ML19225A291: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:- - _-- .- - | {{#Wiki_filter:- - _-- .- - | ||
g' | g' | ||
[ NRC PUBLIC DCCUMENT RCOM CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I he. eby certify tnat copies of Revised page 21 of CASE SUFFLSIE:T 20 PETITICN FOR LEAT : TO I:ITERYE'iE A:ECC:i~'ENTIcNS of 5/7/79 and Revised AFFIDA7If CF MARILYN STINSCN | [ NRC PUBLIC DCCUMENT RCOM CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I he. eby certify tnat copies of Revised page 21 of CASE SUFFLSIE:T 20 PETITICN FOR LEAT : TO I:ITERYE'iE A:ECC:i~'ENTIcNS of 5/7/79 and Revised AFFIDA7If CF MARILYN STINSCN | ||
'of 5. 22/79 in Dceket :ios. 50-445 and 50 kh6 have been served on the fellowing by hand deli ~ery+ or cy depcsit in tne U. S. = ail, fir.;t clase** as indicated belev by the asterisZ or double asterisk, this 23rd day of May,' 1979; I have alac sent Mr. Fouke rand W . Gay, by First Class Mail today, copies of the 5/18/79 ALAE-549 decision. | 'of 5. 22/79 in Dceket :ios. 50-445 and 50 kh6 have been served on the fellowing by hand deli ~ery+ or cy depcsit in tne U. S. = ail, fir.;t clase** as indicated belev by the asterisZ or double asterisk, this 23rd day of May,' 1979; I have alac sent Mr. Fouke rand W . Gay, by First Class Mail today, copies of the 5/18/79 ALAE-549 decision. | ||
Lwrence J. Chandler e Mr.. Dick Fcuke W* f Counsel for U2C Staff C7UR U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=:issica 14C0 Eemphill Washington, D. C. 20555 Ft. Worth, Texas 761Ch | |||
Lwrence J. Chandler e Mr.. Dick Fcuke W* f Counsel for U2C Staff C7UR U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=:issica 14C0 Eemphill | |||
. Elizabeth C . Ecvers, Esq. , Chair =an* Atc=?c ' Safety and Licensing Ecard Panels .,< | . Elizabeth C . Ecvers, Esq. , Chair =an* Atc=?c ' Safety and Licensing Ecard Panels .,< | ||
Af.c:nic Safety and Licensing Ecard U. S. Nuclear degul tory Cc =ission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=nission , | Af.c:nic Safety and Licensing Ecard U. S. Nuclear degul tory Cc =ission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=nission , | ||
Washingten, D. C;. 2C555 | Washingten, D. C;. 2C555 Washington, D. C. 20555 Atccie Safety ar.d Licersing Appeal Lester Kornblith Esq.,Me=ber 4 Fanel'(5) $..g-Atc=1c Safety a 1 Licensing Scard U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=:ission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cac:=1ssion Wachington, D. C. 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555 i Decketing and Service Sectica (L) 4A | ||
Washington, D. C. 20555 Atccie Safety ar.d Licersing Appeal Lester Kornblith Esq.,Me=ber 4 Fanel'(5) $..g-Atc=1c Safety a 1 Licensing Scard U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=:ission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cac:=1ssion Wachington, D. C. 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555 i Decketing and Service Sectica (L) 4A | |||
- Richard Cole, Esq., Me=ber % Office cf tne Secretary . | - Richard Cole, Esq., Me=ber % Office cf tne Secretary . | ||
Atcc:ic Safety and Licensing Ecard < U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=.ission U. S. Nuclear Reg..latory Cc=nission Washington, D. C. 20555 Washingten, D. C. 20555 Nichclas S. Reynolds y , | |||
Atcc:ic Safety and Licensing Ecard < U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=.ission | |||
U. S. Nuclear Reg..latory Cc=nission Washington, D. C. 20555 Washingten, D. C. 20555 | |||
Nichclas S. Reynolds y , | |||
Debevcis & Liber =an-1200 - lith St., N. W. | Debevcis & Liber =an-1200 - lith St., N. W. | ||
Wasninrten, D. C. 2CO36 | Wasninrten, D. C. 2CO36 | ||
/} | /} | ||
V(Mrs.) Juanita Ellis, President Mr. Geeffrey M. Gay f CASE (Citizens Asscciation for Scund Enercy) | V(Mrs.) Juanita Ellis, President Mr. Geeffrey M. Gay f CASE (Citizens Asscciation for Scund Enercy) | ||
Line 53: | Line 37: | ||
Austin, Tenas 73711 p' V | Austin, Tenas 73711 p' V | ||
4 08 g 3 H | 4 08 g 3 H | ||
nf | nf u[a\ w"s e r.:. | ||
g' b "s | |||
u[a\ w"s | 428 045 Non p 7 @ &, % 'e i | ||
g' b | |||
,\ s | ,\ s | ||
I further proof in the form of ec=parisons aith other studies by the applicant to substantiate the stated figure. | I further proof in the form of ec=parisons aith other studies by the applicant to substantiate the stated figure. | ||
The report " Nuclear Pcver Costs," a report by the subec==ittee en Environ- | The report " Nuclear Pcver Costs," a report by the subec==ittee en Environ- | ||
Line 79: | Line 55: | ||
In the May 7, 1979 issue of FORTUNE =agazine, Peter N. Skinner, an environ-mental engineer in the New York State atterney general's effice, is qucted as saying: , g cy, S | In the May 7, 1979 issue of FORTUNE =agazine, Peter N. Skinner, an environ-mental engineer in the New York State atterney general's effice, is qucted as saying: , g cy, S | ||
ny- eo 4sy a | ny- eo 4sy a | ||
* See Ccntention No. 6. 2, felleving. $ y eg> | * See Ccntention No. 6. 2, felleving. $ y eg> | ||
, y 428 046 w" | , y 428 046 w" | ||
e COUNTY OF SOMERVELL STATE OF TEXAS AFFICAVIT OF MARlLYN STINSON 1, Marilyn Stin:en, being duly sworr. on oath, state the following: | e COUNTY OF SOMERVELL STATE OF TEXAS AFFICAVIT OF MARlLYN STINSON 1, Marilyn Stin:en, being duly sworr. on oath, state the following: | ||
: 1. That I am a resident of the municipality of Glen Rose, Somervell County, Texas, and that I live at 506 Barnard. . | : 1. That I am a resident of the municipality of Glen Rose, Somervell County, Texas, and that I live at 506 Barnard. . | ||
Line 92: | Line 65: | ||
: 4. That our home, personal and business property are located within five (5) miles of the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant. | : 4. That our home, personal and business property are located within five (5) miles of the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant. | ||
5 That I am a charter member of CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy) and have been a member for over five years. | 5 That I am a charter member of CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy) and have been a member for over five years. | ||
: 6. That for the reasor,s stated in the most recent Petition for Leave to Intervene and Contentions filed by CASE in Docket No. 50-445 and 50-446, dated May 7, 1979, the licensir g for operation of the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant I will constitute a serious threat to our property and our health, safety and i environment. Specifically, such threat from the routine or emergency operation | : 6. That for the reasor,s stated in the most recent Petition for Leave to Intervene and Contentions filed by CASE in Docket No. 50-445 and 50-446, dated May 7, 1979, the licensir g for operation of the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant I will constitute a serious threat to our property and our health, safety and i environment. Specifically, such threat from the routine or emergency operation of the Comanche Peak plant includes: ininediate or later death, cancer, other health probletas, excessive danger to me personally from the effects of low-level radiation due to my heart condition, destruction c- loss of our home, personal and business property, and possibly irreversible damage to the environment. | ||
of the Comanche Peak plant includes: ininediate or later death, cancer, other health probletas, excessive danger to me personally from the effects of low-level radiation due to my heart condition, destruction c- loss of our home, personal and business property, and possibly irreversible damage to the environment. | |||
7 That for this reason, I have authorized CASE to represent me in the public ! | 7 That for this reason, I have authorized CASE to represent me in the public ! | ||
health, safety and environmental aspects of the operating license hearings for the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant. , i "Rio ~ | health, safety and environmental aspects of the operating license hearings for the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant. , i "Rio ~ | ||
n'i fQ $$c) | n'i fQ $$c) | ||
Ma'rilyn Stinson ~~ | Ma'rilyn Stinson ~~ | ||
V Somervell County State of Texas - | V Somervell County State of Texas - | ||
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 22nd day of May, 1979 n 22 Notary P o' lit | Subscribed and sworn to before me this 22nd day of May, 1979 n 22 Notary P o' lit | ||
Line 105: | Line 75: | ||
~ | ~ | ||
\ | \ | ||
P (of ficial seal) if 4Ab 4 a # #' 4, % - | P (of ficial seal) if 4Ab 4 a # #' 4, % - | ||
423 047 s- a. e hy& N 6 | 423 047 s- a. e hy& N 6 | ||
\ //}} | \ //}} |
Latest revision as of 03:52, 2 February 2020
ML19225A291 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Comanche Peak ![]() |
Issue date: | 05/23/1979 |
From: | Ellis J Citizens Association for Sound Energy |
To: | |
References | |
PLED-790507, NUDOCS 7907180768 | |
Download: ML19225A291 (3) | |
Text
- - _-- .- -
g'
[ NRC PUBLIC DCCUMENT RCOM CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I he. eby certify tnat copies of Revised page 21 of CASE SUFFLSIE:T 20 PETITICN FOR LEAT : TO I:ITERYE'iE A:ECC:i~'ENTIcNS of 5/7/79 and Revised AFFIDA7If CF MARILYN STINSCN
'of 5. 22/79 in Dceket :ios. 50-445 and 50 kh6 have been served on the fellowing by hand deli ~ery+ or cy depcsit in tne U. S. = ail, fir.;t clase** as indicated belev by the asterisZ or double asterisk, this 23rd day of May,' 1979; I have alac sent Mr. Fouke rand W . Gay, by First Class Mail today, copies of the 5/18/79 ALAE-549 decision.
Lwrence J. Chandler e Mr.. Dick Fcuke W* f Counsel for U2C Staff C7UR U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=:issica 14C0 Eemphill Washington, D. C. 20555 Ft. Worth, Texas 761Ch
. Elizabeth C . Ecvers, Esq. , Chair =an* Atc=?c ' Safety and Licensing Ecard Panels .,<
Af.c:nic Safety and Licensing Ecard U. S. Nuclear degul tory Cc =ission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=nission ,
Washingten, D. C;. 2C555 Washington, D. C. 20555 Atccie Safety ar.d Licersing Appeal Lester Kornblith Esq.,Me=ber 4 Fanel'(5) $..g-Atc=1c Safety a 1 Licensing Scard U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=:ission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cac:=1ssion Wachington, D. C. 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555 i Decketing and Service Sectica (L) 4A
- Richard Cole, Esq., Me=ber % Office cf tne Secretary .
Atcc:ic Safety and Licensing Ecard < U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=.ission U. S. Nuclear Reg..latory Cc=nission Washington, D. C. 20555 Washingten, D. C. 20555 Nichclas S. Reynolds y ,
Debevcis & Liber =an-1200 - lith St., N. W.
Wasninrten, D. C. 2CO36
/}
V(Mrs.) Juanita Ellis, President Mr. Geeffrey M. Gay f CASE (Citizens Asscciation for Scund Enercy)
West Texas Lep.1 Ser rices 1h26 S. F01%
EC6 W. 2. Jaggener Building Callas, Texna 75224 810 Ecusten Street 21k/9h6-9h--6 Ft. Werth, Tenas 761L2 Riccard W. Lcverre, Esq. A ,
Assis ann Attcrney General ( % @f /
I:re-~-a Prctectica Divisica p
?. O. Een 125L.3, Capitel Statica g:$
Austin, Tenas 73711 p' V
4 08 g 3 H
nf u[a\ w"s e r.:.
g' b "s
428 045 Non p 7 @ &, % 'e i
,\ s
I further proof in the form of ec=parisons aith other studies by the applicant to substantiate the stated figure.
The report " Nuclear Pcver Costs," a report by the subec==ittee en Environ-
=ent, Energy, and Natural Resources of the Cc=mittee on Government Operations of the Ecuse of Representatives, released April 26, 1978, yields far different figures. It states, in part:
s
" Dis =antling a nuclear plant nov =ay cost anywhere from $31 =1111cn to = ore than $100 Milion in 1977 dollars -- between 3 percent and lo percent of the
$1 billion capital cost. Even the higher figures, however, do not include perpetual care costs for rubble frca the plant containing radicactive nickel which may remain hazardcus for up to 1 5 million years. After 30 to LO years, the expected lifespan of a nuclear plant, decc=missionirg costs would quad-ruple (assuming 5 percent annual inflation) .
"But these figures are all estimates, frcm the lovest to the highest, and no one really knows how such it will cost or who will pay the bill to de-cc==ission this Nation's coc=ercial nuclear reactors. Decocnissioning ecsts therefore represent substantial unkncvn costs of nuclear-generated electricity
-- costs ratepayers =ay be burdened with LO years af ter the reactor startup date."
If the a=ount for decc==issicnir4 the CPSES vere figured to be 3% or 10%
of the current cost of construction, il,7CO,500,000 ($17 billion plus $5CO,CCO estimated for the ecst of correcting the errer in design of the second reacter+),
it would yield a figure of between $51 millien and $170 million.
In the May 7, 1979 issue of FORTUNE =agazine, Peter N. Skinner, an environ-mental engineer in the New York State atterney general's effice, is qucted as saying: , g cy, S
ny- eo 4sy a
- See Ccntention No. 6. 2, felleving. $ y eg>
, y 428 046 w"
e COUNTY OF SOMERVELL STATE OF TEXAS AFFICAVIT OF MARlLYN STINSON 1, Marilyn Stin:en, being duly sworr. on oath, state the following:
- 1. That I am a resident of the municipality of Glen Rose, Somervell County, Texas, and that I live at 506 Barnard. .
I
- 2. That I am over 21 years of age and of sound mind.
3 That my husband and I own a five-axle semi-tractor trailer and operate a business from the above address which consists of refrigerated hauling service in a five-state area, including Texas.
- 4. That our home, personal and business property are located within five (5) miles of the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant.
5 That I am a charter member of CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy) and have been a member for over five years.
- 6. That for the reasor,s stated in the most recent Petition for Leave to Intervene and Contentions filed by CASE in Docket No. 50-445 and 50-446, dated May 7, 1979, the licensir g for operation of the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant I will constitute a serious threat to our property and our health, safety and i environment. Specifically, such threat from the routine or emergency operation of the Comanche Peak plant includes: ininediate or later death, cancer, other health probletas, excessive danger to me personally from the effects of low-level radiation due to my heart condition, destruction c- loss of our home, personal and business property, and possibly irreversible damage to the environment.
7 That for this reason, I have authorized CASE to represent me in the public !
health, safety and environmental aspects of the operating license hearings for the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant. , i "Rio ~
n'i fQ $$c)
Ma'rilyn Stinson ~~
V Somervell County State of Texas -
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 22nd day of May, 1979 n 22 Notary P o' lit
~ 4d &LO(5M
~
\
P (of ficial seal) if 4Ab 4 a # #' 4, % -
423 047 s- a. e hy& N 6
\ //