ML20147H839
| ML20147H839 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 03/04/1988 |
| From: | Edgar G, Edger G NEWMAN & HOLTZINGER, TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| CON-#188-5769 OL, NUDOCS 8803090081 | |
| Download: ML20147H839 (63) | |
Text
00LKElE0 Filed:
March 4, i'9Id' 18 MNt -4 M2 37 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA gFFicE OF ytyig,ran t NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION OCKEi tj f;t evitf.
before the ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
)
In the Matter of-
)
Docket Nos. 50-445-OL
)
50-446-OL TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING
)
COMPANY et al.
)
)
(Application for an (Comanche Peak Steam Electric
)
Operating License)
Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
)
APPLICANTS' TENTH PROGRESS REPORT Pursuant to the Board's "Memorandum and order (Progress Report and Notice of Available Documents)" entered l
June 6, 1986, the Applicants submit herewith their tenth "Progress Report".
This Progress Report covers the period December 25, 1987 through February 29, 1988.
1 1.
CPRT Progress During the reporting period the Senior Review Team ("SRT") approved and published Results Report VII.a.9, Adequacy of Purchased and Safety-Related Material and Equipment.
l With the completion of Results Report VII.a.'9, the SRT has l
)
published all of the applicable 47 Issue Specific Action 8803090001 080304 ADOCK05000gg5 g
PDR y so-a
T
^
g-.
_4 '
l 5
Plans'as well as three Discipline Specific-Action Plans i
!u Results-Reports.-
In late December 1987, the SRT-approved and published the Collective Evaluation Report.
On February-26, 1988, i
the SRT approved the Collective Significance Report for publication on February 29, 1988.
The notice to CASE of the availability of the l
a
-Working Files for.all reports except Results Report VII.a.9 1
and the Collective Significance Report has been made.
The notices of availability for these two reports will be issued 9
as soon as the files have been assembled.
J t
Responses to the Board's 14 questions have been t
provided for all but 5 of the published Results Reports.
i Preparation of these responses is in process.
2.
Corrective Action-Program i
I The following six Project Status Reports were issued during the reporting periods Equipment Qualification o
o Electrical Mechanical, Supplement A - Systems Interaction o
and Supplement B - Fire Protection t
o Instrumentation and Control o
Civil / Structural Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC)
L o
i I
F t
f
i
- s. All eleven of the Project Status Reports have now been issued.
The notices.of availability for all the above Project Status Reports, with the exception of HVAC, were issued during the reporting period.
The notice of availability for the-HVAC Project Status Report will be issued in early March 1988.
On December 18, 1987 via TXX-7099 TU Electric provided an initial response to NRC comments received during the December 9, 1987 public meeting.
This was followed by TXX-88135 dated February 1, 1988, in which TU Electric provided a status report of actions previously identified.
Several public meetings related to the Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station were held during this reporting period as-follows:
Technical meeting to February 5, 1988 discuss development and attenuation of jets from i
high-energy line breaks Technical meeting between February 18-19, 1988 TU Electric and CASE Technical meeting between February 25-27, 1988 TU Electric and CASE
r is.
6-
.4 The next Progress Report will be issued April 29, 1988.
Respectfully submitted, TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC COMPANY For the Owners of CPSES J
George L y gar '
//
Newman & Holtzinger, P.T.
1615 L Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036 (202) 955-6600 Attorneys for Texas Utilities Electric Company 9
'w
..c A
~
s g
s N
(-
. '.) =
\\.A i,_
(
Is
\\
i
\\
y
- ,.. X.
Y t>t
. k.
s 1
T.g
,4 N,
\\ } C, a,s yQ h
3 y
's a N
N(4-s c;
.,1 ' s s,
s y
f' i\\.
/
,f i
{t
\\\\
V
..s
.\\,
1
?
r j
A N *,'*0 T A 'T p D WIB{I0gRAP(P1W 3
,\\
'y l'A-y f_.
$'t,..
)L
,9 s'
s Pursuants the Boare's 5.rbr 'of tJune O f($6 Adplicants submit the at:,. c';ed j1 sAnnotateo'toB W iographies ofddcuments ist % b ime period of 1
t 7 t-c2mber 26,1987 thru February 25,- IntAr.,1 The p'rinciMes that were utili. zed,
.\\ 'g.t.4 0
2 sthe documents that are annota{aa and the Cicument sot.rces are consistent with;')
tne Ud*hijneand procedurcsfihat were used by ApplJepats.in previous
'i >
yAnnoteed Bibliographies.
y p'N
\\ s (y t
?]
IQ.
a sj-y s,% s 3/
N-k\\
I:
- 3 q
A,
\\t v
w
+..7 y.t
'M~
J(
/
y b ('
]
\\/
,,(
l j
3,i j N "f p k '!
C'
,)
vs,
.)
i I
l\\
4 3
3 s~
1
)
1/
s..
s.
)
.'$,,w 3,
\\
j i
S\\
g
'\\_
..S.
(
I 5
l I
,\\
'/
4 \\,
-/
i; 3
a I
A) 1 a4 j
1 1
> ({ J 1
,1 i
1 1
f s.
1, m 3
10 CFR 50.55 (el During the period of December 26, 1987 to February 25, 1988, Applicants issued 145 letters to the NRC concerning 133 items which had previously been identified as potentially reportable under the provisions of 10 CFR 50.55 (e).
The letters are categorized as follows:
A.
22 letters - Interim Reoort - Evaluation to determine reportability is continuing.
(No listing provided)
B.
42 letters - Interim Reoort - Item determined to be reportable and evaluation / corrective action is continuing.
a pais Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 9/30/87 TXX-6807 CP-86-10 Electrical Penetration Assemblies This letter was transmitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving the electrical penetration assemblies supplied by Bunker Ramo.
Q314 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 10/2/87 TXX-6831 CP-85-14 Unauthorized Support Repairs
- x =
TE,is' letter was transmitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving unauthorized repairs made to hangers.
D2hg letter NQ.
SDAR No.
Subject 12/17/87 TXX-7109 CP-86-18 Safety Chilled Water Chiller Units This report was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving difficulties in starting and operating the 4
s?fety' chilled water chiller units.
2-s
,f
[
4 DAlg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/18/87 TXX-7111 CP-86-63 Pipe Support Installations This report was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving pipe support installations.
D111 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/18/87 7XX-7117 CP-87-51 480 V Containment Electrical Penetration Backup This report was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving backup protection for the 480 V containment electrical penetrations.
Ejltg letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/23/87 TXX-7041 CP-87-21 Effect of Thermolag on Derating Factors This report transmitted information regarding a reportable deficiency involving the effect of thermolag on cable derating factors. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications, and corrective action is provided for this issue.
DAt.g letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 12/23/87 TXX 7124 CP-87-85 Degradation of Class 1E Circuits This letter transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving the Safety Systems Inoperable Indication panel. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
I l
3-t
t b
QLig Letter No.
SDAR N9.
Subiect 12/23/87 TXX-7125 CP-87-26 Diesel Generator Oil Transfer Pump Suction lift This report transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving the diesel generator fuel oil transfer pump.
The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Enig Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/29/87 TXX-7133 CP-82-07 Defective Governor Design Couplings This report was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date in connection with a deficiency involving defective governor drive couplings on the diesel generators.
QLt1 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 12/30/87 TXX-7044 CP-86-31 Diesel Generator Sump Tank Foot Valves This letter was transmitted to status corrective actinn implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving the possible failure of the rubber facing en foot valves mounted in the diesel generator lube oil sump tanks.
l D_q.tg Letter No, SDAR No.
Sykig.qt I
12,20/87 TXX-7141 CP-87-124 Xomax Valves This report transmitted information concerning a deficiency involving Xomax valves. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
l l
l
[
l -
o Qilta Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/5/88 TXX-88026 CP-87-122 Nozzle Load Interface This letter transmitted information regarding a reportable deficiency involving nozzle load stresses which may fail to meet FSAR limits. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qjtta letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/5/88 TXX-88027 CP-87-132 Unqualified Limitorque Actuators This letter transmitted information regarding a reportable deficiency involving unqualified limitorque actuators. The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qilta letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/5/88 TXX-88028 CP-87-139 Unqualified Terminal Blocks This letter transmits information regarding a reportable deficiency involving equipment qualification of terminal blocks inside and outside of containment.
The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qjtta Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/6/88 TXX-88016 CP-87-127 Overstressed Structure Design This letter transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving platforms and supports which may be over stressed. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
QLta Lgtter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/6/88 TXX 88031 CP-87-129 Containment Spray System PH This letter transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving the containment spray ph.
The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue. _.
t 4
agig Letter No.
1DAR No.
Sub.iect 1/6/88 TXX-88032 CP-87-128 Loss of Control Power Indication This letter transmitted information regarding a reportable deficiency involving the Emergency Diesel Generator Auto Start Circuitry for loss of control power. The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qitta letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/6/88 TXX-88034 CP-87-130 Service Water System Water Hammer This letter transmitted information regarding a reportable deficiency involving the water hammer and column separation in the Service Water System.
The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Q1.t1 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/6/88 TXX 88039 CP 85-31 Electrical Raceway Support System This letter was transmitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving the Unit 1 Class IE Electrical Raceway Support System.
QJLt1 13.1.le" No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/8/88 TXX-88050 CP-86-45 Seismic Category 11 System This report was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving the interaction of Seismic Category II Systems and components with Seismic Category I installations.
Qilta letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88007 CP-87-91 Startup Transformer Overload l
This letter transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving the overload capacity of the start up transformers. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
l l
Djtt.g letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX 88021 CP-87-49 Safeguards Systems Wiring Terminations l
l This letter transmitted information regarding a reportable deficiency involving a condition cited at another nuclear facility in which an open I
electrical connection on one crimp lug caused a failure in load sequencing equipment. The required formation as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Q1t_q Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect l
1/11/88 TXX-88035 CP-85-39 Equipment Conduit Interface This letter was transmitted to provide information and to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving conduit which was l
not installed in accordance with design documents.
Qjtt.g letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88057 CP-86-52 Cable Tray Splices and Field Drilled Tray Holes This letter was submitted to status corrective action associated with a deficiency involving splice / connections used for cable trays in Units 1 and 2.
Q.a_1.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX 88059 CP-876-13 Class IE Separation Violations i
l This letter transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving Class IE j
separation violations resulting from the removal of or modification of non-safety class cable tray covers after acceptance by CPSES Quality Control.
i The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qjtt.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88060 CP 87-40 Electrical Isolation Class IE, Non IE l
This report transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving electrical isolation between Class lE and Non Class IE equipment.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
(
l 7
Qgg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88061 CP-87-45 Reactor Coolant Pump Motor Circuitry This report transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving control logic and control power for the electrical breakers supplying the Rector Coolant Pump Motors.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qug Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88062 CP-87-79 Cable and Raceway Data System Calculations This report transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving cable field installations which may be inconsistent with the manner in which the Cable and Raceway Data System calculates percent fill and cable weight loading for cable trays.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qgg letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/11/88 TXX-88066 CP-88-07 Reactor Coolant Pump Wiring This report transmits information regarding a deficiency involving reactor coolant pump wiring.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
D.ilt.g letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88069 CP 88-10 15 KV Bus Ampacity Rating This report transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving the 15 kv bus ampactiy rating. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
i QLtg Letter No.
SQAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88070 CP-86-ll Battery Charger Overheating This report transmits information regarding a deficiency involving battery charger overheating. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
QLt3 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/11/88 TXX-88071 CP-88-12 Class lE and Non Class IE Cable Separation l
This report transmits information regarding a deficiency involving electrical l
separation criteria.
The required information as to description of the l
deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this l
issue.
Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect l
QLig 1/11/88 TXX 88072 CP-87-51 480V Electrical Penetration Backup Protection L
l l
This report was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date l
regarding deficiencies involving backup protection for the 480 V containment l
electrical penetrations.
I Di.tg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/12/88 TXX-88001 CP-87-62 Class 5 Pipe Supports This report was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency identified in the use of nomographs to design seismically supported class 5 piping systems.
QLt3 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect l
l 1/13/88 TXX-88004 CP-87-16 Purge Gas Overpressurization of Tanks This report was submitted to provide information regarding a deficiency l
involving the postulated failure of the nitrogen purge regulating valves which could overpressurize the Condensate Storage Tank and the Reactor Make Up Water Storage Tank.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
.g.
l l
I L
QA11 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/13/88 TXX-88091 CP-86-35 Motor Operators for Manual Valves This letter was transmitted to status corrective action implemented to date i
J regarding a deficiency involving the motor operators for several valves in the main steam system, j
Q111 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/15/88 TXX-88008 CP-87-47 Consumable Materials Placement Program This letter transmitted information regarding a deficiency involving the program for technical approval of replacement consumables. The required information as to description of ti.e deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
QLtg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/15/88 TXX-88098 CP-86-10 Electrical Penetration Assemblies This letter vas submitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving the electrical penetration assemblies supplied by Bunker Ramo.
Q1tg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/18/88 TXX-88123 See List Reportable Items under Attached to 10CFR50.55(e) letter This letter transmitted a status report on several items reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
Q1tg letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 4
1/19/88 TXX-88042 CP-87-50 Feedwater Pump Bearing Temperature This letter was transmitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving abnormal thrust bearing temperatures on the Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump.
, }
o DAlg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/25/88 TXX-88147 CP-85-35 Cable Hanger Design This latter was transmitted to status corrective action implemented to date regaroing a deficiency involving the design and construction activities of the cable tray support program.
Q111 letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/26/88 TXX-88149 CP-86-73 ASME Snubber Attachment Brackets This letter was submitted to status corrective action implemented to date regarding a deficiency involving installation of ASME snubber attachment
(
brackets.
l.-
C.
26 Letters - Final Reoort - Deficiency is not reportable.
(See listing as follows)
Data Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 12/22/87 TXX-7083 CP-87-Il7 Service Water System Electrical Design This is a final report of a deficiency involving the 118 volt interlock control circuitry for the Service Water System recirculation line isolation valves.
Evaluation has determined that in the event of failure of either of the affected valves to close due to simultaneous power failures, the amount of Service Water System flow unavailable for heat removal would be insignificant and would not affect the safe operation of the service water system. Had this issue remained uncorrected, no condition adverse to the safety of plant operations would exist. This issue is not reportable under the provisions of l
Q111 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 12/23/87 TXX-7047 CP-86-55 Seismic Air Gap Design This is a final report of a deficiency involving a potential design inadequacy of the seismic air gap between the Auxiliary Building and Units 1 and 2 Containment Buildings.
Evaluations have confirmed that the existing seismic air gap is acceptable for the loading combinations contained in the FSAR.
This issue, therefore, does not represent a significant deficiency in design or construction of the plant and is not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
Q111 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect i
12/23/87 TXX-7048 CP-87-35 Raychem Motor Connection Kits This is a final report of a deficiency involving Raychem Motor Connection Kits which were provided to CPSES with shims which may not be compatible with the use range requirements of the supplied breakout components.
Because of the location of areas where the motor connection kits were used and the acceptability of insulation properties, it was concluded that this deficiency would not adversely affect safe plant operations.
This issues is not reportable pursuant to 10 CFR 50.55(e). ---
o Q111 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 12/2/87 TXX-7053 CP-87-105 Conductor Lug Terminations This is final report a deficiency involving cable termination inspections which indicate that multiple cable termination deviations may exist.
Engineering evaluation has determined that all lugs had full crimp impression on the barrel, all connections were mechanically sound, there were no loose connections and that imperfect crimping of conductor insulation has no adverse affect on the function of the cables. Based upon such evaluation it has been determined that this item is not reportable pursuant to 10 CFR 50.55(e).
Q1tg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 12/23/87 TXX-7055 CP-87-Il2 Hot Shutdown Panel Seismic Analysis This is a final report of a deficiency which indicated the Unit 2 hot shutdown panel and main control board may not be seismically qualified.
Calculations were prepared to verify the structural integrity of the main control board and the hot shut down panel. There calculations confirmed structural integrity of the main control board and that the hot shutdown panel would not be impaired had the deficiencies gone uncorrected. Since this deficiency would not have caused a condition adverse to the safety of plant operations, it is not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
D_itta Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject i
12/23/87 TXX-7059 CP-87-75 Epoxy Grout Temperature This is a final report of a deficiency involving the proper recording of contact surface temperatures prior to placement of epoxy type grouts.
Review by Stone & Webster has determined that construction procedures in effect when epoxy grouts were used as well as related Inspection Reports provided confirmation that inspection personnel usually documented temperature readings or referred to manufacturers requirements and therefore were aware of I
temperature requirements associated with epoxy grout placement.
This condition, therefore, is not reportable under provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
j l
I D.A.ta Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 12/23/87 TXX-7066 CP-86-81 80P Safety-Related Instrument SetPoints This is a final report of a deficiency involving the calculations of 80P safety-related instrument setpoints, indicating that omissions of required data or use of incorrect information occurred in performing the calculations required.
Stone and Webster Engineering Corp. has reviewed the B0P instrument setpoint calculations and concluded that the condition has no safety significance.
Further, new calculations performed by Stone & Webster Engineering Corp. using revised methodology for most of the setpoints has been completed, with no significant deficiency resulting. This issue, therefore, does not represent a significant deficiency in design or construction of the plant and is not reportable under provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
Q.g.11 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/23/87 TXX-7114 CP-87-84 Secondary Meter and Relay Circuit Cable Leads This is a final report of a deficiency involving long electric cable leads in the secondary meter and relry CT circuits for the emergency Diesel Generator.
Evaluation has been determined that the circuits in question are automatically bypassed during an emergency start of the diesel generator, and would not have prevented them from performing the intended safety function.
It was concluded that had this issue remained uncorrected, no condition adverse to plant safety would have existed, therefore, the issue is not reportable under 10CFR50.55(e).
Qjtta letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/28/87 TXX-7126 CP-87-70 Pre-Bend Pipe Wall Thickness This is a final report of a deficiency involving possible violation of pre-bend pipe wall thickness due to inadequate QC inspector procedures.
To date all bends tested meet the manufacturer's minimum pipe wall thickness j
requirement.
There is no indication that either the bending process or the lack of post bend inspections resulted in any pipe wall thickness violations.
This testing provides the basis for concluding this item is not reportable pursuant to 10CFR50.55(e)..
Djttjt Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/29/87 TXX-7070 CP 87-38 Fire Detection System PC Boards This is a final report of a deficiency involving possible excessive current damages to the annunicator circuitry of the printed circuit boards (PC boards) for the Fire Detection System.
The problem was identified as resulting from a bent center pin within light sockets in local fire protection panels supplied by Allison Control, Inc. Analysis revealed that the problem was restricted to lamp sockets and appears to be a manufacturing defect.
All sockets similar to those damaged are being replaced and specifications have been revised to require UL or FM listings an components used within Fire Protection Panels.
Based upon evaluation, it was determined that this issue is not reportable pursuant to 10CFR50.55(e).
Djttjt letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 12/29/87 TXX-7127 CP-87-106 Component Design Specification Discrepancy This is a final report of a deficiency involving the configuration of foundation bolting for safety-related nechanical equipment.
The investigaticn of this issue performed under Issue Specific Action Plan VII.c, determined that by direct calculation or by reference to design calculations, the deviations in each case would not affect the safety function of the equipment, even under seismic loading conditions.
This item is not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
Djtijt letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/5/88 TXX-88012 CP-86-32 Thru Wall Embedded Conduit Sleeves This is a final report of a deficiency involving thru wall embedded conduit sleeves.
Evaluation of pertinent data regarding this issue has not identified any deficiencies meeting the requirements of reportability under provisions of 10CFR 50.55(e).
QLt.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/6/88 TXX-88005 CP-87-126 Fire Detection System Power Supply This is a final report of a deficiency in the fire detection alarm circuitry in which a loss of emergency power would disable the fire detection functional capability of annunicating in the main control room.
Evaluation of this issue has determined that the a fail-safe trouble contact in the Fire Detection Main Control Panel (FDMCP) would indicate a troubled condition at the FDMCP. This contact would close and annunicate. Therefore, no reportable deficiency exists.
QLta letter No, SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/6/88 TXX-88018 CP-87-81 Weidmuller Terminal Block Connections This is a final report of a deficiency involving apparent inadequacies in the installation and inspection procedure which have resulted in unacceptably loose wire connections at Weidmuller terminal blocks. An assessment of the safety significance of this issue based upon the results of field validations has resulted in the conclusion that no conditions adverse to the safety of plant operations exist. This issues is not reportable pursuant to 10CFR50.555(e).
D111 Leiter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/7/88 TXX-88043 CP 84-12 Impact of HELB Temperatures on Equipment This letter transmitted a final report of a deficiency involving the environmental qualification of equipment outside containment for high energy line breaks.
The results of engineering analysis and review have demonstrated that all CPSES equipment and cables, which are required to function to mitigate the consequence of a MSLB with a superheated steam release outside l
containment and to provide subsequent safe shutdown capability, are qualified l
with adequate margin to function during the event. This issue is not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
I l
l l
l L
h11 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/8/88 TXX-88054 CP-87-72 Improperly Defined Weld Lengths This letter transmitted a final report of a potential deficiency involving inadequate measurement of weld lengths in joints of structural tube steel for small bore and large bore pipe supports. After an evaluation, it has been determined that the subject welds meet applicable design requirements end no significant deficiencies exist.
This issue is not reportable under the provision of 10CFR50.55(e).
h11 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/8/88 TXX-88056 List Attached Potentially Reportable to Letter 10CFR50.55(e) Items This letter transmitted a list of potentially reportable items that evaluation has determined are not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
l hti Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/11/88 TXX-88019 CP-87 36 Equipment Qualification This is a final report of a deficiency involving evaluations which indicate l
that the vendor equipment furnished in cecordance with several balance of plant project specifications contained deficiencies and discrepancies.
l Engineering evaluation has concluded that deficiencies in the vendor reports do not affect the qualification of equipment.
hta Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88022 CP-87-95 Design of Power CP-87-89 and Control cables CP-87-88 This is a final report of three deficiencies involving inadequate design of power and control cables connected to the 125 VDC vital buses.
After engineering evaluation it was concluded the deficiencies were not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
l hta letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX 88047 List Attached Potentially Reportable I
to Letter
.10CFR50.55(e) Items This letter transmitted a list of potentially reportable items that evaluation l
has determined are not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
l l
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/11/88 TXX-88073 CP-86-68 Weather Protection This is a final report of deficiency involving weather protection of Class lE components used in outdoor installations.
Evaluation has found no safety significant conditions relating to this issue, therefore, it is not reportable pursuant to 10CFR50.55(e).
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 1/13/88 TXX-88082 CP-87-65 LOCA Effects on HVAC duct This letter transmitted a final report of a deficiency involving a postulated loss of coolant accident effect on HVAC ducts inside the Containment Building.
Based on the results of parametric studies and related analyses, it was determined that the ductwork will not fail catastrophically due to loss of coolant accident inside containment. This issue, therefore, is not reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
Q111 letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 1/18/88 TXX 88120 CP-87-12 Containment P/T Analysis Computer Error This letter transmitted a final report of a deficiency involving a computer error in the containment pressure / temperature analysis.
Evaluation of all safety related equipment inside containment required to be qualified for peak containment temperatures indicated no significant deficiency was created by the increased peak temperature value. This issue, therefore, is not reportable under provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/19/88 TXX-88046 CP 87-30 Roll-Away Missile Shields This is a final report of a deficiency involving errors in the seismic qualification report supplied by the vendor of the Roll-Away Missile Shields.
The completed evaluation has concluded that this issue is not reportable pursuant tu 10CFR50.55(e).
Q311 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/19/88 TXX-88121 See List Potentially Reportable Attached to Letter 10CFR50.55(e) Items This letter transmitted a list of potentially reportable items determined not to be reportable under the provisions of 10CFR50.55(e).
Q311 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/28/88 TXX-88152 CP-87-32 Quality Control Inspection Qualification This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving apparent weaknesses in the Quality Control Inspector Certification Program. Reference was made to the evaluations made pursuant to ISAP 1.d.1, "QC Inspector Qualifications" which concluded the certification program was adequate.
This issue, therefore, is not reportable pursuant to 10CFR50.55(e).
t D.
55 letters - Final Report - Deficiency is reportable and corrective action taken.
(See listing as follows)
Q111 letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/6/88 TXX-88025 CP-87-121 6.9 kv/480V Transformer Bus Bar Clearance This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving 6.9 kV/480V transformer bus bar clearance. The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
Q11g letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88049 CP-87-123 Terminations Not Per Drawing This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving wire terminations not in accordance with design drawings. The required information as to descriptions of issue, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
QAlg letter No.
SDAR Not Subiect 1/11/88 TXX-88063 CP-87-101 Class IE Cable
[
Arrangement This letter transmits a final repnrt nf a deficiency involving Class IE Cable arrangement.
The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action for this item is providad in the report.
Q11g letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88064 CP-87-134 Class IE AC Electrical System This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving cable ampacity ratings, voltage ratings and Class IE separation criteria. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
I
?.
Dtt.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88065 CP-87-136 Motor Control Center Space Heaters This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving electrical separation related to space heaters for Class IE motor control centers. The required information es to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
D.it.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/11/88 TXX-88068 CP-88-09 Electrical Penetration Overload Protection This letter transmitted a final report of a deficiency involving the overloading of and the lack of backup protection devices for Class lE and non-Class IE electrical penetrations. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
QLtg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iett 1/11/88 TXX 88074 CP 87-93 MCC Starter Coils This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving MCC starter coils. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
Qat.g letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/11/88 TXX-88075 CP-87-119 Essential and Emergency I
Lighting Supports This letter transmitted a final report an a deficiency involving installation of essential lighting and emergency lighting systems.
This item was not considered a separately reportable item under 10CFR50.55(e) since it had previously been addressed in two SDAR's.
Q31g letter No.
J.QAR No.
Subiect 1/13/88 TXX-88067 CP 88-08 Battery Room Heaters This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving qualification of unit heaters in Close IE battery rooms.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
21-
Q111 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 1/18/88 TXX-88009 CP-87-15 Air Accumulators for Control Valves This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving the air accumulators for air-operated control valves. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in this report.
Q111 letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/18/88 TXX-88078 CP-86-13 Jet Impingement Load Review This is a final report of a deficiency involving a computer entry error which could invalidate portions of the jet impingement load review for high energy line breaks. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
Q111 Ltl.13r_NA SDAR No.
_ Subject 1/18/88 TXX-88102 CF-87-17 Control Room Habitaoility This is a final report of a deficiency involving control room habitability following radiological accidents. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety imp 1,ications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Ditt Letter No.
SOAR No.
Sub.iect 1/18/88 TXX-88103 CP-87-18 Safety Chilled Water System Chiller Units This item was transmitted to status corrective action and to provide a final report concerning a deficiency involving the Safety Chilled Water Chiller units. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action are provided for this issue.
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 1/18/88 TXX-88104 CP-87-19 Ambient Air Effects-MSIV Actuators This letter transmitted a final report regarding a deficiency involving the ambient temperature effects on MSly actuators. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for the issue.
Ella letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/18/88 TXX-88105 CP-87-25 011 Tank Vent Missile Protection This letter transmitted a final report regarding a deficiency involving failure to provide missile protection for the diesel fuel oil storage tank vent piping. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety significance and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Q11g letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 1/18/88 TXX-88107 CP-87-29 Isolation of Component Cooling Water This is a final report submitted to provide additional information describing the cause of the deficiency involving instrumentation and controls used for isolation of component cooling water to the reactor coolant pump thermal barrier heat exchanger, and corrective actions for the issue.
Qatg letter No.
SDAR Nqi Subject 1/18/88 TXX-88108 CP-87-55 Containment Spray Pump Recirculating Piping This letter transmitted a final report regarding a deficiency involving the containment spray pump recirculation piping. The report provides information concerning the preventive and corrective actions implemented for this issue.
I.
Q3h Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/18/88 TXX-88112 CP 87-108 Feedwater Pump Low Suction Trip This letter was transmitted to status corrective and preventive action and to provide a final report concerning a deficiency involving the low suction pressure trip function of the Auxiliary Feedwater (AFW) Pumps which may render the AFW System inoperable.
Q11g letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/18/88 TXX-88114 CP-88-01 CCW Surge Tank Capacity This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving the failure to properly establish the low and empty level setpoints for the Component Cooling Water System Surge tank. The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action is provided for the issue.
DAR Letter No.
SDAR No2 Subiect 1/18/88 TXX-88115 CP-88-15 Containment Maximum Flood Level e
This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving containment maximum flond.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this issue is provided in the report.
Q11g (gtter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.ieel 1/18/88 TXX 88118 CP-87-133 High Energy Line Break Analysis Th's letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving multiple examples of potentially significant conditions concerning High Energy Line Break Analysis. The required information as to description of the deficienev, safety implications and corrective action for this issue is provided in the report. 1 u
Qgig Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/18/88 TXX-88119 CP-88-53 Pipe Whip Restraint Design Methodology This letter transmitted a final report of a deficiency involving the methodology used for design of pipe whip restraints. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this issue is provided in the report.
Egig letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/19/88 TXX-88109 CP-87-90 RHR Relief Valve Piping This letter transmitted a final report regarding a design deficiency involving relief valve piping connected to the Residual Heat Removal Pump suction piping. The report addresses the the cause of the condition as well as the preventive action and corrective action implementation schedule.
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/19/88 TXX-88113 CP-87-129 Containment Spray System PH This letter was transmitted to status correctiva action and to provide a final report concerning a deficiency involving the containment spray ph.
The final report addresses preventive action and an implementation schedule required to resolve the issue.
Q11g (etter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect I
1/19/88 TXX-88116 CP-87-16 Containment Spray Chemical System This letter transmitted a final report of a deficiency involving the Containment Spray System chemical additive tank and associated piping which has been identified as being designed and fabricated from material that does not provide the specified design life. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
l l 1
Qgig Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/20/88 TXX-88086 CP-87-64 Design Basis Tornado Analysis This letter is a final report of a deficiency involving the pressure relieving capacity of the tornado venting devices in Units 1 and 2.
The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Egig Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/20/88 TXX-88106 CP-87-26 Fuel Oil Transfer Pump Suction Lift This letter transmitted a final report regarding deficiency involving diesel generator fuel oil transfer pump suction lift.
The report provided the corrective action for this issue.
QLig letter No.
SDAR No.
Igble,ql 1/20/88 TXX-88110 CP-87-100 Containment Piping Penetrations This letter was transmitted to status corrective and preventive action and to provide h final report concerning a deficiency involving the la:k of everpressure protection fcr three containment peaetrations.
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 1/20/88 TXX 88127 CP 87-137 Diesel Generator Heat Exchanger This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving the diesel generator governor heat exchanger which could reduce the cooling capacity of the heat exchanger. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for the issue.
l l
QLig letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/21/88 TXX-88020 CP-87-103 Cracked Gears in Valve Operators j
l This letter transmitted a final report of a deficiency involving cracked gears in valve operators. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
26-l
QAlg Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/21/88 TXX-88126 CP-87-46 Containment Pump Rotor / Stator Gap This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving unsatisfactory internal clearances for two Containment Spray Pump Motors. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this issue is provided in the report.
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Eghfggt 1/25/88 TXX-88138 CP-88-13 Auxiliary Feedwater System Air Accumulators This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency in which the Auxiliary Feedwater System air accumulators for the flow control and recirculation valves may be inadequately sized to satisfy FSAR commitments. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Q11g letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/25/88 TXX 88141 CP 88-05 AFW Instrumentation Electrical Separation This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency invciving Auxiliary 3
Feedwater instrumentation electrical separation. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective / preventive action is provided in the report.
Q11g Letter No.
SOAR No.
Subiect 1/25/88 TXX 88142 CP-88 104 Safety System Setpoint Calculation Errors This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving errors in protection actuation setpoint calculations for NSSS systems. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
27-
Q11g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/25/88 TXX-88144 CP-88-18 Post Accident Monitoring Instrumentation This letter transmits a fina'I report of a deficiency involving post accident monitoring channels for the Reactor Coolant System. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
Q311 Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 1/28/88 TXX-88137 CP-87-54 Class 1E MOV Motor Starters This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving electrical design drawings which do not implement FSAR requirements for Class 1E motor-operated valve motor starters. The requfvad information as to description of the deficiency, safety implicatf or.s and corrective action is provided for this issue.
Qalg Letter No.
SDAR No.
jyhja.gl i
1/28/88 TXX-88157 CP 88-20 HEL8 Detection rad Mitigation This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving instrumentation utilized in the detection and mitigatien for several high energy line breaks located outside containment. The required information as to description of the deff etency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
Q1la Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iegt 1/29/88 TXX-88099 CP 86-36 Large Bore Piping and Supports This letter transmitted a final report regarding deficiency issues associated with large bore piping and pipe supports.
References was made to the Project Status Report on Large Bore Piping and Pipe Supports for a discussion of the program to resolve these issues, the results and corrective and preventive action implemented.
o e
/
)
28-
- "~]'\\'y ~
77 V
3g 9 m q)\\,Mq
'()
y 3
(
q.s
( q' a
8 d,
8 4
y
- 3 i-y 11tb.iect QLt1 Letter No, t
SDAR No'.
.^.3; s
1/29/88
y;;
This 1cttir transmitted a final report regarding deficiency issues associated with una11 bore piping and pipe supports. Referer<'e was made to' the Project Status Repoet on Small Bore Piping and Pipe' Supports for a disedssion of the progrd$ to resolve these issues, the results and corrective and preventive action implemented.
h II i
'9di letter No.
19AR hif.1 Sub.ibdl
\\ j' j
's 1/29/88 TXX-88129
[
CP-8'11Y4 Flexible Metal hbing g N,'
/
t.M salignment 3.
r,.
Thislettertransmitsafinaireporto',adeficiencK(involvingunacceptable flexible metal tubing installe,tions in safet'y elate aoplications.
The required informatien as to description of 'the (.tsbe,{pc*
sa correctiveactionforthQitemisprovidedinthe,r t.
.1 a
% 2
~
4 h
Sub.iect QLig letter EL SDAR No.
1/29/88 LXX-Bh112 CP 87-44 Unistrut Tubing Support Bolting s
y
.s This lattir transmits a final report of a deficiency involving specification l
CPSES d-1018 Installation of Piping / Tubing and instrumentation" which allows the use of either A5EM A-307, Grade A or B,or S3E J-429, Gradt 1 or 2 bolting in tuoing supports.T Therequiredinforma$ynast.1 description ~ofthe deficir:ncy, safety staplications and correchve action is provided for this A
issue, 5 l
Qtta letter No.
SDAR NL Sutdect 3
l 1/29/88
,TXX-88140 CP-88-21 Instrument Tubing Clamps s
l This letter tre.]smits a fir,a1 repnrt of a deficiency involving J. C. White i
Tube Clamps. The, required inforn:ation as to dt<crMtion of the da'iciency, safety significMce and corcective/preventfve acticn is provided for the issue.
l 8
l 3
l l '
l i
S h
l
tA, i
N, 4
'\\
k hig Letter Not SDAR No.
Subiect y%
e s )/29/88 TXX 88143 CP-88-19 Cable Insulation Resistance Loop Accuracy
',This lettecLtransmits a final report of a deficiency involving instrument cable insulation inside containment not being suitable for post-accident environments. The required information as to description of the deficiency, s_aiety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
Qttg Letter No, SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/29/88 TXX 88146 CP-86-19 Instrumentation Installations 3
'This letter transmits a final report of deficiencies involving pressure instrumentation installations at CPSES. Evaluations addressed in the final report include the following related issues:
Fire Effects on Instrument Tubing (CP-85-16), Unistrut Spring Nuts on Instrument Supports (CP 86 50),
El u ated Temperature Effects on Tubing (CP 86-70) and Instrument Tubing Minimum Wall Thickness (CP 86 77).
ht.g letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect
.r/29/88 TXX 88156 CP-87 16 Limit Switch Wiring This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving installation of
. safety related valve limit switches. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
Qtta Letter No, SDAR No.
Sub.iec t l
1/29/88 TXX-88164 CP-88-24 Instrument Tube i
Restraints and Supports I
This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving instrument tube restraints and supports. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
I l
! l-
QLt.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 1/29/88 TXX-88170 CP 88-25 Auxiliary Feedwater Pump Control Panel This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving the design of the Auxiliary Feedwater Pump Turbine control panel which would impair the Auxiliary Feedwater System's ability to provide emergency feedwater to the steam generators. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action is provided in the report.
QLtjt letter No.
SDAR No.
Sub.iect 2/4/88 TXX-88036 CP-87-120 Tornado Missile Barriers This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving tornado missile barriers. The required information as to description of the issue, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
QLt.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 2/4/88 TXX-88055 CP 87-Il5 Seismic Analysis of Water Intake System This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving the seismic analysis of the Service Water Intake Structure. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
Q31g letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 2/4/88 TXX-88124 CP 88 23 Design Groundwater Elevation This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving the design basis groundwater level at CPSES. The required information as to description i
of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this issue is provided in the report.
I I
I QLt.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 2/4/88 TXX-88125 CP-87 53 Seismic Category I Platforms This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving Seismic Category 11 platforms. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this issue is provided in the report.
QLt.g letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 2/4/88 TXX-88131 CP-87-67 Undersized Bolts and Missing Jam Nuts This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving the absence of Jam nuts on the Unit I rotating platform and undersized bolts in vendor fabricated structural steel installations. The required information as to description of the problem, safety implications and corrective action is provided for this issue.
QLt.g Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subject 2/4/88 TXX-88159 CP-87-130 Service Water System Water Hammer This letter transmitted information regarding implementation of corrective action and a final report for a deficiency involving Service Water System l
water hammer and column separation at the inlet and outlet of the emergency diesel generator jacket water coolers.
l l
Ett.g Letter No.
SDAR NL Subject 2/5/88 TXX-88017 CP-87-78 Bolted Connectors in Shear Planes This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving deviations in the structural steel bolting in the cable spreading rooms. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and l
corrective action for this item is provided in the report.
1 1,
1 i
r agig Letter No.
SDAR No.
Subiect 2/11/88 TXX-88010 CP 87-109 Inappropriate Deficiency Documentation This letter transmits a final report of a deficiency involving inappropriate deficiency documentation. The required information as to description of the deficiency, safety implications and corrective action for this item is provided in this report.
i i
I l
l 1
l 33 1
RESPONSES TO NRC INSPECTION REPORT /
NOTICE OF VIOLATION / NOTICE OF DEVIATION The following correspondence was issued by Applicants to the NRC concerning inspection reports, during the period of December 26, 1987 to February 25, 1988:
D.Lt.g letter Sub.iect 7/31/87 TXX-6597 Revised Response to Notice of Deviation This letter transmitted a revised response to NOD, Item 1.5 relating to Inspection Report No. 50 445/86-07.
Q.Lt.g Letter Subiect 12/7/87 TXX-7037 Response to Notice of Violation and Notice of Deviation This letter transmitted a response to NOV, Item C and NOD relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87 16 and 50-446/87-13.
Q.Lig Letter Sub.iect 12/18/87 TXX-0767 Response to Inspection Reports This letter transmitted a response to open items identified in connection with Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87 04 and 50 446/87-04.
M Letter Subiect 12/31/87 TXX-7119 Revised Date of Full Compliance 4
This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV, Item 0.1 relating to Inspection Repart Nos. 50 445/8603 and 50 446/8602.
l l
Q11g Letter Subject 12/31/87 TXX-7120 Revised Responses to Notice of Violation This letter transmitted a revised response to NOV, Item A relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50-445/86 26 and 50 446/86 22.
Q11g Letter Subject 12/31/87 TXX-7131 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/86 03 and 50 446/86-02.
QAlf Letter Subiect 12/31/87 TXX-7132 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOD 445/8716 D 01.
Q11g Letter Subiect 12/31/87 TXX-7139 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV Item B and C relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87-18 and 50-446/87-14.
Q11g Letter Subiect 1/7/88 TXX 880ll Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV, Item A relating to inspection Report No. 50-445/84-16.
i QAlg letter Subiect 1/11/88 TXX-88030 Revised Response to Notice of Violation This letter transmitted a revised response to NOV, Item C relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/85 18 and 50 446/85-15.
Dilg letter Subiect 1/13/88 TXX 88080 Response to Notice of Deviation This letter transmitted a response to NOD relating to Inspection Report Nos.
50-445/87-29 and 50 446/87 21.
QAlg letter Subiect 1/13/88 TXX 88092 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV, Item C relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87-16 and 50 446/87 13.
Q11g Letter Subiect 1/15/88 TXX 88079 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV, Item B relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/67 30 and 50 446/87-22.
Q11g letter Subiect 1/18/88 TXX-88081 Response to Notice of Deviation and Notice of Violation This letter transmitted a response to NOV, item A and B and NOD relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87-31 and 50-446/87-23.
i 36-
s QAlt Letter Subiect 1/29/88 TXX-88136 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV, Item D relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/18-13 and 50 446/85-09.
Q11g Letter Subiect 1/29/88 TXX-88158 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV, Item A relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87-11 and 50-446/87-09.
Q11g Letter Subiect 1/29/88 TXX-88160 Revised Response to Notice of Deviation This letter transmitted an updated response to NOD relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50-445/87-18 and 50 446/87-14.
Q11g Letter Sub.iect 1/29/88 TXX 88162 Revised Respense to Notice of Deviation This letter transmitted a revised and updated response to NOD relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87-31 and 50 446/87-23 Q11g Letter Subfect 1/29/88 TXX 88163 Response to Open Items This letter transmitted response to Open items relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50 445/87-04 and 50-446/87-04.
QAlt Letter Subfect 1/29/88 TXX 88165 Revised Date of Full Compliance This letter transmitted a revised date of full compliance for NOV, Item A relating to Inspection Report Nos. 50-445/87-11 and 50 446/87-09.
.o a
CPRT/ CORRECTIVE ACTION PROGRAM The following correspondence was issued by Applicants to the NRC concerning CPRT and/or the Corrective Action Program during the time period of December 26, 1987 thru February 25, 1988:
D.A.t.g Letter Sub.iect 6/25/87 TXX 6540 CPRT Program Plan This letter transmitted Revision 4 to the Comanche Peak Response Team Program Pl an.
Q1.tg Letter Subiect 9/23/87 TXX 6783 Post Construction Hardware Validation Program This letter transmitted the Attribute Matrix for the Post Construction Hardware Validation Program.
QA.tg Letter Sub.iect 9/29/87 TXX 6809 CPRT Results Reports This letter transmittea SRT approved CPRT Results Reports.
Q1.t.g Letter Sub.iect 11/2/87 TXX-6845 Project Status Report This letter transmitted copies of the Project Status Report for "Large Bore Piping and Pipe Supports," Rev. O.
Q3.t..g letter Subiect 11/2/87 TXX 6846 Project Status Report This letter transmitted copies of the Project Status Report for "Small Bore Piping and Pipe Supports," Rev. O.
Date Letter Subject 1/8/88 TXX 88044 Project Status Report This letter transmitted copies of the Project Status Report for "Equipment Qualification," Rev. O.
Date letter Subject 1/15/88 TXX-88097 Project Status Report This letter transmitted copies of the Project Status Report for "Electrical,"
Revision 0.
Date Letter Subjerd 1/25/88 TXX-88117 Project Status Report This letter transmitted copies of the Project Status Report for "Mechanical Supplement A - Systems Interaction," Revision 0 and "Mechancial Supplement B - Fire Protection," Revision 0.
Date Letter Subject 2/1/88 TXX-88135 Corrective Action Response This letter transmitted a status of.netions identified in a letter of December 18, 1987 responding to comments on the CPSES corrective action effort made by the NRC Staff during the Dece.tber 9, 1987 public meeting.
Date letter Subject 2/1/88 TXX-88145 Project Status Report This letter transmitted the Project Status Report for "Instrumentation and l
Controls," Revision 0.
i Da_te letter Subject 2/29/88 TXX-88269 Collective Significant Report l
This letter transmitted an SRT approved Results Report for ISAP Vll.a.9 and the Collective Significance Report.
I QA1.g Letter Sub.iect 11/6/87 TXX-6930 Project Status Report This letter transmitted the Project Status Report for "Cable Tray and Cable 7 ray Hangers," Rev. O.
Qitt Letter Sub.iect 11/11/87 TXX-6948 Project Status Report This letter transmitted the Project Status Report for "Conduit Support Train C 2 Inch Diameter and Less," Rev. O.
Q;1.tg Letter Sub.iect 12/16/87 TXX-6958 PSR Referenced Procedures This letter transmitted the latest revisions to field verification methods, quality inspection procedures, and erection specifications referenced in Project Stttus Reports.
Q11.g Letter Sub.iect 12/18/87 TXX-7099 Response to Comments on Corrective Action Program This letter transmitted a response to comments made by the NRC Staff during a public meeting held on December 9,1987 concerning the CPSES corrective action effort.
i Q11g Letter Subiect 12/30/87 TXX-6858 Results Report Information l
This letter provided a response to the NRC Staff's request for additional i
information on ISAP V.a Results Report.
QLig Letter Sub.iect 12/31/87 TXX-7134 CPRT Results Report l
This letter transmitted an SRT approved CPRT Results Report for ISAP VII.c.
j and the Collective Evaluation Report.
I
. l l
L
CYGNA
-The following correspondence was issued by Applicants concerning CYGNA during the time period of; December 26, 1987 thru February 25, 1988:
QAlg (glifr Subject 6/9/87 TXX 6515 Cygna Document Request This letter transmitted documents requested by Cygna.
Q111 Letter Subject 9/4/87 TXX-6718 Cygna Document Request This letter transmitted documents requested by Cygna..
INTERNAL AND TECHNICAL AUDITS The following internal and technical audit reports of CPSES Engineering and Construction activities were issued in the period from December 26, 1987 -
February 26, 1988:
Number:
ATP 87-55 Date:
12/9/87-12/16/87 Report Date:
1/4/88 Scope:
Verification of implementation of technical and design control requirements applicable to seismic qualification of CPSES plant equipment within Impell's scope of work as performed at Impell's Fort Worth, Texas and Walnut Creek, California facilities. All category I equipment considered except NSSS equipment under Westinghouse and Impell Chicago.
Location:
Impell, Fort Worth, Texas Number:
ATP 87-62 Date:
11/17/87 11/23/87 Report Date:
12/29/87 Scope:
Verification of implementation of Ebasco Systems Interface prog' am, which included technical and programmatic aspects of the progran for essential plant items.
Location:
Ebasco, CPSES site Number:
ATP 88 64 Date:
1/4/88-1/8/88 Report Date:
1/22/88 Scope:
Verification and Technical evaluation of the preparation, issuance and control of calculations and design validation packages within the civil / structural discipline.
Location SWEC, Boston, MA Number:
ATP-87-65 l
Date:
9/18/88 1/22/88 Report Date:
2/6/88 Scope:
Verification and technical evaluation of SWEC-CAP electrical design validation program.
Location:
SWEC, Boston, MA l
v-c Number:
ATP-87-66 Date:
12/14/87 12/18/87 Report Date:
12/31/87 Scope:
. Technical evaluation of SWEC CAP nuclear and the effects of radiation on safety relateo equipment and components.
Location:
ATP 87 67 Date:
11/17/87-11/24/87 Report Date:
12/31/87 Scope:
Verification of Unit 1 Cable Tray Hanger site design validation and reconciliation of designed and as built configuration work as performed by Ebasco Services.
Location:
Ebasco, CPSES Site Number:
ATP-87-68 Date:
11/16/87-11/20/87 Report Date:
12/17/87 Scope:
Verification of implementation of Grinnell's technical and design control program for CPSES Unit 1 Fire Protection Systems within the Unit 1 Safety related areas.
Location: Grinnell, CPSES Site Number:
ATP-87-71 Date:
11/9/87-11/13/87 Report Date:
12/22/87 Scope:
Verification of implementation of EPM's technical and design control program for CPSES fire protection program as related to the safe I
shutdown analysis.
Location EPM, CPSES Site Number:
ATP 87 73 Date:
11/9/87-11/3/87 Report Date:
12/12/87 Scope:
Verification and technical evaluation of SWEC-CAP I & C design validation program as related to setpoint calculations and Design Basis Documents.
Location:
SWEC, Boston, MA I I
e 9
Number:
ATP 87-75 Date:
11/9/87 11/13/87 Report Date:
12/12/87 Scope:
Verification and technical evaluation of Impe11 compliance with the technical and design control requirements as related to seismic qualification of plant equipn.ent.
Location:
Impell, Lincolinshire, IL Number:
ATP 87-76 Date:
4/7/87-7/16/87 Report Date:
12/14/87 Scope:
Tenera technical audit surveillance report on piping and pipe supports review.
Location:
SWEC, Cherry Hill, NJ Number:
ATP-88 77 Date:
1/6/88 2/4/88 Report Date:
2/19/88 Scope:
Verification and technical evaluation of the adequacy of design validation activities including the resolution of generic issues as related to feedwater and component cooling water systems.
Location:
SWEC, Boston, MA New York, NY Impe11, Fort Worth. TX Number:
ATP 88 78 Date:
1/5/88 1/13/88 Report Date:
1/27/88 Scope:
Verification of implementation of the technical and design control requirements as applicable to the SWEC-PSAS Unit 2 small bore pipe stress / pipe support design requalification program.
Location:
ATP 88 79 Date:
1/2S/88 1/29/88 Report Date:
2/12/88 Scope:
Verification implementation of technical and design control requirements as applicable to seismic qualification of Unit 1 NSSS plant equipment within the Westinghouse scope of work. Audit also included the verification of satisfactory resolution of previously identified deficiencies and observations.
Location-Westinghouse, Pittsburgh, PA.
44-
[
?
Number:
ATP 88 80 Date:
1/25/88-1/29/88 Report Date:
2/12/88 Scope:
Verification and technical evaluation of HVAC systems calculations as related to modifications and changes in design, procedural compliance, DIR resolutions and CPSES fire protection program.
Location EBASCO, New York, NY Number:
ATP 88 81 Date:
1/20/88 1/26/88 Report Date:
2/10/88 Scope:
Verification of implementation and technical evaluation of the design control requirements as applicable to Train "C" conduit support program.
Emphasis placed on evaluation of computer analyzed supports, resolution of DIR's and control of support modifications.
Location:
Impell, CPSES Site Number:
ATP 87 536 Date:
11/2/87-12/2/87 Report Date:
12/18/87 Scope:
Verification of implementation of corrective action commitments in CPRT commitment tracking report, Rev. O for ISAP VII.a.4, "Audit Program and Auditor Qualification".
Location: TV Electric, NEO Senior Management, CPSES Site Number:
ATP 87 538 Date:
11/30/87-12/18/87 Report Date:
12/31/87 Scope:
Verification of implementation of corrective and preventive actions relative to ISAP VII.c, Appendix 17, "Mechanical Equipment Installation".
Location: TV Electric, CPSES Site Number:
ATP 87 539 Date:
11/16/87-12/8/87 Report Date:
12/31/87 Scope:
Verification of implementation of corrective and preventive actions relative to ISAP Vll.c, Appendix 10. "Piping and Fabrication".
Location: TV Electric, CPSES Site _
Number:
ATP 87 541 Date:
11/9/87-12/16/87 Report Date:
12/31/87 Scope:
Evaluation of the adequacy and effectiveness of the corrective action relative to selected portions of ISAP VII.c Appendix 31, "HVAC Duct Supports".
Location: TV Electric, CPSES Site Number:
ATP-87 544 Date:
12/7/87-12/16/87 Report Date:
1/12/88 Scope:
Verification of implementation of corrective and preventive actions relative to ISAP VII.c, Appendix 6, "Electrical Equipment Installation".
Location: TU Electric, CPSES Site J
Number:
TCP 88 01 Name:
TU Electric Site Subcontractors (Engineering & Construction)
Date:
1/25 2/3/88 Report Date:
2/12/88 Scope:
TU ilectric QA audit TCP 88 01 was performed at CPSES during the period of January 25, 1988 thru February 3, 1988.
The purpose of the audit was to verify the adequacy of all project organizations Quality Assurance Programs. The Audit was to include the review of written policies, procedures or instructions to determine compliance with the requirements of 10CFR50 Appendix B, Criteria I & II.
Number:
TCP 87-43 Name:
Impell Equipment Qualification i
l Date:
12/28/87-1/8/88 l
Report Date:
1/26/88 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit TCP 87 43 was performed December 12, 1987 thru January 8, 199 at CPSES, to verify the implementation of Impell's Equipment Qualification (EO) Program.
This review included personnel qualifications of engineers and auditors, organizations preparation of Project Instruction, Correspondence Control, Technical Quality Review, Technical Reports, Audits, Surveillances, i
NCR and SDAR processing and Discrepancy Forms.
{
l
- l
Number:
TCP 87 45 Name:
12/7 14/87 Report Date:
12/23/87 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit, TCP 87 45, was performed on December 7-14, 1987 at Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, to verify adequacy and the implementation of the HVAC program including duct / duct support installation and inspection, design and design change control, document control, maintenance of records, and personnel training.
Number:
TCP 87-49 Name:
CPE:
EA Surveillance Program Date:
12/21-23/87 Report Date:
1/8/88 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit, TCP-87 49 was preformed on December 21-23, 1987, at Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, to verify the implementation of the CPE Surveillance Program by CPE Engineering assurance. This audit also included a review of the organization, personnel training, and control of records.
Number:
TCP.87 50 Name:
Electrical Conduit Installation / Inspection Date:
12/14-22/87 Report Date:
1/14/88 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit TCP 87-f0 was performed on December 14 22, 1987 at Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station to verify the adequacy and implementation of the Electrical Conduit Installation Inspection Program. This included personnel training, records control, organization and design / design control.
Number:
TCP 87-51 Name:
Specification Review (SPASU) Program Date:
11 30/12 10-87 Report Date:
12/18/87 f
Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit, TCP 87 51 was performed on November 30 through December 10, 1987 at CPSES, to evaluate the implementation of the Specification Procedure and Drawing Update (SPADU) Program activities being performed by SWEC CAP for the Phase I installation I
specification review and approval.
1 1
(
47-l l
Number:
TUG 87 02 Name:
ODCM (Offsite Dose Calculation Manual)
Date:
1/11-14/88 Report Date:
1/27/88 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit, TUG 87 02 was performed on January 11-14-88 at CPSES to verify the readiness of the ODCM (Offsite Dose Calculation Manual) for submittal to the commission for approval. The contents of the ODCM was verified against the requirements of NUREG 0133, Reg. Guide 1.09 and 1.11. The plan for approval of the ODSM and the approval of the implementing was verified.
Number:
TCP 88-03 Name:
Document Control (Operations)
Date:
1/25-29/88 Report Date:
2/12/88 Scope:
A scheduled Audit, TUG 88 03 was conducted January 25-29, 1988 to assess the adequacy and implementation of the CPSES operations Document Control Program. The Document Control Program was evaleMM for pegram compliance with the applicable elements of 10CF3f0 Appendix B, Criteria I, II, III, V VI, and XVil. The Audit also includes an evaluation of the CPSES organization units (Office Service and Operations Document Control) for compliance to the Stction Administration Procedures (STA's) relative to their respective document control activities. Audited elements of the document control program include but were not limited to the control and issuance of station manuals, Technical Manuals, Drawings, Specification Special Orders and forms.
Number:
TCP 88 28 Name:
Reportable Occurrences and Required Reports Date:
12/14 17/87 Report Date:
12/23/87 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit, TUG 88-28, was performed on December 14-17, 1987 to evaluate the implementation of the program for reportable occurrences and required reports.
This evaluation included procedural controls and specific training for personnel that would be required to submit the reports.
l l
1 l
Number:
TCP 88 29 Name:
Operations QA Surveillance Date:
12/28 31/87 Report Date:
1/15/88 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit. TUG-87-29, was performed on December 28 31, 1987, at Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, to review and verify the implementation of the surveillance program for operations and startup activities. This review included the training and qualification programs for surveillance personnel.
Number:
TUG 87-32 Name:
Housekeeping Date:
10/19 11/17/87 Report Date:
12/17/87 Scope:
Verification of provisions for housekeeping and equipment protection during construction, startup and Operations phases was performed via audit TUG 87-32 at TV Electric Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station during October 19 to November 17, 1997.
Number:
TCP 87 33 Name:
Quality Assurance Trending Date:
12/14 17/87 Report Date:
12/23/87 Scope:
TV Electric QA Audit, TUG-87 33, was performed on December 14 17, 1987 to evaluate and verify implementation of the Quality Trending Program.
Number:
TUG-87 34 Name:
Licensed Operator Training Date:
12/14/87-1/7/88 Report Date:
1/26/88 Scope:
Evidence required to support implementation of Licensed Operator Training and Requalification Programs was reviewed at TV Electric Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station during 12-14 87 to 1/7/88.
Records were reviewed to verify completion of on the job, procedure simulator and performance evaluation, education and experience, as well as implement.
~
49-l
MISCELLANE0US i
The following additional correspondence was issued by Applicants to the NRC during the time period of December 26, 1987 - February 25, 1988:
QA11 Letter Subiect 6/12/87 TXX 6492 Interim fuel Storage Plan This letter transmitted a response to NRC Comments on Revision 6 of the Interim Fuel Storage Plan.
QLt1 Letter Sub.iect 10/26/87 TXX 6602 Generic Letter 83-28 This letter provided additional information concerning Genaric Letter 83 28, Section 2.2.1.
QA11 Letter Subiect 10/26/87 TXX 6628 Design Adequacy of Component Parts This letter transmitted a response to changes in yield strengths applicable in Code Case N 71 9.
Q111 Letter Seb.iect 12/15/87 TXX-7068 Deviation from Codes, Standard and Guides This letter transmits a response to NRC Staff concerns regarding the development and application of certain design and acceptance criteria for cable tray hangers and their compliance with applicable codes and regulatory standards.
i j ;
Egig Letter Subiect 12/23/87 TXX 6999 FSAR Amendment 66 This letter transmitted advanced draft copies of FSAR Amendment 66 changes and other potential FSAR changes.
QAlt letter Sub.iect 12/29/87 TXX 7130 CPSES Project Procedures This letter transmitted current revisions of the Comanche Peak Project Procedures and associated Project Memorandum.
Q111 Letter Subiect 1/8/88 TXX 88006 Procedures Manual Update This letter transmitted updated material to be included in the Project Procedures Manual.
Q11g Letter Subiect 1/11/88 TXX 88029 NRC Bulletin 87 02 This letter provides a response to NRC Compliance Bulletin 87 02.
Q11g Letter Sub.iect 1/15/88 TXX 88041 FSAR Amendment 66 This letter transmitted a description of FSAR Amendment 66, i
Q111 Letter Subiect 1/15/88 TXX-88041 FSAR Amendment This letter transmitted copies of Amendment 66 of the Final Safety Analysis r
- Report,
Qalt letter Subiect 1/18/88 TXX-88077 Jet Impingement Information This letter provided a response to an NRC staff request for additional information concerning the effects of jet impingement due to a break in the superpipe region of the main steam and feedwater piping.
Qalt letter Subiect 1/19/88 TXX 88094 Revised Emergency Dose Assessment Model This letter transmitted revisions to the previously submitted Emergency Dose Assessment Model.
Ralt letter jipb.iect 1/22/88 TXX 09096 Response to NUREG 0737 This letter transmitted a revised response to NUREG 0737, item II.F.2.
Qalt letter Subiect 1/25/88 TXX-88139 Nuclear Material License This letter transmits informatior, regarding fuel shipment pursuant to Special Nuclear Material License No. SNM 1912.
Q11.t Letter Subiect 1/29/88 TXX 88089 Special Nuclear Material License This letter transmitted an application for a Special Nuclear Material License.
52-
i.
QA11 Letter Subject 1/29/88 TXX-881500 Enforcement Action 86 09 This letter transmits a rovised response date for Enforcement Action 86 09.
Q113 Letter Subject 1/29/88 TXX 88161 Nuclear Liability Insurance This letter transmitted copies of Nuclear Liability Insurance ANI Policy.
Q111 Letter Subject 2/5/88 TXX 88148 FSAR Amendment 67 This letter transmitted a description of FSAR Amendment 67.
QAli Letter Subject 4
2/5/88 TXX 88089 Special Nuclear Material License This letter transmitted clarifying information requested by the NRC Staff concerning non confirming conditions delineated in NCR No. M-2690.
QAlg Letter Subiect 2/16/88 TXX 88151 Response Clarification to AMSAC SER Evaluation Report This letter transmits additional information requested by the NRC Staff regarding the AMSAC safety evaluation report.
i l
i 53-
i l
OTHER On behalf of TV Electric, R. A. Wooldridge has submitted various documents to the ASLB for their information.
These documents include the following for the time period of December 26, 1987 - February 25, 1988:
1/8/88 Transmittal of copies of the Project Status Report for "Equipment Qualification,"
Revision O.
1/14/88 Transmittal of the Texas Utilities Electric Company's Form 8 X, Current Reports, dated November 18, 1987 and December 14, 1987, respectively, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
1/15/88 Transmittal of copies of the Project Status Report for "Electrical," Revision 0.
I 1/18/88 Transmittal of Approved Results Reports for ISAP
!.d.1, QC Inspector Qualifications and ISAP Vll.b.3, Pipe Supports Inspections.
1/25/88 Transmittal of copies of the Project Status Reports for "Mechanical, Revision 0 and its supplements "Mechanical Supplemental A - Systems Interaction," Revision 0 and "Mechanical Supplement B - Fire Protection," Revision 0.
2/1/88 Transmittal of copies of the Project Status Report "Instrumentation and Controls,"
Revision 0, i
1 2/5/88 Transmittal of a notice of a meeting between CASE and TV Electric.
2/5/88 Transmittal of a notice of a meeting between CASE and TU Electric.
2/8/88 Transmittal of copies of the Project Status Report for "Civil / Structural," Revision 0.
2/18/88 Transmittal of copies of the Project Status Report for "Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC)," Revision 0.
2/19/88 Transmittal of the Texas Utilities Electric Company's Form 8 K, Current Report dated February 12, 1988, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. i
The following listing represents the consultants' reports received by CPSES Engineering during the time period of December 26, 1987 - February 25, 1988:
Qualification of Piping and Pipe Supports attached to Secondary Walls SWEC to TUE Transmittal of Documentation for HVAC Design Verification Program Volume 1 Book 17 - Rev. 0 Corrosion Evaluation Station Services Water System, CPSES Unit 1 (Final Report)
Measurement of Tube Vibrations in the Component Cooling Water Heat Exchangers CPSES - Unit 1.
Project Status Report - Electrical CPSES - Unit I and Comon Specific Technical Issue Report for Reinspection of Coated Welds CPSES - Units 1 and 2 (Final Report)
Project Status Report References Non Contact Cap Splice Test Program CPSES - Units 1 and 2 (Final Report)
Project Status Report - l&C CPSES Unit I and Common Project Status Report References - Mechancial CPSES - Unit 1 i
Project Status Report - Mechancial CPSES - Unit 1 and Common (transmittal)
Project Status Report - Mechanical CPSES - Unit I and Common Project Status Report Reference - Train C Conduit Program l
Design Verification of Floor Response Spectra Project Status Report - Equipment Qualification - Unit I and Common i
Project Status Report - Fire Protection Unit I and Common Project Status Report - Conduit Supports Train C 2 inch Diameter and less - Unit I and Common Project Status Report Cable Tray and Cable Tray Hangers -
Unit I and Common l
es; s.,
4 a.
3
,j' y
p.
j A
CPSES - Unit 1 - Flexible Corduit Slack Final. Project Report
'i
- M Pipe Stress and Support Requalification Reference Documents,for f
Large and Small Bore Pipe Support Project Status Report j
Train C Conduit Program - Transmittal of Impel Report No.
01 0210 1671, Rev. O.
TU Electric Design Basis Consolidation Program Plan Project Status Report Cable Tray Hangers CPSES - Unit.1 Oversize Bolt Holes CPSES 3,
Reference Document Index Cable Tray and Cable Tray Hangers Project Status Report Systems Interaction Program -
'l]
Subappendix A Mechanical Fire Protection Technical Position Papers for the NRC Fire Protection Audit Project Status Report Civil / Structural r
I I
i i
i i
.s l
.c l
l 9
l t
L i
i
?
1 l
l l
56-i 1
y
- q. -
7 tr 4
. ll ry i;
3.,
g, Y
')
.\\
{'t Ql Y
s
..a 4
00CKETE0 UNITED,STAyES OF AMERICA-USNRC ia
^
.t s
l
. NUCLEAR REGULATORFCOMilSSION-g'y, ;.,
u 1
x
'88 MR -4 Pl2:37
)
T before the J.
- s..
s
. ATOMIC N FE7N AND LICENSING BOARD 'f0
- f k')'d I
'3 RANCH o
i
)
In the M'atter 'ofe s
)
Docket Nos. 50-445-OL
~)
50-446-OL TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING
)
)
. COMPANY et al.
/;
)
(Application for an (Conanche Peak Steam Elen ric 1
Operating License)
Station, Units.1 and O'
)
1
)
j CERTIFTCATE O'F SERVICE s.
r I, TlidadA. Schmdtz,'hereby certify that the T
f oregoing Appdd; ants' Tenth Vr. ogress Report was served this.
4th day of March 1988, by rtailing copies thereof (unless otherwise indicated), first class mail, postage prepaid 4
.to:
i
~
.c
- Peter B.L31och, Esquire
- B. Paul Cottt.:r, J I '.,
Chairman Esq.
-l Atomic Safety and Licensing Chairman J Board Atomic 3afe'ty and Licensing -
i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Board PMel Commission U.S. Nuci.%dr Regulatory Washington, D.C.
20555 Commissi.on Washington, D.C.:
20555
- Alan S. Rosenthal, Esq.
Chairman
/
Assistant Dirsptor for Atomic Safety and Licensing Inspection Prcigrams Appeal Panel Comanche Peak Project Division U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commist. ion Commission Wasnington, D. C..
20555 P.O. s Box 1029 ranbury, TX,176048
' \\ )5 i
,y
,)
. I,
/
Asteriskindicatesservice,..dr hand or odernight courier.
/
1
(
3
[
p n y
~
.. n
yyl( -
Is o
2-
- Juanita
.lis Robert D.
Martin
,s Preridens, Case Regional Administrator,
?
1426 South Polk Street Region IV Dallas, TX 75224 U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission
'1' William R.'Burchette, Esquire 611 Ryan Plaza Drive Heron, Burchette, Ruckert, Suite.1000
& Rothwell Arlington, Texas 76011 Suite 700 1025 Thomas Jefferson St.,
N.W.
- Dr. Kenneth A. McCollom Washington, D.C.
20007 Administrative Judge 1107 West Knapp
- William L.
Clements Stillwater, Oklahoma 74075 Docketing & Service Branch U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Joseph Gallo, Esquire Commission Hopkins & Sutter Washington, D.C.
20555 Suite 1250 1050 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
- Billie Pirner Garde Washington, D.C.
20036 Government Accountability Project
- Janice E. Moore, Esquire Midwest Office Office of the General Counsel i
104 E. Wisconsin Avenue - B U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Appleton, WI 54911-4897 Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Renea Hicks, Esquire Assistant Attorney General
- Anthony Roisman, Esquire Environmental Protection 1401 New York Avenue, N.W.
- Divisior, Suite 600 Capitol Station Washington, D.C.
20005 P.O. Box 12548 Austin, Texas 78701 Lanny A.
Sinkin Christic Institute Robert A.
Jablon, Esquire 1324 North Capitol Street Spiegel & McDiarmid Washington, D.C.
20002 1350 New York Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20005-4798 Nancy Williams CYGNA Energy Services, Inc.
- Elizabeth B. Johnson 2121 N. California Blvd.
Oak Ridge National Laboratory Suite 390 P.O.
Box X Building 3500 Walnut Creek, CA 94596 Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 David R.
Pigott Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe
- Dr. Walter H. Jordan 881 West Outer Drive 600 Montgomery Street Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 San Francisco, CA 94111 4
t I
4
..r ks
[2,
U.
~
.)-
"-o,..
.
- Robert A. Wooldridge, Esquite Worsham, Forsythe, Sampels
~& Wooldridge 7
'2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 3200
~
Dallas, Texas ;75201 l
- W.
G'.
Counsil Executive-Vice Presiden't Texas Utilities Electric -
General Division 400 N. Olive, L.B.
81 Dallas, Texas 75201
,/.
/
VbY hhfW i
p}
Th6 mas A.
Schmutz l
V l
l i
Dated:
March 4, 1988 k
r i
I l
l-l