ML13004A173

Email Meeting to Discuss in on Callaway Passive Shutdown

ML13004A173
Person / Time
Site:	Callaway
Issue date:	10/20/2010
From:	John Monninger Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Lawrence Criscione NRC/RES/DRA
Shared Package
ML130040225	List: ML13004A173 ML13004A225 ML13004A226 ML13004A228 ML13004A229 ML13004A230 ML13004A231 ML13004A233 ML13004A235 ML13004A265 ML13004A266 ML13004A269 ML13004A270 ML13004A271 ML13004A272 ML13004A273 ML13004A274 ML13004A319 ML13004A321 ML13004A322 ML13004A323 ML13004A324 ML13004A326 ML13004A327 ML13004A328 ML13004A329 ML13004A330 ML13004A331
References
FOIA/PA-2012-0259
Download: ML13004A173 (1)

Text

V Criscione, Lawrence From: Monninger, John Sent: Wednesday, October 20, 2010 7:06 AM To: Criscione, Lawrence Cc: Pace, Patti

Subject:

RE: Meeting to discuss IN on Callaway passive shutdown Yes, today I am available from 9:00 -11:30, 1:00-2:00, and 3:00 -4:30. I could also provide times for Thursday or Friday if needed.From: Criscione, Lawrence Sent: Tuesday, October 19, 2010 8:26 PM To: Monninger, John Cc: Pace, Patti

Subject:

Meeting to discuss IN on Callaway passive shutdown John, Do you have time to meet with me to discuss the Information Notice being written on the October 21, 2003 passive reactor shutdown at Callaway Plant?I was given an opportunity to review this IN today with the author. It has most of the pertinent information in it, however it is lacking some key facts and wording. It appears to me that the NRC is reluctant to unambiguously state the facts regarding the 2003 passive reactor shutdown.This issue has languished for three years. As an agency, we need to decide what our opinion of the 2003 shutdown is and what needs to be stated about it. It appears to me that technical people who have investigated the incident are being prevented from succinctly and unambiguously stating the facts by their management.

For instance, the author of the Information Notice was not able to use the word "passive" to describe the shutdown.Please let me know if you have 30 minutes when we can meet.Thanks, Lawrence S. Criscione Reliability

& Risk Engineer RES/DRA/OEGIB Church Street Building Mail Stop 2A07 (301) 251-7603