ML20215K944
| ML20215K944 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 05000000, Shoreham |
| Issue date: | 10/07/1986 |
| From: | Kerr K Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | Clements W NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20213F109 | List:
|
| References | |
| OL-5, NUDOCS 8706250492 | |
| Download: ML20215K944 (1) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:7. _ = ;- -? bf , y naug fi k UNITED ST ATES 1 y' G NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD PANEL ,.3p r ' t - j/ ~ W ASHIN GTON,0.C. 2055$ 'j )$ F C t 12 OCT -8 P 3 :07 October 7,1986 0FFILL O' -t e # i n'ICI 000KEigg 1 SERVED OCT -91986 ^ MEMORANDUM FOR: William L. Clements Chief. Docketing and Services Branch FROM: Kathaleen Kerr Secretary to Judge Morton B. Margulies I
SUBJECT:
LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY J (SHOREHAM NUCLEAR POWER STATION, UNIT 1) j DOCKET N0. 50-322-OL-5 i P" ease serve the attached correspondence on the Shoreham/EP Exercise Service List--Docket No. 50-322-OL-5: 1 1 Enclosures ( As Stated I y i 1 s' /
- 6y B706250492 B70622 PDR COMMS NRCC CORRESPONDENCE PDR'
{ i
~ 9 @h; { bbec [ n. bfan sackers' ,f i e P. O, DOX 162 j MIDDLE ISLAND. NEW YOftK I1953 J September 17, 1986 j i Board / Chairman of Atomic Safety and Lic. US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555
Dear Sir:
f ' Association Enclosed is the Middle Island. Teachers i that I respectfully request Resolution against Shoreham. f the " official record" that this resolution become part o ithin the 10 mile s'. tows opposition f rom employee groups w zone. Sincerely,
- )
3 /, /.. '. e % 6-gw Ron Posnack MITA 2nd V.P. 6 }. %f 6
9 ) j hid)fs befan$ Seacbore' heocialien, bac. P. O. 90X 162 MIDDLE ISLAND, NEW YORK I1953 f a t MIDDLE ISLAND TEACHERS' ASSOCIATION RESOLUTIOS AGAINST THE 3 } M SHOREHAM NUCLEAR POWER PLANT WHEREAS, the n (number] members of this Association, many of whom are women of child bearing age, teach in 7 schools miles of the Shoreham nucleah.pewer plant; and l located within A 1 ) i WHEREAS, many members of this Association live within 10 miles of the Shoreham plant and/or have family members or chil-dren who work or attend school within 10 miles of the Shoreham plant; and WHEREAS, Tederal regulations require that before full power i operation of the Shoreham nuclear power plant can be permitted, f there must exist a workable emergency plan which can be ireple-mented and which assures that the population will be adequately protected in the event of a nuclear accident at the plant; and v WHEREAS, the governments of Suffolk County and the State of New York, af ter extensive a..alysis, determined not to adopt or implem'ent any radiological emergency plan for a Shoreham plant accident and court decisions have upheld Suffolk County's deci-sion not to adopt or implement such an emergency plan; and WHEREAS, in light of the recent nuclear power plant accident in the Soviet Union and its devastating ef fects, this Association is mindful of the potential for, and the dangers associated with, t a nuclear power plant accident, and is mindful'as well of the j q y ;. 7 ~.. ' ~ ~t '. l ~E. ~ ~~~' '.i'jk'lY l- ~ .~Y*,,.llm ~,
necessity of assuring that real and adequate protection can be provided to school children and school personnel before creating f the risk of.such an accident by permitting a nuclear power plant to operate; and Il the Long Island Lighting Company has preparet! an WEREAS, emergency plan for Shoreham according to which P.ILCO employees I would perform functions normally performed by dJ!y authorized . i governmental officials, and the proposed LILCO plan has been ruled by the courts to be illegal and beyond LILCO's authority to j s 1 implement; and l WEREAS, the LILCO emergency plan includes provisions sup-l posedly to be implemented by school of ficials and school person-School District which are purportedly nel in the ungnna the school children in their charge f rom the intended to protect effects of a nuclear accident at Shoreham; and WHEREAS, the Board of Education for the District has adopted a resolution setting forth Longwood its position that the proposals contained in the LILCO plan could not be implemented ef fectively by its personnel and, even if im-plemented, would not adequately protect.the school children in this district in the event of a Shoreham accident, and deter-4 mining not to implement or cooperate in implementing any LILCO-i proposed emergency plan for Shoreham; and A' ..-r~..,_ =:2. ;. ~C s -.,. a c a -: i .u.;.. s, :...g . ~.... . w :,-, %,u 5 n a~..
- % W.w b. g w c.5..
'. 3.g.s- ..se a y ;#-5: + ~ ~../, r e. a-t. g .. ;. u n q ;.s. ; 7% ~.- w,.- %~, 5k.>,.,$..'.~5*;y.5& g;g 2gg,$-$wY J %.:Ny ;E ~:,....n. y.:a. ;. - y-s. m,.
- 3.. q,;.. y y,..
~- py g n e
WHEREAS, the LILCO plan makes unwat tanted and f alse assump-tions and representations about (a) the existence of plans in the District for the early dismissal, sheltering, or Longwood Longwood evacuation of children from schools in the District during a Shoreham accident; (b) the ability and willing-ness of the members of this Association to undertake or perform and particular duties and actions during a Shoreham accident; ~ the purported effectiveness of such actions even if they were (c) taken; and + 4 this Association understands that according to the
- WHEREAS, LILCO plan and representations made by LILCO to the Nuclear the Regulatory Commission, in the event of a nuclear accident at i
+ members of this Association are expected to: Shoreham plant, (a) remain in school, inside the emergency planning zone, to supervise children during an early' dismissal; i remain in school, inside the emergency planning zone, (b) to supervise children while they are attempting to shelter from harmful radiation; accompany children on buses which would take them (c) through the emergency planning zone to evacuation centers to be located substantial distances away from school; S - a'b, ..bg:. 4f.h,.... ..gf, ~c ..,. '..y . y 7. y ..,, v m .e m... n ;. _Q.~Q' , 'y,. f,.No '-. ?-{. " ? ~ ',. t's ~ ,-5 _d '-
l s ~ J remain with cnildren to supervise them in evacuation (d) centers; and, even drive senoel buses through the emergency planning (e) zone as part of an early dismi.ssal or an evacuation of schools; and WHEREAS, the Association is informed that in order to its own employees who are supposed to participate in protect .] implementing the proposed LILCO plan for Shoreham, the LILCO plan l expressly orchibits any LILCO employees who are women of child l bearing age from accepting any emergency assignments that require them to be inside the 10 mile emergency planning zone during a l Shoreham accident; and this Association is informed that based upon
- WHEREAS, LILCO's false assumptions and representations, the Nuclear Regu-
\\ j latory Commission's Licensing Board has asserted that prepared-i ness in the Longwood School District is adequate to pro-l tect school children in the event of a Shoreham plant emergency l the Federal Emergency Management Agency, without even l and that f speaking with members of this Association, has ignored the fact District has adopted no plan to respond that the Lonrwood to a Shoreham emergency and its officials and personnel have received no training on how to respond to such an emergency;
- lp e
.d w - g.;<5 f . - 3.. e y.. ag.
- p..
,.u. x :..t: eg b..pl r qq.:.9.s.,. ;.., y._ r a ,e ~. g.s4.g., ~;. c_,. .= p.; ~- c-r * .Z..j~,. ~.s ~ ..+,s. 7 ".g,g,,:',.. @a '*#. g,*g.g,$ g' 4 _ p.Q:p,, 'g**; E' * ;*...
1 j l l { NOW THEREFOR'E BE IT the representations and assumptions made by RESOLVEO, that I the ability and LILCO and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission about to participate in i willingness of members of this Association (a) I implementing LILCO's illegal emergency plan for Shoreham or n to endanger themselves by performing emergency duties inside (b) [ the emergency planning zone during an accident which LILCO does its own employees to perform, are unwarranted, not even expect I j i without basis, and false; and be it further l I t l i that because members of this Association have im-
- RESOLVEO, portant personal obligations and responaibilities to which they would have to attend in the event of a nuclear accident at commit or agree to Shoreham, members of this Association cannot 4
remain at school during a Shoreham accident, to accompany chil-1 dren on buses during an, evacuation, to remain with children in l evacuation centers, or to drive school buses during an evacuation l and be it-further or early dismissal from a Shoreham accident; f i ( RESOLVED, that the members of this Association are not re-r Longwood quired by the terms of their employment with the k School District to perform during a nuclear accident at Shoreham j i the actions which LILCO and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission j i improperly and f alsely assume or expect them to perfcrm; and be f .I it further .. }) i
- ~,yf,w x.
. % : iy*.c.. .. ; r.: ,,4-i-f,, ~,,j$ e..j..]..Q.t;p. *. a 'j., ..a...- .. ~.-.
,. s l RESOLVED, that based upon the substantial experience of its i l members, this Association finds that the portion of LILCO's emer- l gency plan supposedly intended to apply to school children and, according to LILCO, supposedly to be implemented by school offi-cials and personnel, could not in fact be implemented in the District during a Shoreham accident; and be ten mnna it further RESOLVED, that this Association believes that / \\ in the absence of a workable emergency plan that could be , i impicmented and that would provide adequate protection for school children, the danger posed by the full power operation of the Shoreham nuclear plant should not be permitted. This resolution was passed by the Middle Island Teachers' Association's Board of Trustees'on July 15, 1996. 1 <.,)' "Ks. s Barbara Governale MITA Presidenc ] / h/ c*ve Ron Posnad. 5 MITA 2nd V.P. y A l J ' t . ~;- r,,.. ;. _ 9 .. ~ ' 3 '* ; e p kl.. -{. > <. W % ~ s:ist, ) & ~=f' S.~;'{ ', .lY. i ~- .T r y m W.%, %#r .- M_ _ W . = _._ _ m w., (}}