ML19312D168
| ML19312D168 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Hartsville  |
| Issue date: | 03/14/1980 |
| From: | TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19312D167 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8003210376 | |
| Download: ML19312D168 (2) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:h %, P ,w .. L . :L ~ % fx 'a w :; .
~
- -
. -
~
W - - W
,
.: % <- * *"- e l~ , ,' ,
-
q q;.-
-
+ p
,.
3, , , . h(y ,},'y , . .: < .
. .
.
, .
, ,
,
W :".' :t pg s ' _
; . '
, '
r
' %,.j :; >
.
L: --
-
_,_ _
' ~
y"%y g lM
"
[ [-ENCLOSURE (4' .. -
-
+,m' -
.
> +
3.- .
. %'c :>. , ',, . ,
M [l h yw
, gp ;7 ,
- di , 1, JHARTSVILLE NUCLEAR 1 PLANT; UNIT- B-1a .
'
"
'
I a 94 , 2 [3 ;'USE'0FcINCORRECT s [10'CFRIPARTj50.55($)) REPORT CONCRETE ~NO.' 3 f(FINAL)1 MIX IN SHIELD BUILDING WALL
. q;m . N, "
s ENCR :HNP-B -023 L
~ ; , + ;-' ~ -: n ,
ML ,;n eu x
._
. . . .. .
.
.. _
- ,~
.
-
m M $0nIJunef26,;:1979(TVA notified.NRC-0IE? Inspector, W.;BF Swann, that-the-
~~ '
,
--
-
laubject<NCR was/ potentia 11yfreportable'under 10 CFR)Part 50.55(e).;
-
iThisfisithe final lreportion the subject NCR.;
'
'
<
~ ;
%
b N '~ _, ,.. i Description of-Deficiencvi -
. . ,
~ '
-
..
f, _ q:n. _
~ k- i,'-
~ -
, .
n ,z
~N' <
\ c
., , _ , , , , ,
LThe 'second 'concreto L pour, vnumber' BlR-2'B,' Jof": the unit;B-1J reactor shield.
,
,
M ,' : building"from (--): 21'7." i ot ?(-): 11'7";and from 0 to :360. degrees was _
'
, - _'placed with Tconcrete mix 300;75)BFW-p ^ (3000. psi concrete) rather than-
,L_ ,chefrequir'edl mix 1401.5,BF (4000_ psi concrete).
r _ m-s .
- s. .. < .. . . .
- ; LThe" deficiency wasfdiscovered by the materials en;;ineer who made - . .
!the mistakeJ(see cause?of:the deficiency). When'he was.looking back o.ver'
.
F' (. -
, cwh_atihad .b'esn ?done,Lh'c foundf that he had specified the wrong: concrete -
- , imix 'on;: thel pour- card for (that; pour. -
~
c .
':Cause ofJ the Defic'iency
,
_ [W/' (The. materials \ engine' e riresponsibledor pour: number BlR-2B 'faile'd to:
,
Lfollow?procedureiand{ consult'the applicable' construction. drawing for w.f (determinationfof1the: required _' concrete ~mixtfor that_ pour. Asfa result,
'
w che' filled iout 'the pour card for pour BlR- 2B? incorrectly' and the' concrete'~
't q - (was.placed according to,.otherwise; proper procedures.1
_
~
V - ' .
. .
,
., . m ? Safety-Implications-
;,n- '
*
, .
Afterfreviewing;the results of the'compressiveistrength_ tests on the
,
'
7 fg
'
Q "
.;aamplesltaken[from7this. mix, TVA and GE/C. F. Braun: concur that the
, ; concrete:in" pour number BlR-2B is acceptable for use. Therefore, s i i
%thiscondition[doesinotipresentasafetyconcern.: ,
'
.a .. ....1 ...
g Q Test;Results and" Corrective-Action-
<.
;
- ~,
#*
-
. . . ,
2TVA.made compressive strength 1 tes_ts on:three.fsets of cylinder's(taken:
.
,
W ' c'
.
Jfromlthis~po.ur. 1Thefre'sults/arejshown below.
-
-
;
, ,
M
^
,, -
_ _ n .2;[ 3 .., + mr _; y~' y; ,
- s _y
k r '* 3 4 , , . 6, . ., _. g ,
.
<
j g ;jSample.NO.- ', 8-dav? ,'90-Dag; '180-Dgy. 270-Dgy;
.
- m -lb/in 21 ' lb/in* .Ib/in ^ 1b/in W , K m <- . . .
-
,
. _
N
.
,e s *M ,at ^ S11 '
. 12909 R :4156-' '46521 ,
<2696?
"
s [2 . L38377 4758
"
7[43L , l_' ' deferredCto
]9~ w), '+? ,' ,S , t _y '1839;- 3767
< -
'
'
M4 '270-Day! 3697? w y+ 7
-
?.
g .
~
,
,
JM[x ; ^?Ikerage: ,
," [2481'.3' -
-. 4392.3 ~.
, ~~sc , 3. ,
. ,
, z'# .'
> ., . Q 6'? . . . . , ~ ,4 , V.
ps y ,' - , , , ~ ~ ' qv . , , ,
<
.g < ^'
,
a v~:.' ,
,
, ,' ' *hN ~ ' " '
'4y.
* * *
', s" J M;ie--y . < .
- ~-
'y h .,#
,
* * ." 'C
^
[ ; e'm - c < # we e - ~ "
~~ g. . ,
-
-
~ . __.
, : x 3 2 . - e &, s , s ~- - > '
- < - +
? Q JR %.h n?& f-?'y N h . . f M
,
y ,,r. M ~. .S m :6 , .'l,{l. . c.3
,' ,
, 4 , -
-
g 4
-
;
' v.E' ' ' '
.
'
~
4
,
N e -l YhI '
" p,) , g"q " 3 "jp.-'
'
~
- " " $5
- M,"'y.r -r
-
< j j
- ~ ,
y li . w q .; .s ..~- 4.M@ M[%~ o, . [~ ['ns. 3. ,G
N,e f t %
~
m, - e . _ T
"
v - - .
^ ' 11 %
- n M' ,,
, v .-
4
~~ y 4m, % 4 i. MN , _ # . '.
y' % t ' ' %,. 1J
'5 ay
-
g ,.,_s g _ ,v s , , -3 sd5 - - -y , m _ . . . 1 -
%. ' ac; L ' ih,t '.. ,.- S2V - '
^ '
'
%,l.
,,
q+
.u. c &c a n- x&,B
. . ,
- w. .
s L ,,m_, Q:
.? '
&~. .
.
, *
..
*
-
'
.n :
,
~
.
.$ N.bs ff ' . + -
q';an - _- 1 - - -
@nm. 3
%y g.3 7 ; ::
.,
, , ~ , j::7v . 3:- ,.: . ~ i,n.
.
'
g g_ _ g . d@@@gC up D'%h6 .
'
,
MMW
~
f the; strengths;at t180! days fare acceptablec onichelbasisiof 2the. critcria : i ; lin; ACIt301-72f(Sectionl17.-2)Tand lACIf 318-71 (Ssction- 4^.3)3)'.e (Additiona119;<
^
Q
!M,P ~ Mbecause7the wa11[isi36 ihcheaf thickhthe! water : loss: from; evaporation:wou
$
k *Q b , M gainingi,p'eriodfu.nder? consideration ~.1 shaveLaffected(no:more?than twofinches_of.' concrete duringlthis strengthb r
,,;;;;_ + ~
m #. ,- m e, 'y' A. .,I: 1 N,'d.u ih ^
)
c). ... _
-
3-w- - e'" ^ m ..m j
,
m
. _ .
. _
w W (Means'Taken _toiPreventERecurrencee _ 4 m- s g , %_ .- _ , -
-
,
.% s
,
i _- . +
&
* .. , . . l i . , ~; A c _.e '
y#
,_
'
s._responsibleTfortincorrectidesignation of-x2 _ _ _
%m.
+
~-
?The 1the mix ,ma,~teri.als'engineerswho'M...been; onjtherpour? card has
.
--
_ reinstructed as" toltholimportanc ? ? M. M.following)proceduresiin?determina' tion:oC the:specified" concrete mix.:
.
M M k , lItLwa'sWerbally;reemphasizeditMthe othuJtwo' plant;B'materialsiengineers J f,~ $ F ~ $ tolfollowjproceduresfinidetermination oflihe.Lspecified concrete mix:for-Q w -
-
- fa[pqur6 -
L
~
s . - - ,
,. "' , g , ,
- , , ,
' <
< ,
--
"' '
,w
- ~
r , y_ T ', .* '#'
. ~,- Ei'-
' ' '
? -> 7' 4
-_
-' Y 2" w ,, , ;
4
' , , ( ... -"r'-_ - V
* '
se y _ {^ j ~ J m:.
.
"
e
.g : s.
- "
~...
*[. . . . '
' '.- t
#
, ,J,. ^*
~^'
.
( _x, , . . ,
,.,
- .- N
<
#
;1,
, .,a ,A
^ 1 A..
i'$ l .Q ;. ' ' g,s
, _
4 - _
$
7 s [~r i s'./g i*\
'
g
,,,
'u y + - S 3 '
y 4- 4 5 4 k "
\ ' '
t v c
* .'- , _,
s . m dt. *~. '
-
- i.,. J d '? .,$ '"'
d&
+v iK,qg ~; ' '
,
,
.a 7 _ ,
,e e <.,, W , -
,y. j
~
, _ _ 31 ,
,s
'
$5 *- Q l . ; %1 s ,.-
^&L ,
l
's.
& f, '< py '
. ,
-
p-
, @_ fi 4 , ,
,
--* .. T
- 4. L
,gg .;, _[
-
u ,
,
. ~ ,
, A._ - .
, -:2,
, )d' s f m
^
T ' c '- 3
/O / r -
- r. ._ s n
, _
.
e
'
#
' - _ '
k , .e1h_} 5 __ _' s~ ;- ~p ('hll1-* 4' ',,Z d f Q m,
, , . .,
. ' , .YA ~ \
~'
.s - -a; Y % -'
.,, 4 , , , .
> e= .g . - 3. r : r}[.,A .y . *
,.:s*
-
*-{*
3...:1: * ;- 7
-
-[ , *
,a
'
y, '. .. . x '. e
,
L
-' '
.
, ,
,kQ:,',' 1, ;;; m._ m
.
* ..
j _;
,-Q, p r..-
cp
- ,
-
4
, -
t . m-: ,* L; l y-@z ;
,
6 dy s d. y._C.. > +
-
,;' x
* -
; - '&
e ' %.3g;-y. : --;. g,. c
,
e_s , . ' 9; '> ,-
-
,
- '+ .n . _
, + , > a ;
, -
'l.'.i' dh
~
'
5
}*-J ' ; -l.-V1 . - ef ' t L.. s
-
Y
- --
-.y 1.a.
.yr,g.,
;
y n..,LL#*-I
; "" s
'
m;_:
.:.-
'
~.'N -
w ~.' { '.
-e.
t _ y g , e f '.'
- 5
> }.3 l z . 4., -
u+, , ? W :. _
,ZW.5 5y . -. f.'~--l y i. ' .. i ^
>
'
;
'
i y ,. ;e._Ma.r. , , , -- W 2 s 4 u-;7. . e, , - ' '.i; ~ ., ' m ,
'
,
r - -
#4
'
b- ",, ,k , ,_, h ._{"' [ }
, { ','" ? -- p'-R. +' -
t y a m ('h.Q
-
'
- j. M'#> < ~
'
'
d $ ".5)D; 3@!Ay"
,'s ~ y lq O Q'
. sl;:x :. s
,
i rQ ' U4h i MW . .
, .W'
,' ,'
s
'
; i .: >
J i u -
~ .w ~
u
,
,
(,,9 %..an m( -
,
*
- l "
- _ . : h
'A, f ,.x,.
n .e
,
yn wn. ..: .
- e.
.m,[ * - -
2.x n < , , ,
-
Q i.! . *- 4
._4
"
.a~."-- ..g a ;. ,
,, .,
,' % ;r x;E- ,
-
- , .
- y ' '~ . .
^'uLy . >
.
, ,
nc C- + i
~
'
\ " ?
AW;%.1:, , < gp < v,
-
- t. .
+ o gs'w3e ,
.,
w
- u. oe. e'
.
,
m)$R s - , _
-
w _ m ._ m - ,
. - ,- +
- c. -
5 , A g ,,.,/ ^IF' .+* ep.\
' . -
'
A " I .),N
*(
-- ^' -*[ g (
.4 .s.-
.e
'('h4 '.A*
='1 e
-
s,
+ k$} ,; ,_ .. _
g- ? h (_ ,,,u
'Yf/*'*h,',_ ,
6 4 q ;_r >1.e , - - r.\i-Qlf';$'f w ,. p:v.5 Q ,, <e, r m> _ . ,; -. ,n w ,. e : a,
,
-
s.:
-
, , c a
-
y+ g 1 -u , z_- ' g ,,. ,
) z _^
_
~
3 y
'}' & f a
#
; ,4}}