ML051050151

AMS No. RIII-04-0067, Document Serial List

ML051050151
Person / Time
Site:	Point Beach
Issue date:	04/13/2005
From:	NRC/RGN-III
To:
References
FOIA/PA-2004-0282, RIII-04-0067
Download: ML051050151 (5)

Text

I - .

AMS NO. Rill-04-0067 DOCUMENT SERIAL LIST date received 5/21/04 due date of 15' ARB June 20, 2004 due date of ACK Ltr June 20, 2004 date -90 days old August 19, 2004 date -120 days old September 18, 2004 date -150 day old October 18, 2004 date -180 days old November 17, 2004 date -365 days old May 21, 2005 projected date for the 5 yr statue of limitation May 20, 2009 SERIAL # DOCUMENT

1. IDENTIFICATION SHEET

2. ALLEGATION

SUMMARY

OF CONCERNS

3. Receipt form

4. Redacted receipt form

5. Initial ARB 6 Letter to licensee 7 response from licensee 8 iMtI 1'90PM's >f 9 Kpcr-rac, (ul T0r &Cce-S ae S/.&/o- '.

10 rXCf5p A a 11 50Z-C V) 11A A 12 &e426 AV1 13 o2ttv 4Fb 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

Transferred 1RIII-2004-A-OO67 #Of ConI source ucenseeEm ee Out _ _ _

Cocrs~oue nomto & Point Beach 1 - A,> .s.

1 lCbDatef Pr OINUBEERA all 1-2 2Substaniatedi An individual is concerned that the UT examination was not capable of finding the damage discovered within the penetration 26 VJ"groove weld, and that primary water stress corrosion cracking (PWSCC) damage probably exists in other penetration VJ"groove welds in the Unit 1 reactor pressure vessel head. The individual believes that the licensee will not pursue the PT examinations of other "J" groove weld in view of the potential for finding additional evidence of PWSCC damage.

The individual stated that 'UT" examinations revealed an anomaly In the root of the penetration 26 VJ"groove weld. The anomaly was believed to be manufacturing related. The presence of the indication lead to the performance of a surface PT examination of the penetration 26 'J" groove weld. The PT examination revealed numerous crack like surface indications. Follow up grinding and re-examination revealed that the indications had depth and deemed to be not acceptable for continued operation.

Basisfor Closure concern pertains to an NRR order and has aspects that are generic to a number of utilities. case was transfered to NRR.

the NRR number Is NRR-2004-A-0026 Page I of I

Recleved 05/21/2004 CLOSED CASE CHRONOLOGY Enterred 05/2412004 - R -

Date Closed 06/02/2004 Total Datis Ope 1 1 Transfered NRR-2004-A-0026 CONCERN ACTION PERSON .--DATE DAT I I DATE DAYS TO NOI SSGETS-SIGNED - DUEl I.COMPLEE COMPLETE r3 1 HELLER' 05/25/2004 05/28/2004 05/28/2004 3-Response to Referral HELLER 05/25/2004 05/28/2004 05/25/2004 0 :

Referral Leffer Referral letter to licensee. For signature 5/25/04 clayton W HELLER 05/21/2004 05/21/2004 05/21/2004 0 Letter From Alleger HELLER.. - 05/21/2004 06/20/2004 05/21/2004 0 InitialARM Meeting

'HELLER': 05/21/2004 06/20/2004 06/02/2004 12 Aoknowledgement Letfer Need to draft letter, tile wiroy for signature on arb. Ril ack letter not requied since case was transfered to NRR.

- PageI of 1

CHRON QA ARB DAYS ALLEG CN ASSIGN DONE DYS ID ACTION action desc Olrpt date RIII-2004-A-0067 1 05/21/2004 05/21/2004 0 2 Initial ARB Meeting Page I of 1

CHRON QA LTR DAYS ALLEG CN ASSIGN DONE DYS ID ACTION actiondesc R111-2004-A-0067 1 05/21/2004 06/02/2004 12 1 Acknowledgement Letter Need to draft letter, file w/roy for signature on arb. RllI ack letter not requied since case was transfered to NRR.

Page 1 of 1