ML20095C111

From kanterella
Revision as of 12:52, 2 May 2020 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Prefiled Testimony of Rd Mcbee on 840816 in Glen Rose,Tx. Pp 1-24
ML20095C111
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 08/16/1984
From: Mcbee R
BROWN & ROOT, INC. (SUBS. OF HALLIBURTON CO.), TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To:
Shared Package
ML20095C073 List:
References
OL-2, NUDOCS 8408220380
Download: ML20095C111 (35)
v • d • e


Text

y w , - -

1 '

~1-1

-UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

~1 h)

L . 2' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE-THE ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING BOADD CCUrE W

.. 3. IN THE MATTER OF ) ushnt,

+

.) 1 4 - TEXAS. UTILITIES ELECTRIC ) DOCK

' COMPANY,'ET AL-- ) 50-4 P5:05

'_ ~5 ) 50-446 ot,t.

(COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ) un tu y 5tuul-6 ELECTRIC STATION, UNITS ) 00CKiiftgEWh 1 AND 2) )

7

. 8- PREFILED TESTIMONY OF RONALD D. McBEE 9 AUGUSTJ16, 1984 .

10'

11;

~

~

. 12 .

f5 .13 -

' ,)

, 14 PREFILED-TESTIMONY OF RONALD D. McBEE, taken on 4: IS[ the 16tht; day of August,,'1984, in the above-styled 16 and; numbered cause, at Glen Rose Motor Inn located

, 17 -at Highway'67 & FM Road'2.01, in the City of Glen

~

c18 . Rose, County of Somervell'and' State of Texas, before

~ .

19 Janet E.'Schaffer,=a Certified, Shorthand R'e p o r t e r . i n ho and:.for the.. State of Texas.

  • p;,

21--

E g j

. 22-

  • w ,

~

5+ 23' 4 . , _ 3

.W- .'

. 24:J 'B408220300 840820

" - PDR ADOCK 05000445 ,

PDR T)~

- 2S; T ,

e t

'.. 7 y: ^

& 'h  ; *

, + ,

C/, ' .

FEDERAL [COURTcREPORTERS;.

~

I

~

' ;y* . ,.

,~

r ,

_2 s, ,

4~ - J .

,-1 APPEARANCES . /

I'ISHOP, LIBERMAN,: COOK,~PURCELL & REYNOLDS.

~

/- 2 B 2

Attorne.ys at . . -  ;

Law' .

3-

~

1200/ Seventeenth:LStreet, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036
f .' .4 -'

. BY 1 4 McNeill Watkins II,,Esq.- '

x :5 ' "

, f , APPE A RING ' ~FOR . A PPLI'C ANTS '

6  ;

7x- ' .-

+ . * ~

' < .- t 7,

.s -

, s.

8 .

.,9 t M ,

,1 - 3 .

[, - 10 .

a.

' .~

fil. >

3

12 '

^

!O ,

13" 14: ,

' ;/ . .,-

, ,.15 1'6 4 ..- ,

17-

  • 16 ,

9 J

'l 9 .

, . 2 0- -

7 21- ^

22- .

p- 23; -

5 i T

k FED'ERAL' COURT HEPORTERS-

~g ..

m q -- .

< ~1 1 N.D E X

, y4 VM 2' WITNESS: RONALD D. IMcBEE _

, 3- Examination by Mr. Watkins Page 4 4.

, , 5 . DEPOSITION EXHIBITS 6 Exhibit Number 1, RT Request Form for Field Weld 39C 12

. 7

^

Exhibit Number 2,'RT Request Form-8 for' Weld 34A 12 ,

9 Exhibit Number 3, RT Request Form

'for' Field Weld 40C dated 1/14/84 12 10 Exhibit Number _.4, RT Request Form 11 for Field : Weld 40C-dated 1/16/04 -16

-12 Exhibit Number 5, Progress report dated 1/16/84 17-13-

-k-- (] L ExhibitaNumber 6, NDE c h l t' referring 14 to Field' Weld 39C 19 15- Exhibit Number 7, NDE-chit. referring to Field-; Weld 34A '19 16' Exhibit Number.6, progress report 17;. for 1/17/84 21 ~

18. Exhibit Number 9, NDE chit for 21 Field Weld 40C 19' Exhibit Number-'10, Startup Work s 20, Authorization 23 2 11 22~

23

.24

(~Y -

\_J 25 I?NbRM @@ltllML1MtJ2[T2tNM

m. .;

^

, 4

^

t[ 1  :, <

. RONALD D. McBEE,

.fh sf 2 I . ,

the witness'hereinbefore named, being .first: duly

~

J 3.- -cautioned-and sworn'to_ testify the truth, the whole' -

'4-. truth and.nothing but the truth, testified on his:

r

$! -oa th: .a s ~ follows:

6 MR. WATKINS: This-is the prefiled

. 7 direct testimony of Ronald-McBee. Mr. IMcBee is a

'8; ' Brown & Root employee at Comanche Peak. He is

'9 appearing as a witness in this proceeding

- 10' , . voluntarily and is not under subpoena.

11 My name in McNeill Watkins, counsel for i 12' Applicants in this' licensing' proceeding.

'N '13 EXAM 1 NATION'

, 'w) ' '

14 BY MR. WATKINS:

. ,15 Q. Would you state your full name, please.

16 A. Ronald D. McBeo.*,

17 Q. By whom are you employed?

18- A. Brown & Root.

' ~ ~

^

19: Q. Where are you emp1oyed?

20' A. Comanche Peak.

21 Q. What is your job title?

-22 A. Piping foreman. _

23 Q. How long have-you been a piping foreman at 24 Comanche Peak?

h'~

25 ,

A. Almost five years. ,

c v

i l- FEDERAR @@MMW mR&@MWRRA . , _

( w.-- .- - .- - - - - - - - - - -

= 2 t ,

1 Q. Would'you briefly$ escribe your.; duties as a

.A if ,

2 piping Tforeman?

f:

- .3: A .' Supervise the installation and welding'of f 4;  : the piping a tems.

5. Q. How many people do you' supervise?

.~

6 A. 13.

37 Q. Do they consist of crews?

s :-

.8l A.. Yes, sir.

..c 3 _.

y 9> Q. Ilow many crews do you supervise?

i10- A. 'I have six.

, '11 O. .Do you remember working on January the 14th, E12 ' 1984?

_ -13 'A. 'Y e s',' s i r .

.:14 -

Q. Why do'you remember?

~

15 ,.

4 A. -The most hours I put in in one day at that ,

.161 -plant.in nine years'.

17 Q. What were you'doing on that day? ,

_.18.- A. Superv'ising the installation of six-inch

~

1 91 auxiliary feed valves.

~

2 0. ' O. Was. Jackie Ables one of_your welders in- .,

b -21 January 1984?. -

.g .

r 22; A. Yes.

,Was Iticha rd. Simpson .one of your pipefitt'ers 23 , Q.-

.. ,-q 24 in January 19847,

^^; -

.i  ;

23 A. Yes.

t i _[U-.__..[FEDERALiCOURT,;HEPORTERS__,,,,__. ,__, _ ,___,_

6 5'

s. 4 .

L 1

Q. . Would ~you' describe:their work on that day? '

i_) 2 'A. We had~ to install a six- inch. auxilia ry feed.

3' valveLinto a six-inch. system.

4 -

Q.- How many welds were involved in tha't valve l x ,

5. ' ins talla tion ?

s

+ ./

.6 A./ Three. .

7 Q. Was: Saturday a normal. workday forJMr. Ables 8 and Mr. Simpson?

9 A. No,. sir.

10 Q. Did you, at~some. time on Saturday, request

':11 another welder? i 12 A. 'Yes, sir.' He/was there on another job and

[(~} 13 -finished his job and we pulled him.over to auxiliary v

14 feed.

15 Q. What was~ that welder's name?

l 16 A. Danny Wright.

'17 Q. Duringfthis period, Januaryiof,1984, were f

.18 QC inspectors normally working on Saturdays?

~

! l 19 A. No, si!r. -

20 Q. Did you request that.a QC. inspector report g

21- to work in connect' ion with the work that:your crew ,

22 was doing on Saturday?

23 A. Yes, sir.

{

24- Q. Who did you'make the request to?

(m) s 25 A. Al Justice. ,

' FEDERAL ~ COURT HEPORTERS

~

. a n .

x ,,' ~'. -

., 7 J

s- _

=

1 Q. Would you describe the work that youri r'ew d p:tj 2 .did on-Saturday morning in connection-with thisl ,

3 valve operation? "

l 4 A. Wo prepared the pipe for QC inspection of S cleanliness, fit-up'and' preheat.

6 0.. Earlier you mentioned that there were threc

, 7-  : welds involved. On what welds was your crew

.8 . performing the cleanliness, fit-up and preheat?

~

9- A. Fielo Weld 39C and Field Weld 40C.

10 Q. What was the other weld associated with

~ '11 ,

this valve?

. 12 A. Weld 34A. ,

' (~'g 13 Q. Mr. McBee, what was the status of Weld 34A v .

11 4 on. Saturday morning when,your crew.was working on

.15 cleanliness and fit-up,of the other two welds?.

16 A. It had been weld,ed 35 percent. ,

' ~

17 'Q. Do;you recall'when it was welded 35 percent?

18 A. (The day before,# Friday.

19 Q. Did QC perform an inspection of the 20 cleanliness,. fit-up andspreheat operations on s21 Saturday morning for Fleid Welds'39C~and,40C7 ,

.2 2 - A. Yes, sir. ,

23 Q. Who was.the.QC inspector performing those

-24 inspections?

'25 A. Jack Stanford.

.[.

E d ..

  • k$ hh h b'

. _ . :,. - -g -

, ~ , .

oi. .t '

p1y- .

8 -

] ,4pf =

}i ,

?

a

-j ,,,

E A t

M: 1- Q. When did your? crew '

commence welding on j.,

1 >

if ,

f 2 Saturday, January 14th?

e 3 A.. As-I~ recall, it was after lunch. -

', 'When d'id.your crew complete the welding?

4 , DQ . -.

i 5' j ,

A. Atter. midnight..

~ '

A' 6 Q. .Did Mr. Stanford stay until the wel' ding was 7 completed?

'A.

'8 No,. sir.

.I<

9- Q. When did he leave? ,

10- A.- 3:30 1"n' t h e , a f t e r n o on .

11 Q. How do you remember'that he left at 3:30?f

-12 A. Al Justice and myself.had discussed whether 13 we were going to.get' finished and need the

}.

u. ' ' :14 inspections done by QC that day, and we decided that s

15 we would'not finish the welds.for some time. Al .

16 decided to let Mr. Stanford go at 3:30, which was

'17 the-normal shift change.

18 Q. Who is.Mr. Justice?

19: A. lie is my general foreman.

H2 O LQ. When did you leave work that day?

21 fA. After midnight'.

22. Q. ,

Did anyone leave with you?

23 A. The fitter, Richard Simpson, and the extra 24 . welder, Danny Wright.

L 25 Q. Was anyone still working on this operation r

'I DRDRBSA COMRT REPORTERS

=--

. , '9

~

. l i  !

1:

I i

=when you left? / /

. /% ,  !

[3 .

2. / A.- Yes, sir. Jackie' Ables was working,;and'Al-

~l /

o ., ', 3 ' Justice was~ supervising. ./ -

i -

4 , O.- What was,Mr. Ables doing?

5 .A. .The' welding had been completed and Mr.

6 . Ables was prepping the' pipe for inspection.

-e 7 Q. Could you describe prepping, please? ,

^

8~ ,

A. Yes. You get a power grinder with a -

9 ' sanding disk on it, and yru grind the rough part of

- 10 th'e welb down.

b 11: 10 You mentioned that they were preparing thel 12 welds for inspection. Was t'heta a QC inspector t

'r"T

' 13 lthere to; perform-the inspection?

s) ~'

j' 14 I A. No, sir.

15- ,

Q.. M r . . 'McBe e , is there: any way that your crew.

I'6 .of craftsmen could'have presented any of the three 17 welds involved in this1 operation for~a final visual 18 test or penetrant ~ test to QC inspection on Saturdays.

~ 19 January 14th? .

'20  : A. No,' sir.-

21- Q. Why is that?

o 3' . .

, 22 A. The welds were .not finished 4and prepped

~

23' 'until after midnight, and there was no QC inspectors

}

24' ;on the job. ,

O:: y~ '

25 Q. Was'there any reason.why you would!want'one

i. _. _ _. _ _ _S $MM b ..$M R __ D B RM RB M ______________________

%Q ,

.10 -

g

?' '.x ! -a,f^

g. .

. $. - E- 't 4 v u. z p.. --offthe. welds. inspected for* visual 1 or p 'enetrant test _

7 9; i)'

c-

.l 2 ,~on~ t h e ~ 1.4 th , andinot'the others? -

. / 3' A. :No, s'ir. -

14 Q. Why.lis that?

'!L '

A. ;They all need to be done at the same time.

.) ,, r 6" The system ~ was needed to turnothe water on. A's far

7 ' 'asEour< work was concerned, we needed.to-complete all l

8 thise welds and.have'them. inspected. ,e

, D i ci -' y o u request that any-typeNot testing be

, f .9 ' _ Q.

?d one on ' January.the 14th?

' ^

t 10 L

11 'A. son the 14th? RT.

.12,

.Q. What is RT7 r('s ; ' 13 A. Radiographic testing.

a_) ~

~

How did you request _that'RT's be performed?-

14- ,

0.

15 A. 'I had filled out a standard R T- request the

~

16 morning of the 14th, and- I kept it with me~all d r. y .

17; . Q. Did you fill out a request.for each: weld?

h '

. 18 A. 'Yes, sir.

-r -

.19'

O. Mr. McBee, I show you aidocument that's i

l~

.been marked for identification as McBee Exhibit 1.1 s

. 21 Could you identify that form, please?

' 2 2' A.~ 'It's an RT for Field Weld 39C on '

t 23 AF-1-SB-007.

I' 24 Q. Did'you prepare that request?

( )' 25 , A'. Yes, sir.

l ,

i

(

j .

(

[-

~_ ..-. _ _ _._ _ . _ ,.._ _ _ FEDERAL COURT._HEPORTERS__ _.,_

, .ll' t  ?

What is the . date on that forn?

Q.

y 1 '

! ym, .

.. (J 2 A. The date is'l/14/84.

s 3- Q. I'll show you.a document'that's been marked 4 McBeeTExhibitl2.and ask'if you will identify that, 5 _please.

~

~6: A.- That is and RT request for AF-1-SB-007, 7- -Weld 34A.

, 8, Q. Did you prepare that request?

.9 _A._ Yes, sir.

10. O. What is the date onfit?

1 1' A

'. 1/14/84. ,

i 12, 'Q. Mr. McBee, I'll show'you a document that's j :13; been marked-as McBee Exhibit 3 and ask you to- ,

-14  : Identify that, please. ,

I 15 A. That's an RT request for Fie,ld Weld 40C for -

e, 16 'AF-1-SB-007.

17 Q. Did yo u ' p r e pa r e' that request?.

. 18 A .- Y e s ,-: s i r .

19 Q. When is it' dated? '

. a 20 ~A.' 1/14/84. ,

21 Q. Mr. McBee,-onLthe copics..of.these RT 22- request forms that we have, there' appear _to be m 23

  • stamps, " accepted"fand " accepted," on Exhibits 1, a nd ' >

i '

i L24 2, and on Exhibit 3 " rejected." Were those stamps on

-,C,1 25' there when you: prepared the request?

  • J

'4' q , ,, .t i

7 - - DBDBDOS.Me80R DOD@QNGO& _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

c.t .

~

+

. 12 e e w.- ..,

e , _

e '- -

t .A,. No,-sir'~ .

s f

, ..,  ?-

g .j M2 . Q. :Did youLpersonally_-submit'these forms-to

/ ,

3 radiography. requesting:that the RT be performed?

4 A. No, sir. tI turned',them over to Al Justice. ,

~ 15 :Q. When'did you_ turn them'over.to Mr. Justice?

(  : .

6. A. ~Before-I left Saturcay nighy -- or Sunday ,

- .7 . morning.

8 Q. After you'_left the site on Sunday morning,

.-when did-you-next report for. work?

10. A. Monday morning, 6:30.

^

~

11 Q. What was the status of Field. Welds 39C and

..12 40C and Weld 34A on-Nonday. morning?

13 A. I went to Bob Reed's office first thing

~}-

If Mond,ay' morning. That's where I found out the L 15 results-from the RT's, and I saw that Field Wald 39C

~

'16 qwas accepted, Weld 34A-was accepted and Field Weld 17 40C was. rejected.

10 Q. Ilow did you learn that?

19 A. The sheets had be'en stamped by the QC'shich 20 reviews the-film.

21 Q.1 Are you referring to the acceptance stamps 22 on Exhibits 1 and 27 23 A. Yes, the ' acceptance stamps at the bottom 1

, 24 righthand-side corner of the sheets.

25 Q.. What action did you take with respect to T

A .

g. ,

- - +

13 -

k y

~

3 ~

"r :

j, 11 Field Weld 39C and Weld 34A7 ps - -

jc u ,

Q 22 A. .I put my crew back onto them and told them <

~

P/ -#

~3 to g e t.; QA/QC to come down and inspect a final'VT and 4- ~PT.

. 5 Q. With respect to Field Weld 40C, which

6. you've-testified had a rejected RT, what action did s . -

7 you.take?

8 A. I waited 'till seven o' clock when welding 9 engineering was.open. I went to Zeke, who prepares ,

10 ,

RPS's.

~

=11 Q. Who~is "Zeke"? .

3

12 A. James Zwahr.

l

,'h 13 Q. What f in _ an RPS?

A__.) -

' ~

Ll4 A. A. Repair-Process Sheet. -

l- , l 15 Q. Did you request Mr. Zwahr to prepare an

- c 16' RPS?

V:

i 17 A. Yes,.I did.

18- Q. Did you receive the RPS from welding 6 19 engineering? ,

20' A. -Yes, in mid-morning.

'21 Q. Did your crew work on the repair that day?

22. A. Yes, sir. ~

.23 0. Do you recall.when.they completed their- -

24-. repair?

dd: ' 2 5: A.- That'same day.

s

~

+

DB8BCBS @@@DU :DBD@Q9300_ ---_ - - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _

+ ._ _

ps ,

+

t ' . 14

?

. l$ ? ,

l' O. Did you request.another RT on Field Weld qm; f(f ^ 2 40C?- ,

_' 3' A. 'Yes, sir.

6' '

4- _ Q. When did you do that?. s t 5 A. .The same, day. I prepared a request.' form ,

u -6' tha t' . mo r n i ng .

'7 Q. When did you submit the form .to 'the 8i radiographers?

9 A. When we finished the repair. It just so 10 happened that the group tha.t shoots the welds were 11 in'the.same area doing another weld, and we just '

~ 12' handed.it to them in the area and they proceed to do m- 13 ' setup on it.

(d ~

14 Q. Mr. McBee, I show you a document marked as 15 McBee Exhibit 4 and ask if you can identify it?

16 , A. Yes. This is the RT request that I 17 prepared for Field Weld 40C on Monday, January.16.

18 Q. Did you or your crew c'all for any other QC 19 inspections on Field Wold 40C, other than the RT, on ,

20 Monday,' January the 16th?

21' A. No, sir.

22 Q. Does o' piping foreman, such as yourself, 23 fill out any document that reports the progress on

, 24 . work'done by your crews? ~

b)

'~

25 A. I fill out progress reports.

15 1 *0. Can you describe a progress report?

2 A. It's a report which shows the size, the t

3 system and the type of work done on that systen.

4 Q. lio w often do you fill out those reports?

5 A. Each day.

6 Q. Mr. Nebec, I'll show you a document that's 7 been marked as McBee Exhibit 5 and ask you if that 8 is a progress report that you have just described.

9 A. Yes, sir.

10 0. Did you prepare thic report?

11 A. Yes, sir.

12 0. Does your signature appear on it?

13 A. Ycc, sir.

(~)

14 0. hhat is the date of that report?

15 A. January 16th, '84.

16 0. And,is that when you filled this report out?

17 A. Yes, sir.

18 0. Did you, in that report, record your crew's 19 progress with respect to any of the welds that were 20 involved in the valve operation that you have 21 discussed in your testimony?

22- A. Yec, sir.

23 0. Which welds does it report?

24 A. Field Weld 39C and held 34A, 100 percent.

1 25 O. In the column on the far righthand side of L -. .DPNVEA-_@_@MQ9 DBIPGBffn01 -

y.-

16

-a I' s t :- '+

L 4 3

i 1- thim Pipe Department field progress report, -the're

fR

(_/ .2 appears in the line that's next to' those two welds,

-.3 'the. legend NDE followed by.a number. To what.does-

,4 that NDE number. refer? .
5. A. To a non-destructive' examination report .

61 . chit.

+

7 0.. Can you describe that chit, please?

8 A.. It'has the print number, the field weld 9 number and the QC signature, and what type of work 2 10 was performed.

'll Q. Who' submits the chits to you, as a foreman?

~12 A. The craftsmen. -

h ~13 Q. What l's the purpose of the chit?.

N) .

14- A. So my crews can report their progress to 15 me.

I 16 Q. Mr. McBee, I'll.show you a document that's

' been marked as McBee, Exhibit 6 and a's k you to 17 18- identify it.

.19. A.- This is an NDE chit.-

u 20 0. To what' weld'does: that chit refer?

21 A. Fleid Wald 39C.

1 .

22 Q. 'What is the ~ date of the chit?

23 A. 1/16/84.

  • 24- O. Does the chit number correspond to one of 25 the numbers on,your progress report?

J

& 4 FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS'

_. . _ . _ . - . ~ _ _ .-

a .

gy ,

4 1[ A. Yes,' sir. .To Field' Weld 39C.

7- - ,

fus$ ' 2- Q. 'I'll.show you a document that's been marked 3 as'McBee Exhibits 7 and'ask you'if you can' identify

-r 4' that, please. "

~

5. A. Yes, sir. That's an NDE chit for Weld 34A.

4 '

6 Q. What is the date on that chit?

7 A. 1/16/84.

8 -

Q. 'And-does the NDE chit number correspond to

<9 the~ daily' progress report entry-for Field Weld 34A?

10 A. Yes, sir.

i 11 O. Are these chits the partial; basis on which

12. you fill out the entries in your daily progress ,

13 reports? -

14 'A. Yes, sir.

~

15 Q. Your progress. report for January.the 16th 16 does'not list any progreat for Field Weld 40C;'is 17- that correct?

~18 .A. ~True,'yes, sir.

19, O. hhenidid you learn the results of the

. 20 second RT that you earlier testified you had ordered 21 for' Field Weld 40C7

+ >

22' A. Tuesday morning. ,

_23 Q. How'did you learn?

24 A.. I went to Bob Reed's office a t '6 sJO,J a nd

' L)' ~ 25 .t he RT request was there with an accept stamp on'the e

.t FSDERAL QOURT REPORTERS

. - - - _ x -

- . .. 10 . y

,it 11, righthand-side corner.

r~y

,V- 2 Q.- On-zthe basis of that acceptance, did,you' -

p. .

. issue'any instructions to your crew-regarding'Fleid L' :3' 14 Weld 40C?.

i' -5 A. I told them to go out and request PT.and VT 6: inspections on'the weld as soon as'possible.

7 .Q. Mr.'McBee, I'll show you a document that's 8 been marked as McBee' Exhibit 8 and ask you to 9 - identify that, please.-

.10 A. It's_a daily progress for January 17, '84.

11. -Q. Did you sign that document?

12 <

A. Yes, sir. .

13 Did you prepare that document? ^

Q.

~

'l4 A '. . Yes, sir.

15 Q Does that document, report your progress'on 16 Field Weld.40C7' J

s 17 A. Yes, sir.

100 percent complete on 40C.

18 Q. .And does it list an NDE chit number for

.19 > Field 1 Weld 40C7 Yes, sir. '

-20' A.

. n s

R ,

21 Q. Mr. McBee, I'll show-you a document ~that's 22- been marked as McBee Exhibit 9 and ask you if that-23 is the chit for Fleid Weld 40C that. corresponds to 24 the entry in.your daily progress report? '

25 A. Yes, sir,.It is.

t a FEDEH A L' COUH11 HEPORTERS-

,f - '

19 x- s ,. .

1: Q. : Was that chit the basis for.your entry in

,2 -:

your' progress report of' January the 17th?

3- A. Yes, sir.

7 4 10.. Why did you and your crew work for so long 5 on. Saturday on this valve operation?

-c

. 6: A. As I recall, Brown & Root, wanted to turn-7 the system over to TUCCO, the owner.

~8 Q. When was the system: turned over to the 9 owner?

10 A. On January 18, 1984.  !

? .

- " When a system is turned over, is thet

.11 Q.

i :12' , turnover documented?

?

. /'y,

~ (13 A. Yes, sir. We have a startup work tJp .. , , ,

-14 . a u t h o r,i s a t i o n , 'SW A'. >

~

s .35 -Q., Who' prepares the SWA?

-16 'A. The'startup test. engineers for.TUGCO.

17 0.- Do you in any way'p'articipate in the- -

L

" ~

p' 18- . preparation of that document?~ ,

> . j d 19' / ~ A .: I:-have to sign coupletion of the work being m

'20' .

' performed ~on:the; system.

1-

~

I j 21 Q. Did'you prepare or sign an~SWA with respect- ,

ki[ [22 toithe system of which Field Welds 39C and 40C a'nd

  • y,' ~23' WeldL34A welds were a part? 4

. l'/ :12,4 . A. Yes, sir.

'I b y:'

25_ Q. When didcyou do so?

4

' i 3

3; -. .. -. - .- -. -

% .Y 4;

. i '.2 0 -

g4 - , ,

h s 3

p. ..
b. ' _ , .

1- .A.- J a n'u a r y 18 th ,; 8 4'.

EQ(

4{ '2. Q. . Mr..McBee, after' January 18,.did you havA 8

3 -: a n y : f u r t h'e r conversations r_egarding these welds?

. .: ~

c4 - A. Y e s , ^. s i r .~

? , .

15! 12 . . With whom did'you have a conversation?

w

. , '6 5. J a c k 'S ta n f o rd,. .

~

-; 'Q. Would.you' describe:the substance of the 7

{

8 .conve rsa tion ? .

c ,

9 A. Some time later~he come to me and was

'10 asklug meLif I could help._him.-jog his memory on 11 .

[ inspections and what took place. .

12 ,0 . - What was the basis for his concern?

He said tha't he had sonebody had sa'id he

~

13 A. --

q'}=

m 14 had illegally changed the date onsa card on av' The reviewygroup up on the: hill was

'15 . inspections.

16 hitting him up about it. And we e- my fitterlj'ust.

17 happened to be present at~ the time with me,'and we e

18 -talked to him -- we all conversed between ourselves L ,

19 about the' dates, Saturday through Monday, on it-and 20 , nelped jog'his memory.- All of us jogged our memory

2'1 lon it. .

22 4

-And before he.left the conversation, he'was

23. remembering partially what had happened, took place.

. .24 Ile-looked at the backoof the card ~and saw the other  ;

(

' 'T) 25' dates and just accidentally wrote down the same-l -

EKDBRAR C@MBR hmB@mWRB1

-- .. ~ .. . . . . .,.

- -e 21 L ,

~ ,

. l' dates he was looking at, wrote'down the other dates jy l-

." 2 f w'hich was on the card,- which was:. cleanliness and 3 f i t--up , . whi ch wa s Ma r ch the 14th. And he just

. -4 accidentall'y; wrote down those-dates because he was

~

5 looking at'them.

Q.- Who was the. fitter that was ~ present,during

}6

e ',7 L ' this conversation?

'.3 - -8~ A ~. Richard Simpson.

, 9L ,Q. Does-that: conclude your testimony?

3
' 10 ~ A.' Yes, it does.

[3 11 1 Q. . Thank you,-Mr. McBee.

12 'A.- You're welcome.-

Q u ' ', ' '13;

' 14 , ,

~

y'5 *

.16 . 4 m

I.t 17

'1 g 19 ,

.20- , 4 -

't g 21' -

. ..t -~22: - ,' ,

i.- ' ' '

23' +-

!. ' ,I 24 '

, \. =

~

125 4 '

e '

v.4

'~

I --- - ' _ FEDERAL COURT R E P o l4 T E M S - 1

7-. ;_ <

q;-

.. . g ,

Q. ' -

I
A ~g ,

q, ,

7 2t - -

b

3 ,

4 "I , HONALD D. McBEE,~have read the foregoing m ., ,

- l'S ' deposition , -and hereby affix'my signature'that same.
6 -is t r tie 'a nd correct, except as noted herein.

I

  • Q 7.

>" 8 RONALD D. McBEE 9- i 4

-10 SUBSCRIBED and sworn to'before me this the  ;

. 11 day of , 1984. ,

. 12

~

13 _

-14 NOTARY PUBLIC for the p

15 State of Texas.

16 My Commission Expires:

. 17 f '

18

. 19 .

20 *

- 21 22 23 24 f - 25 I F

'?

'T

  • v ee t- V y-w w-- y- wwww y =w- vivv-ge- yvy- v-t- -

- - - ,q..y ,w-,,e9+y.---,,y- 9 y, 9 ,-,7,,--c. gy-n- ,

-- i.

/ ,,

T (f .

1 23 1 .i .s, 1

~f 3 is)  ;. ,

  • ' *> , 4, ,4 9,-Q .

f  % .

.J,  : S' TATE 'OF , TEXAS

)

-sa p

c - ),i l <

q [..

~

9 3 31 ,

1 I, Janet E. Schstfer, RPR, Certified Shorthand-x .

. j ,

4" '

.Heporter in and for the' State of Texas, do hereby-

~

- ;5' certify that there came before me on the 16th day of

.. 6 ' f August,cA. D., 1984,-at the Glen Rose Motor Inn,

<- o x, ,

, 7 . Glen' Rose,\2exas, the following named person, to-wit

..c

[, _

, 8 Ronald D..McBee, who'was by me duly sworn to testify

r ,9' the truth and nothing.byt the truth of his knowledge
10 touching'and concerning the matters in controversy

':, >11 in this causer-and that he was thereupon examined

~

It 12 'upon his-oath'and his examination reduced to writing pv 13 under sy supervisions'same to be sworn'and

. ' 14 subscribed to by said witness'before any notary r  :

15 public2,> -

U, 1 4

't... .. ' i,

.1 17 'l further certifft that I am neither~ attorney or e  ;;

+

.. 18 counsel for,, nor relcied to or employed by, any of.

A. < _

the parties to the action in which this deposition

. r,/, 19] ,

< 20 isn aken, and further'that 1 am not,a relative or Q. .

a; p ~

- 21 employee of any attorney or' counsel employed by the

, 33 ,1

' *  % 22 '

parther hereto,.or; fin'ancially interested In the r

7.1. ,

23 a c t i o,n .

..  ?

24-

.(n) '

c1

'-I L $

25 In' witness whereof,.I have hereunto set my. hand l

1  !

  • _t ___m2.___.___._. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __'__ _ _b ___. '

24 1 and affixed r. y seal this ___ day of August , A.D.,

2 1984 3

JANET E. SCHAFFElt, 1543, HPR, CSR 5 IN AND FOR TiiE STATE OF TEXAS 1226 Commerce, Suite 411 6 Dallas, Texas 75202 (214) 742-3035 7

8 My commission expires December 31, 1985 9

10 11 12 l

g 13 14 15 16 17 la 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 F E D E li A fl, COURT R T7 PO D 9?ftli fb

4

~ /

s i(OL . wo. 62068

! FILM TO: Quality Assurance Final Date Joint Welded '!

ding Engineering Information Only REQUEST FOR RT REQUESTED BY ' L DATE  !~ FLAGGED BY 677 DATE ~!

( -

( 6 PRIORITY DRAWING A r- /* bb ISO OO7 UNE C3-EeZ-j ' WELD #'J (R)

~

PREVIOUS RT LOG NUMBER IF A REPAIR f PIP DIAMETER (IN.)

JOINT DESIGN:

WALL THICKNESS (IN.) OPEN BUTT h MATERIAL TYPE 3 (NSERT O -

PIPING SYSTEM CLASS BACK.NG RING O WELD PROCEDURE NO[O WELDER'S SNMBCL(S)[M- b$

i Min wr- RR MK STAGE OF MANUFACTURING

1. INFORMATION ONLY (A) REPAIR _

4 ROOT INTERMEDIATE COMPLETED AREAtS)

,N ,

l 18) ROOT -

, 2. RT BEFORE STRESS -

_ r

3. ROOT g _

j

'I 4. REPAIR AREA (S) _'

3' DEPOSITION -

5. FINAL HIBIT LOCATION COM M 7D M. [ L. _

LOG NUMBER: ACCEPTED BY DATE  ! ~' '

REJECTED ,

S

prW no.

62069

~

FILM TO: Quality ssurance FiMal Date Joint Welded iding Engineen Information O REQUEST FOR RT

~ ~ ~

REQUESTED BY - C OATE FLAGGED BY M DATE -

c -

t t PRIORITY DRAWING [ /~ b b ISO OO7 UNE03&2O E 3 WELD (R)

~

~

PREVIOUS RT LOG NUMBER IF A REPAIR PIP DIAMETER [o (IN.) JOINT DESIGN:

WALL THICKNESS

  • 5 76 (IN.) OPEN BUTT @

MATERIAL TYPE INSERT O PIPING SYSTEM CLASS. BACKING RING O WELD PROCEDURE MO[O WELDER'S SYMBOUS) [M7" 8$

M7D%T - $$'>ANS

., STAGE OF MANUFACTURING

1. INFORMATION ONLY (A) REPAIR ROOT INTERMEDIATE COMPLETED s AREA (S)  ! o
j '

j DEPOSITION i; (B) ROOT SHIBIT

! 2. RT BEFORE STRESS

, e' _

i  : ": o E R ACCEPTEff AREA (S)

5. FINAL LOCATION OM '
  • i LOG NUMBER: ACCEPTED b BY ^ DATE 'M'b

' / .

REJECTED ,

AF/'c. c- u.. s2071-(

. . FILM TO: Quality Assurac;e Final Date Jo:nt We ded ~d helding En' gin %r hformation Or.!

, i.. . , , -. m ,

.. f. ..v.-*:3, .

..,. . ' > 2, . r > e,. . , - -. . ^

, REQUEST 'FOR RT ,

~ ~

~

  • DATE FLAGGED BY C /~ 7 DATE REQUES ED BY

.J!-

PRIORITY ". /GT 350 DRAWING f /~ S8 ISO OO7 UNEdb'DI'8 WELD & 4' b (R)

~

'REVIOUS RT LOG NUMBER IF A REPAIR k

i PIP DIAMETER M (IN.) JOINT DESIGN:

t -

WALL THICKNESS +

- - ' (IN.) - . , . OPEN BUTT h

MATERIAL TYPE 3 INSERT PAPING SYSTEM CLASS BACKING RING O WELD PROCEDURE //6/O WELDER'S SYMBOUS) OCT" --

' 5' $/l$

b$f.b 0 5 -

. . 1 '

li

-r w m ? . .n.:

s- . , .g; .

,  : ,. ;.9 . - % , o g ', c, . ; ,, - . , , .., y _.

p.a '

j, . .. .;'

s.,. < . , . C'. . i~.~ \ : .~ j'. .e

. ., ^.-

STAGE OF MANUFACTURING" 1 INFORMATION ONLY ,

(A) REPAIR ?0R If0 M OL Of1U ROOT INTERMEDIATE COMPLETED AREA (S) 4

, IB) ROOT

2. RT BEFORE STRESS 3 DEPOSITION
3. ROOT (

4 REPAIR l

g

. ( AREA (S) #,8 s FINAL LOCATlON om 72 S'B.# l - 7570firy.

LOG NUMBER: ACCEPTED BY 'I DATE /" d '

RbECTED 4-L A i-B h). :g,Ly-.. ']_-) C,...%.&. P 0 - A~Ny w Th 7:,h ,' ( ,, ,

l

/ @ 'l N o. 66668

~

FILM TO: Quahty Assurance Final Date Joint Welded Welding Engineering)

REQUEST FOR RT ,

REQUESTED BY i

6 DATE  !~ ' '

FLAGGED BY. A DATE *

(

PRIORITY fffor ORAWING . b~5O ISO OO7 LINE 8D N8E' 3 WELD [M- Nb (R) 1 PREVIOUS RT LOG NUMBER IF A REPAIR O PIP DIAMETER b (IN.) JOINT DESIGN:

WALL THICKNESS (IN.)

i OPEN BUTT N MATERIAL TYPE INSERT O

! PIPING SYSTEM CLASS BACKING RING O F

WELD PROCEDURE f _

WELDER'S SYMBOLIS) 3 DEPOSITION STAGE OF MANUFACTURING EXHIBli

1. INFORMATION ONLY l?hbf8 Y j

(A) REPAIR _

ROOT INTERMEDIATE COMPLETED

~ ~

AR EA(S) '

t <.

(B) ROOT

+

2. RT BEFORE STRESS

\

, 3. ROOT pp g

~

) '

4'. REPAIR -

AREA (S) M S. FINAL LOCATION M LOG NUMBER: ACCEPTED 0 97k BY

~

DATE l"N

/

REJECTED

r- s;j , q .- ~

  • r y

$

  • 5

~

  • 1.

PIPE DEPARTME NT oLO _ U N I. AEA TOlGl A D S etil \ * .I\

} FIELD :P G "6a"" '*- l-N- M rinus [h _o___

g; ,t g' / spoot. /

"d ' "

5 0 -

Foreman _ . . _  :._ ._C neiner. 2 O n F.iA A R K S f . . ,,7 [ ? g[ .-

9 WELoer c "#

e '

P'. w ir.g nu rn ber 1.ta n , g'4 .t i ( cuc- not E t,c.) .

3 b COST CODE ' -

f line

.gf vot" CCI 'V

  • C l D / ~/. / HOOT a

/V F.L.D OUT ((

9 ~ .. ==!!trm b e r . = . - - - - - [-bed.- T-v by --- No. [Ct m t

_n_h.'s'8 0 C C f 5 / 5.-= Y'.D [ lOCe55.-

$" So he.'c g$to - - - - ..-U. w = .

N .-.g ,

/b N& //o/0 S//$ //0/0 755jb i

o s.- . . - . - .

Y% ,k 00f S, J A

g C5-I-CB-M9 syf 2 f j g

$4R

,& gy, p,,

//cto p

% /1010 hstf p

li

=

g7gu you ,

&ty_fj)7p Q}QQf Q-[QB, _

gg lyj jf i

. 0' Tim %zo.!ssoc

,- Eu j'

=

uw&wd y V4 - --

j-- - .

l I i _ . . . _ .

1 _.. , .___ q _3 t

i .

._ .. l )  !

..!_....f_......__._..,_..__

_ i '

. . _ _ - -  !  ! l i  ! '

- I  !

-1 - - -  ;

I-

___ ,i

.t

!- al 7I j

l

- ~ ~ -

-l i -

_j

t. _.

i -- - . - _ .- _

i  % . _ _

i _

P!1000CTION CONTROL DEPT. .by brag UNIT '

UNIT f - - -

'Y** '

g

-1 I

- U tJ-I T - - ?.- ,

],[1 _ , , . _

t

---_--.-y _

group H t w &. I 2 rM Week ending ' DEPOSITION '

, HIBli '

i. . .. .- c: . p IE . ( , ,

j_ 8

....n { _

,i  !, . ' ,. . , , ._.

r a.

. .-..--w% , . g ewsai . w-, -... u . .y. - - 3_. + g*T. go,77 3_ . . , g ,----,e-.-.--=~-y-ow.- --,-*_;.+=j _ =

.==p.- %ww u,%,=+ .eee.-..

1

.il f

k v

l _

EROWN 8 ROOT f

No. 17 55 30.

NON-DESTRUCTIVE TEST . Time Date

, INSPECTION REQUEST FOREMAN # IN I -8(t li WELDER: A Ldb STAMP A Nb LOC. I ELVNO* 7M PlPE DIA. b" DWG NO/LINE NO. /@ I'bS' C JT. NO. 90 2,q C.

l Ch-scc 3 2, _

lj; INSP. I CJEAQ FIT.UP . ROOT INTER STRESS REL.- '/INg . . f. ' .A W

,! (- ,

f:- REQ. - i (VISUAj) (L.P.) . _ R.T. M.P. U.T. HYDRO TEST .

COMMENTS:

h jlCID

, INSPECTOR LL D A ACCEPT: DATE:

I '

p.  ;. .-

6 i'

lj j DEPOSITION

, EXHIBIT 1, , . . ~

[d' NS .

r~ a , . .

- w.- m;; .- V No. 1755

., i .

NON DESTRUCTIVE TEST .

. Tha* - g, ,

INSPECTION REQUEST '

' ' ' . . , .'$ l '

Tim)

$s.

Date FOREMAN ? t

! ., ,. ' 3 , WELDER:$Id5 f.jg.gf -

\_r

- tg- PIPE DIA. _ /* ,, STAMP 2 'M) LO $6"l DWG. NO/LINE NO. ' 1-sfs AF c._o ; EL D *k7L - -

T. NO._Uts A -

' M...

INSP.

ni CLE

=AN Fl P osto- boob. ' -' -

- gga- ~

ROOTa . INTER 4

'[ VISUAL L.P STRESS REL. N *'

.!.I. d COuuENTsM) (-)

R.T' ' ' M.P- u.L ma usr

, ,['d - ; .- .

2.. . _ __

(lOIO . .

. .. s r ,

. e. . .

~,. .' '. l. .

~;

u INSPECTOR: dl & '

~

a .

s. I

_ A CEPT: -( DATE: I'/b' O

~?

e.:s a. "

fi i;

-e

.: .c . s .

~:T  :

  • i "f >. -

2

" DEPOSITION U

', u .-

? IBIT

l. Qef 3 .
b. } ' >-

. t., - 1

.'i? '

3, a -

- , g' +

4

, t ,

_ :P ;r .

1 f; .

i~ '

e N'

~.- ra'

}. .;; .

., j, i.'--

.;< J.

e

' t 7. .. ) ..

': . s -'5 5

T ' .*:

rt:

t, ' -t 7,., -; .

S .

.,, .'7,5 .

..'c; ' ,. '

' .l:.. .

lt

. 4.- -

1' ,

n . _'; -

t*..,,, i *

.  ? ;.,,*. .,

  • ,J' ..

% . s .*

. . Y, t.

I' -)/ , ,-

j ;e- . ..

> - 4s ... - -

l ,

e l t I f i f ~~ \ f llI' 1%

l z%

w- . N .

l > .

o ,_

c-u.

e. . :h M  ;

t; x4\ ns -

i

.- . ,!!. * . ' I am Ox

a. m .

-.' e

, t 1 I

- \.,,q I .

l l l j l l J . -

i t -

l  ;

i i i i  !

O 2p!j S l DI M % Ml W j'6.d.

'9. h k k N'

(l bi k , ,

%g 5

C s,g qq E

m ).,,.ra 7 Yw f(i - l 1 1 2

u C $] a (, Ah q i

. 8. 2 1

olic . , -

mNc-2

,- C

~

S >

.~

.. i

[E-N @N k  ; ,p,k .

'I

EE:'J} D

. . . 9% > N % yig bi M) , % r j$ ,!

EN $.0 m[2 l.s ?NR, R,f UllE-

.~?: c!. c% qxR '

Q Q .R.

I'.'

5) d'

> 2: y w g - \

3 dMN

\

-- l 6

i l N

- .M, _m .Rh_ ,s 9 m

.x o g

> g wm. +N a , cs e+4 D g N a j

e

~

q '

c,;

$(k s.

s, S

  • d s 'd e l q ,1 s t J. ti w $h 5 -

1 '

i w v yi ll RET i

ts !IFI N 'Mi t

$ i

! $l -m &lwe I Ml N' I ~

l l i { l

%,1 ~ l 31 gIig-9 ,l% 9 i gi n

! D. k d 3 j'y' N

%8 gi

'it

" et .

w.ws'w cMgw bdeM g WI s% ,

m n,yln-sin.

-d eS i is h

, 3 d %j S K ' E' W,%ds E 'i sg es s )- -

o c i b @ i.

e' kk'k,I i

F-- O- I S6

~ h.4

~_

c.; o, . i ,s 'Q t . m,1 . "! I j

l lo N e , , 3 Nr  ! -.. .

hl

! N W 1 s "'  : K (.k: N '

I

'k 5, l .

P 9c.'; ! L ~ll ,150 A'! w, (X l N.!

dj .31-2 e1i-l.3 ,3 3

  • '~ .

Py .C*

g

. ._V...- . . _N .%, .N . . .N u i  ;

'-9 h@I .

. .. N n '

it a 3_

0 -

C

  • I c_a' . 9

= , g j t '

w ,, >.

t l

l 8= " ,, i :  !

O l i i  ;

a m c

!. . l , i i I

WJ B 3l l i

.t 1

O l I I-LW E  :

l l 1

I ~- p E i 1

-- o s. I s o E,

  • C it. E o! I ' o I i ! -

g C i o VI 1 l

O l l  ;

f C l l

... ,- I } I i

. . . . . . _ - . . . . . - - - ~

m  :, . , mo, ,$--( 33n n .

., . v. 57 . ..

~

s. :NON DESTRUCilVE TEST - .

. p . . .w: s .v .

Tima Data .

INSPECTION REQUEST FOREMAN ~ .!I /dI I~IF - .

h LOC _ bl

. WELDER: ' STAMP' ' Mil 3 ELV. ,"

' PIPE DIA.' V DWG. NO/LINE NO. AE-t-SE5-01 JT. NO.  %-400. '

':t . -

86-M-M m  :

<INSP. i CL FIT UP . ROOT INTER . STRESS REL. QiNAL) s

/

. :REO.. 'I _ ) R.T. M.P. U .T. . . HYDRO TEST

. COMMENTS: . M. _ q .

'w .

s .sy , .

' f Q.;

. , ' , -h) .

~ ;; u -

'. %. . ., , la. . %. .

3.L ,

,  ?. :; ,_

e. ..

tag f;. '

'.,',,5 1..-

. . .t g INSP OR: ACCEPT: DAT; / '/ 7 ~ #~/-- '

.., . . _ - M ..

' k.h!' '

.6

y,' . .,

r, 5-

  • .] ; G  %

' ;?.1 ji- ,

. e.

.#., . . .. 3

~.

s.' <*

Y c

- -3 4

4

. . .v.x

% , s

,. 3 DEPOSITION HlBIT

' 'NPf mj*

r j

, 4:

a

    • ... ..,J- . . e

n _

F Q

)

ATTACm!ENT C CP-SAF-6 Revision 9 Startuo Work Authori ation Page 17 of 17

%.' h System

Title:

UX hEEDWA M

.) Unit No.:

/

I

$N7 Startup System No. : _ 3 7 0 Z Authoritation No.: h, j ,

Work De'scription (Include identification of components affected): *-

REPLACE V A W E. T AF- OG7 \N rru TM G UN\T TWO VALVE PER PET # $3\7 AND BRP- AF- \- SB - tc7 REv 14.

REF G" AF-\- 36 '2002-3 i .' k fe,o- -h> b F h.,, va lve. <J

(; /A.s,4~

\. cL. M si e L c. /e a - , + c , s ;O

/6 / Hen,n,,A 787 " ~ O " "% DQ Reference Drawings: Ml-O2.oG '

p S Work Location (Bldg., elevation, room, area, etc.): b.O. EL D O o, g. Reason for Work: (i.e., DCA, CMC, NCR, etc.) 9AUAc,ko YALVE

,1 Esti=ated time required to complete work: 7 DANS Work Requested By: N\M Y \R\N\ w

  • 576 12-\2-63 Nace/ Phone Extension /Date l Safety Tags Required: -K YES NO If Yes, CP-SAP-5 Authorization No.: #M STA-605 Clearance No: 7%7 Work Authoriaed By /1-//-[Placed on Hold by:

M /;r-/7 33 STE/Date' STE/Date s.

All Construction

'I .

k;

! Work Co=pleted: /f/ [('# ! ~

Construction Deparecent/Date RETURN THIS FORM TO TUCCO STARTUP q Work Verified Coc:plete: '

5 Startup Engineer /Date j DEPOSITION

!!XHIBIT Recesting Required: -

t  ;

Retest Complete:

}, Startup Engineer /Date Required Retests and Retest Data Approved By: Date:

OR GIN A_

- - COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION . .

. CLEARANCE REPORT Number y ] dj;"**) ] Date work to begin Th -/: .~

-U Time

- ~ , ,

~

.A '

,tf' - ^ . I /

f,,s : c.

s., .equested by -

Department /Section v '" ->

Equipment Description /II 'I M' / / '-

6i /I O Reason for Clearance Il / M /- " / 'E sr -

M

~'

Attached by > ' ' 4- i f- '. )

, . .r. y osm- /

7 i . Verified by / . / /I / ' F-Larensar Opereto, MAR No.

~

l 4 . Released by RWP No. ^'

, , cz,.,e=,

4 me , = = n, L j,' ~ Removed by WBP No. '/4 op, -

[ Verified by '-

1 ., " 9'" '

Clearance Authorized by i

Date - "

Time

, sne se.-

Release Authorized by Date Time Sa# 58P'r' dor a Comments 3

i t

s TAG COMPONENT CONDITION TAG TAG LOCATION Valve Breaker REMOVED BY

, NO.

Open Closed Open Racked Out Other (Initials)

~

/NS 2'iS~D A A r!Ji) & I

.; 1. :7.

2. / N's av ri A /t=<.j?
  • 2 :rt--

} 1 /Ed / J?.A 1 a.l) d/ ,d 9 .W.y

i. ,/K.3 ) in ) a = . ,, ) up i:. c p t. .

W . :../

f V  : ._ , '

-} s. j 4 i- (c (,.

9.- _ _, ,

j - . ,, Y

6. i j ..' , .. , b (gu ,t1 ;- t,; )<,'

) 7.

i

[ 8.

1

( 9.

,  ; 10. Seca e /f / g A / '74' 95 127 t?

11.

JC ]&~ f' 9 l 12. / 3 33y / 3,(f(

l

i. C <'3- J2 / FY )3151 I4- / $)

lt' 1s. ,o gr t' -

, i 6. - /.37 or .  :

, r.7 Fo o sum.i

,_

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20095C111&oldid=2785384"