ML19323B104: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 18: Line 18:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:*
{{#Wiki_filter:*
         $N      0
         $N      0 Merch 26, 1980 ps United States of America        M~- CORRESPONDENCE q            //
                      -
Merch 26, 1980 ps
                                                                                        .
        .
United States of America        M~- CORRESPONDENCE q            //
Nuclear Regulatory Commission
Nuclear Regulatory Commission
  %  -
           #  Before the Atomic Eafety and Licensing Board O  In the 14atter of Metropolitan Edison Company, Three Mile Island Nuclear Ltation, Unit _1,_ Docket 5c-289 FOLLO. UP  --
           #  Before the Atomic Eafety and Licensing Board O  In the 14atter of Metropolitan Edison Company, Three Mile Island Nuclear Ltation, Unit _1,_ Docket 5c-289
                    .
FOLLO. UP  --
AAMODT INTERROGATORIEL OF C0iG40!f.iEALTH OF TENTLYLVANIA (LECOIO LET)
AAMODT INTERROGATORIEL OF C0iG40!f.iEALTH OF TENTLYLVANIA (LECOIO LET)
Numbering is continued.
Numbering is continued.
1C. Frovide number of live births at each of five hospitals named in response to Interrog.1 for time periods 7/1/78 to 12/21/78                  l and 1/1/79 to 12/31/79
1C. Frovide number of live births at each of five hospitals named in response to Interrog.1 for time periods 7/1/78 to 12/21/78                  l and 1/1/79 to 12/31/79
: 11. Frovide number of infants screened during 1979 for lancaster
: 11. Frovide number of infants screened during 1979 for lancaster Osteopathetic and St. Joseph Hospitals.
                                                                      '
Osteopathetic and St. Joseph Hospitals.
: 12. Of the seven cases of hypothyroidism reported in period Jan. - Dec. 1979, give date of birth of each case.
: 12. Of the seven cases of hypothyroidism reported in period Jan. - Dec. 1979, give date of birth of each case.
13  Has Dr. Bouden resolved whether possible link between the defects and 'H4I-2 accident should be investigated?
13  Has Dr. Bouden resolved whether possible link between the defects and 'H4I-2 accident should be investigated?
Line 43: Line 33:
: b. If not, why not?
: b. If not, why not?
15  Has Dr. Bouden established any basis for rejection of all environmental link to the defects?        Explain.
15  Has Dr. Bouden established any basis for rejection of all environmental link to the defects?        Explain.
                                                        '
: 16. Interrog. 4 restated as it was misunderstood.        Iancaster data was compared to national data, which established a base line.
: 16. Interrog. 4 restated as it was misunderstood.        Iancaster data was compared to national data, which established a base line.
Does national data include all cases of neonatal hypothyroidism, or are those cases related to inheritance and those cases of undeveloped
Does national data include all cases of neonatal hypothyroidism, or are those cases related to inheritance and those cases of undeveloped a
                                                                                          ;
a
                                        -
                                                    -                        . _ _ - _


                                              . - . _  _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _
                            -
'
    '.
       .      .                        2                                                                                            .
       .      .                        2                                                                                            .
i) 1 1
i) 1 1
Line 70: Line 51:
: 20. Regarding Response to Interrog. 7, what level of confidence                                                            j do you have that the " dose" to the public was an accurate measure of the dose to the women who have birth to the hypothyroidism cases?                                                                j
: 20. Regarding Response to Interrog. 7, what level of confidence                                                            j do you have that the " dose" to the public was an accurate measure of the dose to the women who have birth to the hypothyroidism cases?                                                                j
: a. Does the " dose" you referred to, take into account dispersal of the radioactivity through. plumes?                                                                                      1
: a. Does the " dose" you referred to, take into account dispersal of the radioactivity through. plumes?                                                                                      1
                                                                                                                                          !
: 21.      Regarding Response to Interrog. 8, you refer in para. 1                                                                )
: 21.      Regarding Response to Interrog. 8, you refer in para. 1                                                                )
to "the farm".        Identify this farm by location -- county, township, I
to "the farm".        Identify this farm by location -- county, township, I
Line 78: Line 58:
l 23, . Is there a hypothyroidism screening program in Colorado?
l 23, . Is there a hypothyroidism screening program in Colorado?
: a. If so, provide data available.
: a. If so, provide data available.
24      Provide NCRT Report #5 if possible, or information on its
24      Provide NCRT Report #5 if possible, or information on its availability.
                          .
availability.
e                                                                                                          ,
e                                                                                                          ,


l . .                    .
l . .                    .
3                                        l
3                                        l l
  - ..                                                                            .,
l
* I 25  What is the basis for the suggestion that " external rs Jiation may be twice as effective in producing late effects as are internally deposited radio-iodines'.'? (Response to Interrog. 9, para. 3)
* I 25  What is the basis for the suggestion that " external rs Jiation may be twice as effective in producing late effects as are internally deposited radio-iodines'.'? (Response to Interrog. 9, para. 3)
: a. .Is there any other evidence to support this suggestion?
: a. .Is there any other evidence to support this suggestion?
Line 103: Line 79:
: a. Have any died 9
: a. Have any died 9
: b. Have any had measureable brain damagei
: b. Have any had measureable brain damagei
                                                                                    ;
: c. What is their life expectancyi 29  Provide number..of still births at^ bach.of five hospitals named in response to Interrog. 1 for time periods 7/1/78 to 12/31/78 and 1/1/79 to 12/31/79 Respectfully submitted, 1
: c. What is their life expectancyi 29  Provide number..of still births at^ bach.of five hospitals named in response to Interrog. 1 for time periods 7/1/78 to 12/31/78 and 1/1/79 to 12/31/79 Respectfully submitted, 1
                                                                            "
                                 <            (
                                 <            (
h Wbt . &&
h Wbt . &&
                                    .
It.abjoie!..Aamodt a}}
It.abjoie!..Aamodt a}}

Latest revision as of 20:46, 18 February 2020

Second Set of Interrogatories Directed to State of PA Re Health Effects of TMI-2 Incident
ML19323B104
Person / Time
Site: Three Mile Island Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 03/26/1980
From: Aamodt M
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
PENNSYLVANIA, COMMONWEALTH OF
Shared Package
ML19323B100 List:
References
NUDOCS 8005090263
Download: ML19323B104 (3)
v • d • e


Text

$N 0 Merch 26, 1980 ps United States of America M~- CORRESPONDENCE q //

Nuclear Regulatory Commission

  1. Before the Atomic Eafety and Licensing Board O In the 14atter of Metropolitan Edison Company, Three Mile Island Nuclear Ltation, Unit _1,_ Docket 5c-289 FOLLO. UP --

AAMODT INTERROGATORIEL OF C0iG40!f.iEALTH OF TENTLYLVANIA (LECOIO LET)

Numbering is continued.

1C. Frovide number of live births at each of five hospitals named in response to Interrog.1 for time periods 7/1/78 to 12/21/78 l and 1/1/79 to 12/31/79

11. Frovide number of infants screened during 1979 for lancaster Osteopathetic and St. Joseph Hospitals.
12. Of the seven cases of hypothyroidism reported in period Jan. - Dec. 1979, give date of birth of each case.

13 Has Dr. Bouden resolved whether possible link between the defects and 'H4I-2 accident should be investigated?

a. If so, why?
b. If not, why not?
14. Has Dr. Bouden determined whether links to any other environmental cause should be investigated?
a. If so, what environmental effects?
b. If not, why not?

15 Has Dr. Bouden established any basis for rejection of all environmental link to the defects? Explain.

16. Interrog. 4 restated as it was misunderstood. Iancaster data was compared to national data, which established a base line.

Does national data include all cases of neonatal hypothyroidism, or are those cases related to inheritance and those cases of undeveloped a

. . 2 .

i) 1 1

- thyroid fcctor:d out?

a. shat is the rate of occurrence nationally of (1) hypothy-roidism related to inheritance and (2) hypothyroidism related to totally  !

undevelopedthyroi}d?

17. Regarding Response to Interrog. 5, give numerical basis or other specific reasons why data collected in the last six months I of 1978 "are not as good as that for 1979'? Why wouldn't comparison

[

of six month periods be informative?

18. Have any cases been reported to date this year?

19 Regarding Response to'Interrog. 6, it is not clear how j 0

this interrogatory distortet Dr. Tokuhata's statement, in view of the final statement of your response: " Questions of this type are difficult to answer with certainty." Please explain how I have )

misinterpreted Dr. Tokuhata's statement to the press.

I

20. Regarding Response to Interrog. 7, what level of confidence j do you have that the " dose" to the public was an accurate measure of the dose to the women who have birth to the hypothyroidism cases? j
a. Does the " dose" you referred to, take into account dispersal of the radioactivity through. plumes? 1
21. Regarding Response to Interrog. 8, you refer in para. 1 )

to "the farm". Identify this farm by location -- county, township, I

road or R. D. l

22. Regarding Response to Interrog. 9, can natural background radiation (Denver, Colo.) be equated with radioactive iodine?

l Explain rationale. ,

l 23, . Is there a hypothyroidism screening program in Colorado?

a. If so, provide data available.

24 Provide NCRT Report #5 if possible, or information on its availability.

e ,

l . . .

3 l l

  • I 25 What is the basis for the suggestion that " external rs Jiation may be twice as effective in producing late effects as are internally deposited radio-iodines'.'? (Response to Interrog. 9, para. 3)
a. .Is there any other evidence to support this suggestion?

! If so, provide. j

26. Using answers provided to Interrog.12, indicate which l

births were full term, and weeks short or beyond full term of others .

1 i

27 Provide data for 1978 and 1979 by county in Pennsylvania showing: . j

a. number of births'
b. number of live births
c. number of infants screened 1
d. number of cases of neonatal hypothyroidism
28. Provide data for 1978 and 1979 by state giving same  ;

infonnation as requested in Interrog. 27

28. What is the prognosis for each of the 1979 Lancaster, Berks and Montgomery counties' hypotlyroidism cases?
a. Have any died 9
b. Have any had measureable brain damagei
c. What is their life expectancyi 29 Provide number..of still births at^ bach.of five hospitals named in response to Interrog. 1 for time periods 7/1/78 to 12/31/78 and 1/1/79 to 12/31/79 Respectfully submitted, 1

< (

h Wbt . &&

It.abjoie!..Aamodt a

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19323B104&oldid=2489021"