|
---|
Category:LICENSEE EVENT REPORT (SEE ALSO AO RO)
MONTHYEARML20203L0281986-04-25025 April 1986 Informs of Planned Site Visit to Obtain Info Supporting Implementation of Emergency Response Data Sys,Including Availability of PWR or BWR Parameters in Digital Form & Characterization of Available Data Feed Points 05000237/LER-1983-084, Updated LER 83-084/03X-1:on 831230,during Normal Operation, Primary Containment Oxygen Sample from Torus Alarmed on Low Level Sample Flow.Caused by Sample Line Moisture.Line Drained & Leads reconnected.W/840314 Ltr1984-03-14014 March 1984 Updated LER 83-084/03X-1:on 831230,during Normal Operation, Primary Containment Oxygen Sample from Torus Alarmed on Low Level Sample Flow.Caused by Sample Line Moisture.Line Drained & Leads reconnected.W/840314 Ltr 05000237/LER-1983-080, Supplemental LER 83-080/03X-1:on 831124,offgas Log Rad Monitor 2-1705-A Delivered Offgas High Alarm & High Alarm Spiked & Drifted Downscale.Caused by Burned Out Resistor. Power Supply Installed & Monitor Calibr1983-12-20020 December 1983 Supplemental LER 83-080/03X-1:on 831124,offgas Log Rad Monitor 2-1705-A Delivered Offgas High Alarm & High Alarm Spiked & Drifted Downscale.Caused by Burned Out Resistor. Power Supply Installed & Monitor Calibr ML20081M2021983-11-0202 November 1983 83-037/03L-0:on 831005,during Daily Battery Surveillance, 250-volt Battery Charger Float Voltage Indicated Improper Float Voltage.Caused by Defective Amplifier Board.Defective Board Replaced 05000237/LER-1982-023, Revised Deviation Rept for LER 82-023/03L-0:on 820623, Wrong Assumption Made for Drywell to Torus Differential Pressure.Caused by High Torus Pressure Transmitter 2-1673 Measurement1982-07-23023 July 1982 Revised Deviation Rept for LER 82-023/03L-0:on 820623, Wrong Assumption Made for Drywell to Torus Differential Pressure.Caused by High Torus Pressure Transmitter 2-1673 Measurement ML20147A9091978-09-0808 September 1978 /03L on 780821:during Survey,Dis 250-1,MSL Hi Flow Isolation Switch Psid 3-261-2C Tripped at 135.5 Psid.Caused by Bent Indicator Pointer Dragging Across Face Plate Prohibiting Proper Oper.(Encl to 7809220139) ML20147A9051978-09-0808 September 1978 /03L-0 on 780908:steam Leaking from Ventrom Vent Line.Caused by Cracked Weld.Repaired by Welding Externally. (Encl to 7809220138) ML20147A8941978-09-0808 September 1978 /03L on 780817:room Cooler Fans Failed to Start When Pumps 3B & 3C started.4KV Switchgear 33 & 34 Auxiliary Contacts Were Found Dirty.(Encl to 7809220129) ML20147A7211978-09-0808 September 1978 /01X-1 on 780320:Cracks Found on end-to-pipe Weld on CRD Return Line.Caused by Intermittent to Low Cooling Water Flow Leaving the CRD Nozzle.Pipe Was Removed & Replaced. (Encl to 7809180035) ML20147A7361978-09-0707 September 1978 /01T-0 on 780824:Unit 2 Diesel Failed W/ Diesel Generators 2 & 3 Out of Serv Because Pinion Gear on an Air Start Motor Did Not Engage W/ Diesel Ring Gear.Air Start Motor Replaced. (Encl to 7809180225) ML20147A7891978-08-25025 August 1978 /01X-1 on 780428:During Unit 2 Startup Opers, a LPCI & Core Spray Subsys Were Inadvertantly Rendered Inoper Because Personnel Had Closed LPCI Pump & Discharge Valves on Unit 2 Vice 3.(Encl to 7809180320) 05000237/LER-1950-237, Updated LER 50-237/75-048:on 751007,through-wall Crack Found in Drywell/Torus Nitrogen Purge Line 1604-18.Addl Mods, Including Temp Controlled Isolation Valve Installation, Delayed Until Proposal Review1977-06-10010 June 1977 Updated LER 50-237/75-048:on 751007,through-wall Crack Found in Drywell/Torus Nitrogen Purge Line 1604-18.Addl Mods, Including Temp Controlled Isolation Valve Installation, Delayed Until Proposal Review 05000237/LER-1976-066, Updated LER 76-066/01T-1:on 761113,during Maint Outage,Hpci Injection Valve M02-23018 Found in Closed Position W/Valve Stem Severed.Caused by Mechanical Overstress of Stem.Stem Replaced1977-05-13013 May 1977 Updated LER 76-066/01T-1:on 761113,during Maint Outage,Hpci Injection Valve M02-23018 Found in Closed Position W/Valve Stem Severed.Caused by Mechanical Overstress of Stem.Stem Replaced 05000237/LER-1976-063, Updated LER 76-063/03L-l:on 761003,stack Gas Sample Pump Flow Appeared Abnormally Low.Caused by Collection of Carbon Impeller Vane Products in Pump Cavity & Filter.Pump & Filter Replaced1977-03-0303 March 1977 Updated LER 76-063/03L-l:on 761003,stack Gas Sample Pump Flow Appeared Abnormally Low.Caused by Collection of Carbon Impeller Vane Products in Pump Cavity & Filter.Pump & Filter Replaced 05000237/LER-1976-053, Updated LER 76-053/01T-1:on 760803,util Advised by GE That MAPLHGR Limits in Effect No Longer Considered Sufficiently Conservative at Low Core Flow Rates.Problem Thought to Be ECCS Models Used to Determine Rates1977-01-0303 January 1977 Updated LER 76-053/01T-1:on 760803,util Advised by GE That MAPLHGR Limits in Effect No Longer Considered Sufficiently Conservative at Low Core Flow Rates.Problem Thought to Be ECCS Models Used to Determine Rates 05000000/LER-1950-237, Updated LER 50-237/01L:on 760406,unacceptable Ultrasonic Indication Found on Isolation Condenser safe-end.Caused by Cracks in safe-ends.Cracked safe-end Removed & Sent to Bmcl for Metallographic Analysis1976-07-13013 July 1976 Updated LER 50-237/01L:on 760406,unacceptable Ultrasonic Indication Found on Isolation Condenser safe-end.Caused by Cracks in safe-ends.Cracked safe-end Removed & Sent to Bmcl for Metallographic Analysis 1986-04-25
[Table view] Category:TEXT-SAFETY REPORT
MONTHYEARML20249C8491999-09-30030 September 1999 1999 Third Quarter Rept of Completed Changes,Tests & Experiments Evaluated,Per 10CFR50.59(b)(2), for Dresden Nuclear Power Station. with ML20217A1691999-09-22022 September 1999 Part 21 Rept Re Engine Sys,Inc Controllers,Manufactured Between Dec 1997 & May 1999,that May Have Questionable Soldering Workmanship.Caused by Inadequate Personnel Training.Sent Rept to All Nuclear Customers ML20210R6081999-07-31031 July 1999 Monthly Operating Repts for July 1999 for Dresden Nuclear Power,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20209E1291999-06-30030 June 1999 Monthly Operating Repts for June 1999 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20209J3481999-06-30030 June 1999 1999 Second Quarter Rept of Completed Changes,Tests & Experiments, Per 10CFR50.59.With ML20210D3071999-06-30030 June 1999 Corrected Page 8 to MOR for June 1999 for DNPS Unit 3 ML20195G6381999-05-31031 May 1999 Monthly Operating Repts for May 1999 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20195B2591999-05-19019 May 1999 Rev 66a to CE-1-A,consisting of Proposed Changes to QAP for Dnps,Qcs,Znps,Lcs,Byron & Braidwood Stations ML20206N2821999-04-30030 April 1999 Monthly Operating Repts for Apr 1999 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20206B1901999-03-31031 March 1999 First Quarter Rept of Completed Changes,Tests & Experiments Per 10CFR50.59 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station. with ML20205N7491999-03-31031 March 1999 Monthly Operating Repts for Mar 1999 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20207M6921999-02-28028 February 1999 Monthly Operating Repts for Feb 1999 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20207E9311999-02-26026 February 1999 Part 21 Rept Re Sprague Model TE1302 Aluminum Electrolytic Capacitors with Date Code of 9322H.Caused by Aluminum Electrolytic Capacitors.Affected Capacitors Replaced ML20199M0891999-01-22022 January 1999 Part 21 Rept Re Failure of Square Root Converters.Caused by Failed Aluminum Electrolytic Capacitory Spargue Electric Co (Model Number TE1302 with Mfg Date Code 9322H).Sent Square Root Converters Back to Mfg,Barker Microfarads,Inc ML20199D3261998-12-31031 December 1998 10CFR50.59 SER for 1998-04 Quarter, of Changes,Tests & Experiments.With ML20199C8951998-12-31031 December 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Dec 1998 for Dnps,Units 1,2 & 3 ML20205M7061998-12-31031 December 1998 Unicom Corp 1998 Summary Annual Rept. with ML20197G8591998-11-30030 November 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Nov 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station.With ML20196A4191998-11-19019 November 1998 Safety Evaluation Accepting QA TR CE-1-A,Rev 66 Re Changes in Independent & Onsite Review Organization by Creating NSRB ML20196J0061998-11-19019 November 1998 Rev 66 to Topical Rept CE-1-A, QA Program ML20195D2861998-10-31031 October 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Oct 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station.With ML20154L3681998-09-30030 September 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Sept 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20154N4131998-09-30030 September 1998 1998 Third Quarter 10CFR50.59 Rept, for Dresden Nuclear Power Station of Completed Changes,Tests & Experiments ML20153C5061998-09-21021 September 1998 SER Accepting Qualified Unit 1 Supervisor Initial & Continuing Training Program for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Unit 1 ML20151Y2711998-08-31031 August 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Aug 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3.With ML20237E2331998-08-21021 August 1998 Revised Pages of Section 20 of Rev 66 to CE-1-A, QA Topical Rept ML20237A7161998-07-31031 July 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for July 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3 ML20236Q5851998-06-30030 June 1998 1998 Second Quarter 10CFR50.59 Rept, for Dresden Nuclear Power Station of Completed Changes,Tests & Experiments ML20236F8131998-06-30030 June 1998 Rev 0 to Defueled SAR Dresden Nuclear Power Station Unit 1 Commonwealth Edison Co ML20236T8331998-06-30030 June 1998 COLR for Dresden Station Unit 3,Cycle 15 ML20236T8391998-06-30030 June 1998 Rev 1 to EMF-96-141, Dresden Unit 3 Cycle 15 Reload Analysis Rept ML20236M6041998-06-30030 June 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for June 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3 ML20248M3021998-05-31031 May 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for May 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3 ML20248F3531998-05-21021 May 1998 Part 21 Rept Re Electronic Equipment Repaired or Reworked by Integrated Resources,Inc from Approx 930101-980501.Caused by 1 Capacitor in Each Unit Being Installed W/Reverse Polarity. Policy of Second Checking All Capacitors Is Being Adopted ML20247F3391998-04-30030 April 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Apr 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3 ML20217D0281998-04-22022 April 1998 Part 21 Rept Re Additive Constants Used in MCPR Determination for Siemens ATRIUM-9B Fuel by Core Monitoring Sys Were Found to Be non-conservative.SPC Personnel Notified All Customers w/ATRIUM-9B Lead Test Assemblies ML20216D4411998-03-31031 March 1998 First Quarter Rept of Completed Changes,Tests & Experiments for 10CFR5059 ML20216C9651998-03-31031 March 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Mar 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3 ML20216E2531998-02-28028 February 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Feb 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station ML20202F7831998-01-31031 January 1998 Monthly Operating Repts for Jan 1998 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station ML20199K1651998-01-23023 January 1998 Rev 65h to Topical Rept CE-1-A, Comm Ed QA Tr ML20198P5321997-12-31031 December 1997 Monthly Operating Repts for Dec 1997 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station ML20198P7021997-12-31031 December 1997 Fourth Quarter Rept of Completed Changes,Tests & Experiments Per 10CFR50.59 ML20216D3611997-12-31031 December 1997 Unicom Corp 1997 Summary Annual Rept ML20203F8781997-11-30030 November 1997 Monthly Operating Repts for Nov 1997 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station ML20199B0701997-10-31031 October 1997 Monthly Operating Repts for Oct 1997 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station ML20217H7201997-09-30030 September 1997 Monthly Operating Repts for Sept 1997 for Dresden Nuclear Power Station,Units 1,2 & 3 ML20210V2401997-09-19019 September 1997 Rev 65g to Topical Rept CE-1-A, Comm Ed QA Manual ML20216J3781997-08-31031 August 1997 Monthly Operating Repts for Aug 1997 for DNPS ML20210H5511997-07-31031 July 1997 Monthly Operating Repts for July 1997 for DNPS IAW RG 1.16 & GL 97-02 1999-09-30
[Table view] |
LER-2083-012, Updated LER 83-012/01X-1:on 830210,while Conducting Routine Mechanical Snubber Test,Main Steam Line Mechanical Snubbers 44,46,50,51 & 53 Found Inoperable.Thorough Investigation Revealed No Cause.Snubbers replaced.W/840302 Ltr |
Event date: |
|
---|
Report date: |
|
---|
2372083012R00 - NRC Website |
|
text
,CRO PCRM 386 U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATCOY COMMIS$10N
' ~
U P dated Report LICENSEE EVENT REPORT Previous report dated 3-9-83 CONTfCOL BLOCK: l i
l l l l l o
h (PLEASE P!lNT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED INPORMATION) -
17 o l 8t l9 l T l uCENsEE
- 1. l D CocE l R l S l 2 15l@l O ! 0 l -llicense i4 0 l 0l0 l0 l Ol- l0 l 025l@l28 4 l LICENSE NuMSER 1 l 1 ITYPE l l 1JOl@l57 CAT l 54 l@
CON'T I0I2I " 1"CE sou I L hl 0 l 510 l 010 l 2 l 3 68l 7 @l 0121 Il 0l'8l 374 @l013 l0 l 2 l 8 l480l@
$ 80 81 DOCK ET NUMB ER 69 EVENT QATE 75 REPCRT QATE EVENT DESCRIPTION AND PRO 8ASLE CONSEQUENCES h lo l2l l During Unit 2 refueling outage, while conducting routine mechanical snubber l f6oTTl I functional test (Tech. Spec. 4.6.I.2), Main Steam Line (MSL) mechanical snubbers l lo 141 1 44,46,50,51,53 were found to be inoperable. Safety significance is minimal because l 1oisl~l analysis showed that even without the snubbers, or with one snubber failed rigidly l lo is 1 l oer line. the piping stresses were less than vield stress. A similar event was l l o 171 l renorted by R.O. 82-16/03L on Docket 50-249. I l o is i l l T 8 9 80
' C$I[E To"o*! stSSCi!E couroNENT CODE st 8 CO'E s 33E lo191 7 8 l C ltoClh Wh Wh l S l U l P l 0 l Rl Tlh l D lh W h 9 11 12 13 18 19 20 SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE REPORT REVislON EVENT Y EAR REPQHT NO. CQQE TYPE No.
@ y*LER/RO E
g
, 21 l8 l3 l 22 l-l ,
23 l011l2l 24 28 y
27 10l1l 28 29
[XJ 30
[,,,,j 31
[1]
32 KN AC 0 0 P NT ME Hours s i Fom 8. sL Li MANuPAC RER L
33 cl@lx 34 1@ L2_J@ Izl@ 10101010 l 37 I rl@ IY l@ ~ l43A l@ l44P l 0 l 2 l 947l@
35 36 40 di 42 CAUSE OESCRIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS h '
g3 lol l The cause of snubber failure is not known even though a thorough investigation was ;
gl conducted. However, it was concluded that continued operation is justified. The ;
I: 12 I I defective snubbers have been replaced. Surveillances will continue per DTS 020-1 ;
i,i3gl and Technical Specification 4.'6.I. l L' J.4 J l I 7 8 9 80
's'TSY snowER ofwfR status @ 5EoEv' c scovfRy oEscRirTioN h 1 5 [g.j@ l0 l 0 l 0 l@l N/A l [.B.,,jhl Survei1 lance Test l
- dTiviTv CoSTENT mELEAsE LOCATION OF RELEASE @
Q*
d*@o
- emRELEAsa{Ql AMouNTOF N/A ACTIVITv l N/A@l l
- ERsoNNEL Exposures NuuSER DESCRIPTION IITil 1010 l0 lhlTYPEZlhl N/A l
- ER3cNNEL iNau' Ries NuM8ER oEsCRipticNh 7
1 3 8 9 l0l0l0lhl 11 12 N/A 30 l
LOSS OF OR DAMAGE TO FACILITY Q TYPE QEsCP'PTION %,,r
~
i 9 l Z l@l30 N/A B403230096 840307 l
, 8 9 PDR ADOCK 05000237 40 issue OE CRIPTION e, 7
2 o 8 9 hl 10 N/A l 48 49 lllllllllllll1 p 80 5 Ben Schroeder/R. Mirochna PHONE. 815-942-2920!o -- hk.
CFP PARER - ,i i
> ~- , ,.- .
z_ - <- - '- -
ATTACHMENT TO LICENSEE EVENT REPORT 83-012/01X-1 COMMONWEALTH EDISON COMPANY (CWE)
DRESDEN UNIT (ILDRS2)
DOCKET # 050-237 This supplemental-report concerns the inoperable snubbers found during the routine mechanical snubber functional tests during the previous Unit-2 refueling outage (Jan. 1983). Main Steam Line (MSL) snubbers #44,46,50,'
51,53 were identified as being inoperable and/or in questionable condition.
Please refer to the initial D(R/LER submittals.
The Station Nuclear Engineering Depeartment (SNED) performed a comprehensive investigation (assisted by Sargent & Lundy, Pacific Scientific, and Dresden Station)to determine the mode and cause of snubber inoperability.
The conclusion of this investigation forms the remainder of this supplemental report.
Conclusion of SNED's report is as follows:
As a result of the Main Steam line snubber failures on Dresden 2, an intensive effort was initiated to assess the safety significance and to identify the cause of s'nubber failure. The results of the safety significance assesement would determine whether the safe operation of Dresden Unit 2 had been in jeopardy while operating with the failed snubbers. It would also provide assurance that continued operation of D-3, QC-1, and QC-2 as well as D-2 would not jeopardize plant safety.
Several actions were taken to verify safe plant operation. To begin with additional inspections were performed on Dresden 2 to quantify the extent of damage. Snubbers surveillances were also condheted on D-3, QC-1 and QC-2. No other damage was found on D-2 and no snubber failures were found on the other units.
A variety of operability assessments assuming differing failure configurations <
and a different SRV opening time were performed. First, these indicated that D-2 was operable while operating with the failed snubbers. Second, considering the results of the different postulated failure conditions analyzed, these operability assessments indicated thet the D-2, D-3, QC-1 and QC-2 Main Steam Lines will remain operable even in the event of similar snubber failures. Since no snubbers failures were found on the other units, additional D-2 pipe and steel inspections showed no failures, and the results of the operability analyses indicated that the piping was operable; safe operation of the plants was ensured.
This conclusion is reinforced by the existence of the Technical Specification surveillance which originally identified the failures. These requirements delineate an augmented snubber inspection to be performed in the event of snubber failures. The safety significance of operating without knowing Page 1 of 3
_m . _.. _ _ . __ _ _ . _. _ _ _ . _ _ _
l ATTACHMENT TO LICENSEE EVENT REPORT 83-012/01X-1 (CONTINUED) -
the cause of a snubber failure was assessed when these requirements were j instituted. Therefore, the Technical Specification escalating surveillance requirements ensure safe operation.
Concurrent with the above actions a comprehensive investigation was being
, pursued to determine the cause of snubber failure. All possible evidence concerning the D-2 failures was gathered. As previously stated additional
- inspections were performed to quantify the extent of the D-2 damage. Snubber >
autopsies were performed to determine the nature of the snubber failures.
Finally, an action plan was pursued which concentrated on items which seemed most likely to have contributed to snubber failures. The areas investigated were:
- 1) Adequacy of snubbers materials
- 2) Vibration
- 3) Overload
- 4) Installation
! 5) Design The original autopsies indicated that the snubbers had been subjected l to an overload condition. The investigation, however, to identify a possible
- overload condition proved negative. A load high enough to fail the snubbers i could not be identified by either in plant testing or by analysis. The conclusion drawn from the D-2 steel inspection also indicated that a high ,
, load did not exist.
+
The in plant tests which were performed monitored snubber loads for the highest
[ known load producing transient (the SRV actuation) having occurred while j the snubbers were installed. In fact the SRV actuation was determined to be the highest load producing transient of those which could occur to the subject
, lines. Also the plant startup was monitored to seek out unanticipated transients. As a follow-up, provisions have been made to continuously monitor the remainder of the D-2 operating cycle. (Note: This is already ,
- installed and operating). "This will aid in detecting unknown transients causing snubber failure.
l A detailed review of the snubber as-built configurations was also done to determine if an installation problem existed. Binding of snubber components had been identified early on as a possible mode contributing to snubber failure. The as-built configuration was modeled with the actual (as i determined by field test data) pipe movements input to simulate the field conditions.~ In no case did binding occur. Therefore, binding wcs ruled l
out as a cause of these specific failures.
One of the PSCo (Pacific Scientific Company) field trips revealed that there could be'a field installation technique which degrades the' snubber. This places the snubber in a condition in which.it may lock up. This' installation
. problem has been determined not to.be the cause of the extensive snubber.
- damage occurring on D-2. This conclusion.is based on two supporting' facts.
i i l
I Page 2 of 3
.. _ , _ _. ,--m . , . _ . . _ _ _ , , ., , _ _ _ , . _ , _ . _ _ _ _ - . .__ ,_. .
. , . )
ATTACHMENT TO LICENSEE EVENT REPORT 83-012/0lX-1 (CONTINUED) -
First, the investigation into the magnitude of thermal loads created due to snubber lock-up have resulted in loads which have been determined not to be severe enough to have caused the additional snubber damage. Second, only four of the five failed snubbers exhibited this installation prompted condition. This area will be pursued further, but considering the above, the results of this action are not significant to this failure investigation.
Since overicad was not the cause of failure, a snubber testing program was initiated to delineate the PSA-10 snubber capabilities. It was determined that the snubber performed adequately when subject to a cyclic high magnitude dynamic load. The results did indicate that the snubber performance would be drastically degraded with the snubber subjected to a bending moment.
As previously stated, though, binding did not occur on the Dresden 2 snubbers. Therefore, this information is not applicable to this failure investigation.
The failure investigation also included a review of the Main Steam support system design. This included a review of the analyses performed and the assumptions used in performing the analysis. Comparisons of other support system designs for similar piping s'ystems were also performed. The results of these reviews indicated there was no item which would result in the analyses producing loads near the snubber failure point. -
Finally, investigations were performed to verify snubber material adequacy and to determine if vibration was degrading the snubber performance. The material investigations were performed considering the extent of snubber damage. The vibration concern was raised because of prior knowledge of Main Ste am Line vibration. The issults of these efforts indicated that the materials were adequate and that the vibration was not severe enough to affect snubber operation.
In summary, the data is contradictory and, therefore, inconclusive.
The snubber autopsies indicate that the snubbers were overloaded. The review of the possible transients and of the analyses, and the results of the inplant testing program and the pipe and steel inspections all indicate that an overload con 2ition did not exist. This would lead to the conclusion that other factors r ch as component binding must be degrading snubber performance. But, again, the investigations performed have indicated that binding did not occur even with the mismatched components.
No conclusion delineating the cause of snubber failure can be drawn; however continued operation of the plants has been shown to be justified
- . even considering the lack of a definitive cause of snubber failure.
l i
I Page 3 of 3 L
JM
. x Commonwealth Edison
_c ) Dresden Nucle:r Power Stitlin
( m ~ R.R. #1 Morris, Illinois 60450
\N Telephone 815/942-2920 March 2, 1984 l l
DJS Ltr. #84-197 James G. Keppler, Regional Administrator Region III U.S. Nuclear-Regulatory Commission 3
799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 Updated Reportable Occurrence Report #83-12/01X-1, Docket #050-237 is being submitted to your office in accordance with Dresden Nuclear Power Station Technical Specification 6.6.B.1.(i), performance of structures,
- systems, or components that requires remedial action or corrective measures to prevent operation in a manner less conservative than assumed in the accident analyses in the safety analysis report or technical specifications bases; or discovery during plant life of conditions not specifically considered in the safety analysis report or technical specifications that require remedial action or corrective measures to prevent the existence or developemnt of an unsafe condition. This updated report is provided in order to report further investigation regarding the cause of the event and the corrective actions taken.
D. . Scott Station Superintendent
- Dresden Nuclear Power Station i
DJS/jmt i
Enclosure I
cc: Director of Inspection & Enforcement Director of Management Information & Program Control U.S. NRC Document Management Branch File /NRC I-MAR'fg393,.
l JEao\
. SUPPLEMENT TO DVR '
DVR No. .
STA UNIT. YEAR NO.
D - 12 -
2 - 83 - 17 PA'(T I i TITLE OF EVENT OCCURRED . ._
1 2/.10/83
~
0800 !
Inoperable Main Steam Line Snubbers DATE TIME i REASON FOR SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Tn vannre on He results of an investication into reasons for the failure of the MSL snubbers detected during the spring 1983 refuel . outage. This supplettental report is incorporated with Deviation Reports 12-2-83-19, 12-2-83-20 and 12-2-83-27.
PART 2 l ACCEPTANCE BY STATION REVIEW
././// L. . .)
DATE . 3l 13l8Y 1
f /g/ e/ -
i
- 7 SUPFLEMENTAL REPORT AFFROVED
/
AND AUTHORIZED FOR DISTRIBUTION MM 3 EI
. STATION DATE JP@'INTENDENT a
_ . _ _ _ _ _ ... ,-.--...-----n - - --
-~-~<--~---~~--*~'*^-~*~~~~#
|
---|
|
|
| | Reporting criterion |
---|
05000237/LER-1983-001, Forwards LER 83-001/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-001/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-001, Forwards LER 83-001/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-001/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-002, Forwards Updated LER 83-002/03X-1 | Forwards Updated LER 83-002/03X-1 | | 05000249/LER-1983-003, Forwards LER 83-003/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-003/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-004, Forwards LER 83-004/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-004/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-004, Forwards LER 83-004/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-004/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-005, Forwards LER 83-005/01T-0 | Forwards LER 83-005/01T-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-005, Forwards LER 83-005/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-005/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-006, Forwards LER 83-006/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-006/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-007, Forwards LER 83-007/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-007/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-008, Forwards LER 83-008/01T-0 | Forwards LER 83-008/01T-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-008, Forwards Updated LER 83-008/01X-1 | Forwards Updated LER 83-008/01X-1 | | 05000249/LER-1983-009, Forwards LER 83-009/03L-0.Detailed Event Analysis Encl | Forwards LER 83-009/03L-0.Detailed Event Analysis Encl | | 05000237/LER-1983-009, Forwards LER 83-009/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-009/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-010, Forwards LER 83-010/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-010/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-010, Forwards LER 83-010/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-010/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-011, Forwards LER 83-011/01T-0 | Forwards LER 83-011/01T-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-011, Forwards LER 83-011/01T-0 | Forwards LER 83-011/01T-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-012, Forwards LER 83-012/01T-0 | Forwards LER 83-012/01T-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-013, Forwards LER 83-013/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-013/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-013, Forwards LER 83-013/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-013/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-014, Forwards LER 83-014/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-014/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-014, Forwards LER 83-014/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-014/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-015, Forwards LER 83-015/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-015/03L-0 | | 05000249/LER-1983-015, Forwards LER 83-015/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-015/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-016, Forwards LER 83-016/03L-0.Detailed Event Analysis Encl | Forwards LER 83-016/03L-0.Detailed Event Analysis Encl | | 05000237/LER-1983-017, Forwards LER 83-017/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-017/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-018, Forwards LER 83-018/01T-0.Detailed Event Analysis Encl | Forwards LER 83-018/01T-0.Detailed Event Analysis Encl | | 05000237/LER-1983-020, Forwards LER 83-020/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-020/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-021, Forwards LER 83-021/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-021/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-022, Forwards LER 83-022/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-022/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-023, Forwards LER 83-023/03L-0 | Forwards LER 83-023/03L-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-029, Forwards LER 83-029/01T-0 | Forwards LER 83-029/01T-0 | | 05000237/LER-1983-080, Supplemental LER 83-080/03X-1:on 831124,offgas Log Rad Monitor 2-1705-A Delivered Offgas High Alarm & High Alarm Spiked & Drifted Downscale.Caused by Burned Out Resistor. Power Supply Installed & Monitor Calibr | Supplemental LER 83-080/03X-1:on 831124,offgas Log Rad Monitor 2-1705-A Delivered Offgas High Alarm & High Alarm Spiked & Drifted Downscale.Caused by Burned Out Resistor. Power Supply Installed & Monitor Calibr | | 05000237/LER-1983-084, Updated LER 83-084/03X-1:on 831230,during Normal Operation, Primary Containment Oxygen Sample from Torus Alarmed on Low Level Sample Flow.Caused by Sample Line Moisture.Line Drained & Leads reconnected.W/840314 Ltr | Updated LER 83-084/03X-1:on 831230,during Normal Operation, Primary Containment Oxygen Sample from Torus Alarmed on Low Level Sample Flow.Caused by Sample Line Moisture.Line Drained & Leads reconnected.W/840314 Ltr | |
|