ML20095C093

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Prefiled Testimony of RM Duncan on 840815 in Glen Rose,Tx. Pp 1-17
ML20095C093
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 08/15/1984
From: Duncan R
BROWN & ROOT, INC. (SUBS. OF HALLIBURTON CO.), TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To:
Shared Package
ML20095C073 List:
References
OL-2, NUDOCS 8408220374
Download: ML20095C093 (23)
v • d • e


Text

-,.3 g -

,y. . . - -. .

-.v ,_

'" ~ *

~

73 .

1 r ?' W _

~

~l' i- ~ UNITED' STATES O F. - A M E R I C A -

5,r~N e -

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ~ .

lN' _

-f BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY ~& LICENSING BOARD ,

IN T'H E MATTER OF: ) , 00D:ETE:

ussac

)

I4- TEXAS UTILITIES. ELECTRIC ) DOCKET NQg

' COMPANY, ET AL.

) 50-445 0Tl kbO 20 PS:04 5 ) 50r4460 t.p (COMANCHE PEAK' STEAM' ) ,j g g , ,

  • 6~ ELECTRIC. STATION, UNITS'  ;) 00C6E!!NG & SEFV!U 17AND'2) ). '

BRANCH 7

^

,8 PREFILED TESTIMONY OF.

' ROBERT MARSHALL DUNCAN 79 AUGUST 15,-1984

'10 11 _

- 12

~

] 13

~

.- 14 PREFILED TESTIMONY OF ROBERT MARSHALL DUNCAN,

'15 .taken on the 15th day'of' August, 1984, in the 16 above-styled and numbered cause, at Glen Rose Motor

~

17 Inn located at Highway 67'& FM-Road 201, in the City l 18 of Glen Rose, County of Somervell and State of 19 .T e x a s ,;'b e f o r e Janet E. Schaffer,- a Certified i  : 20 Shorthand Reporterrin and for the State of Texas. 4 21

~

22 "2 3.

8408220374 840820 J g . 24 PDR ADDCK 05000 a 25 r .

6D'

(rN--_'IS- f~

c , ,

"- 7 .,

- _ , 4 2  ;

e at , _

k J 4 *

. : j; - g.

g

.3; e "

1 APPEARANCES :,,

x <

i- - .

i '. ', >2 BISHOP, LIBERMAN, COOK, PURCELL & REYNOLDS i' V~~ '

Attorneys at.-Law  ;

3a 1200 ~ Seventeenth. Street, N.W.

s

. Washington, D.C. 20036 ,

,} T-B'Y : McNeill__Watkins-II., Esq.- ' *

~ * ' *

<- .5 >

+

[ '

- APPEARING FOR APPLICANTS

't i

-6

m, .

7' ,

,. +

. < , - , '8

+ *

, e <

  • ~

-:r_

f_ Q r' ,

I 3-

'10 '

~

. c .

I s

. . 11 g,

  • s .

f 3,

1 'l 12' - "'^

i < 4 D #

D 13-gy .
- s -,

1 g ..

_. , . , -1 43 .~ . <

~;

(

. 2 '

..15-

=

r _

u . ,

i:. * , . ^,

a ' '. , , 116 ' ., -.:

. L' .. .

. 2

. 17 .

, I i s __ n. t..

~

<18 - . : ,.

r- , -

, J f, LW e

,,v: - <

19' / - " '

~

,e. . 1 ,

L' k ., .

- [, "

'Y" *

  • '. *' Y .

+',, ' e. L

n g , ,,

l UA r s .>

. A-- a, '2 14 -.

+

- _. e. .

5

.+ t F

_ 'g -+e ., , r  %

,,- ~ - f-es, '_- g e. ' _ %n y

_y +9 ,

s. c h. ~

s x -

' ]'$

y

% i , J ' . , ,

. m. ,

,23..

q'u7' r 1 >.

4

- A -- 4 - e

, .,o . i.

u

'I  ! o 4w }

r

.r a .

~

.c

'.,-N

  • j ' i[= t '% ,4 .I t,

N

-3 s

+

<, .a s..

k3 ,y 5

, a r -

z..25- 9- -

. x. .

t } , ' M' .-g 3 > # p 9 ,

I w Q 4 q- q,

a. m . g_ , , , ,

3*

' "~

y l,.  % e

_y. x-

^

.W _. - z, g'; Y", -

+_.~.f_.

'g- s '1 s .

' 9 r.

r 3_ _

.= - -

s' ~'r; -

. 3 r .1 .

+

3

'" J -

' c e

' 7<? ,

ll. ,

, .[ ,

"l' ,

t I' N D ,E X.

s V 2: WITNESS: ' ROBERT M AR S il A L L DUNCAN

~

.3 ~ Examination by Mr._Watkins .Page'4 s.

' - 4, . ., .. ,

5' DEPOSITION' EXHIBITS- ,

PAGE

, .6 ' Exhibit Number l ', Weld Data Ca rd

- for' Weld'34A - 5 7.

1 Exhibit' Number-2,>NDE request chit 8' for Weld 39C. 6

s. 9 Exhibit Number 3, Weld Data Card for Weld 39C ^ 7 10 .

f -

Exhibit Number.4, NDE request chit '

. . '11 for Field Weld 39C

8 il2  : Exhibit ~ N u m b e r .-5 , NDE-. request chit for Field Weld 40C 11 f) -

13 Exhibit.. Number.6, Liquid Penetrant

. 14 r.eport for Field Weld 40C' 12

~'

15.

e 16

, + -

.18 ,

.. n ,-l 9 A

l 20~

21 22 23

,- s _ 24

- !)

)

25 5-m .

%. - .a ' -

,l .

~u V ,

4 4

, , y

. 1 ROBERT MARSHALL DUNCAN,

  • c f)

-2e .*th'e witness hereinbefor,e named, being first duly

~ -

g_ ,

3 ;c.a u't i o n e d - a n d sworn to testify the truth, the whole

+ .,

4 .:truthLand nothing but tihe truth, testified on his ,

, y _

~

5 oath as.follows: '

6' -

MR.'WATKINS: My name is McNeill 77; Watkins,-with the-law firm of Bishop, Liberman, 8 Cook,,Purcell,&'Reynolds. We represent. Applicants

% ' 9 . i n~ t h i's . l i c e n s i n g proceeding..

This is the prefiled

^

, _10- . direct testimony of Robert M. Duncan, a Brown & Root

-.1 1 ~- em pl o y e e ' ~'a t Comanche Peak. Mr. Duncan...is appearing.

.e- '

12 voluntarilyfas.a-' witness; he,is not under subpoena; "

, n .

"13_ byL'anyfparty.

1 L] .

!- /

14' N: .

-. EXAMINATION _. , ,-

, s > > -

'h . .  ;

15.

~

tr

'BY MR. WATKINS: ,

y

[.' l' 6. Q.  : W i l l' y o_u state your full'name, please..

~ '

cg . "17;

. A. -Robert Marshall Duncan.

q

'. y - ,

18 ,

-Q.

' By) wh om 'a r e _ yo u ~ 'em pl o ye d ', M r . Duncan?-

01 9 A. ,

Brown-&' Root,: Incorporated. ,

i.c -m .

. . . ..e ,.,. .

Q.. And.where are you ~ employed?'

.- ' t ." 2 0 -

i

>~A- . .

^

~ -

3 21-A.. / Currently at,Comanch"eDPeak Steam-Electric .

's y .

22I

~

a4 - .

' Station. .

. <t. .

-M . .,, .__ _ _ _ .fl .

723 ,

p ~ ,Q .' ' Wha _t n i s' you r l j ob_.. ti tl e ? -n

- < ~ .

, .; q f

.12 4.. . <A. ?I'm an_ASMEjQualityJControl inspector.

S /~ , .

What? certifications.do;you hold?-

. g- - n2 5 : , Q.

t - m'- u.. .

b .

'f} )

  • N 'q

~

, r ,

[ ,

' A' *

)

  • p. 4 ,,

w__ _ : : ~~ ' - +~__;_ s' a ,

~ _=_= = , +

. . ~ - . - ,

1 5

s ,

.s . ,

  • t'

~

l' . {A. I'm[a Level II MIFI, VT, PT,.VI, MEI and I \ ~

FI 2 hilt'i bolt. ,

13 10. >How long-have'you:been a QC inspector at 4 ' Comanche. Peak?

,5 A. Approximately one, year.

f6~ Q.~ Who'.s ~your current supervisor?

7 A.- My direct supervisor isLMelvin Todd.

+

'8 Q. And who is'Mr. Todd's supervisor?

< 9 A. Douglas Snow.

10 ,0 And who'is Mr. Snow'.s supervisor?

11 A. Bob Siever.

'12 . Q. Mr. Duncan,.let me show you this document

~

r e-( 1 13 that's been marked as Duncan Exhibit 1. It's a' weld-

..V .'

, 14 ~ data card"for Weld 34A. Does your s'i g na t u r e appear 15 anywhere on that~ weld data card?

e 16 A.- "Yes,. sir, it does. ,

17 ,

Q. .In-what connection does your signature

-18 appear?

19 A. I. bought the final visual of that weld.

20 Q. What is_the date of:your ' inspection?.

~+

21' A. 1/16/84.

22 Q. From, examining that document, Mr. Duncan, 23' donyou_ conc ~1ude that you did perform.that inspection'

[ 24 of that hold point on January the 16th, 1.084?

n.

25. . A. Yes, sir, I do.

l FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS

6 I

1 Q.' 'I'll show you a document th'at's been marked 3s- , . .

L( J' 2- .for identification as~Duncan Exhibit 2 and_. ask you if'you'caniidentify 'he t form of document that that

'f 3 4 is.

J 5 .A. Yes, sir. That's an NDE chit r- they call

~

6. it --

used by craft.

s 7 0.; 1s that-a QC' document?

.8 A. No, sir.

. cv

/ 9 Q. Do.you~know what the craft uses those

~

10~ documents for? ,.

' 11 'A. More or less' of statusing,whercethey are.

'12 It's more or ~.ess of a progress report. ,.

j-4 13 Q. Does your signature appear on that chit? ~

t L)-

c14-A. Y e s ,.. s i r , ' i t does.

+

15 Q. What is the-date that'you' signed it? ,

'16 A. 1/16/84.

7 J17 Q. What. weld do,es that chit identify?:

c .

, 18 A. Weld 34A., ,

- 19 Q. Is that theisame weld.and the same 20 inspection that'is identified ~ by'your s ig na tu r e .on.-

.  : 21" the hold. point on Exhibit I?>

t '22 A. {Yes, sir.

g f, f23 Q. Would you, on.either.of these documents,-

~24 have pub'down a date different than t h'e ' d a t e that f

>-)~  :

.25 J you ac tba lly., sig ned it?

2 i

FE ERAL COURT REPORTERS '

y l

L

~

'~'l ;A. (No , sir._

~.

'~'

(s Y' 2F Q. I will show you1a document that's been

  • i .y

~

- '3 '

imarked for. identification'as Duncan E x h.i bi t 3, whichf 4 isia weld'date. card. Does your signature. appear on 5 that document,' Mr. Duncan?

66 A.. .Yes, sir, it does.

'*-7

'Q.- In what connection? ,

8 A. Again, I' bought final visual.

I 9' O. What is the weld identified on this j 10 ' document?

11 A. The weld is Field Weld 39C. -

-12 Q. What is the date of your signature?

'131 -A.. 1/16/84.

t, ') .

.v 14 .Q . ' From your signature and that date, can-you  ;

15 , conclude'that.you performed that inspection'on 4 16 January 16,.1984?

17 A. -Yes, sir.

18 Q. Would you put an'y'other date in connection

- 19 - with your' inspection than'the d' ate that you actually

~ 2 0. performed the-inspection?

21 A'. 'No, sir.

22 Q. I'll show you a document.that's been marked 23 for identification as Duncan Exhibit 4. Would you 24 . identify the form of that document, please, Mr.

. !3

\~' 25 Duncan? ,

i,

-h -

~

j [ FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS

m = -- ~- -- .. - . . . . . . , - - . . . . . ,

u ,g * .

8

_n  : -

y

- -~ ?

l .1 y A '. .Again, that's a craft NDE chit, used for'

,y>.

^

, $. - ' prog re ss ~ r'e po r t.

2 -

-3 Q. lDoes'you'r signature appear on that document?

.I: .

4 .A. . Y e s , ,'s i r .

-5 Q. What.is,the date?

~

6 .A. -1/16'/84.= - >

a 7 -- O. ,

What is the Ueld to which that document i 8' ' relates? ,

[ 9' 'A. '

Field Weld 39C. ,

lof Q. LSo that chit and: the weld data card that's 1 1, . . been identified as ~Duncan Exhibit 3 relate to the

(

r, ,.

'12 sameiveld?' -

% 13 ~A. f Y e s , J s i r .- -

'M '

514 ~ ~And do t6ey relate to the same' inspection?

.Q. ,

'~

15' -

A. ,Y e s , .'s i r .

y r

16 0.- .Mr._Duncan, do you recall performing an

~

'17 l'n s p e c t i o n" o f Field, Weld 40C.on Tuesday,' January

.18 17 t h , . 19 8 4 ? -- ,

~

-19 . s

' A. Yes,' sir. . _ .3 4.

~ '

20-' <,

Q. 'Would you describe your. recollection =ofL 4

21, that-inspection? o ,:.

r;

s. 22- .A. #Y es, sir. Let's see.. Jack Stanford and I r~.

f:

y- *

.23 were working the. call board.' LI was,in the process

.L - . . -

-') , , 24 'of?gettingl175: hours' required-PT time under a Level 1 -:

Lt ~

.?' s -25 II so that I.could become a certified Level II.

at-ji- , r .

-q [ S 4

j; ~

1; . - -

w'4' .

-FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS

j = _. -

. - . . .- , - . . . ~ .,-

w ~

- ' Si gj K_ = .

. 4. ,

e g ,

~ 1-- .They,came up and signed up.

.p TT _%

T' -

2 O.; .Who-is "they" when you say they signed up?

  • g ,, .

i

, V; L3  : , .. A . . , Thefcraft. Craft came and' signed uplfor.an t

~ 4- ' . inspection', and Ii, n o t i c e d they hadl signed' ul[>-- f or 7 - . .. . . , ,

Ilwas on the lookout for more 5-  : final.. visual andcPT.

tu .e

.6 PT' time,-so. Jack and I.both;.went on-the inspection.- _

.. ,. --7. O. Were you training under~ Mr. Stanford?

8'  : A '. -I1was getting~PT time from him, yes.

~

.9' .

Q. PleaseEcontinue. ,

9- ,

~

1 10, A. =We went down to the auxiliary:.feedwater room.-where th ey we r e L wo rldi ng ,;..an'd we went up on the

. 11 ,

I performed they PT. . PT takes anywhere

~

. 12 -

scaffold. . ,

-13. from.30 minutes to -an 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br />,' depending.on-the' tu v- f) '

.,14 inspection. The time was=up'for the develop'er.- ,

4 15- '

Jack was not on the scaffold at that time.

16 'He~had climbed down off the', scaffolding to make out

~

.17' a'1 1 the necessary reports. 'When'he was down'there,

- 18 'I: told: Jack, " Jack,- I don'tlhave'any. indications.

I You want to come look at'it before'I clean it up?"

~

19' r

20 Q. 'A t t h'i s . t i m e you were on top-of the "21 1 scaffold?-

22 'A. I.was in the' scaffold about ten foot in'the 3-23 'a i r . . Jack was on the: ground.

,2 - -24 , J a c'k s a i d' , f " N o . If you don't have any

'25- ' Indications, that's' good enough'for me. Go ahead ,

. .c en Y

-s ' ./

FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS

' ' ~

- -s -

'y o~

1 A T y

4'

. , ci and ~ clean-it up." _

.( } .2: I was in the process of cleaning it up, and 13 'I heard Jack say something along the lines of, "Oh,

~

'4 _

shit,_today's not'the 14th, is it?" I said, "No,

.5 Jack. Today is'the 17th."

~

6 I h' ear ~d him remark,."Well, hell,.I put the 7 wrong dates down. I got to change them." I said,

^

'8 "Yes, you do." And that's about the extent of it.

9 -We made out the paperwork, signed everything off and

~10 -left.

[11' O. Do you re' call whether you signed the weld

^

121 ~datancard hold. point for either the visual'or

.s 13 penetrant test for that inspection?

$-) '

114 A. No, sir, not offhand.

}

.15 , Q.- .

Let me show.you the document that's been

~16 . marked'as Duncan Exhibit 5 and ask if you can 17,~ ide tify that document. ~

18 L. 'A. .Yes, sir. That's"an NDE chit for Field

19. Weld [40C.

20 0.- Is.your ' signature on that document?-

.;; .t 21 'A. Yes, sir, it is.  ;

22 -0. What is the date that you signed.it?

1/17/84._

p ~23 A. ,

24 '-0 .Does your signature next_to the date t

r n .

,25 indicate.to.you, beyond a doubt, that you performed p -

p ,

FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS

_ -=. _ _ - . _

11

)

~1 th'ef ins pe c t i o n on the: 17th?  :

I');

2 A. Yes,-sir, beyorid a doubt.

13, '

O. Mr..Duncan,'when you sign a n 7. N D E chit such

.- t ~ '4 -as ~ Dunca'n. . Exh i bi ts ' 2, 4 and 5, where do you sign 5 them, normally?-

r

~

6. A. -Usually at the place of' inspection.

7: , Q.- "And is that at the time the inspection is -

~

8 . performed? s

<9 A. .Yes, sir.That's after the inspection is I 1 01 performed.. .,

y Mr. Duncan, I'll show you_a document'that's

~

11= JQ .

- 12 been. marked for identification as Duncan Exhibit 6

~

7, 13 and-ask.you to identify the-form of that document.

Qf

,  ; s 14 :A. It's a liquid penetrant report.

15 Q; Does-your signature 4)r. your initials. appear L 16 -on that document?

17: A. Yes, sir,amy' initials.do.

~

. 18 Q. Wh e r e ch) they appear?

. 19, A. TNey appear right above-Jack. Stanford's

- 20 name, who.was the. Level II PT.

~

- 21' And to what weld does that penetrant-report' 2

O.

22 relate?

23 A. Field Weld'40C.

24 c Q.- .When did you initial that report?.

, im 2' S ,

A. 'I initialed it 1/17/84. -

[. .

./ ' FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS-

_ . - . . . - . - . .. . . . . .. . . . . . - - - . . - ~ -

W:6 ;.: .9 ~ .

12 P

p<~ si _,7 , ,

m '

e <

t t*'

1~

~

'.~s A a . . . ,

l . -Q.g: Mr. Duncan, did you hear anything further 7

Q,L.

2' .ablout'th'is i nspection orhthe 17th?.

~

~3, -

_' .A .

-No, s'i r , 'I ( d o n ' t t h'i n k so. '~

I

~

s .

4 ,. rf Q ._ After thefl7th, did you hear anything  ;

1 e .-

i.' ..

.Si L f u r th e r ..= r eg a r d i ng this' inspection? ,

n . .

6 . 4 9

- '6:

N. ,Yes,Esir, I did. _

n. , ,
And ' 'f rom whom ..did you hear ~it?'

47f

~ Q. . .

a ,h' i s 8_ _,

A. Jack. Stanford. _

, s< ,

.9 Q '. ' What did-Mr. Stanford s a y' to you? -

, , ie -

10? w~ A. .Well, h e . wa r; trying --: h e was trying to get-

- ll- me to help.himl-jog hisjmemoryton it.

s  ; -

[l[2 .

.Q. .How xlong after-the 17th did this .

_.' V ;,, 13- conversation-take. place?. ,

c ic- 1,9 ,

L 1 'i4 'It s eems jl'i k'e ? a . co u ple / o f ' wee ks.

~

A.

Why.did[Mr.-Stanford.appea'r'to n'eed his v 15- Q. '

4 -> _, ,

m emo'r y, j og g e d ? -

' 16 - *

' ~

l17- .

..>A. .

4 -He was being , questioned about conflicting 4 (18  ; dates or someth'ing"on-the.weldIdata card.

1a '

, 19 ~ . Q. DidThe'appedrf to, remember, at tha t. time,

-20: , the' inspection;that you'ha've-just ~ described?

4

.. r . ,

.' ~

T' 'A. dN o',' s i r ..

, 21

~

2'2 -

01 " Didf'he, aftier' talking'with you, remember

\W'_ '

L23'

>V 'the inspection .that you have described? '

, ..- y

v. >

A.  ;

v'24 -

'A..y(No, sir.-

- s

~in. '

,M g-

.~25' .<

, Q.. jWha't'did-he'dofto f u r the r, inve's tiga te ?

a

.f a ,

w. >: c: .

8 > -s >

4,

- g -

4 4, -4 ,

y, ' P _

5- , .

FEDERAL COURT-REPORTERS

q s -

13 g ,

y ,

L  : '

l' -

11 A. Henwant and talked to the' crafts that did

.+s ..

.b 62L the . work. ,

J. '

-3 10. - Do,you-know wh'o he spoke with?_ . .

4 ,' A. IEthink he spoke with Ron McBee and Richard  ;

5 51mpson. -

~

6 Q.. Did he.come back to you after speaking with 7 them?,

8 A. Yes, sir. '

j o -

9 10. And what-did he say? '

10' L A ~. Well,'after speaking-to Ron and Richard, he 11; remembered. Hei' remembered the inspection. And upon 12 ~ ' talking.to me=about it, I remembered it.

73 13 Q. Did'you remember Mr. Stanford's having (J _

14 written down the. wrong date on the' weld data card?

^

15 ;A. .Just exactly like it happened, yes, sir.

16 It just came back to me.

~

17 . Q .' Did M r". Stanford 'a s k you'to' speak.to anyone i

t' la regarding that inspection?

19 A. Yes,' sir.

20 -Q. -Wbo did he ask you to: speak to?

,' 21- 'A.- Bob Siever.

~

22 Q. Did you do so?

L2 3 A. Yes, sir, I did.

i -

~

'And did-you exp1ain your recollection of c

~24'

  • Q.
l. . 7- s ,

!A - . 25 the inspection to Mr. Siever?

r A

e -

i ,

14

- _ , 4 C .

&I . - c

.1 j - A.' Yes,l sir..

22- O. D ,i d he' appear satisfied?

3:4.

~

-3 <

.A. -Yes, sir,.he did.

  • ~ - 6

'4 Q". . Mr. Duncan,'wh'en a OC inspector makes an -

5, i "errorfon a' reporting document / what is the proper t

37 , 6[ j p rocedure for-correcting that. error? .

7l A .+ The proper procedure is to cross out the w . . ~.

~

8 error,~ enter the correct information,; initial and p,

2 s

i ' 9f :d a t'e,... -

JS. -

410 -Q.

Does'thaticonclude'your testimony?

3 .

, , , 11. .A. Yes, it does. _

t. * , ,

12 ,

x ,

T l '3 '-

~

,ry - ,

b ..

~'*

J -

14 s

-[ . 15 .

_ko 1 -- < . 16 <

s  ; . ,

+. 17 . u;

,4 18 - , -

~

19:

+

ic ,-

i f .J

20 -

, m ,' -

, . 21 ,

. . ; 22  :. .

4,

.'23'

,s-

,4** 24

g y. ,
d. .. '2 5 - ,

i

-t

i. .

~ ' "

]. . _ ..

s FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS-

--m _ , < - - . - , _ . . - , . . . . . . _ , , . , . . - . . . . _ . . _ . , - . _ - .

., A ; '

,J _

J:. ,

15 Ti; L,% ,

1 -

. j,j<,*1f3 .

- .r.

21 ) ,

2 ,

,1 <

_ .f .

-3 4 .I, ROBERT MARSHALL'DUNCAN,,have read the

, .i.

f.

[ foregoing deposition 'and hereby af fix my signature 5

f

/-

6 that'same is true and correct, except=as noted

.i- f 7 herein. .

k,Ii 8

_~ ,

- fi 9 10 ,

ROBERT MARSHALL DUNCAN j

.11

/. ,

-,1(. 12 ;_

f-)

'I-13 SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me'.this the

.' v '- -i .

l 14 , day of , 1984.

1

.s

y 15 e r ,-

16 17 ,

NOTARY PUBLIC IN AND FOR THB-a STATE 1 OF TEXAS l 18 19

'20  :-My. commission expires 21

'22 i

23 I . ^14.

(

O '

25

' t FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS ~

D ALLASg, TE XAS, _. __ _ _,._. , _ _ _

m . -

.z .

m , ,

4 16 a ~1 STATS' OF TEXAS ) i

-! 2 COUNTY OF DALLAS )

~  ;

w 4 I, Janet E. Schaffer,'RPR, Certified /

i: "

5 ' Shorthand Reporter in'and for the State of Texas,

d. -6 Ed hereby certify.that there came before me on.the 7 15th day of August, A. D.,,1984, at the Glen Rose 8 LMotor Inn, Glen". Rose, Texas, the following nam'ed ,

9 person, to-wits' ROBERT MARSHALL DUNCAN, who was by

. 10 me duly sworn to testify the truth and nothing but 3

e . 11 the' truth ~of his knowledge touching and concerning

~

~

12 <th'e matters in controversy in this causer and-that

'13 'heLwasi.thereupon examined upon his oath and his

[Ji 14 examination:freduced to writingi same to'be' sworn ' -

L' 15 to}and subscribed by said witness before anyz, 16 INotarylPdblic.. ~

. v ,

t 17

~

.; 18 JLIfurther I certify that xI am.ne ti her attorney o n .

. l19 for counsel.for, nor _related'to.or employed by, any -

( f 20 'of'the; parties:to thef. action =in which this-

' ~

\ . .

~

,21 -

depositio'n is;taken, _and further thatI am-not a 22 -

relatihef.orjemploye's of any attorneygr_ counsel _

, '. !23 employediby the-parties hereto, or financially-4

.- 24 interested in the action. '

rh'.

f ['25 i.- ^

6 -

g- ' F E D E R A L - C O U R T ' R E P'O R T E R S' Li -

^

- L --DJLLLASE TEXAS:

u ,

m _:.

-17

j. .

~

2-1 Iniwitness whereof,'I have hereunto set my.

p) .

't. ~2 hand:'and-~ affixed my seal.thi's 15th day of August, a

4 3 .A.D.,v1984. .

A 4

,. r

'5 License' Expires

~6 De cents'e r' '31, 1985.

CSR No. 1453-

-7 . JANET _E. SCHAFFER, RPR, CSR

~

IN.'AND.FOR THE STATE OF TEXAS 8

1226: Commerce, Suite-411

. Dallas,. Texas 75202 9 (214) 742-3035

.10

~

4 jyy .

M-

~

I12 g3 L .

. ( ~)

V ,

=

14 15 3

~

16 ' ~

\

17 . _

18

- 19

, 20 21 22 23 M

24

-n.

-s i n

v. 25 4

', ~

FEDERAL COURT-REPORTERS z; _ _

fiyN W \fla_5Mn8D

., l M b RIQUIRED ,

  • 1
  • M* Affects x ste w "ev.1am a. tha-6 n ~t(Tp'. -tatrx+~~ ~

%: ;-yy:~tm~ m a -~

"w" ru4..I.ro::

p r -

s ..

worh e s

+

---'4 gNs;2n.AT1CN 70 Es IN m es.u ,4i n
a:F'"ass s w .-sinst. m e .

11 - 41013 as.= m eto(" .r.c r.r at .w.

~

x ce.n i xc:T,3-1.'.J5i :ec. .'

3

+>' m ,;;310 gs --

ru. ins .u. Af'/-58 mW-1 e 3-ica -

' 'ia14 30. b$h  ? \

l

~

L::i 27: i th'LO ~ es/bs 7 /

mx::27 :.1 c=t i

~ tE2.'AC:. C:.

i

/,-18 i-O'64TA 3 79 3 << N i c/oi a t I::

(

l

..+o - 4 / o ; 'g ;wc.s.s 3-1.ri?..*a.i ' Edta 4.3 .-i.si iids?.IGT qF T i- A) t2 hT7 Ad T"?! wa Mrs.. TIJ?. *s .

., u = rs ,

ME;T*:33 xATI vs . ,/Mr. vs y ( c7i i -

, If 5 u, .es - 5 rt :icATica vs,.. e.90 o

i 19 ~C

'J~

FT/10.2-1 MT/1'J.Z-2 AT/10.2 3 g . CAP /RFl *// m

.4 s.11.1-25

5. -=. .* ail?..,,s .u s u D i lak.ai; 1

4 n 4G .

I , , .a.si. . li G e Tr un l 1 ca.13 _/ 7m . 2  :

f;. 'tt- G " i / g g e.- . / 4-< .g V, . /w;w . Ac07 e i A '
. CL 13 L7M 1 e w,oy
4

-Z l

M: . . . . .

. c .u o,e

.u t -

%. m -:= o u . cc. au m ;mau. u . :. =:u.= n :ce.=2., <.

z) /tI f.
ee: en ;mta:: t m d a .ac .4 (:). .. .S ...

4, '

' i 'i .

~

!! Se-Es 14-dthe--- e i' ?:M""dert 'rv an *T*: 'l.-?t-d rhe : r' f r*! *?*d *Mt N t **J"'

e,. yg ) n CG2 AGE - r

~ m *O l.

1 p.,,,, g

g_2. .;s ax :a m.cs .

=a m.  ::mc u: u.r. :s 5:a .u: :e ae j AG i Ali  ::-  % ;r si i .si lAT. l Aik [

l I I ':'tff.? I ' IVII.

I I f IC'easitaess l M i V I C-I _ _ l h8h/s[.[, ///3M! I  !  !

i z in _= 1 n I s I" I 1 5 f f l % A s i- p l E I I

! -. e- . I u 1 -/ I ~ l I5/rr iMBBras3-4+ E I I l s. Ir...tr- I u .I v i - ! l6of PfhE3 R i$l nul I l c IC/ggffbasI s, I ~ l Ife,rd$rL4/4 ;s::  !
. [GdboNTr$d///dwII43-WI l' ' '. I i 9M6m '

i l 'gi i . I "l/l #1 l- 1 I I i

.!, I I i  !

. I i l  !  !

s l'l - I- .D1 I I I kna W u.,..J , ,, , , I l,rm t u imstui l! Jt.r  ;

.  ; l l l i

I I t i I  ! i i l i l

' ' i i i I i i I i  ! i

! I mM74 thMi e i i t w: 9 % sheti/

\ e ,a: s p a.a u s.a:: := afexn = == ; se :=r. anif : i 4/ == : u-j s .= n a= u=.ru.'

!  : DliPOSITION

( XHIBIT G4A)/ ~

  • - x ,

' - j

._ g g ,

y .

NON DESTRUCTIVE TEST

- INSPECTION REQUEST

^;

  • s

O, 1733pg'

  • rOReuku; p f7  %* Date -
WELDER:N/L_$ 1 l~ /b-8d J-

.~

STAMP . All$

PIPE DtA- f, " LO Sbsnl

_ DWG. NO/LINE NO. AF Ctss.o i  ; -

INSP* iwCLE p, Ob-h&-p _ ELV.M[O

_ JT. NO. $42' % C E7L.

ROOT + ' INTER REQ'

, ' STRESS REL. * #

- VISUAL R y- (EINAL)

COMMENTSp) (wL.P)

M.P. u,y- o'

^

HYDRO TEST .--

. %Q + posa .

F *s

> g4 F

Z INSPECTOR: _f_F h ~' -

3-( -

O_ e $

I ACCEPT: DATE I ~ /b

  • 8 b ,

Dmxq "-- t

.s --

Ox

n. ina

+ . -

w tas .

T -

=

O l

.i -Q W j

  • l t - "

. '.-c!

. ( -
  • 4

. 1* t*

,i: y, .

f f

7;; , , . .

  • =,, 4

. .. 'v* .

rc- .

y: .

f;,

.':.~'

.. m. ,

.9 '
L' . . .

4

,o... -

c:. . .

. y ;.

+

l' .

  • va "

g .>.;

2 ',

r; , .

  • \* * .

J. .'.', C  ;- .* - . -

1 i

I.' -

a

. p:a  : 4 .

t . .

E. .

I.- . .,

[ '," ( ,.

': 1 ,,

.- - - - - _ ~ ~ - . ~ . . - _ . . . .- -- . . . - - - - . . .

f CLD.?)R E EE03:EED INSTALLATION TO EE IN 4G$5-Q,

  1. 'I y h wtainea tro:t tne startup st be NC- I WELD OATA CARD Ortwing No. Af f-<f OO7 k-i- -

Engineer ~ pric to starting

  • k - .

.. Wald_o. N t039C

( WPS f

//otO _.f/,d_

RElf/IC1f FABRICATION C005 &

CLASS /ACC. STD.

//,Sf-I-D D ,L"D1 3 < o t.t s /_o Asis III N0/0 5' / D h78Tpg 6,9

  • MATER u FOST'nEi.0 NEAT TREASif 0

.t D to hT7YWN-73 TIME NA Hrs . . TE4P. NA ~

F -

f-C 6 ?NS ts PCP t 4 r-%7

'P F r to P # / HEATING RATE NA ',/Hr. NA

~

, 56/ SPECIFICATION WPS/ CPM 6.9D __

//b Vi/11.1-26 MPT/10.2-1 MT/10.2-2 RT/10.2-3 UT QI-QAP/REV ~

M.&T.E. CALIS. QC WELD FILLER MATERIAL Riqu1 RED WAF(i)

! /3 ff CUE DATE l GC VERle, tea h tu 4w-91/4 /t ,/.o,w tROOT CLASS c we.a DATF: I # '4 y '

IFILL CLASS 4 7%3_.

l l CLASS C. > p de qs,og g i i CLASS jiOTE.5: Appl 1cacle QC/ANI nold points.snal.1 ca inc1: ate 2 cy enecxmarxf. - .

l ANI inspection points indicated by (X). .

[

(3) Denote Satisfactory inscection by an "S"1 Unsaf sfactorv'inscectiens'by' a "U". ' e g . m . PRODUCTICN RELEASE- . ., , c..

.j ,  ; , .. , , ,

CFERATION HOLO FOINTS CON SAT. INSPECT ON RESULIS (SIG.N AND OATE)

MAR.

30. WT QC ANI or QC cr Wi - NDE CERT. ANI l UNSAT. LEVEL 1 VaH *v Cut Y NA 4.IG 8 /-/MY --

_ z clean 1tness NA / /)c .b f 8d ha d M /8 W I 3 Fituo NA /

z)( hj',k/,./gk/9y if A Preheat KA / / )[, hk Uh fr 3 5 Final VT NA / 4)r, [ T_.L __

Aelb.h w _ 2c 1_ E L0ndi3 on \- d 7

ll  :%,ndM%dn IM/ f hL1+8 1

~t "

l 0 .

i i FOR ltlFORMATION DNLY j DEPOSITION EXHIBIT

> i" dun 0ME ' l i; ~ l l

i WE /1.J'Ak /!M/6%C ANi & Lja- $/D9l$ --

Accreval signatures shalt be affixed cri tne I fne i=ediately belcW taa last g

) s:as in eaca sequence. y9 g ,

1 t

BROWN & ROOT No. 175530 NON. DESTRUCTIVE TEST Time Date INSPECTION REQUEST FOREMAN # N I -81t li WELDER: A Ldb STAMP llNb LOC. l ELV.NO*k7Y PIPE DIA. b DWG. NO/LINE NO. /W'l'6S' C 7 JT. NO. 60 #flC-03b .3Ce,}-3 .

IN SP. I CJEAQ - FIT.UP ROOT INTER - STRESS REL. /IN -

REQ. i(VISUAj) (L.P.) R.T. M.P. - U . T. HYDRO TEST . .

COMMENTS:

llCID 3

INSPECTOR L GO *V ACCEPT: ' DATE:

Ij > -

,4

, l' l

DEPOSITION l

' EXHIBIT bxK1441 y

  • . T

~

~

..n._..--. , , . . . ..

, , n n,g , r , . n . .~--;-., ,.g,-,,,,~

. . . _ . - . , - _ . . . ~ . . . _ _ . . . _. _ - . - - - - - ~ - - -

__7___

BROWN 8 ROOT

.No. 17 5766_ ,

NON. DEST RUCilVE TEST Time Date INSPECTION REQUEST II b FOREMAN I-I WELDER: b STAMP III LOC. I ELV.

PIPE DIA. V DWG. NO/LINE NO. Al'- 1 ~68-07 JT. NO. NO-40$.-

36-dd-P n INSP. FIT UP ROOT INTER STRESS REL.

JCL 8

. REO. t(VISUAL ) R.T. M. P. U.T. HYDRO TEST COMMENTS:

s 4

4 INSPECTOR ACCEPT: DATE- b .

L _ . _ . - . . . ___ . _ . _ _ .. . 4'

.e t

t p

I 9

. pgosm0"

. 'I s

I

~; BrownffRoot.inc. 19726' QUALITY ASSURANCE DEPARTMENT MT/PT REPORT PROJECT: COMANCHE PEAK JOB NO. 35-1195 UNIT [ PAGE__/__OF[

MT O PT &~

WDC/ Traveler # hWI Drawing ((-6 6-00') System h , f, Class ]

l< tem # F.u). N O C- Location see. sos ' 3 T' s', C,. l M 7.2_

Mfg Stage [lg4[ NDE Procedure Not2r gap fo,2, f Rev. 3 Equip / Mat'Is Mfg. f))q g [(q Acceptance Std. fgg g g PenetrantBatch # kdl07 Ciecner

[ Batch # M k[D O Developer Batch # 8 10 O I AC Yoke O DC Prods O A/A Model # gj g M&TE IRC # fV A

[ Mat'l Type h( Mat'l Thickness /10 nt 6

, Sketch & Comments ID Cl OD V

&g qq ec.kAk(c $Al IC'9YOM$ NOh l

, FOR 3 FORMAT ON DM.

, i.

.I f,f i

DEPOSITION XHIBIT v

utseart (o I= .

//n ~

t Jr/ U

, inspector M g d / Certification Level I Date / SV $**e$YReject O e t ..--...n.-...

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20095C093&oldid=2785392"