ML18113A868

LER 78-033/03X-1 on 780926:circulating Water Outlet Valve MOV-CW-200D Failed to Close When Operated Electrically. Caused When Actuator Cam for Shut Torque Switch Became Wedged Against Torque Switch Hold Down Screw

ML18113A868
Person / Time
Site:	Surry
Issue date:	02/20/1979
From:	Stewart W VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.)
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML18113A867	List: ML18113A866 ML18113A868 ML18113A869
References
LER-78-033-03X, LER-78-33-3X, NUDOCS 7902260472
Download: ML18113A868 (2)

Text

e U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY C~MMISSION LICENSEE EVENT REPORT e

CONTROL 3LCCK:I'-_ _.__,..___;__...__:__--'i 0 (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED fNFORMATIONl I ~

~

,_-_._._, VJ A I s ! p Is 12 101 UCE:'~5.C:: C:JiJE i4 i5 0 I O I - I O I O l O l O l O

• I - IO IO !GI 4 11 11 UC'E1\JS~ NU~~IBE?f 25 2:5 11 l 1 101 ! I 0*

LiCE:-,sE TYP: ;o 57 ~Al 50

:.

s-n 3

~~~~~ b©lo j 5 10 10 I o l 60 cl COC:<.::T NUM3i::.=!

2 I s 11  !GI o I 9 i.i3 o9 I 2 j 6 I 7 1s EVENT DA Tc l©I o I 2 I 2 Io

,4 75 I 7 19 JG)

R::~CRT QAT:0 30

'/::~JT DESC::11?T!ON ANO PRCBAaL:: CGNSEQUENC::S@

JDuring steady state power operation, circulating watef outlet valve NOV-CW-200D 1~ :J, l failed to close when operated electrically. This. is reportable pursuant to Technieal 10

,.!, 1srecification 6.6.2.b.(2).

-J ' aI 7 3 9 so SYSTEM CAUSE CAUSE COMP. VALVE CODE CODE SUBCOOE COMPONENT CODE SU8COOE suac

:ioe IJ 7

l3I 0

lw IA I@ ~@ L.!U@ 1v I A I L I v , o r p 1e L!.J.@ L£!@.

9 10 11 12 13 18 . 20 19 SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE AE?ORT REVISION Q. REPORT NO. CODE TYPE NO.

w L'::RIAO c-VENTYE.6.R l.}.J r1<::r>0Rr NUMBER I7 I s j l=.I 10 /3 /3 I l/i I28 01 31 L!J 21 22 23 24 '.;:6 27 29 JO 32

,'.CTION  ;:uruRE EFFECT SHUTDOWN (.;'.:;\ ATTACHMENT NPR~ PRIME C.OMP_ COMPONENT

,..,.KEN ACTION ON PLANT METrlOO HOURS \;;;:;) SUBMITTED FORM SUB. SU?PUErl MANUFACTURER l!J@L!J@)

i J4 LU@

JS LU

.36 I o Io Io Io40I 41W@} L:£.J(§ J7 42

.LLJ@ 11 12 lo lo I@

43 47 CAL;SE DESCRIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS @

I The actuator cam for the "shut" torque switch became wedged against the torque switch l2...!.2..J I hold down screw .

r:-;""7i Corrective action was to. remove the lock washer.

I BO

.ic;uTY MET1-i00 OF 57,

,.rus ~ POWER OTHER STATUS DISCOVERY DISCOVERY OESCRIPTTON @

I i i 5 I W@ 11 IO IO l@l...__~N=A________ W@I NA 7 3 3

.>.CTlVITY 10 CONTcNT

2 11 .

~

44 45 46 so

?.ELEASEO OF RELEASE AMOUNT OF Ac.TVITY ~ _LOCATION OF RELEASE @

L0 W@) lz.J§I.______N._~_ _....... NA 7 'i 3 10 11 44 46 80

?ERSONNEL EXPOSURES r.:;,:;\

I

'J

'l 3

IO 3

\jt~Bro 1@1~=1@'-D-ES_C_R_IP_TI_O_N__

¥;.;:A,;;.__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___,

11 12 13 30

?'::RSONNEL INJURIES Q

~!UMBER DESCRIPT10N6

! : I::. I j O lO IO l@L..-_____N_A_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~___.

7 3 ,I 11 12 30

..css OF OR O..>.MAGE 70 FACILITY '4JI

'r'°f::>;: DESCRIPTION V (2ID 3 9

~{§)s--~~~~~~___;;.;NA_;__~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,.-J 10 1 30

?*JBLICITY (:;;:'\ f!j1 9 NRC USE ONLY OE5CRIPT!ON ~ I' 0 2 2 6 0 L/ 7.' 'J ,0

[ITJ 15.SUEDr,;;'\~6.__________..;..NA_ _ _ ___,..__,.._ _ _ _7__~______ W. 1_J I I I I I I Ii 1 a :i 10 sa 63 so ;

0 W. L. Stewart ~HON~ (804) 357-3184 a.

-*~Utt.?chment, page 1 of 1 .

Surry rower Station, Unit 2 Docket No: 50-281 Report No: 78-033/03X-1 Event-Date: 9/26/78 Failure of'Circulating Water Outlet Valve MOV-CW-200D

1. Description of Event:

During steady state power operation, circulating water outlet valve HOV-CW-200D failed to operate electrically. This is reportable pursuant to Technical Specification 6.6.2.b.(2).

2. Probable Consequences and Status of Redunant Systems:

The corresponding inlet valve, MOV-CW-206D, was fully operable, providing full redundancy. In addition, l10V-CW-200D was operable in the manual mode. The health and safety of the general public were therefore not affected.

3. Cause:

Sometime prior to this event, MOV-CW-200D was manually closed to assure leak tight closure. Manual closure of this valve causes the torque switch actuator cam to travel farther than when operated electrically. This addition-al cam travel caused the torque switch cam to wedge against the torque switch hold down screw. This situation did not interfere with the remote opening signal to the valve, but, the renote closure circuit was interrupted because of the wedged position of the switch. *

4. Immediate Corrective Action:

An operator was immediately assigned for administrative control of MOV-CW-200D and it was closed manually.

5. Subsequent Corrective Action:

The torque switch hold down screw lock washer was removed to provide a clearance between the actual cam and the.hold down screw, allowing full cam movement without interference. All other circulating water valve operators were inspected and found to have adequate clearance.

6. Action Taken to Prevent Recurrence:

The interfering lock washer was removed to allow for proper clearance for the torque switch actuator cam. This washer is not required by the torque switch manufacturer and its removal will prevent a recurrence of this event. The corresponding lock washers on all condenser inlet and outlet valves for Unit 1 and Unit 2 have been removed.

7. Generic Implications:

None