ML20147B967
| ML20147B967 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 01/07/1988 |
| From: | Johari Moore NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC) |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#188-5352 OL, NUDOCS 8801190039 | |
| Download: ML20147B967 (31) | |
Text
w 4- January 7, 1988 Y
s
- DOCKCTED USt3RC
[fNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION M dW 14 P3 38 PEFORE THE ATGt/.!C SAFETY AND LICENSINC 00ciin BOMtpc gdo BRANCH In the Matter of )
)
TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC ) Docket Nos. 50-445-OL CCP/.PANY, ET AL.
) 50-046-OL
)
(Corranche Peak Steam Electric )
Station, Units 1 and 2) )
NRC STAFF'S ElGHTH PROGRESS REPORT AND ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY
- 1. PROGRESS REPORT This progress report is prepared in response to the Licensing Board's "Memorandum and Order (Progress Report and Notice of Available Documents)" dated June 6,1986, and covers the period September 1,1987 through October 31, 1987. O
- 1. DISCOVERY This Staff attended depositions taken by Intervenors of Appil-cants' personnel on October 14-16, 1987.
- 2. CONSTRUCTION PERMITS The Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board issued a decision en June 30, 1987 resolving the Staff's and Applicants' first and second appeals in the Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station (CPSES), Unit 1,
-1/ It is Staff counsel's understanding from a discussion with Intervenor, that Intervenor will be filing a combined 8th and 9th progress report shortly. The Staff has decided to file its 8th progress report at this tirre, and to file its 9th progress report after receiving Intervenor's combined report.
8801190039 880107 PDR ADOCK 05000445 G ,PDR C,Qq
-s construction permit extension proceeding.
The Appeal Board majority affirmed the Licensing Board's admission of Amended Contention 2, stating that the Consolidated Intervenors had provided sufficient basis for the claims in the Amended Contention that Applicants had a policy to deliberately ignore or violate NRC requirements, and that the policy had not been actually repudiated by the Applicants. On July 17,1987 Appli-cants petitioned the Commission for review of the Appeal Board Decision.
The Decision became final agency action on October 6, 1987, as the time provided by NRC regulations within which the Commission may act to re-view the Decision expired and the Commission declined any review.
The Applicants' April 29, 1987 request for an extension of the latest construction completion date of Construction Permit CPPR-127 for CPSES, Unit 2, is still under Staff consideration. On October 23, 1987 the Staff requested additional information regarding local wells, Texas Water Development Board observation wells, and geologic features in the vicinity of the plant site in order to complete its evaluation of the effects of continued groundwater withdrawal for CPSES construction. Groundwa-ter withdrawal for construction is limited by a condition in the construc-tion permits, as amended.
i 3. OPERATING LICENSES On October 2,1987, the Staff responded to the App!! cant's mo-l tion filed on August 20, 1987 before the Licensing Board for establishment of a schedule for identification and litigation of matters that remain to be resolved under Contention 5. The Staff's response proposed Licensing Board adoption of an alternative litigation schedule. In preparation for a prehearing conference originally scheduled for October 20, 1987 and later i
l l
changed to November 2-3, 1987, the Licensing Board requested the par-ties to respond to three questions and to propose a format for the pre-hearing conference. The Staff responded on October 29, 1987 to the Board's nuestions and proposed a format for the prehearing conference.
4 STAFF REVIEW AND EFFORTS The Staff is currently reviewing recent submittals by the Appli-cants on the engineering evaluation methodology of the post-construction hardware validation program (PCHVP) and the technical audit program and engineering functional evaluation (September 8, 1987) and on the PCHVP attribute matrix (September 23, 1987), some of which supplement previous submittals. The Staff is using this information to finalize a com-prehensive schedule for completing Comanche Peak licensing activities.
The Staff's schedule will focus on the Applicants' current fuel load readi-ness date of August 1988 and will be ready for release to all interested parties during the next reporting period.
Staff review and evaluation of the high priority licensing items listed in the sixth Progress Report is ongoing. On October 30, 1987, the Applicants submitted for Staff review a mark-up of the current Westing-house Standard Technical Specifications (STS) with specific changes for CPSES, Unit 1. Review of the marked-up STS is under way. The staff completed its review of the Applicants' request to eliminate arbitrary in-termediate pipe breaks in their analysis of high energy piping systems and transmitted a safety evaluation to the Applicants on October 13, 1987.
The Staff closed out Confirmatory issue 10m of the CPSES Safety Evalua-tion Report regarding NUREG-0797 Item II.K.3.31 (compliance with 10 C.F.R. 50.46 for small break LOCA analysis), issuing a safety evaluation
_4_
on October 26, 1987. On September 2, 1987 the- Staff requested additional information- from Applicants on implementation of Generic Letter i
83-28, "Required Actions Based on Generic implications of Salem ATWS Events," item 4.3, Parts 3 (life testing of breakers) and 4 (periodic replacement of breakers or components consistent with demonstrated life cycles) .
The Staff continued its review of the Applicants' design valida-tion activities associated with the Corrective Action Program (CAP), com-pleting the imtlat design inspection of the mechanical, civil / structural, electrical, and instrumentation and control design areas being reviewed by Stone and Webster Engineering Corporation (SWEC) and Ebasco Services, incorporated. The results of the initial design inspection are documented in inspection Peport 50-445/87-19; 50-446/87-14 issued on October 15, 1987. A follow-up inspection commenced on October 26, 1987 to resolve open items from the initial inspection and to review areas of design vall-dation that were not complete at the time the initial inspection was con-ducted. The Staff expects to complete this second design inspection during the next reporting period. The results of this inspection are ex-pected to be available in early 1988.
In the other CAP review areas (piping and pipe supports, cable tray hangers, conduit supports, and heating ventilation, and air condi-tioning (HVAC) supports), the staff has continued to review the resolu-tion of generic technical issues and audit the as-built procedures and procedure implementation, design criteria and methodology, and design verification being performed by SWEC, Ebasco, and Impell Corporation for the Applicants. Staff efforts in these areas conducted during this
=
4+
s reporting period are documented in various audit and meeting summaries and trip reports which were provided to all parties. The Staff is con-ciuding its review of the pirang and pipe support issues and expects to issue a safety evaluation '.af this area in early 1988. Further audits of the Applicants' desig r. verification efforts in the areas of cable tray hangers, conduit supports, and HVAC will be conducted in early 1988.
The NRC Comanche Peak Allegation Review Committee ( AP.C) met on September 2,1987 and October 8,1987. The Committee discussed staff actions necessary to address 5 new allegations received during this reporting period. In addition, the ARC reviewed the status of past alle-gations and actions needed to close those that remain open.
- 5. ONSITE INSPECTION ACTIVITIES The NRC onsite inspectors and consultants continued their in-spections of construction, operations, and the Applicants' corrective ac-tion prcCram including issue Specific Action Plans, follow-up on previously identified NRC findings , nonconformance reports, and the post-construction hardware validation p rog ram. Concerted efforts have been made to reduce the time it takes to issue NRC inspection reports.
Consideraole improvement has been made towards the goal of issuing team inspection reports within 30 days and individual inspectors' reports within 20 days. During this reporting period, the following inspection reports were issued:
l Report No. Issue Date Findings l
50-445/8711; 50-446/8709 9/2/87 1 violation and l 1 unresolved item 50-445/8713; 50-446/8710 10/7/87 1 violation and 3 unresolved items i
t
r Report No. Issue Date Findings 50-445/8715;50-446/8712 9/9/87 3 unresolved items and 1 open item 50-445/8716; 50-446/8713 10/23/87 3 violations, 1 deviation, and 9 open items 50-445/E717 9/22/87 1 open item 50-445/8720; 50-446/8716 10/22/87 2 unresolved items and 2 open items 50-445/8770; 50-446/8716 10/22/87 2 unresolved items and 2 open items 50-445/8721 10/23/87 None The findings are discussed further in the following paragraphs:
- a. Inspection Report SG-445/8711; 50-446/8709 documents one viola-tion for improper electrical splices and one unresolved item for apperent improper disposition of nonconformance reports.
- b. Inspection Report 50-445/8713; 50-446/8710 documents one viola-tion for failure to provide the torque requirements for bolts on the pres-sure boundary portion of a charging pump. The three unresolved items concerned the applicability of the ASME Boller and Pressure Vessel Code to capscrew installation, the homogeneity of HVAC work, and the qualifi-cation of inverters with spliced wire.
- c. Inspection Report 50-445/8715; 50-446/8712 documents three l
unresolved items, the first concerning the Applicants' practice of chipping out concrete cracks to evaluate the extent or significance of the crack prior to documenting the crack as a potential nonconforming condition.
The second unresolved item concerned the practice of documenting defi-ciencies on inspection reports (irs). The NRC questioned this practice i
in the past because irs were not trended prior to 1985. The third
-7~
unresolved item involved electrical cables that were broken during pull-back. The open item involved the identification of a white' residue leeching through a concrete wall coating.
- d. Inspection Report 50-445/8716; 50-446/8713 documents three violations one deviation , and nine open items. The first violation involved nonconformance reports (NCRs) being invalidated with no further action being requ! red when follow-up action appeared to be appropriate.
The second violation involved an undersized 6.9kv Jackshaft weld not be-ing identified during inspection. The third violation involved two cotter pins missing from a support. The deviation involved an administrative control of retesting following maintenance / modification of equipment that had been preoperationally tested. The nine open items all relate to NCRs. Two involved follow-up on the NCR review process and the other seven involved follow-up on the disposition of specific NCRs.
- e. Inspection Report 50-445/8717 documents one open item regard-ing administrative control over preoperational testing.
- f. Inspection Report 50-445/8720; 50-446/8716 documents two unre-solved items involved in the failure to write NCRs on potentially non-conforming conditions. The two open items involved the control of system cleanliness and protection of equipment and a broken stud on a pump motor body.
All of the above concerns will be followed up by NRC inspectors during the coming months.
Members of the NRC fire protection inspection team made a planning visit to the site on September 9-10, 1987 in preparation for the inspection which was conducted October 19-23, 1987. Results of the fire
e O
protection team inspection and will be documented in an inspection report which the Staff expects to issue in early 1988. Representatives of the i
Texas State Department of Labor and Standards (ASME Code inspectors) were on site during this reporting period. NRC staff met with them periodically to discuss and coordinate the resolution of NRC issues involv-ing the ASME Code. The NRC approach to resolving outstanding NRC "open Itens" involving the ASME Code is outlined in a memorandum at-tached to inspection Report 50-445/8720; 50-446/8716 which was issued on October 22, 1987.
NRC staff performed an equipment qualification (EO) status review on October C-8, 1987 to determine an appropriate schedule for an EQ follow-up inspection. Dates for the follow-up inspection have not been established.
- 6. OTHER During this reporting period the Director, Office of Special Projects issued a decision concerning a 10 C.F.R. 2.206 Petition filed with the NRC on March 19, 1984 by the Government Accountability Project on behalf of the Citizens Association for Sound Energy and several CPSES nuclear workers. The Petition requested NRC to take certain actions with respect to alleged serious construction and documentation deficiencies at the CPSES. Relief requested included immediate suspension of construc-tion and the construction permit, a special NRC inspection at the facility, an independent design and construction verification program to assess the j integrity of the Comanche Peak Quality Assurance Program, and a com-prehensive management audit of the Applicants' officials by an indepen-dent management auditing firm. The request for special NRC inspections 1
e
has been granted. The other requests were denied as explained in "DI-rector's '. Decision Under 10 C.F.R. 2.206," DD-87-17 issued on October 16, 1987.
On September 4, 1987, representatives of the Apolicants met with regional safeguards and Office of Special Projects staff to discuss the reqlon's preoperational inspection experience in the security program area and how that experience might be applied to CPSES.
The Staff issued Preliminary Notification PNO-OSP-87-11 on Scotember 15, 1987 to report a construction accident at the site in which a mobile crane had overturned due to high winds crushing a temporary buildino and resulting in 2 fatalities.
During this reporting period the Staff completed record search-es on 7 Freedom of information Act requests related to CPSES received during August, September, and October 1987, b and received 11 new reauests for action. Approximately 44 5taff hours and over $700 in con-tract funds were expended in searching and preparing the responses for the 7 completed record searches.
fl. ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY The attached annotated bibliography is a computer-generated report prepared from the NRC's document control system. It contains separate l -2/ Documents provided in response to these FOIA requests include in-l spection reports and related correspondenc?, Applicant 10 CFR 50.55(e) deficiency reports, ARC documents , Board Notification 87-12, a Staff audit summary, and a meeting between NRC site in-spection personnel and representatives of the Texas Department of l
Labor and Standards, Boller Division.
i i
Q
4
- 10 -
. lists of all documents originated by NRC that have been sent to the Ap-plicants and to intervenors relating to the Comanche Peak Project. that were indexed durina the period September 1, 1987 .through October . 31, 1987.
As explained in the Staff's Hrst Progress Report, the listing of any-particular document does not constitute a determination by the Staff of the document's relevance to either the OL proceeding or the CP extension proceeding.
Respectfully submitted, L)cu7/ (R)G_11LQ32D .
Janice E. Moore Counsel for NRC Staff Dated at Rockville, Maryland this 7th day of January,1988 l
t i
l l
l
i l
l i
LIST 1 NRC Documents to Applicants I
l r
I i
i I
i
{
l -
11/25/87 PAGE 1 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
. DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 8709010140 Ack receipt of 780728 Itr in response te NRC 780630 Itr te item of noncompliance from Insp Repts 50-445/78-11 &
50-446/78-11. Corrective actions will be reviewed during future insp.
FROM: SEIDLE,W.C. Reactor Construction & Engineering Support Branch, R4 TO: GARY,R.J. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 780804 AVAIL: PDR 1p. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNIU FPAC: 8709010117A TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 0500044S 05000446 FICHE: 42435 106 42435 106 RIDS:
8709020179 Ack receipt of 870427,0615 & 30 Itrs in response to violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/86-22 & 50-446/86-20.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870826 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709020179 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42448 092 42448 095 RIDS:
8709020279 Requerts addl info re groundwater withdrawal rates to complete NRC review of util 870429 & 0722 requests for oxtension of CP CPPR-127. Response requested within 10 days of ltr receipt.
FROM: GRIMES,C.I. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.C. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870825 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709020279 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42447 070 42447 075 RIDS:
0709020314 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-14 & 50-446/87-11 on 870708-0804.No deviations or violations noted.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
l ISSUED: 870826 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709020314*
l TASK: ODID: FORMAL PEPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42447 179 42447 194 RIDS:
l 8709020413 Forwards corrected forwarding ltr for Insp Repts 50-445/87-14,50-446/87-11 & 50-445/87-12 previously mailed on 870826 w/o date on 1 tr.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870827 AVAIL: PDR 1p. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709020413*
I TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
l DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42449 105 42449 109 RIDS:
l
11/25/87 PAGE 2 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT B709020422 Corrected 1tr forwarding Insp Rept 50-445/87-12 on 870708-0804. No violations or deviations noted.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870826 AVAIL: PDR 1p. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709020413A TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42449 106 42449 109 RIDS:
8709030008 Ack receipt of 870713 response to 870330 notice of violation from Insp Repts 50-445/S6-20 & 50-446/86-17. Listed portions of Item A.2 of violation withdrawn due to addl info presented which shows that items complied w/ procedures.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
I SSUED: P70826 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709030008 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42473 068 42473 071 RIDS:
0709030012 Ack receipt of 870722 ltr te steps taken to correct violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/87-02 & 50-446/87-02.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870826 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FP AC: 8709030012 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42473 009 42473 012 RIDS:
0709030019 Ack receipt of 870630 ltr informing NRC of steps taken to correct violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/86-31 &
50-446/86-25.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870825 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709030019 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42507 209 42507 212 RIDS:
0709030086 Forwards Insp Rept 50-445/87-12 on 870708-0804. No violations or deviations noted.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870826 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709030086* '
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42470 211 42470 220 RIDS:
\
l
11/25/07 PAGE 3 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 0709030510 Reminds licensee of intended purpose & proper usage of Hoalth Physics Network Emergency Communication Sys (HPN),per IE Info Notice 86-097.NRC has noted improper usage of notwork & requests licensee review HPN controls.
FNOM: GAGLIARDO,J.E. Region 4, Ofc of the Director TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870901 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709030510 TASK: ODID: IEIN-86-097 FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42463 313 42463 315 RIDS: IE35D G709030510 01 Reminds licensee of intended purpose & proper usage of Health Physics Network Emergency Communication Sys (HPN),per IE Info Notice 86-097.NRC has noted improper usage of notwork & requests licensee review HPN controls.
FROM: GAGLIARDO,J.E. Region 4, Ofc of ':he Director TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870901 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTO FPAC: 8709030510 TASK: ODID: IEIN-86-097 FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42463 313 42463 315 RIDS: IE35D 0709080359 Forwards request for addl info re util 831103 response to Generic Ltr 83-28, Item 4.2 (Parts 3 & 4),re life testing of reactor trip breakers.WCAP-10835 unacceptable response to generic 1tr.
FROM: GRIMES,C.I. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Flectric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870902 AVAIL: PDR 7pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709050359 TASK: ODID: GL-83-28 FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42548 075 42548 081 RIDS:
4 0709090071 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-04 & 50-446/87-04 on
- 870101-0228. Certain items of potential generic concern
! identified.
FROM: GRIMES,C.I. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.O. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
l ISSUED: 870831 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709090071*
l TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
1 DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42557 095 42557 175 RIDS:
8709090241 Notifies that team insp to ensure compliance v/ requirements of Branch Technical Position CMEB B.5-1, "Fire Protection for Nuclear Power Plants," will be conducted during wk of 071019-23.
FROM: GRIMES,C.I. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL W. G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870901 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709090241 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO: .
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42559 073 42559 076 RIDS:
'11/25/87 PAOE 4 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
. DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 8709100089 Confirms arrangements for safeguards insp program meeting in Rogion IV ofc on 870904 to review NRC security regulatory criteria required to meet performance objectives of 10CFR73.55(a).
FROM: GAGLIARDO,J.E. Region 4, Ofc of the Director TO: COUNSIL,W.O. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Oenerating Co.)
ISSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FFAC: 8709100089 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42585 173 42585 176 RIDS: IE45D 8709100461 Ack receipt of 870605 & 0713 ltrs in response to NRC 870402 Itr.Addl info re Items B & C in notice of deviation requested per 870813 & 20 discussions w/J Streeter. Response roquested within 20 days of ltr date.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNIU FPAC: 8709100461 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOOKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42606 010 42606 015 RIDS:
0709110379 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-11 & 50-446/87-09 on 870605-0707 & notice of violation.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
I SSUED: 870902 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709110379*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42626 001 42626 052 RIDS:
0709180097 Ack receipt of 870904 ltr informing NRC of steps taken to i correct violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/87-06 &
50-446/87-05.
l l FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
l ISSUED: 870909 AVAIL: PDR 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709180097 l TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42722 081 42722 082 RIDS:
8709180132 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-15 & 50-446/87-12 on 870805-0902. No violations or deviations noted.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Flectric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
, ISSUED: 870909 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709180132*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42722 040 42722 053 RIDS:
i -
- 11/25/87 PAGE 5 U. S. NUCLEAR RECULATORY COMMISSION
. DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT B709180368 Ack receipt of listed ltrs in response to violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/86-07 & 50-446/86-05. Corrective steps taken re Item A inadequate. Bases for statement in 870218 Itr i on Item E requested.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
IGSUED: 870911 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709180368 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42724 001 42724 004 RIDS:
8709220382 Confirms arrangements for reactor & senior reactor operator licensing exams. Written exams will be administered on 871214
& operating exams on 871215 & 16.Ref mat 1, written exam administration & facility review requirements enc 1.
FROM: GAGLIARDO,J.E. Region 4, Ofc of the Director TO: C OUNSIL, W. G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 370917 AVAIL: PDR 7pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709220392 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42744 310 42744 316 RIDS: IE42D 0709230483 Ack receipt of 870819 ltr informing NRC of revised response to Notice of Violation, Item E.NRC will review util implementati:n of corrective & preventive actions during future insp to determine if full compliance achieved.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
I SSUED: 870914 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709230483 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42780 023 42780 025 RIDS:
0709240289 Ack receipt of 870612 & 0803 ltrs informing NRC of steps taken to correct violations & deviations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/86-08 & 50-446/86-06. Response to Violation A.1 occeptable. Violation A.2 retained. Deviations withdrawn.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870914 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709240289 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT Nt':
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42786 138 42786 141 RIDS:
8709240424 Requests addl info re results rept for Issue Specific Action Plan V.a, including proposed resolution of incorrect data I presented in tables. Response requested within 30 days.
FROM: GRIMES,C.I. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870916 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709240424 TASK: ODID: FORMAL d2?T NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 0500044o FICHE: 42788 242 42788 244 RIDS:
11/25/07 PAGE 6 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 0709290229 Discusses 870904 meeting te Region IV pre-operational insp oxperience in security program area & how experience might bo applied to plant effort. List of attendees enc 1.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870921 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709290229 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42833 255 42833 259 RIDS:
0709290229 01 Discusses 870904 meeting re Region IV pre-operational insp oxperience in security program area & how experience might be applied to plant effort. List of attendees enc 1.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
I SSUED: 870921 AVAIL: PDR 5p p. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FFAC: 8709290229 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42833 255 42833 259 RIDS:
0709290367 Forwards Insp Rept 50-445/87-17 on 870805-0902. No violations or deviations noted.
FROM: WARNICH,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Oenereting Co.)
ISSUED: 870922 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8709290367*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42831 024 42831 032 RIDS:
t 0710070428 Advises that proposed date of 880426 for full participation omergency field exercise compatible w/ Region IV insp schedule,in response to util 870604 I t r.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Region 4, Ofc of the Director TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 871002 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8710070428
[ TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
l DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42957 354 42957 357 RIDS: IE35D 0710150254 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-13 & 50-446/87-10 on 870708-0804 & notice of violation.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc sP Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.C TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Oenerating Co.)
ISSUED: 871007 A4 AIL: PDR 7pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8710150254*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43069 347 43070 042 RIDS:
u... .. . .
v ._ - - . - . - - .. .
- 11/25/87 PAGE 7 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
. DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 8710220280 Ack receipt of 870202,06,0415,0519,22 & 0605 ltrs informing NRC of steps taken to correct violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/86-15 & 50-446/86-12.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 871005 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTO FPAC: 8710220280 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 00000445 05000446 FICHE: 43137 047 43137 050 RIDS:
8710220339 Ack receipt of 871002 Itr inforniing NRC of steps taken to correct violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/87-11 &
50-446/87-09.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formovly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 871013 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTO FPAC: 8710220339 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FIC'fE: 43130 084 43130 087 RIDS:
8710220361 Forwards safety evaluation of util request to eliminate orbitrary intermediate pipe creak < in high energy piping sys. Request acceptable provided util does not relax environ qualification of safety-related equipment.
FROM: GRIMES,C.I. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Fiactric (formerly Texas Utilities Ganerating Co.)
I'JSUED: 871013 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTO FPAC: 8710220361*
TASK: ODID: GL-87-11 FORMAL REPT NO:
POCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43135 310 43135 320 RIDS:
8710230220 Expresses appreciation for 870908 Itr that provided supplementary response to notice of deviation, Item B.
Doscription memo for reinsp of large bore pipe ,
supports-nonrigid,GA/GC-RT-313,Rev 1, excludes mati defects.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
! ISSUED: 871014 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTO FPAC: 8710230220 ,
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43143 275 43143 278 RIDS:
0710270257 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-16 & 50-446/87-13 on 870805-0902 & notices of violation & deviation.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: C OUNSIL, W. G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 871023 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8710270257*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REV' NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43185 362 43185 238 RIDS: IE01D l i
i i
. _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - - _ _ , _ _ - _ _ . . _ _ . .. __ - - - - ~ .
- 11/25/87 PAGE 8 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 0710270377 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-19 & 50-446/87-15 on 870803-0903 of plant design validation program. Attention should be given to open items identified in rept & util should be prepared to address items in 871026 followup insp.
FROM: GRIMES,C.I. OFc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 871015 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8710270377*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43181 260 43102 086 RIDS: IE01D G710280064 Forwards Insp Repts 50-445/87-20 & 50-446/87-16 on 870903-1006.No violations or deviat ions noted.
FROM: WARNICK,R.F. Ofc of Special Projects TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TV Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 871022 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTU FPAC: 8710280064*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43193 293 43193 310 RIDS: IE01D
- 11/25/07 PAGE 1 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
, DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT B709110201 Forwards cost analysis for OL application review for 860622-1220,per 10CFR170.12(b). Invoice will be submitted within next few days.
FROM: HOLLOWAY,C.J. License Fee Management Branch TO: COUNSIL,W.G. TU Electric (formerly Texas Utilities Generating Co.)
ISSUED: 870909 AVAIL: PDR 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTV FPAC: 8709110201 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000446 FICHE: 42626 252 42626 253 RIDS:
l
LIST 2 NRC Documents to Intervenors
" 11/25/87 PAGE 1 U. S. NUCLEAR REQULATORY COMMICSION DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 0709010102 Final response to appeal re denial of FOIA request for documents about plant. Forwards documents listed in App D. App D documents also available in PDR. App E documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project IssVED: 870827 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNT1 FPAC: 8709010102*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42435 219 42435 229 RIDS:
8709010102 01 Final response to appeal re denial of FOIA request for documents about plant, Forwards documents listed in App D. App D documents also available in PDR. App E documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870827 AVAIL: PDR Spp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709010102*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42435 219 42435 229 RIDS:
8709010102 02 Final response to appeal re denial of FOIA request for documents about plant. Forwards documents listed in App D. App D documents also available in PDR. App E documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870827 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709010102*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42435 219 42435 229 RIDS:
0709010102 03 Final response to appeal re denial of FOIA request for documents about plant. Forwards documents listed in App D. App D documents also available in PDR. App E documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project I SSUED: 870827 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLN TZ FPAC: 8709010102*
l TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42435 219 42435 229 RIDS:
8709090295 Final response to FOIA request for rept of investigation of intimidation & coverup at Texas Util Generating Co. Forwards App C documents. Documents partially & completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemptions 5,6 & 7).
FROM:
- Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: QARDE,B.P. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709090295*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKLT NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42559 355 42560 143 RIDS:
l l
l
- 11/25/87 PAGE 2 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT C709090295 01 Final response to FOIA request for rept of investigation of intimidation & coverup at Texas Util Generating Co. Forwards App C documents. Documents partially & completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemptions 5,6 & 7).
FROM:
- Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: GARDE.B.P. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709090295*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42559 355 42560 143 RIDS:
0709090295 02 Final response to FOIA request for rept of investigation of intimidation & coverup at Texas Util Generating Co. Forwards App C documents. Documents partially & completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemptions 5,6 & 7).
FROM:
- Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: GARDE,B.P. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709090295*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42559 355 42560 143 RIDS:
0709090295 03 Final response to FOIA request for rept of investigation of intimidation & coverup at Texas Util Generating Co. Forwards App C documents. Documents partially & completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemptions 5,6 & 7).
FROM:
- Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: GARDE,B.P. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709090295*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42559 355 42560 143 RIDS:
G709090303 Final response to FOIA request for documents te Insp Repts 50-445/87-02 & 50-446/87-02. Forwards App B documents.
Documents also available in PDR. App C documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709090303*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42560 325 42561 045 RIDS:
0709090'J03 01 Final response to FOIA request for documents re Insp Repts 50-445/87-02 & 50-446/97-02. Forwards App B documents.
Documents also available in PDR. App C documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project I SSUED: 870903 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709090303*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42560 325 42561 045 RIDS:
.11/25/C7 PAGE 3 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 1 8709110435 Final response to FOIA request for documents re 870625 Itr concerning Insp Repts 50-445/87-07 & 50-446/87-06. Forwards App B documents. App A & B documents available in PDR. App C documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project I SSUED: 870910 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709110435*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42644 057 42644 154 RIDS:
0709110435 01 Final response to FOIA request for documents to 870625 ltr concerning Insp Repts 50-445/87-07 & 50-446/87-06. Forwards App B documents. App A & B documents available in PDR. App C documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: SAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870910 AVAIL: PDR 5p p. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709110435*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42644 057 42644 154 RIDS:
C709110435 02 Final response to FOIA request for documents re 870625 Itr concerning Insp Repts 50-445/87-07 & 50-446/87-06. Forwards App B documents. App A & B documents available in PDR. App C documents withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project
! ISSUED: 870910 AVAIL: PDR 5pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709110435*
l TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42644 057 42644 154 RIDS:
l
- 0709150098 Responds to 870824 ltreinquiring why 870713 meeting between NRC & representatives of State of TX not public. Meeting simply acquainted representatives of agencies w/each other &
cssigned responsibilities.Related correspondence.
FROM: WOODHEAD,C.P. Assistant General Counsel for Hearings TO: GARDE,B.P. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870902 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709150098 l TASK: ODID: OL FORMAL REPT NO:
l DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42620 354 42620 359 RIDS: DS07D G709180123 04 Partial response to FOIA request for documents, including V Stello B70319 memo to J Keppler te delegation of authority to Ofc of Special Projects. Enc 1 App A documents also
, available in PDR.
! FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: TAYLOR,J. Dallas Times Herald, Dallas, TX ISSUED: 870916 AVAIL: PDR 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLN TZ FPAC: 8709180123*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000000 05000439 05000445 FICHE: 42722 262 42722 279 RIDS:
11/25/G7 PACE 4 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT C709180450 Partial response to FOIA request.Insp Repts 50-445/87-10 &
50-446/87-08,dtd 870731, available in PDR.
'FROM: ORIMSLEY,D. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: PAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUEP :70916 AVAIL: PDR 1p. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709180450 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42724 229 42724 229 7 IDS:
0709220297 Forwards proprietary response to 850731 Itr to V Noonan raising concerns re NRC Technical Review Team review process for 1984-1985 allegations.SSER 8,dtd Feb 1955,re containment b1dg overexcavation & 17 other allegations discussed.
FROM: ORIMES,C.I. Ofc of Special Projects TO: ELLIS.J. Citizens Association for Sound Energy ISSUED: 870914 AVAIL: CF 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNIZ FPAC: 8709220297*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET *NO: 05000445 FICHE: 69021 052 69021 054 RIDS:
C709220517 Proprietary ltr requesting reconsideration of decision to decline contact w/ Comanche Peak Technical Review Team.
Review of recipient concerns re mechanical / piping area ccmplete. Desire to discuss resolution expressed.
FROM: NOONAN,V.S. Comanche Peak Project (Technical Review Team)
TO: C L ANCY, G. Affiliation Not Assigned ISSUED: 850128 AVAIL: CF 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709220297BA TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 97161 195 97161 196 RIDS:
0709220579 Proprietary, partially withheld 1tr forwarding SSER 8 (NUREG-0797) on evaluation & resolution of 86 technical concerns & allegations in civil, structural & miscellaneous creas.W/o enc 1.
FRON: NOONAN,V.S. Comancne Peak Project (Technical Review Team)
TO: CLANCY, G. F. Affiliation Not Assigned ISSUED: 850507 AVAIL: CF 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709220297BB TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 97161 197 97161 198 RIDS:
0709220592 Proprietary ltr forwarding SSER 7 (NUREG-0797) re evaluation of approx 80 technical concerns & allegations in areas of olectrical/ instrumentation & test programs. Record of 841029 toicon & supporting info enc 1, FRON: NOONAN,V.S. Comanche Peak Project (Technical Review Team)
TO: C L ANC Y, 0. F. Affiliation Not Assigned ISSUED: 850509 AVAIL: CF 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709220297BC TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 97161 199 97161 202 RIDS:
- 11/25/07 PAGE 5 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 4
, DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT
.I 4
4 0709230159 Partial response to FOIA request for documents. Forwards App A documents te facility. App A documents placed in PDR.
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISbuED: 870921 AVAIL: PDR 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709230159*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42782 055 42782 061 RIDS:
8709280307 Final response to FOIA request for records re C Orimes 870818 Itr to ASLB concerning Ofc of Inspector & Auditor Rept of Investigation 86-10. App A documents already available in PDR.
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870923 AVAIL: PDR 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709280307 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42799 297 42799 298 RIDS:
8709290290 Partial response to FOIA request to Ofc of Inspector &
! Auditor rept on plant. App A documents completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
l l
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: TAYLOR J.H. Dalles Times Herald, Dallas, TX ISSUED: 870924 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709290290 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42833 189 42833 191 RIDS:
0709290290 01 Partial response to FOIA request re Ofc of Inspector &
Auditor rept on plant. App A documents completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: TAYLOR,J.H. Dallas Times Herald, Dallas, TX ISSUED: 870924 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8709290290 TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42833 189 42833 191 RIDS:
8710050053 Partial response to FOIA request. App C documents re deficient practices by util bolt supplier enc 1 & available in PDR.
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: CONDIT,R.E. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870930 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8710050053*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000000 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42907 249 42907 262 RIDS:
- m. _. _ _ . _
- m. ,, .
- 11/25/97 PAGE 6 i U. 8. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION l
. DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT ;
t i
8710070426 Final response to FOIA request for documents te proposed
- NRC organizational alignment concerning TVA & Comanche Peak projects. Forwards App B documents. App C records totally withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rulen & Records (Post 870413)
TO: TAYLOR,J. Dallas Times Herald, Dallas, TX ISSUED: 871005 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. D'3CUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8710070426*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42979 007 42979 019 RIDS:
8710070426 01 Final response to FOIA request for documents to proposed NRC organizational alignment concerning TVA & Comanche Peak projects. Forwards App B documents. App C records totally withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GR IMSLEY, D. H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: TAYLOR,J. Dallas Times Herald, Dallas, TX ISSUED: 871005 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLN TZ FPAC: 8710070426*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42979 007 42979 019 RIDS:
8710070426 02 Final response to FOIA request for documents re proposed NRC organizational alignment concerning TVA & Comanche Peak projects. Forwards App B documents. App C records totally withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: TAYLOR J. Dallas Times Herald, Dallas, TX
! ISSUED: 871005 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLN TZ FPAC: 8710070426*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO: ,
DOCKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 42979 007 42979 019 RIDS:
0710770306 Final response to FOIA request for documents re plant.
Forwards App A document.Apps A & B documents available in PDR.
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
To: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 871023 AVAIL: PDR 4pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLN TZ FPAC: 8710270306* i i
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO: ,
j DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43188 262 43188 268 RIDS:
l 8710280339 Forwards Director's Decision DD-87-17 & FR notice granting
- in part & denying in part GAP 840319 petition on behalf of CASE & nuclear workers requesting action re alleged serious i const & documentation deficiencies, i FROM
- KEPPLER.J.G. Ofc of Special Projects i TO: GARDE B.P. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 871016 AVAIL: PDR 6pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8710280339*
TASK: ODID: DD-87-17 FORMAL REPT NO: ;
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43205 073 43205 088 RIDS: i t
- 11/25/97 PAGE 7 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
. DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 8710280400 Partial response to FOIA request for documents. App A documents available in PDR. App B documents enc 1 & available in PDR. App C documents completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: DAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 871027 AVAIL: PDR 7pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8710280400*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 43206 019 43206 035 RIDS:
8710280400 01 Partial response to FOIA request for documents. App A documents available in PDR. App B documents enc 1 & available in PDR. App C documents completely withheld (ref FOIA Exemption 5).
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: BAUMAN,L. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 871027 AVAIL: PDR 7pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8710280400*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOOKET NO: 05000445 FICHE: 43206 019 43206 035 RIDS:
l
11/25/97 PAGE 1 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
. DCS PARTIAL RECORD FORMAT REPORT 0709180123 05 Partial response to FOIA request for documents, including V Stello 870319 memo to J Keppler te delegation of authority to Ofc of Special Projects. Enc 1 App A documents also cvailable in PDR.
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D.H. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: TAYLOR,J. Dallas Times Herald, Dallas, TX IOSUED: 870916 AVAIL: PDR 2pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLN TZ FPAC: 8709180123*
. TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000000 05000446 FICHE: 42722 262 42722 279 RIDS:
0710050053 Partial response to FOIA request. App C documents te deficient practices by util bolt supplier enc 1 & available in PDR.
FROM: GRIMSLEY,D. Division of Rules & Records (Post 870413)
TO: CONDIT,R.E. Government Accountability Project ISSUED: 870930 AVAIL: PDR 3pp. DOCUMENT TYPE: CLNTZ FPAC: 8710050053*
TASK: ODID: FORMAL REPT NO:
DOCKET NO: 05000000 05000445 05000446 FICHE: 42907 249 42907 262 RIDS:
l l
l
DOCXCIED USNhC UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION agg jgg j4 p3 3g BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
$0CNINGN$ffiE[
0 In the Matter of )
)
L TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC ) Docket Nos. 50-445-OL COVPANY, ET AL. ) 50-446-OL
)
(Comanche Peak Steam Electric )
Station, Units 1 and 2) )
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of "NRC STAFF'S EIGHTH PROGRESS REPORT AND ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY" in the above-captioned proceeding have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mall, first class , or, as indicated by an asterisk, through deposit in the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's internal mall system, this 7th day of January,1988:
Peter B. Bloch, Esq. , Chairman
- Mrs. Juanita Ellis Administrative Judge President, CASE Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 1426 South Polk Street ,
i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Dallas, TX 75224 Washington, DC 20555 Renea Hicks, Esq.
Dr. Kenneth A. McCollom Assistant Attorney General '
Administrative Judge Environmental Protection Division 1107 West Knapp P.O. Box 12548, Capital Station l Stillwater, OK 74075 Austin, TX 78711 '
Elizabeth B. Johnson Robert A. Wooldridge, Esq. +
- Administrative Judge Worsham, Forsythe, Samples Oak Ridge National Laboratory & Wooldridge 1 P.O. Box X, Building 3500 2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 3200 Oak Ridge, TN 37830 Dallas, TX 75201
! Dr. Walter H. Jordan Joseph Callo, Esq.
! Administrative Judge Isham, Lincoln & Beale
- l c/o Carid Terrace Motel Suite 1100 522 N. Ocean Blvd. 1150 Connecticut Avenue, N.W. ;
Pompano Beach, FL 33062 Washington, DC 20036 i
l
- o-
. Rillie Pirner Garde. Mr. W. G. Counsil i GAP - Vidwest Office Executive Vice President 104 E. Wisconsin Avenue - B Texas Utilities Generating Company Appleton, WI 54911-4897 400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 ,
Dallas, TX 75201 William L. Brown, Esq.* Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Suite 600 611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000 1401 New York Avenue, NW Arlington, TX 76011 Washington, DC 20005
~
Asst. Director for inspec. Programs William H. Burchette, Esq.
Comanche Peak Project Division Mark D. Nozette, Eso.
U.S. Nucicar Regulatory Commission Heron, Burchette, Ruckert-
, P. O. Box 1029 6 Rothwell, Suite 700 Granbury, TX 76048 1025 Thomas Jefferson Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20007 L
Lanny Alan Sinkin James M. McCaughy Christic Institute GDS Assoc. Inc.
1324 North Capitol Street 1850 Parkway Pl. , Suite 720 Washington, DC 20002 Marietta, GA 30067 ;
Robert D. Martin
- Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Board Panel
- 611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000 U.S Nuclear Regulatory Commission Arlington, TX 76011 Washington, DC 20555 t
Robert A. Jablon, Esq. Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal l
^
Spiegel & McDiarmid Eoard Panel *
- 1350 New York Avenue, N.W. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ;
Washington, DC 20005-4798 Washington, DC 20555 l l Thomas G. Dignan, Esq. Docketing and Service Section*
Ropes & Gray Office of the Secretary 225 Franklin Street U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l
Boston, MA 02110 Washington, DC 20555 Jack R. Newman, Esq.
Newman & Holtzinger, P.C. :
Suite 1000 1615 L Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036 0 MJLE2JL NJIDW Janice E. Moore Counsel for NRC Staff ,
4 f
~,, - .., . - - - - -
-- . _ . . - . . . . , , . . , - .---- - . - - - -