ML17254A450: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:AttachmentA1.ReplaceTechnicalSpecificationpages6.2-7and6.3-1withtheenclosedpages.8507260038850719PDRADOCK05000244P:PDR m'~'i<
{{#Wiki_filter:Attachment A1.ReplaceTechnical Specification pages6.2-7and6.3-1withtheenclosedpages.8507260038 850719PDRADOCK05000244P:PDR m'~'i<
R.E.GINNASTATIONOPERATIONSANDTECHNICALSECTIONSGROUPORGANIZATIONSOPERATIONSMANAGERTECHNICALMANAGEROPERATIONSSUPERVISOR(SRO)RESULTSANDTESTSUPERVISORREACTORENGINEERTECHNICALPROJECTSSUPERVISORENGINEER(S)SHIFTSUPERVISORI/SHIFT(SRO)TECHNICIANS8REPAIRMENTECHNICALCOMPUTERSYSTEMSANALYSTHEADCONTROLOPERATORI/SHIFT(RO)CONTROLOPERATORI/SHIFT(RO)AUXILIARYOPERATORS2/SHIFTCOMPUTERTECHNICIANSFIGURE6.2-5RGSEREV.54$pcf42S C"1I~'
R.E.GINNASTATIONOPERATIONS ANDTECHNICAL SECTIONSGROUPORGANIZATIONS OPERATIONS MANAGERTECHNICAL MANAGEROPERATIONS SUPERVISOR (SRO)RESULTSANDTESTSUPERVISOR REACTORENGINEERTECHNICAL PROJECTSSUPERVISOR ENGINEER(S)
6.3STATIONSTAFFQUALIFICATIONS6.3.1EachmemberofthefacilityshallmeetorexceedtheminimumqualificationsofANSIStandardN18.1-1971,"SelectionandTrainingofNuclearPowerPlantPersonnel"<assupplementedbyRegulatoryGuide1.8>September1975iforcomparablepositions<exceptfortheShiftTechnicalAdvisoriandexceptfortheOperations1ManagerwhoshallhaveheldanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseforGinna.References1Ltr.J.Maier(RG6E)toD.Crutchfield(NRC)idatedDecember30'980.6.3-1PROPOSED r4f AttachmentBTheproposedchangewoulddeletetherequirementthatthestationOperationsManagercurrrentlyholdanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseandreplaceitwiththerequirementthattheindividualmusthaveheldanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseforGinna.TheOperationsSupervisor<towhomtheShiftSupervisorsandoperatingpersonnelreport<willstillberequiredtomaintainanNRCsenioroperatorlicense.Thus<anindividualonthemanagementchainwillstillberequiredtomaintainalicense.TheANSIN18.1-1971requirementisonlythattheOperationsManagershouldhavealicenseonlyatthetimeofassumingtheposition.Theproposedrequirementswouldmeetorexceedtheintentoftherequirement.TheadvantagesoftheproposedchangearethattheOperationsManagerwillhavemoretimetodevotetomanagingtheoperatingorganizationduetoareducedtrainingcommitment.InadditionsthebaseofpersonnelwhocouldfilltheOperationsManagerpositionwillbebroadenedtoincludenotonlythosecurrentlyholdingalicensebutalsothosewhohaveheldalicense.TheproposedchangeisacceptablesinceitwillretainthenecessarymanagementknowledgeandcontrolswhileimprovingtheabilityoftheOperationsManagertomanagetheoperatingorganization.Inaccordancewith10CFR50.91<theproposedchangetotheTechnicalSpecificationshasbeenevaluatedagainstthreecriteriatodetermineiftheoperationofthefacilityinaccordancewiththeproposedamendmentwould:1.involveasignificantincreaseintheprobabilityorconsequencesofanaccidentpreviouslyevaluated;or2.3.createthepossibilityofanewordifferentkindofaccidentfrom'anyaccidentpreviously"evaluated;,or~~involveasig'nificantreductionin"a'margino'fsafety.Theproposedchangewillnothaveanadverseimpactasjudgedagainstthesecriteria.TheproposedTechnicalSpecificationchangeconformstotheintentofregulatoryguidanceandmeetstheCommission'sexample(vi)ofamendmentsthatdonotinvolveasignificanthazardsconsiderationbecausetheresultsofthechangearewithinallacceptablecriteriaestablishedbyregulatoryguidance.Theproposedamendmentdoesnotinvolveanyirreversibleconsequences.Therefore<thereisnounduerisktopublichealthandsafetyandafindingofnosignificanthazardsiswarrantedfortheproposedTechnicalSpecificationchange.
SHIFTSUPERVISOR I/SHIFT(SRO)TECHNICIANS 8REPAIRMEN TECHNICAL COMPUTERSYSTEMSANALYSTHEADCONTROLOPERATORI/SHIFT(RO)CONTROLOPERATORI/SHIFT(RO)AUXILIARY OPERATORS 2/SHIFTCOMPUTERTECHNICIANS FIGURE6.2-5RGSEREV.54$pcf42S C"1I~'
6.3STATIONSTAFFQUALIFICATIONS 6.3.1Eachmemberofthefacilityshallmeetorexceedtheminimumqualifications ofANSIStandardN18.1-1971, "Selection andTrainingofNuclearPowerPlantPersonnel"<
assupplemented byRegulatory Guide1.8>September 1975iforcomparable positions<
exceptfortheShiftTechnical AdvisoriandexceptfortheOperations 1ManagerwhoshallhaveheldanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseforGinna.References 1Ltr.J.Maier(RG6E)toD.Crutchfield (NRC)idatedDecember30'980.6.3-1PROPOSED r4f Attachment BTheproposedchangewoulddeletetherequirement thatthestationOperations Managercurrrently holdanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseandreplaceitwiththerequirement thattheindividual musthaveheldanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseforGinna.TheOperations Supervisor<
towhomtheShiftSupervisors andoperating personnel report<willstillberequiredtomaintainanNRCsenioroperatorlicense.Thus<anindividual onthemanagement chainwillstillberequiredtomaintainalicense.TheANSIN18.1-1971 requirement isonlythattheOperations Managershouldhavealicenseonlyatthetimeofassumingtheposition.
Theproposedrequirements wouldmeetorexceedtheintentoftherequirement.
Theadvantages oftheproposedchangearethattheOperations Managerwillhavemoretimetodevotetomanagingtheoperating organization duetoareducedtrainingcommitment.
Inadditions thebaseofpersonnel whocouldfilltheOperations Managerpositionwillbebroadened toincludenotonlythosecurrently holdingalicensebutalsothosewhohaveheldalicense.Theproposedchangeisacceptable sinceitwillretainthenecessary management knowledge andcontrolswhileimproving theabilityoftheOperations Managertomanagetheoperating organization.
Inaccordance with10CFR50.91<theproposedchangetotheTechnical Specifications hasbeenevaluated againstthreecriteriatodetermine iftheoperation ofthefacilityinaccordance withtheproposedamendment would:1.involveasignificant increaseintheprobability orconsequences ofanaccidentpreviously evaluated; or2.3.createthepossibility ofanewordifferent kindofaccidentfrom'anyaccident previously" evaluated;,or~~
involveasig'nificant reduction in"a'margino'fsafety.Theproposedchangewillnothaveanadverseimpactasjudgedagainstthesecriteria.
TheproposedTechnical Specification changeconformstotheintentofregulatory guidanceandmeetstheCommission's example(vi)ofamendments thatdonotinvolveasignificant hazardsconsideration becausetheresultsofthechangearewithinallacceptable criteriaestablished byregulatory guidance.
Theproposedamendment doesnotinvolveanyirreversible consequences.
Therefore<
thereisnounduerisktopublichealthandsafetyandafindingofnosignificant hazardsiswarranted fortheproposedTechnical Specification change.
I<<<<.<<$JtI~~Jt}}
I<<<<.<<$JtI~~Jt}}

Revision as of 14:05, 29 June 2018

Proposed Tech Spec Changes,Revising Requirements for Station Operations Manager to Hold Senior Operator License
ML17254A450
Person / Time
Site: Ginna Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 07/19/1985
From:
ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML17254A449 List:
References
NUDOCS 8507260038
Download: ML17254A450 (8)


Text

Attachment A1.ReplaceTechnical Specification pages6.2-7and6.3-1withtheenclosedpages.8507260038 850719PDRADOCK05000244P:PDR m'~'i<

R.E.GINNASTATIONOPERATIONS ANDTECHNICAL SECTIONSGROUPORGANIZATIONS OPERATIONS MANAGERTECHNICAL MANAGEROPERATIONS SUPERVISOR (SRO)RESULTSANDTESTSUPERVISOR REACTORENGINEERTECHNICAL PROJECTSSUPERVISOR ENGINEER(S)

SHIFTSUPERVISOR I/SHIFT(SRO)TECHNICIANS 8REPAIRMEN TECHNICAL COMPUTERSYSTEMSANALYSTHEADCONTROLOPERATORI/SHIFT(RO)CONTROLOPERATORI/SHIFT(RO)AUXILIARY OPERATORS 2/SHIFTCOMPUTERTECHNICIANS FIGURE6.2-5RGSEREV.54$pcf42S C"1I~'

6.3STATIONSTAFFQUALIFICATIONS 6.3.1Eachmemberofthefacilityshallmeetorexceedtheminimumqualifications ofANSIStandardN18.1-1971, "Selection andTrainingofNuclearPowerPlantPersonnel"<

assupplemented byRegulatory Guide1.8>September 1975iforcomparable positions<

exceptfortheShiftTechnical AdvisoriandexceptfortheOperations 1ManagerwhoshallhaveheldanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseforGinna.References 1Ltr.J.Maier(RG6E)toD.Crutchfield (NRC)idatedDecember30'980.6.3-1PROPOSED r4f Attachment BTheproposedchangewoulddeletetherequirement thatthestationOperations Managercurrrently holdanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseandreplaceitwiththerequirement thattheindividual musthaveheldanNRCsenioroperatorlicenseforGinna.TheOperations Supervisor<

towhomtheShiftSupervisors andoperating personnel report<willstillberequiredtomaintainanNRCsenioroperatorlicense.Thus<anindividual onthemanagement chainwillstillberequiredtomaintainalicense.TheANSIN18.1-1971 requirement isonlythattheOperations Managershouldhavealicenseonlyatthetimeofassumingtheposition.

Theproposedrequirements wouldmeetorexceedtheintentoftherequirement.

Theadvantages oftheproposedchangearethattheOperations Managerwillhavemoretimetodevotetomanagingtheoperating organization duetoareducedtrainingcommitment.

Inadditions thebaseofpersonnel whocouldfilltheOperations Managerpositionwillbebroadened toincludenotonlythosecurrently holdingalicensebutalsothosewhohaveheldalicense.Theproposedchangeisacceptable sinceitwillretainthenecessary management knowledge andcontrolswhileimproving theabilityoftheOperations Managertomanagetheoperating organization.

Inaccordance with10CFR50.91<theproposedchangetotheTechnical Specifications hasbeenevaluated againstthreecriteriatodetermine iftheoperation ofthefacilityinaccordance withtheproposedamendment would:1.involveasignificant increaseintheprobability orconsequences ofanaccidentpreviously evaluated; or2.3.createthepossibility ofanewordifferent kindofaccidentfrom'anyaccident previously" evaluated;,or~~

involveasig'nificant reduction in"a'margino'fsafety.Theproposedchangewillnothaveanadverseimpactasjudgedagainstthesecriteria.

TheproposedTechnical Specification changeconformstotheintentofregulatory guidanceandmeetstheCommission's example(vi)ofamendments thatdonotinvolveasignificant hazardsconsideration becausetheresultsofthechangearewithinallacceptable criteriaestablished byregulatory guidance.

Theproposedamendment doesnotinvolveanyirreversible consequences.

Therefore<

thereisnounduerisktopublichealthandsafetyandafindingofnosignificant hazardsiswarranted fortheproposedTechnical Specification change.

I<<<<.<<$JtI~~Jt