment Isolation:
Verify Containment Area Monitor alarms clear: YES/NO (Depends on BOP timing: All four in alarm, not corroborated with High Range Gamma Monitors)
Verify Condenser Off Gas Monitor alarm clear: YES Verify Main Steam Line Monitor alarms clear: YES Page 15 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 4 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Time Time Containment Atmosphere: NO Containment temperature > 125°F Containment Pressure > 0.85 psig CONTINGENCY:
o ENSURE OPERATING ALL available Containment Air Cooler A Fans and ensure all CAC Hi Capacity outlet valves are open per RO EOP-1.0 immediate actions (attached):
o At 4 psig:
ENSURE OPEN Containment Spray Valves CV-3001 and CV-3002 ENSURE OPERATING Containment Spray Pumps P-54B an P-54C Vital Auxiliaries - Water: NO RO At least two SW Pumps operating: NO (only P-7B is operating)
BOTH Critical SW Headers in operation with pressure > 42 psig At least one CCW Pump operating Vital Auxiliaries - Air: YES/NO (depends on when compressor is started)
RO Instrument Air Pressure > 85 psig CONTINGENCY ACTION:
o Start available Instrument Air Compressors (C-2A or C-2C)
BOP Verifies SIRWT level > 25%
PLACES LEFT train CRHVAC in emergency mode:
BOP STARTS V-26A Air Filter Unit Fan ENSURES OFF: V-94, Purge Fan; V-47, Switchgear Exhaust Fan May follow up with SOP-24 verification Report that neither Condensate Pump nor Cooling Tower Pump is operating BOP due to loss of power. CONTINGENCY:
CLOSE MSIVs, CV-0510 and CV-0501 (already completed)
SRO MAY direct isolating AFW to B S/G When directed, isolates AFW to B S/G:
SELECTS MANUAL on FIC-0727, P-8A/B flow to S/G B BOP SELECTS MANUAL on FIC-0736A, P-8C flow to S/G B RAISES flow output to 100% on each controller (RED signal indicator to the full right position)
Page 16 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 5 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Performs Event Diagnostic Flow Chart per EOP-1.0, Attachment 1 o Diagnoses EOP-9.0, Functional Recovery Procedure.
SRO Performs EOP-9.0 strategy brief Establishes PCS pressure and temperature bands with RO SRO Directs closing CV-1064 and CV-1065, CWRT vent valves CLOSES CV-1064 and CV-1065 (already closed due to Containment BOP Isolation)
Directs performance of EOP Supplement 5, Checklist for Safeguards SRO Equipment Following SIAS BOP Completes EOP Supplement 5 SRO Directs placing a Hydrogen Monitor in service in accident mode Places left train H 2 monitor in service in accident mode (back of Panel C-11A):
PLACES HS-2419 to ACCI BOP PLACES HS-2417 to OPEN and RELEASES PLACES HS-2413A, HS-2413B, HS-2415A, and HS-2415B, to OPEN PLACES HS-2427L to 'ANALYZE' position SRO Directs SE to perform EOP-9.0 SFSCs Page 17 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 6 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Determines success paths for each safety function:
Reactivity: RC-3 Maintenance of Vital Auxiliaries-Electric: DC-1, AC-2 PCS Inventory: IC-2 SRO PCS Pressure: PC-3 PCS/Core Heat Removal: HR-2 (challenged)
Containment Isolation: CI-1 Containment Atmosphere: CA-3 Maintenance of Vital Auxiliaries-Air: MVAW-1, MVAA-1 Directs actions from HR-2:
Perform EOP Supplement 4, SI flow verification (SE action)
May secure Emergency Boration SRO Commence a cooldown of A S/G using ADVs Verify natural circulation exists Isolate 'B' S/G Initiate action to restore AFW by either restoring P-8B to service or restoring power to ED-21A (AOP-17)
SRO Directs steaming unaffected A S/G to within 50 psi of B S/G Begins steaming A S/G:
RO HIC-0780A, Steam Dump Controller, MANUAL pushbutton PUSHED Slidebar taken to the OPEN position MONITORS S/G pressures and cooldown rate on PPC Page 18 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 7 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO May directs use of PZR Auxiliary Spray to lower PCS pressure Refers to EOP Supplement 37, PZR Pressure Control Using Auxiliary Spray:
ENSURE CV-1057 and CV-1059 switches in CLOSE RO ENSURE at least one charging pump in operation ENSURE OPEN HS-2111, Charging Line Stop ENSURE CLOSED MO-3072, Charging Pump Discharge to Train 2 OPERATE HS-2117, Aux. Spray CV-2117 keyswitch as desired SRO Directs placing handswitches for Letdown Orifice Stop Valves to close PLACES handswitches to CLOSE:
RO HS-2003 (CV-2003)
HS-2004 (CV-2004)
HS-2005 (CV-2005)
Directs isolating B S/G per EOP Supplement 18, B S/G ESDE Isolation SRO Checklist Page 19 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 8 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Isolates B S/G per EOP Supplement 18 (attached)
Isolation from inside the Control Room:
(CRITICAL TASK PL-000 209 05 01: The MSLB analysis assumes operators terminate auxiliary feedwater flow within thirty minutes.
Isolating the affected steam generator limits the addition of energy that is added into containment for which containment spray and containment air cooling have to cope, and to a lesser extent prevents the accident from exceeding the flood plain analysis. The time frame for isolating the affected steam generator is reasonable. Operators have steps in both EOP-1.0, Standard Post Trip Actions, and EOP-6.0, Main Steam Line Break to isolate auxiliary feedwater to the most affected steam generator. The only things that might prevent operators from meeting this time requirement are problems with the automatic actuation of SIAS/CIAS or small steam leaks that make determining the most affected steam generator difficult. Since the MSLB is a large steam BOP leak and the analysis doesnt include an active failure on SIAS or CIAS it is likely that operators would isolate water to the affected steam generator well within 30 minutes.)
o ENSURE CLOSED BOTH MSIVs (already completed) o ENSURE CLOSED MO-0501, B' S/G MSIV Bypass Valve.
o CLOSE CV-0703, B' S/G Main Feed Reg Valve.
CLOSE CV-0744, B S/G Main Feed Reg Block Valve o CLOSE CV-0734, B' S/G Bypass Feed Reg Valve.
o CLOSE S/G E-50B Blowdown Valves: CV-0768, CV-0770, and CV-0738 (may be performed in EOP supplement 6) o CLOSE S/G E-50B Auxiliary Feedwater Flow control Valves CV-0736, CV-0736A, CV-0727 DIRECTS Auxiliary Operator to isolate 'B' S/G per EOP Supplement 18 SIMULATOR OPERATOR: When requested for isolation of B S/G use Remotes on PIDMS01:
Manual isolation valves: SG10 and SG12 to CLOSE Air Supply isolations: MS18 and MS19 to CLOSE Page 20 of 21
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: ONE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 9 of 9 Event
Description:
ESDE/LOOP//Failure of D/G 1-1 to auto start/ Loss of AFW Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Directs expedited return to service of AFW Pump P-8B.
SIMULATOR OPERATOR: If requested, report that P-8B can be ready to be returned to service in 10 minutes. When requested for restoration of P-8B perform the following:
Delete override for P-8B green light (CV-0522B-G)
Delete Malfunction FW16B Report to Control Room and request permission to remove Caution Tag, then remove Caution Tag and report that P-8B is ready for operation.
SRO Directs start of P-8B.
Starts P-8B (CRITICAL TASK PL-061 102 01 01: (This operator action is required should automatic AFW flow control provide insufficient flow to the steam generators to makeup for decay heat boiloff. Should AFW level be on a declining trend, operators must restore AFW flow to start level restoration prior to dry-out of unaffected S/G.)
RO May use SOP-12 section 7.2.2 (steps 7.2.2.g through 7.2.2.i OR EOP Supplement 19 sections 4.0 and 5.0 o VERIFY CLOSED the associated Auxiliary Feedwater flow control valves for the A S/G o OPEN CV-0522B o CONTROL flow to A S/G by throttling the associated AFW flow control valve TERMINATE Scenario when B S/G has been isolated per EOP Supplement 18 AND a source of feedwater is established to the A S/G OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner.
Page 21 of 21
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Palisades Scenario No.: TWO Op-Test No.: 1 Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 25% power. P-8A, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump is out of service for pump seal replacement.
Turnover: A startup from a forced outage is in progress. GCL-5.1, Power Escalation in MODE 1, has been completed through Step 3.1. Shift orders are to rotate Instrument Air Compressors and then resume the power escalation to full power at 6% per hour.
Event Event No. Malf. No. Event Type* Description 1 N/A BOP (N) Rotate Instrument Air Compressors SRO (R, N) 2 N/A RO (R) Power Escalation BOP (N)
SRO (I, T) 3 CH06B Loss of B Control Room HVAC Train BOP (I)
SRO (I, T) 4 ED08B RO (I) Loss of EY-20, Preferred AC Bus (AOP-13)
BOP (I)
SRO (C, T) 5 RC03 PCS Leak (requires Reactor trip) (AOP-23)
RO (C) 6 FW03B BOP (C) Failure of P-8B, Steam Driven AFW Pump, to auto start MS06B RV-0711, Main Steam Relief, partially opens (time delay 7 MS15B ALL (M) initiation from time of trip). PCS Leak increases. (EOP-9.0)
RC04 8 SI09B RO (C) Failure of P-66B, HPSI Pump, to Auto start
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor (T)ech Spec
Scenario TWO - Simulator Operator Instructions Reset to IC 14 and swap in-service Main Feedwater Pump: (IC150 for ILT2014) o Place P-1A Main Feedwater Pump in service o Secure P-1B Main Feedwater Pump.
o Change status to MV-FW0707 OPEN and MV-FW0705 CLOSED on PID FW03 using remotes and also ensure placards on Panel C-01 reflect status Ensure FIC-0210A set for 40-gallon dilution on Panel C-02 Ensure C-2C, Instrument Air Compressor is in service and C-2A and C-2B in Auto Place Right Train CRHVAC in service per SOP-24.
AFW Pump P-8A is OOS:
o Use FW16A on PIDFW01 to trip P-8A o Override P-8A-G (green light for P-8A) to OFF o Override P-8A-W (white light for P-8A) to OFF o Place P-8A Auto/Manual handswitch to MANUAL o Hang Caution Tag on P-8A handswitch o Ensure EOOS indicates P-8A is out of service INSERT MF FW03B (PIDFW01) Failure of AFW Pump P-8B to auto start INSERT MF SI09B (PIDSI02) Failure to AUTO start P-66B, Safety Injection Pump Create Event Trigger 4: Event: 0, Action: imf RC03 20 (raises PCS leak to 20 gpm)
Create Event Trigger 5: Event: Reg Group 1 Rod 21 less than 110 Event # Remote or Instructions Trigger #
1/2 No actions required.
3 REMOTE 1 CH06B (PIDCH06) Loss of B CRHVAC train 4 REMOTE 2 ED08B (PIDED02) Loss of Preferred AC Bus NO.2 (EY-20)
RC03 (PIDRC01) PCS Leak, Severity = 6 (6 gpm).
5 REMOTE 3 [Simulator Operator will insert Remote 4 after Crew determines Tech Spec implications]
5 TRIGGER 5 Action: imf RC04 15 [PCS leak rises by 150 gpm when reactor trips]
6 ACTIVE AT SETUP - No actions required.
MS06B (PIDMS01) Safety Relief Valve RV-0711 Leak, Severity = 100, Time Delay = 5 minutes 7 TRIGGER 5 MS15B (PIDMS01) B S/G Steam Line Break Outside Cont, Severity = 2, Time Delay = 5 minutes 8 ACTIVE AT SETUP - No actions required.
Special instructions:
Provide a marked up copy of GCL 5.1 completed through step 2.13.f.
Page 2 of 22
Scenario TWO - Turnover Information The Plant is at approximately 25% power MOL following a startup from a forced outage. The Turbine Drain Valves are closed per SOP-8. A Chemistry hold has just been lifted with S/G chemistry within specifications. P-8A, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump, is out of service for pump packing replacement (LCO 3.7.5.A.1 - 72 hrs.) Shift orders are to alternate running Instrument Air Compressors by placing C-2B in service, and C-2A and C-2C in AUTO, per SOP-19, section 7.2.8: inform CRS to direct BOP to perform this task. Then, resume the power escalation to full power at 6% per hour.
Page 3 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 1 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
Alternate Instrument Air Compressors Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Refers to SOP-19, section 7.2.8 BOP STARTS C-2B per SOP-19 section 7.2.2:
PLACE Compressor Switch in HAND position VERIFY the UNLOAD light is de-energized BOP IF the compressor UNLOAD light is energized, THEN DEPRESS C-2B, Instrument Air Compressor's Load/Unload button o VERIFY the UNLOAD light is extinguished Simulator Operator: Role play as NPO and follow along in procedure when RO is performing SOP-19 section 7.2.2:
For Step 7.2.2.c: C-2B UNLOAD light is deenergized and C-2B is loading.
PLACES C-2C in OFF per SOP-19 section 7.2.4.
IF time allows, THEN PERFORM the following:
BOP o WHEN PIA-1210, Instrument Air Header Pressure Ind Alarm, reaches peak air header pressure, THEN after at least 10 seconds PLACE Compressor Switch to OFF PLACES C-2C in AUTO per SOP-19 section 7.2.7.
IF C-2C is being taken from HAND to AUTO, THEN PERFORM the following:
BOP o WHEN PIA-1210, Instrument Air Header Pressure Ind Alarm, reaches peak air header pressure, THEN after at least 10 seconds PLACE C-2C Control Switch to OFF PLACE C-2C Control Switch to AUTO Simulator Operator: Role play as NPO and follow along in procedure when RO is performing SOP-19 section 7.2.7 as needed: no responses expected.
Page 4 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 2 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
Power Escalation Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Enters/continues and directs the actions of GOP-5.
Operates turbine generator on the DEH panel for power escalation @ 6% per hour:
Places DEH Speed Loop to OUT ENTERS setter value BOP SELECTS rate of 6% per hour After coordinating with RO, PUSHES GO pushbutton and observes white light illuminate Informs CRS/RO that turbine is in GO Performs periodic dilutions and/or control rod manipulations to maintain T AVE within 3°F of T REF per SOP-2A Attachment 12 For Dilution:
RESET PMW Controller if not already RESET SET quantity and batch flow limit on FIC-0210A, PMW flow controller OPEN CV-2155, Make Up Stop Valve PUSH start pushbutton on FIC-0210A RO MONITORS reactor power and T AVE VERIFIES FIC-0210A output signal at zero when dilution complete CLOSES CV-2155 For Control Rod manipulations:
Operates Rod Control Switch to WITHDRAW Group 4 Regulating Rods in increments specified by CRS MONITORS reactor power and T AVE Simulator Operator: IF asked, role play as Reactor Engineering and report that surveillance MT-10, is completed.
May divert CVCS letdown to Clean Waste as VCT level rises:
PLACES CV-2056, Letdown to VCT or Radwaste, in the TO CLEAN RO WASTE RCVR TANKS position When desired VCT level is achieved, PLACES CV-2056 to the AUTO or TO VOL CNTRL TANK position (then AUTO)
After power has been raised 1%-2% OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #1. ALSO ENSURE THAT DPIC-1659 AND 1660 PLACARDS (showing low pressure) ARE HUNG ON BACK OF PANEL C-11A.
Page 5 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 3 Page 1 of 2 Event
Description:
Loss of operating CRHVAC train Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Simulator Instructor: When Event 3 is initiated, place placards on the back of C-11A showing DPIC-1659/1660 indicating '0' inches H 2O Diagnose loss of B Train CRHVAC:
V-96, Air Handling Unit Fan, stops running BOP Noticeable lowering of background sound EK-0249, Control Room LOW Pressure DPIC-1659/1660 Operator actions from EK-0249:
VERIFIES CR HVAC not operating per SOP-24, Ventilation and Air BOP Conditioning System START opposite CR HVAC train in service per SOP-24 Simulator Operator: Role play as NPO and support as requested, no problems are noted in CR HVAC other than V-96 is not operating.
DIRECTS BOP to place A Train CR HVAC in service per SOP-24 in Normal SRO Mode.
May direct Turbine placed in HOLD.
IF placing CR HVAC to A Train in service per SOP-24 section 7.7.1 in NORMAL:
ENSURE Control Switch for VC-11 in AUTO ENSURE Control Switch for V-26A, Air Filter Unit Fan, in AUTO BOP ENSURE Control Switch for V-95, Air Handling Unit Fan, PLACED to ON PLACE Control Switch for V-96 in OFF/RESET (per ARP)
CHECK indications for train (A) being placed in service:
o All Dampers in correct position (OPEN/MODULATING)
Simulator Instructor: When CRHVAC is restored, post placards on the back of C-11A showing DPIC-1659/1660 indicating > 0.125 inches H2O Page 6 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 3 Page 2 of 2 Event
Description:
Loss of operating CRHVAC train Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior IF placing CR HVAC to A Train inservice per SOP-24 section 7.7.2 in EMERGENCY:
PLACE Control Switch for V-26A, Air Filter Unit Fan, in ON ENSURE Control Switch for V-95, Air Handling Unit Fan, PLACED to ON PLACE Control Switch for V-96 to OFF/RESET (per ARP)
PLACE Control Switch for VC-10 to AUTO ENSURE Control Switch for VC-11 in AUTO BOP CHECK indications for train being stopped:
Notes that Train B Dampers reposition to CLOSED:
o Outside Air Damper, D-8 o Modulating Damper, D-9 o Recirc Damper, D-10 o Discharge Damper, D-11 CHECK indications for train (A) being placed in service:
o All Dampers in correct position (OPEN/MODULATING)
Simulator Instructor: When CRHVAC is restored, post placards on the back of C-11A showing DPIC-1659/1660 indicating > 0.125 inches H2O CRS Evaluator: If CRHVAC was placed in EMERGENCY, then ask CRS follow-up question for his reason for using that mode instead of Normal Mode.
Refer to Technical Specifications and determine the following required actions due to inoperable B CRHVAC train:
SRO LCO 3.7.10.A.1 (7-day action)
LCO 3.7.11.A.1 (30-day action)
After SRO has briefed CRHVAC event OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #2 Page 7 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 4 Page 1 of 4 Event
Description:
Loss of Preferred Bus EY-20 Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnose loss of Preferred AC Bus EY-20:
B RPS channel parameters all in trip (red lights illuminated);
PIP Control Rod indications read -188.0 TAVE temperature reads minimum B channel PZR Pressure Controller power loss B PZR Level Controller power loss SRO/RO/BOP Major Alarms:
EK-0545, Preferred AC Bus NO.2 Trouble EK-0154, FW Pump P1B LO Suction Flow or LO Disch Press EK-0764, Pressurizer Level Ch B LO-LO EK-0754, Pressurizer Pressure Off Normal HI-LO EK-0918, PIP Trouble; EK-1145, Sequencer Trouble EK-1378, Contmt Iso Safety INJ Right Side Cont CKT UV SRO May order Turbine placed in HOLD BOP May DEPRESS HOLD on the turbine if directed RO May stop dilution/VCT diversion ENTERS AOP-13, Loss of Preferred AC Bus EY-20 SRO DIRECTS BOP to have NPO CLOSE MV-FW734, Feed Pump P-1B Recirc Valve (isolates CV-0710)
Contacts NPO to CLOSE MV-FW734, Feed Pump P-1B Recirc BOP Valve (isolates CV-0710)
Simulator Operator - If requested by Control Room as NPO to close MV-FW734, wait approx. 6 minutes , use FW62 (PIDFW03) with a one-minute RAMP, then report back MV-FW734 is closed.
Page 8 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 4 Page 2 of 4 Event
Description:
Loss of Preferred Bus EY-20 Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Direct the RO to place:
Pressurizer Level Control System (PLCS) to channel 'A' Pressurizer Pressure Control System (PPCS) to channel 'A' PLCS to CASCADE SRO PPCS to AUTO And then:
Refer to SOP-1A, Primary Coolant System to ensure all steps are completed referencing the procedure Directing RO to swap controllers and then reference the SOP OR following step by step guidance in SOP are both acceptable RO PLACES Avg Temp Display Switch to LOOP 1 position TRANSFERS PPCS and PLCS to CHANNEL A PLACES HS 1/LRC-0101, Pressurizer Level Control Switch to the A position RO PLACES HS 1/LIC-0101, Heater Control Selector Switch to the A position PLACES HS 1/PRC-0101, Pressurizer Pressure Control Selector Switch to the A position PLACES PLCS in CASCADE per SOP-1A Section 7.2.1:
ADJUST blue pointer to match red pointer on LIC-0101B RO DEPRESS the AUTO pushbutton on LIC-0101A DEPRESS the CASCADE pushbutton on LIC-0101A PLACES PPCS in AUTO per SOP-1A Section 7.2.2:
RO ADJUST blue pointer to match red pointer DEPRESS the AUTO pushbutton on PIC-0101A Performs Operator Actions for EK-0545, Preferred AC Bus NO.2 Trouble:
BOP Refer to AOP-13 Contacts NPO to go to investigate loss of AC Bus EY-20 Page 9 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 4 Page 3 of 4 Event
Description:
Loss of Preferred Bus EY-20 Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Simulator Operator - When contacted by Control Room as NPO to investigate, wait approx. 4 minutes, then contact the Control Room and STATE: the Inverter DC input breaker is closed and the AC output breaker is tripped SRO Directs bypassing all Channel B RPS trips per SOP-36 RO/BOP Verify alarms are due to loss of EY-20 and actions are completed.
BYPASS B Channel RPS trips per SOP-36:
INSERT bypass key above affected RPS Trip Unit BOP TURN key 90° clockwise (note: yellow light will not light due to loss of EY-20)
Repeat for remaining trips May direct BOP to close 2400V breaker 152-211 per AOP-13 or SOP-30, SRO Station Power to restore power to PZR Heaters from 'D' Bus If directed, CLOSES 152-211 to restore PZR Heaters from D Bus (SOP-30 steps shown):
ENSURE all Pressurizer Heater controls OFF for Xfmr 16 VERIFY Pressurizer level greater than 36%
VERIFY Charging Motor white light lit above 152-211 handswitch BOP CLOSE 152-211, Bus 1D to XFMR 16 VERIFY Charging Motor light for Breaker 152-211, Xfmr 16 Feeder, lights within 10 seconds after closure ENSURE CLOSED 480 V group supply breakers (lights on heater controls for Xfmr 16)
OPERATE Proportional Heater Group switch and Backup Heater Group switches when directed by Shift Manager Page 10 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 4 Page 4 of 4 Event
Description:
Loss of Preferred Bus EY-20 Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior The following Tech Spec LCOs apply:
3.4.1, Action A.1, PZR pressure, (2-hour action): applied IF pressure exceeded 2100 psia during transient 3.8.9, Action: B.1, Preferred AC Bus, (8-hour action) 3.8.7, Action: A.1, Inverter, (24-hour action) 3.8.1, Action: B.1, One D/G (DBA/NSD sequencer), (1-hour action)
(may invoke LCO 3.0.6 - support/supported system)
SRO 3.7.5, Action A.1, and B.1, (6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> to MODE 3) (can NOT invoke LCO 3.0.6 for supported systems since P-8A was already Inoperable) 3.3.1, Action A.1, RPS Trip Units, (7-day action) (may invoke LCO 3.0.6 - support/supported system)
NOTE: SRO may not reference Tech Specs until after AOP-13 attachment 1 is reviewed with the crew.
Refers to ORM 3.17.6 for instrumentation per AOP-13 Attachment 1 SRO May review AOP-13, attachment 2 with the Crew.
SRO May exit AOP-13 After SRO has briefed loss of EY-20 OR B Channel RPS is bypassed OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner (may want to wait until PZR Level has stabilized)
INSERT REMOTE #3:
Page 11 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 5 Page 1 of 2 Event
Description:
PCS Leak requiring a Plant Shutdown Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnoses PCS leak:
Indications from PPC:
o Containment Gas Radiation Monitor rising SRO o Containment Sump level rising RO o Containment Sump fill rate rising BOP o Charging line flow rising P-55A Charging Pump speed rising P-55B Charging Pump Start (may occur)
EK-0734, Charging PP Seal Cooling LO Press (if P-55B starts)
Enters AOP-23, Primary Coolant Leak:
Directs PCS Leak Rate calculation by AOP-23 or DWO-1, (PPC SRO Page 550)
Reviews reactor trip criteria RO/BOP PERFORMS PCS Leak Rate calculation, approximately 6 gpm leak Directs closing:
SRO CV-1064 and CV-1065, CWRT Vent Valves CV-1910 and CV-1911, PCS Sample Valves RO Isolate Letdown per AOP-24 Attachment 12.
CLOSES CV-1064 and CV-1065, CWRT Vent Valves BOP CLOSES CV-1910 and CV-1911, PCS Sample Valves Determine the following Tech Spec LCO applies:
SRO 3.4.13, Action: A.1, PCS leakage > 1 gpm unidentified, (4-hour action)
Simulator Operator - When Crew determines Tech Spec implications AND Letdown is isolated, then INSERT REMOTE #4 to raise PCS leakrate to 20 gpm.
Page 12 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 5 Page 2 of 2 Event
Description:
PCS Leak requiring a Plant Shutdown Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior RO Determines reactor trip criteria have been exceeded (unidentified PCS BOP leakage > 10 gpm)
SRO SRO Directs reactor trip (unidentified PCS leakage > 10 gpm)
RO PUSHES reactor trip pushbutton on Panel C-02 RO/BOP Perform EOP-1.0 immediate actions Page 13 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 1 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior When Auxiliary Feedwater Actuation occurs, DIAGNOSES that AFW Pump P-8B did not auto start and P-8C did not start due to loss of EY-20 Contingency Actions: PERFORM the following:
START P-8B by taking HS-0522B to OPEN BOP (CRITICAL TASK PL-061 102 01: This operator action is required should automatic AFW flow control provide insufficient flow to the S/Gs to makeup for decay heat boiloff. Operators must start an AFW pump to maintain level. Task should be completed prior to exiting EOP-1.0.)
Note: If BOP attempts to start P-8C it will trip due to loss of EY-20.
When Safety Injection actuation occurs, DIAGNOSES that Right Train SI did not actuate and that P-66B HPSI Pump did not start Contingency Action: PZR Pressures less than 1605 psia, THEN PERFORM the following per EOP-1.0 immediate actions (attached):
o Informs CRS that that P-66B HPSI Pump did not start o START P-66B HPSI Pump RO o START P-66A, HPSI Pump and P-67A, LPSI Pump OPEN Right Train HPSI and LPSI Loop Injection Valves (CRITICAL TASK PL-000 433 05 01) - This action is to manually initiate HPSI following a SGTR or Small LOCA should failure of the safety injection actuation signal occur. Action should be completed prior to exiting EOP-1.0. Task met when P-66B is started OR P-66A/P-67A started and loop injection valves open.)
SRO Commences EOP-1.0 verbal verifications Reactivity Control:
Reactor power lowering YES RO Negative SUR YES Maximum of one control rod not inserted YES Page 14 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 2 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Main Turbine Generator criteria:
BOP Main Turbine tripped YES Generator disconnected from grid YES Feedwater criteria:
Main FWP Controllers in MANUAL at minimum speed: YES BOP (however, the MSIVs are closed)
Main FRV and B/Ps CLOSED: YES Vital Auxiliaries-Electric:
Buses 1C and 1D energized: YES Bus 1E energized: NO (if SIS present)
Bus 1A and 1B energized: YES BOP EY-01 energized: YES Six DC Buses energized: YES 3 of 4 Preferred AC Buses energized: YES (however EY-20 de-energized)
PCS Inventory Control:
PZR level 20% - 85% and trending toward 42% - 57%, YES/NO (depends on timing), IF NO, due to PZR Level < 20%.
RO Contingency Action:
o All available Charging Pumps in service and Orifice Stop Valves Closed PCS 25°F subcooled YES Page 15 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 3 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior PCS Pressure Control:
PZR pressure 1650 - 2185 psia and trending toward 2010 -
2100 psia NO Contingency Action:
o Ensure Spray Valves are closed o Ensure all available heaters are energized (all heaters will be RO de-energized due to PZR level < 36%
o At <1605 psia: INITIATE Right Train SI and START P-66B HPSI Pump o If PCS pressure is < 1300 psia, stops A and D PCPs o Informs CRS when PCS subcooling is below 25F (CRS will note for Emergency Plan) o At < minimum pressure for PCP operations, trip remaining PCPs Core Heat Removal:
At least one PCP operating YES RO Verify Loop T less than 10°F YES Verify PCS at least 25°F subcooled YES PCS Heat Removal:
Verify at least one S/G has level between 5% to 70% with Feedwater available to maintain S/G level YES Verify both S/Gs intact (no indication of ESDE or SGTR) NO o Secure FW to B S/G Verify TAVE between 525°F and 540°F YES/NO (depends on timing)
If TAVE is less than 525°F:
o ENSURE FW flow is NOT excessive o RESTORE TAVE between 525°F and 540°F using Turbine Bypass Valve (preferred) or Atmospheric Steam Dump Valves BOP Verify BOTH S/G pressures between 800 psia and 970 psia YES/NO (depends on timing)
If <800 psia:
o ENSURE Turbine Bypass Valve is closed o ENSURE Atmospheric Steam Dump Valves are closed o CLOSE BOTH MSIVs: CV-0510 (AS/G) and CV-0501 (B S/G):
places one handswitch to CLOSE momentarily and back to OPEN If <500 psia, ENSURE CLOSED the following valves:
o BOTH MSIVs, CV-0510 (A S/G) and CV-0501 (B S/G) o CV-0703, B S/G Main Feed Reg Valve o CV-0734, B' S/G Bypass Feed Reg Valve Page 16 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 4 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Containment Isolation:
RO Containment pressure < 0.85 psig YES/NO (depends on Timing)
No Applicable Contingency Actions (< 4 psig)
Containment Isolation: YES Verify Containment Area Monitor alarms clear YES BOP Verify Condenser Off Gas Monitor alarm clear YES Verify Main Steam Line Monitor alarms clear YES, but no power due to loss of EY-20 Simulator Operator - If directed to check for steam leaks, report that steam is coming from ADV/Relief stack area and also in CCW Room upper level: cannot tell exact source (i.e. ADV or Relief).
Containment Atmosphere:
Containment temperature < 125°F YES RO Containment Pressure < 0.85 psig YES/NO (depends on timing)
No Applicable Contingency Actions (< 4 psig)
Vital Auxiliaries - Water:
Verify at least two Service Water Pumps operating YES RO Verify BOTH Critical SW Header Pressures greater than 42 psig YES Verify at least one CCW Pump operating YES Vital Auxiliaries - Air:
RO Instrument Air header pressure greater than 85 psig YES Page 17 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 5 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior BOP Verifies SIRWT level > 25%
PLACES LEFT train CRHVAC in emergency mode:
STARTS V-26A, Air Filter Unit Fan BOP ENSURES OFF: V-94, Purge Fan; V-47, Switchgear Exhaust Fan May follow-up with SOP-24 verification Verifies BOTH of the following:
BOP At least one Condensate Pump operating At least one Cooling Tower Pump operating SRO May direct tripping both MFW Pumps (due to no SW and MSIVs closed)
SRO Directs isolating AFW to B S/G per EOP-1.0 immediate actions (attached)
ISOLATES AFW to B S/G (may have been performed during verbal verifications):
SELECTS MANUAL on FIC-0727, P-8A/B flow to S/G B BOP SELECTS MANUAL on FIC-0736A, P-8C flow to S/G B (will not have power due to the loss of EY-20, NPO may be called to close CV-0736A - will be closed)
RAISES output to 100% on each controller (full right position)
Performs Event Diagnostic Flow Chart per EOP-1.0, Attachment 1 o Diagnoses EOP-9.0, Functional Recovery Procedure SRO Performs EOP-9.0 strategy brief Establishes PCS pressure and temperature bands with RO Page 18 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 6 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Directs closing CV-1064 and CV-1065, CWRT vent valves (may be performed SRO previously in AOP-23)
BOP CLOSES CV-1064 and CV-1065 (may be performed previously in AOP-23)
Directs performance of EOP Supplement 5, Checklist for Safeguards SRO Equipment Following SIAS BOP Completes EOP Supplement 5 (repositions components as needed)
SRO Directs placing a Hydrogen Monitor in service in accident mode PLACES left train H2 monitor in service in accident mode (back of Panel C-11A) per SOP-38:
PLACES HS-2419 in ACCI position BOP PLACES HS-2417 to OPEN and RELEASES PLACES HS-2413A, HS-2413B, HS-2415A, and HS-2415B, to OPEN PLACES HS-2427L to ANALYZE position Page 19 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 7 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO May direct throttling of Safety Injection If directed, throttles Safety Injection:
Throttling HPSI Loop Injection Valves on left train RO Secure HPSI Pump P-66B as necessary Throttle right train HPSI Loops Injection Valves as necessary SRO Directs SE to perform EOP-9.0 SFSC Determines success paths for each safety function:
Reactivity: RC-3 Maintenance of Vital Auxiliaries-Electric: DC-1, AC-1 PCS Inventory: IC-2 SRO PCS Pressure: PC-3 PCS/Core Heat Removal: HR-2 Challenged Containment Isolation: CI-1 Containment Atmosphere: CA-1 or CA-2 (depends on conditions)
Maintenance of Vital Auxiliaries-Air: MVAW-1, MVAA-1 SRO Directs closing Letdown Orifice stop valves, CV-2003/2004/2005 RO Places handswitches for CV-2003/2004/2005 to the closed position SRO May direct closing CV-2001 and CV-2009 Letdown Isolation Valves RO If directed, CLOSES CV-2001 and CV-2009 Page 20 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 8 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO May direct closing CV-2083 and CV-2099, PCP Controlled Bleedoff Valves RO If directed, CLOSES CV-2083 and CV-2099 SRO May direct restoring Bus 1E BOP If directed, restore Bus 1E by closing breaker 152-302 per SOP-30 SRO Directs PCS cooldown using ADVs Begins PCS cooldown of PCS using the Atmospheric Steam Dump Valves:
HIC-0780A, Steam Dump Valve Controller, PLACED in MANUAL RO Manual Signal Lever used to OPEN ADVs for PCS cooldown Lowers pressure using PIC-0101A to stay within EOP Supplement 1 SRO Directs isolation on B S/G per EOP Supplement 18 Page 21 of 22
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: TWO Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 9 of 9 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0/EOP-9.0, SBLOCA and Main Steam Safety Valve Leak Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Isolates B S/G per EOP Supplement 18 (attached)
Isolation from inside the Control Room:
(CRITICAL TASK PL-000 209 05 01: Isolating the affected steam generator prevents excessive cooldown of the Core and PCS and thereby lessens the potential for a Pressurized Thermal Shock Event that can threaten Reactor Vessel integrity. Operators would isolate water to the affected steam generator well within 30 minutes.)
o CLOSE both MSIVs, CV-0510 and CV-0501 (performed previously)
BOP o ENSURE CLOSED MO-0501, B' S/G MSIV Bypass Valve o CLOSE CV-0703, B S/G Main Feed Reg Valve (performed previously)
CLOSE CV-0744, B S/G Main Feed Block Valve o CLOSE CV-0734, B' S/G Bypass Feed Reg Valve CLOSE S/G E-50B Blowdown Valves: CV-0768, CV-0770, and CV-0738 o CLOSE S/G E-50B AFW flow control valves; CV-0736, CV-0736A, CV-0727 (performed previously)
Directs NPO to perform Supplement 18 outside the control room Simulator Operator: When instructed by BOP to isolate B S/G outside the Control Room per Supplement 18, then perform the following:
MS18 (PIDMS01) Main Steam Dump Manual Valve CA-0779, value = CLOSED MS19 (PIDMS01) Main Steam Dump Manual Valve CA-0780, value = CLOSED SG10 (PIDMS01) Manual Throttle Vlv MS-102 for CV-0779, value = 0 SG12 (PIDMS01) Manual Throttle Vlv MS-104 for CV-0780, value = 0 TERMINATE Scenario when B S/G has been isolated per EOP Supplement 18 OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner.
Page 22 of 22
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: Palisades Scenario No.: THREE Op-Test No.: 1 Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 60% power.
Turnover: Shift orders are to continue power ascension.
Event Malf. No. Event Type* Event No. Description SRO (R, N) 1 N/A RO (R) Power escalation BOP (N)
SRO (C, T) 2 P-40A-1 P-40A, Dilution Water Pump, trip/breaker failed BOP (C)
SRO (I) 3 RX05B Channel B Pressurizer Pressure Controller failure (AOP-28)
RO (I) 4 N/A SRO (T) T-10A Diesel Fuel Oil Inventory Low RC12A SRO (C) PCP P-50A failed lower seal 5
RC16A RO (C) PCP P-50A High Vibration (requires pump trip) (AOP-29) 6 RC04 ALL (M) LOCA (when reactor manually tripped) 7 TC02 BOP (I) Failure of Turbine to auto trip CH05A 8 RO (I) CHP Channels Auto Initiate Failure CH05B
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor (T)ech Spec Since this was the third scenario for two of the groups of applicants, Events 2 and 4 were eliminated since the SRO and BOP applicants already had more than the required Instrument/Component Failures and Technical Specification Evaluations.
Scenario THREE - Simulator Operator Instructions Reset to IC-15 (IC151 for ILT2014)
Ensure FIC-0210A set for 40-gallon dilution on Panel C-02 INSERT MF TC02 (PIDTC03) Failure of Turbine to trip on Reactor Trip INSERT MFs CH05A and CH05B (PIDCH01) Failure of CHP channel to AUTO initiate Create Event Trigger 4: Event: AN:K09(3) {this is Alert alarm for PCP Vibration}
Create Event Trigger 5:
Event: ZDI2P(123) {this is P-50A HS to TRIP position}
Action: ior LTVR-0901-08 (0 00:00) 0.55 15:00 Create Event Trigger 6: Event: rdsr(13)<100 Event # Remote or Instructions Trigger #
1 No actions required.
P-40A-1 (DWS P-40A Selector Stop) to ON (= trips P-40A) 2 REMOTE 1 P-40A-W (P-40A white light) to OFF P-40A-G (P-40A green light) to OFF 3 REMOTE 2 RX05B (PIDRX01) Channel B PZR Pressure Controller failure 4 No actions required (Simulator Operator phone call: see end of Event #3)
RC12A (PIDRC03) Lower Seal Failure on P-50A REMOTE 3 RC16A (PIDRC03) HI Vibration on PCP P-50A, Time Delay = 9 minutes 5 LTVR-0901-08 (PNL C-11) P-50A Upper Thrust Bearing Temperature TRIGGER 4 Final Value = 0.75, 7 minute ramp
[Trigger #5 will activate when P-50A is secured]
6 TRIGGER 6 RC04 (PIDRC01) Severity = 100 (1000 gpm LOCA) 7 ACTIVE AT SETUP - No actions required.
8 ACTIVE AT SETUP - No actions required.
Special instructions:
Provide a marked up copy of GCL 5.1 completed through step 4.3 Page 2 of 17
Scenario THREE - Turnover Information The plant is at 60% power, MOL after a short forced outage. Power ascension was in progress when an engineering hold was implemented to monitor the performance of both Main Feedwater Pumps.
The engineering hold is no longer required and both Main Feedwater Pumps have been deemed acceptable for 100% power operation.
Shift orders are to resume power ascension at 6% per hour. At 80% power, the rate of power ascension will be adjusted to 4% per hour.
Page 3 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 1 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
Power Ascension Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Enters/continues and directs the actions of GOP-5.
Operates turbine generator on the DEH panel for power escalation @ 6% per hour:
BOP ENTERS setter value SELECTS rate of 6% per hour PUSHES GO pushbutton and observes white light illuminate Informs CRS/RO that turbine is in GO SIMULATOR OPERATOR: If asked or told to perform GOP-5 trending, respond that it is in progress.
Performs periodic dilutions and/or control rod manipulations to maintain T AVE within 3°F of T REF per SOP-2A Attachment 12 For Dilution:
RESET PMW Controller if not already RESET SET quantity and batch flow limit on FIC-0210A, PMW flow controller OPEN CV-2155, Make Up Stop Valve RO PUSH start pushbutton on FIC-0210A MONITORS reactor power and T AVE VERIFIES FIC-0210A output signal at zero when dilution complete CLOSES CV-2155 For Control Rod manipulations:
Operates Rod Control Switch to WITHDRAW Group 4 Regulating Rods in increments specified by CRS MONITORS reactor power and T AVE May divert CVCS letdown to Clean Waste as VCT level rises:
PLACES CV-2056, Letdown to VCT or Radwaste, in the TO CLEAN RO WASTE RCVR TANKS position When desired VCT level is achieved, PLACES CV-2056 to the AUTO or TO VOL CNTRL TANK position (then AUTO)
After power has been raised 1%-2% OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #1 Page 4 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 2 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
Dilution Water Pump P-40A Trip Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnoses Dilution Water Pump P-40A trip:
P-40A red light OFF, green light OFF, white light OFF BOP P-40A amps are ZERO SRO Notes A Cooling Tower level lowering EK-3518, Dilution Wtr Pump P-40A Trip (ARP-24)
THROTTLE OPEN MO-5305 (Cooling Tower Pp. P-39A discharge) to BOP maintain cooling tower basin level.
Supply both Water Boxes from P-40B per SOP-14, section 7.3.5:
ENSURE CLOSED MO-5313, P-40A/B Disch to E-30A Makeup/Fill ENSURE CLOSED MO-5315, P-40A/B Disch to E-30A Makeup/Fill SLOWLY OPEN MV-CW735, Dilution Water Pumps P-40A/B Disch BOP Xconn (call to NPO)
SIMULTANEOUSLY THROTTLE OPEN MO-5315, P-40A/B Disch to E-30A Makeup/Fill, for a total of 15-20 seconds AND THROTTLE CLOSED MO-5316, P-40A/B Disch to E-30B Makeup/Fill CONTACT chemistry to obtain Cooling Tower samples SIMULATOR OPERATOR: If directed to open MV-CW735, use CW19 (PIDCW02), value = 100 SRO May order Main Turbine placed in HOLD.
BOP DEPRESS HOLD on Main Turbine if directed.
SRO Notify Chemistry or RMC concerning degraded dilution capability.
SRO Notify NPO and Work Week Mgr to investigate P-40A and breaker.
SIMULATOR OPERATOR: Call CRS as NPO and inform that P-40A breaker 152-102 has no control power light and there is a smell of burnt insulation from breaker.
SIMULATOR OPERATOR: When asked, inform CRS that P-40B discharge pressure is 11 psig.
SRO Determines that LCO 3.4.9.B.1, 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br /> to restore to OPERABLE status, applies for P-40A breaker 152-102 being inoperable.
NOTE: After CRS has determined LCO OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #2.
Page 5 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 3 Page 1 of 2 Event
Description:
Failure of B Channel PZR Pressure Controller Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnoses failure of B PZR Pressure Controller:
Indications: PIC-0101B, B Channel PZR Pressure Controller reads 2500 psia; Signal output on PIC-0101B in full Spray position; PZR Spray RO CVs 1057/1059 show full open; PZR pressure lowering on PI-0104 and PIC-0101A Major Alarm EK-0754, Pressurizer Pressure OFF Normal HI-LO:
Performs Operator Actions for EK-0754:
RO Notifies CRS to refer to AOP-28 Enters AOP-28, Pressurizer Pressure Control Malfunctions SRO Directs subsequent actions to be taken May direct RO to perform:
PIC-0101B to the M position Control PZR pressure using Slide Bar Direct a pressure band in which to maintain pressure Swap to PIC-0101A per SOP-1A SRO OR Placing HS 1/PRC-0101 to the A Channel position And then Refer to SOP-1A, Primary Coolant System, to ensure all steps are completed referencing the procedure Directing RO to swap controllers and then reference the SOP OR following step by step guidance in SOP are both acceptable Page 6 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 3 Page 2 of 2 Event
Description:
Failure of B Channel PZR Pressure Controller Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Per SRO direction performs:
PLACES PIC-0101B to the M position Control PZR pressure using Slide Bar Swap to PIC-0101A per SOP-1A OR RO PLACES HS 1/PRC-0101 to the A Channel position And then Refers to SOP-1A, Primary Coolant System, to ensure all steps are completed referencing the procedure (CRITICAL TASK PL-000 423 04 01: This action is to manually alternate PZR pressure control channels should failure of the in-service channel occur (OR operate failed channel in Manual). Action should be completed prior to an automatic reactor trip.)
PLACES PPCS in AUTO per SOP-1A Section 7.2.2:
RO ADJUST blue pointer to match red pointer DEPRESS the AUTO pushbutton on PIC-0101A The following Tech Spec LCO may apply:
SRO 3.4.1, Action: A.1, PZR pressure < 2010 psia, 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> SRO May exit AOP-28, may direct BOP to check instruments on back of C-12.
After the SRO has briefed the loss of the B Channel Pressurizer Pressure Controller OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner, make phone call to CRS as I&C technician and report the following:
- a. During calibration of T-10A fuel oil tank level transmitter for LIA-1400, we did a dipstick check of T-10A.
- b. The dipstick check results are that T-10A actual level is 86" which means we will need to recalibrate LIA-1400 since it is reading inaccurately.
Page 7 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 4 Page 1 of 1 Event
Description:
T-10A Diesel Fuel Oil Inventory Low Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Receives phone call from I&C that T-10A dipstick reading is 84.5".
SRO Verifies that LIA-1400 in the Control Room is incorrectly indicating adequate BOP T-10A inventory.
Refers to SOP-22, Attachment 3 and determines that based on a dipstick SRO reading of 84.5", there is inadequate fuel oil inventory in T-10A (~30,000 gallons).
Refers to Tech. Spec. 3.8.3 and determines that LCO 3.8.3.A applies. Must SRO restore fuel oil inventory within 48 hours5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br />.
SRO May direct T-10A fill from T-926.
At the discretion of the Lead Examiner, INSERT REMOTE #3 Page 8 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 5 Page 1 of 2 Event
Description:
PCP P-50A Lower Seal Failure/High Vibration Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Responds to P-50A alarm:
SRO/RO EK-0949, PRI COOLANT PUMP P-50A SEAL PRESS OFF NORMAL RO Reviews seal pressure readings on PR-0130A (Panel C-12)
RESPONDS to alarms for P-50A using AOP-29, Primary Coolant Pump Abnormal Conditions.
Monitor affected PCP Seal Flow Recorder Monitor affected PCP Seal Pressure Recorder AND COMPARE to Attachment 1, "PCP Seal Staging Schematic" SRO/RO VERIFY the following:
o Controlled Bleedoff flow is available o Only one seal stage has failed o Pressure breakdown device not plugged SRO Determines continued operation is allowed with one failed PCP seal.
EXAMINER NOTE: Malfunction for PCP High vibration has a 9 minute time-delay from start of this event and also needs time to cause any alarms.
Page 9 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 5 Page 2 of 2 Event
Description:
PCP P-50A Lower Seal Failure/High Vibration Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Diagnoses P-50A high vibration:
Vibration Monitor VIA-131A readings on Panel C-02 above normal, in ALERT or DANGER SRO/RO Alarms EK-0913, Pri Coolant Pump Vib Alert/Mon Trouble and/or EK-0914, Pri Coolant Pump Vibration Danger P-50A upper thrust bearing temperature on Panel C-11, TIA-0138A, trending upward RESPONDS to alarms for P-50A using AOP-29, Primary Coolant Pump Abnormal Conditions.
RO DETERMINES that reactor trip is required (based on rate of rise and other corroborating indications) and that PCP should be stopped.
SRO Directs tripping reactor and then securing P-50A RO DEPRESSES CO-2 Panel Reactor Trip Pushbutton TRIPS P-50A using switch on Panel C-02 RO ENSURES associated AC or DC lift pump automatically starts BOP/RO PERFORM EOP-1.0 immediate actions Page 10 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 1 of 7 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0 actions/EOP-4.0 (LOCA)
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Informs the CRS that the Turbine did not trip, CONTINGENCY ACTION:
PERFORM the following:
CLOSE both MSIVs: CV-0510 (AS/G) and CV-0501 (B S/G): places one handswitch to CLOSE momentarily and back to OPEN BOP (CRITICAL TASK PL-000 007 05 01: This action is to manually close the MSIVs due to the failure of the Turbine to trip. Action prevents excessive cooldown of the Core and PCS and thereby lessens the potential for a Pressurized Thermal Shock Event that can threaten Reactor Vessel integrity and should be performed prior to starting verbal verifications of EOP-1.0.)
SRO Commences EOP-1.0 verbal verifications Reactivity Control: YES Reactor power lowering RO Negative SUR Maximum of one control rod not inserted Main Turbine Generator criteria: YES BOP Main Turbine tripped (Contingency taken to close MSIV)
Generator disconnected from grid Feedwater criteria:
PLACES Main FWP Controllers to MANUAL and RAMPS to minimum BOP speed NO - MSIVs closed PLACES Main FW Controllers to MANUAL, Main FRV and B/Ps CLOSED YES Page 11 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 2 of 7 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0 actions/EOP-4.0 (LOCA)
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Vital Auxiliaries-Electric:
Buses 1C and 1D energized: YES Bus 1E energized: YES/NO (depends on SIAS status)
BOP Bus 1A and 1B energized: YES EY-01 energized: YES Six DC Buses energized: YES 3 of 4 Preferred AC Buses energized: YES PCS Inventory Control:
PZR level 20% - 85% and trending toward 42% - 57% NO Applicable Contingency Actions:
RO Ensure all orifice stop valves are closed Ensure all available charging pumps are operating PCS 25°F subcooled YES/NO (depends on timing)
PCS Pressure Control:
PZR pressure 1650 - 2185 psia and trending toward 2010 - 2100 psia NO Applicable Contingency Actions:
RO Ensure Spray Valves are closed Ensure all available heaters are energized (all heaters will be de-energized due to PZR level < 36%
Ensure all available HPSI (P-66A/B) and LPSI Pumps (P-67A/B) operating with associated loop injection valves (12 total) open Page 12 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 3 of 7 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0 actions/EOP-4.0 (LOCA)
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Core Heat Removal:
May SECURE ALL PCPs due to loss of CCW for cooling At least one PCP operating: YES or NO (depends on timing)
RO Verify Loop T less than 10°F: YES Verify PCS at least 25°F subcooled: YES/NO (depends on timing) o Informs CRS when PCS subcooling is below 25F (CRS will note for Emergency Plan)
PCS Heat Removal:
Verify at least one S/G has; level 5% - 70%; Feedwater available: YES BOP Verify both S/Gs intact (no indication of ESDE or SGTR) YES Verify TAVE 525°F - 540°F: YES Verify BOTH S/G pressures 800 psia - 970 psia: YES Containment Isolation: NO Containment pressure > 0.85 psig Applicable Contingency Actions (will occur later- see Page 16)
When Containment pressure > 4.0 psig perform all of the following per EOP-1.0 immediate actions (attached):
RO ENSURE EK-1126 (CIS Initiated) OR PUSH High Radiation Pushbuttons on Panel C-13 ENSURE CLOSED: Both MSIVs (MO-0510 and MO-0501); Main FRVs; Main FRV Bypasses; CCW Isolation Valves ENSURE EK-1342 (Safety INJ Initiated) OR PUSH left and right Injection Initiate pushbuttons on Panel C-13 Containment Isolation:
Verify Containment Area Monitor alarms clear: YES/NO (Depends on timing: All four in alarm, not corroborated with High Range Gamma BOP Monitors) Applicable Contingency Actions (will occur later- see Page 16)
Verify Condenser Off Gas Monitor alarm clear: YES Verify Main Steam Line Monitor alarms clear: YES Page 13 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 4 of 7 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0 actions/EOP-4.0 (LOCA)
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Containment Atmosphere: NO Containment temperature > 125°F Containment Pressure > 0.85 psig Applicable Contingency Actions (may occur in EOP-4.0):
RO ENSURE OPERATING ALL available Containment Air Cooler A Fans and ensure all CAC Hi Capacity outlet valves are open per EOP-1.0 immediate actions (attached):
At 4 psig (will occur later: see Page 16)
Vital Auxiliaries - Water: YES Verify at least two SW Pumps operating RO Verify BOTH Critical SW Headers in operation with pressure > 42 psig Verify at least one CCW Pump operating Vital Auxiliaries - Air: YES RO Instrument Air Pressure > 85 psig Directs performance of EOP Supplement 6, Checklist For Containment Isolation and CCW Restoration SRO Directs performance of EOP Supplement 5, Checklist for Safeguards Equipment Following SIAS BOP PERFORMS EOP Supplement 5 and Supplement 6 BOP Verifies SIRWT level > 25%
PLACES left train CRHVAC in emergency mode:
STARTS V-26A Air Filter Unit Fan (will auto start if CHP has occurred)
BOP ENSURES OFF: V-94, Purge Fan; V-47, Switchgear Exhaust Fan May follow-up with SOP-24 verification Page 14 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 5 of 7 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0 actions/EOP-4.0 (LOCA)
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior Verify BOTH of the following:
BOP At least one Condensate Pump operating At least one Cooling Tower Pump operating BOP TRIPS both Main Feed Pump Turbines due to MSIVs being closed.
Performs Event Diagnostic Flow Chart per EOP-1.0, Attachment 1 Diagnoses EOP-4.0, Loss of Coolant Event SRO Performs EOP-4.0 strategy brief Establishes PCS pressure and temperature bands with RO Directs cooldown of PCS using ADVs SRO Directs SE to perform Safety Function Status checks for EOP-4.0 Directs performance of EOP Supplement 4, Pre-RAS Minimum HPSI SRO Injection Flow BOP/SE PERFORMS EOP Supplement 4 Page 15 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 6 of 7 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0 actions/EOP-4.0 (LOCA)
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Directs placing handswitches for Letdown Orifice Stop Valves to close PLACES handswitches to CLOSE:
HS-2003 (CV-2003)
RO HS-2004 (CV-2004)
HS-2005 (CV-2005)
SRO Directs closing CV-1064 and CV-1065, CWRT vent valves SRO Directs closing CV-2001 and CV-2009, Letdown Stop valves SRO Directs closing CV-1910 and CV-1911, PCS Sample Isolation valves CLOSES CV-1064 and CV-1065 BOP CLOSES CV-2001 and CV-2009 CLOSES CV-1910 and CV-1911 WHEN Containment pressure exceeds 4 psig, THEN takes applicable Contingency action:
ENSURE EK-1126 (CIS Initiated) OR PUSH High Radiation Pushbuttons on Panel C-13 ENSURE CLOSED: Both MSIVs (MO-0510 and MO-0501); Main FRVs; Main FRV Bypasses; CCW Isolation Valves (CRITICAL TASK PL-000 443 05 01: This action is to manually initiate RO Containment Isolation should failure of the automatic actuation signal occur. This action should be completed prior to Containment pressure exceeding 5 psig.)
ENSURE EK-1342 (Safety INJ Initiated) OR PUSH left and right Injection Initiate pushbuttons on Panel C-13 ENSURE OPEN Containment Spray Valves CV-3001 and CV-3002 ENSURE OPERATING all Containment Spray Pumps, P-54A/B/C Page 16 of 17
Appendix D Required Operator Actions Form ES-D-2 Op-Test No.: 1 Scenario No.: THREE Event No.: 6/7/8 Page 7 of 7 Event
Description:
EOP-1.0 actions/EOP-4.0 (LOCA)
Time Position Applicant's Actions or Behavior SRO Directs placing a Hydrogen Monitor in service Places left train H 2 monitor in service in accident mode (back of Panel C-11A):
PLACES HS-2419 in ACCI position PLACES HS-2417 to OPEN and RELEASES PLACES HS-2413A, HS-2413B, HS-2415A, and HS-2415B, to OPEN BOP Energizes H2 Recorder, AR-2401, by: PLACING to ON Power Switch and PLACES to ON Chart Drive Switch PLACES HS-2427L to 'ANALYZE position REMOVES pen caps from chart pens SRO Verifies all available charging pumps operating SRO Evaluates securing/reducing Containment Spray flow per EOP-4.0 Step 16 BOP SECURES either P-54B OR P-54C TERMINATE Scenario after first Containment Spray Pump is stopped per EOP-4.0 Step 16.a OR at the discretion of the Lead Examiner.
Page 17 of 17