ML18037A054

From kanterella
Revision as of 21:46, 1 May 2018 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Comments Based on Review of NRC Jul 1984 Des (NUREG-1085) Re Operation of Facility.Recommends That Concerns Be Incorporated Into Fes
ML18037A054
Person / Time
Site: Nine Mile Point Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 10/11/1984
From: CONCRA L M
NEW YORK, STATE OF
To: SCHWENCER A
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RTR-NUREG-1085 NUDOCS 8410180228
Download: ML18037A054 (14)


Text

NewYorkStateDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation50WolfRoad,Albany,NewYork12233-0001HenryG,WllliamsCommissionerOctober11,1984Mr.AlbertSchwencer,ChiefLicensingBranch42Divis'ionofLicensingU.S.NuclearRegulatoryCommissionWashington,D.C.20555

DearMr.Schwencer:

Re:DraftEnvironmentalImpactStatement:OperationofNineMilePointNuclearStation,UnitNo.2TheattachedcommentsarebasedonreviewbytheappropriateNewYorkStateAgenciesoftheU.S.NuclearRegulatoryCommission'sJuly1984DraftEnvironmentalImpactStatementrelatedtotheoperationofNineMilePointNuclearStation,UnitNo.2(DocketNo.50-410,NUREG-1085).WerecommendincorporationofourconcernsintotheFinalEnvironmentalImpactStatement.ThankyoufortheopportunitytocommentonyourDraftEnvironmentalImpactStatement.Sicerelyyours,LouisM.Concra,Jr.,DirectorDivisionofRegulatoryAffairsLMC/kwcc:SeeDistributionListL.Marsh~6302288410iiQCK050004i0PDRADPDRD>Cy'-/I0gO

Commentsofthe.StateofNewYorkontheU.S.Nuc'learReulatorCommission'sDraftEnvironmentalmactStatementDEISRelatedtotheerationofNineMilePointNuclearStationUnitNo.2Octoberll,19842~Section5.3.1indicatesthatonly1,000gallonsperdayofCityofOswegowaterwillbeneededatthefacilityforpotableandsanitarypurposes.Thisfigureseemsverylow.ThesanitarywastewatertreatmentplantatNineMilePoi.ntNo.1typicallydischargesover10,000gallonsperday,andthenew.wastewatertreatmentplantforNineMilePoint1andNineMilePoint2hasadesignaverageflowof120,000gallonsperday.Thediscrepanciesinthesefiguresshouldbeexplained.Dieselenginesgreaterthan400horsepowermustobtainconstructionandoperationpermitspursuanttoNYCRR201.NiagaraMohawkshouldsubmitalistofalldieselenginesandtheirsizestotheDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation,Region.7office,P.O.Box5170,FisherAvenue,Cortland,NY13045(Attention:Mr.AllanCoburn).3~Section5.3.2:Thewaterqualitycertificationshouldberevisedtoreflectalimitof.005milligramsperliterresidualchlorinebecauseoftheabundanceofsalmonoidsaroundtheeffluent.4~5.Section5.5.1:TheEISshouldincludefurtherdiscussionofthepoten-tialforbirdstrikesonthecoolingtowerandpotentialmitigationmeasures.Thereshouldfirstbeabirdcollisionmonitoringprogramtodeterminewhethermitigationwouldbenecessary.Applicantshouldcon-tacttheNYStateDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation(addressabo-ve)toobtainaScientificCollectorsLicenseforsuchaprogram.Theresultsofthestudyshouldalsobesenttothatoffice.TheEmergencyPreparednesssection5.9.4.4(3)shouldincludelocalfivedistricts,ambulances,andemergencyservices,sincetheywouldbedirectlyinvolvedinanemergency.6.TheEISshoulddiscussthemodeoftransportationandrouteswhichwillbeusedtodisposeofnuclearwastes.7.Therewasnot.discussionabouttrafficmanagementrelatingtotheopera-tionofthestationinthecompletedphase.8.SpecificdetailsoftheemergencyevacuationplansshouldbeincludedintheEIS,includingtransportationimpacts.Thesummaryshouldincorporatetransportationeffects.9.TheapplicantshouldcontacttheNew.YorkStateDepartmentofTransportationRegionalOfficeinSyracusetosatisfyanypermitrequire-mentsrelatedtotransportation.Theaddressis:VMr.RichardA.LucasRegionalPlanningEngineerNYSDepartmentofTransportation333EastWashingtonStreetSyracuse,NewYork13202(315)428-4409 1

'j4+Ci~~UNIT2DEISEDITORIALCOHifENTSl.Onpageiii,line3,"Environment"shouldread"Environmental",andonline5,"Nuclea"shouldread"Nuclear".2.Onpagev,section(2),line13,"PowerAuthorityoftheStateofllewYork"shouldread"NewYorkPowerAuthority".3.Onpagev,section(3),line1,"Nuclear"shouldbeinsertedbetween"Point"and"Station".4.Onpagevi,section(5)(a),line3,"Thewithdrawalofwaterwithdrawals"shouldread"thewithdrawalofwater".6.OnpagebetweenOnpageline3,.vii,section(5)(d),line6,"to"shouldbeinserted"parallel"and"existing".xv,section(4),line7,andpagel-l,footnote.""-,"Pennfield"shouldbe"Penfield".7.Onpage1-2,paragraph4,line6,"relationg"shouldread"relating".Onpage4-2,line1,"PowerAuthorityoftheStateofNewYork"shouldread"HewYorkPowerAuthority".9.Onpage4-5,paragraph4,line5,"operator"shouldread'operation".10.Onpage4-7,section4.2.7,line12,"23-mby151-m"shouldread"23-mby15.1-km".ll.Onpage4-10,paragraph3,line1,"geneneral"shouldread"general".12.Onpage4-13,section4.3.4.1,line.8,"Tables4.1and4.2"shouldread"Tables4.1and4.4".13.Onpage4-14,section4.3.4'.1,paragraph2,line3,thereference"(1977,1981and1981)"shouldread"(1977,1981,and1982)".14.Onpage4-27,Table46,"Bartramialonicauda"shouldread"Bartramialongicauda","Chilidoniasnigra"shouldread"Chlidoniasniger",and"Pooecetesgraminens"shouldread"Pooecetesgramineus".15.Onpage5-9,line7,"(Lawler,HatuskyandSkelly,1983)'houldread"Lawler,HatuskyandSkelly,1984".

0e 16.Onpage5-10,Section5.5.2.2,line13,"condusions"shouldread"conclusions".17.Onpage5-15,paragraph3,line4,andparagraph4,line15,"Effluent"shouldbeinsertedbetween"Radiological"and"Technical".18.Onpage5-17,paragraph5,line5,"eachunitat"shouldberemoved.19.Onpage5-31,line4,"security"shouldread"severity".20.Onpage5-37,line2,"HiiP-1,NHP-2"shouldbeinsertedbetween"around"and"andtheadjacentFitzpatrickunits.'1.Onpage5-44,paragraph3,line1,areferencetoTable5-11ismade.ThereferenceshouldbetoTable5-12.22.Onpage8-1.,line11,"Envronmental"shouldread"Environmental".23.InAppendixD,TableD-l,"Ru-103m"shouldread"Ru-103".24.InAppendixD,page1,paragraph5,lines4-5,"62m"shouldread"61m"and"9.lm"should.read"8m".,25.InAppendixD,page2,paragraph6,line4,anincorrectreferencetoTableD-9isprovided.ThereisnoTableD-9.TheproperreferenceisTableD-8.26.OnthecoversheetforAppendixF,line2,"with"shouldread'within'.27.InAppendixF,apaginationerrorexists.Theorderofpages4and5shouldbereversed.28.InAppendixJ,page1,line8,"ciscok"shouldread"cisco".29.InAppendixJ,page1,line11,"NineHilePointUnits2and3willbelocated"shouldread"Ninei~iilePointUnits1and2are'ocated".30.OnthetitlepageforAppendixK,"HIAGARA"shouldread""iI=AGARA" re eARReerl4pA.nglOOIP+)i*++DOCKETNo.50-410UNITEDSTATESUCLEARREGULATORYCOMMISCRVNWASHINGTON,D,C.20555gUG301984Dist:7DocketFileLB)II2ReadingE.HyltonM.HaugheyC.Miles,PAMEMORANDUMFOR:DocketingandServiceBranchOfficeoftheSecretaryoftheCommissionFROM:

SUBJECT:

.OfficeofNuclearReactorRegulationNiagaraMohawkPowerCorporation-NineMilePointNuclearStation,UnitHo.2OnesignedoriginaloftheFederalRegisterNoticeidentifiedbelowisenclosedforyourtransmittaltotheOfficeoftheFederalRegisterforpublicatiori.Additionalconformedcopies(6)oftheNoticeareenclosedforyouruse.NoticeofReceiptofApplicationforConstructionPermit(s)andOperatingLicense(s).NoticeofReceiptofPartialApplicationforConstructionPermit(s)andFacilityLicense(s):TimeforSubmissionofViewsonAntitrustMatters.NoticeofConsiderationofIssuanceofAmendmenttoFacilityOperatingLicense.NoticeofReceiptofApplicationforFacilityLicense(s);NoticeofAvailabilityofApplicant'sEnvironmentalReport;andNoticeofConsiderationofIssuanceofFacilityLicense(s)andNoticeofOpportunityforMearing.53NoticeofAvailabilityofNRCDraft/FinalEnvironmentalStatement.ClNoticeofLimitedWorkAuthorization.NoticeofAvailabilityofSafetyEvaluationReport.NoticeofIssuanceofConstructionPermit(s).NoticeofIssuanceofFacilityOperatingLicense(s)orAmendment(s).Order.Exemption.NoticeofGrantingofRelief.Other:OfficeofNuclearReactorRegulationADVANCECOPYOFNUREG-1085SENITOPDR8/9/84.EnQJQ@EPUBLISHINFEDERALROISTERONAUGUST17,1984TOCOINCIDEWITHEPANOTICE.AsstatedOirtCE)SURNAME)DATE)DL/Lak......MRQok-81/8,-C(ag.85chwencex8/P/84.OFFICIALRECORDCOPY itl,~R1RERdd,t,Id'I.~Rt111=~I~t'Id*IIlth 7590-01UNITEDSTATESNUCLEARREGULATORYCONHISSIONDOCKETNO.50-410NIAGARAY)OHAWKPOWERCORPORATIONNOTICEOFAVAILABILITYOFTHEDRAFTENVIRONt1ENTALSTATEMENTFORNINEtlILEPOINTNUCLEARSTATION,UNIT2PursuanttotheNationalEnvironmentalPolicyActof1969andtheUnitedStatesNuclearRegulatoryCommission'sregulationsin10CFRPart51,noticeisherebygiventhataDraftEnvironmentalStatement'(NUREG-1085)hasbeenpreparedbytheCommission'sOfficeofNuclearReactorRegulationrelatedtotheproposedoperationoftheNinehlilePointNuclearStation,Unit2locatedonthesoutheastshoreofLakeOntarioinScriba,OswegoCounty,NewYork.TheDraftEnvironmentalStateme'nt(DES)addressestheaquatic,terrestrial,radiological,socialandeconomicimpactsassociatedwithnormalstationoperation.Stationaccidents,theirlikelihoodofoccurrenceandtheirconsequences,includingsevereaccidents,areaddressedinSection5.9ofthisstatement.CopiesofNUREG-1085areavailableforinspectionbythepublicintheCommission'sPublicDocumentRoomat1717HStreet,N.W.,Washington,D.C.20555,andatthePennfieldLibrary,StateUniversityCollege,Oswego,NewYork13126.ThedocumentisalsobeingmadeavailableattheStateClearinghouse,NewYorkStateDivisionoftheBudget,StateCapitol,Albany,NewYork12224.AfreesinglecopyofDraftNUREG-1085,totheextentofsupply,mayberequestedforpubliccommentbywritingtothePublicationServicesSection,DocumentManagementBranch,DivisionofTechnicalInformationandDocumentControl,U.S.NuclearRegulatoryConmission,Washington,D.C.20555.

7590-01-2-InterestedpersonsmaysubmitcommentsonthisDESfortheComnission'sconsideration.Federal,State,andspecifiedlocalagenciesarebeingprovidedwithcopiesoftheDES.Otherlocalagenciesmayobtainthesedocumentsuponrequest.CommentsbyFederalStateandlocalofficials,orothermembersofthepublicreceivedbytheCommissionwillbemadeavailableforpublicinspectionattheCommission'sPublicDocumentRoominWashington,D.C.andthePennfieldLibrary,StateUniversityCol1ege,Oswego,NewYork.CommentsareduebyOctober-l,1984AfterconsiderationofthecommentssubmittedontheDES,theCommission'sstaffwillprepareaFinalEnvironmentalStatement,theavailabilityofwhichbpblihdtvth~Fd1RCommentsonthe.DraftEnvironmentalStatementfrominterestedmembersofthepublicshouldbeaddressedtotheU.S.NuclearRegulatoryCommission,Washington,D.C.20555,Attention:Director,DivisionofLicensing.~-'.J(:..DatedatBethesda,MarylandthisJ,dayof.<..,=1984.ImFORTHENUCLEARREGULATORYCOt'1NISSIONg/g~p~kg~ggcZc~'AlbertSchwencer,ChiefLicensingBranchNo.2DivisionofLicensing

/,g