ML20091Q632: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:}}
{{#Wiki_filter:- - - -
Ql                          ,w-
                                    ,Q .            -                        >;
            ~                              '
                                                        ' 9:'                                <
ATTACHMENT ~5
  ; e-n                                                                .
KIRK 1*ATRicx,6LocxlIAuT, IIILL, CIIRISTOl*1IER & ' l'111LLIl2S
            . ;                      Ng                                                    b r.m u.mua benmso ,, ore..o6..oi,    nor N"                                                                                      1900 M STREET, N. W.
y                                u WasnixoTox, D. C. 2oom.
I 1438 ! BRICEELL iv1NUE ,                                        7ELEPI!ONE!!202).432 7000            1300 OLIVER BUILDING g                            (- Mt.M*I, TIARIDA 33131:                                              ,
PITTMMMtGII, PENNSYLVANIA 13222
                                              . 303) 374 -8182 0312) 333 4 300 r          +
May 30,.'1984
    ' H wsEmi mater om. xotarR -
I      '                                                                                  '
{[ J20'2/452k70'44                                      ,
x r  g.1 s
                                      ..:Eichard M.jGcffari,.Esq.
f0ffice*ofsExec_utive Legal Director TU.S.JNuclearjRegulatoryjCommission 773510ld:Georgetown: Road-vBethesda,1(Maryland'                                            z2081'4;
                                                                ~
 
==Dear? Dick:==
1
[_ Last week,dduringftheidepositioniof Carl Berlinger, Isofferedu to;l furnish.youlwith theTlist-of TDIl engines'and their owner /
operators _, which15uffolk5CountyJobtained:from TDI durinlg.
                                                                                                                                      ~
t
[.                                  ; discovery.: LA copyoof that list.is enclosed. 'I understand that.
                  +
Jcounsel'fortNew-York State had writtenoto the customers-whose s              1namesLarefcircledito request. operating: history. data on the engines
                                        ' arid theirs^principair components . .
            ~
                                          'D .The' County's[ diesel? experts:believe1that the operating .
  -                  Q~' historyfofsTDIfdiesels in marine service may be relevant-.to the-e>                            , -Shorehamidiesels",'an'dJduring:their-deposition last week, the NRC's
                                      " diesel 'consultantsf agreed. ~ 'While : Carl Berlinger-~ does :not: believe
                                                                                                          ~
.    :                  - Loperatingl data 3forJTDIJdieselsiin non-nuclear stationary _appli--
{ cations (is ilikelyLto 'be' detailedfenough to :beluseful,Cwe: thinkiit -
1:is vorth : findingJout"if'thatiview is correct. 'Our own'ireview"of b;                        3 lTDI files 0duringjdiscovery: suggests.that. records of' failures;or.
g,                                      defectsiinLsuch plantsfmay be.quiteLrelevant and' helpful e                                        .
                                            .., ..Accordingly, Suffolk County reques'ts.that;the. Staff contact
.                      ;              ialliTDI custor.ers .circledEonithe - enclosed -list: tofrequest opera--
  . m                                  ltingshistoryidata ofLTDILdiesels, particularly'withLrespect to
? -                        <
l cylinder blo'ck cracking,; cylinder; head cracking (post-1980. heads),
                                      , AE pistons , c crankshaf ts ,.- andL the t other 16 f significant ' components ,'
                                                                      ~
4                ,
t                                iaalwellLas fxpwienceJas;to. engine rating, loading, and other
:cperating parameters.'(Such. data may_ prove critical to the Staff's
                        .                evaluating;the'TDI! Owners'; Group program, which utilized onlyTa' 4
veryclimited, primarilyinuclear cplant.(tests), data! base.7 We 6y                  '
believefthat diese1Lowners are far'moreLlikely.toL. respond'to
                            ' : requests;from'1thelNRCithan.to those from the. County or New! York 3;                          ' State,iespecially:'in" view ofLthe= cautionary. letters previously-
          ',                        Lwritten bygTDI.
~'                                  "                        -
9-3
 
I              ,HM                                  .
j
  ''y                :
7sl ~                  #
_ ~KraxrArnicx, l                    LOCEMART, HILL. GuarzToPHER & PRILLIPS
... --?y CfM,Jr, Richard J.3 Goddard,-Esq.
                        ~ MayV30, 1984~
: Page52
                            . .        2We'hopelyouJfind'the 'nclose'd    e              information useful, and that, 1                given?the-Staff's responsibility for'. safety in nuclear pla.ts, you will; immediately :act:- to obtain operating -history data that could'-
                        . profoundly. impact on.the Staff's review of TDI~ diesels.
very truly y:urs , .
                                                                                          ' Alan Roy.Dynner iARD/dk (cc i          Fab'ian1 Palomino,. Esq.
CarlrBerlinger-  ~
                                        . Odes L. Stroupe, Jr.,.'Esq.
                                        . Ralph Caruso ,
Harold'R. Denton.-
                                        . William.J. Dircks-I-
4; g ,.
-'{.
4 6
P 1
k
                                                                *  ,.4- . - %.- , + .r,  m  _  ,,  em , . , - . , , , _ , , , . , ,. , . _ , , , , . _ , . . .,i
 
I eg i.
m                                                                                *0lKETED USHRC
            * *n                                  ' UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIM JUN 13 P1 :53 JBefore the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board un u. ef hue ;;,-.
00CXEilNG & '5E Pvt .
                                                                                        . BRANCH
                                                                      )
          ,        In the Matter:of                                  li
                                                                      -- )
LLONG; ISLAND LIGHTING-COMPANY                      )    Docket No. 50-322 0.L.
N
                                                                      -)
                    -(Shoreham-Nuclear-Power Station,                -)
Unit 1);                                        -)-
                                                                      ~)
                    ~
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1                          .      .
                              .:I'hereby certify that copies of.SUFFOLK COUNTY'S FILING iCONCERNING LITIGATION OF EMERGENCY DIESEL GENERATOR CONTENTIONS, idated June 111',~1984,3have been served on:the following-this.llth day of? June 1984 by:U.S. mail, first class, except as otherwise indicated.
ILawrencejJ. Brenner,'Esq.*                          Ralph Shapiro, Esq.
1 Administrative: Judge:                              Cammertand Shapiro
                  ' Atomic-SafetyLandTLicensing-Boardc                -9 East 40th Street JU.S.fNuclear Regulatory Commission                    New York, New York            10016
: Washington;.D.C.            20555 Mr. Stuart Diamond
[Dr. George'A. Ferguson*                              Business / Financial Administrative Judge                        .    :NEW YORKzTIMES
                  ' Atomic Safety and LicensingfBoard-.                  New York,:New York 10036'
:-School.of Engineering Howard University                                  W. Taylor Reveley, III, Esq.*
2300. 6th Street,:N.W. .                            Hunton!8 Williams-1    EWashington,' D.C.'            20059                  P.O. Box:1535-y                                                                    707 East Main ~ Street
                  'Dr. Peter A. Morris
* Ricemond, Virginia            23212 1 Administrative Judge.
(E Atomic Safety and Licensing' Board                  Mr. Jay Dunkleberger U.S. Nuclear Regulatory = Commission                New York State Energy Office Washington, D.C.' :20555                            Agency-Building ~2-Empire State Plaza EdwardLM. Barrett,LEsq.                              Albany, New York          12223 General' Counsel
                  .Long; Island' Lighting Company                        James B. Dougherty,.Esq.
250 Old Country-Road                              .3045 Porter Street, N.W.
                  ;Mineola, New York'            11501                  Washington, D.C.          20008 6
I L.
 
U
,      n; Ib                                                              "
      .p (Robert'E'.fSmith,iEsq.                        Stephen.P. Latham, Esq.
              .Guggenheimer;&lUntermyer                    -Twomey, Latham & Shea
        '*    180 Pine' Street                              P.O. Box 398-
              .New; York,JNew York        10005              33 West Second Street
                                                          .niverhead, New York 11901 Mr'.-BrianlR.'McCaffrey
              -Long Island: Lighting ~ Company              Mr. Marc W. Goldsmith Shoreham Nuclear'PowerJStation-              EnergyJResearch Group, Inc.
              - P .O . - . Box f 618 -                        400-1 Totten Pond Road North; Country Road                          Waltham, Massachusetts 02154
              -Wading River, New York          11792
              -Joel Blau', . Esq .- .        .            .MHB Technical Associates
:New York.Public Service Commission          -l'723 Hamilton Avenue The' Governor Nelson A. Rocnefeller          Suite K g7                " Building-                                San Jose, California      95125
              ._ Empire: State Plaza-l Albany ',1 New ' York -  12223              Hon. Peter F. Cohalan Suffolk County Executive
: Martin'Bradley Ashare, Esq. .                H. Lee Dennison Building
              .Suffolk~ County Attorney                      Veterans Memorial Highway H. . Lee Dennison Building-                  Hauppauge,-New York. 11788
              ' Veterans Memorial: Highway Hauppauge, New York ~      11788            Fabian Palomino, Esq.#
Special Counsel to'the Atomic-Safety and Licensing Board          .
Governor.
Panel              .                  . Executive Chamber.
U.S.1 Nuclear Regulatory Commission.          Room <229 1 Washington,.D.C.        20555              ~ State Capito1~
Docketing and Service"Section.
Office of the Secretary                        Atomic Safety and_ Licensing.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory' Commission            . Appeal Board
              '1717=H, Street, N.W..                          U.S.-Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C.          20555                  Commission Washington, D.C.      20555~
Bernard M. Bordenick, Esq.*-                                  .
              .Edwin J.'Reis,.Esq.                            Jonathan D. Feinberg,.Esq.
iRichard J. Goddard,.Esq.                      Staff Counsel
              ; Office..of Exec.l Legal Director              New York, State Public U.S.~ Nuclear Regulatory Commission _          Service Commission.
iWashington, D.C..        20555                3 Rockefeller Plaza Albany, New York    -12223
 
                                                          =                            ..
g                              f    ' -
                        . -                                                                                                                                            ('i I  0                                                                                                                                            'h n:                                                              -                                i(f s
                            )ig
                                                                                                .;p yI                                    (  , ri Q,                          -
w ..                                                              -
4' y; M
d 1
                          <              1 Stewart : M. Class ,- Esq.:-.
fRegional Counsel LFederal. Emergency Man'agement.'    '
                                                ' Agency.              _
i26; Federal-l Plaza:
    };'                            ~ /Ne.w/ York',.News York                            '10278-
                                        "ME . Frank : R. : Jones .
iDeputy7 County 2 Executive-                                              m H ' C Leet:Dennison.-' Building LVeterans. Memorial' Highway (Hauppauge,.New1 York                            11788 l
  "~
                                                    ,'                                                                          ;;;P -
J Alan Roy Dgnner/
KIRKPATRICK,'LOCKHART, HILL,:
s
                                .                          y                                                      CHRISTOPHER & PHILLIPS
                                                                .                                          19001M Street, N.W., Suite 800
: Washington,.D.CL        ~20036
                  ; c-                                                                                      DATE:- June'll,-1984 r;,                      .
(#7-By'FederaliExpress
                                            *: By-Hand > Delivery
                                                                            ~
n ..
1-        ,7
                      ';f_
1p; ;
a
            .p
                                        'i
  ,.r    -
ei < c                4 t
J t
s A
                                                                                                                                  .-.        . - . - - . . - - - .}}

Latest revision as of 00:02, 13 May 2020

Forwards List of Tdi Engines & Owner/Operators Obtained During Discovery.All Tdi Customers Circled on List Should Be Contacted for Operating History Data,Particularly Cylinder Block Cracking.Certificate of Svc Encl
ML20091Q632
Person / Time
Site: Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date: 05/30/1984
From: Dynner A
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, SUFFOLK COUNTY, NY
To: Goddard R
NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD)
Shared Package
ML20091Q620 List:
References
NUDOCS 8406140114
Download: ML20091Q632 (5)
v • d • e


Text

- - - -

Ql ,w-

,Q . - >;

~ '

' 9:' <

ATTACHMENT ~5

e-n .

KIRK 1*ATRicx,6LocxlIAuT, IIILL, CIIRISTOl*1IER & ' l'111LLIl2S

. ; Ng b r.m u.mua benmso ,, ore..o6..oi, nor N" 1900 M STREET, N. W.

y u WasnixoTox, D. C. 2oom.

I 1438 ! BRICEELL iv1NUE , 7ELEPI!ONE!!202).432 7000 1300 OLIVER BUILDING g (- Mt.M*I, TIARIDA 33131: ,

PITTMMMtGII, PENNSYLVANIA 13222

. 303) 374 -8182 0312) 333 4 300 r +

May 30,.'1984

' H wsEmi mater om. xotarR -

I ' '

{[ J20'2/452k70'44 ,

x r g.1 s

..:Eichard M.jGcffari,.Esq.

f0ffice*ofsExec_utive Legal Director TU.S.JNuclearjRegulatoryjCommission 773510ld:Georgetown: Road-vBethesda,1(Maryland' z2081'4;

~

Dear? Dick:

1

[_ Last week,dduringftheidepositioniof Carl Berlinger, Isofferedu to;l furnish.youlwith theTlist-of TDIl engines'and their owner /

operators _, which15uffolk5CountyJobtained:from TDI durinlg.

~

t

[.  ; discovery.: LA copyoof that list.is enclosed. 'I understand that.

+

Jcounsel'fortNew-York State had writtenoto the customers-whose s 1namesLarefcircledito request. operating: history. data on the engines

' arid theirs^principair components . .

~

'D .The' County's[ diesel? experts:believe1that the operating .

- Q~' historyfofsTDIfdiesels in marine service may be relevant-.to the-e> , -Shorehamidiesels",'an'dJduring:their-deposition last week, the NRC's

" diesel 'consultantsf agreed. ~ 'While : Carl Berlinger-~ does :not: believe

~

.  : - Loperatingl data 3forJTDIJdieselsiin non-nuclear stationary _appli--

{ cations (is ilikelyLto 'be' detailedfenough to :beluseful,Cwe: thinkiit -

1:is vorth : findingJout"if'thatiview is correct. 'Our own'ireview"of b; 3 lTDI files 0duringjdiscovery: suggests.that. records of' failures;or.

g, defectsiinLsuch plantsfmay be.quiteLrelevant and' helpful e .

.., ..Accordingly, Suffolk County reques'ts.that;the. Staff contact

.  ; ialliTDI custor.ers .circledEonithe - enclosed -list: tofrequest opera--

. m ltingshistoryidata ofLTDILdiesels, particularly'withLrespect to

? - <

l cylinder blo'ck cracking,; cylinder; head cracking (post-1980. heads),

, AE pistons , c crankshaf ts ,.- andL the t other 16 f significant ' components ,'

~

4 ,

t iaalwellLas fxpwienceJas;to. engine rating, loading, and other

cperating parameters.'(Such. data may_ prove critical to the Staff's

. evaluating;the'TDI! Owners'; Group program, which utilized onlyTa' 4

veryclimited, primarilyinuclear cplant.(tests), data! base.7 We 6y '

believefthat diese1Lowners are far'moreLlikely.toL. respond'to

' : requests;from'1thelNRCithan.to those from the. County or New! York 3; ' State,iespecially:'in" view ofLthe= cautionary. letters previously-

', Lwritten bygTDI.

~' " -

9-3

I ,HM .

j

y  :

7sl ~ #

_ ~KraxrArnicx, l LOCEMART, HILL. GuarzToPHER & PRILLIPS

... --?y CfM,Jr, Richard J.3 Goddard,-Esq.

~ MayV30, 1984~

Page52

. . 2We'hopelyouJfind'the 'nclose'd e information useful, and that, 1 given?the-Staff's responsibility for'. safety in nuclear pla.ts, you will; immediately :act:- to obtain operating -history data that could'-

. profoundly. impact on.the Staff's review of TDI~ diesels.

very truly y:urs , .

' Alan Roy.Dynner iARD/dk (cc i Fab'ian1 Palomino,. Esq.

CarlrBerlinger- ~

. Odes L. Stroupe, Jr.,.'Esq.

. Ralph Caruso ,

Harold'R. Denton.-

. William.J. Dircks-I-

4; g ,.

-'{.

4 6

P 1

k

  • ,.4- . - %.- , + .r, m _ ,, em , . , - . , , , _ , , , . , ,. , . _ , , , , . _ , . . .,i

I eg i.

m *0lKETED USHRC

  • *n ' UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIM JUN 13 P1 :53 JBefore the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board un u. ef hue ;;,-.

00CXEilNG & '5E Pvt .

. BRANCH

)

, In the Matter:of li

-- )

LLONG; ISLAND LIGHTING-COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322 0.L.

N

-)

-(Shoreham-Nuclear-Power Station, -)

Unit 1); -)-

~)

~

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1 . .

.:I'hereby certify that copies of.SUFFOLK COUNTY'S FILING iCONCERNING LITIGATION OF EMERGENCY DIESEL GENERATOR CONTENTIONS, idated June 111',~1984,3have been served on:the following-this.llth day of? June 1984 by:U.S. mail, first class, except as otherwise indicated.

ILawrencejJ. Brenner,'Esq.* Ralph Shapiro, Esq.

1 Administrative: Judge: Cammertand Shapiro

' Atomic-SafetyLandTLicensing-Boardc -9 East 40th Street JU.S.fNuclear Regulatory Commission New York, New York 10016

Washington;.D.C. 20555 Mr. Stuart Diamond

[Dr. George'A. Ferguson* Business / Financial Administrative Judge . :NEW YORKzTIMES

' Atomic Safety and LicensingfBoard-. New York,:New York 10036'

-School.of Engineering Howard University W. Taylor Reveley, III, Esq.*

2300. 6th Street,:N.W. . Hunton!8 Williams-1 EWashington,' D.C.' 20059 P.O. Box:1535-y 707 East Main ~ Street

'Dr. Peter A. Morris

  • Ricemond, Virginia 23212 1 Administrative Judge.

(E Atomic Safety and Licensing' Board Mr. Jay Dunkleberger U.S. Nuclear Regulatory = Commission New York State Energy Office Washington, D.C.' :20555 Agency-Building ~2-Empire State Plaza EdwardLM. Barrett,LEsq. Albany, New York 12223 General' Counsel

.Long; Island' Lighting Company James B. Dougherty,.Esq.

250 Old Country-Road .3045 Porter Street, N.W.

Mineola, New York' 11501 Washington, D.C. 20008 6

I L.

U

, n; Ib "

.p (Robert'E'.fSmith,iEsq. Stephen.P. Latham, Esq.

.Guggenheimer;&lUntermyer -Twomey, Latham & Shea

'* 180 Pine' Street P.O. Box 398-

.New; York,JNew York 10005 33 West Second Street

.niverhead, New York 11901 Mr'.-BrianlR.'McCaffrey

-Long Island: Lighting ~ Company Mr. Marc W. Goldsmith Shoreham Nuclear'PowerJStation- EnergyJResearch Group, Inc.

- P .O . - . Box f 618 - 400-1 Totten Pond Road North; Country Road Waltham, Massachusetts 02154

-Wading River, New York 11792

-Joel Blau', . Esq .- . . .MHB Technical Associates

New York.Public Service Commission -l'723 Hamilton Avenue The' Governor Nelson A. Rocnefeller Suite K g7 " Building- San Jose, California 95125

._ Empire: State Plaza-l Albany ',1 New ' York - 12223 Hon. Peter F. Cohalan Suffolk County Executive

Martin'Bradley Ashare, Esq. . H. Lee Dennison Building

.Suffolk~ County Attorney Veterans Memorial Highway H. . Lee Dennison Building- Hauppauge,-New York. 11788

' Veterans Memorial: Highway Hauppauge, New York ~ 11788 Fabian Palomino, Esq.#

Special Counsel to'the Atomic-Safety and Licensing Board .

Governor.

Panel . . Executive Chamber.

U.S.1 Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Room <229 1 Washington,.D.C. 20555 ~ State Capito1~

Docketing and Service"Section.

Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and_ Licensing.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory' Commission . Appeal Board

'1717=H, Street, N.W.. U.S.-Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C. 20555 Commission Washington, D.C. 20555~

Bernard M. Bordenick, Esq.*- .

.Edwin J.'Reis,.Esq. Jonathan D. Feinberg,.Esq.

iRichard J. Goddard,.Esq. Staff Counsel

Office..of Exec.l Legal Director New York, State Public U.S.~ Nuclear Regulatory Commission _ Service Commission.

iWashington, D.C.. 20555 3 Rockefeller Plaza Albany, New York -12223

= ..

g f ' -

. - ('i I 0 'h n: - i(f s

)ig

.;p yI ( , ri Q, -

w .. -

4' y; M

d 1

< 1 Stewart : M. Class ,- Esq.:-.

fRegional Counsel LFederal. Emergency Man'agement.' '

' Agency. _

i26; Federal-l Plaza:

};' ~ /Ne.w/ York',.News York '10278-

"ME . Frank : R. : Jones .

iDeputy7 County 2 Executive- m H ' C Leet:Dennison.-' Building LVeterans. Memorial' Highway (Hauppauge,.New1 York 11788 l

"~

,'  ;;;P -

J Alan Roy Dgnner/

KIRKPATRICK,'LOCKHART, HILL,:

s

. y CHRISTOPHER & PHILLIPS

. 19001M Street, N.W., Suite 800

Washington,.D.CL ~20036
c- DATE
- June'll,-1984 r;, .

(#7-By'FederaliExpress

  • By-Hand > Delivery

~

n ..

1- ,7

';f_

1p; ;

a

.p

'i

,.r -

ei < c 4 t

J t

s A

.-. . - . - - . . - - - .

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20091Q632&oldid=2800769"