ML20100G217
| ML20100G217 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oyster Creek |
| Issue date: | 12/15/1972 |
| From: | Yoder J AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| To: | US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20100F143 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-95-389 NUDOCS 9602230023 | |
| Download: ML20100G217 (14) | |
Text
___-.
t 66-O/k Ceo n L d a ) OAA YYD41,l E W M G: l:
,gj ggggg1Lg 'f
&(
- 33) (4 7,,
jj -
tht lw;wa/Crysa.rw,ce.
f d
0 ppg g ',,,,/ g., fg U31IC
}
f$un.1a b a/ be'es+
yp 3
%;ng=fi na-w -
p,
.y
\\/'N.g/20 \\
.dt?W.M'ff/4 g.
m n~one won ><.-oeoo December 15, 19/2
,73090: Oyster Creek Marina United States Atorr.ic Energy Commission Wachington, D.C. 20545 Gent]emen:
i;nclosed herewith Petition of Sands Point Marina, Inc., Oyster Greek Marina and Briarwood Yacht Basin to intervene in the matter of the application by Jersey Central Power & Light Company for permanent operating license, Oyster Creek Nuclear Power Plant, Unit 1.
V-truly yours, w
. LES'T g
e JLY,JR./pb Of W.
Roccived in Office of tuo Genorcl Cat.'9e 5 h_"
._at W --- *
- .n l
r a
p
'P p
V 7
9602230023 960129 PDR FOIA DEK,0,K95-389 PDR j'
- c
- ~.g..
t I, -
t.'
t
.In'the Matter'of the Ay$slication of-JERSEY CENTRAL POWER as 20HT -
COMPANY RE. 0YSTER CREEK NUCLEAR j POWER PIANT, UNIT NO.1, LACEY, TOWNSHIP, OCEAN COUNTY, NEW JERSEY.
PETITION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE The Petitionelrs SANDS POINT:NARINA, INC., a New Jersey 3-y
,e corporation, HENRY 'J. KURTZ 'ana ' MARY A. KURTZ, d/b/a Oyster Creek Marina, and CHARLES B.iMALLIE and JOSEPH P. DiPAOLO, d/b/s' I Briarwood Yacht Basin, all'doing business-in the Village of
- Waretown, Township of Ocean,+Cpunty of Ocean and State of New I
1, t
l Jersey, do hereby petition; thal;U. '8. ATOMIC ENERGY. COMMISSION for i
4
, leave to intervene in th w'ith captioned matter for the
.l;
.! following reasons:
p
- 1. The design of the aforementioned. plant.and the manner
.l in which it has been operating has changed the salinity 1
of the water in Oyster Creek upon which lands owned by l
these petitionets adjoin.
The petitioners own and operate marinas.,. As the result of the change in the I
salinity of the water and the increase in temperature,
, Oyster Creek has.become infested with shipworm 8 l
resulting in damagi to. 'theSpiling and bulkheading in the petitionefs' marinas, and damage to the i
]
boats owned by '.th'a petitioners'. custom,ers.
2.'PetitionersfhttheFsafthat.sincetheplanti was built and operated there has been extensive silting in, Oyster Creek reducing the depth of
-navigable water in the petitioners' marinas.
b...
l-The statem6nts;.ce.ntained herein are confirmed by
- 3 extensive investigationWMd'ertak up by Dr. Ruth D. Turner of the t
]MuseumofComparativeZoolhgy,;,Narva'rdUniversity,Cambridgej u
s Massachusetts, made' atLtho'requesi $nd expense of these petitioners, k
I e
i b.
_.B8 m im s.
l,,
i s
4,r.g;r;;.i r;;,Ir, r f
e q.
.,,,t 6 -j ' e
'r a.
3 l
f DTATE OF NfN JERSEY' T
ss.
I COUNTY OF OCEAN se
~.
,3 i
s i
HENRY.J.KURTZYoffull', age','beingdulyswornaccording tolaw,upon!isoathNspSsesandsays:
h l
, _ s i
He is one _ of the. Petitioners in the within captioned l
t matter.
He has read the attements contained in the within j
l Petition and to the Nest of his knowledge and belief the same l-are true and' correct..
l Sworn to4and subscribed'before,
)
l me this /NN ay ch N
.a
).
/# /h d
I NKEA f
)
MtJIMX A U-e U
1972.
, y.. '
~.
j I
i i
CAROL A. CAMBdRN
I.
. NOTARY PUBLic 0F NEW IERSEY l
I
% M'ishwi Expirk May 15.1977 -.;,
i i
l 4
- f.,'.*g 9
I I
)
.i
?
t 2
A
'l
,,s lJ
.f,. j g,.
'g
' '.i.,
,?
n'
(;
'e
.4 4
i
.c I
- 1
% i'
.. *j ;,
e, y 1 g?-
g e
O.
l s
)
g s
t Il j
11
- =.
-~
3 l,'i,
1
.i Petitioners-have instituted an action in the Superior i
o.
lCourtofNhwJersey,,,'LawDivision,againstJerseyCentralPower l
' & Light Company, a coph"of which conslaint is attachsd to this Petition.
The allegations contai'ned therein are made a part of
}lthe within petition..by'. reference thereto.
These petitioners,c,ontend that the continuin6 CPeiationa of the applicant's plant.i.n4th'e' manner in which it'is bein6 i
l flpresentlyoperatedl*Villc4hstituteacontinuingnuisancetothese
+; n i
!, petitioners an'd irr'eparable. damage.
f li STRYKER, TAMS & DILL j
'7
'e,
Burtis W. Horner i
, Attorneys'for Petitioner,
- cE I
~'-
' 'i..
Sands Point Marina, Inc.
l 5
- i rC m}fa m Q.
's s '.
I
>!/.[, J. LESTER YODER] JR. Attorney for 9 l
l
'. Henry J.,Kurtz and Mary A. Kurtz
- ' d/b/a Oyster Creek. Marina
/
t) d}&k I
.p' I ,,,.g. g DAN 12.1 RAFF0 FORT /.y d
/
4.Attornby for Petitioner, l
- 9. P q,r
- + -
...: p M t,i
' Charles B. Mallie and Joseph P.
DiPaolo, d/b/a Briarwood Yacht f,
l ';, '.. ( '
Basin
'., y l'
,e e
i,,
- 1. 7.,s.., ! (!.
I
's, ;i
'., a l.
j I
q
}
f j
.i
',. i.
,l s-t fi 1
8
'~
e' '
x :be ver
-_ ~__ _
e I
.. ~...
I
& ;; = ' Q f g'
- p.
),'I* f
'c
' *' f( 1 *f l,;.'j. t'
- j %,ydG.#R,, t}6l/,'.;.';
tl
'.lft
?*
2.,. l U..M.y,,y.; p,. ( '
, h &c '.M. f.,"
I je
/>
y v./..lAs.7,j.?e; H,p.g.w, q6.,om. u,,. y Q p.
N.b.;.,c,. p N )_ y...Q. ;.
, f: y
?,i.
,j.
..a..
. <., g w.. m v
e
[,. ~..., I'.
' d *!,,
ir.. e.
j l'
4'
- r. ' 0 i
6 e as
,it g,,
7
-g g
plW,h,.ng,h,;w'.,%[ 4,.
A.
.M d.
',e ;t );'.
.. ' ', i,.
g vmc. t. c. m)
.. -, ' ?c. m,
h y 'y..r, e M. ;g '. T.,1..
4 a
4g u
,.r:
E.r.
,.t~v
,w u
q.
..y i
o..,
'g',' J, I,
J.
7, ;;. y. w,., +o. m...y,, g
- g, e, a.., n, it'
. ' s',.v, s
.r 2
s
't
- 6
'-l 1.\\pwk)i
'l
(*%'
p4 l
( " he.d'. i
- y STRYKsR.,76M's & Dib.f;k.9,N,k.f I h .. l,
~
I
,*; *,. :.f A.n.
,r..
a,5,. ~
en uma nvenua 7 *.<: :g.j
,gp e'I.w ?. ec. ;.
l
- .A s - [. *, ".
i..
uonRISTOWN, N. J. 07960, M g 8 y...,.';..,,.
' e
,g p v*romMaysropo see ense,. ' 3...m.s... g,,g..,.w,1,
.c g. c.f 1 7,p i.. t..,., '.. a t
- i i
.. -l )
... c..
.,' y y.
4 j
3p p-
' y.,A g-a J
gands Poins 3derina,,. Ensi J',J i
'. ~,.
~
', :.b;..:,w$.4 h, *m ' '.
'i..
s spyERIOR cogar'Or Nw Jgsagy q
s.,
b:'g;ti, a)ep Cd's.LAN DEVISEON=0CEAlf
.o i
j SANDS POINT BENDIAE:U n.
""9504. $.w. 'V.
j ' EDEFE emi IEtt A E552Ei M.JJ @b/ y M k m
Jersey'eespuestias,.
4
- 8 Oyster C!reak 30 erie,s,WaWC$Aarma {', V M'.... ( Q.C.' Q n'j f
j
- 5. WALLIE and JOSEPR T.j(MFAOLO,.. /' 6 F[. ""; %, ygfMp.
g'/
i d/b/a Briarwood Yeaht Bastab. l3 f 37;.,7:tK... CM. n 4."A
+. g.w y
j 4
,.; e..., o r.
2.,
.r i..,n.....
y J'%,Plaihtiffss.', qlg,.my.,.M, q.c,9...' n gj s
v.
.' CCBG%AI3rf,' AND '".,'
6
.)i J
c
.n
,'.., $ "g (W. @u..c.,f/f M
,N.. y.., ~. y W "
9
- t J
-ve-
- d.
o
-m,s. U.
. 0
.e t
z o
f,.
- i.
JER8EY CINTRAL 70WER 5 L10!W,7,r.;.."e,pb J
'. i.
.4
- 5 'Y. i 3/
l, 4'
'1., i he u
C(BIPANT, a New Jersey c.os@ra.tths,Q.5,J l<$c..f. N i,f N.s o
8 M " h;l MM.i W.. ~:...,
. t v< n. >.... n.. s., n
.+
a
,A.s n ~-
s t,, w. ;..d,sa..
w
,,e
' t.y - c!
.. n; j.
. <'.i. d.c.,.y.. fd e Samt s,.t,"1 4 pe N ".
. n'Q,.j;g Qt w a,g,$. p iq AAp pe.'p p.'l&pgQgQH n..<g,Q.. V h'
.,2
, a s
4q.
/
.3;c,A t m
- ^
l Y, '(' ;j!
oosporatics.RENRY.(d.GdK4.:ame; Bd&Er 'A'l EURTEJ d/b/a Oystes'r.l-i Creek assrias,, d'YadtiSasia,1heging plaeos'of;busiases in and'CilARLE8 5. 3m41E'and' J06EP5 P..LDiPAGEA,..i T
d/b/a'Briarvee n
the State of New JwseyiWM. & Sount[y of Osoon,.eseAsin f "'j,f ing agaiset tho' defeed4mt,?sep,ttptW ii
. q,?.g. 7 .G
- g. h
?
t
.. j,'
.. A.. ~g a.. \\. <. ',
- a.. f
... +.
s,
' ' ~.. '
' ii C '(,s h;. '., ?
~
,. \\
e,.;
,;,eg.h. h,';h h
.h. ! <
o f
s
,fl
,6
.h i'
.Q' gq.y
- 1 ;"
- l' 0
.,.pc,..
', g.. (
t. ;,-
1
. '.., i e pp,. t.,.s.,Q, n.
1
,. 3 y
e-*eff
.j..Q
. tain marine des 111tted; v?arerthefusere and corstors of easted.onOysterCassicfWarecous,Nas d
9
.c.
, aim,-
s,
,.,',p,;h*',
a),
..l ',
,' **l p'*
s.
..i,
y ;,, _,
c p
r
. f.s.
a'.<..
46.....
b
. ' d, 4 I
t-t g., i.a "e
5 I.f * )
fA d,, *
'~
'P
+,..
w
..s
,,,,i.
.. a,.i, y' *
' ';,'3,,.,.
L,'
.. ) @ei. g,N.it e p'., '
. '].
r i'
i y3 q.4,
[. '.
l i'
$,....... e...3., i 4,,,.
.o g
.'t i
m.m a
\\.
,. f ;,
,e -
,0
.*9 s
G
_t,.
L
-~,
. _ _. _. ~..
+
,e,g v
r ;..,.....
1. n, h., y.. A..,,,.,,4 c.
,,. c,4 p..J..ft e
o;, M "~,,..
y
..y t
, !,. s.c s v
-<,.4.',4)sl,v,,,.,;.Jhgq. pn M.g.'., '... <.'..
,y
. A,.. ', '. e. ;., y:
l i-
.,.e
.t..' i-
+
c. 4 "j %o
..., e.. j, a[.'.' #. h.gy ' O M.
- JM,.....
,e, x
.C.,,.4
",T'
.2 M.i b %.n o,':a.
o~
ubish 'as'eias(tseid shd harm been ucedl$st.assy. years' J
for pumposes'aif storages repair ' asistemasse and asle i, o
e, u; g
..ll of pleasure boats"i :. 7.n c, 7. i.. w. fl g ;
'. 4?..',
Flaintiffs have. enjoyed's profischte basL ess
. 2.
e, over the. years distiuds'im.1arge part ene to' the fact t^at.
,, oyster Creek uns:a.ocol^ fresh water streami attractive to the*
owners of pleasure boats boosuse of the elsanslag prepartisz.
of fresh water to,,the asters!and bulls'ef bac.ta, coming from.
' ~ the saline. waters.o.f.,Baab.negat. Bay and the Atlaest.id'.coaca.
w A..: \\ 1,.w.
- 3. ; Bistorie&11y,, by rasson of tha' fre::d waccr in
,,,0yster Creek, plefaciffs have been able tc, use untreated ce$ -
lightly treated esdar pilings and bu12eado t'ar'the arcotica of best lalips,tdoeks{and:pists.j,
y,;, ' \\
... r <
.. <, w..... g, :.,,c,,...
.,, 3.. J ev....,.
9 s : f'2 4..,The'dsfeedse$ is61a the business.of the genera '
, tima,and sale.of elastrf;sity to the"gscarai tablic and has a
been so engaged..for tiesy, years'1ast page.
1 v
,.. ! u, "%
e,.e...,
s
- 5. ' Desfag'the* course of its businose defcMast "i
f erested and ist De6 amber (of 1969 connanced the scenercial operation ofilta pystenhCreek Nuclear Elect:rio Genenting', '.
f
.gla.i+.4 m.. a.,
n. c.0,
station...
/
Esid Oyis.,%,p," Creek thacts&U Electric GeneTating
. ;; i
.a n
.f f -
.3.,.*.
i ;,
t r
q
.'C b'6.
tm Station'uses;:for'oooling purposes large qwmti):1es of salt,
,a I
,,' water whieb'is pumped: from'Barnegat.5py inte"ite. plant and.
. 'is them disaharged,iM's')eated" state into en-adjacent canal'
' whi&',emptiesjistojthe'q,'p,ortion'of oysp;sr creeke
'M P,
!Q!"c'gl
,g.gg f
y,g L,,s,jj( [ { }
4 i'
e.titi.s.of heated y1t.steraatth. -=ar,..t foreh 1. Y, '. j bas' hee 64o chsage the nature of oyster l
16 hereof! sstai taLai salt water seremo, hes sub
.O a fresh t
.4 l
/t n. 5.!l' 4 J.staat elevate ('.,ths'tamperature.of so'chuster and has, d greatty' edithe plumejof waterissd thereby the spee.e ',, ; ".
' of'tha'.eurrent. l..d Ic A)gh%e., j w,Y...v.i fm..
.~
.,..a.
.a
., f.,, p. m..a, c.,.,.
<..o
- .,a" 3.
cr 4
...y
. 8...'.AsPaJerther..resatt of,the-herossed eatinity.
~u:
,, ' sad hisber' tempacoture of the watero fr. Gyetcr crech, acrdd
' ff l
tiens'havo' been,6eef:ed'ubioh' are ideal Cor the proliferstion ' y j yi
.t ~,..
e'..
,f.,,,,. c
.t.
j.
r i*.o
...L t
I".,'."
4 8
. m *.,9(*q.f[. 3 f ',
,, f,
s s
- f.,. j '
4 U
,y
.m
..... 1 1
_(4,,
,w l 1
, c.
% ".J )h.,gl f ','
jy.
?
Ii
,,,,;/ j l%
3 lt"),.
].
.[fg,.,
,.i b.. '
,4 i,
,. tv c.-
- t..
[-[,,If'[(,,vN ', '.s,. 2
,. e '[ '
'e '. * ? 'i d,),a.,
4 h 'I; ?
, '.. ), i e,,
4 w.ia...
m.5.
. t.....
w w ag... %
i
...,,h,7p...j c..: -
.. g ;,,....,,,,
..,,.:,,, _,4 1
, _.. _ ~
,..w.-
~
a..e,.,
-y u
I
.p.
- 4y,f..
),4[Q,. '.h,4,
..g
,.:. c'.
r .'.'P,,' pl igf(d[a,.7.,g,.
..... g,..n r.3 -
j.,,.
,.gi '* 3 3
'q m
( / *..g;. g j 1 p p,I s j' e,s O-
- s*
..g.;
( e. ;@#, j,',[o,,A:;%..,..,,p j
.g l
(,.j ;.
.yo f.., 3.':
,; p,.. r o.,.,3, %;, c$' j..v, ' c.,
- . v,
,l
- s q'..,,,.
l
.,., e '., i' ;.
$s.
.. m., n...
...r..
s
.s ; -
I' 4 ';
4'
.,.,.~ ~ y..
4
- I # TSW4 g b9F8f f.
- jeEE AMAa.ElWde 4
innewn ks su$5sMesa EHEM 888
$86,e
' 6. ~ said shiposumis' attack 'all forms of untr'estad.
i
!. or 11$ tl
', 9 t=dthaad=y treated wood,'ineluding boat huus, pilings an
^
i ei
".y.15;.E, '. ',, '. e l
f J of time. :< > u
.g.
.. '...i.
- ~, '. 67
- '10.0 Plaintiff's buDheeds'r Cachiand boat c"'.h
.j.
i
.j ' p111dginsve bemaend.iare',tsow ibeins d'isereyed iand many lost
'f lumns have been desaged,by'said shipmq
- .l'.
,P 4-
, ',1
.,4 t
2 i
j
- .. '" :H.- !A,s s'further result of the defer. dant?s dis-d "sherse of.a greativoimmic,of' water isto. oyster. Croak,, erosica e, i
of thephanks and bettem'have;takad pleos which,. in curu, has.'
.o
- 4 orested?shes11ag c 'iffhlof the botte:s ta~.and meer. 'picia n] tiffs'@ljames 'of bestaams l..W 'a,.O
't u '*b.# -
. L %w...
e
~,..%,w y j',Y
+ ' '
r n
.'q e
.. V.do.1f..'"Aci iM\\rdmalt of the hig.or.iteogpersturk*)!, 'I l
of th's water. in Of(' tatf /Jreektglosa% f i
s y
frequently occura,and Losts and;contcats hcie.$eentsubjectl
,1 c
to unusual mildaw conditions? ;,-
r:
l
,1, T k s,. g l W,, 2.., y,,1 T p, *s' h,,. qtsctfv,,,,, yde
^" 1I.gpfj w gr.
s p
g, L
' ' '. l" S '. 4 ',
i,." 0 "
3 t
to a==t==noa.
y.cf'gM M p,lyJjl.itj jh[ h b
,pgg g g
,(
been teorsesed anse to all' 'of ~this*Maf.ntifgs tea pt. in dbuph'eado;g$$$$'d+
wey. o stoquest. rep e(#
- h *;**as ma t n,%..
c 48'P'
- ** * * * **IF "'
91sbia and< "
. the immters of the 1,$hS8 salves
' L ' bS' 1
"te' 10apre luso of humisees by we4+3., a !
and R eseg and, sam 4
mere eWaste di persun bocts hava '
i som of the fees',
p/
soups onbet
.dd faellities due to thsin!oomern anc r
Fy
.their craft art bein5 forced, TfM the prospeet;of either
.i
'avanse iq ' ceder,to pro.
tounderse'sub9 tal addit
.)h;n,n,,.4 testthehu15s,
. s,th9 '.9,,.'. s: of tM.. tr,rms. t m
.r.,
.m..
.,;.p.,,
N,
- OBEREftbs)$,,q).'..(fis he,psad 5M l
h '$
e i.
d ka' u'ry to p!sitw i,fdlM tiffs' peopertypd bu%5. p sh e d Or ne'%j]".
(a) ' Dan 1l sinessgl'
!J,3 -
,g e ')
i
[.
'f,,7!.
..-l '
j
.< I,,, i., y.
...J(.,
41 3
,,,,s.. e r, ;,.;
4
% :rJ[a i L.., '
a,k, ?.'.,,./.,) h Y..i(V-.
.".h.t t
.Nk;h..D'b.t,'$g.(k,
,.p. s, _ 4 ',. d l.h 4 II1 ( ' b ' 'r . I,I I. i . v,.;.a .c ~ pa;. .n. .,r
g6 m .-w-.e6 1 ec n',t 4 l q t' p . <;'q d, x.. y" g,2' f,;),,- p..y...:...y,,j",,g'hjd[lo.
- T
?'s v. .d 1,. ".MVt.,7 '1p.f,P,,.; t .\\.,,,,n +. a.. / n.y;.. :,p , p.. v .:s. ~ - n ...e.. h >h w .,.. g, % ;; y. r. o e.v,v..... ; n.y u ~ .,>n. , n,"h., .s.e, ,c. e...., ' - c .b , j. .. ps :,.
- ei v., n. w..
-,., /.,
- g,,.
o y ,, e . n..ap.- ..(b) An injusetism a, gainst the eastimmaties of de-e sendams'.s'eentimmed disaharse,ef het este water into oyster .' creek.: . m..., /.,. n, p Y, : '. . c . e >-.,. ..6 .,o. ) s...... 'n. e.. U u..- (e)' A = mad **y.iajunstion requiring the dc.f*= dame to. restore the bottestof the. Creek including.the bottoc withic. 2, t . a.., the marinas themse%ves' to it..foemer depth. ccd sentour. 1,, '<,
- *,- (d) sush"
... s...yo: ,y . a
- p.. w,
i andiaarther ediar as.aay;seen appro. w priate under' the. : ens '. H m... ",> h...,.....,
- r. w.
.s ,. < >/ n.. u,
- w*..
- g..,,-.p.
r
- N
{e y, _. ' M_QQUR ? ' '.' c*.
- a.c,,,,.,,
a
- 15. Flotattffs,,,r(esti att ~of W diasations of parassaphs 1 through,12,'taelmetve...,
- f. }.. a.
4 ' j . pip, q ' < ;: '.' 'v 7. 1 ',16... Said, assivinite$,..b[the.defadece'coastitute'. . e t1= mins er ptog' agsdnetrehgytaintiffs.1'y'n. 9 9,,"d .,." fp m f, "" 3,.- I a o i 17.' Theydrepost, the? allege.tione of$scagraph 14 hereof as am11y as'though 'se(forth herafa..w. n j,.. .' o 4 p :,, i.,.1,;..; r. .(
- , i.c..
wptnMPORNj)' plaintiffs demand the folfowing'relieft'. '. i + (a) Damages for all'past and fisture indary,to Plain ,'" ;/). i .e y 3 a 2 l r. j tiffs' property aw3'busistessy e V . #. u.M. '. '. t (b) Aa,tajanstign' aga, inst the conciamation of de'd / ' i'7:)p i fendast's esatinued, discherso,of het ede Octer into Oyster. v l L,;, creek.-.- 3.ih.p i V $ h '[hMc, m..il f i aW,k..:.;... ,4 ,1 1, .+ + , m..'.. i f g,,.j 3 i:l ,( h't '/j Q.' i,.g '. ' f, t, t. ' ; p.l ',] ,,[ '. a ff" .4 j (e) A mondetery?tajunction regaitting tho' defendant ,U.R j , to restore the bottes'of 'l37 the mariass, themselves'tio,the Cyeck including the bottesa within b"f t i 'its.former' depth and e ntour.. , _., :i,' r f
- c. T. i h ' (d) such ' ether'.and earther rbitof 'es us'y coca'appr6
- Dk,i f
priate underl'the, etWa==a4,p.;., '; ' ; * : ,L l.f " t,..n..,p.i ,3,o 4 q:. n.- "N: w ,,u, 2. t.., 9.. yf ~ .c p , e,/,[ g ,j g g e, ga y '..l l C j,, 1 ,g/ . i n1' ..,,. p .0 m s 4. 9 I 182 Flasatiffbapest di of tho'a11G24ULO 8 of N paragraphs 1 throar,tp17,l inclusive, ne ih1Ey,c clunga est 4 forth hereia. '. E '., l 'i s. . 1.$ .c c. i .t
- I 8 h, 1-
- ' T O '!,'g 't t g> ip' f.g
,) i... ...j i it,i ,.,i l ,; p,
- Ib 4.-
.e o w .i. .?,, .q.). +s. ... ' h'n a v I-3 .P ..[elI r );4 ,e,..). 9- '3 .'$..,b. . fi e, .s , ~, rn ,y.y..$.'.. s r.l..f. .. ~. .i. sq 4J sAl. ,,.}(;p#1-vj ) .e j ' s 4 t,. 1 .. '.P ' t T MI a . W. m, ~ ~
- i 4,
s . _ _. _ _, _ ~ i t
- a.,r,m s.4T.
..t 1.p4 .s'"E.. c ', A.... r. ',. "4. r)M.'.F.? ? i j 5 ,, ; r s..,,. t , 'g.M,,. 5 t. '. J-g ' .,, '. Q., p' g' ,Pi - s v te ,'ag, ,,,.i g ,si ., &,, y..,.i.,*.,,.t,. s.4 g .,2 y r.,, ,4 g "!.,*: 's3. ' 4
- l.
1 . o g t ;* -i. e e;l.'.3* > ' e : A. y. c' 4 s *. .y.
- .s
- - Q 4ti g"..,* *
- , '.4 y
. / * ..T g ' [, I / j.:.... [if. S',H'.!', - ..' t. c.p,,, L.t. 6 i, . 4.,.. t,. s....s /. 3 .c.* t c p t. ) q f,*. y a y D% I q.7 . $.. l
- f. 5 N.
ri.,.e: - .,... : t a.. Wp./. ,. i. c. 31 1:$ .4. b,. j t lq. .e ..,, i t.. i,. ..J, ] s. w n hk' 6 g 4 4 i este adequate and saffiatest 4tudine of the effect of the i l l eyesettaa of tes peeposes pleet upon the unters.of Oyster .f 4 creek pater to its sometrussian ame to take adequate.sese- .' tute'intentiesel weengdesig'esplast the pietatter J, dial measures useres.witsuttumatsni:se asessans go ] . u. y p:.{ ..'a. + t unemesess. tadattre, dessed:en"this, commt. punt. - i j save esamens assinet',the defendentiin.smeh' sums as.witt assant t,. { !]1: + <.. N .: ev,
- m. ':. &.,
' g, v 9 ::., dV W Q.,. 4
- .. C Wf ** %c N:.QV. l "
w mr,ia.afer .'1t of the.mm..f l e l c. $ully as though L vs,..hestof 'as[7
- l.
1 through 12ii ' hemets.*/.r..y, r,Ig N 7 qw;. < M./. /. 'J ; L,.*S'A.,. U o.,r ...,:.e, /'c. + 'A 1. 3..s} ' ' <M. 'i:'@.. i . < set. %.j. m.M;y.,. d 5 Nias'to sobs h.3!
- 21. '# flE h adeemsteFand^suffia!Anqt'ptdlei'the defen ant.ia fi l
dales of.tha. effest'ef the ties b!,0 } , of its ysoposiid p$ ant:e tbs 1se to.'. ..d ; ' its esmatsustima med.daigtehe,I (ters:of' Oyster'dreisk yis equa ?.#p l d.'.. ' p' q$ ' seitsted nestianese.!;g,n".r.:!t.s11ogatione,efipe ";';<.~. ::m ;.,;. fin. c e 1
- 22. l;ttisy repeat'she
' w. y .,:a t. m.. ', i' raph 14 ',L hacesi ass 8s117.se.; thous'.u t forth herein..g.,,/ i o.9 i ' ', 9..f..N, j. se ao - t .e. ..... ;, n n. ".pg.. v".. a. n....;,. ', g. v .L p 3333p(33[.... pia ( f g'. d e m a,D d t h e $ s 1 1 0 N i d s r e t .v..y njgf g.;.9,. 44siness, pnr:p:rgcMW.fu a ",1ein.% I y ~.- l. :.;, y p,t:,.<ent.e,;.gteyto can 3,1 m. .b. lt c;pi!, [ ]p. tiffs'peeporty. .o . J. . ;. u t M. ~ ~ i.
- 14..
,'d. k.h,(b) Ag" 'l.,1 w,sMlnl A. gbg amm's.4 meat.4mm of 43. j,.,,84%CI O feedsat's"' dioshagen ofAst(satt. water tate oyster;7 h.i,% .h EE*AE'.. f$..i,.h..i.i,f.k'fu.'hN,, h. p.4 ;,. h,,9:' ~[N!p a.f.3 i [' ' [
- 'Yi '.h.a'k b
l . 2 a.l.MM, l p -[. ip. /'. ] g m* @...n. .4 ,u 3, z .c.x ,' ;., f :,9 gggg[g[gg$ f
- n....e+,j.n,.sq U. +ty. ; creek in i
i ki is y,the .M*. ,gi i U! to restese ,, c the 'emetmas thinesd. ., h. : ~.. .w.. :.... .. :.,,i v,, " (d) such istber'.....;, :and furthat'reli,ef as sair,.seen gprep.fy. a.- ../ ...,. 1. e - prisp under.the e "W o .t- .g ,.y.'- e .w:s"m, q.x, [E) ;"
- t'..,,< w(.)n.,. n.
>,q ~ '1' I~ ~* ..* d..g ' e %i..
- 8 s' x,lJ i,;
w ..;4 . m m J. j, n J;.. : em.,...g J. ' ) q i.; ; ;t i. , n m i<. D 4 , j. 6 ,, '%.., s ~.. s,i ~g L.. y.t.'mlf' d.s. j-t J s,- 1 .. ~.
- s.. m..
.R.p ?t : ' a, s. . ~ s.;(, );h (;; ogtsb:.$ f4-: O y ::.y : .Ve ^..?. ~... ~ v.!.. ~ y .].y...::,4;f p.. }g Q W lp y :j g 9'y y'f ?
A, 1 y :.., ;.r. x ..q.,gr .5,.y.,.,,,., -..gy 1.. ,e. . ~.. ' #.,, r m a.,,.. . ]y's '. ft. . f' y s
- +. -
s ,u. ,;.. y n,; s,. .,, y.,. 9 ' r-l !.'
- [ '. i
!; Sf f 5 ';* Ph, , /,. 1 c c.d..\\ t v. ,I - M h Plaintiffs repost the ellegattats of "E2 s k 23. . t u, s.1 1,...m se o e uy = m e. -', ' '..,,,+. ',... 6.. r: la..- i herois. .[ . eativities and 'condert ok the9efendent k seh. f 24. 1 t amount 'te am tsioenst$tutional' eaking of the' property of ^the - ., plaintiffs without'duis.psesses:of law withis ehe'Fifth and.. f'.yourteamek Amendesnes to the camatituttoc of the B
- of New Jersey 1947.land' Artiste,.4, s4. V3 of f and Artista 1, 820
) l, .,,,s..... j. f(...,,.,. n ., c ; 25. They rMthe' allegations of paragraph 14 'f ! 4 ', /; hereof as. fWLly es; shou $ setj forth hereia,,,.j ' 4 "' f f )gggs.densed as this Count moepen.- 3': < y m,:. f.s ab,h.c a kin s. A.; L,... u 'J.: > ej setesy.damases en" .wn.v,i,mpam.q;:3,h,. ,p wy.3,g.. <.p. hf $:n 3 ~4... ,~? i e '. [ e ,., i,/. t'..,{. t
- g. kg i
- [ Burtte W. Rommee.s HWQ*qpu,.gi 1g
} 1:. i..gl I.' e'. Wunh,.. i ( '..j { s .I' p,q .. ~ : pks. for Plaint ~ L ) j torn 1 ' }fs.li;'figd ' g g j '4 .g.Mq 7i yw g ~.w %,Q.. .. % i c . m; -.,f a,,. a a,'t.,b',># wjJ f'. D' y.A.> marts, h,h i.. i.i,.], '.h;s,'p[u'.h,,'+hl,d, {,;3aary J.' c (. l .j' r.,, g j d/b/aOysterCreekMarina' i ),. ,,J ,) . e? l '.... .,P d
- 6 ',.
t .. ~,. p - , e.. ' t ( ",i,c i,,'.9. ) d,v dt y, '"g. 't., . i i,, ' " 'n - [N',l.- 3.,. ' d;m",.C'.' 'v ' '? !' '. **,P' '. ;.. 1 I- ' '.' *V' '. - \\ *. 4 t .s
- 't
'a .s
- s' 5 , #.fhf b. N
.i $. ] 1j, B.,jy,l/[ll/:: nn[,."F mang, ac,,cronc .! i 'f ..?<.y. p,, .. J.,. M.. ,,g,g,g,g,, t ,. j..q,.s t.7:,1; q i y,.g. . > :. 'l Av.... 'y fy @'q,' j,, Charles 3. Mallie and. Joseph'F.'H;.:. ,,,,7 ., y 3 4. ; '.ti 'F d'.. LD1Paolo, 4/b/a Briarwood Tae t.,..j... -n. s.,,.; ,,. i e h / l , 1.... ..,j, ..,. a.,I.
- 4....
',,,........y)g .~ s '3.r.. g.r.. j, J y! '4 (.- .. s. r' I. ...? ..g- , e, ; :,, it:.qNdpli.,... .,, 3ip,. ; .. e .., y~,. i g f. ')-. ,. i ' _ y..V.,.i. .i kie }
. ~... . g. L'"'1% ??i%;;
- i. j 3 3.,.;,4 NT, q ;:}W :+. ;; g(#...,
e c m pqyq'o..y n ' ' W. j.:.
- .
- . wy u
~ 9,,,lt. 4,,;j,;. .E'. A;.g / .q .s,y. 9.. ;., 1 f.r y Q'? f,f l, 'f [rV:i
- 4. f,,:,,,
\\ . w,.>.,.p w...,, f.4e.9w.g.g77.;.m,m.n. 4 . v.,1 w + p,.i,, v :. i. .i i .r y.. '..;* ' f. y...c ;3 +,.N r, j:.4,. n ", ).:u,. f.1. M.e d;> %;,t r', .a; ca r e n.
- f. s w. %.,y.,h.'F..M. T.
, ~, ' x.g 'y. . y U. +.'.. - a 4 ,3 ..',m,.. q,...o ,t ,e i e
- p
'( # ' }.. S Q g g.! e 0F TWELVE J 5... p .T 3 assordemos.with R.18-2(b), the pWmHefs i hereby demand trial.by jury of twelve as te~ all Assues,' . -.i t _o
- s. *
' %
- p, y
- [j t ' 9, ' i* '; i l, f,. ;. ' ' '. ' ' d 'NfIlj. y j-M*,[,g r .h
- h. r,.,j l* [i ' '.5), kt
., p.$[mli,14.dij. ! 'a. g... m,;,. w,'pa;w y.} ' ' '.}m. ,w., ..y'3V'(,' 1 4 'L 1 ,, i M 3 'N ' '.... A ,.. ' c.@a e ,a e. . w. i y,. .w . n. a,. 9,y. 7 c. n.e.,> .c.. +. .c,., ,o .. N l: .,.!'t,. i' ' (;' N BAERM rcN'f.Wj.@;hh,I,!.gy'.'.fgfggyedaW$g.,i,su n.: i V; ]- ,s .;., w.r. pM y V. A1g.,.c. sambde poht., Marinse,, e'
- p..W,,;.4 i,,.. e m or,. c.,v a i
- tre, 0 J,!.,$-.e:,6 i
,).. . v. '1,fe.q'g f.5. ! vg j h.- h'd. ge.,',.',
- / ; ):
4,1. .l 's
- f. g jIig.,, f, j ;g
.. J,, ;,,. e.f,,.,.
- {
s .1 ,,.. J r 'i. F i . '
- p ?'ll I',.
,.g. , J [, ej' g a .I Pi' ['I 6 ,4 s ,.,!'l' )dv 'J.,.LESTER YtW5R JR ' jf W' iy, ',p } U $.,jt{4AtterSep for Fle,intkids, .9 ,.. i i. .1.,,il.
- p. 3, ]! ' l'g @r f.D.9 ',Jeary J. Earts"an e
k )$hy,i/Jh d/b/a Oyster ' Creek Marias - .; ~ Ti.. l W . Q, y #p./ M. v, p p a.,, M,r. a... 3.' g., t 1, 4 y .a a u. i.1,1,; a, A, l.gd!4.' ?.M :#. '.(.,ff[t,Q[~ 3, h' ! #. ' *.O ';,. I ',1.{t. ' Q l ll 7.i r," (, l,'.. g, hsd,;. c
- l...
p;. 3 73. 9{qs n:i,s,p.,.dp:1pMgA@ql:)%j'f, g..lQ . y, m.f:p .;;g,,... ,g u m,,a w stemme .k . w, mq. gb;h.p'3.d.cn.,s y:sor plaintiffs.1,J " wrryN,& g n e. u,,s.,n.f.,u e n,n r. 4 atus a m 3 .nt m ce; :%4 f... ' i. g<.. m;, y &g f $p3gpasia'.1.. ~ f ).4.J9 .4f .t # i
- ' M M 4 % y n, yd %r w. c. 7 ; 7 t
Q, ..g g..,; .,y,y.V 8 n l QO i,L.. p,y ~g N r. ~. g.g. ?rf.,y.4' m- } %m.c. . /,. l "b ....s p y. G ', s.. ;wf sm. '. ;
- f w. "4, Iik,.
'(( a.. w i .f , s. l J n y ".a m. .~ vh. 7.'#:!:p.g.hk,,yd,g*h.,;.,;g.'rt,,Q,@e..s'j,Q. y,~ u9", .s, ...s ; ,p. M 0 i,,.. u. g j s y...n' j i .j;fjfjc.+',3,4 a n, y,, c. a... . u. Mp.,n.'. O <.g.. y.c.
- ,y.
.g 3 . :.. p. - o . i .....pv..., ;) Yr f.J.. - '. A' ' fI* M,g y, . q i. a 4..
- f.
l'f p. ' E g('f if.\\.q. par. l,,i s&;;m$lY. 'jll,',9. ;6)'\\V [".N,' '. 4' 78. ' s 7 .t, t 1. ' /g,r.J t .t [ ,.s. .g. i'*,, ' ..,q.y :. u.s, 3e ,,. c. .m i .o ~(, '+,.d Tf . s., ' ' d 1.e i u,.w.... r...., %, a, s, .t,,
- , ;.,-m. 3 n
. a i.{.m, ~ e. 3... 'l(si ' }. L. %,p,t ) I s.ga P ,$p, * ' ', g ' ( r *.4 \\. g f .atg.,- 6 .: '. g 4 '. . 9 6I. '; i .. t. - -r . - m a a
. ~. -.. - - -... _....... .~ -..... - -. -. _ - _ ~ -. -. - _. ~ - I .n !) i t .w 1 3 ,..u. J I e l "fi Ti(cD Min {cs Mc7ta!8 t ?, t February 15, 1973 f I Ms. Dorothy R. Horner, Township Clerk a i ~ ' Re: i Township of Ocean I Waretown,' New Jersey 08753 3-1 Respectfully referred to l Congressional Liaison Office 1 Atomic Energy Commission ,L_ Tsshington, D. C, 20545 } b ,4 for such consideration as the communication s herewith submitted may marrant, and for a reecri i l J thereon, in duellente to accompany return ef inclosure. W ) ' By direction of l ? 4 Clifford P. Case I j i U. S. S.- CPC/ve l l l 1. ] 4 i t-i o e 4 )f !323 copy sen, pg,,. 1 ~ f d 9 4 e 4
i 1 \\... / ~7bh '.k$h) \\ .\\.-.Cll'- ~ s.g., e s TOWNSHIP of OCEAN \\ couayofcua ~ .[ WARETOWN, NEW JERSEY j usin i s I
- I '
.pg g g G* y j , Honorable Cliffeni P. dase, Senator United States SerAte Building Washington, D. C. 20510 \\ Enclosed, herewith, is a certified ecpy cf a Resolution which was adopted by the Township Co=aittee of the Township of Ocean on the lith day of Janur.:y,1973 relative to the Townships' concern over the r. ass destruct-ion of rarine life and the fish kills in Oyster Creek. f It'is the Tcunshipsi desire that the necessa:7 steps be taken by Jersey Central Ib.rer & Light Co. to install any cad all equipe.ent necessary to el'r.inate the rapid changes in water te.perature in Oyster Creek. s Ver truly yours,
- ' 3... ~,,,,
+ Dorothy R. rner Township CAerk Enc. Resolution , li .s. 4 e e l 4 e FDWNDID APRib 13,1BT S $ / e e
Janusry 11, 1973 6 j . VER12S, a fish kiu occurred at Oyster Creek during the latter part cf December, 1972 through Jr.nua n S, 1973; cnd WHERFAS, a similar incident occurred appror.imately cne syear age; cnd W , HEIEAS, the members of this governing body are deeply. . concerned over this mass destruction of worine life; and WHEREAS, immediate stepe must be taken to prevent a -furtber*reoccu,.-rrence of fish kills in Oyster Creek;' u s.......... i NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the TCLC: SHIP MITTdE of the TOWHSHIP CF OCFAN, as follows: { l. The! Atomic Energy'Co m.ission, Department of Environmentc1 I Protection e.nd the Ocean County Conservation Comission cre r = hereby requested to ttle the necesscry steps to compel the Jersey = Central Power and Light Comp:ny to install any cnd all equipment I necessary to eliminste rapid changes in water temperature thereby eliminating the possibility of theres1 shock to m.rine life, i i .2. Ihe, Jersey Contral Feuer and Light Comp ny is hereby l requested to furnish this comittee with a report cs to the l steps taken to implement the intent and purpose of this resolution. I 3 Copies of this resolutien be forwarded to the fellowing: c. Atomic Energy Cemission ] ,b..Depcrtment of Environmental Protection c. Occen County Conservt. tion Com.insicn d. Jersey Centrcl Pbwer cnd Light Company e. Henorable Clifford Case f. Henerable Charles Sandman g. Henercble John F. Drown ... h. Honorcble Frc.nklin H. Derry, Jr. ' i Honorable Jcmes J. Ecncini s e certification v I, DC't0 THY R. Hon"t, Clerk cf the Tcwnship of Oce:n, County of Ocean,' do heroby cortify that the forecuing Resulution traa passed,by the Coverning Dody of the Township of Ocecn, Cour.ty of Ocean at their regular meeting held on the lith day of Jrenev. lot 4. / ~ Y f I N +m--@ h= us a w ,-i.4 _}}