IR 05000010/1978020
| ML19338F249 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Dresden  |
| Issue date: | 07/11/1978 |
| From: | Belanger J, Christoffer G, Hind J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19338F244 | List: |
| References | |
| 50-010-78-20, 50-10-78-20, 50-237-78-18, 50-249-78-20, NUDOCS 8010140638 | |
| Download: ML19338F249 (30) | |
Text
.
'(
(;...
,_
r*
.
,t
-
.:
.
,
,
.
.
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION OFFICE OF INSPECTION AND ENFORCEMENT
'
REGION III
,
Report No. 50-10/78-20; 50-237/78-18; 50-249/78-20
'
Docket No. 50-10; 50-237; 50-24?
License No. DPR-2; DPR-19; DPR-25'
Licensee:
Co=monwealth Edison Company Post Office Box 767 Chicago, IL 60690 Facility Name: Dresden Nuclear Power Station, Units 1, 2 and 3
-
Inspection At: Dresden Site, Morris, IL Inspection Conducted: June 20, 1978
/3/9i Inspectors:
n
.
-
.
/d b/4 W h 6[?c ///
"
G. M. Christoffer 7 /7[
Approved By:
.A
C ief Safeguards Branch Inspection Su : mary Inspection on June 20, 1978 (Report No. 50-10/78-20; 50-237/78-18; 50-249/78-20)
Areas Inspected:
Reviev of licensee corrective action taken with respect to matters discussed during a telephone conversation between Region III representatives and mcabers of the licensee's staff on April 21, 1978 and confirmed by "Immedic.te Action Letter" dated April 25, 1978.
These matters related to the apparent falsification of guard firearms qualification
,
records and vital area door check records at Dresden Station.
Results:
Corrective actions requested in the referenced Immediate Action Letter (IAL) have been satisfactorily completed.
00 10140{3f
.
"
(-
,
,
w.
%r
-
.
.
.
.
'
'
DETAILS l.
Persons Contacted B. Saunders, Dresden Station Security Administrator A. Brown, Account Supervisor, Burns International Security Services, (BISS)
,
L. Creed, Sergeant, BISS
,
D. Rollando, Guard, BISS
M. Foley, Guard, BISS J. Murphy, Watchman, BISS 2.
Licensee Corrective Action / Region III Immediate Action Letter dated April 25, 1978 On April 17, 1978, Region III was telephonically advised by the licensee that their audit of guard contractor records and interviews with three guards disclosed that firearms qualification records may have been falsified.
On April 19, 1978 licensee representatives met with RIII to discuss the above matters.
Additionally, RIII was advised that a guard sergeant, on being questioned about guard activities, admitted to the Dresden Station Security Administrator
-
that he instructed guards to complete the door check patrol sheet covering vital area doors even though other guard activities pre-cluded their making the required checks.
On April 21, 1978, RIII called the licensee to discuss actions initiated /to be initiated to correct the licensee-identified items of noncompliance.
This discussion was confirmed by RIII in an "Immediate Action Letter" (IAL) issued April 25, 1978.
(Enclosure A)
'
By letter dated June 2, 1978 (C. Reed to J. Keppler), the licensee advised Region III of corrective actions taken in accordance with the IAL.
This inspection confirmed the licensee's response.
The following identifies each corrective action irem required by the IAL, the licensee's response to that item as not.ed in their
letter of June 2, 1978, and the inspection findings.
,
IAL Item 1:
Take immediate steps to requalify those guards iden-tified to date who appear to have questionable or falsified firearms certifications.
Completion of certification will be witnessed by CECO.
To be completed by May 5, 1978.
Licensee Response: A requalification program was undertaken to assure that those guards that had been identified as having
-
questionable or falsified firearms certifications receive the-2-s
.
--
.
.
.
se:
b 7=
k..
.
,
.
.
.
i proper qualification..The requalification started on May 3, 1978 and was originally scheduled to be completed by May 5, 2978.
There was, however, some difficulty in requalifying these individuals and additional time was needed.
Mr. L. Bean contacted Mr. J. Donahue (Region III) on May 5, 1978 and informed him of a required extension until May 18, 1978. to complete the requalification, completed by May 18, 1978
~
Inspection Findings:
Seven guards were identified by.the licensee
as not having been properly firearms qualified.
During requalifi-cation, three of the seven failed to achieve the minimum score and are no longer acting as members of the Dresden guard force.
The requalification was witnessed by a member of the licensee's staff.
The inspectors reviewed records documenting the requalification.
IAL Item 2: Take immediate steps to determine the extent to which
-
additional guard force members are not fully firearms qualified.
If such non-qualified guards are identified, they will be requali-fied and their requalification witnessed by CECO.
To be completed by May 29, 1978.
Licensee Response:
The requalifications of the remaining members
.
of the guard' force were not questioned. We did, however, initiate requalification for the entire guard force on May 23, 1978.
This
,
requalification is being observed by a Commonwealth Edison represen-tative to ensure requalification is properly completed. We expect the requalification of these individuals to be completed by June 16, 1978.
- Inspection Findings:
All remaining members of the guard force requalified, with one exception.
The latter is currently serving-j l
as s' watchman (unarmed).
Interviews with members of the guard force disclosed that requalifications were witnessed by represen-tatives of the licensee's staff.
l i
I'AL Item 3:
Only authorized individuals who have been fully firearms. qualified will perform as guards.
<
Licensee Response:
All individuals that were identified as having j
falsified firearms qualifications were not permitted to carry'
weapons..These individuals were not used as " guards" but only as
" watchmen" until the requalification was completed.
Inspection Findings: The licensee's response was confirmed through inspector observations during the course of the investigation con-j
-
'
ducted by RIII, and through interviews with guards who were identified i
as not having been properly qualified.
l
!
.
i-3-
. -.
_
.
_
.
_
.
.
'
.*
k= =
Q._
L;;.
... _.
.
.
.
=
,
.
.
I AL Item 4 : With respect to apparent falsification of vital area
" door check" records, take steps to assure that pertinent door checks are being made as required and associated documentation is maintained.
To be completed by April 28, 1978.
Licensee Response:
Corrective action to assure that door checks are being completed was initiated as soon as we discovered the fact that there was falsification of these documents.
On April 13, 1978 the guard force was instructed that f alsification of. door checks,
would not be tolerated and that anyone coatinuing this practice
,
would be subject to dismissal.
To prevent recurrence and assure that door checks are~ completed and documented, Dresden Station has ordered'and installed at all the exterior vital area doors a key punch clock (Detex) with " key
~
stations." These keys are " punched" at the time the door is checked.
.
Inspection Findings: The referenced April 13, 1978 verbal instruc-tion to guards was confirmed through guard Laterviews.
As of June 1,1978, vital area door checks are being verified through the use of the Detex Key Punch Clock in addition to the door check sheet documentation.
.
3.
Exit Meeting At.the conclusion of the inspection, the results were reviewed with'
the Dresden Station Security Administrator. He was advised that satisfactory corrective action had been conpleted with respect to the items noted in the IAL.
Enclosures:
A.
Immediate Action Letter dated April 25, 1978 B.
Letter dated June 2, 1978 (C. Reed to J. Keppler)
.
-4-
<
t
...
s...
,-
,
's1 ET.TERIOR D'OR CIECE Sh, t..
.
'
'
r
'
.
.,
TDS TDS TDZ TDS TDZ TDC TI.d TDS
..
-
-
~
GD'!S TNT GD'S INT., GD'S ITU.
GD'S DC.
GD'S DC.
GD'S DC.
GDtS INT.
GD's I
i IOCITD IDCIID IDCRED ILC)2D IDC)TD IOCKED l IOC)2D l 70010
^fYES NO YES
YES NO E
NO YED NO m
NO YES NO YES NO
.
.
.
l
.
..
l
..
~
l
..
l l
i
-
-
.
i
,
i I
i
.
!
. !...
_... __.._.L....
.._.
.._.
. _L l
.. l-
.
.
l
.
.
.
.
j i
-
.
.
I
-
!
!
I i.
-
m-I l
I I
l
'
.
,
,,.
i l
l l
l l
l l
!
I i
l l
!
I 12.
i i
o.
!
i l
I i
I I
i a.I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
s5 I
!
I I
I l
l l
l l
'6-i l
l
!
l l
-
27-
!
l l
l l
j 18.
l l
-
!
l l
l l
l i-
I I
I l
l
!
l l
20.
l
-
2'-
i l
l l
l l
l i
l l
l 22.
j
..
Ui I
i l
l I
I i
l l
Ml l
I I
.i l
I
-
15. l l
l l
l l
i
i i
26. I I
L I
l
-
27. l l
l l
l l
l
,
I
.
J._
I I
I J
l
,
-
.
dxhibit A Pag 7 1 of 1
-.. _ -
.
.
'
DY-
-.
(
( w..
jQ=
- (;=
'. 8
,
,,
....
.
-
.
gey;3;c:
,
E!2170
.
SECURITY INCIDENT REPORT D.O.S.it
-
.
Vd/l[ov.)
^l
'
Report No. N ' b /C Occurred
,Date Tice
.
_
.
_h A B (C D E (Circle applicable category)
Catecory of Event PART I vek c40 Sob 5t kr i/bu 000cc $/bf2'.c r'd/(tU 0llecdc.
.
Description of Event:
.
4 n ik& W d ditv W
pg&/
O /rnJ-. &
%
b & s do m S A n ! L s 'ohl u ~. sEL.
S
^
a bs
/3 /97 0 b 41<xt $i i
t rn A w
]
/
/
-
)
l
.
.
_
- >2 a// ~
M
/ //b f M u M
.
Inrnediate Action Taken:
2).
[]b'E
&
W/"4 Gn x0 (Tndtvidus? ?)
Yh s
'
G/
/
N O
y
'.
_ g
'
/)) 2 1 4 M -
'use, reverse s ide i f n9cfssf ry)
U HAME(Security Admin.)
DATE V/.2//7f
.
'/
.
.
,
PART II
% m,,I.mb Prsliminary Evaluation an~d/or Further Action Taken:
Mnesh O z m Gtd %
h c/ O /usu 4 m4l Tt4 L
- A 4 Gin
. W J &aum-
/.XO
/ (Individual.P).
dh C/M
.
- Af Abfds0s.,L 4 A M ~ A M d2
/,' tesv>M/MO I
(Individual P)
,c. /
l21,buduc YAdmb&&O8$
An d! Y /
Y
/ / Y t1-.
/
An
/
/
.
.
Further Evaluation Requir
'Ho 'Furiher /c't !'on' Required l
Deviation Report No.
.
_
.' ' Date:
2/
~~ 7
-
Station,f ecurity Administrator
-
Exhiait B
,
-
'h (finaI)'
Page 1 of 2
- ._ j'... 4.. -
Hf
.f.'
~
- :. Q
..
.
,
(.:...
(..
L
'
-
.
.
M, b
Y4 u
- b" ggj k y ApJe X
'? 4'
-'
-
'?? !&
&&?
gd g J ;A4L$f"A Aa d
..,~....,, A z9"si &
g -g p,a += s1 aaDg&
r j s a g4 ye
& A"& MP da,.J/A M x4as &au ~d~-
A aq d 4%
A
&
2 k x A d'g n s w t a f f j'"m A d & A L& ga/
~
& >cg Mn 4 A acft w - A f
p M M
,4M q. b zu-
& JAM-A & &p smgM-sm ~ 4 s
~A nsx e ass
_
g
m
/
. A ~-a 4 su'.- / n 4 s, a p
,
g ue /,,,/ rg{g,,,fp,f4
.
(1naiv1aual r>
na ayA4 u? m e %c. sec. iemis n _ g a4 RL L A M..xs xee -
~ pa Opud9(A 4 mtk:
-
.
.
.
u.-
Exhibit B Page 2 of 2
.
li.h.. ni;..s:-b.r.:
C b 2.y.
b-(2-
"
'
-.
,
,
,
'
il!Cii)Ei!I REFOiG
. _..,.
-
.
-
l oATE oF REpor:-
.
April 17u 1978
~~~
TiMC of RCPoRT
-
-
8:30 A y.
y; i,
..
-
.
lCUENn Co=monwealth Edison
Dresden Station #12
!
AooRESS:
- [aoa t.ocArloN oF INCloENT SeCuritynTrailer l
i NumscR: 230014/00
-
~l
!
j iNciotwT Falsification of Records l
lo*Teoccunate 12-17-77/4-14-78
-
Timeoccunaco av
,M
.
onans suo circuu.stAn:ts cr Discovered falsification of records done by nu=brous guards on tie
."l'.IN,$'.'~C.S.UEr.'Ou7 wutu. s ce..
crder?.s of the 7/3 shift supervisor, (Individual P)
.
1. number of guards questioned cdmitted to falsifying door checks.
Key checks were mentioned by a few. They also stated there firearms qualification for Burns was not correct due to farious reasons.
They stated the falsification of records on site was done for(Ind.Pjonly because of him bring short of guards.
(Individual P)
was questioned, he denied everyting, except to sa;- he could not rcenober, but it was possible.
I then info:ced the Com Ed Security Administrator, of what I had discovered.
I now feel (Individual P) is responsible fde the attituEe of numerous guards conerning their job guties, and job performance.
.
Tucs; April 18,1978-Informed by Burns security Office that(Individual P)had turned in his resignation.
.
.
}
.....
.
~a
..
,,,,
CENTRAL REGION
'/
h M!
/
.,
'
- - -
i
'
Exhibit C P ' # f-
.
-.
c:9genge mop
% n_ g c
-
.
b..
.
,
.
-
(
(I (=..
-
-
... ; _
-
-.
,
.....
'
INCICENT REFO.V.
..
_ _ _.
DATEoFREPoRT-April 17, 1978
'
TIME OF REPORT
-
-
6:30 A.t
-
--
uj
.
i
- ti E NT.
Co=monwealth Edison ADDRESS.
Dresden Station 812 l
Loc ATioN
,og
.
NUMGER:
230014/00 OF INCloENT Ouardhouse e
mCioENT Personnel Observation of " Phoney Door Checks"
-
h or to N7[N TIME OCCURRED AM PM
~
7 ATE OCCURRED fit-st 5 AN') CIRCUMST ANCE 5 or f,'7,3,77J, S U21.Ysig After the announce=ent of myself being promotoed to Lt., (Individual P)
- EN. & HOW-)
g came to and asked what if af charSes could he expect after I became the Lt.
At that time I infomed (Individual P) that in the past week I had observed guards co=ing off of escort, and them being asked by him to fill out the door check log as if they had done a door check, which I knew they could not have done.
I did. report all of this to(Individual G). I assumed the site supervisor had been told, by him.
I then informed (Individual P) this practice vuuld stop, that it was fa3se documentation of records and would not be allowed.
I also thold him not only had I observed this practice but that one b:ard had co=plained to me about this type of incident
,
and another guard, (Ind. T)
.had told me about being asked and that she had refused cad did not like being asked. I was assured by (Individual P)that this practice would and.
. At this time I also discussed with(Individual P) his practice of underednding the management, especially the Site Supervisor, and the Security Administrator, I Pointed out to him the effect this would have with the guards and the
.
poor image it presented to the public.
I was assfred by (Individual P) that this
-
practice would also end.
On April 14, 1978, a guard came to me and told me that the week before she had again been asked to falsify a door check. She informed (Individual P) she d3,5
+... -
( s y.u
-
(Individual J)
.-
.
/
p _,
l e,
ENTRAL P.EGION pgma a
-
-
(..
(...
(--~"
.
.
- s
- . : lou.
. ;.:..
..
,
.
..
s
.
INCIDEt.'T REFU:~.
,
_
(2)
DAT E OF. R E PQ RT
,
_
TIME OF REPORT l
M.
M C LIE N T:
,.. -
ADDRESS.
,
ns- "
- * ~
,
JOQ LOC ATIO.N
-
N U M E E R:
OF INC ""
]NCIDENT
- -rE 0 CU R R E D TIME OCCURRED AM pM
[1 AILS AND Ci8CUMSI ANCis or
.:emi i A.., on ce i~ w.-.a.
......,pe,, wuo. ws AI. wain.
to sign for it yet he had insisted. This occurred after his
.
.
ar:!N. & H3N 1 ascurancer to me the practice would not happen again. I then informed the Site Supervisor myself of what had been occurring.
.
.
~.
.
i....: o (Individus1 J)
..a
.
..
ExhRbRe D-l NTRAL REGION m
.. _
,
,
(r.....(:n.
(r...
hn
-
,.
,
m
.
,
'
.
Date lS ~?~ l7
,
.
-
.
A
-
.
.
TO UHG4 IT MAY C0;IERH:
-
~
On the above indicated date, (Individual C)
.f red a score of
' /O _C/ "out of 360.
Ihe course of fire i
was the NRA Short Cou'rs'e (as' outlined in HRC Regulatory Oaide 5.20, Appendix C).
1he scoring sequence was.as follows:
\\b
<
.
Slow Fire
-
c t of 100 points.
,
,
d Timed Fire
c of 100 points.
Rapid Fire f7 of 100' points.
.
.
Signature (Individual B)
earns Intl Security Services, Inc Authorized Firear=s Instructor
.
--
-.
_.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Exhibit E Page 1 of 1
.
'.
e 6:=
(k (=
-
.
..
.
.
'
.
.
-
.
-
..
.
,
-
~
'
STATEMENT OF (INDIVIDUAL C)
.
I, (Individual C)
, make the following statement freely and voluntarily to G. A. Phillip who has identified himself to me as
~
.
Investigator, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Co= mission.
Mr. Phillip has advised me that I do not have to make a statement and that any
~
statement I do make may later be.used 'in a judicial proceeding'..
,
_
I am employed as, a member of the guard force by Burns at Dresden site.
In December 1977 I fired a qualification course for the use of a weapon.
In-firing for score (Ind. B) allowed me to use a bench rest even though he was aware that this was not permitted when firing a qualification course.
I know that (Sec. Adnin.) and (Ind. B) had discussed this matter when (Sec. Admin.) saw that bench rests were being used a day, or a few days, before the firing I have descr16ed above.
The targets I fired into using the bench rest were used 'for my qualifying score.
,
I have read the above statement consisting of two pages and it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
.
(Indiv.idual C)
4/25/78 (signed)
.
.
.
Exhibit F Page 1 of 1
.
-
.
-
..,
,
'
',
.
.
l'd=
.
.
..
..
- '
,
,
.
,
Date M-I-72
_
.
-
-
.
.
TO WC4 IT MAY CO.'CERN:
.
On the above indicated data (Individual D)
. fired a score of
/7 Y ~
out.of 300.
fne course of fire was the tiRA Short Cotjrse ('s outlined in NRC Regulatory Guide a
5.20, Appendix C).
- 1he scoring sequence was.as follows:
Slow Fire
out of 100 points.
,
Ti.ced Fire
out of 100 points.
Rapid Fire C
out ':f 100 points.
.
.
.
.
-
Signature (Individual 3)
Burns Intl Security Services, Inc Authorized Firear=s Instructor
.
.
.
l
.
-
Exhibit G Page 1 of 1
,
. -
.
.
'
'. =
(?
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
s
-
.
.
~
~
STATEMENT OF (INDIVIDUAL D)
.
I,(Individual D), make the following statement freely and voiuntarily to G. A. Phillip who has identified himself to me as an Investigator, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
Mr. Phillip has advised me that I do not have to make a statement and that any statement I do t ake may later be used in a judicial proceeding.
I an e= ployed as a guard by Burns International Security Services, Inc. at the Dresden site. When I fired a.38 revolver for weapons qualification in December 1977 I fired the course three or four times.
To obtain a qualifying score the last. time I tried, ope of
-
the targets I had fired at during an earlier firing was substituted for one of the last set.
I also saw either (Ind.,B) or (Ind. A)
fire into a target of (Ind. E)
so that she could get a qualifying score.(Ind.E),
however, did not work at Dresden as a guard.
She didn't enter on duty because she found another job.
I have read the above statement consisting of two pages and it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
(Individual D)4/24/78 (signed)
.
.
.
.
.
i l
i
-
Exhibit H
,.
l Page 1 of 1
.
.
.
.
..
ijg
,
,
.
.
!
.
'
Date
-
't
.
-
.
.
.
TO OHCi IT.44Y CONCERN:
'
.
0:i t'h'e above indicated date, (Individual F)~
rired a score or 192 out of 300.
Ihe course or fire was the NRA Short Course (as outlined in HRC Regulatory O.lide 5.20, Appendix C).
1he scoring sequence was.as rollows:
.
'
Slow Fire
out or 100 points.
..
Tiraed Fire
_ out of 100 points.
out of 100 points.
Rapid-Fire
'
.
.
(Individual A)
-
Signature
_.
_
Burns Inti Security Services, Inc
.
Authorized Firearcs In,structor
.
.
.
'
.
,
l l
l
,
.
Exhibit I Page 1 of I
-. -
.
_
_
_
_
,
'P
..
"
= ::
,
,
'
..
dte-Y 2 7
~~~ - Q ) 2 %--- i f
'
'
f I
.
-
_
l
-
-
.
....
.
.
.
....
ID WO4 iT MAY COI;CERN:
-
.
.t a....
...................
Cm the above indicated date, (Individual F)
.i'Ged k score of -- -I 9 L
-
out of 300.
Tne coufse' of fire
'
.0as.t.he,IEA Shor't Course (as outlined in HRC Regulatory 0.2ide
$.20, Appendix C).
The scoring sequence was.as follows:
.
^
31o4 Fire,
.= ~' ~ 3
-
-
,.
......-
e.
.
....
out of 100 points.
.
.
....
...
Timed Fire 6 0 -- oilt of 100 points.
...i.
..
Rapid Fire
out of 100 points.
t
,
l
.
.
.
-
jyj{@f (Individual A)
...
Burns Inti Security Services. Inc Authorized Firearts Instructor
-
,
.
.
i
.
-
.
.
.
' ~
'
-
Exhibit J
,
Page 1 of 1
.
_
_
_
__ _
\\
i
.
.
.
-
.
.
.
-
>.
.
.
.
.
-
,
_
STATEMENT OF (IND!VIDUAL F)
'
'
,
.,
I, (Individual F)
, make the following statement freely and voluntarily to G. A. Phillip who has identified himself to me as an Investigator, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
I have been advised by Mr. Phillip that I do not have to make a statement and that any statement I do make may later be used in.a judicial
'
proceeding.
I fired a I am employed as a guard by Burns at the Dresden site.
.38 revolver at a firing range in Joliet in February 1978 to On that occasion I fired at
,
requalify in the use of that weapon.
three targets, a silhoutte, a large bullseye and a small bullseye.
,
After checking the scores on those targets, it was determined that I needed a higher score on the small bullseye.
I was instructed to fire at another'small bullseye.
Since I scored better on that one, it was combined with the other two type targets to achieve a qualifying score which was in the 190's.
I do not know what happened to the first small bullseye target.
I have read the above statement and it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
.
.
(Individual F)
4/25/78 (signed)
'
.
.
.
.
I i
I
'l Exhibit K Page 1 of 1
.
..
_. _.... _
_ _.
_
_
.
_
..
.
.
...
.
,,
s
.
.
.
Date 2/23/78
-
.
.
.
i TO WHC4 IT MAY C0!.'CERf!:
.
,
(Individual H)
On :the above indicgep date, out of 300.
'Ihe course of. fire
. fired a score of was the fiRA Short Course (as outlined in HRC Regulatory OJide l
5.20i Appendix C).
'1he scoring sequence was.as follows:
.
~
Slow Fire
out of 100 points.
"
'
,
a
.
.
T.imed Fire
out of 100 points.
Rapid Fire out of 100 points.
"
.
.
.
'
Si nature (Individual A)
-
Burns Intl Security Services, Inc
Authorized Firearr_s Instructor
.
.
.
.
.
i
.
_w
.
,
'
Exhibit L Page 1 of 1
.
,.
_
_
_ (
.
i.- :
.
,
,
.
.
,
.
.
.
'
-
,
STATDfENT OF (INDIVIDUAL H)
-
.
I,(Individual H), make the following statement freely and voluntarily to Mr. G. A. '/hillip who has ide.tified himself to me as an I have been Investigator, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Com=ission.
advised by Mr. Pnillip that I do not have to make a statement and that any statement I do make may later be used in a judicial
,
proceeding.
I am employed by Burns as a guard at the Dresden site.
To requalify On that in the use of a weapon I fireu for score in February 1978.
occasion I fired about five practice shots into a s=all bullseye e
Since these shots were well placed in the target I was target.
allowed to fire some additiocal shots into this target as part of I then fired at the large bullseye target the qualification score.
and a silhoutte target without being timed.
These three targets were used for my qualifying score.
I looked at my targets but (Ind. A)
added up my score which he said was 222 to the best of my recollection.
I have read the above statement consisting of two pages and it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
(Individual H) 4/25/78 -
(signed)
-
.
.
Exhibit M Page 1 of 1
,
.
.
.
_ _ _
_
_
. _..
_
.
.
.
.
-....
.
/E 7-7 7 tete
.
'
.
-
.
.
-
-
.
.
.
.
.
>
.
.
TO WEC4 IT. AY CO;CEFJI:
i
.
.
.
(Individual K)
~
U1 T.he"above ' indicated date,
-
fired a score' of
/9 M out of 300. :Jhe course or fire was the liiiA Stort Course '(as outlined in NRC fteE;ulatory O. zide 85.20, Appendix C).
'1he scoring sequence was.as follows:
.
N out of 100 points.
'
Slow Fir'e
\\
~
.
/* #-d out Ur.-100r paint.r..
-
!
- neea r.tre
'5RapidF
_' Yd out of 100 points.
'
,
.
.
.
.
.
(Individual B)
.
.
ggg
,
. Burns Inti Security Services, Inc Authocized Firearcs Instructor
.
.
.
-
.
..
_
.
.
Exhibit N Page 1 of,1
.
-
-
_
_...
-
'
,
+=.
~,
"
- .m.
.
.
.
-
.
A ~ f-ll
Date
.
.
-
--
.
.
e
'ID WHC4 IT MAY CONCFJd!:
(Individual L)
On the above indicated date, _
fired a score of
/97 out'of 300.
me course of fire was the NRA Short Course (as outlined in NEC Eegulatory Gaide
.
5.20, Appendix C).
The scoring sequence was.as follows:
/out of 100 points.
'
Slow Fire o
k t of 100 points.
Ti=ed Fire
.
Rapid Fire ND out of 100 points.
' '
.'
..
.
.
.
!
.
(In.dividual B)
Signature ___
Burns Inti Security Services, Inc Authorized Fireares Instructor
-
.
.
.
-
.
,
e
.
.%
.
.
.
-.
Exhibit 0
__.
Page 1 of 1_
_ - _. _
_
_
_ _ _.
'
(:...
({.,.
(h
'
'
',
==
-
,
,
A lb ~ ? D Date
.
-.
_
-
.
.
.
.
TO UHC:4 IT MAY C0t.'CERN:
On the above indicated date, (Individual M)
fired a score of
/9 k our..of 300.
'Ihe course of fire
~
was the IEA Short Course (as outlined in NRC Regulatory O.:ide 5.20, Appendix C).
1he scoring sequenee was.as follows:
.
'
Slow Fire I,2 *
out of 100 points.
~
,
Tined Fire EI ~~' out of 100 points.
-
-
j, //. L.S.
.
Rapid Fire O/
out of 100 points.
'
V. '-
.
-
,
.
.
(Individual B)
'
Si6 nature Efurns Intl Security Sdrv~ ices, Inc Authorized Firearns Instructor
.
.
.
.
.
'
.w
.
'
!
-
.
.
Exhibit P
Palm R aff R j
.
'
i
'
'
c,=
,
,
,
,
/ 2/23/78-
-
Date
_
.
-
.
,
_
_
.
.
TO.WIK 4.'[T MAY CO"CERN:
,
(Individual J)
On the above indicated date,
. tired a score of 216 out.or 300.
Ihe course or fire 4:ss 7.he fiRA Stort Course (as outlined in HRC Regulatory Guide ~
5.2D, 4pendix c).
Ihe scoring sequence was.as rollows;
.
YD out of 100 points.
'
. Slow Fire
.
Timed Fire
cut of 100 points.
<9.-
out or 100 points.
3tapid Fire
.
(Individual A)
'
Siif,nat.ure _.
,,
Burns Jntl Security Services, Inc
'
Author.ized Firearcs Instructor
.
.
.
.
.+,
.
i Exhibit Q Page_1 of I
'
'
t
-
-
,
,
= =. -
.,
,
(
'
-
.
.
-
-
.
.
_
~
'
STATEMINT OF (INDIVIDUAL J)
I, (Individual J), make the following statement freely and voluntarily to G. A. Phillip who has identified himself to me as an Investigator, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
I have been advised by Mr. Phillip that I do n,ot have to make a statement and that any statement I do make may later be used in a judicial proceeding.
I am employed as a tember of the guard force by Burns at the Dresden site.
In February 1978 I fired for score to requalify in
-
the use of a weapon.
Af ter I had fired at the first bullseye target and failed to hit it, (Ind. A) ~ who was in charge of the firing range fired into the target from close range.
The second bullseye was also fired into by (Ind. A)
I was allowed to
.
fire into the silhoutte target myself from close range, about 10 yards from the target.
I signed the three targets and they were used as the basis for my qualifying score.
While this was going on I also observed (Ind. G)
fire into (Ind. I's)
targets to help her get a qualifying score.
I have read the above state =ent and.it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
'
/
(Individual T)
4/25/78 (signed)
.
.
'
i
Exhibit R
.
'
Page 1 of 1
-
..
'
- l..
g::
_
_
s
-
.
.
,
-
,
,
.
_
.
2/23/78
'
"
-
-
'
'
Date
.
-
,
.
-
.
.
.
TO UH04 IT NAY CONCER!h
.
On the above indicated date,
'(Individual I)
. fired a score of 195 out of 300.
The course of fire was the NRA Stort Course (as outline'd in HRC Re5ulatory Guide 5.20, Appendix C).
The scoring sequence was.as fc11cus:
-
'
'
Slow Fire
out of 100 points.
-
,
Tined Fire
~'66
.out of 100 points.
Rapid' Fire out of 100 points.
.
.
.
.
.
Signature (Individual A)
-
Burns Intl Security Services, Inc Authorized Firearms Instructor
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
s Exhibit S j
.
Page 1 of 1
(....
...
..
': "
.
,
,
.,
'
.
.
m--.s
-
-
-
-
.
STATEMENT OF (INDIVIDUAL I)
freely and voluntarily make. the following statement I,(Ind. I)
,
to G. A. Phillip who has identified himself to me as an Investigator, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Co= mission.
Mr. Phillip has informed me that I do not have to make a statement and that any state =ent I do make may later be used in a judicial proceeding.
.
I am employed by Burns International Security Services, Inc. as a in the security forces at the Dresden Nuclear Power Plant.
On or about February 23, 1978 I fired a.38 revolver for requalifi-cation at a firing range in Joliet, Illinois under the supervision of (Individual A)
and (Ind. G)
On that occasion I fired six
.
rounds at a bullseye targ st and I was informed that the score was Then I fired ten founds not good enough and it was thrown away.
I at a silhoutte target firing at will, that is not timed fire.
was told that target was good.
Then(Individual G)
fired into two dif ferent sized bullseye He then instructed targets from about half the normal distance.
I was me to sign all three targets as though they were my own.
told that my score was 195.
This experience bothered me and I later talked the catter over with
, Acccontt Supervisor for Burns at Dresden.
After this discussion I decided to tell
,
it.
Station Security Ad=inistrator, Co==onwealth Edison, about
-
I have read the above statement consisting of two pages and it is true,and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
.
(Individual I)
4/24/78 (signed)
.
Exhibit T Page 1 of 1
^
-
-
I....
(5 c
,
'
~
- .:-
='
.
.
,
.
!2-7-27 Date
.
_
.
.
TO WC4 IT MAY CO:;CERN:
.
-
On'the above indicated date, (Individual 0)
fired a score of Ao7 out of 360.
n:e course of fire was the fiEA Stort Course (as outlined in liRC-Eegulatory Oaide 5.20, Appendix C).
Tne scorirs sequence was.as follows:
.
Slow Fire YO out of 100 points."
k
"
ik w
/ pout of 100 points
-
Timed Fire I/
.
'~
Rapid Fire out of 100 points "
-
.
.
_
Signature (Individual B)
_ _ _
Eurns Intl Security Services, Inc Authorized Firearcs Instructor
'
.
.
.
Exhibit U Page 1 of 1
-
'.
I
'
pq; (;:-
-
'
,
.
,
.
..
'
- --
--
.
-
-
.
.
.
STATEMENT OF (INDIVIDUAL G)
'
I, (Ind. G)
, make the following statement freely and voluntarily to Mr. G. A. Phillip who has identified hihself to me as an Investigator, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Coz:: mission.
I have been advised by Mr. Phillip that I do not have to make_ a. statement. and that any statement I do make may 1,ater be used in a judicial-.
proceeding.
..
While I was employed by Burns at the Dresden site on two occasions I assisted (Ind. A)
at the firing range while guards were firing a qualification score.
On one occasion I was, instructed by (Ind. A)
-
to have (Individual F)
nove several feet closer to the target so that he could get a better score on.the target that he had difficulty with.
(Ind. F)-then fired from the shorter distance and got a qualifying score.
I,ater I told the Burns Accounts Supervisor about this a'nd (Ind. F)
was required to fire again the next day.
I understood he qualified the next day.
On the second occasion I iired some shots into the target of a-I did guard who was having difficulty getting a qualifying score.
this at the instruction of (Ind. A).
-
I have read the above statement consisting of two pages and it is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
-
(Individual G)
'4/29/78 (signed)
,
.
.
-
.
-
Exhibit V Page 1 of 1
.
.
--
___
.
.
s
~~
J:
ig (3
.
.
.
.
.
/[2V lhte e
'
I
.
-
-
- -
.
.
,..
,
.
u.
-
TO UHCi IT MAY COllCERil:
,
.
,
.
.
(Individual R)
On the above indicated dat.
'
. fired a score of
/7 Y out of 300.
'Ihe course of fire
'
was the tiRA Short Co6rse (as outlined in NEC Regulatory Guide 5.20, Appendix C).
'the scoring sequence was.as follows:
3f out of 100 points.
"
Slow Fire
,
TirJed Fire d. 7 out of 100 points.
7I out of 100 points.
~
Rapid Fire
'
'
.
.
(Individual B)
Signature Burns Inti Security Services, Inc
'
Authorized Firear=s Instructor
.
.
.
.
.
'
%
.
i
.
.: t
.
i
!
.
Exhibit W Page I of 1
,
.
-
..
.
.
(
'-
6:=
([.
I;=~
- ', -
.
,
,
.
..
0%
\\N,IW Y ~
'
'
'
Date
'
.
_
-
-
.
-
.
,
.
.
.
..
.
.
'
,
TO WHCi IT MAY CONCERN:
.
-
-
.
,
On the above indicated date, (Individual S)
fired a score of ' c101 out of 300.
'Iheco'u'rse of fire
was the NRA Short Course (as outlined in HRC ReSulatory Guide 5.20, Appendix C).
'1he scoring sequence was.as follows:
.
b
~
'
Slow Fire out of 100 points.
Timed Fire out of 100 points.
~
'
Eapid Fire out of 100 points.
-
.
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
-
.
.
.
S@atre (Individual A)
.,
Burns Inti Security Services, Inc
.
Authorized Firearrs Instructor.
~ ' -
s.-
.
,
)
.-
.
.
-
.
.
,
,
-
.
.
...
.
.
.
.
.
.
-
.
-
.
.
.
Exhibit X Page 1 of 1
k
(
-
... _.
,
't!//t-i e;-
,
'.
-
- -
..
.
.
.
,...
.
,
g#* "'%
UNITED STATES f
S NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
_
f
,,1 1I R E GloN ill
e n'
r 199 ROOSEVELT RoAo
- -
GLEN ELLYN,ILLINots 60137 e...*
.
APR f519E
-
.
Docket No. 50-10
.
Docket No. 50-237 Docket No. 50-249,
.
.
Commonwealth Edison Company ATTN:
Mr. Byron Lee, Jr.
Vice President P. O. Box 767 Chicago, Illinois 60690 Gentlemen:
.
This letter confirms'the matters discussed during a telephone con-versation on April 21, 1978 between you, Larry Bean of your staf f and J. T. Donahue and J. L. Belanger of this office related to guard firearms qualification and vital area door check records at Dresden Station. The questionable qualification records, possible impropri-eties in the manner of conducting f.irearms requalification and the apparent falsification of vital area doors checks were reported to us by members of your staff on April 17 and 19, 1978.
>
Based on the above conversation, it is our understanding that the following vill be accomplished within the below specified time frames:
1.
Take immediate steps to requalify those. guards identified to date who appear to have questionable or falsified firearms certifications.
Completion of certification vill be witnessed by CECO. To be completed by May 5,1978.
-
2.
Take it::nediate steps to deter =ine the extent to which additional s
guard force members are not fully firearms qualified.
If such non-qualified guards are identified, they will be requalified and their requalification witnessed by CECO.
To be completed by
,
May 29, 1978.
.
- g a p r,1 7 ;;
- r :
. : ;.. a
-
,
)LL 2C OM@M zncIc3URE A
.
l
'
'
(
-
.
f C-N j'
....
'
=
.
7..
lNMDIAT5ACTidd[fM'
-
.
Co==oovealth Edison-2-Conpan7 APR 2 51978
~
3.
Only authorized individuals who have been fully firearms qualified vill perform as guards.
.
.
4.
L'ith respect to apparent falsification of vital area " door ch~eck" records, take step,s to assure that pertinent door checks are being cade as required and associated documentation is maintained.
~
To be co=pleted by April 28, 1978.
If your understanding of these matters is not in accordance with that described above, please contact this office iz=ediately.
,
Sincerely,
,
.
James C. Keppler Director
.
cc:
Er. B. B. Stephenson, Station Superintendent Central Files Reproduction Unit NIC 20b PDE Local PDE
'
, ESIC TIC
A=tbony Poisean, Esq,,
Attorney Lana Cobb. IE Porter F111s, IE-e
.*
,
mse =
l-l
'
.
.
-l
-
.
."