ML20213F387
| ML20213F387 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 05000000, Shoreham |
| Issue date: | 07/11/1985 |
| From: | Kessel R NEW YORK, STATE OF |
| To: | Palladino N NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20213F109 | List:
|
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8508080766 | |
| Download: ML20213F387 (1) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:- _, i- ((sg- 1 gbNEW YORK STATE,7~M CONSUMER PROTEC 7 (F. 99 WASHINGTON $) gy ALBANY Ny i21G'11AM sc _ . _ 1 1 u-0259425192 07/11/85 ICS IPMMTZZ CSP WHS8 51847a3516 MGMS TOMT ALBANY NY 307 0T=11 0211P EST { 1 CHAIRhAN NUNZIO PALLA0!NO l
, UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$!0N ; I 1717 H ST NORTHWEST i WASHINGTON DC 20555 , 3 l'
6 i - .i ~ I CALL UPON THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 70 IMME0!ATELY HALT THE LOW POWER TESTING OF THE SHOREHAM NUCLEAR POWER PLANT UNTIL THE _ i NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION HAS COMPLETED A THOROUGH INVEST!GATION, l' OF YESTERDAY'S ACCIDENT IN WHICH A VALVE SYSTEM IN THE PRIMARY y
- CONTAINMENT BUILDING WAS IMPROPERLY LEFT OPEN, RELEASING GAS INTO THE
; ATMOSPHERE. THIS ACCIDENT, COMING ONLY FOUR DAYS AFTER'THE START OF i l
LOW POWER TESTING RAISES FUNDAMENTAL QUESTIONS ABOUT LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY'S COMPETENCE TO SAFELY OPERATE A NUCLEAR' POWER
- PLANT. IT IS PART OF A CONTINUING PATTERN OF MANAGERIAL INEPTITUDE EVIDENCE 0 IN THE RECENT NEW YORK STATE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISS!QN 1 DECISION To DISALLOW 1.35 SILLION DOLLARS OF SHOREHAM COSTS BECAUSE
- OF LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY'S IMPRUDENCE. THE IMPROPER OPENING OF A VALVE IN THE PRIMARY CONTAINMENT SUILO!NG MAY HAVE HAD SERICUS CONSEQUENCES IF SHOREHAH HA0 BEEN OPERATING AT FULL POWER. IT IS NO
). COMFORT TO THE CITIZENS OF LONG ISLAND THAT THERE WAS NO RA0!O ACTIVE' RELEASE BECAUSE THERE WAS NO RADIATION !N THE REACTOR BUILDING. !F THERE HAD BEEN RADIATION IN THE REACTOR BUILO!NGe LONG !SLAND i LIGHTING COMPANY'S ERROR COULO HAVE. RELEASED RA0!ATION INTO THE ATMOSPHERE AND NECESSITATED AN EMERGENCY EVACUATION OF THE SURROUNDING AREA. IT IS CLEAR.THAT LONG !$LANOIS GEOGRAPHIC CONFIGURATION PRECLUUES A SAFE EVACUATION OF THE AREA SURPOUNDING '
SHOREHAM. THU$e A MAJOR SAFETY PROBLEM COULO HAVE OCCURRED. IN V!EW OF THESE CONSIDERATIONS I URGE THAT THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISS!0R PROMPTLY UNDERTAKE A THOROUGH INVESTICATION OF YESTERDAYf5 ACCIDENT AS aELL AS THE LARGER ISSUE OF THE LONG ISLAND LIGHT!NG COMPANY 13 COMPETENCY 70 SAFELY CPERATE SHOREHAM AT LOW OR FULL POWER. LOW POWER TESTING SHOULO BE SUSPENDED IMMEDIATELY PENDING COMPLETION OF THAT INVESTIGATION. RICHARD M KESSEL EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR NEW YORK STATE CONSUMER PROTECTION BOARD 49 WASHINGTON AVE ALBANY NY 12210 , 14: 13 EST [ MGMCOMP N gjiogqRo % cF tf m =E=LY 3Y WMcM.WEESAGE, SEE :Ev!?SE E05 C2 WEE !:N UWrs ?OL' . ME! SwCNE NUMegas
l 1 -nf/ . _ . P903.&'J.... * *+ A' ^ ' ' '.. r n- * . T .i n '
- _
(l . .g . b -
'W
- SHOREHAM WADING RIVEM CENTRAL SCHOOL 01". AICT l 5horeh.im. New Yo,rk ll*%
. e tni v.'v aw u.c;m i ll.n 4 o a (
whard R. 60cemus. Fd. D. , s, ,, c
; w,w=,en.Jem of w am,,
Is dl() I,
- d. h.
. dU e me we mermerav /er tem re,m MM MG . / lg ...
> , . ..r ,.' 6 f/
.~.2...-.,,
a 4 i l um. su owew oes=ww= .41%
- 7 .-
l g . f 3aly 12, less .? i' 15 A." -5 P C29
=
d'f {i Betten B. Margulies, Chaitsan : ;' akemie safety and E.icensing Boerd ,- 1 j gelted States Buclear Regulatory Commission ,f 2 Doom 402A cy i Best West gewer 4354 East West Eighway %. !
' tethesda, naryland 20814 .y
%, . : .a l np% e- -
/
l Deer nr. asegulies , .
- v. p'J.a -
..v-rit:& , MV4 W. l: # ? " ,the morehea-medtag River meerd of[mE'scation has "the licensing of 1 long he ee;,
- entsegulatseest. .
te,QT y
.;Tthetithem'pleets;should mmannae poser he.- , WWe;therefore ,
- M
'engport efgerts;to'Essentats7 tavaluate emergency plans for the area aresm8~thehof ~ % clear" Power
~
.HM b Stettaa. a v
. ./ag
?;.M W 'ct %. R...n. dMfk~%fEQ x 7 *i ~k "".: "
k g% W Wyp Q y :.a .. tk ^M 5 M of Education l 4 sometime consti .aThoamittee' ~ 1 board mambers,
. members, high
'GM
%g passets,.manimiseenemen,. 's,chool bes' company %
scheel students,' school bee' '
.., ?
plan for
! .,sagemeestatives.te .
e.screview,.a ha
<;.am
.3 mh ,; a
"'peteetes' .
' district;~had. .
~ #'
'has drivess amt statt volunteered to be. .
. as.hasserivess* ant.
- and.mia h === to ?
W.
, tsensportfall;the TWT
- . k iipeblic, private,.
'i
-ame parochial,#at one" vy time to7any" site . .
ldeiisignated in an .
.y..pg ,,, ..
7 The school district has noar moved to reactivate this a committee and'we are prepared to communicate and collaborat;e j with aar organisation or government agency charged with the " g responsibility for emergency planning for the Shoreham suelear Power Station and to participate in tests of the emergency plan. s , 5 l i l Cordially yours, a 1
,M M LM f Albert G. Prode11 F - President, Board of Education ..y' */
d
,G 1 f n
mDR eso AD3M 0S0003F2 m - A '.h
- '7 ; '.up 1
i
\
s FDR g l A %.
,f V . 24-j w
l N'MI'E W M'IM'"M MPM.'WVgig.g gy gi = ., r
]
)
I i Meet & U m.,FA3.., ,..u - r l , &I June c7,19c5 1, , Q' t 1 It'. & Mrs. Roger clin $l N " " *f h8) Joan Street l Ronkonkoma, N.(. 11779 , ., ) . l M l Jeans A. Laureness, Chairman '85 MG -6 P a :29
~ Atessa safety a Lisensias soard J .
u.a. anstear ansaastery commission .n i i mahtagten, 0.c. 20555 f,e
. . ,. ~s . .
-( .
3
" i Daar k. Zaarenson: i L 4 Ag' eg g Ta1.and M ' M 'sitisens, we are writin( to fou ,
l kne esprose ear esteege at peer greeting a' $$ 1pyr testing license for ,d
,.r$y lths merehma..amm1mme Steer, a. Fla,at
.~~.
(suusi m,,,.m , s ,. tqr.~the ~1 mag Island Lighting Co.).
~-@.Q?&g*fy/ Q'y.Ci&.hh6L.py
) ,l & l ,
~ fS iy *i'y; & : u_th s 21essee,,.the N.B.C.._has , O_
; tan are'sese pos are'auere
. g g gg, ,,,-~ ~
w aGutagWamargency plan sub ,
, y#!Q j,j i aatted ter a prisets esegesy,:1.e41IE00 estetitute far that of a duly 41 elasteds m M 3eter F. Cohn3aa 18 7
mf,'in and of himself, a duly 3: ( elected gasesemiset. ;As a.aatterV stais .very matter is now in , .; .
.,T,ehalas has, overstepped his :jl
~
i litagst&en.' It"is'aggereet' to all' -
. eathenity.. -J; i:a:& g.49%$gM5Q- w -
. .) p;d 9
. . . . . a ;;., , a As for ths 4 34L. Bened, we believe yes,have acted very irre&iMs.
I I .l move. .Long Islanders hr.ve I
~
And in this ease, yes've ande a mest " mover Caee(afeetais asl2hemeeshing ' 7 No emergensy evaamation , l ples easTgtse Zeeg falamd y==4danda "
. Skis license has. .-
, been greeted ukils the -44 is still unregelved. Is it 4 year th to past, to liessee"and then, therefore, ecent the suffolk County Legislature,.to aggreve the~eveemstien plan besasse *their hands are j
; ties , .,
,. w
... n. :.
. .w > p..v.:q g ,-
m Over the ;, ears be issue of Acrehms has been very depressing -- as LILCG
- has shallenged > sot only our health and prosperit;,, but our constitt.tional ,
rW to sneere our eum ante future. Heuever, recent1s there has been I too mesh petitieel thiemaMng'. Apparently if LILCO can't get its own way playing by the rules, they'll change the rules. ( i We streegly urge you to please w i, the appeal of the Suffolk Count .J 1egislature on this licensing decision. Help us regain our faith in -Y cur - .e.t.tive ,o m nt. y marm. Very trul . ar c , :
%e
*/
4 Roger & Earbass cli'n'
- N
. r.c.,.n.
w
'!.n't. :
90
** i a
4 -3
. ~ . . .
T a i - my p. > %
.3. i MAET NUC8f R p atos,atrro rac..
..w a.g g .. g- ,s i u
l
. j :i MALVERNE UNION PREE SCHOOL DISTRICT ..
use.wm-en=== = i 6 ROADSCHOOL '
.. ROCalvuA CSmW. NSW YORK IIS70 '
514487 7733 ""WO AUG ~I .. T
\ -
"e j '
4 ;, g . g essapeemdue of theads .
- 9 7 ;
) I June 20.L9Ya 4 -5 gg ]
d j j l Mr. Morton 3. Margulies . 1 u i A M nistrative Law Judge 4
. ,-p i
, Ate _i.2, Safety and Licensing Board Panel ,
l U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Coeusission . JJ q a..(i nasahington. D. C. 20555 ; 1
.d ; i Dear Mr. Marguliest hh j
.. {
'].. y' t[./
Please be advised that the M1verne U.F.S.D. Agreement to cooperate with the Red Cross in the event of a national disaster . i. WZ
]
was not intended to indicate any agreement or disagreement with the ' 5 j opening of the LILCO Plant at Shoreham. ,
.q
.. 1i lile would be most cooperative with the American Red Cross if ".'i1 -
an emergency occurred involving Long Island residents; however. we do - J, .j j not condone LILCO's implication that our school district has given . ,.
, gj them, consent to use our facilities.
- q Thank you for the opportunity of clarifying this matter. ,
,y@
' g;:l.y
.i S yours. -]
]
I
. kN) me J. Tolle -
fj id JJT:rab f ec: Members, Board of Education Community Action Network ,
. .j l t
if l i y,
..m- ,
"W E Yt f.h *s
'W"$ t y m op,,.e50712 -
Y PDR ADOCM 0S000322 . O PDR ,1
!h ---
3 .. r.~ % .. x . ,, , . .. b e i 1. SERVIGS yM . ,-- + % g g 7 ,, CJUNTT OFFICE OF THE D15TRICT WPlRINTLNDIN T Of KHOOL% i
'F 0. S.. .
m v4 N . h, 4
~
'85 #6 -6 P d .2%ne to,1985
.. . ... j ,
]!
m 4' s . . ; - I Mr. Itseton B. Margulias P ' '&
.'*.;) '
Administrative Law Judge Atomia. Safety & Licensing Beard Fanel [ U.S. Emelear Seestatory Commission
- i Weekiastem, D.C. 20555 j.e..i ,
' W:j:4 q Deer Mr. Marge 11 met Jo .; .' '. . -
. ,. :va-fe % ;4.,uG..
ux < e ,
.v, .
I hose seeently hecean aware that ,the,American Red Cross sad the Long
'"g.wf' f taland Lightaas Campany have designated'the campus of the Nassau County -
'i>;
30CES Saliahury Center as a relocation ' canter in the event of a radio-logical emergency at the Shoreham Nucisar Power Station. '# - cw %.g .gqq@giep.;gf3g g g p3g g
. g:q g Fleese he advised that Reseen 30 CSS has setsred'into'any agreement *
, .M with tha'ameriasm Red Crose~er LIECO'ii 'iIsi a"relsestion center. dN I er as a damaneand=me4== and maastor1 4 $ ff ~'. for a Shoreham emetgency. '%<i
- Amy seek agreement would have to hieve'boem 7speroved by. us, and no such
- c. .". /' .'
. : appesual han been geomhed.'33hs has entered.into an agree-
, r. gramme e edMarssenM Cesse 7 'WW ,
as mese Mahoitersfbut*that #~ ]' 'e.uie $f 30CES st Mc'the hisfacilities' Red . 'N ' j Crees ar LIMB perm &asise to use'est.'esisius si a relocation center, or as 4
. a c'e4== and semisaring' **ait**ws M.to LI1CO's proposed t
.d di plas'es ' dest with in radialogical amargipfEyi at'L5heMehem. ' -
- p. y . , ..y ,e.:. y. 9.g : , ,g( ,
;Q..
In additism, the Governor of the Stata of New York has' determined th~t a i , the Stata of New York will not participate in the implementation of the . off-site radiological eastgemey response plan for Shoreham proposed by ,J< j, LILCO. In accordamos with the Governor's position, the campus of the -O Salisbury Center will not be available to the American Red Cross or .ll = LII40 for use in implementing the LILCO Plan. - As Acting District Superintendent of the Nassau County BOCES I am advising you that we have not entered into any agreement to serve as a d relocation center, or as a decontastaation and monitoring facility, in *;
- he event of a radiological amargency at Shoreham.
Sincerely yours. J v . '
, A EJMsyk 4,7 Edward 4 Mufp b w
,;py f1 !
g Acting strict Supe intendent 1 ; i O w vv.ana --* 3' , 9 FDR p
- i \ SN .
illaburv Center 9 Valentine, Road and ihe Plain Oad % e thun %m York 1 t wo e ';in.w.8 00'
'O '? { 1
\ '
.,t:-,u t nuMEGM i JRO C. L UTIL 9 0,,. Q. ,se. j Q g }
I' LYNBROOK PUBLIC SCHOOLS LYN S ROOK UNION FREE SCHOOL OlSTRICT ,, ,,,, w,..'* j 1 Ot$TRICT AO MINISTR Af tV E OFFIC ES .J . .
*^\*
ATLANTIC AVENUE SCHOOL. ATLANTIC AVENUE h L.YN S R OO K, NEW YORK 11563
**7 * *
'65 S2P 25 A10 58 C .- ; . ~. - ,; .
l CCChib".sse%im6;rnusn l sune)A@NT CP SCMOOLs
\.
June 28, 1985 grg/ED$EP23 nob 1 Honorable Morton Margulies l Administrative Law Judge Atomic, Safety & Licensing Board Panel , i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l Washington, D.C. 20555 ,
Dear Sir:
It has come to my attention that we have been placed on the Shoreham i evacuation plan as a victim relocation center. .I would like.you to know that Lynbrook has never been approached by the Red Cross for participation in this matter. l Our schools are neither equipped, nor capable of. handling ) i emergencies in the event of an atomic disaster. Consequently, ' l i please do not consider this district as a participant under the l present approach. We will want more details before we can make an l intelligent decision. Sincerely, , r y^tQ)t1[*,\. M (/ Dr. Bern Seiderman Superintendent of Schools BS:jp cc's: Mr. Rasbury , Mrs. Sherwin e 44
'g EQUAL OPPORTUNITY / AFFIRMATIVE ACTION EMPLOYER HPP -
l
.f.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA i ^ NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION l In the Matter of I LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY l Docket No.(s' 50-322-OL-3 l . (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station) I j l i
* :1 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE i l I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Ltr Lynbrodk Public Schools have been served upon the following persons in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR section 2.712. .
I Administrative Judge Administrative Judge ! Alan S. Rosenthal Chairman Gary J. Edles i , Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal < Board Board j U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission , , Washington. DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555
- 1 i
Administrative Judge l Howard A. Wilber Administrative Judge ! Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Morton B. Margulies, Chairman Board Atomic Safety and Licens'ing Board [ i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 i I t Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Jerry R. Kline Frederick J. Shon Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board l U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 -
.1 Donna D. Duer, Esq. Edwin J. Reis, Esq. -
Law Clerk Office of the Executive Legal Director Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington. DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 5 W. T. Reveley. III, Esq. C. K. Mallory, III. Esq. Hunton & Williams Hunton & Williams ! 707 East Main Street 2000 Pennsvivania Avenue, N.W. Richmond. VA 23219 Washington. DC 20036 ; 1 3 .
- 5 s
..g
, _ . . . . . --. . . . . _ _ . _ . - - . - . . :_ _a \
. v ,
6 j Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 1 Herbert H. Brown, Esq. Lawrence C. Lanpher, Esq. Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Kirkpatrick & Lockhart .i t 1900 M Street, N.W., Suite'800 1900 M Street, N.W., Su.u 900 d Washington, OC 20036 Washington, DC 20036. *
.i
'l Stephe.%,0. Latham, Esq. James B. Dougherty. Esq. .j t Twomey, Latham & Shea Attorney-at-Law ,
33 West Second Street 3045. Porter Street, N.W. Riverhead, NY 11901 Washington, DC 20000 l Anthony F. Earley, Jr., Esq. Nora L. Bredes
; General Counsel
- Executive Coordinater - -{ )
Long Island Lighting Company Shoreham Opponents Coalition l
. 175 East Old Country Road 195 East Main Street . ..
)1 Hicksville, NY 11801 Smithtown, NY 11787 l ,
f Dr. Robert Hoffman Spence W. Perry, Esq. -
, Long Island Coalition for Safe Living Associate General Counsel j P.O. Box 1355 Federal Emergency Management Agency 1 Massapequa, NY 11758 500 C Street, N.W., Room 840 i Washington, DC 20472 -
Jay Dunkleberger Stewart M.. Glass, Esq. -
) } New York State Energy Office Regional Counsel Agency Bldg. 2. Empire State Plaza Federal Emergency Management Agency ,
Albany, NY 12223 26 Federal Plaza, Room 1349
, New York, NY 10278 4
Jonathan D. Feinberg, Esq. Fabian G. Palomino, Esq. Staff Counsel i l Special Counsel to the Governor New York State Public Service Office of the Governor Commission - State Capitol, Room 229 3 Rockefeller Plaza Albany, NY 12224 Albany, NY 12223 i Mary M. Gundrum, Esq. Peter Bienstock i Esq. $ New York State Department of Law New York State Department of Law j Two Norld Trade Center, Room 4614 Two World Trade Center, Room 4614 i ! New /ork, NY 10047 New 'f o r k , NY 10047 ,, i! 1 A ! 4' l / ,; 6 1 <
-O 4
t
. _ . . . . . _ _ _ . , - - . .. . . _ _..._.4 t ,
Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 ( 1' Martin B. Ashare, Esq. Suffolk County Attorney Suffolk County Offices - T H. Lee Dennison Bt;ilding . Veterans Memorial H.ghway .; Hauppauge, NY 11788'
; 4 r
ff Dated at Washington, D.C. this j i 23 day of September 1985. j . { j g,- ,
~~
6iiii ~ i ihE"5EdEeiahy~$i~the om$iss[on
- I
,n
,.3 P a
.i .
h* i l
! 9 i
I t
'b i
i 4 h A
-4 i
j . d'
- :iq
.D,
" .h i
0 4
(.
. %' . *p?,
l s ,. s l- ] a DOCKETEC 1 c "**<4 USNRC -
!, 'j UNITED STATES , i
- 2. ' 'n NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION -
l s, .,. . . . / WA$mOTON,0.C. 20555 '85 JUN 28 P1 :25 , q June 27, 1985 ' FFiCE e CF Ent. - . 00CXETING & SEih 9i BRANCH Docketing & Service Branch USNRC WRVEI) JUN 2 8 1985 l Please serve the attached letter from Anthony ) and Mary DellaVecchia on all parties on the service f list for Shoreham (Emergency Planning), Docket No. 50-322-OL-3. - i Thanks, i l Joyce McDow - 1 Ext. 24329 { 9
- t. .
1 a i J
-s !
4 Ma
-m ny -%a. ,~ n I v 92 jpYs ,
l . June 16, 1985 l Mr. & Mrs. A. DellaVecchia ! 151 Ave. O Holbrook, N.Y. 11741 l 4 i James A. Laurenson, Chairman lj 1 Atomic Safety & Licensing Board , U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm. We.shington, D.C. 20555 j
Dear Mr. Laurenson:
1 fI As residents of Long Island, we are writing to you to express ) our outrage at your recently granting a 5% low' power testing.11cenae *
. j for the Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant (owned by the Long Island' Lighting Co.).
'1 de age sure you are aware that in granting this license, the #
i N.R.C. is virtually ignoring its own regulation by allowing an emergency plan submitted by a private company (namely LILCO) to
- substitute for that of a duly elected government. You might argue that it appears that the Suffolk County government is now fully .
+
cooperatinF with this evacuation plan as submitted -- you are wrong, Mr. Laurenson. PETER F. COHALAN is fully cooperating, yes. But - Peter F. Cohalan is not, we assure you, in and of himself a duly . elected government. It would serve you well to note that this very matter is now in litigation. One judge has already found . Mr. Cohalan has overstepped his bounds. Mr. Cohalan thinks not - we'll see. As for the A.S.&L. Board, we believe you have put the cart before , the horse. In this case, a most dangerous move. A move which jeopardizes the safety of the residents of Long Island. This license has been granted while the evacuation plan issue remains unresolved. Is your plan to grant the lic?nse and then, therefore, expect the - 1 Suffolk County Legislature to approve the evacuation plan because "their hands are tied"? , l It must be said that this entire Shoreham issue over the years (but most especially recently) has been quite enlightening. There
- has been more blatant " underhandedness" and political whitewashing than one would imagine possible. It seems that the motto is "IF YOU CAN'T OPEN IT GOING BY THE RULES, JUST ' CHANGE THE RULES!"
We cannot urge enough that the appeal of the Suffolk. County Legislature on this licensing decision be taken most seriously into I consideration. This county is becoming more and more disillusioned with the " fairness" of governmental proceedings on this matter -- j we pray that you will restore our faith in representative government, i 'l Thanking you in advance -- S'ocerely, j k , j Anthony
%m Mary DellaVecchia a
v QM/o2W 49f
~
- ._. . _ . . . . . _ . . . , , . . . . . ~ ._ ... ,
_ _._ _ ._ . a
. 'N o
UNITED STATE 3 0F AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$10N In the Matter of i .)
. l t LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY I Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 '
l 1 (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station) l l
. I 4 l
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Letter to Judge Laurenson have been served upon the following persons in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR section 2.712. i t Administrative Judge Administrative Judge 'j Alan S. Rosenthal, Chairman Gary J. Edles -j Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal . '} ' Board Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 ~ 1 Administrative Judge . I Howard A. Wilber Administrative J'udge - il Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Morton B. Margulies, Chairmam Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 1 , U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission-l Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 j Administrative Judge Administrative Judge i Jerry R. Kline Frederick J. Shon i Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board j U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Com-ission m U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission < Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Donna D. Duer, Esq. Edwin J. Reis, Esq. ,5 Law Clerk Office of the Executive Legal Director Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 l W. T. Reveley, III, Esq. C. K. Mallory, !!!, Esq. Hunton & Williams Hunton & Williams l, 707 East Main Streat 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. j Richmond, VA 23219 Washington, DC 20036 3 _e ;
- l
,. 4- ,
t .; . l; . p . I Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 I. - l Herbert H. Brown, Esq. Lawrence C. Lanpher, Esq. Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Xirkpatrick k Lockhart j. 1900 M Street, N.W., Suite S00 1900 M Street, N.W., Suite 900 '; j Washington, OC 20036 Washington, DC 20036 ' I i Stephen 8. Latham, Esq. James B. Dougherty, Esq. 4 Twomey, Latham L Shea Attorney-at-Law 33 West.Second Street 3045 Porter Street, N.W. , l Riverhead, NY .11901 Washington, DC 20009
; I I'
j Edward M. Barrett, Esq. Nora L. Bredes General Counsel Executive Coordinator
' ', j)
Long Island Lighting Company Shoreham Opponents Coalition 1 250 Old Country Road 195 East Main Street .. $j { Mineola, NY 11501 Smithtown, NY 11787 l
~
I l Dr. Robert Hofiman Spence W. Perry, Esq. ! j Long Island Coalition for Safe Living Associate General Counsel - P.O. Box 1355 Federal Emergency Management, Agency Massapequa, NY 11758 500 C Street, N.W., Room 840 , Washington, DC 20472 l l ,' Jay Dunkleberger New York State Energy Office Stewart M. Glass. Esq. Regional Counsel
) l Agency Bldg. 2, Empire State Plaza Federal Emergency Management Agency Albany, NY 12223 26 Federal Plaza, Room 1349 l New York, NY 10270 _
{ l Jonathan D. Feinberg, Esq. l Fabian G. Palomino, Esq. Staff Counsel , j Special Counsel to the Governor New York State Public Service Office of the Governor Commission ! State Capitol, Room 229 3 Rockefeller Plaza l Albany, NY .12224 Albany,'NY 12223 g Mary M. Gundrum, Esq. Peter Bienstock, Esq. New York State Dacartment of Law New York State Decartment of Law Two World Trade Center. Room 4614 Two World Trade Center, Room 4614 3 New York, NY 10047 New York NY 10047 j 1 14 11 ,
'/
"'/ll4'
. 01 f
> Occket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 ) 1 1
i l Martin B. Ashare, Esq. Suffolk County Attorney Suffolk County Offices - d) 4 H. Lee Dennison Building . j Veterans Memorial Highway j + Hauppauge, NY 11788 Dated at Washington, D.C. this
/
28 day of June 1985 - / .
.. /..G. .. ..... j/. . s. ....
Office of h e Sycr t a r y 'o f t
.ommission
]
I q
! l j 1 i 't
.,. .' d, e
? 't
! .I .g a
'1
' $l
- i I
. 1 j!
I
-1 i .
t
-i.
of i q$b
.d
,1 s .
=e'} .
~
'Y) io
- 3 .1 U h' 3 E R
= eR O C '.'i~i'. F..Mw ,-,,, .. g g g &g/,, . [
4 oJ*g 0.00 ~ June 27,1985 l l l Mr. & Mrs. Roger Olin 'l
$f # @- . 1483 Joan Street i Ron'<onkoma, N. f.11779 James A. Laurenson, Chairman
'85 MG -5 P d :29 Atomic Safety & Licensing Ecard U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission .. '
- Washington, D.C. 20$$$ Q; , [ '
2.^ ' 9
Dear Mr. Laurenson:
l As residents of Long Island and concerned citizens, we are writing to you to express our outrage at your granting a 5% low-power testing license for the Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant (owned by the Long Island Lighting Co.). l l We are sure you are aware that in granting this license, the N.R.C. has j virtually ignored its own regulation -- by allowing an emergency plan sub- l mitted by a private company, i.e., LILCO to substitute for that of a duly. j elected government. Peter F. Cohalan IS NOT, in and of himself, a duly l elected government. As a matter of fact, this very matter is now in j I litigation. It is apparent to all, that Mr. Cohalan has overstepped his authority.
, As for the A.S.&L. Board, we believe you have acmd very irresponsibly. l And in this case, you've made a most dangerous move. .Long Islanders have never faced a crisis as farreaching as this one. No emergency evacuation l plan can give Long Island residenta real protection. This license has i been granted while the evacuatior. plan issue is still unresolved. Is it your intention to grant the license and then, therefore, expect the Suffolk County Legislature to approve t'ae evacuation plan because "their hands are tied" ?
Over the ;7 ears the issue of Shoreham has been very depressing -- as-LIICO has challenged not only our health and prosperit), but our constitutional right to secure our own safe future. However, recently there has been too much political " whitewashing'. Apparently if LILC0 can't get its own way playing by the rules, they'll change the rules. We strongly urge you to please support the appeal of the Suffolk County legislature on this licensing decision. Help us regain our faith in . our representative government. 1 Thank sou. l
'iety tr.tl; jours, L f** f
^
~.
.. ( & ::e , )
Roger & Earbars'Olin
,;f I
2
~
, Q(- 4 e [ m % 6 4 TV tP
g _ 1
. 'J f k C.. .hb
. MALVERNE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT US.S.O. e tt ADMINaSTRAfloN SuttotNG
WOOOFIELO ROAO SCHOOL ,
ROCKVILLE CENTRE. NEW YORK 11570
. $16-887 7733 "ai,, , a ,.'lj Q ] "f M
- v.
- JAmas J. tous -.
c y' W
'j 1 sup ine.nd.ne .# sowa l
- 1 June 20, 1945 9 o5 /,UG -5 P4 :29 4 i
c'F . i Mr. Morton B. Margulies
% .q.f ; 'g.y Administrative Law Judge :aANO- j Atomic, Safety and Licensing Board Par.el
- l
. U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 -
Dear Mr. Margulies:
Please be advised that the Malverne U.F.S.D. Agreement - l to cooperate with the Red Cross in the event of a national disaster was not intended to indicate any agreement or disagreement with the I opening of the LILCO Plant at Shorehem. . I 1 We would be most cooperative with the American Red Cross if an emergency occurred involving Long Island residents; however, we do , i not condone LILCO's implication that our school district has given them consent to use our facilities. - Thank you for the opportunity of clarifying this matter. 1 . Sin re yours, me J. Tolle j JJT:rab cc: Members, Board of Education Community Action Network , c. F 4 J >
. .e is -[,
4 ; o g 9 \ 3f? -
l L
~
' * ~ -v l M gQM .}
.; raea,sinwrne.. .
l SYOSSET CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT OFFICE OF THE sL*PERINTENDENT Sot'TH wood $ Jt1908 Ml0H School Pf L L L A fs t. St o88 7. N E. Y O R E i l f 9. ii. n.ii..
.W,W .'.!'. T . M ". . .
. e.n,W^Hi ""A^ E S M MvW o ~' !
'"f.a?."
. . .N.. ,.^."f.4.17 . . .......,
. . . . . .. "PW.v.a, v.a - ,
a =a~< a < .'
"!,.?#.,.Y".,*. t.".!.!,1.tP.e
'"Md30';,.,v;;,, ' . t.,
l 'E5 M -6 P 4 '29 1j 5, June 19, 1985 . kI 3 Mr. Frank M. Rasbury b~" ' f~ Executive Director of Nassau County ... i Chapter of the American Red Cross , 264 Old Country Road .W i Mineola. New Jork 11501 *\.,4 ' M
Dear Mr. Rasbury:
E.9
- i,?i I have recently become aware that the American Red Cross and the Long Island %.
Lighting Company have designated Syosset Central School School District as 5 a relocation center in the event of a radiological emergency at the Shoreham
'u - h;CA Nuclear Power Station. .
.2
-b:vq[
t ..s. . Ploese be advised that the Syosset Central Schoo1~ District has not entered into any agreement with the American Red CrossJer LILC0 to serve as a reloca-
, n:/ . , .. . -
fN tion center, or as a decontamination and monitoring facility, for a Shoreham $ y) i" emergency. Any such agreement would have.tp hayje been approved by the Syoss'et central'5chool District and no such approvei tiis.been' granted. Syosset School- '
~
- i. '
, District has pefeitted the American Red Cros's'td Ifst our District as a mass , .,
t care shelter, but that-listing does not q"rast the American Red Cross or LILCD M permission to use our facilities es a re ocation cienter, or as a decontamination .
- c. -
and monitoring facility, pursuant to LILCO's' proposed plan to deal with 1 al emergency at Shoreham. ,
. , ' ii l l
In addition, the Governor of the State of New York has detamined that the State
' of New York will not participate in the implementation of the offsite radiological .,
emergency response plan for Shoreham proposed by LILCO. In accordance with the . i 2 Governor's position, Syosset Central School District will not be available to the American Red Cross or LILCO for use in implementing the LILCO plan. Consequently, as Superintendent of Schools and Chief Executive Officer of the 4 Syosset Central School District. I am advising you that we have not entered into any agreement to serve as a relocation center, or as a decontamination and 4 monitoring facility, in the event of a radiological emergency at Sherehr. Very truly yours, ,5 ' 1 4
.&=- 1>.
Philip E. Tieman ' , ..gf Superintendent of Schools ;J.} . . .
'^
5 PT:c1 cc: Morton B. Margulies, Adm. Law Judge M At W c. Safety & Licensing Board Panel - U.S. Nuclear 0.eyulatory Com. .Washincton,0.C
~ "n.TR .a W~ -
~) ll
~
.. - COUNTY OF SUFFOLK - 00.
i . 1 PsTam F. Co m w --d
- sueiroL4 cou,try esacutive *: a '
'.
- C . .t
- - . - Maart h snacLay AsQams - t' ENT OF 1.AW
.n...
._C'""^"**'"' 4.m.6wi v .
' ~
BY TELECCPY ._.y June 11,1985 '@ J@l.24'N' p pppg " ** . q
, , p o gzz. erc. . - - - - - " .. . c. ..
PR$0. & Um. P** -
~~~'~"' IU ~ ~
m F M' t
. ,,. 00CniitHG & SEW.' i
- BRANCH '
XIRKPATRICK & LOCREART - 1900 M Street, N. W. Washington D.C. 20036 h s -- l
-(^', ATTENTION: Herbert Brown M d@ ll M -
1
, l 1
i Dear Mr. Brown . - -
'l
. . . . . Your office, as you know, was retained as outside * ;- - .
.. . -counsel pursuant to a contract signed by the County:dbeecuti.ve.- ; a
. - - l
... . :That. contract was entered into pursuant to lagfsistive- reisciutierr: t u - : ;
No. 43-1982 delegating complete authority to th.e Country' 1Descotive' - : : : ~ ;
-J 1 l
- ,to:tetain counsel to represent the County in al1 Shoreham :related.': t:.-u -
proceedings. . i -
. i
- 1
\
- 4., , The County Executive 's authori ty to control theselec ' - - - -
tion of counsel in connection with.Shoreham is not sitered or -' -- - - - . diminished in any way by the recent court decision concerning -
- l Executive Order No.1. The letter you received f rom individual , I m members of the County I.egislature requesting that you continue. as
- t. counsel for the County is of no legal significance.- . . . - - :
\ .'
Accordingly, the County Executive's letter to you~ o# - - - - - ;- - June 3.: terminating your services f or the County remaint Tn 'eff ect. - M
.- .-Under no. circumstances are you or any mesnber of your firm authow ' + - - -
. 12 ed to speak f or or represent the County. I am adv.ised, although' .
. 2. have not received actual notice of the same, that you recently: - i -
. requested, on behalf of Suff olk County, an adjournment! cf NRC - :- : - -
proceedings in light of the Court decision concerning: Executivo -' ' -
. order No.1. Your request f or an adjournment was made after you- -
* - - 4
.. were discharged as counsel for suff olk County and vas :ne'e auther -' - -
12 ed. Any further attempts by your of fice to 1.ntervene in any . 4--*-' , legal proceedings relating to Shoreham will be .reporred to' the-: '.: ' - M appropriate bar association. "
-' - - "- u--- -
a
%g 4 mADOCK me-ese611 i 05000322 .
PDR j
... ., ..q) . . .m s m _ _.... _ ,. .... _._ _ . _ _ ._... _ . _ , _ m _ ...._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ,_
.f y E .UATRICK & LOCXHART 4- . -. . :: -
J ane 11,1985 r' .. . - '. - Page 2 - s-
._e . . . . . I must reiterate our demand that you return all County . - - - -.
1 : . : files in.your poasessinn to th's . office. Your insistenc~e 'on- hold-
.- :: ing County flies hostage tr., your demand that you bis ecrntinued at ': 2.+ -- -
, . counsel in this case is not only outrageous, frut.1's al'so a' com ~ ~ - -
-. plate breach of your ethical obligations as an .etterney.. Tour - * * :;
- .uhlawful retention of our flies is compromising our abil-ityto. . --
participate in pending Shoreham litigation. As you well knew,' - this office does not have a complete set of files. ~It i s,; there- '~
- fore, imperative that you surrender the flies 'to this office imme- -'
diately. . +
-. t.. Your pr:mpt cooperation and attention to this matterr: :: : : :1 ? > : . :
/S,
\
will be appreciated.
- :' 5::rr: -
.- l Very t-Q urs, .
e.. .-
~. ~- i $- 1 1
w
~
F. . C MARTIN BRADLEY ASHAR ..:: 4 Suff olk County Attorney AR.t./ dag ,
,k ? ' 01: .
1 cc Michael Blume, Nuclear Regulatory Commission M . : e e. E .: 5 . . : .
- a r.: 2=:
Samuel K. McCune, Kirkpatrick & Lockhart : 2. .+ -
.- : ; ; ' *~-*:r Nunzio J. Palladino, Chairman, NRC : :
- . . n - -
James K. Asselstine, Commissioner, NRC . i. + - m .:- . :- - '
^
Frederick J. Bernthal, Commissioner, NRC *i- . 1-- .. ?::: Thomas M. Roberts, Ccamiasioner, NRC :. : : : ,. - : .-.- r\ ^. Lando W. S ech, J r. , Commis si oner, NRC ..: :- - +:'
.:n .:e
\. 7 '
9
- S*
/ ~;9 N i q 1 4
~
l alPMl!Mistllll'lltHliWlJil?lMllilillll'llil*ll()({lli;litihtl]Hillitflig!ltfff\;;glggy.gt!*peliislfity!\ II?]g(llllll,'jgo}',;*;
*n\Yeseistu:.ttFfot* tap,ft::acI:liti:n!,iinsl14llsutillst.'tI't;;ii!!fntitslliitIllti:'nllllillfl'IllHfilHlllHisll:iDlill'!PI'!lW!\:!!Hlil)lllll*I5
. s ,. --......-..;.., .-. , ,
' :"~~ l }
g A DANlbL P. MOYNtHAN
. ,8stur YOMM 3CnHeb hiss J>enale 1 WASHINGTON. D.C. 20810 SERVED JUN 117985 June 11, 1985 'l 00LXETEE USNRC DOCKET NUMBER
*noo. & tmL ,-pac...p -J22-Ce[ ,
15 JUN 11 P3:45 ;
Dear Chairman Palladino:
GFFll.E Or ud:. c, . - 00CXEilNG & SERvn - ; BRANCH ! I understand that the Cormission has scheduled a possible vote l later today on the matter of the low power operating license for > the Shoreham nuc1'ar e power plant. :4 l Ii Given the present legal wrangling within Suffolk County, there , ( is reason for the Commission to refrain from any licensing action until the disputie is resolved, and until the Commission provides an opportunity for che legally authorized representatives of Suffolk County to present the County's views on this matter. Sincerely, -
%L Daniel Patrick
'u nihan a
.I Honorable Nunzio Palladino Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1717 H Street, N.W. '
Washington, DC 20555 3 i l
.~h
- 1y
-If!
u ci.nid,30W g , -
o - 4
, , UNITED STATES OF AMERICA .
j s . NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION , In the Matter of I ! I i LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY i Docket No. (5) 50-322-OL-4 I I l (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station) i 1l
\ 1l t :
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE jl 4 l
! hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Letter Moynihan to Palladino have been served upon the following persons in accordance with the s requirements of 10 CFR section 2.712.
Administrative Judge Administrative Judge ! Alan S. Rosenthal, Chairman Gary J. Edles " l Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal , j Board. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
*l Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 ,
7 Administrative Judge ; Howard A. Wilber Administrative Judge ; Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal James L. Kelley, Chairman ) Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Administrative Judge Administrative Judge l Glenn 0. Bright Elizabeth B. Johnson Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Oak Ridge National Laboratory ~ U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P.O. Box X, Building 3500 Washington, DC 20555 Dak Ridge, TN 37830 j t , Ellen C. Ginsberg Edwin J. Reis, Esq. Law Clerk Office of the Executive Legal Director Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ; U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 i Washington, DC 20555 Donald Irwin, Esq. C. K. Mallory, !!!, Esq. Hunton k Williams Hunton & Williaan j 707 East Main Street 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Richmond, VA 23219 Washington, DC 20036 g 4 t 4 4
.1 I
N
, s em
' ~
i- < , ,
~
Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-4~ l l l .) I j Herbert H. Brown, Esq. Lawrence C. Lanpher, Esq. .' j Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Kirkpatrick & Lockhart j 1900 M Street, N.W.i Suite 800 1900 M Street, N.W.,' Suite 800 ) Washington, DC 20036 Washington, DC 20036 ) Stephen B. Latham, Esq. James B. Dougherty, Esq.
- i
, Twomey, Latham & Shea Attorney at Law i 33 West. Second Street 3045 Porter Street, N.W. f Riverhead, NY 11901 Washington,.0C 20008 -
l 1 i i Edward M. Barrett, Esq. Fabian 6. Palomino, Esq. J, ,
, General Counsel Special Counsel to the Governor i Long Island Lighting Company Office of the Covernor . .i i
250 Old Country Road State Capitol, Room 229 ' i Mineola, NY 11501 Albany, NY 12224 ' Martin B. Ashare, Esq. l Mary M. Gundrum, Esq. Suffolk County Attorney i
; New York State Department of Law Suffolk County Offices - i Two World Trade Center, Room 4614 H. Lee Dennison Building New York, NY 10047 Veterans Memorial Highway -
i Hauppauge, NY 11788 j i I Dated at Washington, D.C. this l 11 day of June 1985 u ' i
/
....... \... . M................ 1
', Office of the Secretary of the Consission 1
4 [ .
+ , :&
*p 4
., . Y) l 1 BOARD OF COOPERATIVE EDl'CATIONAI, SERVICES i
" OF NASSAU COUNTY cof^$ i, h
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS
- E00 ?nYt.N?c..$t 5 -
, .. c* n .
- gg.0 g g4,. 1;j
'85 AUG -6 P d :29 tune 10,1985
-l
.. n G C.,' C T ,. . c. ' ' ,
l 3 Mr. Morton B. Margulies Ad.ninistrative Law Judge S*^.HC" *{ { Atomic, Safety & Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission >
,[
Washington, D.C. 20555
Dear Mr. Margulies:
- )
I have recently become aware that the American Red Cross and the Long 'j
. Island Lighting Company have designated the campus of the Nassau County -
3 BOCES Salisbury Center as a relocation center in the event of a radio- ! logical emergency at the Shoreham Nuclear Power Station. - s i Please be advised that Nassau BOCES has not entered into any agreement ! with the American Red Cross or LILCO to serve as a relocation center,- ' i or as a decontamination and monitoring facility, for a Shoreham emergency. I Any such agreement would have to have been approved by us, and no such ! approval has been granted. The Salisbury Center has entered into an agree- i l ment with the American Red Cross concerning the use of BOCES facilities i as mass care shelters, but that agreement does not grant the American Red . ] Cross or LILCO permission to use our campus as a relocation center, or as f a decontamination and monitoring facility, pursuant to LILCO's proposed l plan to deal with a radiological emergency at Shoreham. j
' In addition, the Governer of the State of New York has determined that the State of New York v111 not participate in the implementation of the
'l j off-site radiological emergency response plan for Shoreham proposed by ;
LILCO. In accordance with the Governor's position, the campus of the , 9 Salisbury Center will not be available to the American Red Cross or l LILCO for use in implementing the LILCO Plan. ! i As Acting District Superintendent of the Nassau County BOCES, I am l advising you that we have not entered into any agreement to serve as a j} relocation center, or as a decontamination and monitoring facility, in j the event of a radiological emergency at Shoreham. j; Sincerely yours, s , s '. i Q s
, EJM:vk Edward J -Mufphy/ '
a Acting' strictFSupe intendent ; M]p 4 Salisbury Center e Valentines Road and The Plain Road, Westbury, New York 11390 e 516-997 8700 Q,500v]CWOU u
m; _ JHassapqua lluMic $ctcols 7l em. . .mi.mm. m m *- , i
. ....= . um....gA.._ ynf -
4 l l l MASSAPEQUA. NEW YOMM 11754 , . an.na.14600caos sie . ). ,
...,e.c. WPICE W f>e SWWe*ef 8Wed7 k_ l M W M A*A M h scheduty memesse
; \ d' '48E8 J " ' "' ' %"***.*see.* s tr oe n s wnuansa suwe a s ww..
']k I
f 1 g ago, ,,, pies o asera aussies.
*****
- oh *==='a' h
^
( ) u eu M M -6 P 4 3 ~a w* * *~w**'='",. - . w e ,- l meee na.naam , e o. e.c . . '}( , l e , wasuna su a e o, -. v - - y_ ; I [i N ,* g e , . , , ;= L van agosmteps0 Jn toers t>e===
- Da==.. ,
ire MsC
- i,Q {
9> . l June 6, 1985 d., _. 2 l
~
@'f,D ,
o
..a_
- - age Lee Judpo atente Safety and Licensing Penel
~f
. S.Y
,fg jj j!
3 ansleer sogalatory Ceemissies " gg.f , a seer Jedge assystas: - ,. .N.,g - l
,..,.^ - ,'.
i 'T,Q 8 I the perpose of this serrespondoese to to provide you with inforestion ' -.s7 '. i pertoietey to the desteise of the mesespequa seerit[of Education regarding ,
%. g )
the stilisettee of its facilities ender the Amerieen Red Cross meergency .ylj- l
- i = coster Flam for Baseen Coasty. .v.
,u
.J ' Ai u ' f;Q QQ%' , , ,, . ,. ; ., ,
l myrIpsevideyeewith'f;',tgqyMy...a sayyr of the'1stter;that tsee-seat to the , WQ;~ ' < : j, meertees and Crose en March 11; 1995. We forward'this letter at the specific . i l regaaet et a seesdent tulee -is a oesher of a coalities opposing the opening of -f f ',l the mesehen Wading R11mur Fleet. ,, IF. O ' ad < l
,;.,3fc ..; c . .g . ; ,
.i, ,
Q l i fer peI$ poses of clarification, the Necespequa Board of Education has not M l considered the question of utilising the schools as an evacuation center in % ?' insteeses of as energency at the shorehas Nuclear Plant. ~,
.f i
12 yee regoire any additiamat inforestion, please contact the undwrsigned I{ l
! et yeast convenience. Ii }*
1 i very truly yours, 4 f C k*, c4 LAA.dbh . I Heroert J. )Lusenau , l I i Superintendent of Schools f i 3 7 e NJP/nm , s ., ,
. a
+ * %% *
- ?
a .ag .
~ U d,-
0801 S=J0712 -, PDR ADOCM 05000322
;f , O PDR
.?
l 1 - A .. .%.il%$.b
! d ! $1 g,v voeg' h: l
~
L ,, ' . .. @'. , w ge..h y
,4 <.. ;
- =(m
/ p c.eu..n % ~ .,7 Le3 g;d g+.n ege.n,
~ .teses., S,een f9. Y. 4~ teds,"
,,,, gg,,,,,,,, .g wAgenossestestsees em,,,, y. s +
eme e.ee. ** m.eme
'M j ay, .[, ...
%r. " , 9e6 test 9 . amen tees sts~ $65 L . '. M
?
, ;;,, J me s, toes
- c. u " 4: . . ,
. .t s
% M -6 *P :29 ,p I .
g' ' ) . '
;. . .. t:
s $. . ' [ ~
. - . c.J 1
' :f norton B. seargelies 48.f.l l ;
b, o Administrative Lear Judge me ate, safeer a s.Aeonsin, noare panel
' W.S. Naclear Regulatory Commission y gg.g; .$y e.. .,
- I '
- , u !
. ,,s t ..C.
.Myi ly. '
, . ~
i Dear att. Margulies j This is to inform you that contrary to the documents dated July 25,-1964, 11 filed with the Iloclear Regulatory commission by the American Red Croa the Berricks Public Schools has not'. agreed to any plan with the Red Cross', ,;
,' }',; j or LII40 for any of its schools or community center to serve as, shelters , i:
as part of a meclear evacuation plan for the shoreham plant. , I .. , > t Appsominadely eidek years ago, Serricks agreed to cooperate with the and ";j r Crees by offering its schools as shelters in the event of n.tural, disasters (floods, fires, etc). No approach has been made to Herricks since that time by the med Cross to anodify. that agreement to include nuclear evacuatiou. .
,_ j ;
',. 2' -
y tee see s' real distinction between our initial agreement' with the Red - Cross i and this latest attempt to exploit the Herricks Public Schools, suggesting A f that, by inference, it is in agreement with the "ILCO evacuatten scheme. ' W object stronously and do not endorse any such pian. ! 3 J Sincerely, i
, 'j.
&p]-
' Ira J./ Singer - p g
Superintendent of Schools . ! IJS:1s t I cc Mr. Frank Rasbury
-f f
Executive Directvr Nassau County Red Cross . , .a
,.3# *
~l k.
. a T
'9900070794 850712 I)/
nDR ._ ADOCK . 0 3 000'322 1
- v. . ..
- l .
9/.
) ..
' '))3
't e
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGOLATORY C0ffi!SSION
-- g[. j ,
' ~
COMMISSIONERS: d + Et 00f.xgC
'J5" Nunkie J. Palladino, Chairman .
Thomas M. Roberts James K. Asselstine Frederick M. Bernthal W 3 5 P202
- Lando W. Zech, Jr. .
-m i[ocbihG5'5Ei -
BRANCH ( In the Matter of SEVED JUN -51985 7 LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY Docket'No d-322OL ,- 4 (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station) ORDER , In a Motion dated April 1,1985, Suffolk County and the State of i New York requested the Coninission to investigate the U.S. Department of ' Energy. In support of their motion, movants attach a March 27, 1985 New
/ York Times article describing 00E documents which,'according to movants, Q,)
reveal DOE's effort to improperly " lobby" the NRC and FEMA, and to
" force" the NRC to license Shoreham. The State and County assert that these activities are " repugnant" and " unlawful."
We deny the motion. .Our reading of this motion is that the
" unlawful" conduct o'f which movants complain involves some unspecified
. .. l b
9
.i
{V&jh 5 a
.,,,4 a
5t P .* ' ' s u) lp y ./. ' A
a .- UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD -lt Administrative Judges: Dotyrg
' hic Alan S. Rosenthal, Chairman June 3, 1985 .
rd A ber # -4 A9:51
. CFF'l Da sick.7,,
) 00CX:.TpG a spy;;,;' i In the Matter of )
#'* 1
) i
! LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322-OL-3 'l
) (Emergency Planning) )
(Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, ) ,, j Unit 1) g .,41985 ) ORDER , On the morning of May 31, 1985, it informally came to - the attention of this Board that, on the prior day, the Suffolk County Executive had issued an executive ord.er 1 having a possibly important bearing upon the pending appeals from the Licensing Board's April 17, 1985 partial initial i i decision in the emergency planning phase of this operating license proceeding. Counsel for the County was thereupon ll
- 1 orally notified by the Secretary to this Board that, ~ if the information that had been received respecting the executive ,
i order was correct, the Board would expect to be seasonably ! so advised and to be provided with an indication of the County's position respecting the impact of this development upon the pending appeals. e d 1 l LBP-85-12, 21 NRC .
. ;1, h
2.f f
]
/ .
- i 2
- Still later on May 31, counsel for the applicant I
provided the Board with copies of Suffolk County Executive Order Number 1-1985 dated May 30, 1985, together with cooles - of certain newspaper articles (one of which contained the , substance of an interview with the County Executive). This submission relieves the County of the necessity of furnishing the Board with the executive order. But the Board still e> pects to receive the County's position ! s respecting the present significance of the executive order -l as soon as that position has been formulated. Once the l. County's views are in hand, the Board will solicit those of the other parties to the proceeding (including, most - particularly; those of the State of New York). In the meantima, the terms of this Board's May 15, 1985 order, as amended by its May 20 order, will remain in effect. It is so ORDERED. 4 FOR THE APPEAL BOARD O.. b S e b C. Qan Shoemaker Secretary to the .) Appeal Board ] tt . Edles.did not participate in this order. 4 l j t
.i m
.d a
$' ]
$i s
I'l-50 ~.5@!A MINEOLA UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT 200 EMOR R6dD MINEOLA, NEW YORK 11501 (516) 741-1242 BOARD OF EDUCATION APPOINTED OFFICERS 3 WALTER GLENN ROBERT GROMAN ... .... C L E R K w ident CC' r.y,, JAMES R. WICKS - .TREASU RER
HENRY A. WEINSTEIN ... . COUNSEL MARJORIE KU8AT -
Vice Preeldent J E M.SHERR E ll Sll ROBERT RICKEN , LARRY EGAN SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS
- f. J.
- lCCau:.y u itsu y a n.<. .
BRANCH gg. JUii111985 May 31, 1985 I
- Atomic Safety & Licensing Board, ~
N.R.C. Washington, D.C. 20555 Gentlemen: . ; The Mineola Board of Education has directed me to inform you ' hat the Mineola School District never gave permission to the Red Cross to use our facility as an evacuation base in the event of an accident at the Shoreham LILCO plant. Sincerely, i Robert Ricken Superintendent of Schools RR:ds ,
~
C.Sharleene Sherwin, N.Y.CAN , ,, dl' l ;L t
..a 4 '
._~....--a.............i. . - - _ ._._._m,.. . . _ . . . . . _ , , , . e , ,, ,1 o
4...au......,3L66JALM8 n oc. G G " PLAINEDGE PUBLEU'UUiOOLS HICKSVILLE AD. BETHPAGE. N.Y.11714 ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES (516)?35 8100 CEORGE M. KANE su,uNfNoeNfo,se e s May 29, 1985 '~:j l AL8tRT N. UNO assisfANT $UP(4NTINQgNT WILUAM HULKOWER eusam Nieu l .~ dl r. :' .,
=- - 4 r!
00CKETED USNRC :
't
'85 Jldl1 Mi:29 CFf!CE OF SEC: QA '
00CXETING A SERV d 3RANC4 Mr. Martin Margulies . Atomic Safety & Licensing Board .
. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission gg g y g Washington, D.C. 20555 -
L lx
Dear Mr. Margulies:
The Plainedge Board of' Education has recently become ] aware that the American Red Cross and the Long Island Lighting - Company have included Plainedge Public Schools as one of a number of relocation centers in the event of a radiological , emergency at the Shoreham Nuclear Power Station. Please be advibed that the Plainedge School District does not agree to serve as a relocation center, or as a decontamination and monitoring facility for a Shoreham emergency. Sincerely yours, .
/$. .
George H. Kane= .
,1 Superintendent of Schools l
GHK/jw cc: Mr. Frank Rasbury American Red Cross , , i ,.
}l
- q e
.j 1- .
. .}
', J:\ <
]{,.
(f .
i UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION l In the Matter of f I , LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY I Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 . 1 (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station) 1 I
. l .
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
- hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Six Letters to Licensing Board have been served upon the following persons in accordance with the .
requirements of 10 CFR section 2.712. Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Alan S. Rosenthal, Chairman Gary J. Edles Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cosaission
- Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555
- i Administrative Judge Howard A. Wilber Administrative Judge '
Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Morton B. Margulies, Chairman Board Atomic Safety and Licensing. Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Jerry R. Kline Frederick J. Shan
- Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board' U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Consission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 i
Donna D. Duer, Esq. ' Edwin J. Reis, Esq. Law Clerk Office of the Executive Legal Director Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 W. T. Reveley, III, Esq. C. K. Mallory, !!!, Esq. Hunton & Williams Hunton & Williams 707 East Main Street 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Richmond, VA 23219 Washington, DC 20036
]
Ik a
s 4 I ' Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 Herbert H. Brown, Esq. Lawrence C. Lanpher, Esq.
- 1 Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Kirkpatrick & Lockhart 1900 M Street, N.W., Suite 800 1900 M Street, N.W., Suite 000 Washington, DC 20036 Washington, DC 20036 !
s
' Stephen B. Latham, Esq. James B. Dougherty, Esq.
Twomey, Latham & Shea . Attorney at Law 33 West Second Street 3045 Porter Street, N.W. Riverhead, NY 11901 Washington, DC 20000 Edward M. Barrett, Esq. Nora L. Bredes ' General Counsel Executive Coordinator - > Long Island Lighting Company Shoreham Opponents Coalition 250 Old Country Road 195 East Main Street , Mineola, NY 11501 Smithtown, NY 11787 j Spence W. Perry, Esq. Jay Dunkleberger Associate General Counsel New York State Energy Office Federal Emergency Management Agency Agency Bldg. 2, Empire State Plaza i 500 C Street, N.W., Room 840 Albany, NY 12223 - Washington, DC 20472 ) Stewart M. Glass, Esq. Fabian G. Palomino, Esq. Regional Counsel Special Counsel to the Governor Federal Emergency Management Agency Office of the Governor 26 Federal Plaza, Room 1349 State Capitol, Room 229 How York, NY 10278 Albany NY 12224 ; Jonathan D. Feinberg, Esq. I Staff Counsel Mary M. Gundrum, Esq. - New York State Public Service New York State Department of Law Consission Two World Trade Center, Room'4614 3 Rockefeller Plaza New York, NY 10047 Albany, NY 12223 Martin B. Ashar e, Esq.. Peter Bienstock, Esq. Suffolk County Attorney New York State Departmen'. of Law Suffolk County Offices - Two World Trade Center, Room 4614 H. Lee Dennison Sulloing New York, NY 10047 Veterans Memorial Highway Hauppauge, NY 11780
# e il
f 4 Docket No.(s) 50-322-OL-3 Dated at Washington, D.C. this
/ )
11 day of June 1985 ,/ U $ hG .%.....w. / .8............
./.4. "
Oftice of the Secretary of the Commission ( i 1 e i I I 1 l l 1 e b i l l 1 I I s ',
- i 4,
e
]
u w. y jo2,2/ d b 8
$C"oo I 2
.a HICKSVILLE PUBLIC SCHOOLS o
!$(i, 8,
+,g O
= , ADMINISTRATION BUILDING
- DIVISION AVENUE -
HICKSVILLE, NEW YORK 11801 5 S
- 878 1
^
0 '. rC i. - OR. CATHERINE J. FENTON L"bl1d C Supenntendent of Sch00ls
'85 JUN 11 All :30 l May 29, 1985 CFf %:. E ' e. -
00C4E!!Nd & SE?; - BRANCH Mr. Morton Margulies Ed0 M 111985 Atomic Safety & Licensing Board I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l
, Washington, D.C. 20535
Dear Mr. Margulies :
It has come to my attention that the Hicksville Public Schools- - i have been improperly designated by the Red Cross as part of an evacuation plan for 2400 people in case of a radiological emergency at the Shoreham
, Nuclear Plant. .
e . Permission wris granted by the Board of Education in 1975 for the .tise of our schools by'the' Red Cross in the event of a natural disaster. In- i ciuding our schoo?.s without any knowledge to the administration'and the l
- Board of Education for such a joint, venture with the Shoreham Plant. does ;
not meet with our approval. Use of o,ur schools by the Red Cross is hereby j withdrawn. ! As always, our school district will respond to public need and we will be.willing to discuss the needs of our residents at some future time. Very truly yours,
, _q L p.-
Q f '; M ..i_._) /
-~.
!M
,CJF: bis Catherine J. Fenton Superintendent of Schools cc: NY Community i Action Network l
j' i I t , t.
- L
_]
.g
$41CK8VILLE $$NCR HIGH SCHOOL
- MICKt /ILL8 JUNICR M10H SCH00t. . $ URNS AVINUE SCHOOL . DUTCH LANE $CH00( ,
EAST tfREET SCHOOL . FORK LANt SCHOOL
- Lit AVENUE SCHOOL
- OLO COUNTRW ROAO 8CM00L f *){D f l
. ._ _ . . . . . _ . . . . . _ _ _ _ _ . . ._ .x
$6 p;;c;,
c 31 g.jfa d4dI y ELMONT PUBLIC SCHOOLS stuoNT UNION FRf( SCHOOL CISTR8Cf ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES . ELMONT ROAD. ELMONT. N.Y 11003 . , .i
)
.M h . ) $ $1$ -l "
00f.KEIEO DR. RICHARD J. CALIENDO U$hiRC Supenntendent of Schools May 29, 1985
'85 JtN 11 All :29 .j CFF..ile 5.L. .
OCCoc'" G & 5W!- 5 " Ch Mr. Morton Margulies Atomic Safety and Licensing Board j; United States Nuclear Regulartory Commission SERVED JUN 11198R-Washington, D.C. 20555 -11 l1
Dear Mr. Margulies:
-j ; . i \
This letter will confirm that the Elmont Union Free School - District has not authorized the use of its facilities for evacuation ~ purposes in the event of a disaster at the Shoreham facility. The use of Elmont's facilities for this purpose will have to be negotiated separately by the American Red Cross and have the approval of the Board . ., of Education of this district. , Yours vp y truly,
.i Dr. Richar J Caliend
'Superinte de of Sc ois jm -
j cc: New York Community Action Network Board of Education 1 it' i i;
' 4, 7
~p 6' .
dj ! wr]
- 1 utetsupu r
. I}}