ML20085A407

From kanterella
Revision as of 04:56, 17 April 2020 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of 781204 Telephone Conference W/B&W Re ECCS Small Break Analysis N4M-2-14 - Response to K-5020
ML20085A407
Person / Time
Site: Three Mile Island Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 08/03/1979
From: Simmons R
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY
To:
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY
References
TASK-06, TASK-07, TASK-11, TASK-6, TASK-7, TASK-GB GPU-0480, GPU-480, K-5020, NUDOCS 8307060458
Download: ML20085A407 (4)


Text

, =

(r i TELECON: ECCS - SMALL BREAK LOCA ANALYSIS N4M-2-14 12-4-78 REF LTR K-5020 gg gg g g W10C144 C-K Regr.ested by Carl Michelson jff/fl_.3, A, E;2;U 2:00 / '

8-671-1060 x2707 LHC Carl Michelson Lee Haack B&W: Bob Lightle Bob Jones' TVA: RIS Stu Thickman Harry O'Brien Jim McF.t.l Lou Cartin Dennis Renner Henry Daily Carl: What co - nts does B&W have on K-5020 and where do we go from here.

Bob L: Very detailed study - hard to respond w/o equally detailed study -

are trying to get problem in perspective.

Carl: Question of vapor formation - Temp at t pt = temp at core exit (steam in U-bend)

Bob J: Steam bubble does form - natural cir.culation does cease ..

Carl: What is heat removal mechanism when natural circulation ceases.

Bob J: Pool boiling. When accident starts - lose offsite power get natural cire mode thru system. At this time, bubbles form in core region and are carried throughout RCS. Steam pocken forms .

O t P

XC405?4

= -

.?

in upper portion of RV. Press of RV supports hydrostatic head in ,

hot leg (?) - vent valves open - liquid depletes to cold leg elev and steam escapes thru the break.

Carl: Break isn't big annf to take all heat out'.

. Bob J: Removal of all hest is not controlling factor in small break analysis. Trying to remove certain volume of steam. Some steam quenched by HPI.

Carl: We factored this into our analysis. Your predictions are based on larger breaks - small breaks don't behave the same way.

Bob J: You probably don't have any natural circulation for'small break case.

1 Carl: Do you keep the core covered - If so, how do you know.

l Bob J: Because of vent valve, will deplete system inventory - level will drop below secondary side of SG. At thi. time, will still have water in RV - if you have inventory in system, you have water -

. in RV.

Carl: Do you disagree with my Figures 2 and 37

. e Bob J: Haven't checked your numbers. ,

I -

XC40575

Carl: Have to calculate to determine if core stays covered for breaks under

.05 ft - This is really all we're asking.

Bob J: We've looked at .05 break, in extrapolated to smaller breaks and concluded that covering the core is not a problem. NRC has accepted this, verbally, that smaller breaks are not a problem.

Carl: Need B&W to point out where your results differ from ours - your calculations are more sophisticated than ours so we want B&W to tell us where we're wrong.

\

Bob L: To give the answers you want will require a detailed calculation from B&W.

Bob J: We don't feel this effort is warranted.

Carl: Just reply to our K-5020 describing how you replied to NRC for breaks

(.05Ft.2 . Not asking B&W to do a new analysis.

" XO40576 i

( _

S

_.... - .-.--.==

t

-' y gaae w< u.u.m /} s n :co,C. w .*f' D

'T6 LE Co M '

EcG5 5 mt.t ih E x Loc. A Aat +u s Wi 2-14= uv or il- 4 ~76 R e ;:. t TR l'- 402.0 Ul0c !44 c.-K R ,,,n ie.4 I,.. r ,, A Ak(d.,,m b d 1*.0 & e .uva. . ara ewe =ro o.ee 9-Ml.lobb L C0~1 L.Mc CA Mt,b l< , .*

Let Rtu

  • k 4 JsA,, Rt s A Ttdex- L , o'c,'

6 (td

  • BtA l. *d-tie Tva. .

-fk is hu aa%& es- _- d on

.i 1

,w 4es.

I Ju' . AAc.F l-% C, rL '

De w .,'iL,,., L, N'1 h cA -f. I. 3

  • B ~[ ~79 a

( '

l fCh Wke -_k 4 6W k ..,e  % K -c -.o t iJL.uc h - 4. . 1, b ,h. 4- .m o.

I Ti. L. wi nLi .s L s

LL 4,

.a .A. .. .tL Mu t 4 A - m L

y

,rt

. s

,,4 k .'. .

U- 6 J )

' (**h On h w h. A - % .1 L:,k r:- . ud A nre r 3 ( < .h  :<

b 8 ). Th ~. kWs he , b ,- ubul <Iedb ,l.v e rh,. .

ca. .

u..,., w u x w a<n,. - ., ,

%R b\ '.0L , uk . , %d A , A . f. u. & 3. m..,,

- ,,+ .mbi , :<, :.,. 4 h s

c-. s ^<-

, 3

.N, bDes .b .'. i s..% M are cer2s] 'Tk . s .'s sf US. Msm .k ,. %N

. afL t e.ve q , .

.av.se N h e- .

S- tv. 7,e,x & thl L/4h %.1 :.t+ K , -..t3 . 4e, ru_.,

I M.r 4.,)it< t-

,4! t- eb

%. . . a. . ,

k4 m ###* r_r. .A Uf *O*.k

, o a

' f*q h * *# Ye9 ,,v $ /N A _ *

.s'~ e,.d,s \ l,'- s tS afw- .\ s.~11 %.S. a- L. < tr .

fr ,% k <*

% J: fL.e-J JA st, J .>

.i x ~ P. L sr k , 8 6. _ ,- b . ,+ ,,a... D ' , , li f I. .

Cw b tob A.-% d 4L.'r ?A, u $.sIe, 'b e p-l.ds% w l.a eJ - h.. u h<s~ I

  • s ~M k . > 1.2 % .x Lu 9

%h % ,,%t) >> 1 Its.,e ..., _ %.I e.% J41, ,- G,r u 11 hr- V a <e. -

l Cut: Ds -.

kom A, tw tun.t- J h% 4 < V- - -,

I ES3- b ,e & <3 w . J b. l.-Ij s-<4_., . .,,.4,. ~ b4 ,*1f Ar (A . ., < . . ,i .. n 4%

(
s w.

,,,dt, u 'N L., ,..mf ".'J M-u-G ..a'. s'M %.., .' A .,-. ?. a.,e .,s .

r .

Ced s T an :n.,<,'

f ,

7h, 143 1 - v e, , _ _

Aus%9tng

.N 3$ II= <4 , f.e, I - p u uf A. ~ ken

  • kh '* l'w % e ,t e .I & % Jri ,.J . b w A-. ,a as.s re.4

. kw % V- . . . >. r M N* s "W. I. *\

l . cs tL. 4 tl v1.* se ,.&:,,

Ok, .) '. Utv (>9.s g r a uf \, s.f . * - n  ;. r An n.31%) -H r olf t s L ,w V a 4 e .. . ,4, *:d %W

. n..u; s. is.<  :. .. ,0 pr .Mr -. . AlRE tw . ,+- t A :< a st., s. - -

< ,..1I s[ bre.v, ~, .u:t- ~ t><.A A . -

i Ca k N-t 6 xt,) 6 ty.ct s t- ,,A.e , ,y,,

,,... dh  % k p.,s - 'fav i n ,A ,.. : H . . .

,dv 3r.akM. , Ac t L. c ,, s 4. i.e vu.0 6.W -t

  • MI. -4 . h A'. - .e+.

6.hb'. Ts 4.,e -1b . s.,4 f, ,,,,et- v3I is , :. .* < . ,d daf..L L'rh.

' b, 6. 'f. l. 'G Aer'E----

b b '* M ),vt Iarl 'b 'a Mi< /5- ?< re . , . ..h f Cr. /b *. J 4 . et.. -M 3. - K- 60'io .to., ,W, . b .3 in e **. 4 -t - Ni'C- Iv b + l' -<' i~ .

h4 _. w. bwi % 6. _ , ...s . t . . t, '

,