ML20106F453

Forwards Two Pages of Tables I-III to Accompany 28 Pages of Dictated Proposed Findings on Foreman Override Issue

ML20106F453
Person / Time
Site:	Catawba
Issue date:	10/26/1984
From:	Guild R PALMETTO ALLIANCE
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#484-791 OL, NUDOCS 8410300249
Download: ML20106F453 (3)

Text

over w: : -

run.umt.re.:..E..d...,.8,jsjpf o 99b S6-4/46L.

'84 ogi gg p; ;;g

'"~ - '

-; .; , ! 1 TO: Board and Parties From: Robert Guild, Palmetto Alliance Date: October 26, 1984 Enclosed please find 2 pages of Tables I-III to accompany the 28 pages of dictated Proposed Findings on the " foreman override" issue in thp Cat ba proceeding.

}

8410300249 841026 l

PDR ADOCK 05000 G

s$

O s

TABt.E 1 yhe following table liste e!! workers who expressed override concerne in their effideelte. These concerne are not distingelshed for their eefety alginificance ord reflect ISO cht!! ring W yes B. Willines (W. Sr.)

both actual override incidente end geraret override concerne. No 186 erc strike W ..-

D. Hendria (W. Sr.)

etteopt vee sede by DPC to tabulate override concerne beyond the 191 loose backing ringe W yee J. A. Moore ten cases identified. Molline. Tr.13260,13271. The table to interpose W yee .....

broken down by type of override concern craft of alleger, whether 192 violate procedures W yes J. A. Moore the worker wee e direct witnese to en incident end which interpene W ... .N, Baker esporvisore may have been involved. If the incident la sentioned violate procedures W yes H. Beet by othere en estarik follows the incident description. teterpees W yee .....

bed weld W ...

L. Leetherwood worker direct 196 lookout / foresee grindeo W yee J. A. Moore e incident nature craft witneset supervisor foresen grande

• W no J. 4. Moore

................................................-..........- 3nterpeea W yee J. 4. Moora 13 weld without purge W yes J.A. Moore interpose W yee J. A. Moore 27 Lgnore red tag W ... B. Cobb interpees* W yes J. A. Moore ignore oefety etere W ... B. Cobb no process control W ...

J. A. Moote 28 cut oute too large W yes E. Brown (W.Sr.D 208 violete bevel fate W yes J. A. Moore 31 deceive ANI W yee H. Berker 209 violate bevet fit W yes J. A. noor, 226 etc strike W y*e ****.

25 evpension colle stening PMN yee K. Dodd 33 interpose W yee J. Gledd'a lie about red-heads PMN yee B. Mattereen coldepring* W yee J. Gladden /J. Johnson etease meteriale PNN yee K. Dodd 36 violate bevel W yes J.A. Moore 39 no procese controle PMN yee .....

Interpees W yee J.A. Moore 77 no process control PHN yee E. Cobb exceso penetration W yes Leatherwood/Meersch 88 no procese control PMN yes. E. Cobb 58 no procese control W yes ----.

no procese control PMN yes D. Willisse 66 fit-up violation W no T. Hollingsworth 95 no procese control PHN yee E. Cobb 70 interpene W yee J.A. Moore 228 coldepring* PMN yee J. Johnson interpose W yee T. Abernethy 127 condepring* PMN yee J. Johnson lookout W yee E. Brown (W.Sr.) 131 coldspringe PMN yes J. Johnson 20 faulty weld W yee t.. Leatherwood 162 empenaton loope pMN yee K. Dodd 72 feletty atenette W yes J. Chrieley bed suey welde PMN yee K. Dodd 76 agnore red tog W no B. Cobb cheeting ou test PMN yee K. Dodd bed welde W yee B. Cobb violate fit PMN yee K. Dodd 91 1 pase/ falsify atenet! W yes L. Price slause meteriale PMN yee K. Dodd 94 violate hold point W yes J. Gladden eteeling seteriete PNN yee K. Dodd no procese control W yee J. Gladden 163 coldepring* PMN yes J. Johnson 106 interpose W yee J. Gladden coldepring PHN yee J. Johnson feutty welde W yes J. Gledden 118 falsify cable peint E yee J. Ktener 101 foremen grinde are etk. W yes J. A. Moore violate tie-down spece E vee J. Kinner are strike removete W yes J. A. Moore 32 vlotate bevet fite OC yee 1. A. Moore 114 interpose W yee M. Best interpose DC no J. A. Moore 167 work after NCI W yes M. Best lookout OC no J. A. Moore 168 eteeing bolte on nut W yee ***--

work efter MCI OC yee B. Smith lookout /foresen welde* W yee J. A. Moore welding speed contest QC yee J. A. Moore lookout /foresen grinde* W yee J. A. Moore 62 coldepring OC yee .....

173 no process control W --- B. Setth 110 foresen welde OC yes R. Penmon 176 violate bevel fate W yes J. A. Moore 120 coldsprieg* OC yes Gladden /Jokeson 177 feletfy atencile W yer J. Chrieley

TABLE 2

- Tho following tunctry tcblo lieto tha nunb r of instances of override concerns by craft. The total number of instances of override concerns is listed first. This is followed by the total number of instances of unique events *ot duplicated by another witness to the same event). The final column lists total number of these unique events which were directly witnessed:

DIRECT WITNESS, CRAFT TOTAL UNIQUE EVENTS UNIQUE EVENTS WELDING 55 46 37 POWERHOUSE MECH. 20 14 -

14 WELD /PHM 3 3 2 ELECTRICAL 2 2 2 PHM/STEELRIGGER 1 1 1 81 66 56

=Some individuals mentioned seeing a number of instances--in one case there may be 35-40 separate instances (see affidavit 177,see also affidavits 70 and 95). However, the affidavits do not clarify their nature--they are excluded here. -

TABLE 3 i The following table contains a list of all forenen implicated in override concern allegations compiled from the affidavits. Included in the list are three welder seniors and two General ~ Foremen mentioned in override concerns. They are identified with an asterik.

WELDER SUPERVISORS IDENTIFIED B. SMITH = J.HAMRICKa (J. WILSON) (D. MILLS) (H.CHATMAN)

Moore Gladden Best Cobb Penson Barker Leatherwood Chrisley Hollingsworth Abernathy Price R. Baker B.Willianse E. Brown

• CD.Hendrix=--insufficient data to determine supervisor)

SUPERVISORS POWERHOUSE MECHANICS / ELECTRICIAN E.Cobb J. Johnson K.Dodd B.Halterman / J.Kisner

[D. Williams--insufficient data to determine supervisorJ

- -