ML20129H034

Forwards for Implementation,Charter for Preparation of Enforcement Proposal Associated W/Oi Investigation Case 2-90-020 Re Reporting DG Reliability.Nominated Individuals to Review Info Collected by OI Listed

ML20129H034
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	09/16/1993
From:	Murley T Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Matthews D NRC
Shared Package
ML20128F432	List: CLI-94-05, Discusses Commission Order,CLI-94-05,affirming in Part & Reversing in Part LBP-94-06 Re Release of OI Rept ML20128F428 ML20128F447 ML20128F465 ML20128F475 ML20128F489 ML20128F495 ML20128F526 ML20128F542 ML20128F567 ML20128F586 ML20128F609 ML20128F685 ML20128G131 ML20128G152 ML20128G229 ML20128G249 ML20128G267 ML20128G283 ML20128G303 ML20128G317 ML20128G348 ML20128G379 ML20128G431 ML20128G606 ML20128G630 ML20128G716 ML20128G828 ML20128H268 ML20128H290 ML20128H311 ML20128H333 ML20128Q071 ML20128Q076 ML20129F252 ML20129F457 ML20129F532 ML20129F554 ML20129F587 ML20129F716 ML20129G407 ML20129G457 ML20129G551 ML20129G624 ML20129G845 ML20129G873 ML20129G901 ML20129G959 ML20129H012 ML20129H034 ... further results
References
FOIA-95-81 NUDOCS 9610070407
Download: ML20129H034 (13)

Text

_ _

PAE4EGISI0llALANF@lNQ's*LMSTR18UTION OJN

?

,/e es:%,%

y" l'

4 E

^I UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION k

)

WASHINGTON, D.C. 20066-4001 September 16, 1993 MEMORANDUM FOR:

David B. Matthews, Group Chair Vogtle Coordinating Group l

FROM:

Thomas E. Murley, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

SUBJECT:

V0GTLE COORDINATING GROUP CHARTER FOR ENFORCEMENT PROPOSALS RE: 01 CASE NO. 2-90-020 l

Consistent with your role in coordinating activities underway throughout the agency related to Vogtle, enclosed for your implementation' is a charter for the preparation of an enforcement proposal associated with the OI investigation (Case No. 2-90-020) with regard to reporting of diesel generator reliability following the March 20, 1990, Site Area emergency at the Vogtle facility. The objectives of your group's efforts are to review the information collected by 01 as part of their ongoing investigation and develop, for management consideration, a proposal on what enforcement actions may be appropriate related to the alleged wrongdoing.

The following individuals have been nominated by their respective management to serve under your direction in completing this assignment:

OE:

Renee Pedersen Jim Luehman (part time)

RII:

Pierce Skinner NRR:

Darl Hood Duke Wheeler Dick Hoefling, OGC, will serve as Legal Advisor for enforcement-related matters, and Mitzi Young, OGC, will serve as Legal Advisor for hearing-related matters.

Your principal points of contact in 01 are Dan Murphy (OI-HQ) and 1

Larry Robinson (01-RII). Jim Partlow, or his designee, will provide senior management oversight and direction.

I I

I l

/

9610070407 966557 T10N HL

~ ' * *

• PDR FOIA WILMOTH95-81 PDR

I O yNINT @ ISTA David B. Matthews September 16, 1993 If you have any questions regarding these objectives or the enclosed charter, please do not hesitate to contact me or Jim Partlow.

- { h k s ?'

1:

Thomas E. Murley, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regula on

Enclosure:

Charter for Enforcement Proposals i

cc w/ enclosure:

J. Sniezek

~~

T. Murley F. Miraglia J. Partlow S. Varga G. Lainas B. Grimes J. Lieberman L. Chandler B. Hayes S. Ebneter as E. Herschoff Wg A. Herdt R. Pedersen J. Luehman 3%-

P. Skinner B Uryc w

D. Hood t C*

D. Wheeler D.' Hoefling C

M. Young I

l l

i

MN"*! SzainaETiun um.W i

ENCLOSURE CHARTER FOR V0GTLE ENFORCEMENT PROPOSAL PREPARATION l

(0! CASE NO. 2-90-020)

In response to the information briefed by the Office of Investigations (01) on August 18, 1993, to members of senior NRC staff, the Vogtle Coordinating Group is to complete the following actions:

1.

Working with 01, conduct a detailed evaluation of the information and evidence thus far produced by OI's investigation.

2.

Based on the review conducted above and the preliminary findings of 01, identify any violations of NRC requirements and make a preliminary determination of what enforcement action (s) should be formulated in this matter.

3.

If there are potential enforcement actions that may be appropriate based on the evidence that 01 has produced, develop a recommended course of action for management consideration and prepare a draft enforcement package to support the recommended action.

4.

Determine whether the potential enforcement action (s) require consultation with the Commission and, if so, prepare a draft paper to forward the proposed enforcement approach to the Commission.

5.

Identify whether and, if so, what additional investigation / field work by 01 may be needed to allow a determination as to the appropriateness of a particular enforcement measure or to: fully support certain of the proposed enforcement' actions.

6.

If your preliminary detemination is that enforcement is appropriate, prepare the draft enforcement package (Item 3) and Commission paper (Item 4),

l if needed, for management review by October 22, 1993.

7.

In the event that additional 01 effort is required (Item 5), you should notify management as soon as such a determination is made in order to revise the above schedule, if warranted, consistent with 0!'s estimate of the additional effort that may be needed.

W L

N M f/ D M7A? 7 L Z syy s a

$$0?N/Y

~SAk8NS lb

$b 6%A/S

^ % 8.

y?t4 E G. 5 - Ysiuc';S fA /

k,e. -.4 - +op \\

8 59 /$W $0 V

,47 W

??WrE.

M 77Hf= '

/7JSWLE C Dst $ //D

1. iA'fD M/ M EO ;ep /fB d M 1

i pc

?7&AY5 i

of4G 4%4GvfA e CEnr4W co d w

• BA/AEY

~.

l s

s 6s fh

{

/b l

j MCC M 'V

.? cv saac as sevsnes sr $ 4 p fl 7

u.....

l-l lo h

hbb hb h/ hf

$AW d fc/80

?

i f0dW N/NINE 7 A&W C.;QE?47.Bf7/zrEAJ o&DC@cZf b

Yf m,a,, a f8620 Ab765 606tBM6M6 l J s

s e,-

hb

,7W[f i

p

/.Z W

/7MN 8 c

'A "/ats si a sss s

• 6

• sw& nu dure /MdX (7AdL'8 57275 por AS

\\

/a544WNK/"c)l hJ fp.S Oc-W Cp' ft.s EG/ ELF

. r".i,a.i FMAca r= n d b 0

[G {G O T Of)6 SLAY / $

f?

/(-

x_

.m...

_m..

,a D

ew-A / 5 7 / M 2 7 4 ft Y

/5 A,

e S/DE df~

fd fd sf

? TANKS 998.

.a

(

Y6W W(b $ Wf A 'feeswad W

\\

lY/

hS /W N'hk( & z/

j

/ AxH ME N

(Wf fh h

l I

A M ra n na BAJ 4 /'/.

/4 bud 6 hVf//E (WIF8 m L. ?zEs7AeA V fklffa ha@ HXf W AJ

,, - a a Abr ??257a~ nerby WhY Q(

l 78#/72 68 JgzAr sc tadAes/p e d 7l2~/1 nWv' of N n C E M M A/'

--maa 6%US& W 5,brl9/

f/'d Anst fouao sw ptA7 A m ca+5

/

b I

G 6'Y O Y A 5 f/ O C

t<

j

W/YY NSI f)Vf'b;

/?ff $7/9WWSU or

/f l&FJFb A AssaGY o

BUN / ff

( 0801OO VCCEY AlADV)V SAlo i7 f

l TT LWl 76' 4f4NTc El triwhil~

(7 8(GH7' AAtsf~ (aC57?cas)

V fad =

/ M F 699D f:E M M M E D Shbffdh

~

l LES7%Z)/US X) &9W576&

• m

~,

Aofbang4+PE

[

N bf W a

C

^

(pp u.

sM /s sskE sw& fa;e

/raa AWDE20*&foF 70 coceK7

+ "/ VA /W ZEL ABU 6%!B2 /FM?f.

w Sc4/Z ro ss' ' W s e p s wp a

_ZfT2A

,g a m e #"- -

MT

@ 6ple%MJM 7FAf 9 #tus 6cr/G/oL{} A g o1Hr (k nKr wm) car-r smAv60'6 da

@c?ur M/FEdgj&'

$U<BW a K409E d'Mko /WAurcs/.Pr 4

s.,

6,---

w rGe-.o+em--

e y

e I

'.)

1 9

f 7~d MMBY LAdAE J

a 27 97

/l 3b bYS DO e w sc" P 7

-n280'28f SHecCS Hf DM

$h f

V DF M13 At/ESAP7D41

,P') /EbVEEU e s'~

??tMS i.Dxs /

. - - c o, _IS S W kk e,

$N 8

//W

,f' sTGL7: fit.iiintMmue :aw:-.u.

,,o,-,,,,e...,m.. ce;,e.1,.maggjigggg

~-

c.A <..

4 a

i

// 4 0 R ff.

q w s71st/sb uwv 80 sw Mrich fOA 7785 JA6l6 ho(f82Ar#/C WP /, A 2 amusee mua w paesecj rs k

W 4

O YB wr SF SA*YE 9207'"

DJLD DC i

i=al B//Al,

/ W

$2220 WIFE AG/fo A/y',

77NS Gufs cuwp)

AK '725577FMA sEsav4e cowss n

ne n l

t

/' '

l

8ACK,

\\l G

_.,a.a m

i,.~.

e _

c 4__

-.4 L

.a J.r a

.Aa.

I

// f f.5 4.woFAf l

fYfS

/ b b

Oh f $f k M A A YJ A + 2 / W )

2 V E T E L

. r r/ 9 4 7

/YAVA?/x Ach THE

/ 8 A&7 DAME ~

h z.

A ?o d w. r w i

I h

. Y~:,

... ::.. ::..:. ngy.tpm e

i g

94,

/

t3c.\\ A

_ E7D4'T

% WTotY Pot mASA% %WO #9tAL If 4

j S7%%1 t erf t S7%*,T 5749 15%S44 wa.

w e st mu a.

i Ellige e130 es\\S 3% c55-1 1

11114m a4n ieN4 mfimb. tema b %s4ndsk b k uD inease est pas it. =a sur der 3

3)td%4 055 04%.

1.4 7 0 -\\

+ "T

• LW4 ' %t* 0%

lg 9

1htl%

ORE Ot%

sg5n.\\

g 7.w w.ge-eg y

im.

!III' 3

3ht\\%

684%

OMt n

1

mi 6

3})Llie

4M2, SW1 se it f

G. g Nl

'l dlLH6

/ 611

/ejs 347;9 3

+

g

~

1, 3ltd%

J03L

/434 il it i

shal%

/206 taal 7 - tw& - %-e 4 (h4 ime, bT se slat %

one cro6 i,

n wi s c.,wnA, -

4

. ossa o,sase a -

i ti 3146146 etta bu\\

ha g.DMt tem s=k-i

't @

m64=e to se,e..

swhA-os.s* h u3,Sa i

n vu)%

onw\\

ot%s g4 ge*ggen, t#Ane 'To 8ec.

j n

3knlw,

oss6 13n s...A m.

A u,

, sex,\\au

-m

..t.

_a

.a i

- =>

Etic pW Sa m e var w. i.wsse me swa.ggy 4. W im"tsW l

W sluHe sist a, taw stin194 taas ssst 5armeN eksww6% j %*%%

15 86 8'

l its 38146%

st&&

' %sM 7eemMihmNag 11

'3)nah6 615 %

mt5 "A & c.

1

• =

s.

s.

ua

.