ML20095C140
| ML20095C140 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 08/15/1984 |
| From: | Jonathan Brown BROWN & ROOT, INC. (SUBS. OF HALLIBURTON CO.), TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20095C073 | List: |
| References | |
| OL-2, NUDOCS 8408220393 | |
| Download: ML20095C140 (29) | |
Text
p
^
~
., c 4.
m.
1
- p. / A f -
y.
y' q:
[/j '
s
~
~
1 UNITED [ STATES'OF~ AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION n
2 BEFORElTHE-ATOMIC SAFEhY.
LICENSING ~ BOARD' 3
rIN iTHE ' MATTER. OF::
)
gggggn
)
' t.lSNitC ' '
h~
f4l TEX 5S UTILITIES _ ELECTRIC
)
DOCKET-NOSg 5.
)
50-'4 4 5 0N AG0 20 PS:08
.)
50-446 g,4k
- f
- (COrNNCHE1 PEAK STEAM
)>
~6 ELECTRIC > STATION, UNITS
)
8FL E M"U C,'
90CKETIE & SEF.'io.
lJAND.2)-
_)
BRANCH 7
8
-PRNFILED TESTIMONY OF^
JAMES E.-BROWN
'9 AUGUST 15, 1984
,?
.10
- 4 11
' 12:
D' 13; M _.
il4 PREFILED TESTIMONY'OF JAMES E.
BROWN, taken on 15 thet 15th' day of August,-1984, in the aboverstyled n
16 a'nd numbe r ed : ca us e, at Glen Rose Motor Inn located 17'-
-ate Highway 67 & FM Road'201, in the City-of Glen
-18 Rose,. County of Somervell and State of= Texas, before Schaffer,.a Certified Shorthand. Reporter in 19 jJanet E.
3,.
z.
'20-and for~the State of Texas.
21 22 s
23-
?$f22039 24
' Q'.s.
OhhhO T
.2g p
1 FEDERALJCOURT__ REPORTERS. _._ _,,__, _ _
. ~ -.-.
--~ ~.-
,i,',. -
4 2
e 2
n a
~
(,
' k _
.1
- APPEARANCES:1
-6' m
{fy 4Q * ~
1
\\./:
2' BISHOP, L'IBERMAN, COOK,'PURCELL & REYNOLDS
- Attorneys.~at Law i
.g j
-3
.1200_^ Seventeenth Street, N.W.
LWa s h'i'ng ton,
D. C.
20036 y
g.
q.4 J
1 J
,BY: 1McNeill Watkins II,-Esq.
3 N.'
APPEARING FOR APPLICANTS s
. r i,
s 4
4
'nh
.g., >
u-
,~
f
.a
- r e.
. - _ s
\\
+,;;
r s.
p.
-9
-r
+
~
<s
?
- 10. '
b n
e:.
4 s
4 V'-,I!_
g
+
W
. 31
+
m';
f,. '
s j:
, i e
,1 21 4'
+
e
-.; ^
w a'
'.13
{
a-
~
y 'l 4
k g
[
14"
^
.r F
e
(
+
y w
g_
^
y.
r rm -
g y w;.
..16-g s
M.
- I.,
5g 4
'N "g
' k
.s
.17'
.I
/
/
1sE
_'18-
- 3. cir
!' 4 4"
'19 "
J
~
g 7
20'
~
r.
. [[
i
/
[
721 j.
- ; T' 2 2. '
.t.'
~~
s r
s t' ?
r
+
q
' A E
-- '23 t
w.,,
a A
f k-
., _ h k
. v
.\\
~
._ 2 5 '..,
s l
.3
.-,, q _g,
q f_
M
.f f
3,<
1 4
v
..g.
t l -i.L
- A-e a
p y
- m
, _-w; 4
A_,
+
- p. ' ; _o q.,
- -t
-3
," l %
.. ~ :: g 33_
y o
_s 1-I N'D E X"
'f-N;y, y
2,-
1 WITNESS:_ - J AMES- - E.
BROWN 7
w
~
O
$ ?-3 Exsmination.by Mr.~Watkins
.Page 4
- 3 s
s
,. p
.4 5
PAGE P:
,/~
6' Exhibit Number l', Blank Labor Control' Sh~ee't for Brown'& Root employees 6
_.7 Exhibit Number 2', La b'o r f C o n t r o l' e S h e e t
_for week ending 1/14/.84 11.
~
8'
- 4
- 19c.
Exhibit--Numbers 3,throughs-7, Labor
-Control Sheets for. week e nd i ng. -1/14 / 8 4 12 n _:
- " 10 yk p
ExhibitoNumber-8, Sign-out. sheet for Ell '
B rown.:&
Roo t e m p l o y e e s
17' t
p 12-
. x.
<N-J13
- k) '
14
^
^
y
-15
~
. 16 f
17
,18 19, 4
T 20
. 211. #
i
(
22 L
~
23 i
!, f{
~
25-y.
i,e
. FEDERAL"_ COURT REPORTERS
- m. 3, -
1 2,
a
.F 4
, 4 b.J g.
1 a.,
- gg r
JAMES E.
- BROWN, l
I
)
(s[
2'
, the. wit' ness hereinbefo're named, b'eing first duly
{
r 3
cautioned and sworn to testify-truth, the whole the t
~
ex >
- 4 truth and'nothingEbut the truth, testified on his
" f1 5
= oath--as follows:
4 6:
MR.;WATKINS:
My name is McNeill c
e.
.c
~ I'm with the law firm of Bishop, Liberman, y
7-1 Wa t k,i n s. -
8
' Cook, Purcell
&' Reynolds in Washington, D.
C.
L' e
~9 are'counselIfor' Applicants in this licensing 10 proceeding.
This is thefprefiled testimony of Mr.
11
, James Brown,'a Brown
&' Root employee at Comanche 12 P e a k.' / 'H eil s.a p p'e a r i ng here voluntarily for this
'13 deposition and has not been subpoenaed by any party.
- V('il
,;14I
, /
EXAMINATION g
y 15.
BY MR. WATKINS:
16 Q.
'Mr.
Brown, would you please state your full
'17 n a, m e.
- 18
'A.
James-E. Brown.
fl 9 Q.
By:whom are'you= employed?
(c 20 A.
' Brown & R o o_t,- Incorporated.
21 fr
-Q.
jWhere'are.you employed?
v
- .2 2 -
A.
Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station.
~
23 Q.
1What is.your title, Mr. Brown?
2 "I
- 24 A.
Chief'Timekee,per and ~ Payroll Supervisor.
~
q P
)
~~
'25 0.'
How~long have you held that position?
F 4
i a
i
3' 5
t:,-r r
+
r
- 1=
. A'.
'A little over five years.
g y-xJ
- 2 0.-
-Where, physically,cisLyour-office located
~
3 atLComanche Peak?
~
4 A.
[In the Time. Office.
~
5
'Q.
Would you,briefly describe.your duties?.
~ responsible for documentation of hours 6-A.
I:am n
.7 worked by Brown & Root employees on the job site.
n 8
Q.
How does the Time Office keep track of the 9
n u m b'e r of' hours that'each Brown & Root hourly 10
, employee' works'on a given day?
-- 1 1 '
A.
As the employees come to work, t h e y ', r e L12 sissued a' brass with an employee identification
(]{
13
~ number on it, and then we go behind them and log the 14.
-time-that they' pick ~their brass up.
At the end of 15[
the day, whenever they l e a v e.
for the day, the d'op'their brass of; w'e ' l o g them out.
16 em p'l o y e e s r
- 7 v
17 Q.
Do Time office personnel write down the-18; timesEthat Brown & Root employees-check in and out?
19 A.
In most cases we don't actual'ly write down 20 nthe time, no..
What we do is, when an employee comes 21 <
in at tre beginning of a shift, Time office 2 2..
personnel p it a pencil mark down for that employee.
^
23 The pencil marks are color-coded to shifts.
For j;'
24 example, a blue pencil mark would mean ~that the t
t t
t a
l
~25 employee clocked in on the 5:30 a.m.
shift, and a
,t I
9
= W'
~
6 kYl.
4 c-
.c y
1-green pencil; mark-would mean that the employee-74 c ri-)
~
2
~ reported':.for workron the 7:30 a.m.
shift.
The a
s
~
T 1
'3 L reason ~ we use color codes is that on some shifts we 1
4 '
havebover' a thousand-people reporting or leaving at 5
ithe same time.
'It's not feasible for the Time-
~
a 4-f6
' Office to. write down the. times.
7 O.
What happens if a shift. employee rep' orts 4
^
8 forJor leaves work at a' time other than the-normal 9
shif'd?.
q j
~,,
it
,E10 A.
Then we write down the' actual time'that-the 7
(
- m.
11 employee reports or leaves.
12e Q.
Do'the Time'0fficeopeople use a form for
' (~y 13 recording'the times that Brown & R'oot employees 5s 14 /-
-reportefor and leave work?
s".
-15 A.'
Yes,. sir. We use a" Brown &" Root. Labor s
_1
?
M 16, Control Sheet.
^ -
- 17. -
O.
Ji r. Brown, I'll show you the document 18 that's been marked for identification as Brown-
- 19 Exhibit I and ask.you if that is a blank copy of thel 9
20 Labor Control Sheet to which you just referred.
21 A.-
Yes, sir,'it is.
I
-[
22' O.
Mr. Brown, are these Labor Control Sheets 23 filled out daily for each Brown & Root hourly f
24 employee that works at Comanche Peak?
h vf4 25
'A.
Daily, yes.
m
m.
3
.m-
.s v
p.
y
~
3 s,
?1 '
Q..
-Does the Time office retain these Labor J.3
,, %J
-2 Control ~ Sheets after they have been filled out?
E 3
A.-
(Yes, sir.-They are the basis for paying 4'
= Brown'&" Root employees.
~
[
-5_
Q.
After-they are filled'out, do they remain 6-in,your personal: possession and control?
t.
7 A.
. Yes, sir.
up 8
Q.
' Physically where do you keep, and how do 9'
,you keep, these Labor Control-Sheets once they have
' 10'
.been' filled'out for'a given; week?
p 7
11
.A.-
Each-week' the Labor Control Sheets and te' 12 -
'other documentation are bound together for each
- ('T 13 week-ending period.
w '.)
~
1:
'14 Q..
Mr. Brown., do you have all of the_ Brown &
15 P.oot" hourly Labor Control Sheets for the week ending 16,
January.the 14th, 1984, here with you at this time?
17, A.-
'Yes, sir. I have before.me the binder 18
. including all Labor Control Sheets for-that week.
19 Q.
Are those Labor _ Control Sheets the 20 originals?
21
.A.
.Yes,~ sir.
22 Q.
Mr. Brown, how do the Labor Control Sheets' 4
2,3 identify employees?
24 A.
By badge. number.
,/T LJ
,25
-Q.
Is there a list.of names and corresponding 4
I.
~
T1TRf6pg[Afl, @(61Mggt Tdf4fpATRRfCBR
_m
y f
=,
. m..
~
g
! "w A
s
- ;g 1
- badge numbers.for alliBrown &-Root employees at gm
~
, '2 s Comanche P e a k ?~-
f
'3
[A.
.Yes,, sir.
14 -
Q.
Would you describeLthat: list., please?
m5 A.-
1It's called a' timekeeper's listing.
It's a r,
6
. com pu te r. pri n to ut. tha,t lists all the employees
.9 k,
J' 7' ',
alphabetically.-
The list _gives their badge ~ number n,
S E
and. o th e r-li1f o rma ti on.
. Q.
How often-is the list updated?.
im 9-
.s
~ ~
10.-
+
. A.
'Once a week.
.j
- ' > 1 1 LQ.
. D 'o y.ou have a current list with you at this o
12'
't i m e ?.
~
-Q, 132 i A...
.Yes,. sir.
,, (;c t
, 14 X
,0.
.Mr.
Brown, is: Ronald-McBee a Brown & Root-15
- empl'oyee at' Comanche Peak?
16-.
A..
Yes,, sir.
',17 Q.
What is'his badge number?.
>.=
~,. '
18-A.-
.3164.
s..~
t
>19
'Q.
-Is Richard Simpson a Brown
&. Root employee
- (
'2 0 '
at, Comanche Peak?
' 21;
'A.
Yes, sir.
'~
22
- Q.
What-is Mr..Simpson's badge number?
H, 4:
u,
'23 A.
8554.
e t
24 Q.
'Is~ Alan Justice a Brown & Root employee at L/ '
25 Comanche Peak?
M.a
- };.-
W fr 9
b' fg
.pr,,%,.
- d~.
_ z.
9
.'a T
,U e
r r
- ?.
- y_,
sq.
sir..
'31'
-._ A.
- J
.Yes,
..,,f
~
r
, 2 ~.
Q'.,,What'is:Mr.vJustice's badge n_ umber?
- M
~
o 3
'e
'A.:
2371.I i
=m.
,n
-i
- 4
}lQ.,
"Is Danny' Wright an employee of' Brown & Root 1,
- 5.,....
at'. Comanche Peak?.
a e
. 6
' A '.
Yes, sir ~.
.e g
,7;
--Q..
What.is.Mr. Wright's. badge number?
u 2
1 8e A.
'5823':
. r, y
.y
.s.
/9 Q.
'Mr.
Brown, have you establishe'd each of the
}
,10 b'adg'e numbers for those individuals'by. reference to y
- 1'l ~
- the.. compu te r_ pri n tout,tha t you have before-you.as
~
~12
,you_ testify today?-
,.,D-13 '
'A. '
JYes,= sir, I have.'
S,x.
31 4
~
0.
Mr.. Brown, i f._ a ' ba dg e number: includes the s
n.
~
indicate?
h
- 15 '
(prefix
- ._y HQ,,, wha t. doe s that
(,
+
L16 A..
-QC inspectors _at-Comanche Peak are carried' j'
Kj _,
.17 an~the.' Brown.& Root Ilouston-payroll c om pl e t'e l y
- 5 5
18' J-sepa ra te Jf rom. the s i t'e Craft. personnel. An "HQ"
~"
.a a
f
- g19 ibadge number, indicates that the employee is on the
- p "2 0 )
Houston payroll.
'21
' :Q.
Are' employees.with "HQ" badge' numbers q223 listed on'your timekeeperfs list?
123 f ?
-A.
No, they.are_not.
.1
!24 Q.
Is there'a separate list of Comanche'. Peak *
)
~ ~"1,
525 employees'ca'rried.on.the Houston payroll?
4.
ji
^
L f
1;,g g.qi
- , 93 < g.
~,
c.
. b.
10 J.
tpr J ~ g./xly+_
v
-q g@y 4-L L
4,r
.. s
.,1 47 iMA.
G.f;;h N '
Lyes.
I i'
g-t y
(
t M;e ;
0.
Do you bavew.:a4 current copy of that. list s-s
,4 27 3
.m qw g-yc i
L(.,
4-3.
.ebe f o re ' youf a t'!thi's t ! n e ? t "> >
t t
- f. ;
3 ;;l, A
L
',a 4'
J-
'A.
Yes,, sir,f ;do.
S I
/
t v
't V '
q :, '
..10.
- I's.fJ a c k Stanford included on that list?
s i
d5 O
3 s
.i..,
- ^
,A.'
Yes,. sir,Jhe-is.
-6
.s.4 3
f.
F/;..
1
- 7. 3
. Q.
tWhat i s, (Mr. Stanford's badge number?
+
.t,,
s a
m 78 h'2A.
' H Q -- 10. :
, -Q' t;
1 fgs
,9 Q.
LIs^Mr. Stanford currently a? Brown.& Root
~
m~
lemployee at Comanche b P'eak?
T10 '
~
'i,c 4
?_y
.A.
Yes, s'ir.
+'.;
3 e..
Mr. Brown,.is Jackie' Ables currently a "Q1-12 v
.N
'k e,'m
-13 Brown 4 Ro.ot employee at ~ Comanche Peak?,
x
%c,
< g.
.c
- : e,":
.. A.;
'No,. sir, he-is not.
Y*
31 4 uh,
.d
! 15'
-Q.
Has Mrk Abids-ever been a. Brown & R'oot v
p.
c, 16 t einployee,a t ; Comanche. Pea k ?
. f
, 4 /[
1 71
-A..
Yes,< sir, he has.
e,.
1 r
18,
.Q.'
When'did.he terminate his employment?
p
\\f
'{l 9 -
A.
Ma y; 2 4i 19 8 4..
3
- y..
~&~ Root,.at
,r.sAblos employed by Brown 20 y
, Q '.
Was7 M x
~21 Comanche Peak in January of 1984?
k.'
Yes, sir.
22' - 1 1
.s 23
- 0.
Wha,t4was his badge number?
2 ;
t
.24 A.
7794.t O
t 1
. e, M
- 25' QL-Mr.
- B'rown,'I show you a document that has e
\\
+
t wi-
[R$
g g,
N 11:
~
pg
. ;r.
7;q; w
~ JQ '
-Q 1
.I
.,e
?
.la-Jbeenimarked for identificati'on as Brown Exhibit:2.
s, o
s Ji). 2 Can you identify it?
)
~
-s
~3-DA'.
- This 'is'a copy of the Labor Control Sheet
.o t
b:
'4' for ~ certain./ Comanche-Peak employees.with "HQ" badge 5
numbersifor-the ~w'e e k-e nd i ng. J a n u a r y' 14,'1984.
y' 6-
,0..
. Earlier.you testified that Jack Stanford's
.g
- 7 b~a d g e in u'mbe r '. i s I HQ-10.
Does Brown Exhibit 2'show 3
worked on Saturday, January the
't 8:
that Jack Stanford
=
,.9 14th?
~10 A.
Yes, sir, it d o'e s.
11 ~
_Q.,
When'did-he clock in that day?
l12.
A.-
7 o' clock a.m.
1 s
f'Jl 13 Q.
When did'he-leave on that day?
R A.
b:30 plm.
~ 14 ~
[
'15
-Q.
Mr. Brown, I show you five additional y~
16 documents which -have ~ been : marked for identification i
-17 as Brown' Exhibits 3,
4, 5,
6 and 7,'and ask you to o-
., ~.1 8.
identify them.
t L.
+
O 19
~
A.
These are'copics of Labor Control Sheets e
-20' for Brown & Root'C'omanche Peak employees for;the 21; week ending January 14, 1984.
~2{
Q.
Have'.you' compared those exhibits with the
~
23 orig 1nals in the binder.that is in your possession?
j3 24 A.
Yes, sir.
i 1%J binder is for the week ending 25 Q.
And'that Y'
E q
RRRR@aR c@MBR mm@@RTERS
p,
.c
,9 -.
m
,!.J ' 'y' 6
V u,.
y
.;1 danuary th'e ^14th, 1984; is^that correct?
,., - ~.
.b'('
2' A.;
Yes, sir.
3
'O.
' Earlier you' testified that Ronald McBee's c
4-
. b'a d g e numbe'r.was 3164.
Referring to Brown Exhibits l.
u 4;throughi7,.can you state whe thc r M r. McBee worked E'
~
^
3
+
e~,
~
6-on ! Saturday, January-the 14th?
~
.' A.
Yes,' sir,'he did.
. A 7
; + ^ c ~a' O.-
To which exh'ibit are you referring?
i, 49-
^A.
Brown Exhibit 4.
'10 Q.
What hours did Mr. McBee work on Janua'ry b
1I
- t. h e 14th?c h
L,.
12 A.
F r o m ~~7 o' clock a.m.-till.1:30 Sunday'
[ },.,.13 morning.
, y,
..., [
'14 Q..
.Is/there an actual notation as to the time
,'he. checked: ~
s-
-15
.out_on the'14th?
,,y'
- ' n l= f. t ; J. ' ' 16 A.
Yes,: sir, there-is.
p:.73 t
y.
i f,
17.
Q..
Wh'at:isuthatJnotation?
f18
~
.y (A.
'0130.- '
i-
$f ', U19 Q.
- Does that mean he left work'att 1 : =3 0 'a.m.-on 1y' 2
-.1
- S 20;...
~ Sunday morni'ng, January the 15th?.
s:
Jo_
121 ',.
~ A.
Yes, sir'.
L 't. ',..
h* f
+, ~,
7
", 3, ', 2 2 4
.Q."
.Earlierfyou'gave, Richard-'Simpson's badge
.p s
"i Referring to Brown Exhibits 4
[ ".. 3 23
, number as 8554.
7
, [ i24 th r o u g~hf 7f, can you tellTme whether Mr. Simpson
,r~
)
worked'on' January!the 14th?
a
=
a
~
]i l2 5,
\\
l,.L y
~
_%2
~,
T' %,
BD JTs-v r
)
o 13
+
s
.g 2
- 1 1
A.,
Yes,Jsir, h e' d i d.
i
'2-Q.
'To'which exhibit;are you referring?.
k m.,/
i
>3+
A.
Brown Exhibit.7.
~ 10.
. When did.Mr. Simpson check in that day?
~
0
~
5
'A.
- 7 c'c1'ock a.m..
4
~6-O.
'When did he leave work?
f 17'
.A.
'1:30 Sunday morni'ng.
y
~ :8 O.
' A n'd 't h a t would be. Sunday, January the 15th?
6 x
8:
,9;
'A.
Yes, sir.
?
10' 0
Mr.' Brown, earlier you gave Danny Wright'.s
~ 11' badge numb'er'as 5823.
.By referring to Brown J
12:
Exhibits.4 through.7, can you. state:whether M r'.
(J~'t
-13 Wright worked on: January the 14th, 1984?
14 A.
.Yes,. sir, I can.
He d i d _. w o r k.
[
11 5 Q.
To which-exhibit are you referring?
4
. 16 A.
Brown Exhibit 5.
17 Q.
When.did Mr. Wright commence work that day?
' 18 A.
7.o' clock a.m.
1 9' Q.-
And when did he icave, work that day?
2'O'
'A.
1:.30. Sunday morning.
^
. 21' Q.
So'he'would have left at~1:30 a.m.,' Sunday, 22.
Januaryithe 15th; is that correct?
/
-23 A..
lY e s', sir 1 f
hx 24 Q.,
Earlier you gave Alan Justice's badge o
25 number as;2371.
Referring to Brown' Exhibits 4 i
N L
y e
m _..
L
,c t-14 3
~
J 4
,?
.6
. g., f '
l.
through 7,
can youlstate whether Mr. Justice worked t
.2 on January.the 14th, 19847 s
,.. ]..f
'3
.7' Yes,' sir, he did.
'A
.y Q.:
To which exhibit are you referring?
c:
.,.g.,
5 A.
Brown Exhibit 3.
s
'6
^;
Q.
What time did Mr. J u s't i c e commence work? 1
,s.
n.
.i i
^ '
7 A.~ '
7 o' clock a'. m.
c
~
'8' Q.
<And-when did'Mr. Justice leave work on'the
- 3 -
9I el4th?
' )I f
10 A.-
c2:30 Sunday morning.
L
(:
s Q.
So he Idft work on.zJanuary the 15th at 2:30.
r -. l l, ' T
- cc
.. s y, r M.,; ~
12!
- a.m.; 'is'that correct?'
w
/'~i.1 - cl 3
' A '.
. Correct.
.WV 214
-Q.
Earli.er youlgave. Jackie Ables' badge number k.
11.5
. a's -7 7 9 4 4
~ Referring.to'the exhibits before you, can -
~
s r,
4 516 j
. you s' tat'e whether Mr. Ables w o r k e d,.- o n ' J a n u a r y ' t h e l'
[/
=
r-y
- :17
- 14th, 1984?
j:_l #
\\$ -W ;,
7_
-;" 1_g -
" : A '.
Yes, sir, he did.
. e:
f
.19 Q.
. To ~ which' exhibit are you, referring?
yy je.g gg
.A..
Brown E x h i b'i t -6.
L -
~;
-t b
X 121 Q '. -
t Wha t,. time: did: Mr. Ables commence work on.
.y.
A[. i
- January'the 14th?
1 u-
"2 21 '
N i
~ ' 1 2 3 i,.
- A.
'Seven'o'clockDa.m'.:
~
a
}:u n., '
Q.'
And,wilen,did-he-leave?',
3
- ^24)
.E,.a
~
.'e.)
i
- v e
- (g
.33
~ 2 '~ 3 01 a.m.; S und a y -mo rni ng.
2 1 A.:
y. 51 t
4.
.,.o g_ '
- -i -
-w :
2 i
c
[..,
-?.
,a
(.
U[ T.u f d ? _ _,
R (s
(u~
.i t,..O '
yq:). r.
e
=-
'sa g' r 1;';-
^M.
15 l:
a F.J + y
- 4 -
s; r
i.
-v 4
~ U I
,1 ~,
'Q.
'And' that;would be 1 J a n'u a r y the~15th; is that b2;.
),.
r v-
,2.
' c o r r,,e c t ?
,b
,'. j3 4
'A.
Correct.
~l '*
~
>4'.
^
0.
Mr. Brown, for.each of the. individuals that o
4 gN.
(
tl, 5.
we.have just identified and discussed,-the time that l
Lp,
~6, "they began _ work.that' morning is not_actua11y'
~
2._
J7 1 recorded'by' number, is it?
4
'8:
A.
- N o,; s i r',
it's not.
o
-9 Q.
'Are they referred to by' color code on:the
^
r 10[
- original Labor _ Control Sheets?
i
~,
l l11{ -
A.,
Yes, sir, they are.
^,-
12
'O.-
Have you compared the markings'on the e
T0
, []
13'
' copies 1of..the Labor-Control S h e e t's ' t h a t have~been-x, i
r
- .t 14 marked as Brown E x h i;-i t s 4 through 7 in this.
g t
s
.. ~
11 5 1 proceeding.with the origin ~al color. codes in the e:
'.; 4 -
-16 '
. binder that is in your possession?
w 2A.:
.Yes, sir, I have.
y
'17 c:y a
18, Q.
- And on -that-basis your t e r t'i m o n y s is-that
+
19 leach of-these individuals' commenced'workcat seven-3 4,,
f
-20:
'a.m.'.on January the 14th; is~that-correct?
y
~
- 21=
-A.
Yes, sir, that's' correct.
r
.c Mr. Brown, is'there'any-independent ~means cy
- 2 2. ~
-Q.
a
~
423/ -. o f : v.e r i f yincj ~ when an employee leaves work a ti g
hj_;,
24
' Comanche T Pea k'. othe r. tha n the Labor, Control.' Sheets?/
A i
- av p'..'
' 25~
~
-A.
Yes,' sir.
Oftentimes'.they will sign out,in c-
.),
b;
_d 9
k Wy Of '
' ~ ' '
10 4
+3 at
.g e
~
11'4 my office, when my people are'not available to n.
(.
12;,
~ 2 actually log them out a t. that time when they leave.
c,c
' 3'.
Q.
VAnd when they sign out, is there.a form for..thbt purpose?
c 4
used
.c
^
A.
- Yes,' sir.
- 5 4
6 Q. --
Are these forms retained in your possession, E
. supervision:and control in the Time.l Office?
1 8
A..
Yes, sir.
^
9 Q ~.
Mr. Brown, I'll~show you a document that's "P-L1 d,
[been_ marked as Brown Exhibit 8.
Would you identify a l1 ~
that'docume,nt,'please.
" 2 12 A.
. T h i.s.i s a copy of.the sign-out sheet for, 7
[h 13 '
Brown
&' -Root, employees who leave'other-than their. _
- c. g
... a
- 14x regultyrLscheduled time, for January.14, 1984.
a.
15 Q.
'Does it record the names of-any of the
.y g;
~16 :
ig_'e n til e m e n' - t h a t ' y o u ' h a v e discu'sse'd in.your testin'ony?
'-; p-4 i.-
> :s
' 1,7 ~
k
- A.'
zYes, sir.
L.
}'
18' ~
0.
Who are those?
, e
. 1 Jackie Ables,and Alan Justice,
+.
-A.
E'
-19 w
a s
Q,
, 22 0
.Q.
What: t i.n e' d o e s itishow that they signed out?
-[
[21t 1 A.
A ta ~ 2:30:a.m.
n t-g
+ +
v1 1 22-Q.
. Now',
the. sign-out sheet issfor. January the.
m'
,f'l l '~
m
$,.s4,
l23Q 714th.
Earlier.you~ testified that
,t h e s e g e n t l e m e n 2.
7
.j
'jk
. 24:
11eftiwork at3
?
2': 3 0.-a. m. on the 15th.
Could you J
i a.
3
' Y l2 5' (ex'pla'in tha t?
~
- l4 - #
~
't 5
1 g.-
+,
t
y w 9
m 3,.
s;
.,c ', f A -:
17 -
m cs.,-
7 L;.:- if X' Q g
a s:,
f
, g: :
a
+
,g' i i; l,^ '
.a tTherfirst person on the top'of thi s ipa g e,. ;I.
- A..
e
~
,, x, r:
6
- s x
,u /fi"<'12?
JknowCpersonally, comes in ati l l' o.' c l o c k p.m.
every q.e
>7 a.
y s,
^
h -J
+
(n'i g h t'. y A n d is o, t h a t.' s - p ; m.
The sicj n-ins ~and
- s hic 4 = 3 ",,
,p.
5 7
k ( ]1 Y i4
..sig n-o u ts: o n ! th i s s'h'e e tE sta r t ; cin J a n ua ry 14, but
~
I:
~
i X.f5 L f spill s i ov e r n into - th'e~.ea rly mo r ning. ho u r s of Ja n u'a r y
^
~
c
< ^
.n,
M:-
.6' 71 5 :
~
n
' 73 gh ;
7
., s tha t ',co n c, l u d e your t.estimony?;
f
',7 ?,
-Q.
Does
%m....
,_ 1 y
-?
r
,a
,' C T ' 8. d'
~A2
.Yes,zit'does.
fjf
-:'}
~
c,
+9,
~h
- MR. WATKINS
Thank~you, M'r.' Brown.
g f 5',
r_
- w l>
..(10),
i.
THE/ WITNESS:1 'Okay.
s.
ue
~
" r:~
7. ' fl'l[
r
+
MR.jWATKINS b For the record, Mr.
- 7. n.
+
% 212 Brown;has?withihim.a't[this' deposition the computerc m - '
n
~
+
, i._.-
in his' testimony.
'rhe
-W fprintout; tha t.he. described 'i,n 13 e
a._j~'
~'
a s
~
,4:
a.. ~, T 214.
computer printoutLisEquite bulky, and'itiwouldibe m
N t
J id i f f i c u l"t ? t o in t rod uce'.' ind'i v id ua'1 pag e sl f rom 'thei
.S' 51 5,
c s
s
+
/
J L 16 C y p r i n t o u t'. i M r.1 Brown? also has f theVo riginal' Labor ^
f.
k
' 17 '.
Control Sheets showing the color codes for: th e ~ we e k'.
c e
e_
e o,f
,~
,x 4
t
, ::18 :-
,ending.Januaryfthe',14th, 1984.._The color coded i
=
,g.
4 g[#
195 '
Lsheets'must' remain;in Mr. Brown's possession and.'
2
.v w
- 20T ic o n t r'ol at9the Time
- Office'at Comanche, Peak,.so we.
, 3 :p *
, c
..ill-not: attempt.to f.nt rod uce = the originals of7these 214'
~
w 3
s m.
4,,. 37
+:.(
r.
4:
- 2 2" ~
documents into evidence.-
.d n..
_23
",- S A ppl i c a'n t s m o v e. t h e'r, a d m i s s i o n J o f Brown Exhibits y
s N
jh [v. ' (2 4?
tl tthrough 8. i n t o 1 e v i'd e n c e.
Anticipating a possible..
1 a -
r u,w
! hearsay objection-to Exhibits 2 through 8,
'~ '
- 25
- .m p
- w.,
,.3 - 1
.N'
..9 -e
.-y'
+n' r
+
y 4
... j i
~r
,x 3
(.
^s
,s
m S.
~
18
[
4d 9
p fApplicants invoke the b u s i rie s s records' exception to.
fl?
4 m
M,- 8. ^ ;
2 the rule.
Federal Rule of Evidence 803 (6).provides
~
t.-
-3
that business records'are not excluded by the rule 1,
- 4. -
against hearsay.-if such records are sho~wn by the I
25 '
.custodiui of such-records that they are kept in the
^
[;.
tu
~
- y 6-course ~ of.a regularly conducted business activity,
<t 7,
and,1f.such records were kept as part of regular EU 87
' pir a c t i c e.
1 s
3 L-
'9' Mr.-' Brown ^has testified that he is the
~
l S
I10) custodian'.of the Labor Control Sheets, and that they u
- lli
'.are made out and kept in'the regular course o f.
F 1 * '12 f business, tall'.within the beaning of the : Rule 803 (6).
1 7,,
.r3:-
13 v
w
,)
LIl 4 ' 2 b
[15 "c
16
+
' ' ;r; jl 7--
,s
.} 3 c
,18 q-
'19
~
20:
s_.,.
b
[
-21 t.
'22 7.*
~I'
- 23:
,j_1-24-10
, q)
A 25-s
[
t c
(-
I
-+
. [
e 3s
'/
w g
- 1 4
1
.s(
Jy 2
+
3
+-
a
, ~I,,f TAMES E. BROWN, have; read the foregoing-
~
'4 p-
~5' deposition-and hereby affix-my signature that'same 4
~
is'.true andccorrect,-except as noted herein.
6 3
y L
8~
r-
,9 JAMES.E. BROWN
.10
~
11 9
12 SUBSCRIBED,ANb SWORN to'before me this the D['] '
13 day of
, 1984.
W 14
- 15 16 NOTARY PUBLIC IN AND FOR THd
~
STATE OF TEXAS
.17 s
J i
p
. 18
.. v.
i 19 My commission.expiress' l
4 u
-20
'~
m 21 s,
-.22
~
(f
't 23
(-
24 s
-25
-1 s
FEDERAL: COURT. REPORTERS s
3
F 2
g
+
F-il STATE OF. TEXAS
)
-2
- COUNTY OF DALLAS
)
~.
3 4
'I, Janet-E.'Schdffer, RPR, Certified
.5 Sho.rthand' Reporter in'and for the State of Texas, s
s 6
..do hereby certify'that there came before me on the 7
- 15th. day '-o f 1 Augus t,
A..D.,
1984, at the Glen Rose 8'
Motor-Inn, Glen Rose, Texas, the following named 4
- 9 person, to-wit: JAMES E.
BROWN, who was by me duly 4
'10
.-sworn.to te'stify the truth and nothing'but the
~ ' ~
ll.,' truth df'his knowledge touching and concerning.the
.,12 - ' matters inycontroversy-in this causes and thatlhe 4.-
/
,i 13
' was-thereupon; examined upon his oath and, his:
v
.g 14
) examination _. reduced to writing; sam % to be sworn-c t
~
15 to'and0 subscribed.by aaid. witness.before any.-
~
9 4
Notary Public..
~
W16
- v. -
o 17
^
~
LI : f urtlier ' certify _ that I amJneither:attorne'y
-; 18 c
~
19 zor;couns'el for, nor-'related to or employed by,-any' 7
, ?'. 2 0
, of the. parties to the.act'i'on'in which this 21 deposition i's;taken,.and further.that"I am not:a S22
'relativefor employ'al of a'ny attorney or: counsel
~
--5 w23 employe'd 'by - the' par ties '_ he reto,.. o rg financially =, s 0*~
l L
f*c f "
..,24
_ ~1nterested'in the action.
, 4.x.
< o.
25 3_ '
~*
n
--I
/
I(,
9
~
t 2
y.,.,.,,
I
~
e-c-
e ' "I
-FEDERAL [ COURT'REPORTERSy
~
~
y J
-w
-=
a 11 1
In witness < whereof, I have hereunto set my 2-hand and affixed my seal this 15th day of August, 3
A.D.,
1984.
4-5 License Expires:
6 December 31, 1985 CSR No. 1453 7
, JANET E.
SCHAFFER, RPR, CSR IN AND FOR THE STATE OF TEXAS 8
1226 Commerce, Suite 411 Dallas, Texas 75202 9
(214) 742-3035 10 11 12 13 s-14, 15 16 17 18-
- 19j 20!
21 221 23 1ll 24 25-FEDERAL COURT' REPORTERS
BROWN & ROOT,1NC.
" LABOR CONTROL SHEET" WEEK ENDING:
JOB NO.:
351195 BADGE SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESOAY THURSDAY FRIDAY SATUROAY BATCH TOTAL REf NUMBER 8
HRS.
IN OUT HRS IN OUT HRS IN OUT HRS IN OUT HR$
IN Oui HRS IN OUT HRS IN OUTHRS 4
s A
[9
?;
T
. a 4
h
= = ~ -
i
.g..
t 4
6.
t.
,y s
- i A:
k i.
a?
I.
r r
4.
TOTALS:
I:!
DEPOSITIC EXHl81T I
E
..-.=.-:.
1RdV'N & ROOT, INC.
^
A
'" LABOR CONTROL SHEET"
~ ~, "_,
r-a
- j 35-S5 vex oee os no.
3 a
in our as -
ne-,g a,-s s.,-,
s-,
q ourj as i jourimas i
our' mas
- our as - our as
- our.~as iu
+v: ls Y2K~
n
" Hoot
- w/
n 1
G HOO2 L//
' ' /V ' f/
/ /' l/ /
AO 9003
// \\//
- //
/ /
V /
POOA A/ 1//
V,/
/
/, y/
/A:
1 HQDS
//l
! /- -/ /
}' /
as/
Wi
{
NOOlo
~
/ll.//
!//" / / W/
d j
-u
' G/ ddd/ n ho/ 4 gf""#
1 W:/[gQ9i:f69l/
i MOO $
A HOLO b/. //
- k/ /IT k//.1 l/
~ V/.
Wh ?At f /; b {/ isw +
i
//
V/
. ' ;//
//
HQOC) /r$
3
/
Yl
=.
lx-M kdec a emW L
HQll 4
i HQl1 yc/ A// O'//
' / /'I/ /_ W/ / '. / pV '
L'Mt.$/h f
' HQ}$'
!l//; ' / l ' ".i f f.': ~ / / hV /,m /} /:-
??r @h
&lA.
' 1/ll *k/!
' / /J $,. / ' ~ W~oW $/
.e'$$
. d;;Y8 M@}$
d//?-f
[# U//M/
LW HQ}{o
/ #
/$
O / l4*, ' /}f J/ /
l. //?
f-Ah%
Hol1
+ / / w / /
j /4 l- + W30!
~*
Y O:YsC\\% PA/
~ 64)&
HOl$
'//
< /W -%/$
- i/ \\
~
j d l9
$,. / 7 / /
/l/
'. N% $
i'
)[p :: i// Q f:/ /
1 i,
.k
& 20
.N
%'// ~? '/ /&//
' //?
- -l^ W '$2
' ~
f
'I HQ 2)
// i /[/ -:/ /
>c // 8 / /
?M 4/C i
+
UQ 21 kd/ i fbQ/* l,9/ v L&/I
%/
&l, $/D 2 / JW/
acl/
o' e WA HQ23 Ed/
60 /
f (rf
. I$ ;f' a. f)0 'p QQ)f l
f yy
?. Spo; x:v t*:
hD 25 a: /
xd; @f: ljo e%f W
//l.
. 9n hQ 2(o
//
/ /
//
/ /
. //
- rAnh
'L i
l Hn27
//
- //
/ /
/ / - / /
42l
/
tid /
00 /
eso/ :
r.'l:<.@jl * "~*
j
_HQ2R
'.// 10 d
- .. HQ29 m y / ;,=f / n j g? *
.:/
m%,
//
- l HQ30
' /
//-
/ /
f /
//
- %fd
/
@//S
/$3 /1/ + / /
HQ3\\
I//
/ /
~
^
ll M032
- //
- JS Tl,9
/ /
/ /J //9/ /
'^
o G
s QQS3
/ /:
/ /;. /
/.
y n,4c0
//
/ /
s' c
/ $ / f. / f iW /
//
- . & :. 4g G
- QQ34
//% /
HQ35
/ 9 ff ' / /
/ Y
/FD
/ /
' /V '.
. m~- %
?
~
_/. A-
/ /- l' /fV
. /17 M
HQ3(o j /b /
/ A~ // :- / /
4/-
a fffl.
HQ37 V-jf
/
5938
- e s
//i; F l.
/ /l. *c /~/
/
F.
w N/il'
//
l~
w 14U 4039
./V
/A
/ A: / /
~
- uM AO W
/fl- /LA8 t
%V
//l:
- ~
ucM f
t I a l_ t Iakk i
I I
vorus:
Y' M $ l l h {T
- l DEPOSITION OT1 g"a"2 9r l
, BROWN & ROOT, INC.
" LABOR. CONTROL SHEET' MN WEEK ENDING:
JOS NO.:
SADGE SUNOAY MONDAY TUESCAY WEDNESDAY THURSCAY FRCAY SATLRDAY BATG4 Y AL REMARKS IN OUT HRS IN OUTHRS IN 10VT HRS IN 'OUT RS IN IN OUT;HR$
IN OUTjHRS OUTlHR$
I9C9 6Aidizd/KH%/h4FifIdwVle an 5pt
\\
Al2
/ViT /A? A/ ?/Ad / / T(
- *40
%p2f_
1-AAlo//\\C/\\/ 10AAD// to m so
/ Alo //4 l / / 10/l/\\lC/\\/\\n c '; H3
__20st h:bl
- /Alo /V1U } A O / / IC/V!!O M
50 2n/
I= // 10/_]/10 / fl0/ / \\0/'/ 101 AA'h st
=-
/V@ /\\Al0 //10/\\AIO//IUVl/'b M4 53 2121 Jwf
' /i/ lo A/flOf/AO // IO / / llX W 60
~
10//IR~~$$
LQ/AI0fb
% ~
%t 2z)0 A/l10 /VilO]/I/!!D/ A t
2ili 1//\\fa /V!l01/ AIU/)
d 50 z 237
- / Vlio /Vil0/VilO/
/,lO/ / ID M*so i
_2334 AST //iLi(/IlOl'/llO/ '/ 10 V M 49 J 37/
D' //
10 /f II /l/lOI/ /lb/l#l/2 /l/119
^ M'- 7I iMb / /10" \\
M// 7 / As /\\/7/Vlo! ";:: M4
^
237[
/l/lO //Il0/1/10//!!D //
[D M
50 2420 fi/ IOfill()l/l/i0*
h /I))D b N&c QO l
2470 L Al 10//i(OVIAfD// IO/ '/ lb
&. 50
\\
2 vfl U // 10/Al0VV
/lC6 c:
M:P40 20lf 20/ /dB0//#TMd MO/lGWG J WA 47L
~
[
ayn.
' //T, / /9/AI t //T//%
5 m'*
- bt-
_2 kcl
//fT /A7 /i/? '/ /3/rY
~
- '?" 40 f
.29 t.
r / /%/ /t/Vi / /W// 2 UO xio Wr.s \\\\ 9WGy$$fIl %iilt 31wfl
- =
SQL 2s24
'//
15 //V/fl0// 10 // (D // l0.: 1o 2 531 l
/ YtkVAC W V lll/ / ID// ]O
'5\\
2 544
. //IO /Aln /\\/ li / / L)/# 1k/ / 10 sit 20)
A/ 10 //in/f/10/ /Ili/ / ID
~ m
)so i
2stl
// to //iu /, /10/' /Illn
+
- r l-n w
2k2 Af 7 A/ 'd '
/ /!'l / / '6 I
x 3a I
2L27 AA% / / 7 //ISt /\\AX /V %
+ W 4w r
J A /lic /g$$ F i
zw7 n e I5L 2Wi AAY/AT / / X / /ll //l i
-W +0 s
2LM i AAT A/8 / T/ 7 AA7 / /8 / /I% M 4tl 3L13 9d/\\\\t A/IC/Vil(1/V ?/ /JD
- W W 265
//ilo /\\/DVV IDIA/ 10 / /\\ln
~
Bo 11 %
V/i(0 A}IOffl/ll1A / IC/ /ID n 5d 2RW
/VllC//lDlA /JOV/fl0//llC_
5 06 l.
~
GOI 1951 //. 10 V/ 10/Vil0V710 / / b//\\l0 f; =
2914 92&//K A /i?l/ f 7 / / ID/ /lO/M;Ilo ~= Wd
@l '2ObJa571J S%1 ! m2.I a=ml 73YA -
Touts:
'/
lt --
/
/
m DEPOSITION
~ ~~
~
EXHIBIT Aeowd
EROWN & ROOT, INC.
"LA'2OR. CONTROL SHEET'-
m 'S5 wrax ENo-o xewo; SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY SArbaDAY BArCH TOTAL aEMARKS
=jourmas -pur;as our; mas c ourwas - ourmas = ourNas
- our as 2 9//
// 16//u/VIC// In/ / ID
+n So 9939
//lO// I!*/ / l0 / / 10// JC T
50
_2972 A/fa /V 10\\ / / 10 //10/ AID, :: /M W
i 203/
/ /lo/\\/ IU/i/IDAhl0/AC so pon
// loa /!UA/ 10 Al 10/ l. lO M
5a
~
// 101/ VICf/lD* I
/ / 10
'W 40 i
20 @__
/ /1d/)/10//f(D/I/ (Of/In 50 20(c1.
f Yl
- 6. jA
- 4
+
JAc.
3,03,f 2)l7 l / IO //II?V /10// 10 //HD 50 3My
// 10/ #G /T/s IG //< %/Xp?/e%$% D:
mt 9tP '/z s
3)?4
/ /Tl//f /V1f//W/M ao 3 Xfo
' A/ lotAAC/l/lOf/flO/ /\\lC i-W- bo
//1[(: /\\/10I/ /ID/$1'7 v
W7 1
3 230 1A/ IO 329'4
- A/9 /i/i? /IAT '/ / 8 / /7 F
+o
/V3/ N VIA b /9 // 9i w+
40 2275 327.S-A/ 10 //l!O /f/ll) ifAl) /J ll) f
~.
50 3MU
/V lo A/IO/fAIO/VfD/ / 10 / /10
<bo 2293
/V \\o //10/ /fl0/V 10// 10 A "
so m%%d/64 /I(M/laL*
.W 47 33o2
.a
- ~
3314
/ AT //7/I/8fA M //X
' =n= 40 f /f
/ /If C /!/U()/ V IO(/f/UI)h.~ /Qt V~
49t 332D l
A/iiG /AIO/ /7 AM
//%'
44 23/z.
A/%/ A7 / /7 A/3 //
16 2,'2 40 3372 l
A/ l0VAIO / /ID JT/ II) //in 50 a
338).
A/T / A7 / Af / /l8 A/l 40 33flo
/1Alo /All) / Aln / / 10// 10 5a 3399
/ /IlD //Ill1/_1 finl / IU / /lh so c
)
.3V/4 a /'/ ll0 / / 10 /V (C /'/ \\!O/ / in
. v Sd i
347]
/ fi3' //2i A/7 / / T/ / Y // S 1*i5 b
.3527 AAlO/ /lO /V lh i / l() / /l10 50 l
As3D A/ 2 / / % /t/ X // V /1/ 7
=
'5 40
' {
36 2/
/ /T / A% /If X l' / 7 / /' T L
HQt t
2451
// 10 // 10/V 1(J VI10 //In n
so 1
3 bit
/ /\\lo // IO/ /\\l0! /;16/ All) so 3 70'l 77h A//l#i/ /}ID/ / /C/ A//J
'i 5I j
373&
/IAT '/ A7V /1C / /ID A WIN 3RiVW N/TL@6 /# '#h* ll S$h
'37W o
I
~f/F A71/ / ? f/ /iC VIF/f/17 4ot 3
?
3t33
' / /\\\\ol /418!AAlt / \\ /InA All) 5at
~ * ' -
/ l ar7kkIW, 'l 9t/71557 l 735 l 67 I 5 l To m s:
l le'l'
\\W /Ob IOV -
I r;l DEPOSITION
__..._ _f
[XHIBIT u _._ _ _-
.L
CROWN & ROOT, INC.
t "LAEOR CONTROL SHEET'-
5"S5 wtEx tuona aos wo:
l TUESDAY f
SUNOAY McNDAY WEDNESDAY -
THURSCAY FR60AY SATURDAY SATCs vorAL REMARKS
=jourjaas= ourisas.x,ournas nRs, = ou jsas n,our sas a our
= our sas M ff l//E //%//
TAA(O//%
42 h
Af'd!
//10l/10/ A OIf AIC A f \\O 50 JJf6 AAlolA/1H/AD /\\AIUIAAIO so 4t/
I l/l/ITVI/!?VIA7 /l/ !?l// 7
'40 A%dlald 9 $ / N d9 @l9# 5' i*ld-Tla i 57K d
//f#
_ 2 90_ _II
/ A9V Ai' VIAZ / ATl/ A7 4o scc 3
/ V Wu / A fA V If IID /llllb/TA{n l5 \\
.57fD A/ loi//ly //)lOfi/\\\\0 //(Q 1
50
~
l
_J7M
&/\\IN3)/l(h$Al&#IA(OWY%%
fra so
/\\AT / A1 VI/TY /\\/iV( A/ Y 5)3L V
c/54
/Ifl@ v l l/AVI/AIC/V 10 Mo 11 S174
//10 A/ 19//ildAA0!//\\\\C/i/IC 60 rzel i f A/85lA ATVTAT A, !7/ /7 l
ao riz z.
I A/\\\\OVVil0lAAD AA0/
/ 10 5o sd7 l
AA% A/_L8/1/\\fA A9 // 7 ao s 291 A/llo AA10VVil0/i/10 /V IC 5a i
s3ll A/ 10/AIOVIAD/\\/ll0 //(b so i
sn?
/V 10 AAID/AIO/ vin// ID so i
53ss e7 Y
/\\AK1/ Alo/V to //10 5
ns i
rrsz.
/ / foVVilWV10/ AID/ AG sO
__g13 A/IT A /l7Vi/ 9fA /IV/ /!?
40\\
suo
/ VI'o/AIG /IAO A Alb //lf0 //\\l0 so fliz
/\\/T5 / /T AATAA8 //?
l 40 i
sid
/ AIC // lC /Auf/IID/f10 /A10 ho Sitt 1
' A\\o / /W f AD //!!W /itC Sol
- I cnf
% A%/ /Y /T/ 7 /jl? / A7 mtL
?
sWf I
go/l@J26A&u/llBWifWo /O S40 4
5 714 #
1!6&lWi$0!Pi e 4 # H9d#191af vAYW M5 sit l
^
/ AIU / A nA AIO// lD //10 so h
en7 Sf6
// (0/ / Il['/I/lhl/\\/ll0 /tf l.1 / OXJd 70t 5%$
G50 /ihlWU / 9&/ 75$ /\\lk '>Of ?i.
HDL i
'i s#
//!ld// //D / A6GVl7 //10 47 ti s-951
/Alo\\//!bfi/IlVf/ ID/AfD so E9w
/ lol/AlW /lO/V IO/ /floff l01 uo Sc13
/V l0f/A!C//lD/V fD // ID f
so
~
t.js1
/Vl\\n! AAlnVV\\lO / Alfi// ID//10 so 617f
/ /\\lo AAOl//1!D/ AIDA/llO/' AID
- co.
I2tf(
A/d ^^( )//\\l0VA\\o *l
\\
\\
s 45 (2r4 1/\\ AT 14 /WlA /l2l/ VF/ //69 l
ua fl I sl9 M $/S l 33L132M IS'Ft l 6MI a5 Torns:
la 39
% I 40 40 aob
,; DEPOSITION x
i
BROWN & ROOT, INC.
~
" LABOR CONTROL SHEET" s m ss wEsx Euon2-
.cs NO, SUNDAY MONCAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSCAY FRIDAY SATURDAY BATCH TO AL REMARKS IN OUTHRS IN OUT HRS IN 'OUT HRS IN 'OUT HRS IN OUTHR$
// (0//I!D//l0 / /\\l0//,lD
~: ' 1 So
//10//fl0 / /\\C //iUf//10 so von 7ofI ~
/ AT//V / A9ff/ 7/V18
~-
ao 7N.3
' A/ !6 //10VIAIld/lf10/ /IO/ A 0
'oat 7)U
+ / /7 //4ff/\\Z(// L / /7 w
72tf
~ !/% /A? \\//TI/ AT f(/lY
~ ' yo 73r4
'ViTV A'd V ( A 8 /\\/F{ /fl%
,.:) 4o 94pz.
AA7i/ /iEV1A7:/(A8VVlR Mo
%AiT.WA T blVP,% G k.A 7l% k. M
?
- 40 7M7 1
7495
- //
10/ffG/\\/ MJA f 10/V jd W
sn A/10 %927A/l0//IDA/ In /A0 &
s, 7s2'
_2rjo
- / / lo'/!AOfAAto! A A lli//ID 'Affil0 %
ao 7551
/VIIOVill0/\\/IlD A 0IU// IU /L/10f :~
ho 7103
/ A9 // ICV lAlO/,/ilD!/\\/\\T1
@ ~I%
//fi /Nl//ITA/T!il7 G^
40 76/f
^
7 721
/ /IE / /W//lT /VW!
/1S a
aL 40 77N
// IO//l0 /1/1C A / % //\\lIl e M 4'6 2799
// V)A/10 /\\ AN/T/10/4%/$W+n mL*_ts.
(7)9
@T 4 % 40 7tz.T et)T M
47 7Rf
' ad/1kn AfW/ IDWAQlobV/\\\\bL h 'hT1? La 7///
/l/T /l/ii'Id/7 / /l7I/ /7 B
2a 940
~
7/Z7
' // 10/fu&OAif//\\lO// 11 9 dP:
%t 2/54
// to//In7f/lb/ /\\\\W / IC
- mF 3a 4
7114
- / /In // fii /T/ ID/ /IIC // (C /fly) + " 160
/ Al0 //!UV /lO/ /!D// l0
'~< 5s fess' MM
/ fT / AU / A7 / / W/ / 7 r
R 4o 1
=
i mov
' / /ll0//ll0/\\/Il1/ / 10 / /ll)//il0 W so N
MM l-i//T / / / //}{V / \\1 / / X
- ? ne mo l
9/S4
/ / !O //II) /An\\// IC/ / IC V 10
%o'i.
9201
//
10 // li)'/ifl0I// 10// ll]
a%
b Gzzt 7 // f0 //1]D /lAlh / /10/ f10/ /%
. ' 5%
'9t2V # /l$%m/ f& # A W S / Tl0llKVl0.MV llh
}l0 W GdCtik L,~5
,~
b 92)?
?
/lD //)!1/A2)O // ID/ $0i/
91W A/ \\0 A / I W / IIi/ / lb /Alb 5o FM
/f/ lek/ViMVAC A/)D/AlO
, ' 5I 931$
A/10 !VTill 1/IIC '/\\/ID/ lll0 /fiO &*
L,o
/
232b
/ /7 /\\/i?VIlT/ A7A A 6~
1
- 40
((3B
// I4/Vtl0/\\/w/! AID /Vllt) (t/ 10 w
l SO A/ Ifj //ll/Tl// f(J/l//O/ /llDI 1
-lM '50 M l 2,95 I314 I 3 6 3 E.! 3 ',2 f I %.Z. l / d 7 $l %
ToTas:
lev f3/
to'(v\\\\s V lou -
c
, DEPOSITION
'~
EXHIBIT t-broah)b i
'c e
t
-r - = 1 "LAEOR CONTROL SHEET
- M G5 WEEK ENDtNG-JOB NO.:
SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNELDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY SATUROAY BATCH TOTAL REMARKS i
~
OUTjHR$ IN OUT' HRS IN OUT'MRS IN OUT HRS IN OUTMRS IN OUT MRS IN OUT HRS IN F3W p :% /ARV/flJ//10 / /10 //!lo
~18 L&
13b1 I \\//lofA!W /101/ V10 / Vin i
F431 l \\A/\\o//itO/tA)0l//\\ Wl/ la I
sa f43t.
l /A10Vfi10/}/(KIA/\\lCOf T l
I 24E l
/ATl/ A E Vl/T// 9 C/X 40
~
~
89ao I
/ AZIAndV)/7 }/ 7 / lA7 a b +10 fMff
/ / 10 //\\\\C4/ AIO/VW/
10
\\so 9 414
/ / r6 % V W / '/l3 A/ 7 /L/b 39%)
229 AAID/AIG 4Aln/lj ICA'/VO sol ffff
/V 10/VJOJfAD A/ l0AMIC/df6 H@lz-2 s 10
/VT1 / /ii0 V T/ K /I/ TC/ A7
~ qa fr73 M17iM-d7 @MT$1d7 4. kA7 40 fto?
//ilo /\\/901//70 A/ ID /\\/lll) /YA' W W
2 700 A/f7 //f DVI A0AJIW1/10l41910 ss fX4 41A10/180/(/IIOVl AIOl/ / I0/VI%
sss fun 7 Tp
- j. p FC i3 9 761 J / '10 *
-\\^ / T '
//il0/ / ID MA0:~- 40 1777 A/\\f/&&/AlOf/Pl7t1/ / IC /Q)LO ;L9(sO ' ~ ^ "
~
FWO
/\\/ 3 /A7lAA'W /!? // IUf/n :: 52.
r?)b V A/E AA1\\/(AK / /\\f / /1 40
~~
M57 J
//7 AA7Vl/i;C/ ^7A/T to
=
993 5
/ d % AP C / 9lTi/ f?t/ A k/Al0 524.
9M((
mp7/1/
? / ATd/%DSL / k?)
\\
(41L 9fiff A/S / /7 AARTA AV/ 't ?
l:
-> Ja 9ffl I. /Yth/hxVLA!0/ / In// \\ll) si
~ n3 l
/ A% / A if / Vi? /\\/\\S7 /i/7 l
40 9
._915L / /\\0 2 c/ R U k/ M 1!) W!W9/ll^i(W/l16 l
c:D 1
922!/
//f% A/ Y A/ 8 / / XI/AWI 40l i
91C'l
//\\lo // 10/\\/IO / / Il>/'/lDl//10 sol 1
9251
//l%//d /\\/7 /AD /J ID /w 14 Sst1
^
qD3 AAT / /7 /VY//V
//ld 1
4o
/IAE / / V /V T / I V/ A9 h
40 92 71 93tt
- AAS / / TVl/ V /i 7 / AZ to L
+
=
13t3 A/hO //IWlhN/ / 10/ '/11()
59 9331 A/T / /7 //2/
/ W / AX
^
no 1&f
\\
A A10 A/llO / AVT l.
3o 9431 A/it0 /V l{i/ViU/ AIU/ A!O So 9%1 1/\\ /IZ /\\/ 2 4 / ?\\/ A Y/ /X
_ l1Y - \\8 40 l
kin
!A/S AeiW i*l \\" ?
l I
i roua
<10 I sl% i s/5 I 3<13 I ::/3 15/7LI /v/!41 % I
?s I
l0
\\V I
/0 i t0' 1O l - I Geosirion l'desan) l 2XHiB t
?
7
o w !'s' h.t" L S M a":??a*?*.?_'.
~
TIME T1M c Ar A,M E
- BADGE, In our ljbef 0 Hoo
$)
L,M h T'/ 0 h
h l
l i
18 a
//70 b
/ //n
&ff/
Nl 3
i d I)! lL
?)
A~, X dn. _
o S40 u
7 71't l
}
} 2.30 01 W I})
9 no A fL @
zu
/
CoS7 ?)
h 330 L
9AM
$NSA DTI $N) h Do n
a Anw N V:oo
$c
%LL
~
'J
'J u dm,r)4 u o$
Gh n i
3 If/
kk kvf/
O m d, N),
0)W k
al I h) 0)al7
,khs RW yNi s)
T i
O I'N Os S]
DEPO 5 MON l
N 8
i.
l 3 ate _
/-/W EV
- 20!>r
.