Text

Prefiled Testimony of Je Brown on 840815 in Glen Rose,Tx. Pp 1-21
	ML20095C140
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	08/15/1984
From:	Jonathan Brown; BROWN & ROOT, INC. (SUBS. OF HALLIBURTON CO.), TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To:	;
Shared Package
ML20095C073	List: ML20095C069; ML20095C081; ML20095C093; ML20095C111; ML20095C114; ML20095C120; ML20095C127; ML20095C140; ML20095C145; ML20095C159; ML20095C169; ML20095C180;
References
	OL-2, NUDOCS 8408220393
	Download: ML20095C140 (29)
	v • d • e

p , .-

^

~

., c 4.

m. . , .

1

p. / A f - y.

y' q: -

~

[/j ' s

~

1 . UNITED [ STATES'OF~ AMERICA ,.

n '

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 2

BEFORElTHE-ATOMIC SAFEhY. &' LICENSING ~ BOARD' 3 rIN iTHE ' MATTER . OF:: ) gggggn

,, ) ' t.lSNitC ' '

h~ f4l TEX 5S UTILITIES _ ELECTRIC ) DOCKET-NOSg

= COM PANY , ET AL,, )

50-'4 4 5 0N AG0 20 PS:08

- - 5.

.) 50-446 g,4

f: (COrNNCHE1 PEAK STEAM )> _ k 8FL E M"U C,'

~6 ELECTRIC > STATION, UNITS )

90CKETIE & SEF.'io.

lJAND.2)- _) BRANCH 7 .

8 '

-PRNFILED TESTIMONY OF^

JAMES E.-BROWN

. ,. '9 AUGUST 15, 1984

,?

.10 -

4 11

' 12:

D' 13; M _. _

,' il4 PREFILED TESTIMONY'OF JAMES E. BROWN, taken on 15 thet 15th' day of August,-1984, in the aboverstyled n 16 a'nd numbe r ed : ca us e , at Glen Rose Motor Inn located 17'- -ate Highway 67 & FM Road'201, in the City-of Glen

-18 Rose, . County of Somervell and State of= Texas, before 19 jJanet 3,.

z. E. Schaffer, .a Certified Shorthand. Reporter in

'20-and for~the State of Texas. .

21 s

22 .

23- -

?$f22039 24 T '

' Q'.s. OhhhO -

.2g ,

p 1

FEDERALJCOURT__ REPORTERS. _ ._ _,,__, _ _

.. . . ~ - .- . - - - -

. . . - - , --~ ~ .-

- . ,i,',. - 4 e !

2 - - ,

2 n -

. ,. a ~

- APPEARANCES:1 -6'

(, 'k_ _

.1 m

1

{fy 4Q * ~

, \./: , 2' BISHOP, L'IBERMAN, COOK,'PURCELL & REYNOLDS

.g . - Attorneys.~at Law .

i j - -3 .1200_^ Seventeenth Street, N.W.

, y LWa s h'i'ng ton , D. C. 20036 '

g. q.4 .

1 ;-J ,

J '

,BY: 1McNeill Watkins II,-Esq.

3 APPEARING FOR APPLICANTS

,. ,. '. . r N.' s i , s 4

4

,, - 'nh

, .g. u- ,> .

f

,~ ,' -

-r ,

.a -

e. .-_s

\

+ ,;; *

, r

s. p.

+

-9 ~ .

-r -

% ?

. $. .. . . <s ,

b n e:.

4

. s 10. '

< 4 V'-,I!_ ,-

g +

W - +

. 31 ,

. m';

s f, . ' j: .

, . , . - . , i e + ,1 21 4'

e .

- .; ^ .

, w

'.13 a- a' -

~ ,

y 'l '# '

4 k

{ g

[ ^

14" ,

.r . F e

(

w --

g_ + y

' ^

y. -

r .

rm - gy w; . ..16-M. :I.g , '._' s ,

5g 4 'N "g - '

' k

.s

.17' ,

/ .I 1 /

sE _'18- - -

3. ; cir '

!' 4 4

" J ~

.. '19 " -

g 7

~

20' ' '

r. ,

. [[ ' ' '

i ._

/

[

721 -

j.

... , .t.' ~~ '

s r

,- - ; T' 2 2. ' s t' ? r + >

q

' A .>- E w., , -- '23 < -

t a

,, A f k-

- k

., _ h -

.v

.\ ~

. " - ,: s

. , , ._ 2 5 '. .,

l M

f

.f q ,

.3 f_

3,< .- ,, q _g , 1 v

4 ; ..g. , ,

t

A-l -i.L , , , ., > ',' ,

e a

p y _

,. - m , _-w; , ,

A_,

4 ._ : -

p. ' ; _o

+

q ., - -t

-3

," l % , . .,

. . ~ :: g y

33_ , , .

o _s 1-I N'D E X" " -

'f-N;y, 7 y 2,- 1 WITNESS:_ - J AMES- - E. BROWN w ~ ;; ,

O $ ?-3 '

Exsmination.by Mr.~Watkins .Page 4 s

3 .

,. p '

s _

.4 5 ;DE PO S I T I ON. E X H I B ITS . PAGE

- ' ,. P:

,/~ , 6' Exhibit Number l' , Blank Labor Control' Sh~ee't for Brown'& Root employees ,

6

_.7 .

Exhibit Number 2' , La b'o r f C o n t r o l' e S h e e t ..

~

8' _for week ending 1/14/.84 11.

4: 19c. Exhibit--Numbers 3,throughs-7, Labor 12 n _: -Control Sheets for. week e nd i ng . -1/14 / 8 4

, ;" 10 yk

p ExhibitoNumber-8, Sign-out. sheet for Ell ' B rown .: & Roo t e m p l o y e e s 17' t

, p '

12- .

. x. ,

<N- J13 -

- k) ' .< _ .

14 .

y ^

' ^

-15 _

~ ,

. 16 f 17 - ,

,18 19, 4

, T 20 i .

- . 211. # , .,

( 22 ,

L ' .

~

23 i

! , f{ .

25-

~

y. .

i,e ,

. FEDERAL"_ COURT REPORTERS

m. 3 , - ,

2, : 1 a

,4

.F _

4 ;

g. .

b.J a . ,

1

, I ;% JAMES E. BROWN, l

gg _ r '

)

(s[ 2'

, the. wit' ness hereinbefo're named, b'eing first duly {

r 3 cautioned and sworn to testify- the truth, the whole

~

. t ex >

4 truth and'nothingEbut the truth, testified on his

" f1 4 5

= oath--as follows:

6: MR.;WATKINS: My name is McNeill

' - - c -

e . .c _

y 7- 1 Wa t k,i n s . - ~ I'm with the law firm of Bishop, Liberman, 8 ' Cook, Purcell &' Reynolds in Washington, D. C. L' e

._ ~9 are'counselIfor' Applicants in this licensing 10 proceeding. This is thefprefiled testimony of Mr.

11 , James Brown,'a Brown &' Root employee at Comanche 12 P e a k .' / 'H eil s .a p p'e a r i ng here voluntarily for this

'13 deposition and has not been subpoenaed by any party.

V('il g ,;14I "

, / EXAMINATION y 15. BY MR. WATKINS:

16 Q. 'Mr. Brown, would you please state your full

'17 n a, m e .

18 'A. James-E. Brown.

. fl 9 Q. By:whom are'you= employed?

(c 20 A. ' Brown & R o o_t ,- Incorporated.

21 fr -Q.

- jWhere'are.you employed?

v

.2 2 - A. Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station.

~

23 -

. , Q. 1What is.your title, Mr. Brown?

2 "I

~

q :24 A. Chief'Timekee,per and ~ Payroll Supervisor.

P )

~~

F '25 0 .' How~long have you held that position?

4 ,

i a

i #'

3' -

5 t: ,-r r .

+ r

1= . A'. 'A little over five years.

g y-xJ ;2 0.- -Where, physically,cisLyour-office located

~

3 atLComanche Peak?

~

4 A. [In the Time. Office.

~

5 'Q . Would you,briefly describe.your duties?.

n 6- A. I:am ~ responsible for documentation of hours n .7 worked by Brown & Root employees on the job site.

8 Q. How does the Time Office keep track of the 9 n u m b'e r of' hours that'each Brown & Root hourly 10

, employee' works'on a given day?

-- 1 1 ' A. As the employees come to work, t h e y ', r e L12 sissued a' brass with an employee identification 13 ~ number on it, and then we go behind them and log the

(]{ '

14. -time-that they' pick ~their brass up. At the end of 15[ the day, whenever they l e a v e. for the day, the 16 em p'l o y e e s d'op'their r brass of; w'e ' l o g them out.

- 7 v

17 Q. Do Time office personnel write down the-

,_ 18; timesEthat Brown & Root employees-check in and out?

19 A. In most cases we don't actual'ly write down 20 nthe time, no.. What we do is, when an employee comes 21 < in at tre beginning of a shift, Time office 2 2.. personnel p it a pencil mark down for that employee.

23

^

The pencil marks are color-coded to shifts.

For j;' 24 example, a blue pencil mark would mean ~that the t t t

t a -

l

,t

~25 employee clocked in on the 5:30 a.m. shift, and a I .

, 9

= W' ,

~

6 kYl .-

.c- -

4

.c y 1- green pencil; mark-would mean that the employee-74 .

shift. The ac ri-) s

~

2 ~ reported':.for workron the 7:30 a.m.

~

T 1 '3 L reason ~ we use color codes is that on some shifts we 1 4 ' havebover' a thousand-people reporting or leaving at

' ~

. 5 ithe same time. 'It's not feasible for the Time-

a 4- f6 ' Office to. write down the. times.

7, O. What happens if a shift. employee rep' orts 4

^

8 forJor leaves work at a' time other than the-normal q 9 shif'd?. .

j ~,,

it ,

,E10 '

A. Then we write down the' actual time'that-the 7

( -

m.

11 employee reports or leaves.

12e _

Q. Do'the Time'0fficeopeople use a form for

' (~y 13 recording'the times that Brown & R'oot employees 5s 14 /- -reportefor and leave work?

s". -15 A.' Yes, . sir. We use a" Brown &" Root. Labor s _1

? M ,

16, - Control Sheet.

^ -

17. - O. Ji r . Brown, I'll show you the document

, 18 that's been marked for identification as Brown-

19 Exhibit I and ask.you if that is a blank copy of thel 9 20 Labor Control Sheet to which you just referred.

21 A.- Yes, sir,'it is.

,. I

-[ ,

22' O. Mr. Brown, are these Labor Control Sheets

. 23 filled out daily for each Brown & Root hourly f 24 employee that works at Comanche Peak?

h v f4 25 'A. Daily, yes.

m

m. ,,

3 .m- .s v

p. . . .

y

~

.,. 3 ,

s , >

?1 '

Q.. -Does the Time office retain these Labor J.3

,, %J -2 Control ~ Sheets after they have been filled out?

E , ,

3 A.- (Yes, sir.-They are the basis for paying 4' = Brown'&" Root employees.

~

. [ -5_ Q. After-they are filled'out, do they remain

t. 6- in,your personal: possession and control?

7 A. . Yes, sir.

up 8 Q. ' Physically where do you keep, and how do 9' ,you keep, these Labor Control-Sheets once they have p ,

' 10' .been' filled'out for'a given; week?

7 11 .A.- Each-week' the Labor Control Sheets and te' 12 - 'other documentation are bound together for each 13 week-ending period.

w- '('T .)

1: '14 Q.. Mr. Brown., do you have all of the_ Brown &

~

15 P.oot" hourly Labor Control Sheets for the week ending 16 , January.the 14th, 1984, here with you at this time?

17, A.- 'Yes, sir. I have before.me the binder 18 . including all Labor Control Sheets for-that week.

19 Q. Are those Labor _ Control Sheets the

- 20 originals?

21 .A. .Yes,~ sir.

, 4 22 Q. Mr. Brown, how do the Labor Control Sheets' 2,3 identify employees?

24 A. By badge. number.

/T LJ '

,25 -Q. Is there a list.of names and corresponding 4

I. -

_m '

~

T1TRf6pg[Afl, @(61Mggt Tdf4fpATRRfCBR

y

=,

~

g f

. m ..- .

! "w A

s

: ;g 1 - badge numbers.for alliBrown &-Root employees at gm ~

, '2 s Comanche P e a k ?~- ,

f

'3 [A. .Yes,, sir.

14 - Q. Would you describeLthat: list., please?

', m5 A.- 1It's called a' timekeeper's listing. It's a r, .

.9 6 . com pu te r. pri n to ut. tha,t lists all the employees k, J' 7' ' , -

alphabetically.- The list _gives their badge ~ number n, S E and . o th e r- li1f o rma ti on.

im 9- "

. Q.

How often-is the list updated?. '

.s ,

~ ~

+

. 10.- . A. 'Once a week. '

.j y.ou have a current list with you at this

' < *' > 1 1 . LQ. -

. D 'o

. o

~

. ; 12' 't i m e ? .

-Q, 132 , i A . .. .Yes,. sir.

, , (;c

, 14 X ,0. .Mr. Brown, is: Ronald-McBee a Brown & Root-t 15 - empl'oyee at' Comanche Peak?

16-. A. . Yes,, sir.

',17 Q. ,

What is'his badge number?. ,

~,. ' , > .= -

18- A.- .3164. '

s..~ ,

t

>19 'Q. -Is Richard Simpson a Brown &. Root employee

(

- '2 0 ' at, Comanche Peak?

'~

' 21;

'A. Yes, sir.

22 :Q. What-is Mr..Simpson's badge number?

H, 4: .

u, '

'23 A. 8554.

e -

t 24 Q. 'Is~ Alan Justice a Brown & Root employee at L/ '

25 ,

Comanche Peak?

M.a

};.-

W fr 9 ,

b' -$ '

.pr,,%,. >'

fg

d~.

_ z. .

9

. T

.# .'a . .

, ,U '

r e r y_, sq. ..

?. __

'31' - ._ A .

J .Yes, sir..

.. ,,f

~

r ; .. .

- M

, 2 ~.

~

Q'. ,,What'is:Mr.vJustice's badge n_ umber?

o 3 'e 'A.: 2371.I i

=m. , ,n

-i ;4 .

}lQ., "Is Danny' Wright an employee of' Brown & Root 1,

5 . ,. ... at'. Comanche Peak?. -

e a *. .

- . 6 ' A '. Yes, sir ~.

g ., .e -

,7; --Q.. What.is.Mr. Wright's. badge u number?

2 1 . r, y , 8e A. '5823': .

.y

.s.

/9 Q. 'Mr. Brown, have you establishe'd each of the

} ,10 b'adg'e numbers for those individuals'by. reference to -

y

~

1'l ~: the .. compu te r_ pri n tout ,tha t you have before-you.as

~12 ,you_ testify today?-

D-S,x .

13 ' ' "

'A . ' JYes,= sir, I have.'

~

s 31 4 0. Mr. . Brown, i f ._ a ' ba dg e number: includes the n.h . ,.

~

15 ' (prefix HQ ,,, wha t . doe s that indicate?

(,

._y +

L16 A.. -QC inspectors _at-Comanche Peak are carried' j' ,

Kj _ , .17 an~the.' Brown.& Root Ilouston-payroll c om pl e t'e l y

-5 -

~"

5 18' J-sepa ra te Jf rom . the s i t'e Craft. personnel. An "HQ"

.a

, a f - g19 ibadge number, indicates that the employee is on the

p '

"2 0 ) Houston payroll.

'21 *

, - ' :Q. Are' employees.with "HQ" badge' numbers

, q223 listed on'your timekeeperfs list?

123 f ? , -A. No, they.are_not.

.1

!24 Q. Is there'a separate list of Comanche'. Peak *

, )

~ ~"1 , 525 employees'ca'rried.on.the Houston payroll?

4 .

ji ,

^

L . . .

f .. .

c. 1;,g g.qi ; , 93 < g. .- ,.

~,

t

. b. 10

, . -> J .

pr v J ~ g./xly+_ : . -

L

-q g@y L 4,r .. s.

- 4-

.,1 47 iMA . '

Lyes. I G .f;;h N' , i' g-t y

(

t M;e ; 27 s-

- s -

,4 3 0. Do you bavew.:a4 current copy of that. list

.m qw g- yc

4-L(.,

i

> 3. .ebe f o re ' youf a t'!thi's t t! n e ? t ">* >

t

' A L

f. ;

3',a;;l, 4' J- 'A. Yes,, sir,fI ;do.

S /

t

.. _ v *

't V ' q :, ' .

s i d5 , ..10. ,

- I's .fJ a cOk Stanford included on that list?

s .i..,

, 3 ,

- ^

-6 ,A.' Yes,. sir,Jhe-is.

.s.4 ,

3 f. . . .

a:7. 3 F/;. . 1 . Q.

+

tWhat i s, (Mr . Stanford's badge number?

.t,, s

. m .

, -Q' ,

78 1 :%

h'2A. t;

' H Q -- 10. :

fgs '

,9 . Q. LIs^Mr. Stanford currently a? Brown.& Root m~ ~

lemployee at Comanche b P'eak?

~

T10 ' '-

'i,c - - ,

4

?_y . .'; ,,

Yes, s'ir.

+' , . .A.

.* 3

' e ..

12 "Q1- v ,

Mr. Brown, .is Jackie' Ables currently a ,

.N 'k ,

,'m e ,. .

-13 Brown 4 Ro.ot employee at ~ Comanche Peak?,

x

%c, <

g.

, .c .

Y*$ 31 4 >

. . A.; .

'No,. sir, he-is not.

- : e ,":

uh,

.d p.

v ! 15' "

. -Q. Has Mrk Abids-ever been a. Brown & R'oot -

, , c, - ,

. f 16 t einployee ,a t ; Comanche . Pea k ? ,

, 4 /[ , 1 71 *- -A.. Yes,< sir, he has.

1 e ,.

- r p ,

18,

.Q.' When'did.he terminate his employment? .

\f '

Ma y; 2 4i 19 8 4. .

3 '{l 9 - A. - - <

y. . ., .

20 y , ,

, Q '. Was7 ,r.sAblos M employed by Brown ~&~ Root,.at

, , x , .

~21 Comanche Peak in January of 1984?

k.'

, , 22' - 1 1 Yes, sir.

.s ,

_ 23 :0. Wha,t4was his badge number?

2 ; ;, t .

.24 A. 7794.t t

O 1

. e, .,-, ' .,

M

25' QL- Mr.: B'rown,'I show you a document that has e

\

+

t wi- - . [R$

g g, - -

N '

- . ~ , 11:

w pg . ;r .

,, 7;q; .

-Q ,-

~ JQ ' : ,

1 . .,e .I

. ? .la- Jbeenimarked for identificati'on as Brown Exhibit:2.

s, ,

o s Ji). 2

~

) -s Can you identify it?

~3- DA'. ;This 'is'a copy of the Labor Control Sheet

.o -

t b: '4' for ~ certain./ Comanche-Peak employees.with "HQ" badge

5 numbersifor-the ~w'e e k- e nd i ng . J a n u a r y' 14,'1984.

y' 6- ,0 . . . Earlier.you testified that Jack Stanford's

.g ;7 , 3 b~a d g e in u'mbe r ' . i s I HQ- 10 . Does Brown Exhibit 2'show

't 8: that Jack Stanford worked on Saturday, January the

, =

. ,.9 14th?

~10 A. Yes, sir, it d o'e s .

11 ~ _Q., When'did-he clock in that day?

, l12. A.- 7 o' clock a.m. 1 s . .

13 Q. When did'he-leave on that day?

f'Jl R

~ 14 ~ - A. b:30 plm.

y~

[ '15 -

-Q. Mr. Brown, I show you five additional 16 documents which -have ~ been : marked for identification i

o- -17 as Brown' Exhibits 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7,'and ask you to

. , ~ .1 8 . identify them.

t

+

L.

O 19

~

A. These are'copics of Labor Control Sheets e

-20' for Brown & Root'C'omanche Peak employees for;the 21; week ending January 14, 1984.

Q. Have'.you' compared those exhibits with the

~2{

~

23 orig 1nals in the binder.that is in your possession?

j3 24 A. Yes, sir.

1 i

%J ..

25 Q. And'that binder is for the week ending Y' E q RRRR@aR c@MBR mm@@RTERS

p, .c

'y' ,9 - .

m ,

,!.J ' . ,

6 V ,

u,.

y

.;1 danuary th'e ^14th, 1984; is^that correct? *

,.,-~.

.b'(' 2' A .; Yes, sir.

3 ,

'O. ' Earlier you' testified that Ronald McBee's c 4- . b'a d g e numbe'r.was 3164.

Referring to Brown Exhibits l.

u -

. , . ~

^

E' 4;throughi7, .can you state whe thc r M r . McBee worked 3

. + ,

e~, , ~

~

6- on ! Saturday, January-the 14th?

. A 7 < Yes,' sir,'he did.

.' A .

; + ^ c ~a' i, O.- To which exh'ibit are you referring?

49- .- ^A. Brown Exhibit 4.

. '10 Q. What hours did Mr. McBee work on Janua'ry '"

b 1I t. h e 14th?c .

L,.

h 12 A. F r o m ~~7 o' clock a.m.-till.1:30 Sunday'

[ } , . , .13

, y, . .<

morning. ,

. , [ ._

'14 Q.. .Is/there an actual notation as to the time _

,,y' s- -

' n

-15

,'he. checked: ~.out_on the'14th? ,

l= f. t t; J. ' ' 16

.' A. Yes,: sir, there-is.

p:.73 i <

y.

f, ,.

17. Q. . Wh'at:isuthatJnotation?

~

i-f18 _ (A . '0130.- '

.y ,

$f ' , U19 Q. :Does that mean he left work'att 1 : =3 0 'a.m.-on 1y'-.1 . ,

2

! - S 20;. . . ~ Sunday morni'ng, January the 15th?.

s: . .

L 't . ', . . ', , ,

Jo_ 121 ' , . ~

A. Yes, sir'.

h* f +,~,

7

.Q."

.Earlierfyou'gave, Richard-'Simpson's badge

" , 3.p , ', 2 2 4 *

. "i .. .

s

[ ".. 3 23 , number as 8554.

Referring to Brown Exhibits 4 7

,r~ , =[ i24 th r o u g~hf 7f, can you tellTme whether Mr. Simpson a

a" ) _

~

]i l2 5 , worked'on' January!the 14th?

\ ,

l, .L y

~ , '

' ~ '

T'! % , _%2- '.,

BD JTs-r o

) ,., ,

, v 13

+ , < s

.g ,

2 -1 1 A., Yes,Jsir, h e' d i d . .

'.i -

m.,/ '2- Q. 'To'which exhibit;are you referring?.

k ;- i

. >3+ A. Brown Exhibit.7.

~

~ '

10 . . When did.Mr. Simpson check in that day? -

0 ~

5 'A. :7 c'c1'ock4 a.m..

~6- O. 'When did he leave work?

f 17' '1:30 Sunday morni'ng.

.A.

< - y

~ :8 O. ' A n'd 't h a t would be. Sunday, January the 15th?

6 x

,9; 'A. Yes, sir.

8:

?

10' 0 Mr.' Brown, earlier you gave Danny Wright'.s

~ 11' badge numb'er'as 5823. .By referring to Brown J 12: Exhibits.4 through.7, can you. state:whether M r' .

-13 Wright worked on: January the 14th, 1984?

(J~'t 14 A. .Yes,. sir, I can. He d i d _. w o r k .

[4 11 5 Q.

To which-exhibit are you referring?

,' . 16 ,

A. Brown Exhibit 5.

17 Q. When.did Mr. Wright commence work that day?

'- , ' 18 A. 7.o' clock a.m.

1 9' .

Q.- And when did he icave, work that day?

^

2'O' 'A. 1:.30. Sunday morning.

So'he'would have left at~1:30

. 21' Q. a.m.,' Sunday,

22. ,

Januaryithe -

15th; is that correct?

/

-23 A.. lY e s', sir 1

f hx 24 '. Q., Earlier you gave Alan Justice's badge o .. 25 number as;2371.

Referring to Brown' Exhibits 4 i N y L e

m _.. L _ _ . _

,c ' *

- t-

- # 14

~

3 J

4

,? .6

. g ., f ' l. through 7, can youlstate whether Mr. Justice worked t .,

%> .2 s on January.the 14th, 19847

..y]..f '3 .7'

'A Yes,' sir, he did.

- , Q.: To which exhibit are you referring?

c: ,- -;.

.,.g.,

5 A. Brown Exhibit 3.

,- s

. 1: ,s.

'6 n.

^; Q. What time did Mr. J u s't i c e commence work?

. . .i

^ '

i -

7 . A .~ ' 7 o' clock a'. m .

, c

' ~

3 - '8' Q. <And-when did'Mr. Justice leave work on'the 9I el4th?

' )IL f 10 , A.- c2:30 Sunday morning.

(: -

r - . l l, ' T So he Idft work on.zJanuary the 15th at 2:30.

cc Q.

s <

. .. .. s y,rw M.,; ~

12! - a.m.; 'is'that correct?'

. /'~i.1 - cl 3 ' A '. . Correct.

WV -

, 214 -Q. Earli.er youlgave. Jackie Ables' badge number

' k.

~

r, s

,,, 11.5 . a's -7 7 9 4 4 ~ Referring.to'the exhibits before you, can -

[/4 516 j . you s' tat'e whether Mr. Ables w o r k e d ,.- o n ' J a n u a r y ' t h e l' r-y

. =

j:_l

:17 - 14th, 1984?

\$ -W ;, _,; ,

7_ -;" 1_g -

" : A '. Yes, sir, he did. > -

. e: .

f .19 Q. . To ~ which' exhibit are you, referring? ,

yy je.g gg

.A.. Brown E x h i b'i t -6 .

L- ,_

~; -

, -t ;

b X 121 ,

, Q '. - t Wha t, . time: did: Mr. Ables commence work on.

- .y.

1 .

A[. i u- "2 21 ' ; January'the 14th? -

N .

i ~ ' 1 2 3 i,. 'Seven'o'clockDa.m'.:

~

A. -

a , ,.

.E ,.a ~ ,

.'24). . n ., '

^

3 Q.' And,wilen ,did-he-leave?', .

}:u

.'e.) i ;v ,

e

- (g .33 '

1 A.: ~ 2: '~ 3 01 a .m.; S und a y -mo rni ng .

y .251 t

.,.o ,

4 . - -i -

g_ ' , -w :

2 .

i c ,

[.., -?. ,a (. -

, .. t ,..O ' > > (s (u~ .i U[ T.u f '

d ? _ _, R

yq:) . r . . ,

e ,

,- - =-

-; 'sa g' r 1;';- '

^M. ,, "

15 l:;4 -

F.J + y s;

a r

4

i. -v I

~U

,1 ~ , '

'Q. 'And' that;would be 1 J a n'u a r y the~15th; is that ,

b2;. ,

r

) ,.

v- -

,2. ' c o r r,,e c t ? -

b .

,' . j3 - 4

'A.

. Correct. .

~l '* '

^ ~

>4'. Mr. Brown, for.each of the. individuals that o

0.

4 gN .

( .

tl, 5. we.have just identified and discussed,-the time that l ~6, "they began _ work.that' morning is not_actua11y' Lp,

~

2 ._ . .

J7 1 recorded'by' number, is it? .

4

'8: A. - N o ,; s i r', it's not. # '

o . - - --

^

-9 r ', Q. 'Are they referred to by' color code on:the .

10[

originali Labor _ Control Sheets?

~,

^ ,-

l l11{ - A., Yes, sir, they are. ,

12 '

'O.- Have you compared the markings'on the

, e . T0

, x,[] 13' ' copies 1of..the Labor-Control S h e e t's ' t h a t have~been- ,

i . _ . .- r

.t <

14 marked as Brown E x h i;-i t s 4 through 7 in this. -

g ,

t s .

. . ~ '

%: , 11 5 1 proceeding.with the origin ~al color. codes in the '

'.; 4 -

e:

-16 ' . binder that is in your possession?

w ,

y '17 >

2A.: .Yes, sir, I have.

c:y , ;. .

.. a

- , 18, Q. ;And on -that- basis your t e r t'i m o n y s is-that

+ '

, 19 leach of-these individuals' commenced'workcat seven-3 4 ,, f

'a.m.'.on y -20: January the 14th; is~that-correct?

"' ~

21= -A. Yes, sir, that's' correct.

r .c cy a : 2 2. ~ ~ -Q. Mr. Brown, is'there'any-independent ~means

. o f : v.e r i f yincj ~ when an employee leaves work a ti 423/ -

g hj_;, 24 ' Comanche T Pea k' . othe r. tha n the Labor, Control.' Sheets?/

A av i

p'..'

' 25~ .

~

-A. , Yes,' sir. Oftentimes'.they will sign out,in c- , ,

.),

b; ,

_d .' 9

k Wy Of ' '~ ,,

4 +3 10 at

.g

~

e

n. 11'4 my office, when my people are'not available to .

(.

12;, ~2 actually log them out a t. that time when they leave.

c ,c

' 3' . . Q. VAnd when they sign out, is there.a form c 4 used for..thbt purpose?

.c -

^

5 4 A. ;Yes,' sir. -

6 Q . -- Are these forms retained in your possession, E

1 supervision:and control in the Time.l Office?

8 . A.. Yes, sir. ^

9 Q ~. Mr. Brown, I'll~show you a document that's "P-

, L1 d, [been_ marked as Brown Exhibit 8. Would you identify a l1 ~ that'docume,nt,'please.

" 2 12 A. . T h i.s .i s a copy of.the sign-out sheet for,

, 7

[h

c. g .

13 ' Brown &' -Root, employees who leave'other-than their. _

. .. a .

14x regultyrLscheduled time, for January.14, 1984.

a. -

15 , Q. 'Does it record the names of-any of the

.y ig_'e n til e m e n' - t h a t ' y o u ' h a v e discu'sse'd in.your testin'ony?

g; ~16 :

'-; p- ,

4 - -

i.-

> :s ' 1,7 ~ k - A .' zYes, sir. '

L.

}'

, 18' ~ 0. Who are those? ,

, e .

E' -19 +. -A. . 1 Jackie Ables,and Alan Justice, w .

a Q ,

s .. .:

, 22 0

.Q. What: t i .n e' d o e s itishow that they signed out? ,

g

-[ n

[21t 1 -

A.

A ta ~ 2:30:a.m. .

t-v1 -

+ + ,

. Now', the. sign-out sheet issfor. January the.

m' 1 22- -

Q.

,f'l l '~ m , ,

$,.s4

7

, l23Q .j 2.

714th. .

Earlier.you~ testified that ,t h e s e g e n t l e m e n

'jk . 24: 11eftiwork at3 2': 3 0 .-a . m . on the 15th. ? Could you -

J i a. 3 .

' Y , l2 5' (ex'pla'in tha t?

~

l4 - # ~

't 5 1

g.- . ,

t + ,

y w

-- ,;. - 9 .

m 3, . -

s; , . ,c ' , f .

, A -: : -

17 -

cs . ,- % m ' '.

7 Q

L;.:-

s:,

if X' g a .

, g: :

,; f , a

+ : > < . , -

,g' i e i; l,^ '

A.. .

tTherfirst person on the top'of thi s ipa g e ,. ;I .

, , x, r: .a

~

6 *

s .

" ,

x

,u /fi"<'12? JknowCpersonally, comes in ati l l' o.' c l o c k p.m. every q.e _

h -J

^

+

>7 a. y s, hic 4 = 3 " ,, (n'i g h t'. y A n d is o ,. , t h a t .' s - p ; m . The sicj n-ins ~and -

-s

, ,p. . 7 ; 5 Y i4 ..sig n-o u ts: o n ! th i s s'h'e e tE sta r t ; cin J a n ua ry 14, but

~

k ( ]1 I: , ,

i X .f5 L

~

f spill s i ov e r n into - th'e~ .ea rly mo r ning . ho u r s of Ja n u'a r y

^ ~

c

' <^ -

.n , - . .

M:- .6' 71 5 : -..,

' 73 gh ; >

~

. n -

7 . , s f

%m .r. .%-. *

' ,7 ? , -Q. Does tha t ',co n c, l u d e your t.estimony?;

,.,..-: , y _

-? ,

, . . . , ,a ,_ 1 . ,

T ' 8. d'

,' C ~A2 .Yes,zit'does. .

fjf -:'} c,

' ~

wg f 5', , -

+9, ,

~h

MR. WATKINS

Thank~you, M'r.' Brown. ,-

r_ ,

l> , ue

..(10) , i. THE/ WITNESS:1 'Okay. -

s.

~

- +

" r:~ r , .

MR.jWATKINS b For the record, Mr.

, 7 . ' fl'l[ > -

+

- . 7. n. .

m-' -

% 212 Brown;has?withihim.a't[this' deposition the computerc

' ~

n

, i ._.- in ".. .- +

-W a._j~' -

13 fprintout; tha t .he . edescribed 'i,n his' testimony. 'rhe a

s

~

,. ,4: .*. - -

~'

a .. ~, T 214. computer printoutLisEquite bulky, and'itiwouldibe , m .

t -

J N

.S' 51 5 , id i f f i c u l"t ? t o in t rod uce'.' ind'i v id ua'1 pag e sl f rom 'thei

., c . . ,

., +

s . . . s .

/ J L 16 C y p r i n t o u t'. i M r .1 Brown? also has f theVo riginal' Labor ^

f.

k ' 17 Control Sheets showing the color codes for: th e ~ we e k'.

c e e_ '.

e .

4 , t ,~ . ,x

, ::18 :- ,ending.Januaryfthe',14th, 1984.._The color coded -

o,f =

,g . -

i 4

.v g[# 2 195 ' Lsheets'must' remain;in Mr. -Brown's ; possession and.' ,

w

20T ic o n t r'ol at9the Time: Office'at Comanche, Peak,.so we. : '

, 3 :p * .

, c 214' ..ill-not: attempt.to f.nt rod uce = the originals of7these

~

s w

3

, m. .

4,, . 37 ._ , , +:.( ' -

r. 4: :2 2" ~ documents into evidence.- .d <

... n.. .

_23 , " ,- sS A ppl i c a'n t s m o v e . t h e'r, a d m i s s i o n J o f Brown Exhibits y ,

N .

jh [v. ' (2 4? tl tthrough 8 . i n t o 1 e v i'd e n c e . Anticipating a possible..

1r u,w a - ... :.

'~ '

25 ! hearsay objection-to Exhibits 2 through 8, -

, ;.m p w. ,

, .3 - 1 .N' . .

+n' .-y' 9 -e y

r +

4

... j i , ~r '

,x 3 .

(.

^s -

,s ,

m S. ~

18 4d p 9

[

fl? 4 fApplicants invoke the b u s i rie s s records' exception to.

m M,- 8 . ^ ;

~

2 the rule. Federal Rule of Evidence 803 (6) .provides t .-

- -3 that business records'are not excluded by the rule 1, ,,

4. - against hearsay.-if such records are sho~wn by the I 25 '

^

.custodiui of such-records that they are kept in the

[;.

tu <

~

y .

6- course ~ of.a regularly conducted business activity, ,

<t .

7, and ,1f.such records were kept as part of regular EU 1 87 ' pir a c t i c e .

s 3 .

L-

~

'9' .

Mr.-' Brown ^has testified that he is the l ,

S I10) custodian'.of the Labor Control Sheets, and that they u

lli ' .are made out and kept in'the regular course o f.

F 1 * '12 f-business, tall'.within the beaning of the : Rule 803 (6) .

1 >

, 7,,

13 w.r3:- v -

b ,) LIl 4 ' 2

_ [15 "c 16 '

+

' ' ;r; , ,

,s jl 7-- , ,

.} 3 c .

,18 q- . ,

'19

~

s_ . ,.

20: ,

b

[;;. :- . t.

-21 . .

'22 . .

7.* -

~I'

, , :23: -

24- 10 '

- ,j_1-

, q)

A 25- , ,

s .

[ #

t

,

c

. [

(- I -+

e w '/

3s g .

- 1 4 ,

- 1 ,- ,

.s(

Jy . . 2 _

+

, 3 _

+-

-# a

, ~I ,,f TAMES E . BROWN, have; read the foregoing-

' ~

'4 ,

p- , .- ,

~5' deposition-and hereby affix-my signature that'same 4

~

6 ; is'.true andccorrect,-except as noted herein. . .,

3 y .

L 8~ -

r-

,9 JAMES.E. BROWN

.10 .

~

, 11 -

9 12 SUBSCRIBED,ANb SWORN to'before me this the .

13 day of , 1984.

D['] '

W '

14

- 15 ,

~

16 NOTARY PUBLIC IN AND FOR THd STATE OF TEXAS ,

, .17 '

J s

i .

p . . 18 .

.. v.

i ,

19 My commission.expiress' l .

4

'~

u -20 -

m '

21 s, -

- .22

' ~

(f 't *

- ,- 23 -

24 '

(- s

, -25 ,

-1 s

s ->

FEDERAL: COURT. REPORTERS 3

F < ,

2

. g

+

F- il STATE ;

OF . TEXAS )

,' -2 : COUNTY OF DALLAS )

~.

3 4 'I , Janet-E.'Schdffer, RPR, Certified

.5 Sho.rthand' Reporter in'and for the State of Texas, s s 6 ..do hereby certify'that there came before me on the 7 - 15th . day '-o f 1 Augus t , A. .D., 1984, at the Glen Rose '

8' Motor-Inn, Glen Rose, Texas, the following named 4

9 person, to-wit: JAMES E. BROWN, who was by me duly 4

'10 ,

.-sworn.to te'stify the truth and nothing'but the

~ ' ~

ll .,' truth df'his knowledge touching and concerning.the

.,12 - ' matters inycontroversy-in this causes and thatlhe 4.-

.' . .. / .

,i v .g 13 ' was- thereupon; examined upon his oath and , his:

14 ) examination _. reduced to writing; sam % to be sworn- ,

c

~ '

t 15 to'and0 subscribed.by aaid. witness.before any.- .

~

4 9 . ,_ .

~

W16 Notary Public.. , .

- v. - -

o

. 17 -

^ ~

. -; 18 LI : f urtlier c ' certify _ that I amJneither:attorne'y

~

19 zor;couns'el for, nor-'related to or employed by,-any' 7

. ' , ?' . 2 0 , of the. parties to the.act'i'on'in which this ,

21 ; deposition i's;taken,.and further.that"I am not:a -

S22 'relativefor employ'al of a'ny attorney or: counsel ~

.. . --5 w23 employe'd 'by - the' par ties '_ he reto ,. . o rg financially = , s ,

L < . - 0*~ l ,

, f*c 4.x. f "

. . ,24 _ ~1nterested'in the action.

o.

~*

3_ ' %

25 , ,

n

. --I / *

~

I(,

9 <- , t ,

2 y.,.,.,,

I '

e ' "I -

~

e- c- y

~

J

-FEDERAL [ COURT'REPORTERSy , ,

-=

-w .

a 11 1 In witness < whereof, I have hereunto set my 2- hand and affixed my seal this 15th day of August, 3 A.D., 1984.

4-5 License Expires:

6 December 31, 1985 CSR No. 1453 7 , JANET E. SCHAFFER, RPR, CSR IN AND FOR THE STATE OF TEXAS 8 1226 Commerce, Suite 411 Dallas, Texas 75202 9 (214) 742-3035 10 -

11 12 s- 13 14, 15 16 17 18-

- 19j 20!

21 221 23 24 1ll ,

25-FEDERAL COURT' REPORTERS

_ BROWN & ROOT,1NC. .,

" LABOR CONTROL SHEET" WEEK ENDING: JOB NO.: 351195 BADGE SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESOAY THURSDAY FRIDAY SATUROAY BATCH TOTAL REf NUMBER 8 HRS.

IN OUT HRS IN OUT HRS IN OUT HRS IN OUT HR$ IN Oui HRS IN OUT HRS IN OUTHRS 4

.- s A

?;

[9

. a T 4

h

= = ~ -

i

.g..

t 4 6 .

t. .

s ,y

! *i

'. A:

k

i. -

a?

I.

r r 4.

TOTALS: ,

DEPOSITIC I:! EXHl81T I

E

..-.=.-:.

A 1RdV'N & ROOT, INC. ^ '

, . # '" LABOR CONTROL SHEET"

j vex oee os no.

~ ~, "_ ,

35- S5 l

3 a s-,

- our.~as

our as - our as r-a ,

our as - ourj as i jourimas i

s.,-,

our' mas ne- ,g a,-s ,

q ,

iu in n " Hoot : w/ n

1 - +v: ls Y2K~

/V ' f/ / /' l/ /

G HOO2 L// '"

AO 9003 // \// // -

// V/

POOA A/ 1// V,/ / /, y/ . /A: -

1 HQDS //l ! /- -/ / }' / .

as/ Wi

{ NOOlo

~

/ll .// !//" / / W/ d j -u &

i MOO $ 1 W:/[gQ9i:f69l/ A ' G/ ddd/ n ho/ 4 . gf""#

HQOC) /r$ /

// 3 // V/ . ' ;// f /; b {/ isw + Wh ?At i -

HOLO b/. // ; k/ /IT k//.1 l/ ~ V/. '

Yl emW L HQll =. 4 lx- M kdec a i HQl1 yc/ A// O'// ' / /'I/ /_ W/ / '. / pV ' L'Mt.$/h f ' HQ}$' !l//; ' / l ' ".i f f.': ~ / / hV / ,m /} /:- ??r @h

. . ., - &lA. ' 1/ll *k/! / /J $,. / ' ~ W~oW $/

.e'$$

M@}$ d//?-f [# U//M/ LW .

! . d;; Y8 HQ}{o / # /$ .'* O / l4* , ' /}f J/ / //? l .

f- Ah%

~* + / / w / / j /4 Hol1 l- + W30!

! . HOl$ '// /W -%/$ :i/ \Y O:YsC\% PA/ ~ 64)&

< ~

! j d l9 i' )[p :: i// Q f:/ $,. / 7 / / 1 /l/ :- '. N% $

/

i, .k & 20 .N %'// ~? '/ /&// '

//? '

~

-l^ W '$2

/ ?M 4/C f 'I HQ 2) ;

// /[/ -:/

i >c // 8 / / + "

i UQ 21 kd/ i fbQ/* l,9/ v L&/I %/ '

&l, $/D HQ23 Ed/ 60 / 2 / JW/ acl/ o' e WA QQ)f ..

(rf I$ ;f' a. f)0 'p lf f yy ?. Spo; x:v %

t*:

hD 25 a: / xd; @f: ljo e%f W //l . . 9n i hQ 2(o // / / // / / // : rAnh

': 'L l Hn27 // : // / / / / - / / -

42l j _HQ2R / tid / 00 / eso/ : r .'l:< .@jl * "~*

'.//// 10 d :. . HQ29 ,

m y / ;,=f / n j g? * .:/

m%,

l HQ30 // //- / / f / // ,- - %fd HQ3\ I// / / /$3 /1/ + / /

~ ^ '% @//S ll M032

'^ -

// / / / /J //9/ /

o .

, :JS Tl,9 G s QQS3 s' // c / / '

/ /: / /;. / /. , y n,4c0 -

G ; QQ34 '

//% / / $ /

f. / f iW / *

// :. & :. 4g ff ' / / / Y /FD / / /V '

HQ35 /9 '

HQ3(o j /b / ? ~

_/ . A- / /- l'

/fV /17 '. m~-

M%

HQ37 V- jf / ' / A~ // :- / / 4/- a fffl.

5938 ::e s //i; F l. / /l. *c /~/ / F. w N/il' 4039 ./V /A / A: / / // l~ w 14U

~

uM AO W /fl- /LA8 t ' %V //l: :~ ucM vorus: f t I a l_ t Iakk i I I

l DEPOSITION l9rh {T Y' OT1 M$l g"a"2 l

, BROWN & ROOT, INC. ,

" LABOR. CONTROL SHEET' WEEK ENDING: JOS NO.:

MN SADGE SUNOAY MONDAY TUESCAY WEDNESDAY THURSCAY FRCAY SATLRDAY BATG4 Y AL REMARKS IN OUT;HR$ IN IN OUT HRS IN OUTHRS IN 10VT HRS IN 'OUT RS IN OUTjHRS OUTlHR$

I9C9 6Aidizd/KH%/h4FifIdwVle an 5pt -

Al2 /ViT /A? A/ ?/Ad \ / / T( -

40

- %p2f_ 1- AAlo//\C/\/ 10AAD// to m so c '; H3

/ Alo //4

__20st ,

l / / 10/l/\lC/\/\n h:bl -

/Alo /V1U } A O / / IC/V!!O M 50 2n/ I= // 10/_]/10 / fl0/ / \0/'/ 101 AA'h =-

st 2121 -

/V@ /\Al0 //10/\AIO//IUVl/'b M4 53 Jwf '

/i/ lo A/flOf/AO // IO / / llX ~ W 60 2z)0 A/l10 /VilO]/I/!!D/ A LQ/AI0fb % ~ %t t 2ili 1//\fa /V!l01/ AIU/) 10//IR~~$$d 50

z 237

/ Vlio /Vil0/VilO/ /,lO/ / ID M*so i _2334 AST //iLi(/IlOl'/llO / '/ 10 V M 49 J 37/ D'

// 10 ^/f II /l/lOI/ /lb/l#l/2 /l/119 ^ M'- 7I iMb / /10" \ M// 7 / As /\/7/Vlo! ";:: M4 237[ /l/lO //Il0/1/10//!!D // [D M 50 fi/ IOfill()l/l/i0* b N&c QO 2420 l h /I))D .

2470 L Al 10//i(OVIAfD// IO / '/ lb \

&. 50 '.

2 vfl U // 10/Al0VV /lC6 .

c: M:P40 20/ /dB0//#TMd MO/ lGWG J WA 47L '

[ -

20lf ~

ayn. '

//T, / /9/AI t //T//% 5 m'*

bt- '<

//fT /A7 /i/? '/ /3 /rY f

~

'?" 40

_2 kcl ;

r / /%/ /t/Vi / /W// 2

.29 t. UO 9WGy$$fIl %iilt 31wfl :=

xio Wr.s \\ -

SQL 2s24 '/ / 15 //V/fl0// 10 // (D // l0 .: 1o 2 531 l / YtkVAC W V lll/ / ID // ]O *

'5\

2 544 .

//IO /Aln /\/ li / / L)/# 1k/ / 10 sit

20) A/ 10 //in/f/10/ /Ili/ / ID ~m )so i 2stl -

// to //iu /, /10/' /Illn + -

r l- n w --

2k2 Af 7 A/ 'd '

/ /!'l / / '6 I x 3a I

2L27 :

AA% / / 7 //ISt /\AX /V % + W 4w A /lic /g$$ F r J -

n e I5L i zw7 ,

2Wi AAY/AT / / X / /ll //l i .

-W +0 s

2LM i AAT A/8 / T/ 7 AA7 / /8 / /I% M 4tl 3L13 9d/\\t A/IC/Vil(1/V ?/ /JD -

W W

//ilo /\/DVV IDIA/ 10 / /\ln Bo 265

~

11 % V/i(0 A}IOffl/ll1A / IC/ /ID n 5d 2RW /VllC//lDlA /JOV /fl0//llC_ l. = ~ 5 06 1951 //. 10 V / 10/Vil0V710 / / b//\l0 f; GOI 2914 92&//K A /i?l/ f 7 / / ID/ /lO/M;Ilo ~= Wd Touts: @l '2ObJa571J S%1 ! m2.I a=ml 73YA - ,

- - m '/ / lt -- - /

" DEPOSITION EXHIBIT Aeowd

~ ~~ ~

, l

-- EROWN & ROOT, INC. ,

. . "LA'2OR. CONTROL SHEET'-

wrax ENo-o xewo; m 'S5 l

SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY SArbaDAY BArCH TOTAL aEMARKS

- our as =jourmas -pur;as . our; mas c ourwas - ourmas = ourNas 2 9// // 16//u/VIC// In/ / ID +n So

//lO// I!*/ / l0 / / 10// JC 9939 T 50

_2972 A/fa /V 10\ / / 10 //10/ AID, :: /M W i 203/ / /lo/\/ IU/i/IDAhl0/AC so pon // loa /!UA/ 10 Al 10/ l. lO

~

M 5a 20 @__

i

// 101/ V ICf/lD* I / / 10 'W 40 20(c1.

/ /1d/)/10//f(D/I/ (Of/In . 50 3,03 ,f f Yl 6. jA - 4 + . .:. - -

JAc.

2)l7 l / IO //II?V /10// 10 //HD - '

50 3My // 10/ #G /T/s //< IG %/Xp?/e%$% D: mt 9tPs '/z 3)?4 / /Tl//f /V1f//W/M %" ao 3 Xfo A/ lotAAC/l/lOf/flO/ /\lC i- W- bo 3 230 1A/ IO //1[(: /\/10I/ /ID/$1'7 1

v W7

+o 329'4 -

A/9 /i/i? /IAT '/ / 8 / /7 F 2275 '

/V3/ N VIA b /9 // 9i w+ 40 327.S- A/ 10 //l!O /f/ll) ifAl) /J ll) , f ~. 50 3MU /V lo A/IO/fAIO/VfD/ / 10 / /10 <bo 2293 /V \o //10/ /fl0/V 10// 10 A " so .

~

33o2 .a m%%d/64 /I(M/laL* .W 47 3314 / AT //7/I/8fA M //X '

=n= 40

/ /If C /!/U()/ V IO(/f/UI)h.~ /Qt V~ 49t f /f 332D l A/iiG /AIO/ /7 AM //%' -

44 23/z. A/%/ A7 / /7 A/3 // 16 2 ,'2 40 3372 l A/ l0VAIO / /ID JT/ II) //in a 50 A/T / A7 / Af / /l8 A/l 338). 40

. 33flo /1Alo /All) / Aln / / 10// 10 5a

3399 / /IlD //Ill1/_1 fin l / IU / /lh c so _

)' .3V/4 a /'/ ll0 / / 10 /V (C /'/ \!O/ / in ":i . v Sd 347] '

/ fi3' //2i A/7 / / T/ / Y // S 1*i5 AAlO/ /lO /V lh i / l() / /l10 b .3527 50 l ': As3D A/ 2 / / % /t/ X // V /1/ 7 = '5 40

'{

36 2/ / /T / A% /If X / 7 / /' T l' L HQt t 2451 // 10 // 10/V 1(J VI10 //In

n so 3 bit / /\lo // IO/ /\l0! /;16/ All)

so 1

j 3 70'l 77h A//l#i/ /}ID/ / /C/ A//J 'i 5I

373& /IAT '/ A7V /1C / /ID A %

WIN 3RiV W N/TL@6 /#

'37W o '#h* ll S$h I

~f/F 3 A71/ / ? f/ /iC VIF/f/17 4ot

?

3t33 '

/ /\\ol /418!AAlt / \ /InA All) 5at

~*'- To m s: / l ar7kkIW, 'l 9t/71557 l 735 l 67 I 5 l

- l le'l' \W /Ob IOV - -

I r;l DEPOSITION '

u _._ _ _- __..._ _f [XHIBIT

.L

CROWN & ROOT, INC. -

t "LAEOR CONTROL SHEET'-

wtEx tuona aos wo: 5"S5 f SUNOAY McNDAY WEDNESDAY - THURSCAY FR60AY SATURDAY SATCs vorAL REMARKS l TUESDAY -

a our nRs, = ou jsas n ,our sas = our sas =jourjaas= ourisas .x ,ournas M ff l//E //%// TAA(O //% 42 h Af'd! //10l/10 / A OIf AIC A f \O 50 JJf6 AAlolA/1H/AD /\AIUIAAIO so 4t/ I l/l/ITVI/!?VIA7 /l/ !?l// 7 '

'40 .

//f# A%dlald d 9 $ / N d9 @l9# 5' i*ld- Tla i 57K

_ 2 90_ _II / A9V Ai' VIAZ / ATl/ A7 4o

' ~

scc 3 / V Wu / A fA V If IID /llllb/TA{n l5 \

.57fD A/ loi//ly //)lOfi/\\0 //(Q .

1 50 l _J7M &/\IN3)/l(h$Al&#IA(OWY%% fra so 5)3L >

/\AT / A1 VI/TY /\/iV( A/ Y %

V c/54 /Ifl@ v l l/AVI/AIC/V 10 Mo 11 S174 //10 A/ 19//ildAA0!//\\C/i/IC 60 _

! rzel i f A/85lA ATVTAT A, !7/ /7 l ao riz z. I A/\\OVVil0lAAD AA0/ / 10 5o sd7 l AA% A/_L8/1/\fA A9 // 7 ao s 291 A/llo AA10VVil0/i/10 /V IC 5a i s3ll A/ 10/AIOVIAD/\/ll0 //(b so i sn? /V 10 AAID/AIO/ vin // ID so i 53ss e7 Y /\AK1/ Alo/V to //10 5 ns i rrsz. // foVVilWV10/ AID / AG sO

__g13 A/IT A /l7Vi/ 9fA /IV/ /!? 40\

suo / VI'o/AIG /IAO A Alb //lf0 //\l0 so fliz /\/T5 / /T AATAA8 //? l 40 i sid / AIC // lC /Auf/IID/f10 /A10 ho Sitt A\o / /W f AD //!!W /itC 1 Sol

I

. cnf % A%/ /Y /T/ 7 /jl? / A7 mtL

? sWf I go/l@J26A&u/llBWifWo /O S40 -

4 5 714 # 1!6&lWi$0!Pil e 4 # H9d#191af vAYW M5 sit

^ / AIU / A nA AIO// lD //10 so h en7 Sf6 // (0/ / Il['/I/lhl/\/ll0 /tf l.1 / OXJd 70t '

5%$ G50 /ihlWU / 9&/ 75$ /\lk i'>Of ?i. HDL

'i s# //!ld// / A6GVl7 //10 //D 47 ti s-951 /Alo\//!bfi/IlVf/ ID/AfD so E9w

~

/ lol/AlW /lO/V IO/ /flo ff l01 uo Sc13 /V l0f/A!C//lD/V fD // ID f so t.js1 /Vl\n! AAlnVV\lO / Alfi// ID//10 so 617f / /\lo AAOl//1!D/ AIDA/llO/' AID :co .

I2tf( A/d ^^( )//\l0VA\o *l \ \ s 45 (2r4 1/\ AT 14 /WlA /l2l/ VF/ //69 l ua Torns: fl I sl9 M $/S l 33L132M IS'Ft l 6MI a5 la 39 % I 40 40 aob - ,; DEPOSITION

_ . _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ . . . . . . x i

~

BROWN & ROOT, INC. ,

" LABOR CONTROL SHEET"

' s m ss wEsx Euon2- .cs NO, SUNDAY MONCAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSCAY FRIDAY SATURDAY BATCH TO AL REMARKS IN OUTHR$ IN OUT' HRS IN OUTHRS IN OUT HRS IN 'OUT HRS IN 'OUT HRS IN .OUT{ HRS

~: ' 1 So 7p 74 // (0//I!D//l0 / /\l0//,lD '

von -;

//10//fl0 / /\C //iUf//10

so 7ofI ~ / AT//V / A9ff/ 7/V18 ~- ao A/ !6 //10VIAIld/lf10/ /IO/ A oat 0

7N.3 ' '

7)U + / /7 //4ff/\Z(// L / /7 w %

72tf ~

!/% /A? \//TI/ AT f(/lY ~'

yo '

73r4 'ViTV A'd V ( A 8 /\/F{ /fl% .

- , .:)

4o .

94pz. AA7i/ /iEV1A7:/(A8VVlR -, & Mo 7M7 1 %AiT.WA T blVP,% G k.A 7l% k. M ? -

40 7495 -

// 10 /ffG/\/ MJA f 10/V jd W "

sn 7s2' : A/10 %927A/l0//IDA/ In /A0 & s,

_2rjo : / / lo'/!AOfAAto! A A lli//ID 'Affil0 % ao 7551 /VIIOVill0/\/IlD A 0IU// IU /L/10f& :~ ho

/ A9 // ICV lAlO/,/ilD!/\/\T1 7103 @ ~I%

76/f ^ //fi /Nl//ITA/T!il7 G^ 40 7 721 / /IE / /W//lT /VW! /1S a aL 40 77N // IO/ /l0 /1/1C A / % //\lIl e M 4'6 -

2799 // V)A/10 /\ AN/T/10/4%/$W+n mL*_ts.

7tz.T -

et)T M 47 -

(7)9 @T 4 % 40 -

ad/1kn AfW/ IDWAQlobV/\\bL h 7Rf 'hT1? La

~

7/// /l/T /l/ii'Id/7 / /l7I/ /7 B 2a 940:

7/Z7

// 10/fu&OAif//\lO// 11 9 4dP: %t .

2/54 // to//In7f/lb/ /\\W / IC .

mF 3a 7114 -

/ /In // fii /T/ ID / /IIC // (C / fly) + " 160 fess' '

/ Al0 //!UV /lO/ /!D// l0 - '~< 5s 1 ..

=

MM / fT / AU / A7 / / W/ / 7 r R 4o i mov '

/ /ll0//ll0/\/Il1/ / 10 / /ll)//il0 W so N .

MM l- i/ /T / / / //}{V / \1 / / X ; ? ne mo .--

l*

9/S4 / / !O //II) /An\// IC/ / IC V 10 %o'i.

9201 // 10 // li)'/ifl0I// 10// ll] a%

b Gzzt 7 // f0 //1]D /lAlh / /10/ f10 / /% . ' 5%

'9t2V # /l$%m/ f& # A W S / Tl0llK Vl0.MV llh ,

,~ L,~5

? /lD //)!1/A2)O // ID/ $0i/ }l0 W GdCtik b .

92)?

91W

A/ \0 A / I W / IIi/ / lb /Alb -

% 5o FM /f/ lek /ViMVAC A/)D/AlO , ' 5I 931$

A/10 !VTill /1/IIC '/\/ ID/ lll0 /fiO &* L,o 232b / /7 /\/i?VIlT/ A7A A 6~ 1 :40

((3B // I4/Vtl0/\/w/! AID /Vllt) (t/ 10 -

w _

l .

SO A/ Ifj //ll/Tl// f(J/l//O/ /llDI 1 -lM '50 ToTas: M l 2,95 I314 I 3 6 3 E .! 3 ' ,2 f I % .Z. l / d 7 $l %

lev f3/

to'(v\\s V lou - c

- , DEPOSITION t- _. __

'~ EXHIBIT

'c e i ; broah)b t

-- -- - . -r - = 1 . . _ _ . . _ . _ . . _ . . _ _ _ ._. _

"LAEOR CONTROL SHEET *

. WEEK ENDtNG- JOB NO.:

M G5

, SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNELDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY SATUROAY BATCH TOTAL REMARKS

~

i IN OUT MRS IN OUT HRS IN OUTjHR$ IN OUT' HRS IN OUT'MRS IN OUT HRS IN OUTMRS F3W p :% /ARV/flJ//10 / /10 //!lo , ~18 L& _

13b1 I \//lofA!W /101/ V10 / Vin i %'

F431 l \A/\o//itO/tA)0l//\ Wl/ la I sa

/A10Vfi10/}/(KIA/\lCOf T %

. f43t. l l 24E l /ATl/ A E Vl/T // 9 C/X 40

~ ~

I 89ao I / AZIAndV)/7 }/ 7 / lA7 a b +10 fMff / / 10 //\\C4/ AIO /VW/ 10 \so '

9 414 / / r6 % V W / '/l3 A/ 7 /L/b 39%)

229 AAID/AIG 4Aln/lj ICA'/VO sol

/V 10/VJOJfAD A/ l0AMIC/df6 H@lz-ffff 2 s 10 /VT1 / /ii0 V T/ K /I/ TC / A7

~ qa fr73 M17iM-d7 @MT$1d7 4. kA7 40 fto? //ilo /\/901//70 A/ ID /\/lll) /YA' W W 2 700 A/f7 //f DVI A0AJIW1/10l41910 -

ss fX4 41A10/180/(/IIOVl AIOl/ / I0/VI% ;-

sss

j. p FC fun 7 Tp i3 ._

9 761 J / '10 * -\^ / T ' - //il0/ / ID MA0:~- 40 ' .

1777 ,

A/\f/&&/AlOf/Pl7t1/ / IC /Q)LO ;L9(sO

' ~ ^ "

~

FWO '

/\/ 3 /A7lAA'W /!? // IUf/n :: 52.

~~

r?)b V A/E AA1\/(AK / /\f / /1 40 J //7 AA7Vl/i;C/ ^7A/T M57 =

to 993 5 / d % AP C / 9lTi/ f?t/ A k/Al0 524.

9M(( mp7/1/ ? / ATd/%DSL / k?) \ (41L 9fiff A/S / /7 AARTA AV/ 't ? l: -> Ja 9ffl I. /Yth/hxVLA!0/ / In/ / \ll) ! si

.. ~9 n3 l / A% / A if / Vi? /\/\S7 /i/7 l 40

._915L / /\0 2 c / R U k / M 1!) W!W9/ll^i(W/l16 l c:D 1 922!/ //f% A/ Y A/ 8 / / XI/AWI

40l i 91C'l //\lo // 10/\/IO / / Il>/'/lDl//10 sol 1 9251 //l%//d /\/7 /AD /J ID /w 14 Sst1 qD3 AAT / /7 /VY//V //ld

^

1 4o 92 71 : /IAE / / V /V T / I V/ A9 h 40 L -

93tt -

AAS / / TVl/ V /i 7 / AZ + = to 13t3 A/hO //IWlhN/ / 10/ '/11() 59 9331 A/T / /7 //2/ / W ** AX / ^

no 1&f A A10 A/llO / AVT 3o

\ l.

9431 A/it0 /V l{i/ViU/ AIU/ A!O So

, 9%1 1/\ /IZ /\/ 2 4 / ?\/ A Y/ /X 40 kin !A/S AeiW i*l \" ? l I_ l1Y - \8 l

i roua <10 I sl% i s/5 I 3<13 I ::/3 15/7LI /v/!41 % I

?s I l0 \V I /0 i t0' 1O l - I Geosirion l 2XHiB l'desan) t 7

?

- . o - . - . . .

~

w !'s' h .t" L S M a":??a*?*.?_' .

1

TIME our

T1M c BADGE, . In Ar A ,M E &

ljbef 0 Hoo $)

L,M h l h T'/ 0 h l

a - - -

i 18 .

&ff/ i Nl '

//70 3

b / //n d o S40 I)!

u lL ?) A~, X dn. _ _

7 71't l

} } 2.30 01 W zu I})

/

9 no A fL @ '

CoS7 ?) h 330 L 9AM DTI $N) n h Do $NSA - -

a

Anw N V: oo $c %LL 'J

~

dm'J ,r)4 u u i

o$ Gh n 3 If/ kk kvf/ O al m d, N), 0) W k RW I

h) 0) al7 ,

khs yNi s)

T i O Os .

I'N N S] -

l 8 i.

. DEPO 5 MON l 3 ate _ /-/W EV - 20!>r

.

ML20095C140

Text

Navigation menu

Search