Latest revision as of 14:22, 12 May 2020

Text

Prefiled Testimony of AD Justice on 840816 in Glen Rose,Tx. Pp 1-20
	ML20095C081
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	08/16/1984
From:	Justice A; BROWN & ROOT, INC. (SUBS. OF HALLIBURTON CO.), TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To:	;
Shared Package
ML20095C073	List: ML20095C069; ML20095C081; ML20095C093; ML20095C111; ML20095C114; ML20095C120; ML20095C127; ML20095C140; ML20095C145; ML20095C159; ML20095C169; ML20095C180;
References
	OL-2, NUDOCS 8408220371
	Download: ML20095C081 (20)
	v • d • e

~ - - "

M --

-- ~ ~ - ~

% 7.; 3r

~ ; , = 7~ .. _ .y ; ~ {

. _ . m 1

.. . . . ~ L+^ T c r-

/g

_ t ;

. .- m ._ .

s. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , , .

,1 : .

^

~f3- $ b l. M UNITED: STATES OF AMERICA

~

s ,-

NUCLEAR' REGULATORY COMMISSION Ns- 7 .- 2 -:- 'DEFORE THE.ATOMICc SAFETY &. LICENSING BOARD

+<

^

. 3 -IN. --TH E - M ATT E R OF:

) ,

) 00:METEP

-4. TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC ) DOCKET NO EihRC '

1 COMPANY,_ET'AL ) 50-445

)-

. 's . 7 ' 50-44iW AGO 20 P5:03

.(COMANCHE PEAK STEAM )- *

6 ELECTRIC STATION, UNITS- -)

'1'AND 2)~ -

)

NE~'!ULE ; '

- 00CXt.Ilt4G & SERM i 7i -BRANCH 8 >

PREFILED TESTIMONY OF' ALAN DALE JUSTICE

'. 9 AUGUST 16, 1984 10 1 -11 '

, m l12 +- -

13' w .

~

14 -PREFILED TESTIMONY OF ALAN-DALE JUSTICE, taken'

~\ 15 on the 16th day of,' August, 1984, in the above styled

.. + .

I 4: 16- and 'nuinbe red c r. u s e , at. Glen. Rose-Motor Inn' located 17 at Highway 67 & FM Road 201, in-the City of Glen

, 18 Rose, County of Somervell and State of' Texas, before-s.

;19 . Janet E. Schaffer, a-Certified Shorthand Reporter in

!- 20 and;for the State of Texas. '

.o 21 -

~

22 i

23 r , 8408220371 840820 24 PDR ADDCK 05000446 '

^

l.

25 OSn3

,r s

3~ . . .

, ,1,._

j. >-.,

c

~

2'

~ < + w .

f- ' *

[. > . , . ..

1 i .

t-

, -l , APPEARANCES .

e. .- 12 2 BISHOP, LIBERMAN,~ COOK, PURCELL ~ &iREYNOLDS '

. -. , -Attorneys at_ Law ,

.3 1200 Seventeenth Street, N.W.

s D , .- .

Washington,,D.C. 20036 _

i

'4 -

3 (BY McNeill Watkins II, Esq.

.5 -

APPEARING FOR hPPLICANTS 6, w

., 1

-l ?

e i- -

.y 1

- g. 1 v

r- 4

9. _

4 r, .

10' >

.,s ~ 4

<- - i

- n -17 5

x y

,,V L P} -

o- -- 12 ,' -

, e t

'f

'131

! 'I '

<. v. < Yy

-p g ' -4

-;14 - - ' ~

.. s

. ; - o ,

s .i "h p

~ 1 5 .'

-Y . $ '* '

g

~ '

-,16 ' '

e *

, 'y .< _ , ~y7 - + '

, s

. > +

J .-

~ '

1 18 ', v E

,g e ,

I t 19

. s

+

g g; '

s' t'

A -O, ..

'6 6

vp ,

+ . .*#' ,

f '.

s '

- .' . -., ,4 s e.

.,., , . g- , .

I g, .

'I t 1

[

i

,, g 4

. . ,, y s,

"?

w ,

g

- 24 i

,1 9

-g.2 5

~

5 4 t' gi g 3f, F- L M

s) ., .y ,- ~

s ,

j<,

W 'i-

^ + 1 4

Mkdb bh$bk +

't '

_- =-

/. ,.

-^ - -e

~ .

IJ <

ALAN DALE' JUSTICE,

- zs - ,

x

( j- .

2

~

the' witness hereinbefore named, be i ng ' .fi r s t duly.

' cautioned.and sworn to testify theLJtruth' the whole 3

[ 4 truth and nothing but the truth, te'stified ~on his 5 . oath ~ascfollows:

6' .MR. WATKINS: On,the record. This;is

.7 the prepared direct testimony of Alan Justice. Mr.

, 8 JusticeJis a. general, foreman for Brown &LRoot at

. 9

Comanche Peak. lie is appearing here voluntarily-as 10 a witness; he is not-under subpoena by any party.

7 11 My name is McNeill Watkins, counsel for 12 Applicants in'these license proceedings. -

(

' V]-

13 EXAMINATION 14 DY MR. WATKINS:

15 Q. Mr. Justice, would you state your full name, 16 please.

17 A. 7.lan Dale Justice.

18 Q. By whom are you employed, Mr. Justice?

19 A. Brown & Root.

20 Q. Where are you employed?

21 A. Comanche Peak' Steam Electric Station.

22 Q. What is your ~ badge number?

23 A. My badge number is.2371.

~s 24 Q. What is your job title?

(

25 A. Piping general foreman.

E

4:' -

4

~

1 .Q . .How -long have you been a piping general r^%

(_):

2- foreman at Comanche Peak?

3 A. Approximately five' years.

4 Q. How many persons do you supervise?- -

5 'A. -

Approximately 38..

JP ,

Q. Do.those; include foremen?

7 A. Yes, sir. ,

.8 Q. 'How many-foremen do you supervise?- .

,9 A. Three foremen.

10 Q.. And what kind of craftsmen do you supervis'e?

~

11 A. I supervise pipefitters, welders and

~12 ~ helpers. -

-.v fNr '13 Q. Mr. Justice, wereLyou. responsible for 3 -14 completing the construction Work on a part ,of the 15- auxiliary feed system in January 19847 16 , A. Yes, sir, I was.

17 Q. Can you. identify the part of the system for

,18 which.you were responsible?

'19 A. -Yes, sir. We were replacing a valve on the

-20 AFel-SB-007 line.

21 Q. Mr. Justice, I'show you a document that's

-;2 2 been marked for identification as Exhibit 1 to "23 Richard.Simpson's deposition. Can you identify this

,,4 24- document?

i ) , ,

'~'

25 A. Yes, sir. This is a copy of the isometric A

T l_m

- . _ - = -

.s - -

.~ -- - - - - .

~

z,

. , a : 5

~

.j. % .

~

T1.

2 drawing that designated the work that we had to do.

. [ 2.'

~

on this particula ~r'line. . .

, t-7 ' '3: c -0. Is that.a drawing with which your craftsmen 4 work in the field? ,

~ ,

, S' ' -A. 1Yes', sir.

~

6 0.. -Can you identify on'that drawing"the valve 7 on which your. craftsmen' worked in January 1984? ,

8 EA . Yes, sir. It's 1-AF-067.

9 Q. In connection with.that valve, what welding ,

l 10 .operat ions were people"under your supervision f 11 resphnsible for?

12- A. They were responsible for--making. Welds'39C 1 1 ('T 13 and 40C directly on the: valve,.andcin addition' Weld

%)

14 '

34A a little bit farther down the line.

.15 ~Q. Wh'en-did this work ta'ke . pla ce ?

16 A... This work took place between Januarysthe 17 ~ 13th and January the' 17th, 198'.

4 r

18 Q. What were your instructions regarding this '

19 valve replacement * -

,20 A., My, instructions were to get this valve '

'21 ,

replaced and the system on line as soon as possible.

-22 O. Was there a reason for the necessity for

+

. 23 speedy, work?

r.( , 24 A., 'Yes, sir. The Startup Test Engineers were 1 1 I ~25 [ planning some kind of test over in the containment T

l FEDERAL COMHT RED @HTRR@

. - 6 1' Building, and this li ne wa s directly involved with M.

kJ 2 that test.

3- -Q. By what'~date were you instructed that this j,

4 va'Ive replacement had to be completed? .

5 A. January the 14th. i 6

(Q . Do you recall what day.of the. week that was?

e

7 A. That was on a Saturday.

-1 8 Q. When were you given these instructions?

9. A. I was given these instructions January the 10 l'3th.

11. Q. On Friday? ,

12 A. Yes, sir.

J 'N 13" Q. Who gave you these instructions?

y 14 A. Gene Everson, my piping superintendent.

i 15 Q. To-whom did you assign the' responsibility 16 for performing ~this valve' replacement?.

e 17; A. 'Isassigned it.to Hon McBee, oncLof my-

. 18 piping ~ foremen. ,

- 19 Q. When did you assign-him this work?

~2 0 A. ' January the 13th.

21 Q.: RDo.you ~ recall'whether any work was done on 22 this-valve operation or on the associated weldspon 23 Friday, January the 13th?.

n 24 A. .

No, sir.' I,had'many responsibilities <at g

i

)

e 25- that' time,.and I.could not devote my full attention l

1 T2nf.YVWUMMfafLDV2@lfMRf3S

3_c .- - .- -.

^

r g .

L i

'L l P .1

^

t(o E t h i's . o n e p r o j a c t . ,

.y .

x i-- , 2:

O. When' wer e you'able to devote.your full

[ . _ .

L3' attention to this project? .

24. A. Saturday,. January the 14th I became, - -

. $5; d i r e c t l y .i'n v o'1 v e d with"this. '

2 ; - ~

6 s

. 'Q . '

was Saturday.a-normal workday.for welders

' t.

7 and Ipipe fitters under your-supervision? ,

8 A. No, sir.

-9 Q. Did you-instruct <Mr.-McBee to have a- ,

^

10 welding crew report'to work 'on Saturday?

~

- 11 ; A' . Yes,.I did.

m_

12 Q. Was Saturday a normal workday for-QC

(~)

.V.,

13 , inspectors during this' time period?

~

14 A. No, sir.. .,..

~

15 Q. Did you request _that a Oc inspector report 4 16 -for work on Saturday in connection with this welding i

. 17 operation? -

h 18 A .- Yes, sir, I did.

19 .Q.- Who did Mr..McBee have report for work on 20 'these welds on Saturday the 14th?

. 21 A. Ile had Richard Simpson as a fitter,c Jackie i

22 Ables as a welder. '

23 Q. Did you report for work on Saturday the 24 14th?

. th '

25 A, Yes, I did.

ramERA&-MAUMR MRP@MRRRR

8 1 0.- What time did you commence work?

_ 2 A. 7 o' clock in the morning.

3 Q. Do you recall the name of the QC inspector 4 who reported for work?

l 5 A. Yes, sir. It was Jack Stanford.

6' O. What' work did your crew . perform on Saturday 7 morning in connection with this valve replacement?

8 A. Cleanliness and fit *up.

9 Q. Do you know'when actual welding commenced 10 on Saturday?

11 A. I believe it was mid-morning.

- 12 Q. Mr. Justice, were you satisfied with the

) 13 progress of your crew on this operation by noon on 14 Saturday?

15 A. No, sir, I wasn't.

16 Q. What was the nature of your concern?

17 A. The n a t u r e ..o f my concern was it was 18 .becoming apparent that I would not be abic to-19 complete this work as planned.

20 Q. Did it become apparent to you at-some point 21 Saturday that your crew would not finish this job on 22 Saturday, the'date by'which you have testified you 23 were assigned responsibility for completing it?

c 24 A. Yes, it did.

5 25 Q. And what time did that become apparent to 4

t

gg ,_., - - - - - -

g g'*p. -

9 ,. 3 9-

. ,~, +

x

.. x

> ,r<,' , -

~-. , t .

wy y 33, _. . ; _ ,, ., ..

+

- v -

+, ..

1: you? ,- ,

4

(x N

. g

.'.',;5 A..

3: 30 :tha tRaf ternoon.

t. -

(3 ~Q.* What action, if'a'ny,:did.you.take'on the

a- ;

, s .

- 14 1 Lbasis-of that realization?L 1 .

'5 A'. ,

I'got.a conference-together with myself,

16. Ron McBee an'd. Jack Stanford.' We discussed all

't

7- , . aspects of being possible. .to1make this deadline. At.

'8 't h'a t time I decided I couldn't possibly make..it. So

~

.9 SI decided: to send Jack Stanford home'.

. 2 10' Q Why did you do that? ,,

' Ill A. The' reason-was'that IJwould not be able.to il2 complete both'.---all'the wolds, get them prepped and '

e-' -

11 3- have all the NDE requirements met'by that date. I '

e _~

14 ' realized"that my crew was not. going to be able to a _

.15 finish.its work on.this job for many hours. We had 716; called,a QC inspector in.especially to provide QC '

. + ,

J17- support for this operation, and'if. we-asked him to -

18 stay, he would.-jUst 'b e sitting around oing nothing. I

, - 19 didn't believe Brown'& Root should pay anyone to sit! ,

20 around,'so1 1,. told him he could go.

gn .

E v.

. : 21 Q. Was this a difficult decision for you to, 1

^

1^ g

, ,-;22 make, Mr. Justice? e' 23 A. ~Yes, it was. '

. .; 24 Q. Why was tit difficult?

I

- 25 A. It was difficult because at that time I 4 ,

- = -

. . . - - . ~ ~ -- . . . .

j, '

10 I x ~ ~

s

,, s. ', , i !

g .s

. + ,

^

1" realized,that'I didn't meet the time-limit that I

' s

p. .

r* ,

,' l O ..

J

~2- and my supeiintendent had set for myself and I

,Y i

I

'3 re'ilizedji iss rot: going to make it.

j ',,

,s 1 4 ]' '

Q. .f S 'a w , you've testified'that your crew was -

s .f i

. 51 4

~behind y,our. schedule on thes's welding operations. ,

.i i s' 6.. Did'you send (help to the crew at. some.. time Saturday?

, '7 =A. Y e s ,s-s i r , I did. I had another welder

,8 available when he completed another project in ;

t

,9- another area. When he.did this, I brought him over [J 2 10' 'to~ aIsis;tl in'the welding ope'ations. r

, l11 t -y t~ O '.

-And who was that welder? -

1N ^

> 12- 'p: i A ., t y The. welder was'Danny Wrihht. ,

13 Q r4 Justice, wh n did'your crew complete.

". ~

, a 14 its weidi'ng on these three welding operations? .

't . I,.'

(

i

j 15. 'A ). ' n Approximately' midnight.

,e ,,\

Qi< WeYehthe welds then ready for QC final

.. 16 '

' ;, 'r% o ,% -

'.). 17' ~ inspection? .'

,; , ' 18 - A . E < s'o ,' a i r ., '

<t .l, .

/

" 4,s . ,15 T 4 '

, Q. ,what additional steps had to be taken? '

l ;

r . .. '\

, '.)0[S, 7 A. ,',T h e s e f w e l d s .h a d. to be prepped where-they e J wy V,

        ,y                         i21:                              could, perform -- whore,they could periorm the NDE                                                                                            .

y [';,p g g ; } Q. + ' + 4 . r 22 requirements on~them. ;

           ..                 C'd'                                               ' ..O.                Wouldf -you de' scribe-the.. prep process?
      ?                   "U v 2 3 -                                                                                           
       ;,            3                    ,"                           .

fc c, o.

                                 ; 24(                                               A}., av . s , s i r . , The weld,is flat-topped, and the                                                                                    >

v /. r

                                    .       c                                  .
                                                                                                                    ~

d5 ed[esiif the.' beads 2are. blended ~ 1nto the a'djoining

,. a i

w['h pt x nrwnmi;manxra n .;> v fh(f } \,^. _a-a

777 . _ . , - - - - . S , 11-do r . . s ,, .s. . 1 pipe oruvalve, which gives the. weld a smooth

  .m                             ,'                                           .,

b'. 2 ' configuration. Is prepping a weld a standard operation in

3. . . Q.

4 connection with Lwelding?

  .      ..                        ' ~5 A.: ,     'Yes, s i r '.

6 -Q.,..What is the~ purpose of this process?

                                      '7                          A.        'The purpose is to prepare the weld'for NDE                           -

8- inspections. The procedure is-to make the weld as. 9 smooth as possible where, when they perform a PT, 10 , there is no possible indications on the: surface of 11 the weld that might give a. wrong indication. Or 12 'when the weld [is RT'd, that a surface indication ,

                                . 13                   would not show up on the' film, give them a false                                    a

[(~L.} - 14 reading.

                               "15'                              'Q.          What is a PT?

16 A. Penetrant test. ' 17 Q. What is.an RT? l Radiographic test. 18 A. 19 Q. Did your crew complete its weld prep , 20 process some time that night? 21 A.. Yes, sir, we did. 22 Q. At.what time did they complete it? 23 A. Approximately 2:15. 24 Q. Were all of the crew still there, utill at i- ,

l [# 25 work? l ItMUUMA_feAMF$Lmmg:6mthm

                       , '                                                                                                           ^

y ,

               ,F
                                                                            -                                                  12 9                                                             a l'                   A .' -   No, s i'r .

s 1 1

                                                                   ;Who had left?
               ._/                   '2.                   O.

O - 3 A. I had sent Ron McBee, Richard simpson and 4 Danny Wright h'o m e around 1:30. 4 5 .Q. So that l e f t - Jy'o u a n d Mr. Ables; is that

                                   -6             correct?                            '
                  <                   7               . A.       Yes, sir.            ,
                                                                                      .. i
         ,                            8_                  -0        Now, you've testified that the purpose of

, 9 the weld prep process is to prepare the welds for QC (10 'nspection. i We rd' the re any-QC inspectors available 11 to peri'orm NDE examinations at 2:30 Sunday morning?

                                                                                    ~
                                   ~12                     A.       Not to my know1' edge.
                                   .13                              Why,then did you prepare the welds?

y(3-0. 14 - A. Forl expediency sake. I. wanted these welds

   ,                                15_            ready for~ final visual                    hnd penetrant: inspections 16            first thing Monday morning.                       Also, I ' w a's going to 17-           submit these. welds for'RT when I .as.                      w   leaving. We 18            had RT inspectors working on Sunday nights'then.

If

                                  -19'        -they could get these welds shot, then I would.have 20            that much less work ~ to.do on Monday raorning when we--
 ~                                                                                                     ~ '

21- came in. ' 22- -0. Was it your intent that the -final VT o'r PT

                ,                   23            on' these.; welds.be performed at.any time Sunday?

24 , A. N o ', sir. . O - When did ,,ou request that RI be performed-

                                   -25                     O.                       y
                   .-.s--

g- ,.+ ~ _ - __ ,,. 5 13- - I

                  ,-                             1                on '. the se welds?
        /~ n                                 . .

im Vi .2 /, - A. Sunday; night. ~

                                            '3-             ',                     'Q.              I _s ' t h e r e a form.for such RT requests?

m 4- A. Yes, sir,'there is.

                                                                                                  -Did.you prepare t h'e 'f o r m for'these welds?

5 Q. 6' A. No, sir,'Il:didn't.

                  .                  ~~ 7                                         'Q.              Who did prepare the requests?
                                                                  ~
                                                               *S 8:,                3                 A.             Ron McBee.
- -                                      (9                                         Q.             Did'Mr.'McBee submit these forms to the
                                                                                                                                                                              ~

10 'radiographers? , 11 A. No, sir, he didn't.

                                  - 12'                                             O.             Who did?
       -(]~-

13,

                                                                                   .Ai            'I       did.               -

14 :0 Mr. Justice, 1811 show you three exhibits 15 tha t "have; be'en (ma rk ed for'identificati~n o as McBee 16 Exhibits l',-2 and'3, a n d ' I ,' l l ask you to identify,

                                     -17                         t h o s e , s p'l e a s e .                                                     >

18 A. These'are the.[RT requests that were made uit lm. .19' by.Ron'McBee that-I submitted.to the RT trailer t'he L L - 20 -night of-the'14th. F^ - 21 G. Was anyone at the RT' trailer at that itime? 2 2' 'A. No. I le f t' the forms where they would be-23 ~ sureLeo see them.

                                    ' 24                                            Q.            ;Where is"the aT trailer?

h_' -

                                     ,25-                                           A.
                                                                                      ~

TheJRT-trailer is up on the. hill about'150

4

    -        r
                             . -       L'             . .             . - _ , - .          __        ,-,-,_        _@@@@@ & @O@RT.. REPORTERS _              _ , _   _

i < 14 h .-

. .- 1 yards east of the plant site.

      . ('\                                                                         .
      ' if                                 2                         0            When did you leave work on Sunday morning?
                                                                            ^

3 A.- At 2:30. 4 Q. When was.the next time you reported back to 5 -work?' 6 A.. Monday morning at 7 o' clock. 7 0. Did.you learn at that time whether an RT s-.

8' had been performed on these welds?

9. A. -Yes, sir, I ~did.

~ ' 10- O. What were the results?,

                                       '11 ,                         A.           We had two accepted RT's and one rejected 12;                  RT.

N

      ' L./ ;.

13 .Q. Which welds had'been' accepted? 14' A. Field Weld 39C and Weld 34A on AF-laSB-7 15 were accepted..

                                                                                          '                ^

16. O. Did you order any further. action.with t~

17 respect, to,those . welds? . V ;18 ~A. No, sir. '

c .

                                       - 19;                         Q.           Did. you1take any further-. action with
                                                                          ~           ~

2 01 . respect,to the weld thatshad been rejected? V ; m 12- 2.l ' A. Yes, sir.' - n; , Y

                      +
                                       ,22
                                                                  ' Q.           What weld was that?

23 - A. That~was" Field" Weld40C.- f .

                                                                                                                                                                  ^
            ,q                          24                           QL-         .What~ action did you'take?.                                           '
          ,       L               .cc
                                   ~', 2 5 .                         A .-         I instructed Ron McBee to-get?the.-weld m
   ~[#                 ,

A r [ -

            -+s      f                                                                ;,                                   .

_a J.?

                                                     .u_                                                      fhhkk' khk_k
                                                                                                                    ~

0

      .-                                                                                                                   ,-m-yK              ,

l ~" 157

         ~
     > r, ,-              '
                                                 #1.            fixed 7as soon a s . po s s i b l e .'                                                             , ,

y

       ,(cp t

l' '52 , , _Q. ,Did you'personall pa'rticipate in that 1 l

1 process?' *

                                             .c 3                                                                                                                                                                    g g,                                  -

3'

     $                                             4                         .-A.               . La te r tiha t: afternoon 1 got directly w.

5= . involved with mak'ing-surc~~the weld' repair was. _

       ~',, +                                                                                                                    , ,
                                                                                                                                                                                       +                             -

6; completed. '- .. . y

                                      ,     r.
                 .                                 7f                ,
                                                                                   ' O '.       -When;did your. crew . complete ^its work.on                                                                       .
      -                                           .8 ,          that' repair?                                                                -

r.

                                               ~
                                               ._ 9                                  A.          Approxima'tely 7'o' clock that n i g h t .'
                                            '10'                                     O.           Do y'o u .k now whethe^r.another RT wa's                               -                -

i , .. 11 r e q u e s t e'd ' . wi t h r_e s pe'e t : to- tha tiweld ?~ > 12' A .- Yes,< sir.3 '

                                                                                            $                                                                                                    e                     1
        - /~i'                              (13                     V                Q.           Was 'a~ form similar,to McBee Exhibit 3
     - %) -                                                                                                              .
                                                                                                                                                                                                               ,4
                                             .l 4 -           . prepared {for an'RT request 7 s

15 A.- Yes, sir. , t . 16 -Og DidJyou prepare it? .

     %                                                  4

17 A' . , No,-sir. _ _.

1 18' 'O. Who.did:' prepare it?

                ,                               19:                                  A .-         Ron;McBee.

20. =0 Who submitted that request to RT?

'           "                      , J21                                           .A.            I did.t
                                                                                                          ~

22' O. . I'll show youfa document that's been 23 identified as McBee Exhibit I4'and ask you if you can 24 videntify that document. _ h-

                              ,                 2 5' Y

A. .Yes, sir.. .This is the document that we x

                                                  ~~                                                                                           ._

c. - FEDERAL COURT REPORTERS .

16 s b 7 .

                                            ' 1' '             submitted.                                              <

i;g , i

                                ,              2'                               O.-        i W6uld you describe your submittal of"t'his
 ,                                        , 3-                 document to RT?
       .w.

4 'A. 'Yes, sir. When we-finished this weld and 5 g t the prep completed, I was' walking out the door 6' ~'of the~ roomrand there'was two radiographers in the f7 . direct areas that we were at. At that time I did 8- not h a'v e ' t o take it up the, hill and present it 9 ' personally to the RT group. r-

p. 10' O. When did you'. learn t h'e results of the s

11 second RTfon Field Weld-40C?,

                                       ;12 A. .         Tuesday morning.

(~~'y . 13 ' O. 'And wha ts wa s .: tha t result? .

             ,J
 ;                                     : 14 '-                                  A.-          It was an accepted RT.

a .

               ,                           15-                                 'Q.         -Mr.. Justice,Eprior to the time that you
                                    ' :16                 ,
                                                              ' learned? that the seco'nd RT had~been, accepted as.

r

                         ,             '17                      satisfactory, Nad a' final; visual , test or a final' 18                  p e n e t r a n t' .; t e s t been. performed by QC~on Field' Weld s                                                                                                                .x           >
                                                              '40C?
                                       ..19                              .

w k .1 2

                                       ' 2 0, }                            . A.              No, ~ sir,~1t had not.- -                         +

J u s ti c e', _. i s .th e r e any way that aIfinal

                                      \21}

3 - Q.- -Mr.

[22 . visual testfor penetrant testicould-have been n-23, performed on'. Field Weld 40C on Satur_ day,. January the ~

                                       ;24 )                    14th?

s. n h-

                                     . K:                              '

125;, _ LA.- 'No, sir.; x- *

                                                   .p:      <
                                                     >(

r ? . >s, > > > i: .r . c.2_ L. hM)hitM fRTR/*2(6)fDWkfR}% - __

g. _ .. -- - . .

                                                                                                                                                                                           , ,. -                 -             -       -     ~       - -.             . - . - - - . -
                                                '                                    "' '                                F                  *                                                    .f,,
                                          ; *r

f - 17

                                                                     ; .                                              s        ,
   . (x. .:. .
                                 * :I -                       .
                                                                           . , ,         .x.,,

3 4 e. _g'. :

l' - Q.; Why is'that? '

       . . 6,                                           .
                                                                                          .         y,                     ,
                             . i ,  " , ~ 2 . - .                                                                A.-                            Because the welds.were'not. completed.

n-3 /(- r l . Q. M r .' Ju s ti ce , didLyou~~ever discuss with Jack

2 7 l, '4 Stanford c ha ng i~ng the dates on the QC hold points.on 5 fa weld; data card with respect -to: Field Weld 40C? J 6 '- A. 'N o , sir.. - - 7 Q. Does tha t .' concl ude f yo u r testimony, Mr. [

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ~
          -: u                                                   . ._                                 .
                                                                                                                 . 3..    .

s 8 Justice?. > v .c

                                                                    '91                                            A.                             Yes, it ~does.                                                                                                                             -                                  ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,.                                                 <  4 s                                                          <10                                            "

NR..WATKINS: Thank you, M r .' Justice. 1 l' .

                                                                                                                                                                                                       ~
        .                                                     ~12 -t -                                               ;-

y, e ,

__ . , . ~

13. -

j i' . ;14 - J15.

                                                                                                                                                     .                         .<-                                                                                                                                    ;~

16' i~ '

q7.,

w ev, 1 3.x s .. - .

                                                            ~ 18 -                                                    ,

V'I pi , - 19 , s ,

a, .: , :

                                                      .-20 21
                                                          ~

s. l^ - , . t,

                                                                      }_
                   '~                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              E
      .-                                                                                            ,                                                                        s
                       ^

F t 23~, . f .-

                                                          = 2' 4 ~-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   -s r                                                4 ', 25 -                                                                                                                 -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ~

I I< t l- ,, a l 7 s.

  ','IT                               v                 - .

A lr ^ _ FEDERAL COMF2R TREE ff 0 R91E RS __ .' . , _ _ . _ . _ _ . _ . _ _

                                  ~'                                               '
                                                                                                                                                                ,-                    18 t.
                                                                            ~

. ~ l , CORRECTIONS AND SIGNATURE

       ,. T'j .

9. , ~

2 PAGE/LINE CORRECTION REASON FOR CilANGE

                                              .3,,

4 5'

                                                                                                                                                                                  ^
                                              .6 f

7 - 8'

 .                                               9                                                                                                                                -

i 10

                                            ,11 -

i

                   .                         12-I
          ?                   ,

f. : 14

                                                                                                                                                  ~
                                                     .s
         .^
                                          = 15             =                                                                                                                                   -

16' _ 17~ - I, ALAN DALE JUSTICE, have' read the ~

                                                                                                                                                                           ,              t.

18 foregoing deposition, and'hereby affix'my signature

~ '

thatJsame-is true.and correct, except as noted 19 he' rein. .

                                                                                                                                                                                                   .] ,,
                          .,,                20                                   ,
                                                                                                                     -ALAN DALE JUSTICEE
                                          . 21 '                       SUBSCRIBED'and sworn to'before.me this the                 --

d a y :: o f ' , 1984. ,

                                          .2 2 -                                                                          -,
                                                                                                                                                                                      ~

A -231. = NOTARY.PUBLIC for-. thel . State'of' Texas: - 24' -'My" Commission- Expires s' O

            %)   '

25-r

                                                        .}
                                                                                                                             .y
     *i "'

1r#%brtm/AW @@MRW REPORTERS

, . . . . . - - . ~; - - - -

p. ;---.

t v- ( .e t 19 ',

1 STATE LOF' TEXAS )- t g p .L q.) . 2

                     ;                          3                   *I,.       Janet.E. .Schaffer, RPR, Certified Shorthand:

4 m- _

                                                                                                                                                          ~
                                             '4'           Reporter iniand for the State.of Texas,Jde_hereby-
                                                                                                                                                                       ^
                                               -5          certify'thatthere came before ine on the 16th' day of s                                                                                   s 6-       ' August,'A. 'D.,.1984, cat the-Glen Rose Motor Inn, 7        . Glen Rose,-Texas, t h e' following named person,-to-wit 8         Alan Dale Justice, who.'was by' me dulp' sworn:to E -                                                                                                    '

9- testify'the' truth-and nothing but'the truth of his 10 l knowledge touching a,nd-concerning the m a t t e r s . i n -- 11 . controversy i n _ t h'i s cause; and bbatthe was thereupon v - ' 12 examined upon his oath and his examination reduced

                                    .                                                                             ~                                                              .~

M'i 13 '. to writing; same t'o be-sworn and-subscribed to by

   ~ \_/                                                   ,                       ,
                                                                  ~

14 .said witness before any1 notary publice-O . .. 15- - -

16 I further' certify that'I.am n e i t h e r' a,t t o r n e y-. o r

                                          '17              counsel for, nor.related to orcemployed by, any of
                                                                                                                                                               ~

L

                                .          18             ~the parties to the action in which this deposition
                                                                                     .:-                              t
                                          .19               is taken, and further that{I am not a r ela tii ve or
                                         ~ 20            ' employee of any attorney.or counsel employed-by the.
                                  " - ,21                   parties hereto, or financ.ially; interested in the 12 2             action.                                                                 -

23 : 24: '

                                                                    .In witness whereof, I have hereunto set my hand                                                                .

Q 25 .and-affixedJmy seal this day of August' , A.D.,

N

                         .,s-                                 . .._ _ - _ -, .                                                    .-._ _ .             . _ , ~. _ _ . - . . . . .,

y < 20 *

                                                                               $                          Y                                                                              >
                          ,                                                              i;                 -.
                                                                                                                                                                                      -)                                                                  . "*,

vt

                                                                                                        -1984'.

c '1 3 -.- c: -

::.. : 2 _, .

s, '

                                                ~                .<
                                                                        '3                                                                                                                   *
                                                                                                                       ,                                                   JANET E.:SCHAFFER,;1543,'RPR,:CSR
                                                                         -4                                                                                                 IN.AND FOReTIIE STATE 0F TEXAS                                                                                                i
                                                  .                                                                                                                         1226 Commerce, Suite _411
                                                                       >s5                                                                                                 Dallas, Texas                          .,7 5 2 0 2                                                           y
                                    ~.,..                          ,

(214) 742-30351

                                                                  ,-.6                                                                                 '

[ 7- JNy$com. mission expires December 31, 1985 4 ! %.. . 8

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      .a-s 9 ',   ,
                                                                     -10 i
     .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      . ~
                                                                                                                             $                                                                                                                          t "11 -                                                                      .

s g b' 4,

m

                                                                     -1 47                       z--  .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ~
                                                                     ;15.                                                                                                                                                                                             .     . .-                    .

i s

                         -m ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ",                                ,
                                                                                                                                                                    ~                                                                                                                ' '
                                                                    . 16. * :.                                           .

y- . .

                                                            ~,. 171-                                                           ,

y _

18

Y'

                                                       .               19-                   ,
                     .a .

s

                            '                ~

s; ~20 E.,, N T a v21-

A- ,

                                      .                              .22                 w                                                                                                                                          ,.                              ,

I 3 J ~ y

_. :24 '

(O' . 2 51' . 0 a

                                                                                                                                                                    ,k                                                        g              *
                                                                                                                                                                   .#         MR- MMmW .EMMRRM_ '                                                                                                             71}}

ML20095C081: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 14:22, 12 May 2020

Text

Navigation menu

ML20095C081: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 14:22, 12 May 2020

Text

Navigation menu

Search