ML082350067
| ML082350067 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 08/08/2008 |
| From: | Shapiro S, Wagner S Public Health & Sustainable Energy (PHASE), Rockland County Conservation Association, Sierra Club, Atlantic Chapter, State of NY, State Assembly, Westchester Citizens Awarenesss Network (WestCAN), Westchester County, NY |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-247-LR, 50-286-LR, ASLB 07-858-03-LR-BD01, RAS E-136 | |
| Download: ML082350067 (61) | |
Text
DOCKETED USNRC UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION August 11, 2008 (8:30am)
ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND Before Administrative Judges: ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Lawrence G. McDade, Chairman Dr. Kaye D. Lathrop Dr. Richard E. Wardwell
) NOTICE OFAPPEAL In the Matter of )
) Docket Nos.
ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC ) 50-247 and 59-286 LR
)
) ASLB No. 07-858-03 (Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 2 and 3) ) LR-BD01 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT upon the accompanying support Memorandum of Law, Petitioners New York State Assemblyman Richard L. Brodsky, for the 9T"District, Westchester County of the State of New York, Westchester Citizens Awareness Network, Sierra Club Atlantic Chapter, the Rockland County Conservation Association, and Public Health and Sustainable Energy move the Nuclear Regulatory Commission for review of the Order of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Order dated July 31, 2008 in the above referenced matter denying Petitioners' Petition to Intervene and Request for a Hearing for an Order to remand the proceeding to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board for review of the Petition on the merits and to strike any reference by the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board to impute Petitioners' attorney's integrity.
Dated: August 8,2008 Resectfully Subme SpmigVaflqy, New Yok 21 Pernman Drive Spring Valley, N.Y. 10977-5,281 TC, Jk,7z',` JEC1 2 0c3
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative Judges:
Lawrence G. McDade, Chairman Dr. Kaye D. Lathrop Dr. Richard E. Wardwell
) MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF
) PETITIONERS' APPEAL TO THE In the Matter of ) COMMISSION
)
) Docket Nos.
ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC ) 50-247 and 59-286 LR
)
) ASLB No. 07-858-03 (Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 2 and 3)) LR-BD01 PRELIMINARY STATEMENT Petitioners Westchester Citizen's Awareness Network (WestCAN), Rockland County Conservation Association, Inc. (RCCA), Public Health and Sustainable Energy (PHASE), Sierra Club - Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Club), and New York State Assemblyman Richard L. Brodsky (hereinafter "Petitioners") hereby appeal an Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (hereinafter "ASLB" or "Board") Order issued on July 31, 2008 denying Petitioners' "Petition For Leave To Intervene With Contentions And, Request For Hearing" (hereinafter "Petition") because The complete removal of Petitioners from the proceeding, even if all the ASLB's unsubstantiated accusations about intent are true, is disproportionate, unfair, an unwarranted violation of due process and an abuse of discretion.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY On April 23, 2007, and supplemented on May 3, 2007 and June 21, 2007, Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. (hereinafter "Entergy" or "licensee") filed an application to renew its operating license for an additional twenty year period for Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units.
On December 10, 2007, Petitioners electronically served a Petition for Leave to Intervene with Contentions and a Request for a Hearing.
,.", 1, .-.. 1 By Order dated November 27, 2007, Entergy and the NRC staff filed Answers to the Petition on January 22, 2008. The NRC Staff served its Answer multiple times by email and mailed a copy. Entergy served an Answer to the Petition electronically, without the referenced exhibits. Entergy mailed its exhibits, without a table of contents, which was received on January 28, 2008.
On Friday, February 15, 2008, Petitioners perfected service by mailing hard copies of their Reply Brief through DHL to the NRC Office of the Secretary, Entergy's counsel, and the NRC Staff Attorney Sherwin Turk. Petitioners, then sent courtesy copies electronically submitted their Reply Brief at approximately 12:53 a.m. on February 16, 2008 to numerous parties and CD-ROMs all the parties on February 20, 2008. Petitioners' served a revised Certificate of Service dated March 6, 2008 for service of the Reply Brief. Attached hereto and made a part hereof as Attachment 4.
On February 22, 2008, Entergy electronically served a Motion to Strike Petitioners Reply Brief. The NRC Staff, without prior notice, served an Answer to Entergy's Motion to Strike on March 3, 2008, supplemented on March 6, 2008. In three ASLB Orders dated March 7, 2008, March 24, 2008 and April 1, 2008 revised on April 2, 2008, Petitioners were ordered to demonstrate proper service of their Reply Brief. Petitioners filed a response to the March 7 th Order on March 21, 2008.1 Petitioners responded to the March 24th Order on March 25, 2008.
Petitioners responded to the April 1Vt and 2 nd Orders on April 7, 2008. On April 7, 2008 parties submitted responses concerning Petitioners' March 21, 2008 electronic submission. On June 16, 2008 the ASLB notified parties that it was granting itself an extension to rule on the admissibility of submitted contentions. On July 31, 2008, the ASLB stuck Petitioners' Petition.
'The same response was sent to the NRC again on Monday, March 24, 2008 because the electronic submission was undeliverable to NRC email addresses.
2
Petitioners seek reversal of the Board's July 31, 2008 Order reinstating the Petition for consideration of the admissibility of the contentions on the merits and striking any attempt imputing Petitioners' attorney credibility and candor.
ARGUMENT Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.341(b)(1) the Commission has the authority to review any final Board decision. If there is a clear procedural error, the Commission may also review the Board's decision. 10 C.F.R. §2.341(b)(4); see also, Entergy Nuclear Operations,Inc. (Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units Nos. 2 and 3), CLI-07-28, 66 NRC 275 (2007); Consolidated Edison Co. of New York (IndianPoint, Unit 2), CLI-82-5, 16 NRC 27, 37 (1982).
Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.311 the Commission has the authority to review the Board denials of the Petition to Intervene and Request for a Hearing. Specifically, § 2.311(a) "An order of the presiding officer... may be appealed to the Commission with respect to: (1)a request for hearing; (2) a petition to intervene..." Under § 2.311 (c) "[a]n order denying a petition to intervene ... is appealable by the requestor/petitioner on the question as to whether the request and/or petition should have been granted. "Despite the substantial deference accorded presiding officers' procedural decision, such decisions are reviewable on appeal for abuse of discretion";
see Int'l Uranium (USA) Corp., CLI-02-13, 55 NRC 269 (2002).
Petitioners' actions were not the basis for dismissal of the entire petition, they were not, in fact lacking in candor and misleading. Whatever defects exist in Petitioners' Reply Brief, they were not the result of duplicity or other behaviors which the ASLB finds morally repugnant.
Accepting, arguendo, the ASLB's description of events, there is no evidentiary basis for a finding of unacceptable behavior. The heart of the ASLB's reasoning is an assertion about Petitioners intentions, made by adopting a set of unfavorable and insulting assumptions about 3
,-I_. - I Petitioners personal intentions. Certainly, any such allegation by the ASLB should be subject to some adversarial proceeding where the due process rights of Petitioners can be exercised.
Notably in other cases when the ASLB had made a "death-penalty" ruling, the objective insulting and disruptive behavior of those Petitioners were a matter of public record, something that clearly doesn't appear here. The exchange of emails alone should indicate that Petitioners sought to clarify and remedy any actual or perceived inadequacies in the Reply Brief, in a manner characterized by speed, responsiveness, and politeness.
The complete removal of Petitioners from the proceeding, even if all the ASLB's unsubstantiated accusations are true, is disproportionate, unfair, a violation of due process and unwarranted. The ASLB makes no complaint about the service, content, or tone of Petitioners original Petition, which contain the Contentions Petitioners seek to litigate. It is "patently unfair for presiding officer(s) to reject the filing in its entirety" see Int'l Uranium (USA) Corp., CLI 13, 55 NRC 269 (2002). A proportionate remedy would be to have rejected the Reply Brief about which the ASLB has complaints, and judge the sufficiency of the Contentions based on the remaining Record. The governing ASLB order says that invalidly submitted documents will be struck. To go beyond that is a violation of the governing Order, the rules of the Commission, and is an abuse of discretion.
I. THE PETITION AND REPLY BRIEF SHOULD NOT BE STRUCK BECAUSE OF ANY MINOR ERROR IN THE CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.
The July 31, 2008 ASLB Order struck the Petition alleging that Petitioners "lack of candor and integrity by WestCAN [Petitioners] demonstrated by submitting false and misleading information in response to the Board's three orders which attempted unsuccessfully to get a clear, honest explanation of how WestCAN's February 15th Reply was served" was grounds for dismissal of the Petition. ASLB Order dated July 31, 2008 at p. 12.
4
Petitioners maintain that service was properly made and any errors were inadvertent, minor, and similar to errors on the Certificate of Service by the ASLB. Even if the ASLB allegation were true it does not warrant striking the Petition. Petitioners have been proper and acted with courtesy, responding to every motion, request, etc. as quickly as possible only to be treat unequally with the other intervenors. 10 C.F.R. § 2.314.
Petitioners have consistently maintained that their Reply Brief was properly served and have not submitted intentionally false information or misrepresented the truth. Petitioners have repeatedly answered the ASLB and provided tracking documents to demonstrate proper service.
Under § 2.302(a)2 documents must be filed with the Commission either by: (1) First class mail addressed (2) Courier, express mail, and expedited delivery services; (3) E-mail; (4) By facsimile transmission. Filing by mail, electronic mail, or facsimile is considered complete as of the time of deposit in the mail or upon electric mail or facsimile transmission. § 2.302(c). All documents offered for filing must be accompanied by proof of service on all parties to the proceeding or their attorney's of record as required by law or by rule or order of the Commission. § 2.302(b).
Additionally the ASLB in this proceeding addressed the issue of service in its Order. On October 29, 2007 the ASLB stated that service must be made on the Commission, attorney of record, and that amended pleadings must be clearly labeled and dated. Then on November 27, 2007 the ASLB again stated that amended pleadings must be clearly labeled and dated. On February 1, 2008, the ASLB imposed further service requirements on the parties. The February 2 The rules of service that apply are 10 C.F.R. PART 2 Rules of Practice For Domestic Licensing Proceedings and Issuance of Orders in affect as of August 1, 2007, as articulated under the revised 10 CFR Part 2 Rules of Practice became effective on August 28, 2007, begins with the following note: "Electronic filing and service of documents in proceedings for which notices of opportunity for hearing were published in the Federal Register or on the NRC website before October 15, 2007, are governed by the Part 2 rules in effect prior to the NRC E-Filing Rule (72 Fed.
Reg. 49139 (Aug. 28, 2007)). Therefore, Petitioners citations are to the Part 2 in effect in 2007 and not the current Part 2 rules currently in effect that have been amended.
5
,*~% ",J 1, 2008 ASLB Order, at page 3, point 1, required that: In general, documents may be served on the Board and the parties in hard copy, on CD-ROM or as files attached to e-mail messages."
(emphasis added).
As required by 10 C.F.R. Part 2 and the ASLB Orders, Petitioners perfected filing of their Reply Brief on the ASLB, by serving the SECY, and by serving hard copies on the licensee and NRC Staff. Within 2 business days of original filing Petitioners sent courtesy CD-ROM copies of the Reply Brief by overnight delivery, to the mailing address for all parties and those individuals listed on the Certificate of Service dated March 6, 2008.
Petitioners repeatedly stated and maintain that the Reply Brief was properly served on the required parties by depositing the Reply Brief in a DHL box on February 15, 2008, admittedly near midnight. As required the Reply Brief was mailed to the NRC Office of the Secretary, the licensee's attorneys, and a NRC Staff Attorney, which were received the next business day.
Attached hereto and made a part hereof see Attachment 1, tracking documents from DHL.
Petitioners made a good faith effort to email the Reply Brief to all parties 3 at approximately 11:30 pm on February 15, 2008.4 Due to computer difficulties, Petitioners were not able to email the Reply brief until approximately 12:53 a.m. on February 16, 2008.
Petitioners' reply brief sent by email was identical to the reply brief mailed in hard copy and the 3 On the morning of 15'b day of February 2008, Petitioners were made informed by NRC Staff that the NRC was unable to receive documents over 10 megabits. (See Petitioners March 21, 2008 Response to the ASLB Order of March 7, 2008, Exhibit I, Email from Sherwin Turk, Esq. on February 15, 2008). Based on this information, a copy of Petitioners' reply brief of February 15, 2008 was not emailed the NRC Staff Counsel's office.
4 Petitioners did send an email at approximately 12:01 a.m. on the 16 d' day of February to some parties. email sent at approximately 12:00 a.m. on February 16, 2008 sent to: set@nrc.gov, Hearing.Docket@nrc.gov, and Sherwin.Turk@nrc.gov. There was no text in the email and no cover letter. The emails subject was "Att." A Microsoft WORD version, entitled "WestCANReply_BriefFinal_2.15.08..doc, was attached to the 12:00 a.m.
email.
The cover letter attached to the CD-ROM's on February 19, 2008 informed parties that the WORD document was not Petitioners' reply brief. The letter stated that "We transmittedthe document as a word file, but are concerned it may be corrupted, if it arrived at all... Therefore please delete the first transmittal, the "word document", and consider the Adobe PDF file the Reply." (Petitioners' March 21, 2008 Response to the ASLB 6
reply brief contained on the CD-ROM's. A copy of the Reply Brief in adobe was sent by email to several parties and numerous NRC staff, as a courtesy although not required.
Two (2) days are added to the prescribed period when a document is served by express mail or expedited delivery service that is not a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday. 10 C.F.R. § 2.306. Accordingly, Petitioners then mailed by FedEx overnight delivery CD-ROM's with the Reply Brief and exhibits to the Office of the Secretary, ASLB members, an NRC law clerk, and other parties. Attached hereto and made a part hereof see Attachment 2, tracking documents from FedEx.
The Reply Brief sent to the Chairman Lawrence McDade was received on February 21, 2008 at 9:45 a.m. and signed for by J. Hillard. See Attachment 2. No signature was required, according to FedEx, for the package sent to ASLB member Dr. Kaye Lathrop, but tracking documents from FedEx state that the package was delivered on February 21, 2008 at 2:41 p.m.
See Attachment 2. "Under (NRC) rules it is the "service copy" that counts for the purpose of calculating deadlines." see Int'l Uranium (USA) Corp., CLI-02-13, 55 NRC 269 (2002). gffhe Certificate of Service dated March 6, 2008 (hereinafter "COS March 6, 2008"), admittedly the third sent by Petitioners, states who the Reply Brief was sent to whether by DHL, email, or FedEx. Attached hereto and made a part hereof as Attachment 4.
The ASLB mistakenly concludes that the COS of March 6, 2008 was a misrepresentation and/or false submission of information. The ASLB incorrectly states that the ASLB board and Wardwell did not receive the Reply Brief. Petitioners sent one package addressed to ASLB Chairman Lawrence McDade with envelopes individually addressed to Dr. Richard Wardwell and the NRC law clerk included inside the package, since the addresses for these individuals are Order of March 7, 2008, Exhibit D). The differences between the word version and adobe were inconsequential.
The adobe version re-lettered Exhibits and included one additional paragraph.
7
the same. Each envelope contained a CD-ROM with the Reply Brief. This is evidenced by the fact that the weight of that package to Chairman McDade is twice that of the packages sent to the Office of the Secretary and Dr. Kaye Lathrop. Attachment 2. The FedEx was received and signed for by J. Hillard on February 21, 2008. Attachment 2. What happened to the FedEx containing the Reply Brief is not known by Petitioners, but it was delivered to the NRC.
Moreover, the COS March 6, 2008 was submitted by email prior to any ASLB Order questioning service. Attached hereto and made a part hereof see Attachment 3, email from Sarah Wagner, Esq. to parties sent at 1:48 pm on March 7, 2008 and email from Maria Carpentier to parties sent at 2:45 pm on March 7, 2008.
Upon close examination in preparation for this appeal, Petitioners concede that their last COS submitted on March 7, 2008 contained an error. Although the COS of March 7th states that the CD's were mailed on the 15t' of February, 2008 by DHL 5, Petitioners provided the ASLB copies of receipts from FedEx dated February 2 0 th. Petitioners' have repeatedly stated in their responses to the ASLB that the CD-ROM's were sent on February 20, 2008. Petitioners were forthcoming with the FedEx receipts that were dated February 20, 2008.
Therefore, Petitioners have demonstrated that their Reply Brief was properly and timely filed and any reference to Petitioners lack of candor or integrity should be struck from the record.
II. EVEN IF THE ASLB'S ACCUSATIONS ARE TRUE, THE REMEDY IS NOT TO STRIKE THE PETITION.
5 This error is no different than omissions in the COS's attached to ASLB Orders and other errors made by the ASLB. The ASLB's COS's are inaccurate because they fail to state that Orders were emailed to the parties and does not contain email addresses that the Order was sent to. The ASLB mistakenly stated in its July 31, 2008 Order that Petitioners' Reply Brief was due on or before February 1, 2008. The Reply Brief was initially actually due February 8, 2008, but Petitioners were granted a seven day extension to file on or before February 15, 2008. In the ASLB Order dated March 7, 2008, in which the ASLB Scheduled Petitioners' oral argument for April 1, 2008 in Maryland, the ASLB stated that "Susan Wagner, Esq." was available for argument on March 13, 2008. There is no attorney of record for Petitioners named Susan Wagner. Hence the ASLB is not immune from errors.
8
Under 10 C.F.R. § 2.319 it is the Board's responsibility to "conduct a fair and impartial hearing according to law, to take appropriate action to control the prehearing and hearing process, and to maintain order." The Board exceeded its responsibility by dismissing the Petition. The ASLB never questioned the service, content, or tone of Petitioners original Petition, which contain the Contentions Petitioners seek to litigate. It is complete and sufficient of itself to be part of the re-license litigation. If the ASLB accusations are true, and Petitioners maintain they are false, the remedy would be to have struck the Reply Brief and judge the sufficiency of the Contentions based on the remaining Petition and its exhibits. The ASLB's prior Orders state that invalidly submitted documents will be struck. To go beyond that is a violation of the governing Order, the rules of the NRC, and the law governing these proceedings, and an abuse of discretion.
By striking the Petitioners Petition the NRC has unfairly and unjustly barred consideration of many significant issues on the merits and forestalled public 6
participation.
III. PETITIONERS HAVE RAISED SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES WITH MERIT THAT.
THE ASLB IGNORED. THE PETITION TO INTERVENE STANDS ON ITS OWN AND MEET NRC CRITERIA FOR ADMISSIBLE CONTENTIONS.
Under section 2.309(f) Petitioners have set forth with particularity the contentions sought to be raised and satisfy the six criteria under section 2.309(f). The NRC cannot deny a petition to intervene and request for a hearing if Petitioners demonstrate at least one admissible contention.
6 The ASLB's prejudicial treatment of the Petitioners is clearly disproportionate. The board cancelled Petitioner's oral arguments on admissibility, after they had been scheduled and allowed all other Petitioner's oral arguments. The ASLB refused to reasonably acknowledge Petitioner's good faith efforts including courtesy copies, CD-ROM's and failed to acknowledge the NRC's electronic limited capacities as confirmed by members of NRC staff on February 15, 2008. Petitioners responded to any and all questions and Orders by the board and by parties.
Then the ASLB ignored Petitioners request in late March to take notice of exhibits publicly available.
9
In the Staff's Response they acknowledged that Petitioners have raised at least one contention within scope regarding the omission in the LRA by the Licensee refurbishment of the reactor vessel heads. Further the ASLB has accepted at least nine contentions by other Petitioners for hearing that are similar to those asserted by Petitioner, thereby denying Petitioners right to due process and a hearing.
The ASLB's prejudicial refusal to consider Petitioners' Petition which raises at least twelve unique contentions, all of which meet the requirements of 2.309(f), violates the governing Order, the rules of the Commission and the laws governing these proceedings and fails to provide reasonable assurance of adequate protection of the public. It is a blatant abuse of discretion to bar Petitioners who have raised at least nine similar Contentions accepted for hearing by the ASLB, to be prevented from participating in a hearing on the merits based on a minor, inadvertent error on a Certificate of Service of a Reply.
CONCLUSION Based on the foregoing, Petitioners respectfully request that: (1) the July 31, 2008 ASLB Order striking Petitioners Petition should be reversed; (2) an Order that the Petition and Reply have been properly served and that the ASLB should consider the merits of the contentions raised by the Petitioners; and (3) any reference to Petitioners lack of candor or integrity should be struck from the record.
Respectfully submitted, SarCoh L. Wafor etCe. Susan f sC )Pi t.
Co-counsel for Petitioner VsCNet. al Co-couns, Vofr Petitiong"estCAN et. al 10
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
)
ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC.) Docket Nos. 50-247/286-LR
) ASLBP No. 07-853-03-LR-BDO1 (Indian Point Nuclear Generating) )
Units 2 and 3) )
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Petitioners' WestCAN et. al Appeal of the ASLB Order dated July 31, 2008, has been served upon the following by electronically as shown to the email address below, this 8th day of August, 2008. Hard copies have only been sent to the Office of the Secretary, as required by the February 1, 2008 ASLB Order, the licensee's attorney's, and NRC Staff Attorney Sherwin Turk.
Lawrence G. McDade, Chair Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Mail Stop: O-16G4 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Email: OCAAMAILknrc.gov E-mail: LGM1 @nrc.gov Dr. Richard E. Wardwell Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Mail Stop: O-16G4 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 E-mail: REWknrc.gov Email: HEARINGDOCKETgnrc.gov Dr. Kaye D. Lathrop Zachary S. Kahn, Law Clerk Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel 190 Cedar Lane E. Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Ridgeway, CO 81432 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: KDL2@nrc.gov Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Email: ZXK1 @nrc.gov Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 11
Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 William C. Dennis, Esq. Manna Jo Greene Assistant General Counsel Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Inc.
Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. 112 Little Market Street 440 Hamilton Avenue Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 White Plains, NY 10601 Email: Mannaiogclearwater.org Email: wdenniskentergy.com Kathryn M. Sutton, Esq. Justin D. Pruyne, Esq.
Paul M. Bessette, Esq. Assistant County Attorney Martin J. O'Neill, Esq. Office of the Westchester County Attorney Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP 148 Martine Avenue, 6 th Floor 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW White Plains, NY 10601 Washington, D.C. 20004 E-mail: j dp3 @westchestergov.com E-mail: ksuttonkmorganlewis.com E-mail: pbessettegmorganlewis.com Daniel E. O'Neill, Mayor E-mail: martin.o'neill@morganlewis.com James Seirmarco, M.S.
Village of Buchanan Michael J. Delaney, Esq. Municipal Building Vice President - Energy Department Buchanan, NY 10511-1298 New York City Economic Development E-mail: vobgbestweb.net Corporation (NYCDEC) 110 William Street John J. Sipos, Esq.
New York, NY 10038 Charlie Donaldson, Esq.
E-mail: mdelaneyknycedc.com Assistants Attorney General New York State Department of Law John LeKay Environmental Protection Bureau FUSE USA The Capitol 351 Dyckman Street Albany, NY 12224 Peekskill, NY 10566 E-mail: John.siposkoag.state.ny.us E-mail: fuseusa@yahoo.com Arthur J. Kremer, Chairman Joan Leary Matthews, Esq.
New York Affordable Reliable Electricity Senior Attorney for Special Projects Alliance (AREA) New York State Department of 347 Fifth Avenue, Suite 508 Environmental Conservation New York, NY 10016 Office of the General Counsel E-mail: aikremergrrmfp.com 625 Broadway, 14 th Floor kremerna-area-alliance.org
........ *zZt ...............
Albany, NY 12233-1500 E-mail: j1mattheggjw.dec.state.ny.us 12
Diane Curran, Esq.
Hannon, Curran, Spielberg & Eisenberg, LLP 1726 M Street, NW, Suite 600 Washington, D.C. 20036 E-mail: dctirranaharmoncurran.com Robert Snook, Esq. Victor Tafur, Esq.
Office of the Attorney General Phillip Musegaas, Esq.
State of Connecticut Riverkeeper, Inc.
55 Elm Street 828 South Broadway P.O. Box 120 Tarrytown, NY 10591 Hartford, CT 06141-0120 E-mail: phillipgriverkeeper.org E-mail: robert.snook(po.state.ct.us vtafurgriverkeeper.org Daniel Riesel, Esq.
Thomas F. Wood, Esq.
Ms. Jessica Steinberg, J.D.
Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C.
460 Park Avenue New York, NY 10022 E-mail: drieselgsprlaw.com Elise N. Zoli, Esq.
jsteinbergksprlaw.com Goodwin Procter, LLP Exchange Place Ms. Nancy Burton 53 State Street 147 Cross Highway Boston, MA 02109 Redding Ridge, CT 06876 E-mail: ezoliggoodwinprocter.com E-mail: nancyburtonct(2aol.com Janice A. Dean, Esq.
Counsel for NRC Staff Assistant Attorney General U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of the Attorney General Office of the General Counsel 120 Broadway, 26th Floor Washington, D.C. 20555 New York, NY 10271 E-mail: Sherwin.turk(2nrc.gov E-mail: ianice.deanC&,oaR,.state.nv.us Marcia. Simongnrc. gov Beth.Mizunognrc.gov David.Roth@nrc.gov Jessica.Bieleckignrc. gov Office of the Secretary* Mylan L. Denerstein U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Executive Deputy Attorney General Sixteenth Floor Office of the N.Y. Attorney General One Flint North 120 Broadway, 2 5 th floor 11555 Rockville Pike New York, New York 10271 Rockville, Maryland 20852 E-mail: Mylan.Denersteingoag.state.ny.us 13
John Louis Parker, Esq. Marcia Carpentier, Law Clerk Regional Attorney ASLB Office of General Counsel, Region 3 Mail Stop: T-3 E2B NYS Dep't of Envt'l Conservation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Com.
21 S. Putt Comers Road Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 New Paltz, New York 12561-1620 Marcia.Carpentier(dnrc. gov jlparker~gov.dec.state.ny.us
- Original and two copies 14
TAABLE OF: CONT ENi. S Atftachment 1 Dl tacking documents.
Attachhment 2- Feý (,x tracking documentO. -- Email from Sarah-Wagner,-Esq. to parties with a revis;edcrtific..e Service and Email from Crpntier to parties.
r*aria of - Petitioners' Second Rcvised Certificate of:SerVic-e.
L/i iL. r- i flL~cit: IIV y'I ýj I(IdU[
LUI~~
Can Ut I Delivery Signature Detail Signature details 'or 61491770841 Summary details Cu,-r"*Ft 5[01J5 V* Shlptywrt Chhlfw~roqý O.IVre~ .' V ~ 544 wr-'
C-lv.'o !c Shc ; ',.
S,9le, for C"Y R PEARBON Receiver Information SHFR'*N TLRKK Tr.*l, Wil PIuVicfed t, OF L. 0,,'201e 7 1.,5WAM
,IAj You Brre,*o,,'ged to use !'"41 v5ICKI(g sstogmu coier, ,o ra*.*. i*P.I*r -n"e tan r n)j ,, cr y(u to OHL A.'ly OMe' uss Df D41. rt-dmng xyst',.. a J Ifrni1ajojrn s&slr cty p'ufltbwj
- ~ wgwill o v U{ J9Fr;
- '*/* 7 '" q" 0 , 4, f*- $15,_ VQ*f.' ,,
A.9
[ " l p ' *v ..
. "'* r
/
-co.
2 Q OUUStfl ~TO 00
'it a.." -.
T , ..
N-.
- - -~---~. - &,,ta~r *F' 4/ Z[2006"
L)iL' Pr~rt e ýV eiv 31~ .2 Delivery Signature Detail signature details; for 53769121442 Sumrrary details 4itrdon /3 S~~w1 bA JONES Receiver lfnorma;t;on K fiUrT'ON'P F£.SSET7E.
yva~ir.gu". DC 20XA4 Uniw4 SLwO6 You am~ a~ifwoli&d tc U" Dl. notng stysarn$ qojiytoI t~c shp-trts temadettzi Ciyc, (,r yo~j to CH1LAry ocner
,io c~fDili. tro irj; sys~tems ;rw irsmnaifTji, is 4!rf1~y pr~h;LtoA
%LL - I _#- - '-'
- W.W I I -I.
oz,-
Lit L. III.ILi kJ1V7. I .'It~Ici u ulet' Page 1ot Delivery Sigrature Detail in!hqpg Signature detains for 53769120941
$urmyto vhicoon OUiuk Ecctp r P-sNnlTIEM Summary detai~s Cuw rnVD V' Sh4lmint Deflvered R P~EARSON Receive~r Inforrnat on OFFICE OF; RES SECHý VA 1
'UAdtvd StUdre Trtuking "talAlpfoieW by tFI-L 4,*7?2UtU8 5 19:37 AM Y0or avMo-zl to$-[HL tracko'g syv1Wms sooy ýotacK snprm1% 'NISI t y Oft')' YL 0~ Drit Ar'y other yr3r.
uvv cl OD1Ltvpdkirr systsmi x! in'tlofw.Brri SstrCtly rc4,ivt~d 11 W~y ~1N4 F~~O~~9 ~ 954!
Rtrý~
7 , r r ~w 'oc A-~
S~~yD01-y - 'Ma 3 I -
vi / ~ ~L S ~
w.4 -~-
-,- i, 3XV
Pa9g i of i Delivery Sigrature Detail PnnI ?tm$Pak Signature detasils for 53769120546 pjtUIMt 'i JN CO()UC ER EX~CEPTSIý Summary detaiid 2ZiS/ll 9A440'r Deltrfd '
X PEARSON Receiver Informati:)n krw,4 MD "M~
Trsalrg If(i jucivi~fd by )H1.,4i'-70019 ? 09:C.4 AM, Yworog su!!i2r1Id to it OL -ackig If'freernn aOi~y %) tv N1e~~ ýy ,7pv~ you W,UhL. Any' OV utm oI OHL trackIfg syWtmm an, i forrnaljni;rimsWt~y ~~~
p, - -
~1~I4M M. I
_ b ~ I r-' -
'W WIT '`F I r/'7o.Ag pw -w j.) ~ w 4m Yý4j*KWAI t- liwA j %r
- f-4 "4 7!7zoo8 httP: ý/-igpod.chjLUSz. ccm inprintyi~sg .3sp
LAI1L. rIJIL L*IYI ~ f'~ t4dLure uewii p.age 1 of I Delivery Siqrature Detail ý P-M t,)$ IAge Signature deta~s for 53769120845 RF~rr,1-D 04 GAOOD YWVEXCEPT A.w 6 Summary details 2!19;8 W4A De~~wm-c)n S~hipprig Dw-r~
si(wid to, 'y R PEARS0.4 Receiver Informat on QFIQZ OF ThE SECRE-At~r 4JryvIWStAL0 266 Tracxcr~g oei&I pm,.Ar,~c D-Y:3 L 47.200e 7 ý17N>Am Yo re Pijnunr'u t1o ý)*e CHL "ýin syntmms so"er W 0racx~sheVtncl lodrK~r byj, tor yu~ to QHL. Ar'v fth'er j~o of DHL :rna'fý systomý m;d vlo~otion s ztlrUy jrini6Lju
+
I7t' . 10-' . 1 20
-A~
1 4.~~- WM II-.
___Pic,
- -W..V~) -
A~~ 73 -t;
.u .. dN$4o Kri
.- ~ rI=
~~i~aCN C-S~kZO_ -
008
U S"MNtii: PO Bbx'727,.
Cusl&-fier' Suoparl Trace Mernphis, TN 34l194-4643 dExpres 3875 Airways.Boulevbrd MA'ýAdtiIK. 41h Flom- Telepnoine' 9O 69-3600 Nlniphi5. TN 38116, August. 6,2008 Attachment.2 Debr Customer:
The following is the procf-of-delivery.for tracking Un6be r 860847428571.,
DeliVery Information:
Status: Delivered Delivery date: Feb 21, 2008 09:45 Signo for by; JiHILLARD-Service %ype Prirt vrih
.Shipping Information:
Tracking number: 860847428571 Ship date: Feb
.20, 2008:
Recipient: Shippe . N, WASHINGTON, DC US NEW rHAVEN. CTr us Thank. you for choosing FedEx Express.
FedEx Worldwide Customer Service
" ,i800.GoFodEx!.:800A63. *.339
US, MaW P Box-727-FedEx Express Customer SupportTrace Mre"n:his TN 381901 64360
.3875. Airways Boulevard *1elephcae 91).1-3.69-3800 Exprecs3 Module H, 4th Floor MerDhts, M.N38116:
August 6.2008:
Dear Customer.
The rollowing is the prbof-of delivery for tracking number 8W0847428550,.
Dellvery Information:
Status: Delhvered Delivery'date-. Feb 21 2008 09:45 Signed for:by: J.HILLARD Service type: Priority Overnight Az>
Shipping Information:
Tracking-number 860847428550 Shipý date: Febt20, 2008
-Recipient:. Shipper
'WASHINGTON, DC US. NEW HAVEN..-CT US Thank( you r hoosing. F eEx Ex*prýess FecdEx i.80 OCoedIEx"!,.OQ94&). m.$3 WorldwideCus.ore&-Service
Tc~: 2a33B96~57
ýFFOLX ChINTI CAT
.1353B17Q4
~PR~I72IMt:9. F-roQ Page: I' of 2 Fed Services FedEx Services I eCOSMOS I EDR Imagingi Data Viewer Searching database instance newl for Airbill # 8608474.28550 with a ship date of 02/20/2008 and a range of +1-days.
PACKAGE DETAILS:
Tracking Ship 02/20/2008 No: e60847428550 Date:'
UNICH- WITTE LAWRENCE MCDOLE NORTHEM-LIGHTS ATTOMIC SAFETY AND ENGIS L L C LICENSING B 71 EDALWOOD WAY MAILSTOP T-3 F23 WS Shipper: Recipient: NUCLEAR RE NEW HAVEN, CT WASHINGTONI, DC 06515 0555
________S DEL.__VERYNFRMATION/SPOD Letter:
HILLARD Signed For.By:
Delivered to: "11555ROCKVILLE PIKE Delivey Date: 02/21/2008 Delivery Time: 9:45i I ajirbilf(s) matched your query.
FMI m
X * - - -
I n,,-arn
willil~*tS'~tfl, NI ,,mhr- ýn-- f)ntn rq~tW$LdU,.,
rr- n &nt-tlurjnm r I.'
r ý,,n S-566 75522 M a r03, 2008 ...
FedEx EXDress Shimmen Detai By Pavor lpe (OriunaI seader I F w -1
',, ui" 4 41 NU1 -ifiNM11H I S"L% Jr I .I T % C ŽA-H I Y A4NJ I(FNSIVtN3 P,-'. 'r,IJU 145 Nlk r L '- .TC
.LA; P' 3r kJ C Ri:Ec ,v eig, i U: A,':,.
Sr4"W 'r 2, -. I'fP C* W; '- rk 4 Or
- , C*5M Total Charge uso "S. 71
- ~'.' I
- 1< it' i'~C'~t$
A ~r, 1 : -~ LSAJ A,'.-" 'KRFMkR R
3*". .~ I ý:L' ,:j NCR'HEBN - [SITS Ljllý -iW VANT 'N'1' V., Ar-'J~' R I [FEU
'I [:] r WA', , FlT A7 E S'L SL
'uldi: Cl-I NR1 NAV'[6l5! 5 L' .
7 :~re L Iu 1* I ~*~II~j b 7e 27O* 17 Al S
$1 7 S~ ~.; V CAA'A: K I'ilLr U~* Oc.'2E486E100,s59U0 Total Charge USD D 'I",2<s -- t,+, . ; ,s*11
- Dr. 215 c'.,
- 4 0.1 1'
ftlicB(l Ni";' ILl LIIlArs -\+R'v 2 1
- LLA * 'A . C IN'.
'1 W'F* F',VOF3I ';,'tjv 'I,' -l FMAFIIT V A.
- IJIKtSIk<'I \" '/h': )
LA e Fs:E V), t; N ,' I A; ; fI, . 'i, '
I L l 5 I :t .f ,, '!],
ýedE.x L zt, Total Charol USO S1647 A ' ,'r ' :I', ' A:4 r Tt3,A n.) IC 8f]84742V1' L* TI I ItL\EIC UAVI1L
,+Tr
+,+, .If .
?r 1.,
11Th!I.I Ft+-ITS EN,t5*', MA't+jFi *, .+AM'Sl SIR.iL RQl*F PTC'2~C5 7,++vd +',tr:,' 'ill, x++ I':+ t.,i '" AL
':,E'+P. 'i'A'UJUITIT. ~ .I+" 2 + '.CA T'IIL
'*+ N sN S" O
),, BLZIA+,.
++ t IT
'.'l+i*+ Ji~S.
Fec- x Invoice Number 7-5f66-75522 Invoice Date Mar 03, 2008 Account Number Page~
Tha, (;g 1U-3JbD42871' *-cri'nup Tr -s u r' , A - Clh 4 1*
A:. r 1.1 01 F'1C lU--
VT R Kt!f, F-A ~tu, Total Charge USD 5)6 41
ý dLL2~- U sn~af RIi~L$Lý11LV/AS ONF')7 JPY u RII:t.
ýedi, Puk 'I FD .cjL~l2 ~ W.'uPAPY. A,,"
Mjltrl *j. 4 t
tjUNK V v Iý fialr-d -N~tv Il,.,I'fe i.
1*
I PFr,11l A'.) F ~ie Si--argii Fe; Lsel 2O5207!99VJUbt Toual Charge
- ~v rv 4'vCF.,,s .1j1511r1 I ca'..s 19yp.n-v I ¶ )~T'I I A , .o cA ýl .\tAE M 'lI.¶ - I PM ý
- .'~ I~'AI.7C~
ISA5 RIQwp9EI LLHI--ý'I TT NA% \, P.IRUr' N URvT 1-*'NtS L%i14U9 14.-HL,FS I.~
7,iU L,;kjri v Vav PLIjINCI 21 Il jS' S~rW. l.--.k ,
11 ýý'A NF' t I :, h~I
$141 A,
,,,, _--w AA, F.ll S~-ýac USD 14146 I hird Party Sublotal USO S111.39 USU S111.39 FedEx Express o1al FudE~
IIota! Express USO S111.39
Fed~xtý bl~res~s' U!S:AI;ifP.0)lbx7'27 CusOWM~r Suppcln.Tiac6 MNrIOODhis. TN 381091IA513ý 3875 AiiviaV3 Bdulevaraj MildIAI. H'4111 isoof Expri12S! %iempn'is.TN3V 11h, Augusi: 6.2008
Dear Customer:
The f6olowing is the proolo .de-iVer'fyfO&tracking ntimbor 860847428560.I Delivery Information:.
Status; Delivered Delivery date: Feb 21, 2008 1: 4A s gned for by: 999999999999
.Service type'. P*iority Overnight NO "SIGNAT URE REQUIRF.D r
Proof~of-tde~livery details app Iabelow: howeverl. no'signature is avail*,ble for-this FedEx Express shipment .beCause a signature was nut requie-*J.
Shipping Information:
Tracking number l860847428560 Shiip date':: Feb 20:2008 Recipient- Shipper RIDGWAY, CO US NEW HAVEN: CT US Thank yuu for choosi~g FeL'Ex Expressý Fedx Worldwide Custorme 7Service 1,800;GOFedExZ800,4e3J;339
e fxpr . USAAirbill F"%
8608 4742 8550 Sener' Cop
- sub -1MA f 94 Ouat.
a~fx2D F*Ox iirm Sa.w 5-4 C.6.1 w .Mk
""k -IehNab5 4bF~
fi -rat-.-
A . .
.b** . _ . . .
IJ*,.& _e r ., 9b.¶-lf
.G*wt4d..w SPub~q ak ihh k INS. Mh-T~bw
%wE mw Ban R -
WIFtUo-o "Ooo- I~ Vpkd litA -.
~ [ H~r n4 ThrP"~ Cjuft[." i CA.) St. 1 lip ~ -SU ~a .tM I- WW Amk* w0v~pwo~
150
Fe~x. Express USAibill ." 8608 4?42 8560 -a Sender's Copy
- 4. bu Pombp Smwm I ri-Mi rnF"i Omtw*irV
- W V---.MTll~lnlm I b db ipummFie Iwwwa ,. - , *i~iPi IIdbRW& PV ? rg Chft G sw* Abooe-m. I i ITO
%Iogtiwf I-. *.* t***.,*,
K.___
~~UY!L~ 1~ A I aaF Cwp Amx iM Focgw c fl 7 Pa~S m _
Ad (L) ToW P WWI D vamCTOEMC-vamn we
'r&/ .1 I NEW OnusdWofaI DeIl"u S45ut. Op~Om .
I Iftsqmd Ct~~U
.. ~..
'..n in - **~***i*. - 15201
- ~Vw.,tf)4IW4- $r.MflO~ USAiffi
cx. xpe USAirbill ?
8608 4742 8571 Sedo'sCp 4, b.Pat,. Sihi Amimmso d r ,- p,,.m- .... __ *1 mo iftduihm I*
Fn m .wllu**I, Al / 4ý& kf' - ft, b *-,.
Ad& j/ k' -_ s,6 / ce FIft .Wr.he.d flax 00'a 3 I~p Ile ""my llllm 6 SpWcW N'dm ~ &-.
I
%w e* e4l's NaTva.0 s hr NOT fegwt-V'
/Ablmth Dm am 164ý &"OWN" ko v Amval Dff 7t~ P a. M Ci a~ CAOV~
ZW -
... *...' w'
ýf- - b41 ~ v~t ~ m~ a h-apz~~1
~~~Sl I iN Rsjdgda IIDt "I Sipe" Oplw
-ý NOS0041 ogle arsot
. .I -- .-. -,...,,- -- 520 li l ,lll 'af -'i l ul . IWk 'W
- ,Ux ibim 8608 4742 8608 48 bWmm tuAmr,S Ib F*f2m Sa FFrea Sa
- - . h.. ...
. . .. ........... ......... _w.Ab
__l Te 6 l ZIPi IS,-*
TO ildO IT~
Fef-I
~ 44d EAa ~'j j~w kck U d-V
- Si s Rinilliq l-- l* 1"
,ot,, -,
Lat iUNdnWi. $
- Pd~~~~~~M0 kuldeith fo~s~SpuuruO
- OsijMn.4 L dvi r Ponyehn wt Lr~t d -- ar.
No Il.i1W pWi - 1 .,
! il lill n
FeBEx. US Airbill 8608 4742 8593 Sender's Copy 40,J p blpi un,6 F"oti f lrau Swat,
- _- #sl lj.inw I .w
- . 1 4b bUSSFfvWi~IIS Vt 'Aleph -- .~
rft* Idty.Fre ~ .~
5 Pnkd
- GdEKb I To I* Ai S.1A I 7i-s P- H F~cip 4~ b H/&-* 1Pa %ýVd L Fcpt N ~y Cu1Cp ay~~
I-~ - .. "tL .". fl- -f, -,.. - %al a folpl" W;Y te ýj,, u Ap d"- lmmw iiMft il%%W I NEW h dsulil D i weq i paUw.O l ,,.
-V 0
~c~x.
F-pre.ss US Afrbill 8LO8 4742 8582 Seaef Cop FF~m ftip bllU*
=11=1 =1 ft - Fruiwi a- 'hz4*Atli Uw-P~sw hUh K~ ~rujJ~
~0~~.~
I To Hinmx O6 in L .4.-.'
w ya If S D1
-'!Axcm- D, Ccpw 1 4 ', kts stabi&e., %co , tzU Pan 1M U ~
f.ft !
L- %No,* v
%WON, ',d j t*
JS
- =- =- -- 50]
Fec x. USAirbili LO 4742 8744 8608 Sne's Cop FxDr 4.jmEFaurh suwim
~q ft%. r#0* ,-.m 1dtwxr .u"o%" ýNo Ow
,~- -~
- ., " U71_.....
S5npssm I, - M !Ube um ToA 6J WS.!.aN kq
%coErs L Pvo* I I -
SAnMV. - iWWb Roffset 7 hpu MUK I~ )
kwT4 .~ wi~ UFt. ~~ h~gt ~ tw I NEW %iOWN"l~kdivwy Simprt. m ,
bRqur f
.W.qmwo
-5201 Ph.LU
Fe&. LiS Airbill "8608 4742 8755 Sede' Cop 1xPrens 4a Ervwn,'P"m Smvm
-V I*, d,-.OwuX I-I , ,, Iilit 4Iý' r 6 f,
-:-' .. . . .. . ... saw Mat ~ J~I1/2 s .2rimSw Z~z'S n=.
a /, /I6wi.....
I
,,4el Ž.* 4/ C 4bbp ft $wc Ix T,"b ~
you'Yw'u *t" ZIPc Yowalnh ITo Fwgw / Le)eU Pbone I I f-J-#y-*lo w-a -
410c- P-,,k i"hue_
F"u~OMiow lsPu oCd w d I 8 NEW s**-w*'."
Iý271 L. ~
X. US Airbill 8608 4?42 8733 S e 's op xflTusS A aWlif F
iv m -- '-s - --
f.To eb im Fl ýR w
5.i
%ovtow 4 _
FRO 10 P Nam f'C4 I - -%NNd
- .,- - -- *.* T,.
I F4 d -ab t *1i:.tdE NdUT A,& h..h6U
- 0. ~ ~ ib 1wi ~qrYENd ~ .r~A r~tfk N ()/ 1l*6 44
- 7 P" Ff Y lI P F" InCvi u~
Adi fill_
a h N.'.,-.~t *.L~n L I NEW mdaiID y uIU ia.
I II td,.WW -11 IA ,520 i p / ii t i .1,
Fe* . US Arbill '- 8624 4887 6583 Stdes1p I Frotst..r,..- 4a bpm PmakepInc Soig ft ras.w
%a' /, &* sul ..
PIIUVmI I LAL~
r~;$_~~~7 9 Fad ;wxpal Ndi N0t 6 Speci i -w A.N ~ -v '
ci- lb E~yrsU Ar~~vcfoPMN"puWw Ms Vow htgm.I eigIM p~taucs fl..Yes.SDaY To mmwiO Ah,14 ,4 P.- I 7 pow Mo. Ss i C.t
.P. Y hrmpymy U. L. I I LASM;r&O Ac- o--
~0
-. t... 411w twIg... uwrmIl.t.., '.nQa ~
3 Nesrderttial Delivery Smgumntur, O~1,uus ~
NFlSg.~.tiw OtFudSjMt~. ".dm R~~e v
- L520: S,--
F Le.x. USAirbil, 8624 4887 6561 Sen der's Copy A pbms iFlx P"l~t &ouw'm Kdb SUjlidd OMl FWdxRv Oyuwwj
%/, ';r 4b F hoodU5UIC
- -,. _t
- _=/ai* z**
................ *-mSI &C!: ... d k"M mi Yawrn 4141%m.r"4 It4ll. l uugf. fulL luff NOW*
3i, To ~ W~AmA." 4w ri do.~d~oo
-ME (~l N - ,t . . . . . ...
r.%A*k.
rJ1. 4 I..,.
4 aht lA*L Er ý *,,,, Erg* ,C t ,,. .
MA Ze !5216q I~~euIw "
.w
Fec Expres*, USAirbill 8608 4742 8711 Sede' Cop I F w ion i m 4. hve ap~r "w-
.OA Stand Oml fttw aaf I00=
Ijam. ;:ftEqIpu Sow, 4b~4d ID"'""kurt J sww%*T=
5hdb ob ~-ftt . Oh IF."A EivlM wlu IddpKwu NIrn 6 pi Nod*
%amim l5 i 1. Ce &AT~-w pW! 1 1U w Who ca -
Nc 'In V.. .01wf cwvc Ar-CI ,*.
FWcqmt~s Afe I I1 .-
A&"em .P SK F]f facftm ThuU.uiy IL PA.W wP WMO I NZW RasidotifieW OmIiwrySIputzru Vptiom ~
q~ ~, ~
NLS D~-NO M' . ý'Iz*L A UAw
F xUSArbill E*xpress S 8608 4742 8700 Sede's Cop I Fm , ,.I. 4' E2Im~ftekqUW$e AI v I'a.ik
-1e 6/1, I-.T
- Pw" Fax W Mft = 2.1 aa1
!-~ RM ",T.t, 4b bqrmFIWO5.e~
I vowI. IvuUmulmpisum
- SPecia IiAuuiug I I TO IflflWGM 0" 4 1,
- Iapobb.w matwzLcig WON~ i WAM 1*p r.avdAt Or
__.W0 4 Ave- 6-A 4 ~t ~zip~4~
M~~~i A~*~s AL/t S K I NEW ~rni.wtJw~ O441~ty hg t.OpIiom
~fIdS9uWU IC~S0i~aw
~ -.
- - - ~
- a.,.O,4 Sn ,x w
Ujo *oss
. US Airbill - 8608 4742 8696 Sde's op Fmm 40 Opom had;M, a "
4b W*EV Fm, t pmui
- Us imw p 1*,m,,h O*J3 k?'___;,z _ -__~
F-t =*Dwlo
&] ~ ;
F~d~~~
k.diT.
A- MIm 4
jo..Mfift-ao*, -"t -40h l CIT t To
- L i CD-- mi UCOW A---- o*
R -" /12-.
TtD,1 L_. #; S O' t -" _.M ,*/ e /_X ,eA No-7 P&t
- k
.. ___*.:,, - - - ... - .. -- - , - - --ft,.-
S ?*, Rlt~hmI t5,hwry Signtn. 1 ,,..-,,...1. ,20
'- 520
Fecfx.USAirbill 8608 4742 8i685 Sede' Cop
- 4. m q.Smwi symvim lowea r~m -2rfS&%WHob kwftm
.wpit/?p4
___1,1 __
4Sarlo4o___ 77-I babu~
ý%W*ft A&Iayu FwiuW*2 wm*a P,~4~ .ugi mmý 5,z-ITo 4*Ai~kf~ f~
~wwI a
_ P41ý4 nA-- 7 Pau b I.-dO' e* 9l -
ra Av t- w LW . ChW "EL ____
WS Dmcww" I NEW MMMOMsW~. 80*Rn SoUVu O-igm.
wspa -- -
15- 13
I.
Expr* USAirbill w 8608 4742 867 4 Sener' Copy 48 F IPacbpmr~iu~m w b4~~~tU%&~ 4~fix_
f __ _
S"" memo"S,~ IW ITe ft(zc6
- qnn 1 jri~
Ao~gu____ 7 _____
~ .Vol,<
livd .em 4 I tf A . l ea II lwf mg Loceb
ý4- 6-M'- -'ýA
ILEPI USAirbill 8608 4742 8722 Sede' Cop E-xo~ts L~ i LA 5 ftdt.--,l .I
-[--- - r¶_...= r, ..2s* '_
TOM F FTu PM-40 I To - B Y,
,Iw 11 1 r- A."OCTAhqPfr
!*
- I Cm&W
,* d.~0M,, =
___ _e V kU-4bo
.M. .et O4 94 __~
~~S~~w~~a5 1"%. ~~ I.
NS 372 -q I L L l f
Fe*. Expr=..m
.pUUS Aibilh -0=8608 4742 8619 Sede' Cop F* P~iut m mrc'c dl FYW mUIu-i I~ Li lk
~ ~ ~ ..51 ... _dip.zt,.*
Z,*I
>*i*
- 46bm -u*Sgr*ie-Yew'. Po,*., _,#, * .+!~ _ S.i~ Fv&APM We ....
-+ - i I- ..
- *i NI--
CaVbn ro Ace/~.
4aD ~-1 e Ad*"__ _
LCa i l Awcm fU, rb"Panv crior fe )-
bd*he-9
~v~vi a LRI /-__
71,ca LmAI'
$ OD mo. *-
a s" 'Y S ~~ICU~
Lcxoes. US AirbiII 8608 4742 8641 SeIe' Co p 1 Frmw OOPAJCV /oowZ 4b ES
- r iw,8i .i A oIni 4biFi* ft~lullll L.- 7y Z z
°*quw mw
-7~ 1'k~ tý;4e 2M4 vowi s ilfti pfttftd
( m *R*" tx 16h N.m 4rr~ NOT~tW
__ i ~ l IrýLool ftK"~~'
orb F]w No o -
Addrwu
- cw.t..auPlI .u.Ij fl Addi. / ~4, I f// a e k SaI a NVEW mei-don"[a Del~vi" Sipgallu O~
hi. bi,,
I;Wd " 7nlli 7i7 -5001
- 1S A~llllrla-l li*d.DlllUh Iust
FcXUSAirbill 8608 4742 6630 Sede' Cp
%dh A] " "2g
&Sders mu* -
mofftwx S0 YOM ..
MY pr s,47,:94Z k.... 9 ftfuna 5 - P FO IMrws a
- I*aun Irma2 7 -o LIPRm
- spiSm .,-*"m 1 .w P. ,w SAM1 Dakiq Ms"J -As 0W
- P*ca l VA 4*AI.m PIwu~
Nom ~ rs
- ~~ Ih... ~ A aM "S.
7 PuWu.W War kw b f-w 'Rc~wThd." 71t, CuO&i CA dli lod.J imd bm.w 3 f Rl dhel IR
,*tinT S ugwu mure Opoim . .
Wd S.wr,.
m mmug' amman
- a. ii....m r*,
- 6. a'-
[5201
F USUSAirbill *P62&6 4742 Fx;)rq,,s iMon
~Sv*miFwb Iidpr~ilrqs iinlo I , L Sede' Co S-7 10p 7 i I l __/l am l kick-lm~lfM m trOTr.
i I
- AD Cftw__ 12-0 AjV 7 r6*
A .ef4 1 Bsmtwo TMDm*uospsw Sqmo -
520
'G~~~~~i,~~~~iil~~~
-Peitiner We ý'KaN a] st "tbniý§iofjSe&onc Rcvtsed CSfr2 .8scvc v Pag)'e V:o'ri, f2 AttaChment 3 Sarah Wagner ýsarahwa~gnereisq(gma~il.corn-Petitioners WestCAN etal. submission: Second Revised COS 1i messagefor2.15..08 service Sarah Wagnier I<sarahwagneresqgmail.com> Fri, Mar.7, 2008 at 1-:48 PM To: LGM 1@nrc.gOv,.OCAAMAI L@nrc gov, OCAAMAI L-Resource <OCAAMAIL. Resourcen@hrc;gov',,.
REW@nrc.gov, "hearinngdod.et@nrc.gov" <HearfngDocketnrrc.gbv>, zxkl @nrc.gov, KDL2@nrcgov, .Greene-Mannajo@Clearwaterorg>, "Dennis, William" <wdennis@entergy:com>, "Sutton. KathryrV' sut 'moranlewisc ReaseePaul- <pbessette mPugan"ew.scm "O'Neill, Martin"
-<martinbo'neill@morganIlew.'c, comr> "Pruyne, Justin" <jdp3@ westchestergov.COrn >, "O'Neill, Dahie"
--Vob@bestweb;net>" ýDeda.,ey, Michael" .:mdelahey@nycedc:com>, "LeKay. JOhn" <fuse usa@yalioo1com>,
"Sipost John" -ýJohn Sipos*oag staieyu M h Joan ":<Jlmatthedgw.ýýdec,.state.ny. us>, .Kremer,'
- Arthur"',2ajkrerner@rrrmfpr.,c.ý."in- "Kerner(2), ArthUr" <kr;emer@area-alliance.org>; "Curran, Diane"
<dcurran@harmoncurran corn>, "Snook, Robert" <robert.snookepo-state.ct.us>, "Musegaas,. Phillip"
.<cphil. pýZrijverktepppr.
.. . rg., .... Tnfrr. Vi'tcin. .<vt~af *rrjvnv rk*... p.r nr
- s n anlie cl'*rieszel q.r w non>,
"Steinberg, Jessica'. .cjsternberg@spriaw. comr>, "Zoti. Elise <ezoli@goodwjnprocter.com>,
janice dean@oag .stateny; us, myIan'Oenerstein@oag.state.nyus, "Burton, Nancy" <NancyBurtonCT@aot.com>,
Kimberly, Sexton@nrc~gov,. ;herwin Turk <Sherwin.Turk@nr6,9ový, C hristopher.Chandler@nic.gov, Marcia carpentier &marcia.Carpehnte,*@ancgovy>!, "Palisadesart@aol.comr". <Palisadesart@aot.com>, Ulrich Witte.
.. ulrich@ulrichWitte.6oms.
March 7,. 2008 Re: i.censc Rcncwal Applicition submitted by..EmTergg y4ndian Point Unit 2.-LLC. Encrgy lndian PoCint unit.S, L.,
and Entcrgy Nuclear. Opcrat .bns..Inc:.forIndian Poitnt Nuc lear Generating Station. Unit 2 and:3 Doc kvt*:Nos- 50-147-_L R..'Ot4 286*: Lj~k.. L 07:S80:RB0 Docet os.5047-LI5O!86LR;ASII No. U7-858- 3-LR-BDO 1 Lear Parjlis:
Petit ioners Weitchltsrer C1 tia*ins. Awareness -Network (WestCAN), Rockland County ConseTrVaioan Amsociation. lnc.
- (RCCA ~hPublic Health an~diusr~tinabJ le-Eerg:. ~( pHASEj, Sgierra Clu$ .- A lranic Chaptei*(Sieita C.;lb), aiid Ne'*, \r'or-k
- State Aiscnmblyman. R ichard L, lBrodskv(hereiaticr "'Pvtitionrs") herebYx submii tluisSecund Revised c.rtilicateof
- Scrvice. "
Respectfully submitte*d.
Sarah.L, Wagner c:*:Scet*icelikt hIp.:/mailxgoIgkCd.'ntma* V"i 1.& ik-0617t.:cd56 1&.vicpt&.hi 185bdcb54ed2a&scar... 8/6/2008
ei -naiI, Fetuiionrsý WestCAN. tci od n;'Sec i~~ri&
d.R&ees COSý for21508'srie I .7 2o>
I'g-2 Pg L~t 0 L6 P'c.-
WESTCAN REVISED 2ND CERT OF. SERVICE .3.71.08.pdt
.64K
- hrp:P~i~o~dp./~a;i~?i~]&ikIJ~3 1cd5, I&viw'p~lh I88a5bdcb54ed-,a&sea!r... 8, -'200L8
rag-& I o-.(
Gmaii
- C-alenda- Docu-Its Photos;s Reader Web mdre;s sairahwagneresq@gmail corn I Set'iicsg I Mailj[ Search the Web ',o..r Go J..Search h.W
,Coqmpose .Mail \Iewsilems I ZDNet - 'Star Trek comnm nicators tree up doctors'ime*eVr, ':.
Inbox-09.8) li(Ba&ckto Inbox ArchiVe LJ elete'. Mort.rCi;is LR*prtSpain Starred T:
e:ijwE 769 of 1131 _lder.
Chats Sent. Mail Licensing Board Orders, - Indian Point License Renewal Proceeding Inbox S p~a (1[.63 ) ro.', Marcia Carpentier -*-. !9 ' a. t, r, r. c v:. . - Mar 7:
on Zachary Kahn elZo Pihrc1ifh;ly, Trash' Beth Mizunq ':-th, , 't" Christopher Chandler-'Ol"',_mirr -- - .
'V QuickContacts David Roth Q"'a' 'bn, 'or Diarihe Curiran:-dcrhr- rn,;z - .
"Janice A. Dean," ;Janiee ei"mq,;ý-'- s,-a-e ry USn'-
O Sarah Wagner Jessica Steinberg -.: s-einhbergr-.'r c' in-
.Set.statuS here v' "Joan Leary Matthew-5 fjlmatthe@gw dec.state.,ny us," ?IV 1'.
- 4 Rich Paladino
!"John J, Sipos'* -ii'orh si '*o*.
a L ny ui-Emma Furman John Louis Parker , rwI','lm- , .1 Ross Gould -
"Justin D. Pruyne" I ;' "wIA r'- .
John Sipos: iOra v' -,
"Kathryn M, Sutton" -':'t*t Kelly MacMillan-O- *Kimberly Sexton 'i- ' .iupr-Mike Wallace Lloyd Sub nýn ,i '
palisadesart@aol...: Manna Jo:G-reene u i-,* ' w:ii,'i Richard Brodsky Rober'Rader Pull Nancy.Burton ' i,.,ui' ,aI' i.
Ulrich Wilte "Paul Mi Bessette" . , -. . v ,s .. ,
Phillip Musegaas .'," 'rr C-Igiili(
"Richard L. Brodsky Esq." -c ,xa dlA <,r -
0 "Robedf 0. SnO~k- - ob*ii .o,'Tho... **~.., **,
V Labels 'Sarah L. Wagner" : : fLrm i ,Thi2, D Edit Iabells
,Stephen Filler "-:dh," y i r*,* .
- Susan Shapiro "--,;u r.ýni riock n.'.itt.;. c : -
.V Invite a frien&Ibw all Victor Tafur < -A a1r .. e.ep. 9,f, Give.Gmaillto: 'William .C Dennis" werri*.,"erleIC'/ .K:,'.
.Hearing Docket <Hea ing b)ckefn.'
cc KayeLathrop 'Kate K Jthcrpunr' o'J'.
Lawrence McDade Lawrence MrlI . r-paie'pw invite Patricia Hanch ,, atr-ivi r jft'lt" (
.Richard Wardwelf1ir-r*-c,"*r ,-.-". -..
- Ashley: Prange :. -y ',.r' ,
"klathrop@indep~endencene .- 1:*....,,:....
- v - -q :
.,i! 'Mar 7. 2008 2:45 PM Licensing Board Orders - Indian Point License Renewal Proceeding.
nrc.gov Attached are two Licensinqg Board Orders isIued: today in:the Indian Point license .rem
- proceeding. Plbesae let me know if.you have any problems in theatransmission.or reCe I&dn t I'?
http://rnail~~~ &IkO=3i hiz-u'Fo 11I88a 9 O,i. V/612008
PAge 2 Of.2 C-9mposeMail ýattached docurments.
- .tafred_:O Thank you.
Sent Mail All-Mail S pan,..Ct6_) Marcia Carpentier Law Clerk "Coi~tacts Atomric Safety and LicenSing Board-Panel v Quick Contacts
.:SC3vc *h dd, or trivf!e MaiA Stop: Tr-3F23
- 8arah Wagner Set sta§us-here .v U;S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Ri h Paladinor' R
- Emma Furman Washington, DC 20555-0001
- Ross Gould lJ-ohn:'Sipos (E-maiL nixQ;7@_Q90v Kelly'MacMillan-O, Mike Wallace palisadesart@aol-..
Richard .Brodsky Robeit Rader
.. 1UIrICh Witte,
.2 attachments - Download all ttachjments
- Labels r*"Ida.Point.O3072OO8or.pdf.
Edil. labels L.], 1t9KView..as HTML: DoWnlOad.
- Invite a frienc6!-4-1all Indian Point 0307200bor2lpdf:
201K View as HTML. oWnload
- Give Grrail to.
,R3pjy.. . Repiy 6 all --4 Forward Invite Mar*ia oGmailG Fs.11ý1Sc 1 lefi.
Back~tOtIboxT ArchiveII Report Spaom DeledOe, ilinwir 769 of 131 Qlderý
-Search your mail quicker than.ever. Dow wl~ o th_.eGqqgle Toolbar, now With Gmailsearch. Learn more You are cuirently usifig 1459MB (20%-)of your 7004.MB.
3rniaIl 'iew: standard with chat I ,l__ lt6 I tasic1HTML Lta rn .rflo
$D2008 Google - Terms - Q iL~l~o.- Gcogle Hcme h tip: /Atiaii4o oa e: &omn~ihi/?iiI i Ui=& ik=0603 I(d-561I &v icw~c V&sinrchinhlOX&L-h= 11888a90_ V&62008
Clifai - Uci~i'si"gFur()des-ida Point IicneRontwaIl Proceedinig PAQ,ý I:Off:2 G il . Sarah Waqner <sarahWagheresq~gmai1cOm>
Licensing Board.Orders - Indian Point. License Renewal-Proceeding 1 mes sage Marcia. Carpentier <Marcia..Carpentier@nrc.gov> Fri, Mar'.7, 2008 at 2:45 PM To' Zachary: Kahn -<Zachiiry Kahn@nrc.gov>, Beth MizgJnfo <Beth Mizunio@nrc:90ov>, Christopher Chandler
<ChristopherChandler@rrc.gov>, Daniel Riesel .<driese1@sprdaw.com>. David!Roth-4cDavid; Roth@nrc:gov>,
Dianne Curran <dcurrian@h;i:rmoncurran:com>, Jaice A.Dean". <Janice. Dean@oag.state~nyvUs>,. Jessica%
Steinberg: <jsteinbeig@splacom'. "Joan Leary Matthews ijlrnatthe@gwWdec.state.ny.us)"
<jlmatthe.@g:dec.stbte.4ly.js>, "John Jý Sipos°<..<john,sipos@0ag.state:ny.us>., John'LouisParker
<jlparker@gw.dec-state;ny.ts>, "Justin D, Pruyne", <jdp3gweskchestergov.com>, "Kathryn.M. SuE0i6"
<ksutton @.organlewisicom>. Kimberly SeIton < KimberlyISextorh@ ig , Lloyd Subin
<Ltoyd.SulinPnrcgov.., Manna Jo Greene <mainajo@cle,: iaterlorg>, "Martin J. O'Neill"
<martin o0.neiil@mrorganlewvis.5corr--, Nancy Burton *<NancyBurtonCT@a.cohm, >"PauI M. Bessette"
<pbesSet-OPemorqantewis cr'm>, Phillip Musegaas ;*phillio@ii~Verkeeper.or'gý.... "Richard L Brodskw, Esq.`
<richardbrcdsky@msncoln:C , "Robert D, Snook" <0berttsnook@ po.state ct. us-, "Sarah L. Wagner!
< Sherwin TurR <,herwinTurk@nrc9gov>, Stephen Filler <sfiller@nyiawline~com>.
marahwageSehqegmail Susan Shapiro <mbs@ourr6cklanddffice.corn>, Victor Tatur. kvtafur@riverkeeper.6rg>, "William C. Dernnis "
<wdennis$enntergy.com>, Haaring Docket <Hearing, Docket@nrc.gov>;
Cc: Kaye Lathop :<Kaye. Latirop@nrc:gov>, Lawrence McDade
- Lawrence:McDade@nFrc gov>, Patricia Harich
<Patricia. Harich@nrcý:gov. *RiChard Wardwell <Richard.Wardwell@nrc.gov>, Ashley Prange
<AShley.Prange@nrcgov>. kljathrop@independence~net' <klathrop@independence.net:-,
Attached
- re two, Li:erinfn Board Orders.issued -today in the IndianPoint.license renewal proceeding-.
- Please let me know if you 'iave any problems in the'transhrission or receipt of the attached-docUments.
Thank you, Marcia tcarpentier Law Clerk
- Atomic Safety and Licehsiri. Board.Panel
-Mail Stop T-3F23
.US. Nuclear RegulatOry C.Dmmission WashingtMn, DC 20555-70031 (E-nail: mxf7nrcý gov.r hup;-iai
. ....le, .com'.ma,il*.i 1& ik=0613I cd..,61 &:vie,=pt&th= 1 188a9g4&e9c264& sear... 816&2008
(Onaaii- Licensing Boar'd Orders - indian.Pciiit imse RenewiI Pa cocdiin P"Cg2 .2:,f2 2 attachments Indian Point 030720030r.pdf
-197K Indian Point03072003or2.pdf.
20'1K.
- ~IT http
- ,'rnamil *gocur/miV~ui* & k=0603 Icd56.1 &-vi ew'pt&yth-- 1 88a9'04 foc c24&seat., ."/2008
.- 4ý ý .
Attachmine nt 4 UNITED.STATES OF AMERICA
-NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY ANDLICENSING B0A-RD' In the Matter Of "ENTERGY.NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. )) Docket Nos. 50-247i286-LR;
)
.tIndian Point NuclIear.Generating).
- Units 2 and 3)
)3 SECOND REVISED CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1.hereby certify that.;opies of the foregoing Reply of VWestCAN et al. dated February 15,.2008,
'have been served upon the Office .of the Secretary, u.S. Nuclear Regulatory. Sixteenth Flooir.
One Flint Norih.1 1555. Rockville Pike Rockvillt,ý Mairyland 20852, anda'couriesv papYrcopy
.has beeniienilt i0"SlafCind Eniwrgyss.at!briney.'"s I further celtiry that:CD copies-of the foregoing:.
-Reply of WestCAN.et al. dated February 15. 2008. have beenserved upon thelfbllowing.
- addresses. provided below, this 15th day of February, 2008 by DHL courier service.
.Add idonally, I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Reply:Brief of WestCAN et-al, dated February 15, 2008, have been electronically served only upon the:emailladdresses provided below, on thel6th diy of February, 2008, Lawrence G,. McDad,QChair. Office of-Cornmission AppOllate AdjUdication Atomic Safety and Li.:ernslng. Baid Panel U. S. Nucleare Regulatory commission Mail Stop - T-3:F23 Mail Stop: O-16G4 U.-S. Nuclear RegukitOry Comrmission Washinqton6, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, D.C, 20555-0001 Emaii: oCAAMAILn-nr.gov Dr, Richard E. Wardell Office of the.Secretary Atomic Safety and.L.ice nsing :Board Panel Attn:. Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff:
Mail Stop -. T3 F23 Mail Stop: 0-16G4:
UAS. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U_ S; Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington. DC. 20555-0001 Washington, D..C. 20555-0001, Enmail: HEAR INGDOC KET Irrc.gový Dr. Kaye, D Lathrop Zachary S. Kahn. Law Clerk Atrnic Safety and Lii-ensing Board :AtomictSafety and Licensinrg Board 190 Cedar Lane E. Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Ridgeway, CO 81432 U. ,. Nuclear Regulatory Comi'ission Washington, D.C, 20555-0001 Atomic Safety and .icensing Board U, Sý.Nuclear Regulafory.Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Washington, UC,(.:2,0555-0061
V WilliamC. Dennis; k-sq'. Manna Jo.Gtreene Assistant General Counsel' Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, inc.
Entergy Nuclear O'perations tnc. 112 Little Market Street 440 Hamilton Avenue Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 White Plains, NY.1,(601 Email;, wd4nnis*er c Kathry.n M. Sutton 15sq. .Justin b:, Pruyne, Esq.
Paul M, Bessette, Eq. Assistant County.Attorney MartinJ. O'Neill, Es:4, Westchester County Attorney's Office.
MIrgan, Lewis.& ,3ctkius, LLP. 148.Martine Avenue,.56'h Floor 1i111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW White Plains:NY 10601 Washington, D.C. 20004 E-mai&ksuttont*.-.nc.rganlewis.com E-mail: pbessettegiiniorg-anlewis~com Daniel E.. O'Neill, Mayor E-mail- martin.oneilliroanlewis com James Seirtmarco, M.S:.
ViIjagc bf Buchanan' Michael.J. Delaney, Esq, Municipal Buildirng Vice President. E n'rgy"Depadment
- BuchananNy' iO "i-1298 New :York City. Economic Development Corporation JNYCD[:C) 110.:William Sti-eet John JI'Sipos; Esq.
New York: NY 1003ti Chadie tonaldson. Esq..
Assistants Attorney General New York State Department of Law:
,John' LeKay Environmental Protection Bureau FUSE USA The Capitol
- 351 Dyckman Stre et Albany, NY -12224 Peeks.kilL NY %10566 Arthur J. Kremer, C h irman Joan. Leary. Matthews, Esq,.
New York Affordable Reliable"Electricity Sehior Attorney for Special Projects.
Alliance{(AREA) New York State Departmeent of 347 FifthAvenue, Suite 508' Environmental Conseryation New York, NY ir0l1t: :"office of the'General Counsel 625, roadway, 1 4 1hFloor Albany, Ný ý12233- 1500 Diane'Curran, Esq.
Harmon, Curran,. Spie*lberg & Eisenberg, LLP 1726 M Street, NW,.Suite.600 Washington,' D:C. 20036 E-mail: -dcurran,_hharirioncurrancom Robed Snook, Esq. Victor Tafur, Esq, Office of the Attorney General ,Phillip Musegaas, Esq.
State of Connecticut Riverkeeper, lnc6 55 Elm Street :828 South Broadway P:O. Box1:20 Tarrytown, NY 1.05.91 Hartford., CT 06141-0120
Dan iel Riesel, Esq,.,
ThomasF. Wood. Esq.:
Ms. .s.i .8teinberg, J.D.
Sive*, Paget'& Riescl. P.C.
460 Park Avcnuc New York, NY 10022.
- Elise N, Zoli,; Esq . ._
Goodwin PrOcter, LLP Exchange .Place.
Ms. Narncy Burtop 53 State.Street 147 Cross Highway Boston, MA 02109 Redding Ridge, CT 06876
.JaaniceA, Dean SheOwini Turk, Esq.:.
- Assislant Attooegy, C'eneral Offide of tlG"ner[eralCounsel Office of the -Attoe--Icy.Gcn*!&oi U;3. Nuicle1 1c.ar rNegul~atory c%,mmisI 11511 120 Broadway 2 1 Ioor Mail Stop 0-1 5.D-21 New York, -NY 1.0271 Wasihington;. D.UC: :20555 "EMAIL:-!enrcgo tDr(~'nrc,Qgv afDrrc~oo10.
- dnanic. -ov esn(@arcggoý.
eljL'3nrc:qov nsqgcznrc~oo~
r11Oq.nrc nov rxdO~nrc~.qnov
.albnmrc. nov,
'aslbo hiwo @Ciudicbtion~nqrC 'ov slburd ick~rnimpe~scr
'rhathews~býta.rnoranlew'Is-com 6nnette whife~e rnorqanlevis~corr Dated: March 6, 2008
.,(si Sarah L_ Wagner, Esq.
4- * ,,-
UNiiEO"STATES OFAMERiCA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- E FRE THE ATOMIC S:AFETY AND LICENSING.BOAR D In the Matter.of ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATiONS,. INC._ Docket Nos. 50-247"286-LR ASLEBP No. 07-853-03-LR-IBD01 (Indian Point Nuclear Generating). )
Units.2 and 3) *1 CEIRTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Second Revised Certificate0of Servicie.f .'service of Petitioners WestCAN.et al. reply bief served February 15, 2008; have been served upon the following by electr.inically and by first class' mail as shOwn beilw,.thiS 7th.day bf Mardh, 2008:
Lawrence G. McDade, Chair Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Atomic Safety and L -ensing Board Panel U. s- Nuclear Regulatory.Commission Mail Stop:0-;1604
- Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Uý S, Nuclear Regukitory Comrnýmission Washington, DC..20555;0001 Email: OCAAMAfEtUnno Washington,. D,C 20555-0001 E-miail: LGM41 &rcc60cv Dr. Richard E..Ward.vell Office-of the Secretary Atomic Safety and Li.,ensing Board Panel Attn: Rulemaking and AdJudications Staff MailStop.
Mail:Stop- T43 F23 O-16G4 U.S., Nuclear :egulatory Commission U. S, NUclear Regulatory:Commissi0on Washington., D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, D C, 20555-0001 E-mail: REwAnrC rv Email:'HEAR INGDOC KET nrcpov Dr. Kaye 0. Lathtrp Zachatr:S. Kahn, Law Clerk Atomic Safety and.Litýenising B'ld Panel Atomic Safety and Liiensing Board. Panel, 1590Cedar L-ane E. Mail Stop - T-3`1 F23 Ridgeway, CO 81432 U. S.ý Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: KDL2 _,niirý1:ginV Washington, D.C: 20555-0001 EmailL ZXK1.pinrc.gov Ato0nic Safety and Lir;ensing Boiard*Panel.
U. S-.Nuclear Regulalory Commission' Mail Stop,- T-3.. 12..
- Wshington. D-C, 20;555-a001
,William C, Dennils, FEEq. Manna Jo Greene.
Assistant -General.Coinsel Hudson River.Sloop Cleawater, !nt.
Entergy Nutlear Operations, hI,, 112 Little Market Street 440 Hamilton Avenue Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 White Plains, NY 106;01 Email: annaleeiwater~oro "4.
V E mail.,: ideiý.t Lteirgy.crn Kathryn. M..S uttoih. Fsq. .Justi, :D, Pruyne-. Esq.
Paul M.- esSette, Ez`,q, Assistant County Attorney Martin:J. O'Neill, Es.1, .Office. of the Westchester County Attom'iey Morgan, Lewis &,c;ckIus,. LLP 148 Martine Avenue..6mV Floor 1111 .Pennsylvania A*venue- NW White Plains, NY 10601 Washington. D.C. 20004 E-mail:: idp3westchestemov.:com E-mail: ksuttonL.ncýrrqaniewis-com E-mail: obessette) morganrewis corm Daniel E. O'Neill,. Mayor E-maid- martin,o'neil)morganlewis.corm J me1 Seirmarco. M :S.
Villageof Buchanan
.Michael J. Delaney, .Esq. Municipal Building Vice President - ErnOrgy Department Bucchanan.: NY10511 -1298 New York, City EcOn nic Developmentý E-mai:-*bo bbestweb net Corporation
"*101 whiom (NYCDEC) onStreet*
John. J; Sipos, Essq .
New York. NY 1003ff Charlie Donaldson,. Esq.
.E-mail:. rdel~ane v iUv,;ed~c :co Assis'tants Attorney General New York ,State Department of Law.
-JohnLeKa.y Environmental Protection Bureau FUSE USA The Capitol 351 Dyckman Street Albany; NY 12224ý Peekskill, NY 10566 E-mail: oh,,. sios~oa .q:state.,iy.us.
-E-mail: fuse sa0.y-3hoo.corn Arthur J. Kremer,. Chairman Joan.Leary Matthews, Esq.
New York Affoidable Reliable Electricity Senior.Attorney for Special Projects
- Alliance (AREA)'.' New York State. Departmentof
-34.74 ifth Avenue, Si.ite 508 Environmental ConseNation New York, NY 100t1: .Office of the.General Counsel
-maii,.aik eme~C~- mffo.carn
- 625: Broadway. 14"h Floor kremer,@,ar e*-alliance~birq
,Albany. NY 12233-1500 Diane Curran, Es'q.
l4armon, Curran, .Spie~lb*erg & Eisenbelrg, LLP 1726 M Street, NW, !;uite 600 Washington, DýC; 20336 E-mail.:dcurranr.*harmoncurran corn Robert Snook, -Esq, Victor Tafur, Esq, Office of the Attorney General Phillip.Musegaas.. Esq.
State ofConnecticut Riverkeeper,. Inc.
55 Elm Street 828 South Broadway P.O. Box 120 .Tarrytowni NY 10591 Hartford,:CT 06141-0120 h E-mail: vtafur.rhierkeeer,
.llp iverkeeer or.
ora E-mail: roberd sfo kp6.state~d i.s Daniel Riesel, Esq.
Thoma F,. Wood, Esq.
1ý4 Ms" Jessica Steinberg,.J.D.
Sive, Paget & Riesel, PC' 460 Park Avehue New York, NY 10022 E-mail: drieselO pr.aw.comr 'Elise N...Zoli Esq,:.
isteinbern oipawccom :Goodwin Procter;. LLP Exchange Place Ms. Nancy Burtop 53 State Street 147 Cross. Highway Boston, MA. 021i09 Redding Ridge, CT 06876 E-mail: ezoli.oodwinprocter;com E-mail: nancyburtonct aol.com.
Janice A. Dean Counsel for NRC-Stiff Assistant Att6rney: General US. NBclear Regulatiy. Commi.ssisnp .Office of the Aftorney Gen-eral Office of-the General Washington 0 DC Counsel 2')555; 120 Broadway, 26th Floor New. York, NY 1027'1 C_-mail. kirnberly. CAtu6ý,nq '0 ~~V E -16i~
i fi. a'd n ,.Ie .cl ,a rit:ýU (aq t e*. i ::ug
-Sherwin tu*rkk..n rc._qov hrj stoP..her chandler(.nr¢..qov Office of the Secretary* .Mylan L. Denerstein UVS. Nuclear Regulatory Fxecutive Deputy Attorney General
,:Sixteenth Floor Office of the NY.:Attorney General One lint North 120 Broadway' 25u floor 1 1555 Rockville.. Pie New York, New York 10271 Rockville, Maryland: 20852: Eomail:
Mylan.-Denerstei nL{oaq state. ny. us Marcia Carpenuiuer. Law. Clerk Ato,nic Sat'et*V and 'Licensing Board.
Mail.Stop: T-3.E2B U.S., Nuclear.Regulatbry Commission Washington, D,., 20555-0001 SE`-mail: Marcia. nliercirtrco.v r is Sarah L. Wagner., Esq.
Original and two zooies 6
cPK~
1%>
U'7 ~