ML17264B067

From kanterella
Revision as of 12:40, 29 June 2018 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Proposed Tech Specs,Correcting & Clarifying Info Re RCS Pressure & Temp Limits Rept Administrative Controls Requirements
ML17264B067
Person / Time
Site: Ginna Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 10/08/1997
From:
ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML17264B066 List:
References
NUDOCS 9710150247
Download: ML17264B067 (10)


Text

eReporting Requirements 5.65.6Reporting Requirements 5.6.6PTLR(continued) c~Theanalytical methodsusedtodetermine theRCSpressureandtemperature andLTOPlimitsshallbethosepreviously reviewedandapprovedbytheNRCinNRCletterdated<NRCapprovaldocument>.

Specifically, themethodology isdescribed inthefollowing documents:

1.LetterfromR.C.Hecredy,Rochester GasandElectricCorporation (RG&E),toDocumentControlDesk,NRC,Attention:

GuyS.Vissing,"Application forFacilityOperating License,RevisiontoReactor,CoolantSystem(RCS)PressureandTemperature LimitsReport(PTLR)Administrative ControlsRequirements,"

Attachment VI,September 29,1997,assupplemented byletterfromR.C.Hecredy,RG&E,toGuyS.Vissing,NRC,"Corrections toProposedLowTemperature Overpressure Protection SystemTechnical Specification,"

October8,1997.2.WCAP-14040-NP-A, "Hethodology UsedtoDevelopColdOverpressure Hitigating SystemSetpoints andRCSHeatupandCooldownLimitCurves,"Sections1and2,January,1996.d.ThePiTLRshallbeprovidedtotheNRCuponissuanceforeachreactorvesselfluenceperiodandforrevisions orsupplement thereto.R..E.GinnaNuclearPowerPlant,97l0%50247 97l008PDRADOCK:05000244 PPDR5.0-22Amendment No.g,PP Reporting Requirements 5.65.6Reporting Requirements 5.6.6PTLR(continued)

C.TheSohTjt5i'algeet~83os'.'".'undid,'.:::;f o.,:detep.ije,':~t,e:

RCpressureandtemp'erature andLTOPliiiiitsskale1bethnosepreviously reviewedandapprovedby,theNRC.inNRCletterdatedNayR!IT-II$6~(NRCyiappto:.vaI::-::.".:::::;do'clument>:.

Specifically, theI1eIihe+ad-methodology

~<i'sdescribed inthefollowing documents:

1.LetterfromR.C.Mecredy,Rochester GasandElectricCorporation (RGKE),toDocumentControlDesk,NRC,A<<ti:~'CW@igi:,-,,::,i,--g, "Appl'lfFacilityOperating License,RevisiontoReactorCoolantSystem(RCS)PressureandTemperature LimitsReportP.rhOI'ta'aeEt'3'On

~<>>>>~2.IIlAP-14MO~i!NP::-.':A'Methodology UsedtoDevelopColdOverpressure Mitigating SystemSetpoints andRCSHeatupandCooldownLi~ie,,"~p%!I""n---iiil:"-,:::

--icu!,L-'"-..-..=.-"'~~~96:.

~~d.ThePTLRshallbeprovidedtotheNRCuponissuanceforeachreactorvesselfluencmperiodandforrevisions orsupplement thereto.R.E.GinnaNuclearPowerPlant5.0-22Amendment No.Q,PP

2.0 OPERATING

LIMITSThecycle-specific parameter limitsforthespecifications listedinSection1.0arepresented inthefollowing subsections.

Allchangestotheselimitsmustbedeveloped usingtheNRCapprovedmethodologies specified inTechnical Specification 5.6.6.Theselimitshavebeendetermined suchthatallapplicable limitsofthesafetyanalysisaremet.Allitemsthatappearincapitalized typearedefinedinTechnical Specification 1.1,"Definitions."

2.1RCSPressureandTemeratureLimits(LCO3.4.3andLCO3.4.12)(Reference 1)2.1.1TheRCStemperature rate-of-change limitsare:a.Amaximumheatupof60'Fperhour.b.Amaximumcooldownof100'Fperhour.2.1.2TheRCSP/Tlimitsforheatupandcooldownarespecified byFigures1and2,respectively.

2.1.3Theminimumboltuptemperature, usingthemethodology ofReference 4,Enclosure 2is60'F.2.2LowTemeratureOverressureProtection SstemEnableTemerature(LCOs3.4.6,3.4.7,3.4.10and3.4.12)(Methodology ofReference 3,Attachment VIandReference 6,ascalculated inReference 7).2.2.1Theenabletemperature fortheLowTemperature Overpressure Protection Systemis322'F.2.3LowTemeratureOverressureProtection SstemSetpints(LCO3.4.12)2.3.1Pressurizer Power0cratedReliefValveLiftSettinLimits(Methodology ofReference 3,Attachment VIandReference 6,ascalculated inReference 3,Attachment VII).Theliftsettingforthepressurizer PowerOperatedReliefValves(PORVs)is~411psig(includes instrument uncertainty).

PTLRRevision2 Table3showscalculations ofthesurveillance materialchemistry factorsusingsurveillance capsuledata.Table4provides'thereactorvesseltoughness data.Table5providesasummaryofthefluencevaluesusedinthegeneration oftheheatupandcooldownlimitcurves.Table6showsexamplecalculations oftheARTvaluesat24EFPYforthelimitingreactorvesselmaterial.

5.0REFERENCES

2.3.5.6.7.WCAP-14684, "R.E.GinnaHeatupandCooldownLimitCurvesforNormalOperation,"

datedJune1996.WCAP-14040-NP-A, "Hethodology UsedtoDevelopColdOverpressure Mitigating SystemSetpoints andRCSHeatupandCooldownLimitCurves,"Revision2,January1996.LetterfromR.C.Hecredy,RGIIE,toGuyS.Vissing,NRC,

Subject:

"Application forAmendment toFacilityOperating License,RevisiontoReactorCoolantSystem(RCS)PressureandTemperature LimitsReport(PTLR)Administrative ControlsRequirements,"

datedSeptember 29,1997.LetterfromR.C.Hecredy,RGIIE,toGuyS.Vissing,NRC,"Clarifications toProposedLowTemperature Overpressure Protection SystemTechnical Specification,"

datedJune3,1997.WCAP-7254, "Rochester GasandElectric, RobertE.GinnaUnitNo.1ReactorVesselRadiation Surveillance Program,"

May1969.LetterfromR.C.Hecredy,RGIIE,toGuyS.Vissing,NRC,"Corrections toProposedLowTemperature Overpressure Protection SystemTechnical Specification,"

October8,1997.RGIIEDesignAnalysisDA-HE-97-031, "Evaluation ofGinnaRCSCoolantTemperature toSupportLTOPSRequirements,"

Revision0.PTLRRevision2

~\

~whichever isgreater.RT>>Tisthehighestadjustedreference temperature forweldorbasemetalInthebeltlineregionatadistanceone-fourth ofthevesselsectionthickness fromthevesselinsidesurface,asdetermined byRegulatory Guide1.99,Revision2.-AIQeugh3.4EnableTemperature forLTOPSTheenabletemperature Isthetemperature belowwhichtheLTOPSsystemisrequiredtobeoperable.g ill:re,:iHWS",:::

0":-y..':!b~5l.I'd':".Iiiil!:iis

.=.:I:.rrrlyA8taa!CFdNCSSe~Np

>4satt'te%8ME!CsdettCSSer N4g~d::SuppOrtS::a~..eoa8te.;F@8"!ITIO+dt~~epera u~rOeiiSSP~O,dred::te:,.",the'reeetsrereeeetttrat meta%tomcrater;Ot"":BTtsraWSO.'.keraO'O'IIV-Ttte 3-8 whichever isgreaterasdescribed InSection3.3.ttt'Nr~dsffnitiÃf s."alsoaso cnT~d':bTrtlh14o ttfeelfnghcuaeCVmerSeCrcuy'%TfjeQInnaenableternPeratu Iedet~ennnedaa(87~+::.3'Ovs~Fj Q+!gnst~u.

~i:;:eyror Peffpw:::.:Qrnasslft~e..

peratvge~diffsreneedod::

31'%Thssnaa~inurnha logiiwopressure~iagii'0~of i~heatsadLatQa'e:.eve!down.;cttrve:cTNcutatsd.':.In,ac'oordancs;:wtih:fqtltendht

'8%to:,t'OCPsRSOUtj~PsrXASME~!CcdtrsCase::::M4'tsi TheRCScoldlegtemperature limitation forstartinganRCPisthesamevalueastheLTOPSenabletemperature toensurethatthebasisoftheheatinJection transient isnotviolated.

TheRandar4-Technical Specifications

~prohibit startinganRCPwhenanyRCScoldlegtemperatures islessthanorequaltotheLTOPSenabletemperature unlessthesecondary sidewatertemperature ofeachsteamgenerator islessthanorequalto50'FaboveeachoftheRCSCOldlegtemPeratureSKOrithegreeeur!Zeryat~er Valume<IS:

3%4'CnblbVafeet.':{38~741eV Jet'.3-9 curve(with10%additional margin)ascalculated inaccordance withAppendixGto10CFR50orthepeakRCSorRHRSystempressurebaseduponpiping/structural analysisloads.Thelowerpressureextremelsspecified bythereactorcoolantpumpP1sealminimumdifferential pressureperformance criteria.

Uncertainties inthepressureandtemperature instrumentation utilizedbytheLTOPSareaccounted forconsistent withthemethodology ofReference

2.0. Accounting

fortheeffectsofinstrumentation uncertainty imposesadditional restrictions onthesetpolntdevelopment, whichisalreadybasedonconservative pressurelimitssuchasasafetyfactorof2onpressurestress,useofalowerboundK,Rcurveandanassumed~/iTflawdepthwithalengthequalto1Ntimesthevesselwalithickness.

3.3Application ofASMECodeCaseN-514ASMECodeCaseN-514II allowsLTOPStolimitthemaximumpressureinthereactorvesselto110%ofthepressuredetermined tosatisfyAppendixG,paragraph G-2215,ofSectionXIofNtheASMEGodet'I.Theapplication ofASMECodeCaseN-514increases theoperating marginintheregionofthepressure-temperature limitcurveswheretheLTOPSisenabled.CodeCaseN-514alsorequiresLTOPStobeeffective atcoolanttemperatures lessthan200'Foratcoolanttemperatures corresponding toareactorvesselmetaltemperature, ata1/4tdistancefromtheinsidevesselsurface,lessthanRTgpr+50F,whichever isgreater.RTgpyisthehighestadjustedreference temperature forweldorbasemetalinthebeltlineregionatadistanceone-fourth ofthevesselsectionthickness fromthevesselinsidesurface,asdetermined byRegulatory Guide1.99,Revision2.3-7 Itt4*

EnableTemperature forLTOPSTheenabletemperature isthetemperature belowwhichtheLTOPSsystemisrequiredtobeoperable.

TheGinnaLTOPSenabletemperature Isestablished usingtheguidanceprovidedbyASMEXICodeCaseN-514.TheASMECodeCaseN-514supportsanenableRCSliquidtemperature corresponding tothereactorvessel1/4tmetaltemperature ofRT>>r+50'For200'F,whichever isgreaterasdescribed InSection3.3.Thisdefinition isalsosupported bytheWestinghouse Owner'sGroup.TheGinnaenabletemperature isdetermined as(RTD~+50'F)+(instrument errorI~I)+(metaltemperature difference to1/4T).Themaximumallowable pressureis110%ofthesteady-state cooidowncurvecalculated inaccordance withAppendixGto10CFR50'erASMECodeCaseN-514i"ITheRCScoldlegtemperature limitation forstartinganRCPisthesamevalueastheLTOPSenabletemperature toensurethatthebasisoftheheatinjection transient isnotviolated.

TheTechnical Specifications prohibitstartinganRCPwhenanyRCScoldlegtemperatures islessthanorequaltotheLTOPSenabletemperature unlessthesecondary sidewatertemperature ofeachsteamgenerator Islessthanorequalto50'FaboveeachoftheRCScoldlegtemperatures, orthepressurizer watervolumeis(324cubicfeet(38%level).3-8