ML19256G140

LER 79-039/01T-0:on 791130,engineering Review Per IE Bulletin 79-02 Identified 16 Supports Associated w/1-inch Control Rod Driveline Insert & Withdrawal Piping as Not Being Seismically Qualified.Caused by Inadequate Design

ML19256G140
Person / Time
Site:	Peach Bottom
Issue date:	12/14/1979
From:	Cooney M PECO ENERGY CO., (FORMERLY PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
Shared Package
ML19256G136	List: ML19256G135 ML19256G140
References
LER-79-039-01T, LER-79-39-1T, NUDOCS 7912270510
Download: ML19256G140 (1)

Text

is .su ta .i n ..oe .. .

etc > OHM JLA F7H

, Unit.3 LICENSEE EVENI' REPORT hport No. 3-79-39/1T CONiaoloLOco l l

i I I 1 1 6IQ (PLEASE PRWT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED NOHMHOM lahj le l A l P lB lS l 3 lh 010l 10 l 0l 010l 0 l - 01 0 l@l 426 l 1 L4l CENSE 1 l 1TYPEl 1JGl@l'57 CA3 l _j W 14 15 LICENSE NUMSER 2% 51' 8 9 LlCENSEE COoE CON'T Lo.L'J f,

" ls LL_J @Sil0 l5 l ooc 013(ET-lNUMSER 012 17 186tl l@l1l1 3 l o l 7 19 l@ll_j li lh 17 l 9 k) H0 S 60 49 EVENT DATE F4 M REPORT DATL EVENT DESCRIPTION AND PRO 8ABLE CONSEQUENCES h o 2 l An engineering review of vendor design associated with Bulletin 79-02 j o l identified a total of 16 supports associated with Unit 31" CRD insert . .)

@ l and withdrawal piping as not being seismically qualified. A review indi- 1 o s cates that the lines involved would not break during a seismic event and _]

lois! l if a failure occurred the CRD system would operate within design limits. I g I I

gi '*

7 se "

'I![o'E **$5 C sSc' Sot CoucoNENT coos su'sS"o'of sScEEE g 9 R IB @ d h W h l SI Ul Pl Ol Rl Tl h [lj h bLj h 10 13 12 13 18 19 20 7 8 HL k l5'ON SE OuE N16 AL OCCUHHfNCt REPORT EVENTYEAR REPORT NO CODE TYPE No LE pino h atg o

_ l28 7 9 22 l-l 23 10 13 19 24 26 l/l 27 10 1l 28 29 l Tl 30 l_1 31 LO_J 31 T ET HOUH5 58 : TD FOA u. Li MA F HEH TA N T

$[34.Z jh 33 LA_j@

36 Mh 30 3l7 Ol 1 21 0 40

[Y_j @

41

[_N_j@

42

[A_j@

43 l44R l 1 l h 104r @

CAUSE DESCRIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS lil0ll The design difficiency was a result of inadequate initial de- I g,, p,j l sign. For the 16 supports identified, appropriate structural members 1 7 g l were reinforced and some additional members installed to elistinate any I

] l overstressed condition during a seismic event. All modifications were I g,m c1 A,ed by 12/11/79 prior to the Unit 3 startup. j so 9

[$ t(i$.  % P0vvtH oTHER h T A IUS D6 C t Y UthCOVLHY QEbCHIPitON

! Il Bjh l0 l715 l@l NA a

l [_D_jhl NRC Bulletin 79-02 Ho l

, , , , g , ,, i2 n 42  %

dELEASED OF HE LE ASE AMOUNT of ACTIVITV LOC AllGN OF RELEASE

[~Ji] [ zj @ lz lhl 66 9 10 11 NA 44 l 1 45 NA lid I

I' t H NO4N T L i m e' .",UH E S

~ . , .e en<,,,P ,,eN h 1645 005 Q)>]l010l0lh W hi" NA y _

' ~ " ' ,o.,oNNEL NoMu R N.u',iin onCn.PnON@

3D Jwo D

D T}M

'J~ Q # j liil101010l@l p H 9 11 17 NA U"

TYPL f)Ett 4 PT ON l 7912270 8/ O

@ j W @l,o NA e

l PUB L ICI TY N H C. Uhl UNLY

• J assygp OkSCRIP TION ,

7 o [N_jhl NA /d i cs i> 9 llIlllllIIllll so - -

s ,, 9 io g'ffg f 7/LLA f  ;

W J. Cooney/ PHONE:

(215) 841-5020 o NAME OF PREPARER ,