ML17332A556
ML17332A556 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Cook |
Issue date: | 02/03/1995 |
From: | INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER CO. (FORMERLY INDIANA & MICHIG |
To: | |
Shared Package | |
ML17332A555 | List: |
References | |
NUDOCS 9502130202 | |
Download: ML17332A556 (19) | |
Text
ATTAQiMENT 2TOAEP'NRC:1166/
EXISTINGTECHNICAL SPECIFICATION PAGESMARKEDTOREFLECTPROPOSEDCHANGES9502130202 950203PDRADQCK050003i5PPDR CI
~iEACTORCOOLANTSYSTEMSURVEILLANCE REQUIRE."KNTS 2.Tubesinthoseareaswhereexperience hasindicated potential problems'.
Atubeinspection (pursuant toSpecification 4.4.5.4.a.8) shallbeperformed oneachselectedtube.Ifanyselectedtubedoesnotpermitthepassageoftheeddycurrentprobeforatubeinspection, thisshallberecordedandanadjacenttubeshallbeselectedandsubjected toatubeinspection.
c~Inadditiontothesamplerequiredin4.4.5.2.b.l through3,alltubeswhichhavehadtheWcriteriaappliedwillbeinspected intherollexpandedregion.Therollexpandedregionofthesetubesmaybeexcludedfromtherequirements of4.4.5.2.b.l.
d."Thetubesselectedasthesecondandthirdsamples(ifrequiredbyTable4.4-2)duringeachinse'rvice inspection maybesubjected toapartialtubeinspection provided:
Thetubesselectedforthesamplesincludethetubesfromthoseareasofthetubesheetarraywheretubeswithimperfections werepreviously found..2.Theinspections includethoseportionsofthetubeswhereimperfections werepreviously found./5e.Implementation ofthesteamgenerator tube/tube spportplateinterimpluggingcriteriaforonefuelcycle(Cycle4requiresa100Xbobbincoilinspection forhotlegtubesupportplateintersections andcoldlegintersections downtothelowestcoldlegtubesupportplatewithknownouterdiameterstresscorrosion cracking(ODSCC)indications.
Theresultsofeachsampleinspection shallbeclassified intooneofthefollowing threecategories:
InsectionResultsC-1Lessthan5Xofthetotaltubesinspected aredegradedtubesandnoneoftheinspected tubesaredefective.
C-2Oneormoretubes,butnotmorethan1Xofthetotaltubesinspected aredefective, orbetween5XandlOXofthetotaltubesinspected aredegradedtubes.C-3Morethan10Xofthetotaltubesinspected aredegradedtubesormorethan1Xoftheinspected tubesaredefective.
COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT13/44-8AMENDMENT NO.~,~,~,178 REACTORCOOPTSYSE'HSSURVE'ZLLANC REUTR:-.M:-NTS Cont'uedbThesteamgenerator shallbedetermined OPERABLEaftercompleting thecorresponding actions(plugging orsleevingalltubesexceeding therepairlimitandalltubescontaining through-wall cracks)requiredbyTable4.4-2.CeSteamgeneatortuberepairsmaybemadeinaccordance withthemethodsdescribed ineitherWCAP-12623 orCEN-313-P.
4.4.5.5eortsacb.Following eachinservice inspection ofsteamgenerator tubes,ifthereareanytubesrequiring pluggingorsleeving, thenumberoftubespluggedorsleevedineachsteamgenerator shallbereportedtotheCommission within15days.Thecompleteresultsofthesteamgeneatortubeinservice inspection shallbeincludedintheAnnualOperating Reportfortheperiodinwhichthisinspection wascompleted.
Thisreportshallinclude:1.Numberandextentoftubesinspected.
2~Locationandpercentofwall-thickness penetration foreach.indication ofanimperfection.
C~de3.Identification oftubespluggedorsleeved.Resultsofsteamgenerator tubeinspections whichfallintoCategoryC-3andequirepromptnotification oftheCommission shallbereportedpursuanttoSpecification 6.9.1priortoresumption ofplantopeation.Thewrittenfollowupofthisreportshallprovideadescript'on ofinvestigations conducted todetermine causeofthetubedegradation andcorrective measurestakentopreventrecurrence.
Theresultsofinspections performed under4.4.5.2foralltubesinwhichthetubesupportplateinterimpluggingcriteriahasbeenappliedorthathavedefectsbelowtheF+distanceandwerenotpluggedshallbereportedtotheCommission within15daysfollowing theinspection.
Thereportshallinclude:Listingofapplicable tubes.2~Location(applicable intersections pertube)andextentofdegradation (voltage).
e.Theresultsofsteamlinebreakleakageanalysisperformed underT/S4.4.5.4.a.lO willbereportedtotheCommission priortorestartforCycle~.l~COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT13/44-12KKNDHENTNO.+S&g466p+iip178
~~~~~REACTORCOOLANTSYSTEMO>ERATIONAL LEAKAGEIMITINGCONDITION FOROPERATION 3.46.2ReactorCoolantSystemleakageshallbelimitedto:a.'oPRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGEtb.1GPMUNZDENTZFZED LEAKAGEtCoe.600gallonsperdaytotalprimary-to-secondary..leakage,.through allsteamgenerators and150allonsperdaythroughanyonesteamgenerator forFuelCycle4I10GPMIDENTIFIED LEAKAGEfromtheReactorCoolantSystem,Seallineresistance greaterthanorequalto2.27E-1ft/gpm~and,1GPMleakagefromanyreactorcoolantsystempressureisolation valvespecified inTable3.4-0.APPLICABILITY MODESlg2,3and4.<<<<~CTION:a.b.CoWithanyPRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGE,beinatleastHOTSTANDBYwithin6hoursandin'COLDSHUTDOWNwithinthefollowing 30hours.WithanyReactorCoolantSystemleakagegreaterthananyoneoftheabovelimits,excluding PRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGE,reducetheleakageratetowithinlimitswithin4hoursorbeinatleastHOTSTANDBYwithinthenext6hoursandinCOLDSHUTDOWNwithinthefollowing 30hours.Withanyreactorcoolantsystempressureisolation valve(s)leakagegreaterthantheabovelimit,exceptwhen:Theleakageislessthanorequalto5.0gpm,and2~Themostrecentmeasuredleakagedoesnotexceedthepreviousmeasuredleakage<<byanamountthatreducestheTosatisfyALARArequirements, measuredleakagemaybemeasuredindirectly (asfromtheperformance ofpressureindicators) ifaccomplished inaccordance withapprovedprocedures andsupported bycomputations showingthatthemethodiscapableofdemonstrating valvecompliance withtheleakagecriteria.
Specification 3.4.6.2.e isapplicable withaveragepressurewithin20psiofthenominalfullpressurevalue.COOKNUCLEARPLANTUNIT13/44-16AMENDYZNT NO.46&,+66,].78OrderdatedApril20,1981
~~~JVREACTORCOO~TSYSBASES34.4.5SEAMGENERATORS TUBEINTEGRITY TheSurveillance Requirements forinspection ofthesteamgenerator tubesensurethatthestructural integrity ofthisportionoftheRCSwill'bemaintained.
Theprogramforinservice inspection afsteamgenerator tubesi.sbasedonamodification ofRegulatory Guide1-83,Revision1.Znservice inspection ofsteamgenerator tubingisessential inordertomaintainsurveillance oftheconditions cifthetubesintheeventthatthereisevidenceofmechanical damageorprogressive degradation duetodesign,manufacturing errors,orinservice conditions thatleadtocorrosion.
Znservice inspection ofsteamgenerator tubingalsoprovidesameansofcharacterizing thenatureandcauseofanytubedegradation sothatcorrective measurescanbetaken.Theplantisexpectedtobeoperatedi.namannersuchthatthesecond-arycoolantwillbemaintained withinthosechemistry limitsfoundtornegligible corrosion ofthesteamgenezator tubes.Zfthesrycoolantchemistry i.snotmaintained withintheseparameter limitcalizedcorrosion maylikelyresultinstresscorrosion cracking.
Theentofcrackingduri.ngplantoperation wouldbelimitedbythelimi.onofsteamgenerator tubeleakagebetweentheprimarycoolantsystemesecondary coolantsystem.Theallowabeprimary-to-secondary leakts150gallonsperdaypersteamgenerator foronefuelcycle(Cycle.Axialorcircumferent'ally orientedcackshavingaprimary-.to-secondary leakagelessthanthislimitduringoperation willhaveanadequatemarginofsafetyto.'withstand theloadsimposedduringnormaloperation andbypostulated accidents.
Leakageinexcessofthislimitwillrequireplantshutdownandaninspection, duringwhichtheleakingtubeswillbelocatedandpluggedorrepaired.
Asteamgeneatorwhileundergoing creviceflushinginMade4isavailable fordecayheatremovalandisoperable/operating uponreinstatement ofauxiliary ormainfeedflowcontrolandsearncontrol.Wastage-type defectsareunlikelywiththeallvolatiletreatment (AVT)ofsecondaycoolant.However,evenifadefectofsimilartypeshoulddevelopinservice,itwillbefoundduringscheduled inservice steamgenerator tubeexaminations.
Pluggingorsleevingwillberequiredforalltubeswithimperfecionsexceeding
.therepairlimitwhichisdefinedinSpecification 4.4.5.4.a.
Steamgenerator tubeinspections ofoperating plantshavedemonstrated thecapability toreliablydetectdegradation thathaspenetrated 20%oftheoriginaltubewallthi.ckness.
Tubesexperiencing outerdiameterstresscorrosion crackingwithi.nthethickness ofthetubesupportplatesarepluggedorrepairedbythecriteriaof4.4.5.4.a.10.COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT1B3/44-2aAYENDMENT NO.403,@Seesk66s178
~~~~~,~Ie REACTORCOOLANTSYSTEMBASESMaintaining anoperatileakagelimit,of150gpdpersteamgenerator (600gpdtotal)forFuelcycle4willminimizethepotential foralargeleakageevent,duringsteamlinezeakunderLocAconditions.
BasedontheNDEuncertainties, bobbincoilvoltagedistribution andcrackgrowthratefromthepreviousi.nspection, theexpectedleakratefollowing asteamlineruptureislimitedtobelow12.6gpmwhichwi.lllimitthecalculated offsitedosestowithin10percentof10CFR100guidelines.
Leakageintheintactloopsislimitedto150gpd.Zftheprojected endofcycledistribution ofcrackindications esultsinprimary-to-secondary leakagegreaterthan12.6gpminthefaultedloopduringapostulated steamlinebreakevent,additional tubesmustberemovedfromserviceinordertoreducethepostulated primary-to-secondazy steamlinebreakleakagetobelow12.6gpm.PRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGEofanymagnitude i.sunacceptable sinceitmaybeindicative ofanimpending grossfailureofthepressureboundary.
ShouldPRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGEoccurthroughacomponent whichcanbeisolatedfromthebalanceoftheReactorCoolantSystem,plantoperation maycontinueprovidedtheleakingcomponent ispromptlyisolatedfromtheReactorCoolantSystemsinceisolation removesthesourceofpotential failure.TheSurveillance Requirements forRCSpzessureIsolation Valvesprovideaddedassurance ofvalveintegrity therebyreducingtheprobability ofgrossvalvefailureandconsequent intersystem LOCA.LeakagefromtheRCSPressureIsolation ValvesisIDENTIFZED LEAKAGEandwillbeconsidered asaportionoftheallowedlim'it.34.4.7CH=MZSTRY Thelimitations onReactorCoolantSystemchemi.stry ensurethatcorzosion oftheReactorCoolantSystemisminimized andreducesthepotent'al forReactorCoolantSystemleakageorfailureduetostresscorrosion.
Maintaining thechemistry withintheSteadyStateLimitsprovidesadequatecorrosion protection toensurethestructural integrity oftheReactorcoolantSystemovertheli.feoftheplant.Theassociated effectsofexceedi.ng theoxygen,chlor:de, andfluoridelimitsaretimeandtemperature dependent.
Corrosion studiesshowthatoperation maybecontinued withcontaminant concentration levelsinexcessoftheSteadyStateLimits,uptotheTransient Limits,forthespecified limitedtimein"ervals withouthavingasi.gnificant, effect.onthestzuctural integrity oftheReactorCoolantSystem.Thetimeintervalpermitting continued operation withintherestrictions oftheTransient Limitsprovidestimefortakingcorrective actionstorestorethecontaminant concentrations towithintheSteadyStateLimits.COOKNUCLEARPLANTUNIT1B3/44-4AHENDHENT NO88g%44q178
~i'~~J~ATTACHMENT 3TOAEP:NRC:1166$
PROPOSEDREVISEDTECHNICAL SPECIFICATION PAGES r~~r EACTORCOOLANTSYSTSURVEILLANCE REUIREMENTS Contnued2.3.Tubesinthoseareaswhereexperience hasindicated poCential problems.
Atubeinspection (pursuant CoSpecification4.4.5.4.a.
8)shallbeperformed oneachselectedtube.Ifanyselectedtubedoesnotpermitthepassageoftheeddycurrentprobeforatubeinspection, thisshallberecordedandanadjacenttubeshallbeselectedandsubjected toatubeinspection.
c~Inadditiontothesamplerequiredin4.4.5.2.b.l through3,alltubeswhichhavehadtheWcriteriaappliedwillbeinspected intherollexpandedregion.Therollexpandedregionofthesetubesmaybeexcludedfromtherequirements of4.4.5.2.b.l.
d.Thetubesselectedasthesecondandthirdsamples(ifrequiredbyTable4.4-2)duringeachinservice inspection maybesubjected toapartialtubeinspection provided:
Thetubesselectedforthesamplesincludethetubesfromthoseareasofthetubesheetarraywheretubeswithimperfections werepreviously found.2.Theinspections includethoseportionsofthetubeswhereimperfections werepreviously found.e.Implementation ofthesteamgenerator tube/tube supportplateinterimpluggingcriteriaforonefue1cycle(Cycle15)requiresa100%bobbincoilinspection forhotlegCubesupportplateintersections andcoldlegintersections downtothelowestcoldlegtubesupportplatewithknownouterdiameterstresscorrosion cracking(ODSCC)indications.
~Theresultsofeachsampleinspection shallbeclassified intooneofthefollowing threecategories:
Cate~ox~C-lC-2C-3InsectonResultsLessthan5%ofthetotaltubesinspected aredegradedtubesandnoneoftheinspected tubesaredefective.
Oneormoretubes,butnotmorethan1%ofthetotaltubesinspected aredefective, orbetween5Sand10$ofthetotaltubesinspected aredegradedtubes.Morethan10%ofthetotaltubesinspected aredegradedtubesormorethan1$oftheinspected tubesaredefective.
COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT13/44-8AMENDMENT NO.'OS,454,446,477-,
EACTORCOOLANTSYSTEMSSURVEILLANCE REUIREMENTS Continued b.c~Thesteamgenerator shallbedetermined OPERABLEaftercompleting thecorresponding actions(plugging orsleevingalltubesexceeding therepairlimitandalltubescontaining through-wall cracks)requiredbyTable4.4-2.Steamgenerator tuberepairsmaybemadeinaccordance withthemethodsdescribed ineitherWCAP-12623 orCEN-313-P.
4.4.5.5R~eortsa.b.Following eachinservice inspection ofsteamgenerator tubes,ifthereareanytubesrequiring pluggingorsleeving, thenumberoftubespluggedorsleevedineachsteamgenerator shallbereportedtotheCommission within15days.Thecompleteresultsofthesteamgenerator tubeinservice inspection shallbeincludedintheAnnualOperating Reportfortheperiodinwhichthisinspection wascompleted.
Thisreportshallinclude:l.Numberandextentoftubesinspected.
2.Locationandpercentofwall-thickness penetration foreachindication ofanimperfection.
C.d.e.3.Identification oftubespluggedorsleeved.Resultsofsteamgenerator tubeinspections whichfallintoCategoryC-3andrequirepromptnotification oftheCommission shallbereportedpursuanttoSpecification 6.9.1priortoresumption ofplantoperation.
Thewrittenfollowupofthisreportshallprovideadescription ofinvestigations conducted todetermine causeofthetubedegradation andcorrective measurestakentopreventrecurrence.
Theresultsofinspections performed under4.4.5.2foralltubesinwhichthetubesupportplateinterimpluggingcriteriahasbeenappliedshallbereportedtotheCommission within15daysfollowing theinspection.
Thereportshallinclude'.
1.Listingofapplicable tubes.2.Location(applicable intersections pertube)andextentofdegradation (voltage).
Theresultsofsteamlinebreakleakageanalysisperformed underT/S4.4.5.4.a.l0 willbereportedtotheCommission priortorestartforCycle15.COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT13/44-12AMENDMENT NO.403,446,477, r~p04~&4.
CTORC0SYSOPERATIONAL LEAKAGEIMTINGCONDITION OROPERATION 3.4.6.2ReactorCoolantSystemleakageshallbelimitedto:a.b.c~d.e.NoPRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGE,1GPMUNIDENTIFIED LEDGE,600gallonsperdaytotalprimary-to-secondary leakagethroughallsteamgenerators and150gallonsperdaythroughanyonesteam.generator forFuelCycle15,10GPMIDENTIFIED LEAKAGEfromtheReactorCoolantSystem,Seallineresistance greaterthanorequalto2.27E-1ft/gpm~and,1GPMleakagefromanyreactorcoolantsystempressureisolation valvespecified inTable3.4-0.~ACTI0a.b.C.WithanyPRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGE,beinatleastHOTSTANDBYwithin6hoursandinCOLDSHUTDOWNwithinthefollowing 30hours.WithanyReactorCoolantSystemleakagegreaterthananyoneoftheabovelimits,excluding PRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGE,reducetheleakageratetowithin,limitswithin4hoursorbeinatleastHOTSTANDBYwithinthenext6hoursandinCOLDSHUTDOWNwithinthefollowing 30hours.Withanyreactorcoolantsyst:empressureisolation valve(s)leakagegreaterthantheabovelimit,exceptwhen:1.,Theleakageislessthanorequalto5.0gpm,and2.Themostrecentmeasuredleakagedoesnotexceedthepreviousmeasuredleakage*byanamountthatreducestheTosatisfyALARArequirements, measuredleakagemaybemeasuredindirectly (asfromtheperformance ofpressureindicators) ifaccomplished inaccordance withapprovedprocedures andsupported bycomputations showingthatthemethodiscapableofdemonstrating valvecompliance wi.ththeleakagecriteria.
Specification 3.4.6.2.e isapplicable withaveragepressurewi.thin20psiofthenominalfullpressurevalue.COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT13/44-16AMENDMENT NO.462,466,~OrderdatedApri.l20,1981 I~~r(tV"tt~I'P,l EACORCOOSYSTBASES3445STEAMGENERATORS TUBEINTEGRITY TheSurveillance Requirements forinspection ofthesteamgenerator.
tubesensurethatthestructural integrity ofthisportionoftheRCSwillbemaintained.
Theprogramforinservice inspection ofsteamgenerator tubesisbasedonamodification ofRegulatory Guide1.83,Revision1.Inservice inspection ofsteamgenerator tubingisessential inordertomaintainsurveillance oftheconditions ofthetubesintheeventthatthereisevidenceofmechanical damageorprogressive degradation duetodesign,manufacturing errors,orinservice conditions thatleadtocorrosion.
Inservice inspection oRsteamgenerator tubingalsoprovidesameansofcharacterizing thenatureandcauseofanytubedegradation sothatcorrective measurescanbetaken.Theplantisexpectedtobeoperatedinamannersuchthatthesecond-arycoolantwillbemaintained withinthosechemistry limitsfoundtoresultinnegligible corrosion ofthesteamgenerator tubes.Ifthesecondary coolantchemistry isnotmaintained withintheseparameter limits,localized corrosion maylikelyresultinstresscorrosion cracking.
Theextentofcrackingduringplantoperation wouldbelimitedbythelimitation ofsteamgenerator tubeleakagebetweentheprimarycoolantsystemandthesecondary coolantsystem.Theallowabeprimary-to-secondary leakrateis150gallonsperdaypersteamgenerator foronefuelcycle(Cycle15).Axialorcircumferentia'ily orientedcrackshavingaprimary>>to-secondary leakagelessthanthislimitduringoperation willhaveanadequatemarginofsafetytowithstand theloadsimposedduringnormaloperation andbypostulated accidents.
'eakageinexcessofthislimitwillrequireplantshutdownandaninspection, duringwhichtheleakingtubeswillbelocatedandpluggedorrepaired.
Asteamgenerator whileundergoing creviceflushinginMode4isavailable fordecayheatremovalandisoperable/operating uponreinstatement ofauxiliary ormainfeedflowcontrolandsteamcontrol.Wastage-type defectsareunlikelywiththeallvolatiletreatment (AVT)ofsecondary coolant.However,evenifadefectofsimilartypeshoulddevelopinservice,itwillbefoundduringscheduled inservice steamgenerator tubeexaminations.
Pluggingorsleevingwillberequiredfora'lltubeswithimperfections exceeding therepairlimitwhichisdefinedinSpecification 4.0.5.4.a.
Steamgenerator tubeinspections ofoperating plantshavedemonstrated thecapability toreliablydetectdegradation thathaspenetrated 20%oftheoriginaltubewallthickness.
Tubesexperiencing outerdiameterstresscorrosion crackingwithinthethickness ofthetubesupportplatesarepluggedorrepairedbythecriteriaof4.4.5.4.a.lO.
COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT1B3/44-2aAMENDMENT NO.403,454,446,~
p(lgoi,I4~~sym REACTORCOOLANTSYSTEMBASESMaintaining anoperating leakagelimitof150gpdpersteamgenerator (600gpdtotal)forFuelCycle15willminimizethepotential foralargeleakageeventduringsteamlinebreakunderLOCAconditions.
BasedontheNDEuncertainties, bobbincoilvoltagedistribution andcrackgrowthratefromthepreviousinspection, theexpectedleakratefollowing asteamlineruptureislimitedtobelow12.6gpmwhichwilllimitthecalculated offsitedosestowithin10percentof10CFR100guidelines.
Leakageintheintactloopsislimitedto150gpd.Iftheprojected endofcycledistribution ofcrackindications resultsinprimary-to-secondary leakagegreaterthan12.6gpminthefault'edloopduringapostulated steamlinebreakevent,additional tubesmustberemovedfromserviceinordertoreducethepostulated primary-to-secondary steamlinebreakleakagetobelow12.6gpm.PRESSUREBOUNDARYLEAKAGEofanymagnitude isunacceptable sinceitmaybeindicative ofanimpending grossfailureofthepressureboundary.
ShouldPRESSUREBOUNDARYLEDGEoccurthroughacomponent whichcanbeisolatedfromthebalanceoftheReactorCoolantSystem,plantoperation maycontinueprovidedtheleakingcomponent ispromptlyisolatedfromtheReactorCoolantSystemsinceisolation removesthesourceofpotential failure.TheSurveillance Requirements forRCSPressureIsolation Valvesprovideaddedassurance ofvalveintegrity therebyreducingtheprobability ofgrossvalve'failure andconsequent intersystem LOCA.LealcagefromtheRCSPressureIsolation ValvesisIDENTIFIED LEAKAGEandwillbeconsidered asaportionoftheallowedlimit.3447CHEMISTRY Thelimitations onReactorCoolantSystemchemistry ensurethatcorrosion oftheReactorCoolantSystemisminimized andreducesthepotential forReactorCoolantSystemleakageorfailureduetostresscorrosion.
Maintaining thechemistry withintheSteadyStateLimitsprovidesadequatecorrosion protection toensurethestructural integrity oftheReactorCoolantSystemoverthelifeoftheplant.Theassociated effectsofexceeding theoxygen,chloride, andfluoridelimitsaretimeandtemperature dependent.
Corrosion studiesshowthatoperation maybecontinued withcontaminant concentration levelsinexcessoftheSteadyStateLimits,uptotheTransient Limits,'for thespecified limitedtimeintervals withouthavingasignificant effectonthestructural integrity oftheReactorCoolantSystem.Thetimeintervalpermitting continued operation withintherestrictions oftheTransient Limitsprovidestimefortakingcorrective actionstorestorethecontaminant concentrations towithintheSteadyStateLimits.COOKNUCLEARPLANT-UNIT1B3/44-4AMENDMENT NO.53,444,~
~,r~~ll