Text

Response to Request for Additional Information Regarding Relief Requests 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, & 2R2-011 for the Second 10-Year Inservice Inspection Program
	ML092740063
Person / Time
Site:	Harris
Issue date:	09/24/2009
From:	Corlett D; Progress Energy Carolinas
To:	; Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
	HNP-09-095, TAC ME0166, TAC ME0608, TAC ME0609, TAC ME0610, TAC ME0612, TAC ME0613, TAC ME0614, TAC ME0615
	Download: ML092740063 (173)
	v • d • e

Progress Energy Serial: HNP-09-095 10 CFR 50.55a SEP 2 4 2009 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTENTION: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING RELIEF REQUESTS 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, AND 2R2-011 FOR THE SECOND 10-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM (TAC NOS.

ME0608, ME0609, ME0610, ME0166, ME0612, ME0613, ME0614, AND ME0615)

References:

1. Letter from D. H. Corlett to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (SERIAL:

HNP-08-045), "Second Ten-Year Interval Inservice Inspection Program - Final Documentation Including Requests for Relief in accordance with 10 CFR 50.55a," dated February 05, 2009

2. Letter from M. Vaaler, Nuclear Regulatory Commission, to C. L. Burton, "Request for Additional Information Regarding Relief Requests 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, and 2R2-011 For The Second 10-Year Inservice Inspection Program (TAC NOS. ME0608, ME0609, ME0610, ME0611, ME0612, ME0613, ME0614, and ME0615),"

dated July 21, 2009 Ladies and Gentlemen:

On July 21, 2009, Harris Nuclear Plant (HNP) received a request from the NRC (Reference 2) for additional information needed to facilitate the review of proposed Second 10-Year Inservice Inspection Interval Relief Requests 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, and 2R2-01 1. HNP submitted this original request as Serial: HNP-08-045 (Reference 1).

Per discussions with Marlayna Vaaler (NRC HNP Project Manager), HNP was allowed an extension to the September 18, 2009, response date specified in Reference 2. Accordingly, the Enclosures to this letter provide the requested additional information for the Relief Requests.

This document contains no new or revised Regulatory Commitments.

Please refer any questions regarding this submittal to me at (919) 362-3137.

Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. -T Harris Nuclear Plant P.O. Box 165 New Hill, NC 27562 ,i 10'

HNP-09-095 Page 2 Sincerely, D. H. Corlett Supervisor - Licensing/Regulatory Programs Harris Nuclear Plant DHC/kms

Enclosures:

1. HNP's Response to the Request for Additional Information Regarding Relief Request 13R-02 for the Third 10-Year Inservice Inspection Interval

2. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R1-0 18 Response to Request for Additional Information

3. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R1-019 Response to Request for Additional Information

4. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R1-020 Response to Request for Additional Information

5. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R1-021 Response to Request for Additional Information

6. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R1-022 Response to Request for Additional Information

7. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R2-009 Response to Request for Additional Information

8. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R2-010 Response to Request for Additional Information

9. Inservice Inspection Relief Request 2R2-011 Response to Request for Additional Information cc: Mr. J. D. Austin, NRC Sr. Resident Inspector, HNP Mr. L. A. Reyes, NRC Regional Administrator, Region II Ms. N. C. Ritchie-Slaughter, Harris Plant Authorized Nuclear Inservice Inspector Ms. M. G. Vaaler, NRC Project Manager, HNP

Enclosure 1 to SERIAL:JINP 09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING RELIEF REQUESTS 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, AND 2R2-011 FOR THE SECOND 10-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM Summary Carolina Power & Light Company, now doing business as Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc.,

(PEC) (licensee) submitted Relief Requests (RRs) 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, and 2R2-01 1, for the Harris Nuclear Plant (HNP). The proposed RRs are for the second 10-year inservice inspection (ISI) interval, in which the licensee adopted the 1989 Edition of the ASME Code,Section XI, No Addenda, as the Code of Record.

The proposed RRs request relief in accordance with Title 10 of the Code ofRegulations (10 CFR) Section 50.55a(g)(5)(iii) from applicable requirements of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code (ASME Code),Section XI, "Rules for Inservice Inspection of Nuclear Power Plant Components," related to inspection of welds with limited coverage in ASME Code examination Categories B-F, B-A, B-D, B-B, C-A, C-B, and C-A. The ASME Code requires that 100 percent of the examination volumes or surface areas described in ASME Code,Section XI, Tables IWB-2500 and IWC-2500, be inspected during each interval., The licensee stated that 100 percent of the ASME Code-required volumes or surface areas are impractical to obtain at HNP.

10 CFR 50.55a(g)(5)(iii) states that when licensees determine that conformance with ASME Code requirements is impractical at their facility, they shall submit information to support this determination. The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) will evaluate such requests based on impracticality, and may impose alternatives, giving due consideration to public safety and the burden imposed on the licensee.

Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and the NRC have reviewed the information submitted by the licensee and have determined the following information is required to complete the evaluation.

Request 1: General - Information Required on All Requests for Relief In all cases, the licensee has provided only general information regarding the impracticality of obtaining ASME Code-required volumetric or surface examinations, as applicable. Statements such as "physical obstructions and geometric surface conditions," "design configurations," or "inner diameter counterbore and root configuration," are inadequate to explain the bases for not obtaining the ASME Code-required examination volumes. No sketches with dimensional information showing the causes of limited accessibility have been included.

Please submit detailed and specific information to support the bases for limited examination in all requests for relief in order to demonstrate impracticality. Specifically:

a) Include descriptions (written and/or sketches, as necessary) of the interferences present Page 1 of 5

Enclosure I to SERIAL: HNP 09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE-NO. NPF-63 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING RELIEF REQUESTS 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, AND 2R2-011 FOR THE SECOND 10-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM for applied nondestructive examination (NDE) techniques.

b) As applicable, describe NDE equipment (ultrasonic scanning apparatus), details of the listed obstructions (size, shape, proximity to the weld, etc.) to demonstrate accessibility limitations, and discuss whether alternative methods or advanced technologies could be employed to maximize ASME Code coverage.

c) Fully clarify the wave modality and insonification angles used for all ultrasonic examinations.

d) Provide cross-sectional coverage plots to describe the ASME Code volumes examined.

e) If not included, state whether any indications were discovered as a result of these examinations, and how these indications have been dispositioned.

Response: The requested information is summarized in the following

Enclosures:

Enclosure 2 2R1-018 Enclosure 3 2R1-019 Enclosure 4 2R1-020 Enclosure 5 2R1-021 Enclosure 6 2R1-022 Enclosure 7 2R2-009 Enclosure 8 2R2-010 Enclosure 9 2R2-011 Request 2: Request for Relief 2R2-010, ASME Code,Section XI, Examination Category C-B, Item C2.21, Nozzle-to-Shell Weld The licensee has requested relief from the requirement to examine 100 percent of the ASME Code-required inspection volume for two Boron Injection Tank nozzle-to-vessel welds:

II-BIT-01NTHW-03 and II-BIT-01NTHW-04.

a) Please state whether the inspection techniques used to examine these welds included refracted longitudinal waves.

Response: Shear waves were used in all angle beam exams and longitudinal waves used in the 0 degree exam, as follows:

45 degree shear - V2 V 60 degree shear - V2 V 0 degree - longitudinal Page 2 of 5

Enclosure I to SERIAL: HNP 09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING RELIEF REQUESTS 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-024, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, AND 2R2-011 FOR THE SECOND 10-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM b) Please state the material used (austenitic or ferritic steel) and the wall thickness for each of these components.

Response: The material used is alloy steel - ASTM A 204 Standard Specification for Pressure Vessel Plates, Alloy Steel, Molybdenum with a 1.732" Thickness Request 3: Request for Relief 2R1-018, ASME Code,Section XI, Examination Category B-F, Item B5.130, NPS 4 or Larger Dissimilar Metal Butt Welds a) The licensee has requested relief from the requirement to examine 100 percent of the ASME Code-requiredinspection volume for the following dissimilar metal welds on the primary coolant system:

RVNOZCI-N-05SE Inlet Nozzle DM weld at 95 degrees RVNOZBI-N-03SE Inlet Nozzle DM weld at 215 degrees RVNOZAI-N-01SE Inlet Nozzle DM weld at 335 degrees It is unclear from the licensee's submittal why inlet nozzle welds RVNOZCI-N-05SE and RVNOZBI-N-03SE were not included in the previous 10-year ISI request for relief.

Please submit information explaining why these welds were not included previously.

Response: As discussed in Section 8.1 ("Changes in Circumstances") of Relief Request Submittal (SERIAL: HNP-08-045), these examinations were performed by a different vendor during the first interval, resulting in different coverage limitations. Additionally, the second interval UT inspections were performed with examination personnel and examination procedures qualified to ASME Code, Appendix VIII, as administered by the EPRI Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI). This improved method of examination also results in differing coverage limitations.

b) Please provide more detailed information on the ultrasonic testing (UT) inspections performed (i.e., probe type, incident angle, geometrical interference, scanned coverage, etc).

Response: Information is provided in Enclosure 2 of this response.

c) Please explain how the "Combined UT [Ultrasonic] Coverage Total Percentage" in Sections 6.1, 6.2, and 6.3 of 2R1-018 is obtained.

Page 3 of 5

Enclosure I to SERIAL: 14NP 09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING RELIEF REQUESTS 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, AND 2R2-011 FOR THE SECOND 10-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM Response: The Combined UT coverage totals as provided in Sections 6.1, 6.2 and 6.3 of 2R1-018 were obtained from averaging the individual (CCW, CS, UP, DOWN) 700 Longitudinal Wave Dual Scans as follows :

RVNOZC1-N-05SE: (69.15 + 69.15 + 100 + 100)/4 = 84.58 RVNOZBI-N-03SE: (76.67 + 76.67 + 100 + 100)/4 = 88.34 RVNOZA1-N-01SE: (70.29 + 70.29 + 100 + 100)/4 = 85.15 d) Please provide information regarding when the ultrasonic testing inspection for each weld was performed (e.g., what ASME Code criteria were required - Appendix VIII or Section V)?

Response: 'As discussed in Section 6.1 for RVNOZC1-N-05SE, Section 6.2 for RVNOZBl-N-03SE and Section 6.3 for RVNOZAI-N-OISE of the Relief Request Submittal (SERIAL:

HNP-08-045), UT examinations were performed with examination personnel and examination procedures qualified to ASME Code, Appendix VIII, as administered by the EPRI Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI).

e) Please provide more detailed information on the eddy current inspection methods performed, the inner diameter surface conditions of the affected welds, and an assessment of the ability to perform the eddy current testing exam effectively on these types of surface conditions.

Response: The Eddy Current procedure (provided separately) contains this information.

Request 4: Request for Relief 2R1-022, ASME Code,Section XI, Examination Category B-B, Item B2.40, Pressure Retaining Welds in Vessels Other than Reactor Vessels The licensee has requested relief from the requirement to examine 100 percent of the ASME Code-required inspection volume for steam generator tubesheet-to-head weld II-SG-001 SGA-TSTHW-06-1.

HNP is a 3-loop pressurized water reactor plant; there are three steam generators, each containing a tubesheet-to-head weld. The ASME Code states that "the examination may be limited to one vessel among the group of vessels performing similar functions."

Please clarify whether all three steam generator tubesheet-to-head welds were examined.

Because the licensee was unable to meet the ASME Code-required inspection volume on tubesheet-to-head weld II-SG-00 1SGA-TSTHW 1, if the other tubesheet-to-head welds were examined, please describe whether the same coverage area limitations apply to these similar welds on the remaining two steam generators.

Page 4 of 5

Enclosure I to SERIAL: HNP 09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING RELIEF REQUESTS 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, AND 2R2-011 FOR THE SECOND 10-YEAR INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM Response: All three of HNP's steam generators have the same configuration and associated limitation. Since this examination category only requires one examination per similar vessel, only one of the steam generators was examined. Additionally, these steam generators were new in 2001.

Page 5 of 5

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Examination Category B-F, Item B5.130, NPS 4 or Larger Dissimilar Metal Butt Welds RAI REQUEST RESPONSE Ia Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Welds are Cold leg elbow to nozzle weld.

Ia Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

la Interference/Obstruction (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 5.0). Volumetric examination for the subject welds at HNP is restricted due to geometric surfaces (inner diameter surface counter-bore and root configuration) which limit accessibility and make the 100 percent volumetric examination impractical for these areas.

lb NDE Equipment The following procedures are provided separately:

PDI-ISI-254-SE WDI-STD- 146 WDI-STD-088 lb Alternative Methods (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 6.0). To supplement the UT, areas of limitation were fully scanned using eddy current testing (ET), which is effective in detecting surface breaking flaws. This combination of UT and ET further validates that the proposed alternative provides an acceptable level of quality and safety, since these completed examinations would have detected any existing patterns of degradation.

lc Wave Modality/ Insonification Information follows in Enclosure ("70' Longitudinal Angles Wave Dual Scan").

Id Cross Sectional Coverage Plots to Information follows in Enclosure.

describe the ASME Code coverage le Results of the Examination No indications detected.

Indications / No Indications

________ __________________________________________________ I Page 1 of 10

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 3a It is unclear from the licensee's (Reference Relief Request submittal.HNP-08-045 submittal why inlet nozzle welds Section 8.1). During the first interval, these RVNOZCI N 05SE and RVNOZBI- examinations were performed by a different vendor N-03SE were not included in the using different equipment, resulting in different previous 10 year ISI request for coverage limitations. In addition, the second relief. Please submit information interval UT Examinations were performed with explaining why these welds were not examination personnel and examination procedures included previously, qualified to ASME Code, Appendix VIII, as administered by the EPRI Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI).

3b Please provide more detailed Information follows in Enclosure.

information on the ultrasonic testing (UT) inspections performed (i.e.,

probe type, incident angle, geometrical interference, scanned coverage, etc).

3c Please explain how the "Combined An averaging method is used.

UT [Ultrasonic] Coverage Total Percentage" in Sections 6.1, 6.2, and 6.3 of 2R1 -018 is obtained.

3d Please provide information regarding (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 when the ultrasonic testing inspection Sections 6.1, 6.2 and 6.3). UT examinations were for each weld was performed (e.g., performed with examination personnel and what ASME Code criteria were examination procedures qualified to ASME Code, required - Appendix VIII or Section Appendix VIII, as administered by the EPRI V)? Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI).

3e Please provide more detailed Eddy Current procedure provided separately:

information on the eddy current WDI-STD-146 inspection methods performed, the inner diameter surface conditions of the affected welds, and an assessment of the ability to perform the eddy current testing exam effectively on these types of surface conditions.

Page 2 of 10

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: RVNOZCI-N-05SE ASME CATEGORY: B-F ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B5.130 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: ELBOW TO REACTOR % CRV ACHIEVED: 84.58 %

VESSEL NOZZLE PROCEDURES: PDI-ISI-254-SE MATERIAL SS/CS WDI-STD- 146 WDI-STD-088 PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 700 LONGITUDINAL WAVE DUAL SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CCW 69.15% ELBOW TO NOZZLE WELD ID COUNTER-BORE AND ROOT CONFIGURATION CW 69.15% ELBOW TO NOZZLE WELD ID COUNTER-BORE AND ROOT CONFIGURATION UP 100%

DOWN 100%

EDDY CURRENT SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CCW 100%

CW 100%

The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the elbow to nozzle weld ID counter-bore and root configuration obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 84.58 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS Page 3 of 10

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63

-INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: RVNOZBI-N-03SE ASME CATEGORY: B-F ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B5.130 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: ELBOW TO REACTOR % CRV ACHIEVED: 88.34 %

VESSEL NOZZLE PROCEDURES: PDI-ISI-254-SE MATERIAL SS/CS WDI-STD-146 WDI-STD-088 PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 700 LONGITUDINAL WAVE DUAL SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CCW 76.67% ELBOW TO NOZZLE WELD ID COUNTER-BORE AND ROOT CONFIGURATION CW 76.67% ELBOW TO NOZZLE WELD ID COUNTER-BORE AND ROOT CONFIGURATION UP 100%

DOWN 100%

EDDY CURRENT SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CCW 100%

CW 100%

The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the elbow to nozzle weld ID counter-bore and root configuration obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 88.34 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS Page 4 of 10

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: RVNOZAI-N-O0SE ASME CATEGORY: B-F ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B5.130 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: ELBOW TO REACTOR % CRV ACHIEVED: 85.15 %

VESSEL NOZZLE PROCEDURES: PDI-ISI-254-SE MATERIAL SS/CS WDI-STD-146 WDI-STD-088 PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 700 LONGITUDINAL WAVE DUAL SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CCW 70.29% ELBOW TO NOZZLE WELD ID COUNTER-BORE AND ROOT CONFIGURATION CW 70.29% ELBOW TO NOZZLE WELD ID COUNTER-BORE AND ROOT CONFIGURATION UP 100%

DOWN 100%

EDDY CURRENT SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CCW 100%

CW 100%

The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the elbow to nozzle weld ID counter-bore and root configuration obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 85.15 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS Page 5 of 10

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION WELD CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET WELD DOWN SCAN DIRECTION ELBOW SIDE NOZZLE FLOW TO VESSEL Page 6 of 10

01 91 Detection Scaons w

zn (U %D -

ooH vu c-'

C*

V)A.A 0 r 0 N'

of: 0 C

< u N

Silzing. ScAts.:

UH

c,,t*,

CAr QO (u

WELDS - 'RVNDZCI-N-O0SSE <ý95*)

L:a'~. RVN0ZBD-N--O3SE, (215-)

r- .A x 0~~14ZAI -N- OIS E (335*k)

SHEARON HARRIS, .. ...... .CQ , "CL PROGRAM EXAMNzzZe "Ine*. flM PLAN W`eItd I We~sDyne, :Initerncti~ona-l' I)LM~nONNS1NINCm ISHEET ý9.OF 23

EOUIPMENT TAG 2

00 L1DCMDETMILS cj~ C-4 0

In 0

0 Ui 0

0 00 C

09 to) u

$H~kSW 10 L hrw I

0Progress Energy REACTOR VESSEL

EOUIPMOIT TAG IR'-EN1

- z 0 r Z - (TPIAL W THZU

'D')

CA-5O H022LE M-Zj ~ ~ 2~--7-- ~e~d COP REACTOR VESSE Me.,. 1-TST-FN-AE(T~

w WST-RV-4600

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENTS:

A) Reactor Vessel Weld Results Summary RVNOZCI-N-05SE, including:

- Analysis Log # SE-95-1

- ET Analysis Log # SE-95-1

- Data Acquisition Log # SE-95-1

- RPV Coverage Estimate Breakdown NOZ @ 950 B) Reactor Vessel Weld Results Summary RVNOZCI-N-03SE, including:

- Analysis Log # SE-215-1

- ET Analysis Log # SE-215-1

- Data Acquisition Log # SE-215-1

- RPV Coverage Estimate Breakdown NOZ @ 2150 C) Reactor Vessel Weld Results Summary RVNOZCI-N-01SE, including:

- Analysis Log # SE-335-1

- ET Analysis Log # SE-335-1

- Data Acquisition Log # SE-335-1

- RPV Coverage Estimate Breakdown NOZ @ 3350 Page 10 of 10

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT A WesDyne International Reactor Vessel Weld Results Summary RVNOZC1-N-05SE (5 Pages)

WesDyne International Reactor Vessel Weld Results Summary SEARON.HARRJS UNIT I RVNOZCI-N-; INLET NOZZLE DM"WELD, WELD NO. DESCRITIlON 05SE @ 950 LIMITATIONS N01-; YF-SW WeldConfguratio RULTs NI EZI NO. OFINDIC ATIONS1 .0 STATUS M/A EXM DOCUMENTAikA iON INDICATION DOCUMENTATION

[~ANALY-SIS LOG D; ASSESSMETSHEET L~]ACU1I~)NLOG L]PARAGON HARD COPY SC'AýN PRWNOLJT 07jO0iR(sei)

] !COVEPRAE BREAKDOW.N WESDYNE ANALYST

~g~pynE

-Pageo I of ..

ANALYSIS LOG # SE-95;.1 Utility, Pors nerg Plant: j $hearon~Harris unit:", . I Outage: I RFOI3 ".

!'Procedure Rev,:No.: 2

.:o: IZW0,SE ... !d Typa- DM' Exam- Su*"rfac : A D Appllcable, Sensitivty Calibration Da* a Sheaf M6; SE-01 TJ._qulitlon Log No: _PAR'AGON Anal. Release:l 6.1.6ý

.... I .ate: L..... It D 4 181 UT Rgle DataTFileName : Channel Beam ClctlOn NI RI. Examiner ID1 Date No.;____ .- i* *'*cW=.cResolutionIlComments - ILimitatio. .

WN95SEPARDET1N I CC _________________ csw /8'/06 WN95SEPARDETINN 2 Cw X .SW 4/18/0 W`N95SEPRPDETIN : I IN: CSW 4/18/06

,WN95SpEPRPDETIN 2 OUT X SW .4118/06

. - I-...

I*

r _ _ .... ..

____ ___ ....... 1'.

' ............. . t ::

_____.... . :*.:: :,:* E

..-:::.:.=-::::-i l:. *:'i': . ... *:'; , .: ,.. .. .. '... ___:' . . :

'Form 125. PIDW~S[.254-SE,'Rv

~WE6DyflE ETnalsisLog: ýSE96-1 Utplity.. Pregres Enemgy. Io;SernIan nt uae F PpeodumHe: k-Wbl4TD.i46 Proc~dure Rlev. No.:

Ap plxica bl e S ign s t u re:y CallbpIat o , a h et N : T O at te; 4110106 ;

DAta ET. ET Probe Stcan: NI. RI. RI Exmn Oatse EeNaeProbe O~@ton, ResolutinjCM I 'omments I UMitations No. t#Gr WýN95EPAREl I IGXtSW 4M1010 W 9SIARDETIN: 2 . CIRO, X CGW 4118106 MWMUSEPR FIDETIN :.AX XCSW 4O W N'0 WNB5SEPRP~TIN .2. AXx CW4 Forml 25

?I W yn Page 1 -of 1

.DATA ACQUISITIQN LOG`#ý S.E-95-1 Ui ProgresslEqergy Plant: ......HaM*s .. .. . . . .

Shearon . Unit.. Outag: RF_.13 ProceOdure. No:. PP!4lSl-254 SE'11 ___ Procedure Rev., No.:

UTExrrlnr igatre J'jvel: It Data: 4118106 alta File Name Weld Now Index ,Scan Total#

t'AVE' Gain, Date Time Comments

'strt; Start of Signal A.. .

Sweeps Amplitude, .d)

(,mddyy)

WN95SEPARDETIN N-05SEý 25.51's 00 4' 18 0 ESO 418/08 1 CHANNEL-1 WN95SEPARDETIN N-O5SE 125;51' . 5 171 0 ESO 418/06 1746 CHANNEL 2 WN85SEPRPDETIN N-O5SEw 0 114-74! 347 14 0 ESO. 4/18/06 184Z CHANNEL,1 WN95SEPRPDEMIN ."N'0SE 0$ 114.74. .34 7 12! 0 :16 4/18106 1842 CHANNEL.2 Form 12A4 IPDI-SI-254-SE, Rem 2

SHEARON HARRtIS #1 'DI RECTION / ORIENTATION kPV COVERAGE ESTIMATEIBREAKDOWNS PARALLEL SCANS PERP.-SCANS IN/ OUT ITEMIAREA INLET NOZZLEDM WELD' 956 WEELDNO. -RVNOZCI-'N-SE-.

Exa mihation Probes BEAM W70 Dual *ET DiRECTiON r:__...._

Examiotni Vokmb Ex~mna Itn Swf~ce WELD VOLUME WELLVOLUME WELD VOLUME cw .15 100 cw::

cw 69J15 loG-up 100o DOWN 100 -

UT Combined Coverage = 84.58%*

UT:& ET ComblnediCoverage 1,00%.

Ciro Scsns limited as per pm~csdure.POOS due to ID Couoe-o~an o!c iUrain

,ET used' to u psurp6emnt-Ls~m, fr uIl ov~erage.

ANALYSTYS

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT B WesDyne International Reactor Vessel Weld Results Summary RVNOZB1-N-03SE (5 Pages)

WesDyne International Reactor Vessel Weld Results. Summary SHEARON HARRIS UNIT 11 WELDL NO. RVNOZBI-N-3SE DESCRTION INLET NOZZLE, DM WELD LIMI'TATIONS :NO

,.. I.

'YE'SWF-- Coverage = 88.34%

Weld Configur-ation RESU1TS IRf1 NO. OF INDICATIONS 0 STATUS N/A EXAi DOCUMENTATION INDICATION DOCUMENTATION IANALYSIS LOG D ASSSES NT SHEET

[]ACQUISITIO-N LOG: ]PA.RAGON HARD COPY

[]SCAN PRINTOUT L]OTHER (Specify) 7] -COVERAGE BREAKDOWN WESDYNE ANALYST ccc~4~

lESDyvnE Page, , of ANALYSISLOG # SEI-21i54 utility: [Progress Energy '

iPiant: TShearon I arra Unit: I 'Outage: RFO-13 Procedure No: PD-ISI-254-SE Procedure Rev.

Weld No: [RVNOZBI-N-03SE tWe1dType:~ I Ir4TLET-DM Exam. Surface: I D A*Aplicable Sensitivity Calibration Data Sheet No: SE-01,^. 4cqui,,3ition Log No: I SE215-1 j PARAGON Anal. Reease:1 6A~6 UT. Examiner Signaturfe: Dte: 4-1S Data File Name, UT BoaWAngle I N1Ill ~ RI, Examiner ID 1Date Channel * .:Beam ..._.,, ...

Direction : . Resolution R

....,. :/Com m-ents Comm.. L itations*

t. I Lim t"

.WN215-SE-PFA-DET-IN 1I "70( CCW X "SW 4*18/06 WN21 5-SE-PAR-DET-IN 2 70'1/W XCSW 4118?06

'WN2,I5-SE-PRP-DET-1N I 70 IN . CSW 4118106 WN215-SE-PRP-DET-IN. 2 70'/ OUT X CSW 4118/06 Ff-r!-n 12~5DM81-264-SE, Revý 2

mwasco ETAnalySiS 1Lg: SE 215-1 Proc No.WDIST 4$ ... ... . . .. . .... Pe 4RevO.No.:% ".

" Ap pi ca bi~e:s on i i . et 'N o : ETCall ation Da tg S h e"i,ýity 6traJ -11. ... . . . .. . .. . . .. . = Ar q islton No ýSE2,11-1 lb t o Logg Nc E 5-ET am Si r . ., L Ill .. .. .. .. . .. Date: 4-19-6 "

-Data ET 'ET Probe Scan :NI RI RI: Examiner ID 1 Data File Name Probe

No. Dirction Resoltlon 1Comments I LImItations

,WN216S.ERT EIRM NX CSW 14-19,40 WN2 S;PARDEIN .. 2CIRC X CSW 14-119-06 WN2 SSEPRPDETIN, T AXIAL X CSW 4-19-00

'WN2I6SEPRPEN... :2: AXIAL .CSWI 4-49-00 form, 12.-5

lMJWE6DYPEi

'Page 1 -of I DATA ACQUISITION LOG # SEM2I51 Utliy 6m Proced '..rgress;ýEnergy M : ý:PFDWI4S-25". Ei .... . -at*,Shearoq'.

. .r Harr!; .Rev... t.Unit,: 1, .pOutage :,e.. .N. ....... "........2 Applicable SensitivcCalibraon DataSheet No: -Ol ---- -_---

itiatui_ _UTExam_ _1 11, Date: 4-1,806

.ati File Name 'e N6.

,._ index Scan Total # "AVto Gain *.Date Time Comments StLart 'Start o inl Ai Sweqpsý. Amplitude k fmidy)

W21:5SE-.PARDETiN 125251" 0" ,5 88NO3SE 0. S 4-18-06 22 CHANNEL I W .215-SE-.ARDIETN N-03SEt 125.51j 0 -54' 9 0 OS 4,-1,6` 22:28 CHANNEL 2.:

i DN2iN:EPRP ,N.,0'SE' 0 1

.411.74" 034 515 " 4-18-06 23:21 CHANNýEL1 WN25I1SE;7RP.DEI' N-.3SEC '0 '

1i.74*

346

.1",1 ;"

0 S 4-1 :28-06,

2,21CHANNEL ,. .

2,

.$ ,--P ,D, E T-I-N: _ *. § E, .

~~~' ' :.. ... ~ L.. .. .

Form 124. PDiI-SIR-25SE,.Rev. 2

SHEARON HARRIS #1 DIRECTION / ORIENTATION RPV; COVERGE ESTIMATEl *BREAKDOWN0,S PARALLEL SCANS ,CCW/Cw PERP,RSCANS .IN1/OUT ITE=M, A ARE A INLET NOZZLE, DM- WELD .02150 WELDiNO. RVNOZB IN-O3SE.

Examination Probes BEAM 700 Dual =ET DI

_N .RECTIO .. . ... __ .. : .. _____ .. ...

ExaftiwminIovom ýEimin-atlan s~tfac9l :WELD VOLUME WELD VOLUME -WELD VOLUME

'ccw h610

,c~w !*76.67 100

'UP 100-DOWN 100 ' - ;

UT Combined Coverage 88.34%

UT & ET Combined Coverage, i=00 Circ ,Scans limited as'per procedure'.PDQS due to ID Counter-borezand Rbot configuration.

ET used. to: supplemernt exam for fufl coverage,.

ANALYST_____________

Enclosure 2 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-018 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT C WesDyne International Reactor Vessel Weld Results Summary RVNOZA1-N-01SE (5 Pages)

WesDyne Intemrational ReactorVessel Weld Results Summary SHEARON HARRI$UNEIT RVNOOZAI-N- INLET NOZZLE DMWLD WELD NO.

. iSE -R35 LIMITATIONS :NG YES~J 'Coveralge = 854i59/o Weld Configuration I SUILTS NO. OFVINDICATiONS r0 STATUS' N/A 8Ek..M..DQCUMENTATION ANALYSIS LOGI ZASSESSMEi-NT SHEET wACQUiSITION LOG ZPARAGON HAiRD COPY-ZOTER ('specify)

[~]

COVERAE BEKDýOWN WESDYNE- ANALYST

Y~DyflE Page I, of 4-ANALYSIS LOG4# :SE-33541 Uti'ty:, P:ro9ress Energy'Plat: Shea-onI rris Unit: I . Outage:" RF 3 ProcedureNo; N PDI-iSI-254SE ýProcedure RevZNo.: 2 Wetd No: I RVNQZA-N-OsE: WeldType: INLET-DM Exam. Surface; IDi Applicable Sensitifity Calibration Data hetNO:Acquiton LogNo: S.-335A1 PARAGON Anal R . 6 UT Examiner Signature: __Level: Ill Date:. 4-I81.06 Data FieName " ' UT "Beam'Anglel Ni H Ri' RI ExaminerIDl Date

... :No,.

channel BeamDireton O..Q,=.,CW~CC~aj Resolution I Comment. I Limitations.

WN3354SE-PAR-DEiTiN 1. 70' COW X :.SAS 18!06 WN335-SE-PAR-DET-IN , 2: .. 1CW x SAS 4118106 WN*335SEpPRP0DET-iN ....... 10I IN .AS 4118/06 WOW WN335-SE-PRP-IDET-I' 2 .709 1 OUT XSA4/86

.t.

Form 12.5 POI-IS1-254JSEf Rev. 2'

-WwEDynlii

.ET.Anal sfs log: .Sg335-1 oUtiit:i Progress Erergy Nant: Slic-iron liarris u nit: I, Cute

. _9 clkis 1: - ý .

Prmo~dtireNwo, WDI-STD-146 Proc~.dJw. Rev. No.: 61 Weld No.: RVNOZAl44.-OiSl Weld Tj*O6:,JNLETDM'WELD AT 336*

Appllcable SonsItlvity Ca~lfbratfn Data Sheet Vo: ET-1 Acquisitlen Log. Nw: SE33$4l aT Wxminer Sfgnaturi., 0 -~fit.l blate: 44-186 Dataer E~wbecan I RIRi xamlnerlWO/ate

Fi le Nasme Probe ~Dr' No2~nRslto Cmet

-Coittntil~iitaioI i~ain WN335SEPAROETINA. I cIRC X s i.ýo WN336SEPAROETINA 2 CIRC X ________________ CW 14-18j-06 W?433$SEPRPDETIN. 1AiWAL X GSW /4-18-06 WN3,358EPRPOETIN: Z:AXIAL kX iiw: I 4A-18

,Eortni' 12-5

RWR PyIna, pa,96, I of I DATA ACQUISITION LOG # SE336-,

Utility:

ProgressHEnergy hearon Harrs UninPlant I Outage: RFO-13 Procedure No. : PDl-8l-i254-sE . Procedure Rev. No. 2.

.Applicabl6eS.S iIvity Cal i.rao.S Data. Sheet, N.:....

UT Eamier igntur:

____________Levjel: HI Date: 4-80 DatalFlieName Weld No. I"I(ex SCan 'Total# AVE' "Gain -. Date Time Comments Start Start- of . ;Signal 'Adj.. &

Sweepsn:. AmplitudeO dB } * (mm- d

~ ........

~ d )dd!*

~ .. .... ) c * ,/y 0.

WN335SEPARDEiNA . N-ISE 122.49' 0 52 17 0 CSW .418-06. 0600.CHANNELI-WN336SEPARDEINA N-18* 122,491- 06 5-,62 i4 b0. 0'SW 4.-IS-O6,S 0800 ,CHANNELI2 WN335SEPRPDEIN N-OISE *14774*

I0I+ .48 7 0 DS 4-18-0 0730 ;CHANNEL 1.

WN335SEPRPDEIN . N-OISE 0. 114.74" 348 12 0 DS -44M806 0730 ,CHANNEL2 JJ]JJ* , ,sJ*J* -. .

Form 12.4. PDI-iSI,-24+SE Rev.-2

SHEARON HARRIS #1 DIRECTION-fORIENTATION RPV COVERAGEtEsTI MAVT E BREKDOWNS PAPALLEL,SCANS PERP,*. SCANS IN.!OUT ITEM/ AREA INLETVNOZZLE DM WELD @ 3350 WELD NO, RVNOZAI.N-O1 SE:

ExaminatiOn Probes BEAM 70"' Dual 'ET D IR E C T IO N .......... ., . . . . . . ..

Exm~tin okmeExrnnaIa Sfa&WELD VOLUME: WEfLD VOLUME, WELD VOLUME ccw J029 00 cw 70.29 100 u- ico:

DOWN UT Combined Coverage = 85 5%

UT & ETCombined iCooverage = 100%

CircScans limited as per procedurePDQS due t ID-D Couiter-bore and.Ro'ot-"config~umtion; ET. used to su6IemeIntexam rfor fulroverage,,

ANALYSJ T

Enclosure 3 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-019 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Examination Category B-A, Item BI.ll and B1.21, Circumferential Shell/Head Welds RAI REQUEST RESPONSE 1a Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Welds are Lower shell to lower circumferential shell weld and lower head circumferential weld.

la Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

la Interference/Obstruction (Reference Relief Request submittal 1HNP-08-045 Section 5.0). The limitation for Reactor Vessel Lower Head to Lower Shell Circumferential Weld STHW-RV-04 was due to the four core support lugs integrally attached to the reactor vessel. The limitation for Reactor Vessel Lower Head Circumferential Weld CHW-RV-17 was due to peripherally located Bottom Mounted Instrumentation (BMI) tubes integrally attached to the reactor vessel.

lb NDE Equipment The following procedure is provided separately:

PDI-ISI-254 lb Alternative Methods (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 6.0). HNP is proposing to volumetrically UT examine the RPV pressure retaining welds STHW-RV-04 and CHW-RV-17 to the maximum extent possible in accordance with the Inservice Inspection Program schedule. A significant portion of the subject welds have been examined, obtaining 83.9% for weld STHW-RV-04 and 81.77% for weld CHW-RV-17. In addition, the subject welds are subject to visual (VT-2) system Leakage test during each refueling outage.

lc Wave Modality/ Insonification Information follows in Enclosure ("45' Angles Longitudinal Wave Dual Scan", "45' Longitudinal Wave Single Element Scan", "45' Shear Wave Scan").

ld Cross Sectional Coverage Plots to Information follows in Enclosure.

describe the ASME Code coverage Page 1 of 13

Enclosure 3 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-019 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION le Results of the Examination Information follows in Enclosure.

SIndications / No Indications Page 2 of 13

Enclosure 3 to SERIAL: 1HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-019 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: STHW-RV-04 ASME CATEGORY: B-A ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: Bl.1l FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: CIRCUMFERENTIAL SHELL % CRV ACHIEVED: 83.90 %

WELD PROCEDURES: PDI-ISI-254 MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 450 LONGITUDINAL WAVE DUAL SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 75.56% 84.41% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL CW 75.56% 84.41% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL UP 79.11% 79.11% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL DOWN 79.11% 79.11% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL Page 3 of 13

'Enclosure 3 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-019 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 450 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SINGLE ELEMENT SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 82.04% 84.41% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL CW 82.04% 84.41% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL UP 79.11% 79.11% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL DOWN 79.11% 79.11% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL 450 SHEAR WAVE SCAN SCAN % WELD %VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 82.04% 84.41% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL CW 82.04% 84.41% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL UP 100% 97.46% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL DOWN 100% 97.46% FOUR CORE SUPPORT LUGS INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the four core support lug obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 83.90 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: ONE RECORDABLE INDICATION ALLOWABLE PER ASME SECTION XI 1989, IWB-3510-1 Page 4 of 13

C" EQUIPMENr TAG IRC-EO9I TL ~.

-Fi OF 71~-

~~ PIPE~

cj ~ H~ ~v MM -NELWELD 4 AV Akr.:R z _ _ _ _ da-M I]IE HzL P4 WP-W-U Z z C) f m~cI'mrT1.2/

U I,0-0,0 0 re ----------------

_ 0 P.,_

c-d __ _

TUR F.U-i OUNDEON I OMrogreM) nEnergy

5 REACIOR VESSEL

. WY m 1-ISI-RV-1 -

OULEL I ;pNLET Lop 3 OTLET'Loop -3 INLET:Loop:2 OUTLETLoo 2 INLET Loop 1:

25-9 4 1 6 335, I~ r 6 0--- 60 CO 2 0 V-O~ - __ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___

121C6, __

C-4 u~ Z (:)

33.19

~Q 0RV-07 RY708, -7 65 IELD 0 S 1150' W) MV-04 10 MOMNM RV I ILl )RV RV-7 16 105*

~ 165*

4 1VS R3 225 RV -2 25.

(:: W oo SHE-ARON HARRIS CQL.

WesDlyne, 1nte~r.nationial.

TfW V ess et RottbUt EXAM!PROGR'Am"PLAN 1m AMMS HEE~T 1 OF 2

N ON "SCANS IBETV/EEN: LUGS-:

ON SUPREEN ANGULAR SCANNING DOUNDARIES 78:5 R: AREA BETWEEN PERP SCANS PARALLEL SCANS 0' :90 9.4' - 80V -i":'79,0?

0* 9%4BO - 170.6- 1010" -169.0'-

.180' - 270': 1894'. - 260,6 191,0 ** 25o9.0 33T3O19 270 - 30' '27,94- - 350.6 2SL0 7:349,0' TO. TOP:

Noteý Performi scons between si.porfu~' fir cj~

C z OF - -- Expand the lbelqw' scans, If necess dry,. to z 0Y 324,0 TOP.:PERP . cove.1ge.

~1.)

326o0, TOP PAR LLEL

ýNOMINAL. POSITI.ON OF ,SUPPOR.T LUGS,-

0 0 C' 0.180ý,27.0-80.9W 0

7...8 9ý ýBOTTOiM PARALLEL

'78,0V BOTTOM PERP 323i5O

.vESSEL ZQ W'ýELD-Cb AV-1

-SHEARFON HARRIS' - CQL ribOTOIPO[W

,caiw~i &AI4 WesDyne Internationa.(

INEIXSIZEt 7LIOWER SHELL 7T LOWER: HEAD'. CIRC PARALLEL SCANS 015i PERP SCANS = 8,365- EXAM PRBGRAM PLAN IUNUES AUD110OWN INI[SHEET 19. OF 2 -

3 OMWU NOM

ON ON 0

SCANS BE-LV '~LUGS&

SUPREEM ANCGULAR<, SCANNINGý Bý)UNUARIES

-:2 LUG EPSAS PRLE SCANS zo 0.

90..

- 350' 8 -w IV`

41001, 348! - 12'

'78* C 18V 170- 2 18 192ý18 2701 2W_ 28'2 C

0 U

33O~95 r

z 00 0J zoD 0

H 32.150 VE~~SSEL 0

HO WELD I-SrHW-Rv-04.

SHEAPtIN HARRIS - CQL WesDyne 'ThternotionoA CALMLATIIIN OFlEICTT13:POSITION, TM.LOWER SHELL TO LOWER'HEAD.CIR'C ME-lD S IZE I EXA0M PROGRýAMPLAN PoRALLEL & RERP ,SCANS -- 036. ALL DUM~2SIONS ININCMISSHEET I

20-OF 23

Enclosure 3 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-019 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: CHW-RV-17 ASME CATEGORY: B-A ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B1.21 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: CIRCUMFERENTIAL HEAD % CRV ACHIEVED: 81.77 %

WELDS PROCEDURES: PDI-ISI-254 MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 450 LONGITUDINAL WAVE DUAL SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 88.15% 88.15% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL CW 88.15% 88.15% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL UP 75.38% 75.38% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL DOWN 75.38% 75.38% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL Page 9 of 13

Enclosure 3 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-019 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 450 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SINGLE ELEMENT SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 88.15% 88.15% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL CW 88.15% 88.15% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL UP 75.38% 75.38% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL DOWN 75.38% 75.38% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL Page 10 of 13

Enclosure 3 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-019 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 450 SHEAR WAVE SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 88.15% 88.15% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL CW 88.15% 88.15% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL UP 75.38% 75.38% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL DOWN 75.38% 75.38% PERIPHERALLY LOCATED BOTTOM MOUNTED INSTRUMENTATION (BMI) TUBES INTEGRALLY ATTACHED TO THE REACTOR VESSEL The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the bottom mounted instrumentation tube obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 81.77 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: ONE RECORDABLE INDICATION ALLOWABLE PER ASME SECTION XI 1989, IWB-3512-1 Page 11 of 13

z TO. CLAD 0

0 z

0 IDEAL SCAN. BOUNDARIES 0

ADJUST PER ýBMifPENETRATION Pci JINTERFERENCE; 0P-q cj*

C INOEX SIZE:

PARALLEL & PERP- SCANS, =ý P036' z

[SHEARON HARRIS - CQL IV!e.sDyrneý !;h~-. er~ndtion'dt

.L0WER HEAD CIR*'"

EXAKM PROGRAM PLAN 7ic.lvoues'n of perp~an4.PmrateI Positions AUl.OMESN IN K-ir INCE . ET2a F 3

tr~

aN ON gEOULIPMEBqT jjýC=== TAG

_EOOI'q' 0

V) 0 W) z 0-cj~

0 0

C:

H*

W P K 0 2713-------

=Pit ýýP, C NU-N!,

RMOM-N-03 wz-ta NOZ44 DProgress Energy pwur SHAO RS - U I NUL REACTOR VESSEL

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1 -020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Examination Category B-A, Item B1.30, Shell to Flange Weld, and Item B 1.40, Head to Flange Weld RAI REQUEST RESPONSE la Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Welds are Vessel Flange to Upper shell weld and Vessel Flange to Head weld.

la Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

Ia Interference/Obstruction (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 5.0). The limitation that reduces the amount of UT examination coverage for Vessel Flange to Upper Shell Weld FTSW-RV-01 is the vessel configuration at the flange. The limitations for the Vessel Flange to Head Weld FTHW-RV-18 is due to the component configuration (flange directly adjacent to the weld) and the vessel head lifting lugs.

lb NDE Equipment The following procedures are provided separately:

PDI-ISI-254 (FTSW-RV-01)

WDI-STD- 146, WDI-STD-088 (FTHW-RV- 18) lb Alternative Methods (Reference Relief Request submittal 14NP-08-045 Section 6.0). HNP is proposing to volumetrically UT examine the RPV pressure retaining welds FTSW-RV-0 1 and FTHW-RV- 18 to the maximum extent possible in accordance with the Inservice Inspection Program schedule. In addition, the subject welds are subject to visual (VT-2) system Leakage test during each refueling outage. For FTHW-RV-18 Vessel Flange to Head Weld, the Code required MT Examination was also performed in accordance with the ASME Code Section XI.

1c Wave Modality/ Insonification Information follows in Enclosure ("45' Longitudinal Angles Wave Dual Scan", 45' Longitudinal Wave Single Element Scan", "45' Shear Wave Scan",

"Longitudinal Wave Manual Scans from Flange Face", 0' Longitudinal Wave Scan", 450 and 600 Shear Wave 1/2 Vee Scan").

Id Cross Sectional Coverage Plots to Information follows in Enclosure.

describe the ASME Code coverage

_ _ _ _ _ I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ~I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

,Page 1 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 1NSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Ie Results of the Examination No indications detected.

Indications / No Indications Page 2 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: FTSW-RV-01 ASME CATEGORY: B-A ASME CODE IWB-2500-4 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B 1.30 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: VESSEL FLANGE TO UPPER % CRV ACHIEVED: 87.5 %

SHELL WELD PROCEDURES: PDI-ISI-254 MATERIAL CS/CS WDI-SSP-1063 PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 450 LONGITUDINAL WAVE DUAL SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 100% 50% VESSEL CONFIGURATION AT THE FLANGE CW 100% 50% VESSEL CONFIGURATION AT THE FLANGE UP 100% 100%

DOWN 100% 100%

450 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SINGLE ELEMENT SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 100% 50% VESSEL CONFIGURATION AT THE FLANGE CW 100% 50% VESSEL CONFIGURATION AT THE FLANGE UP 100% 100%

DOWN 100% 100%

Page 3 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 450 SHEAR WAVE SCAN SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED CCW 100% 50% VESSEL CONFIGURATION AT THE FLANGE CW 100% 50% VESSEL CONFIGURATION AT THE FLANGE UP 100% 100%

DOWN 100% 100%

00, 60 in, 60 out, 120 out and 160 out LONGITUDINAL WAVE MANUAL SCANS FROM FLANGE FACE SCAN % WELD % VOLUME LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED ACHIEVED DOWN 100% 100%

The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical due to the vessel configuration at the flange and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 87.5 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: ONE RECORDABLE INDICATION ALLOWABLE PER ASME SECTION XI 1989, IWB-3510-1 Page 4 of 16

(f)

COITLET Loop 1 JNLET L-op 31ý OUTLET Loop, 3 INLET Loop 2 COUTLET Loop. a INLET Loop I 25, 14 .... 1I 265 335

27. KYVAM~

. . . 0-0". 90' MV:

z 0 F, U I ,L,*

-J

'#>RV-OS6

. .... 1"*,

RV~-05 890, t I::l*

I]

N 2,

,06:

A>ý 2E 21~

~i3 C/)

3419"'

H

'RV~O7 ,RVI-09 ýV46 C '3465 r"

1.:t 3151ý H C 45Y. .2a5~.' 0

'IN C,

C, RV-09 C.)

15.42' 1150- WELD' an;0 345C 0 270N014 RV RV 15 R 1t4 .1JI3, RV RV-17:

0 1051 165, SHEARON HARRIS -- CQL WVeslJyne Ihterno,,tiona, PW VesseL Roiout EXMH PRJOGRA"M ;PLAN 1;

A11V INNMISH [FT I OF 2,3

0 0

1~

cj~

0 Con 04 0D IV TO-VESSEL ý,, C.-,

z 0 VD z 0L

<7w 0/

4 Z u WELD . FTS'W-RV*-O SHEARIN HARRI.-5 COL FLGE T-S:HE.LL

.:,: LI-AMENTS EXAM PR]GRAM PLAN

____________________________________________________________________ I WlJ cý ALLDMONSNNI hI

.J11uth).h -fII~hwI

~RHET 4 OlF 23

Z 21 0

~z a.)

1~

Cl) 0 C.)

02 0-0ý Top: P&-r~atel z

uj 0 Bottom'r PardteL Cr'

[- Dotori Perp (40 0

WEILfl FTSW.-RV.-.12 P~r~aL co~ n~e .5 S*HEARI :HARRIS - COL PIrp,Sc~a:'n IndexO3 ()

parpat.e scans @bt

,,ror FLANGE TO SHELL TM O* and 19vs Octertoitltons to, Maximize coverageý. EXAM PROGRAM PLAN Md~mqmmm6TMSHEET 5 OF 23

ON ON 21 Cr' 0

0 Cu 40 0 0

to

0. Tp09 Prae DlTO 'Per~p &Bc~ttOrn Pmrao et Supp~eenntoi ý'-Scaqn 3ý650. ottor, Pdrdojete

'Bottom; Pe~rp WELD" - TS/-.RV-O1 Parlt~et Scarn InocI6x 05 'SHEARON .HARRIS - CQL P~erp,: Scian In~de~x_ 0, (0.5*),

We~~s:De !**enn -*; ianot Pirformr,-pdrdt[Oe,C~n's 2 both 60 ana led! sed rotoation *TMI FLANGE TO *SHELL

'to MaXlirZe CoVertdw EXAM PRPMRAM PLAN

'QDT&~ SýHLET eSn &JF 23-

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: FTHW-RV-18 ASME CATEGORY: B-A ASME CODE IWB-2500-5 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B1.40 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: HEAD TO FLANGE WELD % CRV ACHIEVED: 71.7 %

PROCEDURES: ISI-210-T MATERIAL CS/CS WDI-STD-146 WDI-STD-088 PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 450 and 600 SHEAR WAVE 11/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CIRCUMFERENTIAL 65% VESSEL HEAD CONFIGURATION AT THE SCAN FLANGE AXIAL SCAN 85% VESSEL HEAD CONFIGURATION AT THE FLANGE UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 71.7 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS Page 9 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REACTOR VESSEL TOP HEAD TO FLANGE WELD MATERIAL AND WELD IDENTIFICATION SHEET HEAD FLANGE WELD HEAD FLANGE SA-508 CLASS 2a SA-508 CLASS 2a Page 10 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FTHW-RV-18 SKETCH "A" S UpPLEIMEN7EAL U1LTRAS4ONIC.! SHIEET PACE 4jCEi~

-ke rcr, i-. A' A

.1 I,

A 13, c- r)O ~ -~ O

. 1771b EXAtAiNER,~~~ ~ IA~ V EL ~ DATE4 /z, Ic'~

Page. 11 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FTHW-RV-18 SKETCH "B"

SUP1'PL EMIEN1TALE U:LTqRASO)N I Ci SHIvEET "r

FT* t ./'- ,¢ :-,./- ,F*"*A;: tec*.

PAGE- COF d S ;-r E'T' . C" c. t'-', . .. 't* .Z t'r ÷. 4 ;,

I. .: : ?

EB 7-2 I li

-~ - .1-) 1-0

° :C.ABcL:'*) *" 7" ,1; ic 7 :..!o.

.EX,':'A , rviiNE&~- .*... * - LEVEL ,2r I:)ATrE 4 ,, --, b*

EX"A:I.INE R*-.* t,_*'*,y*::Z L.EV.EI:.L ... iD*ATfiC/£q ,'-_.-*Z-.'-

Page 12 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FTHW-RV-18 SKETCH "C" SAP PPLEN4ENTA. ULTRASONIC SHEET

' -ia* - .~V'- r- Q) BC

ý%,

7. EA 3FL PAGE

.,A1 AAE (A ::A k) C-A JOAr-

- 0:- f1 ý EXAM IrNER /, LEVEL I I ,z I Al .

'-.*./i";

Page 13 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FTHW-RV-18 SKETCH "D"

'g=.Tr"~~1EA UIPI-;E

..*:. 4ENTAL U-TRASONIC , S,4DNYC SH:EE'T EE/'.J8*

PAGE * ;OF L"L 4.as - 4 -:

ýz -5ý0'xý 47XkAt1: A&PUE-4A BAsa',L,Er'L S.E c-CA + Z)>p L3,H V') =vý w, D~s .ozAE? 4. u

B p1TAL

,5- = g 77:";Xt

. oF 'AiEA.ý 1'x A fyi I NE ~ f * ~ _ EV L ~ I)~E~

Page 14 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095

/

SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FTHW-RV-18 COVERAGE CALC.

S UPPLEM4ENTAL' ULTR.AS:OINIC )S EEEIT:

(EO F F 2.Z4/l ;e- I5. 4- - -4Rs rt= S

~~~~~~~i -- 4E ot.-// 2r.)q

- 2. H ~ "'.~:

L.5/4.t EXAlv11NER~,~.

EX'A lvii N ER~ - LEM F 2Z D ArE~ iz~i' /:~

A4

'-/

Page 15 of 16

Enclosure 4 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-020 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FTHW-RV-18 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

SUPPLEMENTAL ULTRASONIC SHEET F T 1-1LV - ft- -V - I Je, F A, 13,'C, -

PAGE 1':- OF .7:2

!c..0V R. A C-E '.-(/m 'y' csszx 0 (sk~rc,-rw)

X- A 1-7 L-T-,,t,14 9) 6:57 A i* C~E TC-M'L A3'!

6-rAS m1- A s c. o =', 7 ~5z.

7t~ I CO'/e -~f2. 63'-~-,.~. -7/ '

FX A M PNIR14F, LEVEL r DA-Lt~qjkAfi Page 16 of 16

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL .INFORMATION Examination Category B-D, Item B3.110, Pressurizer Nozzle-to-Vessel Welds RAI REQUEST RESPONSE la Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Welds are Pressurizer Nozzle to Head Welds.

Ia Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

Ia Interference/Obstruction (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 5.0). Nozzle to vessel welds are not conducive to two-sided volumetric examinations due to nozzle configurations.

lb NDE Equipment Information follows in Enclosure.

lb Alternative Methods (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 6.0). HNP is proposing to volumetrically UT examine the pressurizer nozzle welds NTHW-08/-09/-10/-i 1/-12/-13 to the maximum extent possible in accordance with the Inservice Inspection Program schedule. In addition, the welds are subject to visual (VT-2) tests during each refueling outage.

lc Wave Modality/ Insonification Information follows in Enclosure ("0' Longitudinal Angles Wave Scan", "45' and 600 Shear Wave 1/2 Vee Scan",).

Id Cross Sectional Coverage Plots to Information follows in Enclosure Attachments 1 describe the ASME Code coverage through 5.

le Results of the Examination No indications detected.

Indications / No Indications Page 1 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: NTHW-08 ASME CATEGORY: B-D ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B3.110 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: PRESSURIZER NOZZLE-TO- % CRV ACHIEVED: 66%

VESSEL WELD PROCEDURES: ISI-210-T MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 450 and 600 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED PARALLEL SCAN 79.6% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION AND THE PRESSURIZER HEATER OBSTRUCTIONS AXIAL SCAN 38.7% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION AND THE PRESSURIZER HEATER OBSTRUCTIONS The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the nozzle to shell configuration and the pressurizer heater obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 66 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH KBA 1.0", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 00, KBA 0.5" x 1.0", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" x 1.0",

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 2 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1 -021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PRESSURIZER SURGE NOZZLE TO HEAD WELD CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET PRESSURIZER SURGE PRESSURIZER HEAD NTHW-08 WELD Page 3 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: NTHW-09 ASME CATEGORY: B-D ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B3.110 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: PRESSURIZER NOZZLE-TO- % CRV ACHIEVED: 67.14 %

VESSEL WELD PROCEDURES: ISI-210-T MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 00 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 66.31% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 450 SHEAR WAVE 1/2VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.85% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 600 SHEAR WAVE 'AVEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.26% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the nozzle to shell configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 67.14 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH AEROTECH 1.0", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 0°, KBA 0.5" x 1.0", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" x 1.0",

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 4 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PRESSURIZER NOZZLE TO HEAD WELDS CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET

'LE PRESSURIZER HEAD NTHW-09 WELD Page 5 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: NTHW-10 ASME CATEGORY: B-D ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B3.110 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: PRESSURIZER NOZZLE-TO- % CRV ACHIEVED: 67.14 %

VESSEL WELD PROCEDURES: ISI-210-T MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 00 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 66.31% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 450 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.85% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 600 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.26% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the nozzle to shell configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 67.14 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH AEROTECH 1.0", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 00, KBA 0.5" x 1.0", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" x 1.0",

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 6 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1 -021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PRESSURIZER NOZZLE TO HEAD WELDS CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET (TYPICAL)

PRESSURIZER HEAD NTHW-10 WELD Page 7 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: NTHW-11 ASME CATEGORY: B-D ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B3.110 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: PRESSURIZER NOZZLE-TO- % CRV ACHIEVED: 67.14%

VESSEL WELD PROCEDURES: ISI-210-T MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 00 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 66.31% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 450 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.85% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 600 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.26% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the nozzle to shell configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 67.14 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH AEROTECH 1.0", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 00, KBA 0.5" x 1.0", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" x 1.0",

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 8 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R 1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PRESSURIZER NOZZLE TO HEAD WELDS CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET (TYPICAL)

PRESSURIZER HEAD NTHW-1 1 WELD Page 9 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: NTHW-12 ASME CATEGORY: B-D ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B3.110 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: PRESSURIZER NOZZLE-TO- % CRV ACHIEVED: 67.14%

VESSEL WELD PROCEDURES: ISI-210-T MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 00 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 66.31% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 450 SHEAR WAVE '1/2VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.85% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 600 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION SCAN_ ACHIEVED 67.26% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the nozzle to shell configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 67.14 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH AEROTECH 1.0", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 00, KBA 0.5" x 1.0", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" x 1.0",

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 10 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PRESSURIZER NOZZLE TO HEAD WELDS CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET (TYPICAL)

PRESSURIZER HEAD NTHW-12 WELD Page 11 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: NTHW-13 ASME CATEGORY: B-D ASME CODE IWB-2500-8 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B3.110 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: PRESSURIZER NOZZLE-TO- % CRV ACHIEVED: 67.14 %

VESSEL WELD PROCEDURES: ISI-210-T MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: YES 00 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 66.31% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 450 SHEAR WAVE A VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.85% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION 600 SHEAR WAVE 'AVEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 67.26% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the nozzle to shell configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 67.14 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH AEROTECH 1.0", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 00, KBA 0.5" x 1.0", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" x 1.0",

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 12 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PRESSURIZER NOZZLE TO HEAD WELDS CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET (TYPICAL)

PRESSURIZER HEAD NTHW-13 WELD Page 13 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENTS:

A. Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW-08 B. Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW-09 C. Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW- 10 D. Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW- II E. Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW- 12 F. Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW- 13 Page 14 of 14

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR IOWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT A Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW-08 (4 Pages)

iJ~ ~ OT-G~d-f.kfl ISUPPLEMENTAL-ULTRASONIC SHEET PAGE4OF 7

"/J :.*0.

... . .. * .. . . j f 6"

IV

~'1

- /~ S/A~

[~. ~ -.11, C (bS~

zt'

SUPPLE MENTAL ULTRASONTIC SHEET

P AG E : F. .OF ....

7 ...

x 7!

/ '~ ~7 LQý4/E> 6riet (w5r-4y

~~;2 q OILP~H)I( 'fh ~

S.2-I ;-0' Y To ý7,

Tk~J4 Steer~ zlar-%Jv-,o/

SUPPLEMENTAL ULTRASONIC SHEET PA'GE, liOF m,

'-j' f'3' e-as (p :.._, s g Pt)

e. . 4. ...

.A

$~3Z 13.4 T7A .......

Bc3 ....

0. A,/* Z

SUPPLEMENTAL ULTRASONIC SHEET PAGEOF

-7 AfrMk) ~

P o,;erc.:L-7-,:

0 0 - ~peI'c.A. ~'p~ -7, pa - 7 9~6 c, I WX'trt~S 5M 3:3%~.

~ /

17l 5Y 2-

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT B Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW-09 (10 Pages)

£41$4~/1i ~LQ~~zQ4 ui w

K AA' /i 53-7~T

~

6

/

-2.

fJih~-~

a6cD~

co~-f-~

/,

/.

/

-- ~jJ _________________ 4" B 9 3.7*i -. 'el /.'

~ 3~fl 3)- 301

~XafrHA3L Aevi~cA t~/EL 44

COVERAGE'CA, -~-- w Kf1 AnSTfIGTE1 TOTAL, want rEUXAMAW4FI LAWM~ EAMNW WL LEotlGTw sECitiO 1CROSS SECTION SECTIOW (CROSSSECblO WECi O L4T- OEAE TTLOEA L"MIH RETICF MCMU Liit m EXANU4ED A$#'S, !AkEA EXAMINEU RSSTRCTEO

~ rlt~a~E~ ~CTEC%L.. ~JNRB~fRCTEO% ~4c$S~ ~f $0.HZi~ts COVERAGE %,

AREA EXAMINHED (SOuINCl4ES3

)

UN4REMMfeO VRG L CS Srn (LLNTHX","CCROSS (ESTRICTED,.

E~Ou r~

AGE_ ______ __ _______ Is51M

-~

CA IS ItI .,S:

of f-1S24z ~4 w AYPho)A q'ý5C-A-O t4J~L~D~ NTMLAJ-Q~

I."o

~6$i~41~2LEA/7WRY

!!I*/ ./

7 ej6#4 2, W Y ' k6q 2.

N &pA7M A6

-J

$36" 3$~" &:z'~

1 _________________________________________________________________

121

~*~5fl

~X,~P/AIL&~ FLi ~L~47~(3o(9?

AevicweP ____________

O4f~* '~~-3 9?

f5& jk~ZAJ cri t~~LD- ,T~Ow~

w- ~0

%SCý(7ýWmQ L Z;-

4-6VecC~

Ii * * * * *_ * *

i ¢ * * *i*I mI** *

32, 13 3.1*

a AMRA 0

ci

'ri Lu I NOZ~ZL ý10

~11R C Hý AO1c ~jjA6 Si~t04,, q?,eq~ 1,6I.o7 #

5

.A~ZZL~wLflR~1,/607 SQT'

/77

Igo~ 74Fý 3j* 3,I6~ 'p Z-1Y 476?aIs~

D SAO== VgJA 76 ,oL__&

~Ov~RAG~ CALy~. ~

~t~#

7~Siir*1 f/o-9S--o/

4. r WELDR4ON114w4* DECflEE

1. DEGREE

4. * :

riIP.L RESTRICT70 'TOTAL-TOTAL. WELOILENGTH qeslpIclo ITOTAL CROSS~ UNRESTFICTED 'TOTAL CROSS. DUVERAC;E. UNrnES WILTED WELD' EXAI.J!EM LENGTH4 EXAM4NED, N!ELVILUMR~ 5EC'flON :ROSS SECTIONISEC11014 CRODS5CIONhSECUMN LENG71Ax COVERAGE OTAL COVErAGE.

LW4GTH RESTRICTED EXAMINEDi UNREST"PmTE ZPEA {SQ. AEAEXANED

. !RESTCT AIRCAEXAM.INED:UNRESTRICTED 0I1Oss (LENaTHX CROSS IESTRICTED.

LtSTh1(;TW TR* UNRESTRICTE014 ~so NHS 'COVR % SWOIRFIl .0RAC

-. 4.

JKSFSTI4ICTED1 %-

Uh1WARD HEAD1BASE 2~E~%I MATPIAL AXIAL "o00 0 0., 2449%

_ ... ...* 4- . .... .+_

Z,S 3214S

-X4ALCOVý AGE__ 124 0001 12,5 M

__ALE bASE AtWERIAL AXIAL' CCLYERACE 00 00 00% 5734%f Iuw RD 10 zz LE 0.00% C00%. I 0002~

______ -"-"-4 -

il ...........

COVEHAGE _____ -.- 4 + .......... ... :*1%.9 0 0,o ,002..

SIDECMO

ýI~EA0I .10.0

..... I r,77 1W00% 0 0.44 OOYERAOE E CIAr-WELD

+ . 4 S0.0 10005%

102001iooooi 40005 om00% ___ :1000 0" 1667? 0 1A,1 4J 0n I 20o ci:

0 5474 1,477 10.i P' fl 000%

WFL1WELD 4UE6

-+ ÷ cL t~aa 14 ts~o jJAT~

e,4 ýaX5-6?

5Ji~e wu ý6OI 4 o I aXrf 12 9($Q~17

~Ae,7~RWP

/*~~~?'~ 7Yr? L,

- l Ri5S7,-e tc -IeO L0.,

"IN /

JsL2~~~ 45~'A~46*b ~~AVe

&Z 3/5)1 a'j5.f't

-C-poý7 e

~~A14 ~gjg~~ Zio ~ CL I .LL.aF '&

S& S~*-RzJ?-I 6O&c~W ~7~WA~O ~AJVZ2L~

F~ofri tIC ~OW6 7,"L~P6&~~q~s

~6g7~Ic7~7~ 1~6AJ6i7US 7.6$J'-' B 6tWP1 LAV Lx

CJ~A4X ~~-v*

2 Sc~' vsV~,{o2{

3,1*"

~y)

C4L s 4,4AIjý

LPU~ ~ 1 K~ ZIo-98-~

C.

(;j&~~( *s ___________

I Th)ZZ66~O A)rj4o-~/

'I

~,UzzL~so~A~ia:~7q', 5'qA~4-H*AO ~ThC c~1P~p flCA;i 6~L bF 75 Q, t 0~'

4 -

71 ACs-er6 La I,61 q i!/

f~ (77~

4~424~ 2dqe/7~Tk

/.... PC~~~

LceM M64 4

... 15i: 3.1*7/ it5q 3.1*

V

/0W

~~XA"2i~~~J4 ~w~ ~447ýO~

C0VEHAOE C~ --)N'Sl-EET

.7~~4r~i~ '-q 4r -'

WELD 140.l4W4IW-ft ]

iODERE

... I I,*

iII "

TOTAL: TOTAL WELDL&4ww: WVW LElGTI4 GROSS RESTRICTED TOTALCROSS3 di~StRiCTibDiOTALCOS UNRESTRICTED NEL6 LENGTH' EkAM1NED fffEL0LENGTh SECVGO DROSS SECTION SECTIONW CRlOSS.

SECniON SgDC91ON ',lEt!ITH X ~OV~IAGETOTALCOVERAGE.

R~ESTRICTED: EXAWNE4FD U.NRLSTRICTEW EUUWNIýG ARlEAEXAMIINEDRESTRICTED AREAEYXA)I9rEC UNRESTRICTD DROS (LENGTh II CROSS,(RESTRSCTED LENGTHE

%-W FIESTRIC'rED INUIES) COVEWAGE% SECTION)% U~ETIT0 405 ~-~2~~

4 +

TOWAADH EA SAS I.4TiRIAL. XIAI. I&629%

.4 + I TOWARD HEAD WELOD AYUAL COVERAGE Q :.:oI 3-214, 1~ I ~

+/- . . I*. -

66* 152ý ......

I

........i ýo m21G%

BASE MATERIAL AXIAL

,.6:

12 -I . ~l1.43S

-'-I . 4 60mCO

+ . I . .,

WELD AMiL.

.1. t 0*IH"B J .1rntIw,~ 0 W42

~*1~ I-kSAfr 5105CtSc MUEFLAGE WELD,

'40= .1oo0ool 1.07 _ __ _ __ o o&~ , A 04W o . . .,.. . . . I... . .. ... . .. . .

COVERAGE. .... i RAEMATERIAL', 40055 1, 14 m00 0, 1m 41 .t !.

fmz2LE SIDE ClfIC COERAG~WL A I_____- CUD____,

°,! '0~04W H* I

COVERAGE,

n.* -5.1&% 0 RAIw ¶0 15%

-it-TOTAL WELD VOLUMF COVERAGE

.4.~ ~~~~ ~ ~ ~..~~........ ~~ _ _ __ 1 __ _ __ _ _1__ _ _ _

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT C Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW- 10 (10 Pages)

D

O wj ll/ L 5 L.tr 33

/ A,6 6 t

/

N/

9 4-.-&

- :1 Aevtwf

]VJ/6L -'3of L

COVOIAGE CAlLCI BNE 4-S& ,-isx-Rta~ -j t~T~W TOTAL TO TAL WELOE?41ll WEWLDN~ Rf*RCTEE AEOI TOTAL CROSS UNRESTRICIEL OirtACRn-Is MVEWRAP UNRESTEICTEDO WEitto EXAV#JED LEM&GIm E(AMWPE WFIV Lt:6GTH SEdflOt4 CR4OSSSECTIO SECTION4 CROSS SRCTIN SECTION (LENG~hX COVERAGC' TOTAL COVERA 'GE.

LNTH

ýS4NEcti RESTF0GTEb 1flNCI4Eu EXALM16) URESTMCTE nEsTRICTED%_ (11CHIM EMRINED AIREA(OW.

UNHREBYRICtE% N AREAE)CAMINE rESTRICTED AREA EXAiNIONPERSTRIVýD ~CROSS - (EGh~COSR$~CE (SO INIES) COVERAGE % (SatNCHES 1CcVEAGE%__ SECTIG!R% ETOI)¶ iRETiT4

. .D.D...

RAE~LX4

________________~~~~~~o'-

____________{,,,E

____ ~________ _____

0____________________00W__________

cT".~ cflL 11~IGi~c; ~I 2 ~

V c~YF linsOS

flV45Ii6T t

,,AnKK6 dj q*~cP~U-f14P4 4eAA Ai. t 4/7eiq 3,2VSZ4A 1404F4,0ý404

- ~ ~ S7 A,*V R~4 1IL~z&T~;Ic7~Y wc'_4d $

I .if/

1 * /*

~33*~ 3~Z 31*'

'1 I, 3)/Sq

/Z:~Y6~

~~XA'~' IAJL~ ____________/-

6d6ivj47 3/4 /

~ -A~-V

I t Cb~6at~c~cJ~c~ COz L LU

~~%Pf -P,/-t2Z 6X(~

p0frJt Re'Sk147~t3 L~N~fT/is~q2 dvg~

4 IZ

~* ~ ~ k v 'saZP?

IS, Y9

[62 ~$X~~~S7~7& ~51~~~WRYV 00~ AMJ4OZ2licoI Ii I, 3j<6 115.,!

31*

6,zXAMiAJ 40-a/-

i~L ItS _____

U JOZZL6 SJO6 CTh~ C HCA~ ~ro~ cfgc we AWZ~.'~ oAW4 :1.,6071, zý

/ wk2V A4C4

/

/ 44A 5A IS- ~/,06%(pL

/

3,jgJ 3.15 31*

D~T RftIJ1?F~______'IV_

~~A4S~EE~

pq~ vs

-~ -t-~?-t~-

IWELD NO-W#U)4f-to 1U5DEGREE.I OlESTAIC1T# TIOTAL-TOTAL. KLDLmoir1. WELDL4~.. GROSO REISYFCTED0 TOTAL CPOQS-ý "NESTRICTED UNRESTRICTED, WELD~XAMNED LENGTR E"I"lED , WELDLENGER SEcTion CROSS SECTION SECrION CROSS SECTIO6N OOD'RAjGE TOTALWCOERA46 LEN4GTH RfESTRICTED 16AiNw4E I[NRESr!UCTEDp EXA]VINEO AREA (gq hREA EAEE AESTFICTED A--uvntrI tA ARE.AEXMINE S VECTION fRT4jNGTH % (IIENGTH ~CROSS (REmTrICEnD I UNRIUTAIcMEi

~=' 4~- -M-~-1-4-- - ___ "VIFRAGLi 1SECTIONJ% ss"Ot I

- - - - - - . I, GEETRICTDon _______________ I 4----- -

TOARDHE*ADBASE

47j12l' 100,00% l20: Ila .2484% *0 24:M0 24S4.

r, -

411 AALCOVERAGE: moon 12.51%

T ARODN0maE, F-%MATEPVAL CýOERABAE AMAL e471,2 47T,4 00%

I_____

-i___

A7 11.070

.10060%

000%

01 3,214 0

-t . -I . I- -

4. 4 hE'A:DZSID CIR0 HIEADSIE CIRC

47.I~ 100,06% 1.8Am

I '4' 1-E07~

-~

I 'A' SASERATERIAL 47,12 0.00% 47,1~ 0 AJ Ir~ ~ 0 f74 6.222

- ..--.--- ~ -------4 (o ar%

0.00% 47A.? 1_G07 0 000%e, lootus 000% 10001%

CGVERAIE -.EL rBaSzSATERIALP K 47,12 , . 1w 1~QQ% t _____ 0.00% R~?4 1.1771 a 0 tVA~ 11118-A 6001YX 1081e%

I ni ook TOTALWELLVOWUME]

COVERAGE 1'___ _____I_____ _____ _____ ____ _____ _____ _____ ______ _____4.85% V

~-~s--~ ~

11f1Q*~

AA<Aswi~~ -Io -4, Lu I V6W~fgIO IA 6eiAJR 74,/

06jZ PI ~ 7&~4 7~~& AI'eh

'I 16~~

iýPl 5 UN CL~ Ao- 4104

.4$.'iuk4 1~~

2, 3.1* 'I 7~io8-51 P4~~eA/a& g~A -, ,ýe. 7--/Oi j

&600, A~v~wCI LlV*q IttqA,

~A~Yf6~T; Zici9o ej PA- V~w/

O~*cv~~ 7LLA~ ,UO2AL~

w q27, 0*

lliq6:ý7-o- AL eII-e41.r. 'OW05aT1AJ

/ 4 2 ~~ 4~J 6S1~(c/6L~ g~$e1t~AiJRV

~ ~At6~JALL0~Y z/qsivj~~~ ~~/0 clih~m f~e/

WOO)AbPcZL alI 3,/s q.

£t~tLi~A47~ 4

S eA ~I~ C)- ~o.Z

/uThw.~-iv (00 CI/~c~ SCAN II Lu I pJOZ~ZtJ~

cIi~ C s1o~~ IVRY42Z

~~~~4ýrc0!OE~

CLQ4 d t~/" I /

amey RRqA',

I7 /2% a1e?

49,

/uOZZL

$',96

//*4~4 4 fl fl 31* 'I

~A~rn

~~3~44

~16U6~7~iL~Ar pq/r)jA)C~ 5Ig&~&

/2a~d~ A~~q ý- - 4 .,.,ý, , r

~XaJ5k~

I~'-

AeviwsA /~L~~Z~ ~ f'M

C~V~%~J3E CC~ .~M SHEIT

~7 Th~w 4 $vW~ ~Z4O-~- t~7~-

J YEW NQ*~m4W-0 .60 DEGREEI cA R ~ C TTL

[TOTAL: VVELLENOT1:WI LENGTH. OfOS 1STmet!O *T1TALC4S ON1=AG LECTIO LEGTECTI,- SECTION WELDIO :CMOYsCr00t C CXAMINE (LENGTH X EXAM2EOEAMED UREShI~t 'AEA 50 AEAEXMIEDRE~hC~DCROSS SEX MINOWSNESRCTED1 CO COVERAG OA COVERAGE t.QK RESTRICTED. x ~I, a I N Z51ES I jU:RED

[AINM- tICEA 5:

AO AES}XhNDRS M ý RAEXhJsowpSRCm 0 (LENGaTH X &ROSS (REStTRCE1D.+

__________ [m 0E$TI0Ht ______ _________TE % IS0NCHES)

___ COVERACE%

cov INCSJ QOVERAGF W CIN ~ SCIN% URSRCEJ MOATER!ALAXIAL

~~..PG.71

. . 4...

1 100%0Ef1 250 100 4O00%, 14.62 C0% 1442%

TUOWARP HEAD WELD

~AACGVERAC6 41 71 ___1C0%000% 31 AS 151 ____ 0.00% I.I .0%. 1 1 RASI- MATERPLAL AIAA1 __ _

0tAE47A2 47.12 100-00% ____I28%E on 0,00% 90.08

~~GD ,00~71 0.0~ 24__ ___00%21 OI%

100-0_____ 0.01 .001M% 1004m0

___ otal____ .0 .ý 100%

mo-n~W7. .Om 000% , 100

. .000% 4 .2 1 0 ),0 % 1 6 0 7i VE ______ _____

.4.2 4712A~IA 712lo 0 % 56474 :0IT __ "0____ _______ __________ ___ ,___0% _____loom% _____

_ __ZL _10 _ _ _ _

0 1IIl9*.B

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT D Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW- 11 (10 Pages)

d O/is _ Z

-r-) 7'c~

.1 a 4 - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __/

LU 1

/

4.

-J p

F B

3.2f tS 3./* '315!,

ii

~

31t*

~~XaJ~~ L=61t=OzJ~9 ~

COVERAGE CAU rUN§H-EET P's 1

TOTAL jWELD W~EOhWIOL~~l~CROSS AM&D iLENGTH, CXA,.MIED' WELDLENGTH, SMT*N IRESTRICTED TO`TA L CROSS GCOSS SECTION SECTION iiNRESTRITEDý ~T9T#LCROS CROS$ SECTION SECTION.

1 OV!R,69 Iu4RESTRICTED!

(LENGTH) 0 DCVER~A(E TOTAL COVEAlAGE ILENGTH RESTRICTED EXAM14NED 1UNRESTRJCME XAIE AREA jAREA EXAMINED RESIRICTED IO. AREA EAA41NEE W1RESTRICTEI) CROSS (.ENCT14 X CR1OSS(RESTRICTED 4 jfIC~iES) £ICEL RESTR (IN04ESI, ýNREsTROE IGEcrSECmS~CV % %n~ (SO INCNESS CoYeAAoi SECnOoN % UNRE8TRIClE0OI%

BASE HADSIDE5 JCDVERAGE 4t1,T 12j (Io10%.I91 aim% ~ .1 _____ ~omoI5 DES 6 ~ ~

j~A~Jk- CPt..~ ciii U- t~-~

1L414 L~-~ .03 d Pf~A6 LU q*0~cM1-~AR L IV#AA V 0741' 1.5~~~~~~

4 ~,j~ Atex~~7 O~s 6Ao)

'59r4@c~ cA' 2 ',,'Re,

-Ae 4tJzRL:Sfp4c7ZO

/

3~i*aA 5a~~rt~rc ~ WAYV I.

$3*~ ~ 3.Z~

II alt"sit, .3,6"l

~X~1mIAJC~K1LZhLJh /3 o/-YP I:~-7A~

,Zevicw~

Z~ ~q5

~2Oc Z.C.

'wn ~s _____________

6 (CFCk~6AJcC~ 11212'!

6xrr ~K6' %ZAIAJ 1~UJ/$~O ~AJo7~Zt~

I -

W%7WiicfCO L6IJ-774, 1".q2, 2£,ZIz1A WL:-6 EQ'V IA .69*~7~7'16 eWr~4,- aV I s y

,,1

/1~~~~~~~~ie27z 6~:~jPctQ~~f/~~~4.w

~6'~ 3.2: 3.15" j

/d4-4t3~

C

&. 0F ~3 33%

fs&, AJflIw- I*I w

K M'LZLG ~0LO CIFCQAC6673 1 XrA 00v..11ESIARC,~ 621q.q5 dA&e fA7.1L"/V P4-A~S~ c FCA~IA~(L ~ /A~7jetA

/

/ -77SQ R~

a )v6~

W:h)A'0VV .190

/1'%C~t&-'Ae7 U~T*e Al '\ 'I II j

4 Ii

~3*" ~

3.2) 34/5 3 3;I~

~/~~ij7A-i T7If~

.d ml*!

,Q4V/Cw6.f~ \~4~-~ ~ ~1fteL~Z

G SyRAIE GALI. J SHEET.

'0 Tý: 7-ck-q(a -

WELD utO:.*4'THW.1t iS DECGEE

..... ,; ,/,,,i FRES.TRPCTED!TOTAL.

TOTAL IYELDLENGTH WELDLEN=11 UNRESIRliCED TOTAL CRO!.S. UNRESTRICTE IVEAGK WELD EXkAMINiW4 dEJGTH. EXCAMINED sem00 WELD LENOIW- -ROSS SECTION CROSSs*cnON SECTION (LENGTH X COVERAGE TOTALCDVEIIAG.8 LEMMTH WSET1I4CTE INCHES)

EXAMIED:

IESRýCrw -A JNRESTRICTE .0 174KESk EXAUMNUD AREA (W,. kREA EXAMINED REST=lICEn AREAEXAMINEDUNIPTRIIICTED CsISS mcRoss kLE *RSTRICTED L %

USSlSTRICTED%

8-

,, 4 fWAR IADkiVAS MATERIAL AxiAL .4MN _ _ ........

~OVERA0E4712 okoo* 0ý00%

TOWARD EAD WELD

.47M 0.00% 12,51% 0.00% 12-51%

TOWIARDNOZZ -E 100.00%

6ASE MATEUAL AXIAL CVERAGE 47112 IC 12.0I S7.2~% 0 8100% 000%

07-24A 7,24%

I7~C6__

TOWARD NOUZ2II WELV AXIAýL COVFERAGE .0.OOOL , 0.00% :2VA I- ~ 2 -, . 1--*--- l~Jlool

... . ______ 4 4 + 1 4712, 1

ii.ADE 1,E CIVIC 00014 47[i04 10100% 1.907 t.807 0 o 00% AT 1 . . . ... .. 4.222 6 22~ 10004 14 SlE CIRC S42~

O 00% :47.12[. 100,0091 1.807 1801 WleD SIEPAE CQVERA.E, MkSE$4ATE7IIAL _ 10000% 0I.60 8 1177 00% 0.0014 . 11428%

I ~-. .1- k4'74 roTL WELD YOWMC CVE _ _ _ _ _I__ _ _ . _ _ _ _I__ _ _ _.._ _ _ __ _ _ . ~ IL8

( Rison 510000mvzPoI LU

,tc~o

/* S45, 0 0 7$7v~h WkV AeWR 1~~

/0;ys ew SO IAevfQALt~VP N i/

N

'I

ý.X? 31*' :3.t*" 2~I5

~X~7iAJ~cuJ~9~ *&h- /CSE7~//o m l/

i3AIA $ll~~76T ~ Zio

- ~5~ -

w -~

J 2,97~(A AV~~I 1z6q:

~44L~R~T~~1 wk0M!

I6 ' LL) ~ys~A 7-~

Aev/ý5u.

6.k z6S~!tVELAS,4,L dA*r9,6L WKV

/jgl; S:NECJ Z-o- *-

JC k poLZ.Gz o A~C 1 C~IS Clr~z

,jqMLs SIOe ,'tvý ARCA43 I/7 .Z ,/C:L 2 flCAZe 40/qýeN 5,Q&

/

/ 1-77 W,-v A/NA el4rkA 7QP

/ 'S &,0170COM~7E

/ I5f~ C'~44JA~AAC%

3J*. Ii

-Wo :3SI!! ...... :,if: ........#?

Dr<,,

..X a,.:. Pi , i. i

.X, _ . ,.;, .z

CQVKRAGOEC, Air ýýý

?~c4 VS c~c~i~

'WELD; gn-HTwmE4 !

I¸

'LOAL 'WELDLE-Nalw WELDlENGTm, CROSS RESGTMGTED: TOTALL DROSS T*

CMAj GROSS COVERAGE!

TOTAL, UU4RSTRCTEG

ýAEMRc fE0 EXAMMED EX(AmitnE U:NPESTRiCTED WEL 0IVTH,ý SEOtioN1 EXAMINED PREA (S%.

GJIOS SECTIO SECTICN AREA EJXAMINEDRESTRICTEO uECVRAO

" . ;(ENCTD X COVERAGt iLVEUCTH ITOTAL COVERtAGE XGROSSl(RESTRICTED.

r1CNS___ INESTR)CTEOD

% GikESr Isa HE co sERfALGE

% SEGTION~ 1ISR0E~

VERAGE % Is t.,-MN) %

II .....

MAT!MAL AXIAL DOOR 145 t on~ - i4~

tcOiRA COER GE f L o 00%

eAS MAITfOA L AXiAL VOERMSE 4? oct TOW1ARHDý NOZZ LE

~WýL AXAL 5 14

47,12 __ 10000% 1O~D0% lc-a

ýtVEAO r4 Ca 1i I

4712 COVERGE WLD _47J2 .47A2 m000 150 Ol____

qrtAD SIDE CR 3271

0 ~~0.00% 17 EW cOVEJADEWELD 470V

(-.O.IF-.--

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT E Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW-12 (10 Pages)

S/16ro2 i3A1'

.0 '

0AT mk'1-L4r NOIy~-IOT

7/,0.:

&S ,.+/-LýLi-

Cr I S.- VT7'TJ

~4 c~

I I.-.

A

/ ý6.e 4:,.

N /

/

N/ *s B 9

/

3.1*" U 3,3F AeA) L-`g -~ £6vgL~A47~ 4~2~Z~~J'

~Ve L ~

COVERAGE CA ;ONSHEET TTAL -WElDLUEN47M WELD LENGTH ls RESTRICTED fTOTAL CROSS UNfESTRIFTM, T0TA'LCt1OSSl COVERAGE* uNESTR=CTE EXANO LNTK EXAMI NE L6W:~ E C 6RON S SECTION SECTiON CROASSSECT"OSECTION- (LENOaTh, X' COVERAQ E . OTACOVERlAGE lmENGTK RESTRICTED EXAMWPNED UNEt RITE EXAU NE ARVASO AAEXR U KE MWtM ESTRICIE AftfA EXJaMINED UNRESTRICTED CROSS (LENGrh X cRS (RI!STMCTED.

-IC~ ---------- R!ESTICTE]D % YNCIIES1) UNRESTRICTED IWEHESL ISO. 040*125 COVERAGE% (SO; INCNS); COVMAGS % SETO)~ sEC1oNyiý IINMSThCTED) %

COVERAGE, ,_____ 71O 47112 'ý05$ E&21 .0O0E 8.1%

c LAM-11112MI

1 -

'A -;6 f4'~LZ~PZ~A~ ~,

Lul t4J~O~ AmhL9 -12 NeAI' spo - 4 1 ly~

N

/ : 'Q2 s c*.VO :*

2.,/s ,,f 2., , . .

f * , c1,',

,:............7.....

E

Ae$7V 6A,,

z *, *,

I

\/

a 3,15 3J.~~~~- T~~~~4

6U6L7~L. ~47~ig~L~

c~3~

AevCw416 L .

zL 0.- H~p Zis/ i:LO~PzRi Ad0-

~ I wfib

/ / 7 / / r-wiL wRv 4 Sap 77 0,4

__)'1 4MM_ 5 ý ....

Z,9e ci LV0cpkcZ cA&

LU I pCZ.ltk,&

A 47qL MA6 ~Xc~C~I~ AVU-gJc-fJ toabTA~d 167}Z ý4/

I

/ ýQ 77 c 7-~z~ ?7kA

/

/ IleR V5 /6oj cl3,o4~

II*¸¸ i*i"¸¸ aa-

.j ;qA 7AV/6-~

8,flM --- 4e~L i4T L.

oe ,

COV*/GE.GA *4 HSIE1

?cjc.f i~

WELD NO,:NTHW-I2 146O M.

RETOTAL O~TT WELD LENGTH WrLD LENGtw 17OTALCPOSS RES1C¶E' TOTAL CROSS, COVERAOEUI ET!OE WELD 9XA"WED LENGTH. EXAWNED WELD L~ENGTH, SECTION4 CROSS F, GQ10fN ISEUCTIO GýISS.SECTON SECTION', X GLTR iCOVERAGE tOTAL 0,0VE RAGE.

LMTHO RESTFUCTED EXAMINED UNRIESTAICTO AREA(SO. ýRESTBICTED IkItEk EAMIN9D UNPIRE-STRIGTEO%- ts iCHES1 ýCOIVERAGE% aOAINCH29 sCmoSSxaqs COVERAGE%: LJNRESTMCTE0D 14 I.-*~ .4 -4 4- 1-.

4 4 + ... .

TOWARD HEA" BASS . ... ....

24I4 wATERiuiL AXIAL 4.12A '4712 10000% 0.0011 al1 I't'.8 :24E

________ ~ U04,_ _ _ __ ~ 0.00%

I.XAL COVERAO E .47.12 47-2 160000' 0 QM0% a214 1251% 0 '000%

TOWARID NOZZLE "::!

]

C2AVERAGEILAGI

.1, 012 A? ~A.E.

, 12 11 11741 0.00% 8724 0.00%

ýeffi 11074 stv reWARD NOZZLE 4712j 4ELD AXIAL

-47.12 0.00% ¶0000 ~~1 214 3214 Almon00 0.0011. 10000% I~00%

4. 4- -l I 4 4

".. . . . . I' - '4-.. . . . " *. . . , -- I~. .4 1 4EADSU IPEC11 47.A- 0o C100% 100A.M .0 tM 10000% - I 100~00~~

COV4E14A0E V.22 Qt0%

.47,12 BASEMATERIAI 4712, .0 a .oft I1w W00%

4. - 001. ....

.0. 1001M 46ZZLE SIDF CMCRO 'tool I AM0 4712 11 11 rOVERAf2vwFln ' I- ~ ____________ . I J

IOZSIDECIAO

DOVERAG9, BASEMATEI4IAL, 412 1000% a OE~j 647j1+I .. 0 18,18%

~.. W L ...... .... E...- 1"... - -L1 ---- .I I eZPu WSW938

(j NThYv-/Z tLJ 604 6i 6, T 7'~ W~V Ale6

~ 72*~PXA)~

4 O '*L jS1 tW p6 N 6~Se~,s1,v~/~L. 4~ V ~

N /

,~CpIC'~ 4 ~

/

3~U

\ I.

~

3J*.

I.

.315t~

3I6 i I:*i:'* 13Ar fl Als £t~/*LJLLJ~0~ -h--

~-.

-L..q.v

',ý-,CsAJV Arq U'

2i'(4i.1, 7&-of q

~ ~6~;7g;L B$~TqhAA ' ~2 2.

~4W~ gir&rPic7 CAS I W-P\V 100%~~I~L~

/~f~jY;Th/0L A-ol A U

A), ~L~&A -zr6Z or-o~Zq Z5________LAv i/JiA6,"YA-AeV2F-wcA

e4 !(-t(ýfx ALOoil~

c$

is o (0

w K tjOZ L06SzOz IMP SIR 0 W4AOSI C,AAeIý' ~22:7 s 7 A

/I~AO $ThC clp.:c:- N V -Z Z S 5I&eIA 6Rq 7 q 5q:CiTJ1

1) S-" fA7P)AL LR ICAI.,kif-'; IXa7 1/~AL~A40 j Aw2W I~~QL~AA2&1 4'7 I

[71V

ý6 N 1~

_CFA-17d: A ,/q

/ CA ~~c~-

iL/

I 1/

'3A #I I ,!!5' 31g W.CdgA

CAO~C~ SHEET vs

~i$tiA 1--r&~ -T'z.~ -1 2~A$ch~'~

0 -qe~-~ a a

ýWELDMMW WL IpE .RE

. I!

TOTAL TOTAL NEI.DLENGTH roTXL CROSS UNRESTPICTMD TOTAL.CROS COV"EAG UNRESTFRCTED WVýlD EXAMI4NED' WWWh :OXArMUpoW ffeOL&WLNOi SECflOH CROSS SECTON: CR655 iýSECITIN SEC"l~ (LENý X COVFERAGt.

LENQTh TICE

.. E kINSI RESTICTD ,

WRESTR4CTED M"WgfINE ARLA (SO. ArEFALEXAMINEbRESTRICTED' i IlctESI ARZA FXMMED Ut4RESmTMTP, CROSSI ~LN~CIROSS TOTALIOVERAGE (RESMTRICTEI WfglnwTICTU (so. :;OVERAGE%. SC. 4C 2OVMRGrPkL,,%

UNRESTVdMol

-..L ..... _____________ I 4 - ____________

MATERMAL AXMAL 4

DOPVERAGE. 47J21- ,'..4_.

7 . 100f41% 14M5% !0 ODD% .W4Omm's TO6WRD HE*ADWEL

.XIAL COYIE:SAAO 47,4 47:121 000% ý3214 :0,489 15,21*

. 1+0++ 15 2 VY sASE MATZRIL. AXLA 4.

471 :0 'C 00%j 12.054. ..11.4Z49~ 0000% 9om 00.08%

-- 4.

TOWAR 0 N6ZZLE 47.12 47.12 2.21 4

-- 4 . -4 .

- 4 1 .1. 4. . 4.

]COV*ERA.GE.

C*VERAQE WILLA) .0 .0 1.407a :0.00% o004%

iHEAD SIDE CMCC 47.12 47.12 0.00% S 22 0,00%

0o .&M W%.0

" - - _____... .. +- ... .. "+

COVERAGE WE*L*D 4 7.12 47.12 07 W1. '1 4...

oa 00.

NOZZYSIDECIRO BA¢S4AATER4A NOZ:ZLESIDE C4RC COVEI4A09 47-12 47,12 10D COI 0.00% 1~ 111%

0 L - -OTýo 6.474 .1"8 .1&IS%4.

+ I- * -... 4,,-.

4- ________ 4 4.-.

-+ 4. - ... *- ... . 4, . . .+ " "

TOTALvweIDVoLUME

.1. _____....I. ~. __________ 4 617.26%

4. _______ . . _________ . ________

I-at'i7k.4 1/1

Enclosure 5 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-021 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ATTACHMENT F Supplemental Ultrasonic Sheets NTHW-13 (10 Pages)

vjleý-3 err-cS 6414/ob OJCMfLhI- 5-T YV zri w- !I

'p I 1' ~

~1.

N /

/

'~36~ 3,; 3./S" 3~ jg1' .... :jI 31*

L6WZ4,4E~

,,OVERAC9 CALL.; tONI!KLET TO7 WW)OLEN(ITH I j ~ TTCTSO TOTAL WELD LENGTH, mCoSs' n"WTRI TOTALCROSS fLNESRTh~ED ITOTAteRoss WELD D B~~ EXAMINEW, EL LENGTH. c~WrAAGC w14csriTlcTno ECIO SECT SETO SECTIO CROSS SECTION SECT",N (LENGTH ' CovEýRoG TOTAL COVERACO

~LENGTH PrS7RnCTED F(W.NSýO UNES:JTE (AfWNCD AREW(O ARf- EXAMINED RESTRICýTED ARA ZxAW EDUNRESTRICTElD

______ ~lW*EJOH N8S STRCE%(4ESS) ED% [_IO) SOCI1ES '~Vt!AGE% (!soa.wCHES)

CR"SS

%bVEECAGE LEgf sfemyO %

CRS(RIICTD

NETI~f~%

COVERAdF 41-11 '47.12 _________ OOj- 1, _____ _________________

i~-cZ VI

fs& /4s21 -/'z RI LU) q~AJ1~ARL~ flCA~ NThw-/1~

Zw

~x Po '~'

,.If.

.... q" So r, 07

...A &4 q7.

N ~

2~$I2 ~Q

~J~h jj 1j~S7C9ic7~O zReS7~/Cf~O ~

L~OA'W~

~

/ ci ~e*7~ia~ g,~iACv~VA~(A if 9 ~ R~7~~krEz~ 6,lSep7APi6,e/4L w.~ V ~~R$i' 1'*

31*' ii

~I ~~e'

" ... .. e/V1

.. '* ":: ""t+." *; 'o" : " "' fg

"' g9' jj-iY~'

u Zc~t. t*

160 NO b

Ole

(/1J*6~,A~It's~t

.. 71 ,

e~7(6 cA&2 r- L

tt~9?

L~k1A ~A'$6f~

0 CiRC~ ~4¶cV-PZ/&I

~A1

/3 LU L p~Z,Z7-,&O kJ~L-D~ FfiLu

,~c~i~pE G4,C qI7 i /

Ij/ h ~

S 4hV A ýQ C

~%

i i/

Lv-Z3(

~~ ~~"A)WP7iAe

- I 3,1* ~I5Ij I) ~

1omIc.______

GOVETGEcL

?qe~ ~

T~A ~s~riv tioA~- os 4 .1. I 4 .4- -

jOIAL-rOYL RESTRI~CE WELD LoNGTh WELDL-ENTH' CR033. TOTAL CAOSS UNR11TRICTEB TOTAL CROU COVERAGE. JNIRMSýTIPUC EXAMEIED -LINDTH *VELDLENGTH PtOSSECTION SECTION' SIECTiONSECToN cIR101ssI . (LE*oGT X :OVER IAGE ItOTALCOVERAGE LEINGIW RESTRICT40 EXAI.?4E ERRESTRICTE6D EXAMWiE , A:REA(SO. AP.EAEXAMINED1 RESTRIC7TED AREA UMONOEL UNRE$TMCTED CRtOSS LENGTH X CROSi!(RESTRICTID+

'I~SRgp% COVERAGES tSO. rncw4s) 'COVER'AdE 1 IE4TIO~% UHI4ESTMCTEI3ý%

4 4,.-

MAThMALYIAL

q C6VEtAAýU o47,1?,

TcowARDI4mEAD BAS 0

1 ~ ' _ 4 ~ -

~4 NAM__

V40^

TOWAAD HEA WEiD AEALCOVEA ..... 47,12 47-12 1060IMW 0.06% ot45 12.5l% ~0 MRW¶ >12.5114 12.51%

fifSE MATZR!AL AXIALI

.... .[

..... 0>00%

CXIYYRAGCE '4712 . 11

,_____ 19 fmI4 0 DOc14 E;7.4,E% E724%

V.24%

rOw*ARD NOZE 10 .D !

WD0AXIA COVERAGE L

{ 4j 47.12 321.4 0,00% a214 I co I"!

4 1 4 qCOVERACE WELD 47.12 c 0,OMN I. R174 .I~iEJI7 ((IlwID Am OM%

HEADSIDEOIRC

.1005 0 0 011

.. 16... -iO -- 0.222 000%

"I I&mN I

~O014 loom%01 1oobt 4712, 10 AG0cO Covr~nArF*'

BASEMATERIAL- 0 OD" 0.00%

47A 1 _ 1 1.50 47.12 -712 1:177 06oOft 00016 im;

. 15......1...

I.

I ----.-.-......,..,..-~.-......,.

-*1 _______

1 .1 tOTALWIELDVOWME COERAGII

4. . .. . 1._________________ i _________ .1. _______ 1 _________ ___________

I R~P 'N A~U -~

""',~9~

d Uj 6016ýIJ- ,PO flAb0 Ci~~(

I~QE~c6 +72V PO IKT, N

/1'

/ I IIA

/

~;,3~t)

\I3~~gf I 3,1* 3.1*

DA-i

3'1'ý11 Pai-jýQ sx ý V6L -4 ~47~4~f 6~V/CwCA K ~- LCVEL~~ O 1 4?&~j~'

ew jisO~ I-2-fZP -1 6OC0 LU WI~Y~~ cLS6,TA)

~g7~Jl~O 6Y~'/I'5V71+

It AV jq5 6111~) ; 77~L tOe~LO Ai~6 1 (Oo% c~PW/Y 3.1*' 3;I,*" '~ 31*" A1~U I

~36~' ~"

i~)7i~JC~ 4J po S &Cz/~

~qriAg pA/~ ?~ VLYL"AfT 1

.1 ýf d

6OL~cUŽ 1CI 42~LD 4 2N7~~IV LU PJtZl1 k JL ~(gcU~64gCsc 7Wq '04

-5egcT WA61 -/ 7J

/ :c~~k~A~seM(PA

/ LWC T'1 11

/ /177 ~~z

~7~ 8A&/1.4 1<kA

.7 Am7~~L UvZ ~ 10%C'rP~7 3i" ~1~1I I./I P

'p x~(- 5E 'VLZ~ 4~L4

COVERAGEQAý -, sHEET ?i~ ~

WEL.DNO.)1Mtn ...

.......... lED ORES .1_________ .1._________ 1 ______ A .1. I> I. JU EAL

+

... . I RESTRICTED TOTAL TOTAL WELDLENGTH. wELo LENGtvl C~qbss RESTRIOTE TOTAL CROSS UNMr!tCr~cED, TOTAL CROSS COVýERA4E U)NRiESTIETE WE L EXASANýEp ASI- tENtHý SEC 14) CROSSecr(M4 MOCTION CRiSB SECTIN CL.WGTHK COVERACe TOTAL COVERMIE LENGTH, RESTIRICTED EXAMINED u,fRLSTnATtO, -XAM44MD AREA (SO. AREA EXAMMrND RESATRIO4hO AREAEXAM[IdN - LINRES1TRlCT C 0SS~ "LNaTH)CCSAOSS UNIESTRCTED 7NCREsp +

JNRE5TRiCTED % (SO. HENES,,

INCES mi RES)

...i .. [.. . irr .... . . . --I tOWARD HEAD BASE, MATERIAL AXIAL 47.12 ýlO~ '4 ~ (20,1 .o.*o%I 14612-A 144S, I ---

47 1 AX.ALCOVVEERAGE 47A2 2.214 C 462 (I QOTA 15.2'1A 11(2114

0. W'V..

TOWARD ,O*Z ELE, 4 ~V4 + I 7 .1 I t

47.12 WASEMA.EAL AXIAL YO covehiiii .47,1; 1~ NI~a 0.00%

1 000%4 ".N _ _ _ -1 TOPWARD NOZZLE WE5LD AXIIAL.

COVERAGE 47.12 47.i~ 0.214 47~ t'

-4.

- 4 4- + -4 HEAD SIDE CIMC 47.12 0 a ~4~V .5 EIIT *i00 ttk 100 160; 1607.

MEAD lSIECR HASEMA'TT(RIAL.

0 6.222 1oum0

. 6.00%7 joD~l E222

________ ________ 4- -..- I A-

'47A2 CDVrERAOE o w,0% t w7 1.-07 WELD> 47,12 - ~ _____ .4- + ..

I moo.01 I

W%!014 NdizLE SIDE acIR (0001, COVEATMA 47.12 47.12 '1177 1 .i1A 6,0M 16.1 614 1111014

________ I-TOTALWELDVOLU4E II * "/ .. . .... . .7-". "* . . . . ..

L-1E~L1.\9 s~

I 1119A12

Enclosure 6 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-022 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Examination Category B-B, Item B2'.40, Tubesheet-to-Head Weld RAI REQUEST RESPONSE 1a Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Welds is Tubesheet-to-Head Weld.

la Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

Ia Interference/Obstruction Information follows in Enclosure.

lb NDE Equipment Information follows in Enclosure.

lb Alternative Methods (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 6.0). HNP is proposing to volumetrically UT examine the steam generator Tubesheet-to-head weld, II-SG-00l SGA-TSTHW-06-1, to the maximum extent possible in accordance with the Inservice Inspection Program schedule. In addition, the subject weld will be subject to system pressure tests during each refueling outage.

ic Wave Modality/ Insonification Information follows in Enclosure (00 Longitudinal, Angles 45' Shear, 60' Shear).

Ie Results of the Examination No indications detected.

Indications / No Indications 4a Please clarify whether all three All three of the steam generators have the same steam generator tubesheet-to-head configuration / limitation.

welds were examined. Because the Since B-B, B2.40 Note 1 only requires one per licensee was unable to meet the similar vessel, the examination was performed on one ASME Code-required inspection of the three steam generators.

volume on tubesheet-to-head weld (Note: These steam generators were new in 2001).

II-SG-001 SGA-TSTHW-06-1, if the other tubesheet-to-head welds were examined, please describe whether the same coverage area limitations apply to these similar welds on the remaining two steam generators.

Page 1 of 6

Enclosure 6 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-022 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: II-SG-001SGA-TSTHW-06-1 ASME CATEGORY: B-B ASME CODE IWB.2500-6 ASME ITEM NUMBER: B2.40 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: TUBESHEET TO HEAD % CRV ACHIEVED:

WELD WELD 70.106%

BASE METAL 74.20%

PROCEDURES: NDEP-0450 MATERIAL CS/CS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: NO BASE METAL AND WELD METAL VOLUME COVERAGE SCAN % VOLUME % WELD LIMITATION ACHIEVED VOLUME ACHIEVED 00 72.74% 76.6% Lower lateral support pads 450 73.38% 68.852% Lower lateral support pads 600 76.48% 64.867% Lower lateral support pads TOTAL 74.2% 70.106% Lower lateral support pads The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the four lower lateral support pad obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE:

Total base metal volume coverage 74.20 %

Total weld volume coverage 70.11 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO RECORDABLE INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH KBA 1.0", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 00, KBA 0.5" x 1.0", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" x 1.0",

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 2 of 6

ON ON

ý9uPENT %A:G z SGEM

0 HZ 0

C.)

[.-

0 0

0*

u z ITEMNO 01 CHANtiEL EAD ESCRIPTION MTRIAL SPEC.

S NC~ SrA-CLNIR RRIBBO-02 TUBEPlATE PLATE.-5 CL. 3o OZ STUBBARREL, -- * -533 TPE-B CL. 2 H LOWER SHELLBARREL " SA-533 TYPEB C. 2

[..

0S LOWER SHELt.ARREL'T SA-533 TYPE8 a., 2 05r MTAMMITON CONE SA-508 CL. 30, 67 UPPERSHELLB 'RRELI

. SA-533 TYPEB CL 2 0q Be UPPERSHELLBARREL V 5-533 TYPCB CL. 2 09 UPPE'RHEKR(WtT"4INTI.PL NOZZLE) SA-505 CL.30 Hq in FEEOYATER INLETNOZZLE16$ 0.0. SA-53 CL3ý

<0 BOTTOM VIEW It AUXEL1ARY 12 SECONAIDY FEEOWATER SNE NOZ2ZLE?ý WWAYS(2)

O.X. SA-OU CL, 4.

SA-508 CL,3ý

~ ~~

.:J":-::: .: ' ::t: ::.:

.: C H *

' Progress Energy i3 LWER> SHELL TRURNIONS S-B CL. 3. SWI NHA NIS

.rILE 14 UPE SlIELLTUNOS5-O L3 15 PRIAWIYNOMZES(2) $k-503OL Ct 3 STEAM GENERATOR 'A'

ýIMMARY MANWAYS(2) Ct. 3ý =I-e* 17ISI *SG-l,,

Enclosure 6 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-022 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-SG-001SGA-TSTHW-06-1 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

WELD MATERIAL Determination of Percent Coverage for UT Examinationsl -Vessels.

Srte/.t "6fP I I prooedure: Noep-om5 OutageNo,.: tttPO.12:-

summar No:' H-03M4 Prcur Re,:._ 0 Ragot Ito.: UT-04-1t23_

Workacopec, lim Work OdrN.,________ ae:4, "of: B Scn 76.600 % L00X t0000 ON lmolegh10 76.m0 !%6toal Ordag Scan I 76.600 %,Length X MA0O0 % Volume oJeU)thiAQ10- 76.4600 %total for Scan 1 S 2 2a. 76.00o Length X 5*.840 % volume offeth I 100,.0 f5.s4

ý= %total for Suan2 Scan 3 76.600 % Le..th x 100.000 vol t% total for Stan3 Scan 4 76.600 %Legqth X 100.000 % voWume Oalaengh 9100 29 70 % total for Scan 4 Add totals and diie by# scans = 58.02 %tn*bo ltior454og bftl do Sor Scan I 76.00 %LbnglhX 'N00 %volUrreotlajngih I00 76.(60 ltowalforSoa I 70 76.0 %Lanth ean X 36.730 %Voltaottength10.0 29.667' %tl61otrr 2 Scan 3 76.000 % LeVngth X 100.000 %vtueo length / 100v 700 % tota for-Sc-an 3 Sa4 76.800 %A ongthX :100,00 % votlumeof "nthj100= M4.0 %total forScan 4 Ad.d touta anw divide liy, a. a 64. 6 %total for : de.g Add totals lor eachý angle and scan required and fdivite by# ot angles to determi no; 70A106*/,Totalfor comjaleta examn Note.

&rVpptmentolt covearagpauy beachweed by use otofter angles /Imethods., When used,the coverage tot votrert not obta ired w angls,thas noted abovethat be calaed and addedtottotat toprovIde th percenltotal for thb ornpqla Site Foltd Suppervsor."Ot: ,/ at 7thu Dmierrot hsaOARecord Page 4 of 6

Enclosure 6 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R1-022 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-SG-001SGA-TSTHW-06-1 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

BASE MATERIAL Supplemental RepOrt

(~U E~Report No.: UT04Y-023 pawe .5 ..8 Summary.No,: H. . . . .

Of:*

oAAY,2, A,.

7C~i" (~'

uoal 9rvw ~ww3 Ierlao-

-S 2 %L-Whe X, ýA4 .vob,.Maa. iW i.I fSciC I-re .2 Cc~~~~e2l~ ev X(. '/e 10 0 wr I %'earwenlwfO %adCs-f.*4 3 Oe4 _____% Cýlb /70 .ereo 7G,.W

-4, ~i ce-.4 73-3* forsi ScC,2 744 lbcrlgbX: /00 %law 4~.re~nio4 6isice.

agene 7t. ~ ~crx' L-tý /00 %Wk e*I6 looh 190%t~ra~~,

Add UAMi C.d ýd*l byb e,.-l Ce o . ~

AIefer.reo md eeerf n e, oerded yClCge Cefor 7% ~beconpteer "r.. Toe aWdWh.ý

,d 60 Aeftro 6Vý"

SPIC~~~~~~~r)Cet~~~~~~~~tw crya dbyrdb c.c ce erfC eord.e 10~cefreneOr oooo c ShoFlctdSveo-freo 4 &//c ooro 0tZ 7"ctccccICCAfC'c ThaD..rwoitc I. ai eo 14A Page 5 of 6

Enclosure 6 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2RI-022 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-SG-001SGA-TSTHW-06-1 LIMITATION SKETCH

Limitation'Record Poeure., N* P-0460 Oiegr No. IRPO-12

.SumrneryNo N.0384 Proce re ev.: 0' eorNo: UT-04-023 Deecrpttor of birfftattorr:

Sketch of Urrdteton: y "m -"ddeamhp.veerlo2.1

'rcrrr... ornrer.n,,.

rnttation removat reopiremmmts:.

.Raratien lied:

Page 6 of 6

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Examination Category C-A, Item C1.1O, Shell Circumferential Welds RAI REQUEST RESPONSE Ia Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Weld is Pressure Retaining Welds in Pressure Vessels.

la Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

la Interference/Obstruction (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 5.0). Weld configuration (flange to shell) and obstructions (flange bolting) prevent 100 percent volumetric examination to be performed during inservice inspection activities.

lb NDE Equipment Information follows in Enclosure.

lb Alternative Methods (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 6.0). HNP is proposing to volumetrically UT examine the restricted areas of Weld RHRACSW-02 to the maximum extent possible in accordance with the Inservice Inspection Program schedule. In addition, this weld is subject to visual (VT-2) system leakage testing during each refueling period. To supplement the volumetric examination, a 70 degree 1/2/vee shear wave UT examination was performed. A code compliant surface examination (PT) was also performed, although not required by code.

Ic Wave Modality/ Insonification Information follows in Enclosure ("45' Shear Wave Angles 3/4 Vee Scan").

Id Cross Sectional Coverage Plots to Information follows in Enclosure.

describe the ASME Code coverage le Results of the Examination Information follows in Enclosure.

Indications / No Indications Page 1 of 11

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: II-RHR-01RHRA-CSW-02 ASME CATEGORY: C-A ASME CODE IWC-2500-1 ASME ITEM NUMBER: CI.10 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: SHELL CIRCUMFERENTIAL % CRV ACHIEVED: 66.50 WELDS PROCEDURES: ISI-21 IT MATERIAL SS/SS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: NO 450 SHEAR WAVE %VEE SCAN SCAN % WELD REQUIRED LIMITATION VOLUME ACHIEVED AXIAL 96.01% FLANGE TO SHELL WELD CONFIGURATION AND TOWARD INTERFERENCE FROM THE CLOSE PROXIMITY OF FLANGE THE FLANGE CONNECTION BOLTING AXIAL 38.63% FLANGE TO SHELL WELD CONFIGURATION AND TOWARD INTERFERENCE FROM THE CLOSE PROXIMITY OF SHELL THE FLANGE CONNECTION BOLTING CIRC 31.37% FLANGE TO SHELL WELD CONFIGURATION AND FLANGE INTERFERENCE FROM THE CLOSE PROXIMITY OF SIDE THE FLANGE CONNECTION BOLTING CIRC 100% FLANGE TO SHELL WELD CONFIGURATION AND SHELL INTERFERENCE FROM THE CLOSE PROXIMITY OF SIDE THE FLANGE CONNECTION BOLTING The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the four core support lug obstructions in place and the results are representative of the entire weld.

A 700 shear wave, 1/22 vee examination was performed from both sides of the weld for additional coverage but was not listed on the coverage calc.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 66.50 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: GEOMETRIC INDICATION NOTED (ROOT GEOMETRY), NO RECORDABLE INDICATION NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH KBA 0.375", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.375", 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 700 Page 2 of 11

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: FINP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET 211-98-001 PAGE 11 OF 12 COMPONENT DRAWING PAM66 OF :62-WL6'tP4' AII&AA- CSWJ-OL JIrA~L poF qq.v IMs P~F~1 AIC5

- WCLLI'0 VAl-IA4S Page 3 of 11

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: 1HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET 211-98-001 PAGE 10 OF 12 INTERFERENCE MEASUREMENT DRAWING

5Oý *-i-frY

ý ES, hic.

6F O~ i,'-

%aAL rzq (A)~i-U~ f~W&I1- eSW-OZ 0 A~~'~'~' ~ 7~ ~rjJ7~14L.

c9 S/i3C CIA( CO~~66 ;67~2. *~xV%1,U.

FL aN6[

-I

$IEL SIDE

'PS',

17 1- tzr Page 4 of 11

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET 211-98-001 PAGE 4 OF 12 PROFILE SCAN PAiSEET*-.,

'69LVO I.O- j . 11 03)

,~A. .~

Page 5 of I1

Enclosure 7,to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET 211-98-001 PAGE 2 OF 12 450 SCAN TOWARD SHELL

O~r

~xu~t- OA

SOULs*F LH NEI

.: ,:.:Y!

ELL- 'PAQq.-: if.O..e4-L IN*0 q A 61'o 7

-LANA

/2 4 1

7 .i' -

000 4 Page 6 of 11

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET-211-98-001 PAGE 3 OF 12 450 SCAN TOWARD FLANGE

5 OJ4Sc~~tkLNES, finc.

AK/At SC#¶AI zq OFLAu1 I, -r/CJr 7eA d

~rLAN& 6

,7 1 16 CA/0

'(* 1 ktsz4JeO fe4o

,, 3 q~ TIM 4~~<~7)4O A~e~U.6U/ )j 7

Z"' ao,~

fXAA?/NEk ~ VrLo-Z'6 'y0 q Page 7 of 11

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET 211-98-001 PAGE 5 OF 12 CIRCUMFERENTIAL SCAN eIj P&~ 0%

FLAN6[ $J-

.. F i~.

D~l~lil f/c1~A

.1

~e aoA~ be6 -71

~~qgcgft' *T/e6t9 ',u7SO

~ 11AL dec E..&,,1.I SCA. ISiA IO 1

.X/~N(6 A '1 LW'a9VF Page 8 of 11

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET 211-98-001 PAGE 9 OF 12 700 SUPPLEMENTAL SCAN NES, I0c.

PA~ F.02ýZ W6~O RAW-cW~

Q

£LN6 5s(LL SIOLý

, l.. .16:

lAnht~*c~AzI

ý-xAIVII e9v 67/ -ýiflA z ir k Page 9 of II

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET 211-98-001 PAGE 12 OF 12 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

OA~i ~ £~z~Lz-5~

OOffi(

~LL~L-7P

- O~ L~51 A LV~~&~

M~ ~ ____

"A"*0, L ___

m ___ ___I __

"Tom= m9009 ý m9 9M09a M9

. .1W I---

01 90* 1 'a w.. ___

,,i 01 1 -- ~OlJ 1 i

DAT (1~e.co; Page 10 of I1

Enclosure 7 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-009 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DATA SHEET,211-98-001 PAGE 1 OF 1 NDE REPORT

SUMMARY

S" nAROLINA L OHPR &oImGpnT COMrANY te x mein No.m)

NDE REPORT/SUMMAARY Iae____O U-RI4R-0IRHRA-*CSW..02:

Procedure(s) ISI.21 IT Per the ISI Program Plan, Interval 2. Pe*iod L Outage I (RFO-8), ultrasonic examinations (UT) were performed on the subJect weld. These.exminations rmeet the requirement- of ASME.Section Xl, 1989 Ed, and re acceptable to the evaluation critena of-IWA.3000.

This e**donlyreqtihtesa U-r cxal*nation. A code compliant FP was also perfor*ed. No indication swaer.edetcted The, LIT exams were performed us;ing 'procedure. techniques and personnel that meet the requirements of Appe-ndix III of ASMI3, Section XL. A 451, sheatr wavc. V'ývec eXAM wasý performed from both sides. For additional coverage. a 7W Vivee. shear wave was used to scan on both sides of the welds. Examination is incomplete, Scanning was limited due to the flange' to shell weld configuration and interfere*e from the close promimity of the flangeconnection bolting. Total volume of weld and base material coverage was calculate* to be 66.5%.

Co'verge plots and calculations are attached.

Cud i;~2~ :0> 1 millEt 1 e; em Page 11 of.11

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION.

Examination Category C-B, Item C2.21, Nozzle-to-Shell Weld RAI REQUEST RESPONSE la Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Weld BIT-O1NTHW-03 is the Outlet Nozzle to Head Weld located on the top of the Boron Injection Tank and Weld BIT-O1NTHW-04 is the Inlet Nozzle to Head Weld located on the bottom of the Boron Injection Tank.

la Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

Ia Interference/Obstruction (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 5.0). Nozzle to vessel welds are not conducive to two-sided volumetric examinations due to nozzle configurations.

lb NDE Equipment Information follows in Enclosure.

lb Alternative Methods (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 6.0). HNP is proposing to volumetrically examine the pressure retaining nozzle to vessel welds BIT-OINTHW-03 and BIT-O1NTHW-04 to the maximum extent possible in accordance with the Inservice Inspection Program schedule using Ultrasonic (UT) Examination. A significant portion of the subject welds have been examined, obtaining greater than 75 percent coverage for each nozzle to shell weld. In addition, the welds are subject to visual (VT-2) tests during each refueling outage.

ic Wave Modality/ Insonification Information follows in Enclosure ("0' Longitudinal Angles Wave Scan", 450 Shear Wave 1/2 Vee Scan", 600 Shear Wave 1/22.Vee Scan").

1d Cross Sectional Coverage Plots to Information follows in Enclosure.

describe the ASME Code coverage le Results of the Examination No indications detected.

Indications /No Indications Page 1 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 2a Please state whether the All angle beam exams used shear waves, only the 0 inspection techniques used to degree exam used longitudinal waves.

examine these welds included 45 degree shear - Y2 V refracted longitudinal waves. 60 degree shear - V2 V 0 degree longitudinal 2b Please state the material used Material used is alloy steel - ASTM A 204 Standard (austenitic or ferritic steel) and Specification for Pressure Vessel Plates, Alloy Steel, the wall thickness for each of Molybdenum (Austenitic); 1.732" Thickness these components.

Page 2 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: II-BIT-01NTHW-03 ASME CATEGORY: C-B II-BIT-01NTHW-04 ASME CODE IWC-2500-4 ASME ITEM NUMBER: C2.21 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: PRESSURE RETAINING % CRV ACHIEVED: 77.14%

NOZZLE WELDS IN 0 DEGREES 100%

VESSELS 45 DEGREES 58%

60 DEGREES 73.43%

PROCEDURES: NDEP-0448 MATERIAL SS/SS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: NO 00 LONGITUDINAL WAVE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 100%

450 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CIRCUMFERENTIAL 100%

SCAN HEADSIDE CIRCUMFERENTIAL 100%

SCAN NOZZLE SIDE AXIAL SCAN 0% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION TOWARD HEAD AXIAL SCAN 32% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION TOWARD NOZZLE I II Page 3 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEFREQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 600 SHEAR WAVE 1/2 VEE SCAN SCAN % VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED CIRCUMFERENTIAL 100%

SCAN HEADSIDE CIRCUMFERENTIAL 100%

SCAN NOZZLE SIDE AXIAL SCAN 0% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION TOWARD HEAD AXIAL SCAN 93.7% NOZZLE TO SHELL CONFIGURATION TOWARD NOZZLE I II The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the nozzle to shell configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 77.14 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: STAVELEY, SONIC-136, WITH KBA 0.75", 2.25MHZ, LONGITUDINAL 00, KBA 0.5" DIA., 2.25MHZ, SHEAR 450 AND KBA 0.5" DIA.,

2.25MHZ, SHEAR 600 Page 4 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION BORON INJECTION TANK NOZZLE TO HEAD WELD CONFIGURATION IDENTIFICATION SHEET TYPICAL FOR BOTH THE INLET NOZZLE AND THE OUTLET NOZZLE NOZZLE SHELL I WVLLU Page 5 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-BIT-01NTHW-03 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

Detelrmination of Percent COverage for SUTT Examinations - Vessels S "f/011 I'P Proceduro SrnrNo~;~ t-01353 B0aP 5rertN;,ý :UT-04-003

....... 2....3

.Wonks9qjpe'F . oS ýWe~cide No.:,

'S..n 100.000 %!Length Xý 100.000.. .3 otlrn Of.Ieth/j.100' 100.000 i9otal~foSd.

45 d-.,

Soo 10.001 3 Lngjth )ý> 32.000 So vottni Uflength / 100-- 32.00 ,tte for Soon 1

.S-1n2 0.000' 06000

&9LnghX 3yktn length /1O= 0.000 o 3 ttetfrp.-on2

Soen .ý3 10&0d0. 5 LN'ent 100.000, Igo., 1000 3.ot"I

%tiO 6rfterSn3 n

'ScsnO 0000 10010.0 9Le .%39um vo~of 1eghl0=

100.000 .39tot.1fot'S-o4 d.....oe..n ......

.800

... d~d. V , o tSd Sý2n 100.000 %4 Leigth'X_ 63.666 y4o4,me ot lengthL 1'00 9.0 ~ tIo~o ScnS - 0.00 9Length X; i00.0660- P r9lyok.nof lemngth ,.1060 1166oo' 9t0Obelt~n Soon 4 00.0 39Length X 100.00ObO'f egh/10- 0.0 tte:ttSo AA.Utotel.end~dbUsec 73.A42-5 3tfe*fr 60-ý dg:

. 142i.

S~,ptonenntovorge toybe achieved by.use of other angtoe~yrnthocts~hn Date, '10/22/2004 Thist-b-rhent I. Oflcr Page 6 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-BIT-OINTHW-03 ULTRASONIC SKETCH B

Supplp!emental Report:

'A.~port N-' WTý04-0031 f~g: 3: o ~ -

e-~iner: Bwo. R~n bw~f Revi-wor;

'ip~ WMftae ,CPc.,OganUTýLasril MI Doo: -10/2212004 ExarAiLaovol N/A_ Sit0Roqvf(w- Edjwin U. Si6k: 10/23/2004, Iot other.. N/A Le-ef N/A ANit Resvitw. L-ey'JbneS AM11 aet- 10123/ 2004,

.Cnn-e, V ELXVLOCATIONWAND UII4ENS64DS TAKENM FROM 0RAWiN0 C 1219OE77 SHMEYT2.

ifs DomentIs.o.O&floco.-O Page 7 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-BIT-01NTHW-04 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

Dete-mination E of Perce nt Coverage fr zUT'*Examinations - Vessels Siek/ nit.: .. p. . IJ I NO0EP-0448. O~utegpNo. IRFO-iS:

PmoCedur Ro.-r 0 Reor o. T-04-000 P00: 3 et 3

.:0 dee Planar scan, 100.006 n Lenth) X 10r0000 v/lume

-o t lrg t' 100 , o100.000 total f*o 0*dog:

,.d:e Scan 1 100.000 %V.LongthX 32.000; Io v of *lngth/

.11une 100 . 32.000 * . 1,k10 01 V.. Scan, Scbn 2 t 0.000 .l n enth K l '0.000 dvott t2.theolength!o 100= t 0.000 c Vololaltho*oanp e!zn 3tinIt,'lnth i00.000 X 100.000; alngth/

oe 100 100.000 for Sean 100.00 4 V. Legth X 100.000 %-0voterle ofongth! 00 10.00 :tRoatdrSio.

S-an'1 100.000 I%' Longtn 370 .,.atn a.egh 10= 9.00Xttl a er Sea 2~000 5'LenthX . 0000 Vuvutan- f longth 100 -0.000 V%.ltal'fo,:Sman2'2 sic-ni! 100o.000 V. Lengn~tp, -100000 5 volft af length /'100 100.000 V"etlfr;eo Adda looe o .ecgio ýs

-3eef equr0nddvd'ty#onla to detannine s6pptenelioeoereitetatt -- gtt"d -hn civdayue to uethe'coevrae0Olor-lurnenot haltbececuiaedan cblaied~wth~aglaeaS~ntedaavO addd lahe ttait prcidolhc.percntlolat fort,,arp~l Site Field SupolvlaoT:, Ww-laiW VBlee, Dol 1022/00 Th1.onel saARcr Page 8 of 9

Enclosure 8 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-010 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-BIT-01NTHW-04 ULTRASONIC SKETCH

ýSupplemental Report Ftepo.

No. ýUY-04-G00 page: - .2.Z . of, ".3 S.uonotary No:;, H-0113S4 Eeeio:~B~g~. no. . . Le ti it-poE R'Eo. . oe~U.L~JI Dte

>alh~ 10/22)2004 ExoeYinobr;' N/A .Leool NIA' sit. R-o-jc E-d-i. M. Bick Dote 0)23 004

.Qthe ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

ee:NAAn ~ ~ oiw.

Y "/e-y J.... ANII Date;: 10)2320041 This Dec..n*ient Is e OA Record.

Page 9 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Examination Category C-C, Item C3.30, Pumps Integrally Welded Attachments RAI REQUEST RESPONSE Ia Description (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 1.0). Welds II-CSIP-ICSIP-A-WAI, II-CSIP-ICSIP-A-WA2, II-CSIP-1CSIP-A-WA3 and IICSIP-I CSIP-A-WA4 are integral attachments for the support legs located on the bottom of the Charging Safety Injection Pump.

la Sketch Information follows in Enclosure.

la Interference/Obstruction (Reference Relief Request submittal HNP-08-045 Section 5.0). Due to the restricted access caused by the configuration of the components, structural support steel limits, access to one side of the welded attachment, 100 percent surface examinations are limited.

lb NDE Equipment Information follows in Enclosure.

lb Alternative Methods No additional alternative methods or advanced technologies have been employed.

Ic Wave Modality/ Insonification Penetrant Examination.

Angles ld Cross Sectional Coverage Plots to Information follows in Enclosure.

describe the ASME Code coverage le Results of the Examination No recordable indications.

Indications / No Indications Page 1 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 -

RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: II-CSIP-1CSIP-A-WA1 ASME CATEGORY: C-C ASME CODE IWC-2500-5 ASME ITEM NUMBER: C3.30 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: INTEGRAL ATTACHMENTS % CRV ACHIEVED: 77.10%

FOR VESSELS, PIPING, PUMPS AND VALVES PROCEDURES: NDEP-0201 MATERIAL SS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: NO LIQUID PENETRANT EXAMINATION

% VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 77.1% FLANGE MATING SURFACE AND STRUCTURAL STEEL The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the pump fillet weld configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld&

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 77.14 %

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO RECORDABLE INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: MAGNAFLUX MATERIALS Page 2 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-CSIP-1CSIP-A-WA1 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

Supplemental :Repcrrt fio0o0tw N0 P-o4-ooz2 w

Srnn No ir 1-p i' "1' Page,: 2 . JF '2.

Sketch or Photo: v:\Sr.aeU~,aoeart-tNP_0atetflataSheot3ofo~PT-04~002tif

--I 1,rI ýý 'ý- z - : &-c--

.- ~;" *L.

L mwon mrCSK--WA rotpitot I~aai.,~t~o ~tottato1,

- is QArota eaai Step Page 3 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: II-CSIP-iCSIP-A-WA2 ASME CATEGORY: C-C ASME CODE IWC-2500-5 ASME ITEM NUMBER: C3.30 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: INTEGRAL ATTACHMENTS % CRV ACHIEVED: 82.35%

FOR VESSELS, PIPING, PUMPS AND VALVES PROCEDURES: NDEP-0201 MATERIAL SS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: NO LIQUID PENETRANT EXAMINATION

% VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 82.35% STRUCTURAL STEEL The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the pump fillet weld configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 82.35%

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO RECORDABLE INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: MAGNAFLUX MATERIALS Page 4 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 1NSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-CSIP-1CSIP-A-WA2 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

'Supplementa*ti Rep6ot Ropoftl No.; PIT*G4-003 I

go; 2i ot. *2

~.,rcro8,y No.; 14-01 859

~

Sketch ~

Photo;-iý66 ~ .0 4,40 1:.hrdtdal-$Ih~t~aaho tlOP-6"03.t 594P.5- .

A p~t

'retare~nui,.27.65V6a Page 5 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: II-CSIP-iCSIP-A-WA3 ASME CATEGORY: C-C ASME CODE IWC-2500-5 ASME ITEM NUMBER: C3.30 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: INTEGRAL ATTACHMENTS % CRV ACHIEVED: 80%

FOR VESSELS, PIPING, PUMPS AND VALVES PROCEDURES: NDEP-0201 MATERIAL SS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: NO LIQUID PENETRANT EXAMINATION

% VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 80% STRUCTURAL STEEL The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the pump fillet weld configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld...

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 80%

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO RECORDABLE INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: MAGNAFLUX MATERIALS Page 6 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 1NSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-CSIP-1CSIP-A-WA3 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

Supplemental Report AJN

-G- NGI00 0 FAoporiNo,~~To-

~no00,:.N0.: H-01860 -

Skatahor F'hata: ~V,\S~ dlddoa\HNP *O0~OaSheetj.ifo\PT)~'0O~Wit FensitL.lasseaIan0a,..,s-e~ oi~ia..

'Fa0~j

'7.0'.' -.- ~ .0" 4.00" 5- 4,00" .2Z00" 1.0" 5.00" .5- ~00" (t1~~s-~s-. IoI.o0.o.~fl~3a0S) ~.

175" (w.11 IdOh -o .50" 101. .sId~) -52.S0"~

ftncauw.pKata pCS.flIflSStOfl ann:

.75"('.s-s-Id e.Sdth) -- ~1.O' (50",~e,,oo, ens-a s-Itba. 10 at e.s-Id) X GOO" (I.,gh at

- 0. ea.apl000 ,.~s-ai.satIa.. .- en>.= 10.50" 10.S0" ~s- 52 .SO's- = .20 - 20w. h.s-o..,pIs-t e80~ eenpD.t..

Th~e~a~a~s.,1 . '10A 05N5-O,-5 Page 7 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. 1 DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION COMPONENT ID: II-CSIP-1CSIP-A-WA4 ASME CATEGORY: C-C ASME CODE IWC-2500-5 ASME ITEM NUMBER: C3.30 FIGURE:

CONFIGURATION: INTEGRAL ATTACHMENTS % CRV ACHIEVED: 75%

FOR VESSELS, PIPING, PUMPS AND VALVES PROCEDURES: NDEP-0201 MATERIAL SS PDI TECHNIQUE USED: NO LIQUID PENETRANT EXAMINATION

% VOLUME LIMITATION ACHIEVED 75% FLANGE MATING SURFACE AND STRUCTURAL STEEL The coverage achieved was the maximum extent practical with the pump fillet weld configuration and the results are representative of the entire weld.

UT COMBINED COVERAGE = 75%

EXAMINATION RESULTS: NO RECORDABLE INDICATIONS NDE EQUIPMENT: MAGNAFLUX MATERIALS Page 8 of 9

Enclosure 9 to SERIAL: HNP-09-095 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NO. I DOCKET NO. 50-400/RENEWED LICENSE NO. NPF-63 INSERVICE INSPECTION RELIEF REQUEST 2R2-011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION II-CSIP-1CSIP-A-WA4 COVERAGE

SUMMARY

'Supplemental RepOrt-G.- Ii..

Gr- Ftop.r1 N5.ý PT-04-005ý

<:04'b ý I P~goZ2 of 2 s'S.6mnly N-. "-016q1' Skotcti:or-:Phote: .V:~Shaed'.5ddsaN-lNPOata'd1IstonAMFO-i 2WtT-04+OOS;tit

- ~ L.4.i~~,0J 7^ ~ .V .')4

- .7S." n.-t$d~:

fl-CS.-XCSIr..A.-WA.4 rota. c,~asntnat1en V.75" (,,.eld .,Idtb -.-. 50" aith.' alda) = 50.75"'

lfleCfl.nICte C,.OpflbtIOfl area,

1. 275" (~..Id srtdlh) -s-1.0" (.50"ao.ara.ithar .54,. of ,.,aR.j~'X 6.00~ (Ie.s~0.

~f i,.,aoOSpIat. ~,.atataatio.. ~ 10.50

2. .40" X 5.50"-

Total ia.oo=plate a,......kaal1an~rea .=32.70" ~

~a.aaIatad oerraota.,a~

1Z.7O~ 50.75"' = .254)2 = ZS.00~I~ .pI~ta 75.00'A, ao.apiala.

TbIsOdcurrsent is a OA>Rocerd Page 9 of 9

v t e Letter Sequence Response to RAI
TAC:ME0166, (Approved, Closed) TAC:ME0608, (Open) TAC:ME0609, (Open) TAC:ME0610, (Open) TAC:ME0612, (Open) TAC:ME0613, (Open) TAC:ME0614, (Open) TAC:ME0615, (Open)
Initiation Acceptance... Administration Questions Answers 24 September 2009 Results Approval Other:
MONTHYEAR2009-09-24 [Table View]

HNP-09-095, Response to Request for Additional Information Regarding Relief Requests 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, & 2R2-011 for the Second 10-Year Inservice Inspection Program

Text

References:

Enclosures:

Enclosures:

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

Navigation menu

HNP-09-095, Response to Request for Additional Information Regarding Relief Requests 2R1-018, 2R1-019, 2R1-020, 2R1-021, 2R1-022, 2R2-009, 2R2-010, & 2R2-011 for the Second 10-Year Inservice Inspection Program

Text

References:

Enclosures:

Enclosures:

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

Navigation menu

Search