ML16264A363: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML16264A363
| number = ML16264A363
| issue date = 09/20/2016
| issue date = 09/20/2016
| title = 09/20/2016 Pre-Application Public Meeting for Proposed License Amendment Request to Revise the Stpegs Emergency Plan Staff Augmentation Times
| title = Pre-Application Public Meeting for Proposed License Amendment Request to Revise the STPEGS Emergency Plan Staff Augmentation Times
| author name =  
| author name =  
| author affiliation = South Texas Association for Responsible Energy
| author affiliation = South Texas Association for Responsible Energy
Line 9: Line 9:
| docket = 05000489, 05000499
| docket = 05000489, 05000499
| license number = NPF-076, NPF-080
| license number = NPF-076, NPF-080
| contact person = Regner L M
| contact person = Regner L
| case reference number = CAC MF8280, CAC MF8281
| case reference number = CAC MF8280, CAC MF8281
| document type = Meeting Briefing Package/Handouts, Slides and Viewgraphs
| document type = Meeting Briefing Package/Handouts, Slides and Viewgraphs
Line 18: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Pre-Application Public Meeting for Proposed License Amendment Request to Revise theSTPEGS Emergency Plan Staff Augmentation Times September 20, 2016 IntroductionsMike Murray
{{#Wiki_filter:Pre-Application Public Meeting for Proposed License Amendment Request to Revise the STPEGS Emergency Plan Staff Augmentation Times September 20, 2016
-Regulatory Affairs ManagerJoe Enoch
 
-Supervisor, Emergency PlanningStephanie Rodgers
===Introductions===
-Staff, Emergency PlanningKathleen Van Daalen
* Mike Murray- Regulatory Affairs Manager
-Staff, Licensing 2
* Joe Enoch- Supervisor, Emergency Planning
Desired OutcomesCommunicate the content of the planned submittalProvide a common understanding of the planned submittal 3
* Stephanie Rodgers- Staff, Emergency Planning
4Proposed ChangesIncreases the STPEGS (STP) Emergency Plan staff augmentation times from 60 and 75 minutes to 90 minutes.-Increases the required augmentation time for Emergency Response Organization members to respond to their facility
* Kathleen Van Daalen- Staff, Licensing 2
-Expands eligible pool of personnel to fill critical Emergency Response Organization positions, adding valuable technical expertise and defense in depth
 
-Increases Emergency Response Facilities activation timesThe proposed changes considered the guidance of RIS 2016-10 Regulatory ComplianceApplicable Regulatory Documents10 CFR 50.47(b)(2)10 CFR 50.54(q)10 CFR 50.90 NUREG-0654 NUREG-0737RG 1.219RG 1.101RIS 2016-10Referenced in LAR SubmittalPlanning Standard (ERO)Prior Approval (Example 1.219)License Request (required)Guidance (Basis for Plan)STA (Engineering On
Desired Outcomes
-shift)Guidance for Changes (50.54q)Endorsement (NUREG-0654) Expectation (Staff)5 Comparison (RIS
* Communicate the content of the planned submittal
-STP LAR)RIS 2016-10Current License BasisFukushima (FLEX)NUREG-0654 Staffing
* Provide a common understanding of the planned submittal 3
-Major Functions
 
-Technology
Proposed Changes
-Table B-1, 60-90 MinuteOffsite Agency ImpactSTP Submittal 6May 20, 1993No credit takenStaffing > NUREG
* Increases the STPEGS (STP) Emergency Plan staff augmentation times from 60 and 75 minutes to 90 minutes.
-0654-Identified
  - Increases the required augmentation time for Emergency Response Organization members to respond to their facility
-Described
  - Expands eligible pool of personnel to fill critical Emergency Response Organization positions, adding valuable technical expertise and defense in depth
-DefinedState/County Concurrence Comparison (RIS
  - Increases Emergency Response Facilities activation times
-STP LAR)RIS 2016-10Major Functional TasksNotification and CommunicationEmergency DirectorOff-site Surveys / On
* The proposed changes considered the guidance of RIS 2016-10 4
-site (out
 
-of-plant) / In
Regulatory Compliance Applicable Regulatory   Referenced in LAR Documents              Submittal
-Plant SurveysChemistry/Radio
* 10 CFR 50.47(b)(2)
-chemistryTechnical SupportRepair and Corrective ActionsRadiation ProtectionDose AssessmentSTP Submittal 7Details2 Dedicated on
* Planning Standard (ERO)
-shift ( RO & NLO)2 Augmented at 90
* 10 CFR 50.54(q)
-minutesDescribes personnel and technologyOn-shift staffedSTA role and technologyIdentified Staffing > NUREG
* Prior Approval (Example 1.219)
-0654Staffing and technologyOn-shift staffed Site/Program EnhancementsTechnology
* 10 CFR 50.90
-Access/Dosimetry Controls
* License Request (required)
-Area Radiation Monitors
* NUREG-0654
-Dose Assessment
* Guidance (Basis for Plan)
-Plant Computer (System status trees)
* NUREG-0737
-Auto Notifications Systems
* STA (Engineering On-shift)
-Web EOCTraining-Licensed Operator Requalification and Simulator Modeling
* RG 1.219
-Accredited Programs (Operations, RP, Chemistry, Maintenance, Engineering)Procedures
* Guidance for Changes (50.54q)
-Symptom Based
* RG 1.101
-Initiating Events (EALs NEI 99
* Endorsement (NUREG-0654)
-01 Rev. 6)Shift Complement 8
* RIS 2016-10
9Staffing ChangesIncreased in 1993 to staffing of 20Currently staffed at 25
* Expectation (Staff) 5
-Will remain staffed at 25Operations Staff2-SMs (ED qualified)2-SROs4-ROs4-NLOs1-STA Staffing ComparisonMajor Functional Area NUREG-0654NUREG-0654 On-shift/30/60 minutesCurrent STP StaffingOn-shift/60/75 minutesProposed STP StaffingOn-shift/90 minutesOperations *1. Shift Sup/Manager2. Shift Foreman/US3. RO4. Plant Operators5. STA6.Operations Discipline Lead1.1/0/02.1/0/03.2/0/04.2/0/05.1**/0/0   (not counted in On-shift Total) 6.None defined1.2/0/02.2/0/03.4/0/04.4/0/05.1**/0/0 (not counted in On-shift Total)6.0/0/1#1.2/02.2/03.4/04.4/05.1**/0 (not counted in On-shift Total)6.0/1#Emergency Direction and Control***
 
(STA, SS, or Facility Director)1**/0/0     (not counted in On-shift Total)2**/0/0 (not counted in On-shift Total)2**/0 (not counted in On-shift Total)Notification
Comparison (RIS-STP LAR)
/Communication1/1/22/0/22/210*     Unaffected Unit in operation maintain shift foreman, 1
RIS 2016-10                STP Submittal
-RO, 1-NLO**May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions
* Current License Basis
***Assumed by EOF Director when all facilities are manned#     Filled by personnel with plant operations experience Major Functional Area NUREG-0654NUREG-0654 On-shift/30/60 minutesCurrent STP Staffing On-shift/60/75 minutesProposed STP Staffing On-shift/90 minutesRadiological AssessmentEmergency DirectorSenior HP Expertise Offsite/Onsite surveysChemistry/Radio
* May 20, 1993
-chem0/0/10/1/0 0/3/32/1/20/0/11/0/0 2/3/41/0/10/11/02**/7 1/1Engineering, Repair and Corrective Actions1. Technical Support STACore Electrical Mechanical2. Repair and Corr. ActionsRad Waste/
* Fukushima (FLEX)
MechanicalElectrical/I&CI&C1.1/0/0 0/1/0 0/0/1 0/0/12.1**/0/2 (not counted inOn-shift total)1**/1/1 (not counted in On-shift Total)0/1/01.1/0/0    0/1/0 0/0/1 0/0/12.2**/0/0(not counted in On-shift Total)         1**/0/11**and 1/0/11/0/01.1/0 0/1 0/1 0/12.2**/0 (not counted in On-shift Total)1**/11**and1/11/0Staffing Comparison (Continued) 11** May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions Staffing Comparison (Continued)Major Functional Area NUREG-0654NUREG-0654 On-shift/30/60 minutesCurrent STP StaffingOn-shift/60/75 minutesProposed STP StaffingOn-shift/90 minutesProtective Actions (In Plant) Radiation Protection HP Technicians for:
* No credit taken
a.Access Control b.HP Coverage c.Personnel monitor d.Dosimetry 2**/2/2 (not counted in On-shift Total) 2**/4/0 (not counted in On-shift Total) 2**/4 (not counted in On-shift Total)FirefightingPer T/S / Local Support /
* NUREG-0654 Staffing
0Per T/S / Local Support / Local Support Per T/S / Local SupportRescue First Aid2**/ Local Support(not counted in On
* Staffing > NUREG-0654
-shift Total) 2**/ Local Support / Local Support2**/ Local SupportSecurity Site Access Control and Personnel AccountabilityPer Security PlanPer Security PlanPer Security PlanTotals10/11/15 = 3625/8/13 = 4625/21 = 4612** May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions PrecedentPoint Beach Prairie IslandRAIs Reviewed13 Closing RemarksDesired OutcomeSubmittal DateSTP Point of Contact14}}
  - Major Functions           - Identified
  - Technology                 - Described
  - Table B-1, 60-90 Minute    - Defined
* Offsite Agency Impact
* State/County Concurrence 6
 
Comparison (RIS-STP LAR)
RIS 2016-10                        STP Submittal Major Functional Tasks                            Details
* Notification and Communication
* 2 Dedicated on-shift ( RO & NLO)
* Emergency Director
* 2 Augmented at 90-minutes
* Off-site Surveys / On-site (out-of-
* Describes personnel and plant) / In-Plant Surveys            technology
* Chemistry/Radio-chemistry
* On-shift staffed
* Technical Support
* STA role and technology
* Repair and Corrective Actions
* Identified Staffing > NUREG-0654
* Radiation Protection
* Staffing and technology
* Dose Assessment
* On-shift staffed 7
 
Site/Program Enhancements
* Technology
  - Access/Dosimetry Controls
  - Area Radiation Monitors
  - Dose Assessment
  - Plant Computer (System status trees)
  - Auto Notifications Systems
  - Web EOC
* Training
  - Licensed Operator Requalification and Simulator Modeling
  - Accredited Programs (Operations, RP, Chemistry, Maintenance, Engineering)
* Procedures
  - Symptom Based
  - Initiating Events (EALs NEI 99-01 Rev. 6)
* Shift Complement 8
 
Staffing Changes
* Increased in 1993 to staffing of 20
* Currently staffed at 25
  - Will remain staffed at 25
* Operations Staff
* 2-SMs (ED qualified)
* 2-SROs
* 4-ROs
* 4-NLOs
* 1-STA 9
 
Staffing Comparison Major Functional Area               NUREG-0654                  Current STP Staffing Proposed STP Staffing NUREG-0654               On- shift/30/60 minutes On-shift/60/75 minutes                  On-shift/90 minutes Operations *
: 1. Shift Sup/Manager          1. 1/0/0                      1. 2/0/0                      1. 2/0
: 2. Shift Foreman/US          2. 1/0/0                      2. 2/0/0                      2. 2/0
: 3. RO                        3. 2/0/0                      3. 4/0/0                     3. 4/0
: 4. Plant Operators            4. 2/0/0                      4. 4/0/0                      4. 4/0
: 5. STA                        5. 1**/0/0   (not counted in 5. 1**/0/0 (not counted in    5. 1**/0 (not counted in On-shift Total)               On-shift Total)            On-shift Total)
: 6. Operations Discipline 6. None defined                      6. 0/0/1#                      6. 0/1#
Lead Emergency Direction and Control***                     1**/0/0 (not counted in           2**/0/0 (not counted in     2**/0 (not counted in (STA, SS, or Facility                          On-shift Total)               On-shift Total)            On-shift Total)
Director)
Notification/                     1/1/2                            2/0/2                        2/2 Communication
* Unaffected Unit in operation maintain shift foreman, 1-RO, 1-NLO
  **   May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions
  ***   Assumed by EOF Director when all facilities are manned
  #   Filled by personnel with plant operations experience                                                       10
 
Staffing Comparison (Continued)
Major Functional Area NUREG-0654                            NUREG-0654                     Current STP Staffing        Proposed STP Staffing On- shift/30/60 minutes              On-shift/60/75 minutes          On-shift/90 minutes Radiological Assessment Emergency Director                                0/0/1                            0/0/1                          0/1 Senior HP Expertise                              0/1/0                            1/0/0                         1/0 Offsite/Onsite surveys                            0/3/3                            2/3/4                        2**/7 Chemistry/Radio-chem                              2/1/2                            1/0/1                          1/1 Engineering, Repair and Corrective Actions
: 1. Technical Support                   1.                                    1.                           1.
STA                                                1/0/0                             1/0/0                        1/0 Core                                              0/1/0                              0/1/0                         0/1 Electrical                                        0/0/1                             0/0/1                         0/1 Mechanical                                        0/0/1                             0/0/1                        0/1
: 2. Repair and Corr. Actions
: 2.                                    2.                            2.
2**/0/0 (not counted in        2**/0 (not counted in Rad Waste/
1**/0/2 (not counted                       On-shift Total)              On-shift Total)
Mechanical                                              in On-shift total)           1**/0/1                      1**/1 Electrical/I&C                                  1**/1/1 (not counted              1**and 1/0/1                   1**and1/1 in On-shift Total)
I&C                                                                                    1/0/0                          1/0 0/1/0
** May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions                                                                       11
 
Staffing Comparison (Continued)
Major Functional Area             NUREG-0654                Current STP Staffing Proposed STP Staffing NUREG-0654             On- shift/30/60 minutes On-shift/60/75 minutes On-shift/90 minutes Protective Actions (In Plant) Radiation                   2**/2/2 (not counted in     2**/4/0 (not counted in   2**/4 (not counted in Protection HP                              On-shift Total)            On-shift Total)         On-shift Total)
Technicians for:
: a. Access Control
: b. HP Coverage
: c. Personnel monitor
: d. Dosimetry Firefighting                  Per T/S / Local Support / Per T/S / Local Support Per T/S / Local Support 0                    / Local Support Rescue First Aid                2**/ Local Support            2**/ Local Support /    2**/ Local Support (not counted in On-shift Total)     Local Support Security Site Access             Per Security Plan            Per Security Plan      Per Security Plan Control and Personnel Accountability Totals                              10/11/15 = 36                  25/8/13 = 46            25/21 = 46
  ** May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions                                       12
 
Precedent
* Point Beach
* Prairie Island
* RAIs Reviewed 13
 
Closing Remarks
* Desired Outcome
* Submittal Date
* STP Point of Contact 14}}

Latest revision as of 13:03, 4 December 2019

Pre-Application Public Meeting for Proposed License Amendment Request to Revise the STPEGS Emergency Plan Staff Augmentation Times
ML16264A363
Person / Time
Site: South Texas, Perkins  Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 09/20/2016
From:
South Texas Association for Responsible Energy
To:
Division of Operating Reactor Licensing
Regner L
References
CAC MF8280, CAC MF8281
Download: ML16264A363 (14)


Text

Pre-Application Public Meeting for Proposed License Amendment Request to Revise the STPEGS Emergency Plan Staff Augmentation Times September 20, 2016

Introductions

  • Mike Murray- Regulatory Affairs Manager
  • Joe Enoch- Supervisor, Emergency Planning
  • Stephanie Rodgers- Staff, Emergency Planning
  • Kathleen Van Daalen- Staff, Licensing 2

Desired Outcomes

  • Communicate the content of the planned submittal
  • Provide a common understanding of the planned submittal 3

Proposed Changes

- Increases the required augmentation time for Emergency Response Organization members to respond to their facility

- Expands eligible pool of personnel to fill critical Emergency Response Organization positions, adding valuable technical expertise and defense in depth

- Increases Emergency Response Facilities activation times

  • The proposed changes considered the guidance of RIS 2016-10 4

Regulatory Compliance Applicable Regulatory Referenced in LAR Documents Submittal

  • Planning Standard (ERO)
  • Prior Approval (Example 1.219)
  • License Request (required)
  • Guidance (Basis for Plan)
  • STA (Engineering On-shift)
  • Guidance for Changes (50.54q)
  • Expectation (Staff) 5

Comparison (RIS-STP LAR)

RIS 2016-10 STP Submittal

  • Current License Basis
  • May 20, 1993
  • No credit taken

- Major Functions - Identified

- Technology - Described

- Table B-1, 60-90 Minute - Defined

  • Offsite Agency Impact
  • State/County Concurrence 6

Comparison (RIS-STP LAR)

RIS 2016-10 STP Submittal Major Functional Tasks Details

  • Notification and Communication
  • 2 Dedicated on-shift ( RO & NLO)
  • Emergency Director
  • 2 Augmented at 90-minutes
  • Off-site Surveys / On-site (out-of-
  • Describes personnel and plant) / In-Plant Surveys technology
  • Chemistry/Radio-chemistry
  • On-shift staffed
  • Technical Support
  • STA role and technology
  • Repair and Corrective Actions
  • Radiation Protection
  • Staffing and technology
  • Dose Assessment
  • On-shift staffed 7

Site/Program Enhancements

  • Technology

- Access/Dosimetry Controls

- Area Radiation Monitors

- Dose Assessment

- Plant Computer (System status trees)

- Auto Notifications Systems

- Web EOC

  • Training

- Licensed Operator Requalification and Simulator Modeling

- Accredited Programs (Operations, RP, Chemistry, Maintenance, Engineering)

  • Procedures

- Symptom Based

- Initiating Events (EALs NEI 99-01 Rev. 6)

  • Shift Complement 8

Staffing Changes

  • Increased in 1993 to staffing of 20
  • Currently staffed at 25

- Will remain staffed at 25

  • Operations Staff
  • 2-SMs (ED qualified)
  • 2-SROs
  • 4-ROs
  • 4-NLOs
  • 1-STA 9

Staffing Comparison Major Functional Area NUREG-0654 Current STP Staffing Proposed STP Staffing NUREG-0654 On- shift/30/60 minutes On-shift/60/75 minutes On-shift/90 minutes Operations *

1. Shift Sup/Manager 1. 1/0/0 1. 2/0/0 1. 2/0
2. Shift Foreman/US 2. 1/0/0 2. 2/0/0 2. 2/0
3. RO 3. 2/0/0 3. 4/0/0 3. 4/0
4. Plant Operators 4. 2/0/0 4. 4/0/0 4. 4/0
5. STA 5. 1**/0/0 (not counted in 5. 1**/0/0 (not counted in 5. 1**/0 (not counted in On-shift Total) On-shift Total) On-shift Total)
6. Operations Discipline 6. None defined 6. 0/0/1# 6. 0/1#

Lead Emergency Direction and Control*** 1**/0/0 (not counted in 2**/0/0 (not counted in 2**/0 (not counted in (STA, SS, or Facility On-shift Total) On-shift Total) On-shift Total)

Director)

Notification/ 1/1/2 2/0/2 2/2 Communication

  • Unaffected Unit in operation maintain shift foreman, 1-RO, 1-NLO
    • May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions
      • Assumed by EOF Director when all facilities are manned
  1. Filled by personnel with plant operations experience 10

Staffing Comparison (Continued)

Major Functional Area NUREG-0654 NUREG-0654 Current STP Staffing Proposed STP Staffing On- shift/30/60 minutes On-shift/60/75 minutes On-shift/90 minutes Radiological Assessment Emergency Director 0/0/1 0/0/1 0/1 Senior HP Expertise 0/1/0 1/0/0 1/0 Offsite/Onsite surveys 0/3/3 2/3/4 2**/7 Chemistry/Radio-chem 2/1/2 1/0/1 1/1 Engineering, Repair and Corrective Actions

1. Technical Support 1. 1. 1.

STA 1/0/0 1/0/0 1/0 Core 0/1/0 0/1/0 0/1 Electrical 0/0/1 0/0/1 0/1 Mechanical 0/0/1 0/0/1 0/1

2. Repair and Corr. Actions
2. 2. 2.

2**/0/0 (not counted in 2**/0 (not counted in Rad Waste/

1**/0/2 (not counted On-shift Total) On-shift Total)

Mechanical in On-shift total) 1**/0/1 1**/1 Electrical/I&C 1**/1/1 (not counted 1**and 1/0/1 1**and1/1 in On-shift Total)

I&C 1/0/0 1/0 0/1/0

    • May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions 11

Staffing Comparison (Continued)

Major Functional Area NUREG-0654 Current STP Staffing Proposed STP Staffing NUREG-0654 On- shift/30/60 minutes On-shift/60/75 minutes On-shift/90 minutes Protective Actions (In Plant) Radiation 2**/2/2 (not counted in 2**/4/0 (not counted in 2**/4 (not counted in Protection HP On-shift Total) On-shift Total) On-shift Total)

Technicians for:

a. Access Control
b. HP Coverage
c. Personnel monitor
d. Dosimetry Firefighting Per T/S / Local Support / Per T/S / Local Support Per T/S / Local Support 0 / Local Support Rescue First Aid 2**/ Local Support 2**/ Local Support / 2**/ Local Support (not counted in On-shift Total) Local Support Security Site Access Per Security Plan Per Security Plan Per Security Plan Control and Personnel Accountability Totals 10/11/15 = 36 25/8/13 = 46 25/21 = 46
    • May be provided by shift personnel assigned other functions 12

Precedent

  • Point Beach
  • Prairie Island

Closing Remarks

  • Desired Outcome
  • Submittal Date
  • STP Point of Contact 14